uifsa: the fundamentals and more diane sinkus, instructor pennsylvania child support enforcement...

34
UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University [email protected] 1

Upload: noah-miles

Post on 13-Dec-2015

219 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More

Diane Sinkus, InstructorPennsylvania Child Support

Enforcement Training InstituteThe Pennsylvania State [email protected]

1

Page 2: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

Adoption of UIFSA

• PRWORA mandated that states enact UIFSA• The Goal- One Controlling Order

– Multiple states may enforce – Only one has the jurisdiction to modify

2

Page 3: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

Interstate Legislation

• Uniform Reciprocal Enforcement of Support Act (URESA)

• Revised Uniform Reciprocal Enforcement of Support Act (RURESA)

• Full Faith and Credit for Child Support Orders Act (FFCCSOA)

• Uniform Interstate Family Support Act (UIFSA)

3

Page 4: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

Key Aspects

• Visitation may not be raised and is not a defense to nonpayment of support

• UIFSA has enhanced evidence rules• Non-paternity is not a defense, if paternity has

been established or acknowledged• There are one-state and two-state procedures

4

Page 5: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

Analyzing an Interstate Action

• If there is no order, an order needs to be established.

• If there is only one order, determine whether it needs enforcement or modification.

• If there are multiple orders, determine the controlling order before taking further action

5

Page 6: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

Determining the Controlling Order

• One controlling order is the cornerstone of UIFSA and FFCSOA.

• When multiple valid support orders exist, there are rules for determining which support order governs.

• States must give full faith and credit to valid child support orders issued by other states

6

Page 7: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

Determining the Controlling Order

• UIFSA and FFCCSOA use the same rules for reducing multiple valid support orders to one controlling order– No provision in either law invalidates any

previously issued valid support order– A controlling order determination is made only

once, when multiple orders exist

7

Page 8: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

Determining the Controlling Order

• For a state to make a controlling order determination, all of these conditions must exist:– There must be multiple orders for current support– The request must be accompanied by a certified

copy of every order in effect• Two stages to the determination

– Preliminary determination– Formal determination by a tribunal

8

Page 9: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

9

How many child support orders exist?

That child support order is the controlling order even if all parties have left the state.

1

2 or

more

Are any of the orders in the child’s “Home” state? YES

NO

That child support order is the controlling order.

Are any of the orders in the NCP’s or CP’s state? YES

That child support order is the controlling order.

If the individual CP is not in the child’s home state and there are orders in both the CP’s and NCP’s state, the order most RECENTLY entered order is the controlling order

If all parties have left the state the order must be registered for modification in the state of the “non-requesting party” (‘”play away’)

NO

There is no controlling order. A state with jurisdiction over the non-requesting party must establish a NEW order.

Page 10: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

Case 1

10

$250/mo

$150/mo

Page 11: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

Case 2

11

$150/mo

$200/mo

Page 12: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

Formal Determination

• The order must include:– The basis on which the determination was made– The amount of prospective support– The amount of arrears and interest

• Within 30 days, the requesting party must file a certified copy of the determination order with each tribunal that had issued an earlier child support

12

Page 13: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

Formal Determination

• The controlling order determination cannot be relitigated unless overturned on appeal.

• Tribunal with jurisdiction to determine the controlling order also reconciles the arrears– Required by states that have adopted UIFSA 2001

13

Page 14: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

Reconciliation of Arrears

• Consolidates arrears accumulated under multiple orders into a single amount

• Calculation is based on:– Periodic amount of the support order– Number of unpaid periods or accruals– Payments made on any of the orders

14

Page 15: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

Reconciliation of Arrears - Formula1)For any period of time when only one order was in

effect, the total amount of support due for that period is based on that order.

2)From the amount due, the amount that the obligor actually paid in that period is subtracted.

3)The difference between them is the arrears for that period.

4)Any period of time when more than one order was actually in effect, the same steps are followed, but the total amount of support due for that period is based only on the highest order in effect during that period.

5)The arrears for different periods of time are added into a single total less any payments = total due at time of calculation.

15

Page 16: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

Establishment

• Long-arm: Legal provision that permits one state to claim personal jurisdiction over someone who lives in another state. – Meaningful connection between the person and

the state asserting jurisdiction– Service of Process Issues

16

Page 17: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

Jurisdiction

• The power and authority to hear and determine a support matter, which may include, but is not limited to– Establishing paternity– Establishing a support order– Modifying a support order– Enforcing the payment and/or other terms of an

existing support obligation

17

Page 18: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

Types of Jurisdiction

• Subject-matter jurisdiction• Personal jurisdiction• Long-arm jurisdiction (extended personal

jurisdiction) • In rem jurisdiction.

18

Page 19: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

Long-arm Provisions

• Personal service of NCP within the state• Submission to jurisdiction by consent of NCP

– By entering a general appearance– By filing a responsive document having the effect

of waiving any contest to personal jurisdiction

• NCP lived with the child in the state• NCP lived in the state and provided prenatal

expenses or support for the child

19

Page 20: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

Long-arm Provisions

• Child is living in the state due to directives or acts of NCP

• NCP had sexual intercourse in the state, possibly resulting in conception of the child

• NCP acknowledged or claimed paternity in the satte

• Other basis consistent with state and U.S. Constitutions

20

Page 21: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

Establishment

• The tribunal that establishes the order applies its laws regarding the support amount and duration of the support obligation. § 303

• Long-arm jurisdiction cannot be used to modify an order unless the requirements of § 611 or § 615 are met. § 201(b) [01]

21

Page 22: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

One-State Establishment Tools:

Use long-arm to establish paternity and/or order

Directly retain process server

Send interstate subpoenas to secure evidence

Quick locates

CSE Trans #3 to secure documents, including service of process, genetic testing, and assistance with discovery

22

Page 23: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

Two-State Establishment

• Initiating Process includes:– Completing all UIFSA required paperwork– Forwarding the documents to the Central Registry

of the responding state– Following up on the case– Appling the laws of the tribunal that establishes

the order to the support amount and duration of the support obligation

23

Page 24: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

Two-State Establishment

• Responding process includes:– Acknowledging the request– Establishing paternity and support, if requested– Providing details to the initiating state– Enforcing the support order

24

Page 25: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

Direct Enforcement

• Multiple states may enforce a support order.– The jurisdiction is based on personal jurisdiction

over the obligor or in rem jurisdiction over an asset.

• Direct Income Withholding– Communicate with other States– Use on any valid support order to any state– Keep issuing state informed of any payments

25

Page 26: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

Registration

• Process in which a support order issued by one tribunal is filed in another tribunal

• Types– Enforcement-only – Modification-only – Enforcement and modification

• Allows the state in which the order is registered to take action

26

Page 27: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

Registration – Enforcement Only

• Confirmation is of validity of the order and the amount of the arrears alleged

• No objection can be made to the substantive provisions of the order in the registering state

• Laws of the registering state apply for enforcement only

• 20 day contest period available for the non-registering party

27

Page 28: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

Valid Defenses to Registration

1. The issuing tribunal lacked personal jurisdiction over the contesting party

2. The order was obtained by fraud 3. The order has been vacated, suspended,

or modified by a later order 4. The issuing tribunal has stayed the order

pending appeal 5. There is a defense under the law of this

State to the remedy sought

28

Page 29: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

Valid Defenses to Registration

6. Full or partial payment has been made 7. The statute of limitation under § 604

(Choice of Law) precludes enforcement of some or all of the alleged arrearage

8. The alleged controlling order is not the controlling order

Note: Nonparentage is not a defense § 315

29

Page 30: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

Continuing Exclusive Jurisdiction (CEJ)

• Pertains specifically to modification• CEJ maintained by issuing state as long as one

of the parties in the support case resides in that state

• Petitioning party must file for modification in the state with CEJ– If the issuing state loses CEJ, modification must be

filed in the state of the party that is not asking for the modification (Play Away)

30

Page 31: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

Important Points

• CEJ is only relevant when one of the parties wants to modify the controlling order

• Under UIFSA, only the state with CEJ has the right to modify an existing support order.– When CEJ is lost, the issuing state loses the ability to modify the

child support order.• Only the terms that are modifiable in the controlling

order state can be modified. • If another state gains CEJ, it cannot modify terms of the

original controlling order that are non-modifiable – duration of the obligation – age of emancipation

31

Page 32: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

32

Case 3

PAY$250/mo

Page 33: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

Resources

• UIFSA found at www.nccusl.org• OSCE website:

www.acf.dhhs.gov/programs/cse/ – Interstate forms can be found using the Forms link– A link to NECSRS:

http://ocse.acf.hhs.gov/necsrspub/– IM 01-08 is the One-State and Limited Services

Interstate Case Processing Tempo and other policy information

33

Page 34: UIFSA: The Fundamentals and More Diane Sinkus, Instructor Pennsylvania Child Support Enforcement Training Institute The Pennsylvania State University dxs353@outreach.psu.edu

34

Intergovernmental Referral Guide (IRG) Public Map Page

 Intergovernmental Referral Guide (IRG):http://ocse.acf.hhs.gov/ext/irg/sps/selectastate.cfm