THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO

REPORT TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION

DATE ISSUED: December 2, 20 I0 REPORT NO. PC-lO-lOS

ATTENTION:

SUBJECT:

OWNERIAPPLICANT:

SUMMARY

Planning Commission, Agenda of December 9, 2010

AT&T MOBILITY - LA JOLLA COMMONSPROJECT NO. 212265, PROCESS 4

CITY OF SAN DIEGOAT&T MOBILITY

)IVER5I1Y

Issue(s): Should the Planning Commission approve an existing Wireless CommunicationFaci lity located at 4949 Eastgate Mall Drive within the University Community PlanningArea?

Staff Recommendation:

1. APPROVE Planned Development Permit No. 798878.

2. APPROVE Neighborhood Use Permit No. 798879.

Community Planning Group Recommendation: On October 12, 2010 the UniversityCommunity Planning Board voted to recommend approval of this project (Attachment10)

Environmental Review: The project is categorically exempt from the CaliforniaEnvironmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to CEQA State Guidelines, Section 15303,New Construction. This project is not pending an appeal of the environmentaldetermination. The environmental exemption determination for this project was made onSeptember 10,2010, and the opportunity to appeal that determination endedOctober 6, 2010 (Attachment 12).

Fiscal Impact Statement: None with this action. All costs associated with theprocessing of this project are paid from a deposit account maintained by the applicant.

Code Enforcement Impact: None with this action.

Housing Impact Statement: None with this action.

BACKGROUND

The project is located on the City of San Diego North City Water Reclamation Plant. Thereclamation plant consists of several water treatment buildings/tanks in addition to anadministrative building on the north westerly side ofthe property. All authorized vehicles andpersonnel must enter through a secure entrance on the Eastgate Mall access path. The property issurrounded by the 805 Freeway to the west, Miramar Road to the south, Eastgate Mall Drive tothe north, and industrial development to the east. Although the facility is located within the Part77 FAA notification area, the proposed design will not exceed the permitted height allowanceand will not require an FAA No Hazard to Air Navigation notice.

DISCUSSION

Project Description - AT&T Mobility submitted an application for a Neighborhood Use Permit(NUP) and a plarmed Development Permit (PDP) to install a Wireless Communication Facility(WCF) consisting of the installation of twelve antennas concealed behind Fiberglass ReinforcedPanels (FRPs). As illustrated in the zoning drawings and the photosimulation, the FRP panel hasbeen designed to replicate the current rooftop pyramid feature (Attachment 5). Due to this uniqueand creative design, AT&T Mobility will be able to fully conceal their proposed antennas fromany public perspectives. The associated ground mounted equipment is located behind a three­sided 8-foot high wall (approximately 371-sqaure feet) within an existing planter area on thewesterly side ofthe property. Due primarily to the existing topography, the westerly side of theproperty where the equipment is proposed is set back from the 805 Freeway and screened by theexisting raised grade reducing all visual impacts to the proposed equipment location (Attachment8).

Wireless Communication FacilityfWCFl Regulation - The project is located within the RS-l­14 zone and requires an NUP, per Municipal Code Section l41.0420(d)(2) which states that aNeighborhood Use Permit is required for all Wireless Communication Facilities in Residentialzone where the antennas associated with the WCF are located more than 100 feet from theproperty line of day care(s), elementary and middle school, and single or multi-unit residentialuses. The project also requires a PDP to exceed the 35-foot height limit established within theRS-I-14 zone and to exceed the 2S0-square foot equipment size limitation per Municipal CodeSection 141.0420(g)(3). These following deviations result in a consolidated NUP and PDP,Planning Commission decision with appeal rights to the City Council. After thoroughlyreviewing this project, statIhas determined that this WCF is appropriate and complies with Cityof San Diego Municipal Code section 141.0420.

Community Plan Analysis: The project location has been designated for industrial use in theUniversity Community Plan (Attachment 2). The University Community Plan does not containspecific policies on wireless communication facility development.

Council Policy 600-43 - The guidelines establish a hierarchy from the most preferred locations

-2-

(Preference 1) to the least preferred location (Preference 4) for WCFs. The project is proposedwithin a Preference 2 location according to Council Policy 600-43, which categorizes WCF'saccording to land use in which they are located. In this case, the project is located in a residentialzone containing a non-residential use and is considered to be a Preference 2 location. However,the proposed deviations required a PDP resulting in a Process 4 level decision. The applicant isrequired to submit a site justification letter explaining why a Preference 2 site was selected overPreference I level sites. AT&T Mobility's site justification letter pointed to a combination ofconcerns from the limited availability of preference I locations and the ability to design acompletely concealed facility. Also, due to the existing height of the water treatment building,the expected coverage to the surrounding area may be reduced if moved to another location.

General Plan - The General Plan, Section UD-A.15, states that WCFs should be concealed inexisting structures when possible, or otherwise use camouflage and screening techniques to hideor blend the facilities into the surrounding area. The design of the facility is to be aestheticallypleasing and respectful of the neighborhood context. The AT&T Mobility WCF design consistsof twelve antennas fully concealed inside a rooftop pyramid feature. As illustrated on thephotosimluation, the design of the faux pyramid is consistent with the other rooftop pyramid. Theassociated ground mounted equipment is behind a three-sided 8-foot high wall within an existingplanter area on the westerly side of the property. Due primarily to the existing topography, thewesterly side of the property where the equipment is proposed is set back from the 805 Freewayand screened by the existing raised grade reducing all visual impacts to the proposed equipmentlocation.

Conclusion - The project has been determined by staff to be consistent with the purpose andintent of the applicable development regulations of the San Diego Municipal Code, whichincludes the development regulations from the RS-1-14 zone and the Wireless CommunicationFacilities Regulations Section 141.0420 except for the requested deviations. The project asproposed is requesting a height deviation to exceed the 35-foot height limit and to exceed the250-square feet equipment limitation. These deviations can be supported by staff as a result ofthe creative design employed by the applicant. With the fully stealth design, neither the antennas,nor the equipment will be visible. Therefore, staff supports the University Planning Group'srecommendation to support the proposed AT&T Mobility project. In conclusions, Staffrecommends that the Planning Commission approve Planned Development Permit No. 798878and Neighborhood Use Permit No. 798879.

ALTERNATIVES

1. APPROVE Planned Development Permit No. 798878 and Neighborhood Use Pennit No.798879, with modifications.

2. DENY Planned Development Permit No. 798878 and Neighborhood Use Permit No.798879, if the findings required to approve the project cannot be affirmed.

- 3 -

Respectfully submitted,

Mike WestlakeProgram ManagerDevelopment Services Department

Attachments:

I. Aerial Photograph2. Community Plan Land Use Map3. Project Location Map4. Project Data Sheet5. Project Site Plan(s)6. Draft Resolution with Findings7. Draft Permit with Conditions8. Photo Simulation(s)9. Project Site Photoes)10. Community Planning Group Recommendation11. Ownership Disclosure Statement12. Notice of Exemption13. Notice of Hearing14. Project Chronology

-4-

Si n TseA sociate PlannerD elopment Servo s Department

•Aerial PhotoAT&T Mobility La Jolla Commons - Project No. 2122654949 Eastgate Mall Drive, San Diego, CA 92121

North

W

~~

~-I~

(I

\\\

Community Land Use Map (University)

AT&T Mobility La Jolla Commons - Project No. 2122654949 Eastgate Mall Drive, San Diego, CA 92121

UniversityExisting Conditions

Land UseLegendCJ,......,,~Itt.-......

~-.".~"-"., ... --"-: __"Mt.--~e-{UIIlIer_1

c:J N1u.....;W-....sw.CJ _11rI..~r ....,__)"Ii_-.M/)'CJ~ UIiWot.. T....'''''''"'''' IWMM.--

.~-.-..""-~P.....;o,...s_

_ Prlor_,,-"_

0--~8olHI.W_

North

W

~;I>

~-lr->

Project Location MapAT&T Mobility La Jolla Commons - Project No. 2122654949 Eastgate Mall Drive, San Diego, CA 92121

111Muir

Lower Lot

~>

I<.>

t.EICamino

MemorialPa

MIr.rllar Rd

North

W

to\\f8,l1\l'1 Rd

.l'G ~..

'\II\

~'"~

ill

Iqf i

tf Q.1.!'(1~ ~~

d!'<iJ.col'!

car' SorrentoValley

''';';-

V

..

NobelA1h1eIJC Aiel

.I

Nobel 0'

UnlvOf'Sl\y City

w

NOIJl'/¢

.... Jolla V>bg. O!

i llepholll'f I!!i Unlve<oioy4 Towne center

-f»,1S'o",

'''''0,:I''i'"

RegenOl RdWes1Lot

N06o,Or

•Doyl.Comm..nry

Park

.., MOMet We!&$SCience. EMtgl:1l&

Research Ptlrk City Park

Me..~Houoing

4~~.0e0<

cOJ. . PreussQ S<ho<ll

'<JO\ll''''' .../It<

a...1>o1lFoeld

S"'ff L.a'~

San Diego• CalifornIa

Temple

fPV

G

P665~

'~"I"

UniversIty01 CalilomiaSan Diego

~ ~SOlIh

Colleoo

Universrty ofCallforn,a San

o.ogo Pall<

.. La CaS8

i

S<ho<ll ofModiclne 111

cne cale111

,,\/\'Mil" Dr

...~

.., Trackand Fleld

~

Nor1ll,elm"".

'00 111

H

tf.f

I~

~

1

<8

ATTACHMENT 4

PROJECT DATA SHEET

PROJECT NAME: AT&T Mobility La Jolla Commons

PROJECT DESCRIPTION: Wireless Communication Facility (WCF) consisting oftwelve (12)panel antennas completely concealed inside a faux pyramid on therooftop of the existing water treatment building. The groundmounted equipment is concealed behind a 3 7I-square feet CMUenclosure, not visible to the public.

COMMUNITY pLAN AREA: University

DISCRETIONARY Planned Development Pelmit & Neighborhood Use PermitACTIONS:

COMMUNITY PLAN LAND IndustrialUSE DESIGNATION:

(OP-I-O ZONING INFORMATION:

ZONE: RS-I-14

HEIGHT LIMIT: 35-feet

FRONT SETBACK: 15-feet

SIDE SETBACK: 10-feet

REAR SETBACK: 4-feet

ADJACENT LAND USE DESIGNATION EXISTING LAND USEPROPERTIES: & ZONE

NORTH: RS-I-14 Undeveloped Land

SOUTH: RS-I-14 Undeveloped Land

EAST: AR-I-1 US Goverrunent

WEST: RS-I-14 805 Freeway

DEVIATIONS ORVARIANCES The project proposes to exceed the 35-foot height limit and to exceed the

REQUESTED: 250-square feet equipment limitation.

COMMUNITYPLANNING GROUP On October 12,2010, the University Planning Group voted to support the

RECOMMENDATION: AT&T Mobility La Jolla Commons project (Attachment 9).

LA JOLLA COMMONS4949 EASTGATE MALL DRIVE

SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA 92121SS0079

4. AU. ERQSK)H./S£OlU£N'T CONTROl 0EVlC!S SHAll aE MAINTAINED IN WORKING ORDER ATAU.. TINES.

J~~.IIff,.., RGmt l AtIociatn, Int.Arizona' California. Nevada

Att:u>nQ: (602) 2S16-5579California: (Ug) 150-3921Nevado: (702) 795-0059

PROPRIETARY INFORMAnONTHE INFORMATION COHTAIi::D IN THISSET OF CQNSlRUCTlON DOCUMENTS ISPROPRIETARY BY NATURE. !>NY USEOR DISClOSURE OTHER THAN THATWHICH RELATES TO AT&TWIRELESS IS STRICTLY PROHIBITED.

PREPARfD FOR

~ at&t5738 PACIFlC CENTER BOULEVARD

2ND FlOORSAN 01£00. CAUF'ORNIA 92121

~* c-<2!i816 *

~tr(J"CAU~

APPROVAlS

R.F.

ZONING

CONSTiUICTION

SIT! ACOUSlTlON

OWNER APPROVAL

SITE N.WE

LA JOLlA COMMONS

PROJECT NUWBER

SS00794949 EASTGATE UAU.. DRM:

SAN DIEGO. CAUFORNlA 92121

ORAW[H(j OAITS

04/01/10 PREUI.I ZD REVIEW (PI)04/20/10 lem: ZO'S (P2)05/17/10 CL£HT CONtlENTS (FJ)07/06/10 CUENT C(Jlr,l"'~ (F4)07/22/10 CUEHT CONt.400S (FS)

SHEET tlTLE

TITLE SHEET

T-1

APPLICABLE CODES

SHEET INDEXTln.E SHEETGENERAl SPECIFICATIONS

SITE PI..AHENlAAGEO SITE FVN AND .AN1ENNA CONF'lCuRAnONSENlAACED EOUIPMENT LAYOUT AND Af\TENNA. CONFICURAnoNSaEVATlOtolSEl.!VA11ONSNlT!NHA DETAllS

l..NIDSCAPE DEVE1.OPNENT ~ AS-8~T

SITE SliiVEY (FOR REFERENCE ONLy')SITE SURVEY (FOR REF!RENCE ONLy)

1-11-2

A-OA-I10.-1.1A-2A-2.1A-JL-I

0-10-2

Tl"IIS PROJ=:CT IS AN UNOCCUPiED WIRElESS PCS iEl.£COMt,I;UNICATIONS FACllJTYANa. IS EXEldPT fROW DISA£I.EO ACCESS REQlJlRalENl'S.

ACCESSIBILITY DISCLAIMER

SCALE

IN 1'H:E~ 0; COHFUCT, lHE MOST RESTRlCTI\'E COO~ SHALL PREVAIL

ALL WORK SHALL COI.lPLY W1lH THE FOLLOWING APPUDBLE CODES:

CAUF'ORNlA FIRE CODE. 2007 EDITIONCPLlF'ORNlA 6UIL1lIt'tG cOIlE, 2007 EDITIONCAUF'ORNIA PlUt.lBtNC COOt. 2007 EDITIONCAUF'ORHlA WEOWOCAL CODE. 2007 EDmONNAM'Url. El.£CTRICAl COO£. 2007 EDmctt

TliE DRAWING SCAL£S SHOWN IN THIS SET REPRESENT THE CORRECT SCALE ONLYWHEN lHESE DRAWINGS ARE PRlNTED IN A 24"'x.l6" FORlILf,f. IF lHlS OAAWING SETIS NOT 24-XJ6~. TItS SET IS NOT TO SC'lE.

RF INFORMATION

GSM UMTSB69 - 874.6 "Hz

Tx 890 - 891.4 "Hz 874.6 - 879.6 MHz1950 - 1952.8 MHz 194<5 - 1950 MHz1970 - '980 tdHz

B2' - 829.4 MHzRx ..5 - 846.4 MHz 829.6 - 834.4 MHz

1870 - 1872.8 MHz 1865 - 1869.8 MHz1890 - 1900 "Hz

MAXERP: I 850 l.trlz: 54 WATIS'900 "'Hz: 54.5 WAITS

J56 so. n.I-N (NON-SPRiNKl&ED)

U-N (NON-SPRtNKLERED)

B-2

B-2

CITY OF 5N'l DIEGO

AracT'MREI.£SS5738 PAC1FIC C£NTER BOlUV1lRD. 2ND FlOORSNI DIEGO. CALifORNIA 92121

roY Of SNl DIEGOsnc: CONT,.tCT; CHRlS'l'Wi ANDERSON4949 EASTGATE )U,LL DRM:SAN DIEGO, CAUFORNIA. 92121PHONE: (619) 236-7073

NO

J45-<l21-Q1

RS1-14

OTHER ON-SITE m.Ea:Il FJa..lTES:

ASSESSORS PMta WAlSER:

EXtSl1'IC ZOfrIHG:

PROPOSED PRQ.£CT N£A:.

EXI:S'r»fG TYPE OF COHST'R\JC'TKlH

PROPOSED l'YPE OF CONSTRUCOOH:

EXIsnNG OCCUPANCY:

PROPOSED OCCUPANCY:

JURlSlJcnoN:

LNfD OWNER:

BMPS

5. AU.. SlOPES THAT ARE CREATED OR 0ISTIJR8ED BY e:t:ltOSTRl.ICllON ACTMTY NUST BEPROlECTEO AGAINST EROS'ON AHD SEOlwOO TRN.sPORT AT AU. 11101£$.

15. THE STORAGE: OF ALl. CONSTRUCTION hlATERJALS AND EQUIPMENT MUST BE PROTECTEDAGAINST ANY POTENT1AL.. RELEASE OF PO\..l.UTANTS !NIQ mE fNV!BfJNMENI

2. ALL STOCK PUS OF UIIoCOt.IPACTEO SOIL AND/OR eUlI.OHC NATERl.'lS THAT loRE.I~ TO BE t.£fT UH?ROTECTm FOR A PERIOO GREATER THN\I SEVEN CALENDAR DAYSARE TO BE PROVIDED WiTH EROSIDN N¥J SEOIIIENT CONTROlS. SUCH SOIl MUST BEPROTECTm EACH QAY WHEN THE PROBABIUTY OF RAIN IS :(40 OR GREATER.

3. A CONCR£TE WASHOUT SHAlL BE PROVIDED ON All PRo.JECTS WHICH PtlQPO& THECONSTRUC11ON OF ANY CONCRETE IMPROYEt.4ENTS 1l1AT AAE TO BE POURED IN PlACE ONTHE SITE.

DEVELOPMENT SUMMARY

STORM WATER QUAlJTY NOTESCONSTRUCTION SMP'S

THIS PROJECT SHAU COWPlY WITH AU. RECUREMEHTS OF THE ST..TE PERWiT; CAUFORNIAREGlONH. WAT[R QUAlJTY CONTROl BO.t.RD, SJrN DIEGO REGION, OROER NO. 2001.01N'OES NO. CAS<l10875~/fWWW·SWRCI3·CA..GtN/RWQCB9/PROCRANS/SD_STORhlWATER.HTI.l..)AND THE CI1Y OF' SV( OIEGO LAND OE'tn.OPMENT CODE(HTTl'//ClfRKDOC-SANNET.OO'J/RtCl<TS1TE/GETCOtfTENT/lOCALPDf?OtoIW_OBJEcno_090014518008CC4J)

NOTES 1-6 eEl.OW REPRESENT KEY hllNINUM REOU1RENENTS FOR CONSTRUCTION BMP'S.

1. SUF'FJClENT BNPS MUST BE INSTAL1.ED TO PREVENT SILT. t.lUD DR oTHER CONSTRUCTIOND£ERlS FRON BEINe TRACKED INTO THE ADJACENT STREEf{S) OR STORhf WATERCONVEYNICE SYS'1'DfS DU~ TO COHST'RUC'OON VE-UCLES OR N(r OTHER CQNSlRUCTTONACTMTY. THE CQNTR..tCTOR SHotU. BE RESPONSIBLE FOR CLEMlHG Nl'f SUCH DEBRIS THATMAY BE IN THE STREET AT THE £NO OF EACH WORK ClAY ~ Af1ER A STORt.l EVENT THATCNJSES A BRE£Of III THE 1HSTAl...l.£D CONSTRUCTION BM?S.

at&t

ARCHITECT:JEFFREY ROWE a: ASSOCIAlES3 SAN JOAQUIN PLAZAS\ITE: 155

NEWPORT BEACH. CNJF"ORNlA 92660

PHONE: (949) 760-J929FAX: (949) 760-3931

CONTACT: J~ ROJ.IE

lAND SURVEYOR:BERT~ AND ASSOaATES. INC.J68\ }JRWAY A'VENUESUITE: t(-1

COSTA MESA. CAUFORNIA 92626PHONE: 714-!l'57-1567FA:k. 714-~7-15M

CONTACT: BERT HAZE

AT4tT MOBIlJIY PROf'DSES TO COHSlRUCT. OPERATE ANDM,4,INTAIN AN UNI.IANNEO W1REl...ESS COf,lhlUN!CA.TIONS F'ACIl11"'f.TJ-'IS F"ACIUTY WIll CONSIST or tHE FOLLOWING:

• INSTALL eN) (6) ....T&T OUTDOOR EOUIPUENt' CABlNETShlOUNTED ON A PROPOSED COHCRElE PAD WlTH!N ANEXISlWG POURED IN plJoCE ENCL..OSURE.

• INSTAlL (N) (12) ....T&T Nfi'9lNAS WITH (N) (24) TWA'SMOUNTED IN A PROPOSED FRP P'Y1W.lID ON ROOFTOfl.

• INSTALl. (N) (18) UNES OF COAX.

•~ AND TEI...E?HONE lITlUTY RUNS TO PROPOSEDEOUIPNEf','T A~

ElECTRICAL ENGINEER:

EDS. IHe.14BJ5 TOFT ORNELAKE ELSINORE, CAUF'ORNICE 92530

PHONE.: (951) 351-1800FAX: (951) 609-U·4-l1COf«ACT: ROBfRf CASTRO

CUENTS REPRESENTAnVE:ilJlC:K a VEATCH9280 WlL.1.OW CREEK ROADSUIlE:. 310SAN DEGO. CAUFORNIA 92131PHONE: (a58) 603-7&47CONTACT: JAMES O·MAU.£Y

PROJECT DESCRIPTION

CONSULTANT TEAM

SAN DIEGO

VICINITY MAP

SPECIAL INSPECTIONS1 tQNCR'" 13.1 V£RI'Y SOli. COtIlIOOHS WE SlIISTANTIALLY 142 BOlTS INSTAI.LEtI IN CONCIETE COtf'QRUNICE MTH n£ SOl. IN';{Sl'I('JJIO REPORr, CONCRETE' UOWENT-R£S~ SPACE fiW« 13.2 \Of'Y mAT FtIl,H)I.lJON EXCNfAtI)HS 00£JIl TO

• R£lNFORClNC srm N(/) FR£SlRESSI'tC STm PROPER 00'fH AHD eENIItG STRATA5.1 JU STRUCl\JfW. WEL.DI!I; 'J.3 PROY« SOL CCJ,ll>,tCT1ON TEST ll£!il.1JS. OO'TH CF5.2 WELD TESTftG 00C1ll 1I000000-l£SS1IC srm. FJWlE FU. RElATM: 00CSlTY. EI£..W'tG VH.W!.J WEUJNC ROGO~ S!E!l. 13.4 F'RC'tU. SOl. EXf!'N(SI()l TE5f RESW'S. EXPN6(14• l-ICK-SiRENCTH BOlll'lC taX. RfXOa.rlENOlIUIJNS FOR FtUOJIOHS, OH-7 STRUCTURAL WASONR'f GlW)( f\DClR g,.rra 0E5Dl FOR E"JCH u..DIIG SfTE

• ReNfORCW GYPSW COlI:m'E " SNOlIE COHIIICl SlSl£Jj, IttSUI.AnNG CONCRETE m " SPE<>Il. ""'" <_10 SPRAY-APPlIED FlRE?ROOFING " OFF-SITE FAlRCAl10N or Bl.I.l::O«; CX)WP(lNEJffS11 DEEP FOUHDAl101'IS (P1UNG. talED .t CISSOOS) 17 OTHER SFmN. tGPECllONS loS REQtJREll BY12 SHOi1:ftET£ OESICNER

NO. DESCIlIFT10H Of TYPE OF 11\SPEl::tKJN REOURED. UlCAlION. REWARKS.

GENERAL SPECIFICATIONS J~~loIInr _ t _ 1M.

Arlzono • California. NfYodo

(a02.) ty.-~71I

(tit) 1l1D-3t2t(70.1) 71'-00"

5736 PACIFIC CEI'fT'ER OOVLEVARD,.., rLOQR

s,.,.. DlEOO, CAUFORN.... 82121

~

~at&t

P1lOPRIF;T_ INF1lRIlATIOHlliE INFORMATIOH CONfAtHEO IN msSET OF CONS:T'Rl.K:fIO OOCUMENTS ISPROPRlErARY BY N'lTl.JRi. ANY USEoR DISCLOSURE 'OTHEFl' 1'1iI\N THATWHICH RELATES TO AT&:-TWIRl:l£SS IS 'STRICRY PFtOI·U9ET"ED

1 THf I.AT5I [tIlleN OF TIlE ~~ INSTI1l.JTE: OF ARCHITECTS DOCUMENTJa(l1 'XlE~ERll oott[)lTION5 OF il£ CONTRACT FoR CQ~UCl10N· ARE:INCLUDED Irt "ffi£S[ SPEClF'1001),S "5 IF CONPLtTaY FlEJlAlXl.lCE:D ~E1".

1, THIS fACll.lTY IS AN UH/JI:;CJFlED ~cs l'Eu::tt1~lAlH~T1ON5 sm: AH[) ISO:~PT FROM OIs-Bl£D .M;CESS ~Ew~ENfS.

J. PRIOR 10 mE SL.JOIoIISSJCN ~ aSH.a.u. VISIT 1l1E: .tOIl SIT!COtI()rooNS Kl'£CTlNG: THE8..EcrFllCAl.... t.l~ICIIL

WIDl 1'1-iE: COHSTRUCTlOHT*T TME: PRO..f:CT CANffiOCEE~INC; IW1'W cotH5CREF~CllES BE FOuf'(), L'r'H:)J1f'r ATot;fIt WRmNf;, ItlI THEi'ICllJl:E THE lIQAESFEaFlc"w,,'r' DIRECTED OTHEJi'M~ IF II DI~~,l/IjC;V

PROJECt W!NlIIGER AND NtCHIiECl' ARt" Nor "'lTlF1EO.~" !5l'UU. BE Hntl f{SFONSIIlLE: rnA JLl. eoS'TS 1Ht1lRI'£Cl TOREP'~R OR COIW:CT ~ ~S lHIiT IfESULf,

+. OAAw1NGS 5ioiU NOT~""nc ONLY.0fWIIHC SC'rL.£ NlOSCI\I..f DRAWINGS. 00[llI,It/'l5lONS IN 11£ f1F,tMCATE )HY w,1"EA/\CCI,IfW:r OF DRII'MNGlFIELD OINE1'lSIONS.

5. mE COOT1VCTQR SHHJ- INCUJl:I; IN lollS OR HEll: SIO M.L M.I\'1'£fIW.S.EtlUIF'UENT, AF'~~C!3 NO lJ8JR t.£CESSNlY Ta C<l~ THEWOFlK .-s IJOCi,rEO OR WFUJ) 8T lHf:SE: CIWIIINQS.

SITE: ACCUISlTlON

SI1E£T 1m..£.

IJR6,I'fINC I»,"TES

PR£lJ1d zo R~~ (PI)100:lC ZO'S (P2)C~T COH~EJ4TS (P3)CUENT ootAMmTS (P4)CUE:N.T CON~fS (P5)

T-2

GENERAL SPECIFICATIONS

55007949"!f EAS'l'oQATE: WI.l. ORNE

SoloN 01(00, ~AlANlA 9'2121

LA JOUA COt.lt.lONSSIT( """

04/01/1004/20/1005/~7/10

07/015/1007/22/10

OWNER M>PROVAt.

ZONIN(l

!l.F.

fl. CC'JN'mj(.T(lR s;-w.t HanFt JHE,u«r 1rII08IL11'r CON~UCTlClN~I':. ~E: PROPERTY ~D "Ttl!- A/ICHfItCT F" ~ tlETNLS AIlE:OONSlD~m IIiIPi'IJrlCt1CAL. • NOT WAmlPROOF, OR NOT'li'lTHIN CU:5TOWRY ~E 15 PERrtlFlwrn. IT IIIIIU ~I\:SSIJ~D 1li*IT TH~ ~5 N« otTJ.lL CETAJl.S MEHfT'ENDErl 10 Sl-IOW THE QF 'Il-lE DEMN. Ir,lINOfl:NO(lFlCATIONS ~ .efr S\IIT <KIB lXf4rJ1lONS, NtO ~Hl'I..L EEntCLUOED -'5 PART or

7. rnsnlUJ ElEV,\J\CWS AND ~rx:tI$ TO E1E JOI~E:O SHAu.. BE \ItAI1'1~ ElYrnf;:~~ eEFORE COO!iTRlJCJlOH. IF ~EY DIFfER F1«l". THOSE:SHOWN O~ n£ PL.»IS, THE CIMll.I.CTIlA' SIW.l ftlonFY THE "1'.&T *'IoeuTrOONSTftUCTlON I.IANIlG.ER -'NO n( ,tRCl-lrTECT SO 1M41 ".OOIRCItilCtfS c.ANEl(~ II~ pROC£mrlc 'IIr)ol THE 1fltIRM.

&. THE Cl:lHmNITO~ SHALL \€RFr' AlL 1'ELEPHOftlE o!It:~ EWIP1.1fMTLArours. SP£OFlCATJOIttS" PEJilr'mlWlC£, INSTAlJ..AnOH AND FINALl.OCA~ 'Ifml "'1.tr NlJBI.iTf CllMI'RLIC110~ I.INMQEF! !"FIOFl TOBINNWG~ THf.: C~ !iW.L 13[ AESPCHSIBU: FOROOORllllUollNC I-I!t WORI< WITH ER~N IVoQIO S'rS'1'D.lS.

a.. H.L S'YMaOLS .II: AEElREW110NS usm ON ruE DR,WIIIGS ~OONSIDffil::D COIfSl'RI.Jc::no~ $1NllWl£lS. If 'THE: C(I~ HASQlJES'TIOM5' REC.iMlf,Il1 1Ha~ DJ(T ~E,iHlNCi, iflE: ATI:T \IOBJl..ITYOONS'IllUC1ICtI IWfIIrlGiEft ANO Tl€ /lACH~ SI'WL lIE NOflFlED FORClAAIFJrAT1ON: 8ER]R£ llU:: \:IllffiL/CTM PflOaEDS WITH M WORK.

I~ "'E COHTRACTOf; SHALL l]ljT..... AAD PAY FOR ~ITS, LiCENSES ""'DIr-lSPEC1ll)NS"~ roll ~EfflHWICE OF 1JoIE WORt!: AND INCU.D:ll'0S{ IN THE COST OF' TIE: iI'JR~ TO ~l'4:T ""'91Lm'.

". 1lil OONTRACTOR SHALL PJi<IVIIE CCN11NVOlJS SUPER\IlSICH ..,..1.£ MYsuElcoNllW:TORS oR: ~£N ~ IN 1JoIE Sri[" AND !iHAU SUP8MSe~O DIRECT ,i,LL ~. lJ§IfG ItS BEST SiKUJ. ...,., "'TTE~N. 1-11:: SfW.I.BE SOI.£l.'r Rf'SPONSISlE ffIl it!. CDlSl1tUaooH '-lENIS, 1.IfiHD[)S,1'ECWIIQl(S, PRQ(l8)UR£S .WI 5EQUEJ.US Nll FOR COORfJINI\ilNG ALLF'QRTIONS OF 1JoIE WCJRI( UHllEIl TIlE CONlRACT.

Il. 'rI'OI'ltl:WINSHIP THl«luGtlOUl ::rwJ.. BE OF 'Tl£ !lEST' QUNJlY OF' ruETR1DE IH',lCIL~, N'lO Si"lIoI...l ~ Oft E~D rHl! rol..l.Ol'l'l«l ~IHI~LJ'"ftEfiRENCE S'fAMlMDS RlR CIJ.!JJIY AND PRCF(SSION.iL COftlSTRIJCT1a.l_.

NffCA HA~ ~~ ASSOCUoilON(}'I-IAREIN1"EAtooIoNAI.C~102~ ",_ HIODolS ~, S\KTE t100R<lsE:MOtlT, Il 1!OO18

sw.cN.l\ SHEET IrrIIETAL NlO IJ~ OONOlnor-l1fG ~OR5NATlOHAL. IWSOCWlON42(11 tAf'A'I'UT! romn DRI'IIECl'AlIl.l.V, VA :R:I2H2()g

IT1J' JHT'ERNAnoNAI. I~SllnITE F(lA' lAJIoI !INti PI.AS1€R1S20 TRANSF'fft ~CIAO

ST. PAUL. hlN ~'H-140!l

I;J. INSTAlL -'U. EQU~ENT AH{) t.li,1tlI~ PER TH~ L.ATtSr EDITlON or lHE"""'-iFACruRfR's tIS'f,l,l.l,ATION SI'(tI'IC.I.11l)N$ uruss Sfl'EtIF'lCM.L.'"O1HmMsE" INDlCAttD. OR 'MImE lOCAL CODES O~ IirGUl.A1tONS TM:[

-"""'"14 1'HE OONTIW;1'O~ sw.u. \IE!l1F'\', COOF!(lI~T(, AHD ~C1E. A..L

~EI:ESSAWf i1LOCJ(IN(;, aN:.1Ilrt:, FJW.l1NG, HNlGMS OR tnHrR SUPPO!ITSro~ Al.1 ITBIS Il:E.QI.ll~rote:: lrI[ SMIt.

I~. Il'E OONmACTOR AND ......~ 5tt.IU... -G1'1'E AI..L. NOTll:ES ANDsw.u. COtdPl.Y WrTH ALL AP~I..t'SL.r LOCH-~ R~\JlJ,TlONS, IJ.IIfSAHC ORDII'W«:ES M 'ffEU. ,.,s STATE: IlfPARTIolafl OF' lNCMJSTRIH.IID:U!.Al1I)NS ANCI [l9'VISICN llF INDUSTRIAL W'rn" (~) REQUI~~EHTS

HI,. rHE: OON'mACTO~ SJWJ. fl~~ THE ~Rc;l~EJm' ~E~S, ,I,ttO ,l,U;fWWUlY PROF'EIm' mClM DN.IlI:E: MlCH "",r O::CUR OUfII~(oCC1~otl N« o"tUA.c;E TO ~Eil' N'W EXIS11'1G Fl~ISHES.

OONS1RUC1lON,. STRUCTUR~ IJIIll!ICAPIHL':, ClW3S, $l'AJfa, ~ e:t;lL-lIPIiIENT,rn:, SI-WL BE JhlIlEDIATtL,. R[JIJ,IREO QR 'lE:l'I..*(:ED 10 T'rlE WlS'fl'll;1l0NOF AT.&T NoIlUlT, NlO nlE F'liOPoo"Y OWNER'SREPR~ENrATlVE... AT THE EXPelS[ (F Tl-lE CONTIi.'Cl'OIt.

17 ~E cor.m.cTOf; SHALL BE IIE5PCtO!iil8l.E F(JR, N.lO SHAU. IlEPUCE ORfl::EMmT, N« fAUl.lT, I~Pf;OPER. 00 INFERIOR lWEAIALS ORWOFlHLlAN$HII" OF! ItN'f~ I'I1CH S1'WJ. ,lPF'ENt 'fI'ITriIN oot: YEARIf'TEJl: THE CONPLrTION M[I ~E?'TMCE: (l~ THE" "WORI< BY IITI::TMClEllUiY IN)£1I TIfi CONl'1VICI

loS rr Srwl. !lIE TIfE: R~POO5IIlIurr OF THE: GEHERo'IL COtfTRAl;R)Fl TOLlXAiE pu.. EJ(1'mNG iJTIUT1E:S. OR comAO AN OU'mJE AGENCY TOLOCAlE AU- F)CIST\NC UTIum:s. lli8l-lEFI S!-I~ liEREItt OR rtOt, MDTO pRQltCT lNt'II FROM il.lJU(t. tHEC~ $HAI..l. B(AA IUE::NPEN5E:S roR Tl1E REPAIR Qi IIEFl.AC::OtEKT (F lfTlUTlES OR OT~ER

~ IlNW;ED IN CONJUlCJI[»l WfT'H 111E EXEOJTlCN OF WllFlK.

t'S' TH5:~~ SHltU. SE Rt5P1JN:01I..E FOR THE ~PlETE SECUFlIITOF THE flf:Kl.ECT srrr WHIlE: TI£ .l)El IS IN PROCfI€5S..IItO Ut4T1L -mEJOEl 15 COIoIP'l..£1'ED AND ~EII'TiD 8V IIIIIT "'08ILJ1Y.

SIiEET rm.£

A-O

"""""'" OATISPREU~ ZC REVIEW (P1)l00l' 10'S (P::!JCLOIT COWlllENTS (P;J)CUENT COMl.IEm (P4)ClI:NT CONMENTS (P:;io)

SITE PLA!'!

JFOt~WIror _ I MsodIrIoo, IN:.

Arizona oil California I ~ .....odo

(602) Zg&-r557S1i(9od) 1!O-lU9(7U2) 78~DOei'!t

PROJECT NlJI,I8~R

PROPlllETAIl'r INFO_liONlHtE INFORM,t,:nON CONTAINED IN THISSET Of' CON5TRUC11ON DOCl.NENT5 IS~QAltIiETARV ev tu.TURE. ANY USEeli DISCLOSURE OTHE~ THAN TH.6.TWH~CH RELATES TO AT&:TWtRELESS IS S'TR'lCn.'f POOHIBrrm.

PREP,ltll:ED fQA

LA JOllA COMMONS

~

~at&tS738 P~FlC CENTER BOULEVARD

2J<) """"SAN D1E:GO. CAUF'O'lNlA 92121

SS007949-49 ~1'E w.u. -ORNE

SAN DIEGO, CJltjFOfiNlA Et2121

StrE r-w.IE

04/01/10­04/20/10­05/17/H)07/06/tG07/22/10-

R.F.

1

L='~(:",ruf.c""

s"'-"~ Wlref.e.. F...,~il)'Frnjm

"'" P~I-~lJ~~BMP'!.

~ p~ TO 1l1£ ISSIJ/IH:;( Of /IN'( OON511UJCTlOH PERIIiIT. THEPEIUMrrLE 5i-W.l IliCO~RA1'( ANY CONSfR!.JCTIOIII BESTt.U.NAGf:MDIT PAAC1K:ES rtECE'SSARY TO CtJI,FI"Y 'lmltCH.IlPTER i .... AJmClE :l. Of\IIStoN 1 (G~ R'EGUI.},TlONS)OF TI-lE SAN Q~ ..uNK:IF.... COOl, IN'I'O THE CONSlRUCnONPlN6 oR SPECIFlCATIONS.

~ p~ TO THE: ISi$LIA/tfC£ or AN( CONSTRUCTION PERNJT fi.£PERWITE£ SHALl. SOOWT A WAT£~ PQU.I}TI(IN CO"lTflDL plJI.N(WPCP). TtlE WPCP SI-«U. BE: ~EPARED IN ACCORDAHC£ WITHll-lE GlJIDELINES 11'4 APPENDllI: E: Of' fMC: CIlY'S STORU WATER

'''''1lAAOS.

Se<J;'llC1lt~

I';ll':ril:flts­TT"I~ll s: <f,;-.~ri:l.

ll~. n~I1«1",.Jin~ Su.Mtil~c~

OiJ A. Gr'&Xp.~id.&Vit_

r.c.ri~ioks

"''''~ ~1I"icr;.·1~.~I'~ o:f~ r«t'~~ oftllo: p~y"""',i""d ""

~'6'.sTGA1ElN\I.J.llti:IVE.5AN1;IU;~, oCAWJ:n

M"'m.i~ p"".~~pm!:ln TlI[101T~b>lrxtcri!ll~

MilliJoi~ "~f2',\,lg~g faot printby-I;IDMUUCtillg~}i-, llali". "--IIrJ iJli"';l"n\"S wiiJIpcmI(;lbl<s.,n='C'omrcn~ll6l\ll:d"'L=

Uft III1l3ral Llr:l'Il;I~ ~1=5 ~~DJlJl'"~ [0 li"'OO~'IIal"" ..... u::«J,o,'FOllTl<I.dnIiJ1:1.-ge",-Dnl1Jl I">(lfl0jl!', ,-,,·~irJ.3~'" pili!>!: i:nd4ri~ i~~ 1'4.i'lv.ml Looll119~~(l'~.!!:rnil)l' ttldiscllaro-inH tIll~e;t'lb~ir. dl':li"'~ "-l"'IM1L~~~!I n;l.\&," tr-~~~~~" sluuk'l~I"lll«t'!-~ s1Gjl~ f.'oo",.:-ro!iv,~

.\QIf.:~-:<t1all!, l''w~-..:ill;

MifJiJ~i<ll!LIao!"""nf~;-\.,jdc.l

l.' .. d1i~ilIlt irli~irrn "l""t~m~ ""d 1~~6L-1r-;: J""~n. '~D.I<J,"r."in~ ,"in ..ht"uEr: ...~.,;~nld tIow ted1K<:I"S"' n=:i:ed

1lfI.d~~,.jd."c,i~~,<,:,,,,,l~tho.~;w lJi,,-':I" MW)iLi~ ('...1.:, LIUI.tD\l ...~M~., .... I­Stllrr.1W~l«"S~,Lt,'~PfI)ja:( 'I~ rLwrd t~MI.1L:~l'Jy t"O'JUl"J1ll> ITI .... I!J~ Fmjrd ,It=n ~A'!.

i~",qwm,~'~i",~""""" '''';,,".II'<:~ [~<JI"IL.....l~IlMf>

F~{,:::J 'j",~ "fmj '~(J."~, tll~1 ~~n,,-1J~I~n*"n'i(i~~l~~ ~1 ~~~p~ land IJ!.(: Iolt

.... filIJ~ ......>

• ,~'-O~

- ..'-tf- 10·~O·

- 10'-0·

1. ~~~vrn%E~~ ~ ~~,7-2000) To UXATE ~ /JK) JU

2. ALL FACIUTlES ro &E I/IISfAlUO ARE UNt,W.I'*Xl_ NO (E) P-.Rt<1NG SP..cEs Will BEI.,ACTEO 9'l' -mE NEW USE.

PRIOR TO lHE lSSUN«:E Of Nf'( ~ONSTRlICTlOH PERIJ.ITS. m£ APPUCANT SHAU.1N(:()fIpOR),T'E »« CONS1RUCT1OI'.l Bm WlllACEMEHT PRACT!tE'SN~ TO COW\.Y'I'II'n-I CI-W'I'ER 1., ARTla.E 2, DMOON 1 (~lNC F£GiJL..AllONS) OF' TH£ SAoiII D£GOt.llJNI(:IP,q CODE:. INTO M CQNSl"RUCmN PLUfS Ofl: ~jFICAflON$..

SfrMC~

FtlONT YMD""" y,,",5mE YM/ll-liIfTF.RICI.Cl'Sl)E YARO-~

SITE PLAN GENERAL NOTES

fXlsn~ PROPERrr LJ~E.

F1ROPOSEO AT4:r Nn'ENN-'$~ WITHIN PRoPosEDP'YfW,IlD; sa: SHEO A-I.

E:<ISmllG WArER mEATJ.ltNT BlJlLOINGS.

//

//

/<-

"

GRADING DATA TABLE

SITE PlAN

"-"­

"­"-

"­"­

"-

""-"-

"-"-

"­"-

"\\

\\

(602) 2'1i16-5~1'&1

(liQ) J450-392'l(700) ,g:5-oo~'!iI

ORM'ING UATES

~EU'" ZO ~EW (P1)100'lli zo's (P2)CUEN'T COMMENTS (PJ)WENT COM....Er-lTS (P4)ClIEl'lT CQlAMENTS (P~}

"""1Oi'\O)~Cdlll..ml","MOGlia:

A-1

5ng PACIFIC CDllTUi BOULEVAAD2ND FLOOR

SAN DlrGa, CAUF'ORNIA '8:2121

SS0079"'9...g EASTGATE 1.lAU. ORIVE:

SAN DIEGO, CAUFORNI,oI, 92121

.~

~~at&t

-.JR-~JoIkoy _ t I.oooclat.t, 'no,Arllon'tl • C'CIlifomia • Nevoda

lA JOLlA CO......ONS

PROPRIETARY INFORMATIONTHE: IN;FOR~"110N COMTAJNffi IN THIsSEf OF (:ONsmUCThJN OOCU~(NTS IS~OI'lR'IE.TARY 8'f NI\TLJRE ANY 'liSEOR DISCLOSURE OTl-tEfl THAN THA,TWHICH RELot.TES TO Ai&TWlREL~S IS STRICTLY ~ROHIBITEO

ENLARGED SITE PLAN

04/01/10004-/:20/1005/ 1711007/06/1007/22/10

ZONING

CONSTRlJCTlO"l

R.F.

&C_a 3' 6'

oo

---=------ --------------,I.!-.!J - 1

o

r/II

, /, /, /, /, /, /X

/ ,/ ,

/ ,/ ,

/ // ,

~,--------------

o

SECTOR .C"140' 7

o

o

oo

••

, /, /, /

~" "%'r----t---?· "x / ..

JJI /' " •,., ~/ ,

/ ,/ ,

/ ,

o

f.SECTOR "A"320'

o

o

, /, /, /, /, /, /

X/ ,

/ ,/ ,

/ ,/ ,

/ ,

o

o

o

o

COAx SIZE71B~

7/.'71B~

COAX C~S:l.E: LENGTH1~.5'

1,/5'

1<5'

EX:lsnoNG PAVED ACCESS flDAO.

EXlsnNC' ""ST FLOOR ElECTRICAL ROOM ANQ NE'I'I ATtkTj:'OWiiR ANI) TaCO SOUR'CE, SEt Stiffi A~1,1.

t-l:Ew: AT&T COAX DelLE f+~OO.

EXISTlN~ CONcRETE 'tWXIiA"r'.

ExrsrlNG CONCRETE.

EXISTING ROOF ACCESS H.l.fCloj

EXI5nNG ROOF VENT, TYPICAL.

E)(ISTIM~ BUILDING OVERHANG.

Eio:lSTIJIIG SKYLrC;;HT. Ti'PI~

O{I'SnNG LOWER LE\IEJ. ROOF ClEeK

EX'lSTING ROOF ACC(:SS LADDER.

IIlEW \fE:ffriCAL COAl! liABLE: TRAY MOONTro ON WALL6ElOW. flAlNi£D TO ~A1CH EXISTJI'tG eUILLIING

El<ISnN{; UPPER LE\'EL ROOF DECK.

EXISTING: ROO~ DRAIN'.>, IYPICAL-

P~OPOSED ,It,T&:T ANTENNAS (4- PER SECfoR, 12 TOT~) t.lOUNrElJTO PROPOSED PVRMlIO', SE:E: Sf-l~ET 11,-1.1.

PRO~5ED AT&:i EQIJIP'~(1oI1 CA81~ETS WITHIN A1.kT LFj!.S( AREA:SEE SHEET" A- T.l.

[Xlsn~G 8t1ILDlNG '0,

ENLARGED SITE PLAN

SECTOR,•C

ANTENNA COAXIAL CABLE SCHEDULE

PROPRIETARY INI'ORlIATIOIlTHE: INFORWl.TlON ~TAt£D IN. THISS£T OF' 0JNSTRI..ICTI0f OOCUYENTS ISPROPR!ETAR'I' B't ""'TU~ ANY USE00 txSCl-OWR£: ~ER 'rHAN f1i.Il.TWHtCH RELATES TO AT&TWlR£l£SS IS. STRICTLY PAOHlarr£O

~7.38 p,a,cn:: CENT£R ElOOLEVARO..., n.ooo

SNi OI£GO. CAuRl'lNIA 82121

(50!) a9&-!a57!t(1ft) 710-312.\r0i) 700-00..

~at&t

-...J~~Jolfnr_t_ ....AtiZor'lCl .. CaMfomla • Hlivada

CONSTR\!CTION

R.F.

r~

Ir~

I

, /, /, /, /, /, /, /

~,i !,1Ii'" ,./ IJIe

X

011 // " •/ ,. ~

/ ,/ ,

/ ,/ ,

/ ,/ ,

/ ,/ ,

r----- -----~--- -------------------- ----- -~ ----------- ----- ----- ----_. -------------,

io

o

o

~ 2tJ'·r t~ >~~, /, /, /, /, /, /, /, /, /, /, /, /

X/ ,

/ ,/ ,

/ ,/ ,

/ ,/ ,

/ ,/ ,

/ '/ ,/ ,

/ ,

oo

o

o

F'~osm AT4l:T m.oo P~EL MOONl£O ON H-FRN.lE.

f:lROPOS£O AT&T" Floor MOONTW DOG HOUS(.

PRoPOSED GPS /lHTnIINA. YQUNTEO TO EQuiPMENT ~IN[T.

EXISTING UPPER i.£"Ia MOf" DECK.

~FlOflOSEO AT&T P\1l.IJ,I[) TO MAlC.., ExISTIM<;.

~OPOSED AT&:T LlNDERGROUNO OONDUllS WITH COAl(.

PROP'OSE:D Aliel VERTICAL. COAX CA8L.E f1tI,y MOIJNTEC ON 'flI.q,Lsnow, PAINTED MD TEXN1£D ro MATCH EX15n1'fG. BuIL.blNG.

PROPOSED ""141:1 OlJlOOO~ EOOIPItENT CAOINEl" "'lOUI'm:DTO p~F'OSEO COOCli!El"E 5l.JlB

P~5EO ATNr £l£CTJi1CAl PAIIIEl. ~QUHTED 01'1 H-FlWE.

~RO~ro AT&T ROOF MOUNTED HORlZaN1~ COJX CAf:lL£ TRAy.

r:f,~~s A~~~~~~pJ~~ ~6_ ' 2 TOTAl) AND

PROPOSED AT~l LE.ISE #lEA WITH g'-0" I·UC'" PQUFl:E:C IN ~E~CLOSuRE TO liIATC\i rnmNC eUllDlt.lC.

E)(1S'n~G BUILDING: ~O~

PLAN KEYN01ES

LA JOLLA COIilIilONS

PftOJ[CT NU~ER

SS0079~olS EASfGA'l't w.u. CM'!:

SAN ~EGO, CAlJF"OANIA &2121

ENLARGED EQUIPMENT urou

A-1 1ENLARGED SITE PlAN

04/01/1004/20/Hl1»/17/1007/06/1007/22/10

DAAWl"l<;: o.-,TES

PR€lJU ZD R£VlEW (P1)100~ 2D'S ("1'2}CUENT COWNrnrs (P3)CUENT C:OWENT'S (Pol)CUErIT cx:u.lENTS (P5l

SHEET TITLE:

3736 P,t,QFIC CENTER 80UlEVARD2ND FlOOIl:

SAN DIEGO, OOJF'O~IA 92121

~.at&t

PREPI\RED fOR

.J ~,.A,.

JofInI' - a: -... """Artz:ona .. Colffomkl. .. Nevada

~ (.a2) ::U·II-!l$"111CanfGrrlllli~ (,.,) nO-:S'29'~_ (701) 7"--oet

fVF'.

•

8E:KISTING Floor ACCESS \..ADDER. (8EYOND).

tI E)l~Sl'1NG UPi='ER LEVEL RoOf DiCK.

, ~lsnNe;: LQ.WE~ L..£\r(L ROOF' DECK.

0.00 -'GLTOP OF I'.S'.

CEmEJI QF" (roll AHTEN~

ergo~,JT~~o~owro~~~ SECTOR. 12 TOT,iL)

E'XJSTl~(; W1NOOW. lWIC/IL

ORAVilNG CATES

~R£Uu zO~ (PI)1~ ZO'S (.fl:l)-Cu~'f t",;mlYE:NTS IP~)

CU8if CCWEM'rS (P4)-CuEtiT COt.lN£~ (F5)

LA JOllA COMMONS

55007949.' ~TE WoIIU. DMI;£

SAN OIEGO, CAUFORNIA 511:121

04/01/10(H./20/1000/17/1007/05/1007/22/10

SffE ACQUISfTlON

CONSTRUctION

ZONING

1

~~~mO~T'~~~TlfoNA~I~~ S£CTOR. 12 TCT,i;L)

PRCPOSED Af:.tT vttrnCAL COAX cr.aLE TRAY MOUNTED~~I~fM'B~1I.D~g. /lIolO TExTuRED TO NATCf-I

SOUTHEAST ELEVATION

6.00 N,;.L.TOP OF" (N) EQUIPUENT ENCLOSU~

TOP OF F'-S

SHUT llTI.£

ELEVATIONS

SOUTHWEST ELEVATION 2A-2

(6O.i) i'lill5-5e-n(941) 7-5-Q-Jg2i1(102.) -;'~!I

Ar!:li:\IInQ;CalHOf'nla:~~~l

..~

~Jat&t

JoIIroJ Rome ~ -...., ,...Arizona. California'" Nevoda

57~B PAGIF1(: CENTER BOUt£VMm200 FlOOR

!;WI DIEGO, CALIFORNIA 92121

PROPRIETARY INFORMATIONTHE INF'aRI.lAHON COIlliT,o!dNffi l", THISSET OF' CONS'mUCTTON DOCUMIONlS ISPROF'RIETARY BY NjlTURI:;:. ANy LJSEOR IJISCl,.OSUFlE O~ff:r TJ-tA,N TH~T

WHlCH RE-L..ATES To AT&TWIRELE:SS IS STRiCQY PROHrSITEO.

4

'-- ------ -------- ---.. _- ------- -------- -~------ -------- -------- -------- -------. ---- --- ~~._--- -----._- ----- --

___'l< _'---

E;(ISTING lQWffi l.£'JEL ~1Xlf DECK

I;:~ISTING ROOf M:CESS lADDrn

E>:ISTING UPPER LEVEL ROOF' ClEeK.

36.00 AGLTOP OF ~t.} 6IJItDlr-lC.

J4.S0 ACL

E;lI;ISTING WINDOW, TYRCilL

PROF'OSm AT&T a'-(l" HIG:~ POURED IN PLACE ENCLOStlll:!.

PLAN KEYNOTES

fop OF (N) A/IIO Cf) F'YR.liIIDS46.70. AGL

r-------------------------0+~",,'~a~AC,.';_,="""'==---- /

CENTER OF (N} ANr~~ .AN...

/1 II~

J

'l''g ,

.~

APPROvAl.S

R.F.

NORTHWEST ELEVATION

SITE PLAN KEYNOTES

1ZONJNC

CON.5mUCTlON

SHEET frfLE

ORAWII4G DATES

PFlf.:Ur.l ZO AEYIEW lP1)100'1: ZD'S (P2)CUENT COM~ENT5 (P..l)CLJIONt COM~ENTS (P4-)WENT CO~~ENTs (~5-)

ELEVATIONS

S50079~!l491 EASTGAf£ ~.I>ll.. D~IV£

SAN DIEGo:), CAUF'ORNIA 92121

PRI)JECT NUMBER

LA JOLLA CO......ONS

04/01/l0Q+/2Q/1005/17/10Q7/0e/_o07/22/10

OWNfFl APPROVAL

Sin: ACQUISITION

EXISTING LOWI::R LE'I'EL ROOF DECK.

ExistiNG UPPER LEVEL RQClr DECK.

EXISTINC ROOF ACCESS I.ADVER

5E:CroR, 12- TOTAL.)

ROOF DECK,

D.Or) AGL

TQf' Of f",S.

Q,il

<I>+~ii7;i'"".,.""UI;;W"'""'G~.----~-/

.,i!:

TOP 0"- (N) AND (E) P"r'RAIOIDS46.1:5 ~L

8E)(~SnNC eUILDINc;

2 PROPOSED AT&T ArirrNNo\S r", PEl':MOUNTED TO PROPOSED ~ID.

J D:ISTING WIf!lOow. TYPICAL

NORTHEAST ELEVATION 2A-2.1

(.&01) 2i15-"'t(I&t) 780-S5I:2.'

(roz) " .........

........,CaUoml4l:N_de

~EPAR£D FoR

JF=it~JoIfrwy _ t --. 1M.

Arizona • CaHfornla • Mwodo

3738 PI\CIFIC tENTE~ 9OU.£VARO2NO ~OOR

~ LJl(G:O. u.urQ0j.... 92.121

.......~at&t

PROPRIETARY 1IIFORMA110NTHE N"OAWLTlQN CONTAIIlEO IN THISSET Of"~DOCLt.II~ ISPROPRIETARY' BY HAllJR(. ANY USEOR DISCLOSURE OTIiER THAN THATWHICH RELATES TO AT&:"WIRELESS rs SlRlCTI.Y PROHIBIll!D.

ZONING

RLF,

=

?"'I

It

II

~C-g-;+- ..........

.- I

m,,-

I SCAI.£: 1I NOllIE

.. X 7(16 ilft FDW.E

UGHr GAAY

i'2")ji2·~6· {1829xJtl!b1!l2)......

R/lO:IWf: ~~tAJ.:

RIllIOt.€ COlOft:

Olllla.lSIO"fS. l-ixWxD;

WEIGHT, W~ PA£-uou'fl(DBRACKETS:

eor,l~EC1'OlIl:;

ANTENNA SPECIFICATIONS

POWERWAvE AlllTEIllIIIA P4l5-16-XLH-RR

RIGHT VIEW

FRONT VIEW

TMA TO BE LOCATED INSIDE STRUCTURE I 3

ERICSSOIII KRY 112 75/1 TlAA

,[~11,JO-

y-"'0"""" 2:5 • aoo MHZ, eo • H~OO"'Hl

wtlGHT: ;j(J L.a~

A:F" CONNECTO~ DIN 7/1I!:1 F'iMALE TOP VIEW

15

t-----'t---t+---- NIE\Ij ANtENNA MQUNTING POL£, TYPICAl"...

ANTENNA MOUNTINGCONSTRUCTION

SITE ~ulsmON

LA JOLLA COtolWONS

SS00794Y~ EASTGATE UALL DRIV£

SAN DI£OO, CAJ,JroRNVI ~21 Zl

04/01/1004/20/1005/17/1007/05/1007/Zl/10

QRAWlNl; OATES

PRElJI,l ID FlE\llEw (Pl)lOOK ZO'S (P2lCUENT CONU£NTS (P:)JCUEHT C:OW~T'3i (P4)CUEHT ~h+alT'5i (~:i}

SHUT Tm...E

ANTENNA DETAILS

NOT USED 16 NOT USED 14 NOT USED 2A-3

EXISTING LANDSCAPE PLAN N'" "'lSn"" OTES

(£) COriC~nE SEFlVICE WALJ<

SHEET Till£"

DRllWlrtG DA.TES

MaiM lO REV!1OQ';l Zl>'S (P )EW (Pl)

CU~T co 2-L:Llo-.T co~~ENrs (pJfCLIENT COM~~~rsJS (P4)" IP')

SlTt NA.l.IE"

LA JOLLA COMMONS

PR(I..IECT NUMBER

550079"''9~'!l EASTGA

SN'l DIEGO ~F~M.L. DRIVE• R:NI~ 92121

L-1

.". ,~~a:'IlRED FOA

.........~.~ at&t

!:l7;3lS PACIFlC C£NlU!2riD FLOO eOOLE'Y'AR'O

~ DjEOO f;:• CAUFTIRNIA 92121

LANDSCAPEDEVELOPMENT PLAN

AS-BUILT

0+/01/1Q04/20/1Q05/17/1007/06/1007/22/lD

[E:) COriCRETE S£R\IICE: W..... I<

(E) LANTANA ..,PURPLE LANT:

IDIIDEr,i5tS

(E) NERIUM Ol..EANDWARF ~"~DER 0iER PETlTE PINK

{E:l BERM ~IDGE -

(El It,jELALEU4 ~ CAUP.~ lEUCAODiDRA

PUT '""

IoII

PLAN

IE) CISTlJS ~OOCHIO ~~:~~S~ ---

[I;:) If:!RIG.'.TION V~'4.

R(CL'J~ ED WATER

(E) CONCRETE CURB __--L--l

(E) FRITWAYCONe. POSTjBFEriCE:(E) (j LACK F'ABRIC

R4\IU MUL~

(E) CONCRETE: (:ljRB

(E) PlATANUS BlO4. CALJ OD(;ooo

F'. SYC!lUORE

LANDSCAPE SITEENLARGED AS-BUILT

ATTACHMENT 6

PLANNING COMMISSIONRESOLUTION NO.

PLANNED DEVELOPMENT P-ERM-:-::=IT::C:NO. 798878NEIGHBORHOOD USE PERMIT NO. 798879AT&T MOBILITY LA JOLLA COMMONS

PTS NO. 221265DRAFT

WHEREAS, CITY OF SAN DIEGO., Owner, and AT&T MOBILITY, Permittee, filed an applicationwith the City of San Diego tor a permit to install a Wireless Communication Facility (WCF) consistingof twelve (12) panel antennas concealed behind Fiberglass Reinforced Panels (FRP) inside a fauxpyramid structure to match others. The 371- square feet equipment enclosure is located within an existingplanter area on the westerly side of the property behind an eight foot high CMU wall as described in andby reference to the approved Exhibits "A" and corresponding conditions of approval for the associatedPlanned Development Permit No. 798878 and Neighborhood Use Permit No. 798879;

WHEREAS, the project site is located at 4949 Eastgate Mall Drive, San Diego, CA 92121, in the RS-l­14 zone of the University Community Plan;

WHEREAS, the project site is legally described as that portion of pueblo Lot 1306, of the Pueblo Landsof San Diego, in the City of San Diego, County of San Diego, State of California, according to amp madeby James Pascoe in 1870, a copy of which was filed in the Office ofthe County Recorder of San DiegoCounty, November 14,1921 and known as miscellaneous map no. 36, lying easterly of the easterly lineof state highway Il-SD-805 as described in deed to State of California recorded January 8, 1971 asfile/page no. 3902 of official records and lying northerly of the northerly line of Miramar Road asdescribed in parcell of document recorded August 27, 1973 as file/page no. 73-214715 of officialrecords;

WHEREAS, on December 9, 2010, the Planning Commission ofthe City of San Diego consideredPlanned Development Permit No. 798878 and Neighborhood Use Permit No. 798879 pursuant to theLand Development Code of the City of San Diego; NOW, THEREFORE,

WHEREAS, on September 10, 2010, the City of San Diego, as Lead Agency, through the DevelopmentServices Department, made and issued an Environmental Determination that the project is exempt fromthe California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) (Public Resources Code section 21000 et. seq.) underCEQA Guideline Section 15301 [New Construction] and there was no appeal of theEnvironmental Determination filed within the time period provided by San Diego Municipal CodeSection 112.0520;

BE IT RESOLVED by the Planning Commission of the City of San Diego as follows:

That the Planning Commission adopts the following written Findings; dated December 9, 2010.

FINDINGS:

Findings for all Planned Development Permits

1. The proposed development will not adversely affect the applicable land use plan; Neither the

ATTACHMENT 6

City of San Diego General Plan nor the University Community Plan addresses wirelesscommunication facilities as a specific land use. Pursuant to the San Diego Land DevelopmentCode, wireless communication facilities are permitted in all zones citywide with the appropriatepermit process. Wireless communication facilities are separately regulated uses, which havelimitations or require compliance with conditions in order to minimize potential impacts. The intentofthe regulations is to camouflage facilities from public view. The site is currently designated foran industrial use in the University Community Plan. The WCF as designed is located on the roof ofthe existing water treatment building, completely concealed behind Fiberglass Reinforced Panels(FRP) within a pyramid structure designed to match the existing ones OIl site. The equipmentassociated with this project is located within an existing planter area, behind an 8-foot hight CMUwall will not be visible to the public. The General Plan, Section UD-A.15, states that WCFs shouldbe concealed in existing structures when possible, or otherwise use camouflage and screeningtechniques to hide or blend the facilities into the surrounding area. The design of facilities is to beaesthetically pleasing and respectful of the neighborhood contact. The AT&T design is consistentwith the General Plan's requirement since the WCF is completely concealed behind a rooftopfeature minimizing any visual impacts to and from the site. Therefore, the AT&T Mobility WCF4949 Eastgate Mall Drive does comply with the City of San Diego General Plan will not adverselyaffect the applicable land use plan.

2. The proposed development will not be detrimental to the pUblic health, safety, and welfare;The Telecommunication Act of 1996 preempts local governments trom regulating the "placement,construction and modification of wireless communication facilities on the basis of theenvironmental effects of Radio Frequency (RF) emissions to the extent that such facilities complywith the Federal Communication Commission's (FCC) standards for such emissions." A conditionhas been included with the project to required AT&T Mobility to submit an RF report to the City ofSan Diego demonstrating compliance with the FCC standards for wireless facilities. Therefore,based on the above, the project would not result in any significant health or safety risks to thesurrounding area.

3. The proposed development will comply with the regulations of the Land Development Code;The AT&T Mobility WCF complies with Municipal Code Section 141.0420 which requires WCFsto use all reasonable means to conceal or minimize the visual impacts of the wirelesscommunication facilities through integration. Integration with the existing structures or amongother existing uses shall be accomplished through the use of architecture, landscape and sitingsolutions. The project is completely concealed on the rooftop of an existing water treatmentbuilding within the North City Water Reclamation Plant. The associated ground mountedequipment is located behind a three-sided 8-foot high wall (approximately 371-sqaure feet) withinan existing planter area on the westerly side of the property. Due primarily to the existingtopography, the westerly side of the property where the equipment is proposed is set back from the805 Freeway screened by the existing raised grade reducing any visual impacts to the proposedequiprnentlocation

However, the project is located within the RS-I-14 zone which has a 35-foot height limitation. Theproposed WCF is located on highest point of the building consistent with the other pyramid design,and requires a Plarmed Development Permit for tlle height deviation. Although the project exceedsthe height requirement, the WCF is concealed behind the faux pyramid structure and is consistentwith the existing rooftop elements. Therefore, the height deviation can be supported by staff.

2

ATTACHMENT 6

The project is also proposing to exceed the 250-square feet equipment limitation per MunicipalCode Section 141.0420(g)(3). The 371 square feet equipmentenciosure is located within an exitingplanter area. The equipment is effectively screened behind a new 8-foot high CMU wall with theequipment abutting the existing water treatment building. The associated cable tray will also beplaced on the corner of the water treatment building, and will be painted and textured to match.More importantly, due to the existing topography, the westerly side of the property where theequipment is proposed is adequately set back from the 805 Freeway and screened by the existingraised grade reducing any visual impacts to the proposed equipment location. Therefore, theequipment limitation deviation to exceed the 250 square feet can be supported by staff.

4. The proposed development, when eonsidered as a whole, will be beneficial to the community;The proposed wireless communication facility is fully concealed reducing any significant visualimpact to the neighboring residents and surrounding community. As part of this application, AT&TMobility will increase cellular data and voice coverage to and around the surrounding community.More importantly, with the requested deviations, both the antennas and equipment will not bevisible to the general public and when considered as a whole, will be beneficial to the community.

5. Any proposed deviations pursuant to Section 126.0602(b)(I) are appropriate for this locationand will result in a more desirable project than would be achieved if designed in strictconformance witb the development regulations of the applicable zone. The proposed rooftoppyramid with FRP panels conceals all twelve panel antennas minimizing all visual impacts to andfrom the facility. This unique and creative concealment design, allows AT&T Mobility to furtherimprove their voice and data coverage to the surrounding area. To comply with the heightrequirement for the RS-I-14 zone, potential designs may include ta.,ade mounted antennas andother more obtrusive structures at or below 35 feet. This proposed rooftop WCF concealed inside afaux pyramid feature is a more desirable design as opposed to fa.,ade mounted antennas or a 35-foothigh stand alone structure. Such installations are discouraged when a design such as the AT&TMobility's can be accomplished to fully conceal the antennas without adding any visual impacts tothe site. Therefore, the deviations to exceed the maximum allowable height of 35 feet and to exceedthe equipment size limitation of 250-square feet would result in a completely concealed project, anda more desirable project than would be achieved if designed in strict conformance with thedevelopment regulations ofthe RS-I-14 zone and Municipal Code Section 141.0420.

Neighborhood Use Permit - Section 126.0205

1. The proposed development will not adversely affect the applicable land use plan;Neither the City of San Diego General Plan nor the University Community Plan addresses wirelesscommunication facilities as a specific land use. Pursuant to the San Diego Land DevelopmentCode, wireless communication facilities are permitted in all zones citywide with the appropriatepermit process. Wireless communication facilities are separately regulated uses, which havelimitations or require compliance with conditions in order to minimize potential impacts. The intentof the regulations is to camouflage facilities from public view. The site is currently designated foran industrial use in the University Community Plan. The WCF as designed is located on the roof ofthe existing water treatment building, completely concealed behind Fiberglass Reinforced Panels(FRP) within a pyramid structure designed to match the existing ones on site. The equipmentassociated with this project is located within an existing planter area, behind an 8-foot hight CMUwall will not be visible to the public. The General Plan, Section UD-A.15, states that WCFs shouldbe concealed in existing structures when possible, or otherwise use camouflage and screening

J

ATTACHMENT 6

techniques to hide or blend the facilities into the surrounding area. The design of facilities is to beaesthetically pleasing and respectful of the neighborhood contact. The AT&T design is consistentwith the General Plan's requirement since the WCF ;s completely concealed behind a rooftopfeature minimizing any visual impacts to and from the site. Therefore, the AT&T Mobility WCF4949 Eastgate Mall Drive does comply with the City of San Diego General Plan will not adverselyaffect the applicable land use plan.

2. The proposed development will not be detrimental to the public health, safety, and welfare;and The Telecommunication Act of 1996 preempts local governments from regulating the"placement, construction and modification of wireless communication facilities on the basis of theenvironmental effects of Radio Frequency (RF) emissions to the extent that such facilities complywith the Federal Communication Commission's (FCC) standards for such emissions." A conditionhas been included with the project to required AT&T Mobility to submit an RF report to the City ofSan Diego demonstrating compliance with the FCC standards for wireless facilities. Therefore,based on the above, the project would not result in any significant health or safety risks to thesurrounding area.

3. The proposed development will comply with the applicable regulations of the LandDevelopment Code. The AT&T Mobility WCF complies with Municipal Code Section 141.0420which requires WCFs to use all reasonable means to conceal or minimize the visual impacts of thewireless communication facilities through integration. Integration with the existing structures oramong other existing uses shall be accomplished through the use of architecture, landscape andsiting solutions. The project is completely concealed on the rooftop of an existing water treatmentbuilding within the North City Water Reclamation Plant. The associated ground mountedequipment is located behind a three-sided 8-foot high wall (approximately 371-sqaure feet) withinan existing planter area on the westerly side of the property. Due primarily to the existingtopography, the westerly side of the property where the equipment is proposed is set back from the805 Freeway screened by the existing raised grade reducing any visual impacts to the proposedequipment location

However, the project is located within the RS-I-14 zone which has a 35-foot height limitation. Theproposed WCF is located on highest point of the building consistent with the other pyramid design,and requires a Planned Development Permit for the height deviation. Although the project exceedsthe height requirement, the WCF is concealed behind the faux pyramid structure and is consistentwith the existing rooftop elements. Therefore, the height deviation can be supported by staff.

The project is also proposing to exceed the 250-square feet equipment limitation per MunicipalCode Section 141.0420(g)(3). The 371 square feet equipment enclosure is located within an exitingplanter area. The equipment is effectively screened behind a new 8-foot high CMU wall with theequipment abutting the existing water treatment building. The associated cable tray will also beplaced on the corner of the water treatment building, and will be painted and textured to match.More importantly, due to the existing topography, the westerly side of the property where theequipment is proposed is adequately set back from the 805 Freeway and screened by the existingraised grade reducing any visual impacts to the proposed equipment location. Therefore, theequipment limitation deviation to exceed the 250 square feet can be supported by staff.

4

ATTACHMENT 6

BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that, based on the findings hereinbefore adopted by the PlanningCommission, Planned Development Permit No. 798878 and Neighborhood Use Permit No. 798879 ishereby GRANTED by the Planning Commission to the referenced Owner/Permittee, in the form,exhibits, terms and conditions as set forth in Planned Development Permit No. 798878 andNeighborhood Use Permit No. 798879copy of which is attached hereto and made a part hereof.

Simon Tse - Associate PlannerDevelopment Services

Adopted on December 9,2010

Internal Order No. 24000926

5

ATTACHMENT 7

RECORDING REQUESTED BYCITY OF SAN DIEGO

DEVELOPMENT SERVICESPERMIT INTAKE, MAIL STATION 501

WHEN RECORDED MAll TO

PROJECT MANAGEMENTPERMIT CLERK

MAIL STATION 501

SPACE ABOVE THIS LINE FOR RECORDER'S USEINTERNAL ORDER NUMBER: 24000926

PLANNED DEVELOPMENT PERMIT NO. 798878NEIGBORHOOD USE PERMIT NO. 798879

AT&T MOBILITY LA JOLLA COMMONS PTS 212265PLANNING COMMISSION

DRAFT

This Planned Development Pennit No. 798878 and Neighborhood Use pennit No. 798879 isgranted by the Planning Commission of the City of San Diego to CITY OF SAN DIEGO,Owner, and AT&T MOBILITY, Pennittee, pursuant to San Diego Municipal Code [SDMC]section Chapter 12, Article 6, Division 6 and Chapter 12, Article 4, Division and LDC 141.0420of the Wireless Communication Facilities regulations. The site is located at 4949 Eastgate Mallin the RS-l-14 zone of the University Community Plan. The project site is legally described asthat portion ofpueblo Lot 1306, of the Pueblo Lands of San Diego, in the City of San Diego,County of San Diego, State of California, according to amp made by James Pascoe in 1870, acopy ofwmch was filed in the Office of the County Recorder of San Diego County, November14, 1921 and known as miscellaneous map no. 36, lying easterly of the easterly line of statehighway II-SD-805 as described in deed to State of California recorded January 8, 1971 astile/page no. 3902 of official records and lying northerly of the northerly line of Miramar Roadas described in parcel 1 of document recorded August 27, 1973 as file/page no. 73-214715 ofofficial records.

Subject to the tenns and conditions set forth in this Permit, pennission is granted toOwner and Pennittee for a Wireless Communication Facility (WCF), described and identified bysize, dimension, quantity, type, and location on the approved exhibits [Exhibit "A"] datedDecember 9, 20I0, on tile in the Development Services Department.

The project shall include:

a. Wireless Communication Facility (WCF) consisting of twelve (12) panel antennasconcealed behind Fiberglass Reinforced Panels (FRP) inside a faux pyramid structure

Page 1 00

ATTACHMENT 7

to match others. The 371- square feet equipment enclosure is located within an existingplanter area on the westerly side of the property behind an eight foot high CMU walland;

b. Public and private accessory improvements determined by the Development ServicesDepartment to be consistent with the land use and development standards for this site inaccordance with the adopted community plan, the California Environmental QualityAct [CEQA] and the CEQA Guidelines, the City Engineer's requirements, zoningregulations, conditions of this Permit, and any other applicable regulations of theSDMC.

STANDARD REQUIREMENTS:

1. This pennit must be utilized within thirty-six (36) months after the date on which all rightsof appeal have expired. If this permit is not utilized in accordance with Chapter 12, Article 6,Division 1 of the SDMC within the 36 month period, this permit shall be void unless anExtension of Tirne has been granted. Any such Extension of Time must meet all SDMCrequirements and applicable guidelines in effect at the time the extension is considered by theappropriate decision maker.

2. The project complies with the Telecommunication Facility Guidelines as a CompleteConcealment Facility and as a result, the permit will not contain an expiration date. It is theresponsibility of the wireless carrier and owner(s) to maintain the appearance of the approvedfacility to condition set forth in this permit unless the site is removed and restored to its originalcondition. Code compliance shall be notified if the appearance or the scope of the project haschanged without the approval of the City Manager.

3. No pennit for the construction, occupancy, or operation of any facility or improvementdescribed herein shall be granted, nor shall any activity authorized by this Pennit be conductedon the premises until:

a. The Owner/Pennittee signs and returns the Pennit to the Development ServicesDepartment; and

b. The Pennit is recorded in the Office of the San Diego County Recorder.

4. While this Pelmit is in effect, the subject property shall be used only for the purposes andunder the tenns and conditions set forth in this Permit unless otherwise authorized by theappropriate City decision maker.

5. This Pennit is a covenant running with the subject property and all of the requirements andconditions of this Permit and related documents shall be binding upon the Permittee and anysuccessor(s) in interest.

6. The continued use of this Permit shall be subject to the regulations of this and any otherapplicable governmental agency.

Page 2 of7

ATTACHMENT 7

7. Issuance of this Permit by the City of San Diego does not authorize the Permittee for thisPermit to violate any Federal, State or City laws, ordinances, regulations or policies including,but not limited to, the Endangered Species Act of 1973 [ESA1and any amendments thereto (16U.S.C. § 1531 et seq.).

8. The Permittee shall secure all necessary building permits. The Permittee is informed thatto secure these permits, substantial building modifications and site improvements may berequired to comply with applicable building, fire, mechanical, and plumbing codes, and State andFederal disability access laws.

9. Construction plans shall be in substantial conformity to Exhibit"A." Changes,modifications, or alterations to the construction plans are prohibited unless appropriateapplication(s) or amendment(s) to this Permit have been granted.

10. All ofthe conditions contained in this Permit have been considered and were determined­necessary to make the findings required for approval of this Permit. The Permit holder isrequired to comply with each and every condition in order to maintain the entitlements that aregranted by this Permit.

If any condition of this Permit, on a legal challenge by the OwnerlPermittee of this Permit, isfouod or held by a court of competent jurisdiction to be invalid, unenforceable, or unreasonable,this Permit shall be void. However, in such an event, the OwnerlPermittee shall have the right,by paying applicable processing fees, to bring a request for a new permit without the "invalid"conditions(s) back to the discretionary body which approved the Permit for a detennination bythat body as to whether all of the findings necessary for the issuance of the proposed pennit canstill be made in the absence of the "invalid" condition(s). Such hearing shall be a hearing denovo, and the discretionary body shall have the absolute right to approve, disapprove, or modifythe proposed pennit and the condition(s) contained therein.

11. The OwnerlPennittee shall defend, indemnify, and hold harmless the City, its agents,officers, and employees from any and all claims, actions, proceedings, damages, judgments, orcosts, including attorney's fees, against the City or its agents, officers, or employees, relating tothe issuance of this permit including, but not limited to, any action to attack, set aside, void,challenge, or annul this development approval and any environmental document or decision.The City will promptly notify OwnerlPennittee of any claim, action, or proceeding and, if theCity should fail to cooperate fully in the defense, the OwnerlPermittee shall not thereafter beresponsible to defend, indemnifY, and hold harmless the City or its agents, officers, andemployees. The City may elect to conduct its own defense, participate in its own defense, orobtain independent legal couosel in defense of any claim related to this indemnification. In theevent of such election, OwnerlPennittee shall pay all of the costs related thereto, includingwithout limitation reasonable attorney's fees and costs. In the event of a disagreement betweenthe City and Owner/Permittee regarding litigation issues, the City shall have the authority tocontrol the litigation and make litigation related decisions, including, but not limited to,settlement or other disposition of the matter. However, the OwnerlPennittee shall not be requiredto payor perform any settlement uoless such settlement is approved by OwnerlPennittee.

Page 3 of7

ATTACHMENT 7

ENGINEERING REQUIREMENTS:

12. The project proposes to export no material from the project site. Any excavated materialthat is exported, shall be exported to a legal disposal site in accordance with the StandardSpecifications for Public Works Construction (the "Green Book"), 2003 edition and RegionalSupplement Amendments adopted by Regional Standards Committee.

13. The drainage system proposed for this development, as shown on the site plan, is privateand subject to approval by the City Engineer.

14. Prior to the issuance of any construction permit, the Permittee shall enter into aMaintenance Agreement for the ongoing permanent BMP maintenance, satisfactory to the CityEngineer.

15. Prior to the issuance of any construction permit, the Permittee shall incorporate anyconstruction Best Management Practices necessary to comply with Chapter 14, Article 2,Division 1 (Grading Regulations) of the San Diego Municipal Code, into the construction plansor specifications.

16. Prior to the issuance of any construction permit the Permittee shall submit a WaterPollution Control Plan (WPCP). The WPCP shall be prepared in accordance with the guidelinesin Appendix E of the City's Storm Water Standards.

17, Any party on whom fees, dedications, reservations, or other exactions have been imposedas conditions of approval of this development permit, may protest the imposition within 90 daysof the approval of this development permit by filing a written protest with the City Clerkpursuant to California Government Code 66020.

PLANNING/DESIGN REQUIREMENTS:

18. A topographical survey conforming to the provisions of the SDMC may be required ifit isdetermined, during construction, that there may be a conflict between the building(s) underconstruction and a condition of this Permit or a regulation ofthe underlying zone. The cost ofany such survey shall be borne by the Permittee.

19. All private outdoor lighting shall be shaded and adjusted to fall on the same premiseswhere such lights are located and in accordance with the applicable regulations in the SDMC.

20. Once the Permittee deems the construction pursuant to this Permit complete, Permitteeshall send a letter (Subject: Planning Inspection Project Number 212265) to the City of SanDiego, Development Services Department requesting a planning inspection. The site is officiallydeemed complete once the City Manager signs the letter. The Permittee shall be provided with acopy of the signed letter for record purposes.

Page 40f7

ATTACHMENT 7

21. All facilities and related equipment shall be: maintained in good working order; free fromtrash, debris, graffiti; and designed to discourage vandalism. Any damaged equipment shall berepaired or replaced within thirty (30) calendar days.

22. The Permittee shall notify the City prior to the sale or transfer of this site to any otherprovider or if the site is no longer operational requiring the removal and the restoration of thissite to its original condition.

23. The photosimulation(s) for the proposed project shall be printed (not stapled) on thebuilding plans. This is to ensure the construction team building the project is in compliance withapproved the 'Exhibit A.'

24. No overhead cabling is allowed for this project.

25. The Permittee shall not cause or allow the antennas located on the building to be differentsizes (length, width, or height) than as shown on the stamped approved plans.

26. The proposed cable tray shall be painted and textured (design to include the horizontallines) to match the existing water treatment building to the satisfaction of the DevelopmentServices Department.

27. The fmal product shall conform to the stamp approved plans and approvedphotosimulations prior to final inspection approval.

28. Please note that an Administrative Planuing Hold will be placed on the project prior toFinal Clearance from the City's Building Inspector to ensure compliance with the approved plansand associated conditions. Prior to calling for your Final Inspection from your buildinginspection official, please contact the Project Manager listed below at 619-687-5984 to schedulean inspection ofthe completed facility. Please schedule this administrative inspection at leastfive working days ahead of the requested Final.

29. Prior to the issuance of a construction permit, the telecommunication provider shall providea certified cumulative radio frequency model study demonstrating compliance with the FederalCommunications Commission's Radio Frequency Guidelines. All significant contributors to theambient RF environment should be considered in the radio frequency model study.

30. All equipment, including transformers, emergency generators and air conditionersbelonging to AT&T Mobility shall be designed and operated consistent with the City noiseordinance. Ventilation openings shall be baffled and directed away from residential areas.Vibration resonance of operating equipment in the equipment enclosures shall be eliminated.

31. All facilities and related equipment shall be maintained in good working order and freefrom trash, debris, graffiti and designed to discourage vandalism. Any damaged equipment shallbe repaired or replaced within thirty (30) calendar days

Page 5 of7

ATTACHMENT 7

32. The Pennittee shall place appropriate signage on the WCF as required by CAL-OSHA tothe satisfaction of the Development Services Department.

33. Use of or replacement ofany building fa"ade or mechanical screen with FRP material forpurposes of concealing antennas shall not result in any noticeable lines or edges in the transitionto the faux pyramid. All FRP shall be painted and textured to match the existing pyramid featureto the satisfaction of the Development Services Department.

INFORMATION ONLY:

• The issuance of this discretionary use pennit alone does not allow the immediatecommencement or continued operation of the proposed use on site. The operation allowedby this discretionary use permit may only begin or recommence after all conditions listedon this permit are fully completed and all required ministerial pennits have been issued andreceived final inspection.

• Any party on whom fees, dedications, reservations, or other exactions have been imposedas conditions of approval of this Pennit, may protest the imposition within ninety days ofthe approval of this development pennit by filing a written protest with the City Clerkpursuant to California Government Code-section 66020.

• This development may be subject to impact fees at the time of construction permitIssuance.

APPROVED by the Planning Commission of the City of San Diego on December 9, 2010 byResolution Number __~_

Page 6 o£1

ATTACHMENT 7

Planned Development Permit No. 798878Neighborhood Use Permit No. 798879

PTS No. 2l2265/Intemal Order No. 24000926Date of Approval: December 9, 2010

AUTHENTICATED BY THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DEPARTMENT

Simon TseAssociate Planner

NOTE: Notary acknowledgmentmust be attached per Civil Codesection 1189 et seq.

The undersigned OwnerlPermittee, by execution hereof, agrees to each and every condition ofthis Permit and promises to perform each and every obligation of OwnerlPermittee hereunder.

CITY OF SAN DIEGOOwner

ByccN=-A-=-M-=E=------------

TITLE

AT&T MOBILITYPermittee

By _NAMETITLE

NOTE: Notary acknowledgmentsmust be attached per Civil Codesection 1189 et seq,

Page 7 of7

ATIACHMENT8

~at&t

550079North City Water Tr..tment

4949 Eastgate Mall Dr.San Diego, CA 92121

Proposed antennas mounted withinproposed pyramid ----.

Proposed equipment endosure(not visible at this angle)to match existing building

,Photosimulation of proposed telecommunications site

at&t

PHOTO STUDY & KEY MAP

PROPOSAL TO ESTABllSH AND OPERATE ANEW DIGITAL PCS

COMMUNICATIONS FACILTIY

550079AT&T - North City Water Treatment

4949 Eastgate Mall DriveSan Diego, CA

Prepared for:City of San Diego

Development SelVices1222 1st Avenue

san Diego, CA 92101

Prepared by:

PlanCom, Inc.Contractor Representatives for

AT&T

302 State PlaceEscondido, CA 92029

Contact: Sheily Kilbourn, Land Use Consultant(619) 208-4685

May 24,2010

ATTACHMENT 9

Photo Study (550079 Water Treatment)5/24/20 I0

South Elevation

ATTACHMENT 9

ATTACHMENT 9

West Elevation

Existing Rooftop Pyramid (Design to match)

Location of ro osed AT&T architectural yramid element to match existin

ATTACHMENT 9

Location of Proposed Equipment (not visible from public views)

ATTACHMENT 9

Aerial view of project and surroundings

Aerial of Subject Site

ATTACHMENT 10

UNIVERSITY COMMUNITY PLANNING GROUPUniversity Town Center - Forum Hall

Executive Committee Monthly Meeting - Tuesday, October 12, 2010Minutes (Draft)

Directors present: Janay Kruger (Chair), Kris Kopensky (secretary), Milt Phegley (MembershipSecretary), Charley Herzfeld, Peter Burch, Linda Colley, Nan Madden, Mark Young, DerylAdderson, Sam L Greening, Jr., Pat Wilson, Harry Walker, Doug Williamson, Marilyn Dupree,Alice Tana, Sherry Jones, George Lattimer, and Juan H. Lias.

Directors absent: William Geckeler, Petr Krysl, and UCSD Student Representative

1. Call Meeting to Order - Janay Kruger (Chair) at 6:02 PM.2. Pledge of Allegiance.3. Agenda Adoption - Item 10, coast income, rescheduled to November, Item 15, Superloop

moved to its place, motion to move by Alice Tana seconded by Doug Williamson, 13 votes forand 2 against. motion passed.

4. Approval of September Minutes - Revision recommended by Charley Herzfeld to edititem 12.vii and to revise spelling of his name throughout, recommendation by GeorgeLattimer to edit item 12.viii, and recommendation by Doug Williamson to edit item 3.Motio": motion to approve with changes by Doug Williamson, seconded by Deryl AddersonVote: Unanimous (abstention by Harry Walker and Pat Wilson).

Announcements - Janay Kruger (chair),a. update on stop signs at Sodrblom and Bothe, Nan has reviewed policy with parents

of preschool, Janay working to get city and community to meet to resolve.b. Planning commission and UCPG denied variance for Garden Communities however

City Council approved waiver, History of issue from George Lattimer.c. Review of CPC meeting. Discussion was mostly medical marijuana, discussion on

whether or not to bring to UCPG, no strong recommendation to bring to UCPG.5. SDPD AI Alvarez - Community Update, absent.6. Reports-

a. Membership - Milt Phegley (Membership secretary) -i. Forms on hand to sign up as UCPG general member.ii. List on hand to document meeting attendance.

b. UCSD - Milt Phegleyc. Councilperson Sherri Lightner Office - Jesse Mays

i. At last council meeting, Sheri pointed out that more affordable housing wasneeded, Jesse shared stats on community housing.

ii, New community newsletter "spotlight" available by email request.iii, Sheri asked for city council to draft a letter to Governor Scharwzenager in

opposition of increasing cap on CCDC, but motion did not pass.iv, Discussions continue with UCSD on FBA and impact studies

d. Supervisor Ron Roberts Office - Woo Jln Shimi. None

e. Assemblyman Nathan Fletcher - Sterling McHalei. Budget, near passed, should be available by mid Odober.ii. Assemblyman has 21 bills passed, 10 signed in 09/10 session.iii. Discussion on bill passed for increase of CCDC cap.

f. 53"' District - Daniel Hazard for Congresswoman Susan Davisi. SUSan's primary goal and focus is economy and small business.ii. Introduced legislation to further define state education criteria.iii. Newsletters available.

ATTACHMENT 10

g. 50th District - absent.h. MCAS Miramar - Juan H. Uas

i. No announcement but appreciates support or tolerance of air show.i. Planning Department - Absent

7. Public Commenti. None

8. Action Item: La Jolla Commons Cellular - Shelly Kilbourn, PLANCOM representing AT&Ti. Drawings and detail proVIded.

Motion: Motion to recommend approval by linda Colley, seconded by DougWilliamson Vote: Unanimous in favor, motion passed.

9. Action Item: Super Loop Committee Suggestions - Alice Tana and Dale Disharooni. Review of noise issues associated with super loop, presentation by Dale

attached.Motion: Motion for UCPG to send a letter to FfA regarding peer review andnoise fix from report discussed in presentation by Alice Tana, seconded byGeorge Lattimer. Vote: 14 to approve, 2 against, motion passed.

10. Information Item: AMC Theaters at La Jolla Square Center - Paul Mc Neilli. Change in food service and remodel project, presentation and hand out

attached.11. Information Item: Mid Coast Trolley Status - Anne Steinbrenner and Greg Gastelum

i. Presentation and Handout attached.ii. looking at feasibility about adding a station at VA hospital.iii. Environmental analysis underway.iv. Application to FTA in 2010.v. Draft SEIS/SEIR public reVIew planned in summer/fall 2011.vi. More info at www.sandag.orglmidcoast or 619.595.5620 and

midcoast@sandag.oro12. Information Item: Water Purification Demonstration Plan - Cathy Pieroni

i. Presentation attached, details alternative water options and needs as well asdemonstration diagram of advanced water purification processes.

ii. More info at Www.purewatersd.oro. purewatersd@sandiego.gov. or byphone at 619.533.7572.

13. Action Item: NUP, Urgent Care Facility 4085 Governor Drive - Janay Krugeri. Attacment, neighborhood use permit, community planning committee

distribUtion form, and email from Michelle Sokolowski regarding proposedurgent care.

ii. Executive committee shared concerns about needing more information and arepresentative from the Urgent Care Facility available for questions.

Motion: Motion to request more infornnation and a presentation by arepresentative of the Urgent Care Facility by Harry Waiker, seconded by GeorgeLattimer. VOTE: Unanimous (recusal by Deryl Adderson), motion passed.

14. Information Item: Update on RFP for sale or lease of 80 acres east of I-80S, CityProperty to construct a natural gas power plant, south of Miramar Road. RFP Due8/17/10,200,300 megawatts - Russ Gibbons

i. Russ absent.ii. Public recommendation to inVIte Mayor to meeting to discuss.iii. Marines at MCAS have not taken position as they have not been presented

information.

15. Ad Hoc Committeesa. Glider park-

I. meeting about a month or two ago

ii. Things moving through park systemiii. Park system will come to UCPG before going to city

16. Adjourn - 9:02 PM

Submitted by:

Kristopher J. Kopensky, secretaryUniversity Community Planning Group

ATTACHMENT 10

ATTACHMENT 11

Ownership Disclosure Statement

CitY of Sen Diego

- bevulICpment ServicesOwnership Disclosure1222 Flrsl Ave" MS-302

San Diego, CA e2101

T"~ t;"... ..... &~,. eo",,,,,, ~619) 446-5000 Statement

Approval Typo: ChecJr apprwma'fl b.,J/ ttl..~ Of 8pplOWd/ (s) rlu'lue~ted: 0 N~l[Jhborhood U~ Permit I:) Coaslal [JlMllopmenl Pl!lnni1o Naighl::lClrnoCltl Davelopmltli'J1 f"ermi! 0 SlLc DlWslopmsnl PEltmli t:l Plannl3d DeVCdcl=lm"nt Pennlf I;) Condfti61"1al US!! PermitDVM~nec 0 r~!'lr.:.llw ~r Q Vo&line TenlnUIte M61' lJ Mop Waiver w l.andUse PI:l1'1 Ama-/lC'lmBnl • D Olher

PtoctTlIILI

Project Woo Fr:n- GIl)' USE' Only

La Jolla Commons1212265 I-I.wAA~~,~..MObilitY

~~EastgateMall Drive [

Part I - To be c.omplelBd when properly 19 hald by lndlvidual(s) J

By ,Inning thA pWQ4'nihic DiGIOt1lre s'zUro. n riM thst "" linnllQlt!cn for a QA ~fIlmvlI wi!! he filed wllb IhfI Gil" of $,n CieDo nO thi1 ~1".if:!eI ClMdlH1V tyllb the In'AQ'IQ.L..mrd sn enCUmb'3DOO agafn$Uh@ P.rpBPrty PCe8!l!l"Ii:ll below 1hE ownert:;,) and IenurJl(5) (II' illIppflcablel of ~e- above rsfetol'lcecl propeorty. The IISI muSI inellJlS5I thII n8:mS'~ and aljdros;ses 0' allp.r8Dll'E whg have itR hi91'S'! In lt1e lJro~. recorded pr aU,etwIge. and s.1~'~ Ihe tVP'l Dr ,:lroperly Jntere9l ~e.g.. IInants; who wi. beSlefit fromtl1e pernJll. ",r lndividusis who 'Own 1M properly). "'jgMtjrm Iii reQlIjput 'IF /J11,,"1 nm: of !he pror1l1!1y n!fID!I!CJ. Attach addllll>RaJ ~g&t IfM~r:ilJd, A .tllSlhRlure from l!'Ie A&!lIla\tll'lt Ex.ecuUv~ OlttC:IOr af IhE! S8n Cfego PtGdlYelOPftnm[ Agetl~atl be rer:ruirrlr:l for B~ prajEtei Pflr'Cet!l lorwhiCh Et Disposillon:llm! C$telOpmenl AQr&E!manl (OOA) Aa' been Bppro....,d I e.l(il!CUl.ed by Ule City neil. NDle: Tfle apj)Ncsnlls rilSJ'Cf'u.iblnfor nOtifying Ihe PrgJecl Manag:Qr 01 any dlal'1~ In OI.'Jner;.lip dunng ftJ~ lime the op~lir:aliOn Ill: bl'tlng procmed or torI5ld....d. Ohange.!! fnowne~~ip ere fo bll giv9n io the ProJBC[ MQtH!IIgl!lr at IsnBt Ihlrty days. ptlOi' l~ ltIny pubRQ hearlna em 'Ih& 5\.1bjscl prQperty. Failure to pmvldc Ole·elmlls and currenl OwrT1'!t'!Oljp InrO"".tiOn GOUld result In a .:til lay in the hearing proce$£

Additional pages attached I:l y~. 0 No

Name Of lnCIVIOUl'H UYj jl'ieme Of tnOlvidUai (type or pnnt)"City of San Diego! READ

U Owner U T'!:!rJ,flrjIfLes~Gl'o Cl RDd9ve~rflW!nt AgBney q Owner U i"n~flllL.e9see Cl Rlld9YeIl:fpmEJnl Apfmcy

Slre81 AddreBS; 8treBi ACfd~OI";~200 3m Avenue 17th Floor

ClLy/Sb:liefZlp'. Clty/Sm1eJZip;

"'hone No: F:.'IxNu: Phone No: Fux Na;619-236-6722Sigoat~re ; Oale: Signewre: Oat~

Narns of indiVIdual hype or pnm}; Name 01 IndMdUai {type or pmt}"

b awno, 0 TenaniKClr=t.ella Cl RlJdevolcpml'lnl AElenc.y U Own~ 0 TenantllN.ro.a... 0 Rede~elcpmEll\t A;r;:rntty

Sirecl-ArkimM: Sirset Al:fr::lre!l$:

CilyfStslelap: Cily1SL!llel.Zfp~

I Phonfll NfJ~ ~ilIX No; Phone Ng; Pax No:

SiEll'llllllre: OEMI!~ SlplIalurl'!l ; J:)(lle:

ihis information is Elveiiable In a!ll1!mative iQrmals for perl$OnS with dlsabll1tles.Se surEl 10 see us (In the World Wide Web al www-Sandiego,gov/dgvl;!lopment-services

D~-a1B t'5-Q5)

ATTACHMENT 12

NOTICE OF EXEMPTION

TO: X RECORDER/COUNTY CLERKP,O. Box 1750, MS A-331600 PACIFIC HWY, ROOM 260SAN DIEGO, CA 92101-2422

___OFFICE OF PLANNING AND RESEARCH1400 TENTH STREET, ROOM 121SACRAMENTO, CA 95814

FROM: CITY OF SAN DIEGODEVELOPMENT SERVICES DEPARTMENT1222 FIRST AVENUE, MS 501SAN DIEGO, CA 92101

PROJECT No.: 212265 PROJECT TITLE: AT&T Mobility La Jolla Commons

PROJECT LoCATION-SPECIFIC: 4949 Eastgate Mall Drive, San Diego, CA 92121

PROJECT LoCATlON-CITY/COUNTY: San Diego/San Diego

DESCRJPTlON OF NATURE AND PURPOSE OF THE PROJECT: Planned Development Permit and a Neighborhood Use Permit (NUP) fora Wireless Communication Facility (WCF) consisting of six (6) outdoor equipment cabinets and twelve (12) antennas. Theproposed antennas would be concealed inside a rooftop pyramid feature designed to match existing rooftop pyramids. A 373­square-foot equipment enclosure, housing the-equipment cabinets, would be located on the ground level in existing planteI' areaalong the northwest portion of the existing building, The project is located at 4949 Eastgate Mall in the RS-1-14 zone, within theUniversity community plan.

NAME OF PUBLIC AGENCY ApPROVING PROJECT: City of San Diego

NAME OF PERSON OR AGENCY CARRYING OUT PROJECT: Kevin BeckerAT&T Mobility5738 Pacific Center BoulevardSan Diego, CA 92121858-824-9853

EXEMPTSTATUS: (CHECK ONE)() MINtSTERJAL(SEC. 21080(b)(1); 15268);() DECLARED EMERGENCY (SEC, 21080(b)(3); 15269(a»;() EMERGENCY PROJECT (SEC. 21080(b)( 4); 15269(b)(c))(-t') CATEGORICAL EXEMPTION: 15303: NEW CONSTRUCTION

REASONS WHY PROJECTIS EXEMPT: The project is exempt pursuant to Section 15303 because the project proposes new wirelesscommunication equipment (including screening via new roof pyramid and equipment cabinet) with a new telecom use at thestructure_ The project will not result in impacts to any sensitive environments or otherwise result in an impact based on theexceptions to this exemption as idelltified in CEQA Section 15300.2.

LEAD AGENCY CONTACT PERSON: M. Blake TELEPHONE: (619) 446-5375

DATE

IF PIlED BY APPUCANT:1. ATTACH CERTIFIED DOCUMENT OF EXEMPTION FINDING.2. HAS ANOTICE OF EXEMPTION BEEN fILED BY THE PUBUC AGENCY APPROVING THE PROJECT?

( ) YES ( ) No

IT IS HEREBY CERTIFIED THAT THE ITY OF SAN DIEGO HAS DETERMINED nJE ABOVE ACTIVITY TO BE EXEMPT PROM CEQA

~~ 'x"7/tv 1%'7ncr- Xp/. /020/0---=~--=-----~--<-------'------=-------'--"''------- ,SIGNATURE/TITLE

CHECK ONE:(X) StGNED By LEAD AGENCY( ) SIGNED BY APPLICANT

Revised September 8, 2010mjh

DATE RECETVED FOR FlUNG WITH COUNTY CLERK OR aPR:

THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO

DATE OF NOTICE: November 8, 2010

NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARINGPLANNING COMMISSION

DATE OF HEARING:TIME OF HEARING:LOCATION OF HEARING:

PROJECT TYPE:

PROJECT NUMBER:PROJECT NAME:APPLICANT:

COMMUNITY PLAN AREA:COUNCIL DISTRICT:

CITY PROJECT MANAGER:PHONE NUMBER:

December 9, 20109:00A.M.Council Chambers, 12th Floor, City Administration Building,202 C Street, San Diego, California 92101

NEIGHBORHOOD USE PERMIT & PLANNEDDEVELOPMENT PERMIT PROCESS LEVEL 4212265AT&T MOBILITY LA JOLLA COMMONSShelly Kilbourn

UNIVERSITYDistrict 5

SIMON TSE. Development Project Manager(619) 687-5984

As a property owner, tenant or person who has requested notice, you should know that the PlanningCommission will hold a public hearing to approve, conditionally approve, or deny an application for aWireless Communication Facility (WCF) located at 4949 Eastgate Mall in the RS-1-14 zone within theUniversity community plan. The proposed antennas are concealed inside a rooftop pyramid featuredesigned to match existing. The equipment associated with the project shall be placed on the groundlevel, behind a fenced enclosure.

TIle decision of the Planning Commission is final unless the project is appealed to the City Council. Inorder to appeal the decision of the Planning Commission you must be present at the public hearing andfile a speaker slip concerning the application or have expressed interest by writing to the PlanningCommission before the close of the public hearing. See Infonnation Bulletin 505 "Appeal Procedure",available at www.sandiego.gov/development-services or in person at the office of the City Clerk,202 "C" Street, Second Floor. The appeal must be made within 10 working days of the PlanningCommission decision. If you wish to challenge the City's action on the above proceedings in court,you may be limited to addressing only those issues you or someone else have raised at the public

ATTACHMENT 13

hearing described in this notice, or written in correspondence to the City at or before the publichearing.

This project was determined to be categorically exempt from the California Environmental Quality Acton September 10, 2010 and the opportunity to appeal that determination ended October 6, 2010.

If you have any questions after reviewing this infonnation, you can contact the City Project Managerlisted above.

This information will be made available in alternative formats upon request. To request an agenda inalternative format or to reqnest a sign language or oral interpreter for the meeting, call SupportServices at (619) 321-3208 at least five working days prior to the meeting to insure availability.Assistive Listening Devices (ALDis) are also available for the meeting upon request.

Internal Order No. 24000926

ATTACHMENT 14

AT&T Mobility La Jolla CommonsPROJECT CHRONOLOGY

PTS #212265 !NT #24000926

ApplicantR

City ReviewDescriptionActionDateespouse

6.1.2010 First Submirtal Project Deemed Complete

6.24.2010First Assessment

23 daysLetter

8.3.2010 Second Submittal 30 days

9.2.2010Second 30 days

Assessment Letter

10.13.2010 All issues resolved 41 days

Scheduled for12.9.2010 Planning 57 days

Commission

Total Staff Time: Including City Holidays and Furlough 110 days

Total Applicant Time: Including City Holidays and Furlough 71 days

Total Project Running Time: From Deemed Complete to PC Hearing 181 days