the growing demand - pj solomon
TRANSCRIPT
THE GROWING DEMAND FOR OUTDOOR RECREATION & SPORTING GOODS
by Patrick FurlongDirector, Consumer Retail
Peter Diamond Vice President, Consumer Retail
MARCH 2021
with contributions by David Shiffman, Cathy Leonhardt and Jeff Derman
20
+ 6% sporting goods & hobby stores
RETAIL SALES
+ 18% total sporting goods
CONSUMPTION
+ 65% total sporting goods
ECOMMERCE
2020 GROWTH
2OUTDOOR RECREATION & SPORTING GOODS
20 was an exceptional year of transformation for the Sporting Goods &
Outdoor Recreation (SGOR) category. As the effects of COVID-19 disrupted
the U.S. economy, leading states to enact stay-at-home orders and companies
to adopt work-from-home (WFM) policies, the category flourished, with
considerable increases in both new consumer entrants and spend. As we
look to 2021 and beyond, we believe the category is primed to benefit from a
large-scale shift in consumer behavior in a post-pandemic world. This shifting
trend will drive a step-function change in participation and corresponding
spend, setting the category on a renewed long-term trajectory of growth.
As we enter 2021, the U.S. SGOR category generates approximately $220
billion in consumer spend, of which 55% (approximately $120 billion) consists
of athletic apparel and footwear with the balance comprised of durable
sporting equipment and gear. This market expanded significantly in 2020, with
60%+ of industry participants anticipating continued growth in 2021.1
In this letter, we will review how emerging trends and a ‘new normal’ in consumer
behavior could converge with longer term tailwinds to set the category on a renewed
long-term trajectory of growth. We will also contemplate the impact this could
have on M&A and why the category is likely in the early innings of consolidation.
1 Mckinsey, Euromonitor and PJ SOLOMON estimates.
EXPECTED % INCREASE IN PARTICIPATION IN 2021 VS PRE-COVID-19
86%
72% 69%
44% 40%
36%
27% 23%
21% 17%
7%
3OUTDOOR RECREATION & SPORTING GOODS
The SGOR user demographic is expansive and has continued to evolve, with
the majority of new consumers now younger, more ethnically diverse and more
gender proportional than ever before. Historically a highly resilient category,
SGOR has demonstrated consistent growth in both spend and participation
since the Great Recession. In fact, since 2000, SGOR spend has outpaced GDP
growth and delivered positive year-over-year performance in 18 of the 20 years
measured (2008 and 2009 were the only exceptions). This consistency can be
attributed to the category’s alignment with numerous secular trends, including:
• Renewed focus on health and wellness, driven in part by
heightened rates of obesity and diabetes and rising healthcare
costs leading to an increase in consumption of SGOR product
• Behavioral shifts, such as commuters choosing to walk
or cycle to work over public transportation
• Personal Fitness, with pre-pandemic popularity of boutique fitness giving
way to at-home workouts utilizing home equipment and digital content
• Continued growth in the athleisure category as consumers opt to wear
sports and athletic-inspired clothing for a wider range of occasions
• Increased demand for sustainable products with recycled materials
accounting for 20% of activewear styles in 2020, double the level in 2019
• Digital and online taking center stage as consumers integrate digital
solutions / apps / tools into their fitness routines and major manufacturers and
retailers shift their business models toward DTC / eCommerce shopping
• Reconnection with the outdoors in response to the fatigue of constantly
being “plugged-in” in an increasingly digital and virtual world – and further
accelerated by the stress of WFH
Data over the last 10 years demonstrates consistent growth in less densely populated, more outdoor friendly areas of the country. Anecdotal data indicates an acceleration of these trends through lifestyle changes brought about by the pandemic.
THE FASTEST- AND SLOWEST-GROWING METROPOLITAN AREAS IN THE US
4OUTDOOR RECREATION & SPORTING GOODS
2020 TRENDS OBSERVED - USHERING IN A ‘NEW NORMAL’
The global response to the COVID-19 pandemic, including mass shutdowns and work-
from-home mandates, led to a broad shift in consumer behavior, reversing the course
of many established secular trends defining the past 20+ years. While anticipated
widespread availability of a vaccine by 2H 2021 should lead to a partial return to
certain pre-COVID behavior, it is likely that some degree of recent trend changes are
here to stay.
1. REVERSE URBANIZATION DRIVING GROWTH IN SGOR CONSUMPTION
As the consumer has embraced the concept of WFH, the need to live near one’s
employer has diminished, leading to an accelerated suburbanization trend projected
over the next 3 to 5 years. In data published by North American Van Lines and
Allied Van lines, two of the largest moving companies in the U.S., migration patterns
indicate that movement out of population centers (LA, Chicago, NYC) to less densely
populated states such as Florida, Texas and Idaho has accelerated in recent months.
As large numbers of Americans migrate out of denser and higher cost
of living urban locations and into more affordable, suburban areas, we
are witnessing a strong increase in SGOR consumption.
This correlation makes sense on several levels. First, residential and suburban
communities are closer in proximity to many outdoor recreational facilities – golf
courses, parks, public grounds for fishing and hunting, etc. – removing significant
barriers to entry. There is also more infrastructure to facilitate individual and
Metropolitan areas with fewer than 300,000 residents are
excluded from the map. Source: Vivid Maps.
--
2.0%
4.0%
6.0%
8.0%
10.0%
12.0%
14.0%
16.0%
18.0%
20.0%
0.50%
0.55%
0.60%
0.65%
0.70%
2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020
Wallet Share (LHS) Sporting Equipment Consumption Growth (RHS)
SPORTING EQUIPMENT CONSUMPTION GROWTH & WALLET SHARE
5OUTDOOR RECREATION & SPORTING GOODS
team sports activities at lower cost to the consumer compared with dense urban
areas where scarce infrastructure limits supply and drives participation cost
higher. Second, a comparatively lower cost-of-living and a lower density service
industry (bars, restaurants, entertainment) frees up discretionary income. This
combined with more favorable dynamics around access and cost leads to
increased participation and allocation of dollars (covered in greater detail in the
next section). Lastly, deurbanization has a higher correlation with automobile
and recreational vehicle (RV, marine, powersports) ownership which further
supports participation in outdoor activities (camping, hiking, watersports, etc.).
2. RE-ALLOCATION OF DISCRETIONARY SPEND
TOWARD ‘THINGS’ VS. ‘SERVICE EXPERIENCES’
The pandemic has had a profound impact on consumer purchasing behavior,
particularly in non-staple, discretionary spend. Analysts estimate that pandemic-
induced reduction in spend on service-related experiences (e.g. travel, restaurants,
and other in-person entertainment) freed up as much as $500 billion in consumer
discretionary dollars in 2020. While a successful vaccination rollout will likely lead to
some re-balancing, it’s unlikely to fully revert to pre-pandemic levels. As the consumer
becomes accustomed to a more socially distant environment and lingering health
concerns persist, demand for many experiential service categories (travel, concert and
movie theater attendance, for example) may lag. This suggests the pendulum shift
from spending toward ‘things’ from ‘service experiences’ may be a longer-term trend.
One area benefiting from this rotation is the SGOR category. While sporting
equipment consumption had been gaining steady share of wallet over the past
decade (growing 50bps between 2010 and 2019), it took off in 2020, with share
of wallet growing 100bps YoY with the underlying category growing 18% YoY.
142%
66%
122%
(20%)
20%
60%
100%
140%
180%
Mar-20 May-20 Jul-20 Sep-20 Nov-20 Jan-21 Mar-21
Sporting Goods & Equipment S&P 500 Athletic Apparel / Footwear
+56%
+76%
SPORTING GOODS AND ATHLETIC APPAREL SHARE PRICE PERFORMANCE
6OUTDOOR RECREATION & SPORTING GOODS
These trends are reflected in the stock price performance of individual public
companies in the SGOR sector. While the category was not immune to sharp
share price drawdowns at the onset of the COVID-19 spike, it has had an immense
rebound, with the median company outperforming the S&P 500 by 76% in 2020.
3. DEMAND FOR SOLITARY LEISURE DRIVING OUTDOOR
PARTICIPATION AND CATEGORY ADOPTION
As we reflect on the impact of COVID-19 in the U.S., investors remain focused
on two primary questions: How much of the growth in 2020 was attributable to
consumers pulling forward a future purchase – a new bicycle, a new set of golf
clubs or fishing rod, a new powered vehicle – and how much was attributable to
new category entrants and an “increase in the size of the pie.” Analysts estimate
that as many at 265 million Americans – 80% of the U.S. population – participated
in outdoor recreational activities during the height of the pandemic with 87 million
– approximately one-third – doing so for the first time. Preliminary data suggests that
half of outdoor recreationalists believe the events of 2020 will change their outdoor
behavior long into the future, presenting a case where up to 45 million new consumers
will anniversary first-time 2020 participation (and spend) in 2021 and beyond.
Similarly, we see a preference for self-reliance as a particularly interesting driving
force behind SGOR consumption. Take the recreational vehicle category for
example. Following strong demand in 2020, wholesale unit shipments are expected
to grow 17% to 502,000 units in 2021, the second highest level on record. A
significant portion of this growth is driven by consumers “trading away” from
traditional travel – hotel stays, cruises, rentals – in favor of outdoor experiences.
~45m incremental long-term participants
331m Americans
265m outdoor participants
87m new outdoor participants
80% of Americans participated in outdoor activities during the pandemic
33% of whom were doing so for the first time
RE-ENGAGEMENT WITH THE GREAT OUTDOORS
52% of outdoor recreationalists believe the events of 2020 will change their outdoor behavior long into the future
+ 8% 2.7m additional participants
GOLF
+ 22% 6.8m additional participants
TENNIS
+ 16% 8.1m additional participants
HIKING
+ 9% 3.4m additional participants
FRESHWATER FISHING
+ 28% 7.9m additional participants
CAMPING
2020 INCREASES IN PARTICIPATION2
2 Source: Outdoor Industry Association and SGB Media
7OUTDOOR RECREATION & SPORTING GOODS
SPORTING GOODS ECOMMERCE SALES AND PENETRATION
PJ SOLOMON estimates that SGOR ecommerce sales grew approximately 65% in 2020, with penetration surpassing 32% of overall sporting good sales.
13.0%
118.0%
64.0% 54.0%
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
SPORTING GOODS ECOMMERCE YoY % CHANGE
$8.0 $9.5 $11.9
$14.0 $13.9
$17.2 $19.3
$31.8
13.4% 15.0% 17.1% 19.8% 18.5% 23.3% 23.3%
32.5%
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020E
+65%
8OUTDOOR RECREATION & SPORTING GOODS
4. EMERGENCE OF ECOMMERCE, DIRECT-TO-CONSUMER
AND LIFESTYLE BRANDS
With stay-at-home orders sheltering people in place at the onset of the COVID-19
pandemic, consumers increasingly turned towards eCommerce, with some
43% who had not previously shopped online doing so for the first time. The
pandemic rapidly shifted even the most digitally-averse consumers towards
shopping online, with online penetration increasing 600-1,000 basis points
in most categories and retailers such as Hibbett, DICK’s and Academy all
experiencing comparable eCommerce sales growth in excess of 90%.
As these consumers continued to seek out new products online, they often
focused their attention and wallets towards a re-emerging class of technical-
focused, niche enthusiast brands. Hunting and fishing brands such as Marolina,
KUIU and First Lite and cycling brands such as ASSOS and Rapha experienced
rapid growth in 2020 as new and existing users alike increased purchases. While
these “super fan” brands address a smaller market segment, their enthusiast
consumers spend higher amounts and more frequently, often at low customer
acquisition cost and at higher lifetime values. Beyond apparel, lifestyle hard
goods brands such as YETI, Fox Factory and Thule continue to see growth, as
consumers stock up on premium-grade products as part of their new-found outdoor
lifestyles. Unlike prior generations of niche-focused gear manufacturers, these
hardlines lifestyle brands have developed broader-based appeal while still staying
true to their cult-like following and without sacrificing technical capabilities.
5. BURGEONING M&A ACTIVITY
After experiencing a near moratorium on M&A activity in the first six months of 2020,
appetite for acquisitions in the SGOR category exploded in the second half of the
year and into the first quarter of 2021. We believe the SGOR category is likely to
(Amount in Billions)Source: US Census Bureau and PJ SOLOMON Estimates.
01
4
16
7
Q12020
Q22020
Q32020
Q42020
Q12021
2020-21 M&A ACTIVITY & QUARTERLY VOLUME
M&A activity in the sporting goods and outdoor recreation category screeched to a halt in the early months of COVID-19 but rapidly accelerated in the second half of the year with no signs of letting up in 2021
9OUTDOOR RECREATION & SPORTING GOODS
witness continued outsized M&A volume and strategic activity through the remainder
of 2021 and beyond. The confluence of tailwinds, including continued focus on
health and wellness, positive macroeconomic trends as we exit the uncertainty of
2020 and an increased focus on solitary leisure and re-engagement with outdoor
activities, should drive growth in both industry participation and spend over the
next 12-24+ months, which in turn will continue to attract interest from institutional
and strategic acquirers. Further, the SGOR industry remains highly fragmented with
many of the industry consolidators (both strategics and portfolio companies of
financial sponsors) benefiting from improved operational performance, increased
liquidity, healthier financing markets, and a mandate to pursue non-organic growth.
CONCLUSION
As we look to 2021 and beyond, we remain excited about the possibilities for growth
in the sector and the potential for significant strategic activity, including increased
M&A. For founders and investors alike, it’s an opportune time to think about how to
best take advantage of this potentially lucrative – and incredibly fun – category.
This communication is solely provided for information purposes, is intended for your benefit and your internal use
only and does not constitute an invitation, solicitation, advice, recommendation or offer to subscribe for or purchase
any of the products or services mentioned herein. This communication does not constitute investment research
(as it is not a substantive analysis) or a research recommendation. Nothing in this material constitutes investment,
tax, legal, accounting or other advice, or a representation that any investment or strategy is suitable or appropriate
to your individual circumstances. The information provided is not intended to provide a sufficient basis on which to
make an investment decision. It is intended only to provide observations and views of individual investment banking
personnel, which may be different from, or inconsistent with, the observations and views of other members of
PJ SOLOMON and the firm as a whole. Information and opinions presented in this communication have
been obtained or derived from sources believed by PJ SOLOMON to be reliable, but PJ SOLOMON makes no
representation as to their accuracy, adequacy or completeness. PJ SOLOMON is under no obligation to update,
modify or amend the information herein provided or to otherwise notify you that any information contained herein
has changed or subsequently become inaccurate. PJ SOLOMON and its affiliates expressly disclaim any liability for
loss and/or damage from the use of any material or information contained in this communication. Any discussions
of past performance should not be taken as an indication of future results and no representation, expressed or
implied, is made regarding future results.
ABOUT PJ SOLOMON
Founded in 1989, PJ SOLOMON is a leading financial advisory firm with a legacy as one of the first independent investment banks. We
advise clients on mergers, acquisitions, divestitures, restructurings, recapitalizations, capital markets solutions and activism defense
across a range of industries. We offer unmatched industry knowledge in the sectors we cover, providing comprehensive strategic
solutions, tailored to generate long-term shareholder value.
Today, PJ SOLOMON is an independently run affiliate of Natixis, part of Groupe BPCE. Our partnership provides our clients access to
strategic advisory services and proprietary financing capabilities throughout Europe, the Middle East, Asia Pacific and the Americas.
For further information, please visit pjsolomon.com.
PATRICK FURLONG
DIRECTOR
CONSUMER RETAIL
AUTHORS
SENIOR CONTRIBUTORS
PETER DIAMOND
VICE PRESIDENT
CONSUMER RETAIL
CATHY LEONHARDT Managing Director Co-Head of Consumer Retail Group
DAVID A. SHIFFMANManaging Director Co-Head of Consumer Retail Group
JEFF DERMANManaging Director Consumer Retail Group