the housing finance corporation: non deal-specific ... · group 2016 results and 2017 budget thfc...
TRANSCRIPT
THFC
1
The Housing Finance
Corporation:
Non deal-specific
Investor Update September 2016
THFC THFC
Legal Disclaimer
For the purposes of the following disclaimer, references to this presentation shall mean these
presentation slides and shall be deemed to include references to any related speeches made by or
to be made by the management of The Housing Finance Corporation Limited (THFC), any questions
and answers in relation thereto and any other related verbal or written communications.
This presentation may only be communicated or caused to be communicated in the United Kingdom
to persons who have professional experience in matters relating to investments falling within Article
19(5) of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (Finance Promotion) Order 2005 (the “Order”)
or high net worth entities who fall within Article 49(2) (a) to (d) of the Order (all such persons being
referred to as “relevant persons”). Any investment or investment activity to which this presentation
relates is available only to relevant persons and will be engaged only with relevant persons.
This presentation is being directed at you solely in your capacity as a relevant person (as defined
above) for your information and may not be reproduced, redistributed or passed on to any other
person or published, in whole or in part, for any purpose, without the prior written consent of THFC.
The information in this document is subject to change without notice, its accuracy is not guaranteed,
and it may be incomplete and is condensed.
These presentation slides may contain certain statements, statistics and projections that are or may
be forward-looking. The accuracy and completeness of all such statements, is not warranted or
guaranteed. By their nature, forward-looking statements involve risk and uncertainty because they
relate to events and depend on circumstances that may occur in the future. Although THFC believes
that the expectations reflected in such statements are reasonable, no assurance can be given that
such expectations will prove to be correct. There are a number of factors which could cause actual
results and developments to differ materially from those expressed or implied by such forward-
looking statements.
2
THFC
THFC Group is:
• A group of mutual finance vehicles whose sole
purpose is lending on minimum prescribed,
secured, terms to UK registered Housing
Associations.
• No THFC Vehicle undertakes maturity
transformation, nor interest or currency risk.
• Each vehicle acts as a credit principal and is
governed by a trust deed.
• All cash-flows are siloed. There is no inter-
dependence between borrowers in one vehicle, nor
between THFC vehicles.
• Each vehicle is designed as a look-through to the
underlying loans made.
• THFC Group is not regulated, but circa 50% of the
Group loans (AHF) are fully guaranteed by the
Department for Communities and Local
Government (DCLG) and both the HCA and NHF
have been shareholders since inception in 1987.
3
THFC
THFC Investor Relations
• Feedback from Investment Association
to HAs on the quality of disclosure
• Made us think about how we represent
the different vehicle portfolios within the
THFC stable:
• Active:
• AHF PLC
• THFC Ltd
• Historic
• THFC (Indexed )1 Ltd
• THFC (Indexed) 2 Ltd
• THFC (Social Housing Finance) Ltd
4
THFC Five Year Financial Record
£000’s 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
Total Revenues 3,285 4,195 8,316 8,344 8,422
Total Costs 2,047 2,341 3,662 3,201 4,301
Surplus after tax 1,007 1,410 3,572 4,062 3,289
Group Accum. Reserves
11,583 12,993 16,565 20,627 23,916
Group Loans Outstanding
2,882m 3,124m 3,368m 4,155m 5,087m
THFC Limited Reserves
7,575 8,861 12,248 14,238 14,986
5
THFC Group 2016 results and 2017 budget
2016
Actual
£000’s
2017
Budget
£000’s
Total Revenues 8,422 10,021
Total Costs (4,301) (4,197)
Surplus after tax 3,289 4,659
Accum. Reserves 23,916 28,575
Loans
Outstanding
5,087m
5,565m
• New AHF lending volumes
exceeded budget in 2016 by
£163m despite inevitable delays
causes by the July 2015
Government Budget.
• 2017 revenues once again driven
by AHF bond/EIB arrangement
fees and associated growth in
annual fees.
• 2016 costs impacted principally
by further pension provision for
future deficit contributions
6
THFC
THFC Limited – portfolio data
7
THFC
Bond Rating (S&P) Outstanding £k Index Constituent
Funding No.1 A 235,205 iBoxx
Funding No.2 A 370,850 iBoxx
Funding No.3 A 625,300 iBoxx
THFC Ltd Loan Portfolio as at 30 June 2016
THFC Ltd Rated Issuance
-
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500
3,000
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
Outstanding Loan Balance £m (RH Scale)
Number of borrowers
Number of Loans
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
Top 5 exposures as a % of loan book
Top 10 exposures as a % of loan book
Top 20 exposures as a % of loan book8
THFC Exposure balances by HA Group 30 Jun 16
THFC — Top 10 exposures
Borrower (Group) Rating Current
Balance
1 Southern G15 A1 145,482
2 A2Dominion G15 A+ 135,221
3 Network G15 - 130,617
4 Family Mosaic G15 A1 92,927
5 Home A 65,467
6 Paradigm 65,000
7 Hyde G15 AA- 62,648
8 Genesis G15 Baa1 56,500
9 Thames Valley 54,111
10 Westcountry 47,000
0
20,000
40,000
60,000
80,000
100,000
120,000
140,000
160,000£
00
0's
Individual HA Group Loan Balances
9
THFC
East Midlands Total 4%
East of England Total 2%
London Total 35%
National Total 6% North East Total
1%
North West Total 6%
Northern Ireland Total
6%
Scotland Total 5%
South East Total 9%
South West Total 7%
Wales Total 8%
West Midlands Total 6%
Yorkshire and the Humber Total
5%
Geographical Portfolio Spread by Current Balance
10
THFC
0
200,000
400,000
600,000
800,000
1,000,000
1,200,000
1,400,000
1,600,000
1,800,000
To
tal L
oa
n B
ala
nce
s '0
00
's)
Percentage Cover MV-ST
Strong Over-Collateralisation THFC - Fixed Charge Asset Cover
30 Jun 16
THFC has an additional
security covenant:
Net annual Income from
Security must always cover
Interest payable on the loan
11
THFC Asset Cover History
• Significant new business written between 2009 and 2013 with asset cover
between 150% and 200%
• Withdrawal threshold at 200% delivers improved over-collateralisation over
the long term
• Significantly more conservative compared to own-name bond issues where
115% MVT cover is the norm
Quarter End THFC Group THFC Only
% %
31/03/2016 233 216
31/03/2015 226 209
31/03/2014 228 211
31/03/2013 233 215
31/03/2012 244 221
31/03/2011 254 237
31/03/2010 296 275
31/03/2009 318 306
31/03/2008 294 293
12
THFC
Loans funded by bonds issued by THFC (Funding No 1) plc, THFC (Funding No
2) plc and THFC (Funding No 3) plc have bespoke liquidity resources and a two
year grace period between legal final and expected final maturity dates.
• THFC (Funding No 1) plc (the Issuer) has the benefit of access to a liquidity facility
provided by RBS
• Sized at 2 years’ of interest (£24.1million supporting £235.2million of debt)
• Following downgrade of RBS (short term rating) the facility has been drawn in full and held in
cash
• Can be utilised to cover any cash flow shortfall at the Issuer level (i.e. not just in the event of
non-payment by an underlying borrower)
• THFC (Funding No 2) plc and THFC (Funding No 3) plc
• Underlying loans to individual borrowers have a requirement for an interest service reserve
equal to one year of interest
• Can be used by THFC to service its loan to Funding No 2 or Funding No 3 in the event of non-
payment of interest by an underlying borrower under the terms of specific loan agreement
• Total interest service reserves of £56million supporting £996.15million of debt
• Loans funded by Debenture Stocks and bank loans have no bespoke liquidity
resources. Liquidity to cover cash-flow shortfalls while enforcing security in
relation to the defaulted loan would be limited to THFC’s cash reserves and
any bespoke facilities negotiated.
Liquidity Resources in Stress Scenario
(underlying borrower default)
13
THFC THFC Ltd Annual Cashflow with No
Liquidity Risk Mitigation - Top 20 as at 30
June 2016
0
1,000
2,000
3,000
4,000
5,000
6,000
Unmitigated Cash Flow 14
THFC
0
20,000
40,000
60,000
80,000
100,000
120,000
140,000
160,000
180,000
200,000
2016 2019 2023 2025 2027
Nom
ina
l (£
00
0's
)
Bullet repayment debt maturity profile –
debenture stocks
15
THFC 11.5% Debenture Stock maturity 2016
• Next key maturity is October/November 2016 when £156.5m of
debenture stock matures
• Spread across 38 borrower groups
• Immediately available liquidity (THFC Ltd. cash reserves plus
undrawn RCF) £23.5m
0
2,000
4,000
6,000
8,000
10,000
12,000
14,000
16,000
18,000
20,000
Nom
inal (£
000's
)
16
THFC
11.5% Debenture Stock – exposures over £5mill
Borrower/
group
Nominal
amount
(000s)
Credit
Grade
Fixed charge
Asset cover (at
June 2016)
External
Rating/s
Places for People 19,500 3A 288% A+/A3
L&Q 16,000 2A 659% AA-/A1
Radian 10,500 2B 281% -/A1
Family Mosaic 10,100 1B 644% -/A1
ASRA Housing Group 7,250 3A 286% -/-
Black Country* 7,000 2A 229% -/-
Genesis 6,000 3A 377% -/Baa1
* Floating charge security with fixed charges also. Estimated MVT asset cover.
All 11.50% debenture stock borrowers reviewed and none gives any grounds
for concern.
17
THFC Debenture Stock maturity 2023
• After 2016 the next key maturity is October/November 2023 when
£189m of debenture stock matures
• Spread across 46 borrower groups
0
2,000
4,000
6,000
8,000
10,000
12,000
14,000
16,000
18,000
Nom
inal (£
000's
)
18
THFC
AHF summary
19
THFC THFC/AHF Business Volumes
-
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900
1,000
2009/10 2010/11 2011/12 2012/13 2013/14 2014/15 2015/16 2016/17
£m
THFC EIB THFC Bond AHF EIB AHF Bond AHF Budgeted EIB AHF Bugeted Bond
‘AHF budgeted’ includes pipeline applications
20
THFC AHF – the most successful
Government Guarantee programme
• Loans signed and drawn £1.913Bn
• Loans signed but undrawn £0.298Bn
• 54 Borrower Groups to date (average loan size
larger than THFC)
• Progressing through credit and/or documentation
£0.391Bn
• Estimated Portfolio Total £2.602Bn - funded by
EIB facilities and long term bond issues
21
THFC Success of the Affordable Homes
Guarantee Scheme
22
0
200
400
600
800
1,000
1,200
1,400
1,600
1,800
2,000
0.00%
0.50%
1.00%
1.50%
2.00%
2.50%
3.00%
3.50%
4.00%
£ m
illio
ns
AHF - priced fixed rate debt - cumulative amount and rates
AHF EIB FIXED - Amount priced (RHS)AHF BONDS - Amount priced (RHS)AHF BOND - all-in rateAHF EIB FIXED - all-in rateAHF FIXED - All-in RateAHF FIXED - saving achieved
THFC 2016/17 Business themes
• AHF bond and EIB issuance likely
to continue to calendar year end
• AHF second bond series likely to
approach £1Bbn. Application made
for repo eligibility with Bank of
England
• Further EIB activity much less likely
in wake of BREXIT
• Considering some THFC issuance
• Tempered risk appetite while
Government policy intentions
become clearer
• Opportunity to consolidate rapid
growth in portfolio
23
THFC
Sector Outlook
24
THFC
Could rebalancing of policy post BREXIT
represent an opportunity for HAs?
25
THFC Components of GDP
26
THFC From ‘Home Ownership trumps all’ to
‘domestic growth by any means’
• ONS reclassification
• Dec 2015 Spending Review focusses £4.1Bn grant programme
for shared ownership (back-loaded to 2020)
• Introduces LHA cap for HB payments in social housing by 2018
• March 2016 Welfare Reform and Work Act introduces 4x1%
Annual rent cuts for HAs
• Deregulation package designed to reverse ONS decision in
England
• Voluntary RTB (not much impact to date)
• HIST and LA high value asset sales (also not much impact)
• Introduces (but doesn’t switch on) Housing Administration
• 2016 Autumn Financial
Statement:
• Measures for domestic growth:
• Wider tenure mix
• Acceleration of grant?
• Guarantees Mk 2? 27
THFC English Housing Starts
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
110
120
130
140
150
160
170
180
190
200
210
220
230
240
1978 1980 1982 1984 1986 1988 1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014
Ho
me
Sta
rts
Tho
usa
nd
s Annual Housing Starts
Private Enterprise
Housing Associations
Local Authorities
AllDwellings
Government annualised target
“On the subject of housing, the British are experts. Most people either own one or want to. And demand usually
grows by 200,000 units per year; each year only about 150,000 are built. Steadily rising house prices are the result of
this mismatch”. FT Lex 23 August 2016
HA starts don’t
Reflect all S106
28
THFC What does Deregulation Mean?
• 30 October 2015: ONS reclassifies
English RPs as Public Non-Financial
Corporations, listing:
• Control over disposals of housing
assets
• Direction over use of disposal
proceeds
• Powers over disposal of housing
stock following de-registration
• Powers over voluntary winding up of
RPs
• Power to appoint managers and
officers to an RP
NB not rent setting!
• Extended term of Chair to March 2018
Outcome of HCA Review imminent:
• Leading to a fully independent regulator?
29
THFC Markets & Competition
• Short term uncertainties around rent-cuts/policy
drove a s/t shift to private transactions
• Shorter term bank financing embeds more refinance
risk (selective opportunities for THFC?)
• Post BREXIT, HAs viewed by institutional investors
as a defensive investment
• In the short term, many developing HAs have been
strongly cash-generative
• Continued QE means HAs viewed as a value added
investment (witness demand for PfP unsecured)
• AHF has been the competition!
30
THFC Housing Association source of
new funding by financial year:
£Bn Source: HCA 8/16
Sector Snapshot at
June 2016:
£80.8Bn facilities
£66.3Bn drawn
£20.7Bn drawn capital
markets debt
Flows Stock
Source: HCA Quarterly Survey of Providers 6/16
And THFC data
31
THFC Markets & Competition
Minimum Spread
differential
now:0.67% from
average 0.71%
32
THFC HA Public Bond Issues Since May 2014
33
Term Spread Cost Moodys
(Years) over Gilts of funds BCA
AHF 208,000,000 AA/- May-14 28 0.37% 3.76%
Town and Country 80,000,000 A+/- Jul-14 31 1.35% 4.67%
Boston Mayflower 150,000,000 A+/- Sep-14 45 1.30% 4.30%
A2Dominion 150,000,000 -/-/AA- Sep-14 12 4.50%
Cross Keys 150,000,000 A+/- Sep-14 31 1.20% 4.30%
Walsall 250,000,000 -/A2 Oct-14 31 1.25% 4.28% baa1
Guinness 100,000,000 -/A1 Oct-14 30 1.30% 4.00% a3
Yorkshire 200,000,000 -/A2 Oct-14 30 1.35% 4.23% baa1
AHF 198,500,000 AA/- Oct-14 28 0.38% 3.30%
Wheatley 300,000,000 A+/- Nov-14 30 1.60% 4.40%
Herefordshire 120,000,000 -A2 Nov-14 35 1.38% 4.19% baa1
Riverside 250,000,000 -/Aa3 Nov-14 28 1.35% 4.00% A2
Paragon 250,000,000 -/A2 Jan-15 32 1.40% 3.63% A2
Richmond Housing Partnership 175,000,000 AA-/- Jan-15 30 avg life 1.17% 3.30%
Swan 250,000,000 A+/- Feb-15 33 1.30% 3.63%
AHF 194,000,000 AA/- Mar-15 27 0.32% 2.92%
Orbit 250,000,000 -/A1 Mar-15 30 1.15% 3.61% a3
GB Social Housing 16,800,000 A-/- Mar-15 24 2.00% 3.88%
AHF 208,000,000 AA/- Aug-15 28 0.40% 2.89%
Metropolitan 250,000,000 A+/- Sep-15 30 1.67% 4.20%
London & Quadrant 250,000,000 AA-/A1 Oct-15 34 1.35% 3.84% a3
AHF 194,000,000 AA/- Mar-16 28 0.43% 2.71%
London & Quadrant 300,000,000 AA-/A1 Mar-16 10 1.07% 2.63% a3
AHF 130,500,000 AA/- May-16 28 0.35% 2.62%
AHF 191,400,000 AA/- Aug-16 27 0.41% 1.99%
PfP Homes UNSECURED 400,000,000 A+/A3 Aug-16 10 2.25% 2.90% baa2
Rating Date
Issued
Nominal
Amount (£)
THFC Sector Risk – Key Areas of Impact
Rent cuts imposed in 7/15 budget have highlighted “political
risk”, impacted operating margins, but driven the search for
efficiencies.
Income risks from Universal Credit have been deferred due to
delayed roll-out, although “creeping” effect of benefit cuts.
Development risk 1 – move from S106 to in-house
development tests development competence. Potential
complication from the starter homes initiative.
Development risk 2 – build for affordable home ownership and
potential repetition of the problems seen in 2007/8/9.
Development risk 3 – build for sale exposes sector to new
risks, and cash-flow volatility.
Merger risks 34
THFC Sector Risk - recent experience
In the last 12 months, THFC/AHF has undertaken detailed due
diligence on more than 25 (English) associations. These analyses
have evidenced:
A willingness and ability to cut costs, from anything between 5%
and 10% of operating expenses (exc. depreciation).
Most associations have either reduced or maintained pre-budget
forecast development volumes. A small number of associations
have forecasted increased development.
In all cases, the additional developed units more than offset the
budget rent cut impact on income but at the expense of leverage.
A significant shift in tenure-mix, mostly towards shared-ownership,
but also outright sale to a lesser degree.
Bank lender covenants generally present no constraint. 35
THFC Sector Risk - Stress Tests
As part of our credit due diligence, we sight borrower’s stress testing
models, and sometimes request specific additional scenarios. Typical
stresses include:
An assumed extension of the 4 year rent cuts, or CPI flat in
perpetuity.
Interest rate increases well above OBR forecasts.
A “welfare reform” stress that sees bad debts/voids etc. double.
A house price fall of 20%-30% across the entire sales programme.
A sales delay, of typically 12 months above plan.
The usual outcome of stress testing is:
Little covenant stress in the first 5 years (often longer).
Funding usually adequate for at least 2-3 years.
Significant ability to curtail development expenditure.
Fall-back position of fixed asset sales, and/or converting sales units
to rental tenure.
KEY FEATURE – TIME TO ACT/MITIGATE.
36
THFC Conclusion
• THFC continues to deliver good earnings growth
• By end of financial 2016/17 (Sovereign guaranteed)
AHF portfolio will represent c 47% of Group loan
portfolio, driving significant sustainable growth in
Group operating income.
• Post BREXIT the policy environment for HAs possibly
more favourable. May present opportunities for
further guaranteed business.
• But heightened development risks for HAs.
• Continuing desire to shorten maturities by banks itself
presents an opportunity for selective growth.
• Institutional investment appetite positive in the wake
of more QE.
37
THFC
Questions
38
THFC
Appendix
39
THFC
40
The Housing Finance Corporation Limited (“THFC”)
Housing
Association
Housing
Association
Housing
Association
Housing
Association
Housing
Association
Housing
Association
Housing
Association
Housing
Association
Housing
Association
Housing
Association
Housing
Association
Housing
Association
THFC Funding No.2 PLC
(“THFC2”)
(Issuer Rating A+)
THFC Funding No.1 PLC
(“THFC 1”)
(Issuer Rating AA-)
THFC Funding No.3 PLC
(“THFC 3”)
(Issuer Rating A+)
Trustee/s in relation to
THFC
Debentures and Private
Placements
EIB and
other Banks
The Housing Finance Corporation
Limited — Structure Overview
Security — floating charge over THFC’s assets (secured loans)
All secured creditors are pari passu
Relationship between secured creditors regulated by Deed of Priority
Security – first fixed charges over specific residential properties
(or, initially, over cash)
£191m A+ (issued July 2009)
£72.25m A+ (tap March 2010)
£76.6m A+ (tap Jan 2011)
£31m A+ (tap March 2011)
£100m A+ (issued Oct 2011)
£131m A+ (issued Jan 2012)
£130.5m A+ (issued Apr
2012)
£67.6m AA- (issued Dec 2004)
£32m AA- (tap Dec 2006)
£37m AA- (tap March 2007)
£33m AA- (tap Dec 2007)
£80m AA- (tap Aug 2008)
Public stocks
11.50% stock due 2016
8.625% stock due 2023
9.625% stock due 2027
Plus PPs
Issued Bonds Issued Bonds Issued Bonds Issued Bonds Loans
THFC THFC Group Structure
T.H.F.C.
(Indexed)
Limited
T.H.F.C.
(Indexed 2)
Limited
T.H.F.C. (Services) Limited
T.H.F.C. (First
Variable)
Limited
T.H.F.C. (Social
Housing Finance)
Limited
T.H.F.C.
(Capital) Plc
UK Rents (Holdings)
Limited
UK Rents
(No.1) Plc
UK Rents
Trustee Limited
The Housing Finance Corporation Limited
Affordable Housing
Finance PLC
Principal debt
issuing entities
THFC THFC Management
Chief Executive
Piers Williamson
Credit and Risk
Director
David Stokes
Finance Director and
Company Secretary
Colin Burke
• Relationship Management
• Security Portfolio
Management
• Treasury and Portfolio
Management
Group Treasurer
Fenella Edge
Executive
Assistant
• Accounting and Finance
• Managed Companies –
Monitoring and
Reporting
• Company Secretarial
• Borrower risk
assessment
•Risk appetite
• Risk framework
•Credit grading models
42
THFC
Ian Peacock * Non Executive Chairman
Investment and merchant banker. Retiring Chair of
Family Mosaic Housing Group
Appointed 2013
Will Perry Assistant Director of Regulatory Strategy & Performance
HCA
Appointed 2014
Gill Payne * Director of Policy and External Affairs
National Housing Federation
Appointed 2014
Keith Exford
CBE
Chief Executive
Affinity Sutton Housing Group, Chair G15 (Large London
Housing Associations Group)
Appointed 2011
John Parker * Chartered Accountant, Vice Chairman Newbury Building
Society, former building society Chief Executive and
Chairman Building Societies Association
Appointed 2010
Deborah
Shackleton
CBE *
Former Chief Executive Riverside Housing Group,
Governor Liverpool John Moores University, Board
Member NHS Sefton
Appointed 2011
Charlie
Arbuthnot **
Ex-investment banker: Warburgs, Hambros & RBC
Capital Markets. Now housing consultant
Appointed 2008
* Member of THFC Credit Committee
** Chair of THFC Credit Committee
THFC Non Executive Board Members
43
THFC
THFC’s S&P Rating was lowered one ‘notch’ to A
Stable following the UK Sovereign downgrade in July
2016.
Prior to this, THFC’s rating had remained unchanged
at A+/Stable/A-1 since first obtained in 2004
Now classified as a Finance Company along with other companies
whose primary focus is lending to the public sector or lending to
government-supported borrowers
Rating potentially includes one notch ‘Government Related Entity’
uplift from SACP
Strengths Relatively strong franchise value
Strong support from the UK Government, which underpins borrower
creditworthiness
Robust collateralisation of loan book
Match-funded approach minimizes asset-liability risk
Weaknesses Modest liquid financial resources and low capital levels
Exposure to single sector, with borrower-concentration risk
Potential for conflicts of interest could arise from board composition and
responsibilities
Vulnerable to operational risk stemming from small staff numbers and key
personnel risk
THFC: Standard & Poor’s Rating
Major Rating Factors
44