the japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘last command ......table 1. technical data of the 12cm...

29
The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan, CNMI The appearance of the gun between 1969 and 2007— Dirk HR Spennemann Institute for Land Water and Society; Charles Sturt University This brief report was written as a background document in partial response to a request for information on the possible conservation of Japanese guns on public display at the Navy Base, Guam (Bulgrin, 2017). This document provides photographic data on the appearance of the gun in June 1994, when it was photographed as part of a metal conservation course (Look & Spennemann, 1994), and on subsequent visits in 2006 and 2007. The 20cm 12 cal. Model 3 (Short) Naval Gun (1943) The sections under this heading have been extracted from an in-depth description of the 20cm Model 3 (Short) Naval Gun provided elsewhere (Spennemann, 2017d). This gun was designed as an (experimental) support weapon to be placed on light-decked armed merchant vessels over 5,000t for use against submarine (surface) attacks. While theoretically also functional as a heavy anti-aircraft weapon, U.S. intelligence services did not deem it to be very effective in that role (CinCPac– CinCPOA, 1945b, p. 60). The 20cm guns had a moderate range of 6,900 yards. The guns are described as of light weight, having an interrupted thread breech block and a hydro-spring recoil mechanism with the recoil cylinder mounted on the top of the gun. The gun was mounted on a navy-type pedestal mount capable of a 360º traverse. Elevating and traversing occurred by hand wheels, both located on the left side of the mount. The rate of traverse when operated by hand was approximately 8.6°/sec, while the rate of elevation was 8°/sec, making it a slow weapon for anti-aircraft fire (CinCPac–CinCPOA, 1945b, p. 60; OPNAV, 1945, p. 58; USNTMJ, 1946b, p. 16). The gun was not fitted with individual fire control systems (USNTMJ, 1946b, p. 16). From available data it appears that one person could operate the weapon, even though the standard complement appears to have been nine, including gun layers and ammunition handlers. With a full complement, a rate of four rounds per minute could be sustained. The technical data for the gun have been summarised in Table 1. Post-World War II assessment of guns and gun mounts held by the Kure Naval Arsenal showed that the gun was constructed in three subtypes or variants (USNTMJ, 1946b, p. 10), the details of which appear not to be documented. The ammunition required for the gun was semi-fixed and consisted of a 103 (134) pound shell and a Cu-alloy cartridge (7.2lb) containing the propellant (CinCPac–CinCPOA, 1945a, p. 103; OPNAV, 1945, p. 61; U.S. War Office, 1953, p. 505; USNTMJ, 1946a, p. 13). Even through primarily designed as a naval weapon to be carried afloat, the 20cm short naval gun found intensive use as a coastal defence weapon in the late stages of the Pacific War (see below for locations). They were sited in a variety of emplacements: open emplacements, similar to those used for other calibres, open earth covered emplacements, concrete revetments, concrete reinforced casemates and cave positions with concrete or coral boulder embrasures. The local environment governed the choice of emplacement and concealment. Preferred citation for this document: Spennemann, Dirk HR (2017) The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan, CNMI. The appearance of the gun in 1994 and 2007. Albury NSW: Institute for Land Water and Society; Charles Sturt University.

Upload: others

Post on 26-Apr-2021

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command ......Table 1. Technical data of the 12cm and 20cm short naval guns. Gun details. Various sources 200mm Short” Model 3rd

TheJapanese20cmdualpurposegunatthe‘LastCommandPost’,Marpi,Saipan,CNMI

– Theappearanceofthegunbetween1969and2007—

DirkHRSpennemannInstituteforLandWaterandSociety;CharlesSturtUniversity†

This brief report was written as a background document in partial response to a request for information on the possible conservation of Japanese guns on public display at the Navy Base, Guam (Bulgrin, 2017). This document provides photographic data on the appearance of the gun in June 1994, when it was photographed as part of a metal conservation course (Look & Spennemann, 1994), and on subsequent visits in 2006 and 2007.

The 20cm 12 cal. Model 3 (Short) Naval Gun (1943) The sections under this heading have been extracted from an in-depth description of the 20cm Model 3 (Short) Naval Gun provided elsewhere (Spennemann, 2017d).

This gun was designed as an (experimental) support weapon to be placed on light-decked armed merchant vessels over 5,000t for use against submarine (surface) attacks. While theoretically also functional as a heavy anti-aircraft weapon, U.S. intelligence services did not deem it to be very effective in that role (CinCPac–CinCPOA, 1945b, p. 60). The 20cm guns had a moderate range of 6,900 yards. The guns are described as of light weight, having an interrupted thread breech block and a hydro-spring recoil mechanism with the recoil cylinder mounted on the top of the gun. The gun was mounted on a navy-type pedestal mount capable of a 360º traverse. Elevating and traversing occurred by hand wheels, both located on the left side of the mount. The rate of traverse when operated by hand was approximately 8.6°/sec, while the rate of elevation was 8°/sec, making it a slow weapon for anti-aircraft fire (CinCPac–CinCPOA, 1945b, p. 60; OPNAV, 1945, p. 58; USNTMJ, 1946b, p. 16). The gun was not fitted with individual fire control systems (USNTMJ, 1946b, p. 16).

From available data it appears that one person could operate the weapon, even though the standard complement appears to have been nine, including gun layers and ammunition handlers. With a full complement, a rate of four rounds per minute could be sustained. The technical data for the gun have been summarised in Table 1. Post-World War II assessment of guns and gun mounts held by the Kure Naval Arsenal showed that the gun was constructed in three subtypes or variants (USNTMJ, 1946b, p. 10), the details of which appear not to be documented. The ammunition required for the gun was semi-fixed and consisted of a 103 (134) pound shell and a Cu-alloy cartridge (7.2lb) containing the propellant (CinCPac–CinCPOA, 1945a, p. 103; OPNAV, 1945, p. 61; U.S. War Office, 1953, p. 505; USNTMJ, 1946a, p. 13).

Even through primarily designed as a naval weapon to be carried afloat, the 20cm short naval gun found intensive use as a coastal defence weapon in the late stages of the Pacific War (see below for locations). They were sited in a variety of emplacements: open emplacements, similar to those used for other calibres, open earth covered emplacements, concrete revetments, concrete reinforced casemates and cave positions with concrete or coral boulder embrasures. The local environment governed the choice of emplacement and concealment.

Preferred citation for this document: Spennemann, Dirk HR (2017) The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan, CNMI. The appearance of the gun in 1994 and 2007. Albury NSW: Institute for Land Water and Society; Charles Sturt University.

Page 2: The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command ......Table 1. Technical data of the 12cm and 20cm short naval guns. Gun details. Various sources 200mm Short” Model 3rd

Dirk HR Spennemann, The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan

—2—

Fig. 1. Top view of a 200mm short naval gun in operation (OPNAV, 1945, p. 58)

. Fig. 2. Wartime photograph of a 20cm Short Naval Gun in an open emplacement (CinCPac–CinCPOA, 1945b)

The short-barrelled 20cm guns have been reported as coastal defence guns from Western Micronesia, such as Peleliu, Palau (Denfeld, 1988, p. 71); Saipan (this report) and especially from Guam, where they are on record for: Bangi Point, Guam (Denfeld, 1992, p. 51); ‘Gongna Beach (‘Gun Beach’), Tumon Bay, Guam (Spennemann, 2017a); Dungcas Beach, Tamuning, Guam (in replica emplacements on the grounds of the Onwards Beach Hotel) (Spennemann, 2017e); Naval Magazine, Guam (on display)(Spennemann, 2017c); and Ga’an Point, Agat, Guam (on public display)(Spennemann, 2017b).

Page 3: The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command ......Table 1. Technical data of the 12cm and 20cm short naval guns. Gun details. Various sources 200mm Short” Model 3rd

Dirk HR Spennemann, The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan

—3—

Table 1. Technical data of the 12cm and 20cm short naval guns. Gun details. Various sources

200mm Short” Model 3rd Year Year 1943 Manufacturer Kure Naval Yard Calibre (mm) 203 Calibre (inch) 8 Length overall (inch/cm) 100/252 Length of barrel (inch/cm)1 95.9/243.8 Height overall (inch) Length of bore (inch) 80 Length of bore (calibres) 12 Weight with breech (lbs/kg)

1,390/630

Weight overall (lbs/kg) 1,702/772 Muzzle velocity (ft/sec , m/sec)

1,016 / 305

Max range horizontal (yds/ m)

6,900 / 6,300

Max range vertical (feet / m)

10,800 / 3,300

Effective range vertical (ft) 9,000 Maximum rate of fire 4-5 Practical rate of fire 3 Approximate Lifespan 2000 service rounds Traverse 360° Elevation 75° Depression –15º Rate of Traverse 8.6°/sec (hand) Rate of Elevation 8°/sec (hand) Breech system interrupted screw

200mm Short” Chamber length (in / cm) 16.1 / 39.5 Chamber volume (cu.in / l) 891 / 14.6 Length of recoil (inch) 10 Type of rifling raised Nº of lands 32 Groove depth (mm) 1.5 Rifling system left turn,

increasing 1/30 to 1/13

Recoil system hydro-spring number of guns manufactured

ca 250

Loading angle 10º Loading support land-based: simple

derricks ships: cargo hoists

Ramming by hand Type of ammunition semi-fixed round Type of projectile anti-aircraft,

armour piercing, high explosive,

incendiary, incendiary shrapnel

Weight of projectile (lb /kgs)

HE 103 / 47

Type of charge casing brass, later steel Weight of charge (lbs / kg) 4.4 / 2 Type of mount pedestal Total weight (tons) 3.5 (4.1)

Short 20cm Naval Guns on Saipan At the time of the US landings in Saipan, a total of ten short 20cm guns was encountered on the island. Four of these were emplaced in two battery positions, while six were stored at the Garapan Naval Depot in at Tanapag Harbour.2 No serial numbers seem to have been recorded. Both gun batteries were under construction at the time of the US landings. The battery at the southern end of Laolao Bay was accompanied by a completed heavy reinforced concrete magazine, with the second under construction (Wilson, 1944, p. 3). The battery at the northern end comprised of reinforced concrete emplacements under construction. The ammunition magazines for each weapon were placed in tunnels dug into the limestone in cliff to the rear, furnished with concrete bulkheads and steel doors (Wilson, 1944, p. 4). Ø Southern end of Laolao Bay3 (two guns in open emplacements, with a 360º arc of fire, today removed) (Wilson,

1944, p. 3); Ø Northern end of Laolao Bay (two guns in partially completed concrete emplacements, with a 180º arc of fire,

today removed) (OPNAV, 1945; Wilson, 1944, p. 4). In addition, one concrete-reinforced underground ammunition magazine had been built (Fig. 11, Fig. 15).

Ø Garapan Naval Depot at Tanapag (six guns) (Wilson, 1944, p. 1).

Images exist of three different guns (Fig. 9–Fig. 10). Based on the background visible in some images, they could be attributed to the northern or southern gun batteries at Laolao Bay. For reference in this report,

Page 4: The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command ......Table 1. Technical data of the 12cm and 20cm short naval guns. Gun details. Various sources 200mm Short” Model 3rd

Dirk HR Spennemann, The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan

—4—

these guns have been arbitrarily numbered. At the time of writing, no images have been located showing any of the six the guns kept at the Garapan Naval Depot at Tanapag.

Fig. 3. Spatial distribution of short 20cm guns on Saipan. 1–‘Last Command Post’ at Marpi; 2–Garapan Naval Depot; 3–

northern battery, Laolao Beach; 4–southern battery, Laolao Beach.

2

4

3

1

Page 5: The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command ......Table 1. Technical data of the 12cm and 20cm short naval guns. Gun details. Various sources 200mm Short” Model 3rd

Dirk HR Spennemann, The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan

—5—

Fig. 4. A short 20cm gun in an unfinished reinforced concrete emplacement at the northern end of Laolao Bay, Saipan (Wilson,

1944, p. 52). (Laolao North nº 1)

Fig. 5. A short 20cm gun in an unfinished reinforced concrete emplacement at the northern end of Laolao Bay, Saipan Source¶¶

Same gun as Fig. 4 (Laolao North nº 1).

Page 6: The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command ......Table 1. Technical data of the 12cm and 20cm short naval guns. Gun details. Various sources 200mm Short” Model 3rd

Dirk HR Spennemann, The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan

—6—

Fig. 6. A short 20cm gun in an unfinished reinforced concrete emplacement at the northern end of Laolao Bay, Saipan (USMC

89-971)4

Fig. 7. A short 20cm gun in an unfinished reinforced concrete emplacement at the northern end of Laolao Bay, Saipan ((detail of

image above)5

Page 7: The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command ......Table 1. Technical data of the 12cm and 20cm short naval guns. Gun details. Various sources 200mm Short” Model 3rd

Dirk HR Spennemann, The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan

—7—

Fig. 8. A short 20cm gun in an unfinished state of assembly at the northern end of Laolao Bay, Saipan.

(US National Archives 80-G-307741) (Laolao North nº 2)

Page 8: The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command ......Table 1. Technical data of the 12cm and 20cm short naval guns. Gun details. Various sources 200mm Short” Model 3rd

Dirk HR Spennemann, The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan

—8—

Fig. 9. A Short 20cm gun in an open emplacement at the southern end of Laolao Bay (Wilson, 1944, p. 36).

This is the same gun as that shown in Fig. 2 (Laolao South nº 1)

Page 9: The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command ......Table 1. Technical data of the 12cm and 20cm short naval guns. Gun details. Various sources 200mm Short” Model 3rd

Dirk HR Spennemann, The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan

—9—

Fig. 10. A short 20cm gun in an open emplacement on Saipan. Source: (2nd Armored Amphibian Battalion Association,

1991). Location unstated, possibly the southern end of Laolao Bay. (Laolao South nº 2)

Page 10: The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command ......Table 1. Technical data of the 12cm and 20cm short naval guns. Gun details. Various sources 200mm Short” Model 3rd

Dirk HR Spennemann, The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan

—10—

Fig. 11. Concrete reinforced ammunition magazine of the Short 20cm guns at the southern end of Laolao Bay, Saipan (Wilson,

1944, p. 37)

Page 11: The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command ......Table 1. Technical data of the 12cm and 20cm short naval guns. Gun details. Various sources 200mm Short” Model 3rd

Dirk HR Spennemann, The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan

—11—

Fig. 12. Concrete reinforced ammunition magazine of the Short 20cm guns at the southern end of Laolao Bay, Saipan (Wilson,

1944, p. 38)

Page 12: The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command ......Table 1. Technical data of the 12cm and 20cm short naval guns. Gun details. Various sources 200mm Short” Model 3rd

Dirk HR Spennemann, The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan

—12—

Fig. 13. Concrete reinforced ammunition magazine of the Short 20cm guns at the northern end of Laolao Bay, Saipan (Wilson,

1944, p. 54)

Page 13: The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command ......Table 1. Technical data of the 12cm and 20cm short naval guns. Gun details. Various sources 200mm Short” Model 3rd

Dirk HR Spennemann, The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan

—13—

Fig. 14. Concrete reinforced ammunition magazine of the Short 20cm guns at the northern end of Laolao Bay, Saipan (Wilson,

1944, p. 55)

Page 14: The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command ......Table 1. Technical data of the 12cm and 20cm short naval guns. Gun details. Various sources 200mm Short” Model 3rd

Dirk HR Spennemann, The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan

—14—

Fig. 15. Entrance to the ammunition magazine of the Short 20cm gun battery at the northern end of Laolao Bay, Saipan

(Wilson, 1944, p. 53)

Background to the gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan, CNMI The Marpi area, which had been the focus of heavy US bombardment prior to and during invasion (Hofman, 1950) was off-limits for the Saipan population during the 1950s and early 1960s (as a reputed CIA training ground, Wootten, 1984). The area was largely cleared of unexploded ordinance in the mid–1960s, with the project completed in 1968. It appears that the lead contractor, Steve ‘Chief’ Aiken, accumulated a number of Japanese equipment taken from various parts of Saipan and positioned them at Marpi (pers. comm. Scott Russell). Today, the area is called the Banadero Memorial Park. A photo of the area, dating to 1969 (Fig. 16), shows a number of items:6 Ø Short 20cm / 12 cal naval gun Ø 12cm / 45 cal 10th year type dual purpose gun (3 guns, one with a blown barrel) Ø Type 95 Ha Go Light Tank Ø Torpedo (motor and compressed air cylinder only, warhead missing) Ø 14 cm/50 3rd Year Type naval gun without turret Ø 47 mm Type 1 Anti-Tank gun7 Ø narrow gauge flat-bed railway car from one of the sugar trains Ø artillery shells (no longer extant)

The bottom of Suicide Cliff (north cliff face of Mount Marpi) with the associated Japanese defense structures soon became a tourist attraction and was developed as such by the Marianas Visitor’s Bureau.8 In 1984, Marpi Point was nominated to the US National Register of Historic Places (Thompson, 1984), but the artefact collection at Marpi was not mentioned. An assessment of Japanese tourists and their experiences found that World War II sites in the CNMI, among them the ‘Last Command Post,’ were regarded as significant attractions to Japanese holiday makers of the post-World War II generations (Sayers & Spennemann, 2006a,

Page 15: The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command ......Table 1. Technical data of the 12cm and 20cm short naval guns. Gun details. Various sources 200mm Short” Model 3rd

Dirk HR Spennemann, The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan

—15—

2006c), with a high rate of visitation (Sayers & Spennemann, 2006b). Both local Micronesian decision makers, as well high school and college students saw World War II sites generally as less significant (Spennemann, 2003; Spennemann, Look, & Graham, 2002), with concomitant issues of interpretation given the vastly different viewpoints of the combatants, as well as islanders on whose soil the war was fought (for generic dissonance of the issues, see Spennemann, 1992; for interpretation, see Spennemann, 2001).

Fig. 16. The war relics display at Marpi, Saipan in 1969.9.

Page 16: The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command ......Table 1. Technical data of the 12cm and 20cm short naval guns. Gun details. Various sources 200mm Short” Model 3rd

Dirk HR Spennemann, The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan

—16—

Fig. 17. The short 20cm gun at the war relics display at Marpi, Saipan in 1969 (detail of Fig. 16).

Fig. 18. The short 20cm gun at the war relics display at Marpi, Saipan in the 1970s.10

Page 17: The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command ......Table 1. Technical data of the 12cm and 20cm short naval guns. Gun details. Various sources 200mm Short” Model 3rd

Dirk HR Spennemann, The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan

—17—

Fig. 19. The 20cm gun at Marpi in the 1980s.11

An image taken in the 1980s (Fig. 19) shows that the cap of the hydraulic fluid (oil) tank for the recoil cylinder is missing, as are the breechblock, the ammunition cradle at the right, and the gun laying mechanism, as well as elevation and traversing wheels at the left; and the swing arm shell loading mechanism at the rear. From the available imagery it appears that all those sections of the gun had been removed that could be transported away without too much effort. It is reasonable to assume that this was caused by scrap metal collectors prior to the relocation of the gun from its original position to the artefact display at Marpi.

A defining feature of the gun is that the barrel has slid back to the maximum extent of the recoil. This is the only instance of that kind among the extant guns in Micronesia (compare Spennemann, 2017a, 2017b, 2017c, 2017d, 2017e). Such a slide-back only occurs when a) the hydro-pneumatic recoil mechanism, which relies on hydraulic fluid and compressed air, is interrupted and b) the barrel is sufficiently elevated. When the cap of the hydraulic fluid (oil) tank of the recoil cylinder was removed, the pressure would have been lost, allowing the barrel to slide back. This did not happen with the other guns, as by the time the hydraulic hoses and/or the hydraulic fluid had sufficiently corroded for the cylinder to lose pressure, crevice corrosion had occurred between the barrel and the cradle, thus ensuring that the barrel was, in essence, rusted shut in it position. Taken together, this would suggest that the scrap metal removal occurred soon after the war.

An image taken in the 1980s (Fig. 19) also shows that both U-bolts are lacking. It is not clear whether this occurred during war-time or whether it is due to scrap-metal removal. The identification of the exact gun is made difficult by the fact that there appear to be no images of the six guns kept at the Japanese naval depot at Garapan. The only images in hand are those of the four guns emplaced in the two batteries at Laolao Bay (see above). Assuming that the angle of the guns was not significantly modified by US soldiers, then the gun arbitrarily labelled as Laolao North nº 2 appears to be the source gun. That gun already lacks the U-bolts in the wartime image.

Page 18: The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command ......Table 1. Technical data of the 12cm and 20cm short naval guns. Gun details. Various sources 200mm Short” Model 3rd

Dirk HR Spennemann, The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan

—18—

Pattern of corrosion While corrosion is accelerated in tropical environments, this is particularly the case for coastal defence guns. Due to their primary purpose, such guns are emplaced at the shoreline and therefore continually exposed to salt-laden, moist air (Look & Spennemann, 1996). In the case of the four 20cm guns originally emplaced at Laulau Bay, the situation is exacerbated by the fact that Laulau Bay faces east and thus is exposed to continual trade wind driven swell. That swell braking at the shoreline, combined with the trade winds, means that salt laden air is continually blown inland, both at water level and at elevated locales.

The situation is often further exacerbated by encroaching vegetation, which maintains a humid microclimate (Spennemann & Look, 2006). Tropical plants readily colonise concrete and other structures, dispersed by a range of vectors (Spennemann & Lorence, 2006). The environmental conditions are such that conservation management in situ is likely to result in substandard treatment, requiring the gun to be temporarily relocated to a semi-climate controlled facility (Look & Spennemann, 1993, 1994).

The first known image of the gun on display at Marpi (Fig. 18) shows corrosion on the bottom part of the pedestal, with limited corrosion on the bottom part of the barrel and the gun mount and the recoil cylinder. A dark blue-black paint seems to cover the muzzle end of the barrel as well as some of the gun. There are but few data on the nature of Japanese war-time anti-corrosion paints. The majority of the anti-corrosion paints seem to have been zinc-oxide rather than lead oxide based.12

By the 1980s the main section of the gun had become heavily corroded (Fig. 19) while the gun barrel seems to be, by and large, intact. This suggests that prior to placement at Marpi the pedestal was exposed to conditions that were more favourable to corrosion, presumably encroaching vegetation.

An image taken in 2000 shows heavy corrosion of the pedestal mount and the underside of the gun barrel (Fig. 20, Fig. 31). A flame tree (Brachychiton acerifolius) is growing next to and shading the gun, maintaining more shade and thus a moist microclimate. Whipper snippers are used by staff of the Marianas Visitor’s Authority to maintain the grounds of the Japanese Command Post. Soil build up, derived from decaying mowed vegetation, occurs primarily on the left side of the gun. This meant that the wheeled turntable of the pedestal mount is buried and perpetually remains moist. The barrel shows iron-oxide being carried by moisture from spot corrosion locations to the underside of the barrel and from there to the recoil cylinder. The muzzle face itself seems to exhibit limited decay (Fig. 20, Fig. 21).

By 2003 the front left panel was no longer connected to the base, indicating substantial loss of supportive strength (Fig. 21–Fig. 22). Parts of the front right panel were likewise corroded. The rear section of the gun, and the gun barrel shows widespread corrosion

By late 2005 the gun had been repainted in a faux camouflage scheme of large patches of battleship grey and desert sand yellow (Fig. 33).13 Historic imagery of Japanese coastal defense guns shows little evidence of camouflage paint schemes and land-based naval guns. It appears that the gun was painted without much treatment of the metal surfaces.14 The most incongruous part of the efforts by the Marianas Visitor’s Authority seems to be that the paint scheme was carried out throughout, with every part of the display, including the torpedo, painted in camouflage. Corrosion had reappeared in full only two years later (Fig. 34), indicating that the metal surfaces had not been treated prior to paining in 2005.

The image of the 20cm naval gun taken in the mid 2010s shows the gun repainted in light grey (Fig. 25), with incipient corrosion on the barrel and the gun cradle.. The pedestal, however, shows substantial loss of fabric on the bottom front as well as the right rear (Fig. 25). By 2017 the widespread corrosion had remerged indicating that, as earlier, the metal surfaces had not been treated prior to painting in 2014.

Page 19: The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command ......Table 1. Technical data of the 12cm and 20cm short naval guns. Gun details. Various sources 200mm Short” Model 3rd

Dirk HR Spennemann, The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan

—19—

Fig. 20. Frontal view of the 20cm gun at Marpi in October 2000

Fig. 21. Frontal view of the 20cm gun at Marpi in September 2003

Fig. 22. The 20cm gun at Marpi as seen from the front left

in September 2003 Fig. 23. The 20cm gun at Marpi as seen from the front

left in September 2007

Page 20: The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command ......Table 1. Technical data of the 12cm and 20cm short naval guns. Gun details. Various sources 200mm Short” Model 3rd

Dirk HR Spennemann, The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan

—20—

Fig. 24. The 20cm gun at Marpi as seen from the front left

in December 2014.15 Fig. 25. Frontal view of the 20cm gun at Marpi in ca

201416

Fig. 26. The 20cm gun at Marpi as seen from the right left

in September 2007 Fig. 27. The pedestal of the 20cm gun at Marpi as seen

from the right in September 2007

Page 21: The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command ......Table 1. Technical data of the 12cm and 20cm short naval guns. Gun details. Various sources 200mm Short” Model 3rd

Dirk HR Spennemann, The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan

—21—

Fig. 28. The 20cm gun at Marpi as seen from the rear left in September 2007

Fig. 29. The 20cm gun at Marpi as seen from the left left

in September 2007 Fig. 30. The oil reservoir of the 20cm gun at Marpi as

seen from the front right in September 2007

Page 22: The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command ......Table 1. Technical data of the 12cm and 20cm short naval guns. Gun details. Various sources 200mm Short” Model 3rd

Dirk HR Spennemann, The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan

—22—

Fig. 31. The 20cm gun at Marpi as seen from the right in October 2000

Fig. 32. The 20cm gun at Marpi as seen from the right in September 2003

Page 23: The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command ......Table 1. Technical data of the 12cm and 20cm short naval guns. Gun details. Various sources 200mm Short” Model 3rd

Dirk HR Spennemann, The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan

—23—

Fig. 33. The 20cm gun at Marpi as seen from the right in September 2005

Fig. 34. The 20cm gun at Marpi as seen from the right in September 2007

Page 24: The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command ......Table 1. Technical data of the 12cm and 20cm short naval guns. Gun details. Various sources 200mm Short” Model 3rd

Dirk HR Spennemann, The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan

—24—

Fig. 35. The 20cm gun at Marpi as seen from the right in March 201717

Fig. 36. The 20cm gun at Marpi as seen from the front right in September 2007

Page 25: The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command ......Table 1. Technical data of the 12cm and 20cm short naval guns. Gun details. Various sources 200mm Short” Model 3rd

Dirk HR Spennemann, The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan

—25—

Fig. 37. The 20cm gun at Marpi as seen from the rear left in September 2007

Fig. 38. The 20cm gun at Marpi as seen from the rear right in September 2007

Page 26: The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command ......Table 1. Technical data of the 12cm and 20cm short naval guns. Gun details. Various sources 200mm Short” Model 3rd

Dirk HR Spennemann, The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan

—26—

Fig. 39. The interior of the barrel of the 20cm gun at Marpi as seen from the front right in September 2003

Page 27: The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command ......Table 1. Technical data of the 12cm and 20cm short naval guns. Gun details. Various sources 200mm Short” Model 3rd

Dirk HR Spennemann, The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan

—27—

Acknowledgments I am indebted to the following for the supply of historic images of the 20cm gun at Marpi: Joe Butters (Saipan, CNMI); Bryan Chernick (Bothell, WA); Scott Russell (Saipan, CNMI).

Endnotes

† Contact of the author: Dirk HR Spennemann, Institute for Land Water and Society; Charles Sturt University; PO Box 789; Albury NSW 2640, Australia. E-mail: [email protected].

1. Breech face to muzzle. 2. There is frequent reference to three 8-inch guns on railway cars ready to be emplaced (e.g. image caption

in Hofman, 1950, p. 12). The guns were in fact 140mm coastal defense guns (Wilson, 1944, p. 1). 3. In war-time documents referred under the old appellation as ‘Magicienne Bay.’— Both guns in this battery

had breechblocks removed by Japanese forces (Wilson, 1944, p. 3). 4 . Image scan courtesy War in the Pacific National Park, Guam. 5. The image was also reproduced in (OPNAV, 1945, p. 60). 6. The equipment displayed at Marpi is only a fraction of the Japanese armament present at the time of the

US landings. Wilson (1944, p. 1) notes a large number of guns, both emplaced and in storage. In addition, a number of artillery and tanks are known:

Type Garapan Naval Depot

Near Emplacements

Emplaced and ready Total

6-inch naval British 1900 8 8

14cm/50 naval 46 9 13

12.7 cm/50 Type 3 naval 3 3

12cm/45 DP 32 3 20 55

20cm/12 short DP 6 4 10

80mm AA 3 3

75mm AA 8 8

25mm AA fixed ? ?

25mm AA mobile ? ?

13mm AA fixed6 4+ 4+

150mm howitzer 4+ 4+

75mm mountain gun 4+ 4+

Tank Type 97 Chi-Ha 31 31

Tank Type 97 ShinHoTo Chi-Ha 4 4

Tank Type 95 Ha-Go 12+ 12+

Type Type 2 Ka Mi 4+ 4+

7 . (MID, 1945, p. 82; Office of the Chief of Ordnance, 1945, p. 106) 8. Today the Marianas Visitors Authority. 9. Image personal collection Scott Russell. 10. Source: “War Memorials at Marpi, Saipan: Last Command Post and Peace Memorial at Suicide Cliff.

Mostly 1970s. Trust Territory of the Pacific Islands Archives, Reel 2550. Image 2550.03. 11. Image sourced from Resture (2012). No attribution or reference given in that source. 12. A post-war mission to assess the Japanese naval paints (USNTMJ, 1946c) collected a number of zinc-

oxide paints from the Kure Naval Yard, originating from four manufacturers: Chugoku anticorrosive paint No. l (manufactured by Chugoku Paint Co, Hiroshima |中国塗料(株)); Nippon Yushi anticorrosive paint, general purpose; and ‘Takata’ anticorrosive paint No. l (manufactured by Nippon Yushi KK, Osaka |日本油脂(株)); and ‘Suboid’ anticorrosive paint (USNTMJ, 1946c, p. 11). Some chemical compositions are given (USNTMJ, 1946c, p. 21ff).

13. It would appear that these were paints readily available from Navy stores or similar sources. 14. The date of the painting could not be ascertained at the time of writing. 15. Image courtesy of Bryan Chernick. https://www.flickr.com/photos/60348236@N07/15445370703

Page 28: The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command ......Table 1. Technical data of the 12cm and 20cm short naval guns. Gun details. Various sources 200mm Short” Model 3rd

Dirk HR Spennemann, The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan

—28—

16. Image courtesy Joe Butters (Saipan, CNMI). 17. Image courtesy of Flickr user ‘kummerle’’ https://www.flickr.com/photos/33461472@N05/

33130514080. ¶

References 2nd Armored Amphibian Battalion Association. (1991, 2011). 2nd Armored Amphibian Battalion - Saipan. URL:

http://2ndarmoredamphibianbattalion.com/saipan/. [Retrieved on Apr 20, 2017] Bulgrin, Lon. (2017). Metal Conservation of Japanese WWII Guns. Personal Communication. e-mail to Dirk

HR Spennemann, dated Apr 14, 2017. CinCPac–CinCPOA. (1945a). Anti-aircraft defense fortifications. Special Translations No. 62. CinCPac–

CinCPOA Bulletin, 110-45. CinCPac–CinCPOA. (1945b). Japanese Artillery weapons. CinCPac–CinCPOA Bulletin, 152-45. Denfeld, Duane Colt. (1988). Peleliu revisited. An historical and archaeological survey of World War II sites

on Peleliu Island. Micronesian Archaeological Survey Report. Nº 24. Saipan: Historic Preservation Office, Trust Territory of the Pacific Islands.

Denfeld, Duane Colt. (1992). Japanese fortifications and other military structures in the Central Pacific. Micronesian Archaeological Survey Report. Nº 9 (reprint). Saipan: Historic Preservation Office, Trust Territory of the Pacific Islands.

Hofman, Carl W. (1950). Saipan. The Beginning of the End. Marine Corps Monographs. Washington. D.C.: U.S. Marine Corps, Historical Division Headquarters.

Look, David W., & Spennemann, Dirk H.R. (1993). Saving WWII Historic Sites. Metals Conservation Course in the Marshall Islands. CRM Bulletin, 16(5), 22-24.

Look, David W., & Spennemann, Dirk H.R. (1994). Preparing for the 50th anniversary of Guam Liberation. Metals Conservation Course and Demonstration Project. CRM Bulletin, 17(8), 35-36.

Look, David W., & Spennemann, Dirk H.R. (1996). In a tropical marine climate: Conservation Management of Historic Metals. APT Bulletin, 27(1–2), 60–68.

MID. (1945). Japanese Tank and Anti-Tank Warfare. Special Series, no. 34. Washington D.C: Military Intelligence Division, War Department,.

Office of the Chief of Ordnance. (1945). Catalog of enemy ordnance materiel. Office of the Chief of Ordnance.

OPNAV. (1945). Japanese antiaircraft & coastal defense guns. Photographic Intelligence Center Report nº3 [OPNAV 16-VP103]. Washington: Air Intelligence Group, Division of Naval Intelligence, Office of the Chief of Naval Operations, Navy Department.

Resture, Jane. (2012). Saipan. URL: http://www.janeresture.com/saipan/index.htm. Sayers, Elizabeth, & Spennemann, Dirk H.R. (2006a). The Attitudes of Japanese Tourists towards Cultural

heritage attractions in the CNMI. Micronesian Journal of the Humanities and Social Sciences, 5(1/2), 386-397.

Sayers, Elizabeth, & Spennemann, Dirk H.R. (2006b). Cultural heritage attractions in the CNMI: Visitor Satisfaction and Experiences of Japanese Tourists. Micronesian Journal of the Humanities and Social Sciences, 5(1/2), 398–410.

Sayers, Elizabeth, & Spennemann, Dirk H.R. (2006c). The Role of Cultural Attractions in the Motivations and Awareness Spectrum of Japanese Tourists in the CNMI. Micronesian Journal of the Humanities and Social Sciences, 5(1/2), 373-385.

Spennemann, Dirk H.R. (1992). World War II Remains on Central Pacific Islands: Perceptions of Heritage versus Priorities of Preservation. The Pacific Review, 5(3), 278-290.

Spennemann, Dirk H.R. (2001). Memories, Memorabilia and Monuments: Private, Territorial and Federal Interpretations of the Pacific War in Guam. In D. H. R. Spennemann & N. Putt (Eds.), Cultural Interpretation of Heritage Sites in the Pacific (pp. 49-68). Suva, Fiji: Pacific Islands Museums Association/Association des Musées des Îles du Pacifique.

Spennemann, Dirk H.R. (2003). Teacher and Student perceptions of the cultural heritage of the CNMI. An empirical snap-shot. Micronesian Journal of the Humanities and Social Sciences, 2(1–2), 50–58.

Spennemann, Dirk H.R. (2017a). The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at ‘Gun Beach’, Tumon, Guam. The appearance of the gun in 1994 and 2007. Albury NSW: Institute for Land Water and Society; Charles Sturt University.

Spennemann, Dirk H.R. (2017b). The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at Ga’an Point, Agat, Guam. The appearance of the gun 1994 to 2009. Albury NSW: Institute for Land Water and Society; Charles Sturt University.

Page 29: The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command ......Table 1. Technical data of the 12cm and 20cm short naval guns. Gun details. Various sources 200mm Short” Model 3rd

Dirk HR Spennemann, The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the ‘Last Command Post’, Marpi, Saipan

—29—

Spennemann, Dirk H.R. (2017c). The Japanese 20cm dual purpose gun at the Naval Magazine, Guam. The appearance of the gun in June 1994. Albury NSW: Institute for Land Water and Society; Charles Sturt University.

Spennemann, Dirk H.R. (2017d). The Japanese short-barrelled 12cm and 20cm dual purpose naval guns. Their technical details, war-time distribution and surviving examples. Institute for Land, Water and Society Report vol. 104. Albury NSW: Institute for Land Water and Society; Charles Sturt University.

Spennemann, Dirk H.R. (2017e). The short Japanese 20cm dual purpose guns at Dungcas Beach, Tamuning, Guam. Appearance and state of conservation of the guns in 1994 and 2007. Albury NSW: Institute for Land Water and Society; Charles Sturt University.

Spennemann, Dirk H.R., & Look, David W. (2006). Impact of Tropical vegetation On World War II-Era cultural resources in the Marshall Islands. Micronesian Journal of the Humanities and Social Sciences, 5(1/2), 440–462.

Spennemann, Dirk H.R., Look, David W., & Graham, Kristy. (2002). Heritage Ecotourism in Micronesia: What do Decision Makers expect? . Pacific Tourism Review, 6(1), 51-61.

Spennemann, Dirk H.R., & Lorence, David. (2006). Weed infestation and its impact on the preservation of a Japanese-era concrete building in Micronesia. The Agricultural Research Station, Pwunso, Nett, Pohnpei. Micronesian Journal of the Humanities and Social Sciences, 5(1/2), 458–471.

Thompson, Erwin F. (1984). Landing Beaches, Aslito/lsley Field, and Marpi Point, Saipan Island. National Register of Historic Places Registartion Form. Nº 76001965. Washington, DC: United States Department of the interior, National Park Service.

U.S. War Office. (1953). Japanese Explosive Ordnance. (Bombs, Bomb fuzes, Land mines, Grenades, Firing devices and Sabotage devices). TM 9-1985-4/TO 39B1A-11. Washington, DC: U.S. General Printing Office.

USNTMJ. (1946a). Japanese Naval Guns. Intelligence Targets Japan (DNI) of 4 September 1945. Nº Fascicle O-1, Target O-54(N). San Francisco, CA: U.S. Naval Technical Mission to Japan.

USNTMJ. (1946b). Japanese Naval Guns and Mounts. Article 1 Mounts under 18”. Intelligence Targets Japan (DNI) of 4 September 1945. Nº Fascicle O-1, Target O-46(N) and O-47(N). San Francisco, CA: U.S. Naval Technical Mission to Japan.

USNTMJ. (1946c). Japanese Navy Paints. Intelligence Targets Japan (DNI) of 4 September 1945. Nº Fascicle A-1, Target S-59. San Francisco, CA: U.S. Naval Technical Mission to Japan.

Wilson, Vincent A. (1944). Report on Japanese defensive plan for the island of Saipan, Southern Marianas. Engineer Expeditionary Troops (Task Force 56). s.l.: Map Repro Unit, USS Rocky Mount.

Wootten, AV. (1984). The CIA's spy school on Saipan. Glimpses of Micronesia, 24(4), 25-26.