today’s trends in air barriers - · pdf filetoday’s trends in air barriers ......
TRANSCRIPT
10/26/2010
1
Today’s Trends in Air Barriers
• Fred Kramer, Building Envelope Solutions Team
• Marcy Tyler Technical Applications Manager• Marcy Tyler, Technical Applications Manager
A conservative estimate of building envelope failure is 3-5%
Building Envelopes Today
• N.A. building envelope repair is a multi-billion dollar industry.
• Most problems are moisture-related, caused by air or moisture leakage.
• Most façade problems relate to terminations d ti d t il
© 2008 Tremco Inc.
and connection details.
• 70% of all construction litigation is related to façade leakage.
10/26/2010
2
90% of the time, it comes down to the transitions and terminations
A f il i t d d ff t th
What Causes Building Envelope Failure?
A failure in one component can and does affect other components in the building
© 2008 Tremco Inc.
The Evolution &&
Building Science Of
Air BarriersAir Barriers
10/26/2010
3
Premature Deterioration Of 1970- 1980’s Led To Adoption Of Air Barrier Codes
Northern Climates Were Prone To Greater Deterioration
10/26/2010
4
The Uncontrolled Escape Of Warm Interior Air To The Exterior Was The Issue
Lack Of Continuity Of The Envelope Played The Major Role In The Damage
10/26/2010
5
Window, Roof, Soffit Intersects All Proved To Be Trouble Areas
Older Buildings May Not Have Leaked Water, But They Leaked Air!
10/26/2010
6
In Some Cases Severe Air Leakage lead to Complete Re-Cladding
Past Building Practices Focused More On Water Shed Versus
Continuous Air Seal
10/26/2010
7
Energy Loss And Wall Damage Were Caused By Air Leakage
Poor Quality Mortar Joints Added To The Outbound Air Flow
10/26/2010
8
Assembly Transitions Lacked Durable Air Seals
Seals Were Not Made Around Penetrations
10/26/2010
9
Excess Mortar Prevented Drainage Of The Cavity Wall
Evolution Of The Air Barrier
These Older, Deficient Building Practices
And
A Federal Mandates For Energy Efficient Buildings….. Various Energy Acts 2005 to 2009g gy
Created A Demand For Air Barriers.
10/26/2010
10
NIST Study Confirmed ThatA Continuous Environmental Separation –Interior To Exterior Provided a 5 To 8 Year
Payback In Energy Savings!Payback In Energy Savings!
Air Barriers Started Out As …. “THE WILD, WILD WEST!”
WITH MUCH CONFUSION, THERE WAS A STAMPEDE BY MANUFACTURERS TO GET
PRODUCTS TO MARKET!
10/26/2010
11
A Multitude Of Air Barrier Products
Air Barrier Evolution
• Canada – NABA-1995 ABAA Ai B i f A i• ABAA Air Barrier of AmericaAssociation Nov/2000.
• MA Energy Code July 2001• WI 2002• MI• RI• GA• MNMN• FL
Under consideration: NY, NC, SC, IL.
10/26/2010
12
Air Barrier Evolution
• Standards
• Testing Protocols
Air Barrier Guide Specifications Developed• Air Barrier Guide Specifications Developed
Air Barrier Evolution
• Membership• Technical Committee• Education and Outreach Committee• House wrap CommitteeHouse wrap Committee• NEW – Transition Materials Committee• Industry initiatives
10/26/2010
13
300
Membership Growth2009: 2492010: 257ABAA
100
150
200
250
300
Membership Numbers
0
50
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
10/26/2010
14
130 Approved Contractors In 2009155 Approved Contractors In 2010
Growth Of ABAA Approved Contractors
100
120
140
160
Approved Contractors
0
20
40
60
80
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Approved Contractors
Statistics On QAP Participation - Training
10/26/2010
15
Statistics On ABAA Specified Projects
ABAA Specified Projects 2009:3942010:301
200
250
300
350
400
ABAA Specified Projects
0
50
100
150
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
ABAA Specified Projects
THE WILD, WILD WEST IS BEING SETTLED!
10/26/2010
16
Regional Differences In Construction May Cause Confusion
• Some Current, Regional Practices Are Not “Best Practice”.
• Best Practice Calls For The Containment And Conditioning Of The Inside Air.
Only Insulating Between Studs
Is Not A Best Practice.
10/26/2010
17
• Insight The Perfect Wall By Joseph W. Lstiburek, Ph.D., P.Eng., Fellow ASHRAE
Best Practice – The Perfect Wall
Cladding
Control LayersInsulation
Bulk water
Structure
Air & Vapor
Insulation
Climate Zones
10/26/2010
18
ASHRAE - Vapor Drive Zones
N o r th e rn C o ld C lim a te - V a p o r D r iv e In te r io r to E x te r io r
M o d e r a te C lim a te - V a p o r D r iv e E q u a l B o th D ire c tio n s
H o t/H u m id C lim a te - V a p o r D r iv e E x te r io r to In te r io r
ASHRAE
Class I Vapor Barrier 0.1 perm or less
Class II Vapor Barrier 1.0 perm or less and greater than 0.1 perm
American Society of Heating, Refrigerating, and Air-Conditioning Engineers
Class III Vapor Barrier 10 perm or less and greater than 1.0 perm
ASTM E 96 Test Method A (Desiccant method or dry cup method)
Vapor impermeable 0.1 perm or less
Vapor semi-impermeable 1.0 perm or less and greater than 0.1 perm
Vapor semi-permeable 10 perm or less and greater than 1.0 permp p p g p
Vapor permeable Greater than 10 perm
Proposed classifications by Joseph Lstiburek, Ph.D., P.Eng. - Building Science Corporation
10/26/2010
19
• Vapor Permeable (Air Barrier)
Air Barriers Can Be: CONFUSING!
• Vapor Permeable (Air Barrier)
• Non-Vapor Permeable (Air & Vapor
Barrier)
• Insulation (providing air, vapor and thermal protection)
Spray Applied Polyurethane Foam
10/26/2010
20
Fluid Applied Air Barrier Membranes
Sheet Applied – Peel N Stick
10/26/2010
21
Which Is More Effective In Controlling Moisture?
Controlling moisture transport via air flow?g p
Or
Controlling vapor diffusion?
HINT!
WHY ?WHY ?
Moisture Movement Above Ground
The movement of moisture into a building
Diffusion vs. Air LeakageSource: Building Science Corporation “Builders Guide”
The movement of moisture into a building through the wall assembly above grade can take two main forms. The first is the slow transmission of water vapor through vapor diffusion, driven by pressure and temperature differentials. The second is the more sever movement of moisture-laden air through porous building materials, holes and/or penetrations in the building envelope.
Addressing moisture movement above grade byAddressing moisture movement above grade by air is the most significant vehicle in eliminating moisture in the wall. Moisture movement by air accounts for 70-90% of the moisture, while the remaining 10-30% is moved by vapor diffusion.
10/26/2010
22
Air Barrier Continuity Should Be Across The Entire Envelope
Air Barriers Must Be Continuous
10/26/2010
23
What Has The Industry Done To Insure Continuity?
The evolution of industry test standards……
Air Barrier Evolution
Testing of Air Barrier Materials
MATERIAL must have an air permeance of less 0.004 CFM/ft2 @ 1.56 lb/ft2
10/26/2010
24
ASTM E- 2178 Air Permeance Very Relevant To CMU
CMU Leaks Air Like A Sieve!
Air Barrier Evolution
Next Logical Step Forward
Test Assemblies vs. Component Materials
ASTM E2357-05
Standard Test Method for Determining Air Leakage of Air Barrier Assemblies
10/26/2010
25
Air Barrier Evolution
ASTM E 2357Ai L k f Ai B iAir Leakage of Air Barrier
ASSEMBLIES
ASTM E 331 Water Leakage
Air Barrier Evolution
ASTM E 2357Ai L k f Ai B iAir Leakage of Air Barrier
ASSEMBLIES
ASTM E 331 Water Leakage
10/26/2010
26
• D1970 (8.9) Self Sealability (Head of water test)
Air Barrier Evolution
S f B i
Air Barrier Evolution
• Surface Burning Characteristics of Building Materials
• NFPA Codes – Healthcare Construction
• Asphaltic-based materials willAsphaltic based materials will struggle
Photo courtesy of Omega Point Laboratories
10/26/2010
27
• ASTM E84 – Provides Surface Flame Spread & Smoke Density
Air Barrier Evolution
Smoke Density
Photo courtesy of Omega Point Laboratories
NFPA 285 - Evaluation of Fire Propagation Characteristics of Exterior Non-Load-Bearing Wall Assemblies Containing
Air Barrier Evolution
gCombustible Components
Photo courtesy of Dow Chemical White Paper – November 2009
Schematic – NFPA - 2006
10/26/2010
28
Air Barrier Evolution
• Architects and specifiers recognize the importance of an effective air barrier for a building’s energy efficiency, g gy yhealth and durability.
• ABAA requires this testing as part of the product approval process.
ASTM E2357 is a useful tool in testing and evaluating• ASTM E2357 is a useful tool in testing and evaluating the performance of proposed air barrier assemblies under real-world conditions.
• ALMOST REAL-WORLD!
Air Barrier Evolution
• We have put the Air• We have put the Air Barrier Opaque wall surface under a microscope.
• Extremely low i tpermeance requirements
have been established
10/26/2010
29
The Opaque Wall Is Easy To Address
AIR BARRIERS – WHAT IS THE….
What they don’t want you to know!
What they don’t’ want you to know!
What they don’t’ want you to know!
What they don’t’ want you to know!
10/26/2010
30
The Dirty Little Secret Is -
• Most air leakage failures aren’t going to occur through the opaque wall.
• Gypsum Board doesn’t leak a lot of air to begin with.
• CMU when treated, isn’t going to leak an appreciable amount of air.
YOU CAN STILL HAVE A MAJOR AIR BARRIER FAILURE!
WHY?
OPAQUE WALL
It is not about the WALL!
IT is about how DISSIMILAR OPAQUE WALL
TO
WINDOW / CURTAINWALL
CONNECTIONS
COMPONENTS come together!
THE WEAKEST LINK!
10/26/2010
31
Focus On The Opaque Wall Is Not Enough
What about:• Deflection joints?• Deflection joints? • Window/curtain-wall connections?• Seismic requirements?• Wall have three dimensional returns?• Continuity of the roof/wall intersect? • What products/components/assemblies make these
critical connections?critical connections? • Can connections be made in the right sequence?• Proper details? • Tested Assemblies?
Durability Of Connection Points Of Are All Impacted By:
• Wind Drift• Deflection• Deflection• Creep• Thermal Movement• Moisture Expansion• Tolerances
How Long Will The Connections Last?
10/26/2010
32
Wind Drift Is Not One Directional In Nature
Courtesy of Karol Kazmierczak,
The Construction Specifier, Oct., 2008
Wind Drift Can Be As Much As 4” On A 10 Story Building
10/26/2010
33
Envelope Performance
• Are the seals at connection points durable?
• Will they stand repeated pressurized cycling?
• Will they withstand major wind events without damage?
H ll ill h i h d h i li l d• How well will they withstand changes in live load,
wind drift, creep, settlement and thermal stress?
Test Mock-up ASTM E2357
Plywood Does Not Equal Real World
Where should the focus be to deliver an effective REAL-WORLD Air Barrier?
10/26/2010
34
The Typical Options For Attachment Of Air Barrier To Other Cladding Components?
• Sealants (Typically the primary connection method)Sealants (Typically the primary connection method)
• Self-Adhered Membranes (S-A-M)
• Spray-Polyurethane Foams
• Cured and Uncured Rubber Products
• Silicone Sheet Products
• Others?
TYPICAL SEALANT CONNECTION TO AN AIR BARRIER MATERIAL
10/26/2010
35
Sealant Limitations For Envelope Connections
• Limited by a maximum and minimum operable joint size• Limited by a maximum and minimum operable joint size.
• Limited by the amount of movement at the connection points.
• Limited by possible lack of compatibility with rubberized asphalt membrane or other sealants.
Limited by another dirty little secret!
THE DIRTY LITTLE SECRET?
Many sealants do not adhere to the polyethylene backing layer of many self-adhered
THE DIRTY LITTLE SECRET?
membranes!
10/26/2010
36
Sealant Limitations For Envelope Connections:
• Understanding performance on the polyethylene fil f SAM i iti lfilm of SAM is critical:
• Polyethylene is a natural bond breaker for sealants.
• Compatibility has two different meanings!S l t d P l th l t i ll tibl– Sealants and Polyethylene are typically compatible.
(They do not have an adverse effect on one another.)
– But many sealants do not adhere to polyethylene.
– There is variability in the composition of polyethylene.
10/26/2010
37
Best Adhesion
Sealant Limitations For Envelope Connections:
10/26/2010
38
Sealant Limitations For Envelope Connections:
• The industry has left a• The industry has left a void as to how critical connections are made:
– Termination mastic and LM products are not sealants.
AB M f t h– AB Manufacturers have typically pushed off issue to sealant manufacturers.
– “By others” further clouds the issue.
Poor
Adhesion
10/26/2010
39
• ABAA suggests - Single Source is BEST.
Sealant Limitations For Envelope Connections:
gg g
• Why is this important?
If you leave it to chance - then it is likely you will not get the best combination of products!
Sealant Limitations For Envelope Connections:
OKAY!
But remember, sticking to polyethylene is only thefirst hurdle:
• Other issues also impact sealant performance• Other issues also impact sealant performance.
• Other issues limit their use.
10/26/2010
40
Sealant Limitations For Envelope Connections
• Are you relying on the perfect ¼” to ½” inch bead
of sealant to make the all the critical connections?
• Air barrier connections are not the perfect shape!
The perfect hour glass shape.
Sealants May Not Effective For Spanning Larger Gaps
A two inch wide exterior sealant joint viewed from the interior.
10/26/2010
41
Exterior “Cosmetic Seal”
Sealant Limitations For Envelope Connections
Primary sealant line must traverse across mill finish closure plate and shop applied silicone sealant.
Primary (inside) seal was installed from the exterior. Intimate contact could not be made with the substrates or backer rod.
Sealant Limitations For Envelope Connections
Viewed from interior side after removal of backer rod.
10/26/2010
42
Sealant Limitations For Envelope Connections -High Stress Joints
Air Temperature Surface Temperature
Rapid thermal expansion can make sealant installation an impossibility.
Sealant Limitations For Envelope Connections -High Stress Joints
Corners – A very high stress area with multi-directional movement.
10/26/2010
43
Self-adhering Membranes (SAM)
• Spin offs of below grade waterproofing technology. p g gy
• Designed to be full-adhered to:
– Structural
– Smooth surfaces
– Accommodate 1/16”
fof crack movement
– Bridge ¼” gap ONLY
Limitations Of Self-adhering Air Barrier Membranes
• All membrane manufacturers have
stated that SAM
should not bridge over gaps, voids
¼ to ½” in width
1” to 1 1/4”
¼ to ½ in width unsupported
10/26/2010
44
SELF ADHERED MEMBRANES ARE NOTINTENDED TO SPAN UNSUPPORTED GAPS
Manufacturers Typically Require A 3” LapA Misuse Of The Products
Dissimilar movement rates caused fish mouths.
Lack of seal at attachment point with minimal surface area.
caused fish mouths.
10/26/2010
45
Self-adhering AB Membranes Must Be Held Back From The Exterior Plane Of Facade
Hmmm...
Who’s sealant is this?
Who’s membrane is this?
Who’s responsible
when it leaks?
Pathways for air & water leaks.
Self Adhered Membranes Are Not Intended For Origami Tie-Ins
As value engineered
10/26/2010
46
Silicone Sealant Precludes The Use Of ASelf Adhered Membrane As A Connection
Compatible?
Asphaltic Mastic
Structural Silicone
4 Sided Structural Glazing
Air Barrier Membranes As An Unsupported Connection
M Sh d W t B t Th Will L k Ai• May Shed Water, But They Will Leak Air.
• Should Only Be Used For Their Intended Purpose.
• Do Not Have The Lateral Movement Capability Required For A Durable Seal.For A Durable Seal.
10/26/2010
47
Polyurethane Spray Foam Air Barrier
Polyurethane Foam Limitations For Envelope Connections
Drying Shrinkage
10/26/2010
48
Polyurethane Foam Limitations For Envelope Connections
Cracks in foam due to movement of pre-cast panels.
Polyurethane Foam Limitations For Envelope Connections
Spray Foam does not prevent water infiltration.
10/26/2010
49
Polyurethane Foam Limitations For Envelope Connections
Typically Foam yp ySystems will utilize SAM by other manufacturers.
Polyurethane Foam Limitations
If foam is to be primary AB Seal ask:
• What Testing Has Been Done (ASTM 2357)?
• Chemical and Adhesive Properties?
• Long-term drying shrinkage?
• Dynamic Movement Capability
• Weather Limitations For Installation?Weather Limitations For Installation?
• Compatibility With Other AB Seals?
10/26/2010
50
The Evolution Of Engineered Transition Assemblies
How Do You Handle Special Transitions?
2” +
10/26/2010
51
Note That Curtain-wall Race Was Milled Off To Maintain Continuity
Custom Extruded Silicone Sheet Adhered With Low Modulus Silicone Sealant
10/26/2010
52
This Condition Lead To The Development Of Pre-molded Silicone Corners
Evolution/Developments In Tested Silicone Sheet Transition Assemblies:
• Ribbed design improved sealant adhesion layerlayer.
• Thinner silicone sheet for greater visual over-site and workability.
• Adapter bar for attachment to various custom assemblies.
• Three basic design options.
• Pre-Molded corners to eliminate seamed overlaps that are prone to pull apart.
10/26/2010
53
Silicone Engineered Transition Assemblies
Evolution Of Translucent, Low Modulus,Silicone Sheet - Engineered Transition Assembly
10/26/2010
54
Engineered Transition Mock-up Assembly Mounted In Test Chamber
Test Procedure:
Engineered Transition Assembly
1. Install specimen into chamber
2. Air leakage test – ASTM E 283
3. Static water penetration test – ASTM E 331
4. Dynamic water penetration test – ASTM 501.1 @ 115 mph for 15 min.
5. Structural testing – ASTM E 330 @ 100 psf
6. Rack system 2” (three cycles) – AAMA 501.4 (Modified)
7. Repeat air infiltration – ASTM E 283
8. Repeat static water penetration test – ASTM E 331
9. Repeat dynamic water penetration test – ASTM 501.1 @ 115 mph
10. Repeat structural testing to destruction – ASTM E 330
10/26/2010
55
Racking Wall System 2 Inches – 3 Cycles
Assembly Racked 2 Inches – 3 CyclesAAMA 501.4 (Modified)
No Failures!
10/26/2010
56
ASTM E 330 -175 PSF Load. Repeated After Racking, Air, Static & Dynamic Water
Children’s Hospital Of Wisconsin West Bed Tower - Wauwatosa, Wisconsin
Shepley Bulfinch Richardson and AbbottShepley Bulfinch Richardson and AbbottOscar J. Boldt ConstructionOscar J. Boldt Construction
Trainor Glass / Fulton WindowTrainor Glass / Fulton Window
10/26/2010
57
Children’s Hospital Of Wisconsin
Self-Adhered Membrane to be covered with Metal panels
Children’s Hospital Of Wisconsin
Head Condition Jamb Condition
10/26/2010
58
Children’s Hospital of WisconsinMOCK-UP AT ATI LABS, YORK, PA.
Engineered Transition Assembly Curtain-wall To Adjoining Air Barrier Assembly.
Children’s Hospital Of WisconsinHead Connection
10/26/2010
59
Children’s Hospital Of Wisconsin
Continuous spans of 100’ without seams in ETA membrane.
Children’s Hospital Of Wisconsin
10/26/2010
60
University Of ChicagoResidence Hall, Dining Facility
University Of ChicagoResidence Hall, Dining Facility
Deflection Joint Installation
10/26/2010
61
University Of Chicago, Residence Hall, Dining Facility Treatment Of Deflection Joint
THE WRONG WAY!THE WRONG WAY!
THE WRONG WAY!
Deflection joint mock-up
THE CORRECT WAY
Engineered Assembly –Wall To Floor Isolation Seal
10/26/2010
62
Sherman Hospital Replacement Campus
Elgin, IL
Fulton Windows
Shepley Bulfinch Richardson and AbbottWalsh Construction
Contract Glaziers Inc.
Sherman Hospital Replacement Campus Roller Application Of Air Barrier Material
10/26/2010
63
Sherman Hospital Replacement Campus Six Story Curtain-walls
Attached To Adjoining Air Barrier With An Engineered Transition Assembly
Silicone Transition Strip Pre-mounted To Curtain-wall Opening
10/26/2010
64
10/26/2010
65
10/26/2010
66
10/26/2010
67
10/26/2010
68
Wisconsin Institute For Discovery And InnovationAir Barrier With Rain-Screen Design
Ballenger Arch & Uhlein Wilson Arch, WJE Wall Consultant Findorff-Mortenson CM Joint Venture
Wisconsin Institute For Discovery And Innovation
10/26/2010
69
Wisconsin Institute For Discovery And Innovation
Wisconsin Institute For Discovery And Innovation
10/26/2010
70
Wisconsin Institute For DiscoveryAnd Innovation
Wisconsin Institute For Discovery And Innovation
10/26/2010
71
Wisconsin Institute For Discovery And Innovation
ASTM E1183 – Smoke test verifies continuity of Air Barrier & Window Assembly.
Wisconsin Institute For Discovery And Innovation
10/26/2010
72
Remember The End Game:
“The Intent Is to Build Durable, Sustainable Building Enclosures.”
• Communication
Summary - A Durable Enclosure Requires
• Design Review
• Mockups
• Training
• Third Party Testing
• Complete Specifications
• A Team Approach
10/26/2010
73
Integrated Building Solutions
Connectivity:
• It’s not about the OPAQUE WALL• It s not about the OPAQUE WALL.
• It is about how wall, window, panels, components below grade, & roof come together!
• It is about addressing issues like sequence of installation and compatibility.
• It is about recognizing the need for durable, connective seals, not just seals that pass the mock-up!
Air Barrier to Window/Curtain Wall Connections
• Many Choices
• Understand Issues
• Compatible products
• Proper connectivity
• Cover yourself with good specifications
• Work with manufacturers who understand theWork with manufacturers who understand the
issues
10/26/2010
74
• Fred Kramer Building Envelope Solutions• Fred Kramer, Building Envelope Solutions Team, [email protected]
• Marcy Tyler, Technical Applications Group Manager, [email protected] oup a age , y e @ e co c co