te i 1n s . – a o weeks received f in. during s e all kind of ts w ere. s t / g) – ts
TRANSCRIPT
A S
I A
P A
C I
F I C
N
E T
W O
R K
I
N F
O R
M A
T I
O N
C
E N
T R
E
APN
IC U
pdat
eA
RIN
VIII
Mia
mi,
28-3
1 O
ctob
er, 2
001
A S
I A
P A
C I
F I C
N
E T
W O
R K
I
N F
O R
M A
T I
O N
C
E N
T R
E
Ove
rvie
w
●
Mem
bers
hip
& R
esou
rce
Sta
tistic
s●
Ser
vice
Dev
elop
men
ts●
Pol
icy
Dev
elop
men
ts●
Que
stio
ns
A S
I A
P A
C I
F I C
N
E T
W O
R K
I
N F
O R
M A
T I
O N
C
E N
T R
E
How
man
y A
PN
IC M
embe
rs?
A S
I A
P A
C I
F I C
N
E T
W O
R K
I
N F
O R
M A
T I
O N
C
E N
T R
E
How
man
y IP
v4 A
lloca
tions
?
A S
I A
P A
C I
F I C
N
E T
W O
R K
I
N F
O R
M A
T I
O N
C
E N
T R
E
Whe
re a
re IP
v4 A
lloca
tions
?
Millions
A S
I A
P A
C I
F I C
N
E T
W O
R K
I
N F
O R
M A
T I
O N
C
E N
T R
E
IPv6
Allo
catio
ns –
Dis
tribu
tion
Tota
l: 40
Allo
catio
ns
A S
I A
P A
C I
F I C
N
E T
W O
R K
I
N F
O R
M A
T I
O N
C
E N
T R
E
AS
N A
lloca
tions
- To
tal
A S
I A
P A
C I
F I C
N
E T
W O
R K
I
N F
O R
M A
T I
O N
C
E N
T R
E
AS
N A
lloca
tions
- D
istri
butio
n
A S
I A
P A
C I
F I C
N
E T
W O
R K
I
N F
O R
M A
T I
O N
C
E N
T R
E
APN
IC U
pdat
e
Ser
vice
Dev
elop
men
ts
A S
I A
P A
C I
F I C
N
E T
W O
R K
I
N F
O R
M A
T I
O N
C
E N
T R
E
Ser
vice
Dev
elop
men
ts
●Tr
aini
ng●
8 co
urse
s in
200
0, 1
per
mon
th d
urin
g 20
01●
Pla
n to
dou
ble
cour
ses
in 2
002
●“E
xpre
ssio
ns o
f Int
eres
t” m
ay b
e su
bmitt
ed●
AP
NIC
Sem
inar
s●
Ope
n ev
ents
hel
d in
mos
t tra
inin
g lo
catio
ns●
ICA
NN
/Gov
erna
nce
sem
inar
s w
ith A
PTL
D●
Exp
andi
ng o
utre
ach
with
oth
er A
P*
orgs
●A
ll ac
tiviti
es s
ubsi
dise
d by
AP
NIC
A S
I A
P A
C I
F I C
N
E T
W O
R K
I
N F
O R
M A
T I
O N
C
E N
T R
E
Ser
vice
Dev
elop
men
ts
●In
tern
et R
outin
g R
egis
try (I
RR
)●
Wor
k w
ith R
IPE
NC
C o
n v3
sof
twar
e●
Test
ing
and
trans
ition
pla
nnin
g un
derw
ay●
IRR
ope
ratin
g m
odel
to b
e de
velo
ped
●Tr
aini
ng m
ater
ials
to b
e de
velo
ped
●D
istri
bute
d se
rvic
e ar
chite
ctur
e●
PO
Ps
in m
ajor
exc
hang
e po
ints
●M
odel
und
er d
evel
opm
ent
A S
I A
P A
C I
F I C
N
E T
W O
R K
I
N F
O R
M A
T I
O N
C
E N
T R
E
Ser
vice
Dev
elop
men
ts
●In
tern
al S
ervi
ces
●R
e-ar
chite
ctur
e an
d co
ntin
ual i
mpr
ovem
ent
●S
usta
ined
(and
sus
tain
able
) sta
ff gr
owth
●IS
O c
ertif
icat
ion
bein
g co
nsid
ered
●P
ublic
atio
ns●
Web
site
rede
sign
rece
ntly
com
plet
ed●
Join
t RIR
sta
ts p
ublic
atio
n●
1st Q
uarte
rly n
ewsl
ette
r lau
nche
d in
Tai
pei
A S
I A
P A
C I
F I C
N
E T
W O
R K
I
N F
O R
M A
T I
O N
C
E N
T R
E
Ser
vice
Dev
elop
men
ts
●C
ertif
icat
ion
Aut
horit
y●
Res
pons
e to
mem
ber c
once
rns
on s
ecur
ity●
Em
ail,
web
site
aut
h* a
nd p
rivac
y●
Indu
stry
-sta
ndar
d X
.509
cer
tific
ates
●Tr
ial c
ertif
icat
es b
eing
issu
ed n
ow●
“MyA
PN
IC” w
ebsi
te●
Acc
ess
to m
embe
rs’ p
rivat
e in
form
atio
n●
Use
of c
ertif
icat
es fo
r sec
ured
acc
ess
A S
I A
P A
C I
F I C
N
E T
W O
R K
I
N F
O R
M A
T I
O N
C
E N
T R
E
MyA
PN
IC: A
ssig
nmen
t Gra
ph
A S
I A
P A
C I
F I C
N
E T
W O
R K
I
N F
O R
M A
T I
O N
C
E N
T R
E
MyA
PN
IC: A
ssig
nmen
t Tab
le
A S
I A
P A
C I
F I C
N
E T
W O
R K
I
N F
O R
M A
T I
O N
C
E N
T R
E
MyA
PN
IC: E
dit P
rofil
e
A S
I A
P A
C I
F I C
N
E T
W O
R K
I
N F
O R
M A
T I
O N
C
E N
T R
E
APN
IC U
pdat
e
Pol
icy
Dev
elop
men
ts
A S
I A
P A
C I
F I C
N
E T
W O
R K
I
N F
O R
M A
T I
O N
C
E N
T R
E
Pol
icy
Dev
elop
men
ts
●C
riter
ia fo
r ini
tial ‘
porta
ble’
allo
catio
n●
Use
d a
/22
from
ups
tream
OR
●D
emon
stra
te im
med
iate
nee
d fo
r a /2
2A
ND
●S
how
det
aile
d pl
an fo
r use
of a
/21
with
in a
year
●A
gree
to re
num
ber w
ithin
one
yea
r●
Com
plie
d w
ith p
olic
ies
in p
ast (
if ap
plic
able
)
A S
I A
P A
C I
F I C
N
E T
W O
R K
I
N F
O R
M A
T I
O N
C
E N
T R
E
Pol
icy
Dev
elop
men
ts
●P
orta
ble
smal
l mul
tihom
ing
assi
gnm
ent p
olic
y●
App
lican
t mus
t be
mul
tihom
ed w
ith p
rovi
der
base
d ad
dres
ses
OR
●D
emon
stra
te a
pla
n to
mul
tihom
e w
ithin
one
mon
thA
ND
●A
gree
to re
num
ber o
ut o
f pre
viou
sly
assi
gned
spac
e●
Eva
luat
ion
acco
rdin
g to
rfc2
050
A S
I A
P A
C I
F I C
N
E T
W O
R K
I
N F
O R
M A
T I
O N
C
E N
T R
E
Pol
icy
Dev
elop
men
ts
●IP
v4 A
ssig
nmen
ts to
Exc
hang
e P
oint
s●
Min
imum
/24
for t
he IX
P tra
nsit
LAN
●B
ut n
ot to
“crit
ical
infra
stru
ctur
e”●
IPv6
Ass
ignm
ents
to E
xcha
nge
Poi
nts
●A
ssig
nmen
t siz
e /6
4●
Ext
ensi
on o
f IP
v6 b
oots
trap
perio
d●
Unt
il th
e ne
xt IP
v6 p
olic
y is
impl
emen
ted,
on
the
unde
rsta
ndin
g th
at th
e ne
xt p
olic
y ta
kes
acco
unt o
fbo
otst
rapp
ing
need
s●
New
IPv6
pol
icy
prin
cipl
es●
To b
e pr
esen
ted
at m
eetin
g…
A S
I A
P A
C I
F I C
N
E T
W O
R K
I
N F
O R
M A
T I
O N
C
E N
T R
E
Pol
icy
Dev
elop
men
ts
●B
road
band
WG
●‘B
oots
trapp
ing
proc
ess’
for e
valu
atio
n of
CM
TS●
/24
to b
e as
sign
ed fo
r eve
ry C
MTS
●P
urpo
se to
sim
plify
eva
luat
ion
and
requ
est p
roce
ss●
Eve
ry n
etw
ork
assi
gnm
ent g
reat
er th
an /3
0 m
ust b
ere
gist
ered
●IS
P te
chni
cal c
onta
ct c
an b
e ad
min
-c fo
r res
iden
tial
netw
orks
●Fu
rther
dis
cuss
ion
●2n
d op
inio
n fo
r ass
ignm
ents
> /3
0●
Sup
plyi
ng c
usto
mer
list
s in
eva
luat
ion
proc
ess
A S
I A
P A
C I
F I C
N
E T
W O
R K
I
N F
O R
M A
T I
O N
C
E N
T R
E
Pol
icy
Dev
elop
men
ts
●M
embe
rshi
p vo
ted
for
●N
ew m
embe
rshi
p ag
reem
ent
●D
ocum
ent r
evie
w p
olic
y●
Rev
ised
mem
bers
hip
stru
ctur
e●
New
non
-res
ourc
e “a
ssoc
iate
” cat
egor
y, w
ith v
otin
grig
hts
●N
ew “v
ery
smal
l” fo
r up
to /2
2●
New
“x-la
rge”
for g
reat
er th
an /1
0●
Add
ress
Cou
ncil
elec
tion
●D
r Ken
ny H
uang
(TW
) ele
cted
●Fu
ll de
tails
at
●ht
tp://
ww
w.a
pnic
.net
/mee
tings
/12/
resu
lts/
A S
I A
P A
C I
F I C
N
E T
W O
R K
I
N F
O R
M A
T I
O N
C
E N
T R
E
New
est m
embe
r of A
P co
mm
unity
A S
I A
P A
C I
F I C
N
E T
W O
R K
I
N F
O R
M A
T I
O N
C
E N
T R
E
APN
IC U
pdat
e
Questions?
ARIN
VIII
Miam
i , FL
Octo
ber
2001
G
erm
án V
alde
zLA
CNIC
’s In
terim
Boa
rd
LAC
NIC
STA
TU
S
http://www.lacnic.org
Wor
k bas
ed o
n: Cr
iteria
for E
stabli
shm
ent o
f New
Reg
ional
Inte
rnet
Reg
istrie
s Doc
umen
t. AS
O M
oU.
ICAN
N IC
P-2
RFC
2050
, RFC
191
8, R
FC 1
930,
etc.
http://www.lacnic.org
Th
e re
gion
of co
vera
ge sh
ould
mee
t the
scale
to b
e de
fined
by I
CANN
, give
n th
ene
ed to
avo
id glo
bal a
ddre
ss fr
agm
enta
tion.
Cove
rage
:La
tin-A
mer
ican
coun
tries.
LACN
IC O
pera
tiona
l Cen
ter:
Sa
n Pa
ulo, B
razil
. Th
e es
tabli
shm
ent o
f this
uniq
ue R
IR in
our
regio
n cle
arly
will a
void:
➢Fr
agm
enta
tion
of a
ddre
ss sp
ace
alloc
ated
to o
ur re
gion;
➢Di
fficult
y for
coor
dinat
ion a
nd o
pera
tion
betw
een
the
RIR;
➢Av
oid co
nfus
ion fo
r the
com
mun
ity w
ithin
our r
egion
.
EMER
GING
RIR
s DO
CUM
ENT
http://www.lacnic.org
The
new
RIR
mus
t dem
onst
rate
that
it h
as th
e br
oad
supp
ort o
f the
LIR
s (IS
Pco
mm
unity
) in
the
prop
osed
regi
on.
Supp
ortin
g Le
tter a
t LAC
NIC
webs
ite ➢
151
indi
vidua
l sup
ports
.➢
108
Com
pani
es.
➢16
Cou
ntrie
s. *T
he b
road
sup
port
of th
e LI
R (IS
P co
mm
unity
) for
the
LACN
IC re
gion
will
be d
uly
docu
men
ted
and
pres
ente
d du
ring
the
cour
se o
f the
ARI
N/LA
CNIC
tran
sitio
n pl
anim
plem
enta
tion.
EMER
GING
RIR
s DO
CUM
ENT
http://www.lacnic.org
Botto
m-u
p se
lf-go
vern
ance
stru
ctur
e fo
r set
ting
loca
l pol
icies
. Ac
cord
ing
to M
oU w
e m
ust e
stab
lish
mec
hani
sm fo
r ope
n fo
rum
s fo
r reg
iona
lpo
licie
s di
scus
sion.
Emai
l list
s at
LAC
NIC
webs
ite.
Loca
l mee
tings
in d
iffere
nt c
ount
ries.
In D
ecem
ber 6
th 2
000
Buen
os A
ires,
Arg
entin
e we
had
our
firs
t op
en re
gion
alfo
rum
for L
ACNI
C po
licie
s di
scus
sion.
Mor
e th
an 1
00 p
artic
ipan
ts.
Nove
mbe
r 28t
h 20
01, s
econ
d LA
CNIC
’s op
en re
gion
al fo
rum
. Sao
Pau
lo,
Braz
il.
EMER
GING
RIR
s DO
CUM
ENT
http://www.lacnic.org
Neut
rality
and
impa
rtial
ity in
rela
tion
to a
ll int
eres
ted
parti
es a
nd p
artic
ular
ly th
eLI
Rs LA
CNIC
is in
corp
orat
ed a
s an
inde
pend
ent,
not-f
or-p
rofit
and
ope
n bo
ttom
-up
mem
bers
hip
orga
niza
tion,
as
defin
ed in
our
byla
ws
EMER
GING
RIR
s DO
CUM
ENT
http://www.lacnic.org
Tech
nica
l Exp
ertis
e In
the
star
t-up,
sta
ff an
d in
frast
ruct
ure
will b
e pr
ovid
ed b
y NI
C-Br
azil.
Both
ARI
N’s
Natio
nal I
Rs, B
razil
and
Mex
ico, h
ave
been
invo
lved
inLA
CNIC
pol
icies
dev
elop
men
t. Fe
edba
ck re
ceive
d fro
m fi
rst o
pen
polic
y fo
rum
in B
ueno
s Ai
res.
Dec
embe
r 200
0. NI
C-Br
azil a
gree
s in
gua
rant
ee a
ll the
ope
ratio
nal r
esou
rces
for 2
year
s. RI
Rs fe
edba
ck a
nd s
uppo
rt.
EMER
GING
RIR
s DO
CUM
ENT
http://www.lacnic.org
Tech
nica
l Exp
ertis
e (2
) Ap
ril 1
9th
y 20
th A
RIN
visite
d LA
CNIC
’s fa
cility
in S
ao P
aulo
in o
rder
to v
erify
infra
stru
ctur
e an
d m
ake
reco
mm
enda
tions
. LA
CNIC
’s st
aff r
ecei
ved
two
week
s of
trai
ning
in A
RIN
facil
ities
durin
gAu
gust
.
EMER
GING
RIR
s DO
CUM
ENT
http://www.lacnic.org
Adhe
renc
e to
glob
al po
licies
rega
rding
add
ress
spac
e co
nser
vatio
n,ag
greg
ation
and
regis
tratio
n. IP
v4, I
Pv6,
ASN
, Rev
erse
DNS
dele
gatio
n LA
CNIC
poli
cies a
re b
ased
on
➢ R
FC d
ocum
ents.
➢ A
PNIC
Poli
cies.
➢ A
RIN
Polic
ies➢
RIP
E Po
licies
.➢
LAC
NIC’
s Firs
t Ope
n Po
licy F
orum
feed
back
.Pa
rticipa
tion
in all
thre
e RI
R m
embe
rs m
eetin
gs.
Part
of A
SO A
C as
obs
erve
rs a
nd lis
tene
rs.
EMER
GING
RIR
s DO
CUM
ENT
http://www.lacnic.org
Adhe
renc
e to
glo
bal p
olici
es re
gard
ing
addr
ess
spac
e co
nser
vatio
n,ag
greg
atio
n an
d re
gist
ratio
n. (2
) ➢
/20
min
imum
allo
catio
n. ➢
Mul
ti-ho
med
pol
icies
. ➢
IPv6
pol
icies
acc
ordi
ng R
IR re
com
men
datio
ns.
➢AS
N po
licy
base
d on
RFC
193
0.
EMER
GING
RIR
s DO
CUM
ENT
http://www.lacnic.org
Activ
ity P
lan
As fr
om th
e wo
rk m
eetin
gs b
etwe
en L
ACNI
C an
d AR
IN, a
n op
erat
ions
trans
ition
has
been
agr
eed
upon
whi
ch w
ill be
divi
ded
into
3 s
tage
s. St
age
1 –
A tw
o we
eks
train
ing
proc
ess
rece
ived
LACN
IC’s
staf
f in
ARIN
inst
alla
tions
in V
irgin
ia, U
SA. D
urin
g th
is st
age
all k
ind
of re
quire
men
tswe
re re
vised
by
both
ARI
N an
d LA
CNIC
sta
ffs to
geth
er.
EMER
GING
RIR
s DO
CUM
ENT
http
://w
ww
.lacn
ic.o
rg
Activ
ity P
lan
(2)
Stag
e 2
– In
this
stag
e, L
ACNI
C wi
ll beg
in to
rece
ive th
e re
quire
men
ts fr
om L
AC, a
ndth
ey w
ill be
eva
luat
ed b
y th
e LA
CNIC
tech
nica
l/ope
ratio
ns s
taff.
Dur
ing
this
stag
e, a
pro
cess
will
be a
pplie
d wh
ereb
y th
e AR
IN s
taff
will i
ssue
a s
econ
dte
chni
cal o
pini
on. R
ight
now
adj
ustin
g de
tails
with
ARI
N fo
r the
out
set o
f thi
sst
age.
Stag
e 3
Fina
l rec
ogni
tion
of L
ACNI
C by
ICAN
NAs
from
that
mom
ent,
LACN
IC w
ill be
gin
to a
pply
it’s o
wn p
olici
es a
ndpr
oced
ures
.
EMER
GING
RIR
s DO
CUM
ENT
http
://w
ww
.lacn
ic.o
rg
Fund
ing M
odel
No
t-for
-pro
fit or
ganiz
ation
. In
the
start-
up, N
IC-B
razil
will
take
care
of t
he L
ACNI
C co
sts. (
2 ye
ars)
Fina
l fund
ing m
odel
in pr
oces
s acc
ordin
g to
Bra
zil E
cono
my.
Stru
cture
fee
sam
e as
ARI
N. T
his w
ill be
disc
usse
d in
Seco
nd O
pen
Foru
m in
Sao
Pau
lo
EMER
GING
RIR
s DO
CUM
ENT
http://www.lacnic.org
Reco
rd K
eepi
ng En
glish
offic
ial la
ngua
je o
f the
Reg
istry
Sys
tem
. Co
re d
ocum
enta
tion
(at l
east
): ➢
Polic
ies
➢By
laws
➢Pr
oced
ures
➢W
ebsit
e➢
Who
is DB
➢Se
rvice
sta
ff.➢
Mee
ting
(sim
ulta
neou
s tra
nsla
tions
)
EMER
GING
RIR
s DO
CUM
ENT
http://www.lacnic.org
Conf
iden
tiality
Info
rmat
ion
colle
cted
by
a RI
R in
the
regi
stra
tion
proc
ess
mus
t be
kept
in s
trict
con
fiden
ce a
nd u
ses
for r
egist
ratio
n pu
rpos
es o
nly.
LACN
IC e
stab
lishe
s he
rein
that
Boa
rd M
embe
rs a
re n
ot a
llowe
d to
parti
cipat
e in
disc
ussio
ns w
here
ther
e ar
e co
nflic
ts o
f int
eres
t. Al
lbo
ard
mem
bers
and
sta
ff m
embe
rs a
re re
quire
d to
sig
n no
n-di
sclo
sure
sta
tem
ents
EMER
GING
RIR
s DO
CUM
ENT
http://www.lacnic.org
LACN
IC N
EXT
STEP
S
http
://w
ww
.lacn
ic.o
rg
Star
t sta
ge 2
in co
ordin
ation
with
ARI
N. In
crea
se d
ocum
enta
tion
of IS
P’s s
uppo
rt to
LAC
NIC.
Toge
ther
with
stage
2.
Nove
mbe
r 28t
h LA
CNIC
’s Se
cond
Ope
n Po
licy F
orum
. Sao
Pau
loBr
azil.
Send
a d
etail
and
solid
app
licat
ion re
cogn
ition
to IC
ANN
Boar
d sig
ned
also
by A
RIN
in th
e ev
e of
Gha
na m
eetin
g in
first q
uarte
r 200
2.
Questions?
LAC
NIC
STA
TU
S
http://www.lacnic.org