the case of the atlas experiment at cernbaoman.files.wordpress.com/2009/12/max...dec 03, 2009 ·...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: The Case of the ATLAS Experiment at CERNbaoman.files.wordpress.com/2009/12/max...Dec 03, 2009 · Experiment at CERN, 3 December 2009 4 ATLAS Plenary Meeting Collaboration Board Resource](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022050515/5f9f5701fcbc725f49177077/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Prof. Max Boiset: The case of the ATLASExperiment at CERN, 3 December 2009
1
The Case of the
ATLAS Experiment at CERN
Max Boisot
ESADE, Barcelona
&
The I-Space Institute
The ATLAS Experiment at CERN
• The ATLAS experiment at CERN is one of four that,working with the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), willexplore new physics in the 14 TeV energy range.
• The ATLAS detector is one of the largest, most complex,and most ambiHous experimental machines ever built.
• Its construcHon involved over 2500 physicists from 135research insHtutes spread across 33 countries.
2
![Page 2: The Case of the ATLAS Experiment at CERNbaoman.files.wordpress.com/2009/12/max...Dec 03, 2009 · Experiment at CERN, 3 December 2009 4 ATLAS Plenary Meeting Collaboration Board Resource](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022050515/5f9f5701fcbc725f49177077/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Prof. Max Boiset: The case of the ATLASExperiment at CERN, 3 December 2009
2
How does knowledge emerge in anorganizaHon as extended and complex
as the ATLAS CollaboraHon?
3
The Large Hadron Collider (LHC)
4
![Page 3: The Case of the ATLAS Experiment at CERNbaoman.files.wordpress.com/2009/12/max...Dec 03, 2009 · Experiment at CERN, 3 December 2009 4 ATLAS Plenary Meeting Collaboration Board Resource](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022050515/5f9f5701fcbc725f49177077/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Prof. Max Boiset: The case of the ATLASExperiment at CERN, 3 December 2009
3
ATLAS is one of four LHC detectors
5
The ATLAS Detector
6
![Page 4: The Case of the ATLAS Experiment at CERNbaoman.files.wordpress.com/2009/12/max...Dec 03, 2009 · Experiment at CERN, 3 December 2009 4 ATLAS Plenary Meeting Collaboration Board Resource](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022050515/5f9f5701fcbc725f49177077/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Prof. Max Boiset: The case of the ATLASExperiment at CERN, 3 December 2009
4
ATLASPlenary Meeting
CollaborationBoard
ResourceReview Board
CB ChairAdvisory Group Spokesperson
ResourcesCoordinator
TechnicalCoordinator
ExecutiveBoard
InnerDetector
ComputingCoordination
LArCalorimeter
Data Prep.Coordination
TileCalorimeter
Physics b>Coordination
MuonInstrumentation
Upgrade SGCoordinator
Trigger/DAQ
Pub. Comm.Coordinator
Commissioning/Run Coordinator
AdditionalMembers
TriggerCoordination
The ATLAS Organization
7
Detection
Luminosity (Collision Rate)
Data acquisition
ATLAS Performance Spidergraph
8
![Page 5: The Case of the ATLAS Experiment at CERNbaoman.files.wordpress.com/2009/12/max...Dec 03, 2009 · Experiment at CERN, 3 December 2009 4 ATLAS Plenary Meeting Collaboration Board Resource](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022050515/5f9f5701fcbc725f49177077/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Prof. Max Boiset: The case of the ATLASExperiment at CERN, 3 December 2009
5
The ATLAS Puzzle
• The CollaboraHon is held together by MoUs
• Decision making is boWom-‐up
• Decision making is distributed
How does the Collabora/on manage to reach the/ps of the spidergraph?
9
The Information-Space(I-‐Space)
A Conceptual Framework
![Page 6: The Case of the ATLAS Experiment at CERNbaoman.files.wordpress.com/2009/12/max...Dec 03, 2009 · Experiment at CERN, 3 December 2009 4 ATLAS Plenary Meeting Collaboration Board Resource](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022050515/5f9f5701fcbc725f49177077/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Prof. Max Boiset: The case of the ATLASExperiment at CERN, 3 December 2009
6
Three Kinds of Knowledge
• Experien(al – what can I see, hear, feel, smell, ortouch?
• Narra(ve – what can I say about it?
• Abstract Symbolic – what can I extract from itwhich is stable or durable?
11
Structuring Information
Codifiedand
Abstract
Uncodifiedand
Concrete
Abstract Symbolic Knowledge
Narrative Knowledge
Experiential Knowledge
Ref.
1.1.
1 ©
Max
Boi
sot
1999
12
![Page 7: The Case of the ATLAS Experiment at CERNbaoman.files.wordpress.com/2009/12/max...Dec 03, 2009 · Experiment at CERN, 3 December 2009 4 ATLAS Plenary Meeting Collaboration Board Resource](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022050515/5f9f5701fcbc725f49177077/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Prof. Max Boiset: The case of the ATLASExperiment at CERN, 3 December 2009
7
The I-Space: The Key Concept
DiffusedUndiffused
Codifiedand
Abstract
Uncodifiedand
Concrete
StructuringInformation
Sharing Information
Experiential
Narrative
Abstract Symbolic
Ref.
1.1.
2.1
© M
ax B
oiso
t
13
Sharing Information DiffusedUndiffused
Codifiedand
Abstract
UncodifiedAnd
Concrete
ZenBuddhists
BondTraders
StructuringInformation
Ref.
1.1.
2.1
© M
ax B
oiso
t
The I-Space: Examples
14
![Page 8: The Case of the ATLAS Experiment at CERNbaoman.files.wordpress.com/2009/12/max...Dec 03, 2009 · Experiment at CERN, 3 December 2009 4 ATLAS Plenary Meeting Collaboration Board Resource](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022050515/5f9f5701fcbc725f49177077/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Prof. Max Boiset: The case of the ATLASExperiment at CERN, 3 December 2009
8
Scarcity
Codifiedand
Abstract
Uncodifiedand
ConcreteUndiffused Diffused
Maximum ValueRegion
Utility
The Paradox of ValueRe
f. 1
.1.1.1
© M
ax B
oiso
t 19
99
15
Codified & Abstract Knowledge
• You gain manipulability and predictability• It behaves like an object• It can generalize to new cases• You can store it• You can write contracts• You can sell it
But:• You may lose contextual richness, feeling, andunderstanding
16
![Page 9: The Case of the ATLAS Experiment at CERNbaoman.files.wordpress.com/2009/12/max...Dec 03, 2009 · Experiment at CERN, 3 December 2009 4 ATLAS Plenary Meeting Collaboration Board Resource](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022050515/5f9f5701fcbc725f49177077/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Prof. Max Boiset: The case of the ATLASExperiment at CERN, 3 December 2009
9
Lost for Words?
17
Bureaucracies
Clans
Fiefs
Markets
DiffusedUndiffused
Codifiedand
Abstract
Uncodifiedand
Concrete
Institutions & Cultures in I-Space
Ref.
1.1.
1.3 ©
Max
Boi
sot
18
![Page 10: The Case of the ATLAS Experiment at CERNbaoman.files.wordpress.com/2009/12/max...Dec 03, 2009 · Experiment at CERN, 3 December 2009 4 ATLAS Plenary Meeting Collaboration Board Resource](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022050515/5f9f5701fcbc725f49177077/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Prof. Max Boiset: The case of the ATLASExperiment at CERN, 3 December 2009
10
Cultural & Institutional NetworksBureaucracy
Fief
Market
Clan
19
ICTs and the Diffusion Curve
DiffusedUndiffused
Codified
Uncodified
Ref
. 1.1
.1.2
© M
ax B
oiso
t
DiffusionEffect
BandwidthEffect
20
![Page 11: The Case of the ATLAS Experiment at CERNbaoman.files.wordpress.com/2009/12/max...Dec 03, 2009 · Experiment at CERN, 3 December 2009 4 ATLAS Plenary Meeting Collaboration Board Resource](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022050515/5f9f5701fcbc725f49177077/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Prof. Max Boiset: The case of the ATLASExperiment at CERN, 3 December 2009
11
The Impact of ICTs on Culture
DiffusedUndiffused
Codified
Uncodified
Ref
. 1.1
.1.2
© M
ax B
oiso
t
Bureaucracies
Fiefs
Markets
Clans
DiffusionEffect
BandwidthEffect
21
Culture and Complexity
DiffusedUndiffused
Codified
Uncodified
Ref
. 1.1
.1.2
© M
ax B
oiso
t
Bureaucracies
Fiefs
Markets
Clans
Order
Complexity
Chaos
22
![Page 12: The Case of the ATLAS Experiment at CERNbaoman.files.wordpress.com/2009/12/max...Dec 03, 2009 · Experiment at CERN, 3 December 2009 4 ATLAS Plenary Meeting Collaboration Board Resource](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022050515/5f9f5701fcbc725f49177077/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Prof. Max Boiset: The case of the ATLASExperiment at CERN, 3 December 2009
12
Codified/Abstract
Uncodified/Concrete
Undiffused Diffused
Ref.
1.1.
2.4 © M
ax B
oiso
t
IndividualResearcher
Research Group
SponsoringOrganization
ScientificCommunity
Epistemic Boundaries
23
Applying the I-Space to theATLAS Puzzle
![Page 13: The Case of the ATLAS Experiment at CERNbaoman.files.wordpress.com/2009/12/max...Dec 03, 2009 · Experiment at CERN, 3 December 2009 4 ATLAS Plenary Meeting Collaboration Board Resource](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022050515/5f9f5701fcbc725f49177077/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Prof. Max Boiset: The case of the ATLASExperiment at CERN, 3 December 2009
13
Bureaucracies
Clans
Fiefs
Markets
A Distributed Network?
DiffusedUndiffused
Codifiedand
Abstract
Uncodifiedand
Concrete
The ATLASNetwork?
Ref.
1.1.
1.3 ©
Max
Boi
sot
1999
25
Clans
Bureaucracies
Fiefs
Markets
Why Doesn’t ATLAS Fly Apart?
DiffusedUndiffused
Codifiedand
Abstract
Uncodifiedand
Concrete
Order
Complexity
Chaos
Ref.
1.1.
1.3 ©
Max
Boi
sot
1999
26
![Page 14: The Case of the ATLAS Experiment at CERNbaoman.files.wordpress.com/2009/12/max...Dec 03, 2009 · Experiment at CERN, 3 December 2009 4 ATLAS Plenary Meeting Collaboration Board Resource](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022050515/5f9f5701fcbc725f49177077/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Prof. Max Boiset: The case of the ATLASExperiment at CERN, 3 December 2009
14
Traffic Lights asHierarchical
Coordinationand Control
HierarchicalControl Can Get
Complicated!
![Page 15: The Case of the ATLAS Experiment at CERNbaoman.files.wordpress.com/2009/12/max...Dec 03, 2009 · Experiment at CERN, 3 December 2009 4 ATLAS Plenary Meeting Collaboration Board Resource](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022050515/5f9f5701fcbc725f49177077/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Prof. Max Boiset: The case of the ATLASExperiment at CERN, 3 December 2009
15
The Traffic Roundabout as Boundary Object
Detector as Boundary Object?
Group 2 Group 6
Group 3
Group 1 Group 7
Group 4
Group 5
30
![Page 16: The Case of the ATLAS Experiment at CERNbaoman.files.wordpress.com/2009/12/max...Dec 03, 2009 · Experiment at CERN, 3 December 2009 4 ATLAS Plenary Meeting Collaboration Board Resource](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022050515/5f9f5701fcbc725f49177077/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Prof. Max Boiset: The case of the ATLASExperiment at CERN, 3 December 2009
16
Bureaucracies
Clans
Fiefs
Distributed Networks/Boundary Objects
DiffusedUndiffused
Codifiedand
Abstract
Uncodifiedand
Concrete
Markets
Networks
The ATLAS Detector
Ref.
1.1.
1.3 ©
Max
Boi
sot
1999
31
Matrix vs. Ecology
Pro
ject
Axi
s
Technical Axis
The NASA Matrix
CERN
ATLAS
The ATLAS/CERN Ecology
32
![Page 17: The Case of the ATLAS Experiment at CERNbaoman.files.wordpress.com/2009/12/max...Dec 03, 2009 · Experiment at CERN, 3 December 2009 4 ATLAS Plenary Meeting Collaboration Board Resource](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022050515/5f9f5701fcbc725f49177077/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Prof. Max Boiset: The case of the ATLASExperiment at CERN, 3 December 2009
17
The ATLAS Hypothesis:
• The ATLAS CollaboraHon has to navigate mulHple stakeholder cultures
• Each operates with different truth and jus(fica(on condiHons
• The ATLAS challenge is then to manage a cultural ecology
Hypothesis: The Detector acts as a boundary object that binds the cultural ecology
into a complex adap/ve system (CAS)
33
Implications:• A socio-‐technical example of what Andy Clark (2008) refers to as
the extended mind
• Also an example of Per Bak’s (1997) Self-‐Organized Cri(cality(SOC)
• The ATLAS CollaboraHon sits at the edge of chaos
• The binding agents are trust, based on shared values and sharedinteracHons with a boundary object: the detector
Could such a phenomenon be replicated within or across commercialorganiza/ons?
34
![Page 18: The Case of the ATLAS Experiment at CERNbaoman.files.wordpress.com/2009/12/max...Dec 03, 2009 · Experiment at CERN, 3 December 2009 4 ATLAS Plenary Meeting Collaboration Board Resource](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022050515/5f9f5701fcbc725f49177077/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Prof. Max Boiset: The case of the ATLASExperiment at CERN, 3 December 2009
18
THANK YOU
35