the framework and organization of the evaluation
DESCRIPTION
The framework and organization of the evaluation. - PowerPoint PPT PresentationTRANSCRIPT
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
The framework and organization of the evaluation
Finnish and US labor productivity of non-financial firms in 2004 euros (left); Finland’s share of the annual European Patent Office
applications (right)
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Applications at the European Patent Office, 2000–6
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Annual change of all R&D working hours done in Finland (%)
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Evolution of total R&D hours worked in Finland by sector
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Composition of R&D labor hours by workers’ educational level
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Grades of the overall performance of the NIS from 4 (fail) to 10 (excellent)
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Complexity of the national innovation system as a whole (left) and of the promotion for private innovative activity (right)
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
The expected success of the university reform in promoting its four main objectives
(deviations from a neutral position)
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
The role of SHOKs and PROs in the national innovation system(deviations from a neutral position)
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
The penetration of the National Innovation Strategy into national public education and innovation support organizations
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
The scope/broadness of innovation policy and its net gains to the society
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
The inherent tensions among the three key ministries in the education, research, innovation, and growth policy
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Attendance of the Research and Innovation Policy Council
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
97%76%88%3%
25%92%14%25%24%42%41%
76%85%88%64%74%90%78%80%80%90%96%83%42%50%78%91%58%
Prime MinisterMinister of Economic AffairsMinister of EducationMinister of Finance
Minister for Foreign Trade and Dev.Minister of Agriculture and ForestryMinister of Culture and SportMinister of DefenceMinister of LabourMinister of Social Affairs and HealthMinister of the Environment
Academy of FinlandTekesVTT, Technical Research Centre of F.SYKE, Finnish Environment InstituteUniversity: HelsinkiUniversity: Helsinki, TechnologyUniversity: JyväskyläUniversity: KuopioUniversity: OuluUniversity: TampereUniversity: TurkuPolytechnic: Central OstrobothniaEK, C. of Finnish Industries, NokiaEK, C. of F. Ind., Finnzymes OyEK, C. of F. Ind., Juvantia PharmaEK, C. of Finnish Ind., Premix OySAK, Central Org. of F. Trade Unions
Present Not present Not a member
2002 -03 -04 -05 -06 -07 -08 -09
Sectoral research in Finland by research area, budget funding (2009)
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Importance of various public actors as evaluated by other actors within the system
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Percentage of Yes answers to the overlap between different actors of the NIS
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Attitudes of the actors of the NIS regarding the impact of the University Inventions Act on facilitating collaboration
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Rankings based on the number of participants in the EU FP per million inhabitants (left) and per the gross domestic expenditures on R&D
(right)
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
The concept of a demand- and user-orientated innovation policy
Provider User(intermediate?)
Demandgenerator?
Goods and services
(Derived?)Demand User
(ultimate?)
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
A stylized illustration of the steps and interaction in innovative activity
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
The innovation system’s orientation evaluated by the actors of the system
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Share of firms engaged in innovative activity that consider the source in question as being a very important (or important) contributor to their
innovative activity
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Distribution of Finnish innovative firms by the highest type of exercised user interaction in innovative activity
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
User interaction in innovative activity and labor productivity (value added per employee)
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Correlation of the overall innovation index and globalization sub-indices regarding social (top), economic (bottom left), and political (bottom right)
aspects
Socialglobalization50 55 60 65 70 75 80 85 90 95 100
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
BE
EL
LV
LT
ATCA
CZ
HU
IENL
AU
BG HR
CYEE
ITMT
NO
PL PT
RO
SK
SIES
TR
DKFI
FR
DE
IS
IL
LU
SE
CH
UKUS
Inno
vativ
enes
s
50 55 60 65 70 75 80 85 90 95 100
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
AU
AT
BG
CA
HR
CYCZ
DK
EE
FI
FR
DE
EL HU
IS
IL
IT
LV
LTMT
NO
PL PT
RO
SK
SIES
SE
CH
TR
UKUS
Innovati
ven
ess
Economic globalization
BEIELU
NL
50 55 60 65 70 75 80 85 90 95 100
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
AU
ATBE
BG
CA
HR
CYCZ
DK
EE
FI
FR
DE
ELHU
IS IE
IL
IT
LV
LT
LU
MT
NL
NO
PLPT
RO
SK
SIES
SE
CH
TR
UKUS
Innovati
ven
ess
Political globalization
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Finland and the largest countries in terms of R&D in 2005 as % of the world total (left) as well as the 1995–2005 %-point changes (right)
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
The relationship between the relative innovative outputs (triadic patents per 1,000 of full-time-equivalent researchers)
and inputs (full-time-equivalent researchers per capita)
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Year 2005 ranking of countries according to a globalization index as well as the 1995–2005 changes in ranking
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
National VC investments versus R&D investments in 2006
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Respondents’ grades for the Finnish NIS overall (large circle) as well as for its ability to promote growth entrepreneurship and generate rapidly growing
firms (small circle)
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Shares of respondents considering tax incentives efficient in promoting growth firms in Finland
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Share of small innovative companies considering the policy measure to be important for them
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
An outline of a streamlined public enterprise support system
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Geographic origins of significant Finnish innovations
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Geographical distribution of public R&D units
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
The effect of public innovation support on regional aggregate productivity
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Respondents’ opinion on innovation policy and regional aspects
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Shares of respondents considering that universities, polytechnics, and
public research organizations (PROs) are successful in providing international first class research and research for national needs
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Shares of respondents considering that universities, polytechnics, and public research organizations (PROs) are successful in providing
experts for international and regional business activities
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
University department by size differentiating between countries and quality
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Teachers and researchers from Finland (left) and to Finland (right)
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Population-adjusted Shanghai rankings of top 500 universities relative to USA (=100)
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
Respondents view on the importance of the objectives of joint research projects between universities/polytechnics and firms (left) and the business needs
involved (right)
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
An outline of a streamlined research and education structure
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.
An outline of (public) actors and responsibilities in the Finnish NIS
Source: Veugelers, Aiginger, Breznitz, Edquist, Murray, Ottaviano, Hyytinen, Kangasharju, Ketokivi, Luukkonen, Maliranta, Maula, Okko, Rouvinen, Sotarauta, Tanayama, Toivanen, Ylä-Anttila. 28 Oct. 2009. Evaluation of the Finnish National Innovation System – Policy Report. Taloustieto Oy.