the ingenieur vol 47 sept 2010
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/28/2019 The Ingenieur Vol 47 Sept 2010
1/33
Green Township Policy Initiatives
Landscape : The Economic Value
Innovations in Energy Efcient &
Exergy Efcient Designs
PahangSelangor Raw Water
Transer Project
propertydevelopment
-
7/28/2019 The Ingenieur Vol 47 Sept 2010
2/33
BUYERS LAB
2009 PICK
Canon Inc.
imagePROGRAF
iPF755
-
7/28/2019 The Ingenieur Vol 47 Sept 2010
3/33
-
7/28/2019 The Ingenieur Vol 47 Sept 2010
4/33
-
7/28/2019 The Ingenieur Vol 47 Sept 2010
5/33
c o n t e n t s
4 Presidents Message
Editors Note
6 Announcement
COVER FEATURE
7 Green Tonship Policy Initiatives
15 Landscape: The Economic Value
20 Liveable and Sustainable
Housing Development
RESEARCH & DEVELOPMENT
26 Innovations in Energy Ecient &
Exergy Ecient Designs
ENGINEERING & LAw
Contingent Payment 32
The Continuing Saga
FEATURE
Integrated water Resources 36
Management in Malaysia
FEATURE
Pahang Selangor 42
Ra water Transer Project
ENGINEERING FEATURES
An Old Faithul Bridge in Sg 54
Lembing, Pahang
ex-mining ton
ENGINEERING NOSTALGIA
Kajang Ton in 1960s 55
v o l 4 7 S e p t - n o v 2 0 1 0
Cover photo courtesy o Mr. Zainal Arifn Baseri
rom Perbadanan Putrajaya
-
7/28/2019 The Ingenieur Vol 47 Sept 2010
6/33
KDN PP11720/04/2011(029445)ISSN 0128-4347
MEMBERS OF THE BOARD OF ENGINEERS MALAYSIA
(BEM) 2009/2010
PresidentYBhg. DatoSri Ir. Dr. Judin Abdul Karim
SecretaryIr. Ruslan Abdul Aziz
RegistrarIr. Hizamul-Din Ab. Rahman
MembersYBhg Tan Sri Pro. Ir. Dr. Mohd Zulkii bin Tan Sri Mohd GhazaliYBhg DatoIr. Hj. Ahmad Husaini bin SulaimanYBhg. DatoIr. Abdul Rashid MaidinYBhg. DatoIr. Dr. Johari bin BasriYBhg. Datuk Dr. Ir. Abdul Rahim Hj. HashimYBhg. DatoPro. Ir. Dr. Chuah Hean TeikYBhg. Brig. Jen. DatoPahlaan Ir. Abdul Nasser bin AhmadYBhg. Datuk Ar. Dr. Amer Hamzah Mohd YunusIr. Mohd Rousdin bin HassanIr. John AnthonyIr. wong Siu HiengPro. Ir. Ishak Abdul Rahman
Ir. Tan Yean ChinIr. Chong Pick EngIr. DatoDr. Lee Teang ShuiDatoJaaar bin Shahidan
EDITORIAL BOARD
AdvisorYBhg. DatoSri Ir. Dr. Judin Abdul Karim
SecretaryIr. Ruslan Abdul Aziz
ChairmanYBhg. DatoIr. Abdul Rashid bin Maidin
EditorIr. Fong Tian Yong
MembersPro. Ir. Dr. K.S. KannanIr. Chan Boon TeikIr. Prem KumarIr. Ishak Abdul RahmanMr Zamani bin ZakariahIr. Mohd Rasid bin OsmanIr. Dr. Zuhairi Abdul HamidIr. Ali Askar bin Sher Mohamad
Executive DirectorIr. Ashari Mohd Yakub
Publication OfcerPn Nik Kamaliah Nik Abdul Rahman
Assistant Publication OfcerPn Che Asiah Mohamad Ali
Design and ProductionInoreach Communications Sdn Bhd
Printer
Art Printing works Sdn Bhd29 Jalan Riong, 59100 Kuala Lumpur
The Ingenieur is published by the Board o Engineers Malaysia(Lembaga Jurutera Malaysia) and is distributed ree o charge toregistered Proessional Engineers.
The statements and opinions expressed in this publication arethose o the riters.
BEM invites all registered engineers to contribute articles orsend their vies and comments to the olloing address:
Communication & IT Dept.Lembaga Jurutera Malaysia,
Tingkat 17, Ibu Pejabat JKR,Jalan Sultan Salahuddin,50580 Kuala Lumpur.
Tel: 03-2698 0590 Fax: 03-2692 5017E-mail: [email protected]; [email protected]: http://.bem.org.my
AdvertisingAdvertisement Form is on page 56
P r e s i d e n t s m e s s a g e
Property development remains one o the key driving orcesin generating domestic demand and growth o the economy.Te property sectors contribution to economic growth alsohas a multiplying eect as it involves a signicant number odownstream sub-sectors players ranging rom proessionals,contractors, material suppliers, transporters to tradesmen.
arly, any contraction in the property development will have cascading adversein the engineering circle.
roperty development in Malaysia has matured to some extent. Te industry is nor satised with providing shelter or human habitation. Developers are marketingproperties on innovative designs, green technologies, eco -riendly environment,y architecture and interior decoration, energy ecient xtures and acilities, andrsal design that caters to Disabled Persons and the elderly. Many o these requireand imagination rom engineers. It is imperative that engineers keep up with the
and technologies to stay relevant in the shiing market.Te unolding New Economic Model, 10th Malaysia Plan and Greater Kuala
pur Plan have again placed emphasis on property development. While thertunity may sound promising or local engineers, I wish to remind them o thertance o proessionalism in discharging their duties and responsibilities. Public
ption and image o local engineers will have a bearing on their standing inty. Tis will be even more signicant when the ser vice sector is liberalized withinSEAN region by 2012.
Sri Ir. Dr Judin bin Abdul Karimdentd o Engineers Malaysia
e d i t o r s n o t e
Te property industry seems to respond well to theGovernments National Green echnology Policy with moredevelopers launching green townships and eco -parks. Consumerstoo include Green echnology as one o the items on theirchecklists or premium housing scheme.
Details on policy and good practices towards greents in property development are well narrated in the article on Green ownshipy Initiatives in Malaysia. Te essence o landscaping or property development is
er described in Landscaping in Property Development by a landscape architect.aper on R&D Innovations in Energy Eciency & Energy Ecient Designsghts two viable energy ecient technologies that have market potential in this
t eld.In the engineering eature section, the photos highlight an old wooden bridgengai Lembing, Pahang, an ex-mining town that is still servicing villagers on botho the river.Readers are encouraged to contribute engineering eature photos that are unique
nteresting.
y reading!
ng ian Yongr
-
7/28/2019 The Ingenieur Vol 47 Sept 2010
7/33
F e a t U r e Con t I nU e d t H e I n G e n I e U r v o l 4 7 S e p t e m B e r - n o v e m B e r 2 0 1 0a n n o U n c e m e n t s
Correction
Igiu v 46, Ju-Augus 2010
Gaiig A Gba Fh
W pl h yp p 14 whh h saJ
Hl s Bh pu 16 ml w
pl Jh. th u hul b 1600 ml.
BEM FACEBOOKThe Board o Engineers Malaysia has launched itsocial acebook. Ho to nd us on Facebook?
Simple. Just visit http://.bem.org.my ; ClickFind us on Facebook (right pane o BEM eb site).
You may also sign in to .acebook.com andsearch or Board o Engineers Malaysia.
Pindaan Skala Gaji Perunding Di Lampiran H Dalam Manual Perolehan
Perkhidmatan Perunding Edisi 2006
Mulai 1 Ogos 2010, Pekeliling LJM No. 2/1992 bertajuk BEM/MOF Dialogue Update On SomeAspects O Remuneration For Engineering Consultancy Services For Government Projectsadalah dibatalkan.
Skala Gaji Perunding hendaklah menggunapakai Surat Arahan Perbendaharaan bilangan S/K.KEw/PK/P/1100/000000/165/23 JLD 6 SK 2(2) bertarikh 15 April 2010 bertajuk Pindaan SkalaGaji Perunding Di Lampiran H Dalam Manual Perolehan Perkhidmatan Perunding Edisi 2006.
Sila layari laman eb LJM di http://.bem.org.my/v3/circulars_link.html untuk PindaanSkala Gaji Perunding Di Lampiran H Dalam Manual Perolehan Perkhidmatan Perunding Edisi
2006.
2011 RENEWAL NOTICE [Proessional Engineers, Accredited Checkers, Temporary Engineers,Engineering Consultancy Practice (ECP)]
Due Date or 2011 Renewal o Registration: 31st January 2011* Expiry Date or 2010 Registration: 31st December 2010 *
Engineering Consultancy Practice (ECP)
The 2011 Reneal Form and Notice are currently available in BEM eb site.
To donload the notice and orm, please visit: http://.bem.org.my/v3/donloads.html
(or http://.bem.org.my | menu Nes & Event - click BC, MDP, SP, PN - 2011 RENEwALNOTICE)
c o v e r F e a t U r e
Te concept o environmentalsustainability was rst brought to
widespread public attention in 1972embodied in the book Te Limits toGrowth. Te report basically concludedthat the growth o the human population,
and an increase in prosperity, wouldcause an ecological collapse within 50
years. Tis was ollowed by the BruntlandReport in 1987 and the Rio Declarationin 1992 which had spurred strategiesor action towards achieving sustainabledevelopment and consequential initiativesin sustainable communities, greendevelopment and green cities to adaptto environmental degradation, climatechange and a carbon constrained uture.
Green TownshipPolicy Initiatives
Malaysia continuously supports initiatives in implementing
sustainable urban development strategies including green
growth and green urbanism. Initiatives towards developing
green townships in Malaysia in related policies have
been ormulated at various levels o development plans
including planning guidelines that support green urbanism.
Development plans in Malaysia have long recognized the need
or green strategy by way o conservation, promoting green
networks in urban neighbourhoods, promoting walkability
and sustainable public transport. Currently, this has been
value-added by design dimensions related to energy eciency
towards a low carbon society. The role o the community is
instrumental in supporting green cities initiatives.
By Dr Dahlia Rosly and Nor Zaliza
Mohd Puzi,
Research and Development Division
Federal Department of Town and
Country Planning, Peninsular Malaysia(This paper was published in Habitat
Magazine, Second Edition 2010,
Ministry of Housing and Local
Government)
GREEN AND HE SUSAINABLECIIES AGENDA
Cities are actively making changes to becomemore sustainable, oen aiming to promotedevelopment that is contained within itsecological carrying capacity, a development
which is socially just and economicallyinclusive. Te concept o sustainabledevelopment was consequently extendedinto green development, synonymous togreen urbanism. Green urbanism presentsundamental opportunities to shape citiesto be more sustainable, bringing aboutmajor liestyle changes such as walking,cycling and reduction o consumptioncommunities, with provisions to boostrenewable energy, energy eciency and
-
7/28/2019 The Ingenieur Vol 47 Sept 2010
8/33
t H e I n G e n I e U r v o l 4 7 S e p t e m B e r - n o v e m B e r 2 0 1 0
Tey emphasize a high quality o lieand the creation o highly liveableneighbourhoods and communities.
From these criteria, a Green townshipcan be conceived as an integrated
planned habitat that gives emphasisto the protection, use and recycling onatural resources, besides promoting
public health, saety and general welareo urban people. Key characteristicso uture Green Cities is that they are
waste ree, transport ecient withwidely available public transportation,walkable and cycle-riendly, whollyenergy independent with minimal carbonoutput including reduction o ossil-uel
use, adopt sustainable building practices,promote green space and parks aslungs o the cities and clean air quality,implement energy-ecient initiativesand develop well-organized mixed-useneighbourhoods that combine living,
working and shopping.
Instrumental to green urbanism is thecommunity network and cohesion,green consciousness and commitment.Te neighbourhood as a basic modulein developing green cities becomesthe ront line to incorporate eortsin designs and activities to reducegreenhouse gas emissions while meetinga host o other community goals. As thequality o peoples homes is infuencedby the spaces around them, there is anincreasing recognition that well-designed,
well-managed green spaces by and inbetween housing are crucial to makingneighbourhoods liveable, and contributeto peoples quality o lie. Green elementssuch as the network o green spaces and
corridors, tree-lined streets, signicantprivate landscaping (including greenroos) or even small scal e local communityagriculture are examples o good greenapplications. Tus, buildings in theneighbourhood are oen green withexcellent environmental perormance;area-wide green inrastructure is common
place, rom low-impact storm watermanagement to district energy systems.Most important in planning a green
neighbourhood is creating the vision,giving policy directions and guidelinesthat describe all aspects necessary o a
green neighbourhood towards achievingits set o goals. Making a commitment toneighbourhood designs that will supporta low-emission liestyle or all residents,
would involve the widest possible rangeo stakeholders and community supportto set up and maintain internal systemsto ensure continued improvementsand renements as the plan is beingimplemented.
POLICIES RELAED OHE PLANNING OF GREENOWNSHIPS IN MALAYSIA
Te Malaysian Government has beencontinually promoting environmentalstewardship in all development
plans. Since the 8th Malaysia Plan(2001-2005), the incorporation oenvironmental consideration into
planning and development has beenintensied. Consequently, the sustainableuse o energy has been identied in
the 9th Malaysia Plan, highlightingstrategies or using energy ecientlythrough the promotion o greater use orenewable energy or power generationby industries and intensiying energyecient initiatives in the industrial,transport and commercial sectors as wellas applications in Government buildings.Te 10th Malaysia Plan reinorces and
places urther emphasis on the use orenewable energy and on increasing
energy eciency. Various measures suchas relevant guidelines, standards and laws
would be introduced to ensure ecient
use o energy and to reduce greenhousegas emission.
In tandem with the Malaysia Plans andother national policies, the Ministryo Housing and Local Governmento Malaysia through its Departmento own and Country Planning, hadtranslated these into spatial orm throughthe National Physical Plan (NPP) and theNational Urbanisation Policy (NUP).
National Physical Plan (NPPFirst approved by the National PhysicalPlanning Council in 2005, the goal othe National Physical Plan (NPP) isto establish an ecient, equitable andsustainable national spatial rameworkto guide the overall development o thecountry towards achieving developednation status by 2020. Te NPP is preparedin accordance with the provisions o theown and Country Planning Act 1976(Act 172). Selected policies supportingthe green urbanism concept and initiatives
are summarized as ollows:
ransit oriented development(OD2) concept as the basis o urbanland use planning to ensure viabilityo public transport, supportedby walkways linkages to promoteconnectivity and to reduce emissions
Urban settlements to be serviced byan integrated network o solid-waste
c o v e r F e a t U r e Cont I nU e d
environmental restoration. Among eaturesare high-perormance green buildings(extended spatially into high-perormancegreen townships) with investments in
public transport and other sustainabletransport measures, and research into newtechnologies. Indeed, it is the cities thathold the greatest hope or achieving a moresustainable uture o our planet. By 2030,over 60% o the worlds population (4.9billion out o 8.1 billion people) will livein cities. (UN-Habitat 2001). Tus anyeective agenda to reduce the impacts oclimate change and other environmentalchallenges must necessarily include cities asa key element.
Tough there are many earlier historicreerences to the garden city, theimplementation o green elementin modern physical planning can betraced to Sir Ebenezer Howard in 1898through his concept o the garden city.Tese were well-planned, sel-contained,communities surrounded by green belts,containing careully balanced areas oresidences, agriculture and industries.
With environmental issues on theoreront, development is increasinglyocusing on green elements to directlyor indirectly reduce green house gases
(GHG). Tus, the garden city concept hasbeen expanded and enhanced to resolveenvironmental challenges as well. In its
wider interpretation, green developmenthas been described as a land use planningconcept that includes considerationo community-wide implications odevelopment, as well as site-specic greenbuilding concepts1. Tis involves city
planning and environmental planning,urban design, architecture and community
building. Sustainable neighbourhoodswould then become the basic module ingreen urban planning, orming green citiesand green regions.
CHARACERISICS OFGREEN CIIES AND GREEN
NEIGHBOURHOODS
Beatley, . (2000), described cities thatexempliy green urbanism, characterizedas ollows:
Tey strive to live their ecologicallimits, undamentally reducetheir ecological ootprints, andacknowledge their connection withand impacts on other cities and
communities and the larger planet; Tey are designed or and unction in
ways analogous to nature; Tey strive to achieve a circular
rather than a linear metabolism,which matures and develops positivesymbiotic relationships with andbetween its hinterland (whether
that be regional, national, orinternational); Tey strive towards local and
regional sel-suciency and takeull advantage o nurturing local/regional ood production, economy,
power production, and many otheractivities that sustain and supporttheir population;
Tey acilitate (and encourage) moresustainable, healthul liestyles; and
Green elements such as the network o green
spaces and corridors, tree-lined streets,
signifcant private landscaping or even
small scale local community agriculture are
examples o good green applications.
1source : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ Green_development 2ransit oriented development is a development that clusters around a transit station in order to support public transportusage through optimum threshold and ridership.
Green urbanism presents undamental opportunities to shape cities to be more sustainable
Green space and parks are lungs o the cities...
-
7/28/2019 The Ingenieur Vol 47 Sept 2010
9/33
t H e I n G e n I e U r v o l 4 7 S e p t e m B e r - n o v e m B e r 2 0 1 0
green township implementation.Among these are:
PlanningGuidelinesforOpenSpaceandRecreationFacilities
Tis guideline rst prepared in 1997had aimed to guide local authorities anddevelopers to provide adequate openspaces at various levels o hierarchies,locations, sizes and acilities. It alsohighlights the requirement to provide aminimum o 10% o usable open spacesor all types o developments. Tisguideline is being reviewed by the FederalDepartment o own and CountryPlanning.
Planning Guideline for Roof TopGardensWith rising concerns to reduce carbonootprint, the green roo becomes anadaptation measure in a changing climate.Te Federal Department o ownand Country Planning has draed thePlanning Guidelines or Roo op Gardenin 1997 and is currently being reviewedand updated. Originally conceived as parto the open space planning in the urbanareas to ully utilize idle spaces, rooopsare now providing opportunities not onlyin beautication but in energy saving,insulation and air quality improvementand or reducing the eects o urban heatisland. Tere are successul examples oroo top gardens in shopping malls. Tesegardens adopt recycling technologies suchas chilled water irrigation sourced romthe shopping centres air conditioningsystem to grow temperate plants and arainwater harvesting system or generalirrigation. As an example, plants can begrown on a soil-mix based on granulated
horticultural carbon.
e Circular om the Secretary-General, Ministry of Housing andLocal Government on Rain WaterHarvestingSystem,1999(SPAH)
Forward looking, the Cabinet had, in1998, instructed the Ministry o Housingand Local Government to promote theuse o rainwater. Tis was prior to theormulation o the Policy on Climatein Malaysia. Subsequently, the Ministry
o Housing and Local Government hadproduced a Circular in 1999 to instruct
local authorities to install a Rain WaterHarvesting System (SPAH, SistemPenuaian Air Hujan) in buildings.A success story in implementingthe rainwater harvesting system, theMunicipality o Sandakan, Sabah, hadimposed a planning requirement indevelopment applications to provide arainwater storage tanks or new residentialbuilding commencing June 2001. Eachtank is able to store maximum o 400gallons o rainwater. Further guidelineshad been prepared to support this circular.
RESEARCH INIIAIVES
Low Carbon City ResearchGreen Urbanism being the current buzz-
word had rendered numerous interestsrom various Government Ministries,Institutes o Higher Learning and LocalAuthorities into various research aspectsand pilot projects. Te Federal o ownand Country Planning Department
(FCPD) had identied the Low CarbonCity concept as one o its researchinitiatives since the 9th Malaysia Plan andhad produced related guidelines includingone on Sustainable ransportation inLanduse Development in 2007.In a wider context, FCPD is currentlycollaborating with a research team romKyoto University Japan and Universityechnology o Malaysia (UM) toconduct research on Low Carbon City.Te Iskandar Development in Johor has
c o v e r F e a t U r e Cont I nU e d
disposal and/or recovery acilities.Waste generation management willbe promoted including recyclingo waste, solid waste collection anddisposal in accordance with theNational Solid Waste Master Plan.
Strategic assets, electricity generation
plants and distribution mains shall besuitably located to provide a reliableand ecient supply o power toconsumers. Renewable energy suchas energy rom solar, wind, waveand biomass are to be promotedto complement traditional powergeneration sources.
National Urbanization PolicyIn addition to the National Physical Plan
which demonstrated physical planningcommitment to support green urbanism,green urbanism has also been refectedin the Malaysias National UrbanisationPolicy (NUP) approved by the Cabineton August 8, 2006. Te NUP guidesand co-ordinates the planning and urbandevelopment in Malaysia incorporatingkey areas such as urban growth limit,compact cities, urban regeneration,utilization o open spaces, solid wastegeneration / containment, sustainabletransport, energy eciency and renewableenergy. Te National Urbanization Policy
emphasizes the ollowing:1. Optimal and balanced landuse
planning emphasis in urban develop-ment, hence all development shallbe compatible with the surroundinglanduses and concentrated withinthe urban growth limit so as to createa compact city
2. Encouragement o re-developmentprogrammes or browneld areas andpromotion o urban regeneration
3. Adequate provision o open space
the impact o urban heat islands andto ensure that urban development
will take into account reduction oair, noise and water pollution
9. Use o innovative technology inurban planning, development andurban services management aimingto reduce the production o waste,
promote the construction o greenbuildings and encourage the use oecient energy and renewable energy
Indeed, the urban planning ora hadconceived ways to promote greenurbanism since the mid 1990s and was
ormalized in the National UrbanizationPolicy during the early period o the 9thMalaysia Plan. Subsequently, initiativesin the National Green echnology Policy(NGP) serve as a support to ollow-through the green growth agenda.
Planning Guidelines and CircularsIn addition to policy directions and
prescriptions in the National PhysicalPlan and National Urbanization Policy,there are other initiatives to encourage
and recreational areas to meet therequirement o the population, con-sequently promoting the contiguousand integrated development o greenareas in urban centres to reduce car-bon emission
4. Develop an integrated, ecient anduser-riendly public transportationsystem including environmentalriendly vehicles, bicycle lanes, and
pedestrian network or ecientconnectivity and to reduce the levelo air pollution
5. Eective and sustainable solid wasteand toxic management systems
to eect solid waste reduction,ull utilization o bio-degradablematerials and encourage recycling
programmes or the community6. Strategies related to sucient
housing and aordability, taking intoaccount the needs o various groupso society including the disabled andsenior citizens
7. Environmental conservation andimproving the urban quality o lie,
8. Encourage development that reduces
The Iskandar Development in Johor has
been selected as a pilot and tagged as Low
Carbon City 2025, Sustainable Iskandar
Malaysia.
A backyard rainwater harvesting system in
Sandakan
been selected as a pilot and tagged asLow Carbon City 2025, SustainableIskandar Malaysia. Tis study researchesthe easibility o developing IskandarMalaysia into a low carbon city. Temethods involved developing the currentinventory o GHG emissions o IskandarMalaysia; and quantiying the socialeconomic activity level in 2025 basedon Iskandar Malaysia ComprehensiveDevelopment Plans 2025. Initial ndingshad shown that the GHG emissions oIskandar Malaysia will increase 3.6 timeshigher than o the level at 2005 withoutmitigation measures, and by adoptingthe mitigation options, emissions can bereduced by approximately 60% by 2025.
OHER NAIONAL POLICIES
Te National Green echnology Policy(NGP July 2009Te NGP is one o the most current
platorms supporting green growth.It introduces and proposes the im-
plementation o innovative economicinstruments, as well as the establishmento eective scal and nancial mechanismsto support the growth o green industries.Te NGP is held by our pillars namelyenergy, environment, economy and social;
with our key areas ocusing on energy,building, water & waste management andtransportation. Tese areas are expected to
promote oreign direct investments (FDI)in green technology to oster domesticdirect investments (DDIs) and localindustry participation.
Implications on green cities have beenidentied through two strategic thrusts
in the NGP. Te rst thrust ocuseson providing a conducive environmentor green technology development withmeasures to strengthen the understandingo local players in Green echnologyindustries and their value chain.Tis would include technology andinrastructure support required or energyecient neighbourhoods and cities.Similar to economic strategies adoptedby many countries, the NGP acilitatesand inuses unds into sustainability-
Green areas in urban centres reduce carbon emission
-
7/28/2019 The Ingenieur Vol 47 Sept 2010
10/33
oriented projects simultaneously greeningthe economy. Te second thrust promoteseducation and inormation disseminationthrough comprehensive roll - out
programmes to increase public awarenesson Green echnology.
Malaysian Budget 2010
Te topic o green growth continuedwhen the Prime Minister, during his2010 Budget speech in October 2009,announced that Malaysia will developgreen technologies and encouragedevelopment o green buildings. Tedevelopment o green technology wouldbe translated by developing Putrajayaand Cyberjaya as pioneer townships ingreen technology and as a showcase orthe development o other townships.Tese green townships would promote
well-connected neighbourhoods, reducecarbon ootprint through environment-riendly initiatives including greenbuildings and using resources eciently.Tese townships should also be wellmanaged, inclusive, equitable andostering a sense o community within athriving and vibrant economy.
Green rating tools have also beenmentioned, highlighting the GreenBuilding Index (GBI), where buildings
ocus on increasing the eciency oresource use (energy, water, and materials)while reducing building impact onhuman health and the environmentduring the buildings liecycle. Tis can beachieved through better sitting, design,construction, operation and maintenanceo buildings. Te ramework or this greenrating system or single buildings can beurther extended to a neighbourhoodor township level to create a green ratingsystem or townships and neighbourhoods.
Te National Policy on Climate ChangeTe National Steering Committee onClimate Change (NSCCC) serves as thenational ocal point or external nancialand technical assistance or climate change
programme. Te NSCCC also ormulatesand implements climate change policiesincluding mitigation o GHG emissionsand adaptation to climate change. Toughdebates and discourses on climate changehad taken place prior to the ormulation othe NGP, the submission o this Policyhad preceded the submission o NationalClimate Change Policy to the Cabinet inNovember 2009. Tis policy will driveeorts to reduce emissions and contributeto the larger agenda o reducing climatechange impacts.
Te Blueprint comprises ve principles,
ten strategic thrusts and 43 key actions,all ocusing on mitigation, adaptationmeasures and capacity building. InDecember 2009, at the COP-15, the PrimeMinister had announced that Malaysia
will adopt a voluntary national reductionup to 40% in terms o GDP emissionintensity by year 2020. Te Ministry oNatural Resources and Environment(NRE) is currently nalizing the road mapor Malaysia to achieve the national targetreduction o GHG emission by 2020.
Green technology vendors play an
important role in shaping green cities but
the bottom line is that green urbanism is
community-led.
PUBLIC AWARENESS AND GREENCONSCIOUSNESS
One o the keys to successul greening o acity is the commitment o the communityin realizing their green objectives.Fundamental to community commitmentis awareness, more so, green consciousnesstowards shared community goals.Oen an uphill climb, communication,
partnership and sharing betweenall members o the community areinstrumental in the creation o successulgreen cities. Promoting an area-widegreen liestyle such as recycling, wastereduction, working on urban communityagricultural plots or community gardens,or even participating in a composting
programme or eco-estival or example,are green community activities thatrequire collective synergy.
Other green liestyle changes that wouldbe driven by community rapport are
walking, cycling, and initiatives relatedto the use o household and communitygreen technology. Green technology
vendors play an important role inshaping green cities but the bottom lineis that green urbanism is community-led.Tough green networking is maturingin Europe through the social media and
internet portals, Malaysia is new in theseeorts. However, long existing platormscan be used, such as Local Agenda 21and thus ar some activities on greeningsuch as recycling have been realizedthrough Malaysias Local Agenda 21under the Ministry o Housing and LocalGovernment
At the local authority level, GreenCities Network could create public-
private partnership, with local
c o v e r F e a t U r e Cont I nU e d
Putrajaya a pioneer green township
-
7/28/2019 The Ingenieur Vol 47 Sept 2010
11/33
t H e I n G e n I e U r v o l 4 7 S e p t e m B e r - n o v e m B e r 2 0 1 0c o v e r F e a t U r e
Many things are encompassed in ourunderstanding o the word landscape. Itis a matter not only o beauty, aestheticappreciation o nature and architecture,but the whole ecology o an area, thehistory o its occupation and use by
people; geological structure o the land,its soils, animals and its vegetation; andthe pattern o human activity both
past and present. Landscape is describedas the environment we experience inthe interaction o natural resources and
peoples needs. Landscape contributes tosociety in many ways Among benets thatare widely accepted are: -
Eperiencing beauty and source oinspiration.Many people have seen thelandscape they grew up in disappear.Many children o today will share thatexperience. It is experienced as theloss o a shared past. Tis aspect playsan important role in experiencing theidentity o a district, city or country.Landscape has been a source o
inspiration or artists rom practicallyevery discipline: composer, lmdirectors, poets, writers, painters,
photographers and designers. Manyartistic expressions are connected
with the landscape. Tis all makesthe landscape a thoroughly alturas
phenomena. Since landscape ismaniested in the work o so manydierent artists; it emphasizes thedeeper values in society. Landscape isthus a vehicle o values.
Conserving nature and biologicaldiversity. Landscape conserves natureand biological diversity through theeco-system along with vegetation,fora and auna that have evolvedthrough human intervention. Naturallandscape is known to be repositorieso biological richness.
Conserving human history inbuilding and activities by impressinghuman history in monuments,buildings and activities. It willcontinue to provide living spaces andlivelihood or the population to evolvein harmony with the environment.
Oering source o recreation andtourism. Public use and enjoyment areimportant contribution o landscapetowards physical and mental health.A well managed landscape area or
park will integrate recreation withconservation, leading to a wide rangeo experiences walking, climbing,
caving, cycling, gliding, photography,party, nature study or simply enjoyingthe beautiul area created.
ECONOMIC VALUE PROVIDED BYLANDSCAPE
In line with current approach o propertydevelopment which gives emphasis tolandscape and environment, and putsculture and landscape as assets to drive
a citys distinctiveness, appropriatemechanisms need to be ollowed inorder to establish the market value o a
property.
Natural and man-made landscapesprovide a wealth o goods and s ervices inthe economy such as: aesthetic views with beautiful trees
and lake landscape, opportunities for physical exercises
that include brisk walking and jogging recreational activities including
picnicking carbonsequestrationandcarbonsinkSome o these benets are deriveddirectly while others are obtainedindirectly. In other cases, the benetsare obtained without making any actualexpenditure. Te mere presence and
protection o the landscape trees maygenerate emotional satisaction. Tereis also a time dimension to the benetsderived. In most cases people acquirethese benets in the current period, but
there are also circumstances where theyderive satisaction rom the knowledgethat protecting a landscape area nowcould ensure that uture generations alsohave the opportunity to use it.
Te categories o economic value include:
DirectUsevalueTese are the values that accrue romdirect human use o a natural landscape,and can be either extractive or non-
Landscape: TheEconomic ValueBy Puan Hajah Rotina b. Mohd Daik, Jabatan Landskap Negara
authorities developing a community-based stewardship programme withcommunity helping community wherebycommunities share experiences, volunteerand help each other in creating greenenvironments.
CONCLUSION HE WAYFORWARD
Global warming and world climate changehad impacted peoples lie in varyingdegrees. Sustainable development and thegreening o living habitat has increasinglybecome a prominent agenda globally.It is estimated that around 50% 3 o the
worlds population now lives in cities and
urban areas and increasingly so in years tocome. Tese large communities provideboth challenges and opportunities orenvironment-conscious urban makers to
make cities more sustainable, particularlyat the township level. Tis would involvemaking a commitment to townshipdesigns that will support a low emissionliestyle or all residents; involving the
widest possible range o stakeholders ingreen growth with green inrastructureserving as a backbone to support energyeciency and renewable energy withinthe water and energy systems. Tus anintegrated approach linking all dimensiono sustainability is instrumental. Onthe economic ront, green developmentdirectly nurtures green economy. Inusingunds into sustainability-oriented projectsis one way to green the economy, as hasbeen highlighted by the NGP.
Long-term visions in spatial planningto secure progressively green townshipand regions or sustainable utures calls
or a continuous improvement in thedevelopment plan making process toconsciously include green urbanism.Te Ministry o Housing and LocalGovernment through the FDCPhas, since the mid-1990s supportedgreen urbanism through its policiesand guidelines. Likewise the collectivesupport o local authorities, developers,
planners and architects, and relatedagencies in the public and private sectorsin the conception and realization o greentownship is instrumental. With visionsand policies in place, green urbanismis at best community-driven withcommunity support and consciousnessoen supported by an eective social
networking media and under the auspiceso good green leadership.
REFERENCES
1. Beatley imothy (2000), Green Urbanism: Learning From European Cities, Island Press.2. Bristol Accord (2005), Conclusions o Ministerial Inormal On Sustainable Communities in Europe UK Presidency,
Crown.3. Federal Department o own and Country Planning, Peninsular Malaysia (2006), National Urbanisation Policy.4. Federal Department o own and Country Planning, Peninsular Malaysia (2005), National Physical Plan.5. Federal Department o own And Country Planning, Peninsular Malaysia (1997), Planning Guideline on Open Spaces
and Recreational Areas.6. Federal Department o own And Country Planning, Peninsular Malaysia (1997), Planning Guideline or Roo op
Gardens.
7. Federal Department o own and Country Planning, Peninsular Malaysia (2006), Planning Guideline or EnvironmentalSensitive Areas and its surrounding areas (Dra).8. Ministr y o Energ y, Green echnology & Water KeHA, (2010), National Green echnolog y Policy.9. Malaysian Institute o Architects - PAM (2009) Green Building Index (GBI)10. Prime Minister Department (2001), Eighth Malaysia Plan 2001 200511. Prime Minister Department (2006), Ninth Malaysia Plan 2006 201012. Putrajaya and Cyberjaya on environs-riendly ast track. Wednesday January 27, 2010, the Star Online13. Te Speech on enth Malaysia Pla n 2011 2015 by Prime Minister o Malaysi a, Dato Sri Mohd Najib Bin un Haji
Abdul Razak, June 10, 2010 in the Dewan Rakyat.14. Universiti eknologi Malaysia, Kyoto University, Okayama University and Ritsumeikan University (2009), Low-Carbon
City 2025: Sustainable Iskandar Malaysia.15. Wikipedia Dictionary, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Green_development, download on February, 2010.
3AccordingtoCentralintelligentAgency(CIA),USA https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-actbook/elds/2212.html?countryName
=World&countryCode=xx®ionCode=ocx:
urbanpopulation:50.5% o total population (2010)
rateofurbanization:1.85% annual rate o change (2010-15 est.)
tenlargesturbanagglomerations:okyo (Japan) 36,669,000; Delhi (India) 22,157,000; Sao Paulo (Brazil) 20,262,000; Mumbai (India)
20,041,000; Mexico City (Mexico) 19,460,000; New York-Newark (US) 19,425,000; Shanghai (China) 16,575,000; Kolkata (India)
15,552,000; Dhaka (Bangladesh) 14,648,000; Karachi (Pakistan) 13,125,000 (2009)
c o v e r F e a t U r e Cont I nU e d
-
7/28/2019 The Ingenieur Vol 47 Sept 2010
12/33
F e a t U r e Con t I nU e d t H e I n G e n I e U r v o l 4 7 S e p t e m B e r - n o v e m B e r 2 0 1 0c o v e r F e a t U r e Cont I nU e d
water purication, nutrient recycling,carbon sequestration and micro-climatestabilisation, all o which indirectly helpsupport or protect economic activity andhuman welare nearby the park.
OptionvalueInstitutions may want to conserve naturallandscape areas so that uture generationsalso have the chance to enjoy them.Tis is the option value. Individuals orinstitutions may also want to conservenature i they believe there is potential
value in doing so. Local authorities,or example, may conserve beautiullandscape areas o high biodiversity andnatural eatures now in an attempt to
establish new parks in the uture. Tis isan action which is a orm o option value.Tese option values arise because o theuncertainty o uture supplies o greenlandscape areas with clean water bodies.
Non-UsevalueTe above three categories capture thebenets o actually using the landscapearea, either now or in the uture. But
people also derive value rom naturesimply by knowing that it exists. Tisexistence value captures peoples desire tosee environmental and natural landscapesconserved, even though they neverintend to use them. For example, people
pay money to conservation org anisationsto protect charismatic biodiversityspecies, although they may never see or
visit them. Tis is part o the altruisticvalue that some p eople have on uniquelandscapes.
able 1.1 presents illustrations oeconomic values computed or a range o
goods and services provided by landscapeareas overseas, classied according to thedierent categories o economic value.
CASE SUDIES AROUND HEWORLD
JapanStudies show that there are relativeincreases in property value inareas composed o good landscapeenvironment. In Japan, data rom okyoand Kitakyushus large and mediumsized metropolitan areas were used toevaluate 200300 transacted vacant sites,designated or residential development.Te results o principal componentanalysis and hedonic regression analysissuggested that the compatibility othe buildings and the greenery o theneighbourhood were distinctively
perceived; and these actors signicantlyinfuenced land prices or both cities.Te outcomes indicate that programmesshould be provided to motivate residentsto preserve or create landscape amenityco-operatively, and justiy planning
policies to encourage neighbourhood-based co-operation or landscapeimprovement.1
NetherlandsAn attractive environment is likelyto infuence house prices. Houses in
attractive settings will have an addedvalue over similar, less avourablylocated houses. Tis eect is intuitivelyelt, but does it always occur? Whichenvironmental actors make a locationan attractive place to live in? A studyin Netherlands explored the eect odierent environmental actors onhouse prices. Te research using thehedonic pricing method to analyse3,000 house transactions, in eight townsin the Netherlands, were studied toestimate the eect o environmentalattributes on transaction prices. Someo the most salient results show that thelargest increases in house prices due toenvironmental actors (up to 28%) or
houses with a garden acing water, whichis connected to a sizeable lake.
It demonstrate that a pleasant view canlead to a considerable increase in house
price, particula rly i the house overlookswater (810%) or open space (612%).Observation revealed that house price
varies by landscape type. Attractivelandscape types were able to attract a
premium o 512% over less attractiveenvironmental settings.2 Natural settinghelps to boost property value.
extractive. Examples o the ormerinclude the use o the landscape areaby the local community or timber andnon-timber orest products like root,shoots, bark, leaves, fower, ruit ormushroom picking without destroyingthe trees. Te extracted product maybe sold commercially or used orsubsistence purposes. Non-extractivedirect use values include the amenity
and recreational benets individualsreceive rom visiting areas o outstandingnatural beauty, as well as the research andeducational values people derive romstudying biologically diverse and uniquelandscapes. IndirectUsevalueTese are the ecological unctionsand services o natural resources and
landscapes that indirectly providesupport and protection to people andeconomic activity. For example, the
watershed protection unctions oa landscape area can help to controlerosion and sedimentation in riversand drains, and hence the foodingo productive land downstream. Teenvironment also provides a myriad oother ecological services such as air and
Table 1.1: Examples of economic value derived for a range of environmental goods and services
1Xiaolu Gao, and Yasushi Asami, Institute o Geographical Sciences and Natural Resources Research, Chinese Academyo Sciences, 11A Datun Road, Chaoyang District, Beijing 100101, ChinabCenter or Spatial Inormation Science, University o okyo, Kashiwanoha 5-1-5, Kashiwa, Chiba 277-8568, Japan2Te value o trees, water and open space as reected by house prices in the Netherlands
Joke Luttik Alterra, Green World Research, P.O. Box 125, 6700 AC Wageningen, Netherlands
e vlu*
Hbl k lu52.5 ll vnd/h
$54/huhl /y bb pl$12/huhl/y bb h$22/huhl/y w$22/huhl/y u$16/huhl/y $22/huhl/y h u
$25 ll/y
$100.5-210/
28,460-28,700 v nd/(l u) 23,500-23,800vnd/ (u)
$19.1 Bl l$18.5 gzzly b$5.1 cy$9.3 Blu whl$40-64 Hupbk whl
$3 l b p- aul
Lp a Byru
nul lp u b
n-bpu lp
s w lu lph
Wl lp y
vlu lp y
vlu p
c
c e vlu
d u lu
d u lu
n-x u lu
n-x u lu
n-x u lu
n-u lu
n-u lu
L
n d d,cl v
Lu s d, HBh P, v
Ky
UK
Bh m nl Pk,cl v
Us
vlu vuu - - aul
su
mh shhwh l. (2008)
Ph l. (1999)
Bw Hy(1993)
B l(1994)
mh shhwh l. (2007)
UneP (1995)B l(1997)
* xh 2,100 v d (vnd) = rm1 2007 $1 (Us) = rm2.5
Natural setting helps to boost property value.
-
7/28/2019 The Ingenieur Vol 47 Sept 2010
13/33
F e a t U r e Con t I nU e d t H e I n G e n I e U r v o l 4 7 S e p t e m B e r - n o v e m B e r 2 0 1 0
UnitedStatesofAmericaA survey o the sales o 844 single amilyresidential properties in Athens, GeorgiaU.S.A., indicated that landscaping withtrees was associated with 3.5%4.5%increase in sales prices. During the 19781980 study period, the average house soldor about US$38,100 (in 1978 constantdollars) and had ve trees in its ront
yard. Te average sales price increasedue to trees was between US$1,475 andUS$1750 (US$2,869 and US$3,073 in1985 dollars) and was largely due to treesin the intermediate and large size classes,regardless o species. Tis increase in
property value resulted in an estimatedincrease o US$100,000 (1978 dollars)
in the citys property tax revenues.3
Te hedonic price model was used tosimultaneously estimate the eects ostreet trees on the sales price and thetime-on-market (OM) o houses inPortland, Oregon. On average, streettrees add US$8,870 to sales price andreduce OM by 1.7 days. In addition, it
was ound that the benets o street treesspill over to neighbouring houses.4
CONRIBUION OF AMENIYREES IN MALAYSIA
In Malaysia, the value o a standing tree inaman asik aiping has been estimatedby using Tyer ree Valuation method
which was designed to value trees in pub-lic parks or urban setting. Te calculated
value is assessed based on the contributiono trees to landscape, and the extent it isappreciated by the public due to its im-
portance to the environment and humancommunity. A survey done by Jabatan
Landskap Negara and Universiti PutraMalaysia on the value o the sampled ame-nity trees in aman asik aiping revealedthat Samanes saman (Hujan-hujan) treesaged around 130 years were valued be-tween RM1,649,288 to RM2,084,699 pertree. Greater eort should be encouragedor all parties to plan and execute develop-
which eventually will progress topromoting research and developmentrelated to landscape.
FOSERING LANDSCAPE ASPAR OF MALAYSIAN LIFESYLE
Malaysian landscape should refect its
present climate and character as Malaysiais renowned or her unique tropicalcharacter, abundant with an assortmento landscape resources. Te distinctive
physical appearances; namely rainorests,topographical and geological ormation,rivers, and vegetations should be wiselycarved along with development. Te key
ment project that willenhance the quality oMalaysian landscapeby preserving ournatural resources, pro-tecting natural topog-raphy and creatinggreen areas by plant-ing trees with greateroliage.BUILDINGA VIBRANGARDENNAION
Te aspiration o
making Malaysia aBeautiul GardenNation has been
progressing well sincethe vision was putorward in the late1990s. Tis visionneeds to be supportedby drastic changesin the mindset oour society towardslandscape. Strategiesor the Governmentto build a more
vibrant and liveablenation are as ollows:-
actions to promote Malaysias unique
landscape character and value include:-
a) ReectingLocalClimateandTropicalCharacter
Malaysian landscape should refect thepresent climate and character as Malaysiais renowned or her unique tropicalcharacter with distinctive rainorests,rivers, and plants. Tere is also an urgentneed to ensure the uniqueness is creativelyused or a quality living environment.
b) RespectingNatureandEnvironmento respect nature and environment , the reis a need to emphasize the Spirit o Placeor the Genius Loci in every developmentto avoid estrangement. Furthermore,the natural local species should also behighlighted together with the placesculture and history to create a distinctivecomposition. Materials and componentsselected should suit the climate, habitatand ones needs.
c) Conservingnaturallandscapethroughcreativedesignofpropertydevelopment
Practice natural conservation and bio-diversity in order to thwart and controlany indiscriminate acts o destruction oexisting hills and topographical orma-tion as well as natural settings. A constantand proper consideration should be takenin all physical developments to ensurethat natural and landscape resources are
3Inuence o trees on residential property values in Athens, Georgia (U.S.A.): A survey based on actual sales pricesL.M. Anderson and H.K. Cordell USDA Forest Service, Southeastern Forest Experiment Station, Forestry Sciences Laboratory,Carlton Street, Athens GA 30602, U.S.A.4Landscape and Urban Planning Journal
c o v e r F e a t U r e Cont I nU e d
Rows o heritage trees in Taiping, Perak
Promote and improve Malaysianlandscape development parallel to theGarden Nation Vision, with sucientand unctional Green Inrastructurethat benet people.
Conserve and pre se rve p reciousnatural resources to ensure theseunique national assets are in sae
hands. Ensure that landscape i s taken as
a undamental requirement in allprogrammes and projects.
Reviewthelegislationandmonitoringprocedures or matters related tolandscape.
Strengthen the landscape industry
saeguarded. Weshould also protectnatural landscapeand biodiversityin development otownships and in-rastructure.
d)PromotingGreenDevelopment
Moving orwardto achieve WorldHealth Organisa-
tion Standards o 16m o green space per
person, greater eort is need to promotegreen development. Utilization o creativelandscape approach such as creatingroo top garden, vertical landscape andincreased density o green spaces ought tobe put into eect.
e) ApplyingDesigntoFollowFunctionApplying Design to Follow Function
principle is undeniably suitable orspaces especially in the cities. A goodlandscape development should have aunctional, creative and attractive designthat benet the user besides providingcomort and a s ecured living environment.Such a principle will not only createdistinctive Malaysian landscape identityand character, but will also benet andmeet the needs o every level o users.
In addition, optimizing the usage oindigenous materials is also essential toensure its sustainability.
f) Creatinglushopenspace,recreationareaandGreenCorridor
One o the most crucial actions to reducethe elements o hardcape in a de velopment.As what we are witnessing today, too muchusage o hardcape elements is proven tointensiy heat and cause discomort tothe user. Hard-suraced materials usedare unlikely to absorb heat. More greenarea, lush open spaces and seamless greencorridors need to be created.
g) Creatingdedicatedandpermanent
landscapereservebytheroadside,highwaysandrivercorridors
In order to create avenue o scenicbeauty trees in Malaysia, a dedicated and
permanent landscape reserve by roadside,highways and river corridors need to bedeveloped. Tese will eventually orm anintegrated green network in urban areas.
h) AdoptingManagementPracticesIn landscape and parks developments,
properly managed and maintained areassupported by a well equipped organisationis vital in creating sustainable development.Proessional curator and park managersin every park are essential to manage the
park and to carry out park inventories andhabitat identication works with otherrelated experts.
Archway o trees enhances the entry point to development
Trees and landscape enhance the value and eel o a place
-
7/28/2019 The Ingenieur Vol 47 Sept 2010
14/33
F e a t U r e Con t I nU e d t H e I n G e n I e U r v o l 4 7 S e p t e m B e r - n o v e m B e r 2 0 1 0
Housing provision normallylags behindthe rapid growth o urban population.I houses are available, they are beyondthe aordability o most low-income
population in rapidly growing urbancentres. Te impact o urbanisation onour living environment depends verymuch on the management o urbanchange by local Government and other
Liveable AndSustainable HousingDevelopment
Sustainable housing development ensures that no one is
let out in the development process and it addresses socio-
economic and environmental issues. Liveable housing
emphasises human comort, sense o place, saety, community
spirit and neighbourhood. Residential satisaction is an
important indicator o liveable housing conditions, which
aects individuals quality o lie. The actors that determine
residential satisaction are essential inputs in monitoring the
success o housing policies. This paper discusses some aspects
o urban development activities that have implications on
sustainable housing development and an evaluation o
residential satisaction in private low-cost housing projects in
selected states.
parties involved in the developmentprocess.Tere are always risks to the environmentin housing development as it is a complex
process, which involves many players.Amongst them, the key players are thedevelopers and planners. Te role odevelopers is to conceive and produce
the developments or others to use.Tey seek to satisy public needs and getreasonable economic returns rom thedevelopment. On the other hand, therole o Government is to ensure the builtenvironment created by the development
process will eventually enhance theliving environment and economic wellbeing o society. Tey seek to strike
By Proessor Abdul Ghani Salleh, School o Housing, Building and Planning,Universiti Sains Malaysia
a balance between urban economicgrowth and physical growth throughland use development policy, whichconstitutes the core o sustainable urbandevelopment.
Tere is a positive relationship betweenhousing development and economicgrowth. Housing is one o the mainaspects o urban development, whichare directly linked to the economy. Aslong as housing programmes contributeto the distribution o wealth, theycontribute to the long-term economicsuccess o development as well-housed
population generates labour orce o ahigh level o productivity. Tus, housing
contributes not only to economicgrowth but also social equity. Liveablehousing emphasises human comort,sense o place, saety, communityspirit and neighbourhood. Residentialsatisaction is an important indicatoro liveable housing condition, whichaects individuals quality o lie. Teactors, which determine satisaction,are essential inputs in monitoringthe success o housing policies. Tus,urban development activities that haveimplications on liveable and sustainablehousing development need to bemonitored to assist in the ormulationand revision o housing policies.
HOUSING DEVELOPMEN:ISSUES AND PROBLEMSDo the orces o economic growth havestronger infuence than the social andenvironmental considerations in housingdevelopment or to what extent does our
housing system incorporate elements osustainable development in Malaysia?No comprehensive study has so arbeen done to address these questions.Nevertheless, we may able to evaluateand make some propositions regardingthe current housing situation based onthe ollowing observations. Sustainabledevelopment ensures that no one isle out in the development process.Tis explains sustainable cities as citiesor all. Te basic objective o urban
development is to meet human needsand achieve equity and social justice.No one should be marginalised in thedevelopment process. However, many ous eel that housing development tendsto benet the privileged ew rather thanthe poor and deprived. What is wrong
with our housing system or where is themissing link in the sustainable housingdevelopment process?
Over consumption o housingTe current housing system encourages
people to buy bigger houses. For civilservants, they could do so throughsecond housing loans and increasedloan limits as implemented in 2001.Te consumption o housing shouldbe based on needs rather than wants.Over consumption o housing leadsto environmental deterioration. Tegrowth o residential development
in the urban periphery suburbanresidential development is a result o theincrease o population in higher incomecategory. Tis is a normal trend o urbandevelopment in which suburban growthattracts the rich leaving the poor in thecentral areas o the city. Resort, hill and
waterront developments are becomingpopular lately in our country. A studyby Ghani (1997) indicates that resortdevelopment is attractive mainly tothose with proessional and management
backgrounds. Teir purpose o acquiringthese properties is to have better livingenvironment, or amily reasons, weekendretreats and investment.
Squatter settlementsLarge cities in developing countriesare characterised by rapid urbanisationand urban growth that oen results inmultiplication o squatter colonies inthe urban ringes. Malaysian cities areno exception. Tere are many reasonsthat can explain the above phenomena.Urban-rural migration is oen citedto be the main cause or the rapidurban growth. Te pull actors areassociated with more job opportunities
created by industrialisation, betterurban community acilities and betterurban living environment. Most o themigrants are in the low-income segmento the urban population who are noteasily accessible to the ormal low costhousing sector. Furthermore, the supplyo low cost housing cannot cope withthe increasing number o migrants to thecities. Te only opportunity that is opento them to nd their homes in the squattersettlements that are rather ast and cheapto build. Teir living environment isdeplorable with inadequate sanitation,drainage, waste collection and insecurityo tenure.
Te price o low-cost housing has beenxed by the Government at RM25,000or some time until its revision in 1998.Te current price o the low-cost housingis between RM25,000 and RM42,000depending on location. Not long aerthat in 2000, the price o low-mediumcost housing increased rom RM42,000-
RM60,000 to RM45,000-RM70,000,and will inevitably push low-cost housing
price limits higher. High land cost wasquoted to be the major actor or theincrease. Are we building these housesbased on their needs or wants? I we useaordability as a means to deliver housesor low-income groups, we may not beable to meet their basic housing needs,not to mention the housing quality asthere is no such thing as a good qualitylow-cost housing. Tey will eventually
c o v e r F e a t U r e
Squatter issues
Housing development
Creativecommons@t
hienzieyung
Creativecommons@T
ing~
-
7/28/2019 The Ingenieur Vol 47 Sept 2010
15/33
F e a t U r e Con t I nU e d t H e I n G e n I e U r v o l 4 7 S e p t e m B e r - n o v e m B e r 2 0 1 0
be marginalised in squatter colonies.Squatter eviction is not the solutionas the number o low-cost housingunits available is not only insucientbut also may not meet their needs. Teaordability problems among low incomehousing will inevitably require theGovernment to look seriously into socialrented housing sector or a solution. Tesector should not only target the poorbut also a wider range o the society.Moral considerations should be takeninto account in housing the poor. Tecurrent trend is that most o the low andmedium income groups are housed in
private rented sector, which is describedby Harloe (1994) as paying more or less
space and poor quality house.
Smart partnershipsTe extent o smart partnership between
private and public sectors in housingdevelopment depends very much onGovernment policy. Currently, localauthorities are concerned with regulations,controls and limitations, unnecessarilycomplicated, and some times unrelatedto the real needs o public and privatesectors. Lack o communication betweenthe players in the development processand delays are common problems. Strictdevelopment control will not onlyslow down urban development but alsoeliminate development potential andscare investors. Planning as set out inAgenda 21, should be decentralised,
participatory, responsive, accountable,realistic and imaginative (ipple, 1996).Tere is a need or local authoritiesto build their capacity or sustainabledevelopment.
Lack o open spaceLastly, provision o public, open space
within each residential neighbourhood tomeet the needs o dierent groups seldomgets much attention. As a result, there islittle provision or such space in urbanareas and most land sites are developedor other urban activities. Tere may belittle pressures rom upper income groupsto address this issue as their purchasing
power allows them exclusive access tosuch resources. However, the poor should
not be deprived o their basic needs.
MONIORING PROCESS
One o the most important changes inthe last three decades has been the moveaway rom assessing the quantitativedimensions o housing decits orbacklogs within nations to whether
people can nd accommodationthat meets their needs and priorities(UNCHS, 1996). Teir needs and
priorities are assured in sustainabledevelopment. Tus, sustainable hous-ing is not just an ideal, it is a necessity.Tereore, it must be planned,implemented through action plans andmonitored through a system that willassist in the ormulation and revision o
policies.
Housing indicatorsHousing indicator, a tool or monitoring,can assist in evaluation o housingconditions, identication o housingissues and problems, and ormation orational housing issues. Better housingquality and living environment willonly be achieved through rationalhousing policies. Te system canmake comparisons in various aspectso housing between time periods and
locations. Te indicators need not beperect, they need not tell every thingabout housing sector. Tey are indirectmeasures o housing perormance andearly indications o the presence ohousing problems that require treatment.Good indicators can only evolve overtime. Local Government is a powerulbody in generating local economies andsustainable housing environments. Itcan manage and control stakeholders inthe sustainable development process sothat environmental resources and urbanservices are distributed equitably orthe present and uture generations. Weneed to monitor housing perormance toensure housing market works smoothly
and to signal i it is not, and to allocatepublic resources equitably.
A global survey o housing indicatorshas been conducted since 1990 as a joint
programme o the United Nations Centreor Human Settlements (UNCHS) andthe World Bank. Te objectives o thesurvey were to create a comprehensivebasic set o indicators or the housingsector, to establish analytical relationshipamong these indicators and to providetools to measure the perormance o thehousing sector. Locally, an initial eorttowards establishing comprehensive setso housing indicators has already started.Federal Department o own andCountry Plannning, Ministry o Housingand Local Government o Malaysia, hascarried out a study o urban indicators in
which housing is one o the sectors.
Study in Kuantan, Batu Pahat,George own, Pasir Mas andKuching
In the study, ve towns were selectedto orm a sample. Tey are Kuantan,Batu Pahat, George own, Pasir Masand Kuching. Preliminary results otwo housing indicators, namely housing
price to income ratio and foor space perperson, indicate we are in the middleo the extreme values compared tothat o the other countries includedin UNCHS Global Data Base Survey(Ghani, 2001). For instance, the average
value o 2.24 or the house price to
income ratio is relatively low comparedto Hanoi 10.4, Jakarta 9.9, Paris 4.3 andRio de Janeiro 2.4. Te value does notindicate the level o development ourban centres and cities, but it is relatedto the housing policy. Te lower valuesindicate that housing policies enable theGovernment to provide a large amounto aordable housing or the people.Similarly, the average value o 18.6 orthe foor space per person is relativelymoderate compared to Hanoi 5.19,
Jakarta 15.04, Rio de Janeiro 18.6 andParis 30. Te values correlate with thelevel o development o urban centresand cities. Tese are some examples o
what housing indicator system can do to
monitor housing development process.A time series data o housing indicatorsare needed to determine the presence o
problems and to generate a pattern orelationships between indictors. So, thestudy is a starting point or a long-term
process o housing indicat or programmein the country.
Residential satisaction in Penangand erengganu
Another tool or monitoring isresidential satisaction. In a study onresidential satisaction in private low-cost housing in Penang and erengganu,the variables that aect residentialsatisaction were categorized in threemain groups, dwelling units, services bythe developers, neighbourhood acilitiesand environment (Abdul Ghani, 2008).Te level o satisaction was calculated bythe average satisaction o the residents.Tere were 32 indicators within thesethree groups.
Te residents in both states were generallysatised with dwelling units, services bydevelopers and neighbourhood acilitiesand environment. However, the levelso satisaction varied according to someindicators and housing estates. Teresidents were particularly dissatised asshown by some indicators. For the studyin Penang, there were 10 indicators thatthe residents elt unsatised while there
were 13 indicators in erengganu. Temain unsatised indicators were related
to the neighbourhood acilities andenvironment, such as public transport,community hall, parking lot andacilities or the handicapped. Besidesthat, the residents in both states eltthat they had problems with saety andtheir dwelling units regarding diningroom area, kitchen and clotheslineacilities. Tus, house quality, buildingdesign and educational acilities in theneighbourhood determine residentialsatisaction in private low-cost housingin Penang while saety inrastructure,educational and health acilities in theneighbourhood determine residentialsatisaction in private low-cost housingin erengganu.
Despite having reasonable level oresidential satisaction, many residentsin both states wanted to move out romtheir houses. Te main reasons given byresidents in Penang were to own a more
comortable house and to get a biggerhouse. However, the main reasons givenby the residents in erengganu were dueto ar distance to work place and schooland to own a more comortable housethan the present one because o many
problems. Te problems were foods,leaks, poor quality building materials,
poor public transport and communityacilities, and saety and neighbourhood
problems. Generally, the residents olow-cost housing projects developed by
private housing developers expressed theirdissatisaction with certain attributeso dwelling units, services by developersand neighbourhood acilities as discussedabove. Tese problems aected theirliving environment and quality o lie.In order to ensure that housing is not
just a house but a home in liveableneighbourhood, the Government shouldmonitor low-cost housing programmesdeveloped by private developers to ensurethat residents rom low-income groupare housed in a liveable environment. As
we are aware, simply providing housesdoes not measure the success o housing
programmes and policies. Tus, justmeeting the target o housing units orcertain time period is not sucient eortto achieve the goal o housing policy.Te suitability o living environment,services and related acilities to theneeds o residents is essential or housing
programmes to be successul.
CONCLUSION
A sustainable living environment canbe only achieved i development andenvironmental issues and problems aregiven equal emphasis in urban development.Basic human needs must be ullled,
with living standards improved andecosystems sustained eectively. Tereore,as a sustainable development strategy, a
c o v e r F e a t U r e Cont I nU e d
Need or open spaces
Large housing estate
Creativecommons@r
akastajatar
Creativecommons@t
hienzieyung
-
7/28/2019 The Ingenieur Vol 47 Sept 2010
16/33
F e a t U r e Cont I nU e d
greater integration o social, economic andenvironmental considerations is neededin planning and development o housingsector.
Housing development is a complex process,which involves many players and every one isliterally aected by the changes in propertymarket. In order to sustain the growth ohousing development, every player in thehousing industry needs to assess and reviewits position, and appropriate actions shouldbe taken to achieve sustainable housingdevelopment. Government policies shouldremove barriers to decision making processand uncertainties in the development.Encouragement and incentives should be
given to the developers to promote andrevitalise the industry. Smart partnershipbetween private sector and public sectorshould be encouraged in the developmento aordable housing. Te eorts othe private and public sectors should be
geared to overcome the current problemsaced by both parties in the development
process and to stimulate the growth olocal urban economy. When the economicstandard o the people increases, demandor housing will naturally increase and pushdevelopment orward.
As a sustainable development strategy,long-term public interest rather than short-term private interest should be given moreconsideration. Eorts should also be madeto monitor housing perormance by using
various monitoring tools. It would assistthe Government in the ormulation andrevision o the housing policies, whichgenerate liveable and sustainable housing
development.Reerences
1. Abdul Ghani Salleh (2008)Neighbourhood actors in private low-
cost housing in Malaysia, HabitatInternational 32 (4): 485-493.
2. Ghani Salleh (2001) KajianPenerapan Konsep Mampan DalamPerancangan (A Study o SustainableConcept in Planning, Urban Indicators Housing Sector), echnical Report.
3. Ghani Salleh (1997) A marketstudy o proposed resort townshipdevelopment in Seberang Perai, Pulau
Pinang, School o Housing, Buildingand Planning, USM, Penang.
4. Harloe, M. (1994) Social housing past, present and uture, HousingStudies, 9 (3): 407-416.
5. ipple, A. G. (1996) Housingextensions as sustainable development,
Cities, 20(3): 367-376.6. UNCHS (1996) An UrbanizingWorld: Global Report on HumanSettlements 1996, Oxord: OxordUniversity Press/ UNCHS.
c o v e r F e a t U r e Cont I nU e d
DIVERSE
SOLUTIONS
FOR THE
REGIONS
POWER
INDUSTRY
CHALLENGES
27-29 SEPTEMBER 2011KLCC, KUALA LUMPUR, MALAYSIA
WWW.POWERGENASIA.COM
Kelvin Marlow
Exhibit Sales Manager
T: +44 (0) 1992 656 610
C: +44 (0) 7808 587 764
F: +44 (0) 1992 656 700
FOR EXHIBITION AND SPONSORSHIP
OPPORTUNITIES CONTACT:
OWNED AND PRODUCED BY: FLAGSHIP MEDIA SPONSORS: CO-LOCATED WITH
With its oil and gas reserves predicted to last or only another 3
decades, and the Malaysian economy predicted to grown by
6% per annum over the next 5 years, the Government must
reorm its power sector and use private investment to ensure its
national growth.
There is a general agreement that i economic growth proceeds a
predicted rates, there could be a generation defcit by 2018.
Malaysia is part o a region that is recovering rom the recession at
great pace. Singapores economy grew at a record 17.9 percent
pace in the frst hal o 2010, while Indonesia expanded 6.2 percent
in the second quarter and Thailand grew 9.1 percent.
I your company supplies products or services to the power
generation and transmission and distribution industries in Asia
then POWER-GEN Asia is essential to reaching the key industry
proessionals and decision makers.
FOR INFORMATION ABOUT PARTICIPATING
IN THE CONFERENCE CONTACT:
Mathilde Sueur
Conerence Manager
T: +44 (0) 1992 656 634
F: +44 (0) 1992 656 700
-
7/28/2019 The Ingenieur Vol 47 Sept 2010
17/33
F e a t U r e Con t I nU e d t H e I n G e n I e U r v o l 4 7 S e p t e m B e r - n o v e m B e r 2 0 1 0
temperatures are conditioned, both o which are costlymeasures and diminish the appeal or renewable energyresources. Furthermore, conventional HVAC systemsdepend upon ossil uels even when heat pumps are used,as heat pumps depend on electric power generally suppliedrom conventional power plants using ossil uels anddelivered at low transmission eciency. HVAC systems arerated only with respect to their thermal eciencies, whichneglects the overall energy, environment, and economicrelationships. Current HVAC systems generally rely onhigh-exergy ossil uels or comort unctions, when theyshould only require low-grade heat or cold.
Tis mismatch destroys most o the exergy. Exergy oany fow or resource is the total amount o useul workthat is available, and a HVAC system wastes most o that.Tereore, it is no surprise that their exergy eciency is less
than 10% (Rosen and Dincer 1996; Kilkis 2004).
It is unortunate that this problem, which has been knownor a relatively long time, has not yet been addressed: thebuilding sector, with a dominant share in annual energyuse, has very low exergy eciency or energy utilization andcontinues to be responsible or environmental degradation,mainly in terms o CO2 emissions. On the other hand, thethermal eciency o HVAC systems has reached a goodsaturation point, well above 90% on average, except orthermal energy, transport and distribution losses.
Tere are examples o such systems already in the market,such as thermally activated building components usedor foor heating systems or waterborne systems whereheating or cooling pipes are placed into the concreteslab construction. Another is the airborne hollow coredeck system where tempered air rst circulates inside theconstruction walls, thereby heating or cooling the roomsbeore being released as resh supply air to the rooms(Johannesson 2004).
Further research is needed to explore new or not commonlyused exergy resources or incorporation into the builtenvironment, such as the ground (e.g. using ground coolness
or cooling), water (e.g. using ground, sea or riverwater as acooling source), sky (e.g. using the radiation to a clear sky atnight or cooling), or others.
Wide application o low exergy heat ing and cool ing systemsin buildings will create a building stock which will be ableto adapt the use o sustainable energy sources, when desired.
Without this abilit y, the transer towards a sus tainable buil tenvironment will be delayed or decades.
For temperate climate applications, exergy-ecientproducts such as those or geo-thermal heating are quite
well established . Tere are many more examples one maynd listed in the above extracted seminar paper.
As or tropical climatic applications, thus ar theapplications are limited to hot water heaters and morerecently solar thermal cooling. Tere is much more to betaken advantage o. Harvesting renewable solar energy(or electricity) through photovoltaic is merely limiting tothe energy eciency angle. However, harnessing solar (e.g.evacuated tube technology) is many times more energy (andexergy) ecient by means o bypassing the need to convertinto electricity to then produce cooling. Te application osolar absorption cooling is an excellent prospect or tropicalclimate applications. R&D innovations in energy derivedrom renewable energy and suited to local climatic needs
is the key or Malaysian industry. For the built industry,harvesting solar energy to produce exergy-ecient productsrather than merely energy-ecient products is denitely thedirection to go.
wo specic energy technology opportunities are describedbelow.
Solar Termal Cooling (SC
Rather than merely ollowing the global trend o harnessingsolar energy to produce photovoltaic that is limited in their
Exergy-ecient products and services will be the uturetrend. Te ollowing extract rom the American Societyo Heating, Rerigerating & Air-Conditioning Engineers(ASHRAE) will provide an initial insight to this topic orbetter understanding:
Exergy Analysis or Sustainable Buildings is concerned withall exergy aspects o energy and power utilizati on o systemsand equipment or comort and service, assessment o theirimpact on the environment, and development o analysistechniques, methodologies and solution or environmentally
saer, sustainable low- exergy buildi ngs.
Existing building heating, ventilating and air-conditioning(HVAC) and plumbing systems and equipment have already
achieved high thermal eciencie s as dened by the rstlaw o thermodynamics. According to the second law o thermodynamics however, there is a need to increase currentlylow exergy eciencies primarily because existing systems andbuildings demand high-exergy sources.
In this res pect, Inte rnational Energy A gency (IE A) Annex 37recognized exergy-ecient buildings and development o low-exergy systems and equipment to be the most important need
or sustainable developme nt and environment. Currently,
there is a lack o inormation about the importance andrelevance o the subject matter, in particular or greenbuildings and or sustainable development.
Tis G will raise the exergy awareness among engineersand provide the undamental inormation and tools or theimplementation o exergy-ecient designs and development oconsistent exergy related methodologies. Tis G will establish
a robust road map or a comprehensive set o scientic andtechnical steps or environmentally saer building technology
and HVAC systems and acilitate the new A SHRA E theme o Engineering or Su stainability.
Innovations in Energy Ecient &Exergy Ecient Designs
By Ir. Chen Tiam Leong
Editors note: Tis paper was presented at the International Green echnology and Purchasing Conerence,Kuala Lumpur October 15-16, 2010.
eg efcic ply u l y p h
ll y . a xpl wul b ul
hu llw u l h l y h
bl pu; whl ll u-
lh / kylh lh
h ll llu wh l y.
exg efcic h f u y u
p y fy. F , u lw xy y
u u w (40oc) p p h h
pu 20oc, f h u
hh xy y u ly ( p h pup).
th l b h ly ( hh xy y u)
whh pbl h w up 100 oc w wh
h w ly 40oc. n h h pl fy
pu hh xy ly u h lw (
l .).
th r&d hll h y xy
f h h ly y f pu.
ExERGY EFFICIENCY IN DESIGN
Exergy is a qualitative measure o the useul work potentialavailable or a given amount o energy source. For example,low-temperature waste heat is a low-exergy resource becauseonly low temperature and limited applications such asdomestic water service can be realized. On the otherhand, natural gas is a high-exergy resource because severaldierent useul applications such as electricity generationcan be realized.
Existing HVAC systems are not directly compatiblewith low-exergy renewable and waste energy resourcesunless either the equipment is oversized and/or resource
r e s e a r c H & d e v e L o P m e n t
Solar panels
Creativecommons@D
ukeEnergy
-
7/28/2019 The Ingenieur Vol 47 Sept 2010
18/33
-
7/28/2019 The Ingenieur Vol 47 Sept 2010
19/33
F e a t U r e Cont I nU e d
REFERENCE
ASHRAEKilkis2004 TLChenvariouspublicationssince2005
eciency, solar evacuated tube technology with over 80%eciency should be a better choice.
Whilst residential roos are reely a vailable or photovoltaic,similarly roos o industrial and low-rise commercialbuildings (one to three storey/s are ar more productive orsolar air-conditioning applications. In this respect, Malaysiashould nurture this particular industry that today has only ahandul o SME activity.
SmallCo-generationCoolingElectricitySystem
An excellent exergy-ecient product would be the smallco-generation system using LPG/LNG to produce cooling
via an absorption cycle and then harnessing its hydrogenby-product or a uel cell to produce electricity to the grid.
Japan has already produced (since 20 05 see illustrat ions
below) packaged hot water heaters using NG connected touel cell to produce electricity. Producing cooling throughthis same concept has not yet materialized, althoughsuggested by Ir. L Chen back in 2005.
With clean energy gas available in Malaysia or the next30 years or more, this small co-generation system cancommand a substantial market with easible applicationsin high-rise residential buildings, service apartments andeven hotels. Te new trend o shop lot oce buildings alsoconstitutes very suitable applications.
CONCLUSION
R&D in any eld is normally costly and limited inexecution. Tereore, R&D innovations into EnergyEcient & Exergy Ecient designs and products need tobe well thought o, lest we descend into a herd mentalityapproach, more so or Malaysia i we aspire to leaprogover others as a late bloomer. As such, we should not becontented to jump on the bandwagon created by others, butrather examine our own niche market.
A classic case would be that o BIPV (building integrated
photo voltaic) where we risk resigning to be ollowers i wepour our R&D resources in this area. Instead, we shouldcombine the already developed and available photovoltaictechnology with our climatic requirements to R&D onSolar Termal Cooling, to take advantage o our ideal
weather application and our t ypes o built environment.
Tis paper has merely highlighted two very viable exergyecient technologies to refect the enormous market
potential and opportunities in this inant eld and isstrictly representative o the view o the author.
Finally, apart rom R&D innovations into marketableproducts, R&D innovations t o improve on desig n concepts(which unortunately are usually not patentable or dicultto do so) should not be ignored. One potential area (again
suitable or our climatic application) would be the optimalbehaviour o active (airfow) acades.
r e s e a r c H & d e v e L o P m e n t ( C o n t I n U e d )
Congratulations!
Projek Lebuhraya Pantai imur Fasa 2 (JKR
On receiving the Quality Award
or
Best Construction Management 2010
or
Conventional Project Catgory(Inrastructure
or
PROJEK LEBUHRAYA PANAI IMUR FASA 2,ERENGGANU [PAKEJ 5B : DARI CH 60,000 (SERI
BANDI KE CH 67,000 (KG. CABANG] DAERAH
KEMAMAN, ERENGGANU DARUL IMAN
And we, Jurutera Perunding GEA (M Sdn. Bhd.& Mesh Engineers Sdn. Bhd. Joint Venture
are proud to be part o the project team.
Residential Fuel Cell Co-generation System
Hydrogen
Fuel Cell
1kW
Electricity
200
litres
Hot
waterElectricity
Town
Gas
Polymer electrolyte fuel cell for homes launched March 2005
Brands : Panasonic, Ebara, Sanyo, Toyota, Toshiba
ElectricityTown
Gas
How about Fuel Cell Co-generation System
Gas to Airconditioning with Electricity?
Hydrogen
Fuel Cell
? kW
Electricity
Absorption
Air
Conditioner
-
7/28/2019 The Ingenieur Vol 47 Sept 2010
20/33
t H e I n G e n I e U r v o l 4 7 S e p t e m B e r - n o v e m B e r 2 0 1 0e n g i n e e r i n g & L a W
claimed by the deendant was onlydue and payable upon receipt o such
payment by the deendant rom theemployer, because the expressionprogress payment in clause 13.01covers nal payment.
Te main issue beore the Court oAppeal or its determination was onthe true construction o clause 13.01,
particularly progress payment andwhether the nal payment claimedby the plainti ell within the ambito progress payment Clause 13.01
which read:
13.0 Progress Payment / InterimPayment
13.01Notwithstanding the provisiono Clause 27 pertaining tonominated sub-contractor and
payment or works executed,it is hereby agreed that in theevent o any interim certicatewhich includes, or nominated
sub-contract works, the paymentin respect o any work, 75%material or goods comprised inthe sub-contract shall be madeto the sub-contractor within 14days aer receipt by the MainContractor o payment certied
as due in the Interim Certicateom the Client i.e. Messrs, Ng
Chee Yee Sdn. Bhd.
DECISION OF HE COUR
Te Court o Appeal in a majoritydecision dismissed the plaintisappeal with costs; the judgmento the court being delivered by hisLordship Low Hop Bing JCA7.Aer reerring to the plainti s andthe deendants contentions and therelevant case-law cited, he said8:
Reverting to the instant appeal, inordinary parlance, progress payment
portrays any payment according toprogress i.e. the orward movemento the works. Progress paymentclearly includes a payment at any
stage, om the rst stage, to the seco ndstage, culminating in the nal stagei.e. the nal payment. Upon thetrue construction o clause 13.01, in
particular the expression progresspayment, we are o the view that it issuciently wide to include the nalpayment claimed by the plaintif, inwhich case, the plaintif is only entitledto payment aer the deendant has
been paid by the employer. Hence, weare unable to sustain the submissionpresented or the plaintif.
Concurring with the ormer, hisLordship Abdul Malik Ishak JCA, ina similar vein held in avour with thedeendants; the salient points o his
judgment being summarized below.
1. Te eect o a pay-when-paidclause will be entirely a mattero construction, requiringclear and unambiguous
words, and requiring careulconsideration o whether, ona true construction, the clauseaects the right to paymentor only the time or payment 9.Te words generally are tobe understood in their plainand literal meaning. Tis iso course, always subject toadmissible evidence being
adduced to show that thewords are to be understood insome technical or special sense.
2. Tere was no necessity toadduce any evidence tointerpret clause 13.01 becausethe words appearing in theclause are rather plain and they
clearly preclude the deendantrom paying immediately to the
plainti unless the deendantreceives payment rom theemployer.
3. In construing a writtencontract, the proessed objecto the court was to discoverthe mutual intention o the
parties10. Te int