THE BNA ....... :..• :..: ::...:: : :. ..

A1aq, /985PUBLISHED BY THE BRITISH NORTH AMERICA PHILATELIC SOCIETY

CANADIAN PERFINS STUDY GROUP Volume 6, Nwnben

Yim Catfe,?ick, ediLon, 2/0 _Steelez Ave. W. , Apt. 2/02, Dicampton, ON Can. L6Y 2A"3

David Aan.a4co a enda along tALi block

o^ 6 o4 5coa '.4 #//9, the 200 Adm.ucal,with W9, W29. ,4t 4.t,c4t glance iA

&athen. con/u i.ing tAe uuy that the Terc-

4.i4 cue punched on each .stamp, but

cLonea examination aeveaL4 that the_v ent caL pain on tAe Right ate nom.-

maL punched, and the others 4owc ace

mL'uwn pa.uu. An .i.nteneat,ing jAow

piece.

4f

Cohn Pom ej, one o^ our. new members,

aenda along tAL 4dmi1.a1 coLL, with

what Loo% Like Tea^inned S, but one

of the Letterer ih iteve hed. Can any

one help Cohn wt.fA Jdenti.(LcaJJnn.

G3(- Ju/L6Ae2 to the a cLe.i on C15, /4' and

34, by f4LcAaeL D.i,c%e L and Yon Yohni on,

Colin aL3io aenda photocopi e4 o/ Cl4' arid

C34 wiz'h the hoLe1 No. 5, 6 f7 o, the C

in a a tna.igkt line on both at=pi.

Colin aL,.o ham a tevenu.e i amp, wUA

the Let-tea E Te/L ,i.nned, and thence L.

aZ4 o two paiti .aL AoLea in tAe edge o4

the stamp, cLoaeat to the C. Can

d omeone -ident y 1-AL aAao.

2

Yoe TwtceLL wait tee:

7uo o^ mg coLLecLLny. in, e zeAta aite 2aiLnoad goat Ollice and

PLLi WLI Tvai Of f Lce. CanceLLa .ivnn.

eit^i wi th /?/00 canceAA a^Le AeLat,t:veLtt common, petAtapa aA high

a4 / in 25, 000. Qua % eI. zne.d AP O'4 w e a di jgenenf ma .feA. 2ecentZy

through the cotut to 4y o^ 9eo jq WaL6twu•t, 9 Received my ^LL t, a teA25

cyea)L4 o^ aea/tcAutg. .9 i.4 on Scoa'a #254, with. C27 C%? % e4i. n and

poatmwihed /ll Dochgtivt.d, V ic,oitia B. C. Tun /4/43 opt. 48. l enhapa

Joe o^ you with vivid .imagi-nation may Nu/Le owz wA i?

Doc l i n g a , 2 2 4 2 5 BLC cn_e C l -' . OJ a c, 0,,L-,-j K/6 4 #_:), I-

utade one PJ6 AJD on _Scott # /04 WL a 63, d4,, 93, S9, S13d, q/6,

l}J4, N/0t, T4, T7, T8, 74, 75, oA any accvtcest l e4<n with an

.,-nventoAj wwund 20. (9nvent_occy taken (wm the Aepo±) (lave

4 ev en.aL tnadea.

Owrt New lland6ook

yon loAr on Aepo .i that oust. new lland6ook AhouLd 6e avaiLa6Le

tlvwugh the !NAPS Book Dept. 6g the time you n.ead tAL4 noI i..ce. ..92 wiLL

also 6e avaiLa6Le at deaLelth. 91- wiLL 6e .in tuo di enen 6eind& V,

Goth " ,t ect" 6irtdi.ng and proud coven.

4 ve ty apeciaL than i ahouLd go out to Yon 2oAn4on /oit aLL of the

unit/ that Ae has pat into thij new lland6ook. We do appaeciate this

ext1La a vu4, and 9 am acute t/tat L will a/tow up when ue ata2t to we it.

,4 apecthL t/tanha to thoae mem6eit4 who /cave aa6mitied aem oL i e't.eat.

Aa edito^L 9 need moire o/ diem. 7h.t4 type o^ in oirmation gives w a

6e felt knowledge of ow Te t in,i, but aLao ahouLd encocutage ua to look

ove,z otut own coZ&act .on, and then wn..i to the e"A .va w.t tlt item that will

6e o^ i,ttene^t to aLL o^ owA mem6eai. Send along cgocut connu 6u i_on,

no matt.e2 how ,smaLL

1 2n I,; I,)l ,hl, Ir1 ^ Cr y.. c,• ( T ^i.. r..

The following are necessary charges to the tentative die arrange-ment sheet which appeared on Pa{'es 2-3 of the Oct./84 Perforator. Thesechanges are the result of new information and stamp designs submittedby Jean-Guy Dalpe for further study and comment. For those Members who

LZ^ have studied the first reconstruction chart and were able to identifysome of their 'Bellevilles' to the Ottawa Office user, the revised chartwill enable those interested to place all damaged dies and collect suchas varieties. with and without code holes.

STATE I: L;ove 'Complete' Die (3) into Die (1) space and show the pre-sent Die (1) with missing hole at H-5 position as a progression fromits parent complete die. Up to now, my piece with #109 dated, is thesole stamp item discovered, and this possibly short lived damage couldwell be resting in collections on other stamps such as #107 unobserved.

Insert in the blank Die (3) space a new early damaged design on ;#106with a 1914 date, missing holes at C-13, H-6-12, and I-1.

Notes: (1) All State I designs still have the Ottawa Code Hole 9 intact.

(2) Joe Furcell's #109 block of four recorded under Die (2) isnow confirmed in its place since it places the two vertical and'complete' designs in the correct adjoining position of Die (1).

(3) ;/So, stamp recorded in the complete die stamps, and #109added under Die (5), both examined and in Dalpe's collection.

STA` E II : ].:ove 'Complete Die' (1) to Die (5) position and move eachof Dies 2)(3)(4) one position to the left. The remaining design inthe previous Die (5) with missing holes recorded under Index No.2(2)(3)are now believed to be a progression of the recorded Index No.10, 10(2),with missing, holes at C-4 and i1-2. Thus the progressive break of IndexNo.2(2)(3) is now shown at the bottom of Die (1) of the new chart. Thevacant Die (4) space has been filled with a 'complete' die design, thetwo complete dies now adjoining in positions (4) and (5). Jean-Guy hasjust submitted a horizontal pair of 71#231 both with complete dies, andthis first evidence of two complete dies in simultaneous use on a paircaused a lot of the shifting and revisions to State II above. This in-si-nificant pair also answers the problem I recognized on paper of whyweJseemed to have such a complete range of numbers from #150 to #257with 'complete' designs, while the other dies in State II with damagewere much less in proport^n,,. This observation led to correspondenceand after mentioning that^1;^37 issues nearly all periin designs appeared'complete', J.G. suggested that perhaps further repair had taken placeand should a State III be considered?

I agree completely with the proposal of a State III status with therepair of the missing holes under Index No.10, No.11 and the old No.2(2)(3), now a progression of No.10(2) in about 1936-37. This alsoties in with the reason why the missing code holes under the recordedIndexes have not surfaced beyond the 1935 Jubilees and regular 1935issues. The State III complete designs have very regular and beauti-fully machined pin holes as with the examples seen in late 1936 & '37.

STATE III: Jean Guy has also submitted a completely new damage withcode hole present of this new State III with missing holes at C-3,H-7-8-11 as illustrated under the complete Dies (4)(5) of State II, #233.This damage should also continue. on to the end of the War Issue, andI,lembers having a similar damage to a stamp other than ;1233, please letme know for the recording, of this most interesting and rewarding project.

Jack Benningenof/, /9g6- 157 Wildwood Drive SW.,

C'al Marv . Al +a m'^r• -zr^

4

1 L' /,2 /3 - O TT'

rEN r g 7-IV` U/E ,^/'i riNGE/^/.^^/T /7//Tis' /^i ^S^t• ►'6 f^L j ^Df_N7/f/C^?T/,^/3.

ST REV/.s%n,3) - Sr/^w./yG / 1, ^EPP/RE) D/^ PS ST^r^^-.-

^T^TF -^ - a^ ' '/•v6 D/E f> 4D OFi/Ji"^il T G/^'/.:/^i/'^ , /L frE.^p

(I)

' ' - 'NG fl,< Lt

r h.'_ r

Tv 1f-174 /90^'^•,'.^ /:S I FSfJCovT /QUO-!

'4 of ^r /c

/i(jfI/'3 /N .STATE ^o^J/', f TE DES/;NS

►

''tw'7,' .:C/'E'.LJ/ Sr7 " N^ /'J.:;fc^S /C "S/L^^ )' T//E /'/^'.-U^/T)" ^^0^7 (/)/LS,Tr/'' 3 , 4S ^f^i..%.`^

Grt' /i E TOaLF() 1//C fife //3 G'SF /` l /`j i .07L.

WWII 9

•

f ^N^^ ^: /1/0. /oY/^-^ ^/3D.'^X Il^o, // I. ^N z c//zCi)^

c ' Df /%-3C

/o7('-./C /3)

/S317

^p 41)

/n/DEX Nn, 2(2)(3)

/o7(4/

.r)- /SO 7(/Odlth /z1NST)

/s 3 - /55(h^3C) /^er,'/Zo" •- ^ e /, of f'.?3 /

t193 961 9 -/'7- . /3-

ES^•-^,^/CU

/Vnr 3/ rliN ,9 5rs/A'TED /V/T,, ^'o,'; E rE',^>Erout ED

fl.fAD^ A/3oor 2 G P"/v/T/AL oo. 7'J, v GE To T//fSE /3Ei'

9'A Sif/'-

(AY'(. /3)- //3 - /C S// c / /'/.3 L^ lEfJ^' C' 4 - /J

r - 1T^//R' /936-.' 7,/SS vj^- ^ !J 31^ ^oNS, f' f O ^i E3^

7-)7-/- v/Ti1 /tA^ kfGc<

.........

55)

OIL

/97^-9^/9-2^/- 2^333H Sul- ^u/t- Asa

/i/"l3 ^'^ /'en's /nom

-fls !'T IS /95'

5

Sru/ex .to inl'o^ma^u,n on 7 ea(i.n J,ypeA a pu61L ed in "June 7e a otato t" #.o Vo L , A'o. 4

r9 L-,44 1-3,2-10 3Ay 46 5-3, 5-4ns47 5-3n^ A8 /-3

--n - A9 )Pr Cry 4-4

L.3 Cl 4-/, 5-3, 6C3 z-9

c l4('/0 3-5 3

ces Cloa / -2,35-(10i -2

c I`I C12cC.zv C12d

c z C12e

c Z3 C12A

5-1

5-1, 6-1 3.

45,5-3b-C-ZS,-' C122 5-1

z,C12ZL z g C/2m

c z `i C/2n

3 'C12p6 12u

C 36 C13

GYOC17(- 4 / C19c. 4.1 C20

C- 61.3 C20a

4 5,5-4, s-'4-5,5-1,5-3 ---4-5.,5-1.,5-7-31 5-46-445 3

1-3 3

yY 21 1-2, 1-10,c vs 2Ia 1-2, 1-10,

c v, C22 1-2 •^

3 ' 1^+ s /]3

5-3 v' A1-3a

vE C24 2-10, 5-3 3

v , C25 1-2 3

es^ C26 1-2, 1-11,cs z-C26a 1-2, 1-1/,(c s C266 1-2,

C 2 E ) ) 1-2, ,'

s 3 C27 1-2, (=2- C 3 0 4 2

5 ' 6 2 4-2, 4_/

cc-3 C34

Cc4 \ /5

c'-/"Z)3 &J, 4-/ /1-5111,

D^ vf7 5-1

45, 6-3s^6 14

1-9 3

c,ry4

S5 5-2, 5-4S/,) 15V

g©v

1' 41 crfl 4-3

12'.'..'1-4 3 , 1^°^

4s 4-4, 5-2 3

-j

4 L4 c6-2 3

C6i 1-7-1

L8) 2-8, 3-2 r3

4-2)5-2.,5-4) 6-24-2,6-2.,1-2 3

/-2, /-11-2, /_/Q, /- -

1-2,1-10J-2

35

3535"'5-5j 6-2

3-2

5-3, 5-46-2

5-3 V

25,5-3X2-5 3

25^-

r^9Ei 5) I-4 'in to r? 6) (1-7)`,3^^ 3

c-- - 2-9

t-n' 1 l`128- 2-7,3-2

5-5,6-2NZY N6 3-2, 3-3N2.-?N7 3-2,,d A(j ) 1-4IV6 N9 2-1 --7 N9a 2-1

v^ No (2: 3)3''° Rob 5-3,5-4N' `r N/og 2-6,2-8 -

N/o 2-6,2-8 ''^16 N/0L CL , 2-6--

10 ' 1-4.,2-6"7.1 Nl om 4-1 'j-

)2I(NI 1-4rVCA^& 5-1 r'

03 03 4 5,5-1o1 oI

04a 35^c' [, 046 3-51-011-09 5-3 `3

ONJ/9OV 2-3,

.9ndex (romth ued)

P P3

P ; 54 ,1P 3 P9 3-2 VP'^ Plo 35/Prc Pl0a 35, 6-2

,3

P L 713 5-3` 3

P1G ^-4^

?2 2-11, 4-/

2 ?4 2-11 3

2 7 ?5 2-11,4-I'l

1-111/

2-6, 2-11, 4-1

35

5-31-4, 4-3, 3-213--1, 4-3

35.13-5 'z

= ► #1 2-9.,5-4 1

N^^ Qden^i ^%.ad

s Z _S2a

SwS4

1-8

1-2

2-11,' -1, 4-5. 6-2

5 13 58 1-31 4-1

-316,59 3-3s^c.Srr 1-8, 2-7, 4-1,5- S

c"i Stta 15,1-8 3sip J/16 2-7

< 3-3

?D 1-7 -"di.4/?eg 4-2 "

V CNB 5-5Iii SC 5,-4 3

6-^'^

6-4,1

BAi'A NoiJ 4men,^ca 7hiLa, e/ Lc Soc.Le ^

(cazadLars 7en.4tn _5; iLdy y"ty

Chat man

Yon 2oh.ZAon

Box 61 18, Satio n D

Ca4g^g

AL6 enda

327 2C7

FD

_S ecJLe xmy

2. L. Pa&ceLL6 12 haad ion Dflive

h'.c;rugion

On, cO u

K7/ 2.56

?evenccea 3-4, 3-59'ItecanceZ4 3-1, 4-4 3

yen. Jag Pe ii 4 -2

O^,J thL Pei. 1-9A.A S!. DeL. -leg. 3-1 3

CoiLa

7'Ae-AdwiA,aL 4-4., 5-1 "

Po,1 ,i.on,4 1-7, 6-1

PO4J,f . DfL4 6-3 3,

?econded

f1PO',. 6-4

Jhe d.i t_oJL

Jh.e BNA Pea oAatot

2im Caitien.icLz

2/0 SteeLea Ave. W. #2/02

Baampton, Onv.

L6Y 2103