unfair, deceptive, or abusive acts or practices (udaap) webinar 2012 fran sponsler, crcm, cams,...
TRANSCRIPT
Unfair, Deceptive, or Abusive Acts or Practices (UDAAP) Webinar 2012
Fran Sponsler, CRCM, CAMS, CCBCOFred Lutz, CRCM
Val Vought, CCBCO
UDAAP
2
Under the Dodd-Frank Act §1026 it is unlawful for any provider of consumer financial products or services or a service provider to engage in any unfair, deceptive, abusive act or practice.The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) gained control of the UDAAP in July, 2011.
Legal Framework
3
The Act also provides CFPB with rule-making authority, and with respect to entities within its jurisdiction, enforcement authority to prevent unfair, deceptive, abusive acts or practices in connection with any transaction with a consumer for any consumer financial product or service. There are also FTC Amendments and Regulation AA including Cosigner Notices; Contractual Provisions and Pyramiding Late Fees.
Making the Rounds
What is UDAAP?Why it’s high risk.What can you do about it?
What is UDAAP?Why it’s high risk.What can you do about it?
4
The Golden Rule
UDAAP supplements other regulations.Is a general catch-all.Is the golden rule for all that is good and fair!
5
What do you mean, Unfair?
6
The standard for unfairness in the Dodd-Frank Act is that an act or practice is unfair when:It causes or is likely to cause substantial injury to consumers;The injury is not reasonably avoidable by consumers; andThe injury is not outweighed by countervailing benefits to consumers or to the competition.
Unfair Defined:
7
Causes or is likely to cause substantial consumer injury:Injury must be substantial and unavoidable;Loss of free exercise of decision-making;Undue influence.For example…In certain circumstances, such as unreasonable debt collection harassment, emotional impacts may amount to or contribute to substantial injury.
Unfair Defined:
8
Injury cannot be reasonably avoided:Material information withheld so their choice is not informed;Must be coercive or exert undue influence that will unreasonably impair consumer’s ability to make an informed decision; Lack of market alternatives and more than the consumer not picking the best product.The key question is not whether a consumer could have made a better choice but rather an act or practice hinders a consumer’s decision making. For example:Offering a “Rewards Account” when it is not clear how to earn the Reward or although a reward is offered, no one seems to meet the criteria for obtaining the reward. Are your practices for processing holds on demand accounts vs. savings accounts fair?
9
Unfair Defined:
Is not outweighed by countervailing benefits to consumers or competition:Look to net benefits, weighing:•Consumer costs and Regulatory burden.Public policy as established by statute, regulation, judicial decision or agency determination may be considered with all other evidence to determine whether an act or practice is unfair. However, public policy considerations by themselves may not serve as the primary basis for determining unfair.
What do you mean, Deceptive?
A representation, omission or practice that is likely to mislead consumers:
False Statement/Misleading Claims:• Bait and switch or Omitting material information; Legal Standard is likelihood wherein intent is irrelevant; Analysis considers ad as a whole.
10
Deceptive Defined:
Who are acting reasonably in the circumstances presented:
Consider intended audience;Look at the net impression and the totality of
the circumstances;Fine print cannot correct conspicuous
statement.
11
Deceptive Defined:
Representation, omission, or practice is material: Likely to affect a consumer’s choice or conduct:• Express or Implied claims;• Omitting material information. Statements related to:• Purpose• Cost• Performance or quality• Benefits• Limitations
12
The “Four P’s” Test
The FTC’s “four P’s” test can assist in the evaluation of whether a representation, omission, act, or practice is likely to mislead.
o Is the statement prominent enough for the consumer to notice?
o If the information presented in an easy-to-understand format that does not contradict other information in the package and at a time when the consumer’s attention is not distracted elsewhere?
o Is the placement of the information in a location where consumers can be expected to look or hear?
o Finally, is the information in close proximity to the claim it qualifies?
13
Deceptive? For Example:
Disclosing fees for check items, rather than per item fee or per debit fee.
Travel Cards (TravelEx) – all the fees associated with the purchase of the card (bank fees) are not disclosed.
Providing the Opt-In disclosure when the Bank does not offer the “courtesy or privilege” overdraft product.
Providing incomplete itemizations of amount financed, i.e. Settlement Statements vs. Truth-in-Lending disclosures.
Providing a GFE when the loan is not subject to RESPA (are you bound by the figures you provided although the loan is not subject to RESPA?).
14
Unfair vs. Deceptive
15
Comparison Chart
Unfair Deceptive
Likely to cause substantial injury
Likely to mislead consumers(Materially Presumed)
Injury cannot be reasonably avoided
Acting Reasonably
Net Benefits
Note: Distinction is mostly academic!
What do you mean, Abusive?Materially interferes with the ability of a consumer to understand a
term or condition of a consumer financial product or service: Takes unreasonable advantage of a consumer’s:• Lack of understanding of the material risks, costs or conditions of
the product or service;• Inability to protect his/her interests in selecting or using the
financial product or service; or • The reasonable reliance that the Bank is acting in their best
interests.
16
The Role of Consumer Complaints
Consumer complaints play a key role in the detection of unfair, deceptive, or abusive practices. Consumer complaints have been an essential source of information for examinations, enforcement and rule-making for regulators. Consumer complaints can indicate weaknesses in elements of the institution’s compliance management system such as training, internal controls, or monitoring.
17
How does your institution handle a complaint?
While the absence of complaints does not ensure that unfair, deceptive, or abusive practices are not occurring, complaints may be one indication of UDAAPs. For example, the presence of complaints alleging that consumers did not understand the terms of a product or service may be a red flag indicating that the institution should take immediate action to resolve the basis of the complaint(s). Analysis of consumer complaints may assist the institution in the identification of potential unfair, deceptive, or abusive acts or practices.
18
Summarizing UDAAP
Missing/Inadequate/Confusing (not required) Marketing and Disclosures:
FeesPrerequisites LimitationsAsk the question: IS IT HARMFUL TO THE CONSUMER?
19
High Risks
Enforcement ActionsMonetary Penalties/JudgmentsLitigationNew Roommates
20
High Risk, Such As
Harm to Reputation
“When a bank engages in unfair and deceptive marketing practices, it damages its most precious asset – the trust and confidence of its customers.”
John D. Hawke, Jr.Comptroller of the Currency
June 2000
21
There is an ALTERNATIVE?
Review Marketing Materials:Is the message complete and accurate?Could it mislead the average customer?Is there an explanation missing, given how you
operate?BE PROACTIVE!
22
Watch Out!
Watch out for Limited Time Promotions: Duration must be clear; Validate changes that increase costs or reduce value; Send clear and timely notices of fees and other
changes.Choose Your Words Wisely: Limited Time; Pre-approved; Guaranteed; Lifetime
Rate; Free Anything; and Up to or as Low as.
23
More Considerations
Base analysis on your intended market; Promote consumer understanding.Products: Carefully select Third-Party Products• Is the vendor legitimate?• Is the product useful and of value?• Would you want your mother to buy it?
Avoid sales incentives that could lead to abusive practices.
24
Focus on the Overall Impression: Prominent:• The statement should be big enough to attract attention. Presentation:• Wording or format must be understandable. Placement:• Is the information in a location where consumers can be
expected to look?
25
Action Plan
Go Formal!
Develop a formal UDAAP Program:DisclosuresMarketingNew ProductsVendorsComplaints
26
Questions?
27
Thank You!Additional Questions? Please contact us:
Fran [email protected]
Fred [email protected]
1099 18th Street, Suite 2900Denver, CO 80202
303-296-6033www.fblg-cpa.com