taylor johnson, ba a thesis in music theory submitted to
TRANSCRIPT
An Analysis of Text Setting in Selected A Cappella Choral Works of Eric Whitacre
by
Taylor Johnson, BA
A Thesis
In
Music Theory
Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of Texas Tech University in
Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for
the Degree of
Master of Music
Approved
Dr. Michael Berry, Committee Chair
Dr. Peter Martens
Dr. John Hollins
Fred Hartmeister Dean of the Graduate School
May, 2009
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
ii
Table of Contents
Abstract………………………………………………………………………………….iii List of Tables…………………………………………………………………………….iv Chapter I. Introduction…………….……………………………………………………………...1 II. When David Heard…………….……………………………………………………16 III. Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine…………….…………………………..35 IV. A Boy and a Girl……………..……………………………………………………..55 V. Conclusion and Directions for Further Research…………….…………………...73 Works Cited……………………………………………………………………………..76
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
iii
Abstract
This thesis examines three a cappella choral works by Eric Whitacre, When David Heard,
Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine, and A Boy and a Girl, from both a musical and
narrative perspective. Each piece is analyzed using internal framing, structural downbeat,
and text painting, and how all of these devices combine to accentuate the narrative
archetype of the chosen text.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
iv
List of Tables
1.1 Rhythmic Form Symbology .......................................................................13 2.1 When David Heard Form Chart .................................................................31 2.2 When David Heard Structural Chart ..........................................................31 3.1 Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine Form Chart ..............................37 3.2 Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine Detailed Form Chart ...............40 3.3 Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine Structural Chart .......................52 4.1 A Boy and a Girl Form Chart .....................................................................56 4.2 A Boy and a Girl Tertian/Set Class Chart ..................................................58 4.3 A Boy and a Girl Coda/Verse 1 Comparison Chart ...................................71 4.4 A Boy and a Girl Structural Chart ..............................................................72
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
1
Chapter 1
Introduction
Within the last several years, Eric Whitacre has emerged as a prominent voice in
modern American choral composing. His music is performed by high school, university,
and professional ensembles around the world. He is known for a unique harmonic style,
using primarily triadic harmony in nonfunctional ways with non-triadic notes added for
color. He is also known for expressive text setting, letting the music depict, if not
enhance, the story of text. I believe that it is this textual aspect that drives Whitacre’s
compositional process and allows his pieces to be cohesive without operating within a
diatonic framework. There is little scholarly work available on Whitacre’s music, and this
thesis will add to that very limited repertory. I will examine three of Whitacre’s a
cappella choral works—When David Heard, Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine,
and A Boy and a Girl—in order to discover how the musical structures reflect the
narrative of the text because his musical language can prove difficult to the performer,
conductor and theorist.
Eric Whitacre was born in 1970, and went through life with no formal training in
music before his undergraduate studies at University of Nevada at Las Vegas. Whitacre
went on to earn a Master’s degree in Music at the Juilliard School where he studied
composition with Pulitzer Prize- and Oscar-winning composer John Corigliano. Eric
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
2
Whitacre currently lives in Los Angles, California with his wife, soprano Hila Pittman,
and their son.1
I have performed many of Eric Whitacre’s choral works with my high school,
undergraduate, and graduate choral ensembles. This experience led me to believe that the
narratives of the texts Whitacre chooses for his compositions are the driving force behind
the musical content of his pieces. In his session at the 2008 conference for the Texas
Music Educators Association, Whitacre discussed his compositional process and
confirmed some insights I had gained into his compositional process from performing his
works. First he confirmed that the text is one of the most important factors when he
approaches a new project. It is not the only thing he considers, however. He also
mentioned that whenever he begins a new piece, he thinks of his mother. Whitacre’s
mother, as he related, has no formal musical training, and no understanding of thematic
development and musical form. Because of this, he always presents a specific musical
idea in the opening measures of his pieces that he will then reuse in some way at least
once later in the piece. This repetition or slight alteration of a distinctive musical idea
allows his mother to hear and understand, at least on the most basic level, the form of the
piece of music.
1 All of the biographical information can be found on Eric Whitacre’s website, www.ericwhitacre.com. [accessed on February 27, 2009].
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
3
Theoretical Approaches—Eric Whitacre
Very little work has been done on Eric Whitacre’s approach to text setting. In
order to investigate how other contemporary composers set English texts, I examined
several sources that treat that topic in detail.
Andrew Lloyd Larson’s dissertation “Textural and Harmonic Density in Selected
Choral Works (1992-2003) by Eric Whitacre,” was the only scholarly work written on the
music of Eric Whitacre at the time this paper was written. For this reason, it was a very
helpful source for biographical information and for insight into the music. Although
Larson looked at Whitacre’s music from a textural and voice-leading standpoint, his
chapter on harmonic organization, chapter 4, is relevant to the present undertaking. He
asserts that Whitacre doesn’t approach his music from a harmonic perspective, but from a
more linear, melodic, text-driven approach. This ties in with the present project in the
sense that this linear, melodic approach allows the music to be bent to the will of text. In
Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine, for instance, many sections have musical
material derived entirely from text painting. Larson does very little analysis on the
specific relations between the text and the music, though, focusing more on voice leading
of each voice part.
Theoretical Approaches—Textual Treatment
In his dissertation, “Aspects of Textual Treatment in Benjamin Britten’s
Unaccompanied Choral Music,” Douglas L. Jones analyzes four unaccompanied works
by Britten on the basis of the text setting. Jones demonstrates Britten’s technique of
taking each piece as a separate entity, doing so even with movements in a larger work, as
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
4
in Five Flower Songs. Each analysis is concise, pointing out only those musical moments
that have direct relevance on the subject of text setting. For example, he points out that
Marsh Flowers “opens with a strong fp gesture sung in unison octaves, which draws the
listener’s attention to the word ‘here.’”2 Jones then discusses how Britten uses this figure
to create cohesion later in the piece:
A similar gesture is sung to the text “Here the dull nightshade / hangs her deadly fruit…” in the next phrase of music, which begins in bar 4. The word “here” is once again assigned a fp, but in this instance, the sopranos and tenors take up the melody in F major. In the very next bar, the note Db in the soprano and tenor lines accentuates the word “hangs” in an adroit moment of text-painting.3
Jones does not, however, provide a measure-by-measure analysis, trying to explain every
musical gesture as being guided by the text. This allows him to take in more over-
arching instances of text painting without getting lost in each individual measure, as seen
above.
In her article “Aspects of Narrativity and Temporality in Britten’s Winter Words,”
Annabelle Paetsch examines Britten’s setting of Thomas Hardy poetry in his song cycle
Winter Words. The interesting thing about this cycle, with respect to narrativity, is that it
lacks any over-arching plot or any specific narrator or characters. Britten arranged the
songs in order to relate them to the “central theme…the loss of childlike innocence as
2 Douglas Jones, Aspects of textual treatment in Benjamin Britten’s unaccompanied choral music with commentary on the history and meaning of the text (Ann Arbor: UMI, 2000). 3 Jones, 110.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
5
adult consciousness develops.”4 Britten develops this theme by letting it be “seen from
many disparate points of view rather than by progressive sequential development.”5
Although, as mentioned earlier, there is no official narrator, each piece could be seen as
being narrated by a figurative adult. It is this adult that is looking back on each event,
represented by each piece, and viewing it not only from his own mature perspective, but
also trying to put himself into the mind of a child and view the event through those eyes.
This shift from adult to child, from past perspective to present perspective, is what
Paetsch refers to as the temporality of the cycle. It is this temporal aspect that Britten’s
musical settings are designed to reflect. For example, in the first song of the cycle, “At
Day-Close in November,” Hardy describes a nature scene, as viewed from the eyes of the
adult narrator and from the eyes of a child. The piece opens from the perspective of the
child, full of innocence and hope. Britten uses a tonally complex setting here, “as if
Britten is preparing the listener for the ironic twist when the vivid yellow beech leaves
are sardonically perceived as specks in the eye.”6
In his article “Britten and Shakespeare: Dramatic and Musical Cohesion in ‘A
Midsummer Night’s Dream’,” Mervyn Cooke examines Britten’s opera based on the
Shakespearian play to see how the music helps provide continuity to both the plot and the
form of the opera. Britten achieves this by using both large-scale and small-scale musical
ideas. Britten used many different musical and textual devices to create continuity in his
opera. In Act I, Britten actually alters the original play in order to create a symmetrical
4 Annabelle Paetsch, “Aspects of Narrativity and Temporality in Britten’s ‘Winter Words’,” Music and Letters Vol. 1, No. 4 (1998): 539. 5 Paetsch, 539. 6 Paetsch, 541.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
6
division to his Act I. This allows the music of Act I to reinforce the structure of the act
itself. Act II is unified solely by musical devices, as opposed to the textual-musical
unification of Act I. This contrast between Act I and Act II is shown in the Figure 1.1
below.7
7Mervyn Cooke, “Britten and Shakespeare: Dramatic and Musical Cohesion in ‘A Midsummer Night’s Dream’,” Music and Letters Vol 74, No 2 (1993): 252.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
Figure 1.1: Britten Form Chart
7
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
8
Act III is similar to Act II in its textual arrangement, but Act III lacks any musical
cohesion, allowing it to form a stark contrast to Act II. This is designed to “highlight the
stark contrast between the enchantment of Acts I and II and the normality of life at
Theseus’s court.”8 This shows the large-scale musical cohesion and narrativity of the
opera. Britten also used smaller musical ideas to create cohesion.
In Act I, Britten uses ritornello passages to connect the different events of the act.
This not only provides cohesion for Act I, but these passages introduce musical ideas that
become important later in Acts II and III. This is very similar to the opening theme idea
that Whitacre uses in his choral music. It may not be of obvious importance when it
happens at the beginning of the piece, but it will show its importance by reappearing later
in the piece.
Britten uses sequential chord progressions, moving triads up by various intervals,
“of particular significance are the juxtaposition of roots a semitone or major third apart.”9
These intervals appear often as both sequential and melodic devices. This recurrence of
certain intervals allows Britten to create continuity on a small scale.
This article provided excellent direction for me in my analyses of Whitacre. Of
particular help was the discussion of Britten’s large-scale formal continuity. Whitacre
uses small motives often to create continuity, sometimes no larger than a single interval.
His large-scale forms, on the other hand, are sometimes hard to see, with sections
blurring together. The multi-section musical analysis seen here between the acts proved
invaluable in my analyses.
8 Cooke, 253. 9 Cooke, 260.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
9
Theoretical Approaches—Internal Framing
In his book Musical Form and Musical Performance, Edward T. Cone presents
two theoretical ideas that are essential to this thesis: the ideas of musical framing and
structural downbeat. Cone begins the discussion of musical framing by discussing how
the silence before and after a musical performance serves to separate the performance
from the time, and even reality, before and after it, just as a literal frame separates a piece
of art from the wall around it. It is also possible, even essential, to think about whether
the piece actually begins at measure one and ends at the double bar, whether we see all or
only part of the musical world of that piece. The same analogy is drawn to art, and also
literature: even though we see the framed portion of a landscape, it is implied that the
scene did in fact extend beyond the borders imposed by the artist. In a novel, one tends to
wonder what happens to characters before and after the plot begins and ends: how did
they get there? What happens to them now?
Cone takes the idea one step further by positing that even within a given piece of
music there can be internal frames created by introduction and coda. Cone states, “Just as
silence can be forced to become part of the music it surrounds, so occasionally the
extremes of a composition become separated from the body of the work in such a way
that they act as what we might call internal frames.”10 This idea of internal frames is
inherent in every one of Whitacre’s compositions by his own admission.11 At the Texas
Music Educator’s Conference, Whitacre discussed how he includes a musical idea in the
beginning of each of his pieces that he will then use, either in exact repetition or
10 Edward T. Cone, Musical Form and Musical Performance (New York: W. W. Norton, 1968). 11 TMEA Session with Whitacre, February 2008
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
10
modified, later in the piece. This is almost the exact idea of internal framing, and forms
the basis for understanding form in Whitacre’s pieces. The beginning of each piece
always relates to later musical material. The ending may or may not, but always serves a
role in the narrative of the piece. Even this falls in line with Cone’s ideas, as he states,
“Framing codas are especially rare…”12 and “Frame-like introductions are more
frequent.”13 How Whitacre handles the opening and closing frames in each piece will be
discussed in detail below.
Schumann’s “Am Leuchtenden Sommermorgen” from the song cycle
Dichterliebe provides a familiar example that can be used to illustrate framing. Example
1.1 contains the opening four measures of the piece.
12 Cone, 22. 13 Ibid.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
Example 1.1: Schumann, Am Leuchtenden Sommermorgen, mm. 1-4
The piece begins with what appears to be a dominant-seventh harmony in the key of C-
flat, but rather that resolving to the tonic, Schumann resolves the chord as a German
augmented-sixth chord: it resolves through a cadential six-four chord to a dominant
seventh and ultimately to the tonic, B-flat. Because this piece begins with an ambiguous
harmony, either dominant seventh or German augmented sixth, and because Schumann
resolves that harmony deceptively, as a German augmented sixth and not a dominant
seventh, we are forced to consider how and when the piece actually begins. We can
perhaps imagine that the piece began some time before we heard it, and that we have
arrived in medias res, since the first sound we hear is an unstable one. In that case, we
would say that the opening frame lies outside of the beginning of the piece. Alternatively,
11
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
12
le
a
16
e
he
the opening instability could be seen as the frame itself. If we privilege this hearing, then
the piece does not actually “start” until the root-position tonic chord in m. 2.
Cone also presents the idea of the structural downbeat, which he defines as
“…one of those important points of simultaneous harmonic and rhythmic arrival.”14
Cone believes that musical form is determined by rhythm, as opposed to phrasing or
harmonic structure. This moment of harmonic and rhythmic arrival is what most peop
would consider the climax of a piece, a moment “that is so powerful that retrospectively
it turns what precedes it into its own upbeat.”15 The structural downbeat is not necessarily
at the end of a piece, as Cone argues: “A completely unified composition could then
constitute a single huge rhythmic impulse, completed at the final cadence. This does not
necessarily mean, of course, the final chord. The ultimate resolution often requires
feminine ending—sometimes quite extended—as a way of discharging its momentum.”
Since Whitacre is such a text-driven composer, I believe that his structural downbeats ar
the simultaneous harmonic and rhythmic arrival, but it also includes the arrival of t
narrative climax.
To designate the different parts of the rhythmic form, Cone uses the symbols17 in
Table 1.1:
14 Cone, 24. 15 Cone, 25. 16 Cone, 26. 17 Cone, 27.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
13
Table 1.1: Rhythmic Form Symbology18
Symbol Meaning
/ Initial Downbeat
∪ Period of Motion
\ Cadential Downbeat
Preliminary Anacrusis
Feminine Ending
Each of these symbols can apply to the pieces analyzed in this thesis, but each will apply
in a slightly different way, depending on the use of the opening and closing frame in each
piece.
I strongly believe that these two ideas, internal musical framing and the structural
downbeat, are vital to the understanding of the form of Whitacre’s music. However, both
of these ideas are still subservient to the text of each piece, and are used to best portray
the narrative of the given text of a piece.
Theoretical Approaches—Narrative Archetypes
The narratives of each piece will be discussed in terms of their narrative archetype
as defined by Byron Almén in his article “Narrative Archetypes: A Critique, Theory, and
18 These are not the exact symbols found in Cone’s book, but they are equivalent in meaning and use to those found in the book.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
14
Method of Narrative Analysis.”19 Almén broaches the subject of independent musical
narrative, which many theorists in the past have disregarded Citing the work of Liszka,
Almén argues that music can have a narrative in a general sense; it is possible for a
composition to fall under a broad archetype and not a specific story.
Music narrative is the process through which the listener perceives and tracks a culturally significant transvaluation of hierarchical relationships within a temporal span. A piece’s initial network of hierarchical relationships possesses a certain positive or negative cultural value and the subsequent changes in these relationships instigate a crisis that will be resolved in a manner either acceptable or unacceptable to the culturally informed listener.”20
Almén combines the work of Liska with that of Frye to create four narrative archetypes:
Comedy, Romance, Irony, and Tragedy.21 Romance is “a victory of a desired order over
an undesired transgression or opposition.”22 Tragedy is “the failure of a desired
transgression (or an exercise of freedom) against a restrictive or undesired order.”23 Irony
is “the suppression or removal of a pre-existent order, resulting in an undesirable
condition, whether chaos or a differently valued order.”24 Finally, the Comic archetype is
“the emergence of a new desired order (through a transgressive act) out of an undesired
one.”25 The pieces examined in this thesis fall under one of these four archetypes, and
each chapter will examine how the musical material, internal framing, and structural
19 Byron Almén, “Narrative Archetypes: A Critique, Theory, and Method of Narrative Analysis,” Journal of Music Theory Vol. 47 No. 1 (2003): 12 20 Almén 12. 21 Almén 15. 22 Almén 29. 23 Ibid. 24 Almén 30. 25 Ibid.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
15
downbeat are used to portray the archetype of each piece. In a piece of music,
Beethoven’s Fifth Symphony for example, the mode shift from C Major to C Minor
could be seen as the triumph of a desirable order over an undesirable one, producing the
Romance archetype.
The next three chapters will each deal with the specific pieces. Chapter 2 will deal
with When David Heard. In this piece, Whitacre uses a biblical text that falls under the
narrative archetype of Tragedy. Chapter 3 examines Leonardo Dreams of His Flying
Machine, in which Whitacre uses an original text from poet Charles Anthony Silvestri
that falls under the narrative archetype of Romance. Chapter 4 examines A Boy and a
Girl, in which Whitacre sets a poem by Octavio Paz that falls under the narrative
archetype of Irony. Chapter 5 will conclude the thesis and provide directions for further
research.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
16
Chapter 2
When David Heard
As we have seen, composers who set English texts tend to bend the musical
material to fit the text (Cooke 1993, Jones 2000, Paetsch 1998). This results in a very
pragmatic system of composition where conventional strategies of musical organization
might be downplayed or abandoned altogether. In this chapter, I examine When David
Heard in order to find out how the text dictates the musical structure. When David Heard
was published in 2000 and is written for SSAATTBB chorus with a text taken from II
Samuel 18:33.
The piece has a very distinct opening (measures 1-19) and closing (195-214),
section, both of which contrast heavily with the body of the piece. The complete text of
the work appears in Figure 2.1. Whitacre includes nearly the entire text in the opening
and closing sections. The opening and closing sections are primarily homophonic and
homorhythmic and feature syllabic text setting. The expansive middle section includes
only the words “(O) My son” and “Absalom.” The middle section of the piece is very
linear, with large leaps, duple against triple rhythm, and melismatic text setting.
When David heard that Absalom was slain he went up into his chamber over the gate and wept and thus he said, “My son, my son! Would God I had died for thee.26
The story of When David Heard fits into the archetype of Tragedy. The Tragedy
archetype is one that “depicts the failure of a desired transgression (or an exercise of
26 When David Heard complete text
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
17
freedom) against a restrictive or undesired order.”27 In this specific narrative, the desired
“exercise of freedom” is David’s desire to meet his son again and try to reconcile their
differences. Absalom’s murder by David’s generals is the failure of this desire and the
undesired order of unreconciled differences between father and son remains. This is the
narrative of the text, which is presented almost in its entirety in the opening frame, and
then restated in the closing frame. The true narrative of this piece is not necessarily the
story, but the grief that it evokes. That is what the body of the piece serves to accentuate
to the audience.
The opening of the piece appears in Example 2.1. This opening section is
unmetered and marked “recitativo,” both of which encourage considerable rhythmic
flexibility. Whitacre uses breves to indicate “reciting tones,” where text is performed with
natural speaking rhythms (“When David heard”; “up into his chamber over the”). These
freer sections contrast with the setting of “that Absalom was slain he went,” which is
notated rhythmically but not metrically. The rhythmic notation calls attention to the fact
that in these passages the voices change pitches. One cannot know for sure, but it is likely
that Whitacre set these notes rhythmically to prepare and guide the singers through their
note changes.
27 Almen, 29.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
Example 2.1: When David Heard Opening; set classes applied to vertical sonorities
18
Harmonically, Whitacre chooses chords predominantly from the white-note
diatonic collection. The piece begins with a somber A-minor harmony. The second chord
we hear is a member of set class (0158): it contains G, B, E, and C. We can understand
the C and the E as tones retained from the previous chord; we can understand the G and B
as passing or neighboring notes. The B is a lower neighbor to the first chord’s C; the G is
a passing tone in the bass between A and F. The final harmony is an instance of set class
(01358). Here, Whitacre realizes the chord as a root-position F-major triad with an added
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
G juxtaposed with a root-position C-major triad with an added F as seen in the lower and
upper two staves respectively. This is followed by a brief F-major triad, (037), which
leads to (02357) realized as a d-minor triad with an added E and G.
Measure 2 is also without a time signature; this first phrase of text concludes on
an F-major harmony in m. 3. Following that, the sopranos enter in a new register, singing
the words “My son” to a repeated A4. At this point, Whitacre introduces a time signature,
4/4, and has the sopranos singing a dotted half note followed by a quarter note. Example
2.2 contains mm. 5-8 of the score.
Example 2.2: When David Heard, mm. 5-8; Soprano repeated A
This monotonous repetition of the same text on the same note musically portrays a sort of
obsession. The rest of the choir gradually joins the sopranos, and the sonority that we
finally hear in m. 19 is a fortissimo cluster of all of the pitches in the one-flat diatonic
collection, as shown in Example 2.3.
19
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
Example 2.3a: When David Heard, mm. 9-19; preview of Strutcural Downbeat build-up
20
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
Example 2.3b: When David Heard, mm. 9-19; preview of Strutcural Downbeat build-up
It is this section, measures 1-19, that serves as the opening frame of the piece.
The opening frame uses two different pitch collections, the white-note collection in
measures 1-8, and the one-flat diatonic collection in measures 9-19. These are the two
different collections that Whitacre uses for the main body of the piece. In fact, it is the
shift from the white-note collection to the one-flat collection that marks the transition
21
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
22
from the A section of the body to the B section. Measures 9-19 are also a preview of the
build-up to the structural downbeat later in the piece.
Of particular interest with the opening frame is that it has a parallel closing frame
in measures 195-214. Musically, the closing frame is also unmetered and marked
“recititavo” just like the opening frame. The vocal lines are written on breves for
sustained notes and given rhythmic notation for the sections in which the pitches change.
The closing frame stays entirely in the white-note diatonic collection and does not
contain the structural downbeat preview in the one-flat diatonic collection that the
opening frame does. The closing frame serves to summarize the story that has taken
place in the piece, to remind the audience of the story they just heard.
If the opening and closing frames present the text of the piece almost in its
entirety, then what purpose do mm. 20-194, the vast majority of the piece, serve? The
frames may present the story, but it is the grief that King David experiences that the piece
is designed to portray. The back-story to this text establishes, enhances, and literally
frames the grief embodied in the text. David was king of the Israelite people, and his son
Absalom led a military rebellion against him. David sent his forces out to defend the city
of Jerusalem, but ordered his generals not to harm his son Absalom and bring him back
alive so David could reconcile the differences between them. As the battle ensues, the
generals find Absalom, but kill him against David’s direct orders. They send a
messenger loyal to them back to the palace to tell the King that Absalom was killed in the
chaos of battle. A loyal servant of David’s sees what happened and hurries back to the
palace before the other messenger to tell David the truth of what happened. It is here that
Whitacre picks up the story in the piece.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
23
By setting a text that is a small part of a larger story, Whitacre introduces a kind
of narrative framing. Just as the Schumann example in Chapter 1 shows us that a piece
of music can be seen as simply a snapshot of a larger musical spectrum, so the text of
When David Heard can be seen as a snapshot of a larger narrative spectrum. This gives
the opening and closing frame another function in this piece. Musically, they the musical
opening and closing frame in which Whitacre introduces musical material that will be
used later in the piece. They also serve as narrative opening and closing frames that serve
to provide a frame of reference in the larger narrative spectrum so that the listener can
understand why David is experiencing the grief presented in the body.
Except for the structural downbeat itself, the main body of the piece uses only two
text phrases, “o my son” (which will be referred to as X for the rest of this chapter) and
“o Absalom” (which will be referred to as Y for the rest of this chapter). The phrase
“would God I had died for thee” (which will be referred to as Z for the rest of this
chapter) only appears once as the structural downbeat. It is the body of the piece in
which the grief of the story is truly explored ad developed, and this is created in large part
by Whitacre’s treatment of these two text phrases X and Y. In measures 20-88 of the
body, X and Y are rarely sung at the same time in complete rhythmic unity. They are
either sung at the same time which obscures the text, as shown in Example 2.4; or all of
the voices sing X or Y in unison, but with duple settings conflicting with triple settings,
or one voice is rhythmically displaced from the others, as shown in Examples 2.5 and 2.6
respectively.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
Example 2.4: When David Heard, mm. 31-34; different text presented simultaneously
Example 2.5: When David Heard, mm. 46-48; same text presented with duple against triple metrical groupings
24
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
Example 2.6: When David Heard, mm. 74-78; same text with one voice rhythmically displaced
The two text phrases also occur with almost the same frequency; X occurs 30
times and Y occurs 32. It should be noted that at times I counted two occurrences of X as
only one because at times the two-syllable “my son” happened twice against one four-
syllable “o Absalom.” Even though X happened twice, it acts as one contrast to Y. These
25
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
26
two ideas, X and Y, represent the two sides of the coin of David’s grief. On one side,
David is experiencing the grief of losing his son, an idealized image of what a son is.
This ideal represents the continuation of his family, of his name, and the loss of this
person represents a loss of part of himself. The other side of the coin is the specific loss
of Absalom. Absalom is the estranged son, the one with whom David wanted desperately
to reconcile. However, Absalom is also the person that led a military revolt against him, a
person that threatened the lives of the people in David’s kingdom. It is these two images
of his son that David is struggling with in the contrast between A and B.
I believe this equal contrast of X and Y creates the A section of the body,
depicting David’s grief, confusion, and frustration of trying to reconcile two separate
ideas of this event: the death of Absalom and the death of his son. Even when one phrase
happens in unison in the voices, at least one of the parts is in triple against the duple of
the remaining voices, as was shown in Example 2.4. Given David’s emotional state, this
represents that even if one of the two ideas, X or Y, gains dominance in his mind for a
brief moment, the other idea is never completely pushed aside.
The B section of the body is comprised of measures 89-150. In this section, we
witness the victory of X over Y, of the loss of his son over the loss of Absalom. This
represents David grieving more over the loss of his idealized son over the loss of his
physical son Absalom. This is represented musically by “o Absalom” only occurring five
times in the entire B section of the piece. David is still shown to be emotionally
distraught with “o my son” still set in a duple against triple contrast.
Measure 115 brings us to the material that was previewed in the opening frame.
The only difference in the musical material is that the repeated pitch A is now found in
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
27
the low register of the altos instead of in the sopranos. This builds to the 17-voice cluster
that encompasses the entire one-flat diatonic collection and is repeated on “my son” in
rhythmic unison for 8 measures. A secondary build in 136 drives us directly into the
structural downbeat of measures 140-150.
There are several reasons why measures 140-150 constitute the structural
downbeat of When David Heard. First, this is the first time that both text phrases are
heard together since measure 110. Secondly, each is heard alone in complete metrical
unison with no duple against triple rhythms. X still holds dominance over Y, with X
occurring 5 times compared to Y only occurring twice, but the presence of both shows
David’s full acknowledgement of the loss he has experienced. The second reason that this
passage is the structural downbeat is that it is the only time in the entire piece that the
textual phrase Z is heard, in measures 148-150. The men’s voices are displaced one beat
later than the women’s voices, so the new text is still heard as grief-stricken due to the off
set text. The entire structural downbeat is shown below in Example 2.7.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
Example 2.7a: When David Heard, mm. 140-150; Structural Downbeat
28
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
Example 2.7b: When David Heard, mm. 140-150; Structural Downbeat
29
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
Example 2.7c: When David Heard, mm. 140-150; Structural Downbeat
The remaining measures of the body, measures 151-194, constitute a coda. Here
David gives his final lament for his son, using only textual phrase X. The coda begins in
a SSATB voicing, but slowly the other voices divide and fall away: sopranos in measure
174, altos in measure 182, tenors in measure187, and basses and baritones finish the coda
in measure 194. This steady loss of voice parts represents David’s exhaustion after
30
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
31
working through his grief in sections A and B of the body. A chart of the form of When
David Heard is found in Table 2.1.
Table 2.1: When David Heard Form Chart
Opening Frame
A Section
B Section
Structural Downbeat (in B
Section)
Coda Closing Frame
mm. 1-19 mm. 19-88
mm. 89-150
mm. 140-150 mm. 151-194
mm. 195-214
A structural diagram of When David Heard is given in Table 2.2 to show how the piece
moves toward and away from the structural downbeat.
Table 2.2: When David Heard Structural Chart
Opening Frame
A Section B Section Structural Downbeat
Coda Closing Frame
↑ / ∪ \ ∪ ↓
As mentioned before, the narrative of When David Heard falls under the
archetype of Tragedy, with the opening and closing frames presenting the story and the
body demonstrating David’s grief. Because of this, the entire piece could be compared to
a Baroque operatic recitative and aria. In a Baroque opera, the recitative is used to move
the story along, to allow the action to take place, while the aria pauses the action to
portray the emotions of the given character. The opening frame could be seen as the
recitative to this piece, giving the audience the back-story so they can then understand the
grief of the aria, or body of the work. The closing frame then reprises the story after the
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
32
audience has experienced the grief of David through Whitacre’s setting, giving some
perspective to what has taken place.
Along with the aforementioned duple against triple metrical conflict and displaced
texts, Whitacre also uses melodic motives to portray the grief of When David Heard.
Within the individual melodic lines of the voice parts, there is a heavy emphasis on
thirds, fourths and fifths, the consonant intervals. The melodies are characterized by
leaps of these intervals, using the intervals of seconds and sevenths to embellish these
other consonant intervals. These embellishments are shown below in Examples 2.8, 2.9,
2.10, and 2.11. In Example 2.8, we can understand the G4 acting as a passing tone
between the A4 and F5 (an F4 displaced up an octave). In Example 2.9, the second
between the G4 and A4 separates the fourths between D4-G4 and A4-D5. The second in
Example 2.10 acts as a link between the third between G5-E5 and the F5-Bb4 fifth.
Finally, in Example 2.11, we see the seconds acting as extended passing motion to fill in
the gaps of a fourth.
These motives serve two functions within the larger narrative context of the piece.
First, they serve to create a linear representation of the musical material found in the
opening and closing frames. The frames are characterized by tertian sonorities with added
notes that serve to add color and move between the different tertian sonorities. The
seconds and sevenths in the melodic motives provide links between the more tertian
intervals of thirds, fourths, fifths, and sixths. These larger intervals, any interval other
than a second, are physically harder to sing, creating a very disjunct and unsettled feeling
for both the singer and the audience. This unease is used to add to the sense of grief and
loss that King David is experiencing in this piece.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
Example 2.8: When David Heard, mm. 20 tenor solo; seventh used to create a disjunct melodic line
Example 2.9: When David Heard, mm. 31 altos; second connecting a third to a fourth
Example 2.10: When David Heard, mm. 41 sopranos; second connecting a third to a fifth
Example 2.11: When David Heard, mm. 136-138 soprano II; seconds filling in the steps of the fourth created by the first and last notes of the second two measures
33
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
34
Using these motives, along with the aforementioned musical devices of
conflicting text and conflicting metrical groupings, Whitacre creates a grief-stricken
musical setting for this tragic narrative of loss.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
35
Chapter 3
Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine
Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine was published in 2002 and is written for
SSATB chorus with an original text by Charles Anthony Silvestri. The text asks the
question:
What would it be like if Leonardo Da Vinci were dreaming? And more specifically, what kind of music would fill the mind of such a genius? The drama would tell the story of Leonardo being tormented by the calling of the air, tortured to such a degree that his only recourse was to solve the riddle and figure out how to fly.28
It is this drama, this internal struggle that Whitacre accentuates with his setting of the
text. The entire text of the piece is presented below in Example 3.1.
Tormented by visions of flight and falling, More wondrous and terrible each than the last, Master Leonardo imagines an engine To carry man up into the sun… And he’s dreaming the heavens call him Softly whispering their siren-song: “Leonardo, Leonardo, vieni à volare.” L’uomo colle sua congiegniate e grandi ale, Facciendo forza contro alla resistente aria. As the candles burn low he paces and writes, Releasing purchased pigeons one by one Into the golden Tuscan sunrise… And as he dreams, again the calling, The very air itself gives voice: “Leonardo, Leonardo, vieni à volare.”
28 Leonardo score notes.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
36
Vicina all’ elemento del fuoco… Scratching quill on crumpled paper (Rete, canna, filo, carta.) Images of wing and frame and fabric fastened tightly …sulla suprema sottile aria. As the midnight watchtower tolls, Over rooftop, street and dome, The triumph of a human being ascending In the dreaming of a mortal man. Leonardo steels himself, Takes one last breath, and leaps… “Leonardo vieni à volare! Leonardo, sognare!29
The story of Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine fits into Almén’s narrative
archetype of Romance, which is the “victory of a desired order over an undesired
transgression or opposition.”30 In Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine, the desired
order is a world in which people can fly and answer the call of the wind. This desired
order is fighting against the undesired opposition, the current world where people are
limited to travel over land and sea only. Each of the three verses of this piece builds to
the structural downbeat of the word “leaps” and its prolongation in the Flight section.
This is the moment at which the desirable gains victory over the undesirable, when Da
Vinci takes his first flight on his flying machine. Whitacre’s compositional choices, those
of text-driven melodic material in each act and Renaissance-like elements, all serve to
exemplify this archetype.
The opening frame is not comprised of a repeated harmonic, melodic, or rhythmic
figure, but by a repeated text, “Leonardo dreams of his flying machine.” It should be
29 Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine complete text 30 Almén, 29.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
37
noted that even though this text is used as the opening frame of each episode, and as the
title of the piece itself, it is not in Silvestri’s libretto. Whitacre structures this piece into
three episodes, each designated by the opening frame text “Leonardo dreams of his flying
machine.” The form of the piece is given below in Table 3.1.
Table 3.1: Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine Form Chart
Episode I Episode II Episode III Measures 1 – 51
Opening Frame: mm. 1-8 Measures 52 – 97
Opening Frame: mm. 52-57 Measures 98 – 154
Opening Frame: 98-101
The first opening frame, measures 1-8, does provide a preview of a musical
motive that will be used throughout the piece, that of chain suspensions. The opening
frame of Episode I is shown below in Example 3.1, with the chain suspensions occurring
between the first and second sopranos and measures 2-4.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
Example 3.1: Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine; Episode I Opening Frame
Leonardo Da Vinci lived from 1452-1519, which places him in the Renaissance
period of history. At this time musically, these chain suspensions were a very common 38
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
39
compositional device, what we refer to today as fourth-species counterpoint. Polyphony
was also the predominant musical texture of the period, and there are many instances of
polyphonic imitation in this piece, which will be discussed further below. Both of these
devices are used by Whitacre to bring the listener into the world of Leonardo, into the
historical period of the Renaissance.
In his notes for Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine, Whitacre says that he
and Silvestri “approached the piece as if we were writing an opera bréve.”31 With this in
mind, each of the aforementioned episodes could also be considered acts. Within each
act there are three scenes: scene one, which is the opening frame of each act; scene two,
which focuses on Leonardo himself, playing out his torment; and scene three, which
focuses on the call of the air, the voice that is acting as Leonardo’s tormentor. A more
detailed form chart which breaks down each act into its scenes, is given below in Table
3.2.
31 Leonardo score notes.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
40
Table 3.2: Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine Detailed Form Chart
Act 1 Act 2 Act 3 Opening Frame
Leonardo The Call Opening Frame
Leonardo The Call Opening Frame
Leonardo The Call/ Flight
mm. 1-8 mm. 9-30 mm. 31-51 mm. 52-57 mm. 58-80 mm. 81-97 mm. 98-102 mm. 102-115 mm. 116-154
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
41
Each act depicts the progression of Leonardo’s struggle with the call to enable a man fly.
Act I generally serves as an introduction, simply stating that Leonardo has begun to be
tormented by these dreams and visions of flight, and we, as the audience, first hear the
call that torments him. It is in this first Call scene that we are introduced to the Call
theme, which consists of E4 up to F4 up to Bb4 down to A4, is shown below in Example
3.2, along with its embellishments found in the first Call scene.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
Example 3.2: Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine Call Theme
In the second act, Leonardo has moved beyond simply dreaming of flight to
actually beginning to experiment with it. He observes pigeons in flight, pondering how
their wings could be adapted to serve a human being. These experiments are set with
42
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
ascending scalar figures in eighth notes, followed by descending longer note values. This
passage is shown below in Example 3.3.
Example 3.3a: Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine, Pigeons in Flight
43
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
Example 3.3b: Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine, Pigeons in Flight
These ascending scales and descending leaps depict the pigeons flying away and
either landing on a distant perch or falling out of the sky in exhaustion, the two aspects of
flying that Leonardo is trying to understand. This passage is almost the entire Leonardo
44
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
45
scene in Act II, and is an excellent representation of Whitacre’s text-driven compositional
style: all of the musical material for the entire section is derived from text painting.
In the next scene the call continues, using musical material that foreshadows the
final call scene, the scene in which Leonardo has triumphed. The instances of “la-la-la”
from the second call scene are used in the flight section. Measures 92-97 contain chain
suspensions, as shown below in Example 3.4. These suspensions relate back to the
original opening frame, and the word “wing” is set to short ascending melodic figures,
which relate back to the pigeons a few measures earlier and forward to the flight section.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
Example 3.4a: Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine Measures 92-97
46
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
Example 3.4b: Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine Measures 92-97
The third act opens with the opening frame, but in a different way from the
previous two. In the previous two acts, the opening frame is entirely musically separate
from the following Leonardo scene. In the third act, however, the altos begin the
Leonardo scene before the other voices have finished the opening frame. The altos begin
47
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
48
on the word “bong” as a representation of the “midnight watchtower tolls.” This
alteration of the relationship between the opening frame and Leonardo scene alerts the
audience to the fact that this act will be different from the previous two, and it is indeed.
It is this act in which the structural downbeat occurs, the unified climax of the music and
the story. The Leonardo-centric scene depicts the tortured genius preparing to test his
new flying machine. He is apprehensive, however, as shown by him “steeling himself”
and taking “one last breath.” This apprehension is depicted musically by the alternation
between duple and triple metrical groupings, as shown in Example 3.5 below.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
Example 3.5: Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine, Measures 107-110
49
The structural downbeat occurs in the first beat of measure 116 on the word
“leaps.” This single word represents the culmination of the entire narrative of the piece.
For three acts we have seen Leonardo growing more and more tormented by this idea of
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
50
flight, by this call for a man to come to the sky. He paces, thinks, experiments, sketches,
and finally leaps. This is the ultimate test of his genius, to use himself as the final
experiment; thus, this moment serves as the climax of the text, and the structural
downbeat of the piece. Even though the chord prior to “leaps” is far more dissonant and
tense, it is the release of this tension in A-major chord of leaps that represents the final
act of answering the call; the tension of the chord prior represents Leonardo’s hesitation
and nervousness, and “leaps” is him overcoming those feelings to take the leap and
answer the call. However, there is a slight problem with this musically, and that is the
final Call scene. In the score, this final scene is given a separate name, “The Flight
Section.” This section serves as a representation of the excitement Leonardo feels during
his first successful flight, the relief that he was finally able to answer the call. This
section does not contradict the structural downbeat, but in fact enhances it, spins it out.
The flight section serves to prolong the structural downbeat. Whitacre uses nonsense
syllables for the text of the Flight section. Musically, he gives this section fast, driving
rhythms, syncopation, soaring melodies and chain suspensions. The only line of actual
text Whitacre uses in this section is “Leonardo volare” which means “Leonardo fly.” This
all combines to create a very exciting section to represent Leonardo’s first flight, his
victory of the desirable order over the undesirable one. Without Leonardo’s leap of faith
this flight would never have happened, which is why leaps is the structural downbeat, and
the Flight section serves as a prolongation there of. This prolongation does not end until
measure 154, at which point the voices begin to repeat material until they eventually fade
to nothing. The men’s voices even fade to a [∫] sound to represent nothing but wind. This
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
51
final repetitious section is the “feminine” ending, allowing the energy of the flight section
to dissipate. A structural diagram of the piece is shown below in Table 3.3.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
52
Table 3.3: Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine Structural Diagram
Act One Opeing Frame
Act One Leonardo
Act One Call
Act Two Opening Frame
Act Two Leonardo
Act Two Call
Act Three Opening Frame
Act Three Leonardo
Act Three “Leaps”
and Flight Section
Repetitious end of Flight
Section ↑ / ∪ ↑ / ∪ ↑ / \ ↓
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
Whitacre’s opening frames not only help to determine the piece’s form, they also
serve to introduce musical material that will be used later in the piece. As mentioned
before, that musical material is chain suspensions. The instances of chain suspensions
that have not already been discussed will be shown in the following examples. Example
3.6 shows chain suspensions between Alto and Soprano in measures 59-61, and a single
suspension between Soprano I and II in measure 62. Example 3.7 shows chain
suspensions between the two Soprano soloists that are then doubled by the Soprano I and
II of the chorus. Example 3.8 shows chain suspensions between Tenors and Basses. All
of these chain suspensions link back to the first opening frame, in which the Soprano I
and II have three measures of chain suspensions. This link back to the beginning helps to
provide musical continuity for Leonardo.
Example 3.6: Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine, Measures 59-62; Soprano I
and II and Alto chain suspensions
53
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
Example 3.7: Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine, Measures 147-149; Soprano
Soloists and Soprano I and II chain suspensions
Example 3.8: Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine Measure 149; Basses and Tenors chain suspensions
54
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
55
Chapter 4
A Boy and a Girl
A Boy and a Girl was published in 2004 and is written for a cappella SATB
chorus and is a setting of a poem by Octavio Paz. The poem tells the story of the love
between a boy and a girl, a love that grows and lasts, even until death. It is this love and
loss that Whitacre relays to the audience through his unique style.
The poem includes three verses, which appear in Example 4.1.
Stretched out, stretched out on the grass a boy and a girl savoring their oranges giving their kisses like waves exchanging foam. Stretched out, stretched out on the beach a boy and a girl savoring their limes giving their kisses like clouds exchanging foam. Stretched out, stretched out underground a boy and a girl saying nothing never kissing giving silence for silence32
The narrative of A Boy and a Girl falls under archetype of Irony, which describes
the “suppression or removal of a pre-existent order, resulting in an undesirable condition,
whether chaos or a differently-valued order.”33 One would expect a poem depicting the
death of a loving couple to fall under the archetype of Tragedy, but this poem makes
32 A Boy and a Girl complete text 33 Almén, 30.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
56
more sense if understood as Irony. The love the boy and girl share, a love that grows
from verse one to verse two, is the pre-existent order described in the archetype. That
order is then removed in verse three when we discover that the boy and girl are now dead,
their relationship ended, thus creating the new undesirable condition. This removal to
create a new, undesirable world is what the sonorities Whitacre employs are designed to
accentuate. The dissonance created with these added note sonorities and unrelated tertian
chords foreshadow this victory of the undesirable over the desirable.
The exact form of the piece, including measure numbers, is shown below in Table
4.1.
Table 4.1: A Boy and a Girl, Form Chart
Verse 1 Verse 2 Verse 3 Coda mm 1-13 mm 14-27 mm 28-43 mm 44-52
The musical structure basically reflects the text. In addition, Whitacre also adds a
coda, which borrows musical material from the first verse. The coda will be addressed in
greater detail later in this chapter.
It has been discussed previously in this paper that Whitacre uses a style that is at
once very tertian and very triadic, but also uses added notes for color and relates the
triads in non-tonal ways. In his dissertation, Andrew Larson argues that Whitacre’s music
is tonal and provides roman numeral analyses to reinforce this claim. However, his
analyses contain labels that make no sense in a tonal framework. For example, he will
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
57
,
n
em
s
chapter.
label chords as two separate sonorities combined, such as “i+ii64”34, and he will use
labels that make little sense in a tonal framework, like “VI6”35 in a major key. A six
chord will naturally be minor (vi) in a major key and could only be major if it is a bVI
derived from modal mixture. The VI label can only be understood as a nondiatonic chord
and is best explained as a nonfunctional V/iii that does not add to a tonal framework
because of its nonfunctionality. All of these things lead me to believe that Whitacre is a
atonal, but primarily tertian, composer. A Boy and a Girl is probably the most striking
example of this: most of the vertical sonorities can be named in terms of a triad with an
added note, but they do not relate to one another in a tonal way. However, not all of th
can be easily labeled as a traditional tertian harmony. Because of this, it is possible to
discuss each sonority, not only as a triad with an added note, but also as a member of a
set class. In Table 4.2 below, each vertical sonority is listed as a set class and also by its
traditional tertian name. Example 4.1 shows these sonorities within the context of the
first verse of the piece. I believe that these sonorities are, when possible, best realized a
triads with added notes for reasons of large-scale text painting, which will be discussed
later. For ease of discussion, they will be referred to as both within this
34 Andrew Lloyd Larson, Textual and harmonic density in selected choral works (1992-2003) by Eric Whitare (Ann Arbor: UMI, 2004). 35 Larson, 84.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
58
Table 4.2: A Boy and a Girl, Tertian/Set Class Chart
Tertian Label Set Class
Major triad with an added 2 (0247)
Incomplete minor-minor seventh chord (025)
Major Triad (037)
Major triad with added Lydian 4 (0137)
Major triad with added 4 (0237)
Minor triad with added 2 (0237)
Minor triad with added 4 (0247)
Quartal tetrachord (0257)
Major minor seventh chord (0258)
Major triad with added 2 and Lydian 4 (01357)
Major minor seventh chord with added 2 (02469)
Major major seventh chord with added 2 (01358)
Quintal trichord (027)
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
Example 4.1a: A Boy and a Girl, Verse 1; vertical sonorities labeled as set classes
59
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
Example 4.2b: A Boy and a Girl, Verse 1; vertical sonorities labeled as set classes
60
Each stanza of the poem begins with the words “Stretched out,” and it is this text
that Whitacre chooses to set as the opening frame. The opening frame functions as the
introduction to each new verse of text, and also the opening of the coda. He sets the
frame of each verse with a sonority based on C, Eb, and F, the qualities of which are used
to prepare the mood of each specific verse. In verses one and two, all three of the triads
are major with an added second above the root, or set class (0247). In the third verse,
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
however, the C and F sonorities shift from major triads with added seconds above the
root to minor triads with added seconds above the root, set class (0237), in order to
foreshadow the death of the boy and girl in verse three. The coda also begins with (0247)
based on C, Eb, and F, but since the entire coda is sung on a hum, the text of the frame is
omitted. The opening frames from verses one and two, verse three, and the coda are
shown below.
Example 4.2: A Boy and a Girl, Verse 1 and 2 opening frame
61
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
Example 4.3: A Boy and a Girl, Verse 3 opening frame
Example 4.4: A Boy and a Girl, Coda opening frame
As mentioned earlier, the harmonic language of the piece is very tertian. Despite
this, a single tonal framework, or even a single diatonic collection cannot connect the
vertical sonorities. The triads with added notes are actually used as a form of text
62
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
63
painting, on a level specific to the poem and also on a more general level. In Western
classical music, the triad is one of the most fundamental musical harmonies. It is this
basic sonority that is used to represent one of the most basic and primal of human
emotions, love. But Whitacre does not use pure triads: the added notes create a
dissonance in almost every chord, which taints their purity. Whitacre uses this to
possibly represent the risk one takes when he or she falls in love.
These same ideas are used to provide specific text painting in A Boy and a Girl.
Again, the triads represent their love, a love that grows from verse one to verse two. In
the third verse, however, we learn that the boy and girl have died; they are now “stretched
out underground.” Despite their love, they cannot stay together forever. This is what the
dissonances formed by the added-note sonorities throughout the piece represent and
foreshadow. This is made very apparent by examining the C and F sonorities of the
opening frame. In the frames for verses one, two, and the coda, the added pitches of D
and G form whole step dissonances against the E and A in the C and F sonorities
respectively. In the third verse, the E becomes an Eb and the A becomes an Ab in the C
and F sonority respectively in the shift from (0247) to (0237), from a major triad with an
added major second above the root to a minor triad with an added major second above the
root. This changes the dissonance from a whole step to a half step, a sound which is far
more striking. This dissonance, along with the altered quality of the C and F sonorities,
the shift from (0247) to (0237), represents the death of the boy and girl. The coda is sung
all on a hum to represent the silence that is the only thing left for the boy and girl to
exchange. One would expect that the opening frame of the coda to also contain (0237),
since the boy and girl are still dead. Despite this expectation, Whitacre reverts back to
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
64
(0247), and there are two reasons for this. The first is that the coda repeats selections
from the first verse, including (0247) originally found in the opening frame.
The second reason relates back to the fact that love is one of humanity’s
most enduring qualities. Despite the fact that the boy and girl are dead, their love will
live on in the memories of their friends and family. Their love will also live on at a
spiritual level that transcends the sharing of oranges and limes. On this large scale, the
piece actually departs from the narrative of the poem, that of the Irony archetype. The
poem itself ends with verse three; the coda is Whitacre’s own addition. It seems that
Whitacre has chosen to usurp the archetype and end on an idea of hope. Even though the
love of a single couple will not endure, the undesirable will defeat the desirable on a
small scale, love itself will never be defeated, and the desirable will never truly be
defeated on a large scale.
Since Whitacre set a poem that deals with love, each verse can be seen as a
separate period in the relationship between the boy and girl. The first verse represents
them at an early stage of their relationship. Dynamically, the first verse resides in the p-
mp range, reaching a climax of mf only twice, once in measure three, and again in
measure 9. The boy is portrayed as (0247), realized as an Ab-Major triad with an added
Bb, at a piano dynamic, while girl is also portrayed as (0247), but realized as an F-Major
triad with an added G, at a mezzo-piano dynamic; both the boy and girl are set to a
simple SATB voicing, as shown below in Example 4.5.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
Example 4.5: A Boy and a Girl, Boy and girl in verse one
The giving of kisses is set with a single quarter note triplet in measure 9, as
shown below in Example 4.6; the triplet is a delicate rhythm, used to show the tenderness
of said kisses.
65
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
Example 4.6: A Boy and a Girl, Measures 8-10; kisses from Verse I
Verse two can be seen as a depiction of the evolution and maturation of their love.
This can only be understood after one examines and looks at verse one in retrospect, just
as people can only understand the evolution of their own love in hindsight. This growth
generally occurs by going through hardship in one’s relationship, an idea that is
represented, as mentioned earlier, by the added notes creating dissonances in the triads
throughout the piece. Dynamically, the second verse is much more dramatic than verse
one, residing primarily within mp-mf range, with a dynamic climax of f in measure 16.
Here, the boy is portrayed as (0237), realized as a C-Major triad with an added F, set at a
mezzo-piano dynamic, and girl is portrayed as (0247), realized as an A-Major triad with
an added B, set at a mezzo-forte dynamic. In this verse, both the boy and girl are written
in SSAATTBB voicing, as shown below in Example 4.7.
66
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
Example 4.7: A Boy and a Girl, Boy and girl from verse two
From verse one to verse two, the boy and girl have evolved and developed both
dynamically, as each one is one dynamic marking louder, and texturally, each having
double the voicing. The intervallic range of each has also increased. In verse one, the
boy only covered an octave and a major third, but in verse two the boy covers two
octaves and a major second. In verse one, the girl also covered a single octave plus a
major third, compared to verse two where she covers two octaves and a perfect fifth, a
much greater range. The actual sonorities, realized as triads (without their added notes),
used to represent the boy and girl in verses one and two, show the evolution of their
relationship. In verse one, the boy is realized as an Ab-Major triad with an added Bb, and
the girl is realized as an F-Major triad with an added G, two triads that are a major sixth
apart. In the second verse, the boy and girl are realized with a C-Major triad with an
added F and an A-Major triad with an added B, respectively. These two chords are also
related by a major sixth, and each is related to the respective chord from verse one by one
67
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
major third higher. This increased span of the chord parallels the increase in dynamic
level and voicing from verse one to verse two, all of which combine to articulate the
growth of the love between the boy and girl from verse one to verse two. The kisses they
share in verse two are more tender than in verse one, being set with two triplets as
opposed to one, as shown below in Example 4.8.
Example 4.8: A Boy and a Girl, Kisses from Verse 2
In verse three, we find that the boy and girl are now dead, the inevitable end of all
earthly relationships. As mentioned before, this is first acknowledged by the shift from
(0247) to (0237) for the C and F sonority in the opening frame of the verse. The poem
states that they are now “stretched out underground” and Whitacre depicts this with
descending melodic motives for this text. In verses one and two, the boy and girl were
stretched out on the grass and on the beach respectively, and the musical material
expanded outward both in range and dynamics, with verse two more developed than
68
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
verse one. Verse three has all the voice parts descending into the lower parts of their
range, and decrescendoing from p to pp. Dynamically, this is the quietest of all the
verses, with the dynamic range of pp to mf, but staying around the piano range for most
of the verse. For the first time, the boy and girl are represented by musical material that
is unrecognizable as a distinct chord. The boy is represented by a F-G-A-B-C tone
cluster, set class (01357), set to a dynamic of piano, and the girl can be seen as a D-F#-A-
C-E tone cluster, which is set class (02469). The girl is set at a dynamic of piano as well,
and both the boy and girl have the voice parts in the lower part of their registers as well.
The boy and girl from verse three are shown below in Example 4.9.
Example 4.9: A Boy and a Girl, Boy and girl from verse 3
At this point in the previous two verses the boy and girl are depicted as savoring
fruit together, oranges in verse one and lime in verse two. They then kiss, and the kisses
are compared to something light and foamy, waves in verse one and clouds in verse two.
69
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
The third verse does not follow this pattern. It is this break in the poetic form that
Whitacre chooses to make the climax of the piece. In verse three Paz writes that now the
boy and girl are “saying nothing” and “never kissing.” It could be argued that the fruit in
verses one and two could represent sweet nothings that the couple share and savor
together, which eventually lead to the kisses they give each other. In verse three, this
cannot happen, as the couple is dead. It is this idea that they will never again share an
intimate moment together that is the structural downbeat of the piece. Whitacre gives
this moment the greatest dynamic of verse three, a mezzo-forte, and the longest single
phrase of the entire piece. The sopranos and altos also have the most energetic melodies
at this point, with their parts written almost entirely in moving eighth notes. The
structural downbeat is shown below in Example 4.10.
Example 4.10: A Boy and a Girl, Structural Downbeat
70
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
71
The last poetic phrase of the verse, “giving silence for silence” is set, except for
the pickup in measure 38, entirely without discernable triads, similar to the setting of the
boy and girl at the beginning of the verse. The word silence is set with the first syllable
on an F-major plus a C-major triad, set class (01358), and the second syllable on simply a
C-G-D trichord, set class (027). This musical material is repeated three times, with the
last time sung simply on a hum. This third iteration is the transition from verse three to
the coda, which is sung entirely on a hum. Each measure of music in the coda
corresponds to a measure of music in verse one, as shown in Table 4.3 below.
Table 4.3: A Boy and a Girl, Coda/Verse 1 comparison chart
Measure of coda Measure of verse 1
45 1
46 2
47 3
48 10
49 11 (in augmentation)
50 12 and pick up there of
51 13
52 13
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
72
With verse three containing the structural downbeat of the piece, each verse prior,
and the coda after, can be seen as leading to and moving from this moment. Table 4.4
below provides a diagram of this motion.
Table 4.4: A Boy and a Girl, Structural Chart
Verse 1 Verse 2 Verse 3 Coda
mm. 1-13 mm. 14-27 mm. 28-43 mm. 44-52
/ ∪ \ ↓
The material repeated in the coda corresponds to the beginning and end of the
verse that was the beginning and end of the love between the boy and a girl. Despite the
fact that the coda is sung on a hum to show that the boy and girl will never experience
their love again, the fact that the music harkens back to the beginning of their love tells
the listener that love itself will endure, will begin again somewhere new with a new boy
and a new girl. Again, it is this coda that breaks free from the archetype, allowing the
listener to hope for love that will come again; the undesirable order may win the battle,
but the desirable order will win the war.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
73
Chapter 5
Conclusion and Directions for Further Research
Despite exhibiting a relative absence of a unifying tonal framework, Eric
Whitacre’s choral music can be understood as unique and unified through the application
of concepts such as internal framing, structural downbeat, and narrative archetypes. Such
techniques definitely provide insight into his compositional choices.. These devices are
flexible enough to adapt to each individual piece, as we saw in the three pieces analyzed
in this thesis, When David Heard, Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine, and A Boy
and a Girl. Each piece contained all the elements mentioned above, but each was used in
a different way to reinforce the narrative archetype and mood of the piece.
In When David Heard, Whitacre employs a distinct opening and closing frame to
set off the body of the piece in which he presents the grief associated with this tragic
narrative. Musically, Whitacre portrays grief with disjunct melodic lines, large cluster
harmonies, and duple against triple metrical groupings. The structural downbeat is set
apart from the body of the piece with unified duple metrical groupings, and it is here that
the text of the piece is finally completed.
In Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine, Whitacre uses text painting to create
entire scenes in this opera-bréve-like piece. Whitacre uses an opening frame of a
consistent text to begin each act, and each act brings us closer to the victory of the desired
over the undesired in this romantic archetype. This victory occurs at the structural
downbeat, where we see Leonardo taking a literal leap of faith to answer the call of the
air he has been tormented by for the entire piece. Whitacre also uses imitation and chain
suspensions to hearken the listener back to da Vinci’s Renaissance.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
74
In A Boy and a Girl, which is an example of the Irony archetype, Whitacre uses
an opening frame of identical text to begin each of the three verses, and uses the
sonorities of the opening frame to indicate the mood of each verse. In verses one and two
the boy and girl are in love and that loves grows. Verse three finds the boy and girl dead,
and the structural downbeat is here when we realize that they will never again share in
their love. The coda of this piece is unique of all the pieces examined in this thesis, since
Whitacre uses the coda to provide a last glimmer of hope, to suggest to the listener that
love will never die. This is contrary to the archetype, and shows that the composer is
always allowed to provide his own take on an archetypal text.
Further Research
This thesis examined only a small portion of Eric Whitacre’s a cappella choral
works, to say nothing of his accompanied choral and instrumental works. I believe that
internal framing, narrative archetypes, and a structural downbeat will be found in the
majority, if not all, of Whitacre’s choral works, but it would be worth investigating how
they are employed in each piece to gain a better understanding of his compositional style.
Whether or not his instrumental works contain these elements remains to be seen; of
particular interest would if Whitacre tries to employ narrative archetypes in his
instrumental works.
This project also bears consequence on the music of other triadic/tertian post-
tonal composers. The devices employed by Whitacre are not widely known theoretical
devices, but they allow Whitacre’s music to be understood on a deeper level, both
musically and structurally. I hope this thesis provides other theorists the motivation to
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
75
examine other tertian post-tonal composers in nontraditional ways to help build a
repository of tools for this style of music.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
76
Works Cited
Almén, Byron. Spring, 2003. Narrative Archetypes: A Critique, Theory, and Method of Narrative Analysis. Journal of Music Theory, Vol. 47, No. 1: 1-39.
Cooke, Mervyn. 1993. Britten and Shakespeare: Dramatic and Musical Cohesion in
‘A Midsummer Night’s Dream.’ Music and Letters, Vol. 74, No. 2: 246-68.
Cone, Edward T. 1968. Musical Form and Musical Performance. New York, NY: W. W. Norton.
Eric Whitacre Homepage, “Biography,” http://www.ericwhitacre.com.
Jones, Douglas Loyd. 2000. Aspects of textual treatment in Benjamin Britten’s
unaccompanied choral music with commentary on the history and meaning of the text. Ann Arbor, MI: University Microfilms International.
Larson, Andrew Lloyd. 2004. Textural and harmonic density in selected choral works
(1992-2003) by Eric Whitacre. Ann Arbor, MI: University Microfilms International.
Paetsch, Annabelle. 1998. Aspects of Narrativity and Temporality in Britten’s
‘Winter Words.’ Music and Letters, Vol. 79, No. 4: 538-54.
Whitacre, Eric. “Talk-back Session.” Session, annual meeting of the Texas Music Educators Association, San Antonio, TX, February 12-16, 2008.
Whitacre, Eric. A Boy and a Girl. Eric Whitacre, 2004. Whitacre, Eric. Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine. U.S.A.: Walton Music
Corporation, 2002. Whitacre, Eric. When David Heard. U.S.A.: Walton Music Corporation, 2000.
Texas Tech University, Taylor Johnson, May 2009
PERMISSION TO COPY
In presenting this thesis in partial fulfillment of the requirements for a master’s
degree at Texas Tech University or Texas Tech University Health Sciences Center, I
agree that the Library and my major department shall make it freely available for research
purposes. Permission to copy this thesis for scholarly purposes may be granted by the
Director of the Library or my major professor. It is understood that any copying or
publication of this thesis for financial gain shall not be allowed without my further
written permission and that any user may be liable for copyright infringement.
Agree (Permission is granted.)
_Taylor Johnson_________________________________ ___4/1/09_________ Student Signature Date Disagree (Permission is not granted.) _______________________________________________ _________________ Student Signature Date