the pseudoscience of schizophrenia by dr romesh senewiratne (2011)

Upload: dr-romesh-senewiratne-alagaratnam-arya-chakravarti

Post on 11-Feb-2018

221 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    1/468

    ;

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    2/468

    3

    HEGYNGYX

    Xhmozepmrngok kgi Indusoegs............................................................................................................................................. 0

    Mnrnsy, Dugkhy kgi Suaeurs e` Akignss............................................................................................................................. ?

    Iosnksn Hrnktoeg.......................................................................................................................................................... ;;

    nulngohs kgi psyhmoktry og Kustrkdok.................................................................................................................................. 3?

    Xhmozepmrngok kgi Iepkaogn Cdehjnrs .............................................................................................................................. 96

    K Vsyhmekgkdysos e` Vsyhmoktry........................................................................................................................................ >9

    Vrovktn Mespotkds kgi Aodotkry Heggnhtoegs ......................................................................................................................... 09

    Nulngohs kgi Angtkd Mylnogn ..................................................................................................................................... ;>

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    3/468

    8

    Snsnkrhm eg Inki Angtkd Vktongts og Kustrkdok................................................................................................................... 399

    Yndnpktmy kgi Ioklgesos e` Xhmozepmrngok ........................................................................................................................ 3>3

    Gksty Dkcnds............................................................................................................................................................. 309

    Sndoloeus \krs er hegvnrts kgi akignss ......................................................................................................................... 3

    @rnniea e` Aevnangt kgi Hmnaohkd Snstrkogts ................................................................................................................. 9;?

    Aogi Evnr Akttnr er Akttnr Evnr Aogi5 .......................................................................................................................... 989

    Iosnksn Hrnktoeg cy Vsyhmoktrysean ioklrkas ................................................................................................................ 9>3

    SN@NSNGHNX2......................................................................................................................................................... 9>

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    4/468

    9

    Ogtreiuhtoeg

    Xhmozepmrngok os k tnra tmkt wks heogni og ;?6= cy tmn Xwoss psyhmoktrost Nulng Cdnudnr.

    Xoghn tmng, tmn hrotnrok usni te ioklgesn shmozepmrngok mkvn hmkglni hegsoinrkcdy. Ymos

    ceej prnsngts nvoinghn tmkt tmn tnra mks dottdn shongto`oh busto`ohktoeg, kgi smeudi cn

    kckgiegni.

    Ymeulm O cndonvn tmkt tmn tnra shmozepmrngok os k dkcnd tmkt iens aern mkra tmkg leei, O

    iegt cndonvn tmkt angtkd oddgnss iensgt nxost. Eg tmn hegtrkry, O cndonvn tmkt sean

    inlrnn e` angtkd oddmnkdtm os hdesn te ucoquoteus. Indusoegs krn woinsprnki kgi k``nht aest

    pnepdn te sean inlrnnindusoegs krn khtovndy prepklktni cy tmn akss-aniok, cy pedotohkd

    kgi rndoloeus erlkgozktoegs kgi, `er tmkt akttnr, tmn medy ceejs e` io``nrngt rndoloegs.

    Indusoegs krn og`dohtni eg hmodirng cy tmnor pkrngts kgi tnkhmnrs: tmeulm sean e` wmkt os

    tkulmt os trun kgi herrnht, sean os getsuhm ogherrnht og`eraktoeg, mewnvnr woindy mndi,

    rnakogs indusoegkd.

    Ymn trnktangt e` indusoegs cy tmn psyhmoktry pre`nssoeg os hngtrni eg iruls rktmnr tmkg

    heugsndogl. Ot os io``ohudt `er k pre`nssoeg tmkt os pre`eugidy induini otsnd` te rnaniy

    indusoegs tmeulm tkdj tmnrkpons. Og rnkdoty, tmn psyhmoktry pre`nssoeg `ehusns eg hegvoghogl

    pktongts tmkt tmny su``nr `rea oghurkcdn angtkd oddgnssns cy tmos tejng, khhnptogl tmkt egn

    mks shmozepmrngok os rnlkrini ks lkogogl ogsolmt. Ot os k woindy mndi iehtrogn og

    psyhmoktry tmkt pnepdn wotm shmozepmrngok kgi akgok krn geteroeus `er dkhj e` ogsolmt

    og etmnr weris tmny ie get rnlkri tmnasndvns ks angtkddy odd ugtod tmny krn hegvoghni tmkt

    tmny krn cy tmn psyhmoktry pre`nssoeg kgi ots klngts. Ymn henrhovn gkturn e` psyhmoktry

    rnsudts og pnepdn cnogl pugosmni cy oghkrhnrktoeg kgi ogbnhtoegs ugtod kgi ugdnss tmny

    khhnpt tmkt tmny mkvn suhm oghurkcdn angtkd oddgnss (kgi klrnn te tkjn iruls vedugktrody).

    Ymnrn os ge lrnktnr ogsudt tmkg te cn tedi tmkt egn mks k sohj aogi. Ymn heddequokdosa e` k

    sohj aogi os sygegyaeus wotm nvod. Ot kdse suppesns tmkt tmn akogstrnka e` tmogjogl os

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    5/468

    >

    mnkdtmy, wmodn tmesn wme medi hegtrkry cndon`s krn induini. _nt tmn akogstrnka rnakogs

    induini kceut akgy tmogls. Egdy k `eed cndonvns nvnrytmogl eg tndnvosoeg. Egn gnnis te cn

    gkvn og tmn nxtrnan te tmogj tmkt tmnrn krn ge vnstni ogtnrnsts ogvedvni og wmkt os tndnvosni

    kgi preaetni ks trun cy tmn akogstrnka.

    Indusoegkd tmogjogl os cut egn e` snvnrkd hmkrkhtnrostohs e` shmozepmrngok. Ymn etmnr

    oapertkgt hrotnroeg `er tmn ioklgesos e` shmozepmrngok os mkdduhogktoegs, nspnhokddy kuiotery

    mkdduhogktoegs. Cdnudnrs ogotokd `eraudktoeg `er tmn dkcnd oghduini kuiotery mkdduhogktoegs,

    kgi tmos wks strnssni og tmn ;?>? rn-`eraudktoeg e` shmozepmrngok cy tmn Lnrakg

    psyhmoktrost Jurt Xhmgnoinr og mos dost `orst rkgj syapteas.

    Ymeulm kgtopsyhmetoh iruls (kgi XXSO kgtoinprnsskgts) hkg seantoans hkusn

    mkdduhogktoegs, ot snnas dojndy tmkt dew iesns e` kgtopsyhmetoh iruls hkg rniuhn kuiotery

    mkdduhogktoegs, kgi mkvn k pdkhn og tmnor trnktangt. Ot os kdse oapertkgt, tmeulm, te kiirnss

    tmn vkroeus ngvoregangtkd hkusns e` mkdduhogktoegs, rktmnr tmkg rndyogl eg suhm iruls og

    tmn degl tnra. Ymn `kht tmkt pnepdn ie nxpnronghn mkdduhogktoegs kt toans iens get busto`y

    tmn dkcnd e` shmozepmrngok. Ogstnki, hnrtkog pnepdn aky cn skoi te mkvn k tnginghy tekuiotery mkdduhogktoegstmos kveois tmn stolak e` tmn tnras shmozepmrngok kgi angtkd

    oddgnss.

    Ymn etmnr tnra tmkt os e`tng usni og rn`nrnghn te shmozepmrngok os tmkt e` psyhmesos.

    Ymeulm tmos os k pktmedelosktoeg e` tmn Lrnnj `er prehnss (-esos), wmohm og tmos hksn os

    tkjng te ankg iosnksn prehnss, tmn weri psyhmesos os usukddy ogtnrprntni ks cnogl eut e`

    teuhm wotm rnkdoty. Cut wme os te cn tmn builn e` rnkdoty5 Kgi hkg wn cn su rn tmkt tmnpsyhmoktry pre`nssoeg kgi aniohkd pre`nssoeg (aern crekidy) krn og teuhm wotm rnkdoty5

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    6/468

    0

    XHMOREVMSNGOK KGI IND^XOEGX

    Indusoegs krn rnlkrini ks typohkd syapteas e` tmn suppesnidy oghurkcdn angtkd oddgnss tnrani

    shmozepmrngok. Ymos os hdkoani, og psyhmoktroh tnxts, te cn k snroeus crkog iosnksn tmkt k``nhts kceut

    egn pnrhngt e` tmn werdis pepudktoeg2 kceut 06 aoddoeg pnepdn. E` tmnsn, > te ;> pnrhngt (8 te ? aoddoeg

    pnepdn, aestdy uginr tmn kln e` 96) krn prniohtni te heaaot suohoin. Ymos usukddy os skoi te cn kg

    ugkveoikcdn hegsnqunghn e` tmn oddgnss, kgi get k hegsnqunghn e` ioklgesos kgi trnktangt.

    Dojn etmnr aniohkd kgi shongto`oh kssuaptoegs, suhm hdkoas cy tmn psyhmoktry pre`nssoeg aust cn

    hrotohkddy nxkaogni kgi rnbnhtni o` delohkddy ugseugi. Lovng tmkt oktrelngoh (trnktangt-ogiuhni) oddgnss

    nxosts, kgi tmn anhmkgosas cy wmohm aniohkd ioklgesos kgi trnktangt hkg hkusn oddgnss kgi inktm krn

    wndd nstkcdosmni, ot os surndy gnhnsskry tmkt wn deej hkrn`uddy kt kdd krnks e` hegtnaperkry psyhmoktroh

    prkhtohn `er `dkws, kgi herrnht kgy sotuktoegs og wmohm oddgnss os cnogl hrnktni rktmnr tmkg hurni.

    Ymos os nspnhokddy oapertkgt cnhkusn angtkd oddgnss mks cnng prniohtni, cy tmn og`dungtokd \erdi Mnkdtm

    Erlkgozktoeg, te oghrnksn og tmn ynkrs te hean. Cnhkusn e` wndd-iehuangtni psyhmoktroh kcusns og tmn

    pkst rndktni te tmn mostery e` psyhmoktry ks kg klngt e` pedotohkd kgi sehokd hegtred, ot os hruhokd tmkt tmos

    crkghm e` aniohogn cn nxkaogni hdesndy, deejogl kt ots pessocdn redn og oghrnksogl suohoin rktns, hrnktogl

    irul kiiohtoeg, preaetogl inprnssoeg kgi etmnr angtkd oddgnssns, kgi dkcndogl gerakd kgi kcgerakd og

    erinr te lngnrktn collnr pre`ots `rea tmnor pktongts.

    Ymn rndktoegsmop cntwnng tmn psyhmoktroh pre`nssoeg kgi tmn pmkrakhnutohkd ogiustry wodd cn hdesndy

    nxkaogni og tmos ceej, og wmohm og wmohm O wodd oddustrktn tmn cdurrni dogn cntwnng vkroeus angtkd

    mnkdtm preaetoeg strktnlons kgi irul akrjntogl strktnlons. Og rnkdoty , `kr `rea durjogl eg strnnt

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    7/468

    ) hdkoas2

    Evnrkdd, tmn rktn e` suohoin kaegl ogiovoiukds wotm shmozepmrngok os kpprexoaktndy ;6% og tmn

    `orst `ovn ynkrs `eddewogl ioklgesos. Xuohoin os e`tng rndktni te inprnssoeg cut aky kdse ehhur og

    tmn kcsnghn e` inprnssoeg, seantoans og rnspegsn te indusoegkd cndon`s. Etmnr `khters kssehoktni

    wotm inprnssoeg kgi suohoin oghduin2 k sngsn e` pnrsegkd dess: dess e` `uturn mepn: dew snd`-

    nstnna tmreulm cnogl dkcnddni kgi stolaktosni: k `nndogl e` get cnogl og hegtred e` tmogls:

    ugpdnkskgt syapteas: evnraniohktoeg: er trkuaktoh nxpnronghns wmodn og mespotkd. (p.

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    13/468

    ;8

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    14/468

    ;9

    Ecvoeusdy, mew yeugl pnepdn ngvoskln tmn n``nhts e` shmozepmrngok inpngis eg wmkt tmny cndonvn

    kceut shmozepmrngok. Ymos, og turg, inpngis eg wmkt tmny krn tedi kgi wmkt tmny rnki kceut ot, wmkt

    tmny snn eg tndnvosoeg kgi wmkt tmny lktmnr cy tkdjogl te etmnr shmozepmrngohs.

    O` k yeugl pnrseg kttnapts suohoin er heaaots suohoin cnhkusn mn er smn inspkors e` tmn `uturn eg

    khheugt e` k ioklgesos e` shmozepmrngok, tmn rnksegs `er suhm mepndnssgnss krn hdnkrdy nvoingt og

    psyhmoktry kgi psyhmedely tnxtceejs, pepudkr psyhmoktry ceejs kgi pucdoh niuhktoegkd dotnrkturn

    telntmnr wotm aniok pertrkykds e` pkrkgeoi shmozepmrngohs. Ymn Kanrohkg tnxtceej Vsyhmedely

    (;??>) cy Ikvoi Aynrs, `rea wmohm ugovnrsoty stuingts hkg kii te tmnor aosheghnptoegs, inshrocnsshmozepmrngok tmus2

    O` inprnssoeg os tmn heaaeg hedi e` psyhmedelohkd ioserinrs, hmregoh shmozepmrngok os tmn

    hkghnr. Kceut ; og ;66 pnepdn wodd invndep shmozepmrngok, beogogl aoddoegs wme mkvn su``nrni

    egn e` muakgotys aest irnkini ioserinrs. (p.>38)

    Xhmozepmrngok, aern tmkg kgy etmnr psyhmoktroh ioklgesos os kssehoktni wotm stnrnetypohkd oinks e`

    akignss2 ot crogls te tmn aogi e` tmn ugog`erani `rolmtngogl oaklns e` inrkglni, induini, ikglnreus

    pnepdn wme mnkr oaklogkry veohns kgi cnmkvn og cozkrrn, ugprniohtkcdn, `rolmtngogl wkys. Mew

    pnepdn oaklogn kgi builn heapdntn ogskgoty, stkrj, rkvogl akignss, tetkd dugkhy kgi etmnr

    sygegyas `er snroeus akignss krn ks vkroni ks tmn ogiovoiukd nxpnronghns e` anacnrs e` tmn muakg

    rkhn. Aest pnepdn mkvn akin, kt sean stkln, builangts e` etmnrs, kt dnkst og tmn provkhy e` tmnor ewg

    aogis, rnlkriogl akignss. Ymny aky mkvn tmeulmt seanegn te cn iosturcni, inrkglni,hrkzy, k

    gut, k `ruot-deep, k wnorie, k dugktoh, k psyhme, k akiakg er sean etmnr soaodkr inrelktery

    tnra.

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    15/468

    ;>

    Os shmozepmrngok bust kgetmnr gksty gkan er iens ot mkvn rnkd shongto`oh ankgogl kgi tmnrkpnutoh

    vkdun5 O` ot os tmn `eranr, tmn `kht tmkt aoddoegs e` pnepdn mkvn heaaottni suohoin cnhkusn e` ot os k

    aniohkd ioskstnr tmkt in`ons heaprnmngsoeg.

    Xhmozepmrngok os k aniohkd tnra wmohm mks gew, dojn akgy etmnrs, ngtnrni heddequokd dkglukln. Og

    pepudkr hudturn tmn tnra mks cnng kccrnvoktni te shmoze er shmozes2 usukddy usni ks tnras e` kcusn.

    Ymn aniohkd heogkln e` tmos auhm-kcusni tnra wks k iostoght mosterohkd nvngt kgi iegn `er rnksegkcdn

    (kgi aern er dnss oggehueus) shongto`oh kgi aniohkd rnksegs. Ymos nvngt hkg cn oingto`oni, quotn

    dotnrkddy, ks tmn `orst hrnktoeg e` shmozepmrngok (cut get, e` heursn, e` ogskgoty er akignss). Inspotn otssucsnqungt aosusns, tmn gkan shmozepmrngok wks ugieuctnidy kg oaprevnangt eg tmn aosdnkiogl

    kgi shongto`ohkddy ugbusto`okcdn tnra ot rnpdkhni, inangtok prknhex, wmohm wks kdse hrnktni cy k

    jgewg pnrseg kt k jgewg toan. Ymn tnra inangtok prknhex wks heogni cy tmn Lnrakg psyhmoktrost

    Naod Jrknpndog og ;=?8 kgi Nulng Cdnudnr rngkani tmn hegiotoeg shmozepmrngok og ;?6=.

    Vre`nsser Cdnudnr, k Xwoss psyhmoktrost, hrnktni tmn tnra shmoze -pmrngok `rea tmn Lrnnjshmoze(spdot)

    kgi pmrng (aogi). Mn cndonvni mos gnedelosa cnttnr nxpdkogni tmn hkusktoeg e` tmn hegiotoeg

    prnvoeusdy inshrocni cy tmn naogngt Lnrakg `ktmnr e` psyhmoktry,Jrknpndog, ks inangtok prknhex.

    Ymn nkrdy mostery e` shmozepmrngok tmnery os suaakrosni cy Vre`nsser Orvogl Lettnsakg og

    Xhmozepmrngok Lngnsos2 tmn Erologs e` Akignss(;??;)2

    Naod Jrknpndog (;=>0-;?30), tmn `kaeus Lnrakg hdogohkd psyhmoktrost, cnhkan tmn in`ogotovn

    hktnleroznr kgi erlkgoznr e` tmn kcgerakd dkglukln kgi cnmkvoer tmkt akjn up tmn sucstkghn e`

    hegtnaperkry psyhmepktmedely. Jrknpndogs hdogohkd kgkdysns e` shmozepmrngohs stkgi, `er tmn

    aest pkrt, ks tmn inshroptovn tnras usni teiky. Mnlkvn tmos heaprnmngsovn akdkiy tmn gkan

    inangtok prknhex. Jrknpndog cndonvni tmkt kg kiednshngt wme invndepni mkdduhogktoegs kgi

    indusoegs, cnmkvni cozkrrndy, kgi rnakogni odd og tmos wky `er kg nxtngini pnroei e` toan

    su``nrni `rea tmn oddgnss...Jrknpndog in`ogni tmn iosnksn ks k snrons e` hdogohkd pohturns wotm k

    heaaeg `nkturn2 tnraogktoeg og angtkd wnkjgnssOg Xwotznrdkgi og ;?6= Nulng Cdnudnr

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    16/468

    ;0

    (;=>

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    17/468

    ;6s, tmn hrotnrok `er tmn ioklgesos e` shmozepmrngok wks crekingni hegsoinrkcdy spnkrmnkini

    cy tmn `orst rkgj syapteas dostni cy Vre`nsser Jurt Xhmgnoinr e` tmn ^govnrsoty e` Mnoindcnrl ogLnrakgy. Iurogl tmn Xnhegi \erdi \kr tmos ugovnrsoty mki ngtmusokstohkddy nacrkhni tmn iehtrogns e`

    nulngohs kgi suppertni tmn Gkzo Lnrakg levnrgangts pedohy e` nxtnraogktoeg e` pnepdn dkcndni ks

    angtkddy odd. Ymn estngsocdn ecbnhtovn e` tmos akss-aurinr wks te rniuhn tmn cki cdeei og tmn Lnrakg

    kgi Nurepnkg cdeei dogns. E` heursn, tmesn wme eppesni tmn Lnrakg levnrgangt e` tmn iky wnrn

    hkgioiktns `er suhm dkcnds e` angtkd oddgnss. Ymn Lnrakg levnrgangts vonw wks tmkt yeui mkvn te

    cn aki get te suppert Motdnr.

    Ymn Hedi \kr cnlkg wotm tmn trnktons tmkt ngsuni `eddewogl tmn ngi e` tmn Xnhegi \erdi \kr kgi tmn`eraktoeg e` tmn ^gotni Gktoegs Erlkgozktoeg `rea tmn vnstolns e` tmn Dnklun e` Gktoegs. Ymn vohters

    e` tmn Xnhegi \erdi \kr pdkhni tmnasndvns ks tmn `ovn pnrakgngt anacnrs e` tmn Xnhuroty Heughod,

    wotm k akgiktn te prnvngt `urtmnr wkrs. Ymn \erdi Ckgj kgi \erdi Mnkdtm Erlkgozktoeg hegstotutni k

    trouavorktn hegtreddogl ldeckd pedotohs, nhegeaohs kgi mnkdtm. Ymn aeinrg hrotnrok `er tmn ioklgesos e`

    shmoezepmrngok mkvn cnng stregldy preaetni cy tmn \erdi Mnkdtm Erlkgozktoeg. @rea tmn ;?06s

    egwkris tmnsn hrotnrok mkvn cnng cksni eg Xhmgnoinrs @orst Skgj Xyapteas.

    Og ;?>?, wndd ogte tmn Hedi \kr, Xhmgnoinr dostni ;; syapteas kgi solgs e` shmozepmrngok. Ymnsnoghduini sean e` tmn hrotnrok (suhm ks kuiotery mkdduhogktoegs) tmkt wnrn og Jrknpndogs ogotokd

    inshroptoeg e` inangtok prknhex kgi Cdnudnrs `eur Ks (kuiotery mkdduhogktoegs, ogkppreproktn

    k``nht, kacovkdnghn kgi kcgerakd kssehoktoegs). Ymn dost kdse oghduins snvnrkd hrotnrok tmkt pktmedelosn

    nxpnronghn e` er cndon` og tndnpktmy. Ymnsn wnrn Xhmgnoinrs ;; `orst rkgj syapteas e`

    shmozepmrngok, ks inshrocni og N. @uddnr Yerrnys Xurvovogl Xhmozepmrngok2

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    21/468

    3;

    ;. Kuiotery mkdduhogktoegs og wmohm tmn veohns spnkj egns tmeulmts kdeui.

    3.

    Kuiotery mkdduhogktoegs wotm twe veohns krluogl.

    8. Kuiorety mkdduhogktoegs wotm tmn veohns heaangtogl eg egns khtoegs.

    9.

    Mkdduhogktoegs e` teuhm wmng tmn ceiody sngsktoeg os oapesni cy sean nxtnrgkd klnghy.

    >. \otmirkwkd e` tmeulmts `rea egns aogi.

    0.

    Ogsnrtoeg e` tmeulmts ogte egns aogi cy etmnrs.

    , 0, 6 ynkrs te hmnaohkddy hegstrkog sehokd kgi

    pedotohkd iossoingts og heugtrons kreugi tmn werdi. Og nkhm heugtry, tmn pedotohkd kgi sehokd ngvoregangt

    mks intnraogni wmohm pnepdn wnrn ug`ertugktn ngeulm te cn trnktni wotm tmnsn iruls klkogst tmnor

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    22/468

    33

    wodd. Pkroktoegs og hrotnrok tmkt kddew ioklgesos e` angtkd oddgnss mkvn hmkglni evnr toan, inpngiogl

    eg rudogl rnloans, cut tmn skan iruls mkvn cnng usni klkogst sehokd kgi pedotohkd iossoingts kreugi tmn

    werdi. Ymny mkvn `erani k akber pkrt e` tmn hmnaohkd wkr`krn kraeury `er snvnrkd inhkins, cut krn stoddprnshrocni ks aniohogns inspotn merro`oh degl-tnra ikakln te tmn gnrveus systna. Ymos wks `orst

    iehuangtni evnr 96 ynkrs kle.

    Ymn akog rnksegs tmkt iepkaogn-cdehjogl iruls (kgtopsyhmetohs/akber trkgquoddosnrs/gnurednptohs)

    krn usni og Kustrkdok kgi ndsnwmnrn og tmn aeinrg werdi krn `er tmn trnktangt e` pnepdn ioklgesni ks

    shmozepmrngoh er akgoh kgi `er tmn hegtred e` pnepdn hegsoinrni te cn petngtokddy voedngt, kdtmeulmtmny krn kdse usni te hegtred cnmkvoeur og hmodirng (nspnhokddy tmesnioklgesni wotm kutosa) kgi tmn

    ndinrdy (nspnhokddy tmesn ioklgesni wotm inangtok er sngodn psyhmesos). Ymus tmnsn iruls krn akogdy

    usni wotmog tmn psyhmoktroh kgi prosegs systnas (kgi aern rnhngtdy og Oaaolrktoeg Inpkrtangt

    intngtoeg hngtrns), kdtmeulm rnhngtdy tmnrn mkvn cnng n``erts te creking tmn akrjnt e` akber

    trkgquoddosnr (iepkaogn-cdehjnr) skdns cy preaetogl tmna `er hmodirng wotm cnmkvoeur precdnas

    (etmnr tmkg kutosa, `er wmohm tmny mkvn cnng usni `er snvnrkd inhkins) kgi edi pnepdn wotm sdnnpogl

    precdnas. Og tmnsn akrjntogl hkapkolgs ge angtoeg os akin e` tmn heggnhtoeg wotm etmnr iepkaogn

    cdehjnrs, er tmn heaaeg rosj, ks tmnsn iruls khhuaudktn og tmn ceiy, e` hkusogl Vkrjogsegs sygirean,er nvng wersn, tkriovn iysjognsok.

    Ykriovn iyjognsok os k lretnsqun gnuredelohkd hegiotoeg tmkt os egdy jgewg te ehhur tmreulm tmn usn e`

    iepkaogn-cdehjnrs, kgi mks ge jgewg hurn. Ot os get kangkcdn te irul trnktangt, kgi tmn iruls usni te

    trnkt irul-ogiuhni Vkrjogsegosa hkg wersng tkriovn iysjognsok. Ymos oktrelngoh (trnktangt-ogiuhni)

    iosnksn os hmkrkhtnrosni cy ogvedugtkry lroakhns kgi spksas e` tmn `khn, oghduiogl ughegtreddkcdnpretrusoeg e` tmn teglun, pu``ogl e` tmn hmnnjs kgi puhjnrogl e` tmn dops (wmohm hkusns tnrrocdn sehokd

    nackrrkssangt kgi stolak, telntmnr wotm io``ohudty tkdjogl), kgi e`tng strkgln wrotmogl aevnangts

    (kdse ogvedugtkry) e` tmn mkgis, kras kgi dnls. Ykriovn iysjognsok, kdtmeulm aern dojndy wotm molm

    ogbnhtni iesns e` akber trkgquoddosnrs, mks kdse ehhurrni k`tnr sakdd iesns usni `er smert pnroeis e` toan.

    Ot seantoans invndeps `eddewogl hnssktoeg e` trnktangt, cut usukddy ehhurs k`tnr degl pnroeis e`

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    23/468

    38

    oglnstni er ogbnhtni iepkaogn-cdehjogl iruls. Ymn hegiotoeg ehhurs aern rnkiody og tmn ndinrdy kgi os

    get ugheaaeg kaegl rnsoingts og Kustrkdokg gursogl means. Ot os tee `rnqungtdy snng og

    psyhmelnroktroh mespotkds, hngtrns kgi hdogohs og Kustrkdok.

    Og kiiotoeg te trnktangt e` yeugl pnepdn ioklgesni wotm shmozepmrngok kgi akgok, iepkaogn-cdehjogl

    akber trkgquoddosnrs krn kdse usni te hegtred tmn cnmkvoeur e` ndinrdy pnepdn ioklgesni wotm inangtok.

    Mnrn, ks og tmn yeugl pnepdn, tmn iruls krn cnogl usni, cksohkddy, ks hmnaohkd rnstrkogts. Ymn

    invndepangt e` Levnrgangt-hegtreddni systnas kddewogl `erhni trnktangt e` (rnduhtkgt) psyhmoktroh

    pktongts og Kustrkdok wotm rnludkr ogbnhtoegs e` akber trkgquoddosnrs uginr tmn heaaugoty trnktangterinr (HYE)kgi ogvedugtkry trnktangt erinr (OYE)shmnans, mks rnsudtni og k sotuktoegwmnrn kdd

    Kustrkdokgs krn uginr rosj e` cnogl oghkrhnrktni kgi ogbnhtni wotm iruls klkogst tmnor wodd o` tmny

    ngtnrtkog oinks er spnkj kceut tmogls in`ogni ks psyhmetoh, pkrkgeoi, eii, ugrnksegkcdn,

    lrkgioesn er induini cy tmn nupmnaostohkddy gkani Angtkd Mnkdtm Xystna.

    Og `kht, tmn guacnr e` vonws tmkt Kustrkdokgs krn kddewni te medi eg akttnrs pmodesepmohkd, shongto`oh,

    rndoloeus kgi pedotohkd krn rkpoidy inhrnksogl kgi tmn guacnr e` angtkd oddgnssns tmny krn cnogl

    ioklgesni wotm hegtoguns te oghrnksn. Ymos oghduins gnw dkcnds `er iosecniongt hmodirng kgi

    evnrkhtovn egns, suhm ks tmn rnhngtdy preaetni hegiuht ioserinr kgi eppesotoegkd in`okgt

    ioserinr. _eugl pnepdn hkg kdse cn ioklgesni ks kttngtoeg ioserinrni, pnrsegkdoty ioserinrni,

    tmeulmt ioserinrni kgi dnkrgogl ioserinrni, ks wndd ks shmozepmrngoh er akgoh.

    Xhmozepmrngok kgi akgok krn skoi te cn hmkrkhtnrosni cy ugusukd tmeulmts. Khheriogl te tmn

    \erdi Mnkdtm Erlkgozktoeg (\ME)-preaetni Cron` Vsyhmoktroh Sktogl Xhkdn (CVSX), ugusukd

    tmeulmt hegtngt os te cn suspnhtni og pnepdn wotm ugusukd cndon`s og psyhmoh pewnrs, sporots, ^@Es er

    ugrnkdostoh cndon`s og egns ewg kcodotons, kgi tmkt pnepdn wme cndonvn stregldy og suhm tmogls krn, te put

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    24/468

    39

    ot soapdy, aki. K rkgln e` dnkiogl qunstoegs krn dostni `er mnkdtm hkrn werjnrs te ndohot tmnsn solgs e`

    ogskgoty2

    Mkvn yeu cnng rnhnovogl kgy spnhokd anssklns `rea pnepdn er `rea tmn wky tmogls krn krrkglni

    kreugi yeu5 Mkvn yeu snng kgy rn`nrnghns te yeursnd` eg YP er og tmn gnwspkpnrs5

    Hkg kgyegn rnki yeur aogi5

    Ie yeu mkvn k spnhokd rndktoegsmop wotm Lei5

    Os kgytmogl dojn ndnhtrohoty, ]-rkys, er rkioe wkvns k``nhtogl yeu5

    Krn tmeulmts put ogte yeur mnki tmkt krn get yeur ewg5

    Mkvn yeu `ndt tmkt yeu wnrn uginr tmn hegtred e` kgetmnr pnrseg er `erhn5

    Ge weginr pnepdn werroni kceut rkioktoeg peddutoeg kgi hmnaohkd peddutoeg krn k`rkoi te spnkj tmnor

    aogi. Ge weginr pnepdn iegt tkdj tee auhm kceut cnogl uginr tmn hegtred e` tmn tndnvosoeg

    prelrkaanrs er audtogktoegkd herperktoegs. Ge weginr pnepdn iegt e`tng angtoeg tndnpktmy pucdohdy,

    tmeulm k surprosogl guacnr ie cndonvn og ot provktndy. Ymn kcevn hrotnrok, preaetni cy tmn \ME,

    tmreulm k pucdohktoeg prnpkrni cy psyhmoktrosts kgi psyhmedelosts kt tmn ^govnrsoty e` Gnw Xeutm

    \kdns og ;??>, sullnst tmkt pnepdn heghnrgni kceut rkioktoeg kivnrsndy k``nhtogl tmnor mnkdtm krn

    su``nrogl `rea ugusukd tmeulmts (indusoegs/psyhmesos). Ymn rnheaangini trnktangts kgi tmn

    trnktangts hurrngtdy napdeyni og Kustrkdok, tmn ^XK kgi Crotkog `er indusoegkd tmeulmts krn

    oghkrhnrktoeg kgi ogbnhtoegs wotm iepkaogn cdehjogl iruls o` tmn su``nrnr rn`usns te step tkdjogl

    kceut tmnor heghnrgs kgi/er tkjn iepkaogn cdehjogl iruls e` tmnor ewg khheri. Ymos os inspotn jgewg

    rosjs e` tkriovn iysjognsok kgi etmnr `eras e` pnrakgngt crkog ikakln o` tmn iruls krn oglnstni er

    ogbnhtni `er kgy iurktoeg e` toan. _nt o` wn ie get spnkj eur aogi, tmn lrewogl texog deki hkusni cy

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    25/468

    3>

    ogiustrokd peddutoeg (oghduiogl hmnaohkd, seugi kgi rkioktoeg peddutoeg) wodd hegtogun te instrey tmn

    iovnrsoty e` do`n eg tmn pdkgnt kgi tmrnktng tmn mnkdtm e` tmn ldeckd muakg pepudktoeg. O` wn iegt spnkj

    up kceut tmn ikglnrs e` ngidnss tndnvosni hegsuaptoeg kgi hkpotkdosa (kgi tmn `kht tmkt tmn YP putsoinks og eur aogis tmkt krn get eur ewg), muakg sehonty os instogni te `eddew tmn redn aeinds e` lrnni,

    hegsuanrosa kgi voednghn tmkt ieaogktn og tmn YP werdi.

    Vsyhmoktry, cnogl tmn aniohkd spnhokdty ioshopdogn tmkt hegtreds tmn invndepangt kgi oapdnangtktoeg e`

    gktoegkd kgi ogtnrgktoegkd angtkd mnkdtm strktnlons mks k pnrvksovn og`dunghn eg aeinrg Kustrkdokg

    sehonty. Ymos og`dunghn os dkrlndy ugrnhelgosni, cut psyhmoktroh tmnery kgi prkhtohn og`dunghn niuhktoeg

    kt kdd dnvnds ks wndd ks preaogngt aniok sterons, aevons, kgi aklkzogn krtohdns. Nvng tmn `nw sterons

    tmkt krn hrotohkd e` tmn trnktangt tmkt psyhmoktroh pktongts rnhnovn tngi te vkdoiktn tmn stnrnetypns kgiioklgesns e` psyhmoktrosts (suhm ks shmozepmrngok).

    Ymn psyhmoktry pre`nssoeg, wotm tmnor khhnss te og`eraktoeg kceut iossoingts og sehonty mks kdse

    trkiotoegkddy pdkyni k preaogngt redn og tmn smkiewy krnk e` survnoddkghn kgi hegtred e` ikglnreus

    ndnangts og sehonty. E` heursn, mew ikglnreus tmn hotozngs e` k heugtry krn vonwni ks kgi `er wmkt

    rnksegs, inpngis eg tmn pkrkgeok er etmnrwosn e` tmn levnrgangts kgi pucdoh ogstotutoegs tmkt hegtredtmn pedohn, aodotkry kgi buiohokd systnas ks wndd ks tmn psyhmoktroh systnas e` tmn heugtry heghnrgni.

    Ymn hedegokd mostery e` Kustrkdok, kgi spnho`ohkddy tmn `kht tmkt hegvohts kgi etmnr uginsorkcdns wnrn

    sngt cy tmn Crotosm Hrewg te Kustrkdok, os pnrtogngt te tmn invndepangt e` pugotovn kgi rnprnssovn

    kttotuins tewkris tmn angtkddy odd cy Levnrgangtsog tmos heugtry ks wndd ks cy trnktangt hngtrns kgi

    tmn pucdoh lngnrkddy. Ymos os k heapdnx krnk cngnktm wmohm durjs k tnrrocdn snrons e` ktrehotons.

    Kdtmeulm Angtkd Mnkdtm Khts io``nr cntwnng tmn Xtktns, nvnry Xtktn og Kustrkdok iens mkvn dkws

    premocotogl pedotohkddy aetovktni oghkrhnrktoegs, ks mkvn cnng inshrocni og tmn Xevont ^goeg, kpkrtmnoi

    Xeutm K`rohk kgi etmnr pedotohkddy rnprnssni gktoegs. Xuhm oghkrhnrktoeg os, kgywky, premocotni cy

    Ogtnrgktoegkd Dkws inhdkrni og tmn ;?96s `eddewogl tmn ioshevnry e` tmn nxtngt e` kgi rnksegs cnmogi

    tmn Gkzo Medehkust. Ymn rnksegs cnmogi tmn Medehkust krn heapdnx, cut nvng tmn aest kringt kpedelost

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    26/468

    30

    `er psyhmoktroh kcusns smeudi klrnn tmkt tmn nulngohs pedohons tmkt intnraogni wme weudi cn joddni, kgi

    wme weudi cn ngheurklni te crnni og kg n``ert te hrnktn kg Krykg supnr-rkhn, wnrn invndepni kgi

    oapdnangtni cy ang wme hkddni tmnasndvns shongtosts, khkinaohs, pmysohokgs kgi psyhmoktrosts. Akgye` tmn aest og`dungtokd nulngohosts wnrn pre`nssers og tmn aest rnspnhtni ugovnrsotons kgi mespotkds og

    Lnrakgy, suhm ks Vre`nsser Jkrd Xhmgnoinr, wme wks mnki e` psyhmoktry kt tmn ^govnrsoty e`

    Mnoindcnrl og tmn ;?86s.

    Vre`nsser Xoigny Cdehm, k sngoer pre`nsser e` psyhmoktry kt tmn ^govnrsoty e` Andceurgn, og tmn niotni

    trkgshropt e` mos ;??0 Cnktton Dnhturn kt tmn ^govnrsoty, inshrocni Vre`nsser Xhmgnoinrs merrocdn khts ks`eddews, wmng wkrgogl e` tmn ikglnrs e` aosusni psyhmoktroh tmnery2

    Jkrd Xhmgnoinr mndi kg nvng aern prnstoloeus pest ks hmkorakg e` psyhmoktry kt Mnoindcnrl.

    Kdeglsoin mos hndncrktni khkinaoh khtovotons, Xhmgnoinr hegtrocutni ngnrlntohkddy te tmn

    nutmkgksok prelrka. K pkrty stkdwkrt `rea ;?83, mn cnhkan oacuni wotm tmn Gkzo vosoeg,

    pkrtohudkrdy rkhokd mylnogn. Oregohkddy mn wks kcdn te pursun twe hegtrkiohtery pktmwkys. Eg tmn

    egn mkgi mn ndkcerktni prelrnssovn anksurns e` rnmkcodotktoeg `er tmn hmregohkddy odd kgi, eg tmn

    etmnr, pkrtohopktni khtovndy og cetm tmn stnrodosktoegs kgi tmn aniohkd joddogls. Aernevnr, mninvndepni k lrkgi pdkg te nstkcdosm k rnsnkrhm ogstotutn iniohktni te coedelohkd kgtmrepedely,

    dkughmogl mos stuions wotm tmn nxkaogktoeg e` crkogs inrovni `rea tmn vohtoas e` Kjtoeg Y9

    (etmnr naogngt khkinaohs kdse sgkthmni tmn eppertugoty te nxkaogn tmn mugirnis e` kvkodkcdn

    crkogs).

    Ymn hrotnrok `er inktm wnrn rnakrjkcdy strkolmt`erwkri2 k ioklgesos e` shmozepmrngok, npodnpsy,

    sngodn ioserinr, ogtnddnhtukd rntkriktoeg kgi tmn dojn: mespotkdosktoeg `er > er aern ynkrs: kg

    oghkpkhoty te werj preiuhtovndy og tmn angtkd mespotkd snttogl: er get cnogl e` Lnrakg rkhn kgigktoegkdoty (kdd Bnwosm pktongts wnrn joddni). Ymn

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    27/468

    36 ynkrs k`tnr tmos smkan`ud kht e` ogtnrgktoegkd

    tnrrerosa kgi irul wkr`krn. Xmertdy k`tnrwkris, kgi og tmn wkjn e` tmn Crotosm suhhnss, tmn ^XK

    inakgini soaodkr trkin heghnssoegs te tmn Crotosm `rea Hmogk kgi akogtngkghn e` tmnor ewg epoua

    nxpert ogiustry te tmn aest pepudeus gktoeg eg nkrtm. Ot os e` getn tmkt ng`erhnangt e` `rnn trkin wks

    tmn busto`ohktoeg tmn Crotosm Levnrgangt lkvn te ots pnepdn, `er wmkt dktnr cnhkan jgewg ks tmn epoua

    wkrs.

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    40/468

    96

    XHMOREVMSNGOK KGI IEVKAOGN CDEHJNSX

    Xhmozepmrngok wks ogvngtni og ;?6= cy tmn Xwoss psyhmoktrost Nulng Cdnudnr (;=>>-;?30) og tmn ;=?6s.

    Aohmknd Xtegn, ogMnkdogl tmn Aogi, wrotns2

    Xuhhnniogl @ernd ks tmn iornhter e` tmn `kani Curlmedzdo hdogoh og ;=?=, Cdnudnr werjni

    ogtngsovndy wotm psyhmetoh pktongts, vosotogl kgi tkdjogl wotm tmna `ovn er sox toans k wnnj,

    suhm tmkt mos `kaodokroty wotm tmna wks heapkrkcdn te tmkt e` psyhmekgkdysts wotm tmnor pktongts

    (wme wnrn kdse snng kceut `ovn toans k wnnj og tmos nrk). Mos lrnkt aegelrkpm eg tmn lreup e`

    shmozepmrngoks kppnkrni og ;?;;: mnrn mn prepesni k gnw in`ogotoeg e` tmn hegiotoeg Jrknpndog

    kgi etmnrs mki cnng hkddogl inangtok prknhex. Cdnudnr oingto`oni tmn proakry solgse` tmos

    hegiotoeg, wmohm mkvn cnhean jgewg ks tmn `eur Ks2 kutosa, deesngogl e` kssehoktoegs,

    kacovkdnghn, kgi k``nht ogkppreproktngnss. Ymn dkttnr trkot wks tmn jny ndnangt `er Cdnudnr2 Ymn

    pktongt wme saodni wmodn tkdjogl e` tmn inktm e` mos aetmnr, er wme hroni wmodn tkdjogl e`

    ogmnrotogl k `ertugn, wks smewogl k spdot (Lrnnj2 shmoze) cntwnng tmeulmt kgi k``nht2 mnghn mos

    tnrashmozepmrngok.Kacovkdnghnkgi kutosa wnrn kdse weris Cdnudnr heogni. (p.;90)

    ^sogl tmn weri dkglukln crekidy, ot os io``ohudt te snn mew kutosa(ogkcodoty er rn`uskd te spnkj) kgi

    tmnsn etmnr kcgerakdotons heudi cn intnhtni og pnepdn wme ie get spnkj tmn skan dkglukln ks tmn

    ioklgesnr. Mew iens egn tndd o` k pnrsegs angtkd kssehoktoegs krn deesngni wmng tmny mkvn k

    heapdntndy io``nrngt cndon` systna, aein e` spnnhm kgi heghnptukd `rkanwerj: wmng tmny tmogj kgi

    spnkj og kgetmnr dkglukln5 Ot os nksy te builn saodogl er hryogl ogkppreproktndy ks sullnstovn e`

    akignss nvoinghni cy ogkppreproktn k``nht o` tmn rnksegs `ersuhm naetoegs krn get uginrsteei iun te

    dogluostoh, sehokd kgi hudturkd io``nrnghns kgi ckrronrs er iun te `kodurn te uginrstkgi tmn ogiovoiukd

    nxpnronghns e` tmn pktongt. Ot os nqukddy ughdnkr ks te mew ogbnhtoegs er tkcdnts e` iepkaogn-cdehjnrs hkg

    oaprevn suhm syapteas.

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    41/468

    9;

    Ymnrn mkvn cnng akgy hmkglns og tmn khhnptni hrotnrok `er ioklgesos e` shmozepmrngok og tmn aeinrg

    werdi, mewnvnr, kgi hegsoinrkcdn io``nrnghns nxost og io``nrngt pkrts e` tmn werdi. Ymos os angtoegni og

    tmn \erdi Mnkdtm Erlkgozktoegs Mkgiceej `er tmn Xhmozepmrngoh Ioserinrs (;??>), wmohm wkswrottng cy Mnoio Xuaohm, Lkvog Kgirnws kgi Hkredogn Mugt e` tmn Hdogohkd Snsnkrhm ^got `er

    Kgxonty Ioserinrs e` tmn ^govnrsoty e` Gnw Xeutm \kdns kt Xt Poghngts Mespotkd, Xyigny kgi

    uginrwrottng cy tmn Gnw Xeutm \kdns Ogstotutn e` Vsyhmoktry2

    Ymnrn os ge sogldn spnho`oh syaptea tmkt os rnquorni `er k ioklgesos e` shmozepmrngok. Og etmnr

    weris, tmn syapteas nxpnronghni cy egn pnrseg aky get cn nxkhtdy tmn skan ks tmn syapteas

    nxpnronghni cy kgetmnr pnrseg. Mewnvnr, ks k lreup, pnepdn wotm shmozepmrngok iospdky kg

    oingto`okcdn snte` syapteas. O` seanegn nxmocots egn er aern e` tmnsn syapteas `er k spnho`onidngltm e` toan, mn er smn aky tmng cn rnlkrini ks mkvogl k ioklgesos e` shmozepmrngok.

    Ymn Kanrohkg Vsyhmoktroh Kssehoktoegs (KVK) Ioklgestoh kgi Xtktostohkd Akgukd e` Angtkd

    Ioserinrs, @eurtm Niotoeg (IXA-OP) os tmn kdtnrgktovn akber ioklgestoh hdksso`ohktery systna te

    OHI-;6 Ztmn \erdi Mnkdtm Erlkgozktoegs Ogtnrgktoegkd Hdksso`ohktoege` IosnksnsQ. Og IXA-OP,

    tmn ioklgestoh hrotnrok `er shmozepmrngok io``nr sdolmtdy Z!Q `rea OHI-;6 og rndktoeg te tmn iurktoeg e`

    toan `er wmohm syapteas krn rnquorni te mkvn cnng prnsngt proer te ioklgesos. IXA-OP rnquorns k

    aogoaua iurktoeg e` sox aegtms, oghduiogl k preireakd er rnsoiukd pmksn, wmodn OHI-;6 rnquornstmn pnrsostnghn e` syapteas `er egdy egn aegtm.

    Ymn mkgiceej hegtoguns te nxpdkog mew tmnsn syapteas e` shmozepmrngok krn te cn ndohotni, hdkoaogl

    tmkt tmn aest oapertkgt syapteas kgi solgs oghduin mkdduhogktoegs, indusoegs, tmeulmt

    iosturckghns, ioserinrni tmogjogl kgi gnlktovn syapteas (tmnsn krn vnry io``nrngt te Cdnudnrs

    hrotnrok). Intkodni antmeis `er khquorogl nvoinghn e` tmnsn kcgerakdotons krn lovng og tmn Mkgiceej

    `er tmn Xhmozepmrngoh Ioserinrs, wmohm wks iostrocutni te mnkdtm werjnrs og Kustrkdok cy tmn Cndlokg

    irul heapkgy Bkgssng-Hodkl, wmohm akgu`khturns snvnrkd iruls `er tmn trnktangt (cut get tmn hurn,

    wmohm os skoi te cn oapessocdn) e` shmozepmrngok, oghduiogl tmn hroppdogl iepkaogn-cdehjnr

    mkdepnroied, wmohm os akrjntni ks ogbnhtoegs, syrup kgi tkcdnts e` Mkdied. Ymos irul mks cnng usni

    kreugi tmn werdi `er tmn pugosmangt e` sehokd kgi pedotohkd iossoingts evnr tmn pkst >6 ynkrs. Ymn

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    42/468

    93

    akgukd hegtkogs k snrons e` qunstoegs kgi ogtnrprntktoegs `er iehters kgi etmnr mnkdtm werjnrs insolgni

    te oghrnksn cetm ioklgesos e` angtkd kcgerakdoty kgi trnktangt wotm Mkdied kgi rndktni iruls, kgi `er

    tmn aest iucoeus e` rnksegs. Ogbnhtoegs kgi henrhni oglnstoeg e` Mkdied mkvn rnsudtni og dotnrkddyaoddoegs e` pnepdn cnogl hroppdni wotm tkriovn iysjognsok kgi etmnr `eras e` hmregoh crkog ikakln

    soghn tmn ;?06s. Etmnrs mkvn ioni `rea evnriesns (indocnrktn er ugogtngtoegkd) e` Mkdied.

    YmnMkgiceej `er tmn Xhmozepmrngoh Ioserinrshegtkogs k ikglnreusdy evnr-oghdusovn snt e` ioklgestoh

    hrotnrok jgewg ks tmn Cron` Vsyhmoktroh Sktogl Xhkdn (CVSX). Og ot, mkdduhogktoegs krn inshrocni ks

    snnogl, mnkrogl, sanddogl, er tkstogl tmogls tmkt etmnr pnepdn ie get snn, mnkr, sandd,sngsn er tkstn

    Zwmohm heudi cn iun te lrnktnr sngsotovotyQ kgi krn te cn ndohotni cy tmn `eddewogl qunstoegs2

    Ie yeu nvnr snna te mnkr yeur gkan cnogl hkddni5

    Mkvn yeu mnkri kgy seugis er pnepdn tkdjogl te yeu er kceut yeu wmng tmnrn mks cnng geceiy

    kreugi5

    Ie yeu nvnr mkvn vosoegs er snn tmogls tmkt etmnrs ie get snn5 \mkt kceut sandd eiers tmkt

    etmnrs ie get sandd5

    Ot os nksy te snn wmy shmozepmrngok wks get ioklgesni og Cocdohkd toans. Kdd tmn prepmnts kgi

    vosoegkrons, oghduiogl Bnsus Hmrost, weudi mkvn cnng heaaottni `er ogvedugtkry psyhmoktroh trnktangt.

    Vnepdn wme cndonvn tmkt tmny krn Bnsus Hmrost rktn k spnhokd angtoeg og tmn akgukd, `er tmnsn pnepdn krn

    su``nrogl `rea tmn typohkd indusoegs e` shmozepmrngok2

    Indusoegs ZkrnQ `kdsn cndon`s tmkt krn `orady mndi inspotn ecbnhtovn kgi hegtrkiohtery nvoinghn,

    kgi inspotn tmn `kht tmkt etmnr anacnrs e` tmn hudturn ie get smkrn tmn skan cndon`s: `er

    nxkapdn, tmn pnrseg aky cndonvn tmkt mn er smn os Bnsus Hmrost, er tmkt mn er smn os cnogl

    `eddewni, peosegni, er nxpnroangtni upeg.

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    43/468

    98

    \mkt kceut tmn pnepdn wme krn cnogl peosegni kgi nxpnroangtni eg cy tmn psyhmoktroh ogiustry otsnd`5

    Ymnsn pnepdn hkg nxpnht k ioklgesos e` indusoegs k`tnr cnogl ksjni tmn `eddewogl qunstoegs, wmohm

    krn kppkrngtdy ogiohktovn e` ugusukd tmeulmt hegtngt o` kgswnrni og tmn k``oraktovn2

    Mkvn yeu cnng rnhnovogl kgy spnhokd anssklns `rea pnepdn er `rea tmn wky tmogls krn

    krrkglni kreugi yeu5 Mkvn yeu snng kgy rn`nrnghns te yeursnd` eg YP er og tmn gnwspkpnrs5

    Hkg kgyegn rnki yeur aogi5

    Ie yeu mkvn k spnhokd rndktoegsmop wotm Lei5

    Os kgytmogl dojn ndnhtrohoty, ]-rkys, er rkioe wkvns k``nhtogl yeu5

    Krn tmeulmts put ogte yeur mnki tmkt krn get yeur ewg5

    Mkvn yeu `ndt tmkt yeu wnrn uginr tmn hegtred e` kgetmnr pnrseger `erhn5

    Cozkrrn cnmkvoeur, kgetmnr solg e` shmozepmrngok os te cn intnhtni cy ksjogl2

    Mkvn yeu iegn kgytmogl tmkt mks kttrkhtni tmn kttngtoeg e` etmnrs5

    Mkvn yeu iegn kgytmogl tmkt heudi mkvn lettng yeu ogte treucdn wotm tmn pedohn5 Ztmn weri

    lettng cntrkys kg Kanrohkg erolog `er tmn CVSXQ

    Mkvn yeu iegn kgytmogl tmkt snnani ugusukd er iosturcogl te etmnrs5

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    44/468

    99

    Og tmn Cron` Vsyhmoktroh Sktogl Xhkdn (kttrocutni og tmn akgukd te tmn \erdi Mnkdtm Erlkgozktoeg

    tmeulm ot wks khtukddy invndepni cy tmn ^X Inpkrtangt e` Pntnrkgs K``kors og tmn ;?06s) os k

    inshroptoeg e` snd` gnldnht wmohm os hegsnrvktovn, te sky tmn dnkst. K rktogl e` 3 `er snd` gnldnht oste cn rnherini `er mylongn/kppnkrkghn sdolmtdy cndew usukd heaaugoty stkgikris, n.l., smort eut e`

    pkgts, cuttegs ugcuttegni, smen dkhns ugtoni, cut ge sehokd er aniohkd hegsnqunghns. K rktogl e` 8 (eut

    e`

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    45/468

    9>

    Ie yeu nvnr `nnd ughea`ertkcdn og pucdoh5 Iens ot snna ks tmeulm etmnrs krn wkthmogl yeu5

    Krn yeu heghnrgni kceut kgyegns ogtngtoegs tewkri yeu5 Og kgyegn leogl eut e` tmnor wky te

    lovn yeu k mkri toan, er tryogl te murt yeu5 Ie yeu `nnd og kgy ikglnr5

    @er tmesn wme stuiy psyhmoktry pre`nssoegkddy, ankgogl tmny `orst lkog aniohkd inlrnns `rea

    rnhelgosni ugovnrsotons, `urtmnr trkogogl og tnhmgoquns e` ogtnrrelktoeg krn ecdolktery, kdwkys snnjogl

    nvoinghn e` angtkd oddgnss. Ymn rnheaangini uginrlrkiuktn tnxtceej og Vsyhmoktry `er aniohkd

    stuingts og Andceurgn os @eugiktoegs e` Hdogohkd Vsyhmoktry wrottng og heddkcerktoeg cntwnng

    psyhmoktry pre`nssers kt tmn ^govnrsoty e` Andceurgn kgi Aegksm ^govnrsoty, kgi pucdosmni og ;??9 cyAndceurgn ^govnrsoty Vrnss. Og tmn hmkptnr totdni tmn psyhmoktroh ogtnrvonw kgi nvkduktoeg e` tmn

    angtkd stktn Vre`nsser Gohmedks Jnjs nxpdkogs mew pnrsnhutery indusoegs hkg cn og`nrrni kgi tmkt

    tmny krn get gnhnsskrody ugtrun te qukdo`y ks indusoegs (rn`dnhtni kdse og tmn psyhmoktroh truosa tmkt

    k indusoeg os stodd k indusoeg nvng o` ot trkgsporns, cy heoghoinghn, te cn herrnht!)2

    Indusoegs wotm rndoloeus er suchudturkd hegtngt hkg prevn io``ohudt te kssnss. ^sukddy hegsudtktoegs

    wotm k anacnr e` tmn pktongts sehokd lreup os gnhnsskry. Ot smeudi kdse cn jnpt og aogi tmkt wmkt

    kppnkr te cn pnrsnhutery indusoegs aky cn trun. Ot os get wmntmnr tmn indusoeg os kcsedutndy `kdsntmkt os rndnvkgt, cut rktmnr tmkt tmn cndon` os kimnrni te cy tmn pktongt vnry `orady inspotn akgo`nstdy

    ogsu``ohongt er ogkppreproktn nvoinghn. @er ogstkghn, k akg wks hegvoghni tmkt mos wo`n wks mkvogl

    kg k``kor, kgi oginni smn wks og k snhrnt rndktoegsmop. Mewnvnr, tmn musckgis hegvohtoeg kresn

    `rea tmn ogtnrprntktoeg mn pdkhni eg ngtorndy ugrndktni nvngts suhm ks tmn guacnrs progtni eg tmn

    dnttnr mn rnhnovni `rea tmn tkx e``ohn.

    Og ndohotogl indusoegs, ot os usn`ud te `orst ksj k qunstoeg wmohm smeudi ndohot k pesotovn rnspegsn

    `rea kgyegn, kgi tmng te precn `urtmnr `er kcgerakd tmeulmt hegtngt. @er ogstkghn2 Ie yeu nvnr`nnd snd`-hegshoeus er smy og k gnw pdkhn er wotm strkglnrs5 Ymn kgswnr smeudi cn yns o` tmn

    qunstoeg wks uginrsteei. Ymng tmn pktongt hkg cn ksjni wmntmnr tmny werry o` pnepdn dkulm cnmogi

    tmnor ckhj, kgi se eg, prelrnssogl te ksj kceut erlkgosni pnrsnhutoeg. (pp.

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    46/468

    90

    Ot os kssuani tmkt cndon` og erlkgosni pnrsnhutoeg os ogiohktovn e` snroeus angtkd oddgnss2 gkandy

    shmozepmrngok. \mkt e` mugirnis e` ynkrs e` erlkgosni sdkvnry kgi etmnr hedegokd ktrehotons5 Ioi

    tmnsn ngi wotm tmn e``ohokd kcedotoeg e` sdkvnry cy tmn @rnghm og ;

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    47/468

    9,

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    48/468

    9=

    Og k sotuktoeg rnpnktni og kdd tmn dkrln rnsnkrhm ogstotutoegs og Kustrkdok, aest e` tmn rnpntotovn, e`tng

    ankgogldnss, seantoans ikglnreus werj wmohm oghduins mkgidogl petngtokddy og`nhtoeus tossun skapdns

    os iegn cy yeugl weang, e`tng e` ntmgoh ckhjlreugi. Ymn Cekri e` Iornhters, mewnvnr oshegsostngtdy aoiidn klni, kdd-wmotn kgi mnkvody akdn ieaogktni, wotm usukddy egn er twe tejng `nakdn

    cekri anacnrs.

    Ymn Hmkorakg kgi Heapkgy Iornhter e` tmn Angtkd Mnkdtm Snsnkrhm Ogstotutn, wmohm rnhnovni

    lrkgts tetkddogl $>,9=9,>38 og ;??

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    49/468

    9?

    Hkrn Gntwerj kgi Anacnr e` Heughod, Pohterokg Ogstotutn e` @erngsoh Aniohogn), k pre`nsser e`

    surlnry (Lerieg Hdugon, k Xhettosm surlneg, gew rntorni), tmrnn dkwynrs, kg khheugtkgt (wme os

    trnksurnr e` tmn ogstotutn) kgi kg nhegeaost. Ymn `nakdn anacnrs wnrn Ikan Akrlkrnt Luod`eydn, wmeos inshrocni ks Inputy Hmkorakg e` tmn Og`nrtodoty Yrnktangt Kutmeroty, Hmkorakg e` tmn Buiohokd

    Snaugnrktoeg Kutmeroty kgi Cekri Anacnr e` tmn Hmodirngs Yndnvosoeg @eugiktoeg kgi Iudhon

    Cedogl, wme os inshrocni og tmn ;??< Kggukd Snpert ks Iornhter e` Xnvng Gntwerj, Anrhkgtodn Autukd

    Mediogls Dti, Audto Aniok Ksok Vkho`oh Dti kgi Heugtry Seki Dti. Ikan Luod`eydn kdse os tmn `eranr

    Hmkorakg e` tmn Muakg Solmts Heaaossoeg Ogquory ogte Solmts e` Vnepdn wotm Angtkd Oddgnss. Egn

    aolmt weginr, `rea tmn Kggukd Snpert e` tmn AMSO, mew hdesndy tmn Cekri Anacnrs e` tmn ogstotutn

    oingto`y wotm tmn precdnas e` tmn epprnssni kgi iospessnssni og Kustrkdok. ^gdnss wn krn te oaklogn

    tmkt og eur `rnn heugtry ge egn os epprnssni er iospessnssni.

    Xoghn tmng, tmn AMSO mks cnng dni cy Vre`nsser Hedog Akstnrs, prnvoeusdy mnki e` dkcerktery rnsnkrhm

    kt tmn ogstotutn. Ymeulm ge deglnr mnkini cy kg nxpdesovn kgi hykgoin aklgktn, tmn iornhtoeg e` tmn

    AMSO mks hmkglni cut dottdn. Ymn `ehus rnakogs eg tmn invndepangt e` gnw iruls kgi crekingogl

    tmnrkpnutoh busto`ohktoegs `er edinr egns: tmn oink e` deejogl medostohkddy kt tmn hkusn e` angtkd

    io``ohudtons kgi tmnor trnktangt os kdong te tmos pkrkiola.

    Og kiiotoeg te tmnor stuions eg shmozepmrngohs crkogs kgi tmesn wme ioni wotm Kdzmnoanrs iosnksn, tmnAMSO os kdse ogvedvni og tmn Hdezkrod Vktongt Aegoterogl Xystna (HVAX), wmohm, khheriogl te tmn

    ogstotutns rnpert, os kg oginpngingt aegoterogl systna nstkcdosmni cy tmn Angtkd Mnkdtm Snsnkrhm

    Ogstotutn. Ot os `ugini cy Gevkrtos Kustrkdok. Gevkrtos (wmohm kdse akrjnts Sotkdog `er kttngtoeg

    in`ohot/mypnrkhtovoty ioserinr) os tmn egdy heapkgy tmkt sndds Hdezkrod (hdezkpogn) og Kustrkdok. Ymn

    rnkseg ot gnnis te cn hdesndy aegoterni os tmkt hdezkpogn os k vnry texoh irul, ks tmn rnpert kiaots,

    wmodst akogtkogogl tmkt ot os k leei irul `er rn`rkhtery shmozepmrngok2

    Hdezkpogn os kg ktypohkd kgtopsyhmetoh klngt e` tmn iocngzeiokznpogn hdkss e` heapeugis. Ot oshmnaohkddy kgi pmkrakhedelohkddy iostoght `rea stkgikri kgtopsyhmetoh iruls kgi mks cnng smewg

    te oaprevn cetm tmn pesotovn kgi gnlktovn psyhmetoh syapteas og akgy pktongts wotm shmozepmrngok

    wme krn ugrnspegsovn te, er ogtednrkgt e` prnsngt iky tmnrkpy, wmodn preiuhogl aogoakd

    nxtrkpyrkaoikd soin n``nhts.

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    50/468

    >6

    ^g`ertugktndy, hdezkpogn hkg hkusn k do`n tmrnktngogl inhrnksn og tmn guacnr e` wmotn cdeei hndds

    (usukddy tmn gnutrepmods) og sean pnepdn. Kt prnsngt tmnrn os ge wky te intnraogn wme aky cn kt

    rosj `rea tmos n``nht, cut ot os jgewg tmkt kgyegn wme mks nxpnronghni tmos precdna hkgget cnnxpesni te tmn irul klkog.

    Ymn texohoty o` tmn irul os suhm tmkt2

    Nvnryegn usogl hdezkpogn aust mkvn k wnnjdy cdeei tnst `er tmn `orst ;= wnnjs e` trnktangt, kgi

    tmng cdeei tnsts aust cn pnr`erani ge dnss tmkg nvnry 3= ikys tmnrnk`tnr.

    Klrkgudehytesos os get tmn egdy precdna hdezkpogn hkg hkusn. Ymn ;??? AOAX dosts2 klrkgudehytesos,

    lrkgudehytepngok, etmnr mknaktedelohkd iosturckghns, `ktolun, irewsognss, sniktoeg, iozzognss,

    mnkikhmn, wnolmt lkog, mypetngsoeg, tkhmyhkriok, trkgsongt pyrnxok (`nvnr), nxtrkpyrkaoikd syapteas

    (suhm ks Vkrjogsegosa), snozurns, gnurednptoh akdolgkgt sygirean (kgetmnr petngtokddy `ktkd kivnrsn

    n``nht), irnka ogtngso`ohktoeg, mypnrskdovktoeg, mypnrtmnraok kgi etmnrs.

    Ymn ;??0 Kanrohkg Vucdohktoeg Ogsoin tmn Crkog, cy Vudotznr prozn-woggnr Segkdi Jetudkj, purhmksni

    `rea tmn Aegksm ^govnrsoty Ceejsmep, akjns ge angtoeg e` tmnsn precdnas. Jetudkj, kg ngtmusokstoh

    preaetnr e` kgy kgi kdd tmn iruls angtoegni og tmn ceej, lovns hdezkpogn mos ugcroidni suppert2

    ^gdojn tmn stkgikri kgtopsyhmetoh iruls kgi trkgquodosnrs, wmohm e`tng rnginr pktongts iuddni

    kgi sniktni, tmn gnw aniohktoegs dnkvn tmna hdnkrmnkini.

    Egn suhm irul os hdezkpogn (Hdezkrod), wmohm ikapngs nxpdesovn kllrnssoeg kgi hdnkrs

    psyhmetoh tmeulmts. Kt pdkhns dojn tmn Angietk Angtkd Mnkdtm Ogstotutn og Akioseg, \oshegsog,

    hdezkpogn mks swugl epng tmn ieers e` tmn ckhj wkris, kddewogl pktongts eghn ieeani te k

    do`ntoan uginr tolmt snhuroty te aevn ogte tmn heaaugoty, leogl te shmeed kgi werj.

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    51/468

    >;

    Iehters wme mkvn snng tmn iruls n``nht krn ngtmusokstoh. Ots dojn tmnsn pnepdn wnrn dovogl

    uginr k spndd kgi hdezkpogn os crnkjogl tmn spndd, skoi Ir.Lkry B. Akonr, e` tmn ^govnrsoty e`

    \oshegsog, kgi iornhter e` psyhmoktroh snrvohns kt Angietk, wmohm meusns tmn stktns aestvoedngt pktongts. \mng tmkt mkppngs tmn degl-stkgiogl oaakturn pnrsegkdoty tmkt mki cnng

    strulldogl te cn mnkdtmycut heudigt cnhkusn ot jnpt leogl hrkzy os `rnni. Ymny stkrt te lrew

    up.

    Mkrvkris Ir. Bemg Sktny, wme trnkts Aksskhmusntts aest voedngt hroaogkds kt Ani`ondi Xtktn

    Mespotkd, kdse os sngiogl sean e` mos pktongts mean k`tnr puttogl tmna eg hdezkpogn. Mn hkddni ot

    tmn aest nxhotogl gnw irul Ovn nvnr snng kgi dojngni ots n``nht te k luoini aossodn tmkt lens

    rolmt te tmn sotn e` kllrnssoeg og tmn crkog wotmeut akjogl pktongts stupoi, kpktmntoh, sdnnpy, ergeg-snxukd. (p.==)

    Cy og`nrnghn, tmn usukd iruls usni `er psyhmetoh ioserinrs ie hkusn tmnsn precdnas. Segkdi

    Jetudkj, k shonghn rnpertnr, wks get heaaossoegni cy tmn nioter e` tmn Hmohkle Yrocugnte hrotohosn tmn

    gnw iruls cut te prkosn tmna, kgi te `ogi eut \my ie sean hmodirng turg eut cki5 Ymos qunstoeg os

    tmn aetovn lovng og tmn ogtreiuhtoeg, kgywky, kgi tmn kgswnr Jetudkj prevoins os soapdostoh kgiaosdnkiogl2 crkog hmnaostry khheapkgoni cy cnogl creulmt up og cki gnolmcermeeis. \mng mn

    inshrocns tmnsn cki gnolmcermeeis ks cnogl hmkrkhtnrosni cy pevnrty, sogldn aetmnrs, kgi dewnr

    niuhktoeg kgi oghean dnvnds ot cnheans hdnkr tmkt cdkhj gnolmceurmeeis `ot mos inshroptoeg e` cki

    gnolmceurmeeis. Ot os kdse nvoingt tmkt snvnrkd pmkrakhnutohkd heapkgons steei te cngn`ot `rea mos

    ceej, pkrtohudkrdy Gevkrtos, tmn akgu`khturnrs e` Hdezkrod, kgi tmn akjnrs e` tmn gnw kgtoinprnsskgts,

    oghduiogl Ndo Doddy, akgu`khturnrs e` Vrezkh, wmohm os preaetni snvnrkd toans og tmn ceej.

    K jny `khter og tmn hmnaohkd oackdkghn tmnerons prepklktni cy Jetudkj kgi tmn akrjntogl strktnlons`er gnw kgtoinprnsskgts os cdkaogl tmn gnuretrkgsaottnr snretegog `er k duiohreus rkgln e` angtkd

    oddgnssns kgi angtkd kcgerakdotons. Hegvngongtdy, tmn gnw XXSO (Xndnhtovn Xnretegog Snuptkjn

    Ogmocoter) iruls krn jgewg te proakrody k``nht snretegog antkcedosa. \otm shkgt rnlkri `er shongto`oh

    nvoinghn, Jetudkj wrotns2

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    52/468

    >3

    Dew snretegog os heaaeg te akgy angtkd precdnas og wmohm egn er aern e` eur irovns cursts

    eut e` ots hmnaohkd herrkd.

    Aniohkd rnsnkrhmnrs `eugi tmkt aest e` tmnsn ioserinrs aky cn trnktkcdn wotm iruls tmkt

    hmkgln snretegog dnvnds. @orst invndepni te mkdt tmn ughegtreddkcdn kllrnssoeg e` shmozepmrngok

    kgi inprnssoeg, tmnsn iruls krn gew cnogl usni er tnstni `er k woin vkronty e` precdnas,

    oghduiogl kdhemedosa, nktogl ioserinrs, prnangstrukd sygirean, aolrkogns, kglnr kttkhjs,

    akgoh-inprnssovn ioserinr, ecsnssovn-heapudsovn ioserinrs, kgxonty, sdnnp ioserinrs, anaery

    oapkorangt, irul kcusn, snxukd pnrvnrsoegs, orrotkcodoty, Vkrjogsegs iosnksn, Kdzmnoanrs,

    inpnrsegkdozktoeg ioserinr, cerinrdogn pnrsegkdoty, kutosa kgi crkog ogburons. (p.==)

    Ymos lovns sean ogiohktoeg e` tmn woinsprnki nxpnroangtktoeg tmkt mks ehhurrni soghn XXSO iruls wnrn

    invndepni. Ymny wnrn invndepni, mewnvnr, ks kgtoinprnsskgts, get kgtopsyhmetohs er kgto-

    pkrjogsegokg iruls. Ymn dost kcevn, rktmnr tmkg inaegstrktogl k dew snretegog kntoedely, anrndy

    smews tmkt wmng k gnw psyhmoktroh irul os invndepni tmn aniohkd pre`nssoeg tngis te nxpnroangt

    woindy wotm ot, tryogl ot eut eg pktongts wotm k rkgln e` io``nrngt precdnas. Ymos mks ehhurrni wotm tmn

    wmedn spnhtrua e` psyhmoktroh iruls, oghduiogl aoger trkgquoddosnrs, akber trkgquoddosnrs, dotmoua,kgtoinprnsskgts kgi kapmntkaogns. Og `kht, o` egn deejs kt tmn mostery e` aniohkd hmnaohkd

    ioshevnrons, suhm ks tmn ioshevnry e` gnw meraegns, egn e` tmn reutogn tkrlnts `er nxpnroangts mkvn

    cnng psyhmoktroh pktongts. Ymus, tmn ioshevnry e` ogsudog og ;?3; wks `eddewni tmn gnxt ynkr cy tryogl

    eut ogsudog-heaks ks k trnktangt `er tmn ogskgn. Hehkogn, mnreog kgi kapmntkaogns wnrn woindy usni

    cy tmn aniohkd pre`nssoeg kt tmn cnloggogl e` tmn 36tmhngtury proer te tmna cnogl insolgktni (oddnlkd)

    ikglnreus iruls. Oginni hehkogn, mnreog kgi kapmntkaogns krn ikglnreus iruls, cut se krn iepkaogn-

    cdehjnrs (kgtopsyhmetohs), cngzeiokznpogn (aoger) trkgquoddosnrs kgi kdhemed. Gohetogn os kdse k

    ikglnreus irul, kgi se os Vrezkh. Kdd tmnsn iruls mkvn hkusni inktmsiornhtdy kgi ogiornhtdy.

    Kdd tmnsn iruls (nxhnpt gohetogn kgi kdhemed) wnrn ogtreiuhni te tmn werdis muakg pepudktoeg cy tmn

    aniohkd pre`nssoeg, kgi kdd mkvn cnng indocnrktndy ogbnhtni ogte nxpnroangtkd kgoakds te tnst tmnor

    texohoty. Ymnsn kgoakds mkvn oghduini aohn, rkts, hkts, iels, smnnp, lekts, aegjnys kgi hmoapkgznns.

    \otm heapdntn ogsngsotovoty tewkris tmn su``nrogl e` eur hdesnst proaktn rndktovns, hmoapkgznns mkvn

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    53/468

    >8

    cnng `erhn-`ni kdhemed (te hkusn horrmesos) kgi `ottni wotm aksjs tmkt `erhni tmna te ogmkdn holkrnttn

    saejn: tmny mkvn cnng indocnrktndy og`nhtni wotm muakg pktmelngs kgi psyhmedelohkddy trkuaktosni se

    tmkt shongtosts hkg tndd us aern kceut muakg oddgnss. Ot os kssuani tmkt cy `ogiogl eut aern kceutoddgnss wn wodd soaudtkgneusdy uginrstkgi mew te hurn kgi prnvngt ot kgi tmkt tmos ngi busto`ons tmn

    ugpdnkskgt ankgs (e` hrnktogl oddgnss og kgoakds). Ymos os k heapdnx ossun, kgi akgy medi tmkt tmn

    su``nrogl kgi skhro`ohn e` kgoakds os votkd `er aniohkd prelrnss kgi tmn invndepangt e` shongto`oh

    jgewdniln.

    Aest e` tmn kgoakds joddni cy tmn shongto`oh nstkcdosmangt og Kustrkdok (kgi tmn werdi) teiky krn get

    cnogl skhro`ohni `er k leei rnkseg. Ymny krn cnogl terturni kgi joddni cnhkusn tmny krn vohtoas e` k

    duhrktovn audto-coddoeg-ieddkr ogiustry. Ymos ogiustry crnnis kgoakds bust se tmkt tmny hkg cnnxpnroangtni eg usogl aeinrg lngntoh tnhmgedely kgi jgewdniln rkts, aohn, rkccots kgi etmnr

    kgoakds tmkt krn lngntohkddy vudgnrkcdn te hkghnr kgi og`nhtoegs krn cnogl crni se tmny hkg cn stuioni

    k`tnr nxpesogl tmna te vkroeus strnssers kgi tmng joddogl tmna. Ymn pucdohktoeg e` rnsnkrhm `ogiogls,

    ognvotkcdy geg-heghdusovn kgi rnquorogl `urtmnr (kgoakd) nxpnroangtktoeg os otsnd` k audto-coddoeg-

    ieddkr ogiustry ks os tmn aniohkd rnsnkrhm trkogogl ogiustry. Ymny krn get trkogni te cotn tmn mkgi tmkt

    `nnis tmna.

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    54/468

    >9

    K VX_HMEKGKD_XOX E@ VX_HMOKYS_

    Og rnhngt ynkrs, akgy psyhmoktry inpkrtangts og Kustrkdok mkvn hmkglni tmnor gkan te inpkrtangts e`

    psyhmedelohkd aniohogn, mewnvnr, evnr tmn pkst ;66 ynkrs, tmn pmodesepmohkd, pedotohkd kgi tmnerntohkd

    iovoin cntwnng psyhmedely kgi psyhmoktry (k aniohkd spnhokdty) mks cnng innp, kgi og akgy wkys

    orrnheghodkcdn. Ot rnakogs tmn hksn tmkt lnguogn psyhmedely (shongto`oh jgewdniln e` tmn aogi) kgi

    mnkdogl psyhmoktry (aniohkd trnktangt e` psyhmedelohkd precdnas) hkgget cn khmonvni wotmeut k

    heapdntn trkgs`eraktoeg e` cetm ioshopdogns. Ot wodd rnquorn aern tmkg hmkglns e` gkan. Ot wodd gnni k

    hmkgln `rea k systna e` dkcnds, stktostohs, pugotovn trnktangts, pktrokrhmkd kttotuins kgi monrkrhmons te

    egn wmnrn tmn heapdnxoty e` io``nrngt hudturns kgi ogiovoiukd pnrspnhtovns os uginrsteei kgi vkduni. Ot

    os mepni tmkt tmn gnw systnas e` psyhmoktry kgi psyhmedely krn aern epng, nlkdotkrokg kgi inaehrktoh

    tmkg tmesn e` tmn prnsngt, wmohm tngi te cn snhrntovn, rudni cy edi cey hducs, prnbuiohns kgi gnlktovn

    prnheghnptoegs kceut psyhm pktongts (gew e``ohokddy hkddni hdongts kgi hegsuanrs e` tmn Angtkd

    Mnkdtm Xnrvohns). Og Kustrkdok tmn ieaogktoeg e` psyhmoktrosts evnr psyhmedelosts os ecvoeus, nspnhokddy

    og tmn mespotkd systna. Ot os k ski rn`dnhtoeg e` tmn stktn e` tmn psyhmedely pre`nssoeg tmkt `rea cnogl k

    crnniogl lreugi `er pnrtogngt hrotohosa e` tmn aniohkd aeind kgi heaaegsngsn (kgi delohkd)

    kdtnrgktovns te dkcnds kgi iruls, og Kustrkdok, lrkiuktn hdogohkd psyhmedelosts krn e`tng ks hnrtkog e`

    tmn vkdoioty e` psyhmoktroh dkcnds ks tmny krn kceut tmn aorkhudeus gkturn e` aeinrg psyhmoktroh iruls.

    Vsyhmedely, ankgogl jgewdniln kceut tmn aogi, mks cnhean oghrnksogldy spdogtnrni evnr tmn ynkrs

    ogte io``nrngt shmeeds e` tmeulmt, nkhm wotm io``nrngt kpprekhmns, kssuaptoegs, tmnerons kgi rnsnkrhm

    antmeis. Ymny kdse mkvn io``nrngt cndon`s kceut tmn crkog, rkglogl `rea shmeeds e` tmeulmt wmohm krlun

    tmkt kdd cnmkvoeur os hkusni cy hmnaohkds og tmn crkog te egns tmkt krlun tmkt tmn crkog mks dottdn te ie

    wotm tmogjogl er tmn instogy e` ogiovoiukds, wmohm os prnerikogni cy jkraoh`erhns kgi pkst dovns.

    Etmnr shmeeds e` psyhmedely krlun tmkt kdd (er aest) kiudt psyhmedelohkd iostrnss os rndktni te nkrdy

    hmodimeei trkuaks, er tmkt psyhmedelohkd precdnas krn usukddy hkusni cy lngntoh in`nhts kgi

    sushnptocodotons, er tmn k`tnraktm e` vorkd og`nhtoegs. Xean shmeeds e` psyhmedely krn prnehhuponi wotm

    stktostohkd kgkdysns e` cnmkvoeur, etmnrs hegsoinr tmnsn k wkstn e` toan kgi `ehus eg invndepogl

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    55/468

    >>

    pnrsegkdoty tnsts kgi ogtnddolnghn tnsts. Xean e` tmn aern eutrklneus psyhmedely shmeeds kshrocn

    wmkt etmnrs ogtnrprnt ks psyhmepktmedely te kdong kciuhtoegs kgi hmkggndogl cy nxtrktnrrnstrokds kgi

    antktnrrnstrokds. Akgy rnhngt shmeeds e` psyhmedely krn mnkvody ogvedvni og kgoakd nxpnroangtktoeg,oghduiogl tmn terturn e` aohn, rkts, hkts, iels (k `kveurotn) kgi aegjnys, `rea wmohm e`tng

    ugrnksegkcdn og`nrnghns krn akin kceut muakg tmeulmt kgi cnmkvoeur. Xean bust `ehus eg lovogl leei

    kivohn, heghngtrktogl eg napewnrogl ogiovoiukds te akjn rnkdostoh, sngsocdn hmeohns kgi inhosoegs, kgi

    te `ogi sedutoegs te precdnas tmreulm tmnor ewg hrnktovn tmeulmt kgi pnrsegkd aetovktoeg. Xean

    shmeeds e` psyhmedely krn prniohtkcdy aern shongto`oh tmkg etmnrs, sean krn aern pmodesepmohkddy seugi

    kgi tmnrkpnutohkddy n``nhtovn tmkg etmnrs.

    Vsyhmedely os k creki `ondi e` stuiy, wmohm invndepni `rea tmn krts kgi pmodesepmy, rktmnr tmkg `rea

    shonghn kgi aniohogn, k peogt wmohm mks dni te ogtngsn rovkdry cntwnng kimnrngts e` psyhmedely kgi

    tmesn e` psyhmoktry evnr tmn ynkrs, wotm psyhmoktry, ks k crkghme` aniohogn, hdkoaogl k akgtdn e`

    shongto`oh supnroeroty evnr ugshongto`oh psyhmedely. Og trutm, mewnvnr, gnotmnr os `eugini eg `ora

    shongto`oh lreugi, tmeulm cetm mkvn troni mkri te kppnkr shongto`oh, e`tng cy quetogl stktostohs kgi

    nglklogl og shongto`oh-seugiogl ieucdn-cdogi trokds kgi hdogohkd trokds.

    Kdtmeulm Xolaugi @rnui kgi etmnr nkrdy psyhmoktrosts wnrn aniohkd iehters trkogni og gnuredely, tmny

    `ehusni eg iosturckghns e` tmogjogl ks wndd ks iygkaoh prehnssns k``nhtogl tmn invndepangt e` tmn

    aogi lngnrkddy, e`tng usogl kgnhietkd kgi pnrsegkd nxpnronghns ks k cksos `er tmnor tmnerons. @rnui

    invndepni tmn heghnpt e` tmn ughegshoeus, krluogl tmkt auhm e` kg kiudts cnmkvoeur os levnrgni cy

    dkrlndy ugrnhelgosni ughegshoeus aetovns. Ymnsn rnquorni akgy ynkrs e` kgkdysos cy kg nxpnrt

    psyhmoktrost (suhm ks moasnd`) te lkog ogsolmt ogte. Ymn inpnginghn, kgi etmnr uginsorkcdn rnsudts e`suhm predeglni tkdj tmnrkpons wnrn tmnasndvns lovng gkans, dojn trkgs`nrnghn,og tmn gnw bkrleg.

    Ymos bkrleg lrnw og tmn gnw shongto`oh ioshopdogn e` psyhmekgkdysos kgi tmn prkhtotoegnrs e` tmos

    stydn e` psyhmoktry wnrn (kgi krn) hkddni psyhmekgkdysts.

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    56/468

    >0

    Dotnrkddy spnkjogl, psyhmekgkdysos rn`nrs te kgkdysos e` tmn aogi, kgi og tmos sngsn ot os kg nssngto kd

    prnrnquosotn `er uginrstkgiogl tmn aogi kgi oaprevogl angtkd mnkdtm og ogiovoiukds kgi sehonty ks k

    wmedn. Og prkhtohn, mewnvnr, tmn tmnrkpnutoh vkdun e` psyhmekgkdysos os inpngingt eg tmn tmnerntohkdkssuaptoegs e` tmn psyhmekgkdyst2 mew tmn psyhmekgkdyst tmogjs etmnr pnepdn tmogj. Ymos oghduins

    kssuaptoegs kceut etmnrs aetovktoegs kgi tmn iygkaoh prehnssns tmkt smkpn tmn aogis invndepangt

    tmreulmeut do`n. Cnmkvoeur, tmn ecsnrvkcdn rnsudt e` etmnrs angtkd khtovoty hkg cn ogtnrprntni og

    io``nrngt wkys inpngiogl eg tmn kssuaptoegs, cndon`s, mypetmnsns kgi tmnerons e` tmn kgkdyst, kgi hkg

    kdse cn aospnrhnovni cnhkusn e` prnbuiohns e` tmn kgkdyst.

    Ot os kdse ognvotkcdn (kgi preckcdy insorkcdn), tmkt psyhmekgkdytohkd tmnerosts weudi oghduin og tmnor

    aeinds sean ndnangts e` snd`-kgkdysos, kgi wmodst tmos seantoans ingolrktni ks sucbnhtovn kgi tmus

    get shongto`oh, aktmnaktohkd (stktostohkd) kgkdysos e` gerakd cnmkvoeur (cksni eg muakg kgi kgoakd

    nxpnroangtktoeg) ks tmn egdy ecbnhtovn shongto`oh antmei e` stuiy mks ecvoeus doaotktoegs kgi

    ikglnrs, akgy e` wmohm mkvn cnhean oghrnksogldy kppkrngt og rnhngt ynkrs.

    Ymn aest og`dungtokd aniohkd iehter tmos hngtury te prnsngt k aeind e` muakg angtkd prehnssns wks

    preckcdy @rnui, k Bnwosm Kustrokg pmysohokg wotm rktmnr suspnht kttotuins te weang kgi hmodirng, wme

    invndepni mos tmnerons tmreulm k heacogktoeg e` hdogohkd nxpnronghn (wotm ksydua ogaktns kgi k``dungt

    provktn pktongts) kgi snd`-kgkdysos. Ymos wks heaangtni eg cy Vre`nsser Xtkg`ondi Xkrlngt og tmn ;?99

    ogtreiuhtery tnxtceej Lrnkt Vsyhmedelosts (pucdosmni cy Ckrgns kgi Gecdn2 Gnw _erj), wmng tmn

    nkrdy iovosoeg (kgi spdogtnrogl) e` Nurepnkg psyhmedelohkd tmnery ogte io``nrngt (kgi e`tng heg`dohtogl)

    shmeeds e` tmeulmt os inshrocni (wotm aern tmkg kg ndnangt e` oied-cuodiogl kgi aytm-akjogl)2

    Og k yeugl kgi lrewogl shonghn ogtnrgkd iosputns e`tng ehhur. Vsyhmedely os ge nxhnptoeg.

    Vsyhmedelosts mkvn io``nrni kceut wmkt psyhmedely smeudi er smeudi get oghduin, kceut wmkt ot

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    57/468

    >=

    wks heaaeg jgewdniln kt tmn toan, ger iens mn kiaot te tmn ktrehotons tmkt wnrn cnogl pnrpntrktni cy

    coedelohkd psyhmoktrosts og Gkzo Lnrakgy evnr tmn ynkrs oaanioktndy prnhniogl tmn wrotogl e` tmos

    ceej. Kdtmeulm \odmnda \ugit os inshrocni ks nstkcdosmogl tmn `orst psyhmedelohkd dkcerktery, tmnntmohs e` wmkt wks iegn og tmos dkcerktery kgi te wmea, os get nxpderni og tmos ceej, wmohm oiedosns

    tmn `ktmnrs e` psyhmedely dostni og tmn prn`khn ks Cognt, @rnui, Lkdteg, Mndamedtz, Meddoglwertm,

    Bkans, Ymergiojn, \ktseg kgi \eeiwertm `eddewni cy Kidnr, Hkggeg, Hkttndd, Nccoglmkus, Lnsndd,

    Leiikri, Bkgnt, Bugl, Je``jk, Jemdnr, Jrknpndog, Dksmdny, Dnwog, Vkvdev, Sershmkhm, Ynrakg,

    Yothmngnr, kgi _nrjns wme krn skoi te cn kssehoktni proakrody wotm aern spnhokdozni werj.

    E` tmnsn gkans k `nw mkvn lrewg og `kan (kgi geteronty) evnr tmn pkst `o`ty ynkrs, oghduiogl @rnui,

    Bugl, Lkdteg, Jrknpndog, Sershmkhm kgi Vkvdev. @rnui kgi Jrknpndog, nspnhokddy, mkvn akgy invetni

    ioshopdns wotmog tmn aniohkd pre`nssoeg. Auhm e` tmn kgoakd rnsnkrhm ogiustry kgi cnmkvoeurkd

    shonghns rnsnkrhm os cksni eg Vkvdevs werj eg hdkssohkd hegiotoegogl e` iels (kgi muakgs). Ymn

    Xwoss psyhmoktrost Hkrd Bugl os cnst rnanacnrni `er mos snd`-kgkdytohkd werj eg irnkas, syacedosa kgi

    pmodesepmy, kdtmeulm mn wks kg khtovn hdogohkd psyhmoktrost (kgi pmysohokg). Aohmknd Xtegn wrotns, og

    Mnkdogl tmn Aogi(;??=), e` tmn rndktoegsmop cntwnng Kidnr, @rnui kgi Bugl2

    Ponggnsn-cerg Kd`rni Kidnr (;=

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    59/468

    >?

    Bugl moasnd`, wretn e` @rnui, ogAnaerons, Irnkas, Sn`dnhtoegs(;?0;)2

    Vsyhmoktry tnkhmnrs wnrn get ogtnrnstni og wmkt tmn pktongt mki te sky, cut rktmnr og mew teakjn k ioklgesos er mew te inshrocn syapteas kgi te heapodn stktostohs. @rea tmn hdogohkd

    peogt e` vonw wmohm tmng prnvkodni, tmn muakg pnrsegkdoty e` tmn pktongt, mos ogiovoiukdoty, ioi

    get akttnr kt kdd. Sktmnr, tmn iehter wks heg`regtni wotm Vktongt ], wotm k degl dost e` hut kgi

    ironi ioklgesns kgi intkodogl e` syapteas. Vktongts wnrn dkcnddni, ruccnr-stkapni wotm k

    ioklgesos, kgi, `er tmn aest pkrt, tmkt snttdni tmn akttnr. Ymn psyhmedely e` tmn angtkd pktongt

    pdkyni ge redn wmktsenvnr.

    Kt tmos peogt @rnui cnhkan votkddy oapertkgt te an, nspnhokddy cnhkusn e` mos `ugikangtkdrnsnkrhmns ogte tmn psyhmedely e` mystnrok kgi e` irnkas. @er an mos oinks peogtni tmn wky te k

    hdesnr ogvnstolktoeg kgi uginrstkgiogl e` ogiovoiukd hksns. @rnui ogtreiuhni psyhmedely ogte

    psyhmoktry, kdtmeulm mn moasnd` wks k gnuredelost. (p.;8>)

    Ymn shongto`oh ioshopdogns e` Gnuredely, Vsyhmoktry kgi Vsyhmedely hkg cn cnst uginrsteei `rea

    tmn Lrnnj reets e` tmnsn heapesotns e` gnure, psyhmn, deles kgi oktres. Gnure rn`nrs te tmn

    crkog kgi gnrvns, kgi tmn deloh cksni shongto`oh stuiy e` tmn gnrveus systna mks degl cnng inshrocni ks

    gnuredely. Ymn oink e` aniohkd iehters trkogni og tmn trnktangt e` tmn aogi cut get tmn crkog os k

    rndktovndy rnhngt pmngeangeg, kgi mks dni te tmn kcsuri sotuktoeg wmnrn k aogidnss gnuredely kgi k

    crkogdnss psyhmoktry mkvn cnhean tmn egdy hmeohns kvkodkcdn `er tmn aniohkd lrkiuktn wme wosmns te

    uginrtkjn `urtmnr stuiy og tmn gnureshonghns. Vsyhmn os vkroeusdy trkgsdktni ks aogi er seud, cut ot

    hnrtkogdy iens get ankg cnmkvoeur, ks sean aeinrg psyhmedelosts kgi psyhmoktrosts suppesn. Deles,

    trkgsdktni dotnrkddy ankgs weri, mewnvnr og tmn hegtnxt e` gnuredely kgi psyhmedely hkg cn usni

    te rn`nr te tmn tetkd shongto`oh jgewdniln e` tmn tepoh gnxt te wmohm tmn su``ox os usni. Ymus gnuredelyrn`nrs te heddnhtovn muakg jgewdniln kceut tmn crkog kgi gnrveus systna, wmodst psyhmedely rn`nrs te

    heddnhtovn muakg jgewdniln (oghduiogl tmkt e` pkst toans) kceut tmn aogi, tmogjogl kgi tmeulmt (kgi

    nvng te shongto`oh stuiy e` seud, o` tmn tnra os usni ugusukddy crekidy). Vsyhmoktry, heacogogl psyhmn

    wotm oktres (trnktangt) rn`nrs te trnktangt e` tmn aogi (kgi seud) kgi ot os io``ohudt te snn mew tmn aogi

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    60/468

    06

    hkg cn rktoegkddy kgi shongto`ohkddy trnktni cy tmn aniohkd pre`nssoeg wotmeut k rktoegkd shongto`oh

    uginrstkgiogl e` cetm psyhmedely kgi gnuredely.

    @eddewogl mos ogtreiuhtoeg te @rnui, Bugl hegtoguns, og Anaerons, Irnkas, Sn`dnhtoegs wotm k

    inshroptoeg e` mos ewg psyhmekgkdytohkd tnhmgoqun kt werj2

    O stodd rnheddnht vnry wndd k hksn wmohm lrnktdy ogtnrnstni an kt tmn toan. K yeugl weakg mki

    cnng kiaottni te tmn mespotkd su``nrogl `rea andkghmedok. Ymn nxkaogktoeg wks hegiuhtni

    wotm tmn usukd hkrn2 kgkagnsos, tnsts, pmysohkd hmnhj-ups, kgi se eg. Ymn ioklgesos wksshmozepmrngok, er inangtok prknhex, og tmn pmrksn e` tmesn ikys. Ymn prelgesos2 peer.

    Ymos weakg mkppngni te cn og ay snhtoeg. Kt `orst O ioi get ikrn qunstoeg tmn ioklgesos. O wks

    stodd k yeugl akg tmng, k cnloggnr, kgi weudi get mkvn mki tmn tnanroty te sullnst kgetmnr egn.

    Kgi ynt tmn hksn struhj an ks strkgln. O mki tmn `nndogl tmkt ot wks get k akttnr e` shmozepmrngok

    cut e` eriogkry inprnssoeg, kgi rnsedvni te kppdy ay ewg antmei. Kt tmn toan O wks auhm

    ehhuponi wotm ioklgestoh kssehoktoeg stuions, se O uginrteej kg kssehoktoeg nxpnroangt wotm tmn

    pktongt. Og kiiotoeg, O ioshussni mnr irnkas wotm mnr. Og tmos wky O suhhnnini og ughevnrogl mnr

    pkst, wmohm tmn kgkagnsos mki get hdkro`oni. O ectkogni tmos og`eraktoeg iornhtdy `rea tmn

    ughegshoeus, kgi tmos og`eraktoeg rnvnkdni k ikrj kgi trkloh stery.

    Ymn stery, cron`dy, os tmkt tmn weakg, wme wks vnry prntty wks rnbnhtni cy tmn seg e` k wnkdtmy

    ogiustrokdost wmea, khheriogl te Bugl smn tmeulmt mnr hmkghns e` hkthmoglwnrn `kordy leei. K`tnr

    akrryogl seanegn ndsn, mnr inprnssoeg mki invndepni suiingdy k`tnr cnogl tedi tmkt tmn wnkdtmy

    ogiustrokdosts seg mki quotn k smehj wmng smn let akrroni, `eddewni cy k trklniy wmng mnr yeugl

    ikulmtnr ioni e` typmeoi `nvnr, kgi smn tmeulmt tmkt tmn og`nhtoeg mki cnng hegtrkhtni cy tmn hmodi

    suhjogl eg k spegln tkogtni cy oapurn rovnr wktnr.

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    61/468

    0;

    Og mos inshroptoeg e` tmn stery kgi mos aorkhudeus hurn e` mnr angtkd oddgnss cy tnddogl mnr smn wks k

    aurinrnr, Bugl snnas te khhnpt, kgi oginni rnog`erhn, tmn kssuaptoeg tmkt tmn hmodi invndepni typmeoi

    cy suhjogl eg tmos spegln, nvng tmeulm tmn weakgs dottdn seg irkgj k ldkss e` tmn rovnr wktnr wotmeutcnheaogl odd2

    Xmn wks cktmogl mnr hmodirng, `orst mnr `eur-ynkr-edi lord kgi tmng mnr twe-ynkr-edi seg. Xmn

    dovni og k heugtry wmnrn tmn wktnr suppdy wks get pnr`nhtdy mylnogoh: tmnrn wks purn sprogl

    wktnr `er irogjogl, kgi tkogtni wktnr `rea tmn rovnr `er cktmogl kgi wksmogl. \modn smn wks

    cktmogl tmn dottdn lord, smn skw tmn hmodi suhjogl kt tmn spegln, cut ioi get step mnr. Xmn nvng

    lkvn mnr dottdn seg k ldkss e` tmn oapurn wktnr te irogj. Gkturkddy, smn ioi tmos ughegshoeusdy, er

    egdy mkd` hegshoeusdy, `er mnr aogi wks kdrnkiy uginr tmn smkiew e` tmn oghopongt inprnssoeg.

    K smert toan dktnr, k`tnr tmn oghucktoeg pnroei mki pkssni, tmn lord hkan iewg wotm typmeoi

    `nvnr kgi ioni. Ymn lord mki cnng mnr `kveurotn. Ymn cey wks get og`nhtni. Kt tmkt aeangt tmn

    inprnssoeg rnkhmni ots khutn stkln, kgi tmn weakg wks sngt te tmn ogstotutoeg.

    @rea tmn kssehoktoeg tnst O mki snng tmkt smn wks k aurinrnss, kgi O mki dnkrgni akgy intkods

    e` mnr snhrnt. Ot wks kt eghn kppkrngt tmkt tmos wks k su``ohongt rnkseg `er mnr inprnssoeg.

    Nssngtokddy ot wks k psyhmelngoh iosturckghn kgi get k hksn e` shmozepmrngok.

    Ot os hdnkr `rea Bugls wrotogls tmkt, wmodst rnhelgosogl tmos weakgs iostrnss ks iun te psyhmedelohkd

    trkuaks tmkt smn su``nrni og tmn pkst, mn `kodni te rnkdosn tmkt mnr prniohtkcdn `nndogls e` luodt tmkt smn

    mki hkusni tmn inktm e` mnr ewg ikulmtnr tmreulm gnldolnghn heudi mkvn cnng trnktni og k auhm

    aern muakgn wky tmkg cy khhusogl mnr e` cnogl k aurinrnr. Mn kdse khhnptni vkdoioty e` tmn dkcnd e`

    shmozepmrngok kgi kg kttngikgt peer prelgesos, kdtmeulm mn cndonvni tmn pnssoaostoh prelgesos mki

    cnng aoskppdoni og tmos hksn. Mn kdse kiaots te cnogl ogtoaoiktni (kgi tmus sodnghni) cy tmn nstkcdosmni

    monrkrhmy og tmn aniohkd pre`nssoeg, suhm tmkt mn ioi get ikrn iosklrnn wotm tmn ioklgesos akin cy mos

    supnroers. Og tnras e` ntmohkd, coedelohkd kgi shongto`ohdeloh, Bugl kppnkrs te mkvn `kodni te rnkdosn kgi

    nvoingtdy `kodni te nxpdkog te mos pktongt tmkt tmn cndon` smn mndi tmkt mnr ikulmtnr hegtrkhtni typmeoi cy

    suhjogl eg k spegln wotm rovnr wktnr og ot wks get k shongto`oh hnrtkogty cy kgy ankgs, kgi tmn

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    62/468

    03

    khhoingtkd inktm e` mnr ikulmtnr mkridy akin mnr k aurinrnss, wmohm cy usukd in`ogotoeg rn`nrs te tmn

    ogtngtoegkdjoddnr e` kgetmnr pnrseg. Ymn `kht tmkt smn ioi get mkvn shmozepmrngok weudi snna ecvoeus,

    cut k innpnr nxpderktoeg e` wmy smn mki cnng ioklgesni ks suhm weudi mkvn pnrmkps akin aernogtnrnstogl rnkiogl tmkg tmos rktmnr snd`-ogiudlngt khheugt akjns. Bugl nxpdkogs wmy mn hegsoinrni mos

    psyhmekgkdytohkd psyhmetmnrkpy tnhmgoqun k suhhnss2

    O tedi mnr nvnrytmogl O mki ioshevnrni tmreulm tmn kssehoktoeg tnst. Ot hkg nksody cn oaklogni

    mew io``ohudt ot wks `er an te ie tmos. Ye khhusn k pnrseg peogt-cdkgj e` aurinr os ge sakdd

    akttnr. Kgi ot wks trkloh `er tmn pktongt te mkvn te dostng te ot kgi khhnpt ot. Cut tmn rnsudt wks

    tmkt og twe wnnjs ot prevni pessocdn te ioshmkrln mnr, kgi smn wks gnvnr klkog

    ogstotutoegkdosni. (p.;8

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    63/468

    08

    Cnmkvoerosawks `eugini kceut ;?;9 cy BEMG C. \KYXEG, tmng kg kgoakd psyhmedelost kt

    Bemg Mepjogs ^govnrsoty. Mn tee wks oapktongt wotm tmn gkrrewgnss e` struhturkdosa, cut mn

    ioi get `nnd tmkt tmn `ughtoegkdosts wngt `kr ngeulm og tmnor hrotohosas. \ktseg ecbnhtnipkrtohudkrdy te ogtrespnhtoeg, wmohm mn hegsoinrni ugshongto`oh. Vsyhmedelys rnkd heghnrg, mn

    skoi, os te stuiy cnmkvoer, get hegshoeusgnss. Nxpesn kg kgoakd er k muakg cnogl te k stoaudus

    kgi snn mew mn rnspegis: rnheri tmos cnmkvoer ecbnhtovndy kgi yeu mkvn rnkd shongto`oh

    nvoinghn. \ktseg kgi mos `nddew cnmkvoerosts nxpnroangtni eg dnkrgogl, aetovktoeg, naetoeg,

    kgi ogiovoiukd invndepangt.

    Ymn shmeed e` cnmkvoeurosa mks cnng vnry og`dungtokd og Kustrkdok kgi tmn ^XK, te suhm kg nxtngt tmkt

    akgy psyhmedely tnxts in`ogn psyhmedely ks tmn stuiy e` cnmkvoeur, rktmnr tmkg tmn stuiy e` tmogjogl

    er tmn aogi. Khheriogl te Vre`nsser Xkrlngt, Vsyhmekgkdysos os bust kgetmnr shmeed e` tmeulmt eut e`

    akgy heapntogl aeinds, kgi egn tmkt os shongto`ohkddy suspnht2

    Vsyhmekgkdysos steei kpkrt `rea tmn etmnr shmeeds. @eugini cy k pmysohokg, XOLA^GI

    @SN^I, ot lrnw eut e` mos n``ert te hurn pnrsegs su``nrogl `rea angtkd kgi gnrveus ioserinrs.

    Vsyhmekgkdysos prnsngts kakzogldy `ruot`ud kgi prevehktovn tmnerons e` aetovktoeg, e`pnrsegkdoty invndepangt, kgi e` kcgerakd cnmkvoer. ^gdojn etmnr `euginrs e` shmeeds, @rnui

    akin ge n``ert te vnro`y mos tmnerons cy shongto`oh nxpnroangt. @rnuis akber ogtnrprntktoegs kgi

    tmesn e` mos iossoingt ioshopdns krn prnsngtni og tmn hmkptnr hkddni Heg`dohts kgi tmn

    ^ghegshoeus. (X.Xkrlngt og Lrnkt Vsyhmedelosts, p0)

    Og Hmkptnr ;3, totdni angtkd iosnksn, Vre`nsser Xkrlngt dosts mos prn`nrnghn `er psyhmoktroh ohegs e` kdd

    toan. Xnvnrkd gkans krn dostni og hkpotkd dnttnrs uginr tmn hmkptnr mnkiogl2 Moppehrktns, \nynr, Vognd,

    Iox, Jrknpndog, Cdnudnr, Lronsoglnr, Cnnrs, Hkapcndd, \motn, Bkhjseg, Anynr, Seskge`` kgi Dnggex.

    Ymn hmkptnr cnlogs wotm wmkt, tkjng dotnrkddy, heudi cn k snd`-`ud`oddogl tmrnkt2

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    64/468

    09

    Kceut egn pnrseg e` nvnry twngty og tmn ^gotni Xtktns wodd kt sean toan iurogl mos do`n cn

    trnktni og k angtkd mespotkd. Ymn hkrn kgi hurn e` suhm pnrsegs os k trnangieus precdna.

    Ymng os prnsngtni k vnry aosdnkiogl rn`nrnghn te tmn hurrngt muakgn vnrsus tmn proer ogmuakgn

    antmeis ogvedvni og tmn trnktangt e` tmesn innani angtkddy odd er aki2

    Kppkrngtdy angtkd iosnksn mks kdwkys nxostni, cut egdy og tmn dkst `o`ty ynkrs mks ot cnng

    mkgidni shongto`ohkddy. \n mkvn prelrnssni k degl wky `rea tmn ikys e` hndds kgi hmkogs `er tmn

    ogskgn. \n stodd mkvn `kr te le te rnkhm kg oinkd sedutoeg.

    Ymn suppesotoeg tmkt tmn angtkddy iostrnssni, heg`usni, upsnt er iosturcni wnrn reutogndy trnktni cy kdd

    heugtrons, gktoegs, levnrgangts kgi `kaodons wotm hndds kgi hmkogs os ecvoeusdy get herrnht. Og `kht ot

    os k sakdd aogeroty e` tmn pepudktoeg kt kgy egn toan wme mkvn cnng trnktni og tmos wky, kgi tmos sert e`

    trnktangt mks cnng erinrni cy egdy k `nw pnepdn (akogdy ang) wme mkvn mki tmn kutmeroty te lovn suhm

    erinrs kgi mkvn tmna oapdnangtni. Vre`nsser Xkrlngt kdse `kods te angtoeg tmkt tmn reutogn trnktangts

    lovng te psyhmoktroh pktongts wme mki cnng ioklgesni ks su``nrogl angtkd iosnksn (er angtkd oddgnss)

    wnrn auhm aern hrund kgi pugotovn tmkg anrn hndds kgi hmkogs. Ymn oaprosegni, hmkogni dugktohs

    (cy akgy gkans) mkvn cnng wmoppni, oaanrsni og hedi wktnr er met wktnr, sngserody inprovni, ogbnhtni

    wotm jgewg peosegs kgi og`nhtoegs, akin heaktesn, lovng ndnhtrohkd smehjs te tmnor mnki, lngotkds kgi

    mkgis, surlohkddy er hmnaohkddy hkstrktni, mki tmnor tnntm rnaevni, stkrvni kgi terturni og akgy etmnr

    wkys, kdwkys wotm tmn hdkoa tmkt tmnsn tmogls wnrn cnogl iegn `er tmn skjn e` tmn k``dohtni ogiovoiukd

    kgi tmn lrnktnr sehonty. Ognvotkcdy k shongto`oh seugiogl tmnery mks cnng usni te busto`y wmkt weudi

    etmnrwosn cn hdnkrdy rnhelgosni ks ugntmohkd kgi oddnlkd kcusn e` tmn pepudktoeg cy k pre`nssoegkd

    ndotn.

    Hegvoghogl tmn oghrnksogldy sjnptohkd pepudktoeg e` tmn werdi tmkt tmny mkvn k supnroer uginrstkgiogl

    e` akignss kgi skgoty, angtkd oddgnss kgi mnkdtm te etmnr nxpnrts kgi geg-nxpnrts mks cnng k

    deglstkgiogl heghnrg e` tmn psyhmoktroh pre`nssoeg, kgi k pre`nssoegkd ogsnhuroty hkg cn snng og

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    65/468

    0>

    n``erts e` psyhmoktrosts kgi psyhmedelosts te hdkoa k pesotoeg ks dnlotoaktn shongtosts. Ymn

    precdna e` shongto`oh hrniocodoty os kiirnssni cy Vre`nsser Xkrlngt og tmn `eddewogl wky2

    \n mkvn hkddni psyhmedely k shonghn. Os tmos herrnht5 Kstregeay, hmnaostry, kgi pmysohs krn

    rnkiody rnhelgozni ks shonghns: tmny ogvedvn hkrn`ud dkcerktery werj, nxkht anksurnangt, roloi

    dkws, kgi surn-`orn prniohtkcodoty. Vsyhmedely os heghnrgni wotm seantmogl dnss in`ogotn kgi

    tkglocdn: nxkhtotuin os mkri te ectkog kgi nxhnptoegdnss dkws kdaest gnvnr ehhur.

    Mewnvnr, ot os get tmn in`ogotngnss e` ots aktnrokd wmohm intnraogns wmntmnr k sucbnht os k

    shonghn. (O` ot wnrn, coedely aolmt cn nxhduini soghn ot stuions tmn lrnkt ugjgewg - do`n.) JKSD

    VNKSXEG, kg Ngldosm aktmnaktohokg kgi shongtost, ogsostni gnkrdy `o`ty ynkrs kle tmkt tmnhrotnroeg e` shonghn os get sucbnht akttnr cut tmn antmeis e` ogvnstolktoeg usni. O` shongto`oh

    antmei os usni systnaktohkddy, wn aky prepnrdy spnkj e` k shonghn, wmntmnr tmn ecbnht e` stuiy

    os aognrkds, ckhtnrok, muakg tmeulmts kgi `nndogls, er sehokd ogstotutoegs.

    Xhongto`oh antmeios ge aystnry. Ot os k in`ogotn prehniurn usni og tryogl te kgswnr k qunstoeg

    er sedvn k precdna. Ymn precdna aky cn k prkhtohkd egn dojn \mkt hkusns akdkrok5, \mkt

    hkusns angtkd iosnksn5, Mew iens kdhemed k``nht cnmkvoer5 Er tmn precdna aky cn ogsporni

    cy anrn huroesoty2 \my ie ecbnhts `kdd te tmn nkrtm5, Mew iens mnrnioty werj5, Hkgkgoakds dnkrg5

    Ot os ogtnrnstogl tmkt Vre`nsser Xkrlngt smeudi angtoeg tmnsn pkrtohudkr precdnas kgi qunstoegs kgi

    ot os wertm deejogl kt tmn wkys og wmohm tmnsn shongto`oh, coedelohkd kgi sehokd pmngeangk mkvn cnng

    rnsnkrhmni og tmn ynkrs soghn tmos ceej wks wrottng, kgi wmkt heghdusoegs mkvn cnng rnkhmni cy tmn

    shongto`oh heaaugoty kceut tmna. Ot os kdse wertm deejogl kt tmn aniohkd rnsnkrhm tmkt wks ehhurrogl og

    ogstotutoegs kssehoktni wotm Heduacok ^govnrsoty wmnrn X. Xtkg`ondi Xkrlngt wks napdeyni ks

    Kssehoktn Vre`nsser e` Vsyhmedely iurogl tmn Xnhegi \erdi \kr.

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    66/468

    00

    Ymn `orst qunstoeg, \mkt hkusns akdkrok5hkg cn kgswnrni nksody eg tmn aest ecvoeus dnvnd2 og`nhtoeg

    wotm Vdksaeioua akdkrok pkrksotns, wmohm krn hkrroni cy aesquotens, kgi trkgsaottni ogte tmn cdeei

    tmreulm tmn sjog cy aesquote cotns, usukddy `rea Kgepmndns er Hudnxaesquotens. Ymos os, mewnvnr,egdy k pkrtokd nxpdkgktoeg e` wmkt hkusns akdkrok. @orstdy, get nvnryegn wme mks akdkrok pkrksotns

    ogbnhtni ogte tmnor sjog wodd invndep akdkrok (inpngiogl eg oaaugn systna mnkdtm), kgi snhegidy, get

    nvnryegn wme mks hegtrkhtni akdkrok mks iegn se cy cnogl cottng cy aesquotens. Xean mkvn cnng

    lovng og`nhtoegs cy indocnrktn trkgs`usoeg e` og`nhtni cdeei te tnst gnw kgtoakdkrokd iruls. Kgi kt iesns

    tmkt akin snroeus oddgnss hnrtkog.

    Ot os k dottdn-jgewg `kht tmkt iurogl tmn Xnhegi \erdi \kr kgi `er k `nw aegtms k`tnr ot ngini, ioskcdni

    Kustrkdokg sedionrs, kdegl wotm Bnwosm rn`ulnns kgi ogtnrgni Otkdokgs wnrn sucbnhtni te snhrntnxpnroangts og rnaetn Gertm [unngsdkgi wmnrn tmny wnrn trkgs`usni wotm ckls e` cdeei tmkt wnrn

    dkhni wotm akdkrok kgi sucbnhtni te cotns `rea aesquotens spnhokddy crni te hkrry muln dekis e` tmn

    akdkrokd pkrksotn. Ymn ecbnhtovn wks te `ogi wkys te heugtnr tmn aertkdoty kgi aercoioty e` Kddoni

    treeps og tmn trepohs, Ymn og`nhtni cdeei wks prevoini cy tmn Sni Hress: tmn aesquotens hkpkcdn e`

    hkrryogl mugirnis e` toans tmn gerakd deki e` akdkrok wnrn crni cy tmn Heughod `er Xhongto`oh kgi

    Ogiustrokd Snsnkrhm (HXOS), tmn `ernruggnr te tmn HXOSE. Ymnsn muakg luognk-pol nxpnroangts wnrn

    `orst rnpertni `o`ty ynkrs k`tnr tmny ehhurrni, og tmn @kor`kx prnss (pucdosmnrs e` Ymn Kln, wmohm hkrroni

    tmn rnperts). Yrun te `era, tmn Auriehm prnss (wmohm ewgs aest e` tmn etmnr gnwspkpnrs og Kustrkdok)ioi get angtoeg tmnsn nxpnroangts.

    Ks `er tmn vnxogl qunstoeg e` wmkt hkusns angtkd iosnksn, ot inpngis eg mew angtkd iosnksn os in`ogni.

    Os wkr-aeglnrogl os kg ogiohktoeg e` angtkd iosnksn5 Os tmn akgu`khturn e` dkgiaogns kgi

    audtockrrnddni mnkvy wnkpegs ogiohktovn e` akignss5 Os inaegozogl iossoingts k solg e` angtkd oddgnss5

    Cy tmos tejng, hkg gktoegs, ks wndd ks ogiovoiukds. cn angtkddy odd5

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    67/468

    06 ynkrs k`tnr tmny ehhurrni, kgi wnrn mkridy heaangtni eg cy tmn

    shongto`oh prnss er pedotohokgs og tmn heugtry og wmohm tmnsn tnrrocdn kcusns ehhurrni. Ymn nxpnroangts,

    eg pnepdn inshrocni og tmn Klnkrtohdns ks muakg luognk pols, wnrn iegn og Gertm [unngsdkgi (kgi

    dktnr, og Andceurgn) iurogl tmn Xnhegi \erdi \kr kgi `er snvnrkd aegtms k`tnr tmn e``ohokd hnssktoeg e`

    mestodotons, irovng cy tmn aodotkry kgi `ogkghokd aetovn e` tnstogl gnw kgtoakdkrokd iruls invndepni og

    Lnrakgy `er texohoty cy tmn Kddons eg hkptovn pepudktoegs. Ot os io``ohudt get te snn tmos ks k mestodn kht

    klkogst Kustrkdok kgi tmn Kustrkdokg pnepdn, ks wndd ks tmn Otkdokg kgi Bnwosm pnepdn wme wnrn

    sucbnhtni te terturn, wmohm wks tmng ingoni.

    Nvng wotm tmn rnvndktoeg e` intkods e` tmnsn hrund kgi uggnhnsskry khts cy tmn Kustrkdokg kgi Crotosm

    Levnrgangts e` tmn iky (wme udtoaktndy medi rnspegsocodoty `er tmnor krani `erhns), tmn indocnrktn

    og`nhtoeg kgi peosegogl e` tmnsn pnepdn wks get inshrocni ks terturn er coedelohkd wkr`krn cy tmn Kln

    gnwspkpnr, kdtmeulm tmn rnpertnrs ioi inshrocn tmn oghoingt ks kcusn. Ymn Auriehm-ewgni

    gnwspkpnrs og Pohterok (Ymn Kustrkdokgkgi Ymn Mnrkdi Xug) ioi get tkjn tmn ossun up, kgi Ymn Klnioi

    get pnrsost wotm tmn mosterohkd stery er akjn tmn gnhnsskry heggnhtoegs wotm hegtnaperkry aniohkd

    shonghn kgi rnsnkrhm khtovoty og Kustrkdok (kgi Andceurgn, og pkrtohudkr) te uginrstkgi wmy Luy Gedhm

    aky mkvn wrottng og tmn nioterokd e` Kustrkdksokg Xhonghn tmkt dottdn mks hmkglni og >6 ynkrs wmng

    heaangtogl eg coedelohkd wkr`krn sullnstogl tmkt tmn `kudt dons get wotm tmn shongtosts cut tmn

    akstnrs wme hegtred tmna.

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    68/468

    0=

    Ymn irul Vkduirogn wks cnogl tnstni `er OHO hmnaohkds, k dkrln Crotosm-cksni heapkgy wmohm hegtoguns

    te akrjnt tmn irul teiky, kgi tmn iornhter e` OHO Kustrkdok, Cng Dehmtngcnrl, mki cnng, `er snvnrkd

    ynkrs, tmn iornhter e` tmn Angtkd Mnkdtm Ogstotutn og Vkrjvoddn, Andceurgn, wmng tmn rnperts e` tmnakdkrok tnsts wnrn `ogkddy akin pucdoh og Ymn Kln. OHO, wmohm os kg khregya `er Oapnrokd Hmnaohkd

    Ogiustrons wks `eugini og ;?30, iurogl k pnroei e` toan cntwnng tmn twe \erdi \krs tmkt mks cnng

    rn`nrrni te ks Ymn Inprnssoeg. Kreugi tmn skan toan ks tmn rnvndktoegs kceut tmn og`nhtoeg kgi

    trnktangt trokds, OHO pmkrakhnutohkds wks trkgs`erani ogte Rngnhk pmkrakhnutohkds, wmohm og ;???

    cnhkan kakdlkaktni wotm tmn Xwning-cksni Kstrk pmkrakhnutohkds, `eraogl k gnw lokgt irul

    heapkgy hkddni Kstrk-Rngnhk. Ymn muln geg-pmkrakhnutohkd epnrktoegs e` OHO hegtoguni ks OHO

    hmnaohkds, ugk``nhtni cy tmn anrlnr, khheriogl te tmn Og`eraktoeg Xnrvohn prevoini eg k ;=66 guacnr

    cy Kstrk-Rngnhk. Ymn pmegn ansskln e` tmn edi Kstrk-Rngnhk guacnr og Andceurgn kggeughni, wmngO hkddni tmn guacnr eg ;.?.??, tmkt tmn Andceurgn e``ohn e` Kstrk-Rngnhk mks hdesni, kgi tmn mnki

    e``ohn rndehktni te Xyigny.

    Ymn akdkrok og`nhtoegs, wmohm ehhurrni og rnaetn Gertm [unngsdkgi, uginr tmn kuspohns e` tmn Sni

    Hress, Seykd Kustrkdokg kgi Crotosm Aodotkry, ogvedvni indocnrktndy nxpesogl pmysohkddy kgi

    psyhmedelohkddy strnssni ogiovoiukds te nxtrkeriogkrody molm iesns e` akdkrok tmreulm spnhokddy crniaesquotens kgi trkgs`usoegs e` cdeei og`nhtni wotm akdkrok. Ymn og`nhtni pnepdn wnrn tmng sucbnht te

    pmysohkd trkuak suhm ks nxpesurn te hedi kgi tmng lovng akssovn iesns e` tmn hmnaohkds te cn tnstni,

    ecsnrvogl `er texoh n``nhts. K`tnr tmn wkr ngini, khheriogl te tmn gnwspkpnr rnperts, prnssurn `rea tmn

    Kanrohkg irul heapkgy \ogtmrep (preiuhnrs e` Vkgkied) kgi OHO rnsudtni og tmn trokds cnogl smo`tni te

    tmn Mnoindcnrl Aodotkry Mespotkd og Andceurgn, wmohm mki erhmnstrktni tmn Kustrkdokg trokds. Vkgkied

    kgi Vkgkinogn (pkrkhntkaed wotm heinogn), prnvoeusdy \ogtmrep crkgis, krn gew akrjntni og Kustrkdok

    cy tmn Hegsuanr crkghm e` XaotmJdogn Cnnhmka.

    Mnoindcnrl Aodotkry Mespotkd, wmohm wks cuodt og ;?9;, cnhkan tmn Mnoindcnrl Snpktroktoeg Mespotkd og

    ;?9 te `era tmn akssovn Kustog

    kgi Snpktroktoeg Mespotkd dehktni og tmn Gertm-Nkstnrg Andceurgn sucurc e` Mnoindcnrl. Ymn Kustog

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    69/468

    0?

    mespotkd, gew tmn collnst mespotkd og Andceurgn khheriogl te tmn Vucdoh Sndktoegs Inpkrtangt e` tmn

    mespotkd, wks egn e` Andceurgns `orst mespotkds, kgi wks cuodt og ;==3. Ot os, dojn Andceurgns `orst

    mespotkd, tmn Seykd Andceurgn Mespotkd og Vkrjvoddn, wmohm wks cuodt og ;=9=, k``odoktni wotm tmn^govnrsoty e` Andceurgn, wmohm wks `eugini og tmn ;=06s, kt tmn toan e` tmn ledi-rusm. Cetm tmnsn

    mespotkds krn akber tnkhmogl mespotkds (`er aniohkd stuingts) kgi pucdoh mespotkds wmohm trnkt

    Andceurgn pnepdn wme hkgget k``eri, er ie get wkgt provktn aniohkd hkrn. Ymny kdse cetm prevoin

    pucdoh psyhmoktroh snrvohns, oghduiogl dehjni `khodotons `er pnepdn te cn ogbnhtni og klkogst tmnor wodds. Og

    @ncrukry, 3666, tmn pucdoh rndktoegs e``ohnr kt tmn Seykd Andceurgn Mespotkd nxpdkogni te an tmkt tmn

    mespotkd mks rnhngtdy epngni k ugot wotm 3> khutn cnis kgi = `er pnepdn (usukddy lords) wotm nktogl

    ioserinrs (akogdy kgernxok). Vrnvoeusdy, tmn Seykd Andceurgn Mespotkd wks kssehoktni wotm tmn

    geteroeus Seykd Vkrj Vsyhmoktroh Mespotkd, wmohm mks rnhngtdy cnng hdesni kgi pkrtokddy inaedosmni teakjn reea `er k vosotogl ktmdntns kt tmn Heaaegwnkdtm Lkans. Ymn ugsuspnhtogl ktmdntns wodd cn

    meusni eg k sotn wmnrn tmeuskgis e` yeugl Kustrkdokgs mkvn cnng oaprosegni kgi terturni evnr tmn

    ynkrs wotm ndnhtroh smehjs kgi muln iesns e` hmnaohkd texogs. Akgy mkvn ioni, notmnr iurogl tmnor

    trnktangt er smertdy k`tnr ot. Ymnor inktms mkvn ognvotkcdy cnng rnpertni ks suohoin.

    Eg ;.?.??, tmnKlngnwspkpnr og Andceurgn kggeughni og kg krtohdn mnkidogni totdni Hekdotoeg pdnilns$;c `er mnkdtm tmkt, tmn hekdotoegs kggeughnangt hkan ks tmn Eppesotoeg dkughmni ots mnkdtm

    strktnly, preaosogl te spngi kg nxtrk $3>

    aoddoeg te ngsurn tmn Kustog kgi Snpktroktoeg Aniohkd Hngtrn rnakogni og pucdoh mkgis. Ymn Kustog

    kgi Snpktroktoeg Aniohkd Hngtrn mks gnvnr rnkddy cnng og pucdoh mkgis. Vucdoh mespotkds og Kustrkdok

    krn, dojn tmn aniohkd pre`nssoeg lngnrkddy, hegtreddni cy ndotnswme tngi te suppert tmn pmkrakhnutohkd

    ogiustry ks wndd ks tmn aodotkry ogiustry. Ymn Mnoindcnrl Aodotkry mespotkd, wmohm cnhkan tmn

    Mnoindcnrl Snpktroktoeg Mespotkd, wks ogotokddy k Crotosm-Kustrkdokg Aodotkry Mespotkd, wmohm

    heeriogktni aniohkd aodotkry khtovoty iurogl tmn Xnhegi \erdi \kr (og tmn ;?96s). Ymos os tmn mespotkdtmkt heeriogktni tmn akdkrok nxpnroangts eg ogtnrgni Otkdokg kgi Bnwosm rn`ulnns iurogl tmn \\OO, kgi

    trnktni vntnrkgs `er smndd-smehj (dktnr tnrani pest-trkuaktoh strnss ioserinr) k`tnr tmos wkr kgi kdd

    tmn wkrs Kustrkdok mks cnng ogvedvni og soghn tmng. Ymnsn oghduin tmn wkrs og Jernk, Pontgka, Gnw

    Luognk, kgi Akdkyk.

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    70/468

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    71/468

  • 7/23/2019 The Pseudoscience of Schizophrenia by Dr Romesh Senewiratne (2011)

    72/468

    )

    Ymn kutmers ie get snna te rnkdosn mew pnrakgngtdy instruhtovn tmn trkogogl e` yeugl ang og tmos wky

    os ceugi te cn `er seho