taking reading comprehension to the next level: applying ... · conventionality and clarity •...
TRANSCRIPT
-
4/14/15
1
Taking Reading Comprehension to the Next Level:
Applying Skills to Complex Text
Jan Parkman, Presenter
Cory Stai, MN Dept. of Education
Guiding Questions
• What is text complexity and why is this important to reading instruction?
• How can we provide our students meaningful access to more complex text?
2
Text Complexity: An Introduction
What is meant by text complexity and
why is it important?
Prepared by the Minnesota Department of Education
-
4/14/15
2
Reading Informa3onal
Text
Students access words from Science, social studies, the arts, and literature through informa3onal text.
Informa3onal text provides explana3ons,
procedures, direc3ons and other types of informa3on
Text Complexity
“In order to prepare students for complexity of college and career-‐ready texts, each grade requires growth in complexity.”
Appendix A
A step-‐by-‐step staircase of increasingly complex text that goes from CCR down to founda3onal skills,
which makes fuller use of the text. Requires close
and rereading instruc3on.
Academic Vocabulary
Constantly building vocabulary to access and understand grade-‐level
texts and ideas. Be able to produce wriMen and spoken text in mul3ple
areas.
Focusing on Academic Vocabulary in “Value-‐added” instruc3on,
enabling students to have improved fluency and comprehension across wide range of text.
Instruction Shifts for ELA Common Core
Close Reading / Text Dependent
Ques3ons
Students need opportuni3es to prac3ce
close reading by rereading, referencing
other texts and exploring text deeply .
Close reading should be directly linked to
responding to and asking ques3ons related to the text, using eviden3ary
arguments based on text.
Argumenta3ve Wri3ng and Research
Students develop key wri3ng and research skills, using evidence to inform, persuade or support an
argument.
Frequent, short, focused research projects providing textual
evidence should be part of classroom experiences.
Literacy Instruc3on Across Content Area
History/Social Studies Students need to analyze evidence from primary and secondary sources suppor3ng their claims and interpreta3ons.
Content literacy can help students access text iin their subject through reading , wri3ng and cri3cal thinking.
Instruction Shifts for ELA Common Core
Reading Sub-strands
Range of Reading and Level of Text Complexity: Read and comprehend complex literacy and information texts independently and proficiently.
Key Ideas and Details: Read closely to determine what the text says explicitly and to make logical inferences from it; Cite specific textual evidence when writing or speaking to support conclusions drawn from the text.
6
-
4/14/15
3
Reading Sub-strands (cont.)
Integration of Knowledge and Ideas:
• Compare/analyze content presented in different texts, formats and media
• Evaluate arguments and claims in a text
Craft and Structure:
• Interpret words and phrases
• Analyze how word choices shape meaning or tone
• Analyze text structure, point of view or purpose, and how it shapes content and style
7
Seriously? The standards expect me to…
Teach using texts kids can’t read.
Make kids read hard texts independently.
Use texts that are all more complex than they used to be.
Force kids to read frustra3ng texts that will kill their will to read.
8
In fact… The new Common Core standards in ELA demand that teachers: Teach kids to struggle successfully with difficult text. Use a balanced diet of texts across the range of complexity. Increase the trajectory across grades 2-12 to ensure career- and college-readiness. Provide kids opportunities to explore complex texts with support and collaboration.
9
-
4/14/15
4
What is meant by Text Complexity?
Three dimensions must be considered together:
– Quantitative measures
– Qualitative measures – Reader and Task
measures
10
• Spend more engaged time on more complex texts
• Engage students in rigorous conversation • Give students less to read, let them re-read • Use leveled texts carefully to build independence
in struggling readers • Provide scaffolding • Get kids inspired and excited about the beauty
of language and joy of reading
Staircase of Complexity: What the Teacher Does
11
• Read to see what more they can find and learn as they re-read texts again and again;
• Be persistent despite challenges when reading; good readers tolerate frustration;
• Engage with texts w/ other adults;
• Read material at own level to build joy of reading and pleasure in the world.
Staircase of Complexity: What the Student Does
12
-
4/14/15
5
Why is increasing Text Complexity important?
13
Looking at Some Data
• Difference in ability to answer literal vs. inference questions?
• Type of textual element focused on by the questions being asked?
What separates college-ready readers from the rest?
14
o Author’s approach o Suppor3ng details o Rela3onships
o Word Meaning o Generaliza3ons o Conclusions
NO
NO
• They can answer all of these types of questions related to different tasks and kinds of thinking even when the text is complex!
• The one issue found to “bend the curve” of college reading readiness among students is text complexity.
What separates college-ready readers from the rest?
15
-
4/14/15
6
Yeah, but…what about students who are not bound for college?
Student Readiness for Postsecondary Endeavors, Williamson, 2006. University - freshman/sophomore text Workplace - wide variety of career paths Citizenship - papers, documents, quantitative info. Military - Army website docs, manuals High school – Textbook analysis
16
Yeah, but…what about students who are not bound for college?
Student Readiness for Postsecondary Endeavors, Williamson, 2006. University 1355 These numbers Workplace 1260 represent the Citizenship 1230 average complexity Military 1180 of texts in each group. High school 1130
17
Lexile measures can range from 200L to above 1700L
Lexiles
18
-
4/14/15
7
• Students reading several multiple levels below their grade level?
• Students with emergent level skills?
Yeah, but…what about students who have severe deficits in reading
skills?
19
• Applications for loans
• W4 Forms
• CD-DVD Instructions
• USA Today
• Medical Insurance Benefits Pkg.
• Where the Wild Things Are
• Grapes of Wrath
What levels do you think these are?
20
• Applications for loans 1270
• W4 Forms 1260
• CD-DVD Instructions 1080
• USA Today 1200
• Medical Insurance 1280 Benefits Pkg.
• Where the Wild Things Are 740
• Grapes of Wrath 680
What levels do you think these are?
Remember: 1185-‐1385 is Lexile range for HS graduates
21
-
4/14/15
8
Interna?onal Center for Leadership in Educa?on, 2003
Hospitality and Tourism 1230-‐1260
Law and Public Safety 1420-‐1740
Retail/Wholesale Sales and Service 1180-‐1270
Manufacturing 1200-‐1310
Health Science Arts/AV Tech/Communica3ons
1260-‐1300 1100-‐1190
Transporta3on 1170-‐1350
Lexile Levels of Entry-level Occupational Reading Materials
Remember: 1185-‐1385 is range for HS grads 22
What does this mean for instruction?
Text Complexity Reader Ability
23
What does this mean for instruction?
Text Complexity Reader Ability
24
-
4/14/15
9
• Reading is using reading skills to make sense of text systematically and automatically.
• Strategies are effortful and deliberate and occur during initial learning stages when the text is more difficult to understand.
• Strategies become skills with instruction and practice.
Remember: Comprehension is the Goal of Reading Instruction
25
To struggle or not to struggle; is that the question?
“Just right Fit”
Opportunities for “productive struggle”
29
Let’s Talk Babies and Bath Water:
30
-
4/14/15
10
A Quick Word About Assessment
31
• The MCAs are designed to assess the MN ELA Standards in Reading.
• The test specifications use the Lexile bands in the standards
• If you want to “bend the curve” on student scores, build their ability to apply their reading knowledge to more complex texts.
• It’s time to start marching
up the staircase!
Although we believe that a staircase effect can be successfully achieved when purposefully applied over the course of a student’s education, …the first steps on this staircase need to be carefully scaled so the readers successfully acquire the fundamentals of reading texts that allow for practice with decoding and fluency”
Text Complexity and the Emergent Reader
32
Text Complexity: Raising Rigor in Reading Fisher, Frey, Lapp, 2012
Text Complexity:
What do teachers need to know and understand about complex
texts?
-
4/14/15
11
Text Complexity: Putting It Together
35
Text Complexity: Quantitative Features
• Conventional Readability Formulas
– Word length or frequency
– Sentence length
– Text cohesion
Must be measured by a computer.
36
• Simple • Compound • Complex • Dependent/Independent
Sentence Structure Impacts Text Complexity
37
-
4/14/15
12
Text Complexity: Qualitative Features
• levels of meaning or purpose
• Structure • language
conventionality and clarity
• knowledge demands
Must be measured by a trained person.
38
Qualitative Measurements: Continuums of Measurement
Qualitative measures require a trained eye. Easy Difficult
39
Literary Text Qualitative Measures • Meaning
– Density & complexity – Figurative language – Purpose
• Text Structure – Genre – Narration – Order of events/Org. – Use of graphics / text
features
• Language Features – Conventionality – Vocabulary – Sentence structure – Register
• Knowledge Demands – Life experiences – Intertextuality and
cultural knowledge – Subject matter
knowledge
40
-
4/14/15
13
Informational Text Qualitative Measures
• Purpose
• Text Structure – Organization of ideas – Text features – Use of graphics
• Language Features – Conventionality – Vocabulary – Sentence structure
• Knowledge Demands – Subject matter
knowledge – Intertextuality and
cultural knowledge
41
Civil War Article
42
Common Text Features in Textbooks Elements that organize: • Chapters • Titles • Headings • Subheadings Elements for locating information • Table of contents • Indexes • Page Numbers
44
Elements for explanation: • Diagrams • Charts and tables • Graphs • Glossary Elements that illustrate: • Photographs • Illustrations Elements that Notify • Bolded Words • Italics/font changes
-
4/14/15
14
“Considerate” Texts: texts that facilitate comprehension and learning • Structure • Coherence • Audience Appropriateness *These types of texts might be those to start with when adding rigor for students who struggle with reading
Qualitative Measures of Text Complexity
47
• Description: List of Information
• Compare and Contrast: similarities and differences between two concepts
• Temporal Sequence: How events change or remain the same over time
• Cause and effect: Causal relationships
• Problem and Solution: Situation and issue and how it was resolved
Structure in “Considerate” Texts
48
• Main ideas explicitly stated • Information in a paragraph directly
relates back to main idea • Logical order of events and obvious
relationship between events and topics • Readers are provided with a clear
references and ambiguous pronouns are avoided
Considerate Texts: Coherence
49
-
4/14/15
15
• How well the text matches the student’s probable background and prior knowledge
• *Research indicates this is a powerful factor
Considerate Texts: Audience Appropriateness
50
• Levels of meaning and purpose (i.e., Animal Farm) • Density and Complexity (not literal and
explicit) • Figurative Language (irony, idioms,
metaphor, symbolism and other literary devices)
• Purpose is subtle • Structure
“Inconsiderate Texts”
51
• Genre – Fiction vs. non-fiction – Poetry, fables, biography, blogs, historical
• Organization Conventional (Chronological is easier) Non-conventional (different voices, flashbacks)
• Narration • Graphic and Visual Information
Other Structural Factors that Influence Text Complexity
52
-
4/14/15
16
• Language Conventionality and Clarity
• Knowledge Demands – Background Knowledge (life experiences) – Prior Knowledge (formal knowledge) – Cultural Knowledge – Vocabulary Knowledge
Multiple meanings, Domain specific words, Context clues
Other Qualitative Factors that Influence Text Complexity
53
Text Complexity: Reader and Task Considerations
• Motivation • Knowledge • Prior Experiences • Purpose of task • Complexity of task
Typically measured by the classroom teacher.
54
Text Complexity: Matching Readers to Texts
Exploring the Reader • Cognitive Capabilities • Reading skills • Motivation &
engagement • Prior Knowledge & Experiences
Exploring the Task • Teacher led • Peer Tasks • Individual Tasks
55
-
4/14/15
17
• Will this text maintain the student’s interest?
• Will this text tax the reader’s working memory?
• Will this text require specialized supports (e.g., language support, accommodations)?
• Does this text contain enough supports to move the reader’s learning forward rather than cause frustration?
Cognitive Capabilities
56
• Is this topic or genre of interest and relevant to the reader?
• Has the reader experienced success in the past with this topic or genre?
• Is the text being used to connect to larger themes or concepts?
Motivation
57
Does the reader • Possess needed metacognitive skill to
comprehend the text? • Possess specialized knowledge about topic or
genre? • Have sufficient background and/or prior
knowledge to link to the new information? • Have direct experiences that will make this text
more accessible
Knowledge and Experiences
58
-
4/14/15
18
• Teacher led: Does the text require modeling of cognitive comprehension strategies, word-solving strategies, text structures/text features?
• Peer Tasks: Does the task match reader’s collaboration and social skills?
• Individual Tasks: does the task provide sufficient challenge for the reader while avoiding protracted frustration?
Exploring the Task
59
Do questions require the reader to • return to the text • Use evidence to support ideas or
claims? • Analyze, evaluate, and create?
Exploring the Question
60
Reader and Task: Engagement Questions to ask…
• Is the information / story relevant to the student?
• Is this new knowledge or related to previous learning?
• Does it stimulate curiosity and motivation around the topic?
• Does it involve the appropriate level of cognitive engagement?
61
-
4/14/15
19
Reader and Task: Engagement Questions to ask…
• Is the reader cognitively engaged at an appropriate level?
• Will they be asked to use or apply the new skill or knowledge?
• Is it personally meaningful?
62
Text Complexity:
How do we help our students read and comprehend more
complex texts?
• Read text to students or play an audio recording
• Summarize the information the following day • Create study guides which pull out all of the
relevant text (main ideas, concepts to know) • Show a video, simulation, dramatization • Have volunteers share out the most
important information either in groups or a large group Q and A?
How can you teach “around” the text?
64
-
4/14/15
20
Scaffolds Shouldn’t Be Permanent
65
C an’t O r W on’t
“Covering Content” by Teaching Around the Text
67
Increasing Access to Texts
Eliminating Won’t: • Mindset (Diagnosis and Changing) • Reversing Learned Helplessness • Motivation and Engagement • Cultural Relevance /
Responsiveness
68
-
4/14/15
21
Increasing Access
Eliminating Can’t: • Gradual Release of
Responsibility • Frontload your
teaching (Before-reading activities)
• Teach vocabulary expansion skills – Context Clues – Word Parts – Dictionary Skills
• Teach academic vocabulary
• Teach content vocabulary
• Teach comprehension skills – Teach text features – Teach text structures
• Teach comprehension strategies
69
Gradual Release – Fisher & Frey
70
Close Reading of Complex Texts
“Simply selecting hard books and telling students to read them will not work.
From: Text Complexity: Raising Rigor in Reading
(Fisher, Frey, Lapp) 71
Students need to be taught how to read and think about complex texts.”
-
4/14/15
22
Close Reading: Critical Features
• Use a short text • Re-reading
• Annotating • Productive
Struggle
73
Close Reading: Critical Features
Novice readers haven’t fully developed the habit or rereading to clarify information.
Ask Text-dependent questions to prompt students to return to the text.
74
A Three-Phase Model of Close Reading Fisher and Frey
Opinions, Arguments,
Intertextual Connec3ons
Inferences
Author’s Purpose
Vocab & Text Structure
Key Details
General Understandings
Phase 3: What does the text mean? Phase 2: How does the text work? Phase 1: What does the text say?
75
-
4/14/15
23
Progression of Text-dependent Questions
Opinions, Arguments,
Intertextual Connec3ons Inferences
Author’s Purpose
Vocab & Text Structure
Key Details
General Understandings
8 & 9
3 & 7
6
4 & 5
2
1
Standards
76
• “Right There” Questions • Text Structure Questions • Sequence Questions • Clarification Questions • Paraphrasing Questions • Inferential Questions • Organizing Questions • Academic Vocabulary/Key Phrases
Questions • Purpose Questions
Text Dependent Question Types
77
How do we help students access text?
• Apply vocabulary expansion skills – Context Clues – Word Parts – Connotation
• Understand academic vocabulary
• Apply comprehension skills – Teach text features – Teach text structures – Main Idea – Etc.
• Teach comprehension strategies – B/D/A strategies – Annotation – Note-taking – Graphic Org.
78
-
4/14/15
24
How to Teach Strategies
79
• Memory and knowledge-based strategies
• General and non-specific strategies • Self-regulation and motivation
strategies • Specific thinking strategies and
processes
Types of Strategic Thinking
80
Teaching a Strategy
• Declarative knowledge – What is it? • Procedural knowledge – How do you do it? • Conditional knowledge – When do you use the
strategy and when should you not to use it; why does the strategy work and under what conditions?
82
-
4/14/15
25
The Strategies Identifying the strategies good readers use to tackle difficult
texts.
83
Comprehension Strategies (The “Big Six” from NRP)
• Making connections • Making predictions • Monitoring understanding • Visualizing • Questioning • Retelling / summarizing
84
Teaching Metacognition Lesson 1: Reading is about understanding!
85
-
4/14/15
26
Monitoring Your Thinking (metacognition)
1.) attention (manage distractions) 2) comprehension (understanding)
Stop periodically and ask: Did that make sense?
– If yes, move on to question 2. – If no, use fix-it strategies to clarify.
• What's important?
86
Before Reading Strategies Teaching students to prep their own learning.
87
Previewing a Text
• the title / headline and author
• any words that are repeated or in bold or larger type
• the opening paragraphs (the lead)
• any photographs and captions
• any maps, diagrams, charts, or other graphics
• organization
88
-
4/14/15
27
Why Do We Preview?
• the headline – activate prior knowledge, main idea
• author – bias and credentials
• repeated or large type words – main idea, important words
• bold words – Where is the support?
89
Why (continued)
• the opening paragraphs (the lead) – main idea, prior knowledge, make questions/
predictions
• photographs and captions – What is it? access it when it's most helpful
• any maps, diagrams, charts, or other graphics – What is it about? How do I read it? access it
when helpful
• organization – Did that make sense? What's important to
remember?
90
During Reading Strategies What to do while you’re reading to ensure maximum
understanding.
91
-
4/14/15
28
1. Monitor Your Attention
Monitor your attention and concentration • remove distractions, for example:
– shut of the TV – move to a quieter place – stop social media
• focus on maintaining engagement with the text (see "self-talk")
• take a break and come back to it with a clear head
92
Fix-it Strategies Teaching students what to do when they read it but don’t
get it.
93
“Fix-it Strategies” Defined
• A strategy is a plan for achieving a desired goal or outcome.
• Fix-it strategies are plans readers can use when comprehension (understanding) “breaks down.”
94
-
4/14/15
29
2. Reread for Understanding: When you reread, you should read differently from how you read the first time. Some things you should do differently include: • slow down (this allows time for your brain
to process and to do the rest of this list) • stop more frequently to check
understanding • focus on visualizing
– ~ make pictures in your head – ~ draw actual pictures on paper or use graphic
organizers 95
2. Reread for Understanding:
Some things you should do differently include: • address unknown vocabulary (use word knowledge
to tackle words you don't know). – ~ word parts – ~ context clues – ~ use references (look it up or ask someone)
• use "self-talk": – ~ ask yourself questions about the reading (who, what,
when , where, why/how) – ~ ask yourself, "What is the main point, here?" – ~ make connections (to you, the world, other texts, this
text) 96
Plan to Follow Up:
• Create specific questions that state where you're not understanding so that you can ask someone for explanation or help later (in class, for example)
97
-
4/14/15
30
In Summary…
Students need many opportunities to access complex text to be prepared for reading success after HS.
98
What does this mean for instruction?
Text Complexity Reader Ability
99
www.fisherandfrey.com
To do this and be ready for their lives in the work force, as consumers, and as citizens,
Students need to be taught to read closely, and apply strategies and skills to handle complex texts.
100
-
4/14/15
31
Just putting difficult books in to a student’s hands and expecting them to acquire the skills on their own is not an appropriate course of action.
101
Students should also be • reading widely and independently, • building background knowledge and
vocabulary in a wide range of genres and topics.
Students should read for enjoyment, not just as a school project to be avoided outside the classroom.
From: Text Complexity: Raising Rigor in Reading
(Fisher, Frey, Lapp)
Don’t forget: In addition to work with complex text
102
Questions?
Jan Parkman [email protected]
103
-
4/14/15
32
Bibliography/Links
ACT, Inc. (2006). Reading between the lines: What the ACT reveals about college readiness in reading. Retrieved from http://www.act.org/research/policymakers/pdf/reading_report.pdf Williamson, G.L. (2006, April). Student Readiness for Postsecondary Endeavors. Paper presented at the meeting of the American Educational Research Association (AERA). Retrieved from http://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED491516.pdf
104
Bibliography/Links
Fisher, F. Frey, N. & Lapp, D. (2012) Text Complexity: Raising Rigor in Reading. Newark. DE: International Reading Association Daggett, W.R. (2003) Achieving Reading Proficiency for All. International Center for Leadership in Education. http://www.leadered.com/pdf/Reading%20White %20Paper.pdf “Asking Questions that Prompt Discussion” by Fisher & Frey. Principal leadership. Nov. 2011 http://fisherandfrey.com/uploads/posts/Discussion.pdf
105
• “Simplifying Text Complexity” Sarah Brown Wessling, Teaching Channel https://www.teachingchannel.org/videos/simplifying-text-complexity#video-sidebar_tab_video-notes-tab
Videos
106