the argument. (i)each offspring derives half its genes from its mother and half from its father...

38
The Argument

Upload: candice-stockdill

Post on 15-Dec-2015

216 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

The Argument

(i) Each offspring derives half its genes from its mother and half from its father (Equal Contribution of Parents)

The Argument

(i) Each offspring derives half its genes from its mother and half from its father (Equal Contribution of Parents)

(ii) Each offspring / successful mating gives one ‘credit’ to a female and one ‘credit’ to a male (Equal Payoff for Parents)

The Argument

(i) Each offspring derives half its genes from its mother and half from its father (Equal Contribution of Parents)

(ii) Each offspring / successful mating gives one ‘credit’ to a female and one ‘credit’ to a male (Equal Payoff for Parents)

(iii) The total success of all females is equal to the total success of all males (Equal Payoff for Sexes)

The Argument

(i) Each offspring derives half its genes from its mother and half from its father (Equal Contribution of Parents)

(ii) Each offspring / successful mating gives one ‘credit’ to a female and one ‘credit’ to a male (Equal Payoff for Parents)

(iii) The total success of all females is equal to the total success of all males (Equal Payoff for Sexes)

(iv) ‘Individuals’ of the rarer sex are fitter than ‘individuals’ of the common sex (Higher Success for Rarer-Sex Individuals)

The Argument

(i) Each offspring derives half its genes from its mother and half from its father (Equal Contribution of Parents)

(ii) Each offspring / successful mating gives one ‘credit’ to a female and one ‘credit’ to a male (Equal Payoff for Parents)

(iii) The total success of all females is equal to the total success of all males (Equal Payoff for Sexes)

(iv) ‘Individuals’ of the rarer sex are fitter than ‘individuals’ of the common sex (Higher Success for Rarer-Sex Individuals)

(v) Returns from investment into rarer sex higher than from common sex (Higher Returns from Rarer Sex)

The Argument

(i) Each offspring derives half its genes from its mother and half from its father (Equal Contribution of Parents)

(ii) Each offspring / successful mating gives one ‘credit’ to a female and one ‘credit’ to a male (Equal Payoff for Parents)

(iii) The total success of all females is equal to the total success of all males (Equal Payoff for Sexes)

(iv) ‘Individuals’ of the rarer sex are fitter than ‘individuals’ of the common sex (Higher Success for Rarer-Sex Individuals)

(v) Returns from investment into rarer sex higher than from common sex (Higher Returns from Rarer Sex)

(vi) Natural selection favours individuals that invest into rarer sex (Best Investment Strategy)

The Argument

(i) Each offspring derives half its genes from its mother and half from its father (Equal Contribution of Parents)

(ii) Each offspring / successful mating gives one ‘credit’ to a female and one ‘credit’ to a male (Equal Payoff for Parents)

(iii) The total success of all females is equal to the total success of all males (Equal Payoff for Sexes)

(iv) ‘Individuals’ of the rarer sex are fitter than ‘individuals’ of the common sex (Higher Success for Rarer-Sex Individuals)

(v) Returns from investment into rarer sex higher than from common sex (Higher Returns from Rarer Sex)

(vi) Natural selection favours individuals that invest into rarer sex (Best Investment Strategy)

(vii) Natural selection neutralises perturbations from equal investment in the sexes (Convergence on Even Sex Ratio)

The Argument

i

ii

iii

iv

v

vi

vii

Equal contribution of parents

Equal payoff for parents

Equal payoff for sexes

Higher success of rare sex ‘individuals’

Higher returns from rarer sex

Best investment strategy

Convergence on even sex ratio

The Argument

i

ii

iii

iv

v

vi

vii

Equal contribution of parents

Equal payoff for parents

Equal payoff for sexes

Higher success of rare sex ‘individuals’

Higher returns from rarer sex

Best investment strategy

Convergence on even sex ratio

Darwin (1871)

i

ii

iii

iv

v

vi

vii

Equal contribution of parents

Equal payoff for parents

Equal payoff for sexes

Higher success of rare sex ‘individuals’

Higher returns from rarer sex

Best investment strategy

Convergence on even sex ratio

Darwin (1871)

i

ii

iii

iv

v

vi

vii

Equal contribution of parents

Equal payoff for parents

Equal payoff for sexes

Higher success of rare sex ‘individuals’

Higher returns from rarer sex

Best investment strategy

Convergence on even sex ratio

Darwin (1871)

i

ii

iii

iv

v

vi

vii

Equal contribution of parents

Equal payoff for parents

Equal payoff for sexes

Higher success of rare sex ‘individuals’

Higher returns from rarer sex

Best investment strategy

Convergence on even sex ratio

Darwin (1871)

i

ii

iii

iv

v

vi

vii

Equal contribution of parents

Equal payoff for parents

Equal payoff for sexes

Higher success of rare sex ‘individuals’

Higher returns from rarer sex

Best investment strategy

Convergence on even sex ratio

Darwin (1871)

viiTransmit the tendency to future generations

i

ii

iii

iv

v

vi

vii

Equal contribution of parents

Equal payoff for parents

Equal payoff for sexes

Higher success of rare sex ‘individuals’

Higher returns from rarer sex

Best investment strategy

Convergence on even sex ratio

Darwin (1871)

viiiTransmit the tendency to future generations

i

ii

iii

iv

v

vi

vii

Equal contribution of parents

Equal payoff for parents

Equal payoff for sexes

Higher success of rare sex ‘individuals’

Higher returns from rarer sex

Best investment strategy

Convergence on even sex ratio

Düsing (1884)

i

ii

iii

iv

v

vi

vii

Equal contribution of parents

Equal payoff for parents

Equal payoff for sexes

Higher success of rare sex ‘individuals’

Higher returns from rarer sex

Best investment strategy

Convergence on even sex ratio

Düsing (1884)

i

ii

iii

iv

v

vi

vii

Equal contribution of parents

Equal payoff for parents

Equal payoff for sexes

Higher success of rare sex ‘individuals’

Higher returns from rarer sex

Best investment strategy

Convergence on even sex ratio

Düsing (1884)

i

ii

iii

iv

v

vi

vii

Equal contribution of parents

Equal payoff for parents

Equal payoff for sexes

Higher success of rare sex ‘individuals’

Higher returns from rarer sex

Best investment strategy

Convergence on even sex ratio

Düsing (1884)

i

ii

iii

iv

v

vi

vii

Equal contribution of parents

Equal payoff for parents

Equal payoff for sexes

Higher success of rare sex ‘individuals’

Higher returns from rarer sex

Best investment strategy

Convergence on even sex ratio

Düsing (1884)

i

ii

iii

iv

v

vi

vii

Equal contribution of parents

Equal payoff for parents

Equal payoff for sexes

Higher success of rare sex ‘individuals’

Higher returns from rarer sex

Best investment strategy

Convergence on even sex ratio

Düsing (1884)

ix

Behavioural adjustment towards equal sex ratio

Gini (1908)

Gini (1908)

“it has all the appearance of being valid, but only the appearance”

i

ii

iii

iv

v

vi

vii

Equal contribution of parents

Equal payoff for parents

Equal payoff for sexes

Higher success of rare sex ‘individuals’

Higher returns from rarer sex

Best investment strategy

Convergence on even sex ratio

Cobb (1914)

i

ii

iii

iv

v

vi

vii

Equal contribution of parents

Equal payoff for parents

Equal payoff for sexes

Higher success of rare sex ‘individuals’

Higher returns from rarer sex

Best investment strategy

Convergence on even sex ratio

Cobb (1914)

i

ii

iii

iv

v

vi

vii

Equal contribution of parents

Equal payoff for parents

Equal payoff for sexes

Higher success of rare sex ‘individuals’

Higher returns from rarer sex

Best investment strategy

Convergence on even sex ratio

Cobb (1914)

i

ii

iii

iv

v

vi

vii

Equal contribution of parents

Equal payoff for parents

Equal payoff for sexes

Higher success of rare sex ‘individuals’

Higher returns from rarer sex

Best investment strategy

Convergence on even sex ratio

Cobb (1914)

i

ii

iii

iv

v

vi

vii

Equal contribution of parents

Equal payoff for parents

Equal payoff for sexes

Higher success of rare sex ‘individuals’

Higher returns from rarer sex

Best investment strategy

Convergence on even sex ratio

Cobb (1914)

i

ii

iii

iv

v

vi

vii

Equal contribution of parents

Equal payoff for parents

Equal payoff for sexes

Higher success of rare sex ‘individuals’

Higher returns from rarer sex

Best investment strategy

Convergence on even sex ratio

Cobb (1914)

viiiTransmit the tendency to future generations

i

ii

iii

iv

v

vi

vii

Equal contribution of parents

Equal payoff for parents

Equal payoff for sexes

Higher success of rare sex ‘individuals’

Higher returns from rarer sex

Best investment strategy

Convergence on even sex ratio

Cobb (1914)

viiiTransmit the tendency to future generations

i

ii

iii

iv

v

vi

vii

Equal contribution of parents

Equal payoff for parents

Equal payoff for sexes

Higher success of rare sex ‘individuals’

Higher returns from rarer sex

Best investment strategy

Convergence on even sex ratio

Fisher (1930)

i

ii

iii

iv

v

vi

vii

Equal contribution of parents

Equal payoff for parents

Equal payoff for sexes

Higher success of rare sex ‘individuals’

Higher returns from rarer sex

Best investment strategy

Convergence on even sex ratio

Fisher (1930)

i

ii

iii

iv

v

vi

vii

Equal contribution of parents

Equal payoff for parents

Equal payoff for sexes

Higher success of rare sex ‘individuals’

Higher returns from rarer sex

Best investment strategy

Convergence on even sex ratio

Fisher (1930)

i

ii

iii

iv

v

vi

vii

Equal contribution of parents

Equal payoff for parents

Equal payoff for sexes

Higher success of rare sex ‘individuals’

Higher returns from rarer sex

Best investment strategy

Convergence on even sex ratio

Fisher (1930)

i

ii

iii

iv

v

vi

vii

Equal contribution of parents

Equal payoff for parents

Equal payoff for sexes

Higher success of rare sex ‘individuals’

Higher returns from rarer sex

Best investment strategy

Convergence on even sex ratio

Fisher (1930)

i

ii

vi

vii

Equal contribution of parents

Equal payoff for parents

Best investment strategy

Convergence on even sex ratio

Fisher (1930)

iii

iv

v

Equal payoff for sexes

Higher success of rare sex ‘individuals’

Higher returns from rarer sex

i

ii

vi

vii

Equal contribution of parents

Equal payoff for parents

Best investment strategy

Convergence on even sex ratio

Fisher (1930)

iii

iv

v

Equal payoff for sexes

Higher success of rare sex ‘individuals’

Higher returns from rarer sex

i

ii

iv

v

vi

vii

Equal contribution of parents

Equal payoff for parents

Best investment strategy

Convergence on even sex ratio

Fisher (1930)

viiiTransmit the tendency to future generations

iii

iv

v

Equal payoff for sexes

Higher success of rare sex ‘individuals’

Higher returns from rarer sex