the effects of movable novel obiects, novel olfactory stimuli ......the effects of movable novel...
TRANSCRIPT
The effects of movable novel obiects, novel olfactory stimuli
ønd novel auditory stimuli on the exploratory, play and
stereotypicat behaviour of captive species: A comparøtive
study.
Kathryn Lampard, B. Sc. Hons (Adelaide)
Thesis suhmitted to the University of Adetaide infuffilment of the conditíonsfor the
degree of Doctor of PhìlosoPhY.
Department of Psycholory
The University of Adelaide
July, 2002
Table of Contents
List of Figures..........-..
List of Tables.....
Abstract.....
Statement...
Acknowledgements. .. . .. .
CHAPTERl:CAPTTVEPOPULATIONS_ALASTRESORT1.1 Animals and caPtivitY
I .1 . I Zoos as a necessitY
I . I .2 The evolution of zoos
1.2 Captivity and behaviour
1.2. I Abnormal behaviours
1.2.2 Factors that contribute towards abnormal behaviours
1.2.3 Conserving natural behaviours
1.3 Behavioural enrichment
1.3.1 Change in the way animals are perceived
1.3.2 Aims of environmental enrichment
1.3.3 Types of environmental enrichment
1.2.3.1Carl Hagenbeck
1.2.3.2 Hal Markowitz
1.2.3.3 NoveltY
1.4 Chapter summary
CHAPTER 2: NOVELTY AND ITS EFFECTS ON EXPLORATORY
AND PLAY BEHAVIOUR
2.1 The Importance ofNoveþ
2.2 The Effects of NoveltY
2.2.1Level of noveþ and complexity of the stimuli
2.2.2 The social environment
2.2.3Habitvtion
2.2.4 Past exPeriences
2.3 Phylogenetic status and noveþ
2.4 Qualities of the novel objects
2.5 Chapter summary
CHAPTER 3: EXPLORATORY AI\D PLAY BEHAYIOT]R
3. I Exploratory Behaviour
lx
X'T'
JClt
xvi
xvii
1
I
I
J
6
6
Il0
lll1
l3
t4
t4
l5
t6
l7
18
18
t9
2l
22
22
23
23
26
29
31
3l
3.1.1 rWhy animals exPlore
3. l 2 Defining exploratory behaviour
3. 1.3 Theories about exploratory behaviour
3.1.3.1 Environmental Modelling and Discrepancy Theory
3 .1.3 .2 Drive theories
3.1.3.3 Optimal stimulation and arousal theories
3.1.3.4 Fear and exploration theories
3.1.3.5 Information Primacy Theory
3 . I .4 Functions and costs of exploratory behaviour
3.1.4.1 Acquisition of information
3.1.4.2 Familiarity with the home range
3.1.4.3 Location of new resources
3.1.4.4 Avoidance of Predators
3.1.4.5 Learning new adaptive strategies
3. I . 5 Species difFerences in exploratory behaviour
3.2 Play behaviour
3.2.1 Why play is important and the study of play
3.2.2 Defrning PlaY Behaviour
3.2.3 Theories of PlaY
3.2.3.1 SurPlus EnergY Theory
3.2.3.2 Practice Theory
3.2.3.3 Optimal Arousal Theory
3.2.3.4 Surplus Resource Theory
3.2.4 Functions and benefits of play behaviour
3.2.4.1Motor training
3.2.4.2 Social develoPment
3.2.4.3 Dominance hierarchY
3 .2.4.4 Social communication
3.2.4.5 Social integration
3.2.5 Costs of play behaviour
3.2.6 Phylogenetic status and play behaviour
3.2.7 Environmental effects on play behaviour
3.3 Chapter summary
3l
32
34
34
35
3s
36
36
37
37
38
38
38
39
39
40
40
4l
43
44
44
45
45
46
47
47
48
48
48
49
50
5l
52
CHAPTER 4: SUMMARY OF APPROACH
4.1 Past studies into noveltY
4.2 Types of novelty that were investigated
4.2.1 Movability
4.2.2 Olfactory Stimuli
4.2.3 Auditory Stimuli
4.3 Choice of species
4.3.1 Species included in the study
4.3 .l .l Plains zebra (Equus burchelli)
4.3.1.2 Oriental small-clawed otter (Aonyx cinerea)
4.3 .l .3 Collared peccary (Tayassu tajacu).
4.3.1.4 Barbary sheep (Ammotragus lervia)
4.3.2 Reasons for the choice of species
4.4 Chapter summary
53
53
53
53
54
55
56
56
56
57
58
59
60
6l
CHAPTER 5: METHODOLOGICAL ISSUES
5.1 Summary of research
5.2 Research in a zoo setting
5.3 Experimental design considerations
5.3.1 Equipment
5.3.2 Reconnaissance Observations
5.3.3 Experimental design
5.3.4 Data collection
5.4 Data analyses and dealing with low subject numbers
5.5 Magnitude of Effects
5.6 Intra- and Inter-observer Reliability.
CHAPTER 6: THE EFFECTS OF MOVABLE VERSUS
NON-MOVABLE NOVEL OBJECTS ON ANIMALS IN CAPTIVITY 69
6.1 Introduction 69
6.1.1 Hypotheses and rationale 69
6.2 Methodology and Data Collection 74
6.2.1 Subject" 74
6.2.2Diet 79
6.2.3 Enclosure 79
6.2.4 Apparatus and EquiPment 85
6.2.5 Procedure 89
6.2.5.1Reconnaissance observations 89
6.2.5.2 Behavioural categories 89
63
63
63
64
64
64
6s
6s
66
67
67
6.2 -5 -3 ExPerimental design
6.2.5.4 Data collection
6.3 Results
6.3.1 Hypothesis One
6.3.2 Hypothesis Two
6.3.3 Hypothesis Three
6.3.4 Hypothesis Four
6.3.5 Hypothesis Five
6.3.6 Hypothesis Six
6.3.7 Hypothesis Seven
6.3.8 Hypothesis Eight
6.4 Discussion
6.4. I Exploratory behaviour
6.4.2Play behaviour
6.4.3 Habituation
6.5 Conclusions
CHAPTER 7: THE EFFECTS OF DIFFERENT NOVEL ODOTIRS
ON THE BEIIAVIOUR OF ANIMALS IN CAPTIVITY.
7.1 Introduction
7.1.1 Hypotheses and rationale
7.2 Methodology and Data Collection
7.2.1 Subjects
7.2.2Diet
7.2.3 Enclosure
7.2.4 Apparatus and EquiPment
7.2.5 Procedure
7 .2.5.1 Reconnaissance observations
7 .2.5 .2 Behavioural categories
7 .2.5.3 Experimental design
7 .2.5.4 Data collection
7.3 Results
7.3.1 Hypothesis One
732Hypothesis Two
7.3.3 Hypothesis Three
7.3.4 Hypothesis Four
7.3.5 Hypothesis Five
7.3.6 Hypothesis Six
7.4 Discussion
7 .4.1 Exploratory behaviour
90
9l
92
92
97
l0lt0'7
tt4115
116
I l8
120
120
12s
127
t28
129
129
t29
133
133
134
t34
138
140
140
140
140
t4t142
142
149
151
153
158
163
164
164
7.4.2Play behaviour
7.4.3 Habituation
7 .4.4 Olfactory enrichment
7.5 Conclusions
8.1 Introduction
8.1.1 Hypotheses and rationale
8.2 Methodology
8.2.1 Subjects
8.2.2Diet
8.2.3 Enclosure
8.2.4 Apparatus and EquiPment
8.2.5 Procedure
8.2.5.1 Reconnaissance observations
8.2.5.2 Behavioural categories
8.2.5.3 ExPerimental design
8.2.5.4 Data collection
8.3 Results
8.3.1 Hypothesis One
8.3.2 Hypothesis Two
8.3.3 HyPothesis Three
8.3.4 Hypothesis Four
8.3.5 HyPothesis Five
8.3.6 Hypothesis Six
8.3.7 Hypothesis Seven
8.4 Discussion
8.4.1 Flight behaviour
8.4.2 Exploratory behaviour
8.4.3 Comparisons between the avian and mammalian predators
8.4.4 Play behaviour
8.4.5 Benefits ofthreatening events for captive animals
8.5 Conclusions
CHAPTER 9: GENERAL DISCUSSION
9. I General conclusions
9.2 Reactions to novelty
167
168
t69
t69
CHAPTER 8: THE EFFECTS OF NOVEL AVIAN AI\D MAMMALIAN
PRE,DATOR AT]DITORY STIMULI ON AI\IMALS IN CAPTIVITY. I7It7ln2176
176
176
t't6
180
183
183
183
183
184
185
185
189
194
20s
207
208
213
215
215
2t7
219
220
221
221
223
223
221
9.3 Limitations of the current studies
9.4 lmplications for caPtivitY
9.5 Individual differences
9.6 Applications of the current studies
9.6. 1 Exploratory behaviour theories
9.6.2 Play behaviour theories
9.6.3 Enrichment strategies
9.7 Future research
9.8 Conclusion
APPENDIX A - THE BEHA\¡IOT]R AND ECOLOGY OF THE
SUBJECT SPECIES.
PLAINS, COMMON OR BURCHELL'S ZEBRA
Species Classification
Morphological/ Physical Characteristics
Distribution and Habitat
Diet
Activity CYcle
Predators, Defence and Sensory abilities
Reproduction and DeveloPment
Social Organisation and Behaviour
Communication
Status
ORIENTAL SMALL-CLAWED OTTER
Species Classification
Morphological/ Physical Characteristics
Distribution and Habitat
Diet
Activity Cycle
Predators, Defence and Sensory abilities
Reproduction and DeveloPment
Social Organisation and Behaviour
Communication
Status
COLLARED PECCARY
Species Classification
MorphologicaV Physical Characteristics
Distribution and Habitat
Diet
228
229
229
231
23r
232
233
235
238
239
239
239
239
240
241
241
242
242
243
244
245
246
246
246
247
247
248
248
248
249
249
250
251
251
2sl
2s2
2s2
Activity Cycle
Predators, Defence and Sensory abilities
Reproduction and DeveloPment
Social Organisation and Behaviow
Communication
Status
BARBARY SHEEP
Species Classification
MorphologicaV Physical Characteristics
Distribution and Habitat
Diet
Activity Cycle
Predators, Defence and Sensory abilities
Reproduction and DeveloPment
Social Organisation and Behaviour
Communication
Status
APPENDIX B _ SIGNS
APPENDIX C _ CHECKSHEET DESIGN
RE,FERENCE LIST
253
2s3
254
254
255
25s
257
257
257
258
258
2s8
258
2s9
2s9
260
260
261
264
267
IX
List of Figures
Figure 6.1 -The Barbary sheep group. The adult male is at the top ofthe mountain,
and the rest of the animals spread on the levels below'
Figure 6.2 - The male zebra.
Figure 6.3 - The female zebra.
Figure 6.4 - The tvvo oflers with the male at the back left and the female at the front on
the right.
Figure 6.5 - Six of the peccaries, startingfrom the left Orange (R)' Green (L)' Red
(L), White (R), White (L), and Blue (R).
Figure 6.6 - The peccqry at thefront is Red (L) and the one in the middle is Yellow (R).
Figure 6.7 - Diagrammatic representation of the Barbary sheep enclosure showing the
location ofthe novel objects (not drawn to scale)'
Figure 6.8 - Diagrammatic represenÍation of the zebra enclosure showing the location
ofthe novel obiects (not drawn to scale)'
Figure 6.9 - Diagrammatic representation of the otter enclosure showing the location
ofthe novel obiects (not drawnto scale)'
Figure 6. I0 - Diagrammatic representation of the peccary enclosure showing
the placement ofthe novel objects (not drøwn to scale)'
Figure 6. 1 I q - Diagrams showing the frame on the left and the finished product on
the right for the movable novel objects usedfor the Barbary sheep and zebras.
Figure 6. t t b - Diagrams showing the frøme on the left and the finished product on
the right for the non-movable novel objects usedfor the Barbary sheep and zebras.
Figure 6.12a - Movable novel obiectfor the peccaries and otters'
Figure 6. I 2b - Non-movable novel object for the peccaries and otters.
Figure 6.1 3 Exploratory behøviour with the novel objects for the Barbary sheep.
Figure 6. t 4 - Exploratory behøviour with the novel obiects for the zebras'
Figure 6. I5 Exploratory behaviour with the novel obiects for the otters.
Figure 6. t6 Exploratory behaviour with the novel obiects for the peccaries.
Figure 6.t7 Play behqviourwiththe novel obiectsfor the Barbary sheep.
Figure 6.18 Play behqviourwith the novel objectsfor the peccaries.
Figure 6. 19 Play behaviour with the novel obiects for the otters'
Figure 6.20 Exploratory behøviour levels for the adult Barbary sheep'
Figure 6.2 I Exploratory behøviour levels for the sub-adult Barbary sheep.
Figure 6.22 Exploratory behaviour levelsþr theiuvenile Barbary sheep.
Figure 6.23 Exploratory behaviour levelsfor the zebras'
Figure 6.24 Exploratory behaviour levelsfor the otters'
Figure 6.25 Exploratory behaviour levelsfor thefemale peccaries'
Figure 6.26 Exploratory behaviour levels for the male peccaries'
Figure 6.27 Pløy behaviour levelsfor the adult Barbary sheep'
Figure 6.28 Ptøy behqviour levels þr the sub-adult Barbary sheep'
75
75
76
77
78
78
80
82
83
84
86
86
88
88
93
94
95
96
98
99
r00
102
102
103
104
105
106
106
108
108
X
Figure 6.29 Ptay behaviour levelsfor thejuvenile Barbary sheep'
Figure 6.30 Pløy behqviour levels for the zebras'
Figure 6.31 Ptay behoviour levels þr the otters'
Figure 6.32 Pløy behaviour levelsfor thefemale peccaries'
Figure 6.33 Play behaviour levelsfor the male peccqries'
Figure 6.34 Stereotypical behqviour qcross the conditionsfor the otters.
Figure 6.3 5 Exploratory behaviour with the novel objects for the first novelty week'
Figure 6.36 Exploratory behøviour with the novel obiects for the second novelty week'
Figure 6.37 Play behaviour with the novel obiects for thefirst novelty week.
Figure 6.38 Play behaviour with the novel obiects for the second novelty week.
Figure 6.39 Hqbituation times for each of the species'
Figure 6.40 - A sub-adult Barbary sheep exploring the non-movable novel obiect'
Figure6.4l-Themalezebraexploringthemovablenovelobject.
Figure 6.42 - The two otters exploring the non-moyable novel obiect.
Figure 6.43 - A male peccary exploring the non-movable novel obiect.
Figure 6.44 -Two sub-adult Barbary sheep pløying with their food branches.
Figure 7. I - Barbary sheep group with the adult male to the far right'
Figure 7.2 - Diagrammatic representation of the Barbary sheep enclosure showing
the location ofthe novel odours (not drawn to scale)'
Figure 7.3 - Diagrammatic representation of the otter enclosure showing the location
ofthe novel odours (not drawn to scale)'
Figure 7.4 - Diagrammatic representation of the peccary enclosure showing the location
ofthe novel odours (not drawn to scale)'
Figure 7.5 - Logs that the odours were rubbed on'
Figure 7.6 - Exploratory behaviour for eøch odour for the qdult Barbary sheep.
Figure 7.7 - Exploratory behøviourfor eachodourfor the sub- adult Barbary sheep'
Figure 7.8 - Habituation times for the Barbary sheep'
Figure 7.9 - Exploratory behøviour levelsfor each odourfor the otters.
Figure 7. I0 - Habituation times for the otters'
Figure 7.1 t - Exploratory behøviour levelsfor eachodourfor thefemale peccaries.
Figure 7.12 - Exploratory behøviour levelsfor eachodourfor the male peccaries.
Figure 7. I 3 - Habituation times for the peccartes'
Figure 7. 1 4 - Exploratory behaviour levels for the first week of the study.
Figure 7. t 5 - Exploratory behøviour levels for the second week of the study'
Figure 7. 1 6 - Hqbituation times for each species to the novel odours.
Figure 7.17 - Exploratory behøviour levelsfor the adult Barbary sheep.
Figure 7.18 - Exploratory behaviour levels þr the sub-adult Barbary sheep.
Figure 7. 19 - Exploratory behaviour levels for the otters'
Figure 7.20 - Exploratory behaviour levelsfor thefemale peccaries.
Figure 7.2 I - Exploratory behøviour levels for the male peccaries'
109
110
tlI112
113
114
115
116
117
t18
It9123
123
124
r24
126
134
135
136
137
139
143
r43
144
145
146
147
147
148
151
152
j'53
154
154
156
1s7
157
XI
Figure 7.22 - Ptay behaviour levels for the adult Barbary sheep'
Figure 7.23 - Play behqviour levelsfor the sub-adult Barbary sheep'
Figure 7.24 - Play behaviour levels for the otters'
Figure 7.25 - Play behqviour levels for the female peccaries'
Figure 7.26 - Play behqviour levels for the female peccqries'
Figure 7.27 - Stereotypical behoviour levels for the otters'
Figure 7.28 - Afemale peccary exploring the grass odour'
Figure 7.29 - A juvenile Barbary sheep exploring the grass odour'
Figure 7.30 - The two otters exploring the meat odour'
Figure 8.1 - Diagrammalic representation of the Barbary sheep enclosure showing
the location of the speaker (not drawn to scale)'
FigureS'2-Diagyammaticrepresentationoftheotterenclosureshowingthe
speaker (not drøwn to scale)'
Figure 8.3 - Diagrammatic representation of the peccary enclosure showing the
speaker (not drawn to scøle)'
Figure 8.4 - One of the speakers enclosed in a waterproof can'
Figure 8.5 , The car battery on the left, the amplifier in the center qnd the mini-disc
player on the right.
Figure 8.6 - Lockable metal trunk-
Figure 8.7 - Flight behqviour levelsfor the adult Barbary sheep'
Figure 8.8 - Flight behqviour levelsfor the sub-adult andiuvenile Barbary sheep.
Figure 8.9 - Ftight behqviour levels for the female peccaries'
Figure 8. I0 - Ftight behoviour levels þr the male peccaries'
Figure 8. I1 - Exploratory behaviour levels þr the adult Barbary sheep'
Figure 8.12 - Exploratory behaviour levelsfor the sub-adult andiuvenile Barbary sheep'
Figure 8.13 - Exploratory behaviour levelsfor the otters'
Figure 8.14 - Exploratory behøviour levelsþr thefemale peccaries'
FigureS.t5-Exploratorybehaviourlevelsþrthemalepeccaries.
Figure 8. 16 - Exploratory behøviour for the mammqlian and øvian predator phases
for the Barbary sheeP'
Figure 8. t7 - Ftight behaviour for the qvian and mammalian predator phases for the
Barbary sheeP.
Figure 8. I8 - Habituation times for exploratory behøviour for the Barbary sheep
for the mammalian Predator Phase'
Figure 8.19 - Habituation timesfor exploratory behaviourfor the Barbary sheep
for the øvian Predator Phase'
Figure 8.20 - Habituation times for flight behøviour for the Børbary sheep for the
mammalian Predator Phase.
Figure 8.2I - Habituation times for flight behøviour for the Barbary sheep for
the avian Predator Phase'
t59
159
160
161
162
163
165
165
166
177
178
179
181
r81
182
185
186
187
188
190
t90
t9l193
193
t95
196
197
197
t98
r98
xll
Figure 8.22 - Exploratory behaviourfor the qvian and mammalian phases for the otters'
Figure 8.23 - Habituation timesþr exploratory behøviourfor the mammalian
predator Phase for the otters.
Figure 8.24 - Habituation times for exploratory behaviour for the øvian predator phase 196
for the otters.
Figure 8.25 - Exploratory behaviourþr the mammalian ønd avian predator phases
for the peccaries-
Figure 8.26 - Flight behaviour for the qviqn and mammalian predator phases.þr
the peccaries.
Figure 8.27 - Habituation timesfor exploratory behaviourfor the mammalian
predator Phasefor the Peccaries.
Figure 8.28- Habituation times for exploratory behøviour for the avian predator
phase for the Peccaries.
Figure 8.29 - Habituation times for flight behaviour for the avian predator phase
for the Peccaries.
Figure 8.30 - Hqbituation times for.flight behaviour for the tntian predator phase
for the peccaries.
Figure 8.31 - Exploratory behøviour during the mammqlian predator phase.
Figure 8.32 - Exploratory behaviour during the avian predator phase.
Figure 8.33 - Flight behqviour during the mqmmalian predator phase.
Figure 8.34 - Flight behqviour during the avian predator phase'
Figure 8.35 - Pløy behaviour levels for the adult Barbary sheep'
Figure 8.36 - Play behqviour levelsfor the sub-adult øndiavenile Barbary sheep.
Figure 8.37 - Play behqviour levelsfor the otters'
Figure 8.38 - Play behqviour levelsþr thefemale peccaries'
Figure 8.39 - Play behqviour levels þr the male peccaries'
Figure 8.40 - Stereotypical behaviour levels for the otters'
Figure 8.41 - Peccaries gathered together at the back ofthe enclosure after having
fled the Predator auditory stimuli.
Figure 8.42 - Red(L) confronting the predator auditory stimuli'
Figure 8.43 - Adult male Barbory sheep orienting towards the predator øuditory stimuli-
Figure 8.44 The two otters orienting and approaching the predator auditory stimuli'
199
200
200
201
202
203
203
204
204
206
206
207
208
209
210
211
212
212
214
216
217
218
219
xlll
List of Tøbles
Table 5.1 The Kappa scores.for the two independent observers and the experimenter'
The uncorrected scores are shown in brackets'
Table 6. t - Tqxonomic details.for the Barbary sheep group'
Tabte 6.2 - Tmonomic details þr the zebras'
Table 6.3 - Tøonomic details for the otter group'
Tabte 6.4 - Taxon details for the collared peccqry group'
Tabte 6.5 - ExPerimental design'
Table 6.6 - Exploratory behqviour with the non-movable and movable obiects
.for the Barbary sheeP.
Table 6.7 - Exploratory behaviour with the non-movable and movable obiects
for the zebras.
Table 6.8 - Exploratory behqviour with the non-movable qnd movable obiects
for the otters.
Table 6.9 - Exploratory behøviour with the non-movable and movable objects
.for the peccaries.
Table 6.10 - Plqy behqviour with the non-movable and movqble obiects for the
Barbary sheep.
Table 6.I 1 - Plqy behaviour with the non-movable and movable obiects þr the
peccaries-
Tabte 6.I2 - Ploy behaviour with the non-movable and movable objects for
the otters.
Table 6.I3 - Exploratory behqviour during the experimental weeks for the
Barbary sheeP.
Table 6.14 - Exploratory behaviour during the experimental weelu for the zebras'
Tqble 6.1 5 Exploratory behøviour during the experimental weeks for the otters'
Table 6.1 6 - Exploratory behoviour during the experimental weel<s for the peccaries'
Table 6. 17 - Ptqy behoviour during the experimental weeks þr the Barbary sheep'
Table 6.1 8 - Ptay behqviour during the experimental weeks for the zebras.
Tabte 6. 19 Play behøviour during the experimental weelrs for the otters-
Table 6.20 - Plqy behaviour during the experimental weel<s for the peccaries.
Tabte 6.21 - Stereotypical behqviour during the experimental weeks for the otters'
Table 6.22 - Exploratory behøviourfor each ofthe species during the two novelty weeks'
Tqble 6.23 , Ploy behøviour for each of the species during the two novelty weel<s'
Table 7.1 - Tqxon detailsfor the Barbary sheep group'
Table 7.2 Experimental designþr the novel odour study'
Table 7.3 - Exploratory behoviour with each ofthe novel odours for the Barbary sheep'
Tabte 7.4 - Exploratory behaviour with each of the novel odours for the otters.
Table 7.5 - Exploratory behqviour with each ofthe novel odours for the peccøries.
Table 7.6 - Exploratory behaviourfor each of the species during the two novelty weelø'
93
94
95
96
98
99
100
68
74
76
76
77
9l
103
104
t0s
107
109
110
111
113
t14
116
117
133
141
144
145
148
152
xlv
Table 7.7 - Exploratory behaviour during the two novelty weeks for the Barbary sheep.
Table 7.8 - Exploratory behqviour during the two novelty weeks for the otters'
Table 7.9 - Exploratory behqviour during the two novelty weelu for the peccaries'
Tabte 7.I0 - Ploy behaviour during the two novelty weeks for the Barbary sheep'
Tqbte 7. 1 I - Plqy behaviour during the two novelty weelcs þr the otters.
Table 7.12 - Plqy behaviour during the two novelty weeks þr the peccaries.
Table 7. 1 3 - Stereotypical behoviour during the two novelty weeÌcs for the otters'
Tqble 8.1 - Experimental designfor the novel sound study'
Table 8.2 - Flight behaviourfor the Barbary sheepfor eachweek of the study.
Table 8.3 - Flight behaviourfor the peccariesfor eachweek ofthe study.
Tabte 8.4 - Exploratory behaviour for the Barbary sheep for each week of the stuþ.
Table 8.5 - Exploratory behaviour for the otters .for each week of the study'
Table 8.6 - Exploratory behaviour for the peccaries for eachweek ofthe study'
Tabte 8.7 - Exploratory andltight behaviourfor both the mammalian and avian
predator phases for the Barbary sheep.
Tabte 8.8 - Exploratory andJtight behaviourfor both the mammalian and qvian
predator Phases for the otters.
Tabte 8.9 - Exploratory and.flight behaviourfor both the mammalian and avian
predator phases for the peccaries.
Tabte 8.10 Indicqtes the levels ofexploratory behøviourfor each speciesfor the
two novel Phases of the stuþ.
Table 8.1 1 - Indicates the levels of flight behøviour for each species for the two
novel phases of the stuþ.
Table 8. I 2 Pløy behaviour for the Barbary sheep for each week of the study.
Tabte 8.I 3 - Ploy behaviour þr the otters for each week of the study'
Tabte 8.14 Play behaviourfor the peccariesfor eachweekofthe study.
Table 8.15 - Stereotypical behqviour for the otters /'or each week of the stuþ'
Tabte 9.1 - Summarises the most effective enrichment slrategies þr each species.
155
156
158
160
161
162
16s
184
186
188
191
192
194
196
201
207
202
208
2t0
211
213
214
234
XV
Abstract
In recent decades there has been an increasing interest in the area of
environmental enrichment for captive animals. The central premise of this thesis was
that four species in captivity would be enriched, by increasing levels of exploratory
and pþ behaviour and decreasing stereotypical behaviour, by providing them with
access to three different types of novel stimuli. It was expected that each type of
novelty would elicit different reactions from each species. Various theoretical
constructs have been suggested to explain exploratory and play behaviour, however
no theory has satisfactorily explained exploratory or play behaviour in all their forms.
The experimental component, of the current research, involved presenting three
different types of novel stimuli, including novel objects, auditory and olfactory
stimuli, to four species. The subject species were Barbary sheep, zebra, oriental
small-clawed otters, and collared peccaries.
The series of studies employed a modified repeated measures design. In each of
the studies the animals were presented with a different type of noveþ. The novelty
included movable and non-movable objects, food-related olfactory stimuli and
predator-associated auditory stimuli. Visual inspection was the main form of data
analysis due to low subject numbers and because it allowed individual and group
reactions to be reported.
Results indicated each type of novelty stimulated increases in both exploratory
and play behaviour and decreased stereotypical behaviour. In addition to these overall
increases, some types of noveþ were found to affect these behaviours more than
others. Overall these results suggested that the different responses were related to the
biological significance of the novel stimuli for the individual and the species
concerned.
Discussion focussed on factors that can be used to predict how a species will
react to novelty, including the ecological niche of the species, feeding patterns and
the biological significance of the novel stimuli. In addition to this, other factors, such
as the previous experiences of the individual, have to be considered. It was concluded
that novelty, including objects, odours and auditory stimuli, is a simple, cheap and
effective method of enriching the lives of animals in captivity.
XVI
Statemenl
This work contains no material which has been accepted for the award of
any other degree or diploma in any universþ or other tertiary institution
and, to the best of my knowledge and beliet contains no material
previously published or written by another person' except where due
reference has been made in the text'
I give consent to this copy of my thesis, when deposited in the Universþ
Library, being available for loan and photocopying'
Kathryn LamPard
Júy 2002
xvll
Acknowledgements
My deepest gratitude goes to the late Dr. Frank Dalziel, without whom I would never
have even considered starting down this path. Even when Frank became very sick he
stillfoundtimetobesupportiveandencouragingofthiswork.
A special thankyou must also go to Dr. Vanessa Mills for stepping in where Frank
left offand providing me with support and advice. Thanks also go to Professor Ted
Nettelbeck and Professor Tony \I/inefield for their comments'
Many thanks to Steve Tupper and JeffMatthews for building and installing the
apparatus.
Thankyou to Shanthi Sarma and Peter Brayshaw for assisting me with my reliability
assessment
('na)
At the Adelaide ZoologicalGardens I would like to thank Ed McAtlister, Mark Craig'
peter whitehead and Gert Skipper for assista¡rce with setting up the studies' Thanks
also to the keepers, to numerous to mention, who assisted in the day-to-day running
of the studies-
fgnR)
A very special thank you to Munu Dad and David for supporting me through this
lengtþ process.
Finally, thanþou to Peter for the drawing of the otters and to Ben for assistance at
the computer and the encouragement and support needed to see this through'
('IDR)