the proceedings of the 9th european conference on ... · effective leaders hip – can soft skills...

15
The Proceedings of The 9th European Conference on Management Leadership and Governance Klagenfurt, Austria ECMLG 2013 14-15 November 2013 Edited by Dr. Maria Th. Semmelrock-Picej and Dr Ales Novak Conference Co-Chairs

Upload: others

Post on 26-Sep-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: The Proceedings of The 9th European Conference on ... · Effective Leaders hip – can Soft Skills Contribute to the Effectiveness of an Organization? Miloslava Hirsova, Veronika

The Proceedings of The 9th European Conference on Management Leadership

and Governance

Klagenfurt, Austria ECMLG 2013

14-15 November 2013

Edited by

Dr. Maria Th. Semmelrock-Picej and

Dr Ales Novak Conference Co-Chairs

Page 2: The Proceedings of The 9th European Conference on ... · Effective Leaders hip – can Soft Skills Contribute to the Effectiveness of an Organization? Miloslava Hirsova, Veronika

Copyright The Authors, 2013. All Rights Reserved.

No reproduction, copy or transmission may be made without written permission from the individual authors.

Papers have been double-blind peer reviewed before final submission to the conference. Initially, paper abstracts were read and selected by the conference panel for submission as possible papers for the conference.

Many thanks to the reviewers who helped ensure the quality of the full papers.

These Conference Proceedings have been submitted to Thomson ISI for indexing. Please note that the process of indexing can take up to a year to complete.

Further copies of this book and previous year’s proceedings can be purchased from http://academic-bookshop.com

E-Book ISBN: 978-1-909507-88-3, E-Book ISSN: 2048-903X Book version ISBN: 978-1-909507-86-9, Book Version ISSN: 2048-9021 CD Version ISBN: 978-1-909507-89-0, CD Version ISSN: 2048-9048 The Electronic version of the Proceedings is available to download at ISSUU.com. How to use Issuu for the first time 1. Go to the ISSUU home page at www.issuu.com and from there click “log in” - if this is your first visit click “sign up now”

on the log in screen. 2. Enter your name, e-mail address and choose a password. 3. You should then almost immediately receive an e-mail from ISSUU asking you to confirm your details. Do not close

screen until verified on e-mail. 4. There will be a “Welcome back message to verify your account – click verify account. Clicking on the link sent in the e-

mail will take you to the ISSUU homepage. 5. Type http://issuu.com/acpil into the search box at the top of the screen. 6. The proceedings will be displayed they can be opened with various options printing/saving the proceedings being one of

them. Note: click on the Share button at the bottom of the screen in order to access and download the proceedings. 7. When you return to ISSUU.com as a subscriber you will be able to log in straight away. Published by Academic Conferences and Publishing International Limited, Reading UK 44-118-972-4148 www.academic-publishing.org

Page 3: The Proceedings of The 9th European Conference on ... · Effective Leaders hip – can Soft Skills Contribute to the Effectiveness of an Organization? Miloslava Hirsova, Veronika

Contents

Paper Title Author(s) Page No.

Preface Iv

Committee V

Biographies viii

Personality and Expectations for Leadership Tiina Brandt, Piia Edinger and Susanna Kultalahti

1

The Effect of Ownership Structure on Corporate Financial Performance in the Czech Republic

Ondřej Částek 7

Value Co-Creation in the Organizations of the Future Eng Chew 16

The Free State Department of Education: An Audit and Corporate Governance Perspective

Cornelie Crous 24

The Relationship Between Governance and Performance: Literature Review Reveals new Insights

Peter Crow, James Lockhart and Kate Lewis

35

Creative Industries and Creative Index: Towards Measuring the "Creative" Regional Performance

Lukáš Danko and Pavel Bednář 42

Human Resource Control Systems and Family Firm Performance: The Moderating Role of Generation

Julie Dekker, Nadine Lybaert and Tensie Steijvers

50

The Challenges and Benefits of the Multi-factor Leadership Questionnaire (MLQ), in Terms of Gender and the Level of Analysis: A Critical Review of Current Research

Amir Elmi Keshtiban 58

Role of Internet in Supply Chain Integration: Empirical Evidence From Manufacturing SMEs Within the UK

Hajar Fatorachian, Malihe Shahidan and Hadi Kazemi

66

Emerging Organisational Forms: Leadership Frames and Power

Bryan Fenech 76

Responsible Internationalisation of Management Education: Understanding International Students’ Learning and Teaching Needs at a UK Business School

Tatiana Gladkikh, Mark Lowman, Marija Davis, Mike Davies, Mandy Jones, Phill Jennison and Amy Tan

84

IT Governance, Decision-Making and IT Capabilities Kari Hiekkanen, Janne Korhonen, Elisabete Patricio, Mika Helenius and Jari Collin

92

Effective Leadership – can Soft Skills Contribute to the Effectiveness of an Organization?

Miloslava Hirsova, Veronika Zelena, Lucie Vachova and Michal Novak

100

Information Technology Leadership on Electronic Records Management: The Malaysian Experience

Rusnah Johare1, Mohamad Noorman Masrek and Haziah Sa’ari

105

Determining the Most Significant Contributing Risk Factors to Petrochemical Project Failure

Seyed Amirhesam Khalafi, Erfan Haji Akhoondi, Javad Abyar Ghamsari and Parisa Ansari

114

Getting Inside the Minds of the Customers: Automated Sentiment Analysis

Tomáš Kincl, Michal Novák and Jiří Přibil 122

The Impact of the Customer Relationship Management on a Company’s Financial Performance

Karel Kolis and Katerina Jirinova 129

Personnel Planning Reflecting the Requirements of Sustainable Performance of Industrial Enterprises

Kristína Koltnerová, Andrea Chlpeková and Jana Samáková

136

Doing IT Better: An Organization Design Perspective Janne Korhonen and Kari Hiekkanen 144

i

Page 4: The Proceedings of The 9th European Conference on ... · Effective Leaders hip – can Soft Skills Contribute to the Effectiveness of an Organization? Miloslava Hirsova, Veronika

Paper Title Author(s) Page No.

Expectations for Leadership- Generation Y and Innovativeness in the Limelight

Susanna Kultalahti, Piia Edinger andTiina Brandt

152

Managing Organizational Culture Through an Assessment of Employees’ Current and Preferred Culture

Ophillia Ledimo 161

Stakeholder Participation: Legitimization Strategies in Political and Economic Ethics

Michael Litschka 169

An Exploration of the Board Management Nexus: From Agency to Performance

James Lockhart and Peter Crow 177

A Framework for Business-IT Fusion Rob Malcolm and Nina Evans 184

Business-IT Fusion: Developing a Shared World View Rob Malcolm and Nina Evans 191

Māori Women Moving Into Leadership Roles: A New Zealand Perspective

Zanele Ndaba 198

Barriers to Implementation of Batho Pele Framework for Service Delivery in the Public Sector, a Case of South Africa

Telesphorous Lindelani Ngidi and Nirmala Dorasamy

205

Relations Between the Business Model and the Strategy Aleš Novak 214

Women Managers in Croatia: Leadership Style Analysis Morena Paulišić and Marli Gonan Božac 223

Selected Views on the Organizational Culture of Multinational Corporations

Petr Pirozek and Alena Safrova Drasilova 231

The Relationship Between Team Performance, Authentic and Servant Leadership

John Politis 237

What’s Love got to do with Leadership? Angela Senander 245

Human Resources Management and Efficiency in the Public Service: A Nigerian Experience

Olalekan Anthony Sotunde and Akeem Olanrewaju Salami

252

Managerial Capability Valuation of the University Management

Jana Stefankova and Oliver Moravcik 257

The Influence of Quality Management on Corporate Performance

Petr Suchánek, Jiří Richter and Maria Králová

266

Economic Development of Company in Creative Cluster Eva Šviráková 274

Development of a Philosophy and Practice of Servant Leadership Through Service Opportunity

Simon Taylor, Noel Pearse and Lynette Louw

283

Multiple Stakeholder Orientation and Corporate Entrepreneurship: An Empirical Examination

Darko Tipurić, Danica Bakotić and Marina Lovrinčević

290

Relationship Between the Supervisory Board Efficiency and Stakeholder Orientation: Do Stakeholders Matter?

Darko Tipurić, Marina Mešin and Marli Go-nan Božac

299

Proper Strategy Selection as Essential Survival Prerequisite for Small Sport Clubs

Stanislav Tripes, Pavel Kral and Veronika Zelena

308

Significance of Corporate Communication in Change Management: Theoretical and Practical Perspective

Asta Valackiene and Dalia Susnienė 317

The Role of top Management Teams Heterogeneity in the IPO Process

Emil Velinov and Ales Kubicek 325

The Process of Socialization in Relation to Organizational Performance

Tereza Vinsova, Lenka Komarkova, Pavel Kral, Stanislav Tripes and Petr Pirozek

332

The Walls Between us: Exploring the Question of Governance for Sustainability

Philippa Wells, Coral Ingley and Jens Mueller

338

ii

Page 5: The Proceedings of The 9th European Conference on ... · Effective Leaders hip – can Soft Skills Contribute to the Effectiveness of an Organization? Miloslava Hirsova, Veronika

Paper Title Author(s) Page No.

Global key Performance Best Practice Paul Woolliscroft, Martina Jakábová, Katarína Krajčovičová, Lenka Púčiková, Dagmar Cagáňová and Miloš Čambál

346

Gender, Trust and Risk-Taking: A Literature Review and Proposed Research Model

Rachid Zeffane 357

PHD Papers 365

Selection of Employees: Multiple Attribute Decision Making Methods in Personnel Management

Iveta Dockalikova and Katerina Kashi 367

Transformational Leadership, Occupational Self Efficacy, and Career Success of Managers

Chandana Jayawardena and Ales Gregar 376

Manager’s Core Competencies: Applying the Analytic Hier-archy Process Method in Human Resources

Katerina Kashi and Vaclav Friedrich 384

Determining Performance Target Using DEA: An Application in a Cooperative Bank

Manuela Koch-Rogge, Georg Westermann

and Chris Wilbert 394

Strategic Governance of Moroccan State-Owned Enterprises: Constitutional Changes and new Challenges

Abdelmjid Lafram

402

Implementation of CRM in the Industrial Markets in the Czech Republic (Liberec)

Jana Marková and Světlana Myslivcová 412

Tracking Interactions in Collaborative Processes John Rose 423

An Empirical Study of the Contribution of Managerial Competencies in Innovative Performance: Experience from Malaysia

Haziah Sa’ari, Rusnah Johare, Zuraidah Abdul Manaf and Norhayati Baba

432

Critical Path Method Applied to the Multi Project Management Environment

Mircea Şandru and Marieta Olaru 440

Retention of Aging Employees and Organizational Performance: Comparative Study EU Countries and US

Binal Shah and Ales Gregar

449

Application of AHP Method in Service Quality Management Irena Sikorová and Igor Nytra 455

Understanding the Process of Managerial Entrenchment: The Role of Managerial Social Capital in Corporate Governance of a Post-Socialist Economy

Tanja Slišković, Darko Tipurić and Domagoj Hruška

465

Masters Paper 473

A Review of Project Managerial Aspects Influenced by Emotional Intelligence

Mojde Shahnazari, Zohreh Pourzolfaghar and Muhammad Nabeel Mirza

475

WIP Paper 485

The more trust, the fewer transaction costs: Searching for a new management perspective to help solve the challenge of ever rising health care costs

Henny van Lienden and Marco Oteman 487

Late Submission 491

Comparative Corporate Governance Practices by Islamic and Conventional Banks in Pakistan

Sanaullah Ansari and Muhammad Abubakar Siddique

493

Improving Leadership Training Effectiveness through Action Learning Program

Eko Budi Harjo, Yulmartin and Agus Riyanto 498

Development of an organization by adopting the integrated management systems

Dorin Maier, Marieta Olaru, Andrei Hohan and Andreea Maier

507

iii

Page 6: The Proceedings of The 9th European Conference on ... · Effective Leaders hip – can Soft Skills Contribute to the Effectiveness of an Organization? Miloslava Hirsova, Veronika

Preface

These Proceedings represent the work of contributors to the 9th European Conference on Management Leadership and Gov-ernance held this year in Klagenfurt, Austria, on the 14-15 November 2013. The Conference Co-Chairs are Dr Ales Novak from the University of Maribor, Faculty of Organizational Sciences, Slovenia and Dr. Maria Th. Semmelrock-Picej, Austria.

The conference will be opened with a keynote address by Dr Julia Sloan, from Sloan International Inc., USA on the topic of Learning to Think Strategically: A Leadership Imperative for the 21st Century. The second day will be opened by Prof. Vlado Dimovski from the University of Ljubljana, Faculty of Economics in Slovenia with a presentation on the topic of Authentic Leadership.

The Conference offers an opportunity for scholars and practitioners interested in the issues related to Management, Leader-ship and Governance to share their thinking and research findings. These fields of study are broadly described as including issues related to the management of the organisations’ resources, the interface between senior management and the formal governance of the organisation. This Conference provides a forum for discussion, collaboration and intellectual exchange for all those interested in any of these fields of research or practice.

With an initial submission of 145 abstracts, after the double blind, peer review process there are 46 academic papers, 12 Phd Papers, 1 Work in Progress paperin these Conference Proceedings. These papers reflect the truly global nature of research in the area with contributions from Australia, Austria, Belgium, Croatia, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Finland, Germany, Greece, In-dia, Indonesia, Iran, Lithuania, Malaysia, Morocco, New Zealand, Nigeria, Pakistan, Philippines, Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia, South Africa, The Netherlands, UK, United Arab Emirates, and the USA.

We wish you a most interesting conference.

Dr. Maria Th. Semmelrock-Picej and Dr Ales Novak

Conference Co-Chairs

November 2013

iv

Page 7: The Proceedings of The 9th European Conference on ... · Effective Leaders hip – can Soft Skills Contribute to the Effectiveness of an Organization? Miloslava Hirsova, Veronika

Conference Commitee Conference Executive Dr. Maria Th. Semmelrock-Picej, Klagenfurt, Austria Dr Ales Novak, University of Maribor, Slovenia Mini track chairs Dr. Maria Th. Semmelrock-Picej, Klagenfurt, Austria Dr Martina Jakabova, Slovak University of Technology, Slovak Republic Prof Dr John Politis, Neapolis University, Pafos, Cyprus Dr Aleš Novak, University of Maribor, Slovenia Dr James Lockhart, Massey University, New Zealand Dr Coral Ingley, Auckland University of Technology, New Zealand Prof Eng Chew, University of Technology (UTS), Sydney, Australia Prof. Mag. Dr. Larissa Krainer, University of Klagenfurt, Austria Committee Members The conference programme committee consists of key individuals from countries around the world working and researching in the management, leadership and governance fields especially as it relates to information systems. The following have con-firmed their participation: Paul Abbiati (Fellow of the European Law Institute, Member of the CIPS (Chartered Institute of Purchasing & Supply) Con-tracts Group , UK); Dr Mo'taz Amin Al Sa'eed (Al - Balqa' Applied University, Amman, Jordan); Prof Ruth Alas (Estonian Busi-ness School, Tallin, Estonia); Dr. Morariu Alunica (“Stefan cel Mare" University of Suceava, Faculty of Economics and Public Administration, Romania); Mr Sanaullah Ansari (Shaheed Zulfikar Ali Bhutto Institute of Science and Technology , Pakistan); Maria Argyropoulou (Boudewijngebouw 4B , Greece); Dr Leigh Armistead (Edith Cowan University, Australia); Ahmet Aykac (Theseus Business School, Lyons, France); Dr Daniel Badulescu (University of Oradea, Romania,); Egon Berghout (University of Groningen, The Netherlands); Svein Bergum (Lillehammer University College, Norway); Prof. Dr. Mihai Berinde (University of Oradea, Romania); Malcolm Berry (University of Reading, , UK); Professor Douglas Branson (university of Pittsburgh, PA, USA); Prof. Kiymet Tunca Caliyurt Department of Accounting & Finance (Trakya University - Faculty of Business Administra-tion and Economics, Turkey); Dr Akemi Chatfield (University of Wollongong, New South Wales, Australia); Prof Prasenjit Chat-terjee (MCKV, India); Prof Eng Chew (University of Technology, Sydney, Australia); Dr Mei-Tai Chu (La Trobe University, Aus-tralia); Dr. Serene Dalati (Arab International University, Syria); Dr. Phillip Davidson (University of Phoenix, School of Advanced Studies, Arizona, USA); Dr Benny M.E. De Waal (University of Applied Sciences Utrecht, The Netherlands); Mr John Deary (In-dependent Consultant, UK & Italy); Andrew Deegan (University College Dublin, Ireland, Ireland); Dr Charles Despres (Skema Business School, Sophia-Antipolis, Nice,, France); Dr Sonia Dias (Faculdade Boa Viagem, Recife, Brazil); Elias Dinenis (Neapolis University Pafos, Cyprus); Mrs. Prof. Dr. Anca Dodescu (University of Oradea, Romania); Prof Philip Dover (Babson College, USA); Katarzyna Durniat (Wrocław University, Poland); Dr Th Economides (Neapolis University Pafos, Cyprus); David Edgar (Caledonian Business School, Glasgow, UK); Assistant profossor Hossien Fakhari (UMA university, IRAN); Prof Niculae Feleaga (Academy of Economic Studies, Romania); Prof Liliana Feleaga (Academy of Economic Studies (ASE), Romania,); Dr Aikyna Finch (Strayer University, Huntsville, USA); Shay Fitzmaurice (Public Sector Times, Ireland); Dr Silvia Florea (Lucian Blaga Uni-versity of Sibiu, Romania,); Prof Meenakshi Gandhi (IITM, GGSIPU, India,); Associate Prof. Dr Adriana Giurgiu (University of Oradea, Faculty of Economic Sciences, Romania); Professor Ken Grant (Ryerson University, Toronto, Canada); Paul Griffiths (Director, IBM, Santiago, Chile); Adam Gurba (WSZ Edukacja Management Department, Poland); Prof Ray Hackney (Brunel Business School , UK); Joe Hair (Louisiana State University, USA); Memiyanty Haji Abdul Rahim (Universiti Teknologi MARA, Malaysia); Dr Liliana Hawrysz (Opole University of Technology, Poland); Jack Huddlestone (Cappella University, USA); Dr. Pro-fessor Eun Hwang (Indiana University of Pennslyvania, USA,); Dr Katarzyna Hys (Opole University of Technology, Poland); As-sociate Professor Coral Ingley (Faculty of Business and Law, AUT University, New Zealand); Ms Martina Jakábová (Slovak Uni-versity of Technology in Bratislava, Faculty of Materials Science and Technology in Trnava, Slovakia,); Prof Nada Kakabadse (Northampton Business School, UK); Georgios Kapogiannis (Coventry University, UK); Dr Husnu Kapu (Kafkas University, Tur-key); Dr. Panagiotis Karampelas (Hellenic American University, Athens, Greece); Dr. N.V. Kavitha (St.Ann's College for Women, India); Alicja Keplinger (Institute of Psychology at the University of Wroclaw, Poland); Prof Zdzisław Knecht (Wroclaw College of Management, Poland); Maria Knecht-Tarczewska (Wroclaw College of Management “Edukacja”, Poland); Prof Je-suk Ko (Gwangju University, Korea); Dr Dimitrios Koufopoulos (Brunel University, UK); Jolanta Kowal (College of Management and Wroclaw University,, Poland); Larissa Krainer (Klagenfurt University Biztec, Austria); Aleksandra Kwiatkowska (College of Management and Wroclaw University,, Poland); Dean Mieczysław Leniartek (Technical University in Cracow, Poland); Dr James Lockhart (Massey University, Palmerston North, New Zealand); Prof Sam Lubbe (University of South Africa, South Af-rica); Dr Camelia Iuliana Lungu (Academy Of Economic Studies, Bucharest, Romania, Romania,); Ahmad Magad (Marketing Council, Asia, Singapore, Singapore); Dr Virginia Maracine (Bucharest University of Economic Studies, Romania); Bill Martin (Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology, Australia); Dr Xavier Martin (ESSEC, France,); Dr. Aneta Masalkovska-Trpkoski

v

Page 8: The Proceedings of The 9th European Conference on ... · Effective Leaders hip – can Soft Skills Contribute to the Effectiveness of an Organization? Miloslava Hirsova, Veronika

(Faculty of Administration and Information Systems Management, Macedonia,); Dr Roger Mason (Durban University of Tech-nology, South Africa); Michael Massey (International Centre for Applied EQ Leadership, UK); Prof. Luis Mendes (Beira Interior University, Portugal); Mr Philip Merry (Global Leadership Academy, Singapore); Dr Kevin Money (Henley Business School of the University of Reading, UK); Aroop Mukherjee (King Saud University, Saudi Arabia); Dr Birasnav Muthuraj (New York Insti-tute of Technology, Bahrain); Timothy Nichol (Northumbria University, UK); Ales Novak (University of Maribor , Slovenia ); Maciej Nowak (University of Wrocław, Poland); Ass. Prof. Dr Birgit Oberer (Kadir Has University, Turkey); Abiola Ogunyemi (Lagos Business School, Nigeria); Associate Professor Abdelnaser Omran (School of Housing, Building and Planning, Universiti Sains Malaysia, Malaysia); Dr Nayantara Padhi (Indira Gandhi National Open University, New Delhi, India); Eleonora Paganelli (University of Camerino, Italy); Dr Jatin Pancholi (Middlesex University, UK); Ewa Panka (College of Management and Wro-claw University,, Poland); Mr Christos Papademetriou (Neapolis University, Cyprus); Dr Stavros Parlalis (Frederick University, Cyprus); Prof Noel Pearse (Rhodes Business School, South Africa); John Politis (Neapolis University, Pafos, Cyprus); Dr Nataša Pomazalová (FRDIS MENDELU in Brno, Czech Republic); Dr. Dario Pontiggia (Neapolis University Pafos, Cyprus); Adina Simona Popa (Eftimie Murgu, University of Resita, Romania); David Price (Henley Business School of the University of Reading, UK); Dr Irina Purcarea (The Bucharest University of Economic Studies, Romania); Dr. Gazmend Qorraj (University of Prishtina, Kos-ovo); Prof. Dr Ijaz Qureshi (JFK Institute of Technology and Management, Islamabad, Pakistan); Mr. Senthamil Raja (Pondi-cherry University, India); Dr George Rideout (Evolution Strategists, LLC, USA); Prof., Dr Vitalija Rudzkiene (Mykolas Romeris University, Lithuania); Prof. Chaudhary Imran Sarwar (Creative Researcher, Lahore, Pakistan); Dr Ousanee Sawagvudcharee (Centre for the Creation of Coherent Change and Knowedge, Liverpool John Moores University, UK); Dr. Simone Domenico Scagnelli (University of Torino, Italy); Dr. Maria Theresia Semmelrock-Picej (Klagenfurt University Biztec, Austria); Kakoli Sen (Institute for International Management and Technology (IIMT) Gurgaon, , India); Irma Shyle (Polytechnicc University of Ti-rana, Albania); Samuel Simpson (University of Ghana Business School, Accra, Ghana); Dr, Raj Singh (University of Riverside, USA); DR Gregory Skulmoski (Cleveland Clinic Abu Dhabi , United Arab Emirates); Mateusz Sliwa (Wrocław University, Po-land); Dr Roy Soh (Albukhary International University, Malaysia); Peter Smith (University of Sunderland, UK); John Sullivan (School of Information, University of South Florida, USA); Professor Reima Suomi (University of Turku , Finland); Dr Dalia Sus-niene (Kaunas University of Technology, Lithuania); Ramayah Thurasamy (Universiti Sains Malaysia, Malaysia); Dr Xuemei Tian (Swinburne University, Australia); Prof Milan Todorovic (Union Nikola Tesla University, Serbia,); Dr. Savvas Trichas (Open University Cyprus, Cyprus); Alan Twite (COO Vtesse Networks, UK); Dr. Gerry Urwin (Coventry University, UK,); Prof Theo Veldsman (University of Johannesburg, South Africa,); Dr Hab Mirosława Wawrzak- Chodaczek (Institute of Pedagogy , Wro-cław University, Poland); Dr Lugkana Worasinchai (Bangkok University, Thailand); Brent Work (Cardiff University, Uk); Dr. Zulnaidi Yaacob (Universiti Sains Malaysia, Malaysia,); Dr Monica Zaharie (Babes-Bolyai University, Romania);

vi

Page 9: The Proceedings of The 9th European Conference on ... · Effective Leaders hip – can Soft Skills Contribute to the Effectiveness of an Organization? Miloslava Hirsova, Veronika

Getting Inside the Minds of the Customers: Automated Sentiment Analysis 

Tomáš Kincl, Michal Novák and Jiří Přibil Faculty of Management, University of Economics, Prague, Czech Republic [email protected] [email protected] [email protected]   Abstract: Sentiment analysis and opinion mining is being perceived as one of the major trends of the nearest future. This issue follows up on the spontaneous and massive expansion of new media (esp. social networks). The amount of the user‐generated  content published on  social networks  significantly  increases every day and becomes an  important  source of information  for  potential  customers. More  than  75 %  of  the  users  confirm  that  customer’s  reviews  have  a  significant influence on their purchase and they are willing to pay more for a product with better customer reviews. Furthermore one third of  the users has posted an online  review or  rating  regarding a product or  service and  thus became an  influencer himself. Using sentiment analysis, company can take advantage to get  insight from (social) media, recognize company or product reputation or develop marketing strategy responding to the negative sentiment and positively impact consumer’s perception. Moreover,  top  influencers and opinion makers can be  identified  for  further cooperation. Even  though social media monitoring  is  commonly  carried  out  automatically  (by  tracking  selected  channel  or  by  crawling  the  web  and searching  for  given  keywords)  the  analysis  and  interpretation of  retrieved data  is  still often performed manually.  Such unsystematic  approach  is  then  prone  to  subjective  error  and  is  dependent  on  the  experience  and  skills  of  the  person performing  the analysis.  Thus  there  is  a  strong  call  for  automated methods  (based on  computer‐based processing  and modeling)  which  would  be  able  to  classify  expressed  sentiment  automatically.  Good  results  can  be  obtained  with supervised learning models (i.e. support vector machine models). However, for a good performance a good training set is needed.  Such  approaches  also  often work with  lexical  databases  (i.e. WordNet)  or  sentiment  vocabularies  (identifying polarity keywords with the sentiment clearly distinguished i.e. “horrible”, “bad”, “worst”). These models do not work very well when the training set comes from different domain than the testing data and also not many studies have addressed sentiment analysis issue for morphologically rich languages, i.e. Arabic, Hebrew, Turkish or Czech. This experiment tries to develop  and  evaluate  a  sentiment  analysis  model  for  Czech  language  (which  is  morphologically  rich)  which  is  not dependent  on  any  prior  information  (lexical  databases  or  sentiment  vocabularies  which  are  not  available  for  Czech language)  and works well on  different domains. As  training  set data  from Czech‐Slovak  Film Database were used.  The support vector machine based classification model has been then tested on different domain (data from an e‐shop selling a wide range of products from electronics to clothing or drugstore goods). With a good results (accuracy around 80 %), the model  has  been  also  tested  on  other  languages,  including  Amazon  customer  reviews  in  English  (Amazon.com, Amazon.co.uk), German (Amazon.de), Italian (Amazon.it) and French (Amazon.fr). Even on other languages, the model still provided a good performance ranging from 70 to 80 %. This may not sound impressive but there are studies reporting that human  raters  typically  agree  about  80  %  of  the  time.  Thus  if  an  automated  systems  were  absolutely  correct  about sentiment classification, humans would still disagree with the results about 20 % of the time (since they disagree at this level about any answer).   Keywords: sentiment analysis, opinion mining, automated model, morphologically rich languages, support vector machine 

1. Introduction Sentiment analysis is becoming a buzzword these days. With the spontaneous and massive expansion of new media (esp. social networks), this  issue  is being considered as one of the major trends for the nearest future (King, 2011).  Google Trends (showing how often a particular term has been searched across various regions of the world and in various languages) reports more than a fivefold increase of search queries since 2007. Over 7 000 research articles have been written addressing this  issue  in recent years; many startup companies are developing system solutions and also many major statistical packages (SAS, SPSS) include dedicated sentiment analysis modules (Feldman, 2013).   However opinion mining and sentiment analysis is not only a recent phenomenon related to the expansion of modern  technologies. A  long  time before  the www  service was born; people’s attitudes  and decisions had been influenced by their relatives or friends around them (Anderson, 1998, Goldenberg, Libai et al., 2001). As we specialize and narrow our focus, the more frequently we need additional information about certain fields. Thus we have been  looking  for specialists or professionals with  (life) experience who are able to share their opinion or advice. A car enthusiast whom we know could recommend a mechanic or a garage, a respectable 

122

Page 10: The Proceedings of The 9th European Conference on ... · Effective Leaders hip – can Soft Skills Contribute to the Effectiveness of an Organization? Miloslava Hirsova, Veronika

 Tomáš Kincl, Michal Novák and Jiří Přibil 

person we appreciate could help us with the decision  for whom to vote  in the  local election, or a colleague might provide a reference about a job applicant we would like to hire for our company (Pang and Lee, 2008).  The  online  environment made  it  further possible  to  find  out what  others  are  thinking  or  experiencing, no matter  if those are our personal contacts or well know professionals.  In 2008, Pew  Internet & American Life Project Report  (focused on online  shopping behavior) discovered  that more  than 80 percent of US  internet users have previously done online research about a product. Twenty percent do so commonly. More than 75 % of online‐hooked customers confirm that reviews have a significant  influence on their purchase and they are willing to pay more for a product with better customer reviews. In addition, one third of users has posted an online review or rating regarding a product or a service and thus became an influencer themselves (Horrigan, 2008).  Therefore continuous and systematic new media monitoring became an  integral part of company processes. The aim of  such activities  is  to  recognize whether and  (if  so)  in which  context  the media  speaks about  the company, hence companies can adjust  their strategies and  react  in advance according  to public opinions or attitudes (Pak and Paroubek, 2010). Moreover, top influencers and opinion makers can be identified.   The introduction of WWW in 1990s brought revolutionary changes on the media monitoring. Almost all media are now digitalized and available online. New monitoring companies offer a computer‐based processing where country borders or national languages do not matter anymore. CyberAlert – the world press clipping service – monitors  55  000+  online  news  sources  in  250+  national  languages  24 hours  a  day. Many  new  websites spontaneously  emerge,  change  and  disappear  every  single  day.  A  common  user  is  not  only  a  “content consumer”,  but  also  contributes  as  an  author.  Users write  product  reviews,  post  comments  in  discussion forums  or  on  social  networks  or  even  have  their  personal  online  blogs.  Such  fragmented  and  unofficial information is a significant source of word‐of‐mouth or “buzz” about companies and their products. Many of today’s most influential blogs (i.e. The Huffington Post, Techcrunch, Engadget, Mashable) began just few years ago as one‐man‐show, quickly growing into internationally recognized and respected media (Aldred, Astell et al., 2008). However, recognizing sentiment and finding out about people’s attitudes still remains a challenge. Even these days when the data are collected automatically, companies mostly interpret them manually. Such an  approach  is  then  susceptible  to  subjective  error  and  is  dependent  on  the  experience  and  skills  of  the persons  performing  the  analysis.  Nevertheless,  computer‐based  processing  and  modeling  allows  for automated sentiment analysis. Automated systems are repeatedly able to determine the sentiment (whether positive or negative) with 70–80 %  accuracy  (Grimes, 2010).  If  automated  systems were  absolutely  correct about sentiment classification, humans would still disagree with the results about 20 % of the time which is in no contrast to the level of agreement between raters they reached in human‐rated analyses (Ogneva, 2010).  The sentiment analysis is a Natural Language Processing task. The literature highlights two main approaches to this  issue  (Balahur, 2013, Zhang, Ghosh et al., 2011). The  first approach uses a dictionary of words  (opinion lexicon)  to  recognize  the sentiment orientation  (positive, negative or neutral). Thus such approaches are so called lexicon‐based (Feldman, 2013, Taboada, Brooke et al., 2011). Dictionaries for lexicon‐based approaches are  created manually, or automatically  (expanding  the word  list using  seed words)  (Banea, Mihalcea et al., 2013, Zagibalov and Carroll, 2008). Then each word in the document is compared against the dictionary, rated with sentiment polarity score and  its polarity score  is added to the total polarity score of the document. The total polarity score determines the sentiment of the document (Annett and Kondrak, 2008). The weakness of the  lexicon‐based approach often  lies  in  the absence of preselected opinion words  (i.e. slang,  typos or new trendy, fashion words). Furthermore, the polarity of the words might be domain dependent and the analysis is obviously limited just to the language of the lexicon (Zhang, Ghosh et al., 2011).  The  second group of approaches  to  sentiment analysis  is based on  (supervised) machine  learning methods (Pang, Lee et al., 2002). First, the classifier  is trained to distinguish between text elements with positive and negative sentiment. Machine classifiers use not only unigrams or bigrams, but also  longer parts of  the  text, although  the most  successful document  features  are  simple unigrams(Wiegand, Klenner  et  al., 2013). As  a training set, Amazon customer’s reviews or IMDB movie fans reviews are often used (since these sources are publicly available and  contain  large data). However,  it  is well known  that  classifiers  trained on one  specific domain do not perform very well on other domains  (Aue and Gamon, 2005). The most common algorithms used to perform the sentiment analysis are Naïve Bayes, Maximum Entropy or Support Vector Machines (Pang, Lee et al., 2002). Some authors propose hybrid approaches utilizing both approaches – the lexicon‐based and 

123

Page 11: The Proceedings of The 9th European Conference on ... · Effective Leaders hip – can Soft Skills Contribute to the Effectiveness of an Organization? Miloslava Hirsova, Veronika

 Tomáš Kincl, Michal Novák and Jiří Přibil 

machine  learning  together,  i.e.  to  create  the  training  set  for  supervised  learning  (Wiebe  and Riloff,  2005). Others (Godbole, Srinivasaiah et al., 2007) use the Wordnet (a lexical database where nouns, verbs, adjectives and adverbs are grouped  into sets of cognitive synonyms) and there  is also a specialized  lexical resource for opinion mining called SentiWordnet (available just for some languages). Not many studies also have addressed sentiment analysis  issue  for morphologically  rich  languages,  i.e. Arabic, Hebrew, Turkish or Czech  (Tsarfaty, Seddah et al., 2010). 

2. Experiment design  

The  first experiment was designed  to  verify, whether  the  approaches used  commonly  for English  language could be utilized also for the Czech language. Since there are only few lexical resources for Czech language (i.e. stemming  tools or Czech Wordnet) available  (and  those  that are available are mostly paid), we decided  to employ machine  learning methods. All  experiments were  performed  in  RapidMiner  software  (http://rapid‐i.com/), which  is  available  for  free  and  contains most methods  used  in machine  learning based  sentiment analysis (i.e. Naïve Bayes or Support Vector Machines).  As  a  training  set, we used data  from Czech‐Slovak  Film Database  (http://www.csfd.cz/) which  is  the Czech alternative  for  International Movie Database  (IMDB). An automated crawler downloaded and parsed several million comments. The sentiment in CSFD is expressed not only with unstructured text (a fan’s comment about the movie), but  also with  stars  assigned. The  star  scale  goes  from 0  (really bad movie)  to 5 (great movie). Figure 1 displays an example of user evaluation at the CSFD website. 

Source: CSFD website, evaluation of the Avatar movie, available at: http://www.csfd.cz/film/228329-avatar/  

Figure 1: An example of CSFD user evaluation (the Avatar movie) 

The  initial set of experiments  focused on which machine  learning approach works  the best  for  the specified domain (movies)  in Czech  language. Support Vector Machines (SVM) gave best overall performance and was the  fastest  among  tested methods.  This  result  is  consistent with  some  previous  studies  (Boiy  and Moens, 2009).  For  all  experiments,  the  accuracy  (what  percent  of  the  predictions  were  correct),  precision  (what percent of positive predictions were correct) and recall (what percent of positive cases has been caught) was computed. Thus if the results are arranged as in Table 1 

Table 1: A confusion table (pred = predictive, pos = positive, neg = negative) 

  true neg true pospred neg tn  fn pred pos fp  tp 

the accuracy, precision and recall is then computed as  

fntptprecall

fptptpprecision

fnfptntptntpaccuracy

+=

+=

++++

= ,,  

 To  train  the model, 1756 positive and 1575 negative comments have been  selected  (comments with 4 or 5 stars  were  considered  as  positive,  comments  with  0,  1  or  2  stars  as  negative;  3‐star  comments  were considered  as  neutral  and  thus  omitted  from  the  training).  Data  preprocess  included  transformation  into lower‐case  tokenization  (tokens  separated by  spaces  and  stop‐words  filtering  (filtering based on built‐in of Czech stopwords). The model  is shown  in Figure 2  (the grey areas  represent a sub‐setting and sub‐items of given object).  The SVM algorithm was set as C‐SVC  type with  linear kernel. To estimate  the statistical performance of  the model the 10‐fold cross‐validation has been used.   

124

Page 12: The Proceedings of The 9th European Conference on ... · Effective Leaders hip – can Soft Skills Contribute to the Effectiveness of an Organization? Miloslava Hirsova, Veronika

 Tomáš Kincl, Michal Novák and Jiří Přibil 

Figure 2: A classification model in RapidMiner Software 

3. Results Table  2  depicts  the  results  of  training  process.  The  accuracy  of  the  training  procedure  was  almost  80 % (precision and recall reached similar values). 

Table 2: Results of the first experiment 

  true neg true pos class precisionpred neg  1161  319  78.45% pred pos  414  1437  77.63% class recall 73.71%  81.83%   

Accuracy: 77.99 %, precision: 77.63 %, recall: 81.84 %  Then we used  the  testing  set of another 12 000  randomly  selected CSFD comments  (2 000  from each “star rating  class”)  to  evaluate  the  model.  The  star‐rating  has  been  removed.  The  model  established  in  first experiment has been  then used  to  classify  the unstructured data. Table 3 depicts  the key  finding. The  first column displays the rating of the comments; the second/third column then represents the share of comments (with given star rating) classified as negative/positive. For polarized movie fans opinion, the share of correctly classified comments outreached 80 %. 

Table 3: Model performance summary (same domain as training set) 

star‐rating  neg  pos 0  80,40%  19,60% 1  78,65%  21,35% 2  67,50%  32,50% 3  41,90%  58,10% 4  18,45%  81,55% 5  15,35%  84,65% 

Accuracy: 75.14 %, precision: 75.33 %, recall: 74.77 % (0‐2‐stars as negative; 3‐5 stars as positive)  

Thus, for morphologically rich language like Czech, even a simple SVM model worked very well. However it still remains a question, whether the model performs well only in specific domain. Movie evaluations contain a lot of  specific  terms  and  expressions, which  don't  appear  anywhere  else.  Therefore we  decided  to  verify  the model on another domain. An automated  crawler downloaded and parsed  tens of  thousands of  comments from the  largest Czech e‐shop mall.cz (http://www.mall.cz/). The e‐shop sells a wide range of products from electronics to clothing or drugstore goods. 

125

Page 13: The Proceedings of The 9th European Conference on ... · Effective Leaders hip – can Soft Skills Contribute to the Effectiveness of an Organization? Miloslava Hirsova, Veronika

 Tomáš Kincl, Michal Novák and Jiří Přibil 

Source:  mall.cz  website,  evaluation  of  Sencor  hand  mixer,  available  at:  http://www.mall.cz/tycove‐mixery/sencor‐shb‐4355:ranking  

Figure 3: An example of mall.cz user evaluation (Sencor hand mixer) 

The testing set contained thousand randomly selected comments from each rating class (1‐5 star rating). The comments  evaluated  a  variety  of  products.  Table  4  summarizes  the model  performance.  The  accuracy  of classification differs among comments with different  star‐rating. The classification  is more precise  for more polarized opinions. The neutral sentiment is classified partially as positive and partially as negative, but using human evaluators would not give a better results (Ogneva, 2010). 

Table 4: Model performance summary (different domain from training set) 

star‐rating  neg  pos 1  78,60%  21,40% 2  73,80%  26,20% 3  56,20%  43,80% 4  39,50%  60,50% 5  20,80%  79,20% 

Accuracy: 73.03 %, precision: 74.59 %, recall: 69.85 % (1‐2‐stars as negative; 4‐5 stars as positive)  The  first  column  represents  the  rating of  comments, whereas  the  second/third  column displays how many comments was classified negative/positive from each rating class. Even on completely different (and moreover heterogeneous) domain the model performed well. Since many companies are established on more than one market, there might be a good question whether suggested model delivers good and stable result also in other languages. As a training set, we decided to use Amazon data. Amazon is available not only in English, but also in Chinese, French, German, Indian, Italian, Japanese and Spanish languages. As a product we chose the novel Fifty Shades of Grey by E. L. James. This product has enough reviews  in more  languages and the customer’s reviews are also very polarized (see summary on Figure 4). 

Source:  Amazon.com  website,  evaluation  of  the  novel  Fifty  Shades  of  Grey  by  E.  L.  James,  available  at: http://www.amazon.com/Fifty‐Shades‐of‐Grey‐book/dp/B007L3BMGA/  

Figure 4: The user evaluation summary of the novel Fifty Shades of Grey by E. L. James (Amazon.com) 

The experiment was also  limited  to  languages written  in  the  Latin alphabet only. Data preprocess  included tokenization  (into words),  transformation  into  lower‐case  and  stop‐words  filtering  (see  Figure 2).  The  SVM algorithm was set as C‐SVC type with  linear kernel. To estimate the statistical performance of the model the 10‐fold  cross‐validation has been used.  The  set  contained 2884 positive  (4‐5  stars)  and 2247 negative  (1‐2 stars) reviews. Table 5 displays the result for English. 

Table 5: Results of the experiment with Amazon data (English language) 

  true neg true pos class precisionpred neg  2066  157  92.94% pred pos  181  2727  93.78% class recall 91.94%  94.56%   

126

Page 14: The Proceedings of The 9th European Conference on ... · Effective Leaders hip – can Soft Skills Contribute to the Effectiveness of an Organization? Miloslava Hirsova, Veronika

 Tomáš Kincl, Michal Novák and Jiří Přibil 

Accuracy: 93.41 %, precision: 93.80 %, recall: 94.56 %  From Amazon.de, the crawler extracted 1535 positive (4‐5 stars) and 854 negative (1‐2 stars) reviews. Table 6 displays the result for German language. 

Table 6: Results of the experiment with Amazon data (German language) 

  true neg true pos class precisionpred neg  752  64  92.16% pred pos  102  1471  93.52% class recall 88.06%  95.83%   

Accuracy: 93.05 %, precision: 93.57 %, recall: 95.83 %  From Amazon.fr, the crawler extracted 399 positive  (4‐5 stars) and 167 negative  (1‐2 stars) reviews. Table 7 displays the result for French language. 

Table 7: Results of the experiment with Amazon data (French language) 

  true neg true pos class precisionpred neg  118  16  88.06% pred pos  49  383  88.66% class recall 70.66%  95.99%   

Accuracy: 88.51 %, precision: 88.78 %, recall: 96.01 %  From Amazon.it,  the  crawler extracted 88 positive  (4‐5  stars) and 162 negative  (1‐2  stars)  reviews. Table 8 displays the result for Italian language. 

Table 8: Results of the experiment with Amazon data (Italian language) 

  true neg  true pos  class precision pred neg  159  34  82.38% pred pos  3  54  94.74% class recall  98.15%  61.36%   

Accuracy: 85.20 %, precision: 94.90 %, recall: 61.53 %  Thus, the model performed well also on other languages and was able to reach the accuracy over 80 %. Other Amazon websites (in the Latin alphabet) did not contain selected product or enough comments to perform the experiment.  

4. Conclusion The experiment confirmed a good performance of  the model on morphologically  rich  language  (Czech) and even on multiple domains (when the testing and training set doesn’t come from the same domain). The model also performed well on Amazon data from different languages. The suggested model is very simple and easy to implement,  with  no  lexical  databases  or  sentiment  keywords  added  and  thus might  be  a  good  start  for companies which consider sentiment analysis to get deeper inside the minds of the customers.  Automated sentiment analysis became an integral part of market research activities in companies such as Kia Motors, Best Buy, Deutsche Bank,  Southwest Airlines or Paramount Pictures. Even  for morphologically  rich languages,  (supervised) machine  learning methods  can  provide  satisfying  results  not  limited  to  a  specific domain or given language. Although the analysis cannot provide a hundred percent certainty, it can definitely offer important insights (King, 2011). It could be used to gain understanding of customer experience, recognize competitive  dangers  or  discover  emerging market  opportunities.  Opinions  floating  around  the  cyberspace begin to represent vox populi to the degree, in which most market segments participate in online discussions. Automated sentiment analysis might be a good way how to deal with cluttered online environment and how to get insight into the mind of a new millennial consumer. 

5. Discussion and limitations 

The performance of the model could be even better since there are stemmers available for some  languages (i.e. English, German) and  thus  the number of  features  in  the analysis could be  lowered. Some studies also 

127

Page 15: The Proceedings of The 9th European Conference on ... · Effective Leaders hip – can Soft Skills Contribute to the Effectiveness of an Organization? Miloslava Hirsova, Veronika

 Tomáš Kincl, Michal Novák and Jiří Přibil 

suggest to utilize word or character n‐grams to  improve the performance of the model  (Abbasi, Chen et al., 2008). The model will be  tested on more domains and with different settings  to  improve  the performance. Still, the main goal  is to keep the model simple and thus easy to  implement and  find an acceptable balance between the complexity of the model and “good enough” performance. 

Acknowledgements 

This research has been supported by GACR grant no. P403/12/2175 and by IGA VSE project no. 2/2013 

References 

Abbasi, A., H. Chen and A. Salem (2008). "Sentiment analysis in multiple languages: Feature selection for opinion classification in Web forums", ACM Transactions on Information Systems (TOIS), Vol. 26, No. 3, pp 12. 

Aldred, J., et al. (2008). "The world's 50 most powerful blogs" [online]: The Guardian,  http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2008/mar/09/blogs [Accessed 6/4/2013]. 

Anderson, E. W. (1998). "Customer Satisfaction and Word of Mouth", Journal of Service Research, Vol. 1, No. 1, pp 5‐17. Annett, M. and G. Kondrak (2008). "A comparison of sentiment analysis techniques: Polarizing movie blogs", Advances in 

Artificial Intelligence, pp 25‐35. Aue, A. and M. Gamon (2005). "Customizing sentiment classifiers to new domains: A case study". Proceedings of recent 

advances in natural language processing (RANLP), Microsoft Research. Balahur, A. (2013). "Sentiment Analysis in Social Media Texts", WASSA 2013, pp 120. Banea, C., R. Mihalcea and J. Wiebe (2013). "Porting Multilingual Subjectivity Resources Across Languages", pp 211 ‐ 225. Boiy, E. and M.‐F. Moens (2009). "A machine learning approach to sentiment analysis in multilingual Web texts", 

Information retrieval, Vol. 12, No. 5, pp 526‐558. Feldman, R. (2013). "Techniques and applications for sentiment analysis", Communications of the ACM, Vol. 56, No. 4, pp 

82‐89. Godbole, N., M. Srinivasaiah and S. Skiena (2007). "Large‐scale sentiment analysis for news and blogs". Proceedings of the 

International Conference on Weblogs and Social Media (ICWSM), Boulder, Colorado,USA. Goldenberg, J., B. Libai and E. Muller (2001). "Talk of the Network: A Complex Systems Look at the Underlying Process of 

Word‐of‐Mouth", Marketing Letters, Vol. 12, No. 3, pp 211‐223. Grimes, S. (2010). "Expert Analysis: Is Sentiment Analysis an 80% Solution?" [online]: InformationWeek,  

http://www.informationweek.com/software/business‐intelligence/expert‐analysis‐is‐sentiment‐analysis‐an/224200667 [Accessed 6/3/2013]. 

Horrigan, J. B. (2008). "Online Shopping" [online]. Washington, D.C.: Pew Internet & American Life Project,  http://www.pewinternet.org/Reports/2008/Online‐Shopping/01‐Summary‐of‐Findings.aspx]. 

King, R. (2011). "Sentiment Analysis Gives Companies Insight Into Consumer Opinion" [online]: Bloomberg,  http://www.businessweek.com/stories/2011‐03‐01/sentiment‐analysis‐gives‐companies‐insight‐into‐consumer‐opinionbusinessweek‐business‐news‐stock‐market‐and‐financial‐advice [Accessed 6/3/2013]. 

Ogneva, M. (2010). "How Companies Can Use Sentiment Analysis to Improve Their Business" [online]: Mashable,  http://mashable.com/2010/04/19/sentiment‐analysis/ [Accessed 6/3/2013]. 

Pak, A. and P. Paroubek (2010). "Twitter as a corpus for sentiment analysis and opinion mining". Proceedings of LREC, Valletta, Malta. 

Pang, B. and L. Lee (2008). "Opinion mining and sentiment analysis", Foundations and trends in information retrieval, Vol. 2, No. 1‐2, pp 1‐135. 

Pang, B., L. Lee and S. Vaithyanathan (2002). "Thumbs up?: sentiment classification using machine learning techniques". Proceedings of the ACL‐02 conference on Empirical methods in natural language processing‐Volume 10, Philadelphia, PA, USA. 

Taboada, M., et al. (2011). "Lexicon‐based methods for sentiment analysis", Computational linguistics, Vol. 37, No. 2, pp 267‐307. 

Tsarfaty, R., et al. (2010). "Statistical parsing of morphologically rich languages (SPMRL): what, how and whither". Proceedings of the NAACL HLT 2010 First Workshop on Statistical Parsing of Morphologically‐Rich Languages, Los Angeles, CA, USA. 

Wiebe, J. and E. Riloff (2005). Creating subjective and objective sentence classifiers from unannotated texts. Computational Linguistics and Intelligent Text Processing. Springer. 486‐497. 

Wiegand, M., M. Klenner and D. Klakow (2013). "Bootstrapping polarity classifiers with rule‐based classification", Language Resources and Evaluation, pp 1‐40. 

Zagibalov, T. and J. Carroll (2008). "Automatic seed word selection for unsupervised sentiment classification of Chinese text". Proceedings of the 22nd International Conference on Computational Linguistics‐Volume 1, Manchester, UK. 

Zhang, L., et al. (2011). Combining lexiconbased and learning‐based methods for twitter sentiment analysis. HP Laboratories, Technical Report HPL‐2011‐89. 

 

128