universitas prof.dr.hazairin,sh bengkulu fileprofile of prof.dr.hazairin,sh in 2013 and to recognize...

36
Analysis and Relevance Tracer Study Universitas Prof.DR. Hazairin,SH Bengkulu

Upload: others

Post on 30-Oct-2019

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive

Analysis and Relevance Tracer Study Universitas Prof.DR. Hazairin,SH Bengkulu

Page 2: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive

- Unihaz Tracer Study Team was formed in 2013

- This research aims to identify graduate profile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job.

- Method conducted descriptive survey.

- Subjects were university graduates in 2013 amount to 1306 people

Page 3: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive
Page 4: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive
Page 5: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive

No Study Program Total

1 Law Studies (S2) 21

2 Law Studies 306

3 Management 127

4 Accounting 49

5 Economics and Development Science 37

6 Agro-technology 14

7 Aquaculture 3

8 Guidance and Counseling 163

9 Geography Education 297

10 Mechanical Engineering 20

11 Civil Engineering 33

12 Public Administration Sciences 236

Total 1306

Page 6: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive

Interview

Email

Facebook

Telephone

Alumni Data

Page 7: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive

No Method for Collecting the Data

Target Respondent

1. Email 100 graduate 12 graduate

2. Facebook 60 graduate 28 graduate

3. Telephone 915 graduate 311graduate

4. Interview 100 graduate 43 graduate

Page 8: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

Total

Population

Target (a)

Undelivered

(b)

Subyek

(c=a-b)

Responden (d) Gross

Response

Rate

(e=(d/a)*100)

Net

Responase

Rate

(f=(d/c)*100)

Completion

Rate

100%

25%

75%

30% 30%

40%

82%

1306

328

978

394

Page 9: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive

No Faculty Respondent Target Respondent

1. F. Of Law Science (S2) 21 12

2. F. Of Law Science (S1) 306 87

3. F. Of Economy (S1) 213 63

4. F. Of Social and Political Science (S1) 236 88

5. F, Of Education and Teacher Training (S1) 460 102

6. F. Of Agriculture (S1) 17 15

7. F. Of Engeneriing (S1) 53 27

Total 1306 394

Law Science(S2); 3%

Law Science; 22%

Economic; 16%

Social & Politics

Science; 22%

Teaching and

Education; 26%

Agriculture; 4%

Technical; 7%

n=1306

Page 10: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

Law

Science(S2)

Law Science Economic Social &

Politics

Science

Teaching and

Education

Agriculture Technical

57%

28% 30%

37%

22%

88%

51%

Page 11: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive
Page 12: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive

A Questionnaires Responses

1. When do you start looking for the job? 51% Before Graduate 40% After Graduate 10% Not Looking for The Job

2. What do you do to find a work? 34 % Through advertising

30 % Propose to a company

4% Go to job fairs

9% Searching via internet/

advertising

1% Contacted by a company

5% Propose to an office

9% Build networking

2% Through relation

2% Build own business

2% Through a work placement

3. How many months of the time spent (before and after

graduation) to obtain a first job?

Before Graduate 8 (months)

After Graduate 4 (months)

4. How many companies / institutions / agencies that you are

applying (by mail or e-mail) before you obtain your first

job?

2,75 Companies

5. How many companies / institutions / agencies are

responding to your application?

Median 2 (Companies)

Page 13: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive

Before Graduate; 51%

After Graduate; 40%

Not Looking for

The Job; 10%

Page 14: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive

34%

30%

4%

9%

1%

5%

9%

2%

2%

2%

0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40%

Through advertising

Propose to a company

Go to job fairs

Searching via internet/ advertising

Contacted by a company

Propose to an office

Build networking

Through relation

Build own business

Through a work placement

Page 15: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive

1. Before Graduate = 8 month

2. After Graduate = 4 month

Page 16: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive

1

3

1

2,5

4

3

2

5

4

1

0 1 2 3 4 5 6

Law Studies

Management

Accounting

Economics and Development Sciences

Agroteknologi

Conseling Guidance

Geografph Education

Mechanical Engineering

Civil Engineering

Public Administration Sciences

Page 17: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive

1

3

1

2,5

4

3

2

5

4

1

0 1 2 3 4 5 6

Law Science

Management

Accounting

Economics and Development Science

Agroteknologi

Conseling Guidance

Geografph Education

Mechanical Engineering

Civil Engineering

The Science of Public Administration

Page 18: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive

1

2

1

1

1

1

1

2

2

7,5

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

Law Science

Management

Accounting

Economics and Development Science

Agroteknologi

Conseling Guidance

Geograph Education

Mechanical Engineering

Civil Engineering

The Science of Public Administration

Page 19: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive
Page 20: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive

B. Questionnaires Responses

1. Do you work at this time (including part-time work and self-employment)

79% Yes 21% No

2. How would you describe your current situation? 7% Continue to higher education 35% Married 13% Busy with family 19% Looking for Job 26% Initiated to continue to higher study

3. Are you actively looking for a job within the last 4 weeks?

60% Not Looking for Job 11% Waiting for a job 6% Start a have a job on 2 weeks 16% Not Sure work 7%

4. What type of company / agency / institution where you work now?

62% Governmental institution 1% non Governmental organization 21% Private Company 12% Interpreneur 4% Others

5. Approximately how much of your income each month?

Rp.2.500.000,- (median)

Page 21: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive

have a job ; 79%

Jobless; 21%

Page 22: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive

Continue to high

education; 7%

Married; 35%

Busy with family; 13%

Looking for Job; 19%

Wanted to continue

high study; 26%

Page 23: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

Not looking for the

job

Waiting for vacancy Starting work next

2 weeks

Not sure working

for next 2 weeks

Not Sure looking

for the job

60%

11%

6%

16%

7%

Page 24: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive

62%

1%

25%

10%

2% 0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

Goverment Non Govermental

Organization

Interpreneur Private Company Free Lance

Page 25: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive
Page 26: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive

C. Questionnaire on Vertical and Horizontal Alignment

Responses

1. How closely the relationship

between field of study with your

job?

31% Very Close

26% Close

19% Fairly Close

9% Less Close

15% Not Close

2. What Level of education the

most appropriate / suitable for

your current job?

18% Higher Level

74% The same level

7% Lower Level

1% Not need higher education

3. If you think that your current

job is not in accordance with

your education, why would

you take it? Answers can be

more than one

[1]. 50% Question not appropriate; My work now is in conformity with my education.

[2] 14% I do not get a job more in line [3] 22% In this work I obtain good career prospects [4] 1% I prefer to work in the area of work which has nothing to

do with my education [6] 5% I can obtain higher revenues in this work [7] 2% My job today is more safe / secure / secure [8] 2% My job today is more attractive [9] 3% My job today is more lets me take additional work /

flexible schedules, etc. [10] 2% of my current work location closer to my house.

Page 27: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive

Very Close; 31%

Close; 26%

Fairly Close; 19%

Less Close; 9%

Not Close; 15%

Page 28: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive
Page 29: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive

18%

74%

7%

1%

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

Higher Level Same Level Lower Level Not Need higher education

Page 30: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

f1601 f1602 f1603 f1604 f1606 f1607 f1608 f1609 f1610

50%

14%

22%

1%

5%

2% 2% 3% 2%

[1] 50% Question not appropriate; My work now is in conformity with my education. [2] 14% I do not get a job more in line [3] 22% In this work I obtain good career prospects [4] 1% I prefer to work in the area of work which has nothing to do with my education [6] 5% I can obtain higher revenues in this work [7] 2% My job today is more safe / secure / secure [8] 2% My job today is more attractive [9] 3% My job today is more lets me take additional work / flexible schedules, etc. [10] 2% of my current work location closer to my house.

Page 31: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive

D. Item of Questionnaire on Competence Responses

1. At the time of graduation, in which the level of competence below you mastered (A)

Average score 2,67

2. At the time of graduation, how the contribution of higher education in terms of competency below? (B)

Average score 2,18

E. Response Rate

Total Perscentage

Number of Target Population (a) 1306 100%

Number of Target Population not contacted (b)

327 25%

Target Subjects (c = a- b) 979 75%

The number of respondents (d) 387 30%

Gross Response Rate (e=(d/a)*100) 387/1306 29,63%

Net Response Rate (f=(d/c)*100) 387/979 40%

Completion Rate 351 91%

Page 32: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive

Bio information of alumni / graduates obtained registration form Graduation

Data collection via email is not optimal because many emails that are no longer active.

Filling out the questionnaire via facebook a little to get a response and questionnaires contained many errors because respondents do not understand how the questionnaire.

Page 33: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive

Questionnaires through the phone very effective method but constrained respondents time and costs

The number of respondents still below target because the data is incomplete and the response of alumni about the low tracer study.

Page 34: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive

From the analysis of tracer study it can be concluded that 79% of alumni already working, 74% worked by the same level of education and 31% have a close relationship by the study program. But 21% do not work, 2% working free lance, 1% work on the kind of jobs that do not require higher education and 15% work on the types of jobs that are not related to the study program.

From this analysis, the university is improving soft skills and contribution to the alumni.

University that the alumni database systems are always up todate to facilitate the provision of necessary information about the alumni.

Page 35: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive
Page 36: Universitas Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH Bengkulu fileprofile of Prof.DR.Hazairin,SH in 2013 and to recognize the relevance between field study and graduate job. -Method conducted descriptive