u.s. baldrige performance excellence framework for...
TRANSCRIPT
U.S. Baldrige Performance Excellence
Framework for Small Businesses Dr. Manu K. Vora, MBA, ASQ CQE and Fellow
Chairman and President, Business Excellence, Inc., USA Fulbright Specialist, U. S. Department of State’s Bureau of Educational & Cultural Affairs
Adjunct Faculty, School of Professional Studies, Northwestern University, USA Visiting Faculty, IIT (BHU), Varanasi, GIAN Program - MHRD, Government of India, India
Visiting Faculty, Great Lakes Institute of Management, Chennai, India [email protected], http://b-einc.com, Office: 1-630-548-5531
Presentation at the
ASQ Fox Valley Meeting Warrenville, IL, May 1, 2018
2
Outline • My Baldrige Journey (1989-Present) • Why U.S. Baldrige? • What is U.S. Baldrige Framework? • Key Categories of Baldrige Framework (How):
1. Leadership 2. Strategic Planning 3. Customer Focus 4. Measurement, Analysis, and Knowledge Management 5. Workforce Focus 6. Operations Focus 7. Results
• Next Steps • Resources
3
My Baldrige Journey (1989-Present)
• Baldrige Training from ASQ (1989) • Baldrige Deployment at AT&T Bell Labs (1990-2000) • Baldrige Integration in MBA TQM Courses (1993-Present) • Chief Judge, Illinois Team Excellence Award (1993-1999) • Baldrige Coaching to Naperville School District Leadership
Team (1995-1996) • Senior Examiner, Asia Pacific Global Performance Excellence
Award (2004-Present) • Baldrige Coaching to Illinois Pharmaceutical Packaging
Leadership Team (2010-2011) • Baldrige Coaching to Mahamaya Technical University, Noida,
UP, India Leadership Team (2012)
4
Why U.S. Baldrige? • Proven framework for Performance Excellence since 1988 • Applicable for Manufacturing, Service, Small Businesses,
Education, Healthcare, and Nonprofits • Non-Prescriptive Criteria – Adaptable to any Organization • Helps you manage all the components of your
organization as a unified whole, so that your plans, processes, measures, and actions are consistent
• Self Assessment to determine Areas of Strengths and Opportunities for Improvement (OFI)
• Iterative Continuous Improvement using OFIs • Focus on Long-Term Success and Sustainability
5
U.S. Baldrige Video
Getting Results! video – (12 min)
6
What is U.S. Baldrige Framework? With the Baldrige framework, you evaluate and improve your processes along four dimensions: • Approach: How do you accomplish your organization’s
work? How effective are your key approaches? • Deployment: How consistently are your key processes
used in relevant parts of your organization? • Learning: How well have you evaluated and improved
your key approaches? How well have improvements been shared within your organization?
• Integration: How well do your approaches align with your current and future organizational needs? How well are processes and operations harmonized across your organization?
7
What is U.S. Baldrige Framework? You evaluate your results along four dimensions: • Levels: What is your current performance? • Trends: Are the results improving, staying the same, or
getting worse? • Comparisons: How does your performance compare with
that of other organizations, or with benchmarks or industry leaders?
• Integration: Are you tracking results that are important to your organization and that consider the expectations and needs of your key stakeholders? Are you using the results in decision making?
8
U.S. Baldrige Award Winners From 1988-2017, there are 118 Baldrige Winners:
1. Manufacturing (1988-Present) – 31 2. Service (1989-Present) – 16 3. Small Businesses (1988-Present) – 28 4. Education – (2001-Present) – 11 5. Healthcare – (2002-Present) – 24 6. Nonprofit – (2007-Present) – 8 TOTAL – 118 Source: http://patapsco.nist.gov/Award_Recipients/index.cfm
9
U.S. Baldrige Framework Scoring
1. Leadership – 120 2. Strategic Planning – 85 3. Customer Focus – 85 4. Measurement, Analysis &
Knowledge Management – 90 5. Workforce Focus – 85 6. Operations Focus – 85 7. Results – 450 TOTAL – 1,000
10
U.S. Baldrige Winner Video
PRO-TEC Coating Company video – (12 min) 2007 Baldrige Winner, Small Business
11
Organizational Performance Excellence
Delighted Customers
(VOC)
Improved Processes
(VOP)
Excited Employees
(VOE)
Operational Performance Financial Performance
VOC - Voice of the Customer
VOE -Voice of the Employee
VOP - Voice of the Process
Baldrige Criteria Framework: A Systems Perspective (2017-2018)
Great Leaders
Swami Vivekananda Nelson Mandela Abraham Lincoln Mahatma Gandhi
F. D. Roosevelt Dr. W. E. Deming Dr. J. Juran John F. Kennedy
14
Disciplined People
Disciplined Thought
Disciplined Action
Building Greatness
Good to Great* * Jim Collins, HarperCollins Publishers, Inc., New York, 2001
(Study of 1,435 good companies; examined performance over 40 years; companies that outpaced industry by 3X over 15 years in the stock market)
15
Leadership Paradigm Manu Vora (2014)
16
YouTube Video
Leadership …that Mysterious Talent http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UDp87fxfXoM&feature=related (4.36 min)
PRO-TEC Coating Company (Baldrige Winner, Small Business - 2007): Strategic Planning
18
Customer-Supplier Relationship
Supplier Customer Process Input Output
Requirements & Feedback
Requirements & Feedback
Source: AT&T PQMI, Issue 1.1, 1988.
19
VOC Model
Capture
Analyze
Respond
Verify
20
Bad Customer Service (2.20 min.): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bTbHwnxCGaI
Customer Service Example
ARDEC: Measurement, Analysis, and Knowledge Management
• Ensures That Performance Aligns and Supports Strategy
• Ownership Assigned
• Basis for Fact-Based Decision Making
• Comparative Data Drives Performance
Strategic Planning Process
Determine Measures, Assign Owners, Align with Strategic Initiatives/Way
Gap Analysis /Action Plan
Revision
Target Met?
Strategic Objective/End
Determine who reviews and at what frequency
Collect and Validate Data
Daily, Weekly, Monthly, Quarterly, Annual Scorecard, Reports and Responsive Ad Hoc Reporting
Yes
Improvement Cycle
Communicate results report via SMS, Compare to target
Prio
r yea
r per
form
ance
eva
luat
ion
utili
zed
as
an
inpu
t int
o St
rate
gic
plan
ning
pro
cess
a
nd a
s a m
easu
re o
f effe
ctiv
enes
s
No
22
Employee-Customer-Profit Chain, Sears, USA
Employee Attitude and
Behavior
Customer Impression
Revenue Growth
A Compelling Place to Work
A Compelling Place to Shop
A Compelling Place to Invest
+ 1.3 % + 0.5 %
Source: Rucci et al., Harvard Business Review, 1998.
+ 5.0 %
Talent Management Model
Recruit
Involve
Motivate
Develop
Retain
24
Employee Engagement Model
Participation
Motivation
Development
Excited Employees
25
Five Dysfunctions of Team (P. Lencioni, 2002)
Absence of Trust (Invulnerability)
Fear of Conflict (Artificial Harmony)
Lack of Commitment (Ambiguity)
Avoidance of Accountability (Low Standards)
Inattention to Results (Status & Ego)
26
27
28
Strength = Talent X Investment (Strengths Finder 2.0, Tom Rath, 2007 )
T - Thinking
I - Skills
I - Knowledge
I - Experience
T - Behaving
T - Feeling
STRENGTH
Strength – The ability to consistently provide near-perfect performance
30
31
Focus on Continual Improvement of the Quality Management
System
Management responsibility
Measurement analysis & improvement
Resource management
Product realization
C U S T O M E R
R E
Q.
C U S T O M E R
S A T. Output Input
ISO 9001:2015 Standards
32
Six Sigma Methodology - DMAIC
Lean and Six Sigma
22
LSS
Lean Goal – Increase
process speed and reduce waste
Approach – Bias for
action employing Lean Techniques and Kaizen
Events
Six Sigma Goal – Improve quality by
decreasing variation or eliminating defects
Approach – Detailed data collection and analysis using statistical tools
embedded within DMAIC framework
5 S
22
How Project Leaders Can Overcome Crisis of Silence (Grenny et.al., MIT Sloan MR, Summer 2007)
Are we planning around facts?
Is the Project Sponsor providing support?
Are we faithful to the process?
Are we honestly assessing progress & risks ?
Are team members pulling
their weight ?
36
Change Management Model
Determine Need for Change
Prepare & Plan for Change
Implement the Change
Sustain the Change
37
Organizational Alignment – The 7-S Model (Harvard Business School, November 19,1996.)
Staffing
Skills
Shared Values
Style
Systems
Structure
Strategy
38
Baldrige Winners – Multiple Awards (Major Transformations: 1988-2017 –> 118 winners )
• AT&T – 3 (1992 – Mfg; 1992 – Service; 1994 – Service) • Boeing – 2 (1998 – Mfg.; 2003 – Service) • Cargill Corn Milling – 3 (1999 – Small Bus., 2005 – Mfg., 2008 – Mfg.) • Dana Corporation – 2 (1996 – Service; 2000 – Mfg.) • MEDRAD – 2 (2003 – Mfg., 2010 – Mfg.) • MESA – 2 (2006 – Small Bus., 2012 – Small Bus.) • Motorola – 2 (1988 – Mfg.; 2002 – Mfg.) • North Mississippi Health Services – 2 (2006 – HC; 2012 – HC) • Ritz Carlton – 2 (1992 – Service; 1999 – Service) • Solectron Corporation – 2 (1991 – Mfg.; 1997 – Mfg.) • Texas Nameplate Company, Inc. – 2 (1998 – Small Bus.; 2004 – Small Bus.) • Xerox – 2 (1989 – Mfg.; 1997 – Service) Source: http://www.nist.gov/baldrige
39
AT&T Universal Card Services (1992 Baldrige, Service): Best-in-class in employee recognition and suggestion system (spent 2% of payroll on Recognition & Suggestion system).
Federal Express Corporation (1990 Baldrige, Service): Survey/Feedback/Action management evaluation system. From 1985-1990, 91% of employees “proud to work for Federal Express.”
IBM Rochester (1990 Baldrige, Mfg.): Invested heavily in Education and Training, the
equivalent of 5% of its payroll.
Best Practices - Baldrige Winners
40
Milliken & Company (1989 Baldrige, Manufacturing):
“The ‘Pursuit of Excellence’ process continues to evolve after beginning the journey in 1980. Over 90 ‘opportunities for improvement’ were submitted per associate for 1999, providing a means by which all associates can contribute to improving the process.
Milliken associates participate in over 14,000 teams each year. The Sharing Rally is another avenue by which associate involvement is created, and Milliken & Company has now held over 160 Sharing Rallies.”
Craig Long, Director of Quality
Best Practices - Baldrige Winners
41
Pearl River School District (2001 Baldrige, Education): In four years, faculty satisfaction rose from 89 to 98 % and staff satisfaction from 86 to 96%.
SSM Health Care (2002 Baldrige, Health Care): Employee turnover rate reduced from 21% in 1999 to 13% in August 2002.
Trident Precision Manufacturing (1996 Baldrige, Small Business): 95% of the improvement at Trident stems from employee improvement suggestions.
Best Practices - Baldrige Winners
42
YouTube Video
Change is Good..… You Go First http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jwxrsngEJDw&feature=related (3.24 min)
43
Key Lessons to Remember
I. AMA: Ability determines what you are capable of doing Motivation determines how you do it Attitude determines how well you do it
II. 3Hs: Heart – Emotions Head – Ideas and Logic Hands – Implementation
III. Leadership (a Catalyst of Change): Leadership is all about Influencing, Igniting, and Inspiring ordinary people to do extraordinary things.
44
Next Steps
I. If your Leadership Team is committed, involved, and supportive, begin the Baldrige Performance Excellence Journey
II. The journey requires a longer-term commitment to assess your organization
III. The real focus is to delight your customers through streamlined processes
IV. For successful Baldrige journey, need to appoint a Project Manager and Category Champion Leaders
V. Feel free to request our help to assist you in your performance excellence journey using the U.S. Baldrige Framework
45
Resources AT&T (1988). Process Quality Management & Improvement Guidelines, Issue 1.1. Baldrige Performance Excellence Program, (2017-2018). U.S. Department of Commerce, NIST, Gaithersburg, MD, http://www.nist.gov/baldrige Collins, J. (2001). Good to Great: Why Some Companies Make the Leap .. and Others Don’t, HarperCollins, New York, NY. Goodman J., DePalma D., & Broetsmann S. (1996), “Maximizing the Value of Customer Feedback,” ASQ Quality Progress, December . Kessler S. (1996). Measuring and Managing Customer Satisfaction: Going for the Gold”, ASQ Quality Press, Milwaukee, WI. Kotter J. P. (2012). Leading Change, Harvard Business School Press, Boston, MA. Lencioni, P. (2004). Death by Meeting, Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CA. Lencioni, P. (2002). The Five Dysfunctions of a Team, Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CA. Rath, Tom (2007), Strengths Finder 2.0, Gallup Press, New York, NY. Nelson, B. (1997), 1001 Ways to Energize Employees, Workman Publishing, New York, NY. Nelson, B. (1994), 1001 Ways to Reward Employees, Workman Publishing, New York, NY. Vora, Manu K. (2015). “7 Steps to Link Quality Management to Your Supply Chain”, Supply Chain Management Review, pp. 44-51, July/August. Vora, M. K. (2013). “Business Excellence through Sustainable Change Management”, Viewpoint Article, The TQM Journal, Vol. 25, No. 6, pp. 625-640. October issue. Vora, M. K. (2005). “Managing Human Capital” chapter in Six Sigma for Transactions and Service, P. 471-500, McGraw-Hill, New York, NY. Vora M. K., Harthun S. & Kingen R. (1993). “ASQC Certification Committee Practices What It Preaches”, Quality Progress, pp. 99-103, November issue.
Thanks
Any Questions?
Presenter Manu K. Vora, Ph.D., M.B.A., ASQ CQE, ASQ Fellow Chairman and President, Business Excellence, Inc., USA Fulbright Specialist, U. S. Department of State’s Bureau of Educ. & Cult. Affairs Adjunct Faculty, School of Professional Studies, Northwestern University, USA Visiting Faculty, IIT (BHU), Varanasi, GIAN Program - MHRD, GOI, India Visiting Faculty, Great Lakes Institute of Management, Chennai, India +1- 630-548-5531; [email protected]; www.b-einc.com Dr. Manu Vora is Chairman and President of Business Excellence, Inc. a global quality management
consulting firm. He has over 43 years of leadership experience and has guided Fortune 500 companies with Baldrige Performance Excellence assessment. For over 25 years, as an Adjunct Professor he teaches Operations Management courses at business schools globally. He is connected with over 80 educational institutes world-wide. He is a sought after speaker on business excellence and quality management topics with over 750 presentations globally and published 70 scholarly articles in professional journals. As an ASQ Influential Voice, he has published 50 blog posts. In 2013, he gave two TEDx Talks, TEDxIITBHU Varanasi and TEDxIIT Chicago. Since 2013, he has delivered Soft Skills and Quality Management topics using technology to over 50 colleges/ universities in 14 States of India benefitting over 675,000 students/ faculty/ professionals. In 2016 he was appointed as a Fulbright Specialist by the U. S. Department of State’s Bureau of Educational and Cultural Affairs. He completed Fulbright Project at IIT (BHU), Varanasi in 2018.
He has B.S. (IIT BHU Chemical 1968), M.S. (1970) & Ph.D. (1975) in Chemical Engineering from Illinois Institute of Technology, Chicago, and a MBA (1985) with Marketing Management from Keller Graduate School of Management in Chicago. As the Founder Director and President of Blind Foundation for India (BFI), his
team has raised over $4 million to help over one million visually impaired people in India. ASQ has bestowed on him five Medals. He received “2015 BHU Distinguished Alumnus ward, “2015 & 2000 Rotary
International Paul Harris Fellow Medal”, “2012 IIT Alumni Medal”, 2011 Ellis Island Medal of Honor”, and “2010 US President’s Volunteer Service Award”.