the world bank, tata and enduring abuses on india's tea plantations
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
1/110
!"#$ &'($ "#)*+, -#.*+$ ///0
"#$ 1'(23 4.*56 ".7. .*3 8*39()*+ :;9,$,'*
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
2/110
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
3/110
!"#$ &'($ "#)*+, -#.*+$ ///0
"#$ 1'(23 4.*56 ".7. .*3 8*39()*+ :;9,$,
'*
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
4/110
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
5/110
"
-LM"8M"H
8N8-O":K" F:M":"
?2%8@$"%* %A ,%*+"$"%*# %* 78)*$)$"%*# ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////=B
#$%&%$'()*+, +- .+/*(0 1*%$($/2*%& 3333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333334"
5+67%,&()*+, (,8 9(:%& 3333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333334;
+?$ @/) +- AB"A 33333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333334;
5+670*(,/% C*)2 )2% #=@ 333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333334D
>:K" 9%$. -.9 ?$,'"%-%@ +"%A$%37777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777 FB
1%(0)2 .%$'*/%& 33333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333"J
9(:%& 3333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333""
333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333IA
5(&?(0*K()*+, (,8 9+$L%$ M.2+$)(:%N 3333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333I"
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////DE
@?8*)& 33333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333I;
O%&)$*/)%8 @//%&& 3333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333IB
P,*+,& 333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333;J
>:K"
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
6/110
/////////////////////////////////////////////0B
:K" 0$9 777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777BI
F-;A "G :/$ :0>01$.;$ 7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777BD
333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333AJJ
////////////////////////////////////////////////////
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
7/110
GT%/?)*'% .?66($H ;
8N8-O"
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
8/110
!1)+ 0"%*0( =*58+"+ *' CAAB 6"5#8+" *= (1"
5*..)(."'( (* 5*0%*0#(" +*5)#& 0"+%*'+)6)&)(/
#'- )(+ "'9#9"."'( 2)(1 (1" ,LM7
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
9/110
GT%/?)*'% .?66($H B
"'=*05"-7 Q51*+ &)3" ])09)')8+ #N#4 21* 90"2
8% *' 21#( )+ '*2 #' CAAB %'(#()*'4 -"+50)6"
:#+( 9#%+ )' 5*.%&)#'5"4 .#'/ *= 21)51 1#:"
*'&/ 90*2' "0 *:"0 ()."7
'*';5*.%&)#'5" 2)(1 (1" ABC7 P)%)-#("-
#'- *:"050*2-"- 1*8+"+ #0" 5*..*'4 #+
."-)5#& =#5)&)()"+4 #'- #6#'-*'"- 50Z51"+7
Q*." *= (1" .*+( -#.')'9 ":)-"'5" #6*8( (1"
).%&"."'(#()*' *= (1" ABC4 1*2":"04 5*."+
68( =0*. 9*:"0'."'(#& +80:"/+ *= (1" +"5(*07
A0"+8.#6&/4 #=("0 OJ /"#0+ *= 98#0#'(""- 1"#&(1
5#0"4 1*8+)'94 +#')(#()*' #'- =**- +8%%*0( )' #
+(#6&" %*%8()*'4 +*5)#& )'-)5#(*0+ +1*8&- 6"
%*+)():"7 8+( -"-85()*'+ =0*. 2*03"0+G %#/51"53+7 L*0
.*+( >*6+ *' (1" %'(#()*'+4 (1"0" #0" @8*(#+
2#9"a 2*03"0+ 21* =#)& (* .""( (1)+ @8*(# =#5"%#/ -"-85()*'+ *= 8% (* 1#&= (1" -#/G+ 2#9"+7
L0*. IJJU (* IJTY4 (1" @8*(# =*0 %&853)'9
("#;&"#=4 21)51 )+ +"( 6/ ".%&*/"0+ #50*++ (1"
0"9)*'4 1#+ )'50"#+"- 6/ VJb7 !1"0" 1#+ 6""'
'* 5*00"+%*'-)'9 ).%0*:"."'( )' ("51'*&*9/
(* "'#6&" 2*03"0+ (* %)53 =#+("0? 2*03"0+ .8+(
%)53 #+ (1"/ 1#:" #&2#/+ -*'"4 6/ 1#'- *0 2)(1
+1"#0+7 !1" (#+3 0#("+ =*0 %08')'9 (1" ("# 68+1"+4
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
10/110
)'50"#+"- #( CAAB 2)(1*8( #'/ "N%'#()*'7 c'
.#'/ %'(#()*'+4 2*03"0+ +#)- (1#( (1"/ 2"0"
'* &*'9"0 #6&" (* 5*.%&"(" (1" (#+3 *' (1")0
*2'4 #'- 1#- (* (#3" *' 1"&%"0+ 21*. (1"/
5*.%"'+#("- *8( *= (1")0 *2' %*53"(+7
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
11/110
GT%/?)*'% .?66($H AA
)' K"+( *0 =#5(*0 "'#6&)'9
(1". (* "N"05)+" 5*'(0*& *:"0 2*03"0+7
"J8 "K:MH>F
!1" (0#'+)()*' =0*. !#(# (* CAAB 2#+ %0".)+"-
=*0 # .*0" +8+(#)'#6&" %'(#()*' .*-"&7 M"'(0#&
"&"."'(+ *= (1" %' )'5&8-"- (1" +#&" *= 8% (* YJb
+1#0"+ 2*8&- 9* (* +(#== #'- .#'#9"."'(4 (1"
50"-)6)&)(/ *= (1" %' 0"@8)0"- (1#( 2*03"0+ #&+*68/ )'7 !1" ,LM (0"#("- (1" +#&" *= +1#0"+ (* 2*03"0+
#+ # 50)()5#& ="#(80" *= )(+ -"5)+)*' (* )':"+(7
K1#(":"0 (1" ."0)(+ *= (1" %'4 )(+ ).%&"."'(#()*'
1#+ 6""' "N(0"."&/ %0*6&".#()57 C=("0 -"+8&(*0/
%#/51"53 -"-85()*'+ S =*0 (1" %8051#+" *=
+1#0"+4 .#'#9"."'( 9#:" 8% "N%)')'9 #'/(1)'9
(* 2*03"0+4 #'- +).%&/ +"( #6*8( 5*':)'5)'9
(1". (* 68/7 K*03"0+ 4*4 68/4 )' 0"():"&/
" '8.6"0+4 .#03)'9 (1")0 (18.6 %0)'(+ *'
"&/ )'5*.%0"1"'+)6&" -*58."'(+ 20)(("'
)' `'9&)+17 !1" 5*.%#'/ #'- (1" ,LM (0"#("-
(1" 1)91 +86+50)%()*' 0#("+ #+ *%3# 5-6)# %0**= *=
9**- 5*..8')5#()*' #'- 2*03"0 "'(18+)#+.
=*0 (1" +51"."7
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
12/110
d*24 .*0" (1#' (10"" /"#0+ #=("0 CAAB 2*03"0+
+)9'"- *' (* (1" +1#0" %'4 (1"0" )+ +()&&
2)-"+%0"#- 5*'=8+)*' #.*'9 (1". #6*8( 21#(
(1" +1#0"+ 0"%0"+"'(4 #'- 21#( (1")0 0)91(+ .#/
6" #+ +1#0"1*&-"0+7 !1" 5*.%#'/ 1#+ 8(("0&/
=#)&"- (* 5*..8')5#(" 2)(1 (1)+ +86+"( *= )(+
+1#0"1*&-"0+? #50*++ (1" CAAB %'(#()*'+42*03"0+ +(#("- 5#("9*0)5#&&/ (1#( (1"0" 1#- 6""'
'* .""()'9 5#&&"- *0 '"2+&"(("0 -)+(0)68("-
(1" 5*.%#'/ +)'5" (1"/ +)9'"- 8% =*0 +1#0"+7
!1"/ 1#:" '*( ":"' 6""' %0*:)-"- #55"++ (* (1"
5*.%#'/G+ #''8#& 0"%*0(+4 21)51 )' #'/ ":"'(
#0" '*( %86&)5 -*58."'(+ #'- #0" *'&/ )' `'9&)+17
L0*. # %80"&/ "5*'*.)5 %"0+%"5():"4 (1"
6"'"=)(+ (* (1" 2*03"0+ #0" 8'5"0(#)'4 -"+%)("
(1" *%().)+()5 5).+ *= CAAB #'- (1" ,LM7 d*2(1#( %#/51"53 -"-85()*'+ 1#:" 6"98'4 2*03"0+
#0" &*+)'9 #' #--)()*'#& O;eb *= (1")0 ."#9"0
2#9"+ "#51 %#/ %"0)*-7 L*0 =*80 /"#0+4 2*03"0+
#0" &*53"- )'4 #'- -80)'9 (1)+ ()."4 (1" :#&8"
*= (1" )':"+(."'( )+ 98#0#'(""-4 #&*'9 2)(1 #
0#(" *= Ob )'("0"+(7 C&(1*891 (1" )'("0"+( 0#("
)+ 1)91 6/ 2"+("0' +(#'-#0-+4 )( 6#0"&/ (0#53+
)'=()*' )' ,'-)#4 21"0" 5*.."05)#& )'("0"+(
0#("+ #0" 5800"'(&/ .*0" (1#' \Jb 1)91"04 *'
&*'9;("0. +#:)'9+ #55*8'(+7 C=("0 =*80 /"#0+4
2*03"0+G +1#0"+ :"+(4 #'- (1" :#&8" *= (1"
)':"+(."'( 2)&& 0)+" *0 =#&& 6#+"- *' .#03"(
5*'-)()*'+7 ,' *(1"0 2*0-+4 8'-"0%#)- 2*03"0+
=#5" (1" 0)+3 *= (1" .#03"( 2)(1*8( *(1"0
6"'"=)(+ *= +1#0" *2'"0+1)%7
(1" %"0:"0+" 5*'+"@8"'5" *= -)+%*++"++)'9
2*03"0+ *= #90)58&(80#& '- (1"/ 1#- 58&():#("-
=*0 9"'"0#()*'+7 CAAB #''*8'5"- )' IJTJ (1#(
2)(1)' (1" %'(#()*' #0"#7 X*2":"04 2*03"0
)'("0:)"2+ 0":"#&"- (1#( (1" %&*(+ *= '- )'
@8"+()*' 1#- #5(8#&&/ 6""' #&&*5#("- (* 2*03"0+G=#.)&)"+ )' 5*&*')#& ()."+ =*0 (1" 58&():#()*' *=
+86+)+("'5" 50*%+7 !1)+ '- 1#- 6""' *=="0"-
#+ %#0( *= (1" 5*.%"'+#()*' %#53#9" (* )'-85"
2*03"0+ (* 8%0**( (1")0 =#.)&)"+ #'- .*:" (*
(1" %'(#()*'+7 CAAB .#'#9"."'( 5)."-
0#(" =*0 2*03"0+4 #'- '* '"2 %"0.#'"'( >*6+7
"J8 KLF8 :MU K8H>LMH"5(7 ,' *(1"0 2*0-+4 CAAB :*&8'(#0)&/
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
13/110
GT%/?)*'% .?66($H AE
+8%%&"."'("- )(+ +(#(8(*0/ *6&)9#()*'+ 8'-"0
(1" ABC 2)(1 #--)()*'#& 5*'(0#5(8#& *6&)9#()*'+
(* (1" K*0&- "5( )' IJTI4 '*("- +*." *=
(1" %0*6&".+ 21)51 #%%0*%0)#(" -8" -)&)9"'5"
2*8&- 1#:" "N%*+"-4 #'- 0#)+"- +"0)*8+
K)(1 0"9#0- (* (1" +1#0" %'4 (1" ,LMG+ 0*&"
1#+ 6""' %#0()58&/ %0*6&".#()57 ,' "#0&/
%0*>"5( -*58."'(+4 (1" ,LM %0*%*+"- (* %/
*= +1#0"+7 !1)+ 2*8&- 1#:" 6""' #' "N(0"."&/
:#&8#6&" 0*&" =*0 )( (* %/4 9):"' (1" %*2"0
-/'#.)5+ #( 2*03 *' (1" %'(#()*'+4 #'- (1"
)'=*0."- 5*'+"'( (10*891 (1" %0*5"++7 !1"
0*&" =*0 ".%&*/""+ )' 5*0%*0#(" 9*:"0'#'5"7
!1" ,LM %0*%*+"- (1#( )( 2*8&- 1"&% -":"&*%
#--0"++ (1)+7 "5(7 !1" ,LM 1#+ -"5&)'"- (* "N"05)+" )(+
*%()*' (* #%%*)'( # .".6"0 (* (1" CAAB 6*#0-4
#'- 1#+ 0"+%*'-"- -"="'+):"&/ (* 0"%*0(+ *=
%0*6&".+ =0*. # 2)-" 0#'9" *= +*805"+7
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
14/110
.#'#9"."'(4 #'- #0"4 (* #&& #%%"#0#'5"+4 .*0"
%0*("5():" *= .#'#9"."'(G+ )'("0"+(+ (1#' (1*+"
*= 2*03"0+7 C8-)(+ #0" +51"-8&"- )' #-:#'5"
2)(1 .#'#9"."'(4 #&&*2)'9 =#5)&)()"+ (* 6"
+%085"- 8%7 !1" :)+)(+ #0" +86+"@8"'(&/ 5#0"=8&&/
51*0"*90#%1"- 6/ .#'#9"."'(4 "N5&8-)'9 (1"
8'+8%"0:)+"- 2*03"0 )'("0:)"2+7
C+ (1" 0"%*0( +899"+(+4 (1" %0*&)="0#()*' *= '"2
+(#'-#0-+4 21)&" *=="0)'9 (1" %0*.)+" *= .8&()%&"
#:"'8"+ =*0 #51)":)'9 +*5)#& 0"+%*'+)6)&)(/
9*#&+4 +"".+4 #( &"#+( )' (1)+ 5#+"4 (* +"0:" #+ #
-):"0+)*'7 !1" %0):#(" +(#'-#0-+ %0*:)-" (1"
).%0"++)*' *= 5*.%&)#'5" 2)(1 *0 +(#'-#0-+4
HO&&:KQ -LM-FOH? -/$*,- &( )(*+,*- &/*(:4/
.,2,"&'(% $%. 2(,*2'(%7 !1" %'(#()*'+
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
15/110
GT%/?)*'% .?66($H A"
.8+( #5( ).."-)#("&/ (* "'#6&" 2*03"0+
(* *%(;*8( *= (1" +1#0" *2'"0+1)% +51"."4
#'- 0"(80' (* (1" +(#(8+ @8* #'("7 L#)&)'9 #
."#')'9=8& *%( *8( ."51#')+.4 CAAB .8+(
(* # +1#0" 90#'(4 0"=8'-)'9 #&& %#/51"53
-"-85()*'+ (* -#(" #'- 5"#+)'9 #'/ =80(1"0-"-85()*'+4 9):"' (1#( .*+( 2*03"0+ #0" )&&
#6&" (* #==*0- (1".7
"5():" #'-
(0#'+%#0"'( 0":)"2 *= 5*.%&)#'5"4 #'- # 5&"#0
()."(#6&" =*0 ).%&"."'()'9 +*&8()*'+7
_#'/ :)*()*'+ #++*5)#("- 2)(1 (1" +1#0"
*2'"0+1)% %' 2)&& #&+* 0"@8)0" &*'9"0;
("0. 0"."-)"+7 K*03"0 %#0()5)%#()*' )' (1"9*:"0'#'5" *= CAAB4 (10*891 %0*%*0()*'#&
0"%0"+"'(#()*' *' (1"
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
16/110
>K8S:-8
C.#&9#.#("- A'(#()*'+ A0):#(" B(- DCAABE
)+ (1" +"5*'- "+( %0*-85"0 *= ("# )' ,'-)#421)514 )' (80'4 )+ (1" 2*0&-G+ "+( %0*-85"0
#'- 5*'+8."0 *= 65 ("#7 CAAB *%"0#("+ IV
%'(#()*'+ 2)(1 '"#0&/ YT4JJJ =8&& ()." 2*03"0+
)' C++#. #'- (1" P**#0+4 (1" 0"9)*' *= K"+(
"5( )+ #&+* #' "N%"0)."'( )' # 3)'- *=
0"+(085(80)'9 (1#( )+ =#.)&)#0 )' .#'8=#5(80)'94
68( 0"():"&/ '"2 )' #90)58&(80"? !#(# !"# 2#+
# :"0()5#&&/;)'("90#("- "'("0%0)+"4 68( .#-" (1"
-"5)+)*' (* -)++*5)#(" )(+"&= =0*. (1" %0*-85()*'
+)-" *= )(+ 68+)'"++7 Q).) 51#'9"+ *55800"-
*:"0 (1" %#+( -"5#-"+ )' 5*'+8."0 9**-+ #'-
#%%#0"& 21"' 60#'-+ -):"+("- (1".+"&:"+ *=
=#5(*0)"+7 !1" '"2 5*0%*0#(" "'()(/4 !#(# F&*6#&
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
17/110
#$%-(/% A;
(1" ("# %'(#()*'+ )+ 8'5"0(#)'7 !#(#G+ -"5)+)*'
(* 2)(1-0#2 =0*. %'(#()*' *%"0#()*'+ 5#."
#9#)'+( # 6#53-0*% *= # %0"5)%)(*8+ -0*% )'
%0*-85"0 %0)5"+ =*0 %0*5"++"- &"#=4 21)51 &"-
(* (1" 5&*+80" *= %'(#()*'+ #'- (1" +(#0:#()*'
-"#(1+ *= 2*03"0+ #'- (1")0 =#.)&)"+7 !1" 6)99"+(
*2'"0 *= %'(#()*'+ )' ,'-)# #( (1#( ()."4
!1*891 (1" ).."-)#(" 50)+)+ )+ %#+(4 "5*'*.)5
5*'-)()*'+ 0".#)' %0"5#0)*8+4 2)(1 .#'/
%'(#()*'+ +""3)'9 2#/+ (* 0"-85" (1")0
"N%"'-)(80"+7 !1" 5*'-)()*'+ #0" "N#5"06#("-
6/ )'-8+(0)#& 8'0"+(4 21"0" ".%&*/"0+ #0"
@8)53 (* 0"+%*'- 6/ -"5)'9 &*53*8(+ *=
2*03"0+7 K)(1 "#51 +851 5&*+80"4 2*03"0+ #0"
-"%0):"- '*( *'&/ *= 2#9"+4 68( #&+* *= =**-
0#()*'+ #'- ."-)5#& 5#0"7 ,' &)91( *= %0"++80"+*' '- 8+"4 2*03"0+G =08+(0#()*'+ 2)(1 2#9"+
#'- 5*'-)()*'+4 #'- (1" 5/5&)5#& :*()&)(/ *=
%0*-85"0 %0)5"+4 (1" &*'9;("0. +8+(#)'#6)&)(/ *=
(1" %'(#()*' .*-"& )+ '*( 5&"#07
L*0 (1" '"#0&/ YT4JJJ %"0.#'"'( 2*03"0+
*= CAAB #'- (1")0 =#.)&)"+4 #'- (1" ("'+ *=
(1*8+#'-+ *= (".%*0#0/ 2*03"0+ "@8#&&/
-"%"'-"'( *' (1" CAAB %'(#()*'+4 (1" +(#3"+
#0" "N(0#*0-)'#0)&/ 1)917
!1)+ 5#+" +(8-/ )+ #--0"++"- (* (1*+" 21* 2*032)(1 *0 +(8-/ (1" ("# +"5(*04 #+ 2"&& #+ (1*+"
"'9#9"- 2)(1 (1" 60*#-"0 )++8"+ *= #90)58&(80#&
*04 %86&)5 )':"+(."'( )' %0):#(" )'-8+(0/4
#'- 21#( )+ +*."()."+ 0"="00"- (* #+ 5*0%*0#("
+*5)#& 0"+%*'+)6)&)(/7 ,' %#0()58 2" 1#:" )'
.)'- %0):#(" #'- %86&)5 )':"+(*0+4 #-:*5#5/
*09#')H#()*'+4 #'- (0#-" 8')*'+4 #&& *= 21*.
)' (1" 5*80+" *= (1" 0"+"#0517 K)(1)' (1#( 90*8%4
2" #0" "+%"5)#&&/ 5*'5"0'"- #6*8( (1" ,LM #'- (1"
*09#')H#()*'+ (1#( .*')(*0 #'- 5"0()=/ 5*0%*0#("
+*5)#& %0#5()5"+7 !1" 0"%*0( )+ #&+* #--0"++"-
-)0"5(&/ (* (1" !#(# F0*8%4 # +"( *= 5*.%#')"+2)(1 # %0*=*8'- )':"+(."'( )' 6*(1 (1" "5*'*.)5
#'- (1" +*5)#& -":"&*%."'( *= ,'-)#7
!1" 5#+" +(8-/ #++"++"+ !#(#G+ CAAB )')()#():"
#9#)'+( (1" =0#."2*03 *= ,'-)#' #'- (1"
#--)()*'#& /"0 *= %0):#(" +(#'-#0-+ "+%*8+"-
6/ (1" 5*.%#'/4 %#0()58&/ (1" +(#'-#0-+ *=
(1" ,LM #'- Q*5)#& C55*8'(#6)&)(/ ,'("0'#()*'#&7
C+ # %0):#(" 5*.%#'/ 2)(1 #' "N%#'+):" 01"(*0)5
#'- 0"%8(#()*' *= +*5)#& #55*8'(#6)&)(/4 #'-
*'" .*0"*:"0 (1#( 1#+ 51*+"' (* )'=8+" )(+)':"+(."'( 2)(1 %86&)5 %80%*+" 6/ %#0('"0)'9
2)(1 (1" K*0&-
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
18/110
&8"JLULFLVQ
!1)+ 0"%*0( 2#+ 8'-"0(#3"' 6/ (1" X8.#'
W)91(+ ,'+()(8(" *= M*&8.6)# B#2 Q51**&4 8+)'9-)+50"()*'#0/ 0"+"#051 =8'-+ #'- +(8-"'(
+8%%*0( =0*. M*&8.6)#G+ X8.#' W)91(+ M&)')57
,( 2#+ -)0"5("- 6/ A0*="++*0 A"("0 W*+"'6&8. )'
%#0('"0+1)% 2)(1 C+12)') Q83(1#'3#04 # /"0
6#+"- )' d"2 h*03 M)(/4 #'- Q#0.)+1(1# "5(? C.#'-#
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
19/110
U%)2+8+0+:H AB
K*03"0 )'("0:)"2+ 2"0" 5*'-85("- %0).#0)&/ )'
(1" &):)'9 #0"# *= (1" %'(#()*'+4 3'*2' #+ (1"
)'-"%"'-"'5" =*0 2*03"0 )'("0:)"2+4 2" -)-
'*( )'=*0. .#'#9"."'( 6"=*0" "'("0)'9 (1"
B#6*80 C5( )' C++#. #'- K"+( #' #'- C51#6#.4 #( (1")0
)')()#():"7 ,' K#+1)'9(*' P7M74 (1" 0"+"#051"0+
+%*3" 2)(1 ,LM +(#== #'- +(#== *= (1" M*.%&)#'5"
C-:)+*0fc.68-+.#' DMCcE4 (1" ,LMG+ )'("0'#&
6*-/ =*0 1#'-&)'9 5*.%)'(+ =0*. 5*..8')()"+
#=="5("- 6/ ,LM %0*>"5(+7 K" #0" 90#("=8& =*0 (1")0
5**%"0#()*' )' (1)+ 0"%*0(7
!1" 0"+"#051"0+ 1#:" )'("0:)"2"- #'- 5*'+8&("-
2)-"&/ 2)(1 *09#')H#()*'+ #'- )'-):)-8#&+4 6*(1
&*5#& #'- )'("0'#()*'#&4 )'5&8-)'9 (0#-" 8')*'+4
+(8-"'( *09#')H#()*'+4 2*."'G+ 90*8%+4 %*&)()5#&
%#0()"+4 #'- #5#-".)5+7 _#'/ #0" '*( '#."-
)' (1)+ 0"%*0(4 #( (1")0 0"@8"+(7 c80 "==*0(+ (*
0"#51 ".%&*/"0+G *09#')H#()*'+4 %#0()58&/
(1" C++#. #'- P**#0+ 60#'51"+ *= (1" ,'-)#'
!"# C++*5)#()*'4 2"0" 8'+855"++=8&7 Q*."
*== (1" 0"5*0-4 21)&" (1" .#>*0)(/ -)- '*(
0"+%*'- (* 0"@8"+(+ =*0 # .""()'97 F*:"0'."'(
+(#== #( (1" d#()*'#& W80#& X"#&(1 _)++)*' #'-
(1" ,'-)#' M*8'5)& =*0 _"-)5#& W"+"#051 2"0"
9"'"0*8+ 2)(1 (1")0 ()." #'- "N%"0()+"7
K" #0" "+%"5)#&&/ #2#0" *= (1" -"6( *2"- (*
(1" 2*03"0+ #( CAAB4 18'-0"-+ *= 21*. 2"0"
2)&&)'9 (* %#0()5)%#(" )' *%"';"'-"- )'("0:)"2+
#6*8( (1")0 &):"+ 2)(1*8( #'/ "N%"5(#()*' *=
5*.%"'+#()*' *0 0"-0"++7
d*("? !1" 0"%*0( =0"@8"'(&/ 0"="0"'5"+ *0
@8*("+ .*'"(#0/ #.*8'(+ )' ,'-)#' 08%""+ D!E4
0"+"#051 #'- +*4 =*0 (1" +#3" *= 5*'+)+("'5/4 2"
1#:" 8+"- #' #%%0*N).#(" ."-)#' "N51#'9"
0#(" *= !
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
20/110
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
21/110
>:K" *0 51#'9" =*0 %'("0+4 21*
1"#:)&/ 0"+(0)5("- 2*03"0+G .*6)&)(/ 2)(1)' (1"
%'(#()*'4 #+ 2"&& #+ #&& "'(0/ #'- "N)(7I[
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
28/110
#'- +"2#9" (0"#(."'(4 %86&)5 "-85#()*'4 #'-
1*8+)'9 +86+)-)"+ =*0 %**0 #'- .#09)'#&)H"-
5*..8')()"+7YI !* (1)+ "N("'(4 ":"' 21"0"
(1" "N%"'+"+ #0" 0"#&4 5*.%#')"+ #0" ."0"&/
0"%)'9 "N%"'-)(80" (1#( )+ (1" 0"+%*'+)6)&)(/
*= (1" 9*:"0'."'(4 0#(1"0 (1#' 9*)'9 6"/*'-7
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
29/110
(1#( (1" +)(8#()*' 1#- '*( ).%0*:"-7 C55*0-)'9 (*
1).4 (1"0" 1#+ '*( 6""' # +"0)*8+ "==*0(4 6/ ")(1"0
".%&*/"0+ *0 (1" +(#("4 (* ).%0*:" 5*.%&)#'5"
2)(1 (1" ABC +)'5" (1" T[OJ+7VJ
`:"' (1" 9*:"0'."'(G+ :"0/ &).)("- %86&)5
+(#()+()5+ *' ABC 5*.%&)#'5" 1)'( #( (1" +5#&" *=
(1" :)*()*'+7 L*0 IJJe4 (1" 0"%*0( )'-)5#("+ (1#(
%'(#()*'+ )' K"+(
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
30/110
\[7[b *= %0"+51**& 51)&-0"' 2"0" 8'-"02")91(4
#+ 2"0" UY7Tb *= 2*."' #'- O\7Ub *= ."'7
C'".)# 2#+ #( '"#0&/ UIb7 C( (1" ()." *= (1"
+80:"/4 )' IJJO4 '"#0&/ TYb *= 51)&-0"' 8'-"0
!1" %0":#&"'5" *= (86"058&*+)+ 2#+ 1)91"0 (1#'
(1" *:"0#&& %0":#&"'5" )' C++#.7VV
W"5"'( +(8-)"+ +1*2 0"+8&(+ (1#( #0" #+ 6#-4 *0
2*0+"7 C IJTY +(8-/ *= %"0.#'"'( ("# %'(#()*'
2*03"0+ )' P)6089#01 +1*2"- "N(0#*0-)'#0)&/
&*2 )'-)5#(*0+ =*0 1"#&(14 '8(0)()*' #'-
"-85#()*'7 !1" #:"0#9" 5#&*0)5 )'(#3" =*0 ."'
"'9#9"- )' 1#0- %1/+)5#& *0 2#+ \Jb *= (1"
0"5*.."'-"- #.*8'(4 #'- =*0 2*."'4 OOb7V\
C55*0-)'9 (* (1)+ +(8-/4 [O7Tb *= (1*+" +80:"/"-
-"="5#("- )' (1" *%"' #)04 #'- '"#0&/ TJJb 2"0"
=8'5()*'#&&/ )&&)("0#("7VO
!* -)+%"& #'/ +"'+" (1#((1" 5*'-)()*'+ 2"0" 0".#03#6&"4 (1" %0).#0/
0"+"#051"0 '*("- (1#( +1" 1#- :)+)("- *:"0 TJJ
%'(#()*'+ #( (1" ()." *= 20)()'94 #'- (1#( (1"
+)(8#()*' 2#+ +).) ":"0/21"0"7VU
d*( +80%0)+)'9&/4 9):"' (1" %0*6&".+ (10*891*8(
(1" +"5(*04 (1" 9#%+ )' 5*.%&)#'5" 2)(1 (1" ABC
#( CAAB %'(#()*'+ #0" *6:)*8+ #'- 2)-"+%0"#-4
'*(2)(1+(#'-)'9 CAAB 5).+ S #'- (1" +(#0(&)'9
:)*()*'+ #0" -*58."'("- 6"&*24 )' -"(#)&7
VV F7R7 _"-1) "( #&74 R)$4G #5 .(-1)/ :"#=1('3 -+4 8$)"*)*#+-1 R)-)$3 #5 ?(- !-"4(+ :#%$1-)*#+ #5 933-'4 ,'-)#' j7 _"-7 Q5)74 P"57 IJJO4 #(
\JJ7
V\ !7 _#1#'(# "( #&74 U55(6) #5 ]*"(6)1G ^=3("H(4 @"#+ ?/("-%G *+ 9+-('*- -+4 :"#4$6)*H*)G _ 9 B#''$+*)G L-3(4 @+)("H(+)*#+ R)$4G *+
]*="$,-"/< 933-'4 ,'-)#' j7 *= C%%&)"- W"+74 C%07 IJTY4 #( IV7
VO @47 #( IY7 ,' (1" IJJO +80:"/4 0"+"#051"0+ =*8'- O\b )&&)("0#5/ #'- -"("0.)'"- (1#( OYb *= )'-):)-8#&+ 1#- #55"++ (* # 1*8+"1*&- (*)&"(a
(1"/ -)-'G( ":#&8#(" (1" @8#&)(/ *0 #5(8#& 8+" *= (1" (*)&"(+7 _"-1)4 3$%"-'*(" VV4 #( V[[7
VU `.#)& "N51#'9" 2)(1 %0).#0/ #8(1*04 _#/ TY4 IJTY7
9 2#"0(" -) Q$+,-'$))(( U3)-)( K+#2 4(6(-3(4P 4(36"*=(3
)/( "(6"$*)'(+) %"#6(33 -+4 )/( 2((0C1#+, T#$"+(G 5"#'
B/#)-+-,%$" )/-) ="#$,/) /*' )# )/( %1-+)-)*#+ *+ OX``7
B#+4*)*#+3 2("( /-"3/< =$) /( 2-3 4"-2+ =G *+6(+)*H(3#' !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ TI4 IJTIa M1862# !"# +(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ TT4 IJTI7
eU ,'("0:)"2 2)(1 F#8(#.
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
42/110
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
43/110
4%&5- H@#$ +&)W W)$-& A&%H W-88# ) A-W
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
44/110
2#("0 *0 (1" -"#0(1 *= %8.%+ #'- (#%+ #:#)&" )'
(1" *0 &)'"+7 C.*'9 (1" "N#.%&"+?
C( #'4 2*03"0+ +1*2"- 8+ 1*8+"+ 2)(1
'* ."#')'9=8& #55"++ (* 5*.%#'/;%0*:)-"-
2#("0 (#%+a (1"+" 1*8+"+ #0" "'()0"&/ 0"&)#'(
*' 2"&&+ (1#( (1"/ -)9 (1".+"&:"+4 #'- #( (1")0
*2' "N%"'+"7 c'" 2*.#' (*&- 8+ (1#( )' (1"-0/ +"#+*'4 +1" +*."()."+ 1#+ (* 2*03 (1"
2"&& =*0 #' 1*80 #'- # 1#&= (* +"580" "'*891
2#("0 =*0 (1" -#/G+ '""-+7[J
L*0 .*+( *= (1" 2*03"0+ #( d#1*0#') "+(#("4
(1"0" 2#+ '* 5*.%#'/;%0*:)-"- #55"++ (*
2#("07 X*8+"1*&-+ 1#:" 1#- (* 68)&- (1")0
*2' (86";2"&&+4 #( (1")0 *2' "N%"'+"7[T
C( P#. P).4 21"0" (1" 2#("0 (#%+ S (10""
=*0 ":"0/ &)'" *= IJ 1*8+"+ S 2"0" +2)(51"-
*' >8+( (10"" ()."+ # -#/ =*0 1#&= #' 1*804
2*03"0+ #&&"9"- (1#( (1" 2#("0 2#+ %8.%"-
-)0"5(&/ =0*. (1" 0):"0 2)(1*8( (0"#(."'(7
!1"/ 6"&)":"- (1#( (1" 2#("0 +8%%&/ 2#+
0"+%*'+)6&" =*0 (1" 1)91 )'5)-"'5" *=
-/+"'("0/ *' (1" "+(#("7[I
Q).)&/4 2*03"0+ 0"%*0("-4 )' *'" %*0()*'
*= W8'9#.8(("" "+(#(" S B)'" IV S (1#( (1"
2#("0 2#+ %8.%"- -)0"5(&/ =0*. (1" 0):"07
TJ .*'(1+4 #( &"#+( +":"' (* ")91( %"*%&"
[Y
C( d#1*038()#4 2*03"0+ 5*.%)'"- #6*8(
=0"@8"'( -"#(1+ =0*. 2#("0;6*0'" -)+"#+"+
1#:" 6""' +* .#'/ -"#(1+ =0*. 51*&"0# (1#(
[V
K*03"0+ #( +":"0#& "+(#("+ 0"5*8'("- +(*0)"+ *=
2#("0 5*'(#.)'#()*' (1#(4 =*0 (1".4 )'-)5#("-
(1" &*2 :#&8" 21)51 (1" 5*.%#'/ %"- *' (1")0
1"#&(1 #'- (1")0 &):"+7 C( X#(()9*04 2*03"0+ %*)'("-
*8( (1" " "&":#("- (#'3 21"0" (1" -0)'3)'9
2#("0 =*0 (1" *0 &)'"+ )+ 9"'"0#&&/ +(*0"-7
c' (1" *55#+)*'+ 21"' )( 1#+ 6""' )' -)+0"%#)04
2*03"0+ 5)."-4 (1" 5*.%#'/ 1#+ -)+(0)68("-
2#("0 8+)'9 (1" (#'3 )' 21)51 )( .)N"+ %"+()5)-"+
=*0 +%0#/)'9 (1" ("# 68+1"+7[\C 90*8% *= 2*03"0+
#( _#>8&) 5*.%)'"- #6*8( # 0"5"'( )'5)-"'(
(1"0"4 21"0" # 5*2 -0*2'"- )' (1")0 -0)'3)'9
2#("0 +8%%&/7 !1" 5*2 2#+ '*( 0".*:"- =*0 # ="2
[O
?1?,:KG,G:Z
C50*++ (1" CAAB "+(#("+4 #55"++ (* "&"5(0)5)(/
#+ 2"&& #+ (1" "N%"'+" *= 0"5"):)'9 )(4 #0" .#>*0
5*'5"0'+7 C( #&& "+(#("+4 2*03"0+ 5*.%)'"- #6*8(
:"0/ 1"#:/ -"-85()*'+4 +*."()."+ #.*8'()'9 (*
'"#0&/ 1#&= *= (1")0 (#3";1*." %#/7 !* #-- )'+8&((* )'>80/4 (1"/ -* '*( #5(8#&&/ 0"5"):" IV 1*80+
*= "&"5(0)5)(/a )' .*+( 5#+"+4 (1" 5*''"5()*' )+
+2)(51"- *' 6/ (1" 5*.%#'/4 +*."()."+ =*0 #+
&)((&" #+ (10"" *0 =*80 1*80+ # -#/7
c' .*+( "+(#("+4 )( #%%"#0+ (1#( (1" 5*+( *="&"5(0)5)(/ )+ -):)-"- "@8#&&/ #.*'9 2*03"0+
e[
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
45/110
#' !"# +(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ TI4 IJTI7 Q)'5" (1" %0#5()5" #( .*+( CAAB "+(#("+
)+ (* -):)-" (1" (*(#& 6)&& =*0 %*2"0 5*'+8.%()*' "@8#&&/ #.*'9 (1" 2*03"0+4 0"9#0-&"++ *= 1*2 .851 "#51 1#+ 5*'+8."- )'-):)-8#&&/4
)( )+ '*( 5&"#0 21/ (1"0" +1*8&- ":"0 1#:" 6""' +851 .#++):" #00"#0+4 *0 5*'()'8"- -"-85()*'+ =0*. 2*03"0+G %#/51"53+7
TJT R#3#>#' !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ TI4 IJTI7
TJI _#>8&) !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ IT4 IJTY7
TJY @47
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
46/110
5*''"5()*'7 C( d#1*038()#4 =*0 "N#.%&"4 2" +#2
(1" %#/51"53+ *= (10"" %"0.#'"'( 2*03"0+4 &):)'9
)' (1" +#." 1*8+"4 "#51 *= 21*. 1#- %#)- !T[\
=0*. (1")0 =*0(')91(G+ 2#9"+ =*0 "&"5(0)5)(/7TJV
`&"5(0)5)(/ )+ *'" *= (1" +"0:)5"+ (1#( (1"
9*:"0'."'( +86+)-)H"+ =*0 (1*+" &):)'9 6"&*2 (1"
%*:"0(/ &)'" S )'5&8-)'9 .#'/ 2)(1 1*8+"1*&-
)'5*." &":"&+ +).) (* (1*+" *= CAAB 2*03"0+7
!1"0" #0" .#'/ +851 1*8+"1*&-+ *8(+)-" (1"
%'(#()*'4 +*."()."+ 2)(1)' +("%+ *= (1" *0
&)'"+7 C( X#(1)38&) "+(#(" )' C++#.4 =*0 "N#.%&"4
2" :)+)("- (1" 1*."+ *= (".%*0#0/ 2*03"0+
21* &):" >8+( *8(+)-" (1" %'(#()*' %"0)."("04
#'- 0":)"2"- "&"5(0)5)(/ 6)&&+ *= 6"(2""' !YJ
#'- !ITJ %"0 .*'(1 =*0 5*'()'8*8+ +"0:)5"7TJ\
K*03"0+ #( d#1*0#') 21* 1#- .#'#9"- (* +"580"
# -)0"5( 5*''"5()*' =0*. (1" "&"5(0)5)(/ 6*#0-42)(1*8( .#'#9"."'( %"0.)++)*'4 5)."- (1#(
(1"/ %#/ 1#&= *= 21#( (1"/ 8+"- (* %#/7 c'"
2*03"0 (*&- 8+ (1#( (1" 0"#+*' "&"5(0)5)(/ 6)&&"-
(10*891 (1" 5*.%#'/ )+ +* "N%"'+):" )+ 6"5#8+"
(1" 5*.%#'/ %#/+ #' )'-8+(0)#& 0#(" #'- +).%&/
)( )+ # %0*6&".4 +)'5" (1" 5*.%#'/ %#/+ =*0 (1"
TJO
`N51#'9"+ 2)(1 CAAB .#'#9"0+ *' (1)+ )++8"
%0*-85"- &)((&" 5)(/7 !1" _#'#9)'9 P)0"5(*0 *=
(1" 5*.%#'/4 P""%#3 C(#&4 5)."- (1#( (1" 0"#+*'
"&"5(0)5)(/ 6)&&+ 2"0" +* 1)91 2#+ %)&="0#9"4TJU
21)&" (1" F"'"0#& _#'#9"0 *= d#.0**% +).%&/
-"')"- (1#( (1"0" 2#+ # %0*6&".4 )'+)+()'9 (1#(
#&& 2*03"0+ 1#:" IV 1*80+ *= "&"5(0)5)(/ # -#/4 #'-
#0" 6)&&"- )'-):)-8#&&/ (10*891 ."("0+ +8%%&)"-6/ (1" +(#(" "&"5(0)5)(/ 6*#0-7TJe
.0
)'5&8-)'9 =*0 1"#&(1 5#0" #'- +86+)-)H"- =**- S
#0" -"')"- (* (1" 18+6#'-+ *= 2*."' 2*03"0+4
(1" 0"()0"- %#0"'(+ *= .#&" #'- =".#&" 2*03"0+4
.*+( 51)&-0"' *:"0 (1" #9" *= +)N4 #'- .*+( *0 #&&
(".%*0#0/ 2*03"0+7
!"#$"% '()*%(+(#,-(.#
L*0 \J /"#0+4 (1" ABC 1#+ 1#- # 5&"#0 '*';
2#+ "N%&)5)(&/ )'+"0("- )' (1" #5( )' T[OJ7 !1"
#5( 2#+ =80(1"0 #."'-"- )' IJTJ (* "'+80" (1#(
-"%"'-"'( %#0"'(+ 2*8&- #&+* 6" )'5&8-"- )' (1"
2"0" (1" %#0"'(+ *= # .#&" *0 =".#&" 2*03"07TJ[
d":"0(1"&"++4 CAAB %'(#()*'+ +/+(".#()5#&&/
TJV
TJ\ X#(1)38&) !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ TY4 IJTI7
TJO d#1*0#') !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ II4 IJTY7
TJU _""()'9 2)(1 (1" ,LM #'- P""%#3 C(#&4 d"2P"&1)4 j#'8#0/ V4 IJTI7
TJe ,'("0:)"2 2)(1 F#8(#.
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
47/110
*6 21"' 1" 6"5#."
(** +)53 (* 2*03 =*8'- (1#( (1" 5*+( *= 1)+
."-)5#& 5#0" 2#+ '*2 6")'9 -"-85("- =0*.
1"0 %#/4 )' )'50"."'(+ *=!TJJ %"0 =*0(')91(7
c:"0 (1" %0":)*8+ (2* /"#0+4 +1" 1#- #&0"#-/
%#)- 1"0 ".%&*/"0 *:"0 !\JJJ7TTT
TJ[ A'(#()*'+ B#6*80 DC."'-."'(E C5(4 _#/ Te4 IJTJ7
TTJ P#. P). !"# `+(#("4 K"+(
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
48/110
C( R#3#>#'4 # 2*.#' 21*+" 18+6#'- -)"- #(
(1" CAAB 0"="00#& 1*+%)(#& #( M1862# #=("0
+809"0/ 2#+ (*&- (1#( +1" *2"- (1" 5*.%#'/
.*0" (1#' !IJ4JJJ =*0 1)+ 5#0"7 X" 1#- ":"'
6""' # %"0.#'"'( 2*03"04 68( 1)+ 2)-*2
#&&"9"- (1#( CAAB 1#- =*05"- 1). (* 9):" 8%
1)+ >*6 21"' 1" +(#0("- 9"(()'9 +)537TTI
!1" 0"+"#051 ("#. 1"#0- .#'/ +851 +(*0)"+4
21"0" ."' 9#:" 8% (1")0 %"0.#'"'( %*+)()*'+
*:"0 (1")0 >*6 2#+ '*2 6")'9 1"&- 0"+%*'+)6&"
=*0 (1" %#/."'( *= +86+(#'()#& ."-)5#& 6)&&+7
c&-"0 2*03"0+ -"+50)6" (1" 5800"'( -"')#& *=
2*.#' 2*03"0 #( X#(()9*0 6"&)":"- (1#( (1"
51#'9" 1#- (#3"' %" %"01#%+ TJ *0 TI /"#0+#9*4TTY 68( *(1"0+ ."0"&/ +#)- (1#( (1"/ 2"0"
#6&" (* 0".".6"0 # ()." 21"' (1" 5*.%#'/ 1#-
5*:"0"- (1")0 18+6#'-+G 5#0"4 2)(1*8( 6")'9 #6&"
(* +%"5)=/ 5&"#0&/ 21"' (1#( .)91( 1#:" 6""'7
K1"' #+3"- #6*8( (1)+ )++8"4 .#'#9"."'(
%0#5()5"4 &*5#& (0#-)()*' *0 # -"#& 2)(1 (1" 8')*'+7
!1" F"'"0#& _#'#9"0 *= #' )')()#&&/ 5)."-
*= %"0.#'"'( 2*03"0+7TTV *6 21"' 1"
6"5#." (** +)53 (* 2*034 =*8'- (1#( (1"
1"#&(1 5#0" (1#( 2#+ +* 50)()5#&&/ ).%*0(#'(
=*0 1"0 18+6#'- S #+ # 0"+8&( *= (1" (0#'+="07
TTI R#3#>#' !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ TI4 IJTI7
TTY X#(()9*0 !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ IT4 IJTY7
TTV ,'("0:)"2 2)(1 C.*+ j#."+ A#0)#(4 F"'"0#& _#'#9"04 #' !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 C%0)& Te4 IJTI7
TT\ TTO ,'("0:)"2 2)(1 F#8(#. #' !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ TI4 IJTI7
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
49/110
8&) #'- X#(()9*0 S
2*03"0+ +%*'(#'"*8+&/ 0#)+"- (1" )++8" *= (1"
TIU
K)(1 0"+%"5( (* (1)+ )++8" #+ 2"&&4 +":"0#& 2*03"0+
2*03"0 #( d*2"0# d8--/ 21* )+ '*2 0"+%*'+)6&"
=*0 (1" ."-)5#& "N%"'+"+ *= (2* 0"()0"- %#0"'(+7
TIe
,( #&+* #%%"#0+ (1#( *&-"0 51)&-0"' 1#:" 6""'
K*03"0+ 0"%*0("- (1#( (1" 5*.%#'/ 1#-
(1" "&)9)6)&)(/ *= 51)&-0"' #( #9" +)N4TI[(1*891 (1"
)+ 5&"#0 (1#( 51)&-0"' #0" 5*:"0"- (* (1" #9" *=
Te7TYJ`:"' "+(#(" .#'#9"0+4 -*5(*0+ #'- 2"&=#0"
2)(1*8( 1"+)(#()*' (1#( 5*:"0#9" 2#+ #:#)&"
=*0 51)&-0"'4 68( *'&/ 8% (* (1" #9" *= O7TYT
!".%*0#0/ 2*03"0+ #&+* 0"%*0("- -"')#&+ *=
(1" ABC7 !1" -*"+ '*( -)+()'98)+1 6"(2""'
(".%*0#0/ #'- %"0.#'"'( 2*03"0+ 2)(1
0"+%"5( (* ."-)5#& =#5)&)()"+4 68( 2)-"+%0"#- #'-
5*'+)+("'( +(#("."'(+ 6/ 2*03"0+ )'-)5#(" (1#(
(".%*0#0/ 2*03"0+ #0" "N5&8-"- =0*. 5*:"0#9"7
j8+( #+ )' (1" 5#+" *= %#0"'(+ #'- 18+6#'-+4
2*03"0 (* +"0:" #+ 98#0#'(*0 )= (1"/ +""3 5#0"
#( (1" "+(#(" 5&)')54 #'- (1" 5*+( 2)&& 6" -"-85("-
=0*. (1#( %"0.#'"'( 2*03"0+G %#/7
TIT @47
TII X#(1)38&) !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ TY4 IJTI7
TIY P#. P). !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 C%0)& T\4 IJTI7
TIV d#.0**% !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ e4 IJTI7
TI\ !1" *6&)9#()*' 2#+ "N("'-"- )' IJTJ (* #%%&/ (* 6*(14 DABC Q"5()*' I D""E #+ #."'-"- )' IJTJ7E
TIO 8&) !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ IT4 IJTY7
TIe d*2"0# d8--/ !"# `+(#("4 K"+(
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
50/110
!?;1:! T?KUG,?T
!1"0" )+ # +"0)*8+ #'- 2)-"&/ #53'*2&"-9"-%0*6&". 2)(1 ."-)5#& 5#0" *' (1" CAAB
%'(#()*'+7 K*03"0+ 5*.%)' #6*8( (1"
#6+"'5" *= -*5(*0+4 (1" %**0 @8#&)(/ *= 5#0"4 (1"
8'"N%"5("- 5*+(+4 #'- (1" 680-"'+ (1#( #0" %"-
*' (1". 21"' (1"/ #0" +)537 _#'/ )'5)-"'(+ *=
.#++ 2*03"0 %0*("+(+ *' CAAB %'(#()*'+ #0"
0"%*0("- (* 1#:" 6""' (0)99"0"- 6/ (1" 90*++
.)+.#'#9"."'( *= ."-)5#& +"0:)5"+4 *0 5#&&*8+
#'- #68+):" (0"#(."'( 6/ -*5(*0+7
!1" +8+(#)'"- 5 *= -*5(*0+ )+ # 2)-"+%0"#-
*= 2*03"0+ #( W8'9#.8(("" 0"%*0("- )' IJTJ7TYI
"5(80"- (1#(
%'(#()*'7TYU
=0*. (1" ,'-)#' M*8'5)& *= _"-)5#& W"+"#051 %8(
)( )' # :"0/ -)=="0"'( 5*'("N(4 #'- )'+)+("- (1#( )(
2#+ +).%&/ # .#(("0 *= 5*.%"'+#()*'7 !1" %#/
*=="0"- (* %'(#()*' -*5(*0+ 2#+ +* %**04 (1"
5*.%#')"+ &)3" CAAB =*8'- (1".+"&:"+ 8'#6&"
(* #((0#5( *0 3""% 9"'8)'" ."-)5#& %0*="++)*'#&+7,' =#5(4 (1" -*5(*0+ 1)0"- 6/ %'(#()*'+ *=("' -*
'*( 1#:" %*+(;90#-8#(" -"90""+ #( #&&4 #55*0-)'9
TYI W8'9#.8(("" !"# `+(#("4 K"+(
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
51/110
*0
5*.%)'( 0"("- (* (1" ).%"-)."'(+ (1#(
3""% 2*03"0+ =0*. #55"++)'9 (1" +(#(8(*0/
)'("0"+("- )' -*)'9 21#(G+ 6"+( =*0 (1" 5*.%#'/4
'*( 21#(G+ 6"+( =*0 8+7 X" %0"++80"+ 8+ (* 9*
#( X#(()9*07TVO
#0" >8+( %8+1"- *8( *= (1" 1*+%)(#& #'- (*&- (*
TVU
c'" *= (1" .*+( *'"0*8+ ).%"-)."'(+ )+
(1" 0"@8)0"."'( (1#( %#()"'(+ .8+( %0"+"'(
(1".+"&:"+ #( (1" 5&)')5 (2*4 *0 ":"' (10""4 ()."+
# -#/ )' *0-"0 (* #55"++ (1" +)53 &"#:" (* 21)51
(1"/ #0" "'()(&"- 6/ ,' .*+( 5#+"+4 2*03"0+
+#)- (1"/ 1#- (* #%%"#0 (10"" ()."+ # -#/ S )'
(1" .*0')'94 (1" "#0&/ #=("0'**'4 #'- #( (1" "'-
*= (1" 2*03 -#/ S )' *0-"0 (* 6" #%%0*:"- =*0
+)53 &"#:"7 _#'#9"."'( +8%%*0(+ (1" %0#5()5"7
(1"+" ."#+80"+ 2"0" '"5"++#0/4 )' *0-"0 (*
TVe
_#'/ 2*03"0+ -"+50)6"- (1" 0"%*0()'9 08&"
3)&*."("0+ (* (1" 5&)')5 #'- 6#53 #9#)' (10""
_#>8&)7TV[ C( &"#+( *'" "+(#("4 P#. P).4 9*"+
":"' =80(1"04 #55*0-)'9 (* 2*03"0+4 #'- 0"@8)0"+
(1#( (1*+" 21* #0" +)53 6" #-.)(("- (* (1"
TYe ,'("0:)"2 2)(1 P07 j#9-)+1 _#1#'(#4 ,'-)#' M*8'5)& *= _"-)5#& W"+"#0514 C%0)& TU4 IJTITY[ ,'("0:)"2 2)(1 5&)')5 -*5(*04 #' !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 C%0)& Te4 IJTI7
TVJ ,'("0:)"2 2)(1 F#8(#. 8&) !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ IT4 IJTY7
TVe ,'("0:)"2 2)(1 F#8(#.
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
52/110
1LKY8K >KL"8H"H :V:
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
53/110
B#$")(3G @+)("+-)*#+-1
b+*#+ #5 A##42#"0("3
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
54/110
:1-+)-)*#+ "(3*4(+)3 4(36"*=( )/( ="$)-1 "(%"(33*#+ #5 2#"0("
%"#)(3) -) L#"/-) (3)-)( 2/("( 3(6$"*)G 5#"6(3 3$''#+(4 =G
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
55/110
1) *' P"5".6"0 I[4 IJTI7
_#>1) 1#- 6""' -"')"- +)53 &"#:" =*0 # 0"5800"'(
."-)5#& 5*'-)()*'4 #'- 2#+ =*05"- (* 0"(80'
(* 2*034 21"0" +1" 5*&%+"- #'- -)"- +**'
#=("02#0-7T\Y
,( )+ ).%*++)6&" (* -)+58++ %'(#()*' 1"#&(1 5#0"
2)(1*8( #53'*2&"-9)'9 (1" 1)91 -)+"#+" 680-"'
#'- =0#9)&" 1"#&(1 *= %'(#()*' 2*03"0+4 *:"0#&&
T\V !1"-#(# 9#(1"0"- =0*. "+(#(" 5&)')5+G *2' 1"#&(1
=*0 2*03"0+ +""3)'9 (0"#(."'( #0" 2#("06*0'"
-)+"#+"+ +851 #+ -/+"'("0/4 #'".)#4 )'>80)"+
=0*. +(0"'8*8+ %1/+)5#& *04 .#&'8(0)()*'4
(86"058&*+)+ #'-4 )' (1" .*'+**'4 .#)#7T\\
C 0":)"2 *= (1" -"#(1 &*9+ #( #'4 5*'-85("-
)' (1" 5*80+" *= # .#'#9"."'(;*09#')H"- :)+)( (*
(1" "+(#("4 0":"#&"- (1#( # +86+(#'()#& %"05"'(#9"
*= (1" -"#(1+ 2"0" (1" 0"+8&( *= 0"+%)0#(*0/ (0#5(
)'="5()*'+a 21"' #+3"- #6*8( (1"+"4 (1" 1"#- *=
(1" 5&)')5 "N%)'"- (1#( (1"+" 2"0" "++"'()#&&/
T\O C( X#(1)38&)421"0" 5&)')5 +(#== 2"0" #&+* )'("0:)"2"- )' (1"
5*'("N( *= # :)+)( *09#')H"- 6/ CAAB .#'#9"."'(4(1"/ #((0)68("- (1" 1)91 &":"& *= -"#(1+ 0"+8&()'9
=0*. 0"+%)0#(*0/ (0#5( )'="5()*'+ (* .#&'8(0)()*'4
8'1"#&(1/ &):)'9 5*'-)()*'+4 #'- #'".)#7T\U`&)#+
(1#( 1)91;&":"& .#'#9"0+ #5():"&/ 809"- 1). (*
5*'5"#& (1" 8'-"0&/)'9 5#8+" *= -"#(1+ )' (1"
*0 &)'"+ 6"1)'- +).) "8%1".)+.+4 -80)'9
(1" %"0)*- *= 1)+ ".%&*/."'(7 L*0 "N#.%&"4 1"
T\e
!
!
K*03 *' ("# %'(#()*'+ )+ 51#0#5("0)H"- 6/
# -"90"" *= )'+"580)(/ 8'%#0#&&"&"- )' ,'-)#G+
=*0.#& +"5(*0? 2*03"0+ #0" %#)- *'&/ =*0 (1" -#/+
(1"/ 2*03 #'- 2#9"+ -* '*( )'5&8-" # %#)- -#/
*==7 ,' #--)()*'4 #+ -)+58++"- #6*:"4 (1"0" )+ '*
.)').8. 2#9" =*0 ("# 2*03"0+ )' C++#. #'-
T\J P#. P). !"# `+(#("4 K"+(
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
56/110
K"+(
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
57/110
#' !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ TI IJTIa d*2"0# d8--/ !"# `+(#("4 K"+(
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
58/110
FL1 1:V8H6 J
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
59/110
S+$),*:2)0H 8%8?/)*+, )+ 7(H -+$&2($%& *, @##=3 5+%$/*+, (,88%/%7)*+, C%$% C*8%&7$%(8 *, )2%
/(67(*:, )+ &%00 &2($%& )+ C+$L%$&3
#DD^B/WB
R%8?/)*+, -+$ #$+'*8%,) S?,8[ ( &)()?)+$H &/2%6% )2()7$+'*8%& ( +,%W)*6% 7(H+?) )+ C+$L%$& +, $%)*$%6%,)3
#CAZ/DC^A/AD
R%8?/)*+, -+$ %0%/)$*/*)H3+)2 +- C2*/2&2+?08[ >H 0(C[ >% 7(*8 -+$ >H )2% /+67(,H3
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
60/110
C( R#3#>#'4 (2* 2*03"0+ +#)- (1"/ 1#- 6""'
%08')'9 =0*. OC_ (* I?YJA_ (1#( -#/4 =*0 #
+)'9&" 2#9"7TO\
C( X#(()9*04 # 2*03"04 ".%&*/"- #( (1" "+(#("
=*0 *:"0 IJ /"#0+4 5*.%)'"- (1#( (1" (#+3
0#(" 2#+ (10"" ()."+ 21#( )( 8+"- (* 6"4 #'-
'*("- (1#( ":"' 2)(1 #' #++)+(#'(4 6*(1 1#-
(* 2*03 =*0 ')'" 1*80+ (* 5*.%&"(" )(7TOO
C+ # 2*03"0 #( R#3#>#' #0()58("- (1" 5*.%#'/G+
TOU
X*2":"04 CAAB .#'#9"0+ +).%&/ -"'/ (1#( (1"0"
#0" #'/ )'+(#'5"+ *= %#/ -"-85()*'+ =*0 =#)&80" (*
.""( (1" (#09"(4 *0 *= 2*03"0+ 1#:)'9 (* +1#0"
# (#+3 #'- # 2#9"7 C( d#.0**%4 (1" F"'"0#&_#'#9"0 )'+)+("- (1#( '* 2*03"0 2#+ %"0.)(("-
2#+ (1#( 1" *0 +1" 5*8&- '*( 5*.%&"(" (1" (#+3
0#("4 (1"' (1" (#+3 0#(" 2*8&- 6" 0"-85"-4 #(
(1" -)+50"()*' *= (1" +8%"0:)+*07TOe !1" F"'"0#&
_#'#9"0 *= #' #&+* +(#("- 5#("9*0)5#&&/ (1#(
'* 1"&%"0+ 2"0" #&&*2"-4 #+ # .#(("0 *= 5*.%#'/
%*&)5/4 #'- #&+* )'-)5#("- (1#( (1" (#+3 0#("+
=*0 %08')'9 #'- 98(("0;5&"#0)'9 #0" 0*8()'"&/
#->8+("- =*0 #'/ 2*03"0 8'#6&" (* .""( (1".7TO[
!1" )'50"#+)'9 0"&)#'5" *' (".%*0#0/ 2*03"0+
L*0 ("# %'(#()*'+4 (1" 51)"= "5*'*.)5 )'5"'():"
(* 8+" (".%*0#0/ 2*03"0+ )+ (1#( (1"/ #0" '*(
5#0"7 DK1)&" (1" A'(#()*'+ B#6*80 C5( -*"+ '*(
5*'(".%(" # -)+()'5()*' 6"(2""' %"0.#'"'(
(".%*0#0/ 2*03"0+ )+ 2"&& "+(#6&)+1"- #'-
#%%#0"'(&/ 8'):"0+#&4 #( &"#+( )' K"+(
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
61/110
8&) !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ IT4 IJTY7
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
62/110
*'&/ (1*+" 21* .)N (1" (*N)5 51".)5#&+ #0" 9):"'
.#+3+ #'- 9&*:"+a +%0#/"0+ 0"5"):" '*(1)'94
8'&"++ (1"/ 68/ (1")0 *2' "@8)%."'(7
C50*++ (1" CAAB "+(#("+4 +%0#/ 2*03"0+ 21* -*
0"5"):" 9*99&"+ (* %0*("5( (1")0 "/"+ 1"#% +5*0'
*' (1")0 @8#&)(/ #'- "=="5():"'"++?
C( C51#6#.4 *'" +%0#/ 2*03"0 (*&- 8+ (1#(
1" -)- '*( 8+" (1" 9*99&"+4 +)'5" (1"/ 2"0"
*= +851 &*2 @8#&)(/ (1#( )( 2#+ ).%*++)6&" (*
+"" (10*891 (1" &"'+"+7TU[
C( d*2"0# d8--/4 *'" +%0#/ 2*03"0
TeJ
C( W8'9#.8((""4 (1"/ 2"0" -"+50)6"- #+
TeT
C( X#(()9*04 # 2*03"0 +#)- (1"/ 2"0" *= +851
TeI
!1" %0*:)+)*' *= 9"#0 :#0)"- #50*++ (1"
%'(#()*'+?
C( W8'9#.8((""4 # 90*8% *= (10"" +%0#/
2*03"0+ )'("0:)"2"- (*9"(1"0 +#)- (1#(
(1"/ 0"5"):"- # 5&*(1 1#(4 5&*(1 +1*"+4 #'-
# 5&*(1 .#+3 21"' (1"/ 6"9#' +%0#/)'94 68('*(1)'9 "&+"7TeY
C( X#(()9*04 (2* +%0#/ 2*03"0+ )'=*0."- 8+
(1#( (1"/ 0"5"):"- %+()5 +1*"+ (1#( 9* 8% (*
(1" #'3&"4 68( '*(1)'9 "&+"7TeV
C 90*8% *= (10"" +%0#/ 2*03"0+ )'("0:)"2"-
(*9"(1"0 #( R#3#>#' +#)- (1#( (1"/ 1#-
0"5"):"- '*(1)'9 (10*891*8( (1" /"#0+
(1#( (1"/ 1#- 6""' +%0#/)'94 "N5"%( =*0 #
(#0%#8&)' +1""( (* 20#% #0*8'- (1" 2#)+(7Te\
d* +%0#/ 2*03"0 2" +%*3" (*4 #( #'/ CAAB
"+(#("4 1#- ":"0 0"5"):"- 9&*:"+4 "N5"%( =*0
(1*+" .)N)'9 %"+()5)-"+7 C +%0#/ 2*03"0 #(
TeO
K*03"0+ #0" 2"&& #2#0" *= 21#( "@8)%."'( (1"/
+1*8&- 0"5"):"4 6"5#8+" (1"/ #0" 9):"' =8&& 9"#04
)'5&8-)'9 # 51#'9" *= 5&*(1"+4 21"' #8-)(*0+
#00):"4 #55*0-)'9 (* )'("0:)"2+ #( ":"0/ "+(#("
:)+)("-7 C( R#3#>#' #'- #' !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ I\4 IJTY7
TeO _#>8&) !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ IT4 IJTY7
?/*3 3*,+< +(-" )/( Q$+,-'$))(( (3)-)( 5-6)#"G< 3()3 5#")/
*11*)("-)( -+4 #5 2/#' 5(2< *5 -+G< $+4("3)-+4 U+,1*3/7
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
63/110
#')' j#'8#0/ IJTY7 c'" 5800"'( +%0#/ 2*03"0 +#)-?
Tee K*03"0+
9"'"0#&&/ "N%0"++"- #%%0"1"'+)*' #6*8(
5*'+"@8"'5"+ S )' (1" =*0. *= 0"(#&)#()*' S )=
(1"/ 0"@8"+("- 0"98 #55"++ (* (1" "@8)%."'(7
,'-""-4 (1" *'" =*0."0 +%0#/ 2*03"0 2"
)'("0:)"2"- 21* -)- -"+50)6" 1#:)'9 #+3"- =*0
%0*("5():" 9"#0 S # +%0#/)'9 5*#( #'- .#+3 S
)'=*0."- 8+ (1#( 1" 1#- 6""' %8')+1"- 2)(1 #
+)N;2""3 +8+%"'+)*' =0*. 2*03 ).."-)#("&/
#=("0 .#3)'9 (1" 0"@8"+(7Te[
%0*("5():" 9"#0 -"%"'-+ *' (1" 1#H#0-+ *= (1"
51".)5#&+ )' 8+"7 M1".)5#&;0"+)+(#'( 6**(+4
5*:"0#&&+4 9&*:"+4 1**- #'- 0"+%)0#(*0 #0" '*(
0"@8)0"- 8'-"0 #&& 5)058.+(#'5"+4 68( +*." 6#+)5%0*("5()*'+4 )'5&8-)'9 9*99&"+4 .#+34 5*#(4 9&*:"+4
"( 5"("0#4 2*8&- 6" 0"@8)0"- ":"' =*0 (1*+"
+%0#/)'9 .)'*0 )00)(#'(+7 X*2":"04 )'("0:)"2+
5*'-85("- 2)(1 2*03"0+4 #+ 2"&& #+ # 0":)"2 *=
# +%0#/)'9 >*80'#& .#)'(#)'"- 6/ # +86;+(#==
.".6"0 #( *'" *= (1" "+(#("+4 )'-)5#(" 0"98 8+"
*= 51".)5#&+ 5#("9*0)H"- #+ M++ ,, D.*-"0#("&/
1#H#0-*8+E 6/ (1" K*0&- X"#&(1 c09#')H#()*'7T[J
K*03"0+ 5). (1#( *'" %#0()58&/ -#'9"0*8+
51".)5#&4 "'-*+8&=#'4 21)51 1#+ 6""' +86>"5(
(* # 9&*6#& 6#'4 1#- 6""' )' 0"5"'( 8+"7 C( P#.
P).4 # 2*03"0 21* 1#- 6""' +%0#/)'9 =*0 *:"0
TJ /"#0+ (*&- 8+ 5#("9*0)5#&&/ (1#( "'-*+8&=#'
TeU R#3#>#' !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ TI4 IJTIa
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
64/110
)'+"5(4 #'- 21"' (1"/ +"" )(4 (1"/ ("&& 8+ (*
T[T X" =80(1"0 +(#("- (1#( +%0#/ 2*03"0+
8+)'9 "'-*+8&=#' -* '*( 0"5"):" #'/ %0*("5():"
"@8)%."'(4 *0 (0#)')'9 )' %0"5#8()*'#0/
."#+80"+7 C( d#1*0#')4 # 2*03"0 )' # %*+)()*'
(* +"" 5*'(#)'"0+ =*0 %"+()5)-"+ :*&8'(""0"-
(1#( "'-*+8&=#' 2#+ 6")'9 8+"- (1"0"4 (**7T[I
C( R#3#>#'4 # 2*03"0 )':*&:"- )' (0#'+%*0()'9
"'-*+8&=#' 5*'(#)'"0+7T[Y,' 6*(1 *= (1"+" 5#+"+4
(1"0" 2"0" '* +%"5)#& %0*("5():" ."#+80"+ (#3"'
)' 5*'>8'5()*' 2)(1 (1" 8+" *= (1" 51".)5#&7
c' (1" +86>"5( *= %0*("5():" 9"#0 =*0 +%0#/"0+4
.#'#9"."'( )+ 5#("9*0)5#&? (1"/ -"'/ #'/
%0*6&". #'- )'+)+( (1#( (1"0" )+ 0)9*0*8+ #'-
5*'+)+("'( ).%&"."'(#()*' *= +(0)5( +(#'-#0-+7_#'#9)'9 P)0"5(*0 P""%#3 C(#& -"+50)6"- #'
"N("'+):" *558%#()*'#& 1"#&(1 #'- +#="(/ #8-)(
*= .#'#9"."'( +/+(".+4 5*'-85("- 6/ ]"0-"
]"'(80"+4 # 5*'+8&()'9 90*8% 6#+"- )' ,'-)#4 *:"0
IJTT #'- IJTI4 (* "'+80" &*'9;("0. 5*.%&)#'5"
2)(1 +%0#/"0 +#="(/ ."#+80"+7T[VX" )'+)+("- (1#(
(1" *558%#()*'#& 1"#&(1 #'- +#="(/ 0":)"2 2#+
0*8()'"4 0#(1"0 (1#' 1#:)'9 6""' (0)99"0"- 6/ (1"
)+ # +(#03 -)+5*''"5( 6"(2""' .#'#9"."'(
5).+ #'- (1" 0"+"#051"0+G *2' "N%"0)"'5"S &"( #&*'" 2*03"0+G #55*8'(+ S *= ."#+80"+ (*
%0*("5( +%0#/ 2*03"0+?
L*&&*2)'9 (1" -"#(1 *= # +%0#/ 2*03"0 #( (1"
A*2#) "+(#("4 )' IJTJ4 X#0-""% Q)'914 (1"'
(1" _#'#9)'9 P)0"5(*0 *= CAAB4 -"')"- (1#(
(1" 2*03"0 5*8&- 1#:" -)"- =0*. "N%*+80" (*
1#H#0-*8+ %"+()5)-"+7 X" (*&- (1" 0"+"#051"0+
(1#( +%0#/ 2*03"0+ #0" +).%&/ '*( #&&*2"- (*
6"9)' (1" -#/G+ 2*03 8'&"++ (1"/ #0" )' =8&&
%0*("5():" 9"#07T[\X" -)+.)++"- # %1*(*90#%1
*= +%0#/ 2*03"0+ 2)(1*8( 9"#0 (1#( 1#- 6""'
(#3"' 6/ *'" *= (1" 0"+"#051"0+4 # =8&& .*'(1
#=("0 (1" -"#(17T[O
C( #'4 (1" F"'"0#& _#'#9"0 )'+)+("- (1#(
#&& +%0#/"0+ 0"5"):" # =8&& +"( *= %0*("5():"
9"#0 #( (1" 6"9)'')'9 *= ":"0/ 2*03 -#/4
21)51 (1"/ .8+( %8( *' 8'-"0 +8%"0:)+)*'
6"=*0" (1"/ 5#' 6"9)' +%0#/)'97 !1"
"@8)%."'( )+ 5*&&"5("- =0*. (1". #( (1"
"'- *= (1" -#/4 (* "'+80" (1#( )( )+ 5&"#'"-
%#+( (1" 2)'-*2 6"1)'- 1).4 2"#0)'9 *'&/
!;+1)0(+ #'- +1*0(+4 2)(1 =8&& +%0#/ (#'3+
+(0#%%"- (* (1")0 6#53+7T[U
_#'#9"0+4 #( .8&()%&" &":"&+4 5). (1#( +%0#/
2*03"0+ 8'-"09* =8&& ."-)5#& 51"538%+4 ":"0/
(10"" .*'(1+4 (* "'+80" (1#( (1")0 1"#&(1 1#+ '*(
6""' #=="5("- 6/ "N%*+80" (* %"+()5)-"+7 K)(1
+899"+(+ (1" #6+"'5" *= # 5&"#04 5*'+)+("'( %*&)5/
#50*++ (1" "+(#("+?
Q%0#/ 2*03"0+ #( d*2"0# d8--/
#53'*2&"-9"- 0"5"):)'9 6&**- ("+(+ ":"0/
/"#04T[e #'- (1*+" #( P#. P). +#)- 6&**-
("+(+ (**3 %" ":"0/ (10"" *0 =*80 .*'(1+4
#&*'9 2)(1 # 51"538% *= 2")91( #'- 6&**-
%0"++80"7T[[ ,' '")(1"0 5#+"4 #55*0-)'9 (*
2*03"0+4 1#- (1"/ 0"5"):"- #'/ )'=*0.#()*'
0"9#0-)'9 (1" 0"+8&(+ *= (1" ("+(+7
C( d#1*0#')4 # 2*03"0 21* 1#- 6""'
("' /"#0+ 5)."- (1#( 1" 1#- '":"0 1#- #'/
."-)5#& 51"538%7IJJ
T[T P#. P). !"# `+(#("4 K"+(
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
65/110
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
66/110
":"0/ TJ %"0.#'"'( 2*03"0+4 )' (1" &*2 +"#+*' S
#55*0-)'9 (* (1" )'-"%"'-"'( (0#-" 8')*' #( (1"
"+(#("7IJeDC( d*2"0# d8--/4 #'- #&& *(1"0 CAAB
"+(#("+ 21"0" 2" 5*'-85("- )'("0:)"2+4 (1"
%&853)'9 *= &"#= (#3"+ %"7E C( P#. P).4 # 90*8%
(1"0" #0" 5800"'(&/ T4[\V %"0.#'"'( 2*03"0+
#( (1" "+(#("4 #'- #6*8( #+ .#'/ (".%*0#0/
2*03"0+ *' # /"#0;0*8'- 6#+)+7 c'" 2*03"0 )' (1"
90*8% +#)- (1#( (1"0" 2"0" ":"' .*0" (".%*0#0/
2*03"0+ 8'()& #6*8( (2* /"#0+ #9*4 21"' .#'/
*= (1". +(*%%"- (0/)'9 (* +""3 2*03 #( (1" "+(#("
#'- .)90#("- (* '"#06/ 5)()"+7IJ[
_#'#9"0+ #( CAAB #&+* #90"" (1#( 2*03"0+ #0"
6"(("0 %#/)'9 2*03 "&+"21"0"7 !1" F"'"0#&
_#'#9"0 *= d#.0**% )'-)5#("- (1#( /*8'9
%"*%&"4 #'- ."' *= #&& #9"+4 2"0" &"#:)'9 (1"
%'(#()*' (* +""3 ".%&*/."'( )' d"2 P"&1)
#'- *(1"0 " 5)()"+4 #+ 2"&& #+ #( 5*'+(085()*'
%0*>"5(+ 5&*+"0 6/7ITJ L0*. (1" .#'#9"."'(
%"0+%"5():"4 (1" .#)' %0*6&".+ (1#( "'+8"-
2"0" (1" 5 *= .#&" 2*03"0+ =*0 1#0- *04
#+ (1" d#.0**% F"'"0#& _#'#9"0 "N%)'"-4 *0
#6+"'("")+.4 21"0" 2*03"0+ +).%&/ -* '*( +1*2
8% )= (1"0" #0" 6"(("0 %#/)'9 *%%*0(8')()"+ =*0
-#/ *0 )' (1" :)5)')(/4 #+ # P):)+)*'#& _#'#9"0
#( R#3#>#' "N%)'"-7ITT
C55*0-)'9 (* 2*03"0+4 1*2":"04 (1"0" 1#+ 6""'
(* .)90#()*' #'- #6+"'("")+.7 c'" 2*03"0
&"#:)'94 .#'#9"."'( 0"=8+"+ (* 50"#(" '"2
ITI,' =#5(4
#55*0-)'9 (* 2*03"0+ #( +":"0#& "+(#("+4 CAAB )+
#5():"&/ #-:#'5)'9 (1" %0*5"++ *= 5#+8#&)H#()*'4
'*( 6/ ("0.)'#()'9 "N)+()'9 %"0.#'"'( 2*03"0+4
68( 6/ 0"=8+)'9 (* 0"%" (1*+" 21* 0"()0"7 C(
d#1*038()#4 # 2*03"0 5)."- (1#( (1" (*(#&
'8.6"0 *= %"0.#'"'( >*6+ 1#- 6""' 0"-85"-
6/ #&.*+( YJJ4 #+ "N)+()'9 2*03"0+ 0"()0"-4 68(
2"0" '*( 0"%"-7ITYC(
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
67/110
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
68/110
*'" %'(#()*'4 2" 2"0" ":"' (*&- (1#(
%#()"'(+ 2"0" 0".*:"- =0*. (1" 1*+%)(#& )'
%0"%#0#()*' =*0 #' #8-)(7IIY
C( P#. P).4 2*03"0+ 2"0" )'+(085("- '*( (*
+%"#3 (* (1" #8-)(*0+7
IIV
`N(0# +"580)(/ 98#0-+ 2"0" #&+* #++)9'"-
2*03"0 #( X#(()9*07II\`N(0# ."-)5#& +(#== #0"
#55*0-)'9 (* #'*(1"0 2*03"0 #( X#(()9*07IIO
.#/ 1#:" *'" %"0+*' (1"0" 0"98&/4 68( *'
#8-)( -#/+ (1"0" 2)&& 6" (10""a (1"/ 2)&& 1#:"
IIU
Q*." +%0#/"0+ 0"%*0("- 6")'9 %0*:)-"- 2)(1
%"0+*'#& %0*("5():" "@8)%."'( *' (1" -#/ *=
(1" #8-)(4 (1*891 (1)+ 2#+ )':#0)#6&/ (#3"'
#2#/ *0 6"5#." 8+"&"++ #=("0 # -#/ *0 (2*7IIe
C55*0-)'9 (* (1" 2*03"0+4 (1" #8-)(*0+ #0"
5*'+(#'(&/ #55*.%#')"- 6/ .#'#9"."'( #'-
'":"0 :)+)( (1" *0 &)'"+?
C( ":"0/ %'(#()*'4 (1" 0"+"#051 ("#. 1"#0-
+*." :#0)#()*' *= (1)+ +(#("."'( 6/ # 2*03"0
(1" 1*+%)(#&4 .#/6" (* (1" =#5(*0/7 8&) !"#
`+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ IT4 IJTY7
IIY X#(()9*0 !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ IT4 IJTY7
IIV P#. P). !"# `+(#("4 K"+(
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
69/110
8&) #'- X#(()9*0 "+(#("+ 1#:"
5*." =*02#0- 2)(1 #&&"9#()*'+ (1#( (1"/ #0"
=#5)'9 1#0#++."'( =0*. .#'#9"."'( =*0 1#:)'9
+1#0"- )'=*0.#()*' #6*8( 2*03)'9 #'- &):)'9
5*'-)()*'+ 2)(1 +":"0#& &*5#& dFc+ #'- 518051
90*8%+7 K" 1#:" 6""' )'=*0."- (1#(4 )' #--)()*'
(* )'("00*9#()'9 2*03"0+ #'- (10"#("')'9 (1".4
.#'#9"."'( 1#+ =*05"=8&&/ 0")("0#("- (1#(
0"@8)0" #-:#'5" #%%0*:#& =*0 #'/ .""()'9 2)(1
2"0" +8..*'"- (* # .""()'9 2)(1 (1" F"'"0#&
_#'#9"04 2"0" 0"%0).#'-"- 6/ 1).4 #'- .#-"
(* +)9' -"5#()*'+4 2)(1*8( #'/ "N%'#()*' *=
21#( (1"/ 2"0" +)9')'97IYU
IYV C++#. W8&"+4 ABC4 Q"5()*' OJDVEa K"+(
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
70/110
,' "'5*8'("0+ 2)(1 (1" 0"+"#051 ("#.4
.#'#9"."'( .#-" &)91( *= (1" &"9#& 0"@8)0"."'(
(* #&&*2 8').%"-"- #55"++ (* (1" *0 &)'"+7
,' +*." 5#+"+4 .#'#9"."'( S )'5&8-)'9 (1"
_#'#9)'9 P)0"5(*0 P""%#3 C(#& S -"')"- (1#( (1"
2#+ #%%&)5#6&"4 )'+)+()'9 (1#( )( 2#+ (08.%"-
6/ CAABG+ %0):#(" %0*%"0(/ 0)91(+7IYe ,' *(1"0
5#+"+4 .#'#9"0+ %#++"- *:"0 (1" #'- )'+)+("-
(1#( (1")0 *6&)9#()*' (* %0":"'( #9)(#(*0+ #'-
"'+80" %86&)5 +#="(/ #&&*2"- (1". (* "N"05)+"
60*#- %*2"0+ (* .*')(*0 #&& #5():)(/ )' (1" *0
&)'"+7 _#'#9"0+ #&+* .#-" :#98" 0"="0"'5"+ (*
-#'9"0*8+ ":"'(+ #'- )'580+)*'+ 1#:)'9 (#3"'
%"4 )' *0-"0 (* +8%%*0( (1" #098."'( (1#( (1"
5*.%#'/ %*&)5/ 2#+ #5(8#&&/ )'("'-"- (* %0*("5(
2*03"0+ =0*. *8(+)-"0+7IY[
_#'#9"."'( 1#+ #%%#0"'(&/ 5*':)'5"- (1"
,'("0'#()*'#& L)'#'5" M*0%*0#()*' #'- #8-)()'9
#9"'5)"+ (1#( )( 2*8&- 6" )'#-:)+#6&" )= '*(
)&&"9#& (* "'("0 (1" *0 &)'"+ 2)(1*8( #-:#'5"
'*()5" #'- %"0.)++)*'7 P80)'9 # -)+%8(" *:"0
5*'-)()*'+ (1#( 1#- &"- (* (1" -"#(1 *= # %"+()5)-"
#+ # +1#0"1*&-"0 )' (1" K*0&- #' !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ TI4 IJTI7
IVY X#(()9*0 !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ IT4 IJTY7
IVV d#1*0#') !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ II4 IJTY7
IV\ X#(()9*0 !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ Te4 IJTY7
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
71/110
*)' (1" 8')*' *04 =*0 (1#(
.#(("04 #'/ *(1"0 8')*'7
K1)&" (1" .*'*%*&/ *= CM_Q 2#+ +1#%"-4 #'-5*'()'8"+ (* 6" 0")'=*05"-4 6/ (1" C++#. +(#("
9*:"0'."'( #'- (1" M*'90"++ A#0(/ )' %*2"0 )'
(1" +(#("4 !#(# #'- CAAB #0" -""%&/ 5*.%&)5)( #&+*7
C+ P)&"+12#0 !#'()4 F"'"0#& Q"50"(#0/ *= CM_Q
#53'*2&"-9"-4 (1" 8')*'G+ .".6"0+1)% &)+( =*0
CAAB %'(#()*'+ )' C++#. )+ 5*.%)&"- %80"&/
*' (1" 6#+)+ *= +86.)++)*'+ =0*. .#'#9"."'(4
21)51 %"0)*-)5#&&/ +"'-+ (1" 8')*' '#."+ #'-
-"(#)&+ *= #&& 5800"'( 2*03"0+7IVO !1"0" )+ '*
&"9#& 6#+)+ )' ,'-)#' *0 8'-"0 )'("0'#()*'#&
+(#'-#0-+4 =*0 (1)+ %#0()58 :"0+)*' *= #
P8"+ #0" #8(*.#()5#&&/ -"-85("- =0*. (1" 2#9"+
*= #&& 2*03"0+4 )' 21#( )+ 0"="00"- (* &*5#&&/ #+
-8"+ -"-85("- =0*. (1")0 2#9"+7 C55*0-)'9 (*
2*03"0+4 )' *0-"0 (* *6(#)' -8"+ =0*. (1" "+(
%*++)6&" '8.6"0 *= 2*03"0+4 -"-85()*'+ #0".#-" *:"0 +)N (* ")91( %#/ %"0)*-+ -80)'9 (1"
.*'+**'4 21"' #' #0./ *= 5#+8#& #'- +"#+*'#&
*0 )+ 0"508)("- =*0 %&853)'94
CAAB .#'#9"0+ (0"#( (1)+ #+ 8'5*'(0*:"0+)#&7
!1"/ -"'/ (1#( (1"0" )+4 *0 1#+ 6""'4 *%%*+)()*'
(* (1" 5*.%8&+*0/ %#/."'( *= -8"+ (* CM_Q7 !1"
F"'"0#& _#'#9"0 *= d#.0**% )'+)+("- (1#( 1"
1#- '":"0 +""' #'/ *(1"0 8')*'+ )' ("# 6"+)-"+
CM_Q4 #'- 1#- '":"0 1"#0- *= 2*03"0+ (0/)'9 (*
5#'5"& (1" -"-85()*'+ =*0 CM_Q -8"+ =0*. (1")0%#/51"53+7IVU !1" F"'"0#& _#'#9"0 *= #'
*=="0"- (1" ).%0*6#6&" #098."'( (1#( 2*03"0+
2*8&- 1#:" 5*." (* 1). %"0+*'#&&/ )= (1"/ -)-
'*( 2#'( (1")0 -8"+ -"-85("-7 d*( +80%0)+)'9&/4
'* *'" 1#- ":"0 -*'" +*7IVe
IVO IVU ,'("0:)"2 2)(1 F#8(#.
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
72/110
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
73/110
2+&7*)(0[ 2*& /($% C+?08 2('% >%%, %,)*$%0H -$%% ?,8%$
/(&%[ &*,/% 2% C(& )$%()%8 () )2% :($8%, 2+&7*)(0[ )2%%T7%,&%& ($% >%*,: 8%8?/)%8 -$+6 2%$ 7(H/2%/L34";
^+$2() )+08 ?&34"D@06+&) C*)2+?) %T/%7)*+,[ 70(,)()*+,C+$L%$& C+?08 \?(0*-H -+$ :+'%$,6%,) &/2%6%&%,)*)0*,: )2+&% >%0+C )2% 7+'%$)H 0*,% )+ -$%% 2+?&%& +,
)2%*$ +C, 0(,83 #0(,)()*+, C+$L%$& 2('% ,+ 0%:(0 $*:2))+ 0(,8 )2() *& +, )2% 70(,)()*+, (,8[ *, &+6% /(&%&[2('% %'%, >%%, -$?&)$()%8 *, %--+$)& )+ (&&%$) $*:2)&+'%$ 0(,8 )2() )2%H +C, +?)&*8% )2% 70(,)()*+,3 9+$L%$&() ^+$2() (,8 () )2$%% +)2%$ %&)()%& /0(*6%8 )2() )2%HC%$% ?,(>0% )+ $%:*&)%$ &6(00 70+)& +- 0(,8 )2() )2%*$:$(,87($%,)& 2(8 >+?:2) +?)&*8% )2% 70(,)()*+, C*)2+?)
)2% 70(,)()*+, 8+%& ,+) +C, )2% 0(,83 @##=[ (,8 %-+$% )2%6[ 2('% /+,&*&)%,)0H $%-?&%8 )+ *&&?% )2%&%
:+'%$,6%,) &/2%6% +$ %'%, &%00 )2% 0(,834"B
9+$L%$& 2('% (0&+ &+?:2) M>%0+C 7+'%$)H 0*,%N X^#=Z7+C%$ /+,,%/)*+,& )2$+?:2 )2% &)()% %0%/)$*/*)H >+($8-+$ )2%*$ 2+6%& C*)2*, )2% 0(>+$ 0*,%&[ )+ $%70(/% )2%%T7%,&*'% (,8 *,)%$6*))%,) &?770H 7$+'*8%8 )2$+?:2
)2% /+67(,H[ >?) 2('% 0($:%0H >%%, ?,(>0% )+ &%/?$%
%0%/)$*/*)H >*00& -$+6 /+66?,*)*%& *, )2% &(6% $%:*+,&(& )2% 70(,)()*+,& *,8*/()%& )2() 4FW2+?$ /+,,%/)*+,&?,8%$ )2% :+'%$,6%,) &/2%6%[ ?&%8 /+,&*&)%,)0H )+7+C%$ -(,&[ ( )%0%'*&*+,[ (,8 +)2%$ 2+?&%2+08 :++8&&)*00 0%8 )+ >*00& )2() C%$% 0+C%$ )2(, )2+&% -+$ 2+?&%2+08&*, )2% 0(>+$ 0*,%& $%/%*'*,: ,+ 6+$% )2(, )2$%% 2+?$& +-%0%/)$*/*)H 7%$ 8(H34IJ
^%,:(0[ C2%$% )2% ,%C[ *,8%7%,8%,) )$(8% ?,*+, 6(8%
^#= /+,,%/)*+,& *, )2% 0(>+$ 0*,%& *, 4JA43 %8 )2% ?,/0%(, C()%$ (,8 -$%\?%,8H&%,)%$H 8%()2& )2%$%[ (0&+ )+08 ?& )2() ( 7($)*/?0(8*'*&*+, C*)2*, )2% 0(>+$ 0*,%& 2(8 ())%67)%8 )+ &%/?$%( 8*$%/) 6?,*/*7(0 /+,,%/)*+,[ >?) C(& 8%,*%8 >%/(?&% 4I4
$%&7+,&*>*0*)H )+ (88$%&& 8%'%0+76%,) (,8 &%$'*/%& -+$70(,)()*+, C+$L%$& *, :%,%$(0[ *,/0?8*,: V >(&%8 +, +?%T)%,&*'% *,)%$'*%C& (,8 +>&%$'()*+, V C+$L%$& () )2%
0%(&) +, 7($ C*)2 )2% /+67($(>0% :+'%$,6%,) &/2%6%
]-'% -+4 '(-,(" =(44*+, *+ ('%1#G("C%"#H*4(4 /#$3*+, -) L#"/-)
U3)-)( 5"#' - %/#)#,"-%/ )-0(+ *+ )/( '*43) #5 2*+)(" VdOV7
I\U _#>8&) !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ IT4 IJTY7
I\e
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
74/110
,' =#5(4 2" 1"#0- =0*. 2*03"0+ #6*8( +":"0#&
"&/ 8'+855"++=8& "==*0(+ (* 0"+)+( 5*.%8&+*0/
%#/."'( *= -8"+4 )'5&8-)'9 # %0*("+( 6/ .*0"
IOY#'- 6/ .".6"0+ *= *(1"0 8')*'+4 )'5&8-)'9
d#.0**% 0"+%"5():"&/7IOV
*= -8"+ -"-85()*'7 ,' j#'8#0/ IJTI4 (1" 8')*'G+
F"'"0#& Q"50"(#0/4 P)&"+12#0 !#'()4 )'+)+("-
(1#( ":"0/ 2*03"0 *' (1" C++#. "+(#("+ 1#-
)'-):)-8#&&/ #8(1*0)H"- -8"+ -"-85()*'4 6#+"-
*' &)+(+ .#)'(#)'"- 6/ (1" 8')*'G+ 9#0-"';&":"&
5*..)((""7IO\,' #&& *= *80 )'("0:)"2+4 1*2":"04
2" -)- '*( +%"#3 2)(1 # +)'9&" 2*03"0 21* 1#-
#90""- (* -8"+ -"-85()*'4 *0 21* 1#- )'-)5#("-1)+ *0 1"0 -"+)0" (* >*)' (1" 8')*'4 (10*891 #
+)9'#(80" *0 (18.6%0)'(7 C /"#0 ("04 !#'()G+
+(*0/ 1#- 51#'9"-7 X" )'+)+("- (1#( 5*.%8&+*0/
(1" 0"9)+("0"- 8')*'+ #8(1*0)H" (1" -"-85()*'
6/ .#'#9"."'( *' 6"1#&= *= #&& *= (1")0
IOO!1" )++8" *= 1*2 2*03"0+ 6"5*."
0"5"):"- 0"5*9')()*'40".#)'"- 8'"N%)'"-7
!1" *'" "N5"%()*' (* (1" +/+(". *= 5*.%8&+*0/
-8"+ %#/."'( (1#( 2" "'5*8'("0"- #.*'9
(1" CAAB "+(#("+ )' C++#. 2#+ #( d#1*0#')4
*'" *= =*80 "+(#("+ *' (1" d*0(1
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
75/110
>:K"
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
76/110
"J8 8-LML&
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
77/110
"J8 HJ:K8 >F:MX !-O&OF:"OFHLK8&) (* TJJb #(
X#(1)38&) #'- #'7IUO
!1" 0*&& *8( 2#+ 5*.%&"("- )' C%0)& IJTJ4 #'-
-"-85()*'+ 6"9#' +**' #=("02#0-7IUU
("0.+ *= (1" %'4 (1" 5#%)(#& )':"+(."'( #'- #
-):)-"'- *= #( &"#+( Ob %"0 /"#0 #0" 98#0#'(""-
+1#0"+ 2)&& :"+( #'- (1")0 :#&8" 2)&& -"%"'- *'
(1" .#03"(7 CAAB 5"&"60#("- (1" 0*&&*8(4 '*()'9
IUe ,( %*)'("- (* (1" 1)91 &":"&*= +86+50)%()*'+ #+ 5&"#0 ":)-"'5" *= )(+ 9**-
5*..8')5#()*' 2)(1 2*03"0+4 #'- *= (1")0 (08+(
)' .#'#9"."'(?
("+().*')#& (* (1" "==*0(+ .#-" #( #&& &":"&+ (*
IU[
".%&*/""+ #( #&& &":"&+ 1#+ 0"5"):"- #&& 0*8'-
IeJ
.#'#9"."'( #'- *2'"0+1)% *= (1" 5*.%#'/
IeT
IUY
IUV _""()'9 2)(1 (1" ,LM #'- P""%#3 C(#&4 d"2 P"&1)4 j#'8#0/ V4 IJTI7
IU\ X#(()9*0 !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ IT4 IJTY7
IUO _""()'9 2)(1 (1" ,LM #'- P""%#3 C(#&4 d"2 P"&1)4 j#'8#0/ V4 IJTI7
IUU IUe CAAB C''8#& W"%*0( IJTJSTT #( I7
IU[ CAAB C''8#& W"%*0( IJJ[STJ #( V7
IeJ @47
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
78/110
`:)-"'5" *= (08+( #'- 5*..8')5#()*' 2"0"
%#0()58&/ ).%*0(#'( (* (1" &"9)().#5/ *= (1"
%0*5"++7 W"5*9')H)'9 (1)+4 CAAB ".%1#+)H"- )'
+51"." 5*'+)-"0)'9 (1#( .851 *= (1" 2*03=*05" IeI
X*2":"04 )'("0:)"2+ 2)(1 2*03"0+ 5*':"/
# -)=="0"'( :"0+)*' *= ":"'(+4 51#0#5("0)H"-
6/ #68+" *= %*2"0 #'- "N(0#*0-)'#0)&/ %**0
5*..8')5#()*'7 K*03"0+
-"+50)6"- "N("'+):" 5*'=8+)*'4
-"5"%()*' #'- -80"++ )' (1"
+#&" *= +1#0"+7 ]"0/ ="2 1#- #
5&"#0 )-"# *= (1" +*805" *= (1"
*= *2')'9 (1".7 C +86+(#'()#&
.#>*0)(/ *= (1" 2*03"0+
21* %8051#+"- +1#0"+ +()&&
6"&)":" (1#( (1"/ 2"0" %#)-
=*0 2)(1 .*'"/ (#3"' *8( *=
(1")0 +(#(8(*0/ 0"()0"."'(
#55*8'(+ D5*..*'&/ 3'*2'
M*..8')5#()*' 1#+ 6""'
(1" +(#0(? (1"0" 2#+ '* 0"#&"==*0( (* %0*:)-" 2*03"0+
2)(1 20)(("' .#("0)#&+ )' &*5#&
'98#9"+ 6"=*0" (1" +#&"7 ,'
(1" 2#3" *= (1" +#&"4 (1"0" 1#+
6""' '* 5*..8')5#()*' 2)(1
2*03"0+ #( #&&? '* .""()'9+4 '*
%0"+"'(#()*'+4 #'- '* 0"%*0(+
(* 5*':"/ )'=*0.#()*' #6*8(
(1" +(#(" *= (1" 5*.%#'/ 2)(1
(* +*&)5)( (1")0 *%)')*'+7 !1""N(0"." 5*'(0#+( 6"(2""'
(1" "N%"0)"'5" *= (1" 2*03"0+
#'- (1" 5).+ *= (1" 5*.%#'/
0#)+" +"0)*8+ @8"+()*'+4 '*(
*'&/ #6*8( (1" 5*.%#'/G+
2)&& #'- 5#%#5)(/ #( (1" &":"&
*= ).%&"."'()'9 (1" +1#0"
%'4 68( #6*8( )(+ 9**- =#)(1 )' (1" )')()#&
5*'5"%(8#&)H#()*'7
_#'#9"."'( #53'*2&"-9"+ %0*6&".+ *=
5*..8')5#()*' +)'5" (1" +#&" *= +1#0"+4 68(
-"')"+ *(1"0 =#)&80"+7 ,'+("#-4 (1" 5*.%#'/
*(1"0 +1#0"1*&-"0+ S 0"5"):"- # TIb -):)-"'-4
(2)5" (1" 98#0#'(""- 0#(" *= Ob7IeY _*0"*:"04
IeT @47#( I7
IeI @47
F#"0("3 2/# %$"6/-3(4 9::; 3/-"(3 "(6(*H(4 )/*3 3/(() #5 %-%(" #$)1*+*+, )/(*"
(+)*)1('(+)3 $+4(" )/( 36/('(< *+ U+,1*3/7 ?/( 2#"0(" *+ )/*3 6-3( /-3 -60+#21(4,(4
"(6(*%) 2*)/ - )/$'=%"*+) 3*+6( 3/( *3 +#) 1*)("-)(7
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
79/110
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
80/110
Q*." *= (1" 5*'5"0'+ 0"("- (* 5 *=
8'-"0+(#'-)'9 *= (1" +1#0" %'4 #+ # 0"+8&(
*= &":"&+ *= &)("0#5/ #'-f*0 (1" #6+"'5" *=
%0*-85"- )' Q#-0)4 (1" &)'98# =0#'5# *=
-*58."'(+ )' `'9&)+14 # '98#9" (1#( '*'" *=
(1". +%"#3?
C 90*8% *= 2*03"0+ #( R#3#>#'4 )'("0:)"2"-
(*9"(1"04 (*&- 8+ (1#( #&& *= (1" .#'#9"0+
+%*3" (* (1". )' `'9&)+1 *0 C++#."+"4
0#(1"0 (1#' Q#-0) *0 X)'-) D21)51 (1"
.#>*0)(/ *= 2*03"0+ #&+* 8'-"0+(#'-E 21"'
%0*%*+)'9 (1" +1#0" %8051#+)'9 %' #( (1"
I[I
C'*(1"0 90*8% *= 2*03"0+ #( R#3#>#'-"+50)6"- 1#:)'9 6""' 9):"' =*0.+ (*
.#03)'9 (1")0 #++"'( 2)(1 # (18.6%0)'(4 6/
+8%"0:)+*0+ 21* 2"0" 2"&& #2#0" (1#( (1"/
2"0" )&&)("0#(" )' `'9&)+17I[Y
c(1"0 ("+().*'/ =0*. 2*03"0+ +8%%*0(+
(1" %"05"%()*' (1#( (1"0" 2#+ # %0* =*0.#
@8#&)(/ (* (1" )'=*0.#()*'#& .""()'9+4 2)(1
:"0/ &)((&" "==*0( (* 5*':"/ ":"' 6#+)5 -"(#)&+7
,' .#'/ 5#+"+4 2*03"0+ &"=( (1" .""()'9+ '*(":"' 8'-"0+(#'-)'9 (1#( (1"/ 5*8&- 0"=8+" (*
%#0()5)%#(" )' (1" +1#0" %'7
Q":"' 2*03"0+ #( d*2"0# d8--/ +#)- (1#(
(1"/ +)9'"- =*0.+ 8'-"0 (1" ).%0"++)*'
(1#( (1"/ 2*8&- 6" 0"5"):)'9 .*'"/ )= (1"/
-)- +* S =*80 *= (1". (1*891( (1"/ 2*8&-
0"5"):"!eJJJ "#514 (1" *(1"0 (10"" 6"&)":"-
=0*. .#'#9"."'(7 ,' "#51 5#+"4 (1" 2*03"0+
0"5"):" '* 5#+14 68( (1#( 0"98 -"-85()*'+
2"0" 6")'9 (#3"' *8( *= (1")0 %#/51"53+ #+ #
5*'+"@8"'5" *= #++"'()'9 (* (1" +51"."7I[V
C 90*8% *= ")91( 2*03"0+ #( X#(1)38&)4
21"0" CAAB 5).+ (1#( :)0(8#&&/ TJJb *=
8'-"0+(**- (1#( #&& (1" 2*03"0+ 1#- (* -* )(7
I[\
2"0" .#'/?
C 90*8% *= TI 2*03"0+ )'("0:)"2"- (*9"(1"0
#( X#(()9*0 0"%*0("- (1#(4 )' *0-"0 (* %86&)5)H"
(1" +1#0" %'4 .#'#9"0+ 60*891( :#'+
&*#-"- 2)(1 +#0)+ #'- *(1"0 5*'+8."0 9**-+4
(1" (1)'9+ 2*03"0+ 2*8&- 6" #6&" (* 68/ 2)(1
(1" .*'"/ (1"/ .#-" =0*. (1" +1#0" %'7I[O
c'" 2*03"0 #( d*2"0# d8--/ 2#+ (*&- 6/
I[U
C( 8&) 5#." #2#/ =0*. (1"
(1" !eJJJ 2*8&- 6" 2*0(1 !I[[
%'4 *09#')H"- 6/ (1" .#'#9"."'( #(
d#.0**% )' IJJe4 2*03"0+ 0"5#&&"- 6")'9
YJJ
I[T R#3#>#' !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ TI4 IJTI7
I[I R#3#>#' !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ I\4 IJTY7
I[Y R#3#>#' !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ TI4 IJTI7
I[V d*2"0# d8--/ !"# `+(#("4 K"+( 8&) !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ IT4 IJTY7
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
81/110
C( R#3#>#'4 #55*0-)'9 (* (10"" 2*03"0+
21* 1#- #(("'-"- # .""()'9 *' (1#( "+(#("4
YJT
!1" "N%"0)"'5" *= %#0()5)%#()*' )' # +51"."
(1#( (1"/ -* '*( 8'-"0+(#'- #5(8#&&/ #%%"#0+ (*
1#:" =80(1"0 -)+".%*2"0"- .#'/ 2*03"0+7 c'"
-)+%)0)("- 2*03"0 #( d*2"0# d8--/4 #((".%()'9
(* "N%)' 21/ 1" 1#- %8051#+"- +1#0"+4
YJI!1)+5*.."'( 2#+ 0"%"#("-4 2)(1 .)'*0 :#0)#()*'+4
*= #+3)'9 8+ #6*8( +1#0"+4 21"(1"0 2" (1)'3
YJY
!1" %"05"%()*' *= %*2"0&"++'"++ 1#+ *'&/
6""' "'1#'5"- 6/ (1" 5*.%#'/G+ =#)&80" (*
#'- &*++ +86+"@8"'( (* (1" +#&" *= +1#0"+7 C(
X#(()9*04 # 90*8% *= TI 2*03"0+ )'("0:)"2"-
(*9"(1"0 0"5*&&"5("- (1#( (1"/ 1#- 6""' %0*.)+"-
# .*'(1&/ .""()'9 =*0 +1#0"1*&-"0+4 21"0"
(1"/ 2*8&- 6" %0*:)-"- 2)(1 -"(#)&+ *' (1"
(*&- 1*2 .851 .*'"/ (1" 9#0-"' )+ .#3)'94 21/
YJV!1" #' #55*8'()'9 ":"0/ .*'(17 h*8G&& 3'*2 21#(
YJ\!1" 5 *= )'=*0.#()*' 1#+ &"- (* +*."()."+
1#+ (*&- 8+ #'/(1)'9 +)'5" 2" 6*891( (1" +1#0"+4 YJO
-L8K-#' !"# `+(#("4 j#'8#0/ I\4 IJTY7
YJI d*2"0# d8--/ !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 _#/ Te4 IJTJ7
YJY X#(1)38&) !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ TY4 IJTI7
YJV X#(()9*0 !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ IT4 IJTY7
YJ\ d#1*0#') !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ II4 IJTY7
YJO X#(1)38&) !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ IV4 IJTY7
YJU X#(1)38&) !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ TY4 IJTI7
YJe d#.0**% !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 C%07 TU4 IJTI7
YJ[ @47
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
82/110
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
83/110
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
84/110
("#. 0*8()'"&/ 1"#0- 0"%*0(+ *= .*0" "@8):*5#&
(10"#(+ *= >*6 &*++?
C( d*2"0# d8--/ )' K"+( #' !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 j#'8#0/ I\4 IJTY7
YTV @47
YT\ d#.0**% !"# `+(#("4 C++#.4 C%0)& TU4 IJTI7
YTO P#. P). !"# `+(#("4 K"+(
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
85/110
C(
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
86/110
#' *'"0*8+ ).%#5( *' (1" &):"&)1**- *= 2*03"0+
2)(1 #&0"#-/ -"%0"++"- 2#9"+7 !1" -"-85()*'+4
21)51 0#'9" =0*. !VV (* !Ve %"0 %#/ %"0)*-4
(/%)5#&&/ 0"%0"+"'( Ob (* eb4 #'- +*."()."+
#+ .851 #+ TJb4 *= 2*03"0+G '"( 2#9"+7YIV ,'
*'" )'("0:)"2 #=("0 #'*(1"04 2*03"0+ -"+50)6"-
(1" :"0/ 0"#& ).%#5( *= (1" *+("'+)6&/ .)'*0
-"-85()*' *' (1")0 #6)&)(/ (* =""- (1".+"&:"+4
68/ "-85#()*'#& +8%%&)"+ =*0 (1")0 51)&-0"'4 *0
(#3" 5#0" *= *(1"0 -"6(+7 !1"/ 5*.%)'"- '*(
*'&/ #6*8( (1" =#5( (1#( (1"/ 1#- 6""' =*05"-
%"4 68( (1#( (1"0" 2#+ '* #%%#0"'( ."#'+ *=
6" #6&" (* +#/4 , 5#'G( #==*0- (1)+ #'/.*0"7 A&"#+"
2*03"0 #( W8'9#.8((""7YI\
C 2*03"0 #( d*2"0# d8--/4 )'("0:)"2"-
)' IJTJ4 (*&- 8+ (1#( +1" #'- 1"0 18+6#'-
2"0" 6*(1 =*05"- (* 68/ +1#0"+4 ":"' (1*891
(1"/ 1#- %0*("+("- (1#( (1")0 %#/ S #=("0
-"-85()*'+ #( +*805" =*0 "&"5(0)5)(/4 0#()*'+4
A0*:)-"'( L8'- #'- &)=" )'+80#'5" S '":"0
"N5""-"- !\JJ ":"0/ (2* 2""3+7YIO
C 2*03"0 #( P#. P). (*&- 8+ (1#( +1" 1#-
(0)"- (* "N%)' (1#( 1"0 1*8+"1*&- 1#- 1"#:/
(1" &"#:"+ , %)53 2)&& 6" 0"5*0-"- #+ &"++ =0*.
YIU
#. , +8%%*+"- (* 08' # 1*8+"1*&- *' !TJJJ
1*." +* &)((&"7 C'- (1"' (1"/ #0" (#3)'9 +()&&
.*0" =*0 (1" +1#0"+7 !1" .*'"/ , 9"( )' 1#'-4
, +%"'( #&.*+( #&& *= )( (1" +#." -#/4 >8+(
YIe
C( d#1*038()#4 # 2*03"0 21* (0)"-
8'+855"++=8&&/ (* 0"=8+" (* 68/ (1" +1#0"+
(*&- 8+ (1#( 1" 2#+ (1" +*&" +8%%*0("0 *=
(10"" 51)&-0"' )' +51**&7YI[
K*03"0+ 2"0" '*( 6/ #'/ ."#'+ 0">"5()'9 *8(0)91(
(1" "0 )-"# *= )':"+()'9 *0 +#:)'9 (1#( # %'&)3" (1)+ 5*8&- 0"%0"+"'(a +":"0#& 2"0"4 1*2":"04
#-#.#'( (1#( (1)+ %#0()58 +51"." -)- '*(
*= !eJJJ4 , 2*8&- 8+" )( (* "-85#(" ./ 60*(1"0+
#( #' #'- d*2"0# d8--/4 2*03"0+
%#/!VV %"0 =*0(')91(a #( d#1*038()#4 -"-85()*'+
#0" !V\ %"0 =*0(')91(a #( W8'9#.8(("" #'-C51#6#.4 2*03"0+ %#/ !VU7OI %"0 =*0(')91(7
CAAB .#'#9"."'( -"')"+ (1#( (1"0" 5*8&-
6" #'/ :#0)#()*'4 #++"0()'9 (1#( #&& 2*03"0+
%#/ (1" +#." #.*8'(7 ,' *80 )'("0:)"2 2)(1
P""%#3 C(#&4 1" 5*'>"5(80"- (1#( -"-85()*'+
.)91( :#0/ *'&/ )= 2*03"0+ 1#- 0"@8"+("- (1#(
(1")0 &*#' 0"%#/."'( 6" -"="00"- *0 0"-85"-
9):"' 8'#'()5)%#("- "N%"'+"+ =*0 # %#0()58
%#/ %"0)*-7YYI X*2":"04 2" "'5*8'("0"- '*
":)-"'5" (1#( :#0)#()*'+ )' "@8)(/ %#/."'( 2"0"
5*00"("- (* 2*03"0+G 0"@8"+(+7
YIV R((3$%"- YI\ W8'9#.8(("" !"# `+(#("4 K"+(
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
87/110
K1)&" 2*03"0+ 1#:" 0"5"):"- .*0" (1#' (1"
%0*.)+"- -):)-"'- %#/."'(+ (18+ =#04 .#'/
K1)&" 0"98 2#9"+ #0" 9):"' (* 2*03"0+ )' (1"
=*0. *= 5#+14 (1" -):)-"'- )+ -"%*+)("- -)0"5(&/
)'(* (1")0 6#'3 #55*8'(+7 F):"' (1#( 6#'3+ #0" =#0
#2#/ =0*. (1" 0".*(" ("# %'(#()*'+4 2*03"0+ #(
+":"0#& "+(#("+ %*)'("- *8( (1#( 2)(1-0#2)'9 (1"
.*'"/ )':*&:"+ &*+)'9 # -#/G+ 2#9"+ D+)'5" 6#'3+
#0" '*( *%"' *' Q8'-#/+4 21)51 #0" 2*03"0+G
*'&/ 0"98 -#/+ *==E #'- +%"'-)'9 +86+(#'()#&
#.*8'(+ *= ()." #'- .*'"/ )' (0#:"&7 C( X#(()9*04
=*0 "N#.%&"4 2*03"0+ +#)- (1#( (1" 6#'3 )+ (10""
1*80+G >*80'"/ #2#/4 #'- (1" (0)% 5*+(+ !VJ
"#51 2#/7YYY K" 1"#0- +).) 5*.%)'(+ =0*.
2*03"0+ #( .#'/ *(1"0 "+(#("+7YYV
(* 0"%0"+"'( C++#. ("# %'(#()*' 2*03"0+4
%0*:)-"- 8+ # -)+(*0("- :)"2 *= (1" %'4
"N#99"0#()'9 (1" #.*8'( *= -):)-"'- 0"5"):"-
#'- (1" :#&8" *= (1" +1#0"+7 L*0 "N#.%&"4 (1"
CM_Q F"'"0#& Q"50"(#0/ #++"0("- (1#( (1"
-"5"- -):)-"'- 2#+ YJb %"0 /"#0 D!IVJJE4YY\
(1" CM_Q 0"%0"+"'(#():" #( d#.0**% )'+)+("-
(1#( )( 2#+!TIJJ4YYO#'- (1" CM_Q 0"%0"+"'(#():"
#( X#(1)38&) 5*'("'-"- (1#( #&0"#-/4 #&& 2*03"0+
1#- 0"5"):"- -):)-"'- %#/."'(+ "@8):#&"'(
(* ")91( ()."+ (1" :#&8" *= (1" +1#0"+7YYU !1"
F"'"0#& Q"50"(#0/ +#)- 2)(1 5"0(#)'(/ (1#( (1"
:#&8" *= +1#0"+ 1#- )'50"#+"- =0*. !TJ (* !Y\4
#'- (1#( 1" %"0+*'#&&/ 3'"2 2*03"0+ 21* 1#-
6""' #6&" (* +"&& (1". =*0 (1)+ #.*8'(7YYe ,'
0"#&)(/4 '* 2*03"0 5#' +"&& (1" +1#0"+ 6"=*0" (1"/
:"+(4 =*80 /"#0+ #=("0 (1" %8051#+"7
!1" =8(80" )+ ":"' .*0" 8'5"0(#)'4 #( .8&()%&"
&":"&+7 !1" 98#0#'(""- Ob #''8#& -):)-"'- 2)&&
5*." (* #' "'- #'- (1" +1#0"+ 2)&& #++8." #
.#03"( :#&8"7
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
88/110
(10*891 .*0" S #'- .*0"
+"580" S >*6+7YVYQ* =#04 (1" >*6+
1#:" '*( .#("0)#&)H"-7
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
89/110
2*03"0+ =0*. ")91( 1*8+"1*&-+ (*&- 8+ (1#(
(1"/ 1#- 6""' 8+)'9 (1" '- +)'5" (1")0
90#'-%#0"'(+G #'- 90"#(;90#'-%#0"'(+G
()."4 21"' )( 2#+ 9):"' (* =#.)&)"+ 6/ (1"
#'
(*9"(1"04 #&+* -"+50)6"- (1" "N("'( *= (1"
(* 6" #6&" (* 90*2 "'*891 (* +( +)N4 ")91(
Y\J
!1" '- 2#+ '*( +800"'-"0"- 2)&&)'9&/7 c'
+":"0#& %'(#()*'+4 2*03"0+ -"+50)6"- 1#:)'9
2)(1*8( +855"++?
,' )'("0:)"2+ 2)(1 # 90*8% *= T\ 2*03"0+ )'
R#3#>#'G+
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
90/110
C( X#(1)38&)4 2*03"0+ -"+50)6"- # %0*(0#5("-
+(0899&" *:"0 (1")0 '-7 C55*0-)'9 (*
#55*8'(+ =0*. .8&()%&" )'("0:)"2+4 6"(2""'
YI #'- Y\ 1*8+"1*&-+ &*+( (1")0 '- (* #0" 5800"'(&/ *%"0#()*'#&E7 K1"' (1"/
(1" 5*.%#'/7 !1" 5*.%#'/ 6"&*'9+ (* /*84
Y\Y
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
91/110
_#'#9"0+ -)- '*( -"'/ (1" 1)+(*0)5#&
5*..)(."'( *= '- (* 2*03"0+4 68( (1"/
)'+)+("- (1#( (1" #&&*5#()*' 2#+ %80"&/
-)+50"()*'#0/4 #'- 5*8&- 6" 0":*3"- #( #'/ ()."7
!1"/ #098"- (1#( 2*03"0+ 1#- '*( #5@8)0"- #'/
&"9#& *0 .*0#& 0)91( *:"0 21#( 1#- #&2#/+ 6""'
=*0."0 _#'#9)'9 P)0"5(*0 X#0-""% Q)'914 (1"
%0).#0/ #051)("5( *= (1" %' -80)'9 1)+ ("'80"
=*0 -"(#)&+4 1" #53'*2&"-9"- (1#( (1"0" 2"0"
X" 2#+ #-#.#'( (1#( '* =#&+" %0*.)+"+ *= Y\O
!1"0" )+ ":)-"'5" (* +899"+( (1#( (1)+ )+ '*(
(08"4 1*2":"07 C( +":"0#& %'(#()*'+4 2*03"0+
5)."- (1"/ 2"0" *=="0"- *'" %"0.#'"'( >*6
%"0 =#.)&/ (1#( 1#- &*+( '-4 (1*891 '* *'" 1#-
#5(8#&&/ 0"5"):"- )(7Y\U C( X#(1)38&)4 2" +%*3"
(* +*." 2*03"0+ 21* 1#- 6""' *=="0"- 5#+8#&
".%&*/."'( S #( &*2 2#9"+4 2)(1 '* +"580)(/
0"#+*'+7Y\eC( d#1*0#')4 (1" 0"+"#051 ("#. 2#+
+1*2' # >*6 *=="0 &"(("0 =0*. .#'#9"."'( (1#(
2#+ %#0()58&/ -"5"%():"4 %0*.)+)'9 '*( #
Y\[
!1" d#1*0#') "+(#("G+ ".%&*/."'( *=="0 1#+
+"&=;5*'(0#-)5(*0/4 +)'5" 8'-"0 ,'-)#'
(".%*0#0/ 2*03 )+ ).%"0.)++)6&" )= )( )+ =8&&;()."
#'- =*0 #' *%"';"'-"- %"0)*-7YOJQ)'5" (1" &"(("0
2#+ )' `'9&)+14 )( 2#+ #&+* )'5*.%0"1"'+)6&"
YOT !1" 5*'-)()*'+ *= 2*03
5#("9*0/ =*0 %'(#()*' 2*03? 1" 0"%*0(+ (1#( 1"
2*03+ +":"' -#/+ # 2""34 2)(1 '* -#/ *== #'- '*
*:"0()." %#/7 X" )+ %#)- ![Y # -#/ 68( '*( 9):"'
# %#/ +&)%7 C+ +(#("- )' (1" ".%&*/."'( &"(("04 1"
1" 5#' 8+" (1" "+(#(" 5&)')5 68( .8+( %#/ =*0 #&&
6" +*&- )' (1" .#03"(E7
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
92/110
;.
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
93/110
>:K"
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
94/110
KLF8 LS "J8
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
95/110
)' %#0()58 (1" ,LM #++"++."'( *= !#(# 2#+
YU\F):"' (1#( (1" ,LM 2#+ *%"0#()'9 *' (1" 6#+)+ *=
# (1)' 0"5*0- (1#( )'5&8-"- :)+)(+ (* *'&/ (10""
%'(#()*'+ *:"0 (10"" -#/+ #'- '* -*58."'(#0/
YUO!1"2*03)'9 #'- &):)'9 5*'-)()*'+ -*58."'("- )'
(1)+ 0"%*0( %*2"0=8&&/ "51* (1"+" 5*'5"0'+7
?V71MZ?? T!;K? 71;F
!1" ).%*0(#'5" *= (1" ".%&*/"" +1#0" *2'"0+1)%
%' )+ '*("- (10*891*8( (1" ,LM -*58."'(+7
!1)+ ="#(80" *= (1" CAAB )':"+(."'( 1"#-&)'"-
(1" %0"++ 0"&"#+"+ #'- *558%)"- # 5"'(0#& %"
)' (1" ,LMG+ -"+50)%()*' *= (1" %0*>"5(4 #&*'9+)-"
*= ("# %0*-85"-7YUU !1" ,LM -*58."'(+ (*8("-
6"=*0" #'/ ).%&"."'(#()*'4 (1" %0*>"5( %0*%*+#&
+899"+("- (1#( (1" CAAB #%%0*#51 6" 0"%&)5#("-
(10*891*8( (1" ("# )'-8+(0/7YUeC&(1*891 -"(#)&+
#0" #6+"'(4 (1" %0*%*+#& "':)+)*'"- # :"0/
.#+(3) +($)"-1 ="#0(" "#1( )# 3$%%#") - 5-*"
)"-+3-6)*#+D )+ :"0/ 3""' =*0 ,LM (* %#0()5)%#(" #+ #'
1*'"+( '"8(0#& 60*3"0 *' #55*8'( *= (1"
'#(80" *= (1" (0#'+#5()*' 21"0" )( )+ +"&&)'9+1#0"+ (* ".%&*/""+ #'- 2#'(+ (1)+ (* 6" #
=#)0 (0#'+#5()*' 6*(1 =*0 (1" ".%&*/""+ #'-
)(+ *2' "N)+()'9 +1#0"1*&-"0+7YU[
C.*'9 (1" 0)+3+4 (1" ,LM -)- '*(" (1#( (1" .*-"&
3*6
0"5*9')H" (1#( (1"0" 2"0" 9#%+ )' (1" %0*90#.4
".%&*/""+ )' 9*:"0'#'5" 5*8&- 6" # 5#8+" =*0
5*'+)-"0 #' ".%&*/"" ".%*2"0."'( %0*90#.
(* "'#6&" (1" ".%&*/""+ (* %/ # %#0()5)%#(*0/
YeJ"5(4 1*2":"04 )( #%%"#0"- (* 1#:" +)9'"- *==
*' (1" +#&" *= +1#0"+ #+ 1#:)'9 6""' # +855"++7 ,'
=#5(4 (1" ,LM %0"+"'("- # :"0+)*' *= (1" %0*5"++
(1#( 6"#0+ &)((&" 0"+".6'5" (* 2*03"0+G
#55*8'(+7 !1" `':)0*'."'(#& #'- Q*5)#& W":)"2
5*'5&8-"- (1#(
8'-"0(#3"' "N("'+):" 5*'+8&(#()*'+ *' (1" *(1"0+ )' (1" &*5#& 5*..8')(/4 )' #' "==*0(
(* 50"#(" # .*0" +8+(#)'#6&" %'(#()*'
.*-"&7 !1" -)+58++)*'+4 21)51 )'5&8-"-
%0"+"'(#()*'+ *' # ()."(#6&" *8(&)')'9 1*2
#'- 21"' (1" 51#'9" 2)&& 6" 8'-"0(#3"'4 1#:"
(#3"' -*'" D+)5E #( #&& &":"&+ *= ".%&*/""+7
!1" 5*'+8&(#()*'+ 1#:" (#3"' %" 6*(1
)'-)0"5(&/4 (10*891 2*03"0 0"%0"+"'(#():"+4
#+ 2"&& #+ -)0"5(&/4 6/ (1" .#'#9"."'( ("#.
#( "#51 %'(#()*'7 !1"+" 5*'+8&(#()*'+ 1#:"
YU\ MCc C%%0#)+#& W"%*0(4 C.#&9#.#("- A'(#()*'+ B).)("-4 j#'8#0/ e4 IJTY4 #( O;U7
YUO @47#( U7
YUU R((< (7,7 YUe
3$%"-'*(" IUJ4 #( I;Y7YU[ @47#( Y7
YeJ @47#( Y7
YeT Q)'5" (1)+ )+ #' 8'8+8#& 0*&" =*0 (1" ,LM (* 1#:" #++8."-4 '")(1"0 (1" +#="98#0- %*&)5)"+ '*0 (1" A"0=*0.#'5" Q(#'-#0-+ 9):" 5&"#0
%#0()58 0)+3+4 *0 #++"++ (1" #-"@8#5/ *= !#(#G+ 5*'+8&(#()*'+7
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
96/110
*55800"- *:"0 (1" +( U;e .*'(1+ (* 9):"
".%&*/""+ #-"@8#(" ()." (* 8'-"0+(#'- (1"
%*("'()#& ).%#5( *= (1" 51#'9" )' *2'"0+1)%
#'- -)+58++ (1")0 5*'5"0'+ -)0"5(&/ #'-
(1*0*891&/ 2)(1 2*03"0 0"%0"+"'(#():"+ #'-
.#'#9"."'(7YeI
,( )+ '*( 5&"#0 1*2 (1" ,LM 0"#51"- (1)+
5*'5&8+)*'4YeY 68( #+ -*58."'("- )' (1"
%0":)*8+ +"5()*'4 )( )+ -0#.#()5#&&/ 5*'(0#-)5("-
6/ 2*03"0 ("+().*'/7 _*0"*:"04 #55*0-)'9 (*
-"+50)%()*'+ =0*. .#'#9"."'( #'- 2*03"0+4
(1" ,LM 1#- 0"#+*' (* 3'*2 (1#( (1)+ -"+50)%()*'
2#+ )'5*.%&"("4 #( 6"+(7 d*( *'&/ 2"0" (1" "#0&/
%0*6&".+ 2)(1 (1" 0*&& *8( *= (1" +1#0" %' 2"&&
3'*2'4 #'- 2)-"&/ 0"%*0("- )' (1" ."-)#4 68( (1"
,LM 2#+ 0"%*0("-&/ )':*&:"- )' (1" 5*'+8&(#()*'+
2)(1 2*03"0+ (1#( 2"0" 58( +1*0( 6"5#8+" *=2*03"0 =08+(0#()*'7 !1" F"'"0#& _#'#9"0 #(
#' )'-)5#("- (* (1" 0"+"#051 ("#. (1#( #' ,LM
5*'+8&(#'( 1#- "'5*8'("0"- 2*03"0 0"+)+(#'5" (*
(1" +1#0" %' -)0"5(&/4 21"' 1" :)+)("- (1" =*80
%'(#()*'+ *' (1" d*0(1
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
97/110
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
98/110
#%%&)"- +*." *= (1" A"0=*0.#'5" Q(#'-#0-+
)' (1")0 #++"++."'( +)'5" 5*.%&)#'5" 2)(1
-*."+()5 #'- 8+" *= %0*("5():" 9"#0 #0"
6*(1 #--0"++"- )' (1" %0*>"5( #++"++."'(7 !1)+
9"+(80"4 1*2":"04 )+ '*( #' #-"@8#(" +86+()(8("
=*0 =*0.#& #%%&)5#()*' *= (1" A"0=*0.#'5"
Q(#'-#0-+4 +)'5" )( *6+580"+ (1" *6&)9#()*'+ *=
(1" ,LM .#/ '*( 1#:" 6""' 0"@8)0"- (*
+508()')H" !#(#G+ 5*.%&)#'5" 2)(1 -*."+()5
(1" Q#="98#0-+4 5*.%&)#'5" 2)(1 -*."+()5
2#+ '*( # 5&"#0 %0"0"@8)+)(" (* =8'-)'97 Y[T
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
99/110
5"0(#)' &":"& *= 5*.%&)#'5" 2)(1 *0 #'- +*5)#&
#&+* -0#2' =0*. (1" '8."0*8+ &":"&+ *= (1)0-
%#0(/ *:"0+)91( D%86&)54 8')*'4 #'- +(#'-#0-+
6*-)"+E 21)51 2"0" +""' (* #++80" 9**- *0
%0#5()5" )' (1" %'(#()*'+ 7 7 7 7 Q).)&/ 5)'9
2#+ -*58."'(#()*' (* +899"+( (1#( ,LM 2#+ )'
# %*+)()*' (* -0#2 0*68+( 5*'5&8+)*'+ #+ (* (1"
Y[U
,' &)91( *= (1" "N%"0)"'5" *= (1" 0"+"#051 ("#.4
)( +"".+ 8'&)3"&/ (1#( (1" ,LM .#-" #'/ +"0)*8+
"==*0( (* :)+)( (1" *0 &)'"+ *0 (* +%"#3 2)(1
2*03"0+ )'-"%"'-"'(&/7 F):"' (1" )+*()*' *=
(1" %'(#()*'+4 #'- (1" ()." 0"@8)0"- (* (0#:"&
(* #'- =0*. (1".4 (1" (10"" -#/+ (1#( (1" ,LM
+%"'( :)+)()'9 (10"" %'(#()*'+ 2*8&- 1#:"
5*'-)()*'+7 ,= (1" ,LMG+ %0#5()5" 2#+ 5*'+)+("'(
2*03"0+4 (1" :)+)(+ 2*8&- )' #'/ 5#+" 1#:" 6""'
+(0)5(&/ 5*'(0*&&"- 6/ .#'#9"."'( (* "'+80"
(1#( (1"0" 2#+ '* 8'+8%"0:)+"- 5*'(#5( 2)(1
2*03"0+4 #'- '* :)+)( (* (1" *0 &)'"+7Y[e
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
100/110
(1" %0*>"5(4 )( .#/ 1#:" 6""' .*0" #2#0" *=
W":)"2 )(+"&= 0":"#&+7VJI
C'*(1"0 9)'9 9#% )' (1" #++"++."'( )+ (1"
#6+"'5" *= #'/ ":#&8#()*' *= (1" %*("'()#&
(1" &*++ *= (1" '- (0#-)()*'#&&/ 8+"- 6/ 2*03"0+
=*0 90*2)'9 0)5" #'- :"9"(#6&"+ =*0 (1")0 *2'
5*'+8.%()*'7 !1" ,LMG+ A"0=*0.#'5" Q(#'-#0-+
0"9#0-)'9 %1/+)5#& *0 "5*'*.)5 -)+%"."'(
#'- )'=*0.#& 5).+ (* '-4VJY+* 2*03"0+G 5
*= ()(&" (* (1" '-+ 2*8&- '*( 1#:" +(**- )' (1"
2#/ *= #%%&)5#()*' *= ,LM %0*5"-80"+7 C--)()*'#&4
.*0" +(0)'9"'( %0*5"-80"+ #0" (0)99"0"- 21"'
-)+%"- %"0+*'+ #0" )'-)9"'*8+4 #+ )+ (1"5#+" 1"0"7VJV h"( (1"+" %0*:)+)*'+ #%%"#0 '*(
(* 1#:" 6""' 5*'+)-"0"- )' (1" 5*'("N( *= (1"
,;M ,MV71;GF:
,' _#/ IJTI4 (1" M*.%&)#'5" C-:)+*0f
c.68-+.#' DMCcE4 (1" )'-"%"'-"'( 0"5*80+"
."51#')+. =*0 (1" ,LM4 (**3 (1" 8'8+8#& +("%
*= )')()#()'9 # 5*.%&)#'5" #%%0#)+#& *= CAAB7
C55*0-)'9 (* (1" MCcG+ C''8#& W"%*0(4 (1"-"5)+)*' 2#+ .#-" -8" (* 5*.%)'(+ .#-"
*' (2* ("# "+(#("+ 21"0" :)*&"'( %0*("+(+ #'-
VJ\
C( (1" #%%0#)+#& +(#9"4 (1" MCcG+ )':"+()9#()*'
)+ &).)("- (* %0*>"5( -*58."'(+ #'- -*"+ '*(
)':*&:" +)(" :)+)(+7 d":"0(1"&"++4 (1" C%%0#)+#&
(1" ,LMG+ %0*>"5( +8%"0:)+)*' 6*(1 -80)'9 (1"
)')()#& #++"++."'( *= "':)0*'."'(#& #'- +*5)#&
+(#'-#0-+4 #'- -80)'9 (1" *8(60"#3 *= :)*&"'5"
#( A*2#) #'- d*2"0# d8--/4 (1" (2* "+(#("+
Q*5)#& W":)"24VJO VJU
!1" MCc C%%0#)+#& 0#)+"- %#0()58 5*'5"0'+
(1#( (1" ,LM #++"++."'( *:"0&**3"- :)*()*'+
*= A"0=*0.#'5" Q(#'-#0- I 0"9#0-)'9 B#6*0 #'-
K*03)'9 M*'-)()*'+7 !1" 5 *= )'-"%"'-"'(
8')*' 0"%0"+"'(#()*' )+ #&+* #&&8-"- (*4 #+ 1#:)'9
5#+" -".*'+(0#("+ 51#&&"'9"+ )' (1" #++"++."'(
#'- +8%"0:)+)*' *= AQI 0)+3+ (1#( "."09" =0*.
(1" '#(80" *= (1" 0"()*'+1)%+ 6"(2""' #' ,LM
5&)"'(4 )(+ 2*03"0+ #'- (1" 8')*'+ (1#( 0"%0"+"'(
VJe !1" C%%0#)+#&4 1*2":"04 -*"+ '*("N%&)5)(&/ #--0"++ (1" 2*03"0;+1#0"1*&-"0 %'
1"#0( *= (1" ,LMG+ )':*&:"."'( )' (1" %0*>"5(7
>K:K"M8KHJ
,' #--)()*' (* 0"&/)'9 *' !#(#G+ 0"%8(#()*'4 #'-
*' (1" #++8.%()*' (1#( *0 )'+%"5(*0#("+ )'
,'-)# "'+80" 5*.%&)#'5" 2)(1 -*."+()5 (1"
,LM #&+* 9#:" 90"#( 2")91( (* (1" =#5( (1#( (1"
!#(# %'(#()*'+ %#0()5)%#("- )' %0):#("4 .8&();
+(#3"1*&-"0 ."51#')+.+ (1#( #0" +8%%*+"-
VJY
VJV ,LM A"0=*0.#'5" Q(#'-#0- n U7TV DIJJOE7
VJ\ )' (1" %86&)5 %0*>"5( -*58."'(+4 (1" 0"=*0."- +#="98#0-+ #%%&/ (* (1" %0*>"5(7 MCc4 C''8#& W"%*0( IJTI4 #( OO7
VJO MCc C%%0#)+#& W"%*0(4 3$%"-'*(" YU\4 #( U7
VJU @47#( [STJ7
VJe @47#( TJ7
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
101/110
"#$ >"L0.1 )($ $#$.)3 )(-) 3$) "GG L"%A$% '%")$3)3
-) )($ 4"L$%- 4/99@ -.9 @ '-%)03-. 9$G$.9$% "G
?-)- -.9 6
-
8/12/2019 The World Bank, Tata and Enduring Abuses on India's Tea Plantations
102/110
(* "'+80" 1)91 +*5)#& +(#'-#0-+7 !1)+ )'5&8-"+
QCeJJJVJ[ #'- (1" `(1)5#& !"# A#0('"0+1)%7 C+
'*("- 50)()5#&&/ 6/ (1" MCc C%%0#)+#&4 (1"+"
(1" ,LMG+ #++"++."'( *= !#(#G+ 5*.%&)#'5" 2)(1
*0 +(#'-#0-+4 #%%#0"'(&/ +86+()(8()'9 =*0
(1" ,LMG+ *2' >8-9."'(7VTJ ,' 0"#&)(/4 21)&"
%0):#(" ."51#')+.+ +1*8&- +8%%&"."'( (1"
0"@8)0"."'(+ *= ,'-