the pujol method, the parkening method, and today’s guitarist  · web viewwritten by one of...

44
Francisco Tárrega: The Story of Capricho Árabe By Thanh T. Pham

Upload: danganh

Post on 17-Feb-2019

217 views

Category:

Documents


7 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

Francisco Tárrega:The Story of Capricho Árabe

By Thanh T. Pham

Page 2: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

Copyright 2013 by Thanh T Pham

Smashwords EditionISBN: 9781310972805

Page 3: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

DEDICATION

To my former student Akil Dev, his light was too bright to be burned out so

soon.

Page 4: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

Introduction

Today’s guitar repertory contains centuries of music of various forms

and stories. One particular man from Spain has redefined the modern

guitar as a serious solo instrument by transcribing music from piano,

contributing to the development of technique, composition of music, and

furthering pedagogical studies. His name, Francisco Tárrega (1852-

1909), is synonymous with the Spanish guitar.i If one examines the

music of Tárrega, different influences from Chopin to the folk music of

the Iberian Peninsula utilize and require different performances of

particular aspects of the music. Understanding the history also yields

information to determine an appropriate affect of the piece. I believe

these nuances help bring out the characteristics of and strengthen the

affects of Tárrega’s pieces.

How did Tárrega perform his music? What can be learned from how Tárrega performed his music to enrich his music in performance today? Specifically, I will investigate nuances in articulation such as written and unwritten glissando and portamento. First, I reveal the life of Tárrega and some of his influences on music. Tárrega dedicated himself to teaching the practical and theoretical ideas of the guitar. Looking at the music, I determine the affect and character of the piece. Finally, I examine the pieces in detail to determine a possible performance style to bring out the affect, the attitude, of the piece in order for the listener to understand what Tárrega has experienced. Recordings of popular and influential guitarists are studied. Notably, The Complete Historical Recordings 1913-1942 by Augustín Barrios are studied due to the recordings' proximity of time to Tárrega's lifetime. The Miguel Llobet recordings are also studied for the same purpose but it is also significant that Llobet was one of Tárrega's students. While there cannot be an assumption that Llobet's or Barrios' playing would have the same exact

Page 5: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

characteristics of Tárrega's, their style of performance yields relevant information useful for today's guitarist. The interpretations of Capricho Árabe by Andrés Segovia, Pepe Romero, Narciso Yepes, and Anna Vidovic also are studied. The piece I chose for this study is Tárrega’s Capricho Árabe, which ranks among my favorite pieces of music.

The Age of Tárrega, A Transition Period, The Romantic Period

The music of Berlioz, Chopin, Schumann, Schubert, and other

Romantic composers influenced the music in Tárrega’s life. The

nationalistic music found in many of the Romantic composers also is

evident in Tárrega’s music. When one hears Capricho Árabe or

Recuerdos de la Alhambra, the pictures of Andalusia, with over half a

millennium of Moorish rule and influence, may fill the mind after reading

the idea of the piece. In Spain’s turbulent history, each wave of

civilization exercised new cultural influences. The Romans may have

brought the trumpet and the organ (hydraulis), but the Moors brought the

sunuj al-sufr (metal castanets) and the ud (Arabic lute).ii The Arabic ud is

a short-necked plucked lute and a relative to the guitar.

Before Tárrega, Spain’s growth in the arts were stunted. After the tumultuous century that included the Napoleonic wars, revolutions, coup d’ éstats, and the “anti-Romantic” government of Ferdinand VII, the arts began to recover.iii Fernando Sor’s journey took him to England, Moscow, and Paris, in which city he befriended fellow countryman and guitarist Dionisio Aguado. Sor also taught the Frenchman Napoléon

Coste, whom appeared at Sor’s final concert. iv

In 1874 Tárrega entered the Real Conservatorio in Madrid to study piano and harmony. At this point in history, the guitar was not considered an instrument on the same performance level as the piano in Europe. Tárrega’s father even wanted him to study piano in addition to guitar.v Tárrega’s formal education may have started then, but he was anything but a neophyte to performing. He was a traveling bohemian, going city-

Page 6: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

to-city and tavern-to-tavern. Even as a thirteen-year-old, living in Castellón was too mundane, and so he would head to Valencia for new adventures. To pay for room and board, young Tárrega played the guitar.vi Before Tárrega made it into school (where he still was having difficulties paying for tuition), his mother passed away leaving his father behind. His father had been almost blind since he was thirty-five.vii Even Tárrega himself was conditionally unfit for military service due to his vision damage.viii When Tárrega was three, his babysitter hurled him headfirst into a water-filled ditch, and that incident was the source of his eye problems that plagued him until his death.ix

In addition to the performances of Tárrega, his compositions, and his transcriptions of other composers, he is an important teacher and influence. Spanish guitarists Sor and Aguado befriended one another and most likely were influential in each others' music. Similarly, Tárrega was friends with Spanish composers Isaac Albéniz and Joaquín Turina. The circle of influence also included artists, intellectuals of the era such as Benlliure and Chapi, and many musicians.x Some of these known musicians were guitarists Pujol, Llobet, and Fortea.xi Tárrega also was friends with the pianist and composer Enrique Granados.xii Often Tárrega gave his friends manuscripts as gifts, and they gave him paintings (such as a portrait of his daughter sleeping from Francisco Corell).xiii Tárrega also dedicated Capricho Árabe to Tomás Bretón. It is apparent that there was a true bond between Tárrega and his circle of friends. In 1888 Tárrega was touring Andalusia stopping at Seville and heading to Cádiz when his friend Count Foxá asked him to move to Valencia, which he did.xiv Valencia has a rich Muslim legacy that has spread engineering advancements such as dam construction and irrigation, medicine; including Europe’s first psychiatric hospital, numerous crafts; and industrialization, capital of paper making.xv While living in Valencia, Tárrega’s company included many of the great artists of Spain including painters such as Ignacio Pinazo, Agrassot, and others who would dedicate works to him.xvi Valencia was where Tárrega composed Capricho Árabe. The Muslim, Castilian, and Christian culture in Valencia most likely influenced Tárrega in composing Capricho Árabe.

Affect in Music and the Execution

In instrumental music, the affect must be apparent to the listener in

order to move them. The execution of music draws many parallels to that

of the delivery of an orator. In Johann Joachim Quantz’s 1752 treatise on

Page 7: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

Baroque music instruction, On Playing the Flute, he makes the

comparison with the delivery of an orator and indicates that both orator

and musician to “make themselves masters of the hearts of their

listeners, to arouse or still their passions, and to transport them now in

this sentiment, now to that.”xvii Clearly, Quantz believed that music

needed to move the listener and the responsibility charged to the

performer. In Quantz’s chapter “Of Good Execution in General in Singing

and Playing,” he continued to underline the importance for the execution

to be expressive and appropriate for each affect. For example, in an

Adagio or pieces with this character, the notes must be drawn out so the

listener feels the note’s delicacy.xviii In addition, Quantz continued using

the key as the first indicator of the passion. Intervallic distance and

articulation of the notes are important factors in the indication of the

passion. Quantz goes on to state:

Flattery, melancholy, and tenderness are expressed by slurred and close intervals, gaiety and boldness by brief articulated notes, or those forming distant leaps … Dotted and sustained notes express the serious and the pathetic.xix There is rationale with the thought process of these composers, and I do not believe it is just to make music “beautiful” but to tell a message or an orator. If the music would be properly executed, the listener would be moved emotionally. For Tárrega’s music, his music was often the reflection of his life. He wrote pieces named after his wife and his children. Tárrega’s life was anything but easy. For every success, he experienced many failures. Before he received a formal education at Real Conservatorio, Tárrega had met Count Parcent’s son and negotiated a patronage with formal study and organized concerts only to have all hopes and dreams vanquished with the Count’s passing shortly

Page 8: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

after his installment.xx Then, there were the typical financial difficulties that many musicians (and people in general) face. When the economy of Madrid was strong and Tárrega was a student at Real Conservatorio, José Martínez Toboso, a Valencian guitarist, and he dressed up as blind men playing guitar for money on not only the crowd’s ovation of their music but also their pity … until the police found them.xxi

Drawing from his rich background, it is no wonder how vivid the music is. Accordingly, Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach wrote about how to successfully perform in his Essay on the True Art of Playing Keyboard Instruments, stating, “A musician cannot move others unless he too is moved. The must of necessity feel all of the affects that he hopes to arouse in his audience, for the revealing of his own humor will stimulate a like humor in the listener.”xxii While science has moved past the concept of humors, emotions cannot be overlooked. Execution can be examined as a mere technical quandary or, as Roland Jackson puts it, performance practice is “an attempt to return, inasmuch as this is feasible, to the composer’s original conception of a musical work, and to re-enact how music sounded at the time of its initial presentation.”xxiii

The Affect in Capricho Árabe and the Execution

To have a successful performance of a piece of music, one must

interpret process, internalize, and convey the meaning of the music to

the listener. The musician succeeds in communicating the affect of a

piece when the listener perceives and feels the same affect in the music.

This detail of performance is beyond just playing “little black notes and

rests” and separates the musicians from the dilettantes. A firm

understanding of the history and background of the composer, the setting

of the piece, the rationale of the theory, and most importantly, the overall

affect of the piece are important in creating a successful performance of

music. Treatises by Leopold Mozart, Johann Joachim Quantz, Carl

Philipp Emanuel Bach, and Daniel Gottlob Türk will demonstrate ideas

Page 9: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

that, though not always, are often forgotten or interpreted differently by

many beginning students. Deryck Cooke's The Language Music also has

been very instrumental in understanding the affect of the music for this

essay.

These treatises also offer a pedagogical footprint for musicians to follow but are often missing or emphasized differently from modern guitar methods such as The Christopher Parkening Method: Vol. 1 or Jerry Snyder Guitar School.xxiv Scott Tennant’s best-selling book, Pumping Nylon, strictly has exercises that teach the student how to execute technique. In Guitar School: Theoretical–Practical Method for Guitar written by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are two kinds of technique: one, very apparent, which exhibits skill and gives the impression of executing the music; and the other, firm and true, which in reality actually does execute it.”xxv Pujol adheres to the statement put forth in the introduction by having four books based mostly on technical exercises and their execution with text to help fortify the execution.xxvi

The treatises recognize the need for technical efficiency but also

emphasize moving the listener and being faithful to the intent of the

composer. Daniel Türk best sums up execution and its purpose with the

following statement:

It becomes sufficiently clear from these words that execution must be

of the utmost importance for the musician. For even with all his facility in

reading notes and in playing, he will never attain his main purpose, which

is to move the heart of the listener, without good execution. Whoever

possesses both extraordinarily facility and good execution has attributed

which are not only praiseworthy but also rare.xxvii

In Capricho Árabe Tárrega recalls the turbulent history of Spain with over

Page 10: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

700 years of Arabic rule. In the region of Andalucía, Granada was the last stronghold of the Moorish kings, rules, and army. The Alhambra represents an accumulation of Moorish influenced art, Greek classic education, laws, music, Islam, and culture, to name a few. The infusion of this exotic orientalism also can be found in music and literature. Examples from Tárrega’s contemporaries that use exotic Arabian themes include, Tchaikovsky's ‘Arab dance’ in his Nutcracker Suite; Rimsky-Korsakov’s Scheherazade Op. 35, a symphonic suite; and the guitar work by Paraguayan Augustín Barrios, Danza Arabe. Danza Mora, a miniature by Tárrega, also draws upon the imagery. The affect of Capricho Árabe changes as the piece progresses. Changes are not unusual and are to be expected. In his Principles of Violin method, Leopold Mozart writes, “In practicing every care must be taken to find and to render the affect which the composer wished to have brought out; and as sadness often alternates with joy, each must be

carefully depicted according to its kind.”xxviii The tempo for Capricho Árabe is andantino. For the tonal tensions of joy, Cooke describes adagio as serene, moderato as easy going, and allegro as tumultuous.xxix

He defines tempo as part of the “time dimension” with triple meter more characterized as “relaxes and abandoned.”xxx The introduction sets the mood with the tempo and meter until measure 13, where the meter becomes duple. Cooke best puts the duple meter as a “'wooden, slow march.”xxxi One possible interpretation could be to make the first minor section adagio, which enables the listener to have a reference of the tempo. Then, the performer could move to slightly quicker pace in the major section and multiply the affect of pleasure. A notable difference in character occurs when the key changes from D minor to D major. This transition area has material the performer may wish to bring out.xxxii For the final return of the first theme in D minor, a contrast in tempo would add a dramatic and a somber affect to the music.

Figure 1: Capricho Árabe mm. 1- 4

Page 11: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

The character of the piece changes from its opening bell sound,

without the third and using harmonics, to the main theme with

accompaniment. The transition to the major section reuses similar

material and returns to the first theme in minor. The written syntax for

harmonics on the guitar indicates the name of the string with the

fret/position number next to it but does not always reflect the sound.

Although the harmonic notes spell out a D5, the ear hears that it's A5.

This sets up a large dominant introductory area that will lead to the low D

in measure 13 and take the listener to the first theme.

Given the turbulent history of Spain, the introduction section is

appropriately gloomy and what Deryck Cook, using a Freudian

expression, would label as “pain.”xxxiii While there could be difficulty in the

assumption that “pain,” “sorrow,” or “melancholy” are appropriate affects

for the minor mode half, I believe the usage of the minor also enriches

the Arabic atmosphere beginning with the second measure after the bell-

like harmonics. The slurs add an idiomatic articulation from the fingers

pulling off the strings (all the slurs are descending) leading to the second

scale degree after falling from the high G. The slurs and the idiomatic

tendency for the second note to receive a different attack creates a

descending shape or a “sighing” motive.xxxiv This motive will again return

in the music like in measure 52. A performer could lean or play the first

Page 12: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

note with a slight accent over the second note to accentuate this affect.

Quantz would also reinforce a need for a distinction in the execution of

the first note and the second note.xxxv In addition, Cooke discusses tone

color and texture as “characterizing agents” or the devices that set up the

tensions between each note. xxxvi Cooke’s “characterizing agents” include

the texture of the harmonics contrasted to the slurs for the quick passage

of the minor scale. The volume level of the harmonics acts as an

expressive element similar to bells, whether for war, religion, or the strike

of two o’clock (the second set of bells ring after a repeat of the opening

introduction). The performer can interpret the harmonics by changing the

dynamics. The harmonics return at the end on a D5 bringing the piece to

conclusion.

Anna Vidovic, on her 2000 release of Guitar Recital, plays the opening harmonics at a forte level and plays them at a piano level upon the repeat of the introduction. The repeat is very soft and completely contrasts the opening harmonics and introduction. Pepe Romero played the harmonics the same, but he plays the rest of the introduction an octave lower. One interpretation of this passage could be that danger was in the distance, which is exemplified by the harmonics followed by the higher registered notes. Then, the threat was closer with the same notes played an octave lower upon the repeat. These are two different approaches to interpret the introduction. Another, of course, is to play the introduction the same both ways. Andrés Segovia and Augustín Barrios both play the introduction the same without any embellishments on the repeat.

Page 13: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

Figure 2: Harmonics at the introduction

Figure 3: Complementary harmonics at the end

In addition to the “characterizing agents,” the notes themselves lend

to a meaning. These Cooke shapes such as a descending minor 5-3-1

progression of notes would be used to convey an “incoming painful

emotion … passive suffering.”xxxvii The second measure doesn't neatly fit

into one of Cooke's shapes. Upon closer inspection, the listener will

continue to hear an A Dominant sound through an A Phrygian Dominant/

Phrygian passage. The general interpretation for the Cooke shape is of

descending minor tones creating an incoming sense of pain, since the

first interval is of a minor third on beat one of the second measure.xxxviii

This run ends in measure three with an accented second scale degree,

E, but it never touches the minor third scale degree, F.

Page 14: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

Figure 4: Introduction, mm. 1 – 12

In measure nine Tárrega begins to ascend by thirds on the dominant,

reaches the sixth scale degree, and resolve it down to the fifth scale

degree. Leading into beat two, we encounter one of the key expressions

in this piece that gives the listener its exotic Arabic quality. The

appoggiatura and portamento from A to E is also important from the

affect resembling the Cooke shape arched 5-3-(2)-1, missing the third in

our example. The finger change from 1 to 3 creates a combination of an

appoggiatura by means of a portamento with the principal note struck

again. Cooke notes that this shape “conveys the feeling of a passionate

outburst of painful emotion, which does not further protest, but falls back

into acceptance - a flow and ebb of grief.”xxxix Given the historical context

Page 15: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

of the area, the dramatic, viscous cycles of rule by assassination, the

exile of conquered people, and even the Inquisition, keeping the

portamento intact enhances the affect. The tension here is the usage of

time for the duration of the portamento, a long portamento perhaps for a

very dramatic moment such as a return from the major section or the first

encounter.xl

Segovia plays the appoggiatura by means of a glissando in measure 10, but he plays an appoggiatura by means of a portamento before the fermata in measure 12. Pepe Romero also uses the portamento to stretch the time before the fermata but does not use a glissando or portamento for measure nine. The device of “Appoggiatura by Slide or Glissando” is described in Emilio Pujol's Guitar School: Book II. Pujol writes:This appoggiatura consists of executing the two notes by means of glissando or slide that moves from the first note and finishes on the principal note. When the appoggiatura is short, (of the type known as acciaccatura), the slide should be made more rapidly, emphasizing the pressure on the string while moving to the principal note.xli

Pujol continues with the length of the appoggiatura by stating that it

will get half the value as the principal note without extra pressure. With

this expectation, the Cooke usage of time-tension can enhance the

sense of the affect.

The first occurrence of the appoggiatura and portamento combination

occurs in measure 10 with the principal note ending on the second scale

degree. Scale degree two is emotionally neutral. The second occurrence

happens going into measure 12, but this time the note is held on a half-

note fermata on the flat-six scale degree. According to Cooke, the minor

Page 16: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

sixth conveys a feeling of “active anguish in a context of flux.”xlii The

fermata extends the duration of this moment before it steps down to the

dominant, end the introduction, and begins the transition to the main

theme.

Page 17: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

Figure 5: mm. 13 – 20

The theme at the double bar line begins on the tonic with the

appoggiatura by glissando from the minor third, F to A. Narciso Yepes,

on his album Malaguaña, performs the embellishment going into beat

two in measure 10 as an appoggiatura without thes glissando from A (the

same note that is stopped). Yepes also does not perform the F to A

appoggiatura and glissando in measure 15. Pepe Romero, from his

album Recuerdos de la Alhambra, does not perform the F to A

appoggiatura and glissando in measure 15 but does use it upon the final

journey back to the theme. The return to the minor material is at a

ritardando and thus brings out the affect of the minor third scale degree

with a portamento. As he glides, he tastefully includes chromatic tones

as the music reaches the fifth. The chromatic notes multiply the affect,

Page 18: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

and on the final journey to this Arabic theme there exists only the feeling

of hopelessness.

Figure 6: mm. 21 - 24

The feeling of hopelessness continues, and while there may have

been pockets of protests in the ascending runs in measure 21 and 22,

Tárrega grounds any protest by asserting flat-two scale degree before

returning to the theme. A half step away from the tonic, Cooke describes

the minor second as “spiritless anguish, context of finality.”xliii

Page 19: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

Figure 7: mm. 43 - 61

Measure 43 has a long chromatic passage that imitates a slow

portamento but also has the function of going to the parallel major key of

Page 20: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

D. This scale run is similar to the appoggiatura by means of a glissando

in measure 15 but, given the crescendo, appropriately bridges the affect

to an outgoing and uplifting feeling. A sense of arrival to the new key is

felt due to the tendency tone G-sharp resolving to A, the fifth scale

degree.

The harmony follows with a D major on beat two of measure 45 and a cadence going into measure 46. The general interpretation from recordings I've listened to is to play the run in measures 43 and 44 as a quick ascending scale. The notes are all articulated with the written crescendo. The appoggiatura by means of a glissando returns to the melody in measure 47. While the return of the melody is on the same scale degree, this time it is in D major. This creates a mood of outgoing joy and even the sense of triumph with the glissando multiplying the affect.xliv Then the sense of outward joy is echoed on beat one of measure 48 with the appoggiatura by means of a glissando on C-sharp to E. The major seventh is emotionally neutral but has a “violent longing, aspiration in a context of finality.”xlv In this case, it will overshoot the tonic and land on the second scale degree.In the second half of beat three of measure 48, the sighing motive returns, but, instead of using a slur on the first encounter, the portamento exaggerates the sigh from G-sharp to A and leaping to the C-sharp and slurred down to the B and descending G to E. Cooke describes the sharp four (G-sharp) as “devilish” or “pure and simple.”xlvi From this point, the theme returns with a more embellished runs and goes back to the appoggiatura by means of a glissando in measures 55 and 56. Again, the return of material occurs with the sharp four, but this time the climax is on a fermata in measure 58 on the second scale degree before it drops down to the D to continue to the bridging material for the return of the opening minor theme. The end half of measure 59 has one last appoggiatura by means of a glissando (or portamento) from the tonic up to the fifth. This is the last gasp of outgoing joy before the first theme returns.

Figure 8: mm. 61 – 63

Page 21: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

Upon the return of the first theme in minor, the affect must be set.

The listener can hear there is a transition in measures 61 and 62 going

into minor after the cadence has been set up, only to have the rhythm

continue to march. The listener has been fooled; rather than the

expectation of hope, the story returns to the tragic sound of the first

theme.

The guitarist Pepe Romero uses this transition to squeeze the affect

out of the appoggiatura by means of a portamento (the duration and

rationale is to enhance the sound of the outgoing pain). Romero's

interpretation of the passage does not apply an appoggiatura when he

first encounters the section but saves it for the finale. His interpretation

enhances the affect of the minor theme's return because it is

unexpected.

Figure 9: mm. 23 – 25

Page 22: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

Figure 10: mm. 71 - 73

The ending area from measures 71 to 72 returns to the same “death

march” in measure 23. Tárrega repeats the measure to really emphasize

the gloom. The flat-two creates the hopelessness and when is

understood of its affect leads to the ending harmonics and chords.

Similar, to the introduction, the harmonics are on an open fifth on D but

conclude on a D minor chord.

Segovia plays measures 34 and 35 similarly how he plays it in

measures 23 and 24. He accents the bass line that consists of a tonic,

b6, b2, and 5. When the measure is repeated, he softens the attack on

the bass line and observes the written ritardando.

Conclusion

Tárrega's Capricho Árabe is different than the curious addition of

“exotic” material found in many Romantic composers in the story that it

conveys. The affect of the piece is clear from the introduction to the

ending. This piece tells the story of the battles lasting centuries with the

Arabians, Christians, and the struggle for power and life. It is not clear

Page 23: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

whether the story portrays the Arabic people or the inhabitants of

Valencia, where Tárrega has written the piece. Regardless, the

ornaments such as the appoggiatura by means of a portamento or

glissando are vital to reproducing the affects. The chromatic portamento

multiplies the sensation of the outward pain upon the final return of the

minor theme as musical tension from rhythm, duration, and expectations.

Tárrega used gut strings on his guitar, as today's standard nylon strings were not available until Andrés Segovia pioneered their development.xlvii Often, classical guitarists avoid slide noises and today's bass strings (metal-wound nylon strings) produce a slide noise when a finger slides on them. For Capricho Árabe, most of the slides are on the treble strings and are not metal wound. In addition, the availability of “polished strings” allows less string noise on all the strings. Also, the technique of using the fleshy part of the fretted-hand finger, rather than the tip of the finger, also produces less slide noise. Both Romero and Segovia use this technique when they use a portamento in measure 12. The affect used in the passage by Romero and Segovia is breathtaking.Stanley Yates suggests that guitarists leave these ornaments in to more faithfully produce the sound that Tárrega produces when he was alive.xlviii

Listening to the recordings of Miguel Llobet, I noticed that used glissandi when going from note to note or chord to chord. Llobet's interpretation of Bach's Sarabande in B minor, BWV 1002, entailed many slides connecting chords and idiomatic passages. When Llobet played notes on the same string, he often would use a slide to connect the notes. The recordings of Augustìn Barrios also reveal his usage of glissandi and slides. In my opinion, Barrios used slides in Capricho Árabe too freely. The affect was brought out every time he performed a slide, and after numerous repetitions one may become tiresome of the effect. This was most likely the performance practice of Barrios and Llobet's time.In the performance practice of music, performers can mix the combination of expressions with their own feelings and mix the knowledge and the feeling together by adding the rhythmic nuances and ornaments. They have the magic to “transport the listener back into earlier time periods by invoking the technical and emotional qualities that were present in them.”xlix Andrés Segovia's and Pepe Romero's interpretations are not exactly note-for-note to the score, but they

Page 24: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

enhance the affect by embellishing the music with portamenti, glissandi, and appoggiaturas. Given the rich history of Tárrega and the history of Spain, the affect of the piece must be able to re-tell the story or part of the story and feeling can be lost.

Page 25: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are
Page 26: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

Selected Bibliography

Bach, C. P. E. Essay on the True Art of Keyboard Playing. Translated

and edited by William J. Mitchell. New York: W.W. Norton, 1949.

Barrios, Augustín. Plays his own Compositions and other Works: The Complete Historical Recordings 1913-1942. Chanterelle Verlag, CD CHR 102. and © 2009 by Chanterelle Verlag. (Includes Tárrega's Capricho Árabe and others.)

Clough, Francis F., and G. J. Cuming. The World’s Encyclopædia of Recorded Music. London: City and South London, 1952.

Cooke, Deryck. The Language of Music. 1959. Reprint, New York: Oxford University Press, 2001.

Ferrero, Ángela, and Iago Reigosa. “Spanish Guitar ca. 1800: A New Music for a New Instrument.” In Gitarre und Zister: Bauweise, Spieltechnik und Geschichte bis 1800, edited by Monika Lustig, 223-28. Michaelstein: Blankenburg, 2005.

FSTC Limited. “Muslim Heritage: Valencia.”

http://www.muslimheritage.com.

Hodel, Brian. “Twentieth Century of Music and the Guitar, Part 1: 1900–

1945.” Guitar Review 117 (Summer 1999): 9–15.

Hofmeester, T. M., Jr. “Is There a School of Tárrega?” Guitar Review 1

(Oct. – Nov. 1946): 4–6.

Page 27: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

Jackson, Roland. Performance Practice: A Dictionary-Guide for

Musicians. New York: Routledge, 2005.

Llobet, Miguel. The Guitar Recordings 1925-1929. Chanterelle Verlag,

CD CHR 001. and © 2009 by Chanterelle Verlag. (Includes

Tárrega's Capricho Árabe and others.)

Mangan, John. “Chopin for the Guitar: A Newly Discovered Transcription

by Francisco Tárrega.” Guitar Review 109 (Spring 1997): 1–11.

Mairants, Ivor. “From Gut to Nylon.” Albert Augustine Classical Guitar

Strings. http://albertaugustine.net/history.html.

Mills, John. “A Closer Look: Capricho Árabe by Francisco Tárrega.”

Classical Guitar 20, no. 4 (2001): 22–25.

Mozart, Leopold. A Treatise on the Fundamental Principles of Violin

Playing. Translated by Editha Knocker. London: Oxford University,

1967.

Page 28: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

Pujol, Emilio. Guitar School: A Theoretical-Practical Method for Guitar. 3

vols. 1934. Reprint edited by Mantanya Ophee and translated by

Brian Jeffery with introduction by Manuel de Falla. Columbus:

Editions Orphée, 1983.

Quantz, Johann Joachim. On Playing the Flute. Translated by Edward R.

Reilly. New York: Schirmer Books, 1966.

Rius, Adrián. Francisco Tárrega: 1852–1909, Biography. Valencia,

Spain: Piles, 2006.

Romero, Pepe. Guitar Solos. Philips Classics Productions, CD 434 727-

2. 1982, 1983, 1986, 1992, ©1993 by Philips Classics

Productions. (Includes Tárrega's Capricho Árabe and others.)

Savino, Richard. “Essential Issues in Performance Practices of the

Classical Guitar: 1770–1850.” Chap. 9 in Performance on Lute,

Guitar, and Vihuela: Historic Practice and Modern Interpretation,

edited by Victor Anand Coelho. Cambridge: Cambridge University

Press, 1997.

Page 29: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

Segovia, Andrés. Art of Segovia. Deutsche Grammophon, CD 289 471 697-2. and ©2002 by Deutsche Grammophon. (Includes Tárrega's Capricho Árabe and others.)

Segovia, Andrés. My Favorite Spanish Encores. RCA Records. And ©1974 by RCA Records. (Includes Tárrega's Capricho Árabe and others.)

Sparks, Paul R. “Guitar Performance in the Nineteenth and Twentieth

Centuries.” Performance Practice Review 10 (1997): 71–79.

Summerfield, Maurice. The Classical Guitar: Its Evolution, Players, and

Personalities Since 1800. 5th ed. UK: Ashley Mark, 2002.

Tárrega, Francisco. Capricho Árabe. Edited by S. Vincente. Valencia:

Antich y Tena, 1924.

Türk, Daniel Gottlob. School of Clavier Playing: Instructions in Playing

the Clavier for Teachers and Students. Translation, introduction, and

notes by Raymond H. Haggh. Based on the 1789 ed. Lincoln:

University of Nebraska Press, 1982.

Vidovic, Anna. Guitar Recital. Naxos, 8.554563. And ©2000 by HNH

International. (Includes Tárrega's Capricho Árabe and others.)

Page 30: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

Wade, Graham. Mel Bay Presents: A Concise History of the Classic

Guitar. Pacific, MO: Mel Bay, 2001.

Yates, Stanley, and Graham Wade. Francisco Tárrega: His Life and

Music. 21754DVD. Directed by Brendan McCormack. Pacific, MO:

Mel Bay, 2008.

Yepes, Narciso. Malagueña. Polydor International, 289 469 549-2. and

©1977. (Includes Tárrega's Capricho Árabe and others.)

Page 31: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

i Maurice J. Summerfield, The Classical Guitar: Its Evolution, Players, and Personalities since 1800 (UK: Ashley Mark, 2002), 289–91.ii Oxford Music Online, s.v. “Spain” (by Belen Perez Castillo), http://www.oxfordmusiconline.com/ (accessed Nov 1, 2009).iii Oxford Music Online, s.v. “Spain” (by Castillo), http://www.oxfordmusiconline.com/ (accessed Nov 2, 2009).iv Graham Wade, Mel Bay Presents: A Concise History of the Classical Guitar (Pacific, MO: Mel Bay, 2001), 77–80, 81–83.v Oxford Music Online, s.v. “Tarrega” (by Thomas A. Heck), http://www.oxfordmusiconline.com/ (accessed Nov 2, 2009).vi Adrián Rius, Francisco Tárrega: 1852–1909, Biography (Valencia, Spain: Piles, 2006), 27.vii Rius, 34.viii Rius, 34.ix Rius, 18.x Rius, 25, 66.xi Rius, 25, 66.xii Rius, 25, 66.xiii Rius, 76.xiv Rius, 72-73.xv FSTC Limited, “Muslim Heritage: Valencia,” http://www.muslimheritage.com/ (accessed Nov. 3, 2009).xvi Rius, 73.xvii Johann Joachim Quantz, On Playing the Flute, trans. Edward R. Reilly (New York: Schirmer Books, 1966), 118. xviii Quantz, 124–25.xix Quantz, 125.xx Rius, 28–29.xxi Rius, 43.xxii C. P. E. Bach, Essay on the True Art of Keyboard Playing, trans. and ed. William J. Mitchell (New York: W.W. Norton, 1949), 153.xxiii Roland Jackson, Performance Practice: A Dictionary-Guide for Musicians (New York: Routledge, 2005), ix.xxiv Please note that The Christopher Parkening Method: Vol. 2 does spend a little more time into the meaning and rationale of creating music and Jerry Snyder Guitar School does not only

Page 32: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

cover classical guitar but a few styles of playing.

xxv Emilio Pujol, Guitar School: A Theoretical-Practical Method for Guitar, Book One, 1934, ed. Mantanya Ophee and trans. Brian Jeffery (Columbus: Editions Orphée, 1983), xxiii.xxvi Three of the four books have been translated into English.xxvii Daniel Gottlob Türk, School of Clavier Playing: Instructions in Playing the Clavier for Teachers and Students, trans. Raymond H. Haggh (Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 1982), 322.

xxviii Leopold Mozart, A Treatise on the Fundamental Principles of Violin Playing, trans. Editha Knocker (London: Oxford University, 1967), 218.xxixDeryck Cooke, The Language of Music (1959; Reprint, New York: Oxford University Press, 2001), 97-102.xxx Cooke, 97-102.xxxi Cooke, 97-102.xxxii The chromatic run in measure 43 is discussed further on page 18.xxxiii Cooke, 50-58.xxxiv The note is struck once in the plucking hand and the finger is pulled off on the fretted hand sounding a new note.xxxv Quantz, 123.xxxvi Cooke, 34, 112.xxxvii Cooke, 133.xxxviii Cooke, 133-37.xxxix Cooke, 137-38.xl Cooke, 36–38.xli Pujol, 101.xlii Cooke, 90.xliii Cooke, 90.xliv Cooke, 115-19.xlv Cooke, 90.xlvi Cooke, 90.xlvii Ivor Mairants , “From Gut to Nylon,” Albert Augustine Classical Guitar Strings, http://albertaugustine.net/history.html (accessed December 1, 2009).xlviii Stanley Yates and Graham Wade, “Ornamentation,” Francisco Tárrega: His Life and Music, 21754DVD, dir. Brendan McCormack (Pacific, MO: Mel Bay, 2008).

Page 33: The Pujol Method, The Parkening Method, and Today’s Guitarist  · Web viewwritten by one of Tárrega’s students, Emilio Pujol, he states in the introduction, “… there are

xlix Jackson, x.