university of groningen essays on political instability ...iv ˙ , #1$ 2# # bbbbbbbbbbb -* ˙ ˙...
TRANSCRIPT
University of Groningen
Essays on political instabilityJong-A-Pin, R.
IMPORTANT NOTE: You are advised to consult the publisher's version (publisher's PDF) if you wish to cite fromit. Please check the document version below.
Document VersionPublisher's PDF, also known as Version of record
Publication date:2008
Link to publication in University of Groningen/UMCG research database
Citation for published version (APA):Jong-A-Pin, R. (2008). Essays on political instability: Measurement, causes and consequences. Enschede:PrintPartners Ipskamp B.V., Enschede, The Netherlands.
CopyrightOther than for strictly personal use, it is not permitted to download or to forward/distribute the text or part of it without the consent of theauthor(s) and/or copyright holder(s), unless the work is under an open content license (like Creative Commons).
Take-down policyIf you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact us providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediatelyand investigate your claim.
Downloaded from the University of Groningen/UMCG research database (Pure): http://www.rug.nl/research/portal. For technical reasons thenumber of authors shown on this cover page is limited to 10 maximum.
Download date: 10-06-2020
!"##$ ##%&'%(")"*+ * +,-* . +/
#0"%#1#%#'$%(##0$#'1$#( #'## $1'$$'(#( '( 2 &2 1# 0#( %#%$(2##%2##%'1#%
#0&30### '31&
3&0##4%50
#61(782#(#%#0%
3,+'..
6
%%#'.*+#4
'# 1'' 19:& 1!9& 1;% ;'
i
!0'$##'$<###1# 1 %% %# ##$ ## 2# # %)%#' , = $ ,+ # # %#'# 1 ' '#1 #>0#$147&$( # ?#1 #%&1@'$A@A'$%%0######' % ## 0 # %%##$ # ## 2# '$ #(21#2#2#%#(# (%0%(0''#(B (3111((1(#&2'##'#'#%( #'#C(# 2D# #( #2 #%'$##!&E%#(2&##&&1'#'#$1''$%3#$0'##%'$2##(20'10'#'(0#1%#F 2' 1 ''# '0'# $%(2 %' 00 # $ #1 #<#3#$<&5'(6#4(&6(1##%3#G%#$H%###!''1 # 0#''##(;%;'(#:& !' 9&( 1 # 2 # # #'%## & 1 % 2# '$ # 1' %''11# ### ## # 1 # ' ## # ''D # ' %# ' 0$ % ## ;$)$5#%3## % '02#4#5 I ## # 1 # '$ '2####
ii
&&( $ 0 <( 2# 7&'( ;C 4 <5(& #( )' ( F( :$ 6'( 6&6&( 6 #( & # # 1 # ' '#%#'#(### '%#'#(#)6)!2$$###01#2&G@#.,AH # )#' #111 #F3# GF7H ## ! 8 1 0# ' # 2& @# %1A # ####( 1 # %##$ '$ #$ 8 ;%# ####'$0#20$2#2%#1''$(2&##&!$#'1###1%#'####%1$6$%#(&6(1#26& ( ' #( :0&'%( '( $I0#( ' )## 0 )## 1# 12# #$#$##&#%##'###( # %1######& 0E### ##2#'2&% #%'$#1##01(#2%$#&0J#$(4(,%,+
iii
.. ##B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B .
., 6%###$B B B B B B B B B B B B
. ###$'2#B B B B B B B -
.- <'$(5##0B B B B B B
. !'###$B B B B B B B B B B B +
.K #B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B .
! !
,. ##B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B .,, 7#$B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B ., <#1#$#B B B B B B B B B B B .*,- ###$'%#0###B B B B B B ,, !'%#1%###$'2#B B .,K #$B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B , ;B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B *,:#1%###$#(1#-,<%#0###B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B -
" # #
. ##B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B -
iv
, #1$2##B B B B B B B B B B B -* '%$B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B *- #$B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B K ;B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B K*
!$ %&'#()
-. ##B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B -, ###B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B - <#'#B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B -- #'##B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B +-- #$B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B *.-K ;B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B *-;#2#2##6<6#;B B *K-;#2#2##6<6#6B B *+-;<%#0###B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B .
* +
. ##B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B .., ###B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B . <#'#B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B .- #'##B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B ..- 7#$B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B ..K ;B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B .,-
, B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B .,-B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B B ...)/'0B B B B B B B B B B B B .-
1
!
.**( < "# 0 # " 5 ' 1 % 2& ### ' 0%'#### # '$ 0 ## ## ## '## !$ ' % 1 1' ## G( 2(###H(1'##G'10(0#(1'% 1 #H( # 1'# ## G"#(.**H # 2 ### # ## % ##0 ## 1 ##$ %#'5 # "#D # ##?###0'#1#'2$?$200 %1' 11#$ 11# ### #'%# 1 '$ # ' ### ( # #%$#2 ### '#' %$ %'# #1 1 %# '( 2 2$ 1 # '# #0 ' G !( ,( % 0L <5(,(%H
# #( 11# ?###0 '# # #$ #?1%###$# ''$####%# ##$ ##$ 2# %# #1# ### '%(#$11###01((1'(%#G;'(,H
) # 1 %# ##$ #$ # #$0(#%01'$#1#%##('$1##(12#12%''%9:%#G.*KH1'###$(%&1@#%###1%#'$A@#B 1'3%#'0'# %% # # '# 1 # 'A 6 )#0 G.*.H ' 1# %#5 ## %###$ @ # %# $#' 2 # ###5
2
%##1##$&2A(###@#%#'%#%# ## % $ %# 0A ' 11# 0$ ) G.*+.H(2 ## %# ##$ @# ## #2 # 1 # # 0'#( ' ''#$ 0# 1' #%0 $#' %1 M'D %##A 6 #$( ( 5()2G.**KH1%###$#%%#$1 # #0 %2( # $ ### ###' ' %# ##$ ( $ %&( 1 #' 1(#(#%#$#'
%#1'#0#$1#1%###$(### ' '#$ 2# %# # # ''# 1 %###$ $( # ## # #%#$ $#' '$ #& '$ 1' 7 '%( ## G.**KH 11# 0 %# %# 0( % D## %# #( #$ # '%#1%# ##$'2###(#G.**KH#%###$ ''3 ' 0'#2 #$#$##%2#'2#%#1'#%D##(0&' 0#'##02$'%##%$%###$
20( # #0 ## 1?# # #"#0 #%,, ,0 #'? % D## #'#$ #&0 ! )%#' ,K"# #'# ### '#2 %1$%## '& ' # # <1()(##%#F$1##,#
##$#?1%###$(# '%## # &2 2# 11# %# ##$ % #$'!1( #1#'1# # #1#$#1%###$##'%###$#'#1# #7#'( #$2##%#1%###$'%$
9#''###(##'#1#11#1%###$'2#!0##' G )0( .**+H ## %# 0 11# 1 %###$'2#(#G22H#'%1'2&2##%##'%0%
! # ' # #$ #2%##1%# #$%1%# ##$ 7#$( # 2 ' 2#( 2'#('#5#5##0!
3
$%$####1;G,H(2'## # '#5# 5# 20 % 1#�%#1#0%2)$(#2#2##'11####$1#!0 2$ #' &$ # 11# # %1 ###$1#!2%###2 #' # ##$ 2 3# # '%$
!'1#%##%#'##1##
1!!1# '1 # # #' %# ##$ '%##%'#%###%###$#0#$!# ( %# ##$ ## ## ! %$ 1 %###$(#0###07'%(G.**.H # '1%#0#%D##( 2 #'1%## ##( I G,H #&#'1'30'##'1# # %1 %# ##$!0 %# ##$# # ' 1'# # # # 0 1 %###$( # #$ 11 1' ''# !# ( 0$##'%#1%###$
!'%1$1#G$H0'##$(# ' 1 %# ##$( # # %$ $ G.**.H2#' #!%$ ##'#2D%# ##$ %$ %#$0 '%$'%###%'2 ##& #'1##$##'#0#2#(11#%#'1'####01%###$# ##N60(2# 111# # # 1'##11##$%1%###$N
# 2# #&1?#( 0 # 0##0#?#'%###$4%#G.**H(1 #( ## 1 %# ##$ '#$ 11# %% 12 $( 1 #( ;&'( 2!G.**,H(#G.**KH(7G,H(211#%#0# '0 #' #
4
%##%#$10'#!%#%#$10'# # %$ 1 %# ##$ J#(#''###$12$G.*H(6)#0G.*.H(## G.**KH(2'%# ##$%% '%# $ # %%( 2# 0 1 ''1%###$###1##01#1%###$#
)'1 # # ## # %% '%# 1'2&(###1$11#'1%###$6)#0G.*.H(020###'#'#$1%# ##$%#1#2 #2G!#(.*KKH' G7 7( .*KKH 6 )#0#'0 ## %# ##$ # '( (''##$(###$(%##'
# #( ###01'2&2 6%1$( %#$ 7# $ # ' %###$#1#$ &#%%'%#$(##11#######'####'1#0##1#(21#$'##$#1'#''##G9&63(,H
!'1#11#2##$2&7#$(#1##5#$%0#$(( # $ # , #( 2 0 # #)$(###%02&(##$%#%%%#'1'#10#####!$( # #$ # ## # 11# ' # #2##(####1&2'%%0#7$(#''#1#0# #11#'1%# ##$3###$'%
" !'1# # #'2#%# ##$'2#$#!02$%###$'$11#'2#6#0$(0### ' '$ ' #$ %$ %# 11# %#0 60( %# ##$ '$ '% 1' #'#11'1'#%#&$##
5
# ' 1#( %# 1 # 1# 2 12 # 1#'# G)0( .**+H " '## 2# 1'2& ( ###%# 0$%# ##$ '2##0$# 7' '% %# 102( # #%#2 %###$'2###'$### 1 # #%( # # ' G : (.**L(.**.L:0#(.**,L#.**KL##(.**KL;(.**L) 6#(.**L7(.**(;'%"#(,,()#'(,H
!#1$#0 #'#' #'%# %# ' #( < G,( % ,+.H ## @#'#$$'#1#'$#?###&#A#'00##1#'##(''# # ##'# 1 # #' ' '2#$
! 1# ## # #$ # %' 1''# ( 0 %1 %# ##$###''#'$##'#1#'%#1%# ##$ ' 2# 7#'( 11## '$ 0$ # 11# # # G'#%H 1#$ % ## %% #( #0 #1'#1#$%01#'%$$
!'&'#'#'#1'2##'$6&2('9G.**,HG('(.**H(2 # )2 G.*KH 2# ' # #$( #' %1# '#2# #%# ##$0 # 1' # 1# $ ! #'# # '( #$'%$#'456#16'##'#1G.**+H2(200#0#%#'# 7#$( # %% 2 #' # %# #%# 0 2 #$ 1 11# ! ## %$'%##'$#'#1'2# #' 0##1$#$111#7#'(#%%1#%2##%###$1%###$$ 0 1 %# ##$ #'# 0 7$( #%%#0#2#%###$4 '2# G4( .*+H!# ( #2 0#2# %###$% #'2##%#1''#1###2%###$
6
'2#( #20##2###11#'1%###$011#11#'2# %# 1' %#$ 0 ## ' 2# ( #2# 1'2& # '%## '## <1(!'%G,H(1#(##0 #$ $ # #$ 7#'( #$2# $0$ # '%# # '%%%#1# ##(2$0$12###2##0 %10G<( ,H. ! '%1 $ # 2& 1 ### G,H( 2#1 11# 2# %## ( %#( '# #7#'(&G,H %# ## #-+#0%####&#'0%'#.* !####2#%##0#0# # 1 # #'# 1 # 2# %## G5'2&( ,KL &( ,L &( ,('(&###(,H
! 1# ' # 11# 1 %# ##$ '2#( #%%$'# G,H '%$ ## #$#'%#12##1###%%$%1%2#'!$1'# G,H '%0 % 7#$( # ## # # ## # %# ' 0! 2# # # 2 ' !1#( # #'1#1###'%$##1$2###22###1#%'#'###'1 # '% ##0 # ## '% #1# ! # '%0'# # #$ '# #'%1# #1##'# #!# (&' # G,H2 #'# #' $ %#'( # #$ #& # # # % ' 1 # #!1( #' #'##1# ###$111#7$(##$&2##11##0#''%0#0#$##0'1'
.I#0#1%'(##%%'1#3#1$ # ###2 0# #1? #2##0#2%#?&G###(,H
7
$ '#()! # '1 # # # ' # 1 11# #$%1%# ##$!1# #$%1 ##$ '# #0 ; G,H # # #$ 1 # %# '$ # 0% #$2$ #0 # $ ) ##( # % 1 # '#$ ##'# '$ # %'3#$( '#5# 5##0 '% ## ## # %%# # %# 1 #; 9# 3# # %# 1 D #2 '%%#( #$ #'# ## 0#$%#1# %0# '$ # # = #$ M'$'# # 0$ 0 1 #$D G;( , % -H 9 D#$ ' 2# 1 # .*+ .** 0'1 ( # %%# ' 2###10#;%%#$!$2'#''2#%%#$####)#'!'0(2%##$2%%$#'#%#1#'''## ;0&###$D'3###.**+G;(,%-H
4 G,H %0 ## 1# 1 ;D # ' 1 # '&# 1 # # %%$ 1 #'&#(%#2#11# '##'%#111 ' 1 # ##D %%# # # # # ! %%#(#$%%$#1##'%####'##2'#$!'1#'&##1#0###'$0##'20(#2#0# % # #0 # 1 # # ## ! #0% # # 11# # ## 1# 1&2 ### 9 # ( 1( ( ( 21#2(1##'##2##'#$(##$%#?'2#'#,
;D '% # '&# '# '#$ #%#0G#$%$''1H##'$
,!#$14G,H##15#20(#'% 0 G # 0$ $ 4 0&( ,H # #0#%#25# ' ?#$!1( # ##5###01'%##%%$#
8
$#'3#$1#%%#G2'%$#H#$1#2##'
'%##2&1#&1;##$ ## %%# #!1##5#12&$'$111'1'#J#($%###1#0#%1#'(##1;'%$##
! ## # #( # '&# '# '# #1';G,H#(###'%2##1'#6# # & # # G6# # & 3#( ,H ## %0'01#1#0#011##0 '% ' #'# ! ' ## #'#'%#1'$(5##0%111#'#####11#!##11# ; G,H ## # 0 & # 2'$( 5# # % 1 '&# '# '#$'##!'#&0#####$%0##07$(##3###0#$
* +!1%###$##2'#'%#( # 2 ' 2# #' # # ###$ # # ' # ## 0## # #%$#2 #' %# G 7$ :( ,L# ;#( ,L )? )( ,H( 12 ###1#G;(,-LF(,KH(####'###$20(#00######%## ! & #2 #' # ##$ ## 2# #0# ## #' 11# %%7 #( #2&12 # #1<# ##!04$6''$( #2&$%%%1#02O")) 0 ## #%%#$ 1 # 2 G # 6'H %# 4# 9 $'#.%#7#'(##"G,H %# ## 1# # ## ##&)%#'..( ,.(4%
)##%OO222%#&'#O
9
%%0#1>)# '%01'.%#)%#'.#+K%#)%#'. :% )#P' G.**H0%' 2 #$ $5 #?1 1# %% 1# # 0#!'##1' #%' ## #%#0 #1'# # #( ' %# 0# ## # #%2 ## # # # % % & 1 #''%0#'#1'### # # ' 1#( # %#' # #%#%#9#%#$#%##(01 # % ## #1'#%# ## 1'2#:&2(#%##%#1#1'#1' 2 #2# #%%# %#$ 7$( # % ##2#$(#'%#1##&$?1##0# 9 # ' 1 :% )#P' ' ## 1# #%2 ## ( # # # # # 1 % % ! 002 # #%#2 #' %% #( #''$ #%%#$1# 0'# # ## '$ # # # 1## ##&! '# 1'5 #'1 G.*H 73 G.*+KH( 2 # ## '#0'# 1 # 11 #2 # ## % %0 ) # '%# 1 # '# # 0 # '( # 0 1 % %0 ## ### 11# #2 # # $ # 20( ##''1#0'##1$0(#%## # 5#1#'2#&# #11#'%#1#'###(#''$ # %%#$ 1 #0'# ! ## #5# # ' %## 2 # #$ ##& $ 1!%' #@$ #1A11# 1#2## %# %#$1!31!G.*H 0#1##$$6G.*H(01$11#1$(( 5& G.***H( : # G,H( ;2#5G,H ! ## 2# #' # # # ##$( # #' ## # 1 1'# %0 $ #6'###1#0#1!'G6!(,-H)# ## ##& # '( 11# ' ## ##%#11##$%1#'2110#$
10
! '% $ '$ ## # # 1# ! %#$ 1 # 1 ' #1 11# # 20( # %#$ 1 #'$%#$111###(#'#1 &( F#5 !& G.**+H 2 # # 1 #% #1#1( # $ %0# # & 2 #1 '%##$##'
, !'1##512
;%# , 2# # ''# 1 %# ##$ !%###2#%#$1#$,#1%###$ ## # # ## 1# 1 #%%%# 1# '( # # 1 # 1# $ %#> # ## #'# #( # ' ' 1 %###$#11'20## #( # #0 3# # #$ '%!%#1#%#1#G4H'%#1#%# ' 1 %# ##$ ' 2# !#% ' '# )22# '#$'%$#'466#'#1G.**+H!%#2##0#$
;%# 1 # #% #2 %# '( ' 1' ' 2# # 7#( ##1'#$2##$'#G,H%#)(1#####'%0%#2&1' # G,H > # # '1 1#( 2' #'# # '# 1 # 1 11# #9#'1%#1''1'(#'%#1#%#'###'!%#2##0#$
;%# - # '% '# 1 # %%# %#12 $ ; G,H ## '# ## 5 #2#'&# '#'#$ #0 #12$ # # 2 # # ( % 1 11#' #'# ## #2 2$ # 2$ ## 11#!#(#(#%# '11#%#!
11
%# 2# #0 # $ # #0#$1 #'%#
;%# ' # '%# 1 #' # ##$ 1#!'1#?#12##'11###1#! ## ( '%' ## #& ###1#%%#1'#'%#1#' ( # $ ## # '%# 1 11# #$% 1#' 2 # ##$1 #' 7#'( # # # ' # #0 '%# 1 #' 11# ## ! %# 2# 0 # & '# 1 # % 1 '% ##$ # #%#2 #'##( 0#1# '%#1#'##'
;%# K %0 0021 #' 1(
12
13
2
14
15
!
!!$ # 2$0 ##%# ##$ #'#1 #'2#%1'1#(#0###%# #0 1# # #2 %# ##$ '2#G4%#(.**L(.**.L#.**KL##(.**KL ;( .**H! # '%'#2# 0##%0##%###$' 2# G #( .**KL & '( .**KL)0( .**+L<0 9( .**+L<$( : 6#( ,-L4#(:8&(,L$()#'(,H 20( # 1'2& 2 # # #2 %###$'2# $5 #$'##&<G,H('#(##'$1#0#'% $ ' 2#( %# ##$( ' 2# 1 ( # 0$ 11# # 0#$ 1 ##'#''#(##%###1#G%0###0H###0##'%$#% G;'% "#( ,,H # %#(21 #''#1%###$ '#%###$'2# ! 0 0 ##'%# # #& # %' 1''#6####01#'%#1%###$ ' 2# 0 ## ' %% '%# $ G;H G##( .**KH( '#
4 This chapter is based on J G,KH G,+H
16
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
! '1# 11#2 # #$ 2&7#$(2#5#1'##,%###$#=##$%0 #$ )$( ## # %0 2&( # #$ % #%%%# '1' #10 ### ##!$( ## # %0 2&( # #$ # ## # 11# ' # #2##7#$(#''#1#0##11#'1%###$3###$'% 7$( # 1# $ # 3# # #0 #$
17
.*-=,1##'%#24#1'###$1#%#'#'2#7#'(21'01#2 2$#$#2'2####$2##1##'2#'%#%#0 !'1#%#512#,,(21$ #1# $' # ,(2 # # 1# $ # # ,-( 2 %0 '%#0 ### 1 # 11# ' 1 %# ##$ # ,( 2 ' # 11# 1 %# ##$ '2# ! #0#$ 1 #'# # ' #,K)#,
3#'#'#'#1%###$2'%$1#$##'#&#%%'%#$(##11##### ##'####'1#0##1#(21#$'##$#1'#''##921$#1#$'K
( # ' 1 # 1# $ ' # %# #1'# ## '' # # 1' # 1'# ## ? # # $ ' ## # 0 # @#A $ '# 1 0 1# '0#'('%'##'%#0'# 1 # # 9 0# %' ' %1(#1#$##%#1#0 1 # 0 ## 0 G# ' 1 %###$H!1#$'2#'#%1#2##12
nnn By εξ += G.H
2##0G'H#10#(#'#11#(R 0#1##0S ' #' ' # # 2# # ## 0 2
K##'#11#$19&63G,H
18
#2##>#'%#(#0'#1#'
Ω+Φ=Σ 'BB G,H2T#%'#50'#(U#0'#1#1#V#GH0'#1##'!1# #' # # 1 ?# G,H 1# # 0% $ # '# 1 # 1# # #'1##0?##0#!##22'''###
9 #'# # 1# # ? 0 2# #'#16'':&> # '#$ '%#(2 2##&1#
)(log 1StrL −Σ+Σ= GH
2#'%0'#1##
0 %#'5 # & 1#( # % ## #1#1#G#5H#1#'11###%###(2'&1#1######1##%#1#($##'#11# # #1 !# ( # '#% 2# $#' '# 2## 11# # ## 1 # # #2#1#'#%###($### '$ # #%# # '# '% ##$( # # 2# 12 1# % !###?##2##%##1##'##(221#'#1#''5##1#'1#1#'# #( #$% #201#1#(2#2##1#9#'#$#'##%#(#%##0 1 # $ 1#( ( # %# ' 1 %###$!01#'1%###$#0###2#0#(#'%%%###'#'#1#1%#
# 2 ## #?01 # ? . @# #$ 1 ##A!#$1 #1#22# # %$ #1#!#(## ?1#1###1#
19
##$ '! ## (2#1# # %#(20 # # %##1 #1#0##
"'!####%$1%###$(2$#0$$## G.**H( G,H( ;' G,H9#1'# 12 ''$ # # <#& ## G,H(## ;#$ & 4 G,H( #$ I G6 (,,H( ## ### G4#(9#( &())#(,,H(<#1####G&(;&(411(F19,.H #1#0$'#0(#0#( # '%# $ # 1# '( 2 ? ## #%# ##$ # @#A$ 12##0( ## #''# #(20 # , %###$ #1 $! #( # 1# #%%, ##%%%##'%1$(21# 11#2#'10###1#%!#( # # 1 # ;4 # # '% # % .*+- = ,(2####%0###'$1#!## $ # % # 1 # ( 2 %0#'# #1 #2'%!1# $ #%.*+- = , #1 , %# ##$ #!# # % .*- = , # 1 ,. %# ##$# # $ $ 0 1 # 0#+ ! % 2 # '# 1 # %# ##$#1#,.
+ 7 $( # $ 01 # % $ 1 ## #1 0# '#&(2#'##1#'. $ 0 G ( ,KH # # # ## # # # ?##0$1#'%
20
!,.;#'#1#%###$#
I
I
I
I
I
W
W
W
W
W
WI
WI
WI
WI
WI
WW
WW
WW
WW
WW
WWI
WWI
.
,,
.
-K
.
.
I
,
*
,
.
I
.
K
.
..
.
I
,
-
,
,
.,
.
I
,
,K
,.
K
.
I
,
-K
.+
.
.
-
.,
.
W
.,
.
.*
..
.
,
.
W
.
+
.K
,.
.
..
,
.-
.
W
.K
,.
.
-
+
.
,
,.
-
.
W
.*
,K
.
-
.-
.*
.
+
.
-
.
W
.
+
.
-
K
.,
.,
.*
-
.
,-
.
WI
.
.
,
,
.
.
-
.
,
-
,K
.
WI
.
,K
,
,-
.+
.K
,
.
,.
.
,K
.+
,K
.
WI
K
*
.
+
,.
-
.,
.*
,-
.*
.
.+
,
-
.
WI
,.
.-
.*
.
.K
.
,
,,
.-
.K
-.
.
WI
,+
.+
-
.
.-
.
,-
,*
,,
,
,.
,*
KK
-
.
WW
+
.
.-
.K
..
.
.,
*
.
,
,-
-
-
.,
.
WW
.,
,.
,
.+
K
.*
.
,*
,
,.
.
,
-
.
WW
.
.,
.,
.
.
-
..
..
.+
,
,.
,*
.+
,.
,K
,
.
+
.
WW
.*
,,
.K
..
,
.
,
,,
+
K-
.
,,
.
,
,*
.
.
WW
.,
*
.
,
.
..
.
.-
.-
-
..
..
.K
.K
.K
.
*
K
.
WWI
.
K
-
.
.,
,
.,
.
.
-
-
,
,
..
,,
+
.
.
,
.
.
WWI
K.
.
+
+
.
*
.+
.K
..
-
*
.
,.
,
,
-+
.,
,
+
.
*
."#!#2%2#11#!''1#GH#(GH)#&(GH421(GIH630'#(GIH(GIH#(GIH0#(GIH
<'##(GWH;%D##(GWH63###(GWH;#(GWH;#1#0(GWH"'1#(GWIH#'(GWIH40'###$(
GWIH ##(GWIH#(GWIH#1#(GWWHJ1#%#$0'#(GWWH7#5#(GWWH5#(GWWH"'10#%$##%1'11(
GWWH601#(GWWIH6'01#(GWWIH02
21
! ## # %%%# ' 1 1# # 7( 2 0### ## 7#( 2 ;#D ## G;#( .*KKH !%'#2#0#0##'11##5##1,.###11#00#0 ###1#((% #0$ %# 1 # 0 # #(####11#%%%#7,.;#D##1#'%
"# !1# % 2 ;#D ## 1 # '%2# ,. # #%.*- ,!#%2;#D##1#'%2#,##%.*+-=,
"#(2 %1' :&# G:H ##(2 '%#11#'####01##'#### 3# # $%# ## # #'# ? 10 1 #G##H11#'*###1##5###3#0##:###0#0 1##1#'(20######7#(2'121#' 2 1 # 2# 0 1 &&D 1'# # #)2#5#"#(2%%$##1'##%%$"G,,H7$(2###1#&G,H(21#''#####G1#&#''H
*7#1#'%G.*-=,(,. #H( #:### K,G% 0H(21#'G.*+- ,(,#H:X**G% 0H
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 Factor Number
0
1
2
3
4
5
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Factor Number
0
1
2
3
4
5
6 E
igenvalue
Eigenvalue
22
1 1#'2#11#(2 # # ####11#'#%%%#.
. 9 # F #( 2 ## ## 1# 2#0###'#%##(#1#' 1#2# 0# #(2 # ' 1#2#0##.20(## $2!#('1#?01###'#'#'#5$2G$2(.*.H#1%$%1'G6(.**H
23
!,,##1#'#?0#'#
#
I##9#'
>?
0I##9#'
>?
0
421
*
,
,
.,
+-
+
.
.
0#
.
..
,
*
.*
;09
K
,
.
K
#1#
K
,
.
.-
K
##
-
K
-
.
*
#
--
.
.
-
,
-,
.
.+
-
K
#
,
,K
K
6'01#
K
*
+K
-
-
+
+.
7#5#
+
K
*
K
*
.
.
5#
-
,
K
.
.
-
K
K
K
J1#%#$
11
,
.
,
.
,
.
.
K-
"'1#
.
.
-
+
.+
.K
.
+
+,
.
.,
,.
.
*-
K
.,
.
..
*
#
+
.
*
.
++
.
.
,K
<'##
+
+
-
.-
)#&
.*
K
KK
.-
*
K*
601#
+
.
+
.
*.
*
.K
*
+
*
;#1
#0
+
-
*
.
+
K
-,
;#
.
..
.
K,
.
.,
K
63###
-
.
,*
K+
,*
K,
-
;%Y##
-
.
.,
K
,
K
.
..
K
"'10#%$2
%1'11
,
*
K
+
+
#'
.
,
.*
.
K
.K
,
.
-K
K
630'#
*
,
,+
-,
+
*
,
,
-
40'###$
,
+
K
"#7##'#6'':&!'#1##'!1#%
2##'#1#'%.*-=,(12,.#!#%2##'#
1#'%.*+-=,(12,#7##0%%(#1##
G##'H$
24
!#'# #1# ##1# # 2 #,,)#'##''5###2'1#1#'#G&2#%##'#H(#%######0$#1#(2#2 ##1#! #2# 1###%##1## ###'#0#%11##'% # ( # 1# 1# 1 # ####1%#021!1(2#1#@%#$'#0#0A####2#@'0%##A $ #$ #2#1# # 1# ( #1( 2 # 1# $ ' 1 # ## # # # ##$ 10'#O# 1#5# %5# 0 1# ##1#9#1##@##$#%#'A7$( 0 # ## 1# #%#$( %#(###0#1#1#!1#(#(@##$#%#'A.. %#1'#1#(#,,%###'#1#''#1# 0 #!?01 # #0# # 0 #2#### #$1#1# # ## ' ##' 1'# # # @#A01 %# ##$ ##9(21'#%$1%#$'#0#0(#%#'0%##(#'3#$1#00 %# ? 0 # 2 # # ##0$ ' 0 ## # ### # 1 # %###$'
..9%1'0&#####1#1#$#7#(2' # 1 # 1# ' 2 1 # #2#$ # 21'#')(2'#1#1#'2#$ 2 '## 1' # '% 7$( 2 & 2# # 1# #211#111##'%G. ,$0H#1 $0##1#'%
25
$ !)! 1# 2 # 1# 11# ' 1 %###$###%02&(2####'##!,(#'#21#1#%#! , ;# '# 1 # #1 ' 1 %###$)'%.*- ,
I ## 9# '
I .
## ,Z .
9# + .
' Z ,+Z .Z .
)'%.*+- ,
I ## 9# '
I .
## ,.Z .
9# * - .
' KZ Z K ."# #%% % 2 # # 11##2 #1#1 #11#'1#'%.*-=,#;4#!2%2##11#1#'%.*+-=,0#Z#1###%#0
( # ## # # 1 # '% 0$ '7#'( # ## # 1# # '#$( 2'% ## #$ 1# 11# ' 1 %# ##$(#'#11#1#$111' ! 1# # # 11# ' 1 %###$(221,,1#11###2( ( # "#( ) 7#'( 2 %0& 1 # '# # # # '# # # 1
26
%# ##$' #,-=,-.,! & # ' 0# 1 #$ ! %# #'%#'&2#&#'''01%###$#'''01%###$ # # #( #11#2###0&(##11$'
7 ,, ;'% 1 1# #2 2# ##
"# ;#$ 9X#2( )X( ":<X# "#()<"X) ! ' # 5# 1 # # $ % #(2.X.*-=.*+(,X.**=.*+(B (KX.***=, # 1 1 ,, # ,- = ,-( # 120# ' 7#$( #1 2 ## # '1%# ##$0$#2# #2 # 7#'( #1####'?#%##0#')$(#& 1# ## # % # #% . 1'# GH##'#$% # #%.1$#'!1#021##'#%# #,!$( # ##01# # @2#A' #$%$ # ## 0 '$
.,1#0?#
-1
0
1
2
3
4
BWA ISR NLD SDN 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 2 3 4 5 6
I ##' 9#
27
(2###02#$%$#(# # #2 # @2#A 0 ( 1 #( #'$0G%#$H1'6G,,H* !,-&'####%#$'#0#0
Ranking country obs median minimum r min maximum r max
1 Mongolia 5 -0.60 -0.64 2 -0.48 11
2 Russia 3 -0.59 -0.63 3 -0.29 55
3 Korea, Dem. Rep. 6 -0.59 -0.60 7 -0.55 1
4 Vietnam 6 -0.57 -0.61 5 1.44 95
5 Albania 6 -0.56 -0.60 9 -0.26 57
6 Bulgaria 5 -0.56 -0.60 8 -0.36 46
7 Singapore 6 -0.55 -0.57 16 -0.51 5
8 Japan 5 -0.55 -0.59 12 -0.50 7
9 Taiwan 2 -0.55 -0.57 18 -0.52 3
10 Ivory Coast 6 -0.54 -0.56 21 0.09 77
… … … … … … … …
110 Angola 5 1.51 0.92 114 1.82 98
111 Guatemala 5 1.70 -0.45 87 3.44 114
112 Cambodia 3 1.87 1.52 117 1.96 100
113 Myanmar 3 1.94 0.54 113 2.38 106
114 Peru 5 2.03 1.09 115 3.16 112
115 Lebanon 3 2.09 1.75 118 2.49 108
116 Colombia 6 2.11 0.36 110 6.19 119
117 Sri Lanka 6 2.14 -0.08 104 2.63 109
118 Philippines 5 2.32 1.14 116 3.57 115
119 Afghanistan 4 2.41 1.78 119 3.13 111
Spearman rank correlation with median ranking: 0.83 0.79 "# # #2#&1##1#'1#2&1###$(&1###$#' 11# 01 # %# #$( ' # ' 1#( ''' # ''' 1# ( ' # & # 1 #'''1#6''X#'''1#('#&# 1 # '''1# ! )%' & # # 1 #' & # ''' &( # ' & # ''' &(%#0$
28
!,-&'####'0%##
Ranking country obs median minimum r min maximum r max
1 Uganda 5 -0.56 -0.74 1 -0.42 10
2 Cuba 6 -0.55 -0.56 19 -0.35 15
3 Mozambique 5 -0.54 -0.68 2 -0.30 19
4 Laos 5 -0.54 -0.60 6 -0.40 11
5 Singapore 6 -0.54 -0.58 10 -0.48 6
6 Angola 5 -0.52 -0.62 4 -0.48 5
7 Namibia 2 -0.52 -0.56 18 -0.48 4
8 Gambia 4 -0.51 -0.53 40 -0.50 1
9 Yemen, Rep. 2 -0.50 -0.51 48 -0.49 2
10 Lesotho 4 -0.50 -0.54 33 0.01 47
… … … … … … … …
110 China 6 0.81 0.26 113 1.12 96
111 Serbia 6 0.83 -0.37 82 2.88 111
112 Poland 4 0.88 -0.28 94 3.88 114
113 Argentina 4 1.15 0.32 116 1.95 108
114 Pakistan 2 1.47 1.25 119 1.69 105
115 Israel 6 1.66 0.46 117 3.38 113
116 Korea, Rep. 6 1.94 -0.18 100 6.63 117
117 Russia 3 2.59 -0.12 105 6.54 116
118 South Africa 6 2.65 -0.35 83 6.96 118
119 India 6 3.26 0.00 110 8.38 119
Spearman rank correlation with median ranking: 0.80 0.77 "# # #2#&1##1#'1#2&1###$(&1###$#' 11# 01 # %# #$( ' # ' 1#( ''' # ''' 1# ( ' # & # 1 #'''1#6''#'''1#('#&# 1 # '''1# ! )%' & # # 1 #' & # ''' &( # ' & # ''' &(%#0$
29
!,-&'######$2##%#'
Ranking country obs median minimum r min maximum r max
1 Cambodia 3 -1.34 -1.73 2 -1.25 1
2 Iraq 5 -1.13 -1.25 13 -0.45 19
3 Somalia 3 -1.13 -1.50 6 -0.73 6
4 China 6 -1.11 -1.43 7 -0.55 10
5 Myanmar 3 -1.05 -1.19 18 -0.86 4
6 Russia 3 -1.05 -2.01 1 -0.95 2
7 Mongolia 5 -1.02 -1.33 8 -0.27 31
8 Korea, Dem. Rep. 6 -0.99 -1.20 16 -0.91 3
9 Cuba 6 -0.98 -1.21 15 -0.85 5
10 Romania 5 -0.98 -1.06 29 0.98 80
… … … … … … … …
110 Sweden 6 1.35 0.94 109 1.66 104
111 Denmark 6 1.38 1.22 116 1.76 110
112 Netherlands 6 1.44 0.90 107 1.69 106
113 Belgium 6 1.52 0.89 106 1.94 113
114 Norway 6 1.54 1.20 115 1.71 107
115 Bolivia 4 1.55 1.17 114 1.76 109
116 Ecuador 5 1.64 1.53 118 2.10 115
117 Israel 6 1.68 1.32 117 2.02 114
118 Italy 5 1.93 0.97 110 2.42 118
119 Pakistan 2 1.97 1.72 119 2.22 117
Spearman rank correlation with median ranking: 0.90 0.85 "# # #2#&1##1#'1#2&1###$(&1###$#' 11# 01 # %# #$( ' # ' 1#( ''' # ''' 1# ( ' # & # 1 #'''1#6''#'''1#('#&# 1 # '''1# ! )%' & # # 1 #' & # ''' &( # ' & # ''' &(%#0$
30
! ,- & '# # # # ##$ 1 #%#'
Ranking country obs median minimum r min maximum r max
1 Indonesia 5 -0.86 -0.92 10 -0.15 17
2 Namibia 2 -0.86 -0.90 11 -0.81 1
3 Cuba 6 -0.82 -0.83 25 -0.43 5
4 Jamaica 5 -0.79 -0.82 35 0.04 30
5 Germany 5 -0.77 -1.15 1 -0.41 7
6 Singapore 6 -0.74 -0.84 22 -0.06 24
7 Botswana 6 -0.73 -0.89 13 -0.42 6
8 Cyprus 1 -0.68 -0.68 59 -0.68 2
9 Zimbabwe 5 -0.67 -0.86 17 2.23 111
10 Ivory Coast 6 -0.66 -0.83 32 1.77 99
… … … … … … … …
110 Ecuador 5 0.72 -0.49 84 1.11 78
111 Central African Republic 3 0.81 -0.17 106 0.81 68
112 Cambodia 3 0.91 0.14 112 1.44 90
113 Italy 5 1.02 0.13 111 2.36 113
114 Lebanon 3 1.24 0.76 116 1.79 100
115 Pakistan 2 1.37 0.55 115 2.18 110
116 Afghanistan 4 1.85 0.53 114 2.60 117
117 Niger 2 1.85 1.60 118 2.11 107
118 Bangladesh 1 1.95 1.95 119 1.95 106
119 Burundi 2 2.27 1.32 117 3.21 118
Spearman rank correlation with median ranking: 0.75 0.53 "# # #2#&1##1#'1#2&1###$(&1###$#' 11# 01 # %# #$( ' # ' 1#( ''' # ''' 1# ( ' # & # 1 #'''1#6''#'''1#('#&# 1 # '''1# ! )%' & # # 1 #' & # ''' &( # ' & # ''' &(%#0$
7$(2 '%1# %# 11# '1%###$2#'1G#'#%'#H#####! 2 '% # '1%# 0# %D##1 G.**.H( # #1%## $G.**.H(#1##G.**KH(2;(##2 %% $ G.*H G ;H( #%#%#$10'#1#G.**KH(2
31
#1'#'!,2###2# 0 ## 1# # 11# ' 1 %###$! , ;# #2 # ' 1 %# ##$ #### I ## ' 9#
0#;%G(.**.H +. * -* .
#G(.**.H ,, , .,
;G##(.**KH * , -, -
;##G(.*H ,, *+ , K
;IG(.*H + ,* ,
:#G#(.**KH K- -. .-"# # # #'#$ 0 #0# 1 '%1 #1 # % .*- = , ; #%;'%#
! # 2 ## # $ G.**.H( ## G.**KH 1#%#$'#0#0(2#1G.*H%##02'0%##20(#%### # #$ # # 0 1 # ##$ 1 # %#' 2 # ##$ 2# # %# ' ! ##11#1#'-*G#0#%D##01G.**.H2####$1#%#'H!1 # G.**KH(2 #'( #$##'#$#2###1#1'##2###
* + ! ! > # 2$ # 0 ## 1# 11# ' 1%# ##$( 2 ' # '%# 1 %# ##$ '2#90##1G#H*#1#%.*-=,(2%#%K?%1$# ' #' 2# 11# $( 2 1 #211# %# 1 # # #2 %# ##$ '
32
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
ititittitiit XZgg ελγβϕα +++++= − )ln()ln()ln( 1,
2 # 4<2# #% %# #$ 1 # $%##$[1##$111#\##'111#.- ! 0# # # %#$ 0 1' #)21'2&!0##1##10#'##4<##1%(#01$'##$
.)6&2#G.**,H.-9##1#%1#'111#7 ############'11#?1###3## $%#G#.]10H(2 #'111# #' # # $%# # 3#(2'##'111#1'#%1#
33
# #1% (%%#2##$ % %#1'#0(2#&1':G,H(01'#9!K,G#()''#(,KH ! 0# # # 1 %# ##$ # 1#$ % . 7$( ' #' %% ,#%#0###10#$ ! ,K 2 # #'# # ' .( 2 # #'% 0 1 %# ##$ # 1##1'#.*-=,'%(22#0','-212#'%(##2 # 1# # 1' # .*+- = , '% !%1###1##0 #1$####%#####'1#,K#'%1#
.94#$2#01#%###$#
34
!,K#'##
<%#04<2#%%# G.H G,H GH G-H
11#$ - - +- +-
;#'%04;#$ ;# 4 ;# 4
:4<2#%%# , .- ., K
G.+HZ G..KH G*.H GKH
'##$ -+ -K , -
G,-HZZZ G,.HZZ G..H G,HZZ
60%## . .. .
G..H G+*H G.*H G,.H
9###$ , -*
G.H G.K,H G*.H G,HZZ
#$'#0#0 ., .K ,, .+
G+H G*-H G.*,HZ G+,H
0#'# .- *K + K.
G*HZZZ G,KHZZZ GKHZZZ G.*HZ
)$'# ,. ,
G.H G.H G-H G.,H
%#2# *+ . ,., *
G.-.H GH GKH GK+H
;## .. +, .. K
G.*H G+H G.K-H GH
0# ,, . . ,K
;# * *- +K +
7 ###'111# .+ K,+ , .+
% 0 . -
##1## .. -K *
% 0 .* K- *
##10 #1$## -, KK -.- ,*K
% 0 . . .+
9## +*K -.* *,, ,.-
% 0 "##'#'#)$#'466G(.**+H(;#5 ###%#(Z1##.]LZZ1##]LZZZ1##.]##0
7#.*-=,'%(21#####$1#%#'#$'1%###$##1#$#
35
# '2# =# #'% 7 # .*+- =, '%( # # ' 0 ( 2 1 ## # ###$1#%#'###$2##%#'# 11# ' 2# ! '%# 1 # @2#A'( 20( %#0 Q# '&$( 2 1 %1###%#0%#0'%#'2# # # #0(21 ##$ # 0#'# 4< # #$%#0$##'2#
! #'# $ # ## # 11# '011#11#'2#"#$#11##'#11#11(#(51##'#'%#11# # 1 # %#( 2 %0 02 ##2# #### # #%20(21# '##1##'##
,-1# #? # '%2### # # #%% ' %1# <1 Q G.**+H %# # '2# # % ( ( #$ # $0# 11# #$ )'$( # '$ ## '##0 %1##%#0!1(2####0#$1 #'# 1 ##00!0 '$ G ' #& 1' 6 G,,H(52&( 05( ; :' G,H( I G,H(%#0$H( # 12 G;4( ,H( %# G;4( ,H(2?#$ G>!( ,KH( ' 1 % G% $ # F75# 1 <( ,KH( 1# G9 & <0%'##(,KH(#510'#14<G##(,KH'&'(2#%1#1',# ,K G1 #11#1%# ##$1 #'%.*- ,H!#%##, '. *(201##0$ '.(201##0 ##'& %1# # 0 1# 1# #$2#$( # '& #0 ## '#1#0 1# # $' % 1'2& %
36
%##1#$111#.KJ#(2#1##G#01H###$1#%#'1# %1# 7#'( 2 1 ## ' 1 #%1# # ##$ 2# # %# ' ( ( %#0$##'2# !1# & # #1# #(2'2## # 0 $ %1 ! '#0# $ #11;'%"#G,,H(2##0111#1%###$'2#0$##1) )1 # # '% # ,+(2 %# #'##2211# 1'# '% # ## #111# # 1'1 ## ###$1#%#'$11#'2# 7$(2' #%#$10#$ 1''2###01%###$9'#%0( 1 # %# ##$ ' # %#0!#%##,*%#1'#1###'1%###$%##0#'(21##2# # # 2 0 1 %#$ '#0# 07#'(21 ## '2# % # ##$2# #%#'(2##2 2$#%#2#0 7$(21 11# 1' '2# # ##'1%###$!##### 2$ '%# 1 ##$ 1 # %# ' ' 2#( 2 # ' # # #2 ' 0%##'2#
.K1#(22#'#'%%#' #'G2###$#'%111#H('$1##0###1#
37
!,)#0#$##
<%#04<2#%%#
G.H
G,H
GH
G-H
GH
GKH
GH
G+H
G*H
G.H
:4<2#%%#
..
.K
.,
-
,.
-
*,
.K*
.
.K
G+,H
G.+H
G+H
G*H
G,H
G,H
GH
G.,H
G.H
G.KH
0#'#
**
.
*K
K
.
*
*
*+
-*
G,HZZZG,HZZZG,+-HZZZ
G.KHZ
G,HZZGHZZZ
G,,-HZZG,KKHZZZGKHZZZ
G.KH
$'#
..
,
.-
,,
.K
.,
-
,-
,
.*
GKKH
G..,H
G*H
G.H
G.H
G,H
G.*,HZ
G...H
G..KH
G..,H
%#2#
,.
,*
,K
,,*
*
-+
-,+
,**
.,+
+
G-KH
GKKH
GH
GKH
G.+H
G.H
G.-KH
GKKH
G,-H
GKH
'##$
-
-
-
-+
-
.
-
*
-
-.
G,.HZZG.*+HZZ
G.*HZ
G*HZZZG-*HZZZGK.HZZZG,*HZZZ
G,*HZZG,K+HZZZG,-HZZZ
60%##
.,
..
.,
.-
..
.+
+
..
+
.
G..,H
G*H
G.H
G.H
G*.H
G.H
G-H
G.H
G,H
G..*H
9###$
.
-K
,
.
.*
.,
,
-
,
G+H
G.--H
GK+H
GKH
G+H
GH
G,,HZZZG,*HZZZ
G.*HZ
G.-H
#$'#0#0
.,
*
..
,
.
.-
,
.K
.K
.+
GKH
G.H
GKH
G.+HZ
G.+H
G.KH
G.+HZ
G.-H
G.,.H
G.-H
<'$G#$IH
G+H
<'$GIH
-,
G*,H
#$G52&#H
-
G-H
12
,
.
G,-HZZ
G.*HZ
;%#
,
G,H
38
9?#$
.,
G-H
45#
,
G..-H
1#
K-
GKK,HZZZ
GKHZZZ
40'#4<
.*
G-KH
;##
.,
.
.*
**
.
,,
..+
+
**
G.-H
G.-H
G**H
G*KH
G-H
G.KH
G,H
G.-H
G,H
G*H
0#
.K
.-
.
,*+
,*+
.*
,*
.
,+*
;#
*
*
*,
++
++
+
+
*,
*-
+
7 ###'111#
*.+
*
+K.
*K,
+
-
KK
-+.
0
.
,
-
,
.-
.
.*
##1
##
K
K
.
-
K
K
+K
+,
0
,
-
,
K.
*
,
-
*
-
-.
##10 #1$
##
*,,
*.
K.+
K
,.-
-K
,
++
0
K
,*
K
K,
-
K
-
9##
*-*
*-
+**-
+,-
,.
.
.K-
.--
-,
.KK
0
"##'#'#)$#'466G(.**+H(;#5 ###%#(Z1##.]LZZ1##
]LZZZ1##.]
39
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
40
!$(21###'010#$!# ( ' 2# 1# ##$ 2# # %# '(2#&12##%#$'#0#021## # ' 0%2# '$( # #%# ##'$G%#'%##H#$#'2#(####$1&11#G00H!11#2##1((6()#$#)#G,-H(2 #'# 0 # % 1 ##( ) ) 1('&001# !(1(0'####$## # # 11#1'0# #?#$!'$%##$##'#(#&$###'1$#%#7#'(11#1''#'$#%# ## # &$##$%0'G0H%#10#(%1%###'(#% #$%$ # 1 # %# #'# 1 %% 02( # # 11# 1 # #$% 1''#%
( ' % ( # # # 1'2&110 $'2#0#%#0#'%$#'$2###2####1#%(2 #11#%#2##'$2G0 #0H ##( # $ 0'$'(%$2#&#'2## $%###$##0%%'#G,H(210###%1%'2#(('(59G,KH(21#12#%(0$ %' # 2# # %' %# ( 2 2 #%% # 0#( '# 0( # 11# 1 %# '%1%'2#
41
!,+ #'##2%11'#'%
<%#04<
2#%%#
))1
)##
6 #^"#1
:#'
'##$
-
.
-,
-
G,.-HZZ
G,,HZZ
G.+*HZ
G,,KHZZ
60%##
.K
.+
.,
*
G.HZ
G.H
G..H
G+H
9###$
.
,,
--
,.
GH
G+*H
G.HZ
G+,H
#$'#0#0
*
.
,
G.H
GH
G-*H
G..H
0#
,
,+-
,*
,-
;#
K
+
+
,
"##'#'#)$#'466G(.**+H!'%1##'
',#,70#$&(##'##1###0#%1###
%%;#5 ###%#(Z1##.]LZZ1##]LZZZ1##.]
42
!,* '#10#$ G.H G,H GH G-H
<%#0 I ## 9# '
:4<2#%%# ++ .+ K. -
G.HZ G+H G,,HZZZ G.,H
#$'#0#0 KK*
G+HZZZ
60%## K+
G*+HZZZ
9###$ .K
G,+HZZZ
'##$ .*,
G,-*HZZ
;## . .-. . ..
GH G*HZZZ G-HZZZ G-*KHZZZ
0# ,. ,. ,. ,.
;# ., ., ., .,
7 ###'111# .-, ,K- ,-
0 . ,
##1## -- *K
0 KK - -+ -
##10#1$## ,-K ,,. .K. ,,.
0 ,, . K+
9## +*. -, .+ -+
0 "##'#'#)$#'466G(.**+H(;#5 ###%#(Z1##.]LZZ1##]LZZZ1##.]
43
%%,:#1%###$#(1# .
# $%#$'#0#'##'%#'10'#11%#
&G,H
;# !'1#'$##2%''O]1##%#%$2'#
&G,H
;02 ''$0(.1##.####%$1##2#0'#1###%%#%2##1#0##2
4##G,,H
;%D## !'1####1##%0'##O#11#0#1##Y%2##0$
&G,H
630'#
$%$0%########211#%#'(##10#'#0#2
&G,H
<'## $%1%#1##.%%1#%'$%%1%$0#%%##0'#%##$('##1##$# 1#
&G,H
## '#1#1#2##$2####(##$0
;4G,H
#0
!'1#'$##11#0#1##0<2
&G,H
7#5# !%#$###2%#%&#'1'##2111#%#
&#G,.H
40'###$
'#1#0'##$#$##%'##$##$11
;4G,H
421 $'#0#$(#('$%#1#51'##0#21#%#'
&G,H
#1# '#1%#0##$##%##'%#0
;4G,H
63###
!'1####Y#####(##'#%#12#####1#$##%#01#010'#
&G,H
6'01#
<''$0(.1#'#,####%$##1##$1'#.####(#12#.%$G#2#0'#1###%%#%2##1#0#H#2
4##G,,H
44
%%,;#
.
601#
<''$0(.1###,####%$10$$#%1##2#0'#1###%%#%(2##1#0##2
4##G,,H
"'1#
!'1#1#21##0$
&G,H
5# 6''%5##2##0%#$#1%%%#1##
&#G,.H
J1%#$11
"'1$###%#$1#1#011
&#G,.H
"'1$#'#%G'#H$3#1%#%%#2##&1#'#%%#
&G,H
' <''$0(.1#0__#%#$I##(2'##2'#######$(#2
6G,,H
# '#1#1#2##$2####0
;4G,H
0# $1##%0'##($##'%##($11'2'%1'##0'#
&G,H
# $0#'##1'#.#500#1%$1
&G,H
"'10#%$2%1'11
!%#10#%$##%1'#0'#0###
&#G,.H
)#& $#&1.('#02&##00'#'%$##'##0'#%##$
&G,H
45
%%,<%#0###5 6 ) 7
'2# K. , . *
!"#$%&'())*
#$'#0#0 -K . * K,
60%## -K K .. +-
##$1#%#' -K + ., K
##$2##%#' -K - *, , ,K
!#$+&'())*
#$'#0#0 K . ** * ,
60%## K .. .K -
##$1#%#' K +, .- *
##$2##%#' K *- .K .
,-
4<%%# K +.*K- *,,K*K ..- +--+,
0#'#4<# K* .K+ *- , KK
%#2# +. *
)$'# K, ,K*+ .K** - ,
.,-
<'$G#$IH + ,+ K . .
<'$GIH -K .
#$G52&#H +, + -* .
45# K-, .++ +K K. ,.
12 -+ K. .+ K
;%# -+ ,* .-. K
9?#$ -* K ++
1# + +. .-.- ,-+ ,KK,,
40'#4< K ,., *+. , .
46
47
!"
##4" I####'1'#%#'%0 #$D '2#%1'.+20( 0 #$2##51 #'##$##$G<1#(,H7#'( #$2#$#0$#'%#1'%%%#1###(2$12### 2# # 0 % 1 0 G< ( ,H.* & G,H %# ## # -+ # 0%' ##& # ' 0%'#!& #0$##2#%##9'#%1#2#(#1%2#12$## 0 %1 )#(# #1 ### #$ ;?#$( '% 2# #'# # '%# 1 ##$ 0##$ 2# #(%$0%#
17 !%# G,H( G,+H.+70$##%#2'2#%#'((52& # G,H9# G,-H %0 0021 # #%#2# 5# ' 2#( 2 # ## ' 1' '2#0$$<(:# ')#'G,KH.*I#0#1%'(##%%'1#3#1$ # ###2 0# #1? #2##0#2%#?&G###(,H
48
%'##$#'#'(%#(###%$###'%$2#%## % ## # 1 $ ' # G,H 2' 2# %# ' ' 1' %2##,!$1##2##1#%$%#'(2'1'$####
# %# 2 ' # #% #2 '1'( %# ' ( 2# #( '& #12 ## 7#( 2 #$ # %# # #'# # 1' # G,H # ## # # 0 $11##%##$(21##'#G,H2#$$#%###$I'1#0 #$ # ## # %# ' ''$!1( 2 %# # # 2 # # # # #( # 2 # '#$ 1 ' # G,H )( 2 '%0 % # 1# $ ' # G,H ##1$2###1#$'##'7'%( , % #1 # 0 2# #$1 # # # # # ##1 # #!(2###$111##&##2'2# # !1( 2 # 1 11# # %% $ ;' G.*+H # 1 G%H %# 7#( 2 # $ 1 G# # 1H '(# ' # 1 # ' % # #7$(2#$$##$I##(#0####1###0'#
'1##'2##%$'1'91##2##&$#%%#%#'=#'$#$= %( 2 G '0 #2H ' '$ # ##$I###&##2##2
! %# % 12 )# , 1# ##1$'2##)#$5##%#2%#'('1'2##(2 # - ' # # 1 # )#
, # %% ## # # %# 0# # #1$ #'#12# & G,(H4055 ! G,H'2##1%#'1''##
49
" 7 # % .* .**,(' # G,H #1$ # +% 1 # 2#( # 121# 7 #$G2# ' # . ' ## ' # , 00#H( ##'1 4< % %# G#&1' # 9!K.1#()'' #(,,H #'10$#$%GXH!#(
2#4<%%##'!#'#%'#(/ ( #&%$1#02##0#%#/ # @# ? 2# #A ! ?1$ 2##( ##?2##'###]%'7#'( # '# # # , %# %# # #%0#$7$(##%11'0$(#014<'###1###$1#####0$?1$####12##(#$2###7 ###1 %2 G %H 2# #& # # 0# $' # G,H 2 1 # %#$ ## # 12$## ######10$1##1#
'#G,H%00#�# ## # # 1 )#(2 ## ## '%0%!.%##2##1### 1 #2# # #1$' # G,H( #2# # # 1# $ 1 # # # # $ 2#0##1'#9!K.
nitgay nttit ,,0,*)ln( , =++= ++ ε
50
!.42###'#G,H 0#1
2
0(13-
0*13
0&14,
0513-67
0813-6 7
0%139)7
.* .K . -,
# .*K K. K
# .** K *+ K.
# .*K. . -+ +
' .** + - -
#2 .*K* . . .. $ $
5 .*K , +- +
; .*K, . - K $ $
; .* + -K $
; .*+K .
; .*+ .. .K K
; .** .K +
;' .*K + ,* -
;' .*, ,+ K
;% .*K* * .,, - $
;% .*+ * . +,
<'& .* - $ <'% .*K* - . <'% .**, -, + K $
.* -, ,* +- $
$%# .*K . *+ - $ $
7 .*+ ,. .
7 .*K . K K $
7 .**, + - ,+ $
4 .*K ,. ,, + 4 .*K* . ,+ +. $ $4 .*++ - .K , $
a# .** .* ..K .,
.*+, , *
.*K .K *-
.*+ , -
.*+ -+
.*+ , K $ $
.* K , $
51
!.;# (1)
2
0(13-
0*13
0&14,
0513-67
0813-6 7
0%139)7
.*K K ., ,
% .*+ - +- *
.* . . *. $ $
%F .*K, - +* K*
%F .*+- , + $
:# .*. - K $ $
62 .* *. ,.+ *
62 .**, . .,+ -+
6$ .* , . $
6$ .*++ K, K- $
6 .*, ,+ K + $ $
6# .*. -- K
6# .*+ , ,K
6 .*+ - . $
"28 .* - . + $ $
" .*K K K -+ $ $
" .* K -, -
" .*K .+ , $
"2$ .**. , ,
&# .*K, . - -+
&# .** . -K
' .** * -
' .* ., K $ $%"24 .*+ -. - $ $
$ .*- * - K,
.** K .K ,
.**, .*
# .*+ , - -
' .** K ,. .,- $ $
2 .* ,. .. -
)% .*K* ., ., +, $ $
)% .** - +, +
)% .*+- . +
):& .** .. -.
)$ .*K* ..- .*, + $ $ $
52
!.;# 0#1
2
0(13-
0*13
0&14,
0513-67
0813-6 7
0%139)7
)$ .*- , .. -+ $
)$ .*+* . K --
!2 .*K. - -K .
! .* .* K $ $ $
! .*+K , +. !^! .* .- + -
! .*K+ * - KK $ $
> .* + K - $ $
> .*+* . , K >#F' .*+, ,- +
>#)## .*K. - - *
>$ .*- .+ -
>$ .*+* . * + $ $
8'2 .*K- K .. ,
"#'G.H####1##L'G,H2##12##$%##L'GH##2### ###1##L ' G-H %# # 0 2# # # %L ' GH#2##2#1###1###2######1#%G$X$LXHL'GKH#2##2#1###1 # # # 0 2# # 1 # %L ' GH 22###02######1#%!'####G,,H9!K.'#G,H!2##.+2##% #1$'#G,H0#02## #1#$1##7#'(,1# #1%02# # #$1#######1##7$(1.%(2##$1####02# # # # # # 1 #1 #'##%1#1##$#1#$(2%1#####1##,. ,. 02( # 2$ # 1# # #1$ # ## 1 # 2##?#$#1#%'#1&2#1##1#( #%#'%# 11#$ #0##$#& # ?( # #1 # # 7 ### 1 #1##1#
53
! #1$ # ## 1 2# # ?#$( 2%% '% # ## 1# #1 % #& 11 1 # ! # ' # # Q ##1$ # %# $ G ( ,,H !?1$ # %## ## 1 '2# # $ (2##1#$1####$1,,
tt gg >+1
1$11##(2&2##11###1'#G,H
tiyy
ppagg
ppag
it
ttnt
nt
≤>>−
>
+
−+
+
max
0.2
5.3
7
,77,
7,
1##12$'#$/##?1$($###1#2##1#0$11#(2#& # $ 2 #01 4< '' # # ##%#1#2##!'%###2###1#$1##0##%0$1# #1 +- #(2 %# ! ,,9& 2 #0 1 2# %# # # # #$'#G,H#########2#1$#0$#0###G#0?#H
0##1####4<(##$#%#'#1#&,,#&(2'######2 $2####2 $2##1###1#2##!##0####2######1######### # % # # ' ## 1# 0$ ' - % #1 #$ # ' $( % 11 . $(2$ % ##1,9&2#%111'#'%'#2#!.#####21##1#2%$$##2####02#####; G.*K*H &# G.*KH # 1 ;( # # 2# ###1#'%%( (.*K!##1&# 11#.*K #1#%##1##%0#
54
!,42###1#
0#1
2
0(1
3-
0*13
0&1:
051:;<=
.* ,. -, ,.
# .*K * K ,
# .** . K. *,
# .*K. . + ,
' .*+ ,- - , .
#2 .* ..- +. .
5 .*KK . , -. .
;' .*, K *
; .*K. . + ,+ .
; .*- . ++ .
; .*+ . -, ,
; .*++ . + -+
; .*K , - ,
; .*+. K
; .*+* , + .
;' .*K .K - ,-
;% .*K* * - -
;% .* + + -* .
<'& .*+ ,, , .<'% .*K+ , K KK .<'% .**. - + .
.*KK . -K -
.*. .K K.
$%# .* .. K .
7 .*+ , ,,
7 .*K+ ,+ ,- .
7 .** - -- -+ .
4 .*K . + +- 4 .*. . .- ,
.*+, . * ,-
.*K + K,
.*+ - ,.
.* . + ,- .
.*+K . -* .
.** -* +, , *
.*+ ,- - ,* .
55
!,;#
0#1
2
0(1
3-
0*13
0&1:
051:;<=
.*K ,+ , --
% .*+ + * ,
.*. . K *. ,
%F .*K .* -* ,
%F .*K ,K - -+
%F .*+. + ,
:# .*K* . * ,, ,
62 .* . * ,
6$ .*. ,. .
6$ .*+K , , ,
6 .** , K *
6# .*K* . - K, ,
6# .*+ . --
6 .* * + + ."28 .*+ ,. -. , .
" .** .. , -. .
" .* ., -
" .*K+ - -K + .
"2$ .**. .- K ,,
&# .*K .+ - K ,
&# .*K ,*
&# .* .K -- , ,
' .** . - *
' .*K .* - .
$ .* ,K * .
.** + , --
# .*+- .K K - .
' .*+ K .- .+ .
2 .* -
)% .*K .K K ,
)% .** -- +
)% .*+- . +
):& .** .* -. ,,
)$ .* , .
)$ .*+* ,* --
!2 .*K K+ - .
!2 .*KK K. +K ,
! .*+ * - K .
56
!,;#
0#1
2
0(1
3-
0*13
0&1:
051:;<=
! .*+ - KK , !^! .*. ,. -+ , -
! .*K* , K- + .
! .** .K ,. *
> .*+* + K -- >#F' .*+, .. , >#)## .*K. * * .
>$ .*- . - ,K
8'2 .*K , KK K- .
8'2 .*K+ K
"#'G.H####1##L'G,H2##12##+$ % # #L ' GH %# # 0 2# # # %L'G-H%##11#2'G,HGHL'GH2#11#21# ##1'# G,H"# ## #1# ##2 #1$ ##( 2#' # G,H # #1$ # # ! # #'111#1###%#$1#1'##$21##1##"*####.**!#$'#G,H!'2###1'##G,,H9!K.2#
!##11#2##1#1'#G,H#1#$,+%G]H #1 # #$ # ' #( . % G]H 11 $(2 . % G.+]H #12#' # $ 117#'(1##%&%*%(2 #1$# 1# 1 ' # G,H # % # 11 #### #2### #1#$1## # #2# # # $1 # #,-7$(2#1$.%#1$'#G,H
! ## # 11# #( 7 . 2 # 4<1;(#26
,- ! % G## $ %#H 4 G.*++H( # G.**H(62G.**,H(6G.*,H(%"24G.*+H(G.**,H()$G.*-H(>G.*H>$G.*+*H
57
7.;'%11#2##1#1'#G,H
#2
;
8
8,2
8,4
8,6
8,8
9
9,2
1951
1953
1955
1957
1959
1961
1963
1965
1967
1969
1971
1973
1975
1977
1979
1981
1983
1985
1987
1989
1991
1993
1995
1997
1999
year
ln(r
gdp
)
HPR
Our filter
6,8
7,3
7,8
8,3
8,8
1960
1962
1964
1966
1968
1970
1972
1974
1976
1978
1980
1982
1984
1986
1988
1990
1992
1994
1996
1998
ln(r
gdpc
)
HPR
Our filter
58
7.;#
6
"#)24<%%#G##%;H # 1'# # G,,H 9! K.! $' # # $ 2 # 2## #1#'# G,H(2# @ 1#A # # $ 2 2 #1$ #2##
!1#2$#2######%% # ## #1;( # #'1#1#1'#G,H##(2##$#1#2 ! 1 6 ## ## # # #1 $'#G,H1##$K$20( # #1 #( # 02# # ## K $1 ##'%#1##02###1##2$1## # ? ## ## # G##H+$( '& ## # ? 2# # ##1,
,'##$(##%?2#####1$1# 2 7 '%( # % ## #2# # #0 # #%0$(12$,$1##%1%2#1$9&%(###2#1$##%%#
6,6
6,65
6,7
6,75
6,8
6,85
6,9
6,95
1960
1962
1964
1966
1968
1970
1972
1974
1976
1978
1980
1982
1984
1986
1988
1990
1992
1994
1996
1998
2000
ln(r
gdpc
)
HPR
No acceleration
59
""!9 '20 # # ##1 2# #!%#02'%$#$#&01###'1###12##5#2,K###1.K#0#%.* .**12#%##2##
%$1 ' 1'2 $ # %0$959G,H(##%#'1##1#G(%1'&# # ' 'H #''0'#G(%1& '&#%''1 1 $H( # # #11 #11 # #72 ' # G,H( # 0 ''$ ###& # 0 1 . # 1# 10 $ 1 ## #2@%A
' 0 #&1' # #$ I # #16 G,,H ' 1 # %###$#$20(#%###$1''1%1$(21$#(212$##1#''1##$:& #'1'''$(2''$?#1 # 1# 10 $ 1# %# ' 5 #272'# G,H(211###2%#0 ' G( ' '$H #0 ' G( '#$H #(2 # #$ #1 %#$0 #%$ #01'$ 7$(2 # #1 ' 1 # '1 $ ## # # ' %(12##1;(F1(F&G.**KH,!# ## # # G# & 1H '# # ## 11#'2####'##%#'%,+
9 # %%%# % # ' # ##%%$' G.*+H! $%# ## #$1
,K912'#G,H###'#1#%#0!#(1###$#$'#/##02#%0#(#'##$##'12##12#%%1'#G,H#%#$1'###1#7#'(2'##0#1'#$2####1##G$/(=/5H,!#11##2'''$##0 ,+7##002(!095G,.H
60
11# ? 5 > # #'# 1 # 1 11# #G;7 :H ' G ;'( .*+H ### G%H #'(#$%#3###'##1'%1#(;7 :%1,*7#'(2'# % 1 #' 11# # # 7 , 2 # 1# 1##2##0$$1##'%%!1####'12###$0#'!1(2#'(2###1#'#%1#7,42##0#'(.* .**
0
0,02
0,04
0,06
0,08
0,1
0,12
0,14
1957
1958
1959
1960
1961
1962
1963
1964
1965
1966
1967
1968
1969
1970
1971
1972
1973
1974
1975
1976
1977
1978
1979
1980
1981
1982
1983
1984
1985
1986
1987
1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
1993
year
grow
th a
ccel
erat
ions
/ ob
serv
atio
ns
"# # 1 2 # #0 ' 1 2# # % $ G' 1#$O##'10#$H)9!K.!'1##1#%#'##
,*#&(2#'#'%#$'2#111########0$'###111###!#0?# 9 # 1 #' 11# ' 2# #'##$(1#(22#20(7 ##'#$%####'11#?#3#1'#%1#
61
#####0$11 ###(2##%###'##1'#G,H> ## # %0$' # G,H(22 #1$ % #+1 # %% G% ,,H( 2 #$ %# ##%#2 #%#$12##%#'20(20##'#G,H2#$$#%###$I'1#0#$### # %# ' ''$. ?( ###1'#G,H#%#'''$#&01.20# #G'H##$,!#2##1#1%#'#090##'2### !%###'##12#1#+1'#G,H##'0(#22##2###1$'#G,H#%#0-#0##$1'# 1 ' # G,H 9 # ## %# ## '0$1#'%##%#$1#1 2# #( 0 # ##( ( '$##2##7#('# G,H1 11#1' ##$1-- # ###1-.K 12 # # # ' #1' # G,H(21#(%#'.1!(11#1..# ###1+:&2(2'#G,H1
.'#G,H'##'20##$I#%0 '0GH1#0#!##$'##%,K#$@I)#-$2# ' ##$ ## ## # 1 %# # #$#'#1)###$;G_ KK_(_ _(_ ++_HA! ## # 0 # - 1 $ # #$ #'#1)###$!?#### 12 2 #$% @I )# - ( # 1#( 5B A,'% $%#.*K####'##$% %###$?('#G,H$###0#'9##$I####'''$!'10# #111'# #+1'# G,H ###1'#G,H%0#1'#12##$I#%0#34 !1##'%#2###1'#G,H2#$'#+1'#G,H
62
###11#1%#0#0'G>( %#0$H $ $ 1#( # 0 0 1#$ # # # %#$ 1 2# # # # 7#'( # 5#0 G? @-H ' 1# # # . %# 0( 2' # G,H 1 ## # 0 2$ 1# !#1##0'##1'#G,H "#( 2 $5 # ? 1 # %%'%0'#!-###'##!#%# ' G.H GH # 1 '%( 2 ' G+H G.-H#%####3#1#'#'&$##'2#%&%1#(22##'&## # # 0 $ # 1 # & 1 @'0$A# #2# # # #2$1 #2##'# .]21#%# 2##K # ''#$ 0 ## # # 1 # #2'%0$' (#'1'02$## ## # %#$'# G,H(21 ## #11# 1 ' 1' # %#$ 1 2# # $1#%1#'G,H GHG*H G.-H('##02$1#!'%(#&$###2##2
20( # # 1 %# ' 'G.HG+H(#11#1#%#'0#1#$11#1'520(22##1# '( # ' 0 '#'' 1# 7# ' GH #0 1#(# # # # ' G.H ;' G-H G..H # ## %#0 ' '##( ( '0 #2 '$ #&1 2##
12 #'# #'2# #' ''(21 ## # %# ' ''$ G%%$ 1H ' 1#( ## '5# #1#$%#1#K > # 1 ] # #$ # ' # G.- %# 2##H1#1 .](21$%
63
!;#1!+1'#G,H
<%#0#'
12##
G.H
G,H
GH
G-H
GH
GKH
GH
G+H
G*H
G.H
G..H
!!b#*
*
-
-
,
,
+
G,.HZZG,,.HZZG,.+HZZG,.HZZ
G,,HZZ
G,.HZZ
G,..HZZ
G,.HZZG,.HZZ
:
*
-
-
-
.-
.-
.-
-
.
,
G.+HZ
G.*HZ
G.+-HZ
G.+HZ
G*H
G+H
G*H
G+H
G.+KHZ
G.H
G.*H
W
,-
..
G.KKHZ
G+H
W%
.
.
,
,
G-H
G,H
GH
G.H
G.H
G,H
GH
G..H
G,H
W
,+
,
,+
,
,.
,.
,
,
*
G.,,H
G..H
G.,H
G.,.H
G..+H
G..KH
G.,H
G..*H
G-,H
:<#
K,
.
.
K,
G.,H
G.*-HZ
GH
G.H
G.H
G,H
G.*,HZ
!
K
-
-+
-+
-+
K
G.*+HZZGKHZZZ
GHZZZ
GHZZZ
GHZZZ
G.*HZ
9
,
.
,
G.KH
G*H
G.,+H
;09
.*
.
G+,H
GK-H
7
..-
..
..K
G.K-H
G,+HZZZ
G,+HZZZ
G,*HZZZ
7<0
--
--
--
G,,+HZZ
G,,+HZZ
G,-HZZ
0#
,*-
,*-
,*-
,*-
.+*.
.+*.
.+*.
.+*.
,*-
,*
,*
?
.
.
.
.
,
,
,
,
,
-
-
!'''X(%c;d,
KK
K
,
K*+K
.
K-+
.*
K.
K+K.
-+
!'''
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
J
J
"##'#'###5###%#(Z1##.]LZZ1##]LZZZ1##.]
64
!-#'##
"##'#'#;#7 11#:#G;'(.*+H#015 ###%#(Z1##.]LZZ1##]L
ZZZ1##.]
<%#0#'
12##
%# %
%# %
G.H
G,H
GH
G-H
GH
GKH
GH
G+H
G*H
G.H
G..H
G.,H
G.H
G.-H
!
KK
K
.
--
,
K
.
-+
-
,*
,+
,
GHZZZ
GK+HZZZ
G,HZZZ
G-KHZZZ
G-HZZZ
G.HZZZ
G,+HZZZ
G,-HZZZ
G.,HZZZ
G-+HZZZ
G*HZZZ
G,-HZZ
G,HZZ
G.-H
'1'
+.,
,
,.
.
K.
K-
K
.K-
*+,
*KK
*-.
*K
*,,
*,
G,+HZZZ
G,KKHZZZ
G,,HZZ
G,-HZZ
G,,HZZ
G,,-HZZ
G,,,HZZ
G-+HZZZ
G,,HZZZ
G.HZZZ
GHZZZ
GHZZZ
G,*HZZZ
G,+*HZZZ
'
.+-
K+
++
.*
-
G,H
G,+HZZ
GHZZZ
G.H
G..H
G,HZZ
'#
,
+
--
K
K
K
-,
-*
K
+
+.
*,
G,HZZ
G.*HZZZ
GKHZZZ
G-HZZZ
G--*HZZZ
G-KHZZZ
G*HZZZ
GKHZZZ
G-.HZZZ
G,-HZZZ
G..HZZZ
G-HZZZ
<'$
,,
K
-
.
G,-KHZZ
G+-H
G.,H
GKHZZZ
G.H
G,.HZZ
#0'
..+
.-
*K
..*
GHZZZ
G*HZZZ
G,K,HZZZ
GKHZZZ
"#0'
,
,
-K
.-
GKH
G+-H
G**H
GKH
#X ,
,*,
.
GH
G-.H
#X .
-,
-++
GKH
GH
#X.
,,.
,
GHZZZ
G,*HZZZ
#X,
-.+
-+*
GKH
G*H
#X
.,
..
G,++HZZZ
G,-HZZ
0#
.,
.,+
.,
.,
.,*
.,*
.,.,
.*
.K.
.*
.*
.+
.+
.-
;#
-K
-K
-K
-K
-K
-K
-K
-K
-K
-K
-K
-K
-K
-K
?
+
*
*
.
..
.,
.,
*
..
..
.,
.
.-
.
'##(%c;,
,
*
.
,
.--
.
.
65
!'#11#1'$1#(2 'GH
GH G.,H G.-H '$ 0 %#$ 0 #11# 2$#0( (2##'&$#$(2'GHG.,H#11#1#$11#1'512%#0#0'G'GKHG.HH( #'$0' 1#(# #%#0 ''1#2##011#'GHG.-H2 # # ' 10 #( # #$ I0#1#X(#%####$0%1#$1#X,###10%###$0%1#$1#X.(##'%###$2##1#'#$%(21=. ##'%###$01=,#'%# ##$ 2#%01( # #####11#101#%#0'#0 1# G%#1#X ,(2 %$ 1# ## # $ 12 0# 1 # 0H 1 %# % (#'$0'1#2G'.-H)#0###G'0#2H''$#&##'2##2
"$-!& # #1 #2 00#1'!#%#!(22#1#1 '% G' G.H G+HH 1 # '% 2 % ####3#1#'G'G*H G.KHH
7#( 2 % # ' 0 $ #2 ##0# # 2& 1 52& # G,H IG,H 9 1 ' 1 # # # ## '2#1''$##$00#1'%(#' 0 # 1#( # 1 2 11###2%#0#0' 12#%# %(1#'0'G'$H1#! # # ## # #% #2 # %#$ ## 2###1%#'##!1%####1'#G,H
66
7$( 2 0 # 0 # # ' !0$'#G,H'GHG.H2 ''$115#(2 ' G+H G.KH2%# #' 1 # >1##$( # 1 # #0 # '%5 # ## # #'1#0#15#'11###1#' 1' 0( 2 ' 1# # 1 '%!#0$#1###'1#%1'# '%( 2 ' 1' 3# 1 2## J#( # '% 2## %( ' 1''1#215##'
920##%###1#%#0'###1%####2###1#%#G12&G,HL#'GKHG.-HH(#1G0H2G'GHG.HH(2##'##' '1'(##1#'( G'0#2H''$1#$11##&12##
1#(#1###%1'#'%121# ' 1' 3# 1 # ## 1 # #( <'&( !(!2>
67
!)#0#$$G'%%#%H
<%#0#'12##
I 52& 0#0
G.H G,H GH G-H GH GKH GH G+H
! -K -K -+ -+ ,- , ,+
G-+HZZZ G-HZZZ G-HZZZ G-K+HZZZ G.+HZ G.*HZ G,,*HZZ G.H
'1' K K+- , ,- K, K K, .+
G,HZZ G,*HZZ G.*HZ G.KHZ G.KH G.*HZZ G.*HZ G,H
'# - - . . + ++
GHZZZ G,HZZZ G,KHZZZ G,K.HZZZ GKHZZZ G-*HZZZ G-+,HZZZ G+HZZZ
<'$ .. +.- K, *K , .* .* K
G+.HZZZ G,-HZZ G,.+HZZ G.,H G++H GKH GKKH G.-KH
' + ..
G.H G..H
#0' ,* , ,+- ,.-* ,, ,.
GKH GH G-K+HZZZ G-K.HZZZ G-.HZZZ G+HZZZ
"#0' - . + - ,.
G*.H G.+H G.,-H G..*H G.KH G.H
!'1# .K.
GH
;02 .-+
G,,+HZZ
12 ,
G+*H
:# -+
G,H
!Z:#
G-H
75# KK*
G.KH
0# .,. .,. .,+ .,+ .. .*K .*K -
;# - - - - -, -K -K
? . . + + . . . +
"##'#'#;#7 11#:#G;'(.*+H#015 ###%#(Z1##.]LZZ1##]LZZZ1##.]
68
!"#
$ %& %% %' % %( % %) *&&+ *&&+ *&&(& *&&(& *&&& *&&%' *&&%) &&, ('--- (&--- ((--- ((--- &( &+) %%' '(--. &++ &$& &,'' &)$ &,$( %%' %&$, &&% '+--- '$--- ''-- '%,-- '&$-- &)--- &'--- %&$/ *&&' *&&' *&&(+ *&&(+ *&%&$ *&%&' *&%&( *&%&% (%,--- (%,--- )--- )'--- ),--- )+--- ,'--- %,---0 *%')) *&) *&+) *&$' *&&), *&&)' *&&$ *&%'+ +(--- %(+ ','--- &$' %,$- %,+- %,- %$$--/ &'%( &+' &)$ %$%- ! *&$% &&&$ *''(( *%$$' *%$++ *%$%' %%' &&' ('--- (&)--- (&+--- %%---1 &,() %&( *&(% *&($% *&(() &+& %+&- '(,-- &, %% %& &$( &&+ &)'2 %%') %, . *&$ %(( 3 %'%' &$% -3 *%&+( %% 4 " &'(( &(& 5 %&$ %&$ %&' %&' +, $(& $(& ()2 $ $ $ $ , (& (& '!/*6 &% &% &%% &%% &%) &%, &%) &%&1 2 4 . 3 2 7 %$+& 8 "* 7- %&9:-- 9:--- %9
69
"*< # # 1# 11 2#( '% 2# #'# # '%# 1 ##$ 0##$ 2##(%$0%#!# #$%2#'#2##1'#%0$##'' %' 1#3#1$# ## #2 0 # #1? # 2# # 0 # 2 % # ? & ! % &$ # #1$ 1'# %0 $ # 0%'# 1 00 #' 1(1 #( # 2# # #1#10$22# # # 11# #$%( #%02#1'#0
! %% # $ ' # G,H ' '%' # # 1'# %0 $ # #' ' !# 1 # %# 2# %1' '#1 %# '2# ## #!$#1$'#+%#.*(1##%# '###$1#%#12##
%#2&$'#G,H(2'&0##7#(2##%#'0$'#G,H)(2'%0%#1#$'###1$2###1#$'##'!(2 ##1#$111#####'#111##%%$;'G.*+H#1G%H%#7#(2#$1G##1H'(#'#1#'%##7$(20####1###0'#
'111##$1'#1'#G,H7#(22###%#'0#&##1#1%#'# ##$I#$(21##'#11##%#$ ## 2# #60(2 1 '0 ## ' 5# # %#$ 1 2## 9 2 # %% '%0'# 1 #'( 2 1 # 0 ## ' 2# # %$ ' 1'9 1 ##2# # &$#%%#%#'= #'$#$ = %( 2 G '0 #2H ' '$
70
# # #$ I # # # & ## 2##2
71
72
73
!$
%&'#()"8$ '$ ;D 2$ @9 7A G;( ,H # ## ## 5# '#5# 20 #0'1#0%2*9#&2#% #5 G 4( ,L&95( ,H( # ' # 0 $ %%#$ # 0-! '1 #%##'#;#'%$
!;##0###'$0%# ' #'#$ ' 0#0 # '3#$ '% # ; )# # ( #:9#1( #19#:#' #'#0$ 1#1' #'&#( ; %#$#' '&# '# '# G6<6H 6<6 #$%$ # %# 1 # '$ ## 5 '&# 10 #'%%#$#(2?###'#'#'3#$2('###(##$% 0#'#$11 &%# G4(,H;D''####'#0#&##6<6(#'&##'$
+!%#5' G,H*);G.**(.**+(,H-&95G,H%%#####@;#A#@%#D'AG& 95( ,( % H # #$ $52# ## # '$11#'2#9#'2#G#1H5#'$11##00('$;
74
;D ' %#$ 0# 0 # #'#5# 5# # 1 # # #2 "01 '$ # # #' % 2# 1'###'#%#G'(,KH7#'(# 5# 20 # % # # 2#& # 2D 1# 5# 1' # .+* # # .*,G2 6#( .***H 9 # 0 # ## #'$ 5# # # 1# #2 #GD"#(,H(##%2##1#G)'( ,,H ; G,H ## 2 6<6 %#( #'#1'$5####'#'
9 ' # ; # 1 %1 . # 0 #%.*+- ,'1#%16<6 #&1'# 6# # & %3# G6( ,H( 2 2 '% 2# $###1';G,H9'%$1 11# % #'# #1 # 0# 1 # 02## '% 1'2& #2 2$ # 2$## 11# # ' 2# 5# '$ 11##06<6#
02 #(21 %## # %%#1 ; 11# #1 '%( # '$( 5#( '#1##06<6#(1$#; 3# #( # # # ## #$ #0 6<6 # 20( 1 2 1 ) )1 #( 2 1 # 0 1 ; 11# !1001%1##& !'1#%#512#-,(2 #;## # ####01# #-(2%###'%1'2&#--(2%#1(2 #-2%1'0 #0#$$#&9$1##'##' 1 #$ # -K # 0 1 1#
75
$-;####1#00%#2#6<6 # 1' # 1 '#5# 5#G;(,(%.KHAB ,>,,>, C' C D - > D > > B - > C E > E > -> , -,C ,F---E,A
' ##2#'$ # '% #%#1#;9#3#%#1D,' %%#( #$ #'# # # %#1 #%0# '$ # # = #$ M'$'# # 0$ 0 1 #$D G;( ,( % -H 9 D#$ ' 2# 1 # .*+ .** 0'1 ( # %%# ' 2###10#;%%#$!$2'#''2#%%#$####)#'!'0(2%##$2%%$#'#%#1#'''## ;0&###$D'3###.**+G;(,(%-H!%###;#2D?1#5#2#12$###0'#5#%0$##'&# '#'#$
2$ # 02 # ; # #'%$ 0 1##D G.*K+H $ 2& ## #'# $ # 1#'2#%2%###$# G1# %0H ###2 %;e3# ' %1 ## # %# ## '$ %21 #'#2$#1%#1#'####10 # '%## ## ## #; ## '%$ ##6<6''# #5#L #$ #$%$ 0 $ '#11$G#;H(;#%1###$#15#'$##0
;%#$( #2 '# '$ ' # % #; # ! 1# ## 5# 1 '&# #
76
%#$1045# '# '?#$0## ##$$ G40&(,H1#2 '%$ ?#$ #2 6<6 # # 1 #%%#( # # # #'# # ' 0!#%#$(#$###?#$#26<6 # #1 # %%###0$( # ?# 0## 5# 2# # # # # ## 6<6('%2#'#5%##0 #2$(5#2#&10#%##$2####2##2(##102 1' %## 1 # & #2 5# 0
'#'%#;######1'$#2#6<61#####&10 ! #%#2 '$ 01 '##%%##'14G,H(2'#' # # %%$ 1 # '&#( %# 2# 11#'##'%#111'1###D%%# # # # #-.! %%#( #$ %%$# 1 # # '%## ## '# #2'#$!'1#'&##1#0#2'$0##'!21 #0# #0 # # #% # #0 # # # ## #0 2&(%#$1##1##2##'#$G#(1#(#11H2#1##;D'% # 6<6 # % #0 G#$%$'' 1H # # '$ $ #'3#$1# %%# G2 '%$ #H #$1# 2# #' !$$10##'#101# ##$ = %$ 1 ) ) 1-, )# ##' # 1 # 0#$ ( ( #$ :0 G.**H(;G,.H 2)'G,H7#'(#11#1G H '$ # $ )' G,.H( 2 )' G,,H ( (4# 4# G,.H(4# 4 G,H 2 G,H 0##
-. ! #$ 1 4 G,H # # 1 5# 20(# '% 0 G 4 0&( ,H # #0#%#25# ' ?#$!1( # ##5###01'%##%%$#-,#0021)'G,,H
77
2#5###1#-#'1##% ' ## #2 11# %#$ 0( #$%#$;G,H#'%$'
$"'! ' 2# G# '# 1H '$ 5#11#GH#0(2'%$%#'2##$#'%1111#--!' %111# %#0# ##%1#'$(2#$111### ## %1 # 0 #$ G( # 1# 1#5# # ### 1'2&H ;D #%##'$5#%�%$6<6#(2#2 2$# 2$##11####$%#'%1#
ititititiitit
itiitiitittiit
XGLDEMMDMGLDEM
DEMMDMGLMDMDEMGLy
εβββββββγµα
++++++++++=
765
4321
***
**
2 #%#0'0 #1'## #$ $ [ ## #'(G # # #$1 11#1 #$ ( H # #' %1 11#1 $ 3@ #'#15##$ $ :?1#'1'$1#$$:#''$ 1 '&# '# '#$ ! 0# # # 1#0 # %0 # # #'#1 01##'1##2#'#
;G,(%KH16<6A , C
I A J J
- # # ## ' # '%# 1 ' 0 ; 11G,,H(7:#G,H6#G,-H--!1##$#'%111#0#####' ## 3# # $%# ## # #'# 1 #1 11# ' ?###'#1'11#'7 ## 3# # $%# ###$#'%111#5
78
'%##%#1#1###$#;
G,(%.-H(##$AKLC > ->>
I> A I C>J F - , - C > - , >> B> M > M -J
; G,H 1 # 2# 6<6 - #
2## 6<6 9 # #' %% - 2& 1 #1# %0 $ ; G,H ## # # 2# ## 6<6 1# #$ # 2&##;D'%#####$$#1#1#'#(#1(0$ 1'# ) # '## % 1# # #%#?##0#$1###1';G,H( 2 # $ $ # 1#( # ##0#6##&##G6(,H
!6 %3# %# # ##1 # '# 2## ## ! 1 # %# % ## #0$11 1# 1' $#'# '#$ ##'# 0 f 0 #%#$LO#0$'51%'#1#1 1##'#$###1##$2#$%%## ##'#$%%#1##.%#1###%%#
7' # 2 # 0 II( 2 %%# #' # @' 11 #2 0 '#$ %#0 # # '3#$A- ! 0 II 1' , G0$0#%#1#'#$H#g-G0$0#%#1 #'#$H! ' %#1 '#$ 0 ''0(2%1#%%#$(1 # % ''( # %1 11%#H7%%(2##''$0G6<61?#2###'#$%2##$2#'$0#%#G II9)H(5#2># 1#( # # 2# 6<6 ..+ 2## 6<6 ;#$ 1# # # 6 # #
-)6##&3#&G,H
79
%%-#-.2'%#1##1';G,H2##6<601'#6#!-.;#16<61#;G,H2#6G,H#
;G,H
1'1 +
6G,H -- .
. ,, ,
+ - *+
);G,H(6##&%3#G,H
! #26<6 ' # 2# #2#$ 11 !$ KK#1*+ GK]H --#; G,H 6#6<6(2,,###%16<6-K##.6<6#;G,H###1$#6#;0$(#6##1$##'&# '#(##;G,(%,.H6<6)# 6 # # 0 ' # # # ; #$ #%###1#(2 # '$2!%##1#(2#;G,H# #'%#######%16<611#1' # 1#5#( $ 1 # %#$ ## #2'$ # 01' %%# #11#%G ( <0( #$( F# 95( ,H 021#5#26<6%#(#1 2 ' ' 1 #$ 1 2 '#'$G;(,H;0$( #;#1%
-K######$#2##21##]1 :# ' # :# 'D ' # # # 1#&G#M%'#$DH(###11##$'#$##'#$ #6##2$##211 #5 ## # 6 #( 2 ; G,H 1 # 0$ '%##'$'#
80
6<6(#1#5#'-60(6<6 1 $ ##$ ( 2 1#5# '11###2(!#11# #-, ## #11#2#1#5# #%#1'&# '#'#$-+! -, ;# 11# #2 6<6 1#5#' 6<6 6<6
6G,H ;G,H
#1#5# , .
1#5# ,, .-
:1#5# , -K
" .-* *
);G,H(6##&%3##G,H
' '$ # # 2$ M>(D 01'##$I%3#G6(,,H!01' . G0$ ##H # g. G0$ '#H # '$11#'$#0###G<(,H(2 $ 2# ##0 '$ # # ## ##1#!##0#4#(2#01%##0#G7'(,KH( 0M'$D''!1# #&1'52& # G,H(21'$'###2#%%# ' 1 2 #& 11 ! ''$#IG,H(21'$'''01%#'%###%#%#-* ! %$ 5#( 2 ' $ # F75#G<(,KH(2#1'(
-!1#5#1#;#1%G2#&#H # 1#5# , G+H( 1#5# , G+H( 1#5#--G*H-+ 7#'( # '%## # # ## 6<6 ' 11# 1' #@# 'A0 $ ; G,.H @ # 'A 1 ###2#%#'##%-*6%1$('%#2##.]1###0###%#%#$0#'#]1#0#
81
%#5#92####0'%##$ ! # # 1 &2( # # %01'# G ##$H1 #0!1(2 # ## ;#$ & 4 G;4( ,H '# 1# 1# # # %$ 1 # 0 !0@#1#AG1'#KH%#0#102(###1> (#1 ## # # ## 1 0 #$ !0@# #A1' #., '#1#1# 2# #$ ### # ( ##$( 0
$( @#1#A A @# #A '%#'1#0@#1#A'$2%#'#$0 #1'# #;0$( # #'$###0##%#1##201'##((#2#0##0' #1#(#####11'%1#!%$#02#1#%#1@##A@#1#A%# 0. 9 # ' '## 1 # 2,( # $##%$1 #1# # ## # ##@#1#A@##A
# ;4 #( 0 # 2 0 1 # 1# ##(%#0$$(2'#%0$ .##0'%$011#GO##H.)%1$(2'#%$@# #A G1' K #H2#@#1#AG1' .,#H#2# .##M#0DG1' ,#L%%-;H( G#0H01@#0A #'#0,7#(1##'###$#1#(#0 @# 0A ##'# # # # ? ( # #%#2# ' #"#( 20( ## ###%#0G#-H
82
7 -. #% G##%#H #2 # 1# ##(.*+- ,
) ##;#$&4 G,H<%# #0 #1#0##!%#.*+- ,
##;4#%%#( # 0## ##$'#7'%(#$2#6<6G$# #$ ##H'# 0 > ## 0 # # '# # %# ! # 1%##(2111##1#2#0#1##7#'(#%###$'#1 $ #$D %# 0 % ! ' #%#$(#$#11###2#%###$'##%##0!1(2## 1# 0 0 3#0 0 # G##2###1#5#1#(,H'%#2#'##1#%#$0
!%#$0#1002''$ G4# # ,, %#H( '' # #%1 '''1#''''1#G4##,,%#H( #'121##&#$(%#0#(%##
AGO
ALB ARE
ARG
ARM
AUS AUT
AZE
BEL
BFA BGD
BGR
BHR BLR
BOL
BRA
BWACAN
CHE
CHL
CHN
CIV
CMR
COG
COL
CRI CUB CYP
CZE DEU DNK
DOM
DZA
ECU
EGY ESP
EST
ETH
FIN
FRA GAB
GBR
GHA
GIN
GMB
GNB
GRC
GTM
GUY
HND
HRV
HTI
HUN
IDN IND
IRL
IRN
IRQ
ISR
ITA
JAM JOR
JPN
KAZ
KEN
KOR
KWT
LBN LBR
LBY
LKA
LTU LVA
MAR MDA
MDG MEX MLI
MMR
MNG
MOZ
MWI
MYS NAM
NER NGA
NIC
NLD NOR NZL
OMN
PAK
PAN
PER
PHL
PNG
POL
PRKPRT
PRY QAT
ROM RUS
SAU
SDN
SEN
SGP
SLE SLV
SOM
SVK SVN SWE
SYR
TGO
THA TTO TUN
TUR
TZA
UGA
UKR URY
USA
VEN
YEM
ZAF
ZAR
ZMB
ZWE
-12
-10
-8
-6
-4
-2
average internal conflicts
-6 -4 -2 0 average ethnic tensions
83
! ?01#'+(2%%##02### %#$ 0 # ## ' # #'#1#07$(#'%####11#0#%###2##(#111##'###& ##0####2#9'%1$####0%$##'0#1-,(22#0%'#1#%$0#'1##%%-;%0%#0###1#7-, #00#'##
"# # 1 2 # 0%'#0 #'1 # # 0 %$1 ##!##%#1###1#G#01';4(,H
%D## #$ G&,H #'1$####& #$G6!(,-H
+
K
-
,
0
.*+ .** .** , ,$
5
"# 8'2
) 6$
#
1#
84
$$ #'# # 2 # - ' . 2?#$'# 2$( #2 2$# 2$ ##11#16<6( '$ 5# #0 #6#6<60'- K212#'%(##1#1;G,H !##1#16 ##2##;# G,H 0$ ' #1# G1#H %1##11##01'$ 1#(#0 %1# , G KH $ 1#( 2# # %# 15# ' GH GH- ! '% ## # 11# 15#'$ ##11#%# # # 20( # - # $# 2 # 0# #'%#1#;#L##'#11#G##H ## $ ' 0 # 0## # # ## 0( $ # %%%#'11#G'(;&4(,KH12(21# # 1 %## '## 0 $ 11##0 ## 0 # ###! # 2#--
-9 # ' @# #A@#1#A %#0 ! #1 # ( 2 0 ?#( 2$####2%##-K-#12$####'1#$
85
!- #'##'
<%#0#0
G.H
G,H
GH
G-H
GH
GKH
6<60
6
6
6
;
;
;
4:
..-
+*
.-.
..++,
,+,K
-K
GK-HZZZ
G,.+HZZ
GKH
GHZZZ
G.-.H
G,.HZZ
< 6
,.
.-
.-K
.
,-+
+K
G,+H
G.HZZZ
G*HZZZ
G.-.H
G,HZZZ
G.*HZZZ
6<6Z4:
.,
,++
-..
-K
GKKHZZZ
GHZZZ
G,HZZZ
G,.+HZZ
< 6Z4:
K*
*K,
+
.,.
GK,HZZZ
G-*HZZZ
G+HZZZ
G..HZZZ
6<6Z< 6
.,+,
,+
.*
K*,
G*KHZZZ
G*-*HZZZ
G.HZZZ
G*.HZZZ
6<6Z< 6Z4:
..K-
.-..
G*-HZZZ
GK+KHZZZ
0#
.**.
.**.
.**.
.K
.K
.K
;#
.
.
.
+
+
+
?
+
K
7 ###$111#(%c7
7 ###'111#(%c7
'$###%c7
-
.-
+
*
## ###%####$#'%111#G#2HZ1##.]LZZ
1##]LZZZ1##.]4:#5#0< 61##'$'6<6#'&# '#
'#$''$
86
'. -20'0#'((4<%%#(4<2#(#'%$'##1#G0 #& 1' # 9 & <0%'# #( ,H;1'11###(21##2'(2'2# '%$'# 1#$ # #'# 0 #( ' '%##$( # 1 1 #0 1 ## ' 2 ' 12?#$1'#>0#$1!?#$3#G>!(,KH(# # '%# 1# "#( 2 ' 1 %#G;4( ,H #' %$12&0 #21#2#0#1##(21## #0$1#7$(2'2##011#$#1#!(212#%%1;G.**H(2 ## 1 %# ##$ ! G2#H 0 1 # ##$ 0 #$ D # (2# # 1#$ $ #1 # #0 0 # #! # 2 ' # ## # 0 #$ # # '# # 0 ' + 2 1# # 0 # # ' >'%$'# '2#21#
87
!-- #'##2###0
<%#0#0
G.H
G,H
GH
G-H
GH
GKH
GH
G+H
G*H
G.H
6<60
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
;
4:
-.+
**K
.K
...
*-
*.,
.
,**
,*K
*
G,.*HZZ
G-H
G-KH
GKH
G,KHZZ
G-H
G+KH
G+*H
G..H
GH
< 6
.*.
.-
,,-.
.K
,K
.,,
.-.
.K,
.+
,K.-
G+KHZZZ
G+,HZZZ
G+HZZZ
G+KHZZZ
G+,-HZZZ
G,HZZZ
GKHZZZ
G*HZZZ
GK*HZZZ
GKKHZZZ
6<6Z4:
-+
K++,
.*+,
K**
.K+,*
*-
K+*
.,K+
KK*
,+-
G+HZZZ
GHZZZ
G--+HZZZ
G-HZZZ
GK.HZZZ
GHZZZ
G-+HZZZ
G+HZZZ
G,.HZZZ
G.H
6<6Z< 6
,.
,+K-
.+K.
,+*
-
.
,..
,.-K
,,K*
,
G+*HZZZ
G*-HZZZ
G,KHZZ
G*-HZZZ
GK-HZZZ
G*+-HZZZ
GKHZZZ
G,K,HZZZ
GK+-HZZZ
G+HZZZ
< 6Z4:
.-*
.,,
.*,
.,,
.*+
..,
K
*K
*,
..*
G+HZZZ
G*HZZZ
G,.HZZZ
G*KHZZZ
G,HZZZ
G-+HZZZ
G++HZZZ
G.HZZZ
GK-HZZZ
G.HZZZ
6<6Z< 6Z4:
.
.,.-
KK
.,+
,.
.
+.
+,-
+
+-
G,HZZZ
GK.+HZZZ
G.-H
GK,*HZZZ
G-*HZZZ
GK.HZZZ
G+HZZZ
G.HZ
G+,HZZZ
GHZZZ
G4<%%#H
.K.-
..
.++
.K-*
G+++HZZZ
GHZZZ
GKHZZZ
GK*HZZZ
4<2#
.K
G.HZ
G+H
>'%$'#
-K-
.-
G++HZZZ
G.,,H
1#
G.,*H
9?#$
--.
G,*H
;%#
.-.
..*
.K-
.K.*
G++HZZZ
G+.HZZZ
G++HZZZ
G,+HZZZ
#0
,K*
.+,
,K*
,-+
G+HZZZ
G--*HZZZ
G+++HZZZ
GK*HZZZ
0#
.*
.*,
..
.*
.,K
.*K
.**.
..K
.*,,
..
;#
.K
.
*-
.
*
.
.
*-
.K
*
?
-
+
+
-
-.
-
-.
-
-
7 ##1#$11#(%c7
7 ##1#'11#(%c7
'$###(%c7
K.
.-
-
,
.
.
,-
+,
,*
## ###%####$#'%111#G#2H4:#5#0< 61
##'$'6<6#'&# '#'#$''$Z1##.]LZZ1##]LZZZ1##.]
88
!1( 2 #' ' *( 2 %1%1# 9 %# # % # 6<6 1# 1;G,H!#'2##1'%1#*(#22# #; G,H6<60 # GH ## # ##0##16<60 !#%##(2%##'11#G#*]1#0H1'$5#16<6# 6<6#1---(%#0$K7 - 6 11# # 0 1 '$ 6<6#
-0.2
-0.2
-0.1
-0.1
0.0
0.1
0.1
0.2
0.2
0.3
0.3
0.38 1.00 2.00 3.00 3.08 4.00 5.00 5.42
globalization
mar
gina
l eff
ect
lower bound marginal effect democracy upper bound "#!%##'###1'*#--!2%%0#*]1#0
90#%1'#% 22%%##1#0#$1#0'!#'##%1#*K!1##1'*(#--
89
7 - 6 11# # 0 1 5# 6<6#
-1.2
-1.0
-0.8
-0.6
-0.4
-0.2
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
-10 -9 -8 -7 -6 -5 -4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
democracy
mar
gina
l eff
ect
lower bound marginal effect globalization upper bound "#!%##'###1'*#--!2%%0#*]1#07 - - 2 ## 6<6 #( '$ 5# # 1#$ # # # 0 ! 11# 1#0#%#1----#'%#%#(#21 6<6#1-- 2(221 ## 11##25#'$)%1$( '$ # 0 #$ #0$ 0 1 5# ( 2 1 $ 11# 15# # 0 = $ 1 0$ ## #5# 3# 1# # 1 # #( 2 1 %%#1#;#
90
7--611##01'$ 6<6#
-0.1
-0.1
0.0
0.1
0.1
0.2
0.2
0.38 1 2 3 4 5 5.42
globalization
mar
gina
l eff
ect
lower bound marginal effect democracy upper bound "#!%##'###1'*#--!2%%0#*]1#0
7 -- 6 11# # 0 1 5# 6<6#
-1.0
-0.8
-0.6
-0.4
-0.2
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
-10 -9 -8 -7 -6 -5 -4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
democracy
mar
gina
l eff
ect
lower bound marginal effect globalization upper bound "#!%##'###1'*#--!2%%0#*]1#0
91
$*-9 3# $ # ' 1 # # %1# & 7#( 2 % '$ 5#$'1##0'!#(2####%#$,2##'1IG,H(52&#G,H#7' G,KH 2 % # 5# $ ## ' G'( %# 5#H 15# 1< G,KH " 1 # 11# #)$(2##0%%#'#09#0##%#1#$'1 0 # 2 # 0 ;4 '+ !# #2 %1 # 1# #11#* !#$( # %###111'###(('1#$0#GJ0H%%1'# '% 0 ' #$ ' ' # G)0H 1 2 1 '% 1 # 1 2 2 0 ### # # #' % G+* #( "X.+H( 2 1 ######0# 9 1# ' # # 1 # ##0#'# #? 7#( 2 '%$ % # ### ##1%#'%$ ## "#(2#'##'11###'#9## # 1 )## *,( 2 ##0$ # ?G!&$ 2#1#H7#'(2 #:#!'' )? #'# $ 2 G.*+H 9 ## ##0$#'%###
9 #'# # ' 1 11# '% # %'%##$7#(21 '%22 ;< #( # # 0 '# 2$ #' G%#1'6H # 0 6<6'1
% # %0 #( # #'# # $ #%####0#!1(2%###%##2##'##7#'(2$2#'11#%#2###0#'## ##$ 11# 1' # # 1 1 - - # 0?#+ # ;4 '#( 2 # ' 0 # '# #-)1##.*9#$G$H#02''$%#0##20$'#'#
92
# # # 11# # "#( 2 1 $ ) ) 1 # # ## '# 1# # 2##%#21--K(##1) )1
7-611##01'$) )16<6#
-1.0
0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
4.0
5.0
6.0
7.0
8.0
0.38 1.00 2.00 2.52 3.00 4.00 5.00 5.42
globalization
mar
gina
l effe
ct
lower bound marginal effect democracy upper bound
"#!%##'###1'%1#*#--=1 '%1$ ) )1 #!2 %%0 #*]1#0
93
7 - 6 11# # 0 1 5# ) )16<6#
-25.0
-20.0
-15.0
-10.0
-5.0
0.0
5.0
10.0
15.0
-10 -9 -8 -7 -6 -5 -4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
democracy
mar
gina
l eff
ect
lower bound marginal effect globalization upper bound "#!%##'###1'%1#*#--=1 '%1$ ) )1 #!2 %%0 #*]1#0
7-2##'$#06<6##11#1015##(5##0 ###(##11#'%#0G#1#H101'$91#%%# 11#1 '$ 6<6 # G1 -KH( ('$#0 ##=%$1015#7$(1-K2## 6<6#(5# 1#$ # 0( '# #$ # 201'$!#1) )1%%##;##'1$#K91##25###'# 0( 0 1 '$ 2& 5#D 0#'%#! 2## G,.H21 ## '2#201'$'#%#1#
K> # ' # & # #( # #1 #) ) '%####
94
7-K611##01'$) )1 6<6#
-10.0
-8.0
-6.0
-4.0
-2.0
0.0
2.0
4.0
0.38 1.00 2.00 2.47 3.00 4.00 5.00 5.42
globalization
mar
gina
l eff
ect
lower bound marginal effect democracy upper bound "#!%##'###1'%1#*#--=1 '%1$ ) )1 #!2 %%0 #*]1#0
7 -K 6 11# # 0 1 5# ) )1 6<6#
-10.0
0.0
10.0
20.0
30.0
40.0
50.0
-10 -9 -8 -7 -6 -5 -4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
democracy
mar
gina
l eff
ect
lower bound marginal effect globalization upper bound "#!%##'###1'%1#*#--=1 '%1$ ) )1 #!2 %%0 #*]1#0
95
$,9$0'$0%#2##&10#0N ; G,H # # # # 15 '&# '$ # 2 '# '#$ '$ '# # '3#$ #%#2'%$'#;#
! %# ## # # ## #22$ 7#( #;#(0##'&# '#'#911# # #1$ # '# 1 ## # ##112#0#'1#1#5# ## ## 2 1 # ## 1 #11('$5#!#####(2'$1##'%#1#0
#1 '% $2 ## # 0122;11#(' ;G,H20(221#(2#$'#1'1##0( 2 1 # 0 ) ) 1( '$%&# 1# #11# # # ' 5 '%##$( 2 1 ## '$ #1#2'&# '#'###%%##'&#'# '# # '# % 1 # '#11#1'$%5#) )1#$#% 1 # %# #$ # $#'#$ 0## 2 # 11#1'# #1 #2 #% # 11##2 ## 0 # 2 '# 1 1#%1 # ) ) 1( 2 '( 0 11#5#( 2& 0'# # G; 11,,(,-L7:#,H90#0##11# # 1 ## # '# 1 '$ 5# #$ # 0 # '&# '#'#!###;2#1#2 @ %# '$ 1 '&#A @ ##A G # ## 1 ; G,H ##H( # '&# '#'##11#($#1##!#1##0###&5#('$0(2##0&#%#1'&# '#'#$
96
%%-;#2#2##6<6#;G,H1'1 1'1 1'1
!# > : #&7 : # ) #0 9# '5 9# #2;#h0 : ;;' 'C&C )2#5;' _1_ ;;# 9# ; 9# 4'$ #% # <'&73 4 : $%#4 :() )%4'(! : 74 : 74#' 9# >#F'$ 2 4 ; ? )(# F$ 9#((F&$ ;' ; #$: ; : ;# %: : F(%1:# 2 F2#6 9# :$6 : ):&6$'G'H ; 66$ ; "#"' 9# "2$" : "28" (: '&# 63 #' 2 Q# 9# )%% ; ) 2 )%$ 9# )2 2 !2 !# !&$
97
%%-# 1'1 1'1 1'1
) : >$): : >#)##)$ 2$# J'! :( 2 ! ; !5 (; > ( I5 9# )#1 9# 8' 8'2 9# );G,H
98
%%-;#2#2##6<6#6G,H
1'1 1'1
53 '( !# ;' '&;(%1 : # 73 #4 &5(5(4 24 )4$ # ;? F()F5&# F$ F3F$$5# : 6#;#()6 66 66$ ;"' %(#" <3' " &# 63 0(F'$&2 !#! 2(F! ;!3&# !&'# > &(>& (;'>5&# )#1 (;( %(8;(<'% :(#("(!#8'2 %
99
%%-#1'1 1'1 1'1
1# #% 6# 7 62 7 "> 4 "## >#F' "2$' 4'(! "%# 4 "28# 4 '' 4#' ' &7 ;# %% a# %"24 $ F"# #0 $5 Q## #$ '#2 ' );#1% ); % ))2#5 ;' )%; F(%1 ):; F2# )0;#h0 : )';' : )0&;' :$ )0;# ):& )2; :# )25;$% :# )$;5% :#0 ;4'$ 6 !^!<3# 60 !<'& 6 !&$<'% 6 !5 6$'G'H >$ $%# 6 >#)## # 65'? I5)% 6# J')6##&3#G,H
100
%%-;<%#0)###
5 6 ) 7
N
#0 ,+ K ,-+ ,
## ,+ ++ .- K
#1# ,+ +- ,+ .,
!0# -+ - .-. K
<$#0# -+ ..+ K ,.K
421 -+ ,. +. -
#0# -+ ,. - *
;02 -*+ ,, .
)'''1# -*+ ,. .
C
6<6G6(,H -,K ,, -. .
6<6G;(,H ,+* - .
3-E
F75#G##H . .+ + + -,
'5# -* . ... K- K.
#5# . .K .- ,
)5# . +- ++ . K,
:
%#$, -K , K . .
%#$''$ - -K .
52&$# -,- + -* .
I -. - .
7' -K* -. ,. .
,-
4<%%# -,+- . - .++
4<2# -, .K K+ -* +*+
1# -, K.KK K.K ,*. ,KK,,
9?#$ ,- K K .
>'%$'# .- +* K+ -
;%# ,+- K-, ,K, ., .
101
!*
+,* !'%##'$2$##''#%$'(0##0#1#'#1 ## ##& # (1 #(2$ '# ####$1#####&##'G ()(.**,H(#0#'#G&'((%(,-H(20G7(,H2011#1#G7$(:)##5(,-HK, ! 1#'# 1 # ## ##& # ###'%#11#!##2#####1# ###&)%#'..(,. G*O..H( # %'#1##%1# #6 #'6..(,- GO..H## #### #''%' #%#'$#0 I#'#%#?1#'7'%( 7$ : G,H # ;# G,H' # ## ###2 ## %#(2)?)G,H0#1####$7#'(0#1###%1#''$ # #%1 G;( ,-L F ,KH!# # ## ## ##& # ##Y%%#1#?#$1#'#0'## '%'#%20(#%1'$11##%#1
K.!%#4( 6G,H4( 6G,+HK,70021'%'###1#'(7$(:)##5G,H
102
###1##%#(2'##&2##''$%%2$'0'#'11## ! 0' ##%02$ #'$#%#2#'###$20(#'# ## %%# # ( :% )#P'G.**H ## # 0# G #'H 11# % %#$ 1# # %2 ##1 %# %#( 2'$#$###(#2$0### ## ## # @$ # 1A 2 # #$ ##&G6(.*H # %#(21# ' # '%#1#'##%1'#,(-# 0.# # % .*K+ ,, ' 1 # # #& 1'<#&##G,H(22##11### # 1 1'# %0 $ # 6! !' F2 G6!(,-H $2 #& ## #%#$ ### 0$ ## ##& # ( #1( # #211##$%1#'11###%#1'$5####11###2#'##(2 1 # #0 '# 1 #' '% # #%# 1 # # 7#'( ' # ### #''$ 0 11# 11#1 11# #$% G(& ' # ( ,-L !0( ,-H( 2 ' # % 1'% ##$ 7$( 2 ' 2# # %#$ 1 #%'#1###%1#'#2###' '1 ## #''#1# '%# # %#$ 1 # 1 !# ( #' # ## #(21 ## # '%#1 #' % ##$%1 #' # 0#$1 # ##& %#(21 ######0'#%##0##&0 '%# # # #$% 1 # # # # ## # '%# 1# # # # # '%# 1 ' 0 ' 2#( # ' # # '%# 1 02 0'#9101'%##$!' # %#$ 10'# 1 %$ # 2#01#'7$(21 ###$####%1#'(####%#$1#%'#1## #%1#'# #1#'
103
!'1#%#512#,(2#####1'220'$%##(2##'%'9%##'###-2##'%#1#'0#$2'%##$# # #( 2 1 # & 1 # 1##)#K#%#
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
K)2(74G.*+-H
104
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
K- # # :% )#P'' 1 # '# %#$ $#' 2# %# ##(2###%#$#2 %#$$#'#1'%##! '%# # 1' #2 # 11# 2 ## %# 2# #%#$>%:% )#P'#0##%21#11#%2##%#$!'##$2# #%#$( %#$ &$ #0 ##O % # '' # # ' 1 # ## % 2%2 1###0#(1#%%1#%# (2##11###2#2 %#$'# %#$$#'
105
# # # #'( # ## $ #02'1#%%0!#(0##(# # # '%#$( 0 # # #' #0# 1 #0'# 20( #$ 0 # ' 1 # 0# ##'#5 # '1 # 0# 0 # ##'#1%#$#0'##%###'%#1#0'#(#'#1#'%0##'%#1#'#1###0###01# ##0'# #G#0 ##%# 0 1 # 11# 0'#H( # '#0'#'&$##1'11 '###2##'11###1#%#0$#0$!1(2 # #'%$#12?#
*"'!'2##'%2$'0'#'11##(2'%$$#'#G!);)H#1' #.#0 #%.*K+ ,, '%## # ' 1 # # # #& # 1 #'%%!1(2%###1&#G.**+H#111## G;7 :H' G;'(.*+HK&#G.**+H2##%####%#####1#$1''$0##''&#'1$#%010#G#H2&1####G#1H11'###'1''$0#(&#G.**+H%#''$02#'#1#%7 ##:&###3## $%#####%%'#5##%#01'%1#KK
K1;7 :''##G'(.*+H9## # $%####$111#?#5$'%##'#1;7 :' ## G%H#'! $%#1 #$%111#3#1'%1#(;7 :%1KK #( 2 0 #'## #' ; %%#5'2# #'0$ 0# # # 0$ ' # # #%####(2#'G#0%?#H7#?01#'#'#1&#(&#
106
'12
)( 011
)|()|1(ttiti Xititit e
XthXcP−++−+
=== κβα
2$0?#.1##1#$%0$1##1#$$'11[#$%111####1##%1##$( 0#1%#$0 #'i# ###%%'# %#0#&1'<#&##G,H!%0##'1#%$1 %'# 1 ' # %# 1 '# O #%'#1#%''#G%%H##'# $ #$$0#(2'#% # %$$'##1#$$#K7.2###1##'111####(#,-K#'%12$,%##'#$!0#1#.*$G#2H(2###0'% #0'#1#(2 ' 111,$G.*. .**+H
G.**+H7#'(F1G.*++H7#'###1##(;'G,,HK 02( # $1'# 1 #'# $%#1#'##%$G,+#1-.*0#H
107
7.<##1##
"# !1 2 # ##1 # #' 11 G' $H 1 ###'%G-.*0#H
9 ## 11# #' # # 1 1'#' $ # 6! !' F2 G6!( ,-HK+ !%0## ##' ####& 2###&O##11##$ 10#0#%.*K+ ,,#0$%###&# 11# '%# % % # 0# *O..( 2## 11# # ## # #2 11# #$% ##1#''##'1#0#%#$%$K*
K+ 0 # ##%OO222#&O ! !' F2 1 # hh0( # ##10(# ###'%11'YY! # # 01'## #12!'#01#%#2###'0$#2$##2 0 ''' %#$( '$ $ ##& 0 60( ## # '#$ # ##' # ''#%$' #'##11#'#K*! ## # # #$1'$0 # ##$F' # 41 # # 0 # 2 #$ #$ #
0
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500 nu
mbe
r of c
abin
et fa
ilure
s
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27
10
8
!.;#'#1##'#
GH
GH
GH
GIH
GIH
GIH
GIH
GH
####&
.
GH)##&
,-
.
GH
#
,
.
GIH
##&2###.3$
+-
-
,*
.
GIH
)'11##
K
*
,
+.
.
GIH7##%0#
,
.,
,
+K
.
GIH
!''$
+
.,
,
K
.
-
."#!#'##1'#6!!'F20###%OO222#&!'1
0#-++0##'
109
!##0 # #'1#0#2####$%3(#'1##&(#'1%# #( # ' 1 #( # 0 ' 1# % ## ##&( ''$ 0 # #% 1 #' ! . 2 # # #2 ######'#%#0$#20( # # # # ! & # # 1'% 1 2 # ##0 #' # #'%$ 7 , 2 # 0# 0 #' 1 # 11# ##1##'%#2%2#1#0##.*.*+(12$#$#.**(( 1',.27#'( # 2## #'1# ##&2 #0$ #0 #'(# %$1#,.7,!%##1#'0#'G.*K+ ,-H
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
450
1968
1970
1972
1974
1976
1978
1980
1982
1984
1986
1988
1990
1992
1994
1996
1998
2000
2002
2004
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Terrorist attacks Suicide attacks Assassinations Sum of fatalities
"#!12#0%'#1#'#0#%.*K+ ,-!1#$ 1##'10#(##&#(2##$ 1##'11##
110
!' 2 2 %' 20( ' #0 '$' ## ##& # #'3#$1 # #'%!#(###2##'#####-+ %# 1 ## ##& # 2( 2 # 1# #2#$##1K*+%#7#'(#G,-%#H##'%######&##1#' &2 #2 ' # 1 # # 0#G(&'#(,-L!0(,-H##%#'%##$2#%###11#1#'(23####'$'%##$ # #%#2 #'# # !1( 2 %# #'# # 1 11##$%'%$ 9 #0 # 1 # 0 ' !#1#041'05G.**H1 #0( # '%## ## ## '%1# # #$ 1 11# ! '% ## 2 #0##00#0#'#$1$$##$111#.
%$ 1 11 2# # 2 #%5# 0 1 # <# 1 # ### G& # (,.H ! 0 # # 2# ## 0'# %# 0 #' @%# A9 %# ## #' %5 # ( # # %#$ 1 # 12 7' # ' ( 2%$1%#((%#1#5#'1#5# # %#$ 1 %#2# #( 2%#%#011##%#$1#17#'(20##'#'1$####%#$%#1##)#0%0'1'###
! #% #2#$ # G' 1 0# %#H G+.+H( :GK+H(7GH(4'$G-.H(>#)##G--KH(4G-H(;'G*H(?GH(!&$G.H(G,KH()%GKH(#$G,*H(#G,+,H(;G,.*H(&#G,H(%%G.+H(4##G.+H( $%#G..*H( )0G..+H1#G..H!##'10#*K,-.#'$####0#%1#'(####$1%#$1#'#'#%#$###!%#01#'G?0F1H%%'#(1#($G10$H'001%#####&20(10$'00$2##001#' GX+H ( #1('#1$$ #111######'G4FH#15#1## 0# # '%$ 2&0'# %1' !'## #( 2 ' ## # 0 14F6?0F1/O( 2 ## # ## 0 1 # ## O # # 0# 1?0F1( 2 ####1%#$#111#
111
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
,900'##0'1'$#'$52&#G,HIG,H########1###0'#0?#!#(20('22##'%0
11
2
!,#'##
<%#0#
G.H
G,H
GH
G-H
GH
GKH
GH
!###&GH
.
.+-
,,
,.*
,-
.*K
...
G,K+HZZZ
GHZZZ
G+HZZZ
G-.HZZZ
G--HZZZ
G,,HZZZ
G.+HZ
630'#
*
K,*
G*+HZZZ
GKKHZZZ
;$
+
G,H
&
,+
G,--HZZ
<'$
+
-
G-+HZZZ
G.*HZZZ
'#
.
*
GKHZZZ
G,-HZZ
4<2#GH
.
.
G,*HZZZ
G,.+HZZ
1#GH
G.KKHZ
G.*KHZ
4<%%#GHGH
.+K
G.--H
;02
+*
K
GHZZZ
G,HZZZ
GH
-.K
K
G,.HZZZ
G,*HZZZ
421GH
,K*
G,.KHZZ
11
3
#GH
,*
.,
G,K,HZZZ
GKHZZZ
)#&GH
+
G-H
<'##GH
,+
G-*HZZZ
7#5#
.,
GHZZZ
5#
+
G.H
J1#%#$11
.
G,H
0#
-,-K
-+-
-+*
--
+
.
-**
;#
.
.
.
.
.*.
.,
.,
?
-
.
.
.
,
,
"##'#'#;#111##G;'(.*+H!2##
%('##%%'#G#2H#%G
&#(.**+H#015###%#(Z1##.]LZZ1##]LZZZ
1##.]
114
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
-0'##%###$%'
115
"#( 2 # ' %1 #$% 1 #( ( #' 1 ##& # ' 1 %# # !' 2# 0 ## ##& 0 '%# ##(2%#$0#'1#0#2###%&3(#'11####'%# $( # 0 ' 1 1## % 0# ''$# # % 1 # ! 12 %## # # #0'11###%1#1#(2###'#1##2(###%1 #' (# # 0#$1 #' ## 11# ##1#9#'##
1#%''##(#$1#######1###"#2&1)#;1#(0# ##%OO222$#'%OO#'( # , 2 # %''# 2 # 20( 2 2 # 1' # $ #11#
116
! #'####0#'#
<%#0# G.H G,H GH G-H GH GKH GH
630'# K K- K.+ K,+ K K- K
G-HZZZ GHZZZ G-*HZZZ GKHZZZ GKKHZZZ G.HZZZ G,HZZZ
<'$ - - -K - - - -+
G.KHZZZ G.HZZZ G-HZZZ G.+HZZZ G.HZZZ G.*HZZZ G,,HZZZ
'# * . * * . . .
G,-HZZ G,-HZZZ G,-+HZZ G,-KHZZ G,HZZ G,+HZZZ G,KHZZ
4<2#GH . .- . . .- .- .-
G,.-HZZ G,,HZZ G,+HZZ G,.+HZZ G,,,HZZ G,,,HZZ G,,.HZZ
1#GH
G,.HZZ G.*HZ G.**HZZ G.*HZ G.*HZ G.*HZ G.*-HZ
;02 +- K- K* K, K K,* K-
G.HZZZ G-+HZZZ GHZZZ G,HZZZ G,HZZZ G*HZZZ G-HZZZ
GH + K K K K+ K K*
G,+*HZZZ G,*-HZZZ G,HZZZ G,*-HZZZ G,*HZZZ G,*-HZZZ G,*HZZZ
#GH .- ,+ ,+- .K ,. , ,
G*HZZZ GHZZZ G,,HZZZ GK,HZZZ GK+HZZZ GHZZZ GHZZZ
!###&GHGH .KK
G,KKHZZZ
)##&GH .+
G,-HZZ
#GH ++
G-HZZZ !###&2###.3$GH ,-
G,HZZ
)'11##GH ..
G,.HZZ
7##%0#GH ++
G..H
!''$ K
GKH
0# -** -** -** -** -** -** -**
;# ., ., ., ., ., ., .,
? -"##'#'#;#111##G;'(.*+H!2##%(' # # % %'# G# 2H # % G& # (.**+H#015###%#(Z1##.]LZZ1##]LZZZ1##.]
117
!0###0'#1#11#1#'(2##' 11# 1 # %#$ 0 %1# 1#,#!#%$#-K
0# # # '( 2 1 ## # # ##& # &1 # $ %# ! 11# #2 2 $ ## ##& ## 00 $'7#'(21###'11#22$ ##&# # ## ## #' '%####'0'2#20(##0#0'#020'%##1##'
**3!1#$52##0#$1#''##1##(2##1''$0?#1#'1####&G0#$$H#?#P#2(2PQR#(M #)S9### # 1 ''$ '% # 10 %# 1 0#912#'%1#'1##(#'1#0$?###%1#72#'02##''#PQ871-2#'11# G 1 #0H1 # 11# ''$0 7 %# # # 1 # 0# '' 2 1 - %$1##$ '' ! % 1' %0 1 !# ( #$2###'%#1#'##1#2#1#'2#''09 ## 1 # ' 1 ##& # ' 11# '1#1 P6((21 # '1 # # ' #1P6#"#%$(#2#1#1#01P0####'11#
K###'11#(0#'0#1 11# # # 5 ! # 2 # 11# 2 # ' 11# 1 ##'1##'##1'##11#1#1#$0
118
!-611#1#'#0##%#$0I 611# 0 6
F "
!###& .
!###&GH . .
)##& . . .
# ..
!###&2###3$ , , ,
)'11## . - ,K
7##%##& . , .
!''$ * ..
.0-1I>,-"
630'# .K .+
<'$ . *
'# , ,,K-
4<2#GH .K
1#GH K-+
;02 .-
+ -
# - .+"##'#'#;#7 11#:#!'%1##%1#1' #,!'11# ###%#$0?##'111###5!%#0'%#'6
119
!2##1'%##$(2%#'%
11# % ) !0 G,-H 1 ## # 2# '%# # 0 # ## ##& #'1 '%1'( 2 11## #2 '# # '# #+ 9 1 0 1 $#'# 11#2##'#0'###'%#1####&##20(22##2 ;<# ;< #(&&' # G,-H(21###'11###%#$####1#7611#1##11#1####&
-0.04
0
0.04
0.08
0.12
0.16
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
"##12##'##1##''$0%1# 1 # , # %# %# #' 11#1 ''$0?#G#2H1#'1####&#?#!'11####%#$0?##'111###5!2#%##'##%##*]1#0
%#1'#1##$(22##11#2###101#'#2#201#'9##2#%(
7 #&10#$( # #1#'%##$#'#%%(#0?#+ ! #5# # 52& # G,H '$ # ###02#1''#$%'%%
120
# &$ ## #%1 ' 11#$ #'2 # ##1#1 #%#%! ## (21#%##1'#'%##0####&#'% % 9 2 '& G# ,('H(21####'0#$#"#(20#'# #%1'?5!1#%#1####.####&##1'.*K+ ,,;##%##.####&#'#-*##&!#%1#####& ' # '% % 2# %##( 2 1 ###' 11# # # %$ #2# 01#'G#%'11#1###10%#0H7-611#1##11#11##
-0.04
0
0.04
0.08
0.12
0.16
1 2 3 4 5 6
"##12##'##1##''$0%1# 1 # , # %# %# #' 11#1 ''$0?#G#2H1#'11###?#!'11####%#$0?##'111## #5!2#%##'##%##*]1#0
7$(2#2$1'##1#$1# 1# # ) # # 0$ $ '#1##1?##'#0(2'%$#;7 :'#
121
' 2# # %'# ' &$ # % 1#'##1#'* !#'## %# #912#''##$#'$0!#('. K## #'# 2 # 11# # 1 # 0 (2'K2##2# # %1%%%####'%#1#'22$1###]10+!#'#'11#((.,!1%%#1 #02## #''$%$11##&1#1##+.
*!# (2# #'%%'##(20##1# % 1 #' 11# 9 ## ! $%# 1 #' 11# 3#1%1#!1(' #'''!1;7 :'G.*+H##+ ; # 0( 2 2 1 ## $ # 0 1 '$( #'1%#%102#$#### 0 # & 1 # ! # 1 # %#''30'#$'$11##%#$11##+.7##$#114#G,+H
12
2 !!'%#1#'#%'#1##
<%#0#1#
#
G.H
G,H
GH
G-H
GH
GKH
GH
!###&GH
-K
KK
--
-,
--
K++
-*
G,-HZZ
G,,HZZ
G,K+HZZZ
G,HZZZ
G.KHZZZ
G..HZZZ
G,HZZZ
630'#
*
G.+HZ
;$
G+H
&
-
G*KH
<'$
*.
.,
G,*.HZZZ
G--.HZZZ
'#
.*
G.,HZ
1#GH
.
G,H
4<2#GH
,*
G.H
4<%%#GHGH
K,
G.*H
GH
.-+
.K
G,+HZZ
G,+*HZZZ
;02
*.*
.
G.K+HZ
G.*KHZZ
421GH
*
G.-.H
12
3
#GH
,K
G.-H
<'##GH
,*
G.,*H
)#&GH
,*
GH
7#5#
**
G*.H
5#
G.*H
J1#%#$11
.
GH
0#
K,-
+.-
+,-
*
..
-*
+-,
;#
.-
..
.,
.,
.-
+
..
?
.-
.
.,
.-
..
.
.
"##'#'#;#111##G;'(.*+H%1##'''
#015###%#(Z1##.]LZZ1##]LZZZ1##.]
124
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
125
!,
"2$(#%#1%###$%$'%##'1%#'$#2$0##%###$##$2# %# #1# ### ' %(#$ 11# # #0 1 ( ( 1' %#G;'(,H!#1#''#(G'1H#?#1%###$%#( #?#####
• 2%###$'N
• <%###$'%'2#N
• < '$ 5# # % 1 '&# '#'#$##0N
• <#'11####$10'#N # %#( 2 %# 002 1 # '% #
%###;%#,#2##''#1%###$ ! ## ( 2 0 G ## # %0 #H %#$7#$G 7H#'#'#$1%###$! #1 # 7 # ## 2'11##1%###$'#1#1#2#$ 10%1%# ##$ 0 ## ###(2 01 ## 1 11# ' 1 %# ##$ #!'%#$'#0#0('0%##(%###$#%#'(%###$#%#'
! ' 1 # %# 2 # ' 2# %###$##'2#90'#'%#1#1 %# ##$ ' ' 2# #2#1'2&###2&1'G.**H7 #'#( 2 0 # $' % # $#'456#16'##'#1G.**+H!%%
126
#& # # # %' #$ 1 %# ##$ $%#01#%###$'#'#
'##$###$1#%#'##0'%#'2#=##'%$24#'1%###$### 1?# 1 # %# ( 1?####(1?##(1?#0'#( 1?# # %#$ #$%( # '$ ## #''###%#'#0'2#$##'1%###$'2#(2%# ##$ ## # ##$ 2# %# # 1####'%)0G.**+H
91'0 ##' ##$2# #%#' 1 ' 2# ! 1 2# #1$# G,H6?## G,H## %# '%## '$ 0 0 # %%# # '#'%##%# '%##%# #1# '%'## 1 %%%# 0'# % # '## 7$( 2 1 ' 0 1 0 #$ !# ('2#1# ##$2# # %# '(2 #& 12# # %#$ '#0# 0 2 1 ## #'0%2#'$(##%###'$G%#'%##H#$ # '2#(# ## #$1&11#G00H!11#2##1((6#G,-H(2#'#0# % 1 ##( ) )1( ' & 01##
1 # 2&1 # #2# %%###'#1##''1###%##?#'#0#$(#%'## # ' #' 2#( # 0 #' %%>1##$( #'% %'1# 3#1 $ # ## # 2 0 # #1? # 2# # 0 #2 % # ?&! % &$ # #1$ 1'# %0$ #0%'#100 #' 1(1 #( # 2## # 1 # % 2 2# # #%#1#%(#%02#1'#0
! 2# # #' ' '% ' 1 '2#( 2 0 '%$ ##0 %% %# !
127
%% # ' 2& 1 ' # G,H( 2#1$%1%#2#'20'$0## @2##A
%#(20%$1#?#12#%#''1' #2##! %1 % '2# ## #1 ###$#1'2&1$'#G,H(##0'%0'#7#(20## ##1 #%# ' 01' # G,H # ## ## # #1 # ##$ 1###$'#G,H!#(%#20 1 ## 1 # ' # & 2( ( 2 1 0##%#'#'2## '%0'# # # # 1# ## # #1$'2###%####1#$%#1#%#1$#1#1'#G,H######$!'%0#1#(20#'%########1%#$1###(###!##%#%$'%##(# ?# '% $ %'$1 0##%'2###'11#(#0+2# # #21 #.*(2 '% ##( 0( 0$ $ # ## # # 2## '2 # 2 '&$( # % 0 #$ #& % # 0% 2 1#( '# ,] G.KH 1 ##&%) )1=#1#2(2'#$##2#'2#
7 # '% $(2 0 ##1 # %%%# %'##(####2&1'#G,H(#$1 11# %#!1(20'%$# 1 11# # %% $ ;'G.*+H>&'#G,H(201##'2## 0 $ ' 1' # $ %# '!1%%##02$###6#$7( 2 ''5 $ # 9# ; G9'(.**-H'1'G#$%#1'H '%## 1 # # 0% '$ 7#'( # # 0 ## # # 1 %# ' '%###'# 1 ' 2# # !# ( ' 2## %#$ #& % $ %# $#' 7$( 201## ###''$#%#$##
128
' 2# # ! 1 % ## 2# #1 %# , ## %# '%## %#0$ 11# '2#
# %#1 # #(2 01 # 111# ' 1 %# ##$ 7#( %# -( 2 0'%$####$1;G,H##'$5# # % 1 '&# '# '#$ # # 09'#1#### 1#1 #$#'#( # #$ 1 ; %0 %# 2$ 2##0'$&##%1''##'7#'(###'#####1#'#11#(# #$1;# # ##1'$(5#( '#
! ' 2# # 3# 1 '$( 5#('&# '#'# ##0(20##'%##''&# '#'#$##1';G,H#6##&## G6(,H!%( #( 1 11# % # ' 2# #2 2$ # 2$##11#### #01#;#$!# ( #'%## #1221#(#'11#%#2###'$5# 1# #2#'&# '#'#$20( 2 2 ## $ # # # 1 ) ) 1#(#01;11#!#() )1#( # 3# 1 '$ 5# #0 # %1 '&# '#'#$(2 # #02'&# '#'#$#!## # ##0 # 1# # %# 0 #%# 0( ##0 #'# '#( ##0 '%1#(###(#
! # %# #' G <' ,H F$ ##2#1F$2(# # ### '##( #0$ %#$ # #$( ## 00##F$'1##1) )120( # %#1 #'&# '#'#$#F& 2 %%# # 2 1 # #( #$ '#0#0&# 1# # #'#1F&( # $'###
%#(201#?#12##'# # # ##$ 1 0'# !# $ 0 %#'#0 # # # # 1 % %
129
%#%#1#'!#1# 2#0####$10'#(202#%# '% $( 2 01 0?# 7#( 1'#(#'11###N)(2##'%#1#'#0###'#1##N!(#0 1 '% ##$ # # #2 #' ##N(1$(#'1##'N
! ' #'( 2 0 # # 1' # 6!#'&2G6!(,-H%###1#'(#0#$1#'(##$%1####&!% #2 %# '% $ # 2 # ?#
##1#?#(20#'#1&#G.**+H##1'2&###%2 # % ' 1 # # ! ' 1 #% %#$ '%## # %#$ ## # ##21'$%#%###$#901 ' 0 ## #' # # # 1 # =%$1' 0 ##&!$ ### 1(20 '% # #0'#1 # 11#1 #'2###'#1## # 1## # '%#1#' ##'%#1(('2#1#(#'##'%#1((0'#027#'(201###'#1####&%##$%1####&2#0#$1###&9101'%##$ !# ( %$ # 2# 01 #'(# # # 7$( 2 1 ## #' # $##(#%$# #%#$1'#0'#
130
131
-(;G.**H(@!$D##$'2#A(T?3(,,* -( 7 I G,KH @< %# ##$ # 1#N%#$A(T C(+.* .+*( (<02( ( #$( 9( F#( ) 95G,H7#5#(T?3(+. .*-((5()((")2G.**KH@###$'2#A(T?3(..+* ,..#(;;# G,H@##$##$1#'A(: <?(.K, ,+,( )5& G.***H @# ' ##2## #$ % # 41 2 % A(T =(-+ ( G,H @42# ### 02 1 # 0A( FU C=.-,(.** .( ) "( G,,H _<#' # "' 1 7# %%'#7#6_(?(.*. ,,.2( 6# G.***H @!22015# %1'#( 1'# 11A( " 9& %( K*-"#1 '(&(G,HVF:4,#+#5'())*'%#("J( G.*H @! # 1 %# ' 'A(<-(.-.* -,
132
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
133
2( (7(<4G.*+-H@0#%%##%'1###$A(>,< (..K .*()G.**+H_##''###$'%#'_(T?(+.. .-##( G.**H @# 0 #$ 2# $A(T?,(...K .*6?#(#G,H(@3,<>A("20J>0#$;'%(" "# G,,H @9 11 %# ##$NA(T:,>?(K. .,;%(4 <F G.***H @ %1 $#' 1 A( <# # 1 # , 0 ###%OO222.2&O1O#'O#b1#'O;'( 7 G,,H @"2 0 # %# ' 1'#%#$##A(T<?(-*,-* ,*;'(7G,H(###$(##$'(T?,(.. -;##( G.*KKH _! ## 1 # ' 1 1#_(,,=(.,- ,K;'(4G.*+H@$102#?##0#A(=,? (-,, ,+;( G,-H @! ,- )% # #' #$# 1NAU?><(,*- *K; J 7 G.**KH( @)' %# #'# 1 '2#_?>T<?(.,K* K,;2#5(;G,H@$#1N#%######A(%%%%1#,6#1#'#)#(;(:
134
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
135
<5( G,H < ? ( # >0#$(#("2$<( G,KH@<5#11#2#N 01'215#A(4>> ?(+.*. ...<( ( 5( I F G,KH @ # & #2$#NABT! ?(.. ,<1( )( ( !'% G,H _42# '#(_ (<1)GH(; -C?3(%#+ K( 0<1( ) <Q G.**+H_!2 '%1 '2#_(V?=UC<>(K-,,"#1 '( #$( 9 :0 G.**H @1D 2# #$ % #0hWT?(..,., 2( ")' G,H @9$ # '$02 1N ># %0# 0# 1#NA( T 4?(*,-- K* 2( " )' G,,H @2 ' 2 2 2 N %#%0102A(T=(-K - 2( ( G,H @45#( ' &( ' 1#A % %# # # , ; 1( 6(4'$()%#'.+ ,. (9()(!4G.**,H'#$1#'%#1#'#'(XC(-. -7( < :# G,H @ ##$( 0 2A(4<=,(* *7( 7( G.*KKH( @0 0 2#%#A(T=(.,-* ,.
136
7(JG.**H@<'$(%###$('2#A(T<(,*. -.+7(JG,H:3, ?3F ?, (! 6! ( 6## ### 1 !$( ;'(6##73( G.*+KH @'# %1' # #A(<-( ,7(<G,H@;###1##1'%#(0%###$A(<-(..K,* .,7' G,KH 7' # 9 # & <#<2##%OO2221'7$( ) : G,H @2 #1# #' ##0 ##A(: <?(.-, ,-*7$((:())##5G,-H@I%#1#1#%%A(?U C<>(..+; )14'7$((:())##5G,H@;##$##1#'A(T?,(,.. ,-4(6( (6G,H@!'##'%$A(X.!UC>>( .+.(F7)2 '###( !84(6( (6G,+H!'###$#&$D#EA?@(1#'4#(;(:(Q8&( G,H@%#'1%$ '$1%###$A(=,:,>?(+ *+4055(74!G,H@ '%#5#A(T?(,.,* .4( G,H @! %# '$ 1 #A(W T ?(.,-=+K
137
4#( "( 9#( ( & 6( ) 6 )#G,,H @'1#.*-K=,. 2# #A(T<=*K.=K
4( "0& G,H@<##11#15#0%#A(T?@(-* +,4(; G.*+H !"20 '#99"#("2J&41'( I 5 G.**H @6 # #$#'#A(T<(,-.* -.4%#(<G.**HF?<N("2J&( < G,,H @<# # $ '#0##A(T?(-*K +.'( G.*+H @)%1# ## '#A(?( -K.,. .,.'((###(:<& G,H @42##A(T?3(. ,*'((5(79G,KH@42#%A(B:UC <>( .K ;# 1 ## <0%'# # 0>0#$( ( ( !( 4#( ) " 4# G,.H @!2 '# 0 %N <'$( %# 0 2( .+.K .**,A(4<=,(*.K ((4#"4G,H@45##1#A%%,. ,)(4((F"4#(GH(3-E 4 (;2'^:##1$( < G.**H ? D 4 7 ? ? (&2(1(>F
138
#( ( )''( ( #( ( ,, 9 ! I K.(;# 1 ## ;'% # # >0#$ 1 $0G;;>H#( ( )''( ( #( ( ,, 9 ! I K,(;#1 ##;'%1#( ' ##>0#$1$0##(66"G,H@#'$1$11#49#2#'A(<"< <(K -,$2(G.*.H@1#?1'A< =4(.--+K=.(<G.*H<N"4V4("2J&9$'( G,.H F : - <>, :E(6#>0#$(6#(>F##()G.*K+H<. "20(;!J>0#$'( " G.**H( _42# '% % # %%(_ F WT?(...., ;4G,H##;#$&4!)4%"2J& 6 ' G,KH @! %## 1 '$ # ,##$ #$ 1 # #$ A( 1#' ;( )2#5(GH(<-: 2 (;#'(>F5'2&(6G,KH@ '%1(%#('#%6&0 2# %% #2#A(T :,> ?( +. +(&G,H@!#'$1## #%2#AV?=UC<>(..,+"#1 '((&G,H@<'##N"#%2#99A(WT?(.,+ K-
139
( G,KH @ #''#1 %# ##$ #'%# ' 2#A( . = =>( K; >0#$ 14( ### )6 G)$#'( # 6'#H ( G,+H @ #''#1 %# ##$ #'%#'2#A((>0#$14 ( G,H @# ' ( '1' 2# #A(? U C <> .* ; )14' ( < G,+H( @42# # '#A(?TU(. +F&( ) F1 G.**H @### ' %1' #$ ## ##0 ### 'A( ? <(, ,,F1("G.*++H@ '##51#A(T?@(,KK-K K*:(<#G,H@$M#>&%# 11 # ># F'A(B W( -*, ,,:0( < # G.**,H @ #0#$ $ 1 #$2#A(4?=,+,*-, *K:%#()G.*KH<(:(9'':'#:(FG.**H@0#$(#%#%(#51#0%2A(U <(*,. ,-:%( F )#P' G.**H @;# #'# # ###'1#0#A(4<=,(+*K-+ KK6&2("('(<<9G.**,H(@####'%1'2#A(WT?(.- -
140
6( 4 ) G.**H, " !("2$:2 '#(6(64 F G,,H #$ I<# )#j;'%#1L0%-0,,k;&(6<;#1 ##<0%'# ;1# 6'#( >0#$ 1 6$##%OO222''OO%#$O6( ()#$#() )#G,-H@ '&01# #'#0 %%A(T <?( ..,, .6##&3#G,H;&(6<;#1##<0%'# ;1# 6'# #0 1'##%OO222''O'O.%,6! G,-H 6' ### 1 # 0# 1 !'##%OO222#&6(<)#0G.*.H(@# ##$ %#&1A(T=(.- K+6( G.*H @# %%#$ 1' !' # A(4<=,(K-.+ -"#(<G.**H@5#A(!)0&&5 ') 6'$ 1 1 " .** 2 ###%OO%5Ob%5O'O#O.**O# ##'(6G.*KH@%2##51AT?;(,,*=,#&(G,H@1'#####1#'11##%%'# 1# 'A( ''(##%OO222'Ol,,O#&7#!#%1D"( # G,HF<":B > B.E("2J&"#
141
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
142
)(< G.*+.H< <B-(!6':!<(:(>#F')?(F!)G,H@!#&( #''##(%$#A(T<-?(*..+ .+.)2( G.*KH( @ ## # # #$1 '2#A(FWT?(K *-)#'( G,H@<#'#1 #'2#2# %%$ # #'# #' $A(?>?(* K.)0( G.**+H @0#'#( %%#$ # %# ##$#$0A(?>?=,(-,.. .-!31(!G.**H@##0#$1#%1#9#)9G H(F<B>=6#$(;& ;!#( G.*KKH @<' 1 1# 0 2# #2#.*+ KA(T=(.-. K-!0( G,H @!% #$ # ' &( #####&A(T?(..* .!0( 95 G,.H @2 '$ 11# 2#A(?>?=,(-.-. .+>!G,KH>0#$1!?#$3#<#)#2###%OO#%0#OI(!G,H@2##1''$(.+. .**+A(T<=(,. ,KI( J < 4%# G.*+KH @' ## %###$ #'# 1 0 # 'A( T <?(*-+=++
143
95( F9 G,H m!5# 2# 20A(V?=UC<>( ..,"#1 '(9&( !( 63 G,H ,- ('#'"#92&(G.**-H3,,,<:;'>0#$("2J&("J9'( G.**-H @ 1 ' 1 #%A( 9' GH( F < ? ? =( 9#( <;###1## '9&G,KH9&<0%'##;< '(9#(<;9#(:G,-H@!#'%1'002A(F?T(..-7- 7,.
144
145
.)<#%11#0#05&0%#& ####&### &3# 0 # %#& ' <# &'#0'3&5&%#& ###05&#'##&&##&2##0#&'#%#&####&'#'<55&1##0%#0%#('a0#('#&'#G;'(,H <5&#%11#0#'#0%#&###(5&0%#& ### 00%#&###0 '#2&&<'00'# '# 2 0 5&0#2
• #%#&####2'#N
• 1#%#&###0%'N
• I5& '# 25 0'&#'#'#2N
• 1##'0%GH###0N 5301#0%#&###'%<'#'0## 1# 0 ) G.*+.H I ' %#&###'#22 1#2#0 02#'123&0#@'%#A<52#2#&00''#�'#%#& ### % 0 ' 2# '# ##G.**KH(30('# %#& ### 0 # ###%##%#&<#&3&G.**KH##2053 # # # ''## 1 25 0 &%$0%#&### # # '3& # 1?# ë(5"%,, ,(515&0 ##%( 5 '# % ! ,K0 23& #05'%##'&'#2F0&50,
146
' # '& # 0 # %#&###( # % 0 %#& ###'###2 53(55(0'##0%#& ### #'# 3&%'0 5'##0 #5'#1#0##2 &'##1 1'#0#0%#&###(1#&'##10' & # '# 3& '#1#( 2# %#&### # %11#'# , # #2% %#07#$6#5'#2#1'#0 #'# &'(01'#&0&#I02%05$0'0%#&###< #&'# 0 5 $ # %#& ### ## # 0' %#& 2( '#%%3& 05#( ### #%#& '( ###0#%#& 'I&05' 2# '##1 #&( &# & 2 0'%5& I0 2# $ 0 0 ' 0 %#& ### 0 %' 53 0 ## ' #%#&####111#1#%' # ' 0 )0 G.**+H( 30( ## # %#&####350%#0&#(253'53'%&##'35&3&('�'# 0( 2 0# &%# # 5 30 '2#' # 11# 0 %#& ### % ' 2## '# '# 0 G.**+H <5 5#4 6'# 6# 0 $' % # '#'&#'#11#0%#& ###%'# $( '# '# & # '# # 1# #'%##&53#%#& ### &53>#$3&##@###0#%#&'A''##3&30 51# 53 # # %#& '0( ##20%#&(##2#235(##%#& # #2<#3&## # '%1# # @### # %#& 'A3# %#1 11# 1# % ' <5 0 22#3'#'#'%#&#### ' ( ' 3 '# 0
147
6?## G,H$ G,H(#%#&'%##%#111#1#%'#&'#('#'%##%#&200 !##3&## $ # '&01#%#20%#& ###'!##''##'%#&'%## %&0253 ##! #2#' '##'%#&2 C0%&0##'##' #'# 0 ' # $( '2%#3'0#2#'2%#'#'52#3#'(#3 ' 0 #'3 ' # % #2 0 % 0 ''0313 <&52& % #% ## ## 5233&# 5# % # 1'# 21# %% 2# # ' 0 # ( 30('5#0&5%5 # 0 &5 %( # ' 0 %#1'#1 ' ?# #3' 0 ' # #'(&52"0##0<5 % # 2& 0 ' G,H( 2 % 00 ' 2 a#1 I0 2#$ 2& 0 5 # 05&# #%11#2#'# '5#1%#& '0 ' 0' @#A 05& <5#53%0'''#32#%11#%#2&0' G,H(0# # # 1#0#!# 2# 1# %#& ' 0 0 ' G,H>#5%#3&###051#####a0#6#'0'G,H#%#& '0%#030&##%##(3#01##(3&##5$&###0# 0# %# 0 0 3# a#1 '# '%$ ##1# #0&2&5&##(3##1#0###<0 ## # #0# 1#0' G,H 2# ## 0 # 2 ?#a#1%0#0#1#2+#
148
a#1 %0 # 3 #2# %# 0 1#%#0 % # ## # 23& 2# '#'('3&) )1& < ' 0 % :# ' '# 0# 11# 2#00 5# 1 %#& ' 0 '0'&a0%##3&##3#' 0' & 0# # #%## # %#& ' 0 6# 2' 03 3& %#& 03 # # '' #2&& <# ## ## & % 0' G,H <# ## # 0#'' '# # # %% 2# # ## 6# 7 =#&@9#;AG9'(.**-H"#' 0' 0 % & # #50#<5&'#&# %& 0 G#1H 3 %#& $#'( 12 '01#%#0#'## #2 0 # %11# 2# # 5& 0%#&####!#2#$5#13 '# ## #'0#2I;G,H3&02#''#5#'&#'#'<##'(#0'5#1# C00;G,H1# ;0& n<5#%0'##%#0##0&0 n( ' 5# 2 %# 0 %0# 'I;G,H#2##&#;0&.**+#00'#0n 4 G,H 1# ## & 0 # #'#(#253'%#%&& ' # # 5 # 3& # ' 53 &'0 2 0 # ## 5#5%#05'2##( 12 2# 53 2 # #&'# 3&%& ;e $ # # 5 ## %&# $%##6 #'3&' 2& # ( '# # 5& 5# @0& 0 0#A # %11# 2#( ' 0 % # ' '# 0# 11# #2 2## 11#($%#0;G,H######'
149
# '& # '# 5 '&#'#' 2# &# '&# 0 1&3& G6(,H( 2# 0& '# 1# 0 ; G,H ># $3&##230$%#0;20 225#< $#% ) )1&'#'&#'#'(23# ###05%1&%2##'#(#2 !## 2# * 0 # %11# # 0# #' #!# %#&'#0###%#&%#a0 530#nG#H## #' &# 53 2# ##'# ##%#####0###(#%#05##50#05353&0#n # #'�&##'0:%)#P'G.**H####&&G5##H 0 % %& % ' '3& '#05###a0##0 (�CC G1 #H0 #%#0#53'####%%'#&###0 ##0#0G.*H###0#23&0 %0 0 %& I # ' # ### 0#23& # 2 %& 2 % ' # ## %&<##'3&##0 0 1# ' ## #0&' <' # 233& # # ## 0#23�&2#% <'0%:#''#0#11#2## 1#& # 11# 0 #' %&# $ 3&%# '0&# 1&3&<# 2 5 # & # &# % %#2#( 1# 0 % # # '# '51&3&#'&2'#0&G.**+H 5#2##''#01'# & # @6! !' F2 AG6!( ,-H < &# '##0 #&& % # ###(###0##
150
># $ 3&# # # ## # #' &# < &# ' ' &# # '& 1# '# #' % 0 03&$'##'#0&###11#0#' #1 < 0 0 #' % &# ##000'0(51#1'0'##11#0#'#'# 2 53( 53% # %2(1253%#0##300&5
