there is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › ed...

67
There is no nal version Thursday, 22 March 12

Upload: others

Post on 29-Jun-2020

10 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

There is no !nal version

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 2: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Content changes

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 3: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

erratumcorrigendum

updatesenhancements

withdrawalsretractions

new editionsprotocol updates

notices of concern, etc.

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 4: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 5: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/478026aNature 478, 26-28 (2011) Science publishing: The trouble with retractions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 6: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

erratumcorrigendum

updatesenhancements

withdrawalsretractions

new editionsprotocol updates

notices of concern, etc.

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 7: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 8: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

When content changes, readers need to know

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 9: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Does this article have corrections?

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 10: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Does this article have corrections?

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 11: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 12: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 13: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 14: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 15: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 16: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 17: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 18: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 19: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 20: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 21: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 22: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 23: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 24: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 25: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 26: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 27: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

What is CrossMark?

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 28: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

A logo that identi!es a publisher-maintained copy of a piece of content

What is CrossMark?

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 29: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

A logo that identi!es a publisher-maintained copy of a piece of content

Clicking the logo tells you

What is CrossMark?

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 30: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

A logo that identi!es a publisher-maintained copy of a piece of content

Clicking the logo tells you

Whether there have been any updates

What is CrossMark?

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 31: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

A logo that identi!es a publisher-maintained copy of a piece of content

Clicking the logo tells you

Whether there have been any updates

If the content is being maintained by the publisher

What is CrossMark?

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 32: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

A logo that identi!es a publisher-maintained copy of a piece of content

Clicking the logo tells you

Whether there have been any updates

If the content is being maintained by the publisher

Where the publisher-maintained version is

What is CrossMark?

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 33: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

A logo that identi!es a publisher-maintained copy of a piece of content

Clicking the logo tells you

Whether there have been any updates

If the content is being maintained by the publisher

Where the publisher-maintained version is

Other important publication record information

What is CrossMark?

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 34: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 35: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 36: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 37: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 38: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 39: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 40: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 41: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 42: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 43: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 44: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 45: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

What kind of Publication Record information could be available?

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 46: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

What kind of Publication Record information could be available?

Funding disclosures - FundRef

Con"ict of interest statements

Publication history (submission, revision and accepted dates)

Location of data deposits or registries

Peer review process used

CrossCheck plagiarism screening

License types

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 47: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 48: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 49: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 50: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 51: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 52: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 53: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Participation is optional

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 54: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Participation is optional

Anything with a CrossRef DOI can have a CrossMark

Online-early content, but not pre-prints

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 55: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Participation is optional

Anything with a CrossRef DOI can have a CrossMark

Online-early content, but not pre-prints

Participants must

maintain their content

keep CrossMark metadata up to date!

adhere to logo display guidelinesThursday, 22 March 12

Page 56: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Participation is optional

Anything with a CrossRef DOI can have a CrossMark

Online-early content, but not pre-prints

Participants must

maintain their content

keep CrossMark metadata up to date!

adhere to logo display guidelinesThursday, 22 March 12

Page 57: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

What Does it Cost?

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 58: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

What Does it Cost?

Current content: 20¢

Backfile content: 2¢

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 59: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

What Does it Cost?

Current content: 20¢

Backfile content: 2¢

Current Content: published in the past two years.

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 60: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Display and Link the CrossMark Logo

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 64: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

http://crossmarksupport.labs.crossref.org

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 65: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Pilot now running

http://crossmarksupport.labs.crossref.org

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 66: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Pilot now running

Additional pilot participants welcome

http://crossmarksupport.labs.crossref.org

Thursday, 22 March 12

Page 67: There is no nal version - publicationethics.orgpublicationethics.org › files › u661 › Ed Pentz_presentation.pdf · updates enhancements withdrawals retractions new editions

Pilot now running

Additional pilot participants welcome

Launch in April 2012

http://crossmarksupport.labs.crossref.org

Thursday, 22 March 12