triage pulse oximetry and the chest x -ray opacity score

1
Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) was first documented in December of 2019. It is highly contagious and in March of 2020 the World Health Organization declared the outbreak as a pandemic due to its rapid global spread. Plain radiograph is often used in the initial evaluation of chest pain and dyspnea. It can be done portably. Additionally, it is widely available, inexpensive, and quick. The initially CXR in combination with vital signs and clinical assessment often guide important decision for patient care such as admission and intubation. BACKGROUND RESULTS Interrater reliability was low in our study. Future studies can compare scores of radiologist with ED physicians. DISCUSSION CONCLUSIONS Triage Pulse Oximetry and the Chest X-ray Opacity Score in ED Patients with COVID-19 Pneumonia Sushi Subburamu MD*, Eryka Bradley PA, Ruchika Darapaneni, Kewa Jiang, Robert Lis, Niloofar Sima, Denise McCormack MD, MPH* North Bronx Healthcare Network, Jacobi Medical Center and North Central Bronx Hospital Albert Einstein College of Medicine* METHODS In COVID-19 pneumonia there was weak correlation between triage hypoxia and pneumonia severity based on the CXR opacity score. Increased mortality was associated with older age, hypertension, dialysis, triage PO ≤ 85%, need for intubation, and CXR score ≥ 3. A retrospective chart review was conducted for patients seen in April 2020. Inclusion criteria consisted of adult ED patients who were admitted with COVID-19 pneumonia. Demographic information, Emergency Severity Index (ESI), triage PO, Body Mass Index (BMI), comorbidities and intubation rates were analyzed using chi-square and student's t-test. An EM attending and senior EM resident determined the CXR opacity scores in severity ranging from 0 to 6. A kappa score was generated to assess interrater agreement. A linear regression model was done to assess the correlation between triage PO and CXR scores. The primary outcome was mortality. REFERENCES Wasilewski P, Mruk B, Mazur S, et al. COVID-19 severity scoring systems in radiological imaging – a review. Pol J Radiol. 2020; 85:e361–e368. Toussie D, Voutsinas N, Finkelstein M, et al. Clinical and chest radiography features determine patient outcomes in young and middle-aged adults with COVID-19. Radiology. 2020; 297(1):e197-e206 THE CXR SCORE Various ways of scoring an CXR have been proposed dividing the lungs into either 4 or 6 sections. In our study each lung was divided into 3 zones as marked above. The top line is marked below the inferior wall of the aortic arch and the bottom line is marked below the right hilar structures. Each zone is then given a score of 0 or 1 based on whether opacities are present. CXR score range from 0-6. 306 patients met inclusion criteria Mortality was 21% 40.2% of patients were male Most patients were triaged as ESI 2 (36.3%) or ESI 3 (60.7%). The mean age was 61.9 ± 14.7 years The mean BMI was 30.1 ± 6.4 The mean triage PO was 88.7 ± 3.9. Pneumonia on CXR was 85.3% bilateral, 6.5% left and 8.2% right. 43.5% of patients were given CXR opacity scores ≥ 3. The kappa score for CXR score agreement was 0.47. The mortality group was associated with: Older age (70.9 ± 11.3 vs 59.3 ± 14.6; P<0.01) Hypertension (66.7% vs 49.2%; P <0.05) Dialysis (12.7% vs 4.5%; P <0.05) CXR score ≥ 3 (84.8% vs 62.5%; P <0.05) Triage PO ≤ 85% (48.4% vs 21.9%; P<0.01) Intubation (35.9% vs 10.3%; P<0.01) Smoking, BMI, asthma and diabetes were not associated with mortality. The R 2 correlation coefficient for triage PO and the CXR opacity score was 0.12. RESULTS (cont.)

Upload: others

Post on 28-Jul-2022

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Triage Pulse Oximetry and the Chest X -ray Opacity Score

• Coronavirusdisease2019(COVID-19)wasfirstdocumentedinDecemberof2019.ItishighlycontagiousandinMarchof2020theWorldHealthOrganizationdeclaredtheoutbreakasapandemicduetoitsrapidglobalspread.

• Plainradiographisoftenusedintheinitialevaluationofchestpainanddyspnea.Itcanbedoneportably.Additionally,itiswidelyavailable,inexpensive,andquick.

• The initiallyCXRincombinationwithvitalsignsandclinicalassessmentoftenguideimportantdecisionforpatientcaresuchasadmissionandintubation.

BACKGROUND

RESULTS

• Interraterreliabilitywaslowinourstudy.FuturestudiescancomparescoresofradiologistwithEDphysicians.

DISCUSSION

CONCLUSIONS

TriagePulseOximetryandtheChestX-rayOpacityScoreinEDPatientswithCOVID-19Pneumonia

Sushi Subburamu MD*, Eryka Bradley PA, Ruchika Darapaneni, Kewa Jiang, Robert Lis, Niloofar Sima, Denise McCormack MD, MPH*

North Bronx Healthcare Network, Jacobi Medical Center and North Central Bronx Hospital Albert Einstein College of Medicine*

METHODS• In COVID-19pneumoniatherewasweak

correlationbetweentriagehypoxiaandpneumoniaseveritybasedontheCXRopacityscore.

• Increasedmortalitywasassociatedwitholderage,hypertension,dialysis,triagePO≤85%,needforintubation,andCXRscore≥3.

• A retrospectivechartreviewwasconductedforpatientsseeninApril2020.

• InclusioncriteriaconsistedofadultEDpatientswhowereadmittedwithCOVID-19pneumonia.

• Demographicinformation,EmergencySeverityIndex(ESI),triagePO,BodyMassIndex(BMI),comorbiditiesandintubationrateswereanalyzedusingchi-squareandstudent'st-test.

• AnEMattendingandseniorEMresidentdeterminedtheCXRopacityscoresinseverityrangingfrom0to6.Akappascorewasgeneratedtoassessinterrateragreement.

• AlinearregressionmodelwasdonetoassessthecorrelationbetweentriagePOandCXRscores.

• Theprimaryoutcomewasmortality.

REFERENCESWasilewski P, Mruk B, Mazur S, et al. COVID-19 severity scoring systems in radiological imaging – a review. Pol J Radiol. 2020; 85:e361–e368.

Toussie D, Voutsinas N, Finkelstein M, et al. Clinical and chest radiography features determine patient outcomes in young and middle-aged adults with COVID-19. Radiology. 2020; 297(1):e197-e206

THE CXR SCORE

• VariouswaysofscoringanCXRhavebeenproposeddividingthelungsintoeither4or6sections.

• Inourstudyeachlungwasdividedinto3zonesasmarkedabove.Thetoplineismarkedbelowtheinferiorwalloftheaorticarchandthebottomlineismarkedbelowtherighthilarstructures.

• Eachzoneisthengivenascoreof0or1basedonwhetheropacitiesarepresent.CXRscorerangefrom0-6.

• 306patientsmetinclusioncriteria• Mortalitywas21%• 40.2%ofpatientsweremale• MostpatientsweretriagedasESI2(36.3%)orESI3(60.7%).• Themeanagewas61.9± 14.7years• ThemeanBMIwas30.1± 6.4• ThemeantriagePOwas88.7± 3.9.• PneumoniaonCXRwas85.3%bilateral,6.5%leftand8.2%right.

43.5%ofpatientsweregivenCXRopacityscores≥3.• ThekappascoreforCXRscoreagreementwas0.47.

• Themortalitygroupwasassociatedwith:• Olderage(70.9± 11.3vs59.3± 14.6;P<0.01)• Hypertension(66.7%vs49.2%;P<0.05)• Dialysis(12.7%vs4.5%;P<0.05)• CXRscore≥3(84.8%vs62.5%;P<0.05)• TriagePO≤85%(48.4%vs21.9%;P<0.01)• Intubation(35.9%vs10.3%;P<0.01)

• Smoking,BMI,asthmaanddiabeteswerenotassociatedwithmortality.

• TheR2 correlationcoefficientfortriagePOandtheCXRopacityscorewas0.12.

RESULTS (cont.)