the fate of the global economy rides on the answer · estate, and other assets enjoyed another...
TRANSCRIPT
eResearch Corporation 100 University Avenue, 5th Floor Toronto, Ontario M5J 1V6
www.eresearch.com
Articles: Peak Prosperity April 20, 2019
It Is 2016 All Over Again. Or Is It?
The Fate Of The Global Economy Rides On The Answer
DISCLOSURE: The contents of this report were researched, analyzed, and written by PeakProsperity,, and were put into this report format, and published and distributed by
eResearch Corporation.
eResearch Corporation is pleased to provide an article written by Chris Martenson, co-founder of
PeakProsperity, entitled “It Is 2016 All Over Again. Or Is It? The Fate Of The Global Economy
Rides On The Answer”
Mr. Martenson’s article begins on the next page.
You can also access it directly at the website of PeakProsperity, at the link below.
Use <CTRL-CLICK>. Is It 2016 All Over Again?
eResearch Corporation
eResearch was established in 2000 as Canada's first equity issuer-sponsored research organization. As a primary source for professional investment research, our Subscribers (subscription is free!!!) benefit by having written research on a variety of small- and mid-cap, under-covered companies. We also provide unsponsored research reports on middle and larger-sized companies, using a combination of fundamental and technical analysis. We complement our corporate research coverage with a diversified selection of informative, insightful, and thought-provoking research publications from a wide variety of investment professionals. We provide our professional
investment research and analysis directly to our extensive subscriber network of discerning investors, and electronically through our website: www.eresearch.ca. Bob Weir, CFA Contributing Analyst
Note: All of the comments, views, opinions, suggestions, recommendations, etc., contained in this Article, and which is distributed by
eResearch Corporation, are strictly those of the Author and do not necessarily reflect those of eResearch Corporation.
eResearch Corporation - 2 - www.eresearch.com
It Is 2016 All Over Again. Or Is It?
The Fate Of The Global Economy Rides On The Answer
APRIL 19, 2019
By Chris Martenson (bio at end of article)
Conditions today mirror 2016, when growing weakness in the global economy and wobbling financial markets caused
the world’s central banks to absolutely freak out. They responded by dumping more thin-air money into the system
than ever before in history. And it worked (for them at least). Economic growth stabilized; and the prices of stocks, real
estate, and other assets enjoyed another three-year joyride.
Similarly, as things started getting shaky in late 2018, the same playbook was deployed. Again, we have seen stocks
rocket upwards ever since. But will the strategy actually work this time? It is unclear, and a lot is riding on the answer.
Back in 2016 the financial world was falling apart. The U.S. dollar was spiking. Emerging market currencies were
getting destroyed. The S&P 500 equities were exhibiting a classic head-and-shoulders formation, indicative of a
coming plunge. The macro-economic outlook looked grim, too, with global trade slipping into contraction:
Then, everything suddenly turned around, as if by magic. Well, we now know that ‘magic’ was actually a massive
quantity of monetary and fiscal stimulus pumped into the system by the world's central banking cartel.
Our concern is that the monetary and fiscal authorities are thinking that , since they were “successful” back in 2016,
they can repeat the same strategy here in 2019. But can they? Maybe. Or maybe not.
eResearch Corporation - 3 - www.eresearch.com
If the answer is “yes,” our prediction is to expect what we got last time, just taken to more extremes: a vastly wider
wealth gap between the 1% and everyone else, accelerated destruction of savers and the middle classes, and anemic
GDP growth coupled with explosive further growth of global debt levels.
If the answer is “no,” a massive crash of epic proportions, unlike any most of us have ever experienced, is in store.
Credit bubbles are ugly beasts. They are fun while they last but devastating when they burst. The longer they carry on,
the worse the crash when it comes -- this bubble has been going on for longer than most people ever could have
imagined.
2016: A Post-Mortem
It is eerie how closely recent developments resemble what took place at the start of 2016. In 2016, there were slumping
emerging markets, a slew of macro indicators pointing to a global slowdown, and equity bear markets all over the
place. Then – presto! – everything reversed during one night in February 2016. It was as if nothing had ever happened.
Somehow all those fundamental macro warnings just melted away in a burst of financial market exuberance.
S&P futures took off in the overnight session between February 7th
and the morning of February 8th
as if the entire
world suddenly had a change of heart:
From that moment on, the S&P started climbing to new all-time highs, practically unabated, until September 2018.
So, what happened here? What new information became available to the world’s investors in the wee late night/early
morning hours of February 8th
, 2016 that was not available the day before?
Nothing fundamental, that is for sure. Massive buy orders showed up in the middle of the night and it was only later
that the economic data began to turn the corner. What came first was the tremendous application of monetary, fiscal,
and financial stimulus. Just gobs and gobs of it. Economic recovery, such as it was, showed up later.
eResearch Corporation - 4 - www.eresearch.com
What you need to understand is that, between 2016 and the middle of 2018, the world’s central banks opened up the
floodgates here and poured the most amount of money into the system since the Global Financial Crisis began back in
2008.
In the chart above, you can see where the central banks panicked back in mid-2015. It didn't take long for their
combined printing to hit the highest run-rate of the entire crisis at $2.5 trillion dollars by mid-2016. They then kept the
pedal to the metal clear through mid-2018. This represents by far, the largest stimulus of the entire mis-begotten
Quantitative Easing experiment that began after the GFC -- printing up money from thin-air to jam into the financial
markets (and thus into the portfolios of the rich).
The Most Money Printing Ever.
By a huge margin. This was not even remotely in line with their public statements, which were all geared towards
soothing and placating the masses.
“The economy is robust”, they said. “Growth is on track,” they cooed.
But, behind the scenes, they were hastily, and often haphazardly, dumping the largest-ever quantity of money and
credit into the system the world had ever seen. Not unlike how a 5-year-old, fearing getting caught, pushes a pilfered
bag of chips quickly under a nearby sofa cushion.
As mentioned frequently here at Peak Prosperity, even though a painful correction was likely avoided by these efforts,
not everybody shared equally in the resulting years of continued gains:
eResearch Corporation - 5 - www.eresearch.com
In a system now as heavily financialized as ours is, the benefits of such extreme stimulus efforts accrue exponentially
to those who own and control financial assets -- those at the very tippy-top of the wealth/income distribution chain.
It is amazing to see how not only does the top 1% dramatically outpace the bottom 99%, but the top 0.1% leaves the
top 1% in the dust. Same for the top 0.01% vs the 0.1%. And the top 0.001%? They are in a stratosphere all their own.
The developed world is quickly becoming an oligarchy, and more central bank printing only exacerbates that dynamic.
The more they prop up the system with more money printing, the more Trumps, Brexits, Yellow Vest protestors, and
populist politicians we will see. Money printing is a political act of wealth redistribution from the bottom to the top. It
is unfair and socially destabilizing.
Even if they cannot yet see the true culprit here, the masses are beginning to wake up to how badly screwed they are
getting.
Until And Unless
“Until and unless,” we wrote in early 2018. We warned that "until and unless" the world’s central banks reversed
course and began printing like crazy, the vast global cesspool of over-expensive bubbly financial assets would soon
undergo a painful downwards re-pricing.
And start to fall they did; through September 2018 up through Christmas Eve. Then, as they have done so many times,
a “miracle” bottom was formed -- one that didn’t resemble a true bottom, where buyers and sellers settle in and wrestle
for a while with neither side gaining ground. What we experienced instead was a very steep “V.”
A “needle bottom” if you will; an upside-down Matterhorn:
eResearch Corporation - 6 - www.eresearch.com
What caused this violent reversal? Some immediate return of global macro conditions to amazing
awesomeness? Some new data revealing massive new sources of corporate profits?
No, none of that. It was just another $1 trillion of central bank money printing, coupled with every other conceivable
option to shove additional money and credit into the system.
In a recent interview, James Grant (of Grant's Interest Rate Observer) provided his views on the Fed and other central
banks and their role in backstopping every downwards wiggle in today's stock ““markets”” (emphasis mine)
Q: What would you do if you were at the helm of the world’s most powerful central bank?
A: I fear it might be too late but, to start with, I am in favor of interest rates which are discovered in the marketplace.
At the very short-end, interest rates ought to be pitched at a level that provides some premium to the inflation rate.
So, my first order would be to give a speech saying that we are out of the business of manipulating expectations; we
are out of the business of manipulating the stock market. The stock market is going where it wants to go, and if it goes
down a lot, so be it. That is not our line of work. We are in the business of securing a currency which holds its value
and which provides a good medium of exchange.
Q: Sounds straightforward. But how would the financial markets react?
A: They would consider it as very radical and very unhelpful. But the way forward is to somehow reinstitute the
interaction of supply and demand on Wall Street and to get the Fed out of the business of wholesale manipulation of
values. Because, today, the Fed is expected to intervene when things go badly and what this has given us is immense
distortions.
(Source)
eResearch Corporation - 7 - www.eresearch.com
The central banks are so terrified of the Franken-Markets they have created that they now intervene both directly and
indirectly, overtly and covertly, to do anything and everything necessary to prevent them from ever going down again.
James Grant thinks the Fed should get out of the business of wholesale manipulation of asset prices, and we could not
agree more. Its constant interventions and manipulations are terribly destructive on so many levels – societally,
structurally, ecologically, and politically – that it is worth an entire book to point them all out. But here we are. And the
Fed does not look like it is planning to change its behavior anytime soon.
This Better Work
Our macro-beef with all of this is that even if the Fed is “successful”, we all lose. The natural end to its current policies
is a tiny fraction of the population owning everything. Even worse than that, our planet is being despoiled by this
desperate quest for more fantasy wealth, represented by fantasy digits within the entirely human-contrived fantasy of
our financial markets.
The "immense distortions" that James Grant mentions above lead to all sorts of mal-investment that should never
happen in a rational world. As long as there is a short-term profit motive funded by endless thin-air money, there is an
incentive to harvest the last tree, fish the last tuna, drain the last aquifer. Then where will we be?
If we don’t tame our addiction to endless growth (always more, more!) then we will simply consume ourselves out of
existence, or at least to a civilization-ending conclusion.
Real wealth consists of real things. It is health. It is the safety and security of those we care about. It is access to food
and clean air and water. It is being in meaningful relationships, held lovingly in the here and now.
What we call money is a claim on wealth. But it is not real wealth in and of itself. Hopefully, we can all agree that, if
the sun blinked out for some reason, we would soon realize that money was never the thing of vast importance we
made it out to be. Similarly, if our ecosystems crash, we will learn that the pursuit of money is much less important
than we currently realize. Certainly not as important as eating. Or, if we stupidly allow the gap between the wealthy
and the poor to widen, we will soon wake up to the type of revolution that history books are full of.
The steps being taken by today's central banks are diverting us from having the conversations we really need to be
engaging in. Those in power perpetuate the repeatedly disproven idea that printing money is the same thing as
prosperity. Our future is bleaker for their actions, not brighter.
The younger generations are starting to figure this out in droves as they face the piling evidence that they are inheriting
a world burdened by debt, pollution, and serious inequality. This is something the Baby Boomers running the central
banks really ought to be noticing. Sooner or later the propping, the manipulating, the cajoling, and the distorting will
fail. When it does, the aftermath will be quite unpleasant.
Tragically, we could have avoided much of the coming reckoning if we had learned the right lessons from 2000 and
2008 and allowed the bad debts and the poorly-run large banks to simply fail. The world would have shuddered for a
brief period, but it would have then carried on from a much more sustainable baseline.
The wealth gap would be a fraction of what it currently is, and Trump almost certainly would not be president, Brexit
not on the table, and populist movements blooming like California poppies after heavy spring rains.
But we didn't learn the right lessons. And so here we are.
eResearch Corporation - 8 - www.eresearch.com
In Part 2: Why This Better Work, we look closely at just how awful the fast-deteriorating macroeconomic situation is.
It is very bad. GDP is falling in nearly every region of the globe, long-hot real estate markets have nosed-over, world
trade volumes are shrinking, industry energy consumption is in decline -- the list goes on and on.
Left to itself, the economy would enter recession in a skinny minute to flush out the many trillions of bad debt and
malinvestment that have accreted over the past decade. To prevent this from happening and to keep asset prices moving
higher -- or to even simply keep them at their current ultra-expensive levels -- the central banks will need to deploy a
truly mind-boggling amount of intervention. Will they? And will the system respond the same way it did before?
Even if it does, will the 99.9% placidly subsist on even smaller crumbs as the remaining wealth is hoovered into the
pockets of the top 0.1%?
If the answer to any of these questions is "no", none of us is fully prepared for what's coming. Buckle up.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Chris Martenson is an independent economist and author of a popular website, PeakProsperity.com. Dr. Martenson’s Crash Course video series explores the intertwining significance of the “three E’s”—the economy, energy, and environment and offers articulate, dynamic insight into the workings of the monetary system. Chris earned a PhD in neurotoxicology from Duke University, and an MBA from Cornell University. A fellow of the Post Carbon Institute, Chris’s work has appeared on PBS and been cited by the Washington Post. He is a contributor to SeekingAlpha.com. Chris is an accomplished presenter who has offered the Crash Course seminar all over the United States. The online course has been translated into several languages, and been viewed over 1.5 million times. His website (see below) offers both daily free content as well as a newsletter service for enrolled members. His goal is to help as many people understand that we are in the midst of a profound economic shift, and that equally profound risks and opportunities lie in our future. For those that can see them coming, tremendous advantages exist. www.peakprosperity.com