the gain-of-function deliberative process (carrie wolinetz)

Upload: national-academies-of-science-engineering-and-medicine

Post on 07-Jul-2018

219 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/19/2019 The Gain-of-Function Deliberative Process (Carrie Wolinetz)

    1/12

    Zdk Mfob-la-AubctolbJkionkrftovk Xrlckss

    Cfrrok J. ]liobktz, XdJ Fsslcoftk Jorkctlr alr Scokbck Xliocy

    Laaock la Scokbck Xliocy, BOD

  • 8/19/2019 The Gain-of-Function Deliberative Process (Carrie Wolinetz)

    2/12

    >

    Xrleltobm Milnfi Dkfitd Skcuroty

    tdrlumd Ioak Scokbcks ^kskfrcd

     F rlnust ioak scokbcks rkskfrcd kbjkfvlr os crotocfi tl prleltobm

    punioc dkfitd fbj wkii-nkobm ob iomdt la kvlivobm tdrkfts plskj nyeocrlnofi pftdlmkbs.

    • [SM supplrts f jovkrsk ioak scokbcks rkskfrcd plrtali ol

    • ^kskfrcd obvlivobm pltkbtofiiy jfbmkrlus pftdlmkbs dfvk

    obdkrkbt nolsfakty fbj nolskcuroty ros`s

    • Sfakiy rkfiozobm tdk nkbkaots la sucd rkskfrcd rkquorks kaakctovk

    pliocoks, prfctocks, fbj lvkrsomdt

  • 8/19/2019 The Gain-of-Function Deliberative Process (Carrie Wolinetz)

    3/12

    Sfakty stfbj-jlwb fbj Bftolbfi NolsfaktyStkwfrjsdop Elbtd

    Akjkrfi Kxpkrts Skcuroty Fjvoslry Xfbki

    (AKSFX) ^kplrt

    Afst-Zrfc` Fctolb Cleeottkk lb Skikct Fmkbt^kmuiftolbs (AZFC-SF^) ̂ kplrt

    Mfob-la-Aubctolb Jkionkrftovk Xrlckss

    3

    Strkbmtdkbobm Nolsfakty fbj Nolskcuroty

    ob Ioak Scokbcks ^kskfrcd

    ^kckbt ifn obcojkbts dfvk spurrkj f skroks la pliocy fctovotoksny tdk [SM foekj ft rkobalrcobm cleeotekbts tl nolsfakty,

    nolskcuroty, fbj rksplbsonik clbjuct la rkskfrcd felbm fii

    stf`kdlijkrs.

  • 8/19/2019 The Gain-of-Function Deliberative Process (Carrie Wolinetz)

    4/12

    SpkbjobmLutsojk BOD

    Spkbjobm

    ft BOD

     Fs pfrt la f rkbkwkj kepdfsos lb nolsfakty fbj nolskcuroty, tdk ros`s

    fbj nkbkaots fsslcoftkj wotd mfob-la-aubctolb (MLA) rkskfrcd frk

    nkobm cfrkaui iy rk-kxfeobkj.

    • MLA stujoks frk lbk fpprlfcd tl fjjrkssobm aubjfekbtfi scokbtoa oc

    qukstolbs.

    • MLA stujoks dfvk tdk pltkbtofi tl7

    Dkip jkaobk tdk aubjfekbtfi bfturk la dlst-pftdlmkb obtkrfctolbs

    Kbfnik fsskssekbt la tdk pfbjkeoc pltkbtofi la kekrmobm

    obakctolus fmkbts

    Obalre punioc dkfitd fbj prkpfrkjbkss kaalrts

    Aurtdkr ekjocfi clubtkrekfsurk jkvkilpekbt

    Mfob-la-Aubctolb ^kskfrcd

    :

  • 8/19/2019 The Gain-of-Function Deliberative Process (Carrie Wolinetz)

    5/12

    Ckrtfob MLA stujoks dfvk rfoskj nolsfakty fbj nolskcuroty

    clbckrbs.

    • Cluij kbmobkkrkj pftdlmkbs plsk f pfbjkeoc tdrkft oa

    tdky wkrk tl nk fccojkbtfiiy lr obtkbtolbfiiy rkikfskj arle

    f ifnlrftlry<

    • Cluij tdk obalreftolb mkbkrftkj arle ckrtfob MLA stujoksnk eosuskj tl tdrkftkb punioc dkfitd lr bftolbfi skcuro ty<

    Xliocy qukstolbs7

     –  [bjkr wdft clbjotolbs cfb tdksk stujoks nk sfakiy

    clbjuctkj<

     –  Sdluij tdos typk la rkskfrcd nk clbjuctkj ft fii<

    ;

    Clbckrbs fnlut Ckrtfob MLA

    Stujoks

  • 8/19/2019 The Gain-of-Function Deliberative Process (Carrie Wolinetz)

    6/12

    1

    MLA Jkionkrftovk Xrlckss fbj

    ^kskfrcd Aubjobm Xfusk

    Jkionkrftovk Xrlckss

    Zdk [SM fbblubckj f prlckss tl rk-kvfiuftk tdk

    pltkbtofi ros`s fbj nkbkaots fsslcoftkj wotd MLA

    rkskfrcd obvlivobm pftdlmkbs wotd pfbjkeoc pltkbtofi.

    ^kskfrcd Aubjobm Xfusk

    Jkionkrftovk prlckss os fcclepfbokj ny f pfusk ob

    aubjobm alr prlgkcts tdft efy nk rkfslbfniy

    fbtocopftkj tl mkbkrftk obaiukbzf, EK^S, lr SF^Svorusks wotd kbdfbckj pftdlmkbocoty fbj/lr

    trfbseossonoioty ob efeefis vof tdk rksporftlry rlutk.

  • 8/19/2019 The Gain-of-Function Deliberative Process (Carrie Wolinetz)

    7/12

    ^os` & Nkbkaot

     Fsskssekbts (^NF)Mrypdlb Scokbtoaoc clbjuctros` & nkbkaot fsskssekbts

    la MLA stujoks

    Bftolbfi Fcfjkeoks

    Clbvkbk punioc alrues tlmkbkrftk nrlfj joscussolb

    fbj rkckovk punioc fbj ltdkrstf`kdlijkr obput

    BSFNNSkrvks fs tdk laaocofi

    fjvoslry nljy alr prlvojobmfjvock lb lvkrsomdt la tdosfrkf la jufi usk rkskfrcd

    [SM MLA

    Xliocy

    Jkvkilpekbt

    Xrlckss

    MLA Jkionkrftovk Xrlckss

    =

  • 8/19/2019 The Gain-of-Function Deliberative Process (Carrie Wolinetz)

    8/12

    Zfs` 

    >

    Xrlvojk alrefi rkcleekbjftolbs 

    tl tdk [SM lb tdk clbckptufi 

    fpprlfcd tl tdk kvfiuftolb la  

    prlplskj MLA stujoks

      Jkiovkrfnik >

    ^kcleekbjftolbs tl tdk [SM 

    obalrekj ny tdk rksuits la  tdk 

    ros` fbj nkbkaot fsskssekbts 

    fbj ltdkr

     obput

    Zfs` 

    >

    Xrlvojk alrefi rkcleekbjftolbs 

    tl tdk [SM lb tdk clbckptufi 

    fpprlfcd tl tdk kvfiuftolb la  

    prlplskj MLA stujoks

      Jkiovkrfnik >

    ^kcleekbjftolbs tl tdk [SM 

    obalrekj ny tdk rksuits la  tdk 

    ros` fbj nkbkaot fsskssekbts 

    fbj ltdkr

     obput

    Zfs` 

    6

    Fjvosk lb tdk jksomb, 

    jkvkilpekbt, fbj clbjuct la  ros`‘

    nkbkaot fsskssekbt la  MLA stujoks

      Jkiovkrfnik 6

    Arfekwlr` alr tdk jksomb fbj 

    clbjuct la  ros` fbj nkbkaot 

    fsskssekbts 

    la  

    MLA 

    stujoks 

    Zfs` 

    6

    Fjvosk lb tdk jksomb, 

    jkvkilpekbt, fbj clbjuct la  ros`‘

    nkbkaot fsskssekbt la  MLA stujoks

      Jkiovkrfnik 6

    Arfekwlr` alr tdk jksomb fbj 

    clbjuct la  ros` fbj nkbkaot 

    fsskssekbts 

    la  

    MLA 

    stujoks 

    Zdk Cdfrmk tl tdk BSFNN

    4

  • 8/19/2019 The Gain-of-Function Deliberative Process (Carrie Wolinetz)

    9/12

    Zoekiobk la Efglr Kvkbts ob tdk MLA

    Jkionkrftovk Xrlckss

    ?

  • 8/19/2019 The Gain-of-Function Deliberative Process (Carrie Wolinetz)

    10/12

    BSFNN tl aobfiozk ots aobjobms fbj

    rkcleekbjftolbs tl tdk [SM nfskj lbstf`kdlijkr akkjnfc` fbj fjjotolbfi obputs fbj

    fbfiysos

    [SM tl clbsojkr BSFNN rkcleekbjftolbs lb fclbckptufi fpprlfcd tl tdk kvfiuftolb la

    prlplskj MLA stujoks tlwfrjs tdk jkvkilpekbt

    la bkw pliocy

    68

    Bkxt Stkps

  • 8/19/2019 The Gain-of-Function Deliberative Process (Carrie Wolinetz)

    11/12

    Stf`kdlijkr obput os crotocfi tl fb kaakctovk pliocy

    jkvkilpekbt prlckss.

    BSFNN jrfat rkcleekbjftolbs fbj ekktobm vojkl frcdovks

    fvfoifnik7 dttp7//lsp.lj.bod.mlv/laaock-noltkcdblilmy-

    fctovotoks/nolskcuroty/bsfnn

    Auturk lpplrtubotoks alr stf`kdlijkr pfrtocopftolb7

    • BSFNN ekktobm (Sprobm >861)

    • Kefoi fbytoek tl7

    Stf`kdlijkr Obput

    bsfnnHlj.bod.mlv

    66

  • 8/19/2019 The Gain-of-Function Deliberative Process (Carrie Wolinetz)

    12/12

    • BOD Laaock la Scokbck Xliocy

     – ]knsotk7 dttp7//lsp.lj.bod.mlv/

     – Nilm7 dttp7//lsp.lj.bod.mlv/ubjkr-tdk-pliosclpk

     – Zwottkr7 dttps7//twottkr.cle/cwliobktzbod

     –  Sunscronk tl tdk LSX iostskrv

    • Skbj fb kefoi tl IOSZSK^QHiost.bod.mlv

    wotd ’Sunscronk LSX\Bkws― ob tdk ekssfmk

    • Scokbck, Sfakty, Skcuroty (S3) –  dttp7//www.pdk.mlv/s3/Xfmks/jkafuit.fspx

     Fjjotolbfi ^kslurcks

    6>