transactions value by segment presented to: international society of hospitality consultants annual...
TRANSCRIPT
TransactionsValue by Segment
Presented to:
International Society of Hospitality Consultants
Annual Conference
October 20 – 23, 2005
San Diego, CA
Sales Comparables - 2005
Full Service Marriott
Residence Inn by Marriott
Hilton Garden Inn
Holiday Inn Express (Manhattan)
Marriott Hotel (suburban-midwest)
Executive Summary
• Opened in 1985, 236 rooms, 18,000 sq. ft. meeting/conference space, restaurant, lounge, fitness facility, abutting public golf course.
• Union labor, weak to flat market, stagnant room demand.
• Product Improvement Plan = +/- $5,500,000 (mandatory)
Financial Data
Gross Rev. $10,000,000
Room Rev. $5,900,000
NOI (after mgt./FFE) $1,000,000
Sales Comparables - 2005
Sale Price $9,000,000
Marriott Hotel (suburban – midwest)
w/out PIP w/ PIP
Sale Price P/Room $38,135 $61,444
Direct Cap. Rate 11% 6.9%
Room Rev. Mult. 1.52 2.45
Residence Inn by Marriott (suburban Northeast)
Executive Summary
• Opened in 1998, 156 extended stay rooms, 2,000 sq. ft. meeting space.
• Airport market, strong OCC. (77%), weak ADR ($73), new supply issues.
• Product Improvement Plan = +/- $1,200,000 (mandatory)
Financial Data
Gross Rev. $3,300,000
Room Rev. $3,200,000
NOI (after mgt./FFE) $1,000,000
Sales Comparables - 2005
Sale Price $11,500,000
Residence Inn by Marriott (suburban - Northeast)
w/out PIP w/ PIP
Sale Price P/Room $73,717 $81,410
Direct Cap. Rate 8.7% 7.87%
Room Rev. Mult. 3.6 3.97
Hilton Garden Inn (suburban Northeast)
Executive Summary
• Opened in 2000, 112 rooms, 2,500 sq. ft. meeting space.
• 50% Corporate / 50% leisure market, strong Occ. (72%), strong ADR ($152), very good physical condition, new supply issues. Pricing significantly higher than the “cost to replace”.
• Product Improvement Plan = +/- $600,000 (mandatory)
Financial Data
Gross Rev. $4,400,000
Room Rev. $4,100,000
NOI (after mgt./FFE) $1,650,000
Sales Comparables - 2005
Sale Price $17,750,000
Hilton Garden Inn (suburban Northeast)
w/out PIP w/ PIP
Sale Price P/Room $158,500 $163,850
Direct Cap. Rate 9.3% 8.99%
Room Rev. Mult. 4.33 4.47
Holiday Inn Express (midtown Manhattan)
Executive Summary
• Opened in August 2005, 124 rooms, 400 sq.ft. meeting space.
• 65% Corporate / 35% leisure market, strong Occ. (83% proj.), strong ADR ($220 proj.)
• 2005 performance for select, limited service product was 84.5% @ $232 ADR
• Non Union employees for construction and operations
Financial Data – projected for 2006
Occupancy 83%
Average Rate $220
Gross Rev. $8,450,000
Room Rev. $8,300,000
NOI (after mgt./FFE) $2,900,000 (35%)
Sales Comparables - 2005
Sale Price $36,500,000
Holiday Inn Express (midtown Manhattan)
Sale Price P/Room $294,354
Direct Cap. Rate 7.96% proj.
Room Rev. Mult. 4.40
Comparison By Product Type
$/Room Dir. Cap RR Mult.
Marriott Hotel
(Suburbs)
$38,135 - $61,444 11.0% - 6.9% 1.52 – 2.45
Residence Inn
$73,717 - $81,410 8.7% - 7.9% 3.60 – 3.97
Hilton Garden Inn
$158,500 – 163,850 9.3% - 8.9% 4.33 – 4.47
Holiday Inn Express
$294,354 7.96% (proj.) 4.40 (proj.)
In Summary
Transaction market remains very strongEquity abundant in every hotel product segment
Lenders are very aggressive
Doctors and Dentists not yet in the market
Pricing may be at PeakSingle digit Cap Rates in every segment
New supply additions in almost every market.
Concerns over the rise in interest rates, fuel oil and construction costs.