u.s. military rejects sikh identity u.s. military rejects ... coalition army press kit.pdfu.s....
TRANSCRIPT
U.S. Military Rejects Sikh IdentityU.S. Military Rejects Sikh IdentityU.S. Military Rejects Sikh IdentityU.S. Military Rejects Sikh Identity
News Conference - Press Kit
April 14, 2009 (Vaisakhi Day)
U.S. Marine Corps War Memorial (Iwo Jima Memorial)
Marshall Dr Arlington, VA 22211
Table of ContentsTable of ContentsTable of ContentsTable of Contents
1. Press Release 2. Sikh Coalition Statement 3. Clients Statement 4. Contacts 5. Complaint Filed with Inspectors General of the
Department of Defense and U.S. Army 6. Letter to Secretary Gates 7. Sikh Articles of Faith Overview 8. Sikh Coalition Mission – History 9. History of Sikhs in North America 10. Profile: Retired Sikh US Officers 11. New York Times, ‘Turbans Make Targets” 12. MSNBC, “TSA Changes Headwear Screening Policy”
PPPPRESS RESS RESS RESS RRRRELEASEELEASEELEASEELEASE
Sikhs Call for Sikhs Call for Sikhs Call for Sikhs Call for Integration of U.S. ArmyIntegration of U.S. ArmyIntegration of U.S. ArmyIntegration of U.S. Army
Sikh Recruits Lead Fight for the Right to ServeSikh Recruits Lead Fight for the Right to ServeSikh Recruits Lead Fight for the Right to ServeSikh Recruits Lead Fight for the Right to Serve
(Washington, DC) April 14, 2009 – Two Sikh military recruits called on the U.S. Army to end its ban on
religious turbans today. The men, both medical professionals in the Army, are being told that they must
remove their turbans and cut their unshorn hair and beards – all mandatory articles of the Sikh faith -
when they report for active duty in July.
Captain Kamaljit Singh Kalsi, a doctor, and Second Lieutenant Tejdeep Singh Rattan, a dentist, were
both assured by military recruiters that their turbans and unshorn hair “would not be a problem” when
they were recruited to join the Army’s Health Professions Scholarship Program. The program paid for
medical training in return for their military service.
Both men maintained their turbans throughout graduate school, during specialized Army training, at
Army ceremonies, and while working in military medical facilities. Now, the Army is telling the two
Sikhs that the recruiters’ assurances were false and that they will have to forsake their religious practices
if they want to serve.
The two recruits were joined today by representatives of the Sikh Coalition, a national civil rights
organization. The Coalition, along with the law firm of McDermott, Will & Emery, LLP, filed a formal
complaint this morning with the Department of the Army’s Inspector General. The complaint challenges
the decision to keep observant Sikhs out of the Army.
“I was shocked to learn that the Army would go back on its promise, and tell me I would have to give up
my faith in order to serve,” said Captain Kalsi. “There is nothing about my religion that stops me from
doing my job. I know I can serve well without compromising my faith.”
In 1981, the Army banned “conspicuous” religious articles of faith for its service members. However,
Sikhs and other soldiers of faith who were part of the army before the 1981 rule change were allowed to
stay. As a result, Colonel Arjinderpal Singh Sekhon, a doctor, and Colonel G.B. Singh, a dentist, have
been serving in the Army with their turbans and unshorn hair for the past twenty-five years. Both men
only retired within the last two years.
“Sikh Americans, like all Americans, should have the right to serve their country,” said Amardeep Singh, Executive Director of the Sikh Coalition. “In 1948, President Truman integrated our military. Today we are asking the Army to keep his promise of equal opportunities for all Americans.”
Sikhs have a long history of serving in armed forces throughout the world with their religious identity intact. A Sikh soldier served in the U.S. Army as far back as World War I. Thousands of Sikh soldiers helped liberate France in WWII. Today, Sikhs serve in the militaries of England, Canada, India and Austria, among others, often alongside American soldiers in Iraq and Afghanistan. To learn more, please visit our Campaign Action Center or email us at [email protected].
Over 60 years ago, President Harry Truman desegregated the U.S. Armed Forces. In his
Executive Order, he declared "there shall be equality of treatment and opportunity for all
persons in the armed forces without regard to race, color, religion or national origin." Today, Today, Today, Today,
President Truman’s promise is being broken President Truman’s promise is being broken President Truman’s promise is being broken President Truman’s promise is being broken - Sikh Americans who want to serve their
country are being refused the right to do so.
Although observant Sikhs have served in the United States Army since World War I, Army
policy has technically prohibited turbans since the early 1980s. Still, despite the policy
against them, some Sikhs want to commit their lives to serving our nation. It is now time for
us to honor their loyalty. We must ensure that the U.S. Army’s soldiers reflect the rich
diversity of this country.
Since the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, the Sikh Coalition has been working to
fight hatred, bias and discrimination against Sikhs who are misidentified as our nation’s
enemies. We have fought employment discrimination by companies ranging from AT&T to
Lexus. But when our own government forces Sikhs to choose between their religion or their
jobs, our indignance turns to hurt. If our government is excluding Sikhs, what kind of
example does it set for our citizens?
Some might argue that this is nothing more than a uniform requirement. However, for
centuries, Sikhs’ turbans and beards have been an intrinsic part of their identity. In 18th
century South Asia, the method of forcible conversions was to cut a Sikh’s hair and remove
his turban. Since then, these actions have been equivalent to denying Sikhs the right to
practice their faith. Our unshorn hair and turbans are not just articles of clothing, but the
essence of our identity, our spiritual uniform.
Sikh soldiers and officers have served in armies across the globe, fought bravely in wars, and
have achieved the highest levels of military distinction. Sikhs served as part of the Allied
Forces in both World Wars and helped to liberate France. Today, we serve in the militaries of
America’s allies, including Great Britain, Canada, India, and as United Nations
peacekeepers. Sikhs’ turbans and unshorn hair have never been an impediment to their
service. Today, when our country’s forces could use all the help they can get, how does it
make sense to keep out Americans who are willing and able to serve?
“Sikh Americans, like all Americans, should have the right to serve their country,” said
Amardeep Singh, Executive Director of the Sikh Coalition. “In 1948, President Truman
integrated our military. Today we are asking the Army to keep his promise of equal
opportunity for all Americans.”
PPPPRESS RESS RESS RESS SSSSTATEMENTTATEMENTTATEMENTTATEMENT
Captain Kamaljeet Singh Kalsi, Riverdale, New Jersey
I come from a long line of military men. For four generations,
my family has been fighting for their country, whether it was as
part of the troops of the British Empire or the Indian Army.
Though my parents left their country decades ago, I want to
keep our tradition of military service alive here in my home.
I have trained in my profession as a medical doctor thanks to the
assistance I received from the U.S. Army. Now, I want to make
sure that I give back to the country and the people who have
invested so much in me. At a time when our troops need as
much help as they can get, I cannot understand why the Army
would want to keep me from serving.
Today, I have children of my own. As a father, I hope that they achieve all their hopes
and dreams. And as an American, I hope they never have to choose between their religion
and their country.
Second Lieutenant Tejdeep Singh Rattan, New York, NY
I was not born in the United States, but this is my home and I am
an American. Our country was built by people like me, from
different parts of the globe, from different races and religions. All
of us came here trusting in the core principle of equality. That is
the same right I am asking for today.
As an immigrant, I hope that my desire to serve in the Army
shows my commitment to my country. I am willing to lay down my life for America. In
return, I ask only that my country respect my faith, an integral part of who I am. My
turban and beard are not an option – they are an intrinsic part of me.
I have been looking forward to my service since I first signed up. It is deeply unfair that
the Army is now asking me to choose between my religion or my country. I know I can
serve well without compromising my faith, just as thousands of Sikhs before me have
done.
CCCCLIENT LIENT LIENT LIENT SSSSTATEMENTSTATEMENTSTATEMENTSTATEMENTS
Dr. Robert M. Gates
Secretary of Defense
1000 Defense Pentagon
Washington, DC 20301-1000
April 14, 2009
Dear Secretary Gates,
We write today to urge you lift the effective ban on members of the Sikh faith from joining the United
States Military. Each of our organizations believes that as Americans, those willing and able to serve in
defense of their country should be permitted to do so.
Since 1981, Sikhs who practice the mandates of their faith in keeping unshorn hair and beards and
wearing turbans have been barred from admission to the armed forces. While federal laws have
sometimes been interpreted to allow members of other faiths to wear religious headwear, Sikhs have
not been included. In addition, while the Army provides for men who must keep beards for medical
reasons to do so, beards mandated by faith are not permitted. The Army’s policies are forcing Sikhs
who want to serve their country to choose between their religion and their service. This practice
undermines the core values of equality, justice, liberty, and religious freedom that have long been
enshrined in the United States Constitution.
In the last few months, two Sikh health professionals, Captain Kamaljeet S. Kalsi and Second
Lieutenant Tejdeep S. Rattan, have been refused the right to continue serving the Army while
complying with the mandates of their faith. This is despite the fact that both men were both recruited
and commissioned – with their Sikh articles of faith – during their respective first years of medical and
dental school (2001 and 2006) through the Army’s Health Professions Scholarship Program. Both are
concluding their training and are slated to begin active duty in July 2009. However, the U.S. Army is
now disputing their ability to serve with their Sikh identity intact.
Captain Kalsi and Second Lieutenant Rattan’s commitment to their articles of faith must be seen in
context. Historically, uncut hair and turbans have been central features of the Sikh identity. For
example, in the 18th century, Sikhs in South Asia were persecuted and forced to convert from their
religion; the method of forcing conversions was to remove a Sikh’s turban and cut off his hair. Since
then, denying a Sikh the right to wear a turban and maintain unshorn hair is perceived as the most
humiliating physical injury that can be inflicted upon a Sikh.
For centuries, Sikh soldiers and officers have served in armies across the globe, fought bravely in wars,
and have achieved the highest levels of military distinction. Captain Kalsi himself is the fourth
generation in his family to serve in the military. His forebears served honorably in India’s military, and
Captain Kalsi joined the U.S. Army with the intent to continue the family tradition. Sikhs also served
as part of the Allied Forces in both World Wars. Sikhs currently serve in the militaries of Great
Britain, Sweden, Canada, Pakistan and India. As United Nations peacekeepers, Sikh troops often work
hand in hand with U.S. forces. Until their retirement last year, a Sikh doctor and dentist served in the
U.S. Army, grandfathered in under the old policy. In all cases, Sikhs’ turbans, unshorn hair, and beards
have never been an impediment to their service.
We urge you to rethink the existing policy that would bar Sikhs like Captain Kalsi and Second
Lieutenant Rattan from joining the thousands of men and women who serve in our armed forces.
We thank you for your consideration of this matter.
Sincerely,
The Sikh Coalition
OneAmerica
International Justice Network
Anti-Defamation League
The Union of Orthodox Jewish Congregations of America
Veterans and Servicemembers Project, Urban Justice Center
The Arab-American Family Support Center
National Council of Jewish Women
Americans for Religious Liberty
NAACP
The American Civil Liberties Union
Interfaith Alliance
Sikh Research Institute
American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee (ADC)
Military Law Task Force
Gurdwara Sahib Hayward
Sikhs in England' (SIE)
The Becket Fund for Religious Liberty
Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR)
Asian American Justice Center
Arab American Institute
Sikh Students Association at the University of Connecticut
South Asian Bar Association of Northern California
The Penn Sikh Organization (University of Pennsylvania)
Wing Luke Asian Museum
International Institute of Gurmat Studies, Inc.
Darbar-E-Khalsa
Institute of Gurmat Studies, (Regd.)
Sikh Council on Religion and Education
Chief Khalsa Diwan-Mumbai Unit
Khalsa Peace Corps
Sikh Sports Association of USA
South Asian Youth Action (SAYA!)
Center for Constitutional Rights
Asian Law Caucus
Sikh Communications Council
GW Sikh Students' Association
Sikh Society of Michigan (Madison Heights Gurdwara Sahib)
South Asian Americans Leading Together (SAALT) *
Western Region Office 39465 Paseo Padre Parkway · Suite 3550
Fremont · California · 94538
(510) 659-0900 (o)
(510) 659-0903 (f)
National Office 40 Exchange Place · Suite 728
New York · New York · 10005 (212) 655-3095 (o) (212) 208-4611 (f)
Sikhs wear an external uniform to unify and bind them to the beliefs of the religion and to remind
them of their commitment to the Sikh Gurus at all times. Unlike some other faiths where only the
clergy are in uniform, all Sikhs are enjoined to wear the uniform of their beliefs. These five arti-
cles of faith, along with a turban, distinguish a Sikh and are essential for preserving the life of
the community. Naturally, for Sikhs these religious articles have deep spiritual significance; and
some practical as well. The five articles of faith start with the "ka" character in Punjabi, and are
thereby referred to as the 5 K's in English.
Kes (unshorn hair)Kes (unshorn hair)Kes (unshorn hair)Kes (unshorn hair)
Guru Nanak, the founder of the Sikh faith, started the practice of keeping
hair unshorn because keeping it in a natural state is regarded as living in
harmony with the will of God. The turban is part of the uniform because it
has immense spiritual and temporal significance. Wearing a turban declares
sovereignty, dedication, self-respect, courage and piety. All practicing Sikhs
wear the turban out of love and as a mark of commitment to the faith. Kangha (comb)Kangha (comb)Kangha (comb)Kangha (comb)
Sikhs wear a small comb called the Kangha in their hair. The social con-
text in which Sikhism arose, matted hair were worn by Hindu ascetics
who had renounced the world. The Kangha in the Sikh’s hair serves as a
constant reminder that the Sikh must remain socially committed and
never practice asceticism. Kara (steel bracelet)Kara (steel bracelet)Kara (steel bracelet)Kara (steel bracelet)
The bracelet is generally made out of steel. It is worn to remind a Sikh that he
or she is a servant of the Guru and should not do anything that may bring
shame or disgrace. Kirpan (sword)Kirpan (sword)Kirpan (sword)Kirpan (sword)
The Kirpan is a religious sword that encapsulates an initiated Sikh's solemn obligation
of courage and self-defense. It denotes dignity and self-reliance, the ca-
pacity and readiness to always defend the weak and the oppressed. It
helps sustain one's martial spirit and the determination to sacrifice one-
self in order to defend truth, oppression and Sikh moral values. All Initiated Sikhs are
mandated to wear a Kirpan on their body.
Kachhehra (soldier's shorts)Kachhehra (soldier's shorts)Kachhehra (soldier's shorts)Kachhehra (soldier's shorts)
A special, slightly longer type of shorts, the Kachhehra is linked to a high
moral character and must be worn at all times. It reminds the Sikh of the
need for self-restrain over passions and desires.
www.SikhCoalition.org
SSSSIKHIKHIKHIKH A A A ARTICLESRTICLESRTICLESRTICLES OFOFOFOF F F F FAITHAITHAITHAITH
The The The The Sikh CoalitionSikh CoalitionSikh CoalitionSikh Coalition’s’s’s’s Mission Statement Mission Statement Mission Statement Mission Statement
The Sikh Coalition is a community-based organization that works towards the realization of civil
and human rights for all people. In particular, we work towards a world where Sikhs may freely
practice and enjoy their faith while fostering strong relations with their local community
wherever they may be.
We pursue our mission by:
• Providing direct legal services to persons whose civil or human rights are violated;
• Advocating for law and policies that are respectful of fundamental rights;
• Promoting appreciation for diversity through education; and
• Fostering civic engagement in order to promote local community empowerment
With a full-time staff of 8 and offices in New York City and Fremont, CA, we are the most-staffed
Sikh organization in the history of the United States.
The The The The Sikh CoalitionSikh CoalitionSikh CoalitionSikh Coalition’s’s’s’s History History History History
The Coalition Is BornThe Coalition Is BornThe Coalition Is BornThe Coalition Is Born
The Sikh Coalition was born in the aftermath of bigotry, violence and discrimination against the
city’s Sikh population following the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001. We began as a
volunteer effort on the night of September 11, 2001, when an elderly Sikh and two teenagers
were violently attacked in Richmond Hill, Queens in “reprisal” attacks by fellow Americans. The
group that became the Sikh Coalition issued a press release the next day under the
organizational title “Coalition of Sikh Organizations of New York” condemning the terrorist
attacks and calling on police to better protect our neighborhoods.
Our DevelopmentOur DevelopmentOur DevelopmentOur Development
Since September 11, 2001, our work to humanize our community has been difficult given the
predominant association in this city and country of the turban and beard with terrorism. We
have provided direct legal services to seventy-one victims of hate crimes, twenty-nine victims of
airport profiling, and twenty-one Sikhs who were prosecuted for carrying the kirpan, a Sikh
article of faith. Over seventy percent of these cases come from New York, the rest are selectively
chosen from around the country when victims requesting assistance have no other means of
support. We leveraged the NYC Department of Education to pass the ‘Respect for All’ regulation
which protects over 1.1 million students. We also rolled back the Transportation Security
Administration’s policy of profiling turbans in U.S. airports.
Sikh Sikh Sikh Sikh Coalition Mission & HistoryCoalition Mission & HistoryCoalition Mission & HistoryCoalition Mission & History
Many of us have seen Sikhs and even worked alongside them without realizing who they are, what they believe, and how they live. We may even have confused them for Arabs, Muslims or Hindus. We may have wondered about these men who wear colorful turbans over long uncut hair. Sikhs are not new to North America. Their first recorded presence in Canada dates from 1897, over a hundred years ago; their first place of worship (gurdwara) in the United States was established in California in 1906. Sikhs helped construct the Panama Canal in 1904. Sikhism is now one of the five largest religions of the world. Over 500,000 Americans and 150,000 Canadians acknowledge Sikhism as their religion. There is a significant Sikh community in almost every major city in the United States and Canada, with over 100 Sikh places of worship and Community Centers. Some of the best farmers and lumber workers in California and British Columbia are Sikh. There are Sikh blue collar workers and taxi drivers; there are Sikh executives, research scientists and stock brokers in contemporary North American society. There has been a Sikh Congressman in the United States. In Canada Sikhs serve as members of Parliament and as members of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police.
History and BeliefsHistory and BeliefsHistory and BeliefsHistory and Beliefs CCCCompared to other major religions, Sikhism is relatively young. Its founder Guru Nanak was born in 1469 in Punjab. It was a time of great ferment and creative activity in the world — the voyage of Columbus and his discovery of the New World in 1492, the discoveries of Copernicus who was born in 1473, the printing of the Gutenberg Bible in 1462 were among the many remarkable achievements and events of those decades. To understand his teachings and his disciples, it is necessary to look at Nanak the man and his times. During Guru Nanak's time in the fifteenth century the two great religious systems of the world - the Vedantic and the traditions of the Old Testament met in Punjab. Fifteenth century India was ruled by Moslems. Indian society of that time was steeped in idol worship, dogma and superstition, and was stratified into castes with rigidly defined duties and rights for each. Neither those of the low castes nor women were allowed to read the Holy Scriptures. Nanak rejected both the forced conversions by the rulers as well as the caste system, idolatry and the inferior place of women. He taught a message of love. He defined God as gender-free, not woman or man exclusively. He taught of a universal God, common to all mankind – not a Sikh God, a Hindu God, a Moslem God, a Jewish or a Buddhist God, or one limited to any sect, nation, race, creed, color or gender. Guru Nanak was followed by nine successor-Gurus over two centuries. They further elaborated on his message of universal love and brotherhood - and sisterhood. They made significant contributions to the development of Sikh institutions. Sikhs believe that all ten Gurus represented the spirit of Nanak and spoke with his authority. The Sikh religion is strictly monotheistic, believing in one supreme God, free of gender, absolute, all pervading, eternal Creator. This universal God of love is obtained through grace, sought by service to mankind. These were the first teachings of Guru Nanak. Sikhism views life not as a fall from grace but a unique opportunity to discover and develop the divinity in each of us. From the time of Guru Nanak five hundred years ago until today, Sikh places of worship (gurdwaras) all over the world usually run free community kitchens, which provide meals to the needy. These kitchens are manned and funded by volunteers. Since in the traditional Indian society people of high and low caste would not mix, nor would they break bread together, the community kitchen (langar) of the Sikhs serves to teach the concept of equality by shattering all barriers of caste and class.
SIKHS IN NORTH AMERICA
Since human dignity and justice form a cornerstone of Sikh teaching, Sikh history speaks of tremendous sacrifice in the cause of freedom and justice. Two Sikh Gurus – the fifth Guru Arjan and the ninth Guru Tegh Bahadur were martyrs to the cause of freedom of religion. The tenth Nanak – Guru Gobind Singh – fought several battles and saw his sons die in battle. In more modern times, Sikhs formed some of the most highly decorated soldiers of the British armed services during the Second World War. They had a significant role in the memorable battles of El Alamein, in the Burma- China front and also in the allied assault in Italy.
April 14, 1699 April 14, 1699 April 14, 1699 April 14, 1699 IIIIn 1699 the tenth and last of the human Sikh Gurus – Gobind Singh – recognized the growing maturity of his followers in a most dramatic manner. On the day of Vaisakhi (which falls in early to mid-April) 1699, he summoned his followers to a small town (Anandpur) in Punjab. Over 80,000 came. History tells us that Guru Gobind Singh appeared before his people, flashed a naked sword and demanded a head. He repeated his call until five Sikhs volunteered. These five came from different parts of India and from different castes, three were from the so-called lower castes. The Guru initiated these five in the new order of the Khalsa and then, in a dramatic and historic gesture, they, in turn, initiated him. On that day he gave the Sikhs their modern form which includes five articles of faith: 1) unshorn hair as a gift of God and Guru and a mark of Sikh identity, 2) a small comb for the hair, 3) a steel bracelet which signifies a reality with no beginning and no end, and is also symbolic of a Sikh’s
commitment to the ideals of his faith, much as wedding ring might indicate fealty and identity, 4) a sword indicative of resolve and commitment to justice, and 5) knee-length breeches in keeping with the disciplined life-style of a Sikh. For the past 300 years, no matter what their street attire, male Sikhs have been easily recognized by their long unshorn hair covered with a turban. (It needs to be pointed out that in the traditional Indian society, only a man of high caste or the ruling class wore a turban.) Sikh women adhere to the same basic life style, symbols, rules and conduct, except that few wear turbans. You might see Sikh boys, who are much too young to handle a turban, walking about in their schools or play grounds with a top-knot of long unshorn hair covered simply with a scarf. SikhSikhSikhSikh----Americans and the Aftermath of SeptemAmericans and the Aftermath of SeptemAmericans and the Aftermath of SeptemAmericans and the Aftermath of September 11, 2001 ber 11, 2001 ber 11, 2001 ber 11, 2001 Sikh-Americans wish to express their deep sorrow and outrage at the terrorist attacks in the United States. Sikh-Americans condemn the senseless violence and aggression that has taken so many lives and shaken many more. Sadly, the violence continues. More than 200 innocent Sikh-American men, women and children have been attacked in the aftermath of the World Trade Center tragedy on September 11. On September 15, in Mesa, AZ, a gunman shot and killed the owner of a gas station, presumably because he wore the religious Sikh turban and beard. The gunman associated the victim with terrorists who are of an unrelated religion. Since September 11, 2001 the Sikh Coalition has received over 500 reports of bias against Sikhs on its website. At a time when Sikh-Americans most need to support those affected by the tragedy, they are burdened with additional concern for the safety of their children and themselves. This kind of misplaced racial and ethnic victimization – of Sikhs, Hindus, Muslims, Buddhists and indeed people of all faiths and colors – must not be allowed. The Sikh-American community invites all Americans to join them in bringing about mutual understanding and deep respect for the many ways in which humanity expresses its faith and individuality. For reports on bias incidents against Sikh-Americans please go to www.sikhcoalition.org.
SIKHS IN NORTH AMERICA, pg. 2
ColoColoColoColonel Arjinderpal Singh Sekhon nel Arjinderpal Singh Sekhon nel Arjinderpal Singh Sekhon nel Arjinderpal Singh Sekhon
(Retired(Retired(Retired(Retired)))) Served in the U.S. Army for 25 years from 1984 Served in the U.S. Army for 25 years from 1984 Served in the U.S. Army for 25 years from 1984 Served in the U.S. Army for 25 years from 1984
until January 2009. He is a Desert Storm veteran until January 2009. He is a Desert Storm veteran until January 2009. He is a Desert Storm veteran until January 2009. He is a Desert Storm veteran and served in Iraq.and served in Iraq.and served in Iraq.and served in Iraq.
Colonel G.B. SinghColonel G.B. SinghColonel G.B. SinghColonel G.B. Singh (Retired) (Retired) (Retired) (Retired)
Served in the U.S. Army for 28 years from 1Served in the U.S. Army for 28 years from 1Served in the U.S. Army for 28 years from 1Served in the U.S. Army for 28 years from 1979 until 979 until 979 until 979 until July 2007. He served in South Korea and various July 2007. He served in South Korea and various July 2007. He served in South Korea and various July 2007. He served in South Korea and various
locations within the U.S.locations within the U.S.locations within the U.S.locations within the U.S.
In the Region
Long Island, Westchester,Connecticut and New Jersey
Go to Complete Coverage »
JERSEY
Turbans Make Targets, Some Sikhs Find
Sikhs worshiping at their gurdwara in Woodbridge.
By KEVIN COYNE
Published: June 15, 2008
Woodbridge
THE men sat barefoot and cross-
legged on the thick burgundy carpet in
the cavernous old supermarket where
they worship, singing hymns in Punjabi
as they faced the palki, the golden canopy that sheltered
the sacred text of the Sikh faith. Most of them wore the
turbans they wear everywhere, but some wore the bandanas they wear only here, their
choice a measure of the cost of life in a new land.
To wear a turban in America — even in a state that has absorbed as many waves of
immigration as New Jersey has — is to subject yourself to judgment by strangers, not all of
whom have warm and fuzzy feelings about diversity.
“You get these looks all the time, especially after Sept. 11,” said Rajinder Singh, 57, who
holds two doctorates, works as a chemist for a pharmaceutical company, has never cut his
hair, following the requirement of his faith, and wears a turban. “You could see people —
their lips inside their car — that this person is swearing at me.”
Muslims have absorbed much discrimination in the United States in recent years, but also
caught in the crossfire have been Sikhs, members of a religious minority from India whose
men happen to wear a similar head covering, and who have endured similar suspicions
since the terrorist attacks and the subsequent wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.
“We have to remind them again and again,” said Hardayal Singh Johal, 68, a mechanical
engineer who came to the United States in 1971 and is now chairman of the planning board
in neighboring Carteret, home to the largest concentration of Sikhs in the state. “We are
more than a thousand times against terrorism and we do anything to stop it. Period.”
Advertise on NYTimes.com
Go to Complete List »
More Articles in New York Region »
Keep up with the latest news from Washington with the daily
Politics e-mail newsletter.
See Sample | Privacy Policy
Politics E-Mail
MOST POPULAR
America’s Outback: Southern Utah1.
Austere Times? Perfect2.
Music: Bring Out Your Dead3.
36 Hours in Palm Springs, Calif.4.
Paul Krugman: Making Banking Boring5.
Op-Ed Contributor: Finding Our Way Back to Lent6.
Judith Warner: This I Believe7.
Personal Health: Flying Healthy, From Takeoff Past
Landing
8.
Showdown Seen Between Banks and Regulators9.
Gail Collins: The Obama Holiday Tour10.
nytimes.com/health
Are you feeling recession anxiety?Also in Health:
State of the economy affects the state of mind
When all you have left is your pride
Raising grandchildren in a recession
N.Y. / Region
All NYT
In the Region
WORLD U.S. N.Y. / REGION BUSINESS TECHNOLOGY SCIENCE HEALTH SPORTS OPINION ARTS STYLE TRAVEL JOBS REAL ESTATE AUTOS
THE CITY IN THE REGION
SIGN IN TO E-MAIL OR
SAVE THIS
REPRINTS
SHARE
BLOGGED SEARCHEDE-MAILED
HOME PAGE MY TIMES TODAY'S PAPER VIDEO MOST POPULAR TIMES TOPICS Get Home Delivery Log In Register Now
Get Started No, thanksWelcome to
TimesPeopleWhat’s this?
TimesPeople Lets You Share and Discover the Best of NY... 8:15 PM
Jersey - Turbans Make Targets, Some Sikhs Find - NYTimes.com http://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/15/nyregion/nyregionspecial2/15colnj.html
1 of 3 4/11/2009 8:15 PM
Categories
U.S. news
World news
Business
Politics
Sports
Entertainment
Health
Tech & science
Travel
News
Tips
Destinations
Deals
Seasonal
Cruising
Active
Family
Business travel
Luxury
Travel photos
Local news
Weather
Browse
Video
Photos
Disable Fly-out
Marketplace
Credit Score $0
at CreditReport.com
Scottrade
$7 online trades
Start a business
Entrepreneur.com
Dr. Oz's Secret:
Anti-Aging Pill
Shopping Deals
Coupon Offers!
MSN Home | Mail More Sign In
featuring Today Show Nightly News Dateline Meet the Press MSNBC TV NBC Sports
Search America's #1 News Site
Excursion Exam
Test your smarts
Test your travel IQ with the weekly
quiz.
TSA changes headwear screening policyAir travelers not required to remove turbans, other bulky headwear
A revised federal guideline,effective Oct. 27, gives airportscreeners the option to pat downheadwear at the metal detector ifa passenger does not want toremove it for personal reasons.
Ann Johansson / AP file
updated 1:43 p.m. ET, Tues., Oct . 16, 2007
WASHINGTON - Air passengers will no longer
have to remove bulky headwear such as turbans
at screening checkpoints if doing so makes them
uncomfortable.
A revised federal guideline, effective Oct. 27,
gives airport screeners the option to pat down
headwear at the metal detector if a passenger
does not want to remove it for personal reasons.
In August, the Transportation Security
Administration changed its guidelines and
subjected travelers to secondary screening at
security checkpoints if they were wearing head
coverings, such as cowboy hats, berets or
turbans. The screenings could have included a
pat-down search of the head covering, if the
screener found it necessary.
But some religious organizations were outraged
at the new rule and felt it was a form of racial
profiling. For instance, in the Sikh religion, the
turban is considered private, and removing a
turban would be like removing a woman's
blouse, according to the New York-based Sikh
Coalition. Since 2001, federal policy has required
screeners to search turbans only if they do not
clear a metal detector.
TSA officials listened to these concerns, and now
passengers wearing bulky clothing — including
bulky headwear — can be subjected to a mix of
screening, such as pat-downs, X-ray devices and
portal machines that check for explosives. If an
item still cannot be ruled out as a potential
threat, the screener
still has the option to
request that the
passenger remove it
in a private screening
Top slideshows
Getty Images
Viva Las Vegas!
Sin City is a major
entertainment center and
business travel destination,
known for its carefully
cultivated image, gambling and
nightlife.
Getty Images
Doggies living in the lap
of luxury
Pet hotels offer deluxe
accommodations and pamper
your pooch while you’re away.
Getty Images
Glorious Greece
See all that the country has to
offer, from ancient sites
steeped in history and religion
to modern-day attractions that
awe and relax.
Most popular
Most viewed Top rated Most e-mailed
10 surprising sex statistics
U.S. ship reaches Kenyan port, minus
captain
AP: More POW claimants than actual POWs
N.H. burglar apologizes, returns stolen goods
Dog eats baby goats, survives on remote island
Most viewed on msnbc.com
Travel News
TSA changes headwear screening policy - News- msnbc.com http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/21324817/
1 of 2 4/11/2009 8:21 PM