time for legal counsel to step up to the sustainability plate
DESCRIPTION
Author - Professor David WheelerTRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Time for Legal Counsel to Step Up to the Sustainability Plate](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022020307/563db8c7550346aa9a96ddca/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
7/17/2019 Time for Legal Counsel to Step Up to the Sustainability Plate
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/time-for-legal-counsel-to-step-up-to-the-sustainability-plate 1/2
Time for Legal Counsel to Step Up to the Sustainability Plate
For two decades now, the ‘leadership case’ for sustainable business has been made in UN conferences,
popular management books, scholarly articles and professional fora. Pretty well every executive
function of the firm from CEO and CFO to Director of Operations and Director of Communications has
been examined for ‘sustainability fit’ and the special contribution the role might make to the
transformation of business in line with sustainability principles.
In a 2011Financial Times article, Anthony Goodman even mused on the prospects for the newphenomenon of the ‘Chief Sustainability Officer’ becoming a stepping stone to the CEO job, such was
the need for leadership skills, capacity for innovation and technical knowledge required by a CSO. So it
is intriguing that in their current ‘Lessons from Leaders’ series examining the roles of ten C-suite players
in sustainable business, Accenture completely overlooks one vital role from consideration – that of the
General Legal Counsel.
In February this year the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development published a series of think
pieces on The Responsible and Sustainable Business: HR leading the way in an attempt to galvanise the
HR profession into a more strategic contribution to the sustainability agenda. If sustainability is a
complex and context-specific concept involving the interplay of organisational leaders, corporate values
and employee belief systems, then the guardians of pay, performance and organizational development
must surely be part of the transformation.
We should wish the CIPD well in their campaign because “look out, here comes HR” is another standing
joke of corporate life, mischievously captured by Dilbert inventor Scott Adams in his character Catbert –
the evil HR director.
So who is going to be brave enough to galvanize the legal profession and what would be the benefits?
Earlier this year I attended a private meeting of four general legal counsels representing very diverse
corporations with the purpose of considering exactly these questions. The meeting was convened by
Bond Pearce LLC, a leading UK law firm with a values-based interest in the topic.
Of course it is not difficult to interest lawyers in issues of immediate risk: legal compliance on
Environment, Health and Safety, oversight of human rights standards in the supply chain, IP protection,
due diligence during mergers and acquisitions, and the Bribery Act. But if the business case for
sustainability is increasingly about new products, new markets and future uncertainties, what is the role
of lawyers in helping companies navigate that terrain?
![Page 2: Time for Legal Counsel to Step Up to the Sustainability Plate](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022020307/563db8c7550346aa9a96ddca/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
7/17/2019 Time for Legal Counsel to Step Up to the Sustainability Plate
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/time-for-legal-counsel-to-step-up-to-the-sustainability-plate 2/2
We found that there was a strong consensus – at least among our small sample of enlightened lawyers –
that compliance is a given. The contribution which really should matter from a legal perspective
involves issues of competitive strategy, enabling new market developments, balancing comparative
ethical values (e.g. in diverse international markets), and reputation management).
Exploring a series of real life case studies from a forthcoming book1
it was not difficult to see where anincisive legal mind could add enormous value. For example we considered the case of Nina (not her real
name), who until recently worked for a global mining company. The company proclaimed publically that
sustainable development was very important to them. However, it was increasingly clear to Nina that
there were many internal barriers to incorporating sustainability principles into the business.
While some members of Nina’s company tried to change how the company built and operated mines to
reflect basic social and environmental responsibility values, most held to traditional mining engineering
assumptions. In Nina’s experience, the dominant mindset of her senior colleagues was to seek the
highest rate of return with little regard for resolving issues in a ‘win win’ way. And so the company, its
leaders and its workers appeared to her to be stuck in a constant identity crisis.
In her words, Nina’s work was eventually: “relegated to the metaphorical dark corner of the basement.
Our work was not supported, recognized, nor communicated to key people because it was considered,
by many managers, to be subversive to the company’s real goal – making money.”
It did not take our meeting with General Counsel very long to decide that in such situations, a proactive
lawyer would very quickly identify the risks to corporate reputation from whistleblowers and local
communities if such contradictions were not addressed. Access to mineral resources and project
finance could vaporise very rapidly if such disconnects persisted, and so legal counsel must be ready to
act as the ‘ethical conscience of the company’.
A suitably smart lawyer might work with her C-suite colleagues and the Human Resources function to
help role model authentic and reflective leadership values and behaviours within the organization for
the sanity of all internal and external stakeholders. And finally, a really forward thinking general counsel
would be anticipating future legal and socio-political trends to help the company’s longer term resilience
and competitiveness.
Professor David Wheeler
Pro Vice-Chancellor (Sustainability) and Dean of Plymouth Business School
This article will appear in the forthcoming edition of Croner Environment.
1 See Kurucz et al 2012. Reconstructing Value: Leadership skills for a sustainable world , University
of Toronto Press.