to design is to dissent

23
To design is to dissent

Upload: ricardo-sosa

Post on 27-Jun-2015

453 views

Category:

Technology


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Some views on the relationship between design & dissent (mostly opinions from my students)

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: To design is to dissent

To designis

to dissent

Page 2: To design is to dissent

A key element: dissent is not only to be in disagreement with someone else. It is to go against a majority.

This is a defining condition

Page 3: To design is to dissent

In Spanish, 'disentir' and 'diseñar' are adjacent in

the dictionary

- Benjamin Valencia

Page 4: To design is to dissent

“Being able to recognise where and how to dissent is a decisive skill for any designer who wants to

innovate”

- Miguel Angel Montiel

Page 5: To design is to dissent

“When innovating in society, a balance should exist... we must consider the consequences that science and technology

may bring”

- Karen Resendiz

Page 6: To design is to dissent

http://www.elche-cola.com/

Page 7: To design is to dissent

Renata Montante

Page 8: To design is to dissent

“Resistance to change is (strong) because all

changes have (unexpected)

consequences”

- Teresita Suarez

Page 9: To design is to dissent

“We are committed to a better world, and dissent...

can be the beginning to act”

- Teresita Suarez

Page 10: To design is to dissent

- Elizabeth Sanchez

http://www.businessweek.com/managing/content/aug2008/ca20080820_960713.htm

“Yes, we have a responsibility to speak up when we are upset by what's going on in the world, but there are better and worse ways to do it, from both ethical and practical perspectives. The goal of any protest is a moral one: to make things better.”

Page 11: To design is to dissent

“Dissent is the key to a great power to propose

reasons and arguments to promote change”

- Juanjo Navarro

Page 12: To design is to dissent

“Complaining focuses on the problem, dissent is the root of the answers to that

problem”

- MA Macias

Page 13: To design is to dissent

“In all successful cases, the acceptance of new

ideas takes several years. They were rejected and modified during those

years”

- Mayela Magaña

Page 14: To design is to dissent

http://www.hup.harvard.edu/catalog/SUNWHY.html

Page 15: To design is to dissent

Societies do need dissent

Page 16: To design is to dissent

But dissent is often punished

Page 17: To design is to dissent

In your social group:

Is it cool to dissent?

Page 18: To design is to dissent

Dissenters are:

- punished before the change- praised after the change

Page 19: To design is to dissent

Too much dissent brings chaos

Too little dissent brings conformity

Page 20: To design is to dissent

What is an adequate dosis

of dissent?

Page 21: To design is to dissent

http://www.barewitness.org/photoalbum/NoWar.jpg

What is an adequate dosis of protest?

Page 22: To design is to dissent

http://vivirmexico.com/

Page 23: To design is to dissent

Freedom fighter? Terrorist?

Terrorist? Freedom fighter?