The INTOSAI Working Group on Key National Indicators

Methodic and informational support of the visualization and assessment of KNI for the

use in SAIs activity for the purpose of international comparisons

The 5th MeetingApril 3-4, 2012, Riga

2

Development Goals Identification ProblemDevelopment Goals Identification Problem

Problem of transparencyProblem of transparency in progress measurementin progress measurement

3

Problem of the dimension of visionProblem of the dimension of vision

4

Population distributionPopulation distribution

5

By 1.01.2010 1099 cities : 13 – million citizens or more 22 – 500-1000 thousand citizens 38 – 250-500 thousand citizens 91 – 100-250 thousand citizens

23 907 municipal formations 512 urban districts 1829 municipalities 1739 towns 19591 rural settlements

Composition and availability of information presented Composition and availability of information presented by G-20 members within Mutual Assessment Processby G-20 members within Mutual Assessment Process

6

7

Global risks 2012Global risks 2012

8

Global Risks 2011Global Risks 2011

9

Version of the social metrics of progressVersion of the social metrics of progress

10

G-20 Mutual Assessment Process results G-20 Mutual Assessment Process results (case of China)(case of China)

11

G-20 Mutual Assessment Process results G-20 Mutual Assessment Process results (case of USA)(case of USA)

12

G-20 Mutual Assessment Process results G-20 Mutual Assessment Process results (case of Russia)(case of Russia)

13

Global Risks InterconnectionsGlobal Risks Interconnections

14

Analysis of the evaluated social development factorsAnalysis of the evaluated social development factors

Социальные сферы

Social spheres

Social development

Regulatingfactors

Indicators

Indicators, factors and spheres of social developmentIndicators, factors and spheres of social development

15

16

Gross National Happiness (GNH)Gross National Happiness (GNH)

OECD Better Life Index StructureOECD Better Life Index Structure

17

OECD Better Life Index in EuropeOECD Better Life Index in Europe

18

19

Analysis of the evaluated economic development Analysis of the evaluated economic development factorsfactors

WEF Global Competitiveness Index StructureWEF Global Competitiveness Index Structure

20

WEF Global Competitiveness Index in EuropeWEF Global Competitiveness Index in Europe

21

Imbalance of social and economic goals and Imbalance of social and economic goals and indicatorsindicators

22

OECD Global Project«Measurement of the progress of

society»

G20 working group on economic imbalances

• Health• Education• Jobs• Income• Life satisfaction• Community

• Public dept• Public fiscal deficits• Private savings rate• Private dept• Trade imbalance• Imbalance of net investment

income flows and transfers

Comparison of Better Life Index and Global Comparison of Better Life Index and Global Competitiveness IndexCompetitiveness Index

(case of Russia)(case of Russia)

23

24

Comparison of Better Life Index and Global Comparison of Better Life Index and Global Competitiveness IndexCompetitiveness Index

(case of Germany)(case of Germany)

25

Comparison of Better Life Index and Global Comparison of Better Life Index and Global Competitiveness IndexCompetitiveness Index

(case of Iceland)(case of Iceland)

26

Comparison of Better Life Index and Global Comparison of Better Life Index and Global Competitiveness IndexCompetitiveness Index

(case of Spain)(case of Spain)

Problem of key development indicators imbalanceProblem of key development indicators imbalance

Industrial capital

Natural capital

Human capital

National wealth

Evaluation of social indicators

Evaluation of economic indicators

Evaluation of sustainable

development

Imbalances of key

development assets

National wealth,

trillion US$

Natural capital

Industrial capital

Humancapital

Russia 10,5 42,8% 24,2% 33,3%

China 25,0 20,9% 31,3% 46,4%

USA 218,0 1,9% 13,6% 85,4%

World 708,0 6,1% 17,6% 76,5%

27

Visualization of countries current positions and Visualization of countries current positions and

development goalsdevelopment goals

28

Thank you for attentionThank you for attention!!

29