teaching and making mechanisms - university college …zchatt3/clarke_exeter_hps_slides_01.pdf ·...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Teaching and Making Mechanisms - University College …zchatt3/Clarke_Exeter_HPS_slides_01.pdf · Mechanistic theories of Causality • Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000 • Craver,](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051406/5ab1179c7f8b9ad9788bd3c5/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Teaching and Making Mechanisms
Fifth Joint Workshop on Integrated History and
Philosophy of Science „What is HPS for?‟
29th June 2010
University of Exeter
Brendan Clarke
Department of Science and Technology Studies
UCL
![Page 2: Teaching and Making Mechanisms - University College …zchatt3/Clarke_Exeter_HPS_slides_01.pdf · Mechanistic theories of Causality • Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000 • Craver,](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051406/5ab1179c7f8b9ad9788bd3c5/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Mechanistic theories of Causality
• Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000
• Craver, 2007
• Glennan, 2002
• Bechtel and Abrahamsen, 2005
• Woodward, 2002
![Page 3: Teaching and Making Mechanisms - University College …zchatt3/Clarke_Exeter_HPS_slides_01.pdf · Mechanistic theories of Causality • Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000 • Craver,](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051406/5ab1179c7f8b9ad9788bd3c5/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Mechanistic theories of Causality
• Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000
– ―Mechanisms are entities and activities organized such that they
are productive of regular changes from start or set-up to finish or
termination conditions‖
• Craver, 2007
• Glennan, 2002
• Bechtel and Abrahamsen, 2005
• Woodward, 2002
![Page 4: Teaching and Making Mechanisms - University College …zchatt3/Clarke_Exeter_HPS_slides_01.pdf · Mechanistic theories of Causality • Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000 • Craver,](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051406/5ab1179c7f8b9ad9788bd3c5/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
MDC
• Activity-entity ontic dualism
• Presented, initially, as a means of giving causal
explanations
• Normative account
![Page 5: Teaching and Making Mechanisms - University College …zchatt3/Clarke_Exeter_HPS_slides_01.pdf · Mechanistic theories of Causality • Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000 • Craver,](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051406/5ab1179c7f8b9ad9788bd3c5/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
How useful are mechanisms for teaching?
• About what?
• Science
• Causality and explanation
![Page 6: Teaching and Making Mechanisms - University College …zchatt3/Clarke_Exeter_HPS_slides_01.pdf · Mechanistic theories of Causality • Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000 • Craver,](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051406/5ab1179c7f8b9ad9788bd3c5/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Derived from Chen, 2001: 1537—8
![Page 7: Teaching and Making Mechanisms - University College …zchatt3/Clarke_Exeter_HPS_slides_01.pdf · Mechanistic theories of Causality • Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000 • Craver,](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051406/5ab1179c7f8b9ad9788bd3c5/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Mechanisms for teaching
![Page 8: Teaching and Making Mechanisms - University College …zchatt3/Clarke_Exeter_HPS_slides_01.pdf · Mechanistic theories of Causality • Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000 • Craver,](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051406/5ab1179c7f8b9ad9788bd3c5/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Mechanisms from teaching; or
“Make me a mechanism...”
• 17 1st year medical students
• Familiar with MDC, 2000
• Make me the mechanism for asthma
– Capable of giving causal explanations for likely clinical
scenarios
• Diagnosis
• Treatment
• Communication
• ...
![Page 9: Teaching and Making Mechanisms - University College …zchatt3/Clarke_Exeter_HPS_slides_01.pdf · Mechanistic theories of Causality • Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000 • Craver,](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051406/5ab1179c7f8b9ad9788bd3c5/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
![Page 10: Teaching and Making Mechanisms - University College …zchatt3/Clarke_Exeter_HPS_slides_01.pdf · Mechanistic theories of Causality • Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000 • Craver,](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051406/5ab1179c7f8b9ad9788bd3c5/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Why so difficult?
• Representation difficulties
• Model difficulties
![Page 11: Teaching and Making Mechanisms - University College …zchatt3/Clarke_Exeter_HPS_slides_01.pdf · Mechanistic theories of Causality • Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000 • Craver,](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051406/5ab1179c7f8b9ad9788bd3c5/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Mechanisms, models and representations
![Page 12: Teaching and Making Mechanisms - University College …zchatt3/Clarke_Exeter_HPS_slides_01.pdf · Mechanistic theories of Causality • Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000 • Craver,](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051406/5ab1179c7f8b9ad9788bd3c5/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Mechanism
![Page 13: Teaching and Making Mechanisms - University College …zchatt3/Clarke_Exeter_HPS_slides_01.pdf · Mechanistic theories of Causality • Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000 • Craver,](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051406/5ab1179c7f8b9ad9788bd3c5/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Mechanistic model
![Page 14: Teaching and Making Mechanisms - University College …zchatt3/Clarke_Exeter_HPS_slides_01.pdf · Mechanistic theories of Causality • Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000 • Craver,](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051406/5ab1179c7f8b9ad9788bd3c5/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Mechanistic model representation
![Page 15: Teaching and Making Mechanisms - University College …zchatt3/Clarke_Exeter_HPS_slides_01.pdf · Mechanistic theories of Causality • Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000 • Craver,](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051406/5ab1179c7f8b9ad9788bd3c5/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Representative difficulties
• Simple complexity
• Collaborative working
• Representational consistency versus conventions
• Gaps
• Stochastic / deterministic causes
![Page 16: Teaching and Making Mechanisms - University College …zchatt3/Clarke_Exeter_HPS_slides_01.pdf · Mechanistic theories of Causality • Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000 • Craver,](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051406/5ab1179c7f8b9ad9788bd3c5/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Model difficulties
• Complex complexity
• Local incommensurability
• Causes versus background conditions
• Level problems and bottoming-out
• Evidential complications
![Page 17: Teaching and Making Mechanisms - University College …zchatt3/Clarke_Exeter_HPS_slides_01.pdf · Mechanistic theories of Causality • Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000 • Craver,](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051406/5ab1179c7f8b9ad9788bd3c5/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
The Complex Mechanism Browser
• Text input of causal claims
• Routing etc automated
• Ability to re-use sections of mechanism
• Clear visual differentiation between different
relationships
– Causes - Prevents
– Similar - Dissimilar
– Background condition - Component
![Page 18: Teaching and Making Mechanisms - University College …zchatt3/Clarke_Exeter_HPS_slides_01.pdf · Mechanistic theories of Causality • Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000 • Craver,](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051406/5ab1179c7f8b9ad9788bd3c5/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
McArdle, 1951
![Page 19: Teaching and Making Mechanisms - University College …zchatt3/Clarke_Exeter_HPS_slides_01.pdf · Mechanistic theories of Causality • Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000 • Craver,](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051406/5ab1179c7f8b9ad9788bd3c5/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
McArdle, 1951
![Page 20: Teaching and Making Mechanisms - University College …zchatt3/Clarke_Exeter_HPS_slides_01.pdf · Mechanistic theories of Causality • Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000 • Craver,](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051406/5ab1179c7f8b9ad9788bd3c5/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Pearson, Rimer and Mommaerts, 1961
![Page 21: Teaching and Making Mechanisms - University College …zchatt3/Clarke_Exeter_HPS_slides_01.pdf · Mechanistic theories of Causality • Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000 • Craver,](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051406/5ab1179c7f8b9ad9788bd3c5/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Conclusions
• Mechanisms are normative– Teaching science
– Teaching causality and explanation
• This normativity is challenged by the difficulties of
constructing representations of mechanisms– Demonstrated in teaching
• Possible clarification:
mechanisms/models/representations?– CMB
– More teaching: more difficulties?
![Page 22: Teaching and Making Mechanisms - University College …zchatt3/Clarke_Exeter_HPS_slides_01.pdf · Mechanistic theories of Causality • Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000 • Craver,](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051406/5ab1179c7f8b9ad9788bd3c5/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Acknowledgements
• Year 1 SSC in Philosophy, Medicine and Society
Students
• Graphviz - http://www.graphviz.org
• Carl Pappenheim (technical consultant on CMB)
![Page 23: Teaching and Making Mechanisms - University College …zchatt3/Clarke_Exeter_HPS_slides_01.pdf · Mechanistic theories of Causality • Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000 • Craver,](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051406/5ab1179c7f8b9ad9788bd3c5/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Bibliography• Bechtel, W. and Abrahamsen, A. 2005.
―Explanation: A Mechanist Alternative,‖
Studies in History and Philosophy of
Science Part C: Studies in History and
Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical
Sciences. 36(2): 421—41.
• Chen, Y., 2001. Glycogen Storage
Disease. In Scriver CR, et al., eds. 2001.
The Metabolic and Molecular Basis of
Inherited Disease. New York: McGraw-
Hill, pp. 1521—51.
• Craver, C. 2007. Explaining the Brain.
Oxford: OUP.
• Glennan, S. 2002. ―Rethinking
Mechanistic Explanation,‖ Philosophy of
Science. 69(S3): 342—53.
• Machamer, P., Darden, L. and Craver,
C.F. 2000. ―Thinking about Mechanisms,‖
Philosophy of Science. 67(1): 1—25.
• McArdle, B. 1951. ―Myopathy Due to a
Defect in Muscle Glycogen Breakdown,‖
Clinical Science. 10: 13—33.
• Pearson, C., Rimer, D. and Mommaerts,
W. 1961. ―A Metabolic Myopathy Due to
Absence of Muscle Phosphorylase,‖ The
American Journal of Medicine. 30: 502—
17.
• Woodward, J. 2002. "What is a
Mechanism? A Counterfactual Account,"
Philosophy of Science. 69(S3): S366—77.
![Page 24: Teaching and Making Mechanisms - University College …zchatt3/Clarke_Exeter_HPS_slides_01.pdf · Mechanistic theories of Causality • Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000 • Craver,](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051406/5ab1179c7f8b9ad9788bd3c5/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
![Page 25: Teaching and Making Mechanisms - University College …zchatt3/Clarke_Exeter_HPS_slides_01.pdf · Mechanistic theories of Causality • Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000 • Craver,](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051406/5ab1179c7f8b9ad9788bd3c5/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Mechanistic theories of Causality
• Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000
• Craver, 2007
• Glennan, 2002
• Bechtel and Abrahamsen, 2005
• Woodward, 2002
![Page 26: Teaching and Making Mechanisms - University College …zchatt3/Clarke_Exeter_HPS_slides_01.pdf · Mechanistic theories of Causality • Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000 • Craver,](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051406/5ab1179c7f8b9ad9788bd3c5/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Mechanistic theories of Causality
• Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000
• Craver, 2007
• Glennan, 2002
– ―...a mechanism for a behaviour is a complex system that produces
that behaviour by the interaction of a number of parts, where the
interactions between parts can be characterized by direct,
invariant, change-relating generalization.‖
• Bechtel and Abrahamsen, 2005
• Woodward, 2002
![Page 27: Teaching and Making Mechanisms - University College …zchatt3/Clarke_Exeter_HPS_slides_01.pdf · Mechanistic theories of Causality • Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000 • Craver,](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051406/5ab1179c7f8b9ad9788bd3c5/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Mechanistic theories of Causality
• Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000
• Craver, 2007
• Glennan, 2002
• Bechtel and Abrahamsen, 2005
– ―A mechanism is a structure performing a function in virtue of its
component parts, component operations, and their organization.
The orchestrated functioning of the mechanism is responsible for
one or more phenomena.‖
• Woodward, 2002
![Page 28: Teaching and Making Mechanisms - University College …zchatt3/Clarke_Exeter_HPS_slides_01.pdf · Mechanistic theories of Causality • Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000 • Craver,](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051406/5ab1179c7f8b9ad9788bd3c5/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Mechanistic theories of Causality
• Machamer, Darden and Craver, 2000
• Craver, 2007
• Glennan, 2002
• Bechtel and Abrahamsen, 2005
• Woodward, 2002– ―... a representation...of a mechanism...(i) describes an organized or
structured set of parts or components, where (ii) the behaviour of each
component is described by a generalization that is invariant under
intervention, and where (iii) the generalizations governing each component
are also independently changeable, and where (iv) the representation
allows us to see how, in virtue of (i), (ii) and (iii), the overall output of the
mechanism will vary under manipulation of the input to each component
and changes in the components themselves.‖