the following slides contain a template that illustrates ... · pdf file– *nbme written...
TRANSCRIPT
ThefollowingslidescontainatemplatethatillustratesthegeneralformatusedforaY3orY4clerkshipreview.Inthe“notes”sectionofsomeslidestherearefurtherinstructionstoclarifywhatisneededforaparticularsectionofthereview.
Thecomponentsoftherevieware:1. revisitprioractionplanandinvestigateprogress2. assesscourseobjectivesincludingessentialskills/diagnoses3. evaluateplanned/unplannedredundancy4. assesspedagogy5. evaluateassessmentofcourseobjectives6. reviewmeasuresofquality(e.g.courseevaluations)
TheDeansoftheappropriateyear,ortheiragents,willserveastheteamleaderforeachcoursereview.Theresponsibilitiesoftheteamleaderare:
1. Assigntaskstothefacultyandstudentteammembersandconveydeadlinesforwhentheworkneedstobedone.
2. Recruitmembersforthereviewteamifnecessary(typicallyteammemberswillbeassignedbytheMEC).
3. Contacttheclerkshipdirectortoarrangeameetingwiththeteamtodiscusstheclerkship;informtheclerkshipdirectorofthedatethereviewwillbepresentedattheMECmeetingsotheycanputitontheircalendar/indicateavailability.
4. CollectalltheworkcompletedbytheteammembersandcollateintoonePowerPointpresentation;collecttheactionplanfromtheclerkshipdirectorandinsertitattheendoftheslides;sendtheslidestoRachel2weeksbeforetheMECmeeting.
5. PresentthefinalrecommendationsofthesubcommitteeattheMECmeeting(lastfewslides)
ReviewofYear3OB/GYNClerkship
• ClerkshipoccursinYear3• ClerkshipDirectors
– PaulHanissianandE.RebeccaPschirrer• ClerkshipAdministrator
– LoriAvery• ClerkshipLength– 6weeks,8cycles• Sitesused
– DH,CPMC,Concord,Nashua,Hartford,CT,SVMC,Keene,Peterborough• ClerkshipwaslastreviewedinFeb2014• ReviewDate/Team:4/29/16:Dr.OgeYoung(GAME),Dr.JohnDick(MEC/GAME);
BrendaGreen(BioMedLibraries-MEC);AaronBarnesMS4(MEC);AlisonRicker(OCE)
ActionPlanfromPriorReview• EssentialSkillsandConditions
– Provideclearalternativemeanstoaccomplish,whereappropriate• Done
– Changestudentresponsibility:frommanageto“managewithassist”• Done
– Drop“Papsmear”fromskillsandadd“CervicalCancerScreening”toconditions• NotDone
• LearningSessionsandActivities– Drop“Litigation&ClinicalPractice”
• Done– PlaceWellWomanCareobjectivesinIlios
• Done– Considerre-distributionendofclerkshipactivitiestostartofclerkship
• Whenpossible,wehavedonesoandwillcontinuetodoso– Increasecontinuitywithpreceptors
• Whenpossible,wehavedonesoandwillcontinuetodoso
CourseObjectivesGeiselCourseObjective HowStudentisAssessed LearningActivity
1 Applyappropriatereproductivemedicalscienceknowledgetopatientcare.
PerformanceEvaluationsShelfExamMentorSeries
Ward/Clinic/ORMentorSeries
2 Recognizeandincorporatecurrentclinicalandtranslationalsciencesintodeliveryofobstetricandgynecologicpatientcare.
PerformanceEvaluationsPowerPoint
Ward/Clinic/ORPowerpoint
3 Describecurrentknowledgeofdiseaseprevention,riskfactormodification,substanceabuse,painmanagementinclinicalproblemsinobstetricsandgynecology.
ShelfExam Ward/Clinic/ORReading
3a Describethecurrentknowledgeofendoflifeandpalliativecareinclinicalproblemsinobstetricsandgynecology
Performanceevaluations Ward,Reading
3b Describethecurrentknowledgeofmedicalethicsandmedicallegalissuesinobstetricsandgynecology
Throughparticipationinactiveworkshop
Workshop,Reading
CourseObjectivesCourse Objective Assessment LearningActivity
4 Communicateeffectivelywithpatientsofdifferentsocial,economicandculturalbackgroundsaroundindividualandgroupfactorsthatimpactreproductivehealth.
PerformanceEvaluations Ward/Clinic/OR
5 Establishcomfortableandmutuallyrespectfulstudent-patientandstudent-familyrelationshipswithdiversepatientsandfamiliesandestablishingarespectfulbasisforthedoctor-patientrelationship.
PerformanceEvaluationsObservedHandP
Ward/clinic/ORObservedHandP
6 Interviewpatientsskillfully,includingafocusedgynecologicandobstetrichistory.
PerformanceEvaluationsObservedHandP
Ward/Clinic/OR
7 Demonstratepelvicexamskillsandsuturingskills,withappropriateattentiontocommunication,skill,cleanliness,infectioncontrol,andpatientcomfortandprivacy.
PerformanceEvaluationsObservedSurgicalSkill
Ward/Clinic/ORSuturingWorkshopPelvicWorkshop
8 Defineandprioritizethepatientacuteandchronicproblemsastheyrelatetoobstetricsandgynecologyandgeneralhealth(needfulllanguageinIlios)
9 Performandexplaintheindications,complications,andlimitations,ofobstetricandgynecologicprocedures.
PerformanceEvalObservedSurgicalSkillShelfExam
Ward/Clinic/ORLecture,Reading
CourseObjectives10 Interpretcommonabnormalitiesandfindingson
commongynecologicandobstetricdiagnostictestsandstudies,suchasultrasound,Papsmears,cervicalcancerscreening andwet-preps.
PPMShelf
Ward/Clinic/ORReading
11 Communicateeffectivelywithpatientsandfamilies. PerformanceEval Ward/Clinic
12 Demonstrateabilitytoassistpatientsinunderstandingtheirtreatmentoptionsandmotivate them tomakehealthyreproductivehealthcarechoices.
Performanceevaluations Ward/Clinic/OR
13 Communicateeffectivelyandcollegiallywithphysiciancolleaguesandothermembersofthehealth-careteamverbally,inwritingandintheelectronicmedicalrecord.
PerformanceEvalPowerPointSkillsForm
Ward/Clinic/ORCommunicationvideoCommunicationlecture
14 Behaverespectfullyandresponsiblytowardspatients,families,colleagues,andallmembersofthehealth-careteamandempathizewith andberespectfulofeachpatient
PerformanceEvalObservedHandP
Ward/Clinic/OR
15 Performprofessionalresponsibilitiesfully inallareas. PerformanceEvalDMEDsObservedHandP
Ward/Clinic/OR
16 Adheretohighethicalandmoralstandards,acceptresponsibilityforpersonalactions,acceptconstructivecriticismandrespectpatientconfidentiality.
PerformanceEvalMentorSessions
Ward/Clinic/ORPowerPoint
CourseObjectives17 Takeresponsibilityforherorhis one’sownmedicaleducation,anddevelopthehabitsofmindfulnessandreflection.
PerformanceEvalMentorSessionsCorecasesPowerpoint
Ward/Clinic/ORPowerpointMentorSessions
18 Describebarrierstoaccesstobasicreproductivehealthservicesanditseffectonvulnerablepopulations.
Performanceevaluations Ward/Clinic/OR
19 Contributeconstructivefeedbackduringpeerreview. PowerPoint PowerPoint/OR
20 Identifyandcriticallyevaluaterelevantinformationaboutevidence-based,cost-consciousstrategiesinthecareofpatientsandpopulationsandtoapplythistopatientcareandtocontinuousupdatingofskills.
Evaluations StudentPowerpointexercise
21 Assessanddiscusstheeffectoftheenvironmentonclinicalcareandoutcomesandapplytheconceptsofimprovingqualityofcare,patientsafety,andvalueofcare.
22 Identifyandutilizeappropriateresourcestosupportpatientcareandcomparetherolesofandcollaboratewithallmembersofthenurse,nursepractioner,midwifeandphysicianinter-professionalteam.
PerformanceEval Ward/Clinic/OR
23 Discusshowhealthcareiscurrentlyorganized,financed,anddelivered,andthelargerenvironmentinwhichhealthcareoccursandtheimpactonfemalepatients.
Performanceevaluation,shelfexam Lecture
24 Identifytherolesofthephysicianinaddressingthemedicalconsequencesofcommonsocialandpublichealthfactors,andtoadvocateforoptimalreproductivecareaspertainstoissuessuchasvaccinations,cervicalcancerscreening,breastcancerscreeningandothers.(notinIlios)
Shelfexam Lecture,wards,reading
CourseObjectives– Comments• Appropriatenumber,understandable• Coversover-archingGeiselcompetencies• UpdatesforIliosrequired• Minorlanguagechanges
FormatofCourse&SessionObjectives• Courseobjectivesarenotprovidedinthesyllabus– APGOobjectivelistedinstead
• Courseobjectivesarewritteninthecorrectformat• Sessionobjectivesaremostlyprovidedinthecoursematerials
andIlios– Several“Lectures”aremissingsessionobjectivesinCanvas– MedicalandSurgicalAbortionmissingobjectivesinIlios– Noinformationon“ChallengingEncounters/ReflectionRounds”
• Sessionobjectivesaremostlywritteninthecorrectformat– “Understand”shouldbechangedtoamoremeasurableverb.
HowdoY1/2coursesprepareforY3• Questionsaskedatendofclerkship– 1=poorand5=excellent
• Openended– Morepelvicexam– More“normal”obstetricsrequested
Results:Overall
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
4.5
FM MED OB PEDS PSYCH SURG GAM NEURO
13-14
14-15
15-16
Results:Communication
00.51
1.52
2.53
3.54
4.55
FM MED OB PSYCH SURG PEDS GAM NEURO
13-14
14-15
15-16
Results:PE
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
4.5
FM MED OB PED PSYCH SURG GAM NEURO
13-14
14-15
15-16
Results:MedicalKnowledge
00.51
1.52
2.53
3.54
4.55
FM MED OB PED PSYCH SURG GAM NEURO
13-14
14-15
15-16
IssuesofRedundancy• Aretheremajorissuesofredundancywithothercourses?– No
EssentialSkills
• Aretheseappropriateforthisclerkship?yes
• Wouldyouaddorsubtractany?No
• Aretheremajorissuesofredundancywithotherclerkships?No
BreastExam PerformwithSupervisionCesareansection PerformwithSupervisionContraceptionCounseling PerformwithSupervisionCounseling:BreastFeeding PerformwithSupervisionGestationalageassessment PerformwithSupervisionHPIrelevanttoclerkship PerformwithSupervisionOralpresentation,inptadmit PerformwithSupervisionOralpresentation,inptprogress PerformwithSupervisionPelvicExam PerformwithSupervisionPelvicsurgery PerformwithSupervisionUltrasoundabd/pelvis PerformwithSupervisionUltrasoundfetus PerformwithSupervisionVaginaldelivery PerformwithSupervisionVaginalsurgery PerformwithSupervisionWrittennote,inptadmit PerformwithSupervisionWrittennote,inptprogress PerformwithSupervision
EssentialProblems
• Aretheseappropriateforthisclerkship?Yes• Wouldyouaddorsubtractany?Considerthefollowing:Incontinence,dyspareunia;change
“Abortion”toDisordersofearlypregnancy/implantation• Aretheremajorissuesofredundancywithotherclerkships?No
AbnormalUterineBleeding ManagewithAssistanceAbortionDisordersofEarlyPregnancy/Implantation ManagewithAssistance
CancerScreening,Cervical ManagewithAssistance
Dysmenorrhea ManagewithAssistance
GynCancer ManagewithAssistance
Laboranddelivery,normal ManagewithAssistance
Laboranddelivery,complicated ManagewithAssistance
Menopause ManagewithAssistance
Pelvicpain ManagewithAssistance
Post-opCare Yes(SURG) ManagewithAssistance
Post-partumcare ManagewithAssistance
Prenatalcare ManagewithAssistance
Uterinedisease,benign ManagewithAssistance
Vaginitis ManagewithAssistance
Fertility add ManagewithAssistance
Urogynecologic Problems add ManagewithAssistance
ExplorationofEthicsandCulturalCompetencies
• Challengingencounters/ReflectionRounds– Facilitatedbymid-wifeandpsychologist– Non-graded– Nosettopics
CourseLearningOpportunities• Clinicalexperiences
– 5weeksatonesitewithmixofObstetrics,OutptClinic,Gynecology,NightFloatorCall
• Conferences– Orientation
• Pelvicexamcommunicationskills• Knot-tying;GTA,FetalMonitoring• Medical/SurgicalAbortion,NormalLandD,MedicalComplications
– DartmouthDay• Studentpresentations,ChallengingEncounters,UrinaryIncontinence,GynOncLectures
– WrapUp• GynAnatomy
CourseLearningOpportunities• Assignments– Onlinewoman’simagingcases(CORE)– Web-basedMicroscopyTest(PPMP)– MentorTeamTopics(4sessionscoveringcommonclinicalproblems/conditions– case-based)
• Structuredclinicalobservation(SCO)– Labor,Surgery,Outpt– 3requiredcurrently(downfrom4requiredlastyear)
Assessment• FinalGrade
– ClinicalPerformanceEvaluation - 40%• PleaseincludecopyonCANVAS
– *NBMEWrittenExam - 35%– DartmouthDay-OralPresentation 10%
• PeertoPeerFeedbackandFaculty
– MentorTeam/Chair’sTutorial 5%– Professionalism**ALLRequiredHomework 10%
• Midclerkshipfeedback– selfassess,reviewskills/conditions,assessfromfaculty
Measuresof
Quality–AAMCGQ
Geiselmean2011
Geiselmean2012
Geiselmean2013
Geiselmean2014
Geiselmean2015
Allschoolsmeans2015
CFM 3.2 3.1 2.9 3.2 3.5 3.3
MED 3.5 3.6 3.5 3.6 3.6 3.5
NEURO 3.1 3.4 2.7 3.1 3.1 3.1
OBGYN 3.1 3.0 3.0 3.1 3.2 3.2
PEDS 3.3 3.1 3.2 3.5 3.6 3.4
PSYCH 3.5 3.6 3.4 3.7 3.6 3.3
SURG 3.0 2.8 2.9 3.1 3.3 3.3
MeasuresofQuality– AAMCGQ“Ratethequalityofyoureducationalexperiencesinthefollowingclinicalclerkships.”[1=poor;2=fair;3=good;4=excellent]
Measuresof
Quality–AAMCGQ
OBGYNGeisel 2014 Geisel2015 AllSchools2015
Observedtakingrelevantportionsofpthistory? 90.5 79.5 78.9
Observed performingrelevantportionsofphysicalorMSE? 97.6 93.2 88.8
Provided withmidclerkshipfeedback? 94 95.9 92.3
MeasuresofQuality– AAMCGQ
PercentansweringYestoquestion(goalis100%)
Measuresof
Quality–AAMCGQ
OBGYNGeisel 2014 Geisel2015 AllSchools2015
Faculty providedeffectiveteaching 3.9 3.9 4.0
Residents providedeffectiveteaching 4.1 4.1 4.0
MeasuresofQuality– AAMCGQ
Scale:StronglyDisagree– 1– Neutral-3- StronglyAgree- 5
NBME“Shelf”ScorePercentiles
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
MED
SURG
OBGYN
NEURO
PSYCH
FM
MeasuresofQuality– StepIICK
*valuesdepictedareSDabovetheUS/CanmeanforGeiselmeanscores
Measuresof
Quality–AAMCGQ
Clerkships OverallSatisfactionAY2014-2015
PEDS 4.5
MED 4.5
CFM 4.5
PSYCH 4.3
OBGYN 4.2
SURG 4.2
GAM 4.2
NEURO 4.0
MeasuresofQuality– CourseEvaluation
scale[1=poor;2=fair;3=good;4=verygood;5=excellent]
scale[1=poor;2=fair;3=good;4=verygood;5=excellent]
MeasuresofQuality– CourseEvaluationObstetrics
2013-14 2014-15 2015-16*
OverallExperience 4.16 4.17 3.96
Objectiveswelldefinedandclearly presented 4.39 4.46 4.39
Ability forY1and2topreparemeforthisclerkship
n/a 2.99 3.25
Expectationswelldefinedand clear 4.17 4.18 3.95
Volumeadequate forlearning 4.43 4.37 4.37
Varietyofdxadequateforlearning 4.22 4.17 4.23
Quality ofteachingbyattendings 4.2 4.36 4.32
Qualityofteaching byresidents 4.05 4.0 3.5
SiteDirectors responsivetoconcerns 4.61 4.56 4.45
Methodsusedto evalstudentperformancemadeclear 4.18 4.13 3.89
Qualityof mid-clerkshipfeedback 3.8 3.79 3.54
MeasuresofQuality– StudentComments
Strengths:• Clerkshipisverywellorganizedwithmanystudentsmentioningclerkship
coordinatorLoriAverybynameasasignificantstrength• Manystudentshighlightedthediversityinbothpathologyandpatient
populationsacrossthevarioussites.• Facultyandinstructorswhowereengagedandprioritizedmedicalstudent
involvementandeducationwereidentifiedacrossallsitelocations.• StudentsexpressedthattheyappreciatedreturningtoDHMConthree
separateoccasionsratherthanweeklyasisthecaseonotherclerkships.• Manystudentsidentifiedthe“ChallengingEncounters/ReflectiveRounds”
sessionasextremelyvaluableandappreciatedtheopportunitytoreflectontheirexperiences.
• Studentsfoundthepelvicexaminstructional/practicesessiontobevaluableandimportant.
MeasuresofQuality– StudentComments
Weaknesses/AreasforImprovement:• Numerousstudentsidentifiedamountofrequiredpaperworktobe
burdensome.• Studentsacrossseveralsitessuggestedthatschedulesattempttobe
arrangedtoallowforlongerstretchesworkingwiththesamegroupofresidentsorattendingssoastoallowformoreconsistencyandbetterfeedback.
• AtCPMC,severalstudentsidentifiedthelargenumberofattendingsandsuggestedthatalistofthestellareducatorsandmentorsbeprovidedsoastoimprovetheoverallexperience.
• SeveralstudentsidentifiedaneedforEMRorientationatNashuasitesoastoallowforgreaterstudentinvolvementinpatientcare.
• OnestudentreportedoverhearingracistcommentsmadebynursesatHartfordsiteinadditiontopatientsreceivingverydifferentcarebaseduponinsurancestatus.
MeasuresofQuality– StudentComments
• Attempttodecreasetheamountofrequiredpaperworkordigitizesomeoftheevaluations
• Worktoarrangestudentschedulesinawaythatallowforgreaterconsistency
• ConsideradditionbriefEMRorientationatNashuasite
• Addressconcernregardingnursingbehavior/commentswithHartfordsitedirector
Recommendations• Objectives– Minormodificationstolanguageasindicated:
• 5– change“establishing”to“establish”• 10– change“PapSmear”to“cervicalcancerscreening”• 12– change“motivating”themto“motivate”them• 14– “respectful”isredundant,considerremovinglastportionofthephrase.
• 15– add“inallareas”• 17– removegenderspecificpronouns– “one’sownmedicaleducation”
• 8&24– endofstatementsarecutoffinIlios.
– AddMECapprovedLearningObjectivestoCANVASsite
Recommendations• EssentialSkills/Conditions– Change“Abortion”to“Disordersofearlypregnancy/implantation”tomorebroadlycoverthetopic
– Consideraddingthefollowing:• Fertility,Urogynecologicproblems- likeincontinence.
• ContinuetoworkwithDirectoratCPMCtofindwaystoincreasetimespentwithmorevaluededucators
• AddressEMRissueinNashuaandRNconcerninHartford• Continuetofindwaystoincreaseteam/preceptor– student
continuitywhileemphasizingtostudentsthatOBGYNisdifferentfromotherclerkshipsgiventhemultipleservicestheyareoninashort5weeks
ActionPlan
• Courseobjectives:seecorrectionsinred.• IliosCourseAdministrator- adddeletedportionsofobjectives
8and24.• MECapprovedGoalsofClerkshiphavebeenaddedtoCANVAS
(tobeeditedpendingapprovaltonight)
ActionPlan• EssentialSkills/Conditions
ü Change“Abortion”to“Disordersofearlypregnancy/implantation”tomorebroadlycoverthetopic
ü Addthefollowing:Fertility,Urogynecologicproblems.ü ContinuetoworkwithDirectoratCPMCtofindwaystoincreasetime
spentwithmorevaluededucatorsü AddressedEMRissueinNashuaü AddressedRNconcerninHartfordonexitinterviewday.ü Continuetofindwaystoincreaseteam/preceptor– studentcontinuity:
MentorTeam(s),LocalClerkshipDirector,Callschedulewithconsistentattendingorresident.Smallersitesdonothavethisissue.
ü EmphasizedtostudentsthatOBGYNisdifferentfromotherclerkshipsgiventhemultipleservicestheyareoninashort5weeks
ActionPlan
• SessionobjectivesinthecoursematerialsandIlios– MedicalandSurgicalAbortionmissingobjectivesinIlios
• WillupdatelectureinIliosandCANVAStoincludeobjectives
– Noinformationon“ChallengingEncounters/ReflectionRounds”– (Discussion/workshop)• Facilitatoraskedforemailtobesentoneweekpriortosession.
• Courseobjectivesarenotprovidedinthesyllabus– APGOobjectivelistedinstead
• OBCourseObjectivesareadded.