the brain balance program in review
DESCRIPTION
TRANSCRIPT
The Brain Balance Program in Review:A Critique Through Sperry’s Eyes
Carrie LeschakPSY 405
Spring 2013
Photo courtesy of nap.edu
What is the Brain Balance Program?• “Neurobehavioral/developmental disorders”
• Attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD)• Autism/autism spectrum disorders• Asperger’s syndrome• Childhood disintegrative disorder (CDD)• Dyslexia/processing disorders• Obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD)• Oppositional defiant disorder (ODD)• Tourette syndrome• Nonverbal learning disability
• Functional Disconnect Syndrome (FDS)
FDS• “An imbalance in the connections and function between and within the hemispheres (sides) of your child’s brain”
Problem #1—Speculation
•Melillo says neurobehavioral disorders can all be “accurately grouped” into the category of Functional Disconnection Syndrome
•Mere speculation
Problem #2—Miracle Cure• Melillo calls Brain Balance a cure rather than a treatment
• Claims that symptoms “disappear” because of Brain Balance
• Cost• Claims to be a panacea• No scientific evidence (a separate problem in itself)
Problem #3—Lack of External Verification•One of the most problematic issues about Brain Balance
•Completely theoretical at this point in time•No evidence
• Website offers one pilot study• List of references on the site are unscientific, dead-links, or referencing works written by the founder of Brain Balance himself
Problem #4—Lack of Primary Sources• Melillo’s book, Disconnected Kids provides countless statements about the science, the statistics surrounding certain diagnoses, previous findings…yet he never mentions anything directly
• Uses generic labels: • “Researchers now know”• “Scientists are now finding”• “They say that”• “It’s been found that”
Problem #5—Oversimplification• Sperry recognized that the brain was made up of two independently functioning halves
• People have manifested this idea into a cut and dry list of abilities for both sides of the brain, and although there is evidence for localization of function, multiple areas of the brain are often part of a single function
Sperry’s Biggest Complaints•Lack of external verification
•Lack of primary sources
•Oversimplification
Sperry’s final say on the program:
• Further research needed to support findings
• Primary sources are needed to validate statements made in the text
• Sperry’s presumed critique turned out overwhelmingly negative