the “miseducation” of american...
TRANSCRIPT
The“Miseducation”ofAmericanIndians
ToviewthisPDFasaprojectablepresentation,savethefile,click“View”inthetopmenubarofthefile,andselect“FullScreenMode”;uponcompletionofpresentation,hitESConyourkeyboardtoexitthefile
TorequestaneditablePPTversionofthispresentation,[email protected]
"Asasavage,wecannottoleratehimanymorethanasahalf-civilizedparasite,wandererorvagabond.Theonlyalternativeleftistofithimbyeducationforcivilizedlife.TheIndian,thoughasimplechildofnaturewithmentalfacilitiesdwarfedandshriveled,whilegropinghiswayforgenerationsinthedarknessofbarbarism,alreadyseestheimportanceofeducation;bewilderedbytheglareofacivilizationaboveandbeyondhiscomprehension,heisneverthelessseekingtoadjusthimselftothenewconditionsbywhichheisencompassed.Heseesthattheknowledgepossessedbythewhitemanisnecessaryforself-preservation.
Educationbefore1492
vBeforelookingatthehistoryoftheAmericangovernment’sattemptsto“educate”AmericanIndians,itisimportanttorecognizethatIndiannationshadtheirowneducationalsystemsfirmlyinplacebythetimeColumbuslandedinHispaniola.
vSucheducationeffortswerebothformalandinformal.Educationwasdeliberate,planned,andvalued,designedbytribalelderstoreflectthesocial,cultural,political,andeconomicneedsoftheirtribe.
vTheinadequateeducationprovidedforIndianyouthpost-ColonizationrepresentsyetanotherwaytheAmericangovernmenthastakenadvantageofandfailedNativepeople.
“Contrarytopopularbelief,education,thetransmissionandacquisitionofknowledgeandskills– didnotcometotheNorthAmericancontinentontheNina,Pinta,andSantaMaria.WeNativeAmericanshaveeducatedour
youththrougharichandoraltradition…” ~Dr.HenriettaWhiteman-Mann
ColonialPeriodvAstheAmericancoloniestookhold,Euro-Americansfeltitwasimportantto“Christianize”and“civilize” NativePeoples.(NoregardwasgiventothefactthatNativePeoplehadtheirownreligions,customs,andformsofeducation.)
vBothGeorgeWashingtonandThomasJeffersonbeganformulatingpoliciesthatwouldpromotethe"civilizingprocess“throughwhichIndianpeoplewouldlearn,appreciate,andpracticeEuro-Americancultural,social,economic,andpoliticaltraditions.
vColonialmissionariesstartedschoolsforNativechildren.MissionariesweretrainedtoconvinceIndians(whowouldcertainlybeuntrustingandresistsendingtheirchildrentocolonialschools)thatfreeroomandboardinacharityschoolwasthekeytotheirchild'ssurvivalinanincreasinglyhostilecolonialenvironment.
vColonialattemptstouseeducationto“civilizeandChristianize”AmericanIndianchildrenfailed,however.FewIndiansattendedandevenfewergraduated.
Intothe1800svWithin20yearsaftertheConstitutionwassigned,twoseparatesystemsofIndianeducationhaddeveloped:
ütribaleducationorganizedandoperatedbyvariousIndiannations;
üfederally-subsidized educationorganizedandoperatedprimarilybyEuro-AmericanChristianorganizations.
TribalEducationvIn the early 1800s, several nations established sophisticated school systems for their children. The Cherokee and Choctaw created an education network which included over 200 classrooms.
vAmong the Cherokee, tribal literacy and journalism flourished as newspapers were published in both Cherokee and English languages. Their motive was clear, according to a Cherokee elder's advice to younger tribal members,
"Remember that the whites are near us. With them we have constant intercourse, and you must be sensible, that unless you can speak their language, read and write as they do, they will be able to cheat you and trample on your rights." (Nabokov, 1991:215.)
vIn1851,theCherokeeNationalCouncilcreatedtheCherokeeNationalFemaleSeminarythatwasoperatedbytheCherokeeNation,notthefederalgovernment.AttheSeminary,CherokeegirlstookcoursesinLatin,French,trigonometry,politicaleconomy,andliterarycriticism.Theyalsostageddramaticproductions,heldmusicrecitalsandpublishedtheirownnewsletter.
FederalEducation:MissionSchoolsChurch&Statepartnerto“educate”AmericanIndians
vDespiteIndianinterestineducationthatcouldhelptribalmemberscopewiththeendlessflowofEuro-Americansintotriballands,thefederalgovernmenttookanentirelydifferentpath.
vIn1819,theU.S.governmentcreateda"CivilizationFund"which providedfederalfundstochurchesandmissionaryorganizationstorunschools(MissionSchools)designedto“educateNativeAmericansinthewaysofthewhiteman.”
vThegoalwasto"civilize"NativeAmericansbygettingridoftheircustoms,traditions,religions,etc.whileteachingthemtoreadandwriteinonlyEnglish.
vTheBureauofIndianAffairs(BIA)wascreatedin1824bythefederalgovernment(andtellinglyplacedintotheU.S.DepartmentofWar)toadministerthefundsgiventotheschools.
TheIndianRemovalAct(1830)&ManualLaborSchoolsvTheIndianRemovalActwassignedintolawMay28,1830,authorizingthepresidenttograntunsettledlandsinthewestinexchangeforIndianlandswithinexistingstateborders.Afewtribeswentpeacefully,butmanyrightfullyresistedtheunjustrelocationpolicy.
vACommissionerofIndianAffairswasappointed(alsopositionedintheU.S.Dept.ofWar)todealwithremovedtribesandchargedwithfiguringoutasystemto“reeducate”Indianstolive“domesticated”livesintheirnewland.
vTheunfairandracistsystemofIndianeducationthatresulted–manuallaborschools-emphasizedvocationaltrainingastheidealtoassimilateIndiansintoindustrialsociety.
TheIndianRemovalAct(1830)&ManualLaborSchools
vManuallaborschoolsturnedthealleged“moral”projectof“civilizingIndians”intoafor-profitexercise,benefitingthereligiousgroupsrunningtheschoolsandsupportedbythegovernment.
vUnderthismodel,churcheswereprovidedhundredsofacresoflandforIndianchildrentoplow,maintainandharvest.ManychurchesmadehighprofitsformthefreelaborofAmericanIndians,creatingincreasedcompetitionforfederalfundingofmoremanuallaborschools.
vIronically,itwasthecompetitivefrictionamongrivalchurchesthatcontributedtotherepealoftheCivilizationFundin1873.
"KilltheIndianinhim,andsavetheman."
BoardingSchools
vBuildingonmodelsestablishedbymanuallaborschools,thegovernmentlookedtodefineanewsystemofIndianeducation.
vFederalplannersdidnotlikedayschoolmodels,whichtheyfeltkeptIndianstudentstoocloseandconnectedtotheirfamiliesandcommunities.(Suchaccessmadetheoverallgoalofassimilation anddeculturalization unsuccessful.)Thus,boardingschoolsbecamethemodelofchoice.
vTheinfamousCarlisleIndianSchool(1879-1918)wasthefirstsuchboardingschool.RichardPratt,itsfounder,attackedthetribalwayoflifeassocialistandcontrarytoAmericanvaluesofcivilization.
"KilltheIndianinhim,andsavetheman."~Capt.RobertH.Pratt,1892(founderofCarlisleSchool)
BoardingSchools
vBy1900,theBureauofIndianAffairswasopening25suchboardingschoolsin15states.
vEventually,over100,000childrenweresenttoover500suchschoolsthroughouttheUnitedStates.
BoardingSchoolsvLikeearliermodels,boardingschoolsweredesignedtoservethepurposesofthefederalgovernment,nottheneedsofIndianchildren.
vThe“education”processbeganwiththe(oftenforcible)removalofyoungchildrenfromtheirhomesandcommunitiesandtransportingthemtoplacesthatwereforeigntothem(bothinlocationandincustoms.)
vUponarrival,studentsweresubjectedtoEnglish-only,Anglo-centriccurriculumand“patrioticpropaganda.”Nativelanguages,customsandreligionswerepurposelyexcluded.
vAnothercentralfeaturewasteaching“workethic”throughforcedmanuallabor.(Inhisannualreportin1881,CommissionerofIndianAffairsHiramPricearguedthatpreviousattemptsto“civilize”Indiansfailedbecausetheydidnotteachthe“necessityoflabor”.)
vChildrenwereoftenundernourishedandsubjectedtoovercrowdedlivingspaces.
vCompulsoryattendancelawsmeantthatfamilieshasnochoiceinwhethertosendtheirchildrentotheseunjustboardingschools.
Warm-UpActivityvConsiderthehistoryyouhavelearnedregardingtheAmericangovernment’spoliciesfor“educating”AmericanIndiansandhowimportantitisthatthishistorybeacknowledged.
vDesignat-shirtthataddressesthishistoryinsomeway.ThepurposeoftheshirtistocallattentiontothemiseducationofNativePeoplethroughouthistory.
vYourshirtcanincludepictures,words,phrases,etc.Becreative!
BoardingSchoolstoSegregated PublicSchoolsvEventually,theboardingschoolexperimentbegantofail.Schoolswerebecomingovercrowdedduetothegovernment’scompulsoryattendancelaws,federalfundingdecreased,andresistancetotheinjusticegrewamongtribes,allofwhichmadethesystemtooproblematicforfederalofficialstomaintain.
vNotonlydidtheschoolsbecomepoliticalandeconomicliabilities,buttheyalsoprovedtobeineffectiveinachievingthegovernment’saimof“assimilation.”
vNativelanguages,spiritualpractices,andothercustomswerenotonlycontinuedbytribalelders,butpasseddownfromgenerationtogeneration.
vIn1906,CommissionerofIndianAffairsFrancisLeupp initiatedthenextplan– thetransferofIndiansintopublicschools.Thegovernmentbelievedthiswouldnotonlysavemoney,butwouldalsohelpwiththeirgoalof“Americanizing”Indianchildren.
vHowever,publicschoolswouldnotbetheperfectsolution.Withsegregationinfulleffectduringthe1900s,AmericanIndianswouldexperienceracismandunequalschoolinginthepublicsystem.
TheMeriamReportvIn1928,anindependentinvestigationoftheIndianOfficebytheBrookingsInstitution,knownastheMeriamReport,sharplycriticizedthequalityofeducationprovidedbygovernment-runIndianschools.
vThereportwasespeciallycriticalofvocationaleducationprograms,whichitnotedwereusedtoprovidestudentlabortokeeptheschoolsrunningandsavethegovernmentmoney.ThereportalsoharshlycriticizedthepolicyofremovingIndianchildrenfromtheirhomesandcommunities andtheseveredisciplinetheyexperiencedatboardingschools.
vThereportcalledformorechild-centered,culturallyappropriateeducationinkeepingwiththethen-currentphilosophyofprogressiveeducation.
vThereportsummarizedthatthemostfundamentalneedinIndianeducationwasa“changeingovernmentattitude.”
JohnCollierandthe“IndianNewDeal”vIn1933,leadingreformerandadvocateofIndianrightsJohnCollierbecametheCommissionerofIndianaffairs.
vHeoversawtheimplementationofmanyoftherecommendationsintheMeriamReport,includingincreasedIndianreligiousfreedomandgreatertribalself-government.
vTheJohnson-O’MalleyAct(1934)wasalsopassedduringCollier’sterm,whichauthorizedpaymentstostatesorterritoriesfortheeducationofIndiansinpublicinstitutions.
vSuchreformswerefeaturesofCollier’sIndianNewDeal,theimpactofwhichsignificantlyincreasedthenumberofIndianchildrenbeingservedbybothfederal(BIA)andpubliceducationalinstitutions.
vTheideaofreform,madepopularbyCollier’sNewDeal,increasedsentimentsto“free”theIndianfromgovernmentcontrol,particularlyfromthereservationsystem.
“Self-Determination”&theCivilRightsMovementvBythe1960s,tribeshaddevelopedacoreleadershipcapableofarticulatingIndianrightsandconcerns.
vInadditiontotheirprotestsofexistingfederalpolicies,thenewIndianleadershipadvocatedanagendaofself-determination,ortheideaof“lettingIndianpeopledecidetheirowndestiny”
vThespiritofself-determinationgaverisetoseveralIndianorganizations,suchasNationalIndianEducationAssociation(1967),theCoalitionofIndianControlledSchoolBoards(1971),andtheAmericanIndianMovement(1972).
vThepoliticalenergycreatedbysuchgroupshelpedtoenergizeeffortstocreatetriballycontrolledschools.
vIn1966,RoughRockDemonstrationSchoolopenedintheNavajoNationinArizonaasthefirstIndian-controlledschoolinmoderntimes.
vCitingthehighcollege-dropoutrateforNativestudents,theNavajotribalcouncilpassesaresolutionfoundingNavajoCommunityCollege(renamedDiné Collegein1977),thefirsttribalcollege.In1978,CongresspassestheTriballyControlledCommunityCollegeAssistanceAct.Today,thereare35tribalcollegesin13states.
Haliwa-Saponi TribalSchoolvIn1957,theHaliwa-Saponi openedoneofthefirsttribalschoolsintheUnitedStates.
vAttheheightoftheJimCrowEra,Nativestudentswereexperiencingracismandinadequateschoolinginsegregatedpublicschools.Tribalschoolswereonesolution.
vFrom1957-1969,theHaliwa-Saponi built,maintained,andoperatedtheHaliwa IndianSchool,oneofthefirsttribalschoolsintheU.S.andtheonlynon-reservation,tribally-supportedIndianschoolinthestate.
vTribalmemberspaidforsuppliesandmaterials,thebuilding,andmaintenanceoutoftheirownpockets.TeacherswereinitiallypaidbydonationstakenupbytheTribe.(Afterafewyearsofoperation,thestateDepartmentofPublicInstructionprovidedfundingforteachersalaries.)
vWhiletheschoolshutdownin1969,itwasreopenedinAugust2000.Theschoolincludesacurriculumbasedonstandardcourseofstudy,smallclassrooms,technology,andAmericanIndianStudies.ItpromotestheculturalandtraditionalheritageoftheHaliwa-Saponi peopleofHalifaxandWarrenCo.
IndianSelf-DeterminationandEducationActof1975vTheeffortsofIndianeducatorsandleadersalsopromptedthepublicationoftwomajorstudiesinIndianeducation:IndianEducation:ANationalTragedy– ANationalChallenge(U.S.Senate,1969)andTheNationalStudyofAmericanIndianEducation(1970)
vThesereportshelpedsecurepassageoftheIndianSelf-DeterminationandEducationActof1975,whichprovidedAmericanIndiansincreasedcontrolovertheirchildren’seducation
vTheactauthorizedspecialfundingforprogramsinreservationschoolsandforthefirsttime,off-reservationurbanschools.
vItalsoadvocatedforparentinvolvementinprogramplanning,fortheestablishmentofcommunity-runschools,andforculturallyrelevantandbilingualcurriculummaterials.
ReportspaintagloomypictureofIndianEducation
vSeveralreportswerealsopublishedduringtheeraofself-determination,suchastheIndianNationsatRisk(1991),theWhiteHouseConferenceonIndianEducation(1992),andtheExecutiveorderonAmericanIndianandAlaskaNativeEducation(1998).IngeneralthesereportsindicatethatwhileprogresshadbeenmadeinIndianeducation,theroadaheadheldmanychallenges.
vOverall,itwasreportedthat:o Indianshavethehighestdropoutratesandthelowestachievementrates.oMostIndiansweresubjecttoschoolswithEuro-centriccurriculums,highteacherturnover,underpreparedteachers,limitedaccesstoculturallearningresources,limitedaccesstotechnologyandcomputers,andracism.Theseproblemsweredeepenedbyadeclineinfederalspending.
oCenturiesofracism,genocideandassimilationistpolicescannotbeundoneinamatterofyears.
ReportspainagloomypictureofIndianEducation
vIn2001,the“ComprehensiveFederalIndianEducationPolicyStatement”wasreleased.Itstatedthatschoolreformmustbesystematicandinclusiveofallaspectsoftriballife.Therelationshipbetweeneducationalreformandthestrugglestopreservetribalhomelands,governments,languages,cultures,economies,andsocialstructuresismadeexplicit.
vThisreportservedasthemodelfor“TheExecutiveOrderonAmericanIndianandNativeAlaskanEducation”issuedin1998bytheClintonadministration.Thisissueofthisexecutiveorderwasahistoricmoment,symbolizingtheeffortsofcontemporaryAmericanleaderstosupportself-determinationbutalsothegovernmentsacknowledgementofthisinherentright.
vWhileprogresshasbeenmade,Indianstudents,incomparisontoallothers,arestillthemostdisproportionallyaffectedbypoverty,loweducationalattainment,andlimitedaccesstoeducationalopportunities.
vAdditionally,thenumberofIndianyouth(12-17yrs.)engaginginhigh-riskbehaviorsisvast.Forexample,druguseismorethantwicethenationalaverageandalcoholuseishigherthanthenationalaverage.
TowardTrueNativeEducation:ATreatyof1992
“Itistimeforanewtreaty,aTreatyof1992,toendashameful,secretwar.Forfivehundredyears,ourtribalpeoplehavebeenresistingthesiegeofthenon-Nativesocietiesthathavedevelopedinournativeland...Ourchildrenfacetheconsequencesofthiswartoday.Everytribalmemberhasfeltthebitterpainsofthisrelentlesssiege.Itdominatesourlives.Itiskillingourchildren.ItisdestroyingourNativecommunities.”-“TowardTrueNativeEducation:ATreatyof1992,”IndianNationsatRiskTaskForce(1994)
vIn1992,theIndianNationsatRiskTaskForcepublishedareportplacingtheliabilityforthefailingsofAmericanIndians’educationinthehandsoftheU.S.government.Yet,italsonotesthatchangewillonlyoccurwhenNativeandnonnativesocietiesmakethecommitmenttoworktogether.
vThereportsummarizesthatNativenationsarestrugglingbecause:o SchoolshavefailedtonurturetheintellectualdevelopmentandacademicperformanceofNativechildren.o Indianlandsandresourcesareconstantlybeingbesiegedbyoutsideforces.o RelationshipsbetweentribesandthefederalgovernmentfluctuatewiththewilloftheU.S.Congressanddecisionsbythecourts.
Readanddiscussthequoteprovidedtoyou:vWhatdoesthequoteprovidedtellyouregardingthehistoryoftherelationshipbetweenindigenouspeoplesandEuro-Americancolonists?
vWhatdoesthequotetellyouaboutthehistoryofAmericanIndianeducation?
vWheredowegofromhere?ImagineyouhavebeennamedasamemberonataskforceforimprovingtheeducationofNativeAmericans.Whatideasdoyouhave?Whoseassistancewouldyouneedandwhy?
v"Thewhiteman'ssuperiortechnology,hungerforland,andethnocentrismseeminglyknewnobounds.ThewhitethreattoIndianscameinmanyforms:smallpox,missionaries,Conestogawagons,barbedwire,andsmokinglocomotives.Andintheend,itcameintheformofschools."CornellPewewardy
v“Understandingthe“theIndianproblem”isnotaproblemofchildrenandfamiliesbutratheraproblemthathasbeenconsciouslyandhistoricallyproducedbyandthroughthesystemsofcolonization:amultidimensionalforceunderwrittenbyWesternChristianity,definedbywhitesupremacy,andfueledbyglobalcapitalism.”SandyGrande
v“Indianeducationwasneversimplyaboutthedesireto“civilize”orevendeculturalize apeople,butrather,fromitsveryinception,itwasaprojectdesignedtocolonizeIndianmindsasameansofgainingaccesstoIndianlabor,land,andresources.”SandyGrande
THECARLISLEINDIANINDUSTRIALSCHOOL:
ThisschoolwasthemodelforanationwidesystemofboardingschoolsintendedtoassimilateAmericanIndiansintomainstreamculture.Over10,000indigenouschildrenattendedtheschoolbetween1879and1918.Despiteidealisticbeginnings,theschoolleftamixedandlastinglegacy,creatingopportunityforsomestudentsandconflictedidentitiesforothers.Inthiscemeteryare186gravesofAmericanIndianstudentswhodiedwhileatCarlisle.
SourcesRedPedagogy:NativeAmericanSocial&PoliticalThought,SandyGrande(2004)
http://americanindiantah.com/lesson_plans/ml_boardingschools.html
http://www.learnnc.org/lp/editions/nc-american-indians/7266
http://www.edweek.org/ew/projects/2013/native-american-education/history-of-american-indian-education.html
http://americanindiantah.com/lesson_plans/ml_boardingschools.html
http://www.ithaca.edu/wise/american_indian/
http://www.edweek.org/ew/projects/2013/native-american-education/running-in-place.html