the law and the lawyer
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
1/130
M.K. Gandhi
The Law and The Lawyer
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
2/130
Section I Gandhiji as a student of
Law
Passed matriculation in 1887 from
Ahmedabad
Unable to pursue one term at college in
Bhavnagar: felt at sea, unable to comprehend
what was being taught
Mavji Dave, a family friend, came up with the
suggestion of sending him to England to
pursue law and become a barrister
Gandhiji preferred medicine over law as a
career choice
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
3/130
Religious hindrances in the pursuit ofmedicine
Family flummoxed by the idea of a foreign
land, the necessary financial input. It is decided to consult the elderly uncle
staying in Porbandar
The elderly uncle consents to what heconsiders as an irreligious act
attempts to get some scholarship from Mr.
Lely and fails
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
4/130
Mother has misgivings regarding all the evils
of western civilization
Gandhiji is made to swear the 3 sacred vows
forsaking wine, woman and meat in the
foreign land
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
5/130
Part 2
Shift to London where Gandhiji prepares for
the Bar examination and also decides to crack
the London Matriculation
He was also enrolled in University College,
London in 1888-89 as a student of Indian law
and jurisprudence
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
6/130
Preparation for London
matriculation
Pre requirement of knowledge of Latin which
is a must for lawyers.
A full paper on Roman law
French as the other modern language
5 months of preparation and in the first
attempt he ploughed in latin Passes all the papers in his second attempt
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
7/130
Called to the Bar Preconditions: attending 12 terms in 3 years
and passing examinations
Keeping Terms meant attending at least 6 out
of 24 dinners in a term. The dinner came at a
price. What made him wonder was that the price of
wine was more than that of dinner. His Indian
sensibility could not swallow the idea ofsplurging so much on drink.
His choice was very limited in the food on
offer
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
8/130
He wondered how these dinners were a
qualification for becoming a member of the
Bar.
When there were few students qualifying for
membership, the dinners could be edifying for
the students who could learn, emulate and
practice public speaking with the Benchers butin the present rush, it was no longer possible.
The convention was now a mere formality
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
9/130
The Bar exam curriculum was very easy. Therewere 2 papers Roman Law and Common Law
which could be cleared by studying notes. The
exams were held 4 times an year
Gandhiji read the Roman law in Latin and
slogged through books on Common law.
Finally, he attained admission to the Bar in
June, 1891 and then returned to India.
In spite of acquiring the degree, his
confidence level was very low.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
10/130
My Helplessness
Theoretical knowledge without the ability to
utilize it in practice
Good knowledge of English common law but
not the faintest idea of Indian law
No knowledge of difference between hindu
and muslim law
Grave doubts about his ability to earn a living
out of the profession
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
11/130
Influence of Dadabhai Naroji
He bore a letter of introduction but neverused it
Fond of hearing Dadabhai speak.
A Mr. Frederick Pincutt had laughed away hisconcerns by saying that every lawyer need not
be an excellent orator. Rest assured it takes
no unusual skill to be an ordinary lawyer.Common honesty and industry are enough to
enable him to make a living.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
12/130
Advised to expand the horizon of
his reading
You have no knowledge of the world, a sine
qua non for a vakil. You have not even read
the history of India. A vakil should know
human nature. He should be able to read a
mans character form his face.
The skill of reading someones face seems an
elusive one for him.
His 3 years as a student of law were over.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
13/130
Section II - Gandhiji as a lawyer His voyage to India was internally stormy.
He was worried about the caste barrier as well
as his inadeptness as a lawyer
His elder brother, who had funded his
education, had built high hopes for him and
was hoping to get him some briefs from his
wide circle of friends.
After his return he was taken to Nasik for a
ritualistic purification and hence readmitted
into the caste
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
14/130
After his return, due to adaptation of a
westernized lifestyle, expenses had gone up in
the house.
Gandhiji was advised to go Bombay High Court
to learn practicial nuances of court procedure
and to get some cases
his early experience after qualifying as a
barrister was a bitter cup of tea with verymeager knowledge and an overwhelming
sense of responsibility
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
15/130
The First Case
Gandhiji grappled to come to terms with CPC,Evidence Act.
His first case was that of Mamibai for which he
received a fees of Rs. 30
His first appearance in the court as a defense
counsel was overpowered by bouts of nausea
and hesitation
Eventually he withdrew from the case and
never appeared for any client till he left for
South Africa
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
16/130
He drafted a memorial, attempted his hand at
teaching but seemed to be facing defeat on all
sides.
He shut up his establishment in Bombay after
a futile 6 months and returned to Rajkot.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
17/130
The First Shock
Back in Rajkot, he was able to make Rs. 300per month by drafting memorials and
application
He is forced to concede to the convention of
paying commission to go betweens
His brother got entangled in some controversy
and only Gandhi could get him out of it by
using his friendship with the political agent.
Gandhi had misgivings about exploiting an
acquaintance but the entreaties of his brother
proved stronger.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
18/130
When he approached the Political Agent, he
was impolitely snubbed and escorted out by
the peon
Gandhi contemplated legal action against the
agent but Sir Pherozehshah Mehta advised
him against it.
Resolution Never again shall I place myself in
such a false position, never again shall I try to
exploit friendship in this way.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
19/130
Preparing for South Africa
After suffering an ill digested insult, he finds
life intolerable in Kathiawad and looks for a
route to escape
His brother receives the offer of sending him
to SA for a big 40000 pound case. The firm
sending the offer was Dada Abdullah & Co.
In his present desperate state, he accepted
the offer
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
20/130
Arrival in Natal
He was now a seasoned traveler and did not
have the initial misgivings as at the time of
setting sail for England (1893)
An uneventful journey to Natal
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
21/130
Some experiences
At Natal port, he notices Indians being treatedas second grade citizens.
Seth Abdullah finds Gandhi to be a white
elephant, an additional expenditure, not muchhelp, open to influence by the other side and
not much legal help.
In the Durban court, the judge asks him toremove his turban which he refuses to do.
He is known as a coolie barrister over there
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
22/130
He decides to keep wearing his turban nad
brings the matter to SA press
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
23/130
On the way to Pretoria
He has to go to Pretoria in relation to the case
but he needs to understand the intricacies of
the case first.
He mastered knowledge of accounts to
understand the case
Gandhi for the first time, starts thinking in
terms of out of court settlement of the case
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
24/130
First day in Pretoria
He met the attorney of Abdulla Seth and
understands a few facts about the case
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
25/130
Preparation for the case His first exposure to public life
Development of religious spirit
Acquired knowledge of legal practice
Learnt the secret of succeeding as a lawyer
He closely understands the preparation of
case by both counsels
Preparation of plaintiffs case for attorney andsifting of facts was entrusted to him
Absorbed himself completely in the case
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
26/130
Learnt book keeping
Ability to translate from gujarati to english
Studied case law on the subject
Gandhi, I have learnt one thing, and it is this,that if we take care of the facts of a case, the
law will take care of itself. Let us dive deeper
into the facts of this case.
Facts means truth, and once we adhere to
truth, the law comes to our aid naturally.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
27/130
Litigation would ruin both the parties while
arbitration would be a more suitable
conclusion to the case
He met the other party, Tyeb Sheth also and
advised him to start thinking in terms of
arbitration
The case was becoming a giant with huge
lawyers fees, increasing ill will and raking up
of insignificant issues
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
28/130
He also realized that the winning side never
recovers the complete costs. Finally he pursued both parties to go for
arbitration. An arbitrator was appointed, the
case was argued before him and ShethAbdulla won.
Gandhi persuaded Sheth Abdulla to take the
award of 37000 pounds + costs in installmentsrather than at one go
Both parties agreed to these installements
and there was a happy resolution of the case
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
29/130
Lesson learnt I had learnt the true practice of law. I had
learnt to find out the better side of human
nature and to enter mens hearts. I realized
that the true function of a lawyer was to unite
parties riven asunder. The lesson was soindelible burnt into me, that a large part of my
time during the 20 years of my practice as a
lawyer was occupied in bringing about privatecompromises of hundreds of cases. I lost
nothing thereby- not even money, certainly
not my soul.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
30/130
Man Proposes, God Disposes
His task over, he started preparing for his
return and was given a farewell party by Sheth
Abdulla
At the party, he reads a piece of news in a
local paper refering to a Bill before Legislature
which sought to deprive Indians of their right
to elect members of the Natal Legislativeassembly.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
31/130
From questioning he came to realize that most
of the Indian community in SA was illiterate,
ignorant, the Christian converts stopped
regarding themselves as Indians and there was
no consciousness regarding deprivation of right
to vote It was decided by all the people present that
Gandhi would delay his return and take up the
issue. He refused to charge fees, wanted toallocate some budget for expenses incurred,
wanted volunteers. All these demands were
readily agreed upon
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
32/130
He delayed his departure by a month and
threw himself whole heartedly into the job of
opposing the Bill
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
33/130
Settled in Natal
An initial meeting was help to offer oppositionto the Franchise Bill
Volunteers were enrolled from amongst
Christian Indian youths. The entire Indian community was united for
the cause
The bill had already been passed and its initialacceptance was proof that Indians were unfit
for Franchise
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
34/130
Initially telegrams were sent trying to
postpone discussion on the bill
The petition to be presented to Legislative
Assembly was drawn up and a signature
campaign was initiated, the petition was
discussed in LA but was eventually passed
The campaign had united the entire
community and infused a new spirit in them
Another petition was submitted to Lord Ripon
who was Secretary of State for Colonies.
10000 signatures were obtained on the same.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
35/130
This second petition gained widespread
publicity.
He was persuaded to stay on in South Africa
permanently but could not do so without
some legal work and an annual income of 300
pounds
He refused to charge any fee for the public
work he did
eventually some merchants started giving him
their legal work
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
36/130
Colour Bar Gandhi set about applying for admission as an advocate of
Supreme Court. He possessed the Certificate of admissiongiven by Bombay High Court but his London Bar exam
certificate was deposited in BHC. He also attached 2 character
certificates by European merchants to his application
The Law society refused to admit him as advocate for tworeasons: first, his original Bar exam certificate was not
attached. Second, a colored man could not become an
advocate of SA SC
After some discussion and an affidavit submitted by DadaAbdulla, his application for enrolling as an advocate was
finally accepted
He was made to remove his turban to confirm to the dress
code of advocates
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
37/130
All my life through, the very insistence on
truth has taught me to appreciate the beauty
of compromise. I saw in later life that this
spirit was an essential part of Satyagraha. Ithas often meant endangering my life and
incurring the displeasure of friends.
(1893-1901 time period spent in South Africa)
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
38/130
Settled in Bombay?
Returned to India in 1901 with intention ofsettling down, assisting Gokhale in Congress
work and practising law (with memories of his
past failure in the same place lingering)
Got 3 briefs from Mavji Dave, won a case,
gained some confidence
The Judicial Assistant kept shifting his court tovarious places, even to plague ravaged Veraval
which displeased Gandhi and caused
tremendous hardships to his clients
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
39/130
He eventually settled down again in Bombay
and this second innings was better than first.
He prospered well and kept on getting work
from his SA clients.
He was again unexpectedly summoned to SA
for the visit of Chamberlain and his second
stint at Bombay also ended suddenly
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
40/130
Some reminiscences of the Bar
Traits- I never resorted to untruth in myprofession, and that a large part of my
practice was in the interest of public work
He never tutored his witnesses to speakuntruth
He never fixed conditions of winning and
losing the case and bringing variance in thefees accordingly
He built a reputation of standing by the truth
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
41/130
In one specific case of accounts arbitration, his
client was getting more rewards than was hisright.
In spite of the senior counsel dissuading him,
he admitted the matter in open court and gotthe error rectified rather than the matter
being referred for a fresh hearing which would
have been injurious to his clients interest Lesson learnt:I was confirmed in my
conviction that it was not impossible to
practice law without compromising truth.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
42/130
Clients turned Co-workers
Specimen of honesty: I discovered that myclient had deceived me. I saw him completely
break down in the witness box. So without any
argument I asked the Magistrate to dismiss
the case i rebuked my client for bringing a
false case to me
In case he was ignorant of any facet of law, he
frankly advised his clients to seek some other
counsel
Hundreds of his SA clients became friends and
co-workers
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
43/130
How a client was saved
An anecdote of Parsi Rustomji who was a friend and co-
worker
While importing goods from India, he resorted to smuggling
and he was once caught red handed
Rather than taking the matter to court, Gandhi suggested
meeting the Customs officer and Attorney General and
confessing the entire gamut of smuggling and paying
whatever charge was levied by them
Parsi was made to pay penalty equal to twice the amount he
had confessed to having smuggled. A valuable lesson for Parsi
Rustomji
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
44/130
SECTION III The Trials of Gandhiji
Before the court in 1907: An association was
formed to protest against the Peace
Preservation Ordinance which in the guise of
protecting the colony from dangerouscharacters, was intended to prevent Indians
from entering and residing in Transvaal
The Peace Preservation Ordinance providedthat anyone of foreign origin entering the
Transvaal without a work permitshould be
liable to arrest and imprisonment.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
45/130
All the opposition of Gandhi and company
remained futile and eventually the Ordinance
became Immigration Act.
Gandhiji and 25 of his co-workers were
arrested under the Act and ordered to
produce their work permits.
In court, Gandhi was not allowed to make any
political speeches and because he had no
other defense, he was ordered to leave the
country within the next 48 hours
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
46/130
Before the court in 1908 Gandhi plead guilty to the charge of
disobeying the order of the court to leave the
colony within 48 hours
Other offenders charged with the same lack of
work permit were sentenced to 3 months of RI
and heavy fine. He also sought the same or a
stricter punishment for he was equally guilty
The judge felt that the Contempt of Court
Gandhi had committed was more a political
offence rather than a legal offence so he was
given 2 months of simple imprisonment
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
47/130
Before the Court in 1913
The agitation here was related to the
compulsory 3 pound taxto be paid by all
foreigners. In spite of many rounds of
negotiations, the tax was not repealed andGandhi asked all indentured laborers to
suspend work till their demand was not met.
Gandhi was arrested, brought to Court, hepled guilty and his defense, Mr. Godfrey
appealed on behalf of his client to levy the
greatest possible penalty on the defendant.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
48/130
In his statement, Gandhi called on the workers
to continue their agitation
The judge in his verdict read It was a painful
duty to pass a sentence upon the conduct of a
gentleman like Mr. Gandhi..
He was eventually awarded 3 months of RI
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
49/130
Was it contempt of court? (1919)
The matter in question was publication of aletter related to a trial lis pendens
two barristers and 3 pleaders had openly
expressed their support of satyagraha and
while the proceedings against them were lis
pendens, the letter sent by Advocate General
through Registrar to the concerned parties
was published in Young India
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
50/130
Gandhi was summoned to court but expressed
his inability to attend because he was
travelling and sent the following explanation:
the letter was received by him in ordinarycourse and that he published it as he believed
it was of great public importance and that he
thought that he was doing a public service incommenting on it. He, therefore claimed that
in publishing and commenting on the letter,
he was within the rights of a journalist.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
51/130
The Court demanded a written apology from him in Young
India which he refused to assent to and wrote In doing so I
performed, in my humble opinion, a useful public duty at a
time when there was great tension and when even the
judiciary was affected by the popular prejudice. I need hardlysay that I had no desire to prejudge the issues that Their
Lordships had to decide.
The instance gave rise to great deliberation on the issue of
Press Commenting upon pending trials. Many examples werequoted from sensational murder trials where the press had
already awarded judgment before the due procedure of law
could be completed.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
52/130
Contempt Case Judgment
Gandhi was charged with Contempt of Court
under 2 heads:
A. any act or writing tending to scandalize the
court
B. any act or writing calculated to obstruct or
interfere with the due course of justice or the
lawful process of the court.
J dgment in contempt case(pg 92
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
53/130
Judgment in contempt case(pg-92-
98) His Lordship Justice Marten wrote: the comments made in
the newspaper were of a particularly intemperate and
reprehensible character. They also amounted to scurrilous
abuse of the JudgeIn the present case the court has very
seriously considered whether it ought not to impose asubstantial fine on one if not both of the respondents, but on
the whole, I think it is sufficient for the Court to state the law
in terms which I hope will leave no room for doubt in the
future, and to confine our order to severely reprimanding the
respondents and warning them both as to their future
conduct.
Gandhis view in Contempt of
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
54/130
Gandhis view in Contempt of
Court case If I dwell upon the judgment it is only because I am anxious
as a satyagrahi to draw a moral from itI had to conserve a
journalists independence and yet respect the law. If it was
disobedience, there was no defiance but perfect resignation,
there was no anger or ill will but perfect restraint and respect;that if I did not apologize, I did not, because an insincere
apology would have been contrary to my conscience. Here
then we have an almost complete vindication of civil
disobedience Disobedience to be civil must be sincere,
respectful, restrained, never defiant.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
55/130
The Great Trial (1922) (pg.100) Arrested for publication of 4 articles in Young
India namely: Disaffection a Virtue
Tampering with Loyalty
The Puzzle and its Solution
Shaking the Manes
The charge in each case was that of bringing or
attempting to bring into hatred or contempt
or exciting or attempting to excite disaffection
towards His Majestys Government.
Once again he pled guilty to all charges
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
56/130
Gandhiji charged under Section 124A of IPC
Trial commenced on 18 March, 1922
The accused was charged with bringing or
attempting to bringing into hatred or
contempt or exciting or attempting to excite
disaffection towards His Majestys
Government
Disaffection defined as disloyalty and feeling
of enmity
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
57/130
Gandhiji in his statement pled guilty.
The judge was free to convict the accused on the basis of
pleas or proceed with the trial
The Advocate General insisted on proceeding with the trial
for it was highly desirable in public interest that the charges
should be fully and thoroughly investigated
The Judge disagreed with idea of fully investigating the
charges to which Gandhi had already pled guilty and full
recording of evidence would reveal no new facts
Sir Thomas Stangmans statement was recorded in which hesaid that the articles in Young India were not isolated
incidents but part of a well planned campaign to spread
disaffection. He quoted other instances from Young India
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
58/130
Sir Strangman said that the Chauri Chaura incident was a
result of this organized attempt to spread disloyalty towards
the Govt.
But what was the use of preaching non violence when he
preached disaffection towards the Govt. or openly instigatedothers to overthrow it?... These were circumstances which he
asked the court to take into account in sentencing the
accused, and it would be for the court to consider those
circumstances which must involve sentences of severity.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
59/130
Gandhis statement (pg.108-09)
to preach disaffection towards existing system of Govt. has become
almost a passion with meThinking over these deeply and sleeping over
them night after night, it is impossible for me to dissociate myself from the
diabolical crimes of Chauri Chaura or the mad outrages of Bombay. He is
quite right when he says that as a man of responsibility, a man having
received a fair share of education, having had a fair share of experience ofthis world, I should have known the consequence of every one of my
actsNon violence is the first article of my faith. It is also the last article of
my creed. But I had to make my choice. I had either to submit to a system
which I considered had done an irreparable harm to any country, or incur
the risk of the mad fury of my people bursting forth when theyunderstood the truth from my lips.
Gandhis written statement (pg
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
60/130
Gandhi s written statement (pg.
110-115) I should explain why from a staunch loyalist or co-operator I have become
an uncompromising disaffectionist and non-cooperator I discovered that
I had no rights as a man, because I was an Indian I thought that this
treatment of Indians was an excrescence upon a system that was
intrinsically and mainly goodThe first shock came in the shape of Rowlatt
Act, a law designed to rob the people of all real freedomI camereluctantly to the conclusion that the British connection had made India
more helpless than she ever was before, politically and economically.No
sophistry, no jugglery in figures can explain away the evidence that the
skeletons in many villages present to the naked eye The law itself in this
country has been used to serve the foreign exploiter. My unbaisedexamination of the Punjab Marital Law cases has led me to believe that at
least 95% convictions were wholly bad. In my opinion, the administration
of the law is thus prostituted consciously or unconsciously for the benefit
of the exploiter.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
61/130
Contd.
section 124A under which I am happily charged is perhaps
the prince among the political sections of the IPC designed to
suppress the liberty of the citizenI have studied some of the
cases tried under it, and I know that some of the most loved
of Indias patriots have been convicted under it. I consider it aprivige therefore, to be charged under that sectionIndia is
less manly under the British rule than she ever was before.
Holding such a belief, I consider it a sin to have affection for
the system.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
62/130
I am here therefore, to invite and submit cheerfully to the
highest penalty that can be inflicted upon me for what in law
is a deliberate crime and what appears to me to be the
highest duty of a citizen. The only course open to you, the
Judge, is either to resign your post and thus dissociateyourself from evil, if you feel that the law you are called upon
to administer is an evil and that in reality I am innocent; or to
inflict on me the severest penalty if you believe that the
system and the law you are assisting to administer are good
for the people of this country and that my activity is therefore
injurious to the public weal.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
63/130
The Judgment
Mr. Gandhi, you have made my task easy in one way by
pleading guilty to the charge Neverthless, what remains,
namely the determination of the just sentence, is perhaps as
difficult a proposition as a judge in this country could have to
face. The law is no respecter of persons. Neverthless, it will beimpossible to ignore the fact that you are in a different
category from any person I have tried or am likely to have to
try. It would be impossible to ignore that , in the eyes of
millions of your countrymen, you are a great patriot and a
great leader.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
64/130
Contd.
I am trying to balance what is due to you
against what appears to me to be necessary in
the interest of the public, and I propose in
passing sentence to follow the precedent of acase that was decided some 12 years ago, I
mean the case against Bal Gangadhar Tilak
under the same section. The sentence thatwas passed upon him as it finally stood was a
sentence of simple imprisonment for 6 years.
Gandhis comment on the
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
65/130
Gandhi s comment on the
judgment
I just want to say that I consider it to be the
proudest privilege and honour to be
associated with his name. So far as the
sentence itself is concerned, I certainlyconsider it as light as any judge would inflict
on me, and so far as the whole proceedings
are concerned, I must say that I could nothave expected greater courtesy.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
66/130
Section IV
LAWYERS AND SATYAGRAHA
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
67/130
Boycott of law courts by lawyers
I submit that national non cooperation requires
suspension of their practice by lawyers. Perhaps no
one cooperates with a govt. more than lawyersthrough its law courts. Lawyers interpret laws to the
people and thus support authority. It is for that
reason that they are styled officers of the court. So
when the nation wishes to paralyze the Govt, thatprofession, if it wishes to help the nation to bend the
govt to its will, must suspend practice.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
68/130
Work for lawyers The lawyers are not to suspend practice and enjoy
rest. They will be expected to induce their clients to
boycott courts. They will improvise arbitration
boards in order to settle disputes. A nation, that is
bent on forcing justice from an unwilling govt, haslittle time for engaging in mutual quarrels.. But
what will happen to law and order? We shall evolve
law and order through the instrumentality of these
very lawyers. We shall promote arbitration courtsand dispense justice, pure, simple, home made
justice, swadeshi justice to our countrymen. That is
what suspension of practice means.
A ressing con ict etween in u
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
69/130
gand muslim lawyers involved in
Khilafat issue Lastly, for Mohammedan lawyers, it has beensuggested that if they stop practice, Hindus
will take it up. I am hoping Hindus will at least
show the negative courage of not touchingtheir Muslim brethrens clients, even if they do
not suspend their own practice.
Hallucination of law courts (pg
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
70/130
Hallucination of law courts (pg.
123) Let those who frequent the law courts bear
witness to the fact that the atmosphere about
them is foetid. Perjured witnesses are ranged
on either side, ready to sell their very souls for
money or for friendships sake. The courts aresupposed to dispense justice and are
therefore called the palladile of a nations
liberty. But when they support the authorityof an unrighteous govt they are no longer
palladile of liberty, they are crushing houses to
crush a nations spirit.
Economic drain caused by law
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
71/130
Economic drain caused by law
courts The best SA lawyers- and they are lawyers of great
ability dare not charge the fees the lawyers in India
do. 15 gunieas is almost a top fee for legal opinion.
Several thousand rupees have been known to have
been charged in India. There is something sinful in a
system under which it is possible for a lawyer to
earn from 50000 to 1 lakh rupees per month. Legal
practice is not- ought not to be- a speculativebusiness. The best legal talent must be available to
the poorest at reasonable rates.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
72/130
Cobblers v. lawyers
Lawyers refused to answer Gandhis call for
suspension of practice and did not want to
join Congress for Gandhi, in an article, had
referred to them as cobblers.
Gandhi apologised Having been myself a
lawyer, I could not so far forget myself as
wantonly to offend members of the sameprofession.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
73/130
Humility in satyagrahis
arrogant assumption of superiority on the
part of a non- cooperator who has undergone
a little bit of sacrifice or put on khadi is the
greatest danger to the movement. A non co-operator is nothing if he is not humble.
Lawyers can certainly do silent work as
lieutenants in the matter of swadeshi. Itrequires the largest number of earnest
workers.
Ways to help the movement by
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
74/130
Ways to help the movement by
practising lawyers
A lawyer who cannot suspend practice can certainlyhelp with money, he can give his spare hours to
public service, he can introduce honesty and fair
dealings in his profession, he can cease to consider
clients as fit prey for pecuniary ambition, he cancease to have anything to do with touts, he can
promote settlement of cases by private arbitration,
he can at least do spinning himself for one or two
hours per day, he can simplify the life of his family, he
can induce the members of the family to do spinning
religiously for a certain time daily, he can adopt for
himself and his family the use of khaddar.
Practising lawyers becoming
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
75/130
Practising lawyers becoming
Congress office bearers
In my opinion, those lawyers who have not
yet succeeded in suspending their practice,
cannot expect to hold office in any congress
organization or lead public opinion onCongress platforms. Will titled men be elected
as office bearers, although they may not have
given up their titles? If we do not face theissues boldly, we stand in danger of corrupting
the movement.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
76/130
A protest
A young lawyer from Jubbulpore protested against 2Malguzars holding congress office while practicing
lawyers were forbidden from doing so. The young
man pointed out in a letter to Gandhi that the british
regime thrives on Malguzars who exploit and collecttaxes from poor farmers so no practising Malguzar
has the right to be a congress office bearer. If a
lawyer who has not suspended his practice is not a
proper person to be an office bearer, certainly aMalguzar too should not be an office bearer. A
malguzar is more attached to the govt. than a
lawyer.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
77/130
Gandhis response
The congress has not yet called upon landholders tosurrender their lands to the govt nor is it very likely to. These
youngmen, like some land holders sons elsewhere are taking
an honorable part in the national uplift and they deserve
every encouragement form lawyers. There are no twoopinions about the fact that intellect rather than riches will
lead. It might equally be admitted by the correspondent that
the heart rather than teh intellect will eventually lead.
Character, not brains will count at the crucial moment. And I
fancied that these young men showed character. I should be
sorry to find otherwise.
Persistent problem of lawyers not
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
78/130
Persistent problem of lawyers not
forsaking practice
I cannot conceive the possibility of the
movement, which is one of self sacrifice,
succeeding if it is led by lawyers who do not
believe in self sacrifice success dependsupon bravery, sacrifice, truth, love and faith;
not on legal acumen, calculation, diplomacy,
hate and disbelief.
h h ( )
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
79/130
The Satyagrahi Lawyers (1919)
Related to the same matter as publication of
an official letter while the trial was lis pendens
Some barristers had signed the satyagrah
pledge and promised to disobey Rowlatt actand other British laws
After trial, no disciplinary action was taken
against them but a warning was issued tothem
Gandhis comment on the
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
80/130
Gandhi s comment on the
judgment
the judgment is highly unsatisfactory. It has
shirked the issue. The logical outcome of the
judgment should have been punishment and
not a postponment of it. The lawyers inquestion had shown no repentance. So far as
the public know, they will be ready to offer
civil disobedience should the occasion arise.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
81/130
Mysore Lawyers A Mr. Dasappa, practicing lawyer at Mysore Chief Court had
been disbarred for participating in satyagrah and addressinganti govt rallies.
He was charged with disobeying govt orders regarding holding
meetings in certain prohibited places and not participating in
an inquiry being conducted by the govt in a case of policetorture
He has done what many patriot lawyers or no lawyers have
done in British India. And nowadays the judges take no notice
of their conduct and the public have made of them heroes.My condolence and pity go out to te Judges who have
delivered a judgment which, let me hope, in their cooler
moments they will regret.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
82/130
Let them remember Thoreaus saying that
possession of riches is a crime and poverty a
virtue under an unjust administration.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
83/130
Instances of legal commentary on many
controversial judgments awarded by British
Courts follow:
The cases are specifically related to PunjabMartial Law cases Tribunal
B b K li h R
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
84/130
Babu Kalinath Roy
Kalinath Roy charged under Section 124A for
publishing provocative writings in the Tribune.
Gandhi examined all the writings and found
the charge and judgment to be a case ofexcessive judicial activism where the reporter
had been unjustly punished for mere
statement of facts.
L l R dh K i h C ( 150)
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
85/130
Lala Radha Krishnas Case (pg.150) More severe than Babu Kalinaths case
The accused here published in a vernacular paper
Pratap
the judgment is a travesty of justice.
The accused sentenced not under 124A but on a ruletemporarily framed as a war measure, a rule
promulgated by the govt under the powers granted
to it under Defence of India Act.
The indictment contained material inaccuracies, was
very loosely drawn up and argumentative. It could
never have been upheld in a proper trial.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
86/130
The judgment also gave an impression of
prejudice and haste
Without going into the question whether he
intended to cause fear or alarm to the public,we are satisfied that the publishing and
circulating of these false statements did
actually cause fear and alarm to the public.
L h J d t
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
87/130
Lahore Judgment 3 lawyers and 2 commoners charged under
section 121 of IPC which read as Whoever
wages war against the Queen, or attempts to
wage war, or abets the waging of such war,
shall be punished with death or transportationfor life, and shall forfeit all his property. They
were tried before a special tribunal and
transported. Even the judges remarked thatthe punishment was too harsh but since the
accused were indicted under 121, there was
no alternative left.
G dhi t i Y I di
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
88/130
Gandhis comment in Young India
The judgment forms the saddest commentary
on british justicethe judges are ruled by
passion and prejudiceJustice in British courts
is an expensive luxury. It is often the longestpurse that wins Agree with thine adversary
quickly is the soundest legal maxim ever
uttered. The judgment intended to condemn the
Rowlatt act agitation.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
89/130
The issue before the court was Can we or can we not, legallycarry on a sustained powerful agitation involving processions,
hartals, fasting etc, but eschewing, always and invariably,
violence in any shape or form? The implication in the
judgment is that we may not do so. There is nothing in thejudgment to show that any of the accused either directly or
indirectly encouraged violence. And where there is absence of
intention to do violence, it is absurd to call a peaceful
combination a criminal conspiracyThe duty of the Indian
public is clear: By a quiet, persistent and powerful agitation,
but without violence and irritation, to secure repeal of the
Rowlatt legislation and the reversal of the sentences.
J th C
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
90/130
Jagannaths Case Not a celebrity case like Kalinath Roy or Radha
Krishna.
Accused charged under section 121 of IPC and
sentenced to transportation for life
He was accused of actively participating in
activities leading upto the hartal in punjab on
14 April, 1919
The accuseds defence rested upon an alibi
that he left Gujranwalla on 12th by 5 pm train
and so did not participate in organization of
hartal
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
91/130
Inspite of the defendants plea, the judges
were impatient to deliver their verdict
whereby they transported the innocent man
for life without proper examination of thedefense and the alibi
Another scandal
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
92/130
Another scandal
Another batch of cases at Punjab Special Tribunals where thejudgment was completely unbearable
The poignancy of the sorrow that the atrocious injustices
such as I have had the painful duty of exposing have caused, is
increased by the knowledge that perpetrators of theseinjustices are judges in whose judgments the people have
been accustomed to put the utmost faith. This unevenness of
temperament can only be accounted for by the supposition
that the trained judicial intellect of the Judges must have
suffered temporary aberration by the events of Punjab.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
93/130
Hafizabad case
I have never come across cases in which
capital punishment has been so lightly
pronounced, on the flimsiest evidence takendown in a most perfunctory manner, as
appears to me to have been done.
19 accused charged under section 121(waging war), 147 (rioting), 149 (unlawful
assembly), 307 (attempt at murder).
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
94/130
The 19th accused was a young student of DAVhafizabad named Karamchand, accused of
inciting riots on the lahore model on 11 April
but the evidence against him was very paltry. He produced an alibi to prove that he was not
in hafizabad on the day of rioting i.e. 14 April
but back in his native village Karamchands is a case of palpable injustice
victims not guilty
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
95/130
victims, not guilty
Ramnagar cases
They constituted not a legal trial but a mockery of it. The
accused, 28 in number, were all tried together, the trial was
finished in one day during which altogether 150 defense
witnesses were examined, the accused were not informed ofthe charge against them except thorough the mouths of the
prosecution witnesses. There was no occasion for indecently
rushing through the trial The judgment is self-condemned. It
breathes vindictiveness and anger. The rejection of the
defence evidence, the explaining away of the weak points in
the prosecution, the punishment of solitary confinement, the
heavy fines point unmistakably to loss of balance and
unfitness to judge.
Dr Satyapals case
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
96/130
Dr. Satyapal s case
Dr. Satyapal and Dr. Kitchlew accused ofinciting violence which took place after their
arrest.
Dr. Satyapal in a clear, emphatic andcourageous statement categorically denied
the whole string of charges against him.
He was charged of committing sedition, thecharges against him were altered
retrospectivley.
Lala Labhu Ram
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
97/130
Lala Labhu Ram
Isolated cases of injustice will happen in thebest regulated society and under a model
govt. But when injustice becomes the order of
the day, it is time for honest men not merelyto protest against it but to withdraw their
support from a system of govt under which
such organized injustice is possible, unlessthat system is changing and systematic
injustice becomes an impossibility.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
98/130
The judgment in Lala Labhu Rams case commences with thesentence The evidence for the defense is worthless.
Lala was a prosperous civil engineer, apolitical by
temperament, with no membership of any political party or
sabha, was arrested on 20 April for being one in a hundredcommitting an assault on a police officer on 12 april,
identification was impossible, many professional witnesses
swore that they identified him, he gave a perfect alibi of being
elsewhere the recorded evidence itself showed a patent
miscarriage of justice.
Gujaratimals case
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
99/130
Gujaratimal s case A young boy of 18, newly returned from Egypt after serving as
a worker in British forces, arrested on 16 April for someunknown cause from his native village.one of 19
simultaneously put to trial Sentenced to be hanged. His
sentence was subsequently commuted to transportation, and
still more subsequently, to 7 years RI.
It is serious matter to sentence a lad of 18 years, who denies
his guilt, who denies having been present at the scene itself
and who has only lately rendered service to the Crown, to be
hanged on the strength of the very questionable evidence of
identification by witnesses of no standing
Gandhi quotes material evidence from Gujaratimals father
saying that all the witnesses had been unable to identify him
at an occasion heretofore.
Labh Singh
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
100/130
Labh Singh
Accused under section 121 of IPC for being present
at Anti Rowlatt meetings on 12th and 13th and then
present with mobs on 14th.
The whole conviction was based on uncorroborated
testimony Labh Singh, the order goes only to confirm and
perpetuate what is a great and serious miscarriage of
justice. The court proceeded to the judgment with
inordinate haste and without waiting for the answers
to the interrogatories issued to some of the
witnesses for the defence.
Gandhis conclusion
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
101/130
Gandhi s conclusion
According to Sir Edward Maclagan they are all clearly guilty.According to the evidence before the public, they are all
clearly innocent. We may not allow young men of brilliant
ability and moral worth to have their careers blasted for life
by our indifference. Posterity will judge us by our ability tosecure justice in the cases such as I have had the painful duty
of placing before the public. For me, justice for the individual,
be he the humblest, is everything. All else comes after. I feel
that even the Government of India will find it hard to
withstand a unanimously expressed public opinion based on
facts and couched in the language of moderation.
More Punjab Tragedies
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
102/130
More Punjab Tragedies
Gurdayal Singh- accused of perpetratingviolence on days when he was confined to bed
with appendicitis. Accused was not told the
identity of prosecution witnesses norinformed of the charge against him
How not to do it?
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
103/130
Important note for pleaders and drafters
Criticism of language of petitions
I assure them that a bare statement of facts embellished with
adjectives is far more eloquent and effective than a narrative
glowing with exuberant laguage. Petition writers must
understand that they address busy men, not necessarilysympathetic, sometimes prejudiced, and almost invariably
prone to sustain the decisions of their subordinates. Both
Gokhale and Dada Naroji told me that if I wanted to be heard I
must be brief, I must write to the point and adhere to facts,
and never travel beyond the cause under notice, and I must
be most sparing in my adjectives.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
104/130
Kesar Mal, one of the 19 in Hafizabad case,was sentenced to be hanged.
The case was that of assault of Lieutenant
Tatam by an unruly mob at the railway station.There was no conclusive evidence against
Kesar Mal. He was not identified in the
identification parade.
An unworthy defence
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
105/130
An unworthy defence
A Miss Sherwood was assaulted in Amritsar by anunruly mob and the govt. passed the orders that
those who wished to pass the scene of assault
should be made to crawl on their hands and knees.
Surely there are nobler methods of ensuring
protection for European women. Have their lives
been in such danger in India as to require any special
protection? Why should the life of European womenbe held more sacred than that of an Indian woman?
Fining the labourers
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
106/130
Fining the labourers
Ahmadabad had to pay a fine of nearly 8 lakhs inconnection with the April, 1919 disturbances and the
subsequent loss to public property.
A law that allows a govt. thus arbitrarily to impose a
penalty is a bad law.My object is to bring to public
notice an unwise and untimely and an almost
despotic application of that bad law. Terrorizing
punishment is hardly the best method of weaningoffenders from wrong-doing, and in the present
instance the punishment will fall upon many
innocent shoulders.
Fining the labourers
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
107/130
Fining the labourers
The recovery to be made by the govt wouldbe deducted from the salary of mill workers.
They have not been given the chance of
appeal not have they been given the option ofpaying the fine themselves. The caution
money, that is, the money retained by the mill
owners out of the wages due to the mill
hands, has been summarily attached without
notice to or consent of the laborers
concerned.
The Amritsar appeals
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
108/130
The Amritsar appeals 21 citizens of Amritsar had appealed in Privy Council against the unjust
punishments of lower courts in connection with the April, 1919 incidents. The Privy council dismissed the appeal against lawless and irregular
procedure.
I must confess that the judgment does not come upon me quite as
surprise My opinion, based upon a study of political cases, is that the
judgments even of the highest tribunals are not unaffected by subtlepolitical considerations. The consequences of a decision favorable to the
people would have exposed the Indian govt to indescribable discredit from
which it would have been difficult (for it) to free itself for a generation.
Deeper discredit, therefore, now attaches to the government by reason of
the judgment, because rightly or wrongly the popular opinion will be there
that there is no justice under the British constitution when large political
or racial considerations are involved.
The Punjab sentences
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
109/130
The Punjab sentences
The Viceroy Lord Chelmsford refuses to commute 2 death sentences inspite of lack of substantial evidence against the accused. The popular
belief favors the view that the condemned men are innocent and have not
had a fair trial. The execution has been so long delayed that hanging at
this stage would give a rude shock to Indian society.But if the govt will
grievously err, if they carry out the sentences, the people will equally err ifthey give way to anger or grief over the hanging if it has unfortunately to
take place.we must be prepared to contemplate with equanimity, not a
thousand murders of innocent men and women but many thousands
before we attain a status in the world that shall not be surpassed by any
nation. We hope therefore that all concerned will take rather than lose
heart and treat hanging as an ordinary affair of life.
Finally some of the accused were not pardoned and hanged.
Lawyers Duty (pg 205)
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
110/130
Lawyers Duty (pg.205) I have never minced words in criticizing lawyers Though the
lawyers deserve criticism, their contribution to the fight forfreedom is no mean one. Pherozshah Mehta, the uncrowned
kinf of bombay, was an eminent lawyer. The Lokmanya was a
lawyer.all these are lawyers and the President of the
congress himself is a lawyer. People expect every lawyer to be
a patriot, as they expect every brahmin to possess spiritual
knowledge. A lawyer, by his very profession, is an advocate of
peoples rights, an expert in law and politics and one who
saves the victims of oppression by the state. When,
therefore, a class of people who should regard service of thecountry as their profession give themselves up to the pursuit
of self interest, lead a life of self indulgence or have no other
aim than making money by encouraging litigation, people
naturally speak ill of them.
Duties of lawyers in national
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
111/130
struggle
Keep accounts of public funds Explain legal intricacies to people
Enquire into civil disobedience cases which have beem arbitrarily dealt with
Be present at places where there is fear of violence
Explain to people cases of arbitrary use of authority
Enquire into injustices being perpetrated at persent Help in manufacturing khadi
Help in boycott of foreign cloth
In absence of political leaders who have been arrested, lead the people and
encourage the present spirit of fearlessness
Section V
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
112/130
Section V
Miscellaneous
How to spiritualize the profession?
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
113/130
Conversation with law students in columbo
The first thing you would bear in mind if youwould spiritualize the practice of law , is not to
make your profession subservient to the
interests of your purseThere are instances ofeminent lawyers in all countries who led a life
of self sacrifice, who devoted their brilliant
legal talents entirely to the service of the
country even whilst I was engaged in
practice, I never let my profession stand in the
way of my public service
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
114/130
The second thing I have found that in thepractice of their profession lawyers are
consciously or unconsciously led into untruth
for the sake of their clients. An eminentlawyer has gone so far as to say that it may
even be the duty of a lawyer to defend a client
whom he knows to be guilty. There I disagree.
The duty of a lawyer is always to place before
the judges, and to help them arrive at, the
truth, never to prove the guilty as innocent.
A Judges indictment
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
115/130
A Judge s indictment
Pg. 211 to 213
(to be read completely)
An unjudicial dictum
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
116/130
An unjudicial dictum
Verdict of 2 appellate court judges on Allahadbad High Court published in YoungIndia
The case is unsatisfactory because we have no less than 5 persons who were in
effect, if their evidence can be relied upon, eye witnesses and yet, having regard to
the slight value placed upon truth in this country, we have seriously to apply our
minds as to whether they can be believed.
Gandhis scathing comment: What legal basis had these two judges for the
sweeping statement made by them as to the character of a whole nation? The
inference is that in other countries a higher value is placed upon truth. Be it
noted that the Allahabad judges have made use of their bias in coming to their
decision and have thus proved their incapacity to hold responsible posts.
Untruth in Law Courts
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
117/130
Untruth in Law Courts
The canker of untruth had eaten the judicial system hollow. Gandhis comment: The atmosphere round law courts is
debasing as any visitor passing through them can see. I hold
radical views about the administration of justicee. But mine, I
know, is a voice in the wilderness. Vested interests will notallow radical reform, unless India comes into her own through
truthful and non violent means. If that glorious event
happens, the adminstration of law and justice will be as cheap
and healthy as it is today dear and unhealthy.
Hindu law and Mysore
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
118/130
Hindu law and Mysore A writer from Mysore enumerated the following social evils in a letter to
Young India
1. women are denied the right of inheritance
2. Near relations are excluded from the list of heirs due to the presence of
distant agnates
3. Women are not allowed to exercise full rights of ownership in properties
inherited or gifted to them4. Deaf and dumb are excluded from inheritance
5. Legality of widow remarriage is not recognized in Princely Mysore
6. Marriageable age for girls should be raised to 14
7. Divorce should be recognized
8. Inter caste marriages should be legalized
9. Orphans should be declared eligible for adoption
10. Widows should be allowed to adopt
11. Necessity of appropriate legislation in Mysore to bring about the
aforesaid social reforms
Gandhis response
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
119/130
Gandhi s response
This very unsatisfactory state of things has tobe changed if hindu society is to become a
progressive unit in human evolution. The
British rulers cannot make these changesbecause of their different religion and their
different ideal. Unless therefore Hindu
public opinion clearly demands it, no drastic
change in our customs or so called laws will be
attempted or countenanced by them.
Establishment of the Federal Court
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
120/130
Establishment of the Federal Court
Gandhis speech at the Federal Structure Committee as arepresentative of Congress (1930)
Discussion regarding the structure and powers of Federal
Court in an India which would be self governed but with
military and purse strings in the hands of the Crown The Privy Council here is an ancient institution, and an
institution which justly commands very great regard and
respect; but in spite of all the respect that I have for the Privy
Council I cannot bring myself to believe that we also will notbe able to have a Privy Council of our own which will
command universal esteem.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
121/130
seeing that the congress holds the view thatthis federal court or supreme court will occupy
the position of the highest tribunal beyond
which no man who is an inhabitant of Indiacan go, its jurisdiction, in my opinion, will be
limitless the greater the power that we give
to this Federal court, I think the greater the
confidence we shall be able to inspire in the
world and also in the nation itself.
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
122/130
Quote from a great Jurist in Transvaal,Though there may be no hope now, I tell you
that I have guided myself by one thing, or else
I should not be a lawyer: the law teaches uslawyers that there is absolutely no wrong for
which there is no remedy, then those judges
should be immediately unseated.
The place of the lawyers in a non
i l i
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
123/130
violent society
Conversation between reader and editor
Pg.228-231
An advocates dilemma
bli h d i Y I di
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
124/130
published in Young India
Dichotomy between obeying everyday overlordship of British rule and trying to
emphasize that India was independent as per
Congress declaration of Independence.
5000 miles away
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
125/130
y
Location of final appellate court i.e. Privy Council 5000 milesaway from the population it governs.
If it were not for the hypnotism under which we are laboring,
we would see without effort the futility, the sinfulness, of
going 5000 miles to get (to buy?) justice. It is said that at thatdelightful distance the judges are able to decide cases with
greater detachment and impartiality than they would be able
to do in delhi a self respecting indian would never tolerate
the location of her final court of appeal anywhere else but in
india.
Justice from 6000 miles
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
126/130
the different forts of india no doubt are a continuous
reminder of the british might. But the silent conquest of themind of educated India is a surer guarantee of british stability
than the formidable courts
Arguments in favor of keeping Privy council inEngland
A. the judges would be more impartial 6000 miles away
B. the expenditure incurred would be the same
C. the Indian judges would not command the same respect as
british ones
The deciding reason for having our Supreme Court in india isthat our self respect demands it. Just as we cannot breathe
with other lungs, be they ever so much powerful, so we may
not borrow or buy justice from england.
Comment on jury trials
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
127/130
j y
Trials by jury often result, all over the world,is defeating justice. But people everywhere
gladly submit to the drawback for the sake of
the more important result of the cultivation ofan independent spirit among people and the
justifiable sentiment of being judged by ones
own peers.
Aundh constitution
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
128/130
Gandhis remarks on the new Aundhconstitution.
A. literacy kept as an eligibility for right to vote
B. easy access to justice by making lower courtfree
C. abolition of any intermediate courts
(wanted the same eligibility before granting
right to vote)
Civil v. Criminal
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
129/130
when a man willfully breaks his own laws, the disobediencebecomes criminal What is true of the individual is true of
the corporation. At the present moment one observes this
criminal breach by the govt of its own laws through out India.
Sections of Penal Code and CrPC are being freely abused and
because non cooperators refrain from questioning orders
issued by officials, bare faced illegalities are being committed
by them with impunity is it any one wonder if one infers
from this campaign of repression an intention on the part of
the govt to incite violence when therefore a govt thusbecomes lawless in an organized manner, civil disobedience
becomes a sacred duty.
Famous customs declaration at the
ti f II d t bl f
-
8/4/2019 The Law and the Lawyer
130/130
time of II round table conference
I am a poor mendicant. My kit consists of twospinning wheels, a few jail utensils, a can of
goats milk, 4 lion clothes, two towels and
my reputation which cannot be worth much.