the history of chemical weapons - dsb | direktoratet for ...€¦ · lockwood, j. six-legged...
TRANSCRIPT
1
The History of
Chemical Weapons: Uses and Efforts to
ContainGuy Valente, Programme Officer, Assistance and Protection Branch
Technical Secretariat
24 April, 2019
Oslo, Norway
22
Objective
Build familiarity with the genesis
of chemical weapons (CW) and
of the international efforts to
contain the threat posed by CW.
33
Ancient CW
China
• 1000 B.C.
• ‘Poison bombs’
• Noxious substances mixed with explosives.
• Contained: excrement, insects, poisonous plant resins, arsenic.
44
Ancient CW
Dura-Europos
(modern Syria)
• 256 B.C.
• Greek, Parthinian, Roman border area.
• Siege defense/Tunnel denial
• Combustion of tar and sulfur
55
Ancient CW
Mithradates VI of Pontus
• 73-63 B.C.
• ‘Poisoner King’
• Arrows dipped in snake venom.
• Hallucinogen contaminated honey.
Ottoman viperRhododendron
66
Ancient CW
Siege of Kirrha
(Greece)
• First Sacred
War
• 6th Century B.C.
• Hellebore root Amphictyonic League of
Delphi vs. city of Kirrha.
Diarrhea left city
inhabitants incapacited
and unable to fight.
77
Ancient CW
China (cont.)
• 4th Century B.C.
• Siege defense.
• Pumping arsenical
smoke into tunnels
dug by invaders
88
Ancient CW
Scorpion Bombs of
Hatra
(Modern Iraq)
• 198 A.D. and
today
• Imperial Roman
Legion and ISIL
• Likely false, but
so what?
99
Ancient CW (Naval)
China (cont.)
• 1141
• Tear gas in naval combat.
• Large firecrackers (paper explosives) filled with lime and sulfur.
• Irritant smoke affecting the eyes
1010
Ancient CW (Naval)
Battle of Sandwich
• 1217
• Quick-lime (Calcium
oxide) in fine powder.
• English ships moved
upwind and
released.
• French crews
blinded.
1111
Pre-modern CW
Siege of Groningen
(Netherlands)
• 1672
• Christoph Bernhard van Galen, the Bishop of Munster
• Belladonna alkyloidspacked within explosives
• Led to the first international agreement on CW
121212
First International Agreement
Banning the Use of CW(Two Parties: France + Holy Roman Empire)
Strasbourg Agreement
(August 27 1675)
Banned the use of “perfidious and odius” toxic devices
131313
(15 Parties: All European)
Brussels Conference of 1874
(July 27-August 27)International agreement concerning the laws and
customs of war submitted to the conference by the
Russian Government. Prohibited “employment of poison
or poisoned weapons, and the use of arms, projectiles or
material to cause unnecessary suffering.”
Accepted by the Conference, but not
ratified by all parties . . . Non-binding
141414
Hague Conventions
(1899-1907)
Contracting parties to the 1899 Hague Conventions
declared their agreement to abstain from the 'use of
projectiles, the sole object of which is the diffusion of
asphyxiating or deleterious gases'.
Additional series of conventions was
planned for 1914 but did not occur.
Why?
1515
World War I
• 1914 Small scale
attacks with tear gas
• First large scale CW
attack with chlorine on
22 April 1915 at Ieper
(Belgium) – 5000
dead, 15000
casualties.
1
5
World War I, 1915Gas attack, Western Front (World War I)
1616
World War I• Choking agents
chlorine and phosgene
gases initially released
from cylinders on the
battlefield and
dispersed by the wind
– many friendly fire
casualties.
• Later in the war
chemical shells and
mortars introduced
• .
1
6
1717
CW in World War I: Not enough bats
1
7
Professor Fritz
Haber (Germany)
1868 – 1934
• Natural source of nitrate
• Imported from Brazil
• Naval blockade forced
research of new options
• Cl2
• CG
1818
World War I
1
8
Soldiers on 10 April 1918 in France,
blinded from exposure to mustard gas
July 1917
blister agent
Mustard gas
first used
By end of war
90000 fatalities
and 1.3 million
casualties due
to CW
Over 100 000
tones of CW
used
191919
Geneva Protocol
(1925)
…Prohibition of the Use of Asphyxiating, Poisonous or
Other Gases, and Bacteriological Methods of Warfare.
Member States could still use CW
against non-Member States.
Only covers use.
2020
Post WWI – Nerve Agents
Dr. Gerhard Shrader (1903-1990)
• Developing pesticides for Bayer.
• Discovered workers suffering blindness and weakness over time.
• Developed first ‘G’ agent (Tabun, GA) and reported it to MoD.
• MoD puts Shrader and colleagues on full time CW development.
Insecticide research. Germany, 1930s
2121
Post WWI – Nerve Agents
Dr. Gerhard Shrader (1903-
1990) cont.
• Sarin (GB) is developed by
1938
• Shrader, Ambros, Ridiger, van
der LINde
2222
WWII – Nerve Agents
Drs. Kuhn and Henkel
• 1944 Soman (GD) developed
• ‘GC’ was not used as a designation to avoid confusing with CG (phosgene)
• 1945 Red Army captured almost all German labs
2323
2
3
World War II
• Why no CW were used on the
battlefield?
Geneva Protocol prohibition
Public opinion
Risk of retaliation in kind
Lack of effective protection
Unpredictable behaviour of agents
Misleading intelligence
2424
Post WWII – Nerve Agents
Preamble to Cold War
• 1947 – USA, UK and Canada form ‘Tripartite Treaty’ to combat USSR CW development.
• Drs. Ghosh and Newman (UK), working in pharmaceuticals, discover ‘Amitom’, later refined as VX
2525
Cold War1947 – 1989 (or ???)
• The United States and the Soviet Union both maintained
enormous stockpiles of chemical weapons, primarily nerve
agents, amounting to tens of thousands of tons
• The amount of chemical weapons held by these two
countries was enough to destroy much of the human and
animal life on Earth
2626
Cold WarUSA USSR/RF
2727
Iran – Iraq War (1980-1988)
• Iraq used chemical
weapons in Iran during
the war in the 1980s
• Around 100,000
Iranian soldiers and
civilians were affected
by Iraqi chemical
weapons during the
1980-88 war with Iraq
2828
Post Iran – Iraq War (1988)
• Iraq used
mustard and
nerve agents
against Kurdish
residents of
Halabja, in
Northern Iraq, in
1988 resulting
in ~5000
deaths
2929
Chemical Terrorism - Japan (1994-1995)
• GB used by Aum
Shinrikyo Cult
Matsumoto : 27 June 1994•carried out the world's first use of
chemical weapons in a terrorist attack
against civilians
•released sarin in this central Japanese city
•killed 8 and injured >200
Tokyo : 20 March 1995 attack on subway in 1995
12 dead ~5000 injured
3030
CWC Enters into force
29 April 1997
(next presentation)
3131
3
1
CW use in the Syrian Arab Republic
• “The OPCW- United Nations joint mission collected convincing evidence that chemical weapons were used in the Ghouta area of Damascus on 21 August 2013”
• The report did not specify whether the government or opposition groups were responsible for the alleged attacks, which happened between March and August 2013.
• Repeat of allegations in May 2014 – followed by establishment of the OPCW Fact Finding Mission.
• Ongoing allegations and counter-allegations (Government and Armed Opposition Groups (AOGs) since then. Work of the FFM continues to this day.
3232
Conclusion• Chemicals have long been viewed as a counter to kinetic
defense methods
• Throughout history, agents and delivery methods have
adapted to meet needs (Siege, siege-defense, ships, lack of
nitrate, psychological effect, etc.)
• CW has always been problematic (indiscriminate, weather
dependent, messy, denies area to advance)
• Efforts to ban CW use are many, but have traditionally
lacked universality and left open the possibility of residual
threat.
• Into late 20th century, near global consensus for a treaty
banning not only ‘use’, but development, stockpiling etc.
3333
Acknowledgements
Thucydides History of the Peloponnesian War, Trans. Crawley, Richard (Hertfordshire, 1997)
James, Peter and Thorpe, Nick Ancient Inventions (London, 1994)
Volkman, E. Science Goes to War (New York, 2002)
Mayor, A. Greek Fire, Poison Arrows, and Scorpion Bombs: Biological & Chemical Warfare in the Ancient
World (Overlook, 2008)
Lockwood, J. Six-legged Soldiers: Using Insects as Weapons of War (Oxford 2009)
Clarke, Robin (1968), We all Fall Down: The Prospect of Biological and Chemical Warfare (London: Allen
Lane; The Penguin Press).
Hersh, Seymour M. (1968), Chemical and Biological Weapons: America's Hidden Arsenal (Indianapolis:
The Bobbs-Merrill Company).
International Encyclopaedia of Law: Intergovernmental Organisations