truro college: cold war booklet 5
DESCRIPTION
HistoriographyTRANSCRIPT
22/09/2015
1
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
Wa
rTo
pic
: D
eb
ate
Why did the Cold War between the
superpowers emerge in the years to 1953?
• How and why have historians’ interpretations of the
causes of the Cold War differed?
• How valid are these different interpretations in seeking
to explain the causes of the Cold War?
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
Wa
rTo
pic
: D
eb
ate Who can we blame for the outbreak of the Cold War?
• Causes of the Cold War
TASK 1a: Write down as many causes as you can. Compare your list
with another student.
22/09/2015
2
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
Wa
rTo
pic
: D
eb
ate Who can we blame for the outbreak of the Cold War?
TASK 1b: Choose one of the causes and write down three events you
might use to help you explain how it created the Cold War. Compare your
list with another student.
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
Wa
rTo
pic
: D
eb
ate TASK 2
• Read pp.49-51 and make notes on how far the USA was
responsible for the Cold War
• Read sources D, E and F on pp.51-2 and complete a chart
like the one below:
Source Reasons in the
source for US
hostility to USSR
(include quotes)
Information from
own knowledge
that supports
source’s view
Information that
can be used to
argue against the
source’s view
Source D (p.51)
Source E (p.52)
Source F (p.52)
22/09/2015
3
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
Wa
rTo
pic
: D
eb
ate TASK 3
• Read pp.52-6 and make notes on Stalin’s motives for Soviet
expansion – use the section’s sub-headings to organise your
notes
• Read sources H, I and J on pp.57-8 and complete a chart
like the one below:
Source Reasons in the
source for the
causes of the
Berlin Blockade
(include quotes)
Information from
own knowledge
that supports
source’s view
Information that
can be used to
argue against the
source’s view
Source H (p.57)
Source I (p.57)
Source J (p.58)
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
Wa
rTo
pic
: D
eb
ate
• Historians disagree about why the Cold War happened and
who is to blame. Complete the chart below using pp.58-61
What does
this school
argue?
When was
this view
current?
Why was
this view
formed?
Value of
this point
of view
Criticism of
this point
of view
Liberal School
Revisionist
School
Post-revisionist
School
Soviet School
pre 1991
Russian views
since 1991
TASK 4
22/09/2015
4
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
Wa
rTo
pic
: D
eb
ate Which historical interpretation best explains why
the Cold War started?
• Read the Exam tip on p.63
• All viewpoints need to be tested for accuracy/validity
- Use your own knowledge to test the accuracy/validity of the
historian’s point of view
- Do not be frightened to disagree with historians – so long as you
explain why you disagree and give specific evidence
• Read handouts 16b Soviets Desire European Domination
and 16c Unit 3 B Question Mark Scheme
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
Wa
rTo
pic
: D
eb
ate TASK 5:
• Using Sources K, L, M and N, and your own knowledge, how far do
you accept the view of Source K that it was American foreign policy
that ‘crystallized the Cold War’?
• Read sources K, L, M and N on pp.61-2 and complete a chart like the
one below:
Source Arguments in the
source on the
causes of the Cold
War (include short
quotes)
Evidence from
own knowledge
that supports the
source’s argument
Evidence from
own knowledge
that challenges
the source’s
argument
Source K (p.61)
Source L (p.62)
Source M (p.62)
Source N (p.62)
22/09/2015
5
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
Wa
rTo
pic
: D
eb
ate Who caused the Cold War – the USA or the USSR?
TASK 6: Write a detailed essay plan to the following exam-
style question:
• Using Sources K, L, M and N, and your own knowledge,
how far do you accept the view of Source K that it was
American foreign policy that ‘crystallized the Cold War’?
How to structure your plan:
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
Wa
rTo
pic
: D
eb
ate Who caused the Cold War – the USA or the USSR?
Your essay plan should include:
• Introduction:
– outline the interpretations in the four sources; end with your answer (‘signpost’)
• (Four) main paragraphs:
– lead with the sources that agree with a particular interpretation. (Look for
opportunities where you can cross-reference, i.e. spot where more than one
source agrees with an interpretation)
– identify their interpretation
– use own knowledge to explain why the historian puts forward this particular
interpretation
– use own knowledge to evaluate the interpretation’s validity. (Remember to
contrast the interpretation discussed in each main paragraph with the claim/view
in the question, i.e. US foreign policy crystallised the Cold War)
• Conclusion:
– ATQ, explaining why with supporting evidence and referring to the sources
22/09/2015
6
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
Wa
rTo
pic
: D
eb
ate TASK 7:
• Use Sources S, T and U and your own knowledge. How far do you
agree with the view that Stalin’s foreign policy was a major
contributing factor to the emergence of the Cold War in the period
1945-50?
• Read sources S, T and U on pp.69-70 and complete a chart like the
one below:
Source Arguments in the
source on the
causes of the Cold
War (include
quotes)
Evidence from
own knowledge
that supports the
source’s argument
Evidence from
own knowledge
that challenges
the source’s
argument
Source S (p.69)
Source T (p.70)
Source U (p.70)
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
Wa
rTo
pic
: D
eb
ate Who caused the Cold War – the USA or the USSR?
TASK 8: Answer the following exam-style question on
pp.69-70 (you have 55 minutes):
• Use Sources S, T and U and your own knowledge.
How far do you agree with the view that Stalin’s
foreign policy was a major contributing factor to the
emergence of the Cold War in the period 1945-50?
22/09/2015
1
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
War
Top
ic:
Inte
rpre
tati
on
s Origins Of The Cold War
Three Major Western explanations for the Cold War
Orthodox (liberal) –product of aggressive/expansionist foreign policy of Soviet Union
Revisionist –result of provocation of USA
Post-Revisionist –accepts USA used economic power but also accepts Stalin an opportunist
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
War
Top
ic:
Inte
rpre
tati
on
s
Origins Of The Cold War
Two stages of Russian explanations for the Cold War
Soviet School (pre 1991) –product of American Economic Imperialism
Russian Views (post 1991) –emphasizes Stalin’s foreign policy was more than just defensive; partly aimed at spreading communism
22/09/2015
2
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
War
Top
ic:
Inte
rpre
tati
on
s Key interpretations
Origins of the Cold War
Ideological Confrontation
Great Power Rivalry
Mutual Misconceptions
Opposing national interests
Dollar Diplomacy
Aggressive Government
policy
Soviet Aggression
US Aggression
Personalities
Stalin
Truman
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
War
Top
ic:
Inte
rpre
tati
on
s
Key Interpretation: Ideological confrontation
• Ideological confrontation:
– Cold War inevitable conflict as capitalism and communism
fundamentally antagonistic
– Marxism-Leninism, official ideology of USSR, committed
Communist Party to world revolution to overthrow capitalism
– US economic success depended on free trade; Soviet economic
system rejected free markets and free trade
• Useful interpretation as explains East-West conflict before
Cold War …
22/09/2015
3
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
War
Top
ic:
Inte
rpre
tati
on
s Key Interpretation: mutual misconceptions
• Cold War came about due to mutual misconceptions and
different perspectives of the two superpowers
• Both superpowers motivated by desire to protect own
interests
• However, these actions misinterpreted as aggressive
policies designed to expand global influence
• E.g.,
– Soviet leaders saw Stalinisation of Eastern Europe as legitimate
actions to safeguard Soviet security; but US leaders interpreted
these actions as desire to dominate
– Similarly, Western initiatives, e.g. introduction of DM into Western
zone of Germany, viewed as provocative by Soviet leaders
• Therefore, Cold War developed due to series of
misunderstandings and overreactions
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
War
Top
ic:
Inte
rpre
tati
on
s
Key Interpretation: opposing national interests
• Cold War came about due to traditional Great Power
Rivalry and opposing national interests
• Both superpowers motivated by desire to protect own
interests – natural process of international relations
• E.g.,
– Stalinisation of Eastern Europe was legitimate action to
safeguard Soviet security after cost of WWII
– US development of economic and military interests in Europe and
Asia was legitimate development of foreign policy as the
world’s leading power after WWII
• Therefore, Cold War a natural development of power rivalry
and neither side ‘to blame’
22/09/2015
4
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
War
Top
ic:
Inte
rpre
tati
on
s Key interpretation: US dollar diplomacy
• US economic interests main reason for development of Cold
War
– Superpower conflict due to US desire to have political and
economic dominance in Western Europe and Japan. So Marshall
Plan a form of ‘dollar imperialism’ as US economic aid dependent
on political compliance
– Cold War developed due to concerns of US politicians to avoid
repeat of Great Depression. So Truman’s desire to promote trade
with Western Europe and Japan really an attempt to stimulate US
economy through trade
– Truman encouraged superpower tensions to justify massive
government spending on armaments to stimulate US economy
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
War
Top
ic:
Inte
rpre
tati
on
s
Key interpretation: Soviet aggression
• Cold War developed due to USSR determination to confront
US
– Communist takeovers in Eastern Europe
– Berlin Blockade
– Encouragement of communism in Asia (support for Chinese
communism, materiel support for North Korea in war)
22/09/2015
5
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
War
Top
ic:
Inte
rpre
tati
on
s Key interpretation: US aggression
• Cold War developed due to US determination to confront
USSR
– Truman Doctrine, Marshall Plan, US leadership of NATO seen
as USA asserting its power against Soviet influence
– US deployment of B-29 bombers in Europe in August 1948
interpreted as evidence of US aggression
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
War
Top
ic:
Inte
rpre
tati
on
s
Key interpretation: Stalin’s personality
• Stalin’s personality as main reason for development of Cold
War
– His feelings of insecurity
– His desire to dominate
– His willingness to do anything to safeguard USSR’s future
• Compelling evidence from Soviet documents released after
end of Cold War (1991)
– Memos from senior Soviet ministers, e.g. Maxim Litvinov, “There
has been a return in Russia to the concept of security in terms of
territory – the more you’ve got the safer you are”
• Stalin’s suspicions played a role in his Berlin policy
– He believed resurgent Germany posed significant threat to
USSR’s security
22/09/2015
6
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
War
Top
ic:
Inte
rpre
tati
on
s Key interpretation: Truman’s personality
• Truman’s personality as main reason for development of
Cold War
– Need to show strength to separate his presidency from FDR’s
legacy
– Mistrust/dislike of Stalin
– Open to persuasion by anti-communist and military-industrial
domestic pressures
• Personal policy intervention – Truman Doctrine
– Overly aggressive and provocative towards USSR?
– Attempt to rollback communism in Korea
How to answer Section B questions well …
Good Luck
Section B is about the origins of the Cold War between 1944 and 1953.
1) To answer these questions you must know in detail all the relevant main events – see textbook
chapters 1 and 2 – between 1917 and 1953 that help to explain how and why the Cold War
came about.
2) You must also be able to debate the different interpretations about the origins of the Cold War
– see textbook chapter 3. E.g.:
i) Can the Cold War be explained as ideological confrontation?
ii) Was the Cold War a traditional great power rivalry (sometimes this interpretation might
be referred to as ‘national interests’ or ‘geopolitics’)
iii) Was it simply a matter of Soviet or American aggression?
iv) Or finally, did it come down to personalities, i.e. uncompromising and inflexible leaders?
Suspicion and misperception?
(1) Here you should consider the roles played by Truman and Stalin's foreign policy, i.e.
the debate over Stalin's motives for expansion
3) The sources should lead the debate, i.e. you must identify the interpretations offered by the
sources. (These are the interpretations that the examiner wants you to debate when you
answer the question, i.e. when you discuss the claim in the question.)
a) The exam is most likely to contain three sources.
i) Within these sources there is always a clear debate, usually the sources will:
(1) Either present three separate interpretations
(2) Or, two will present separate interpretations and one will present a mixture of more
than one interpretation.
(3) Either way, you will need to show where the sources agree and disagree, i.e. cross
reference.
b) The sources need to be carefully analysed for their interpretation.
i) Explain what the interpretation is and
ii) Explain why it is being held (here you bring in your own knowledge to support the
interpretation – see 4 below).
c) But remember, it is not just a matter of generally debating why the Cold War started. You
must answer the question, i.e. debate the interpretations offered by the sources in relation
to the question, in other words stay focused on the question.
4) Your own knowledge should develop the debate in the sources.
a) This requires you to:
i) Have an in-depth knowledge of the relevant main events – see textbook chapters 1
and 2.
ii) Select the most appropriate events to, firstly, support then, secondly, challenge the
interpretations. In other words, you must debate (argue for and against) each
interpretation, do not forget to explain how the events support/challenge the
interpretation.
iii) Evaluate the interpretations. This means you must decide which interpretation you think
is the most valid based on your understanding of the main events, i.e. which
interpretation do you agree with and by ‘how much’?
(1) Obviously, as there is an interpretation in the question then this is the interpretation
you must weigh against the alternative interpretations, found in the sources.
(2) Evaluation should take place in every paragraph not just the conclusion. When
evaluating, you are measuring how far/to what extent you agree with the
interpretation and explaining why you hold this view.
(3) In your conclusion, you must reach a final decision that directly answers the question
and which is based on your evaluation in your main paragraphs. This is called a
reasoned judgement, i.e. you must explain and support your final decision.
22/09/2015
1
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
Wa
rTo
pic
: Te
ch
niq
ue
Unit 3 Part B examination skills checklist
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
Wa
rTo
pic
: Te
ch
niq
ue
• Read the question (RTQ) carefully
– Identify the instruction
• How far do you agree with the view ...
– Identify the topic area
• The origins/development of the Cold War between ...
– Identify the key words
• The claim/argument/interpretation ...
22/09/2015
2
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
Wa
rTo
pic
: Te
ch
niq
ue
• Read the sources very carefully
– Identify the interpretation (point of
view/opinion/argument)
• At least one of the sources will agree with the claim in the
question
– Identify the historiographical position
• Ignore if unsure
– Identify short quotes to suggest both the above
• A technique to help you understand the source and select good
quotes is to place a forward slash (/) wherever there is a
punctuation mark (, ; : . ? !)
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
Wa
rTo
pic
: Te
ch
niq
ue
• Identify areas of agreement/disagreement between
the sources’ interpretations
– Use different coloured pens to help you quickly cross-
reference
22/09/2015
3
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
Wa
rTo
pic
: Te
ch
niq
ue
• Evaluate the validity of the sources’ interpretations
– Use own knowledge to check the
accuracy/completeness of each source’s interpretation
• identify own knowledge to explain why the author puts
forward the interpretation in the source, i.e. to support the
quotes you’ve identified above; this is showing that you
understand what the interpretation is and why it is held
• identify own knowledge you can use to suggest the author’s
view might not be completely valid, i.e. to challenge/disagree
with the quotes you’ve identified above
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
Wa
rTo
pic
: Te
ch
niq
ue
• Answer the question (ATQ)!
Unit 3 Section B question planning checklist
Good Luck
1. Read the question carefully
a. Identify the instruction
i. How far do you agree with the view ...
b. Identify the topic area
i. The origins/development of the Cold War between ...
c. Identify the key words
i. The claim/argument/interpretation ...
2. Read the sources very carefully
a. Identify the interpretation
b. Identify the historiographical position if you can, don’t worry if you cannot
c. Identify short quotes to suggest the interpretation
i. A technique to help you understand the source and select good
quotes is to place a forward slash (/) wherever there is a
punctuation mark (, ; : . ? !)
3. Identify areas of agreement/disagreement between the sources’ interpretations
a. Use different coloured highlighters to help you quickly cross-reference
4. Assess the validity of the sources’ interpretations
a. Use your own knowledge to check the accuracy/completeness of each
source’s interpretation
i. identify own knowledge to suggest why the author puts forward
the interpretation in the source, i.e. to support the quotes you have
identified above; this is showing that you understand what the
interpretation is and why it is held
ii. identify own knowledge you can use to suggest the author’s view
might not be completely valid, i.e. to challenge/disagree with the
quotes you have identified above
5. Answer the question!
Use Sources S, T and U and your own knowledge. How far do you agree with the view that Stalin’s foreign
policy was a major contributing factor to the emergence of the Cold War in the period 1945-50?
Source S
It is difficult to say what would have happened if the west had responded positively to Stalin’s last initiative
on the German question (a call for a neutral, united Germany). It might have led to German reunification
sometime in the 1950s and to a considerable easing of cold war tensions in Europe. On the other hand, it
might have led to greater uncertainty and instability as there was no guarantee Germany would have
remained neutral or disarmed for long. As western diplomats and politicians often pointed out to the Soviets
in the 1950s, there were advantages for Moscow in West Germany’s inclusion in the western bloc. As the old
saying has it: NATO was established to keep the Americans in, the Russians out and the Germans down! But
this sanguine perspective was not shared by Stalin or by his successors as Soviet leader, whose view of the
German question was formed by their experience of the Great Patriotic War and by their continuing dread of
the re-emergence of a powerful and aggressive Germany.
Even as the cold war raged, the idea of a revival of the Grand Alliance to contain Germany still had its allure
in Moscow, not least for Stalin who had been very reluctant to relinquish the project of postwar co-
operation with the west. In January 1949 Stalin responded positively to a question from an American
journalist about whether he would be prepared to meet Truman to discuss a ‘peace pact’ – an American-
Soviet non- aggression agreement. In Europe Stalin sought peace and a resolution of the German question.
In military competition with the United States his policies were reactive and restrained. Although on
occasion he rattled his sabres, he talked constantly and consistently about peaceful coexistence with
capitalism. The one exception to this pattern of restraint was the Korean War of 1950-53.
From Geoffrey Roberts, Stalin’s Wars (published in 2006)
Source T
Stalin’s goal was not to restore a balance of power in Europe, but rather to dominate that continent as
thoroughly as Hitler had sought to do. He acknowledged, in a wistful but revealing comment in 1947, that
‘had Churchill delayed opening the second front in northern France by a year, the Red Army would have
come to Paris’. Unlike Hitler, however, Stalin followed no fixed timetable….Nor would he write off diplomacy
in securing his objective…
Stalin’s was, therefore, a grand vision: the peacefully accomplished but historically determined domination
of Europe.
From John Lewis Gaddis, The Cold War (published in 2005)
Source U
It is tempting to lay total blame for the Cold War on the delusions of Stalin and his lieutenants. A closer look
at the Cold War from the Soviet side reveals, however, that they were not the only culprits in the conflict.
We cannot disregard other complex factors, such as the crass nature of power politics, choices of US and
British policy-makers, and the deeper causes of hostility and mistrust between dictatorship and democracy
in an uncertain world. Stalin, notwithstanding his reputation as a ruthless tyrant, was not prepared to take a
course of unbridled unilateral expansionism after World War II. He wanted to avoid confrontation with the
West. He was even ready to see co-operation with the Western powers as a preferable way of building his
influence and solving contentious international issues. Thus, the Cold War was not his choice or his
brainchild.
From Vladislav Zubok and Constantine Pleshakov, Inside the Kremlin’s Cold War (published 1996)
22/09/2015
1
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
Wa
rTo
pic
: K
ore
aKey Interpretation: US Domestic Politics
• Links development of Cold War to US domestic politics
• Specifically:
– Role played by Republicans and Democrats in Truman’s
administration and Congress
– Attempts to win public support by exploiting Cold War fears
• Evidence:
– China Lobby blamed Truman for ‘losing China’
– Forced Truman to adopt more aggressive stance against
communism …
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
Wa
rTo
pic
: K
ore
a
Assess the reasons why the Korean War is an issue
of historical controversy
TASK:
Yellow cards contain differing interpretations on the origins of
the Korean War.
Blue cards contain some knowledge that will help assess the
validity of the interpretation.
• Can you match them?
• Which are the most convincing interpretations?
• Can you prioritise them?
• Explain why – using your own knowledge
22/09/2015
2
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
Wa
rTo
pic
: K
ore
aHow far do you agree that ‘Stalin was primarily
responsible for the outbreak of the Korean War’?
Use sources P, Q and R, on p.67, and your own
knowledge
• Source P
• Interpretation?
• Quotes to
demonstrate
interpretation
• How valid? Use
own knowledge
to support and
challenge
• Source Q
• Interpretation?
• Quotes to
demonstrate
interpretation
• How valid? Use
own knowledge
to support and
challenge
• Source R
• Interpretation?
• Quotes to
demonstrate
interpretation
• How valid? Use
own knowledge
to support and
challenge
A2
Un
it 3
: C
old
Wa
rTo
pic
: K
ore
a
Historiographical debate: what caused the Cold
War?
TASK:
• Read Source O. What problems face the historian studying the
causes of the Korean War?
• Do you agree with Bruce Cummings ‘no one and everyone was
responsible’ for causing the Korean War? Who are the possible
culprits?
• How far does this interpretation differ from that in Source P and
Q?
• To what extent does Source Q agree with the view offered by
Source R of the reasons for the Korean War?
‘The Kremlin has clearly and consciously risked a World War.’ Alsop
Stalin agreed to supply military and technical assistance to Kim but said he would not intervene to support him if the war went badly.
‘Syngman Rhee precipitated the war, deliberately provoking an attack from the North in order to force the US government to give more aid.’ I.F. Stone
Stalin concluded in April 1949 that, ‘The South Korean regime was determined to launch an attack on the North sooner or later and it was important to forestall the aggression.’ Syngman Rhee was as determined as Kim was to reunify the peninsula and there had been a series of border clashes, killing hundreds, in the months preceding the war.
‘Stalin was the instigator of the war, but not to bring Russia and China closer together, but to put pressure on China.’ H Salisbury
Stalin informed Mao of Kim’s decision to launch an invasion. In 1950 they signed a treaty of friendship. Although Stalin was very suspicious of Mao’s version
of communism which focused on the peasantry and only gave limited economic aid to Mao there was no way Stalin was going to risk a 3rd world war just to put pressure on China.
‘Kim Il Sung was the initiator of the war. He was desperate to unify the peninsula. Stalin urged him to think it over as he had his doubts’ Khrushchev
Stalin was prepared to let Kim Il Sung attempt to unify the Korean peninsula as by 1950 he was feeling more confident for a number of reasons. China was communist; the USSR had detonated its own bomb and Acheson’s ‘defensive perimeter’ speech had appeared to leave out South Korea from areas of particular American interest. Stalin therefore calculated that the US would not get involved but also told Kim Il Sung, ‘If you get kicked in the teeth, I shall not lift a finger.’ He was not prepared to risk war with the West over the reunification of Korea
‘The attack upon Korea makes it plain beyond all doubt that communism has passed beyond the phase of subversion to conquer independent nations and will now used armed invasion and war. If we let Korea down, the Soviets will keep right on going and swallow up one piece of Asia after another.’ Truman
‘The responsibility for the war lies firmly with the North, who was acting under instructions from Stalin to spread communism.’ D Rees
Kim pestered Stalin to give him permission to attack South Korea. It was only in April 1950 that Stalin finally agreed to Kim’s plan. Stalin had built up the military strength of North Korea and therefore was responsible for giving Kim the means to fight the war, but the desire was Kim Il Sungs. Kim had the will and Stalin provided the means.
‘Stalin was far too cautious to risk a war with America. He played the part of facilitator
rather than originator of the war’ K Weathersby
The minutes of a meeting between Stalin and Kim Il Sung in March 1949 reveal that
Stalin gave the impression that he did not approve of an invasion by North Korea. For example he avoided making any commitment of troops to support Kim. However by April 1950 Stalin was more secure and informed Kim that there had been ‘a significant strengthening of the socialist camp in the East.’
‘The Korean War was a local war that drew in the superpowers. ‘ B Cumings
America’s policy of containment was crucial in escalating the conflict in Korea. The US were determined to prevent the spread of communism and with NSC 68 had suggested that in fact communism should be rolled back where appropriate.
‘Domestic pressures on Truman forced him to take a hard-line response to the conflict in Korea, therefore turning a civil war into a cold war conflict.’
A Historian
The Republicans were furious that they did not win the election in 1948 and were incredibly bitter. They accused Truman of being soft on
communism and the McCarthy witch-hunt was evidence of the force of public concern (and the power of the media).
‘Stalin was not blind to the benefits of a secure Korea but was not prepared to risk a war with America to achieve it. He
was therefore prepared to support Kim, but did not direct him to invade’ T Hamilton
Stalin supported Kim’s invasion because a united, communist Korea would secure the Soviet Union’s borders, threaten
Japan which was a new American ally and also place at their disposal South Korea’s extensive supply of lead which was in very short supply in the USSR at this stage.
‘Some historians have suggested that the Truman administration must have set the whole thing up. Were the North Koreans somehow manoeuvred into attacking South Korea as the necessary excuse for US rearmament?’ JL Gaddis
NSC 68 proposed a massive increase in military spending. Truman agreed with the proposals but was aware that implementing them would mean higher taxes and cuts in welfare. As a result of the invasion of S Korea however, nearly every recommendation was put in place and US spending on the military rocketed from $13 billion to $50 billion. While the military-industrial complex must have been pleased, there is no evidence at all that the US manipulated the N Koreans into attacking the South.