the lifelong journey of the adoptee€¦ · the lifelong journey of the adoptee by jaeran kim...

22
1 © JaeRan Kim, 2011 The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee By JaeRan Kim Keynote presentation for Pact Camp Although I’ve done a number of presentations over the past several years, I do not consider myself a “speaker.” I am at heart a writer and a good listener. That is why, as I have been working on this morning’s presentation over the past few months, I have stressed over how to create a great, dynamic talk. When Beth and I brainstormed for ideas, we both agreed on a presentation about the lifelong journey of an adoptee. So I went about busily putting together a talk based on Erik Erikson’s model of psychosocial development, with David Brodzinsky’s additional developmental tasks for adoptees added on top, and a little brain neurobiology sprinkled throughout. But as today grew near, I realized that my presentation that I’d put together just didn’t feel right. I tried to fix it several times, and then realized why it wasn’t working. I am not a psychologist or a child development expert. In fact, tomorrow you’ll get to hear from a true child development expert. I’m also not an expert on brain neurobiology. But I have 42 years experience as a Korean adoptee and I’ve written a lot about my experiences and thoughts about being a Korean adoptee, and I’ve listened a lot to other adopted individuals. So today, I am going to talk about the lifelong journey of an adoptee by sharing my thoughts and experiences, and those of other adoptees I’ve been privileged to know and hear from. Some of what I’ll share with you reflects my experiences as a transracially adopted person, and some will reflect more general adoption themes. While my experience is unique, what I’ve discovered as I meet more adoptees and adoptive parents is that despite the diversity of experiences and families, there are also a lot of common themes. What I want to highlight today is a normalization of these feelings, thoughts and behaviors of adoptees throughout the life span.

Upload: others

Post on 23-Jun-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee€¦ · The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee By JaeRan Kim Keynote presentation for Pact Camp Although I’ve done a number of presentations over

1 ©JaeRanKim,2011

TheLifelongJourneyoftheAdoptee

ByJaeRanKim

KeynotepresentationforPactCamp

AlthoughI’vedoneanumberofpresentationsoverthepastseveralyears,I

donotconsidermyselfa“speaker.”Iamatheartawriterandagoodlistener.Thatis

why,asIhavebeenworkingonthismorning’spresentationoverthepastfew

months,Ihavestressedoverhowtocreateagreat,dynamictalk.WhenBethandI

brainstormedforideas,webothagreedonapresentationaboutthelifelongjourney

ofanadoptee.SoIwentaboutbusilyputtingtogetheratalkbasedonErikErikson’s

modelofpsychosocialdevelopment,withDavidBrodzinsky’sadditional

developmentaltasksforadopteesaddedontop,andalittlebrainneurobiology

sprinkledthroughout.Butastodaygrewnear,Irealizedthatmypresentationthat

I’dputtogetherjustdidn’tfeelright.Itriedtofixitseveraltimes,andthenrealized

whyitwasn’tworking.

Iamnotapsychologistorachilddevelopmentexpert.Infact,tomorrow

you’llgettohearfromatruechilddevelopmentexpert.I’malsonotanexperton

brainneurobiology.ButIhave42yearsexperienceasaKoreanadopteeandI’ve

writtenalotaboutmyexperiencesandthoughtsaboutbeingaKoreanadoptee,and

I’velistenedalottootheradoptedindividuals.Sotoday,Iamgoingtotalkaboutthe

lifelongjourneyofanadopteebysharingmythoughtsandexperiences,andthoseof

otheradopteesI’vebeenprivilegedtoknowandhearfrom.

SomeofwhatI’llsharewithyoureflectsmyexperiencesasatransracially

adoptedperson,andsomewillreflectmoregeneraladoptionthemes.Whilemy

experienceisunique,whatI’vediscoveredasImeetmoreadopteesandadoptive

parentsisthatdespitethediversityofexperiencesandfamilies,therearealsoalot

ofcommonthemes.WhatIwanttohighlighttodayisanormalizationofthese

feelings,thoughtsandbehaviorsofadopteesthroughoutthelifespan.

Page 2: The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee€¦ · The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee By JaeRan Kim Keynote presentation for Pact Camp Although I’ve done a number of presentations over

2 ©JaeRanKim,2011

I’llbethrowinginalittleoftheotherstuffImentionedaboutdevelopment

too,butmostlyjusttoprovideaframeworkandcontextforthesomeofwhatI’m

goingtoshareabouttheadopteeexperience.Iam,afterall,anexpertinmyownlife.

TherearefourmainmessagesIwanttoleaveyouwithtodayandIwillgo

moreindepthforeachone.Thesemessagesare:

1) Youcan’teraseourpast–includingthehurtandlosswehaveexperienced

2) Themajorityofyourrelationshipwithyouradoptedchildwillbeas

adults.AsIseeit,asaparent,yourjobforthefirstdecadeofyourchild’s

lifeistokeepthemsafe.Yourjobfortheseconddecadeoftheirlifeisto

helpthemlearnhowtokeepthemselvessafe.Andfromthatpointon–

theremaining40or50years–yourjobistobepresentandtohavea

mutuallyhealthy,supportive,reciprocalrelationship.Youmaythinkthat

thislastpartisagiven,butwhatI’velearnedovertheyearsisthatit’s

not.Becauseformanyadoptees,it’sadeliberatechoicewhetherornot

theyaregoingtostayengagedwiththeiradoptiveparents.Andsome

makethechoicetowalkaway.

3) Anadoptee’srealidentityworkbeginslaterthanwhatthe“experts”say

4) Theimpactofadoptionlastsalifetime–andforgenerationstocome

Let’sbeginwith1)Youcan’terasethepast.

Alltheadoptiveparentsinthisroomreceivedthechildtheyadoptedunder

differentcircumstances.Butonethingisthesame.Eachchildthatcomestobe

adoptedhadtohaveexperiencedthedisruptionandlossoftheirbiologicalfamilyin

someway.Inorderforonefamilytobeformedtherehastobeanotherfamilythat

experiencedadissolution.Inadditiontothatfirstinitialloss,formanyadoptees

thereareaddedlayersofloss.AccordingtoErikson,ababy’spsychosocial

developmenttaskiscenteredaroundfiguringoutifs/hecantrusttheworldtomeet

hisorherneeds.Thebabylearnshecantrusttheworldifheisfedwhenheis

Page 3: The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee€¦ · The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee By JaeRan Kim Keynote presentation for Pact Camp Although I’ve done a number of presentations over

3 ©JaeRanKim,2011

hungry,changedwhenhisdiaperisdirty,keptsafefromharmandcomfortedand

loved.Someofushavelivedinmultiplehomesorwithmultiplecaregivers–foster

care,orphanages,withfamilymembersorfriends–eachplacementormoveisa

loss,asistheexperienceofgettingclosetoacaretakeratanorphanageonlytohave

themtransferorquit.Someadopteesareadoptedintotheir“foreverhomes”onlyto

havetheadoptiveparentorparentschangetheirminds.Someareabusedor

neglectedintheirbiologicalhomeorinoneoftheirplacementsbeforetheycome

intoyourhome.Thoseofusadoptedtransraciallyorinternationallyloseour

countryofbirth,ourlanguage,acommunityofpeoplewholooklikeus,social

customs,faithcommunities,food,holidaysandmore.

Ourpastalsoincludesourpre-natalexperiences.Althoughit’snottypically

includedindiscussionsofchilddevelopment,whenwethinkabouttheadopted

person’sdevelopmentwehavetolookimpactofprenatalexperiencesonthe

adoptee,whichcouldincludematernalstress,poornutrition,geneticheritable

influences,environmentalorsubstancetoxinssuchasdrugsoralcoholorlivingin

anareaexposedtoenvironmentaltoxins,poverty,lackofprenatalcare,andviolence

inthehome.Impactsofpre-natalexperiencesmayshowupaslowbirthweight,pre-

termdelivery,immaturedevelopmentordevelopmentalorintellectualdelaysor

disabilities.

Beginningatbirth,ourbrainsbegintoformimplicitmemory–which

continuesthroughoutourwholelifespan.Ifyou’veeverexperiencedasenseof

havinganemotionalreactiontosomethingforareasonyoucan’texplain,it’slikely

yourbrainisrecallinganimplicitmemory.Ourbrainsalsogeneralizerepeated

experiencesandstorethemasmentalmodels.Whenourbrainsrecognizes

somethingthatseemsfamiliar–andrecallsamentalmodel–webehave,feelor

thinkbasedonourmentalmodelofasituation,evenifthecontextissomewhat

different.AsDanSiegelandMaryHartzellwriteinParentingfromtheInsideOut,

emotions,behaviors,bodysensationsandperceptualinterpretationsbasedonour

mentalmodelsformedthroughoutourlivesinfluenceourpresentbehaviorsand

perceptions.And,wedon’tevenknowthatthisishappening.Becausetheyare

formedwithoutourconsciousness,mentalmodelsareveryhardtochange.

Page 4: The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee€¦ · The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee By JaeRan Kim Keynote presentation for Pact Camp Although I’ve done a number of presentations over

4 ©JaeRanKim,2011

Adoptiveparentsdon’twanttheirchildrentosufferandmaythinkthatif

theycanjustworktohelpusforgetaboutourpastthenwe’llbebetteradjusted.But

thisapproachcanbackfire.First,iftheadopteeexpressesgriefoverhisorher

losses,orifwebehavebasedonmentalmodelsofourpasthistoriesofabuse,loss,

abandonment,neglect,orprenatalexperiencesthenadoptiveparentscanfeellike

theywerebadparentsorunsuccessful,thatitwastheirfault.Or,theymayproject

this“failuretoresolvethepast”ontheadopteewhoisunableto“getoverit.”

Inhisbook,BeingAdopted:TheLifelongSearchforSelf,DavidBrodzinsky

writesthatinanattempttominimizeadoptionasaloss,peopleoftencompare

adoptiontodivorceanddeath,twootherwaysinwhichchildrenloseparents.But

becauseinadoptionachildgainsaparentorparents,insteadofan

acknowledgementofloss,anadoptioniscelebratedasatimeofjoy.Peoplehavea

tendencytotelladoptedchildrenthattheywerelucky,somethingtheywouldnever

saytoachildwholosesaparenttodivorceordeath.

Adopteesgrieveinwavesovertime.Aswetalkfurthertoday,I’llhighlight

timeswhereadopteesmighthavemoredifficulty.Ourpastispartofwhoweare,

andcannotbeerased.Ithinkthemostsuccessfuladultadopteesarethosewhocan

recognizetheirlossesbutnotbedefinedbythem.Ihavemetmanyadultadoptees

wholooked“adjusted”butwereactuallyincrisisbelowthesurface,oftenbecause

somewherealongthelinetheyhadinternalizedthebeliefthattheycouldn’tbeboth

grievingandgrateful.

I’mnotwhereIamtodayinspiteofthelossesI’veexperienced,butbecauseof

them.I’vehadthesupportofalotofpeoplehelpingmelearnthatIcantakewhat

I’veexperiencedandpassthatknowledgeon.DeborahJiangStein,atransracial

adopteewhowasbornandspentthefirstyearofherlifeinprisonwithherbirth

motherwhowasincarcerated,andIhadaninterestingconversationonfacebook

lastyear.DeborahwroteonherFacebookwall,“Adiagnosisisnotadestiny.Ordoes

ithavetobe?Oncecalled"at-risk&specialneeds"andmore,Icantestifythatone

canout-doandout-liveadiagnosis.Atleasttoliveaproductive,happy,andfulfilling

life.Buthowoftendopeopleliveuptotheexpectationsofadiagnosis,justbecause

that'sexpected?”

Page 5: The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee€¦ · The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee By JaeRan Kim Keynote presentation for Pact Camp Although I’ve done a number of presentations over

5 ©JaeRanKim,2011

Myresponsewasthis:"Ithinkit'seasierforsometoliveaself-fulfilling

prophecythantospendourlivesconvincingbothourselvesandothersthatweare

morethanthesumofourchildhoodlosses."

ImayhavegainedmanythingsbybeingadoptedtotheU.S.,butI'vealso

experiencedmanylosses.AndwhileIbelieveIammuchmorethanthesumofmy

childhoodlosses,therearestilldays–notoftenbutsometimes-whensadness

bubblesupandoverwhelmsme.Becauseit'shard.Formanyofusadoptees,itwould

beeasiertojustshoveallthosefeelingsoflossandgriefwaydowndeep,

compartmentalizethem,andthrowawaythekey.Forothers,itiseasiertostay

overwhelmedwithgrief.Itotallyunderstandwhymanyadopteesdon'tmakeit.As

difficultasitmaybetobelieve,everytimeIhearaboutanadopteewhohastaken

theirownlife,Igetit.I'vehadtoworkhardtoconvincemyselfthatIammorethan

thesumofmychildhoodlosses-andhavingtoconstantlyprovethattogreater

societyaswelltakesaheavytoll.

I'mfortunatethatIhaveagoodrelationshipwithmyadoptiveparents.

However,havinga“good”(howeveronedefinesthat)adoptivehomedidnoterase

thelossesI'veexperienced.ThereisnothingthatmyAmerican,middle-class

upbringingcouldhavedonetoerasethelossofmyKoreanfamilyandcultureand

language.Iamfrustratedwiththeprevailingassumptionthataslongasthe

adoptiveparentsare"good"ones,theadopteewon'teverfeellossandgrief.I'mnot

convincedbythenotionthata"well-adjustedadoptee"isonewhoneverquestions

adoptionloss,whoneverfeelssadnessorgrief,orwhonevergoesthroughan

identitycrisisoverwhos/heisandwheres/hebelongs.Itangersmethatweare

constantlytoldthatweshould"getoverit."

IrecentlyIheardoneadoption"expert"(notanadoptee,ofcourse)statethat

despitethelossesinvolvedinadoption,asaninstitutionalchildwelfarepractice,

"adoptionisstillthebestinterventionwehaveforchildrenwhoareparentless."As

an"intervention"adoptiongavemeahomeandafamilybutitdidnot"cure"what

causedmetobeinneedofahomeandafamily.Adoptionisnotacure,it'sa

treatment,that-iftheadopteeisfortunateandifit'sdonewell-potentiallyhelps

makesthesorrowsmoremanageable.Adoptiveparentscan’terasetheinitialloss

Page 6: The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee€¦ · The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee By JaeRan Kim Keynote presentation for Pact Camp Although I’ve done a number of presentations over

6 ©JaeRanKim,2011

thatiscoretoadoption,norcantheypreventthatlossfromimpactingtheadoptee.

Especiallysincemanyofthemostchallengingtimesforadopteesoccurafterthey

leavethesafetynetoftheparentsandareoutontheirown.Whichleadsmetomy

secondmessage.

2).Themajorityofyourlifelongrelationshipwithyourchildwillbeasadults.

Inthepastthreeyears,overtwentyofmyfriendshavehadtheirfirst

children.I’vebeenempathizingwithlatenights,pottytrainingissues,sleepingand

eatingandthelackofcoupletimeandthegeneraloverallexhaustionmyfriends

havebeenexperiencingasnewparents.Meanwhile,mypartnerandIhave

teenagers–a13-yearoldsonandadaughterwhowillgraduatefromhighschool

nextyear.Whilemyfriendsareimmersedinthedailyinsandoutsofparenting

babiesandtoddlers–thinkingthosedayswilllastforever–mypartnerandIare

facingadifferentrealityandadifferentstyleofparentingalltogether.Welookat

parentinginamuchdifferentway–welookatparentingteenagersaslearninghow

tohaveauthentic,long-termrelationshipswithourchildrenasadults.

Ifyouthinkaboutit,themajorityofourknowledgeandinformationabout

parentingishowtodotheearlystuff–theearlychilddevelopmentstufflikeI

mentioned–gettingthechildtosleepthroughthenight,eatingwell,keepingthem

safe.That’sthefocusofthemajorityoftheparentingbooksoutthere.Thereisa

resurgenceofadviceforwhenourchildrenbecometeenagers–I’vereadthosetoo–

RevivingOpheliaandbooksabouthowtotalktoyourkidsaboutsex,etc.Buthave

anyofyouseenabookabouthowtobeaparenttoanadult?Howdowecontinueto

havegoodrelationshipswithourkidsoncetheyarenolongerkids?They’reonly

oursforthefirst18-20yearsgiveortake(orformanyofuswhoadopted,evenless)

–butwehopefullyhaveanother40-50yearsofrelationshiptimewithouradult

children.

It’sthesamewhenthinkingaboutparentingadoptedchildren.Themajority

ofthebooksoutthereonparentingadoptedchildrenareaboutchildrenandteens–

under18yearsold.Ithinkthisissomethingthatmostadoptiveparentshaven’t

Page 7: The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee€¦ · The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee By JaeRan Kim Keynote presentation for Pact Camp Although I’ve done a number of presentations over

7 ©JaeRanKim,2011

thoughtabout–therelationshipthey’llhavewiththeiradoptedchildrenafterthose

childrenareadults.

Adulthoodiswhenmanyadopteesstartthinkingaboutabirthfamilysearch.

Oriftheyhavecontactwiththeirbirthfamilies,adultadopteesneedtobegin

negotiatingontheirownhowmuchtimetospendwiththebiologicalfamilyandthe

adoptivefamily.Theymaydecidetoliveintheircountriesorcommunitiesofbirth.

Allthesethingscanfreakoutadoptiveparents,andadultadopteescansmellthis

fear.Asaresult,adultadopteesoftenkeeptheiradoption-relatedactivitiesfrom

theiradoptiveparents.It’sverycommonforadopteestoworryaboutsplitloyalties

regardingbirthfamilyrelationshipsorsearches.

Thiscanbetoughontheadoptee’srelationshipwiththeadoptiveparentor

parents.Theadopteemayreplicateparent/childattachmentandabandonment

issueswiththeiradoptiveparents.Manyofmyadultadopteepeershavetenuousor

strainedrelationshipswiththeiradoptivefamilies.I’veknownmanyadultadoptees

thatseveredcontactwiththeiradoptiveparentsduringthisphaseoflife.It’spretty

commoninyoungadulthoodtoexertindependence.Havingarelationshipwithan

adoptiveparentatthisstageoflifeismoreachoice–andsomeadopteesmay

choosetodistancethemselves.

Otheradopteesmaybecomeclingyandoverlydependentandhaveahard

timeseparatingfromtheirparentsandfamily,eventogotocollege,beginacareer

orsettleintoarelationshiporbeginafamily.Thetransitionintoadulthoodisone

thatmightbemoredifficultforanadoptee,andadoptiveparentsmightnotrealize

thattensionsaroundmovingoutofthehome,startingajoborcareerordifficulties

inintimaterelationshipsmaybeadoptionrelated.

Adoptiveparentsoftenhavecomplicatedrelationshipswithadultadoptees.

Particularlywiththoseofuswhoarealittlemore“outspoken.”Asablogger,thisis

somethingthatIandsomemyadopteebloggerpeersoftendiscussedwitheach

other–whywastheresuchanimositytowardsuswhenwewroteaboutour

thoughtsandexperiences(especiallyasatransracialadoptee)andatendencyfor

adoptiveparents,somewhowereyoungerthanuschronologically,todismissour

reflectionsasadolescentangst?Ithinkit’sbecauseadoptiveparentshavebeenso

Page 8: The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee€¦ · The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee By JaeRan Kim Keynote presentation for Pact Camp Although I’ve done a number of presentations over

8 ©JaeRanKim,2011

caughtupinthedailyworkofparentingchildrenthattheycan’talwaysseetheir

childasanadultadoptee,withtheirownthoughtsandopinionsaboutadoption.

Weparentourchildrenwithourvaluesandbeliefsandhopetheytakethose

onastheirownwhentheybecomeadults.Weseeourchildrenasextensionsofus.

Adoptiveparentstendtothinkthatiftheycandothe“right”thingsthatthey’ll

preventtheiradoptedchildfromgoingthroughanydifficulttimesorbecoming“an

angryadoptee.”

Iunderstandwhyadoptiveparentsfeelrawreadingorhearingadult

adopteesbeingcritical.Acriticismofadoptionseemslikeacriticismoftheadoptive

parentandtheirfamily.Soit’sfairlycommonforadoptiveparentstodichotomize

adopteesinto“well-adjustedadoptees”(whichmeanstheydon’teverythinkabout

theirbiologicalparentsandthinkadoptionisthebestthingeverandhavenodesire

tosearchorthinkaboutadoptionidentity)and“angryadoptees”whoget

pathologizedasbeingdysfunctional,mentallyill,orthattheymusthavehadterrible

adoptiveparentswhowereabusive.Thisisn’tthecaseatall.Someofthe“angriest”

adopteeshavethemostsupportive,amazingadoptiveparents.Andmanyofthe

adopteesfromthemostdysfunctionalandabusiveadoptivehomesgotogreat

lengthstodefendadoption.PeopleareoftensurprisedthatIhaveagood

relationshipwithmyadoptivefamily–theyassumefromreadingmyblogthatwe

mustbeestranged.Doweagreeoneverythingadoption-related?Ofcoursenot.We

havedefinitelyhadourchallenges.

Itwasn'tuntillegallychangedmynamethatIfullyunderstoodthatmy

parents’resistancetomyincorporationofaKoreanAmericanidentitycamefroma

placeoffearoflosingourrelationship.TheypersonalizedeveryattemptImadeto

"reclaim"myidentityasreactionagainstthem.Theyhadsetupadichotomy–

either/or–withKoreaononeendandthem(amentalmodelofAmerican)onthe

otherend.InthismodeleverysteptowardsKoreameantmovingawayfromthem.

OnlyoncetheyunderstoodIwasnottryingtobecomemore“Korean”inorderto

leaveourrelationshiptheycouldletgooftheirfearandbecomemoresupportiveof

myKoreanidentity.AlthoughI’veneverbeenestrangedfrommyfamily,therehave

Page 9: The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee€¦ · The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee By JaeRan Kim Keynote presentation for Pact Camp Although I’ve done a number of presentations over

9 ©JaeRanKim,2011

beentimeswhenourrelationshiphasbeensuperficial.Thosewerethetimeswhen

myadoptiveparentswouldnotwalkwithmeinmyjourney.

Thisisaperfectexampleofhowadoptionisalife-longissue.Iwas36whenI

changedmyname-anadult,withapartnerandtwokids.Iwashardlyapetulant

childdoingsomethingoppositionalinordertohurtmyparents.Andmyparents

wereintheir60s.Ifmysisterhadchangedhermiddleandlastnames,theywould

neverhavefeltitwasanactofangertowardsthem.Theyprobablywouldhave

questionedherdecision,andfeltshewasmakingamistake.Buttheywouldnothave

personalizedit.Raceandnationalityandadoptionandadoptiveparentfearof

rejectiongottangledupinmyadoptionjourney.Perhapsresidualfearonbehalfof

someadoptiveparentsmakethemmoreclingyandresistanttotheiradoptedchild's

normalprocessofindependence.Adoptiveparentscanstrengthentheir

relationshipwiththeiradultadopteechildreniftheydon'tpersonalizetheirchild's

stepstowardsfindingout"whotheyare."Theyneedtorememberthatthissearch

foridentityisanormalpartofhumandevelopment.

3)Anadoptee’srealidentityworkbeginslaterthanwhatthe“experts”say

Erikson’staskforyoungadultsistodevelopthecapacityforintimacy.This

canbeachallengeforyoungadultadoptees.Youngadultsaredevelopmentally

individuatingagain,re-definingthemselvespolitically,spiritually,andsociallyfrom

theirparents.Foradoptees,thismightmeaniftheiradoptiveparentsheavily

emphasizedadoptionthattheymightnotwanttoidentifyasadoptedandmayquit

anyadopteegroupsinwhichtheyusedtoparticipate.Oritcouldmeanthatifthe

adoptiveparentsnevertalkedaboutadoptionthattheadultadopteemightimmerse

themselvesinadopteesocialgroups.

Identityworkisoftenconsideredthedevelopmentaltaskofteenagersand

youngadults,andforadopteesthishappenssomewhat,butI’vefoundthatmany

adopteesreallydon’tbegintodelveintotheiradopteeidentityuntillater.For

transracialadoptees,racialidentityoftenbecomesmoreofanissuethanadoption

identitybecauseofthevisualdifferences.Whentheadopteeisoutsidethe

protectiveandfamiliarfamilyandcommunitysphere,theycanimmersethemselves

Page 10: The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee€¦ · The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee By JaeRan Kim Keynote presentation for Pact Camp Although I’ve done a number of presentations over

10 ©JaeRanKim,2011

intocommunitieswithoutdisclosingtheyareadopted.I’vefoundthatthistime

periodiswhenidentityworkgetsintense,particularlyfortransracialadoptees.

WhenIwentintocollege,IhadtoexplaintopeoplewhyIhadanAnglicizedname

becausetherewerealargenumberofinternationalstudentsfromAsiaatmycollege

andmyclassmatesandteachershadahardtimeunderstandingwhyIdidnothave

anaccentorwasnotaninternationalstudent.Ineverhadtoanswerthisquestion

whenIlivedinmyhomecommunitybecauseeveryoneknewIwasadopted.Itwasa

periodofintenseevaluationofwhatbeinganadopteemeant,inawayIneverhadto

thinkaboutwhenIlivedathomewithmyfamily.

In2009,theEvanB.DonaldsonAdoptionInstitutepublishedareportbased

onasurveyofadultadopteestitled,BeyondCultureCamp.Responsesfromthe

Koreanadopteessurveyedfound“mostKoreanadopteesgrewupincommunities

thatwerelessthan10percentAsian,butalmosthalf(47%)indicatedthereare

largernumbersofAsiansintheircurrentcommunities.Thisshiftalsowasreflected

inthefactthat67percentoftheKoreansdescribedtheextentofdiversityintheir

childhoodcommunitiesas“notatall”to“notverymuch,”whereasmany(42%)

indicatedthereis“verymuch”diversityintheircommunitiesasadults(p.25).”

IgrewupinasuburbofMinneapoliswheretherewas,tomyknowledge,only

oneKoreanAmericanfamilyinmyschooldistrictandaverysmallhandfulof

AfricanAmericanfamilies.Althoughwelived20milesfromthecity,mydaily

interactionswithanyoneotherthanWhiteAmericanswasnon-existent.This

changedwhenIbecameanadult.Ifoundmyselfajobwherethemajorityofthe

employeeswereimmigrantsandIattendedaverydiverseuniversity.And,sincethe

dayImovedoutofmyparent’shome,Ihaveonlylivedinthecityandin

neighborhoodsthatareracially,ethnicallyandsocioeconomicallydiverse.Asa

personofcolor,thisiswhereIfeelcomfortable.Myparents,ontheotherhand,don’t

likewhereIchoosetoraisemyfamily.Tothemyouliveinmyneighborhood

becauseyoudon’thaveachoice,andassoonasyoucanyou“moveup.”Formy

partnerandmyself,livinginourneighborhoodwasourfirstchoice.

Sometimesadopteeidentitydoesn’thituntiltheadopteereachestheir30sor

40s.Thiscouldbebecausetheadopteehasreachedapointinlifewheretheyhave

Page 11: The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee€¦ · The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee By JaeRan Kim Keynote presentation for Pact Camp Although I’ve done a number of presentations over

11 ©JaeRanKim,2011

the“space”tobegintoexplorewhatbeingadoptedmeanstothem.Iamaperfect

exampleofthisphenomenon.Growingup,Ionlyhadonetransraciallyadopted

friend,whomIonlysawatchurchcamp,untilthesummerafterfourthgrade.But

likemanychildhoodfriendships,welosttouch.Oneday,whenIwas30yearsold,I

happenedacrossacopyofKoreanQuarterlyandthepageIhappenedtoopen

featuredthestoryofaKoreanadopteeandherfamily.Therewassomethingfamiliar

aboutthiswoman-hername,thereferencestoherfather,andthecoincidencethat

herdaughterhadmyname(whichisnotverycommon).Therewasane-mailatthe

bottomofthearticleandIwrotetothiswoman,hopingitwasmyfriendfromso

longago.Itwas.Lessthantwoweekslater,weweresittinginthemiddleofacoffee

shopcatchinguponourlives.ItwasthebeginningofmyjourneytodiscoverwhoI

amasaKoreanAmericanadoptee.AyearlaterwewouldtraveltoKoreatogether,

forthefirsttimesinceweweredeliveredtoouradoptiveparentsinMinnesota.

Asamazingasitistomeetotheradopteesthathavesharedsimilar

experiences,ifanadopteeisinanintimaterelationshipthisadoptionexploration

canbeapointofcontention.Iwroteablogpostcalled,“BeingMarriedtoHarlow’s

Monkey”inwhichIsharedsomeofmy(andotheradopteesIknow)struggleswith

intimaterelationships.TodateitistheblogpostI’vereceivedthemostfeedbackon

fromotheradoptees.

Intheblogpost,firstIwroteabouttheimpactthatattachmentandlosscan

haveonanadopteeintermsoftheirintimaterelationships.Adopteesmayrushor

settleintomarriagesorrelationshipsthataren’trightforthembecausetheywould

ratherbewithanyonethanalone.Someadopteesontheotherhandmayalways

have“onefootoutthedoor.”I’veheardmanyadopteesexpresstheycanneverfeel

liketheycanjustsettleintoarelationship-theissueswithattachmentmaybe

expressedasexcessiveclinginessoragain,asaneedfortotalindependence.In

manywaysadultadopteesarereplayingtheirabandonmentandattachmentissues

butthistimewithsignificantintimatepartnerrelationshipsinsteadofparents.

DifficultywithtrustandabandonmentisthesinglemostsharedcommonalityI’ve

foundamongdomesticsame-raceadoptees,foster-adopteesandtransracialand

internationaladoptees.Forsomeadoptedpersons,thatcantranslateasbeingstand-

Page 12: The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee€¦ · The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee By JaeRan Kim Keynote presentation for Pact Camp Although I’ve done a number of presentations over

12 ©JaeRanKim,2011

offish,coldandcommitment-phobic,withatendencytoleavepeoplebeforethey

leaveus.Forothers,thismighttranslateintoclinginess,jealousyandneedinesswith

atendencytowardssuffocatingtheverypeoplewelovethemost.Thisiswhat's

referredtoasinsecureattachment.

ButoneofthebiggestareasofconflictortensionI’vewitnessedistheconflict

thatresultswhenadultadopteesthathavepreviouslynotreallythoughtabout

adoptionbeginstoexplore.Thereisatendencyfortheadopteetobecome

immersed–somemightsayobsessive–aboutadoption.Theinternethashelped

feedthiswithalltheblogsanddiscussionforums.OneoftheFacebookgroupsI

belongtoisforalumnioftheWhiteLilyOrphanageinDaegu,SouthKorea.Currently

thereare80+members,andI’malwaysstruckbyhowfeverish“newbie”adoptees

are.Theretendstobeapatternwheretheadopteediscoversotheradopteesthat

haveaconnectionwiththeminsomeway.Theywanttogettoknowasmanyother

adopteesastheycan.Theysharethemostpersonal,intimatethingsabouttheirlives

withpeopletheybarelyknowjustbecausetheyhavetheadoptionconnection.It’s

verycommonforadopteeswhomeeteachothertosharetheiradoptionstorythe

firsttimetheymeet.Soontherearemeet-upsandmini-gatheringsandspecial

discussionforums.RecenttopicsontheWhiteLilyforuminclude:whohasbeento

Korea,whohasconsideredchangingtheirnamesandwhy,whohastroublewith

dating/relationships,whohasbeenabusedintheiradoptivehomes,andwhat

peoplethoughtabouttherecentlegislationpassedinKorea,includingtherightfor

adopteestoobtaindualcitizenshipandthenewonethatjustpassedacoupleweeks

agothatwouldrestrictadoptionsfromKorea.

Theimpetustoimmerseoneselfinadoptionreflectionmightbetriggeredby

havingachildormeetinganotheradoptee.Iftheadultadopteeispartneredand

beginstoreallybecome“obsessed”aboutadoption,thepartnermaywonder“why

now?”andbecomeresentful.I’veseenalotofrelationshipsbreakupbecauseofthis.

IfoundthisarticlebytheBenevolentSocietyinAustraliabestaddressesthefears

andquestionsthenon-adoptedpartnermighthaveabouttheirlovedoneimmersing

themselvesinadoption-relatedidentitywork.Someofthewordsofwisdominthis

Page 13: The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee€¦ · The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee By JaeRan Kim Keynote presentation for Pact Camp Although I’ve done a number of presentations over

13 ©JaeRanKim,2011

article(andI’vefoundmanyarehelpfulforadoptiveparentstoknowaswell)

include:

• Youhaveprobablygrownupwithyourbiologicalfamily.Thisisavery

differentexperiencefrombeingpartofanadoptivefamily.Adopteesare

cutofffromthingsthatnon-adoptedpeopletakeforgranted–birth

parents,theextendedfamily,geneticinheritanceandsometimesethnicor

racialorigins.Adopteesoftensearchinordertore-connectwiththepast

andcontrarytomanypeople’sbeliefs,thosewhosearcharenot

necessarilyunhappywiththeirlife.

• Adopteeswhohavehadahappyadoptioncanalsoexperiencefeelingsof

emptiness,ofyearningandofsomethingmissingintheirlives.

• Thegriefassociatedwiththissenseoflosscansometimessurfaceatthe

timeofspecificevents,suchasthedeathofanadoptiveparent,theillness

ofalovedone,oron‘happy’occasionssuchasbirthdays,anniversariesor

thebirthofachild.Thesesituationscanallberemindersofthelostbirth

family

• Youmaybetemptedtoundertakethesearchonyourpartner’sbehalf,

wishingtoprotecthim/herfrompossiblehurt.However…thesearchcan

bepartofthehealingprocessforanadoptee.Askyourselfwhetheryou

aretakingcontrolofthesituationratherthanprotectingyourpartner.

• Youmight…feelresentmentwhen[yourpartner]becomeobsessedbythe

searchandalltheirenergyisfocusedonit.Youmaybegintoworrythat

thesearchseemstobetakingovernotonlyyourpartner’slifebutyours

• Ifthereareexistingproblemsinamarriageorrelationship,thestress

causedbyreunion[oridentitywork]canserveasacatalystby

highlightingthese,andsometimesbreakdowncanresult.

[http://www.bensoc.org.au/uploads/documents/IS19_Partners_of_Adoptees_2010

06052.pdf]

Page 14: The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee€¦ · The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee By JaeRan Kim Keynote presentation for Pact Camp Although I’ve done a number of presentations over

14 ©JaeRanKim,2011

Withtransracialadoptees,anotherareaofconflictforcouplesinwhichone

ormorememberisadoptedoccurswhenanadopteemeetsothersfromtheirracial

andethnicgroupforthefirsttimeandbeginstorealizetheymighthavemissedout

ondatingopportunities.SomeKoreanadopteesIknowfeltpangsofregretthatthey

marriedwhitespouseseitherbecauseoflackofdiversitywheretheylivedor

becauseoftheirinnernegativefeelingsaboutAsians.Imaginebeingthatperson

whenyourpartnersuddenlyregretsbeingpartneredtoyoubecauseyou'renotthe

samerace.ManyadoptedKoreansgetdivorcedorseparatedaftertheybeginto

addresstheiradoptions.

EventhoughI’vesemi-retiredfrommyblog,Istillgetemailsfromadult

adoptees.Whatadultadopteeswhoemailmewriteissosimilaritisalmostascript.

Statementslike,Ineverreallythoughtaboutmyadoption/racialidentityuntil...

college/marriage/havingchildren.And,I'vealwaysfeltsoisolated.Mostofthese

adopteeshavegoodrelationshipswiththeiradoptiveparents.Mostofthemlove

themtodeathanddon't"regret"theiradoptions.Butallhaveincommonafeelingof

"wheredoIfitin"andasenseofambiguousloss.Manyhavewrittenthingslike,"my

worldisturningupsidedown."

Theywritetomebecauseforthefirsttime,someonehasputintowordswhat

theyhavefeltbutdidnothavethelanguagefor;orjustthatperhapstheir

experiencesresonatedwithwhatIwrote.Theseadopteesareonlyasmallfraction

ofthoseoutthere,butknowingthey'vefoundsomethingrelatablehasreinforced

mybeliefthatmyvoice,ascriticalasitcanbeattimes,isthereasonIcontinueto

speakout.

UpuntilIwas29yearsold,Iwasthat"happy,adjustedadoptee."Therewere

somethingsaboutmyadoptionexperiencethatwerenegative,andmanythatwere

positive.Ijustnevertoldanyoneaboutthenegative.Ididtheadopteeversionofthe

hustleandjiveforotherfolks.Youknow,tellingthemwhattheywantedtohear

whileinside,Iwascringingatmyownwords.Youknowwhatchanged?Imetother

Koreanadoptees.Knowwhattheysaid?They'dhadthesameexperiencesIhad

growingup;thesamethoughts,thesamefeelingofwalkingintwoworldsandfitting

inwithneither,thesameracialincidentsatschool,churchandhomes.Theywere

Page 15: The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee€¦ · The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee By JaeRan Kim Keynote presentation for Pact Camp Although I’ve done a number of presentations over

15 ©JaeRanKim,2011

alsotryingtofindthebalancebetweentheiradoptiveparentsandtheirown

personaljourney,andbetweenprotectingtheirparents’feelings,orbeingtrueto

theirown.

4)Theimpactofadoptionlastsalifetime–andforgenerationstocome

Humansareobsessedwiththeirpersonalhistories.Wetakegreatpridein

tracingourforefatherstotheMayflowerorapastpresidentorakingorqueen.

Witnessthenamingofsonsafterfathers(myhusbandisthethirdgenerationJohnin

hisfamily).Familynamesareimportant–Inamedoursonaftermymaternal

grandparents,descendentofOliverWolcott,whopennedhissignatureonthe

DeclarationofIndependence.Thereisawholeindustrysurroundinggenealogy;web

sitestosearch,booksoncompilingthedata,magazinesforthehomeanthropologist

onthemostbeautifulandelegantmethodofpresentation.Morethanmere

surnamesorthefamilyschnoz,wedesiretopassontothenextgenerationfamily

culture,mythology,impliedinheritedvirtues,andahistoricalcontextinwhichto

framethefamily’sjourney.IrememberbeingprettysadthinkingabouthowIhad

noabilitytopassonmyculturalheritagetomychildren.Whenmydaughterwas

about4½sheaskedwhyIdidn’tlooklikemyparentsandsiblings.Iexplainedto

herthatIwasadopted.Forawhile,mydaughter’sreactionwastoaskwhereher

“Koreangrandparents”were.ItwasdifficulttoberemindedthatIcouldn’tprovide

thatforher.

WhenIwaspregnantwithmydaughteratmyfirstprenatalcheckIhadtofill

outastandardmedicalhistorychart.UntilmypregnancyI’dneverhadareasonto

haveregularmedicalcare.Wasthereheartdiseaseorbreastcancerordiabetesin

myfamily?HadIhadchickenpoxorGermanmeasles?Iknewnothingofmy

personalmedicalhistoryfrombirthto3years.Asmybabygrewinsidemesodid

thefrequencyoffamilyhistoryissues.AtmybabyshowerIreceivedababybook

andonthesecondpage,thereitwas–twosolidpagesoffamilyhistorywaitingfor

mypentofillintheblanks.IfilledinJohn’ssideofthefamilyandmyadoptive

parentsside.Butwhatismissingsaysmoretomethananythingelse–somewhere

Page 16: The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee€¦ · The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee By JaeRan Kim Keynote presentation for Pact Camp Although I’ve done a number of presentations over

16 ©JaeRanKim,2011

outthereistherestofmyhistory,thefamilywhowillneverhavetheirnames

documentedinmygenealogybecauseIwillneverknowthem.

Mydaughterwasbornintheimageofherdad.Fromthebeginning,Iwas

fascinatedwithwhoshelookedlike.Didshehavemyeyes?Shehadmynose.Her

faceshapeandhaircolorweredefinitelynotlikemine.Shehadherdad’sskincolor,

eyebrowsandcurlyhair.Iassumedshewouldhavetheshockofthick,coarseinky

blackhairtypicalofAsians,notthefine,curlylightbrownhairfromherpaternal

sideofthefamily.Allmyfriendsandfamilymemberssaidittoo;shelooksjustlike

herdaddy.Thisupsetme.I’dspentmywholelifestandingout,theonlydarkheadin

familyphotographs.Iwantedmychildrentoatleastresembleme.

Anothertransracialadopteefriendofminetoldmethatrecentlyshewas

lookingatsomephotosofhertwoyoungsonswithheradoptiveparentsandit

struckherthatitjust“lookedwrong”toseehertwoKoreankidssittingonthelaps

ofherWhite,ScandinavianAmericanparents.Someadopteesbecomeso

accustomedtoseeingthemselvesinfamilyphotographsbeing“theoddone”thatit

doesn’tregister.Butforsomereason,seeingherAsianboyswiththeirwhite

grandparentstriggeredherownsenseofracialisolationandfeelingslikeshedidn’t

“fitin”withherfamily.AnotheradopteeIknowsharedthatshefeltherwhite

adoptivemother“fetishized”herbaby,reenactingtheorientalizedchildhoodshe

experienced.Sheworriedthatifherchildwasoutwithhisgrandmotherthat

strangerswouldthinkhewasadopted,andshefoundherselfshockedtofeelthat

way.

I’vehadadopteefriendssharethatthey’reworriedabouthowtobeagood

parent.Manyofmyadopteefriendsareveryanxiousparentsandareafraidthat

somethingwillhappenthatwillcausethemto“abandon”theirchild.Pregnancyand

childbirthcanbeverytriggeringforadoptees.Regulardevelopmentalmilestones

canbetriggeringaswell.Onefriendwhohasanalmost-3yearoldandisexpecting

anotherbabylaterthissummeraskedmeifitwas“normal”tobawlthedayshe

realizedherdaughterwastheageshewaswhenshewasplacedforadoption.Thisis

prettycommon,actually–IremembermyselfthedaythatIrealizedmydaughter

was14monthsold–thedayIwasfoundatthecityhallinDaegu.MY14-monthold

Page 17: The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee€¦ · The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee By JaeRan Kim Keynote presentation for Pact Camp Although I’ve done a number of presentations over

17 ©JaeRanKim,2011

wassaying“mama”and“dada,”sherecognizedus,shewasstartingtofeedherself

andshewaswalking.WhenIthoughtaboutmydaughterbeingleftatCityHall,it

wasunfathomable.IwastriggeredagainwhenIrealizedthatatalmostthreeyears

old,shewastheageIwaswhenIwassentonaplanefromKoreaandflown15

hourstoastrangefamilyinMinnesota.Icouldnotimaginemychildhavingtogo

throughthat.

Otherthingsthatcantriggeranadopteeparent–children’smoviesand

books,sincesomanyofthemfeatureorphansorchildrenthatareabandonedor

abused(likesomanyoftheDisneymovies.Mydaughter’spersonalfavoriteswere

AnnieandTheLandBeforeTimeaboutanorphaneddinosaur).Schoolassignments

suchastheFamilyTreedon’tgoawaywhenyou’reanadultifyouhaveachildand

theyhavetodotheassignment.Onceagain,theadopteehastodecideifthey’re

goingtosqueezeinathirdbranchifthere’snoinformation.And,onceagain,ifyour

childismultiracialyoumayhavetodealwiththequestionatschoolof“Isthatyour

mom?”orpeoplethinkingthatyou’rethenannyinsteadoftheparent.

Anotherwaythatadoptionimpactstheadopteethroughouttheirlivesand

forgenerationstocomeisdealingwithanabsenceofmedicalhistory.Since2004

theSurgeonGeneral’sofficehaspromotedFamilyMedicalHealthDayfor

Thanksgiving–whereitishopedthatfamiliessharefamilymedicalhistorybecause

itisconsideredthesinglemostimportantmedicalpreventionthatapersoncan

have.FacingunknowngenetichistoryformyselfandmychildrenisanissueI’ve

experiencedalotinthepastfiveyears.Somedevelopmentalandneurobiological

disabilitieshavestronggeneticcomponents.MysonhasAsperger’sSyndrome,

whichoftenhasageneticcomponentandmydaughterhasADHDwhichhasalso

beenfoundtoruninfamilies.Overthepastfewyearsthemedicalneedsofmykids

havemeantthatI’vebeenfillingoutcountlessmedicalhistoriesformykids’doctors

andEverySingleTimeIhavetoexplaintothephysicianwhyIdon’thaveany

medicalhistoryinformationformykidsformysideofthefamily.Notonlyisthisa

constantreminderformethatIlackthatinformationformyself,italsostressesme

outthatIcan’tpassonthatimportantmedicalinformationformychildren.

Page 18: The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee€¦ · The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee By JaeRan Kim Keynote presentation for Pact Camp Although I’ve done a number of presentations over

18 ©JaeRanKim,2011

IusedtoworkatanorganizationcalledMinnesotaAdoptionResource

Network.OneofmyresponsibilitieswastoanswertheinformationlineandIwas

surprisedbythenumberofphonecallsandemailsIreceivedthatwerenotfrom

adoptiveparentsbutfromadultadopteesorfrombirthfamiliesseekingadviceand

informationaboutre-connectingwitheachother.Adopteesintheir50sandolder

hadwaiteduntiltheiradoptiveparentspassedbeforetheyfelttheycouldbegina

searchandnowtheyfeareditwastoolate.OneofthemostmemorablecallsI

receivedwasfromawomaninher60swhodiscoveredafterhermotherpassed

awaythathermotherhadplacedababyforadoption.Thiswomanwantedtoknow

ifitwaspossibletofindhersister.Ialsoreceivedphonecallsfromchildrenof

adopteeswhowantedtofindtheirbirthgrandparents,eventhoughtheirparent

(theadoptee)didnotnecessarilysharethatdesire.AdoptionagenciesinKoreaare

nowseeingchildrenofKoreanadoptees,searchingforinformation.

Formanyyearsmymomhasbeenworkingonafamilygenealogy.Thispast

Christmas,mymomsharedwithmethatshehadlearnedhergreat-grannyhadbeen

adopted,likelyfromanorphantrain.Ifyou’renotfamiliarwiththeorphantrain

movement,letmegiveyouabriefhistory.From1854to1929,anestimated

200,000mostlyorphaned,abandoned,orhomelessimmigrantchildrenfromNew

YorkandotherurbancitiesintheEastwereplacedontrainsthattraveledtotowns

intheMidwest,wherefarmfamiliesandtownspeoplewouldchoosethemfor

fosteringorindenturedwork.Theterm“putupforadoption”originateswiththe

orphantrains,becausethechildrenwouldbeputuponthetrainplatformforthe

prospectivefamilytoview.Formymom,havingaquestionmarkinherownfamily

treeactuallyhelpedherunderstandalittlebetterwhyIfelttheneedtosearchfor

myownroots.I’manadvisoryboardmemberforanorganizationcalledAdoptees

HaveAnswersinMinnesotaandlastyearweputonaneventhonoringOrphanTrain

alumni.Asyoucanimaginethereareveryfewleft.Imetonemanwhose

grandmotherhadbeenadoptedfromanorphantrain.Hewassocuriousabouthis

grandmother’soriginsthathebeganaten-yearsearchtofindoutwhereshecame

fromandhowsheendedupontheorphantrainandintheendwassuccessfullyable

tofindherbirthfamily’sinformation.I’vealsometFirstNationspeoplewhohave

Page 19: The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee€¦ · The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee By JaeRan Kim Keynote presentation for Pact Camp Although I’ve done a number of presentations over

19 ©JaeRanKim,2011

sharedtheirstoriesaboutthedevastationtheNativeAmericanBoardingSchools

hadontheirfamiliesformultiplegenerations.Andifyouevergetthechancetosee

thefilmTheTriumveratebyJeanStrauss,youlearnthatnotonlywasJeanadopted,

bothherbirthmotherwasalsoanadoptee,andherbirthgrandmotherhadbeen

raisedinanorphanage.

I’dliketoendtodaybysharingapoembyKhalilGibranthatservesasmy

ownparentingmantra.

Yourchildrenarenotyourchildren.

TheyarethesonsanddaughtersofLife'slongingforitself.

Theycomethroughyoubutnotfromyou,

Andthoughtheyarewithyou,yettheybelongnottoyou.

Youmaygivethemyourlovebutnotyourthoughts.

Fortheyhavetheirownthoughts.

Youmayhousetheirbodiesbutnottheirsouls,

Fortheirsoulsdwellinthehouseoftomorrow,whichyoucannotvisit,notevenin

yourdreams.

Youmaystrivetobelikethem,butseeknottomakethemlikeyou.

Forlifegoesnotbackwardnortarrieswithyesterday.

Youarethebowsfromwhichyourchildrenaslivingarrowsaresentforth.

Thearcherseesthemarkuponthepathoftheinfinite,andHebendsyouwithHis

mightthatHisarrowsmaygoswiftandfar.

Letyourbendinginthearcher'shandbeforgladness;

Forevenashelovesthearrowthatflies,soHelovesalsothebowthatisstable.

Ithinkthisisabeautifulmeditationonhowtobeanengagedparent.Ilove

theideathatasaparent,Iamthebowthatsetsthecourseformychildrentoflyoff

anddiscovertheworld.ThismeansthatImustbestrongyetflexiblesothatwhenI

launchthem,they’reabletogototheirfulldistance.AndthisiswhatIwouldliketo

encourageyoutobe:strongyetflexible.Ittakesalotofstrengthtobeanadoptive

parent.Adoptiveparentshaveextrachallengesinparentingthanthoseparenting

Page 20: The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee€¦ · The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee By JaeRan Kim Keynote presentation for Pact Camp Although I’ve done a number of presentations over

20 ©JaeRanKim,2011

biologicalchildren.Andinalovelyway,thispoemisamodelforadoptivefamilies

andaddressesthefourmessagesIhadforyoutoday.

Firstofall,asGilbranwrote,childrenarenotobjectstobeowned–theyare

“sonsanddaughtersofLife’slongingforitself.Theycomethroughyoubutnotfrom

you.”Whileadoptedchildrenliterallydonotcomefromtheiradoptiveparentsin

thebiologicalsense,whatIloveaboutthislineisthatallchildrenareseenaspartof

alarger,extendedfamilyandcommunity.Asparentsitisagifttohavethe

opportunitytoshepherdchildrentoadulthood.

Gilbranwrites,“Youmaystrivetobelikethem,butseeknottomakethem

likeyou.Forlifegoesnotbackwardnortarrieswithyesterday.”Parentscan’terase

theirchild’spast,includingthehurtsandlosses.Buttheycansupporttheirchildren

throughtheirgrieving–howeverthatlooks–andbyusingallavailableresources

thatarenecessary.Unrealisticexpectationsareoftenplacedonadoptiveparentsto

bethetherapistandtheparentboth.Youdon’thavetobeyourchild’stherapistand

sometimesthebestwaytohelpyourchildiftheyarestrugglingwithadoption-

relatedissuesistofindtheappropriateresourcesforthem.

Themajorityofyourrelationshipwithyouradoptedchildwillbeasadults.

Gilbranwrites,“Youarethebowsfromwhichyourchildrenaslivingarrowsare

sentforth.Thearcherseesthemarkuponthepathoftheinfinite,andHebendsyou

withHismightthatHisarrowsmaygoswiftandfar.”Sendingthemoffistoughto

thinkabout.Iknowthisfirsthand.Mydaughterissoeagertobeonherownand

experiencelifeasanadult.Ofcourse,I’mmuchmorefearfulbecauseIknowhow

hardtheworldcanbe.ButIseemyjobaspreparingmykidstobecompetentin

beingindependentaswellasvaluingrelationshipsandinterconnectedness,both

withmeandwiththosetheychoosetobuildfamilieswithinthefuture.I’veoften

toldadoptiveparentsthattheirrealmarkerof“success”isnotwhethertheirchild

growsuptobean“angry”adopteeornot,butwhethertheystillwanttohavea

relationshipwithyou,andknowyou’llbetheretosupportthemintheiradoption

journey.

Anadoptee’srealidentityworkbeginslaterthanwhatthe“experts”say.

Gilbanwrote,“Youmaygivethemyourlovebutnotyourthoughts.Fortheyhave

Page 21: The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee€¦ · The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee By JaeRan Kim Keynote presentation for Pact Camp Although I’ve done a number of presentations over

21 ©JaeRanKim,2011

theirownthoughts…theirsoulsdwellinthehouseoftomorrow,whichyoucannot

visit,noteveninyourdreams.”Identityworkforadopteesismorecomplexthanfor

non-adoptedpersons.Adoptiveparentsneedtoacknowledgethisandremember

thattherearenotimelineexpectationsthatanadopteewill“resolve”issuesaround

identity.Infact,aswithlivingwithloss,anadopteemaybeworkingonidentityfor

theirwholelifetime.

Andfinally,weneedtorememberthattheimpactofadoptionlastsalifetime.

I’vefiguredalotoutoverthepastfourdecadesasanadoptee,butIknowthereisso

muchmoreIstillhavetodiscover.BettyJeanLifton,anauthorwhoisconsidered

oneofthefoundersoftheadultadopteemovementintheU.S.passedawaylastyear.

Eveninher90s,shewaswritingandadvocatingonbehalfofadultadoptees.

Beingadoptedislikereadingabookwiththefirstfewchaptersrippedout.It

takesawhiletofigureoutthestorywhenyouaremissingtheintroductionorfirst

fewchapters.Myfriend,LaotianadopteeandpoetBryanThaoWorra,described

beingadoptedas“alifewritteninpencil”becauseoftheconstanterasingandre-

writingwhennewinformationabouthimandhisbiologicalfamilyisdiscovered.

Adopteesarenottheonlyoneswithliveswritteninpencil,however;adoptive

parentsarealsodoingalotoferasingandre-writing.

SomeofwhatI’vesaidtodaymayhavebeendifficulttohear.Andasthis

weekcontinues,someofwhatyou’llhearfromotheradultadopteesmaybedifficult

too–orevenscary.ButIhopethatratherthanbeingfrightened,thisweekservesas

acatalystinstead,motivatingyoutoconsiderwhatmightbeaheadforyouradopted

childthroughoutyourlivestogetherasafamily,soyoucanbegintoreflectonhow

youmightaddresssomeoftheseissuesiftheycomeup.IalsohopeI’vehelpedto

normalizesomeofthecommonareasinwhichadultadopteesstrugglesothatyou

knowthatthesearenormalforanadoptee.

I’mheretoday,atPactcamp,forthesamereasonIwrotemyblog.Sincethat

dayin1999whenIsawmyselfreflectedinanotherpersonwhohadsharedsomany

experiencesasme,IknewIwasnotalone.Iwriteandspeaksootheradopteescan

knowtheyarenotalone.OneofthebiggesttragediesIthinkmanyofusadoptees

experienceisisolation.ThatiswhyPactcampissuchanimportantresourceand

Page 22: The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee€¦ · The Lifelong Journey of the Adoptee By JaeRan Kim Keynote presentation for Pact Camp Although I’ve done a number of presentations over

22 ©JaeRanKim,2011

whyIamthrilledtoseeallofyouhere.ButPactCampisjustthebeginning.Your

kidsarestrongandcapableandsurvivors.Myhopeforeachandeveryoneofyouis

thatthisweekyou’llbegin,orcontinuetobuild,boththestrengthandtheflexibility

you’llneedtosendyourchild“swiftandfar.”