the emerging challenges in public education on long island...the emerging challenges in public...

44
The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School Superintendents Association Legislative Committee Co-Chairperson & Eastern Suffolk BOCES Chief Operating Officer SCSSA Advocacy Workshop January 21, 2017

Upload: others

Post on 02-Mar-2021

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island

Presented by:

Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D.

Suffolk County School Superintendents Association Legislative Committee Co-Chairperson & Eastern Suffolk BOCES Chief Operating Officer

SCSSA Advocacy Workshop January 21, 2017

Page 2: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

Overview

• Long Island Shifts Enrollment Free and Reduced Price Lunch District Wealth Students With Disabilities English Language Learners Funding

Page 3: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

Long Island - Shifting Enrollments

Total K-12 Enrollment 07-08 15-16 Total Change % change

Suffolk County 256,138 238,566 -17,572 -6.9%

Long Island 461,540 437,193 -24,347 -5.3%

Rest of State 1,252,451 1,130,768 -121,683 -9.7%

2015-16 & 2007-08 NYS School Report Cards

-2000

-1500

-1000

-500

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

BREN

TWO

OD

CEN

TRAL

ISLI

P

RIVE

RHEA

D

WYA

NDA

NCH

COPI

AGU

E

HAM

PTO

N B

AYS

AMIT

YVIL

LE

BAY

SHO

RE

CEN

TER

MO

RICH

ES

HUN

TIN

GTO

N

SPRI

NGS

SAG

HARB

OR

BRID

GEHA

MPT

ON

SOU

TH H

UN

TIN

GTO

N

MO

NTA

UK

SOU

THAM

PTO

N

EAST

MO

RICH

ES

GRE

ENPO

RT

WAI

NSC

OTT

AMAG

ANSE

TT

NEW

SU

FFO

LK

SAGA

PON

ACK

QU

OGU

E

WES

THAM

PTO

N B

EACH

FIRE

ISLA

ND

FISH

ERS

ISLA

ND

EAST

HAM

PTO

N

EAST

QU

OGU

E

LITT

LE F

LOW

ER

TUCK

AHO

E

REM

SEN

BURG

-SPE

ON

K

OYS

TERP

ON

DS

SHEL

TER

ISLA

ND

SOU

THO

LD

PORT

JEFF

ERSO

N

SOU

TH C

OU

NTR

Y

DEER

PAR

K

LON

GW

OO

D

BAYP

ORT

-BLU

E PO

INT

BRO

OKH

AVEN

-CO

MSE

WO

GUE

NO

RTH

BABY

LON

COLD

SPR

ING

HARB

OR

MO

UN

T SI

NAI

BABY

LON

ROCK

Y PO

INT

ELW

OO

D

EAST

PORT

-SO

UTH

MAN

OR

MAT

TITU

CK-C

UTC

HOG

UE

MIL

LER

PLAC

E

SAYV

ILLE

HAU

PPAU

GE

HARB

ORF

IELD

S

SHO

REHA

M-W

ADIN

G R

IVER

ISLI

P

WES

T BA

BYLO

N

KIN

GS P

ARK

CON

NET

QU

OT

NO

RTHP

ORT

-EAS

T N

ORT

HPO

RT

PATC

HOG

UE-

MED

FORD

LIN

DEN

HU

RST

WIL

LIAM

FLO

YD

EAST

ISLI

P

MID

DLE

COU

NTR

Y

WES

T IS

LIP

COM

MAC

K

THRE

E VI

LLAG

E

SMIT

HTO

WN

SACH

EM

HALF

HO

LLO

W H

ILLS

Suffolk County School Districts Enrollment Change 07-08 to 15-16

Page 4: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

Long Island - Shifting Enrollments

2015-16 & 2007-08 NYS School Report Cards

-2000

-1500

-1000

-500

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

HEM

PSTE

AD

WES

TBU

RY

ROO

SEVE

LT

FREE

PORT

UN

ION

DALE

MAN

HASS

ET

PORT

WAS

HIN

GTO

N

GLE

N C

OVE

GRE

AT N

ECK

MIN

EOLA

VALL

EY S

TREA

M 3

0

NEW

HYD

E PA

RK-G

ARDE

N C

ITY

FLO

RAL

PARK

-BEL

LERO

SE

VALL

EY S

TREA

M 2

4

ISLA

ND

PARK

OYS

TER

BAY-

EAST

NO

RWIC

H

MAL

VERN

E

HICK

SVIL

LE

FRAN

KLIN

SQ

UAR

E

EAST

RO

CKAW

AY

ROCK

VILL

E CE

NTR

E

CARL

E PL

ACE

HEW

LETT

-WO

ODM

ERE

VALL

EY S

TREA

M

NO

RTH

MER

RICK

VALL

EY S

TREA

M 1

3

NO

RTH

SHO

RE

EAST

WIL

LIST

ON

NO

RTH

BELL

MO

RE

BELL

MO

RE

HERR

ICKS

LOCU

ST V

ALLE

Y

JERI

CHO

BETH

PAGE

PLAI

NVI

EW-O

LD B

ETHP

AGE

LON

G B

EACH

ROSL

YN

ELM

ON

T

LYN

BRO

OK

SEW

ANHA

KA

MER

RICK

WES

T HE

MPS

TEAD

GAR

DEN

CIT

Y

SEAF

ORD

LAW

REN

CE

ISLA

ND

TREE

S

FARM

INGD

ALE

PLAI

NED

GE

SYO

SSET

OCE

ANSI

DE

BALD

WIN

EAST

MEA

DOW

WAN

TAG

H

BELL

MO

RE-M

ERRI

CK

LEVI

TTO

WN

MAS

SAPE

QU

A

Nassau County School Districts Enrollment Change 07-08 to 15-16

Total K-12 Enrollment 07-08 15-16 Total Change % change

Nassau County 205,402 198,627 -6,775 -3.3%

Long Island 461,540 437,193 -24,347 -5.3%

Rest of State 1,252,451 1,130,768 -121,683 -9.7%

Page 5: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

Note: Y-axis only ranges from 0% - 40% to better magnify the data points & trends 2015-16 NYS School Report Cards

Long Island Wide Shifting Poverty

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

30%

35%

40%

2007-08N=461,540

2008-09N=458,613

2009-10N=457,193

2010-11N=455,241

2011-12N=450,539

2012-13N=446,998

2013-14N=443,173

2014-15N=440,899

2015-16N=437,193

% of Free/Reduced Lunch Students on Long Island

Long Island %FRL Nassau County %FRL Suffolk County %FRL

Page 6: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

Over 32% of the students enrolled in Long Island school districts qualify for free or reduced-price lunch,

according to federal guidelines.

Key Fact:

2015-16 NYS School Report Cards

Page 7: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

Long Island - Shifting Demographics

2015-16 & 2007-08 NYS School Report Cards

Total K-12 FRPL 07-08 15-16 Total Change % change

Suffolk County 49,092 85,803 36,711 74.8%

Long Island 79,160 140,686 61,526 77.7%

Rest of State 409,682 480,559 70,877 17.3%

-500

0

500

1,000

1,500

2,000

2,500

3,000

3,500

4,000

4,500

5,000

5,500

6,000

BREN

TWO

OD

LON

GW

OO

D

WIL

LIAM

FLO

YD

CEN

TRAL

ISLI

P

PATC

HOG

UE-

MED

FORD

MID

DLE

COU

NTR

Y

SACH

EM

COPI

AGU

E

HUN

TIN

GTO

N

SOU

TH C

OU

NTR

Y

LIN

DEN

HU

RST

RIVE

RHEA

D

DEER

PAR

K

HAM

PTO

N B

AYS

SOU

TH H

UN

TIN

GTO

N

AMIT

YVIL

LE

WYA

NDA

NCH

BAY

SHO

RE

CON

NET

QU

OT

HALF

HO

LLO

W H

ILLS

BRO

OKH

AVEN

-CO

MSE

WO

GUE

NO

RTH

BABY

LON

WES

T BA

BYLO

N

ROCK

Y PO

INT

EAST

HAM

PTO

N

SOU

THAM

PTO

N

NO

RTHP

ORT

-EAS

T N

ORT

HPO

RT

WES

THAM

PTO

N B

EACH

THRE

E VI

LLAG

E

EAST

ISLI

P

COM

MAC

K

WES

T IS

LIP

SMIT

HTO

WN

EAST

PORT

-SO

UTH

MAN

OR

GRE

ENPO

RT

ISLI

P

HAU

PPAU

GE

SAYV

ILLE

MIL

LER

PLAC

E

TUCK

AHO

E

BAYP

ORT

-BLU

E PO

INT

CEN

TER

MO

RICH

ES

ELW

OO

D

MAT

TITU

CK-C

UTC

HOG

UE

KIN

GS P

ARK

HARB

ORF

IELD

S

SOU

THO

LD

SAG

HARB

OR

BABY

LON

SPRI

NGS

EAST

QU

OGU

E

SHO

REHA

M-W

ADIN

G R

IVER

BRID

GEHA

MPT

ON

MO

UN

T SI

NAI

EAST

MO

RICH

ES

PORT

JEFF

ERSO

N

SHEL

TER

ISLA

ND

COLD

SPR

ING

HARB

OR

REM

SEN

BURG

-SPE

ON

K

WAI

NSC

OTT

AMAG

ANSE

TT

MO

NTA

UK

FIRE

ISLA

ND

QU

OGU

E

SAGA

PON

ACK

OYS

TERP

ON

DS

FISH

ERS

ISLA

ND

NEW

SU

FFO

LK

LITT

LE F

LOW

ER

Suffolk County School Districts FRPL Change 07-08 to 15-16

Page 8: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

Long Island - Shifting Demographics

2015-16 & 2007-08 NYS School Report Cards

Total K-12 FRPL 07-08 15-16 Total Change % change

Suffolk County 49,092 85,803 36,711 74.8%

Long Island 79,160 140,686 61,526 77.7%

Rest of State 409,682 480,559 70,877 17.3%

0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

7,000

8,000

9,000

10,000

11,000

12,000

13,000

14,000

15,000

BREN

TWO

OD

CEN

TRAL

ISLI

P

WIL

LIAM

FLO

YD

LON

GW

OO

D

PATC

HOG

UE-

MED

FORD

COPI

AGU

E

MID

DLE

COU

NTR

Y

SACH

EM

BAY

SHO

RE

SOU

TH H

UN

TIN

GTO

N

RIVE

RHEA

D

SOU

TH C

OU

NTR

Y

AMIT

YVIL

LE

HUN

TIN

GTO

N

LIN

DEN

HU

RST

WYA

NDA

NCH

DEER

PAR

K

WES

T BA

BYLO

N

NO

RTH

BABY

LON

CON

NET

QU

OT

HALF

HO

LLO

W H

ILLS

HAM

PTO

N B

AYS

BRO

OKH

AVEN

-CO

MSE

WO

GUE

ROCK

Y PO

INT

ISLI

P

EAST

ISLI

P

NO

RTHP

ORT

-EAS

T N

ORT

HPO

RT

SMIT

HTO

WN

SOU

THAM

PTO

N

WES

T IS

LIP

EAST

HAM

PTO

N

COM

MAC

K

WES

THAM

PTO

N B

EACH

THRE

E VI

LLAG

E

EAST

PORT

-SO

UTH

MAN

OR

ELW

OO

D

HAU

PPAU

GE

GRE

ENPO

RT

CEN

TER

MO

RICH

ES

HARB

ORF

IELD

S

SAYV

ILLE

MIL

LER

PLAC

E

KIN

GS P

ARK

MAT

TITU

CK-C

UTC

HOG

UE

BABY

LON

BAYP

ORT

-BLU

E PO

INT

SOU

THO

LD

TUCK

AHO

E

MO

UN

T SI

NAI

SAG

HARB

OR

EAST

QU

OGU

E

SHO

REHA

M-W

ADIN

G R

IVER

BRID

GEHA

MPT

ON

PORT

JEFF

ERSO

N

SPRI

NGS

EAST

MO

RICH

ES

SHEL

TER

ISLA

ND

LITT

LE F

LOW

ER

REM

SEN

BURG

-SPE

ON

K

COLD

SPR

ING

HARB

OR

WAI

NSC

OTT

AMAG

ANSE

TT

MO

NTA

UK

FIRE

ISLA

ND

QU

OGU

E

SAGA

PON

ACK

OYS

TERP

ON

DS

FISH

ERS

ISLA

ND

Suffolk County School Districts # FRPL Comparison 15-16 & 07-08

# FRPL 2015-16

# FRPL 2007-08

Page 9: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

Long Island - Shifting Demographics

2015-16 & 2007-08 NYS School Report Cards

Total K-12 FRPL 07-08 15-16 Total Change % change

Nassau County 30,068 54,883 24,815 82.5%

Long Island 79,160 140,686 61,526 77.7%

Rest of State 409,682 480,559 70,877 17.3%

-500

0

500

1,000

1,500

2,000

2,500

3,000

3,500

4,000

4,500

5,000

5,500

6,000

UN

ION

DALE

FREE

PORT

HEM

PSTE

AD

WES

TBU

RY

HICK

SVIL

LE

BALD

WIN

LAW

REN

CE

GLE

N C

OVE

CIT

Y

VALL

EY S

TREA

M

EAST

MEA

DOW

LEVI

TTO

WN

SEW

ANHA

KA

FARM

INGD

ALE

PORT

WAS

HIN

GTO

N

ELM

ON

T

WES

T HE

MPS

TEAD

HEW

LETT

-WO

ODM

ERE

MAS

SAPE

QU

A

ROO

SEVE

LT

BELL

MO

RE-M

ERRI

CK

MIN

EOLA

GRE

AT N

ECK

BETH

PAGE

VALL

EY S

TREA

M 3

0

OCE

ANSI

DE

VALL

EY S

TREA

M 1

3

LYN

BRO

OK

SYO

SSET

PLAI

NVI

EW-O

LD B

ETHP

AGE

LON

G B

EACH

CIT

Y

ISLA

ND

TREE

S

HERR

ICKS

VALL

EY S

TREA

M 2

4

MAL

VERN

E

OYS

TER

BAY-

EAST

NO

RWIC

H

LOCU

ST V

ALLE

Y

ROCK

VILL

E CE

NTR

E

CARL

E PL

ACE

EAST

RO

CKAW

AY

NEW

HYD

E PA

RK-G

ARDE

N C

ITY

FRAN

KLIN

SQ

UAR

E

ROSL

YN

NO

RTH

BELL

MO

RE

FLO

RAL

PARK

-BEL

LERO

SE

JERI

CHO

MAN

HASS

ET

WAN

TAG

H

ISLA

ND

PARK

SEAF

ORD

GAR

DEN

CIT

Y

EAST

WIL

LIST

ON

MER

RICK

BELL

MO

RE

PLAI

NED

GE

NO

RTH

MER

RICK

NO

RTH

SHO

RE

Nassau County School Districts FRPL Change 07-08 to 15-16

Page 10: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

Long Island - Shifting Demographics

2015-16 & 2007-08 NYS School Report Cards

Total K-12 FRPL 07-08 15-16 Total Change % change

Nassau County 30,068 54,883 24,815 82.5%

Long Island 79,160 140,686 61,526 77.7%

Rest of State 409,682 480,559 70,877 17.3%

0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

7,000

8,000

9,000

10,000

11,000

12,000

13,000

14,000

15,000

HEM

PSTE

AD

FREE

PORT

UN

ION

DALE

WES

TBU

RY

ELM

ON

T

SEW

ANHA

KA

HICK

SVIL

LE

GLE

N C

OVE

CIT

Y

LAW

REN

CE

EAST

MEA

DOW

FARM

INGD

ALE

ROO

SEVE

LT

LEVI

TTO

WN

VALL

EY S

TREA

M

LON

G B

EACH

CIT

Y

PORT

WAS

HIN

GTO

N

BALD

WIN

WES

T HE

MPS

TEAD

GRE

AT N

ECK

OCE

ANSI

DE

MAL

VERN

E

MIN

EOLA

HEW

LETT

-WO

ODM

ERE

VALL

EY S

TREA

M 3

0

MAS

SAPE

QU

A

VALL

EY S

TREA

M 1

3

BELL

MO

RE-M

ERRI

CK

BETH

PAGE

ROCK

VILL

E CE

NTR

E

ISLA

ND

TREE

S

VALL

EY S

TREA

M 2

4

PLAI

NVI

EW-O

LD B

ETHP

AGE

OYS

TER

BAY-

EAST

NO

RWIC

H

LYN

BRO

OK

HERR

ICKS

ROSL

YN

LOCU

ST V

ALLE

Y

EAST

RO

CKAW

AY

PLAI

NED

GE

NEW

HYD

E PA

RK-G

ARDE

N C

ITY

FRAN

KLIN

SQ

UAR

E

NO

RTH

BELL

MO

RE

ISLA

ND

PARK

SYO

SSET

CARL

E PL

ACE

FLO

RAL

PARK

-BEL

LERO

SE

MAN

HASS

ET

WAN

TAG

H

SEAF

ORD

JERI

CHO

NO

RTH

SHO

RE

EAST

WIL

LIST

ON

GAR

DEN

CIT

Y

NO

RTH

MER

RICK

BELL

MO

RE

MER

RICK

Nassau County School Districts # FRPL Comparison 15-16 & 07-08

# FRPL 2015-16

# FRPL 2007-08

Page 11: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

11

Page 12: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

12

Page 13: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

13

Page 14: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

14

Page 15: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

The percentage of students in districts of below average wealth (CWR<1.00) by BOCES region on Long Island is as follows:

Region

Number of Students (2016-17)

Percentage of Students in

Below Average Wealth Districts

Suffolk County 241,380 61.0

Eastern Suffolk BOCES 160,197 73.5

Western Suffolk BOCES 81,183 36.4

Nassau County (Nassau BOCES) 201,406 30.6 Long Island 442,786 47.2

Long Island Combined Wealth Ratios (CWR)

2016-17 Property Tax Report Card – Enrollment 2016-17 CWR – NYSED

Page 16: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

Combined Wealth Ratios (2007-08)

Page 17: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

Combined Wealth Ratios (2016-17)

Page 18: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

Combined Wealth Ratios (2007-08)

18 2007-2008 CWRs - NYSED

Page 19: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

Combined Wealth Ratios (2016-17)

Page 20: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

Long Island - Shifting Number of SWDs

2015-16 & 2007-08 NYS School Report Cards

Total K-12 SWD 07-08 15-16 Total Change % change

Suffolk County 31,845 34,930 3,085 9.7%

Long Island 55,545 60,417 4,872 8.8%

Rest of State 161,566 167,577 6,011 3.7%

-300

-200

-100

0

100

200

300

400

500

HALF

HO

LLO

W H

ILLS

BREN

TWO

OD

RIVE

RHEA

D

SOU

TH H

UN

TIN

GTO

N

SACH

EM

BAY

SHO

RE

LON

GW

OO

D

COM

MAC

K

SMIT

HTO

WN

CEN

TER

MO

RICH

ES

SOU

THAM

PTO

N

EAST

PORT

-SO

UTH

MAN

OR

DEER

PAR

K

WYA

NDA

NCH

WES

T BA

BYLO

N

HUN

TIN

GTO

N

LITT

LE F

LOW

ER

WES

T IS

LIP

HAU

PPAU

GE

MID

DLE

COU

NTR

Y

EAST

ISLI

P

ISLI

P

BAYP

ORT

-BLU

E PO

INT

AMIT

YVIL

LE

PORT

JEFF

ERSO

N

SOU

TH C

OU

NTR

Y

SAYV

ILLE

SPRI

NGS

COPI

AGU

E

BABY

LON

MAT

TITU

CK-C

UTC

HOG

UE

REM

SEN

BURG

-SPE

ON

K

BRID

GEHA

MPT

ON

ELW

OO

D

HARB

ORF

IELD

S

WES

THAM

PTO

N B

EACH

MO

NTA

UK

BRO

OKH

AVEN

-CO

MSE

WO

GUE

EAST

MO

RICH

ES

FIRE

ISLA

ND

NEW

SU

FFO

LK

QU

OGU

E

EAST

QU

OGU

E

SAGA

PON

ACK

FISH

ERS

ISLA

ND

EAST

HAM

PTO

N

AMAG

ANSE

TT

TUCK

AHO

E

SHEL

TER

ISLA

ND

ROCK

Y PO

INT

WAI

NSC

OTT

OYS

TERP

ON

DS

LIN

DEN

HU

RST

GRE

ENPO

RT

SAG

HARB

OR

MO

UN

T SI

NAI

NO

RTHP

ORT

-EAS

T N

ORT

HPO

RT

KIN

GS P

ARK

COLD

SPR

ING

HARB

OR

SOU

THO

LD

HAM

PTO

N B

AYS

MIL

LER

PLAC

E

SHO

REHA

M-W

ADIN

G R

IVER

CEN

TRAL

ISLI

P

THRE

E VI

LLAG

E

CON

NET

QU

OT

PATC

HOG

UE-

MED

FORD

WIL

LIAM

FLO

YD

NO

RTH

BABY

LON

Suffolk County School Districts SWD Change 07-08 to 15-16

Page 21: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

Long Island - Shifting Numbers of SWDs

2015-16 & 2007-08 NYS School Report Cards

Total K-12 SWD 07-08 15-16 Total Change % change

Suffolk County 31,845 34,930 3,085 9.7%

Long Island 55,545 60,417 4,872 8.8%

Rest of State 161,566 167,577 6,011 3.7%

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

BREN

TWO

OD

SACH

EM

LON

GW

OO

D

HALF

HO

LLO

W H

ILLS

MID

DLE

COU

NTR

Y

SMIT

HTO

WN

WIL

LIAM

FLO

YD

COM

MAC

K

LIN

DEN

HU

RST

CON

NET

QU

OT

THRE

E VI

LLAG

E

BAY

SHO

RE

SOU

TH H

UN

TIN

GTO

N

PATC

HOG

UE-

MED

FORD

NO

RTHP

ORT

-EAS

T N

ORT

HPO

RT

CEN

TRAL

ISLI

P

RIVE

RHEA

D

WES

T IS

LIP

NO

RTH

BABY

LON

COPI

AGU

E

DEER

PAR

K

WES

T BA

BYLO

N

HUN

TIN

GTO

N

SOU

TH C

OU

NTR

Y

EAST

PORT

-SO

UTH

MAN

OR

KIN

GS P

ARK

BRO

OKH

AVEN

-CO

MSE

WO

GUE

ROCK

Y PO

INT

EAST

ISLI

P

HAU

PPAU

GE

HARB

ORF

IELD

S

WYA

NDA

NCH

AMIT

YVIL

LE

SHO

REHA

M-W

ADIN

G R

IVER

BAYP

ORT

-BLU

E PO

INT

SAYV

ILLE

MIL

LER

PLAC

E

ISLI

P

MO

UN

T SI

NAI

CEN

TER

MO

RICH

ES

SOU

THAM

PTO

N

ELW

OO

D

HAM

PTO

N B

AYS

WES

THAM

PTO

N B

EACH

EAST

HAM

PTO

N

BABY

LON

MAT

TITU

CK-C

UTC

HOG

UE

COLD

SPR

ING

HARB

OR

PORT

JEFF

ERSO

N

SOU

THO

LD

SAG

HARB

OR

LITT

LE F

LOW

ER

EAST

MO

RICH

ES

SPRI

NGS

GRE

ENPO

RT

MO

NTA

UK

EAST

QU

OGU

E

BRID

GEHA

MPT

ON

SHEL

TER

ISLA

ND

TUCK

AHO

E

REM

SEN

BURG

-SPE

ON

K

AMAG

ANSE

TT

OYS

TERP

ON

DS

FISH

ERS

ISLA

ND

QU

OGU

E

FIRE

ISLA

ND

WAI

NSC

OTT

NEW

SU

FFO

LK

SAGA

PON

ACK

Suffolk County School Districts # SWD Comparison 15-16 & 07-08

# SWD 2015-16

# SWD 2007-08

Page 22: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

Long Island - Shifting Number of SWDs

2015-16 & 2007-08 NYS School Report Cards

Total K-12 SWD 07-08 15-16 Total Change % change

Nassau County 23,700 25,487 1,787 7.5%

Long Island 55,545 60,417 4,872 8.8%

Rest of State 161,566 167,577 6,011 3.7%

-300

-200

-100

0

100

200

300

400

500

UN

ION

DALE

GRE

AT N

ECK

GLE

N C

OVE

MIN

EOLA

BALD

WIN

LON

G B

EACH

HEM

PSTE

AD

ROCK

VILL

E CE

NTR

E

MAN

HASS

ET

BELL

MO

RE-M

ERRI

CK

PORT

WAS

HIN

GTO

N

LAW

REN

CE

ROO

SEVE

LT

SEAF

ORD

FREE

PORT

FRAN

KLIN

SQ

UAR

E

VALL

EY S

TREA

M 3

0

LOCU

ST V

ALLE

Y

NO

RTH

BELL

MO

RE

FARM

INGD

ALE

LYN

BRO

OK

VALL

EY S

TREA

M 2

4

FLO

RAL

PARK

-BEL

LERO

SE

HEW

LETT

-WO

ODM

ERE

MAL

VERN

E

VALL

EY S

TREA

M

HICK

SVIL

LE

NEW

HYD

E PA

RK-G

ARDE

N C

ITY

PARK

NO

RTH

SHO

RE

JERI

CHO

VALL

EY S

TREA

M 1

3

OYS

TER

BAY-

EAST

NO

RWIC

H

NO

RTH

MER

RICK

GAR

DEN

CIT

Y

BELL

MO

RE

HERR

ICKS

OCE

ANSI

DE

PLAI

NED

GE

ISLA

ND

PARK

BETH

PAGE

WES

TBU

RY

WES

T HE

MPS

TEAD

CARL

E PL

ACE

ISLA

ND

TREE

S

ELM

ON

T

EAST

WIL

LIST

ON

EAST

RO

CKAW

AY

ROSL

YN

EAST

MEA

DOW

MER

RICK

SEW

ANHA

KA

WAN

TAG

H

PLAI

NVI

EW-O

LD B

ETHP

AGE

MAS

SAPE

QU

A

SYO

SSET

LEVI

TTO

WN

Nassau County School Districts SWD Change 07-08 to 15-16

Page 23: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

Long Island - Shifting Numbers of SWDs

2015-16 & 2007-08 NYS School Report Cards

Total K-12 SWD 07-08 15-16 Total Change % change

Nassau County 23,700 25,487 1,787 7.5%

Long Island 55,545 60,417 4,872 8.8%

Rest of State 161,566 167,577 6,011 3.7%

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

LEVI

TTO

WN

SEW

ANHA

KA

GRE

AT N

ECK

FREE

PORT

UN

ION

DALE

FARM

INGD

ALE

BALD

WIN

PORT

WAS

HIN

GTO

N

EAST

MEA

DOW

BELL

MO

RE-M

ERRI

CK

HEM

PSTE

AD

MAS

SAPE

QU

A

SYO

SSET

PLAI

NVI

EW-O

LD B

ETHP

AGE

OCE

ANSI

DE

VALL

EY S

TREA

M

HICK

SVIL

LE

LON

G B

EACH

GLE

N C

OVE

HERR

ICKS

LAW

REN

CE

ROCK

VILL

E CE

NTR

E

WES

TBU

RY

HEW

LETT

-WO

ODM

ERE

ELM

ON

T

GAR

DEN

CIT

Y

ROO

SEVE

LT

MIN

EOLA

NO

RTH

SHO

RE

MAN

HASS

ET

WAN

TAG

H

JERI

CHO

NO

RTH

BELL

MO

RE

BETH

PAGE

LYN

BRO

OK

LOCU

ST V

ALLE

Y

SEAF

ORD

PLAI

NED

GE

VALL

EY S

TREA

M 1

3

WES

T HE

MPS

TEAD

ROSL

YN

MAL

VERN

E

ISLA

ND

TREE

S

FRAN

KLIN

SQ

UAR

E

CARL

E PL

ACE

MER

RICK

OYS

TER

BAY-

EAST

NO

RWIC

H

EAST

WIL

LIST

ON

NEW

HYD

E PA

RK-G

ARDE

N C

ITY

PARK

FLO

RAL

PARK

-BEL

LERO

SE

EAST

RO

CKAW

AY

VALL

EY S

TREA

M 2

4

NO

RTH

MER

RICK

VALL

EY S

TREA

M 3

0

BELL

MO

RE

ISLA

ND

PARK

Nassau County School Districts # SWD Comparison 15-16 & 07-08

# SWD 2015-16

# SWD 2007-08

Page 24: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

Long Island has 35,354 ELLs,

which is 16.2% of the state’s total ELL population

Source: Ensuring Equal Educational Opportunities for English Language Learners, Long Island Regional Bilingual Education Resource Network, October 2016

Page 25: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

Note: Y-axis only ranges from 5% - 10% to better magnify the data points & trends 2015-16 NYS School Report Cards

Long Island Shifting ELL Numbers

5%

6%

7%

8%

9%

10%

2007-08N=461,540

2008-09N=458,613

2009-10N=457,193

2010-11N=455,241

2011-12N=450,539

2012-13N=446,998

2013-14N=443,173

2014-15N=440,899

2015-16N=437,193

% of ELL Students on Long Island

Long Island %ELL Nassau County %ELL Suffolk County %ELL

Page 26: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

Long Island - Shifting ELL Numbers

2015-16 & 2007-08 NYS School Report Cards

Total K-12 ELL 07-08 15-16 Total Change % change

Suffolk County 14,174 19,223 5,049 35.6%

Long Island 25,485 32,972 7,487 29.4%

Rest of State 33,474 43,489 10,015 29.9%

-100

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1100

1200

1300

1400

BREN

TWO

OD

RIVE

RHEA

D

CEN

TRAL

ISLI

P

AMIT

YVIL

LE

WYA

NDA

NCH

SOU

TH H

UN

TIN

GTO

N

HAM

PTO

N B

AYS

PATC

HOG

UE-

MED

FORD

BAY

SHO

RE

SOU

TH C

OU

NTR

Y

SACH

EM

HUN

TIN

GTO

N

NO

RTH

BABY

LON

LON

GW

OO

D

DEER

PAR

K

EAST

HAM

PTO

N

COM

MAC

K

BRO

OKH

AVEN

-CO

MSE

WO

GUE

MID

DLE

COU

NTR

Y

WES

THAM

PTO

N B

EACH

SPRI

NGS

CON

NET

QU

OT

SOU

THO

LD

SOU

THAM

PTO

N

NO

RTHP

ORT

-EAS

T N

ORT

HPO

RT

EAST

QU

OGU

E

WES

T IS

LIP

WIL

LIAM

FLO

YD

ELW

OO

D

CEN

TER

MO

RICH

ES

LIN

DEN

HU

RST

SAYV

ILLE

MAT

TITU

CK-C

UTC

HOG

UE

HARB

ORF

IELD

S

EAST

ISLI

P

GRE

ENPO

RT

ROCK

Y PO

INT

WES

T BA

BYLO

N

TUCK

AHO

E

COPI

AGU

E

PORT

JEFF

ERSO

N

ISLI

P

EAST

MO

RICH

ES

WAI

NSC

OTT

BRID

GEHA

MPT

ON

SHEL

TER

ISLA

ND

FIRE

ISLA

ND

SAGA

PON

ACK

LITT

LE F

LOW

ER

QU

OGU

E

AMAG

ANSE

TT

COLD

SPR

ING

HARB

OR

BAYP

ORT

-BLU

E PO

INT

FISH

ERS

ISLA

ND

NEW

SU

FFO

LK

OYS

TERP

ON

DS

MO

UN

T SI

NAI

BABY

LON

EAST

PORT

-SO

UTH

MAN

OR

SAG

HARB

OR

MIL

LER

PLAC

E

REM

SEN

BURG

-SPE

ON

K

SHO

REHA

M-W

ADIN

G R

IVER

KIN

GS P

ARK

HAU

PPAU

GE

THRE

E VI

LLAG

E

SMIT

HTO

WN

MO

NTA

UK

HALF

HO

LLO

W H

ILLS

Suffolk County School Districts ELL Change 07-08 to 15-16

Page 27: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

Long Island - Shifting ELL Numbers

2015-16 & 2007-08 NYS School Report Cards

Total K-12 ELL 07-08 15-16 Total Change % change

Suffolk County 14,174 19,223 5,049 35.6%

Long Island 25,485 32,972 7,487 29.4%

Rest of State 33,474 43,489 10,015 29.9%

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

4000

4500

5000

5500

6000

BREN

TWO

OD

CEN

TRAL

ISLI

P

RIVE

RHEA

D

SOU

TH H

UN

TIN

GTO

N

PATC

HOG

UE-

MED

FORD

COPI

AGU

E

HUN

TIN

GTO

N

AMIT

YVIL

LE

WYA

NDA

NCH

LON

GW

OO

D

HAM

PTO

N B

AYS

WIL

LIAM

FLO

YD

BAY

SHO

RE

MID

DLE

COU

NTR

Y

SOU

TH C

OU

NTR

Y

SACH

EM

EAST

HAM

PTO

N

LIN

DEN

HU

RST

BRO

OKH

AVEN

-CO

MSE

WO

GUE

SOU

THAM

PTO

N

DEER

PAR

K

NO

RTH

BABY

LON

HALF

HO

LLO

W H

ILLS

WES

T BA

BYLO

N

CON

NET

QU

OT

ISLI

P

NO

RTHP

ORT

-EAS

T N

ORT

HPO

RT

WES

THAM

PTO

N B

EACH

ROCK

Y PO

INT

SMIT

HTO

WN

SPRI

NGS

ELW

OO

D

GRE

ENPO

RT

SOU

THO

LD

EAST

ISLI

P

TUCK

AHO

E

HAU

PPAU

GE

CEN

TER

MO

RICH

ES

COM

MAC

K

THRE

E VI

LLAG

E

HARB

ORF

IELD

S

MAT

TITU

CK-C

UTC

HOG

UE

EAST

QU

OGU

E

SAG

HARB

OR

WES

T IS

LIP

EAST

PORT

-SO

UTH

MAN

OR

KIN

GS P

ARK

MO

NTA

UK

SAYV

ILLE

BRID

GEHA

MPT

ON

MIL

LER

PLAC

E

MO

UN

T SI

NAI

SHO

REHA

M-W

ADIN

G R

IVER

EAST

MO

RICH

ES

PORT

JEFF

ERSO

N

BABY

LON

SHEL

TER

ISLA

ND

AMAG

ANSE

TT

WAI

NSC

OTT

OYS

TERP

ON

DS

REM

SEN

BURG

-SPE

ON

K

FIRE

ISLA

ND

SAGA

PON

ACK

LITT

LE F

LOW

ER

QU

OGU

E

COLD

SPR

ING

HARB

OR

BAYP

ORT

-BLU

E PO

INT

FISH

ERS

ISLA

ND

NEW

SU

FFO

LK

Suffolk County School Districts # ELL Comparison 15-16 & 07-08

# ELL 2015-16

# ELL 2007-08

Page 28: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

Long Island - Shifting ELL Numbers

2015-16 & 2007-08 NYS School Report Cards

Total K-12 ELL 07-08 15-16 Total Change % change

Nassau County 11,311 13,749 2,438 21.6%

Long Island 25,485 32,972 7,487 29.4%

Rest of State 33,474 43,489 10,015 29.9%

-100

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1100

1200

1300

1400

HEM

PSTE

AD

WES

TBU

RY

UN

ION

DALE

ROO

SEVE

LT

FREE

PORT

LAW

REN

CE

PORT

WAS

HIN

GTO

N

GLE

N C

OVE

MIN

EOLA

BALD

WIN

WES

T HE

MPS

TEAD

JERI

CHO

OYS

TER

BAY-

EAST

NO

RWIC

H

WAN

TAG

H

ISLA

ND

PARK

PLAI

NED

GE

ELM

ON

T

LOCU

ST V

ALLE

Y

EAST

WIL

LIST

ON

ISLA

ND

TREE

S

MAN

HASS

ET

GAR

DEN

CIT

Y

BELL

MO

RE-M

ERRI

CK

MAS

SAPE

QU

A

FRAN

KLIN

SQ

UAR

E

ROCK

VILL

E CE

NTR

E

PLAI

NVI

EW-O

LD B

ETHP

AGE

HICK

SVIL

LE

NO

RTH

SHO

RE

NO

RTH

BELL

MO

RE

SEAF

ORD

BETH

PAGE

LYN

BRO

OK

SEW

ANHA

KA

ROSL

YN

HERR

ICKS

SYO

SSET

EAST

RO

CKAW

AY

FARM

INGD

ALE

FLO

RAL

PARK

-BEL

LERO

SE

NO

RTH

MER

RICK

LEVI

TTO

WN

BELL

MO

RE

MER

RICK

OCE

ANSI

DE

EAST

MEA

DOW

VALL

EY S

TREA

M 1

3

NEW

HYD

E PA

RK-G

ARDE

N C

ITY

PARK

HEW

LETT

-WO

ODM

ERE

VALL

EY S

TREA

M 3

0

CARL

E PL

ACE

VALL

EY S

TREA

M

LON

G B

EACH

MAL

VERN

E

VALL

EY S

TREA

M 2

4

GRE

AT N

ECK

Nassau County School Districts ELL Change 07-08 to 15-16

Page 29: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

Long Island - Shifting ELL Numbers

2015-16 & 2007-08 NYS School Report Cards

Total K-12 ELL 07-08 15-16 Total Change % change

Nassau County 11,311 13,749 2,438 21.6%

Long Island 25,485 32,972 7,487 29.4%

Rest of State 33,474 43,489 10,015 29.9%

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

4000

4500

5000

5500

6000

HEM

PSTE

AD

WES

TBU

RY

FREE

PORT

UN

ION

DALE

ROO

SEVE

LT

GLE

N C

OVE

PORT

WAS

HIN

GTO

N

HICK

SVIL

LE

LAW

REN

CE

EAST

MEA

DOW

MIN

EOLA

GRE

AT N

ECK

BALD

WIN

OCE

ANSI

DE

ELM

ON

T

HERR

ICKS

FARM

INGD

ALE

WES

T HE

MPS

TEAD

SEW

ANHA

KA

LON

G B

EACH

LEVI

TTO

WN

VALL

EY S

TREA

M 3

0

SYO

SSET

JERI

CHO

OYS

TER

BAY-

EAST

NO

RWIC

H

NEW

HYD

E PA

RK-G

ARDE

N C

ITY

PARK

ROSL

YN

VALL

EY S

TREA

M

HEW

LETT

-WO

ODM

ERE

VALL

EY S

TREA

M 2

4

LOCU

ST V

ALLE

Y

VALL

EY S

TREA

M 1

3

ROCK

VILL

E CE

NTR

E

ISLA

ND

TREE

S

MAN

HASS

ET

PLAI

NED

GE

BETH

PAGE

ISLA

ND

PARK

FRAN

KLIN

SQ

UAR

E

LYN

BRO

OK

CARL

E PL

ACE

NO

RTH

SHO

RE

EAST

WIL

LIST

ON

PLAI

NVI

EW-O

LD B

ETHP

AGE

NO

RTH

BELL

MO

RE

MAL

VERN

E

WAN

TAG

H

EAST

RO

CKAW

AY

SEAF

ORD

BELL

MO

RE

MER

RICK

FLO

RAL

PARK

-BEL

LERO

SE

NO

RTH

MER

RICK

GAR

DEN

CIT

Y

BELL

MO

RE-M

ERRI

CK

MAS

SAPE

QU

A

Nassau County School Districts # ELL Comparison 15-16 & 07-08

# ELL 2015-16

# ELL 2007-08

Page 30: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

Long Island ELL Enrollment 1991-2016 59

95

7060

8772

9281

1255

0

1217

1

1174

9

1222

7

1182

8

1220

2

1269

3

1296

4

1307

0

1200

2

1216

5

1225

5 1499

6

4519

6350

6897

7685

1085

3

1243

2 1403

7

1504

1

1523

2

1586

0

1627

9

1643

7

1624

9

1606

5

1625

2

1673

8

2035

8

0

5000

10000

15000

20000

25000

Nassau Suffolk

Data Source: CR Part 154 Data/Information Reports for 2015-2016

Page 31: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

Long Island ELLs Served 2015-2016 in Perspective

NYS ELLs Served (Public Schools) 217,804

NYC ELLs Served (Public Schools) 146,742

ROS ELLs Served (Public Schools) 71,062

Long Island ELLs Served (Public Schools) 35,354

Nassau Suffolk Long Island Total

ELL Enrollment 14,996 20,358 35,354 Percent of ROS ELLs 21.1% 28.6% 49.8% Percent of all NYS ELLs 6.9% 9.3% 16.2%

Data Sources: Long Island statistics retrieved from CR Part 154 Data/Information Reports for 2015-2016 NYC data retrieved 10/25/2016 from http://schools.nyc.gov/Accountability/data/default.htm ROS data retrieved 10/25/2016 from data.nysed.gov

Page 32: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

Top Ten Languages Spoken by ELLs on Long Island in 2015-16

84.2%

3.0%

2.2%

2.1%

0.6% 0.6% 0.5%

0.5% 0.4%

0.4% 5.5%

SpanishChineseHaitian CreoleUrduTurkishKoreanBengaliJapaneseFrenchPunjabiAll Others

There is a total of 104 languages other than English spoken by school age children on Long Island.

Data Source: CR Part 154 Data/Information Reports for 2015-2016

Page 33: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

Linguistic and Cultural Diversity 2015-2016 Nassau Top 10 languages Suffolk Top 10 languages

Linguistically diverse state with over 200 languages spoken by our students.

33

Source: NYS SIRS 2015-2016

Spanish, 83.7%

Chinese, 4.5%

Haitian Creole, 2.1% Urdu, 2.0%

Japanese, 0.9%

Panjabi, 0.8%

Korean, 0.7% Russian, 0.4%

Hindi, 0.4%

Malayalam, 0.4%

Other, 3.9%

Spanish

Chinese

Haitian Creole

Urdu

Japanese

Panjabi

Korean

Russian

Hindi

Malayalam

Other

Spanish, 91.0%

Urdu, 1.5%

Chinese, 0.9%

Turkish, 0.8%

Haitian Creole, 0.6%

Bengali, 0.5%

Creoles & Pidgins , 0.5% Portuguese, 0.3%

Pushto, 0.3%

Korean, 0.3%

Other, 1.2%

Spanish

Urdu

Chinese

Turkish

Haitian Creole

Bengali

Creoles & Pidgins

Portuguese

Pushto

Korean

Other

Page 34: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

ELL Subgroups

Nassau Suffolk

Newcomers

12,055 (76.2%) 15,132 (69.0%)

Developing ELLs 2,684 (17.0%) 4,647 (21.2%)

Long-term ELLs 1,077 (6.8%) 2,139 (9.8%)

Students with Inconsistent/Interrupted

Formal Education 376 (2.4%) 956 (4.4%)

ELL Students with Disabilities 2,367 (15.0%) 3,499 (15.9%)

34

Page 35: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

Suffolk NYSESLAT Performance 2015 to 2016

35

17.0%

13.1% 13.7%

43.1%

13.1%

0.5%

5.6%

29.8%

55.2%

8.9%

0.0%

10.0%

20.0%

30.0%

40.0%

50.0%

60.0%

Entering Emerging Transitioning Expanding Commanding

2015 2016

Page 36: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

Long Island 2016 NYSESLAT Distribution of Results

LongIsland K

LongIsland 1-2

LongIsland 3-4

LongIsland 5-6

LongIsland 7-8

LongIsland 9-

12Entering 231 272 236 278 238 738Emerging 570 1204 665 449 591 1745Transitioning 677 3093 1775 1077 682 2094Expanding 2472 3434 2682 2033 1725 2442Commanding 642 578 542 520 414 306

0500

1000150020002500300035004000

Entering Emerging Transitioning Expanding Commanding

Total Tested: 4592 8581 5927 4357 3650 7370 Data Sources: Eastern Suffolk BOCES Student Data Services

Nassau BOCES C.I.T. Student Support Services

Page 37: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

Long Island Comparison of NYSESLAT Data 2006-2016

02000400060008000

10000120001400016000

2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016

Beginner/Entering Intermediate/Emerging Transitioning Advanced/Expanding Proficient/Commanding

24,131 24,047 26,046 27,077 27,307 27,760 28,440 28,275 30,130 31,686

Data Sources: Eastern Suffolk BOCES Student Data Services Nassau BOCES C.I.T. Student Support Services

34,477

Page 38: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

School Funding Foundation Aid

Amount Owed Per Pupil By County

2010-11 to 2015-16 Base Year Aids 2010-11 to 2015-16 Foundation Aid History – Questar III BOCES 2016-17 Legislative State Aid Runs 2016-17 – Full Foundation Aid – School Aid Specialists

0

200

400

600

800

1,000

1,200

1,400

1,600

1,800

2,000

2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 2012-13 2013-14 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17

Nassau

Suffolk

Long Island

2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 2012-13 2013-14 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17

Nassau $813 $493 $902 $893 $1,391 $1,365 $1,760 $1,522 $1,860 $1,842

Suffolk $926 $234 $597 $724 $1,203 $1,194 $1,524 $1,390 $1,449 $1,530

Long Island $875 $352 $735 $801 $1,289 $1,272 $1,631 $1,450 $1,636 $1,672

Page 39: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

School Funding Foundation Aid

Amount Owed Per Pupil By District Wealth

2010-11 to 2015-16 Base Year Aids 2010-11 to 2015-16 Foundation Aid History – Questar III BOCES 2016-17 Legislative State Aid Runs 2016-17 – Full Foundation Aid – School Aid Specialists

-500

0

500

1,000

1,500

2,000

2,500

3,000

2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 2012-13 2013-14 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17

Low <1.0

Med/Low1.0 - <1.5Med/High1.5 - 2.0High >2.0

CWR

Wealth 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 2012-13 2013-14 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17 High >2.0 $98 -$392 -$423 -$407 -$199 -$204 -$197 -$262 -$232 -$198 Med/High 1.5 - 2.0 $494 $179 $390 $392 $819 $826 $864 $760 $774 $819 Med/Low 1.0 - <1.5 $686 $384 $792 $778 $1,008 $998 $1,201 $1,036 $1,036 $1,072 Low <1.0 $1,276 $555 $1,064 $1,208 $1,948 $1,918 $2,538 $2,300 $2,684 $2,718

Page 40: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

40

School Funding – Foundation Aid

0

5,000

10,000

15,000

20,000

25,000

30,000

35,000

40,000

45,000

50,000

55,000

60,000

Bren

twoo

d (0

.345

)

Wya

ndan

ch (0

.337

)

Copi

ague

(0.6

02)

Cent

ral I

slip

(0.4

55)

Bay

Shor

e (0

.765

)

Deer

Par

k (0

.824

)

Will

iam

Flo

yd (0

.548

)

Cent

er M

oric

hes (

0.74

8)

Sout

h Hu

ntin

gton

(1.0

4)

Amity

ville

(0.9

74)

Rock

y Po

int (

0.71

7)

Shor

eham

-Wad

ing

Rive

r (1.

145)

Rive

rhea

d (1

.159

)

Elw

ood

(1.0

97)

Ham

pton

Bay

s (1.

537)

Hunt

ingt

on (1

.605

)

Harb

orfie

lds (

1.25

9)

Half

Hollo

w H

ills (

1.56

)

East

port

-Sou

th M

anor

(0.7

84)

Smith

tow

n (1

.309

)

Nor

thpo

rt-E

ast N

orth

port

(1.8

12)

King

s Par

k (1

.262

)

Patc

hogu

e-M

edfo

rd (0

.808

)

Lind

enhu

rst (

0.78

4)

Com

mac

k (1

.171

)

Islip

(1.0

04)

Wes

t Bab

ylon

(0.8

77)

Haup

paug

e (1

.49)

Mill

er P

lace

(0.9

42)

Mid

dle

Coun

try

(0.7

86)

Gre

enpo

rt (2

.026

)

Bayp

ort-

Blue

Poi

nt (0

.982

)

Wes

t Isli

p (0

.988

)

Broo

khav

en-C

omse

wog

ue (0

.815

)

Baby

lon

(1.3

76)

Long

woo

d (0

.769

)

Nor

th B

abyl

on (0

.779

)

Suffolk County – Foundation Aid Owed Per Pupil 2007-08 to 2016-17

CWR < 1.000 Low Wealth CWR 1.000 - 1.499 Low Mid Wealth CWR 1.500 - 1.999 High Mid Wealth CWR ≥ 2.000 High Wealth

2007-08 CWRs – NYSED 2016-17 CWRs – NYSED

2016-17 CWRs

Page 41: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

41

School Funding – Foundation Aid

0

5,000

10,000

15,000

20,000

25,000

30,000

35,000

40,000

45,000

50,000

55,000

60,000

Hem

pste

ad (0

.325

)W

estb

ury

(0.6

81)

Roos

evel

t (0.

39)

Free

port

(0.5

83)

Uni

onda

le (0

.778

)El

mon

t (0.

824)

Valle

y St

ream

Cen

tral

(0.9

34)

Sew

anha

ka (1

.03)

Valle

y St

ream

24

(0.9

03)

Valle

y St

ream

30

(0.9

19)

Beth

page

(1.1

81)

Wes

t Hem

pste

ad (1

.264

)N

ew H

yde

Park

-Gar

den

City

…Be

llmor

e-M

erric

k (1

.145

)Hi

cksv

ille

(1.3

46)

Bald

win

(0.9

31)

Fran

klin

Squ

are

(1.0

7)Fa

rmin

gdal

e (1

.149

)O

cean

side

(1.2

6)Pl

aine

dge

(1.0

19)

Glen

Cov

e (1

.438

)Ly

nbro

ok (1

.282

)Va

lley

Stre

am 1

3 (0

.959

)M

assa

pequ

a (1

.332

)Se

afor

d (1

.108

)Is

land

Tre

es (0

.926

)W

anta

gh (1

.056

)Ca

rle P

lace

(1.5

76)

Herr

icks

(1.5

24)

Hew

lett

-Woo

dmer

e (1

.703

)Fl

oral

Par

k-Be

llero

se (1

.246

)Pl

ainv

iew

-Old

Bet

hpag

e (1

.338

)Ea

st R

ocka

way

(1.2

4)Ro

ckvi

lle C

entr

e (1

.715

)M

ineo

la (1

.785

)Sy

osse

t (1.

899)

Mal

vern

e (1

.164

)Le

vitt

own

(0.8

48)

East

Mea

dow

(1.0

9)Ro

slyn

(2.1

81)

Nor

th M

erric

k (0

.964

)Be

llmor

e (1

.363

)N

orth

Sho

re (2

.295

)M

erric

k (1

.38)

East

Will

iston

(2.3

64)

Nor

th B

ellm

ore

(0.9

65)

Port

Was

hing

ton

(2.1

41)

CWR < 1.000 Low Wealth CWR 1.000 - 1.499 Low Mid Wealth CWR 1.500 - 1.999 High Mid Wealth CWR ≥ 2.000 High Wealth

2007-08 CWRs – NYSED 2016-17 CWRs – NYSED

Nassau County – Foundation Aid Owed Per Pupil 2007-08 to 2016-17

2016-17 CWRs

Page 42: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

What We Know What’s at Stake What We Must Do

42

Page 43: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

SCSSA LEADERSHIP

Board of Directors

President – Dr. Charles T. Russo, East Moriches UFSD President-Elect – Mr. Lars Clemensen, Hampton Bays UFSD

Vice President – Dr. Kenneth Bossert, Elwood UFSD Treasurer – Ms. Eva J. Demyen, Deer Park UFSD

Secretary – Ms. Bernadette Burns, West Islip UFSD Past President – Mrs. Susan A. Schnebel, Islip UFSD

Legislative Committee

Co-Chairpersons Dr. Julie Davis Lutz

Dr. Walter F. Schartner

Babylon Cluster Ms. Eva J. Demyen

Brookhaven/Riverhead Cluster

Ms. Nancy Carney Dr. Roberta A. Gerold

East End Cluster

Mrs. Cynthia Stachowski Dr. Ronald M. Masera

Huntington/Smithtown Cluster

Dr. David Bennardo Dr. Kenneth Bossert Dr. Donald A. James

Islip Cluster

Ms. Bernadette M. Burns

Executive Director

Mr. Gary D. Bixhorn

Page 44: The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island...The Emerging Challenges in Public Education on Long Island Presented by: Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D. Suffolk County School

President Lisa Israel

Vice President William K. Miller

Member and Clerk Fred Langstaff

Members Stephen L. Gessner, Ph.D.

Linda S. Goldsmith William Hsiang Susan Lipman

Arlene Barresi

Chris J. Cariello Walter Wm. Denzler, Jr. Stephen Dewey, Ph.D.

Joseph LoSchiavo Anne Mackesey

Catherine M. Romano John Wyche

District Superintendent David Wicks

Chief Operating Officer Julie Davis Lutz, Ph.D.

Associate Superintendent Ryan J. Ruf – Management Services

Associate Superintendent Peggie Staib, Ed.D. – Educational Services

Assistant Superintendent R. Terri McSweeney, Ed.D. – Human Resources

Directors Keith Anderson – Building Services

Leah Arnold – Career, Technical and Adult Education Kate Davern – Education and Information Support Services

Colleen Lipponer – Business Services Susan Maddi – Administrative Services Grant Nelsen – Technology Integration

Gina Reilly – Special Education Darlene Roces – Regional Information Center

Candace White-Ciraco, Ed.D. – Planning and Program Improvement www.esboces.org

Eastern Suffolk BOCES Board and Administration

Eastern Suffolk BOCES does not discriminate against any employee, student, applicant for employment, or candidate for enrollment on the basis of gender, race, color, religion or creed, age, weight, national origin, marital status, disability, sexual orientation, military or veteran status, domestic violence victim status, genetic predisposition or carrier status, or any other classification protected by Federal, State, or local law. This policy of nondiscrimination includes: access by students to educational programs, student activities, recruitment, appointment and promotion of employees, salaries, pay, and other benefits. ESBOCES also provides equal access to the Boy Scouts and other designated youth groups. ESBOCES fully complies with all applicable rules and regulations pertaining to civil rights for students and employees (e.g., Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972, § 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, Titles VI and VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, Dignity for All Students Act, § 303 of Age Discrimination Act of 1975, the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990, and the Boy Scouts of America Equal Access Act of 2001). Inquiries regarding the implementation of the above laws should be directed to either of ESBOCES Civil Rights Compliance Officers at [email protected]: the Assistant Superintendent for Human Resources, 631-687-3029, or the Associate Superintendent for Educational Services, 631-687-3056, 201 Sunrise Highway, Patchogue, NY 11772. Inquiries may also be addressed to the Office for Civil Rights at the US Department of Education, 32 Old Slip, 26th Floor, New York, NY 10005, 646-428-3800, [email protected].