the role of technical assistance in lending products for smallholder agriculture
DESCRIPTION
Presentation Fin4Ag S16 by George R. OsureTRANSCRIPT
The Role of Technical Assistance in Lending Products for Smallholder Agriculture
George R. Osure
June 2014
Agenda
1. About SFSA
2. How to make use of Technical Assistance (TA) as a risk mitigation tool plus other benefits to both lenders and farmers.
3. Conveying technical assistance to lenders and farmers as an sharing information service for efficiency.
4. Structure of a Special Purpose Vehicle for Technical Assistance.
5. Conclusion
INPUT MGT PLAN
OUTPUT
MGT PLAN
SERVICES MGT PLAN
3
GOAL: Reach millions of small farmers through scalable, sustainable solutions, raise farmers’ productivity, activate supply chains, increase incomes.
About the SFSA : Where we work
About SFSA: support systems and assets
4
R & D Market-led Extension
Risk Management
Policy Development
Seed Systems Outreach
1. A non-profit organization established by Syngenta under Swiss law.
2. Can access Company expertise but it is legally independent and has its own board.
We will now consider how technical assistance (TA) can support the lending process by reducing cost of transaction, improving accuracy, and mitigating risk.
As an enabler;An agribusiness
environment developer;
It is a virtual trusted broker
who selects and bundles services
to facilitate expansion and
efficiency.
The “go to office” on how to utilize
& leverage on public resource capacity (PPP)
4 benefits from a TA service for agricultural lending
Technical Assistance as an enabler
• Introducing traceability of input-throughput – output linkages
• Improves ease of monitoring QC standards of farmer- lender interaction.
Develops opportunities for both farmer and lender by efficiently
aggregating services required at all levels of
the value chain.
• Access to credit as complex due to the tools required e.g. BP
• Lenders as being only Interested in markets, not production with preference for “town based” operations
• Institutions who work supported by a very harsh legal regime.
Enables farmers by changing mindset (as it
is participatory).
• Uses transparency, accuracy, and timeliness of availability of data as a risk mitigation tool due to availability of predictive nature.
• Relates with suppliers on technology development trends
Integrates information acquisition with risk
management:
TA in the lending business environment
Demonstrates requirements (services support, products, sales, procure products, reduced risk, improve efficiency, through puts) to access credit
High operation costs relate to distribution incurred by lenders can be minimized through use of data availed in a timely manner. This also becomes a basic risk mitigation tool.
The recommended business model for the TA – Farmer- lender is a mix of production & market led systems anchored on joint liability collateral, crop& trade insurance, working thro bundled services for planned aggregated production.
TA and trust between buyer-lender - farmer
Knowledge and personal experience of the farmer e.g.
weather.
Soil health and water quality at the beginning.
Relevant laws related to:
seeds, research, regulatory
institutions, policies,
packaging, and standards.
Annual crop calendars, physical &
geographical location.
The contribution of gross margins
and crop rotation
towards loan repayment.
9
High Quality technical assistance is the virtual trusted broker or glue at the center of the buyer – lender – farmer.
Reports & data TA prepares for an agric. lender
The report should be easy to understand and relate to the
conditions that borrowers (farmers) relate to such as:
Number of farmer groups suitable and available
Labour market available & created to sustain agric prodn
Area cultivated (ha or acres): Revenue/profit/yield generated
and available for loan repayment per unit area.
10
Technical Assistance requires a vehicle to convey the information in a forma, regulated, legally sound in a cost effective manner.
This requires a Special purpose vehicle (SPV) designed for this specific purpose and business environment.
An SPV to provide TA a single or group of lenders
Recommended that for TA to benefit lenders to agriculture we requires a Special Purpose Vehicle (SPV) that can link credit, input suppliers farmers, and buyers.
The SPV is designed to be primarily used as a trusted, legally sound information brokering and exchange platform”.
SPV structure as TA for lender- farmer- buyer
13
A not for profit company whose KPI can be: addditional sales generated for suppliers, work created and incomes generated, additional value of business for the area.
Structured to cover work done between lender and input & services suppliers, buyer, regulator etc.1. The SPV can be financed from transaction costs (loan) reducing insurance/risk costs and hence becomes an virtual risk mitigation tool.
2. Triple bottom line (profit, poverty alleviation, environmental sustainability) becomes an inclusion tool as it will facilitate partnerships with the development community.
14
Board of management
Metrics Support Process/ Farmer financial
management / P&L
Location 1 Location 2 Location 3
Public Enterprise support / Network• Labs• Plant protection services• Agronomy Training
Marketing SupportRegistration of members to SPV
Private Enterprise support / Network• Fertilizer companies• Irrigation firms• Machinery suppliers, etc
External partners & lender loans officers
Production Support • Strong technical focus• Coordination of plans
Private Enterprise support / Network• Loans officers from Lenders
• Implement training • Stewardship (safety) • Tech support• Agro systems
• Market analysis• Market
development• links
• Profitability, • cost analysis, • impact assessment
KPI for the SPV
Location 4
Special purpose vehicle to organize & manage services
Loans officers access information required.
SPV organogram to provide TA & support networks
Conclusion: the SPV as a technical assistant to lenders and farmers
Create a facility which will reduce
transaction costs for lenders by
differentiating individual
smallholders and producer groups.
Share data & knowledge in timely
manner thro’ integration of
different approaches to exploit new
opportunities for lenders and farmers.
This improves efficiency and reduces risk.
Bundle specialized services, technology,
and tools for the smallholder farmers
and hence facilitating access to credit in a
scalable manner.
15
The Role of Technical Assistance in Lending Products for Smallholder Agriculture: THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION
George R. Osure
June 2014
The business model: activities for the pilot year
17
Jan Feb March April May July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec
Register Farmer for
loan, financial &
TA education,
Contracts Signed with lender incl SPV & loan
issued.
Start Prodn & Planting
Harvest & Sales =
loan repayment
Harvest & Sales =
loan repayment
Review of Prodn Season
Farmer org + SPV. Review
Business Plan for SPV +Lender + farmer
org.
Certify farmers &
their scheme