twenty-fifthtwenty-fifth statewide conference on local bridges ... this year’s calendar photo...

38
Twenty-Fifth October 23 & 24, 2019 Holiday Inn Syracuse, NY Presented By: NYS Department Of Transportation NYS County Highway Superintendents Association Federal Highway Administration Cornell Local Roads Program Association for Bridge Construction & Design Western NY Chapter Association for Bridge Construction & Design Eastern NY Chapter American Council of Engineering Companies of New York

Upload: others

Post on 27-May-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Twenty-Fifth

October 23 & 24, 2019

Holiday Inn Syracuse, NY

Presented By:

NYS Department Of Transportation NYS County Highway Superintendents Association

Federal Highway Administration Cornell Local Roads Program

Association for Bridge Construction & Design – Western NY Chapter Association for Bridge Construction & Design – Eastern NY Chapter

American Council of Engineering Companies of New York

Twenty-Fifth Statewide Conference on Local Bridges Syracuse, NY – October 23 & 24, 2019

Handbook Contents:

Conference Steering Committee Membership

NYSDOT Featured Region 3

Agenda

Conference Sessions:

Session 1 - Agency Updates

Session 2 - Featured Region - NYSDOT Region 3

Session 3 - Hydraulics

Session 4A - Geotech & Fabrication

Session 4B - Local Agency Forum

Session 5 - Local Projects

Session 6 - Partnering

Appendices:

2020 Statewide Conference on Local Bridges Program Chair

How to Access Conference Presentations

NYSDOT Region and County Map

Twenty-Fifth Statewide Conference on Local Bridges Syracuse, New York – October 23 & 24, 2019

Steering Committee

James Flynn, Chairman Erica Westhuis Jennifer Hawkins Peter Ryan Steve Emrich Christopher Millington David Orr William Rugg Ryan Henderson James McDuffee Luke Morenus Deborah Donohue Christopher Day Ed McAndrew Jeffery Smith Jeff Griswold

NYSDOT NYSDOT NYSDOT NYSDOT NYSDOT FHWA Cornell Local Roads Program ABCD Western NY ABCD Eastern NY ACEC-NY ASHE New York Washington County (NYSCHSA) Ontario County (NYSCHSA) Sullivan County (NYSCHSA) Tompkins County (NYSCHSA) Town of Preble

518-457-6827 518-485-2389 518-457-8485 518-474-5440 315-793-2594 518-431-8853 607-255-8465 716-989-3334 518-453-4797 607-231-6621 315-457-5200 518-746-2442 585-396-4000 845-807-0261 607-274-0300 607-749-2710

Cornell Local Roads Program

David Orr Cornell Local Roads Program 607-255-8465 Melissa Foley Amanda Link

Cornell Local Roads Program Cornell Local Roads Program

607-255-7733 607-255-5437

Program Committee Larry Tolfa, 2019 Chairman Michael Ruppe, 2020 Chairman Christopher Day

NYSDOT NYSDOT Ontario County

518-485-7265 518-457-5955 585-393-2999

Logistics Committee David Orr Cornell Local Roads Program 607-255-8465 Erica Westhuis Denise Devito Melissa Foley Amanda Link

NYSDOT NYSDOT Cornell Local Roads Program Cornell Local Roads Program

518-485-2389 518-417-6687 607-255-7733 607-255-5437

Training/Communication Committee

Rohit Dagli, Chairman

NYSDOT

518-485-7238

Twenty-Fifth Statewide Conference on Local Bridges Syracuse, New York – October 23 & 24, 2019

Featured Region

Thank you to all our local partners for coming

together to support this year’s conference.

Wednesday, October 23, 2019

REGISTRATION AND BREAKFAST 7:15-8:00 am Registration – Convention Center Foyer 6:45 -8:00 am Breakfast – Cotillion Ballroom

OPENING REMARKS Start Topic Presenter 8:00 am Welcome and James Flynn Opening Remarks Deputy Chief Engineer NYSDOT Office of Structures David Smith Regional Director NYSDOT Region 3 Dennis Davis President NYSCHSA Oneida County

SESSION 1 – AGENCY UPDATES Moderator: James Flynn, NYSDOT Office of Structures

Start Topic Presenter 8:15 am NYSDOT Update Marie Therese Dominguez

Commissioner NYSDOT

8:30 am FHWA Update Richard J. Marquis NY Division Administrator Local FHWA Office 8:45 am Local Responsibilities Mark Struzinsky

and BDIS Reporting Bridge Inspection Unit Head NYSDOT Main Office Structures

9:30 am SCLB 25th Anniversary David Orr Director Cornell Local Roads Program

In 9:45 am BREAK Grand Ballroom East

SESSION 2 - FEATURED REGION - NYSDOT, REGION 3

Moderator: David Smith, NYSDOT Region 3

Start Topic Presenter 10:15 am Featured Region: Overview David Smith Regional Director NYSDOT Region 3

10:30 am Teall-Beach Viaduct Reconstruction Michael Martello Senior Bridge Engineer T.Y. LIN, International Michele Fiorillo, P.E. Geotechnical Department Manager Terracon Consultants-NY 11:00 am Hinmansville Bridge Strike; Charles Tutunjian, P.E. Damages and Restoration Senior Project Manager Creighton Manning Engineering Steven Hagy, P.E. Project Manager Creighton Manning Engineering 11:30 am Accelerated Bridge Deck Robert Rugg, P.E. Replacement on I-690 Regional Construction Supervisor NYSDOT Region 3

12:00 pm LUNCH Cotillion Ballroom

SESSION 3 – HYDRAULICS

Moderator: Larry Tolfa, NYSDOT Office of Structures

Start Topic Presenter 1:30 pm Culverts: Inspection, Failure Modes, Lallman Rambali, P.E. Rehabilitation and Replacement Hydraulic Engineering Unit NYSDOT Region 5 2:30 pm Hy8 – How to Use for David Hensberry, E.I.T. Stone Fill Design or Slip Lining Culverts Hydraulic Engineering Unit NYSDOT Region 9

3:00 pm BREAK Grand Ballroom East

SESSION 4A – GEOTECH AND FABRICATION Moderator: Scott Lagace, NYSDOT Office of Structures

Start Topic Presenter 3:30 pm Highway Slope Stabilization Asif Ahmed, Ph.D. Using Plastic Pin Professor SUNY Polytechnic Institute 4:00 pm Determining H-Pile Lengths Gary Hammond, P.E. Using Non-Destructive Test Methods Tioga County Public Works Dave Kennicutt, P.E.

Delta Engineering William Horne, P.E. NDT Corporation

4:30 pm Fabrication and Design Details Koby Greene and Pitfalls D.A. Collins Construction Co.

In

5:00 pm NETWORKING SESSION * Grand Ballroom East

SESSION 4B – LOCAL AGENCY FORUM

Moderator: Todd Gadd, Wyoming County DPW

3:30 pm Breakout Session for Municipal Engineers, Municipal Department Heads and their

staff only. Invited NYSDOT staff will attend to answer questions. 5:00 pm NETWORKING SESSION* Grand Ballroom East

*Please note - This Year’s Calendar Photo Award Ceremony will be held during the Networking Event. Hors d’oeuvres will be served and beverages will be available for purchase. Dinner will be on your own.

Thursday, October 24, 2018

REGISTRATION AND BREAKFAST 7:15 - 8:30 am Registration – Convention Center Foyer 6:45 - 8:30 am Breakfast – Cotillion Ballroom

SESSION 5 – LOCAL PROJECTS Moderator: Jennifer Hawkins, NYSDOT Maintenance

Start Topic Presenter

8:30 am Cold Brook Road Replacement Karl Weiss, P.E. With Tappan Zee Bridge Panels Highway Superintendent Clinton County Hwy. Department

Nicholas Shrimpton, P.E. Barton & Loguidice

9:00 am Tioga County Bridge Maintenance Younes Drihmi, P.E. Program Tioga County Public Works Gary Hammond, P.E. McFarland-Johnson, Inc. 9:30 am Bridge NY Project: Mark Laistner, P.E. Maiden Lane Bridge Replacement Popli Design Group Kirk Morris Commissioner of Public Works Town of Greece, NY 10:00 am BREAK Grand Ballroom East

SESSION 6 – PARTNERING Moderator: David Orr, Cornell Local Roads Program

Start Topic Presenter

10:30 am Historic Stone Arch Bridge Rehab: Brian J. Carlson, P.E. Preserving the Past for Sustainability Greenman-Pedersen, Inc. In the Future Alexey Brumagin, P.E. Chautauqua County Michael J. Mann, P.E. McMahon & Mann Consulting Engineers P.C.

11:00 am When the Public Hearing Goes Right Christopher R. Wallin, P.E. City Engineer City of Schenectady 11:30 am Bridge Deck Overlay Options Harry White, P.E. Standards and Policies NYSDOT Main Office

CONCLUDING REMARKS Moderator: James Flynn, NYSDOT Office of Structures

Start Topic Presenter 12:00 pm Local Agency Report Todd Gadd Wyoming County DPW 12:10 pm Training Subcommittee Update Rohit Dagli NYSDOT Office of Structures 12:15 pm Final Wrap-Up James Flynn NYSDOT Office of Structures

CONFERENCE SESSIONS

Marie Therese Dominguez, Esq. Commissioner NYSDOT 50 Wolf Road, 6th Floor Albany, NY 12232 [email protected]

About the Presenter: On May 6, 2019, New York Governor Andrew Cuomo announced his intent to nominate Marie Therese Dominguez Commissioner of the New York State Department of Transportation and on June 20, 2019, she was unanimously confirmed by the New York State Senate. Ms. Dominguez has worked in the transportation, water and energy infrastructure, safety and logistics sectors for over 20 years, having served in numerous leadership positions within the Federal government and private sector. In 2015, she was nominated by President Obama and unanimously confirmed by the U.S. Senate to serve as Administrator of the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA) at the U.S. Department of Transportation. At PHMSA, Ms. Dominguez managed the development and enforcement of safety regulations and oversaw safety operations for the nation's interstate gas and liquid pipelines as well as all hazardous materials shipments by rail, highway, sea and air. Prior to leading PHMSA, she served as the Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary of the Army for Civil Works at the U.S. Department of Defense, overseeing policy and budget direction for the U.S. Army. Corps of Engineers. She has served as Vice President for Government Relations and Public Policy at the United States Postal Service, where she led legislative and public policy initiatives for the country's then, second largest civilian employer. She has served as Deputy Chief of Staff and Counsel at the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA); Special Assistant to the Chairman at the National Transportation Safety Board and as a Special Assistant to President Clinton and Associate Director of Presidential Personnel in the White House. For the last few years she served as a member of the Virginia Aviation Board overseeing the policy, programs and funding for all 66 airports in the state of Virginia and as an Adjunct Professor at Georgetown University's McCourt School of Public Policy. Marie Therese obtained her J.D. from Villanova University School of Law and her B.A. in American Studies from Smith College.

SESSION 1.1

NYSDOT Update

Richard J. Marquis Division Administrator Local FHWA Office U.S. DOT/Federal Highway Administration, New York Division 11A Clinton Avenue, Suite 719 Albany, NY 12207 [email protected]

Synopsis: An overview of what is new and upcoming at FHWA. About the Presenter: In March 2019, Rick Marquis was named the FHWA New York Division Administrator. As a key member of the Agency management team, Rick exercises executive direction over the $1.8 billion Federal-aid annual apportionment to New York, one of the largest and most complex in the country. As Division Administrator, he leads a multidisciplinary staff of over 40 professionals in Albany and New York City to provide guidance to State and local funding recipients with the primary objective of remaining a relevant partner in New York while advancing national transportation goals. Beginning in 2017, Rick Marquis was the Senior Policy Advisor for the FHWA Office of the Administrator. In this capacity, Rick was FHWA’s point of contact with the Office of the Secretary on regulatory reform activities and coordinated reform activities on FHWA policies/guidance, regulations, and statues with the various offices of FHWA. Prior to this role, Rick worked as a Division Chief for the U.S. DOT/Volpe Center supporting various FHWA Headquarters Offices, as well as the Office of the Secretary. Rick also spent 20 years working in different capacities in FHWA field offices, including the Indiana Division Administrator, the Massachusetts Assistant Division Administrator and the Director of Technical Services in the Pennsylvania Division. Rick joined FHWA in 1996 and was the Planning and Environmental Specialist and Team Leader in the Massachusetts Division. Prior to joining FHWA, Rick worked for three Metropolitan Planning Organizations, including the Boston, MA MPO.

SESSION 1.2

FHWA Update

Mark Struzinsky, PE Bridge Inspection Unit Head NYSDOT Main Office Structures 50 Wolf Road, 4th Floor Albany, NY 12232 [email protected]

Synopsis: What is a bridge? What is bridge evaluation? Why is a bridge inspected and where can I find the resulting information? What are the local owners’ responsibilities regarding their bridges? These questions will be answered. The New York State Department of Transportation’s role will be discussed in relation to these questions as well. Attendees will also learn about critical finding (flagging) procedures, scour plans of action, ensuring public safety and the corresponding role of the bridge owner. About the Presenter: Mr. Mark Struzinsky is a licensed Professional Engineer with 21 years of bridge design and inspection experience. He graduated with honors earning a Bachelor of Science Civil Engineering degree from SUNY Buffalo in 1998, immediately after which he began his career with the NYS Department of Transportation’s Main Office Structures Division. His design experience includes bridges ranging in complexity from single span box culverts to multi-span interchanges. For several years he supervised a bridge design squad. Currently, he is the NYSDOT Main Office Bridge Inspection Unit Head and is responsible for Statewide oversight of the bridge and tunnel inspection programs, which includes ensuring regulatory compliance, funding procurement and inspection technical guidance. He is the Editor-in-Chief of the 2014, 2016, and 2017 editions of the NYSDOT Bridge Inspection Manual.

SESSION 1.3

Local Responsibilities and BDIS

Reporting

David Orr, P.E. Director Cornell Local Roads Program [email protected]

Synopsis: Overview of 25 years at the Local Bridge Conference. About the Presenter: David P. Orr, PE, PhD. is Director / Senior Engineer for the Cornell University Local Roads Program, the New York State LTAP Center. With over 30 years in the local highway community, David has experiences covering the gamut from the field to the office and from storms to sunny days. He has a broad range of expertise and experience in highway engineering and construction, including design, inspection, project management, purchasing, budgeting and supervision. David interacts with local, state and national partners and works closely with CLRP customers and provides technical assistance to highway and public works officials in New York State. He was the 2018-2019 President of the NLTAPA, the association of 52 LTAP & TTAP Centers located across the county. Before joining the Program, he worked for eight years at the Yates County Highway Department. He is a licensed professional engineer in New York State and has Ph.D. on local roads from Cornell University.

SESSION 1.4

SCLB 25th Anniversary

David Smith, P.E.

NYSDOT-Region 3 Regional Director 333 East Washington Street Syracuse, NY 13202 [email protected]

Synopsis: RD Smith will be introducing Region 3 as this year’s featured Region. Dave will provide a brief overview of the region, highlight the current capital program environment and discuss various, ongoing transportation initiatives. He will also highlight opportunities for continued cooperation with our transportation partners.” About the Presenter:

David Smith was appointed Regional Director of Region 3 in April of 2016. Dave started

his career as a Junior Engineer in the Traffic Engineering & Safety Group in Region 10

in 1992. Over the past 25 years, Dave has gained management and engineering

experience while holding various positions as Signals EIC, Operations & Design

Supervisor, Cayuga/Seneca Resident Engineer, Onondaga East Resident Engineer and

Regional Director of Operations.

Dave earned a Bachelor of Science degree in Civil and Environmental Engineering from

Cornell University in 1992. He has been a New York State Licensed Engineer since

1998 and is also a member of the New York State Association of Transportation

Engineers.

SESSION 2.1

Featured Region Overview

Michael Martello, PE Michele Fiorillo, PE Sr. Structural Engineer Geotechnical Department Manager T. Y. Lin International Terracon Consultants - NY 255 East Ave. [email protected] Rochester, NY 14604 [email protected]

Synopsis:

This project was performed to ensure the continued safety and operational efficiency of Interstate 690 in Syracuse, NY. The project involved reconstructing a ¾ mile section of highway including the replacement of a 1,500-foot viaduct spanning Beech Street and extending to Teall Avenue; replacement of the bridge over Teall Avenue; and improvements to Exit 14 at Teall Avenue. There were structural deficiencies identified along the viaduct which called for its rehabilitation or replacement. Ongoing maintenance operations to perform short-term repairs to this structure had resulted in lane closures that negatively impacted traffic operation. There were also non-standard and nonconforming geometric design features, including reduced sight distance, ramp geometry deficiencies, narrow shoulders, and inadequate bridge railing identified in this area. The project was a candidate for Design-Build due to the scope of work required and the desire to make improvements as soon as possible.

NYSDOT issued a Request for Qualifications, followed by a Request for Proposals to short-listed firms. The Crane-Hogan Design Build Team was selected and awarded a Best Value Contract. In order to eliminate the viaduct, the proposal design was based in installation of Controlled Modulus Columns (CMCs) - also known as rigid inclusions - to provide soil strengthening and ground stabilization. This would allow about a 20-foot tall highway embankment with MSE walls to be constructed and elimination of the viaduct. The designers chose to design the Beech Street Bridge utilizing NEXT Beams (Type D) and design of the Teall Avenue Bridge utilizing Bulb Tee beams. In addition to bringing I-690 up to current standards, the project required replacement of all highway signs, reconstruction and improvements to Teall Avenue, installation of new traffic signals, Intelligent Transportation System (ITS) improvements, aesthetic treatments, and a reduction in stormwater run-off and water quality improvements for flow entering the City of Syracuse’s combined sewer system.

SESSION 2.2

Teall-Beach Viaduct Reconstruction

The Design Build Team was given Notice to Proceed on February 27, 2017 with a proposed completion date of July 28, 2019. The actual substantial completion date was July 3, 2019.

About the Presenters:

Michael Martello, P.E.:

Michael Martello is a senior structural engineer at T.Y. Lin International with over 33 years of experience in structural engineering. His experience includes the design of bridges, hydraulic structures, post-tensioned parking garages, buildings and other miscellaneous structures.

He has a MS Degree in Civil Engineering from Northeastern University and a BS from SUNY at Buffalo. Early in his career, Michael completed the FHWA's Highway Engineering Training Program where he designed bridges, performed construction inspections, and participated in design and environmental reviews. He has also taught structural engineering courses at the Rochester Institute of Technology.

Michele A. Fiorillo, P.E.:

Michele (Michael) Fiorillo is the Geotechnical Department Manager at Terracon Rochester Office. Michele has over 20 years of experience in geotechnical engineering. Michele has been involved in providing geotechnical recommendations for numerous transportation projects, as well as commercial developments, and power generation and transmission. He has ME Degree in Civil Engineering from SUNY Buffalo and a BS Degree in Geology from the University of Rome La Sapienza”.

Charles Tutunjian, PE Steve Hagy, PE Sr. Project Manager/Partner Project Manager/Partner Creighton Manning Engineering Creighton Manning Engineering 2 Winners Circle, Suite 201 2 Winners Circle, Suite 201 Albany, NY 12205 Albany, NY 12205 [email protected] [email protected]

Synopsis: This presentation will briefly discuss the use and implementation of the NYSDOT’s Statewide Emergency Bridge Design Contract for the CR 46 bridge over the Oswego River. The 280 foot, two span truss was struck in late April 2019 by an oversized vehicle severing the truss’s overhead bracing and two truss vertical members. The presentation will focus on the challenges associated with the emergency response including:

• Bridge inspection methods & challenges

• Truss stability and analysis during construction

• Various repair alternatives considered

• Non-destructive material testing

• Restoring ornate lattice bracing

• Load rating and gusset plate analysis

The project was completed and the bridge re-opened to traffic in early June 2019. About the Presenters: Charles Tutunjian is a Senior Project Manager/Partner and has served as head of the Bridge Structures group since joining Creighton Manning Engineering 14 years ago. He is a 1991 graduate of Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute with a bachelor’s degree in civil engineering. He has served as Project Manager for over 80 bridge replacement and rehabilitation projects, including 35 locally administered federal aid projects. He recently completed his term as President of the Eastern NY Chapter of ABCD. Steve Hagy is a Project Manager in the Structures Group at Creighton Manning. He is a licensed Professional Engineer with over 9 years of experience, which ranges from bridge rehabilitation and replacement projects for NYSDOT and various municipalities in New York State to contractor support services in New York, Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and Virginia. In addition to his bridge replacement and rehabilitation design work, he has become a leader at Creighton Manning in contractor support services, such as the

SESSION 2.3

Hinmansville Bridge Strike:

Damages and Restoration

Robert Rugg, PE Regional Construction Supervisor NYSDOT Region 3 333 E. Washington St Syracuse, NY 13202 [email protected]

Synopsis: This presentation will cover the Accelerated Bridge Deck work that occurred during the summer of 2016 which replaced 3 bridge decks on I-690 in the city of Syracuse under a full closure of the I-690 EB expressway. This work employed incentive/disincentive clauses and the work was completed in 8 days using an accelerated 18-hour mix (3000 PSI at 18 hours). General format of the presentation will be as follows:

- Review the need to use accelerated bridge deck construction (I-81 viaduct project is coming along which will replace these bridges in approximately the next 10 years – bridge decks are deteriorating, but we need to reduce inconvenience to the public while not requiring typical bridge deck service life).

- Review contract clauses, special specification for accelerated concrete and touch on the detour/public outreach efforts.

- Discuss accelerated mixes and their benefits and drawbacks. - Go through slides of the work from old deck removal to reopening of I-690. - Discuss lessons learned, difficulties encountered, and observations.

About the Presenters: Robert Rugg is a graduate of Rochester Institute of Technology in 1995 and began working for NYSDOT in 1998 in Region 4 Design as a Project Designer. He then moved to Region 5 Design as a Design Squad Leader in 2006 and returned to the Region 4 Construction Group in 2009 as an Engineer-in-Charge of Construction Projects. Since 2016, he has been a Construction Job Manager in Region 3 Construction and continues in this position today. He obtained his Professional Engineering License in 2003 and is currently a Vice President of the New York State Association of Transportation Engineers, NYSATE Section 3.

SESSION 2.4

Accelerated Bridge Deck Replacement

on I -690

Lallman Rambali, P.E. Region 5 Hydraulics Engineer 100 Seneca Street Buffalo, NY 14203 [email protected]

Synopsis: This course describes various defects associated with culvert deterioration and the failure mode(s) observed for each defect. It also describes how these defects are rated and documented according to AASHTO and the NYSDOT Bridge Inspection Manual. It describes temporary and permanent retrofits that can be carried out on a deteriorated culvert to sustain its structural integrity. This course describes the procedures to be followed when determining the size of a replacement culvert based on Hydrology, Hydraulics and Environmental criteria. COURSE OBJECTIVE At the end of the course, participants should be able to determine:

1. What is a culvert and what is a bridge size culvert? 2. Defects associated with Corrugated Metal Culverts & Reinforced Concrete Box

Culverts 3. Inspection and Documentation of culvert defects 4. Failure mode associated with various defects 5. A suitable rehab alternative for various defects

About the Presenter: Mr. Lallman Rambali is a licensed professional engineer with extensive experience in water resources and river hydraulics. He has served as Regional Hydraulics Engineer for the New York State Department of Transportation (NYSDOT) in Buffalo, NY for 25 years. In that role, Mr. Rambali performs detailed hydraulic analyses for all of NYSDOT Region 5's bridge and culvert replacement projects to determine hydraulic adequacy and scour susceptibility of existing structures and the recommendation for replacement structures. In addition, he is responsible for the Diving Inspection, Hydraulic Vulnerability Assessment, Flood Watch and Post Flood Inspection programs. He is certified as a bridge inspector and designs emergency repairs when necessary.

SESSION 3.1 and 3.2

Culverts: Inspection, Failure Modes,

Rehabilitation and Replacement

David Hensberry E.I.T.

Region 9 Assistant Hydraulics Engineer 44 Hawley St Binghamton, NY 13901 [email protected]

Synopsis: An Introduction to HY-8 Culvert Hydraulic Analysis Program Do you have a metal or concrete culvert, round or square that has structural or hydraulic defects? Are you considering replacement or rehabilitation? Did you know the U.S. Department of Transportation Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) offers FREE software to analyze hydraulics for roadway stream crossings? Known as HY-8 (“high eight”), this free software is easy to use, requires no hydraulic cross-sections and can be a valuable tool for simple and basic projects. During this presentation, viewers will learn basic software capabilities, required data to complete analysis, limitations, resources and viewing results. A range of projects will be discussed. Including, slip-lining, invert paving, full replacement and scour repair. Emphasizing, basic flood-plain requirements and how best to design for various scenarios. This presentation is geared towards entry level users who have no HY-8 experience. Attendees will have the ability to compare various culvert designs, modify cross section designs (circular, box, ellipse or arches), modify pipe elevations, inlet conditions, pipe lengths and pipe materials. About the Presenter:

Dave Hensberry, EIT – Graduated from SUNY Polytechnic Institute in 2016 with a bachelor’s degree in Civil Engineering Technology. Dave began his career as a Transportation Construction Inspector in 2014 with NYSDOT, Structures Management Department. Completing two internships while finishing his degree. After graduation, Dave accepted a full-time position in 2016 as an Assistant Engineer, Structures Management Department, bridge hydraulics unit. Dave is one of three employees with the hydraulics unit who oversee a total of 1,912 bridges over water (645 state owned, 1,267 locally owned). Dave has many duties including hydraulic analysis using HEC-RAS and HY-8, project level reviews,

SESSION 3.3

Hy8 – How to Use for Stone Fill Design or

Slip Lining Culverts

Asif Ahmed, Ph.D. Assistant Professor College of Engineering SUNY Polytechnic Institute 100 Seymour Road Utica, NY 13502 [email protected]

Synopsis: Moderate (3H: 1V) to steep (2.5H: 1V) slopes and embankments underlain by expansive clayey soils are susceptible to shallow land sliding during intense and prolonged rainfall events. These failures are predominant across the nation and cause significant maintenance problems for the corresponding Department of Transportation (DOT). The Recycled Plastic Pin (RPP) has potential to be utilized in slope stabilization as a remedial measure of shallow slope failure. The objective of the current study was to investigate the effect of spacing and length of RPP over the factor of safety using Finite Element method (FEM). The analysis was conducted using 2D FEM software package PLAXIS 2D and factor of safety of the slope was determined using the strength reduction technique. A highway slope constructed using high plastic clayey soil, located over US 287 near St. Paul overpass in Midlothian, Texas was selected as reference slope. The strength of the slope was back analyzed using PLAXIS 2D at factor of safety equals to unity. As a remediation technique, RPP was selected for the slope stabilization and the slope was analyzed with different lengths (2.44 m to 3.65 m, 8 ft to 12 ft) and spacing (0.61 m c/c to 2.44 m c/c, 3 ft c/c to 8 ft c/c) of RPP. The FEM results indicated that RPP provided resistance against the shallow failure and resulted increment in factor of safety by shifting the failure plane to a deeper depth toward deep seated failure. In addition, the factor of safety increased with the increment in RPP length as higher resistance was observed from the foundation soil. After successful implementation of RPP in one single site, several other sites were fixed with the same technique and the results are satisfactory to date. About the Presenter: Asif Ahmed is currently Assistant Professor in SUNY Polytechnic Institute. After completing his PhD from University of Texas at Arlington, Dr. Ahmed continued for couple of semesters as Research Assistant Professor in same institution prior joining SUNY Poly in Fall 2018. Funded by Texas Department of Transportation (TxDOT) during doctoral, his research works include but not limited to unsaturated soil mechanics, modeling soil behavior, slope stability, pavement distress, real time data

SESSION 4A.1

Highway Slope Stabilization

Using Plastic Pin

Gary Hammond, P.E. Dave Kennicutt, P.E. Commissioner Sr. Project Manager Tioga County Public Works Delta Engineers, Architects, & Land Surveyors 477 Route 96 860 Hooper Road Owego, NY 13827 Endwell, NY 13760 [email protected] [email protected]

William Horne, P.E. President NDT Corporation 153 Clinton Road Sterling, Massachusetts 01564 [email protected]

Synopsis: Cost effective and efficient design/repair strategies continue to be a top priority for all owners of our nation’s infrastructure. Bridges large and small are at the forefront of this expectation and according to conditional assessments based on the required biennial bridge inspections, many are in critical need of repairs. Engineers are well schooled in visual observation techniques and physical measurements to determine/assess the deterioration of bridge superstructures and substructures. Often these methods are not sufficient to fully assess the integrity of these members. Utilizing nondestructive testing techniques allows for a comprehensive inspection which produces a cost-effective repair strategy for bridge owners. An example of where this process recently yielded valuable information was for Tioga County in the southern tier at BIN 2218720 Harnick Road over Apalachin Creek. An inspection of the steel H pile pier/bent supporting this 2-span bridge resulted in a “Red Structural Flag. The field inspection and Red flag condition report documented perforations in the flanges and web of the piles at the lower area just above the riverbed. Tioga County engaged Delta Engineers to design a repair strategy to strengthen the H-piles which required excavating into the riverbed. The 2011 flooding of the Tioga County Public Works Facility destroyed many of their documents. There were no as-built plans for this local bridge to confirm the overall length of the piles and more specifically the remaining embedment depth. NDT was contracted to test each H-pile and determine the overall length. A sonic/ultrasonic system, designed and built by NDT Corporation, acquires pulse velocity (ASTM C597-16) data. This information is used to determine the average compressional and shear wave velocity of energy traveling along/in the steel pile. The pile length is calculated by measuring the energy wave’s 2-way (down to the pile tip and back) travel time through the pile.

SESSION 4A.2

Determining H-Pile Lengths Using Non-

Destructive Test Methods

This presentation will focus on this case study using this nondestructive testing method to determine the actual pile length of an unknown bridge foundation and locate the depth to bedrock along this reach of Apalachin Creek. Nondestructive testing can also assess the integrity of existing concrete bridge components such as decks, beams, columns, piers, abutments and foundations. Nondestructive test measurements can bolster confidence for design engineers to rely on existing bridge components. Ultimately it is the bridge owner that realizes the benefits to utilizing these techniques as Reusing or salvaging bridge components can save resources and reduce rehabilitation costs. About the Presenters: Gary Hammond P.E. was appointed Tioga County Public Works Commissioner in May of 2015. He served as the Deputy Commissioner of Public Works for 17 years prior to his appointment. Gary currently oversees a workforce of 38 employees and is responsible for 144 miles of roadway, 77 bridges and 8 county buildings. Gary is a registered Professional Engineer licensed in New York State.

David Kennicutt is Senior Project Manager in the Transportation Department of Delta Engineers, Architects, & Land Surveyors, DPC. He has over 35 years of experience in the design of highway bridges, with expertise in the rehabilitation of historic concrete arch and metal truss bridges. Mr. Kennicutt is a registered Professional Engineer licensed in New York State. Bill Horne PE, Mr. Horne is the president of NDT Corporation, a nondestructive testing company based in Sterling MA, providing innovative nondestructive testing services for evaluating all types of infrastructure materials. For over 20 years, Mr. Horne has successfully managed bridge inspection/assessment/rehabilitation projects for many private and governmental clients. Bill is a licensed professional engineer registered in New York.

Koby Greene, PE, D.A. Collins Construction 269 Ballard Road Wilton, NY 12831 [email protected]

Synopsis: Incomplete and/or inaccurate design details can result in schedule delays and increased costs to projects. Especially prevalent in rehabilitation contracts, overlooked or ignored existing conditions foster the creation of inapplicable details in the contract plans for both bid and construction. Reuse of these details from contract to contract perpetuates these issues. This presentation will be a discussion of some of the considerations that are often neglected in contract details. About the Presenter: Mr. Greene’s experience lies in the construction of heavy highway, civil, and hydroelectric projects, primarily in structural steel erection, structural lifting, steel repairs, reinforcing steel, and miscellaneous metal fabrication. He is responsible for estimating and managing construction projects in these areas as well as generation of shop drawings and structural erection drawings. Mr. Greene graduated in 2009 from RPI with a bachelor’s degree in civil engineering, is currently a Certified Welding Inspector through the American Welding Society and is a licensed professional engineer in the states of New York, Vermont, Pennsylvania, and Massachusetts. Prior to graduation, he interned at D.A. Collins Construction Co., Inc., and has since worked there as a full-time employee.

SESSION 4A.3

Fabrication and Design Details and Pitfalls

Moderator: Todd Gadd, P.E. County Highway Superintendent Wyoming County 4328 Route 19 Rock Glen, NY 14550 [email protected]

3:30 – 4:00 PM – General Discussion – Questions/Issues shared among County representatives

NYSDOT Staff for questions: Brenda Crudele, James Flynn, Dawn Arnold, Regional Managers FHWA Staff for questions: Daniel Wood, Chris Millington, Regional Staff

4:00 – 5:00 PM – Streamline the Federal Aid Process with Panel

Panel Members: FHWA: Chris Millington and Daniel Wood NYSDOT: Brenda Crudele, Office of Structures TBD, Office of Right-of-Way Panel Moderators: Diane Kenneally, Director, Office of Integrated Modal Services Todd Gadd, County Highway Superintendent, Wyoming County

SESSION 4B.1

Local Agency Forum

Karl Weiss, P.E. Nicholas Shrimpton, P.E. County Highway Superintendent Project Engineer Clinton County Hwy. Department Barton and Loguidice 736 NYS Route 3 443 Electronics Parkway Plattsburg, NY 12901 Liverpool, NY 13088 [email protected] [email protected]

Synopsis: The Cold Brook Road Bridge was “red flagged” and closed in the fall of 2018. Due to the long detour route and looming winter months, it was necessary to get the bridge back open to traffic as quickly as possible. Help delivering this project came from an unlikely source located 300 miles away. The Clinton County Highway Department coordinated with the Monroe County Department of Transportation to utilize two of their Tappan Zee panels for the project. The bridge was designed and constructed within 4 months of being closed. The presentation provides a summary of the coordination between the two counties, the challenges encountered utilizing Tappan Zee panels and the obstacles overcome to deliver a project in a compressed timeframe. About the Presenters: Nicholas J. Shrimpton, P.E., Barton & Loguidice Nick has 5 years of engineering experience with Barton & Loguidice. He earned his Bachelor of Science degree in Civil Engineering from Syracuse University in 2014 and became a Licensed Professional Engineer in the State of New York in the fall of 2018. Mr. Shrimpton has been involved in a wide range of local and federal-aid transportation engineering projects, with a focus on bridge design and construction administration. Karl T. Weiss, P.E., Clinton County Highway Department Karl has been the Clinton County Highway Department Superintendent since January 2019. He was previously Deputy Superintendent for 4 years. Prior to Clinton County, Karl worked for consulting engineering design firms in Plattsburgh, NY and New Jersey. Mr. Weiss graduated from Villanova University in 1999 with a degree in Civil Engineering and has been a Licensed Professional Engineer in the State of New York since 2008. During his time with the County, Mr. Weiss has been involved in several Federal Aid bridge replacement projects as well as Multi-Use Trail projects and BridgeNY projects.

SESSION 5.1

Cold Brook Road Replacement with

Tappan Zee Bridge Panels

Younes Drihmi, P.E. Gary Hammond, P.E. McFarland Johnson Commissioner of Tioga County Public Works 49 Court Street 477 Route 96 P.O. Box 1980 Owego, NY 13827 Binghamton, NY 13902 [email protected] Synopsis: The presentation will provide a summary of the Tioga County Bridge Maintenance Program. This will include a discussion of NYSDOT and FHWA Bridge Preventive Maintenance guidelines, the program funding process, bridge maintenance activities and their associated cycles and maintenance costs. McFarland Johnson and the County developed a multi-year maintenance program based on Tioga County priorities, geography, bridge maintenance requirements, maintenance activity cycles, and other parameters. Selected data for each of the Tioga County bridges is being entered into a GIS database that allows on-line review of the locations, ratings and preventive maintenance schedules for each Programed phase. The implementation of this GIS tool provides an effective and quantitative approach to monitor the condition of the County’s bridge inventory and measures the benefit of County’s Bridge Maintenance Program. About the Presenters: Younes Drihmi P.E. Younes Drihmi P.E. is a project engineer with McFarland Johnson. Younes graduated from Syracuse University with a Bachelor of Science in Civil Engineering. He is a licensed professional engineer in New York and Virginia with 10 years of experience in bridge design including a wide variety of bridge rehabilitation and replacement projects, bridge load ratings, bridge inspection and construction support. Mr. Drihmi has been at the forefront of McFarland Johnson’s efforts to develop a bridge maintenance and preservation system that will provide bridge owners with a multi-year bridge preservation strategy and a monitoring tool to track the condition of bridge inventories. He is currently serving as the lead engineer for several federally funded multiphase Bridge Maintenance Programs in Region 9 and oversees the design and construction management on all program phases. Gary Hammond P.E. was appointed Tioga County Public Works Commissioner in May of 2015. He served as the Deputy Commissioner of Public Works for 17 years prior to his appointment. Gary currently oversees a workforce of 38 employees and is

SESSION 5.2

Tioga County Bridge Maintenance

Program

Mark R. Laistner, P.E. Kirk A. Morris, Commissioner Director, Bridge Design Department of Public Works Popli Design Group Town of Greece 555 Penbrooke Drive 647 Long Pond Road Penfield, NY 14526 Rochester, NY 14612 [email protected] [email protected]

Synopsis: This presentation will discuss the replacement of Maiden Lane Bridge over Round Pond Creek in the town of Greece, NY. Funding for the project was provided by the Bridge-NY Program. The bridge carries approximately 11,000 vehicles per day and is located in a highly-developed suburban area, adjacent to a signalized intersection, shopping plaza, gas station and a church. The replacement bridge is a precast concrete three-sided structure supported on precast concrete invert slabs. The structure has a clear span of 30 feet, an overall width of 83 feet and is built on a 38-degree skew.

The project addressed the condition of the existing deteriorated reinforced concrete box culvert structure. Corroded reinforcement and spalling of the concrete top slab had reduced the load carrying capacity of the bridge. The condition, if left unaddressed, would have required posting of the bridge with a load restriction in the very near future.

The presentation will cover the preliminary design, final design and construction phases of the project. The presentation will discuss various challenges encountered throughout the project. These include a strict project schedule, limited funding, unanticipated ROW acquisitions, utility conflicts and WZTC challenges.

About the Presenters: Mark R. Laistner graduated from the State University of New York at Buffalo with a degree in Civil Engineering in 1987. Upon graduation, he accepted a position as a Junior Engineer in the Structures Department at a Rochester, NY consulting firm. He has remained in Rochester throughout his career, providing structural engineering services throughout Western New York. He is a Licensed Professional Engineer in New York, Pennsylvania, and Maine. He is currently the Director of Bridge Design at Popli Design Group where his is responsible for managing the firm’s bridge design staff, the management of bridge projects and the development of new business. Mr. Laistner’s 32 years of experience includes the design, inspection, and load rating of bridges. He has been the lead structural engineer on 50+ bridge replacement and rehabilitation projects, including 35 LAFA projects, ranging from a 20-ft precast concrete box culvert to a 2,300-ft steel deck truss bridge. His design experience includes pre-

SESSION 5.3

Bridge NY Project:

Maiden Lane Bridge Replacement

stressed concrete, steel multi-girder and timber bridges including the rehabilitation of historic bridges, railroad bridges, trusses, and a cable suspension bridge. In addition, he has also designed several buildings, various industrial structures, hydraulic engineering structures, culverts, and retaining walls. Kirk A. Morris has served as the Commissioner of Public Works for the Town of Greece since 2014. Prior to his appointment, Kirk served two terms as a member of the Greece Town Board and is the former Deputy Monroe County Clerk and Chief of Staff to NYS Senator Joseph Robach. He also served as Chairman of the Greece Board of Zoning Appeals and as a member of the Monroe County Planning Board. As Commissioner, Morris manages all divisions of Public Works for the Town of Greece and its 97,000 residents; including highway and road maintenance and construction, snow removal, equipment purchase/maintenance and preparation and administration of the department’s $21 million budget. Morris manages 98 employees and a vast critical infrastructure network which includes over nine-hundred (900) town roads, five-hundred (500) miles of sanitary and storm sewers, thirty (31) sanitary sewer pump stations, six-hundred (600) miles of sidewalks, four bridges, 472 culverts, nine (9) pedestrian bridges and 30 stormwater management facilities. The Town of Greece also maintains eleven thousand (11,000) right-of-way street trees, twelve-thousand (12,000) streetlights and a five (5) mile-long multi-use, pedestrian and bicycle path.

Brian J. Carlson, P.E. Alexey Brumagin, P.E. Senior Structural Engineer Engineer III Greenman Pedersen, Inc. Chautauqua County DPF 403 Main St., Suite 330 454 N. Work St. Buffalo, NY 14203 Falcone, NY 14733 [email protected] [email protected]

Michael J. Mann, P.E. Principal Engineer McMahon & Mann Consulting Engineers, P.C. 2495 Main St., Suite 432 Buffalo, NY 14214 [email protected]

Synopsis: The South Main Street Bridge is a historic arch bridge built circa 1872 and comprised of two stone arches with two abutments, a center pier, and stone spandrel walls and parapets. A 2014 inspection detected severe deterioration of the arches, thereby compromising support of the bridge. Based on the historic nature of the bridge, it was decided to rehabilitate the structure instead of replacing it. During the rehabilitation, the original structure was exposed, providing an interesting snapshot into construction techniques in the late 1800’s.

This presentation will review the project focusing on the foundation improvement work done, rehabilitation of the arch barrels, spandrel walls and parapets Additionally, we will discuss the impact utilities had on the project and focus on lessons learned through the process of restoring this 140+ year-old structure.

About the Presenters: Brian Carlson is a Senior Engineer with GPI/Greenman Pedersen Inc. He has twenty-one years of design experience with a focus on bridge and highway projects; and is a licensed Professional Engineer in New York State. A graduate of Fredonia State College and SUNY at Buffalo, Mr. Carlson received a bachelor’s degree in Civil Engineering and a bachelor’s degree in Math-Physics (1997) and a master’s degree in Structural Engineering (1998).

SESSION 6.1

Historic Stone Arch Bridge Rehab:

Preserving the Past for Sustainability in the

Future

He joined the GPI Buffalo Office in 2011. He has managed numerous LAFAP bridge replacement and rehabilitation projects for cities, towns, and counties across Western New York. Throughout his career, Mr. Carlson has also worked with agencies such as NYSDOT and NYSTA having developed plans, specifications, and contract documents for dozens highway bridge and culvert projects. These structures have included straight and curved multi-span steel girder bridges; single span concrete box-beams and NEXT beams; single span Fiber Reinforced Polymer (FRP) structures; precast concrete arches and frames; stone masonry arches, and moveable bridge rehabilitation. In addition to his duties at GPI, Mr. Carlson is a Past President of the Buffalo Section of the American Society of Civil Engineers and an active member of the Association of Bridge Construction and Design. Alexey Brumagin received a bachelor’s degree in Civil Engineering Technology from RIT in 1993 and is a licensed Professional Engineer in the State of New York. He has over 26 years of experience with the Chautauqua County DPF Engineering Division. He is responsible for establishing the County’s bridge replacement/rehabilitation program. Chautauqua County has over 300 County owned bridges and maintains two dedicated bridge crews active in the replacement/rehabilitation of these bridges throughout the construction season. He is involved in design, bidding materials, scheduling and project management of these projects. He works with NYSDOT, Consultants, and Contractors on the Locally Administered Federal Aid projects and with NYSDOT and County Crews in addressing flags found during the state bridge inspection program. Mr. Mann received his Bachelor and Master of Science degrees in Civil Engineering from the University at Buffalo. He is a licensed professional engineer in New York, Pennsylvania, North Carolina, Oklahoma and Ohio and has 40 years of professional consulting engineering experience. He was employed by D'Appolonia Consulting Engineers, in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania from 1979 through 1987. In 1987 Mr. Mann joined Goldberg Zoino Associates, in Buffalo, New York. Mr. Mann and Donald R. McMahon formed McMahon & Mann Consulting Engineers in 1993, specializing in geotechnical and environmental engineering.

Christopher R. Wallin, P.E. City of Schenectady City Hall, Room 205 105 Jay Street Schenectady, NY 12305 [email protected]

Synopsis: Pedestrian bridges were submitted by the City to be preserved but at the end of the federal aid process the bridges were found to be more of a liability and burden to the community, so the money was used to remove the bridges. The presentation will cover:

• Project Intent and Application

• Award, Funding, Original Scope

• Existing Conditions

• Draft Design Report

• Public Hearing

• Results of Public Hearing

• Scope Change, MPO Planning Committee Action

• Construction

• Conclusions About the Presenter: City Engineer Christopher R. Wallin, P.E. was appointed to his position on June 11, 2012. A lifetime resident of the City of Schenectady Mr. Wallin oversees the operations, management and execution of the City’s Capital Projects related to above ground infrastructure including but not limits to roads, traffic signals, bridges, buildings and the City’s municipal golf course. Funding from these projects is procured from a number of sources including annual budget allocations, municipal bonds and State/Federal Grants. In addition, Mr. Wallin oversees the daily operations of the Department of Engineering including development plan review, permitting, lot consolidation and the daily maintenance of City owned facilities. He was named the Municipal Engineer of the Year in 2014 by the Capital District Chapter of the New York State Society of Professional Engineers. Prior to his appointment as City Engineer Mr. Wallin was employed at both M.J. Engineering (2009-2012) and Creighton Manning Engineering (2008-2009) where he was a design engineer on numerous land development projects located throughout the Capital Region. Mr. Wallin has a Bachelor of Science in Civil Engineering from the State

SESSION 6.2

When the Public Hearing Goes Right

Harry L. White 2nd, P.E. Director of the Structure Policy and Innovation Bureau 50 Wolf Road, 4th Floor Albany, NY 12232 [email protected]

Synopsis: Bridge Deck Overlays are a great way to extend the life of a superstructure that is in good shape but has a poor deck rating. Often, there is a direct correlation to what a bridge deck overlay will cost versus the expected lifespan of the treatment. This presentation looks at the currently available bridge deck overlay options including their costs, expected lifespans, and potential construction pitfalls. About the Presenter: Harry White is the Director of the Structure Policy and Innovation Bureau for the New York State DOT Office of Structures. He previously led the NYSDOT Standards and Policies Unit, the NYSDOT Research and Development Bureau - Structures Unit, the NYSDOT Quality Assurance Chemistry Laboratories, and was a NYSDOT Structures Design Squad leader. He graduated from Union College in Schenectady, NY with a Bachelor of Science in Civil Engineering, and is a registered professional engineer in NY State.

SESSION 6.3

Bridge Deck Overlay Options

Todd Gadd, P.E.

County Highway Superintendent Wyoming County 4328 Route 19 Rock Glen, NY 14550 [email protected]

Synopsis: A review of the topics discussed at the Local Agency Forum. About the Presenter: Todd Gadd first received an Associates Degree in Applied Science from Alfred State College in Construction Engineering Technology in 1995. Then he went on to receive a Bachelor of Science Degree in Civil and Environmental Engineering from Clarkson University in 1997. Mr. Gadd has been with the Wyoming County Highway Department since 2007 serving as the Highway Superintendent. Prior to coming to Wyoming County Highway, Mr. Gadd worked approximately 10 years for a Western New York Heavy Highway General Contractor as a project superintendent on various highways and bridges in Western New York. Todd has been involved with and held various positions within several professional organizations including ABCD, NYSCHSA and APWA.

SESSION 6.4

Local Agency Report

Rohit Dagli, P.E.

NYSDOT Office of Structures 50 Wolf Road, POD 4-3 Albany, NY 12232 [email protected]

Synopsis: The Statewide Conference on Local Bridges’ Steering Committee instructed the Training and Communication Subcommittee to focus on forming an effective partnership among NYSDOT, local highway officials, and the Cornell Local Roads Program to identify training and communication opportunities which will strengthen and clarify technical, administrative, and procedural linkages among the state’s bridge partners. To attain this, the subcommittee, which comprises a cross section of local, state, federal, consultant and academic professionals across the state has surveyed the local bridge community and has identified areas where training can help local bridge owners manage and maintain their structures. The subcommittee update will discuss yesterday’s training sessions, evaluations by attendees and future direction of training workshops in coming years.

About the Presenter: Rohit Dagli heads up the Structures Technology Support Services in the Office of Structures, of the NYSDOT. Rohit had been with the Bridge Design Bureau since joining the Department in 1987. He graduated from L. D. College of Engineering, India with a Bachelor of Engineering in Civil Engineering in 1979. Since joining the Bridge Design Bureau, Rohit has designed different types and varieties of bridges including arch, truss, steel, concrete, and precast structures. Rohit is also actively involved in training activities in the Office of Structures and coordinates training for the Statewide Local Bridge Conference. Rohit can be contacted at the address above if you have any questions or comments concerning the training for Statewide Local Bridge Conference.

SESSION 6.5

Training Subcommittee Update

Statewide Conference on Local Bridges 2020 Program Chair

Michael Ruppe, P.E. NYSDOT Office of Structures 50 Wolf Road, POD 4-3 Albany, NY 12232 (518) 457-5955 [email protected]

Please contact Michael to make program suggestions for the 2020 Conference

How to Access Conference Presentations Online:

1. Go to NYSDOT website – https://www.dot.ny.gov/lbc

2. Click the desired year (2003–2019) on left

3. Click on "Presentations"

October 23 & 24, 2019 in Syracuse, NY

APPENDIX