ORDER NO.

ENTERED

BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITY COMMISSION

OF OREGON

In the Matter of

P ACIFICORP, dba PACIFIC POWER,

2015-2019 Renewable Portfolio Standard hnplementation Plan

UM 1681

ORDER

DISPOSITION: STAFF'S RECOMMENDATION ADOPTED

JUL .22 2014

This order memorializes our decision, made and effective at the public meeting on July 22, 2014, to adopt Staff's recommendation in this matter. The Staff Report with the recommendation is attached as Appendix A.

tYJ_ Dated thi~ day of ~ {=:'.) , 2014, at Salem, Oregon.

~ K-- f1VJ:t/ UA-susan K. Ackerman

Chair

Steplifu M. Bloom Commissioner

A party may request rehearing or reconsideration of this order under ORS 756.561. A request for rehearing or reconsideration must be filed with the Commission within 60 days of the date of service of this order. The request must comply with the requirements in OAR 860-001-0720. A copy of the request must also be served on each party to the proceedings as provided in OAR 860-001-0180(2). A party may appeal this order by filing a petition for review with the Court of Appeals in compliance with ORS 183.480 through 183.484.

ORDER NO.

PUBLIC UTILITY COMMISSION OF OREGON STAFF REPORT

PUBLIC MEETING DATE: July 22, 2014

f_,

ITEM NO. CA13

REGULAR CONSENT X EFFECTIVE DATE Upon Commission

Approval

DATE: July 14, 2014

TO: Public Utility Commission

FROM: £&forlfB

R-yan Bra~ fl!~{,,- M_. 11'. ~ THROUGH: Jason Eisdorfer, Maury Galbraith, and Aster Adams

SUBJECT: PACIFICO RP (Docket No. UM 1681) 2013 Renewable Portfolio Standard Implementation Plan: Compfiance Years 2015-2019

STAFF RECOMMENDATION:

Staff recommends that the Commission acknowledge PacifiCorp's 2013 Renewable Portfolio Standard Implementation Plan (RPIP) analyzing the compliance years 2015-

. 2019 as detailed in the attached Stipulation (Attachment A).

DISCUSSION:

PacifiCorp, Oregon Public Utility Commission Staff (Staff), Citizens' Utility Board (CUB), Renewables Northwest (RNW), Industrial Customers of Northwest Utilities (ICNU), and the Oregon Department of Energy (ODOE) have reviewed PacifiCorp's RPIP. and arrived .at!he Stipulation that is Attachment A to this memo.

PacifiCorp's 2013 RPIP details the Company plans to comply with the Renewable. Portfolio Standard (RPS) from 2015 through 2019. Staff reviewed and concluded that PacifiCorp's RPIP is consistent with the requirements of OAR 860-083-400, including that PacifiCorp submitted the required information and that the required analysis was performed and provided. The Stipulation does request waiver of the requirements of OAR 860-083-400(8); however, those requirements are only procedural and timing requirements.

The Stipulation details that all of the interested groups, with the exception of ICNU, support acknowledgement of PacifiCorp's RPIP with conditions for additional analysis to be included in the Company's next RPIP to be filed at the end of 2015. ICNU does not oppose acknowledgement consistent wi.th the attached Stipulation.

APPENDIX A Page 1of15

ORDER NO.

Page 2

PROPOSED COMMISSION MOTION:

Acknowledge PacifiCorp's 2013 RPIP with the conditions detailed in the attached Stipulation (Attachment A).

pocket No. U-M 1681; Pa'cifiCorp's-2013 RPIP -

APPENDIX A Page 2of15

ORDER NO. li

IlEJi'OJlE .THE PJJJJqC IJT1LlTY ()Q!\1M1S$l0N . Oli' OREGON

t!M ltl8.l 3

4 fa theMa!!erofPADlE!CORP

5

6

7

20f3 Re1rewablello11fol!o Stlli.ldard J11ipleme1\tatioiJ Plali: Coi11plia1ice Years'20:t5'-20[9

& ,PARTIES

9 I. 1'1re~·liest\l this ~t\p.ulafrou are 'StaftofOie fublie Utility C\JJnt11.issio11 QfQregon

JO ("Staff'}, tile Cilize1\s7 Utility Hoard ofOtegoi\ {~00.B''), !'iieilfOoi'P dba Pacilic Power

11 (!~Pa!!'.ifiO~rnpi•),J~eltewabfo Nol'lliwiist ("RNW"), ·allc!Jnd11stfial ·t:iislomers of))lorthwesi

12 !J{iliJies~"IQN0"'~, ~11cl Hm·oregl)nTl¢parlment of Energy .("QPbB'')(eqll!llctively "the . .

14 DACKGROUNJ)

15 2. O,Rs ~ll~pte1• 469Ae&tablls\1J.1Sa Renewable Pnrtfolio.stm1cla1:d{"RPS"} fer Oregon

16 1rtillties.tmde'l: .w.!1lcl1a· speeific pei~ntageo.f'the energy ·$Gld to1:~taii ct1&tome1:s •mist

17 comeffam eertain renewable•Tesources ("Qualifying Electricity"}. Ferlargeufilities,

18 inelucli,\g ~apiftG\>rp, fiye perceil! ofth'« elech'ioity s9ld to;i tel;iil cusfi:111)ei:s1J11!St i.Je

I 9 qt1alifyfog electricity in eafoudat years20Llc2014, liwte•aJih)g lb l.:S: percent foi· .calei1dar

lib year~ JWJ 5<ro2'4; ancl increasing to 25 percent for 2.025 and subsequent years.

21 }. Purst(antto olt$.46f!A.075 and OAR 860-08s-J)4D0,11 utmi.y st1bject to the lWS is

22 reqiiirecl lo file a Renewable Pertfolio Sfaridard ln1plementatidil Plan ('''RPIP") et1 or

23 before Ja!lltat;y 1 o·f ead1 eve1H1umbered calendar year; The RP!P m1.1s! analyze five

24 Cll.f1Jplil'!11Cl! 1lfea1·s, sia,tlng witl1 the ne~~ oddcnut1ibe.red year ani;l ittclu(!e, at a minintttm,

25 tlle anmraJ tatgets for eolnpfiance as well as the estimated costs of meeting these targets.

26 4. Pursuant to OAR 360-083-0400(8), the Commission will acknowledge a RPIP, subject lo

Page 1 - STIPULATION - UM 1681 Dej~1Jrlme111 ofJu~_tis-e­J 162 Co mt StrCll'I NE

Snlen~. 0R97:l01-4096 ()03) 9<7·•1520/ F•x: (503) 178-378<1 APPENDIX A

Page 3 of15

3 ~l

1

2

3

4

~

6.

7

8

g

10

n 12

13

Hr

l~

16

17

Jlf

19

2D

ii

22

2S

24 25

26

iwt c0iiditio11s specil!ed by tire CQ111111issiim ftt a public 1i1eetfog, \111less tile l3Jrm1nis$lQ1i.

.decides fo conuuenee all Jnvesti~iidn or take othe1·a\Jrioh as hebe!l!>ai'ylo.1m1keits

dt11!i$iol1!'Mardipg ii1;k11o;wledgn1e1ii of the plan. AelrnuwJedg111e11! mu!il G'0111e ,,yit)Hn 6

l\Jo1ftfrs of:the RPfP fiff!i!l·

S.. PaGititlorpfi'lect.i!s RPIP.iDn Deb.mliber• :i61 2013, a1id llpdhtecl.thellJ'.tll'o1t:Febt:t1aliy L8~

ilQJ 4, J.11~. £1'.lffdl\te<l')U:'!P indudfld l! J1oncll.<\f1l:idenila)s~m1nary pf R?S !9lal incre11ienlll'1

eo&!$dfc011ip'rfa1\cl)I

6. to.eom]!ly wtlh t11e R:P8<; Pa<.iifiCiD1'p i1T11st1tsil ret\ewa.bfo c11eligy.J:\er1il:icates'(REq}tbat

qua'!jt¥ for tb'e !<PS at ~1l<IJJJ,OlJl!l \lql]al fo i;l.5 p.erc¢1JI oJils e~!:i<fc!ed Q1:egon l1;1adfor eJ!e!i

yea!' .fro ill 2'01$,~'2:tn9. One, REC repl·e~j!)iff'$' @We ~1regaMHt" hput (M'Wl1J iff l)l1¢!1gy

,ge1\e1:;1retlhya,r!JneW!lhletesouree, Af lM£tlliO·peree11t of!he.«REOts.used'ih·a

co11>Jjt~ru1~e~a1· r)Hlst·fl,e. br111dr(llf, tlibqgli 9trofth e· RE'Cs tisec! ilr l\Year eaJJ. be,ge/ie~ated

iilp1·.e.vio11$. yM1·s Ei"''·• biiifked ~EC~). ORS 4tl9A..J !10 e1heet~lh<1thi.1J1kerj IUtGl£ 1~1i1s.t Pe used b!ilfl"reR~Jlenerated.'llt!he,complfanee yem•and< that "banked1•e11ewahle energy

cilt~il:ie<>te& *'l!h j)ie ptcJe~t ifiStiauee d~k 11111~! be use\l tQ ef!111pjy wnh:~tal1da[d be!(J:i:e

bru1ked .. re11ewabJe e11e1•g,yee~tirfc11t:es with tiio1~.rec;e11t fasnaneecfafe$ al'elts!)d.'"1

7, The following graphshow3 .. Pac(!iQprp•~ eJ!pected ).<f:Qretiren1enis by eon\plhm'C<;year

hf\lBllligy .si:f\ll'ci>'tO ~w::et \In> l;; ,pt;rcent.Je!JeW!\hl\l sta11cl.1Jrd. Fil ta .0011.>pa!il.~Ql! on !l).e

C.oi:npah~ 1sabJ!ity.tP me<itits R?S.c<>mioliaitce,obllgalion with a11ntral <*P:!:\¢tecl,

genexl\i'ion2 ~nc! lo sh.ciw the·i.111pa!Jt.QfnC l.?!!1tkii1g:o11compliall'~i:i,. the !l.l'<lPh!ltlscr ~haws

the a.ro111ai ex:Jil~<;ted gener11tio.n l!fB~ct£i~fo1:p's owned and pon)ractedquaJ!fyiim ' - ,- - - '·- - - ' - - - ""'

' !JrOrd~r)>,ld. l:';IA~fi, till' €'01(1'1.1\i\S(9.11 a.db.p1'f'd Stfytr~ 1·ccomn¢•1dajion aUovilng WREGIS ce1tifi~ates with older vi•ll!\IJ~e IP be dt1lv!i1 llti~!~ ltti!ity:':$b.a!lkall<;t WR);i()lscvttif)Jiill6S<Wlil1 l)l~•)'r¥c~1ft vii)tllgtls ll' tl!~ e~s~ oflow imp<ll't hydro (ttMY)•c1lleg!l•:Y m1.\l unbm\llled R.EG ootegol')'. hi t/1e M(Jl(ei· of PMi/ifJo11>, ?lb(t f'rr¢ijiq;!Jou'e!'g/Jf I !if!~ €'0111p/ia1•~e, Docket Ul\11 1~06, Otrl~r N<i. !2·435 at 4PP*•.1dix 4 .Cl'lov, I~. 29l2) \"As.a t·esqlt, Staff reGoi'11n1eJ1ds-'th'e, Conunissio1rapply the l~\V tQ allo\\' the-CoJnpaJl)'"to. 1·d,ra\Y) 2.ECs~ ffii~sri~1 1 fit~ otl't1Ji·an) ih> Q'aok in tltr.01' separate 'draws'; lH1bmrdled; LJHY; and bundled;" Jd:j, · - - . - - . 2 Th1' P~ftk,s note 1!r~J tl1et'' is 11a1M11.ir0t;l\l!l.t (\1rn ntilicz .!IY me~t 'its,RPS cp(iipli;11\ce obHgairo11 Wilh ~nn1u1! cxpec·ted g&11eratiOJL

Pnge2- 8'.flPUL.1\TlQW- UM 16.81 l)tphTlment- Of-i11stTte 11:62-.Comt Sttecr NE::.

_Sh_lti!1,, 0 R 9:7:;,o 0

! "UJ.9'6 CS-03Y947'4ll>,oif•'< (SOJIJ.78'3784 APPENDIX A

Page !I of 15

l

2

3

4

.5

6

7

8

~

10

11

12

13

14

15

ORDER NO.

resources in 2019. l'acifiGdrp plans 11p·majoJ' 1·e11ew11ble resources td coin(; onJ.foe during

the 20l5-2019 pe~iod.

-~~--~.+---~~~~~~~~~~--,

Gr~ph h£11pected ~EC lmtlr~irnmt~forprego•n Rf'~·byCompllance.Year

2p•!!l w'19 E~i>~~tecl )\1l,iiqa:1,

Gei\~1J1tlo1r

:Ill HYdrO-:lfpgfacte;s~ild

LI~

16 8. Oriiph I aMve•ShQws .that 1n 2019 1'11oit)C6rp 0:,pel}l$ .t)1ah'Ougl1lySO p<>tcellt of!ts

17 Q'ualifyingB!ectricity will c01ile fre1\1 wind .power (41 percenlf1'om CcitWmi1y-0Wned

18 re.so\u·ces atld 34 peree11tfr01n cpntractedr~sources)> 17 percent from low-impact hydro

19' {LIH) and 11ydi:o.up~rades, and.the.reinaininglh\'ee:percent fro1~1 ·a combinafi@11 !llf

20 g<mthermal (l .6 pe1wnt~, solar {0.8 perdent), m1d.hiogas (0.2 petoetit/. This generation

2J nxil'f is 11early c.onstant ever tire 2015~2019 eompljli1ice perio\l. V!l!'lalions iil"lhe.mix of

22 RECs thnt PacifiCorp expects te retirexeflect the intetaction between cliffere11aes in

23 resource in-service/qualification dates and tlie fl.rst in/fits! out banked REG reth'ii'fnent

25 9. The Company's aiumal expccte.d ge11eratlon from qualifying renewable resources is 110!

2.6 expected toTeatih !$percent of PacifiGorp's Oregbh load il1 any year from 2015 to.2019,

Page 3 - STIPULATION - UM 16.81 Ocpnr1n1cul l;lf Jus_i,ice 1162 C.<n1rl _S(r)!el .NE

snkri1, OR 97301 •4096 (503) 9·17-4520 l Fnx: (503) J78·Jn4 APPENDIX A

Page 5of15

ORDER NO.

1 which tefle.cts. that PacifiC0111 is;l!tilizh1gba111'6tl RIEts to eo111J?IY witl1{he R\'S il1 thes.e

2 years. PacifiCorp exl)eets ta use:.ba1ikecl buncileclRECs:t0 coinpl)': withltte.Rl!>S. Though

3 Pacifi;C01:p's1ia11k.of hu11df{;d . .RBGs M>ill cl\je.1~ll!le.cl~iring.!h-y C;@mpll.ane.epe.riqg,

4 FaclfiCorpo;l\lill6JpMe.i> tbat·Hwlfl.s,tfl!J1ave. bM1kecl RECs.ilJ tlr<i. en\! of2:llt.9.

5 lO. l'aeifiCoq:!'°sRPIP shows:th~I Ptt6iCoup eXpliets,~o use soi11e ullbtmdl~d RECs f\i{

6 cd111pllance. li1 ~15, Hinveve.r1 ~h{l§e RflJCs :aret;itlre..f(oy· il~ of.'.lleifi.Cgrp's p@sses~i<;>i' an.d

1 t1fo RPIP Ms\°\i11es tli\j .Ot>ll1Pt\!iy ntil\~.1t\.lt(1111>11dt6 ')l uteJJl\~E;:a~ ad;\ljtkilll\) 1)11Jny~clJe<i

8' R.fills. (© use ·during the.101~20,f9·eo11ipliilnee11ei·locl.

9 lL ~tai'f~e."!Jeves th al f1acjfiCarp'cs ~lt{ slio11I'cl h1¢l.r1di; aJ!lllysis.,x;if'the. \1se.of u11~1111al'e.fl

HJ RECs tlia\ liav~ Ab! ·yet~~i P.tir~hase<l.I'©: coj)iJlila1l~ witl1 fl!e.JU!:>° Mc.a11J5t Jl1-efr 11sc

l1

tompliance;l\f'Ule2(!;pen:e1ft lill)it'il:\ tl1e last c.op1p!fa1i?1t ~ea~ (Z(ll~1. at\d !lie J'l9Ssi~Hity

!lll:.IM)l~ywi:l'l ,i1~e·unb11nclle.cl ~qs U1at:tlley have )'et tcqiurehase for cmnJ!lllance J112:\9\,'i,

16

IS

19 13. Staff agrees tlilS isa \tldid·co11ce1'n;.but stfll'believes tha!ilis i1np11ntl!lltio co11S:ider tlm

20. J!loS$lpi!1fyihatm1b\n1cl~ed ~EC~ w!U be J!lll~°Phl\Seclln tl1efuhure a11d ~1sed fo•' GOll'!Plif11lqe,

21 Staf!1•ecm1~11wncls that theC!J111m~soli'ci11\iii'el!t the C)Q111pa11y .to incl<J.\le hi n1J!H·~ RI'Ill$ a

22 sce11arlo that usesJhe basec.ase:assn1\1pfions·where the Com;pai\j'n\axltnl~sthe use uf

2:3 9l1pt\11dled. RE Cs for eaei1 year analyzei! 'hi the· !l.PIP, ·'14'~<~inlng ·al) 1\nbi111clle.cl IlJ)}C 111'i'<;e

24 eljnafto the \lfeigl\fedavcwag;o l)rroo J!!!lidOtbr uilbut1cile<l RIEC.s 1ised hi the L&st coiupl\cynce

25 year;

26

Page4- STIPULATION - lJMlif&l oepart11iqul-0(111stitc 116'2 court S!r~erNU

Stilgm, OR 973'01,-4096 (503) 9{7'452-0i I'n.<: (503)37ll-3Jjl4 APPENDIX A

Page 6of15

l

2

3

4

5

6

'l

8

9

lO

11

l2

r1

14

1.5

JJ

17

J~

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

2.6

ORDER NO.

AGREEMENT

l 4. The Par ti.es olhet than PaQ·ffi Corp ha.ve te:Yiewed Pa11ificorp's RPIP.

1,5, 11re Partres a.gree that PadftCol'p's RPIP sl!oWS''thaLi t !s.jlositiom!d ~be "hi col11JJfia11ce

w\(!1 ORS 46!)1\.052., W,hfo!1c11tates ti\\\! ~~ le.ast 15 Jlyl'ceni Qf.rl\e electrkity sold by a large.

mllityto retail cu.ston~r~ ill 'elloh of the cal1111da1• yCll\~ ofihe ileii,t c1>111plia11ee period

(20!.~2019), 1nust be l:;)\ialifyihg Eletfl'leity:

1'6'..•PacifJ.c<Jr~;QJJJ~. RMW,,an(\ QD0E·supporlack1!r:>Wfo(\ginent of PacifiCorp's 201 ~."2019

RJ>Ili!. ICN tJ (\oes not()p~.0se ack1+owle.dI;i.ne!1tof tl!e RP:IP .h\'cau$e i~ 'h~ consfste11:t With

tlh: atlcpariy st\pulaJlonin IJocketJlilo. UM t616, .si1bjecl to the1oiloW1ng doiidltlo1i:

Pac;'uico1p: will.li1ch1de11110J1'0011ficlentialsu11rn1.~1·¥ o!R.B's··toaal. inc\'el1I\'lltli.l .cps\S for \!!l.Yl!.seena1jg alll!I YZ\lc.l in frl(Ql~ R.Pll"s·

Tl,. $~~£fsuppot.ts.1rck111;>~yl~gm0nfof Hre:RHIP subj0e.t to t,lre c.ondi ti on abov~as we I Las the

fdlJQWillg• .yonditwn;

P<19i~1J$orp will 'ii10lt1c.leij1 s11bseqi1,y11t RP!Psa 1!Cen~rio that.usesihebase ca§i' p1:i'ce l'.\1rve·assu11mtions (medi11l11 gasai\d meclitim C.02 prkes) •si1\1ilar to. that tis~ in flw other scenarios 'liUfieRPIP, wl.Ut tlie assunrp:tfon Jbe C01npany 1ilaxhuizes the. ust> qfmtbundle(i.R.EC for eaeb .Jeat·.ana)yze>I in the RPIP.!!lJd ~m11l\1g.a11. t1i}bu11d.le1fR.EC pl'ice eq9al to !lteWeiglitei( average price pat>l.fol' 1n1b1111dleil RECs trnect fdr.·cqrnpliance in 'their last compliance filing.

18; Thi.' Parpes agree andsc1ppcrt waiVe1· df tl!e1•¢quireu1ents of DAR &{J()•OSJ-

400:(&), p:t1tsw1nt to oA.[{ 8(1\.Fosa.ooos(~).

19,. The Stipufo\iol'l will be o((ered'\1!10 t!1e recotd pf!)le above-c~tiQJleA docket pµrs\nmt \o.

Or\!<. 860~001-0.350, The Parties•agree to coopl)rale in drafting a-net sulmrrnlng an

explat\atory b1'lef Qr wri\tentestimony ]ler OAR 860-001-0350(7), unless such

1'i!ql!iren1ent'is waivec!. Tl1e Parties wfll st1pport the StipiHatlon throughout this

p1:ocee1U11g, including.aqy appeal; provide witnesses to. spoirsor the Stlpolation at any

Page 5 - ST!PULATI•N - UM !681 Di;ltHJJll\ltnl ofJ\isiic:e I lbiConrl Si.r,ce·t NE

Sate,m, 6R 973'0) ·-4U96 (503)947-45201 Fie" (503) 378-3784 APPENIJIX A

Page 7of15

2

3

4

15

9

'!J

8

9

ID

Lt

l2 1$

)II

)5

16

17

IS

19

2jl

'.41

22

23'

24

25

26

/It

JI/

//{

ORDER NO. ' ,1

i1eiil~ii1g h1'11d iiJ' flle:above-capti!lltecl docket, lmel reeoJ1lnlencl t)raHhe OPH)\lliSli!oll isime

an order adoplit)ll the seltlement co11talned herei1\;.

2'g, Jhe .i'-01ti!Jshitlfe neygotlm~tf1~ S'liP\!lcat~i;/1kiµ>.ani1i1Cg~~etl clo.c1m1ent. lfthe

C!linmi\smoh:~ects:a:H de n11y 111atei'.ial portlcin of'tbe l)ll:JJ1t!&t!N1, ·t:>r eonditions Jls

ap!)roval tlpilnfhe ii11posi!i1nt.1:o<l:addtlional matt1rfal c1;mdl\i&ns, :eaeh.P\li:ty 1'ese1:ves·its

r.Jght(i;)'\pwilhClrnw fl't:>lP..tbe:~tirmlat\011,·u,po1\l:Vrit~e1i 1\\lt'll:ie !\l the CP»m1j~lo!l a:11rt

ofh'e.i: t>.1J~tieswlHrii1 fi:ve,~5~ \lhs'h1ess.C!ar;s otseJvice gftW lihlll <ll'fil~rt!i~t.i~jects tll:ls

Stipulatidll in· wh\lre p1:ml)tet'ial j'lart,.or a<ldssuch .material co1rdttio11,;·fi:(),pmsuan! to

o~~ · \t60~P@f .:{)!lS(l~Cj); IO preve11t . eyici'1flce 1\llrl <!!'J?:lf\i:}etit O)l. {lt,e te\;QI:ci ~II ~11.l)pot;t of i 11<;.

:S'li)Jttlatid1t,.i11chlai11g::diil·li!ll1t.to·cross-e'.:llal11ihc.wltI1es.s:es.>.i11t1'(i~11tie· ev(t!~1ce:as Clee1)1ed

~!Jj!rdpti !Jlle t. ci'ros po nrt':fu.lly to .iss11.ea,-a11 d ra'rsdssues th a\,are i11eorporated. £ri the

§eijllon1~1i:ts. ot1~~lie~!1i t11e Slijmtiit.~ot1; a11.cl Qi.iii ,ptli'~1\l:\11ffo, pµ;S: 7'?'$,S 6J and P/\lt

:86<FO~l·'()nQ, lti ~1':.teh1t<1rj11g.i:5r ree011$\Clerat[o1) i:il'l<j ~peal lh¢ Qoulj)Jis~fonqr.dev

111rrler ORS '/!%,61'(), Nothing i11 tj1is:paragr~l)h,prpv:ides any .l'itr\y !he l'itht to withd1taw

fl'out 1J1is .Stipi1ljt~q11 ~s a resillrofthe bo111:111!~a'!1111'~xe~!?Mlon ,gfjs~t1es•t!)~ tl:iis

,\itlpulatiM.<16es 1iotr~ol.ke ..

71. By .e1*~vi!l!lhl!o thl~ 'SVf!t!l.aU:On; .. n<! Pa11ty sh;rll be ~.ee1m;cl tolw¥:e ~l"PrQveq, qdu:i.ittecl or

c.on~11teil to the 'fouts, JZifaGipl\:s, method$ ol'. tlJeori~s lifiU)Jl\>'Yed• ])y!atllf otheJ· Pa;rty l.u

lu'1•iv:il1g.iU t11etel'iUS·of the:Stij'lulatioi1. EKeef]t Vi:ithr<::&arCI tG>. RPfl>s,110 Party shn!Lhe,

deeinecf tlil h~y,e,ag~ed th:at&1l)' part oftbe·Stipi1lati0Jt ls;a)lprg!)ti.ilte for r~s9lving i's~t10s­

l!l'is·h1g.J\i, a;11y 0th er P:J'0,¢eeclhl!js.

2.:2. •. The. Stlpiilaf~oi\ 111ay lie exectHetl.in co1111te1']'larts arul.each signed co\l11terp.art shall

con~tit11te . .an 01:igi!1al do.C\111ie11l.

Pa~ii6- STIPULATION-H;M 16lfl D:ftpnr1ment ofJl!stfcc l 1'62 Cutht Sl~et NE­

Snlem, OR 97301-4096' (503) 94H52o I Vn.'; {50:}, 37S-37b"I APPENDIX A

Page 8of15

2

3

4

s (j

7

8

9

lCJ

11

u 13

b4

JS 16

11

18

19

20

21

26

ORDER NO. 1 C"i A

/,"),. ,L \0

This Stipulation is entered into !Jy cnd1 P!li:ty .on the d1ite(s) enlcl'e.d be)o\V.

ClTliENS~ utIL.ITY BOARD INDUSTRIAL .CUSTOMERS OF THE NQRTHW,Es.t·urrttTIES

Dn~d: ~~------~

PUl!!LllC UTILITY COMMISSION STAl'F l'ACll'lC l'OWER/.J~ACIF!CORP

Dii,fe!I: Dated: ·~~----~~--

BcY; J3y: -~-----~~~

RENEWA.13\.BNORTHWEST

P~tM; ------~--~

OREGON DEl'ARTMENTOF ENERGY

natl:4.: ----------

J'agc 7 • STIPULATION - UM 1681 O.:pa1_!n1{,'11l 11t'Ju..~ti.::c I li12:'Cclih Sfr1:c\ NJZ

-Ssldir.HI~ 117'301-4!llJ6 (SOJ) 947-JIS-20/ jl;i.~ii5fHJJ78-J7~4

APPENDIX A Page 9 of15

ORDER NO. '.]'. ,

1 Tl!i·s Siip1!l~~ion is "ntered into· by each Party.on the dafe(j>) enlered. below•

2

3

4.

s 6

7

~

CITIZENS' UTILITY 13.0ARD JNDUStRJ./\tCVstol¥$Fl.S QVTHE. J'lt. dltrBWEst VtICTTIJ!eS .. · .. ' ' - " - -- ' ·- -' _, ,;,, ' -

Dm~tli , $ ll.il/ f BY,~

fl J?IJ.J3iitD OTJLlTY C01'il!MfSS10N1S\rARI' PACfPICJ?OWER IPAClF¥cORJ'

JO D<\1'llcl.t P>aJe~ll -~~-"-~~-'-~-

tr By: . By•--~~------~ t2

[j

VI

15

16

17

18

19

20

'21

:12

23

24

25

26

Page 7 - STlPULATtON - UM 1681

By:-----------

lk);i;frtnii.:.'iil or~u>!:i:tc tJ6~.C1,Jt1it'Strcel NE

Spte1,1, OR 9730:J-<lb96 [50J);941432G.J ~"·:J50B) l7~,J7&4 APPENDIX A

Page 10 of15

j f. f I

ORDER NO.

l This StipulatiQ11 is ent~r.ed iilto by.each Party on ih.e d.ate(s) e1itered below,

2

3

4

ii

6

7

8

v 10

II

12.

B

14

15

l(j

17

111

19

20

ZI

22"

23

24

25

26

CITIZENS' UTILITY BOARD

Dated: ________ _

~Y'---------.-'--

RENEWABtENO'RTI!WEST

Dated: ----------

,By: --------'~---

INDUSTRIALCUSTO!)')ERS 01'" THE NORTHWEST UTJLITIES

DaOOi ---------)3y1_~-------

PA()!Flc.POWER /PjoH.)IFWOltP

natedi ----------

a~------~~~--

OREGON DEPARTMENT-OF ENERGY

D!!ted; ----------"--

Poge 7. STIPULATJON-UM 1681 Deµ11rtmc11t Of Juslkc M62.Cot1rl Sti~cl NE

Sntcnt, OR 973014096 (50)) 947·4520 I F>W· [503) 378-37&•1 APPENDIX A

Page 11of15

1

2

~-

4

·s &

7

"8

9

m ll

12

\3.

14

15

10

11

18

jf)

20

21

i2 2'.l

24

25

2fJ

ORDER NO.

Tfiffi Biipula"tion is entered irito Q¥ each "Party on the <late~s) ei1.fon~d below.

CITIZiENB' UTILITY BOAR'D

PUBLIC l)TILITY .C.QMMl~SIO'N $')')\.'lfF

Da!edl ------~--~

mougTIHAL ctJ~T'Otyt&:Rg OF 'PHH NORTftW~T U'l;!LlTIEB

J.)ateill -~----------

RENEWABLE NtlRTPlW&:ST OREOON Dl!l'ARTMENT OF El\l&:n,~y

Dateil: Dated: --'--~---~--

Page 7 - ST!PULA TION - UM I 681 P<1•"'1i''"'•flmtkc J_1~~-C?~'t S.l~S<;I f1~­

Sl11!;m, OR r:t73'ql "'101/6 (Ii>)) 947-4520} foe. (501) 37t-1784

APPENDIX A Page 12of15

2

3

4

.5

.6

7

ll

ORDER NO.

This Stlp11!ati911 is entered intcJ llY each P(l)'ty bu tlie cla\l'l(s) ente1·ed below.

CITIZENS' UTILITY BOA,RD

D!t.ted.t ---------

By: _______ ~---

INDL.JST!~AL OtJStQMERS OFTllE NORTHWEST UTILJtJE.S

.By·:--~------

9 llUBLIC UTIL!Tv·coMMlSSI9N STAFF PACIFIC POWER/ PAClFlCORP

10 DaJed: Dated: ---------~

fl ~ ~ -------->-~-~

12

13

14.

15

1.6

!7

18

!9

20

41

22

'.t3

24

25

2(\

RENEWABLE NORtHWEBT

Dated: .· J~ f {J 'Ui!'

Page 7- STIPULATION- UM 168!

O~EGON DEPARTMENT O,EIENERGY

Dated: ____ _,_ ____ ~

Ely: ----------

D~pn111i1efl1 ofJusiicc l !62 CQ11rt :~trcci NE

S11i~m.:qi~ 91Jo) .. \Q,96 (5031,47-4520 /t:a~ cSoJ) 37S-l18.f

APPENDIX A Page 13of15

'f

2

3

ii

5

6

7

,g

9

rn

IT

l2

0

11\

l~.

16

Fl

18

19

:w 21

22

23

24

25

21'

ORDER NO. • 1 /

l'UElJ:JC ttrlr..::rrrwM~tlSSIQN'STAF'f

Date\:!; ----~----.......

a~: .-o..· -~~~ ........ ~--~-

.

INDUSTRIAL C!JSTQMEB,11 ()I' TJ·lE NGJRTl'lWSST UT!l,!Trl!S

tlated: --------~

P:,l;CffJ'C l'QWelR I PAdUitCQ~

Dntett1 ~-~----~-

OREG@J'>f o&AR'rMEMTOf:'ENlilRGY ..

oatcd: 1otrz/t~! ' t-.

e~7~

Page 7 • STIPULATION· UM lfr8l -nq1~rl_tnc-nt pfJust:l~<.Y t 162--CdurtS!r&t!I NE

Srlkl11, OR 97JOl:il096 r103)<~4Hs~o1 r.o1:rs01) Jn"3184 APPENDIX A

Page 14of15

ORDER NO.

OERtIFICA'tE OE SEl(VICEi

2 I .Gill'tify that Qt) .T1.1he, l 2, '.Wl 4, 1. served (hefoJ'egoUlg Stiptllatiun l!Poli au .)Yartl~sofi'ecotd in this

3 proceedlng;by deliverhigacopy byelecfronic mailohl;' asall parties waive.paper set.vice,.

4

!i.

6

7

&

9

w *Ofcl,EGOJJ DEJ>ARTMENT OF ENERGY t<At;A 'BROCKMAN (cl Sf;l\l!OR ENERGY POLl¢Y' ANALYST 625.MAR.IQN st NE .. SALEM OR'$'lt\lc37J7 k'1!c)a,brockm9o@:itate.or.us

~Ul!E PEl\COCl<{C) 625 MARION .SJ NE s/ILEM oR~7.:JD1-g737 julie:peaepck@state.ar;us

w JI) ~Qf{l;GON. DE!'AJ<,TMENT OFJUSJllJE

RE:N.~E M l'i,Af'IC:e:<ci SENrOR'MS!STANT AnbRNE\' GENERAL .NAT.URAL RE$Q\,J.Rc;EI> SECTWN

l l

12

13

14

LS

16

17

l8

19

20

:!J

n :23

24

25

26

1162 CQORT ST Ne SALEM OR 97301-4096

'""""'·' m .rr~ ~l'@il i) J .'a~ie. or ,us

w OITIZENS' UttlIT\' llOARI> OFOilEil'ON QPU<J: DOCKETS 6HL$\ffBROAbWAY, s'TEAoo Pol\HMIP OR91'•:2o'5 ~ a!IB~ts@oregpn cub, org

(<Ol>:ERT .lENKS ~C) .. . 610 SW BROAGWAY, STE 400 PO!<'TCAND OR 97205 1Job@oreg9ncub,or9

lJ, CATRIONA M:CGRACKEN lC) 610 SW BROADWAY, $TE400 PORTLAND \CIR 912.05 catrl'ona@ntegonc1Jb.org

w fl/IVl:Sf;IN I/JIN CLE\/E J.OSHUA P WEBER J33 SW TAYLOR STE 41JO PORTLAND OR 97204 Jdw@dvclaw.com

w. D,Ji\f!SO.N \/'AN. Cl..E\IE pC MELlNDA J [)AVISON il.3$SW. :fAlflOR -STE' 400 i>ORTlAND OR 97204. mJ~.@dliclaw .• ~0!11

w M\JPNJ"/II.N WlfsT.llNllJ.VTics BRADLEY MLJLUNS (G) 333. sW TAYJ.ORSTE 4lYO rokTLAND oil 9.1204 ··· ·· tirr'ritll11n$@h1"14n~Wtlo;;.c:&m

w .PAGIFICPRP Efi A.lOGREV &2.5 N~ MU.l;T~.OMAH sT .• STE ispo PORTLAND OR-9.72'32 e.tta.locke\l@ft~clfl~orp.com

w PJ\.F~FIGO.Jte,. QB/I' !!AClfICPOWER OREGON DOCKETS 1l?~ NE J11U.LtNOM1\Jfl ST, i>TE 2:.QOO PO.IHLAND ¢1R 9723.2 aregancl6~k~@paCiflcalp.-0orn

w PUBUC.U.JIUTYGOMMISSION OF OREi!'lllN R.YAN BRACKEN 1C} . . . P,t) lil<lX 1088 SALEM oR 9730.8-1088 r,yan.br3cken@stafe-.e~.-us

w RENEVf/ABi.E.NDRJtlWEST RENEWABLE NW DO"l<JJTS 421 .SW 6Tfl AllE" ST~ .. '!125 PORTlANID OR 97.204 dockets@renewiJblenw.or9

MEGAN bE[j{~R· (CJ 4~i SW. 6TH AVE !\11125 PORTLAND oR 97204"i629 r'rii!~e:h@rene"'ablenw.org

~~tkhltc Ncotna.La1re Legal Secretary Department ofJustice Business Activities Sectlo1\

Page J - CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE - UM 1681 b(!p_ortm~nt of Ju.s\_i_c:e I !62.l~ourl Street NI~

S<1fCm, bR 97}01-4096 (503) 94'7·4520 '""' (503 318•37&4 APPENDIX A

Page 15of15