third billion fund proposal
DESCRIPTION
The Third Billion Fund proposal was developed by Columbia Impact Investing Initiative’s (CI3) team comprised by Evgenia Sokolova, Sandra Halilovic, Helene Roy, and Vladimir Olarte for the International Impact Investing Competition held by the Federal Reserve in San Francisco on April 13, 2012. The proposal was chosen as one of the finalists among 40 applications from top management and public policy schools around the world.TRANSCRIPT
Third Billion LLC
870 millionwomen between
ages 20 and 65
live outside the
economic system
*Source: Study by Booze & Co. Aguirre, DeAnne, and Karim Sabbagh. "The Third Billion."Strategy+Business May 2010
*
China
India
By 2025…*
*Source: "Home | The Third Billion.” <http://thethirdbillion.org/>.
Women in management positions have 35% greater return on equity*
Investing in women is smart economics
When at least 10 % of a country's girls attend school, its GDP
increases on average by 3%*
Women reinvest 90% of their income in families and communities*
*Sources: Study by the OECD, “DAC guiding principles for aid effectiveness, gender equality and women’s empowerment”, Endorsed by the DAC
Senior Level Meeting, December 2008
“The economic power of women” Calvert Foundation http://www.calvertfoundation.org/the-economic-power-of-women
No property rights No land rights Labor policy
discrimination Market restrictions Unequalaccess to education Unequal pay
Discrimination at workplace Poor childcare services
Lower status of women in society Poverty Lack of
critical resources Denied credit Fewereducational opportunities No access to market
Social restrictions Gender disparities Unableto participate in the supply chain Lack ofentrepreneurial opportunitiesUnequal access to vocational education Lack accessto basic banking services Limitedentrepreneurial skills No access to market
No property rights No land rights Labor policy
discrimination Market restrictions Unequalaccess to education Unequal pay
Discrimination at workplace Poor childcare services
Lower status of women in society Poverty Lack of
critical resources Denied credit Fewereducational opportunities No access to market
Social restrictions Gender disparities Unableto participate in the supply chain Lack ofentrepreneurial opportunitiesUnequal access to vocational education Lack accessto basic banking services Limitedentrepreneurial skills No access to market
No property rights No land rights Labor policy
discrimination Market restrictions Unequalaccess to education Unequal pay
Discrimination at workplace Poor childcare services
Lower status of women in society Poverty Lack of
critical resources Denied credit Fewereducational opportunities No access to market
Social restrictions Gender disparities Unableto participate in the supply chain Lack ofentrepreneurial opportunitiesUnequal access to vocational education Lack accessto basic banking services Limitedentrepreneurial skills No access to market
No property rights No land rights Labor policy
discrimination Market restrictions Unequalaccess to education Unequal pay
Discrimination at workplace Poor childcare services
Lower status of women in society Poverty Lack of
critical resources Denied credit Fewereducational opportunities No access to market
Social restrictions Gender disparities Unableto participate in the supply chain Lack ofentrepreneurial opportunitiesUnequal access to vocational education Lack accessto basic banking services Limitedentrepreneurial skills No access to market
No property rights No land rights Labor policy
discrimination Market restrictions Unequalaccess to education Unequal pay
Discrimination at workplace Poor childcare services
Lower status of women in society Poverty Lack of
critical resources Denied credit Fewereducational opportunities No access to market
Social restrictions Gender disparities Unableto participate in the supply chain Lack ofentrepreneurial opportunitiesUnequal access to vocational education Lack accessto basic banking services Limitedentrepreneurial skills No access to market
Fin
an
cia
l R
etu
rn
Legal Protection
Fund
Growth SMEs
Fund
Higher
Education
Fund
Social
Return
Return: 15%
Return: 7%
Return: 2%
Retirement and Pension Funds
Family Foundations
University Endowments
Equity
Debt
PRI
A Tiered Investment Fund
India
HO
LIS
TIC
AP
PR
OA
CH
Access to
Legal Protection
Access to
Capital
Access to
Higher Education
STAGGERED IMPLEMENTATION
Year1 Year 3 Year 7
� Economic Potential
Geographic Focus on Latin America
� Synergies
� Team Networks
60% of
Latin American
Women*
*Source: IHS Global Insight
Mexico
Colombia
Brazil
Enhance economic contribution of women by investing
in their education, entrepreneurship, and legal protection
THIRD BILLION LLC
Higher Education Fund
� Debt capital in financial
institutions and social
enterprises
� Providing student loans to low
income and talented women
� Promote programs that develop
entrepreneurial capacity
Country Tertiary School Enrollment Rate in 2010*
Mexico 26%
Colombia 40%
Brazil 41%
*Source: World Bank’s World Development Indicators
Phase I Phase II Phase III
DianaDiana
Mexican Mexican
Engineering StudentEngineering Student
� Fund Size: $60 million
� IRR (interest rate): 7%
� Investment Size Range:
$5 – $20 million
�Hold Period: 5 years
� Target: 2,000 students
�Management fee: 1.5%
Phase I Phase II Phase III
Oriana, ColombianOriana, Colombian
MBA Student in the USMBA Student in the US
Growth SMEs Fund
EvaniaEvania, Brazilian, Brazilian
Goldman’s 10,000 WomenGoldman’s 10,000 Women
Gardening Tools CompanyGardening Tools Company
� Equity capital in growing Small
and medium size companies
� Led by women or providing
valuable goods and services
to low-income and vulnerable
women� Areas: maternal health, housing,
nutrition, among others
Phase I Phase II Phase III
LeilaLeila
BrazilianBrazilian
CEO of Beleza NaturalCEO of Beleza Natural
� Fund Size: $50 million
� IRR: 15%
� Investment Size Range:
$0.5 – $5 million
�Hold Period: 5 to 7 years
� Life of Fund: 7 years
�Management fee: 2.5%
Phase I Phase II Phase III
Legal Protection Fund
SimoneSimone
Goldman’s 10,000 Goldman’s 10,000
Women FellowWomen Fellow
Gardening ToolsGardening Tools
� Debt (PRIs*)
� NGOs helping women� Accessing Institutions
� Using Property
� Getting a Job
� Building Credit
� Going to Court
Phase I Phase II Phase III
* Program Related Investments
RenataRenata
BrazilianBrazilian
Federation of Domestic WorkersFederation of Domestic Workers
Phase I Phase II Phase III
� Fund Size: $5 million
� IRR (interest rate): 0%-2%
� Investment Size Range:
$50,000 to $110,000
�Hold Period: 5 to 7 years
�Management fee: 0.5%
LauraLauraMexicanMexicanIndigenous Women’s HouseIndigenous Women’s House
3rd Billion Partners Brazil Mexico Colombia
Women Support
Networks
Incubators &
Accelerators
Events and Business
Plan Competitions
Impact Investors
Third
Billion
LLC
1. Women enrolled
2. Women completed
1. Female low-income clients (and total)
2. Female jobs maintained and created
3. Female shareholders
1. Women provided legal advice
2. Degree of change in legislation
Third Billion LLC will use GIIRs for:
• Transparency and accountability
• Monitoring and comparing impact
• Identifying potential investees
Monitoring and Evaluating Impact on Women
Thank You
Appendix
Summary: Structure and Timeline
Tier Mission Asset ClassExpected
ReturnRisk
Hold
PeriodMgmt Fee
T1Access to
EducationDebt 7%
Medium
to Low
3 to 5
years1.5%
T2Access to
CapitalEquity 15%
Medium
to High
5 to 7
years2.5%
T3Access to
Legal ProtectionPRI 2% Low
5 to 7
years0.5%
3 years 7 years 15 years
T1: Access to Higher EducationT1: Access to Higher Education
T2: Access to CapitalT2: Access to Capital
T3: Access to LegalT3: Access to Legal
Organisational Structure: Investment Team
Investment Committee
Managing Directors (2)
Business Development
(1)
VPs and Principals (2)
Analysts and Associates
(3)
CEO Advisory Board
(2/3)
CEO Advisory Board
(2/3)
Risks & Contingencies
Risk Contingencies
No secondary market
Lack of liquidity
� Companies with sustainable positive cash flows
� Diversification of investees (geographies, sectors
and individual assets.)
Lack of track record� Experienced management team
� Established approvals and monitoring process
� GIIRS rating
Mission Drift � Alignment of financial performance with
demonstration of social impact
Potential of a Loss� Diversified nature of fund’s borrowers, rigorous
selection criteria, track record and reputation of the
fund manager
The 3rd Billion Fund will provide PRI to institutions whose missions
address the following challenges*:
• Accessing Institutions: improve women’s ability to interact with public authorities and
the private sector in the same way as men
• Using Property: improve women’s ability to access and use property based on the
ability
• Getting a Job: reduce restrictions on women’s work, such as prohibitions on working
at night or in certain industries. This indicator also covers laws on work-related
maternity and paternity benefits, retirement ages, sexual harassment and equal pay
for equal work
• Building Credit: reduce minimum loan thresholds in private credit bureaus and public
credit registries, and improves tracking bureaus and registries that collect information
from microfinance institutions;
• Going to Court: improve the ease and affordability of accessing justice (small claims
courts, as well as a woman’s ability to testify in court and initiate court
proceedings.
Example - Improving Legal Representation
* Source 1: Study by IFC. “Removing Barriers to Economic Inclusion.” Women, Business and the Law 2012
* Source 2: UN Women Report. “Progress of the World’s Women: In Pursuit of Justice.” UN Entity for Gender Equality 2011-2012
Multiplier Effect: With less legal gender differentiation,
more women work, own or run businesses*
Improving Legal Representation
* Source: Study by IFC. “Removing Barriers to Economic Inclusion.” Women, Business and the Law 2012
Sandra HalilovicEvgenia SokolovaGenia is pursing a Masters of Public
Administration degree in
Development Practice at Columbia
University. Previously, Genia
worked as a Vice President of
Credit Portfolio Management and
Research in the Natural Resources
Team at JP Morgan Chase.
She graduated from Mount Holyoke with a Bachelor’s
degree in Economics (cum laude) and received an
International Relations Certificate from Sciences Po in
Paris. Originally from Moscow, Russia, Genia lived in
Canada, the US, UK and France.
Sandra is a Masters of
International Affairs’ Candidate at
Columbia University, concentrating
in International Finance and
Economic Policy (Finance track).
Vladimir is a Masters of Public
Administration’s Candidate at
Columbia University, concentrating in
Economic and Political Development.
Currently, he also serves as President
of Columbia Impact Investing Initiative
and Director of the Center for Social
Entrepreneurship HUB Bogota.
Helene is a Masters of International
Affairs’ Candidate at Columbia
University, concentrating in
Sustainable Energy Policy. Prior to
her current studies, she received a
Masters degree
Vladimir OlarteHelene Roy
Sandra carries 5 years of professional experience, working in
investment banking in New York and London, in emerging
market consulting, and for the World Bank’s International
Finance Corporation.
She graduated from the University of Virginia's McIntire
School of Commerce with a B.S. in Commerce, concentrating
in Finance. Originally from Bosnia, Sandra lived in Croatia,
Norway, the US, and UK.
Prior to attending the MPA program, Vladimir worked for
5 years as a consultant at Kaiser Associates Latin America
and 2 years as the Lead Consultant of Invest Hong Kong in
South America. Originally from Colombia, Vladimir has
lived in Brazil, the US, China, and South Africa.
in Management from Audencia Nantes School of
Management in France.
Helene has 3+ years of professional experience in the
investment management industry most recently at UBS
and Amundi Alternative Investments.
Helene is originally from France.