use of a deuterium technique to fluids ingested by … · summary deuteriumoxide (2h20) has...

9
Experimental Physiology (1999), 84, 391-399 Printed in Great Britain THE USE OF A DEUTERIUM TRACER TECHNIQUE TO FOLLOW THE FATE OF FLUIDS INGESTED BY HUMAN SUBJECTS: EFFECTS OF DRINK VOLUME AND TRACER CONCENTRATION AND CONTENT C. P. LAMBERT, D. BALL, J. B. LEIPER AND R. J. MAUGHAN * University Medical School, Foresterhill, Aberdeen AB25 2ZD, UK (MANUSCRIPT RECEIVED 27 AUGUST 1998, ACCEPTED 6 JANUARY 1999) SUMMARY Deuterium oxide (2H20) has been added to drinks as a tracer for water to estimate the availability to the body water pool of ingested fluids, but doubts have been raised as to the reliability of the method. The present investigation evaluated the effects of systematic variations in the volume of fluid consumed and the amount and concentration of added tracer on the rate of accumulation of tracer in arterialized blood after ingestion of a labelled drink. Three separate experiments were undertaken. In expt 1, six healthy men ingested on separate occasions 200, 400 and 800 ml of a dilute glucose-electrolyte solution: all test drinks contained the same concentration (40 g 1-') of 2H20. In expt 2, six healthy men ingested 200, 400 and 800 ml of the same glucose-electrolyte drink: each drink contained 8 g of 2H20 so that the concentration, but not the amount, of 2H20 differed between treatments. In expt 3, six healthy men ingested 400 ml of the same drink on three separate occasions: each drink contained 8, 16 or 32 g of tracer so that amount and concentration of 2H20 both varied. Arterialized venous blood samples were collected for the determination of deuterium (2H) concentration before ingestion of the test drink and at intervals for 120 min after ingestion. All trials for each of the experiments were conducted in the morning after an overnight fast and trials were in randomized order and separated by 7 days. In expt 1, the blood 2H concentration at all time points from 2 min after ingestion of the test drink onwards was higher for the drink containing 32 g 2H20 than for the drink containing 16 g 2H20, which in turn was higher than after ingestion of the drink containing 8 g of 2H20. In expt 2, no significant differences between treatments were observed at any time. In expt 3, the rate of 2H accumulation was greater after ingestion of the drink containing 32 g of 2H20 than after either of the other two drinks, and the 2H accumulation rate was greater after ingestion of the drink containing 16 g of 2H20 than after the drink containing 8 g of 2H20. When data from all three experiments were combined, significant correlations were observed between the rate of accumulation of 2H in the circulation (p.p.m. min-1) and the amount (r8 = 0.75, P < 0.001) and concentration (rs = 0 69, P < 0-001) of 2H20 in the test drink, but there was no relationship (rs = 0.09, P = 0-5) between the rate of 2H accumulation in the blood and the volume of the drink consumed. The results suggest that the rate of tracer accumulation in the blood after ingestion of different volumes of test drinks is not a reliable indication of the availability of the ingested fluid, but that the method gives at least a qualitative measure of the sum of the effects of gastric emptying and intestinal water absorption. INTRODUCTION Techniques that measure either gastric emptying or intestinal absorption have been used extensively to assess the fate of ingested fluids and to assess the efficacy of oral rehydration solutions intended for the treatment of diarrhoeal disease (Leiper & Maughan, 1988; Elliott, * Corresponding author: [email protected] 1826

Upload: others

Post on 15-Oct-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: USE OF A DEUTERIUM TECHNIQUE TO FLUIDS INGESTED BY … · SUMMARY Deuteriumoxide (2H20) has beenadded todrinks as a tracer for water estimate the availability to the body water pool

Experimental Physiology (1999), 84, 391-399Printed in Great Britain

THE USE OF A DEUTERIUM TRACER TECHNIQUE TOFOLLOW THE FATE OF FLUIDS INGESTED BY HUMAN

SUBJECTS: EFFECTS OF DRINK VOLUME ANDTRACER CONCENTRATION AND CONTENT

C. P. LAMBERT, D. BALL, J. B. LEIPER AND R. J. MAUGHAN *

University Medical School, Foresterhill, Aberdeen AB25 2ZD, UK

(MANUSCRIPT RECEIVED 27 AUGUST 1998, ACCEPTED 6 JANUARY 1999)

SUMMARY

Deuterium oxide (2H20) has been added to drinks as a tracer for water to estimate the availabilityto the body water pool of ingested fluids, but doubts have been raised as to the reliability of themethod. The present investigation evaluated the effects of systematic variations in the volume offluid consumed and the amount and concentration of added tracer on the rate of accumulation oftracer in arterialized blood after ingestion of a labelled drink. Three separate experiments wereundertaken. In expt 1, six healthy men ingested on separate occasions 200, 400 and 800 ml of adilute glucose-electrolyte solution: all test drinks contained the same concentration (40 g 1-') of2H20. In expt 2, six healthy men ingested 200, 400 and 800 ml of the same glucose-electrolytedrink: each drink contained 8 g of 2H20 so that the concentration, but not the amount, of 2H20differed between treatments. In expt 3, six healthy men ingested 400 ml of the same drink on threeseparate occasions: each drink contained 8, 16 or 32 g of tracer so that amount and concentrationof 2H20 both varied. Arterialized venous blood samples were collected for the determination ofdeuterium (2H) concentration before ingestion of the test drink and at intervals for 120 min afteringestion. All trials for each of the experiments were conducted in the morning after an overnightfast and trials were in randomized order and separated by 7 days. In expt 1, the blood 2Hconcentration at all time points from 2 min after ingestion of the test drink onwards was higher forthe drink containing 32 g 2H20 than for the drink containing 16 g 2H20, which in turn was higherthan after ingestion of the drink containing 8 g of 2H20. In expt 2, no significant differencesbetween treatments were observed at any time. In expt 3, the rate of 2H accumulation was greaterafter ingestion of the drink containing 32 g of 2H20 than after either of the other two drinks, andthe 2H accumulation rate was greater after ingestion of the drink containing 16 g of 2H20 thanafter the drink containing 8 g of 2H20. When data from all three experiments were combined,significant correlations were observed between the rate of accumulation of 2H in the circulation(p.p.m. min-1) and the amount (r8 = 0.75, P < 0.001) and concentration (rs = 0 69, P < 0-001) of2H20 in the test drink, but there was no relationship (rs = 0.09, P = 0-5) between the rate of 2Haccumulation in the blood and the volume of the drink consumed. The results suggest that the rateof tracer accumulation in the blood after ingestion of different volumes of test drinks is not areliable indication of the availability of the ingested fluid, but that the method gives at least aqualitative measure of the sum of the effects of gastric emptying and intestinal water absorption.

INTRODUCTION

Techniques that measure either gastric emptying or intestinal absorption have been usedextensively to assess the fate of ingested fluids and to assess the efficacy of oral rehydrationsolutions intended for the treatment of diarrhoeal disease (Leiper & Maughan, 1988; Elliott,

* Corresponding author: [email protected]

1826

Page 2: USE OF A DEUTERIUM TECHNIQUE TO FLUIDS INGESTED BY … · SUMMARY Deuteriumoxide (2H20) has beenadded todrinks as a tracer for water estimate the availability to the body water pool

C. P. LAMBERT, D. BALL, J. B. LEIPER AND R. J. MAUGHAN

1989) and of sports drinks used for the improvement of athletic performance (Lamb &Brodowicz, 1986; Murray, 1987). Each of these methods, however, can provide only part ofthe answer, and it is not clear whether the availability of ingested fluids is limited by the rate ofgastric emptying or by the rate of intestinal water uptake. A further disadvantage is thatalthough non-invasive methods are available, quantitative measurements require the use ofintubation methods. It also seems to be the case that the results obtained when using a multi-lumen perfusion set to make measurements of water absorption in the small intestine dependcritically on the precise location of the perfusion set and on the length of the test segment used(Shi et al. 1994).

It has been proposed that the addition of a tracer for water to orally ingested fluids and thesubsequent measurement of the accumulation rate of that tracer in body fluids will give ameasure of the integrated effects of gastric emptying and intestinal absorption and willprovide a useful measure of the availability of ingested solutions. Although a small amount oftracer exchange may occur between the stomach and the systemic circulation, the amount ofnet water uptake that occurs in the stomach is negligible (Scholer & Code, 1954), so bothgastric emptying and intestinal absorption must occur before the tracer appears in thecirculation. This method, using deuterated water (2H) as a tracer, has recently been used in anumber of studies in which drinks with different compositions have been compared (Davis etal. 1987) or in which the effects of exercise (Maughan et al. 1990) or differences in drinktemperature (Lambert & Maughan, 1992) on the fate of ingested fluid have been measured.Objections have been raised to the use of the tracer method as employed in the studies

referred to above, as water movement in the intestine is a bi-directional process, and tracerwill accumulate in the blood even when net secretion of water is occurring in the smallintestine (Gisolfi et al. 1990). Nonetheless, the results of Davis et al. (1987) who comparedsolutions of different composition were largely those that would have been expected from theknown gastric emptying and intestinal absorption characteristics of the solutions beingcompared. Gisolfi et al. (1992) also reported that results obtained using the tracer methodwere qualitatively similar to those obtained using a perfusion method to measure net waterflux in the proximal small intestine.The purpose of the present investigation was to further examine the use of the 2H tracer

method to study the availability of water from ingested fluids. Increasing the volume of fluid inthe stomach will increase the rate of gastric emptying, thus providing a higher rate of deliveryof both tracer and water to the small intestine (Costill & Saltin, 1974; Mitchell & Voss, 1989:Noakes et al. 1991 ). Increasing both the volume of labelled water in the small intestine and thetracer concentration should increase the rate of appearance of tracer in the circulation.

METHODS

Prior approval for this study was obtained from the local ethics committee and the experiments wereperformed according to the principles of the Declaration of Helsinki. Before participation, each subjectwas informed of the potential risks and stresses associated with participation, and written consent wasobtained. All subjects were healthy young men free from any history of gastrointestinal disease. Threeseparate experiments were undertaken, and all trials for each experiment took place after an overnightfast: trials were conducted 7 days apart and were administered in randomized order. The solutioningested for each treatment was a commercially available dilute glucose-electrolyte solution produced foruse in the treatment of diarrhoeal disease. The composition of the test drink (mmol 1-') was: glucose,200; sodium, 35; potassium, 20; chloride, 37; bicarbonate, 18; and the total osmolality of the solutionprior to the addition of the 2H20 tracer was 310 mosmol kg-'.

392

Page 3: USE OF A DEUTERIUM TECHNIQUE TO FLUIDS INGESTED BY … · SUMMARY Deuteriumoxide (2H20) has beenadded todrinks as a tracer for water estimate the availability to the body water pool

A TRACER METHOD FOR WATER ABSORPTION

On the morning of the experiment, the subject was seated comfortably and immersed one hand in watermaintained at a temperature of 42 °C for 10 min to allow arterialized venous blood samples to beobtained (Forster et al. 1972). A 21 g venous cannula was then placed in a superficial vein on the dorsalsurface of the heated hand and a 5 ml blood sample was obtained. The subject then ingested theexperimental drink as rapidly as possible. Further 5 ml arterialized venous blood samples were obtainedat 2, 5, 10, 20, 30, 45. 60, 90 and 120 min after the drink was consumed. Subjects remained seated withtheir hand immersed in water maintained at a temperature of 42 °C for the duration of the trial.Water (a mixture of H20, 2H20 and 2HHO) was separated from the blood samples by vacuum

distillation and 2H was measured by infra-red spectrophotometry as previously described (Lukaski &Johnson, 1985). All samples were analysed in duplicate. The deuterium accumulation rate was calculatedby linear regression of the blood concentration following ingestion of the test solution to the time ofmaximum concentration in the circulation. Blood 2H accumulation data for each of the experiments werecompared with a two-factor ANOVA with repeated measures on both treatment and time factors. Ratesof blood 2H accumulation over time within each of the studies were compared using a one-way ANOVAfor repeated measures. Separate Spearman's rank correlation coefficients (r,) were calculated to relate theslope values for blood 2H accumulation to the volume of drink consumed, to the 2H20 content and to the2H2O concentration in the drinks. After analysis with the appropriate ANOVA, the Newman-Keul's posthoc analysis was used to locate differences between pairs of means. Differences were consideredsignificant when they achieved a probability level of 0-05 or less.

Experiment 1Six men (age (mean + S.D.) 28 + 6 years, height 175 + 5 cm, mass 66-2 + 3-9 kg) participated in this

experiment. On three separate occasions, in randomized order and separated by 7 days, subjects ingesteda fixed volume of the glucose-electrolyte solution: the test drink volumes were 200 ml (LI), 400 ml (MI)and 800 ml (H 1). The concentration of 2H20 in all three drinks was the same (4 g (100 ml)-') so the totalamount ingested was 8 g for treatment LI, 16 g for treatment MI and 32 g for treatment H1.

Experiment 2Six men (age 23 + 2 years, height 177 + 6 cm, mass 73.3 + 9.4 kg) were subjects for this experiment.

Experimental conditions were the same as for expt 1, but the 2H20 content of each of the test drinks wasthe same (8 g). The volume consumed was 200 ml (L2), 400 ml (M2) or 800 ml (H2), so that the 2H20concentration in the drinks was different: 4 g (100 ml)-' in L2, 2 g (100 ml)-' in M2 and 1 g (100 ml)-in H2.

Experiment 3Subjects for this experiment were six men (age 31 + 7 years, height 171 + 4 cm, mass 67 8 + 6-1 kg).

Experimental conditions were the same as for the two preceding experiments except that the volume offluid consumed was constant (400 ml) in all trials. Solution L3 contained 8 g of 2H20 to give aconcentration of 2 g (100 ml)-'; solution M3 contained 16 g of 2H20 to give a concentration of4 g (100 ml)-', and solution H3 contained 32 g of 2H2O to give a concentration on 8 g (100 ml)-'.

RESULTS

Experiment ]

The blood 2H concentration increased rapidly on all treatments, and significant time(P < 0.001), treatment (P < 0001) and interaction (P <0.001) effects were observed.Significant differences between the three treatments in blood 2H concentrations were observedat all time points after the first 2 min sample point. The blood 2H concentration was higher ontrial HI, where 800 ml of drink containing 32 g of 2H20 was ingested, than on the other twotrials (Fig. 1) and was higher on MI (16 g 2H20 in 400 ml) than on LI (8 g in 200 ml). Thecalculated linear rate of blood 2H accumulation to peak concentration was significantly(P = 0.038) greater on trials HI (33 + 3 p.p.m. min-') and Ml (33 + 4 p.p.m. min-') than ontrial LI (16 + 5 p.p.m. min- ).

393

Page 4: USE OF A DEUTERIUM TECHNIQUE TO FLUIDS INGESTED BY … · SUMMARY Deuteriumoxide (2H20) has beenadded todrinks as a tracer for water estimate the availability to the body water pool

C. P. LAMBERT, D. BALL, J. B. LEIPER AND R. J. MAUGHAN

Time (minutes)

Fig. 1. Blood deuterium concentration (p.p.m.) after ingestion of a glucose-electrolyte drink containing 2H20 at aconcentration of 4 g (I100 ml)-': drinks were consumed in a volume of 200 ml (L1), 400 ml (Mi) and 800 ml (H1).Values are means +/- S.D. (n = 6).

c0.r-

CL-

0--U

0

0o0

0i11

o L2* M2A H2

0 20 40 60 80 100 120

Time (minutes)

Fig. 2. Blood deuterium concentration (p.p.m.) after ingestion of a glucose-electrolyte drink containing 8 g of 2H20:drinks were consumed in a volume of 200 ml (L2), 400 ml (M2) and 800 ml (H2). Values are means (n = 6), and thevariance is shown as the S.D. of the mean for the highest and lowest values for each time point.

Experiment 2No significant differences between the three trial conditions in blood 2H concentration were

found to exist at any time point (Fig. 2). The linear rates of blood 2H accumulation were thesame for trial L2 (11 + 2 p.p.m. min-'), M2 (11 + 4 p.p.m. min-1) and H2 (12 + 8 p.p.m. min-').

Experiment 3Significant time (P <0.001), treatment (P <0.0001) and interaction (P <0.0001) effects

were found to exist when the three experimental conditions were compared (Fig. 3). The blood2H concentration on trial H3 (32 g of 2H20 in 400 ml) was higher than on trial M3 (16 g of

394

c 1000

c 7500

0

E 00E c.= a

0

0 250

m000

0.

o Ll* MlA Hl

120

Page 5: USE OF A DEUTERIUM TECHNIQUE TO FLUIDS INGESTED BY … · SUMMARY Deuteriumoxide (2H20) has beenadded todrinks as a tracer for water estimate the availability to the body water pool

A TRACER METHOD FOR WATER ABSORPTION

0toA-

*-0

EEoa

ma00-0

0

0 20 40 60 80 100 120

Time (minutes)

Fig. 3. Blood deuterium concentration (p.p.m.) after ingestion of 400 ml of a glucose-electrolyte drink containing 2H20 ata concentration of 2 g (100 ml)-' (L3), 4 g (100 ml)-' (M3) or 8 g (100 ml)- (H3). Values are means +/ S.D. (n = 6).

80-

0

60-E

E E

C00 0.

0

m 0 4 8 12 16 20 24 28 32

Amount of deuterium oxide ingested (g)

Fig. 4. Combined data from expts 1, 2 and 3 showing the relationship between the blood 2H accumulation rate and theamount of 2H20 present in the test drink. Boxplots show median, first and third quartiles, and maximum and minimumvalues.

2H 0 in 400 ml) at all time points after the first 5 min of sampling, and values on trial M3were higher than on L3 (8 g of 2H20 in 400 ml) at all times after 2 min. Slope values weregreater on H3 (59 + 5 p.p.m. min-1) than on M3 (23 + 2 p.p.m. min-1) or L3(I19 + 3 p.p.m. min 1).When the results of all the data are compared, significant correlations were observed to exist

between the blood 2H accumulation rate and the amount (r, = 0 75, P < 0-001; Fig. 4) and theconcentration (rs = 0-69, P < 0-001; Fig. 5) of 2H20 in the test drink. No relationship wasseen between the rate of blood 2H accumulation and the volume of drink consumed(7^s = 0-09; P = 0*50; Fig. 6).

1,

14

o L3

* M3A H3

395

Page 6: USE OF A DEUTERIUM TECHNIQUE TO FLUIDS INGESTED BY … · SUMMARY Deuteriumoxide (2H20) has beenadded todrinks as a tracer for water estimate the availability to the body water pool

C. P. LAMBERT, D. BALL, J. B. LEIPER AND R. J. MAUGHAN

0

60-E

E E 40-

~ 0.

20-*00

00

on o IT

o 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

Deuterium concentration (gl)Oml)

FiT. 5. Coiibiliied data l1-o111 expts 1, 2 and 3 shosinmg the rel;ationship between the blood 2H acCiLmulalion rate and theconcenltration of 2H20 present in the test drinik. Boxplots show median, tirst and tllrd quiartiles, andiinilxiniiLiln andmiinimumI11 valIUeS.

80-C0

.~60-

E 40-EE

20.

0 20*0

Fn 00 100 200 0 0 0 0 0 0

Fig. 6. Comiblined data From e\pts 1, 2 aind 3 showsing the relattoionship betw en the blood 2 H aCCUMUlation -late and theVoIlume of'test dIiniik Con1SUmed. Bosxplots sliow niediani, fit st anid thu id qiiat tileS, anid ImaXIMum1 and 11tt1iiniin1i VaILoeS.

DISCU SS ION

Yhe re.sults Of tile thl-ee stLidies reportedC heCe sLiggest iat the rate ot 2H .accuiMIilation inarterial ized blood after ingestioin of a drinlk label led x ith 2H11O is relaltd to the aMnounl oftlracer inestecd .ancl to its concentlattiAton in the drink., but thait Wxhere these felctors are Constanl itis tiot affected bx the xolun3e of fluid ingested. This infdicattes thIil, wlhere tIhe deutel-iun tracerit3ethlOd is to bc Ltsedl 1() assess the [Ltte of' ilrt'eStCCl luLidCS, tIhe aLt]OLtnt andI CoenC lralion0 Of'tl aeCr- Used 1niLt1st bC conlstaniit if' vid results are to be obtaltned. BeCause it is nOt Possible to1\eCep both1 ol t1l]sc Ihctors conlStlat W111en tIlh xVoluneC xILaies, tilh dleuLtcl-eium-l tl-racer- lictllodca-Ltinot be uLsecd to compae- responses to the illnestioll of' Ciflenl-llt Cikllk xVol1neCs.CM(o)Mat111-1 theC tsults o1' eX\pts a1ntld 2 it is apparlllent thaIt, wh1en the trrlac concentralttio is

nailit;1attied aIt aL cotistait cvel LbUt the xVol ttvteof ILlCid ingestetd is xVaiied (expt ) the rate of

3936

Page 7: USE OF A DEUTERIUM TECHNIQUE TO FLUIDS INGESTED BY … · SUMMARY Deuteriumoxide (2H20) has beenadded todrinks as a tracer for water estimate the availability to the body water pool

A TRACER METHOD FOR WATER ABSORPTION

appearance of the tracer in the circulation follows the pattern expected: as the gastricemptying rate increases with increasing volume ingested, so the rate of accumulation in thecirculation increases. The tracer concentration in all test drinks was the same, so an increasedrate of appearance suggests that the rate of water absorption in the small intestine isdetermined largely by the rate of gastric emptying. However, when the volume of fluidsingested is varied in the same way but the total tracer content is the same (resulting in adecreasing tracer concentration as the volume of fluid ingested increases; expt 2), there is norelationship between the volume of test drink ingested and the rate of tracer accumulation inthe circulation, despite the faster rate of emptying that would be expected as the volumeingested was increased. The decreased rate of intestinal tracer absorption because of the lowertracer concentration has counterbalanced the effects of an increased volume and thus anincreased surface area for absorption.

In expt 3, in which the volume of fluid ingested was the same on all trials and the samesubjects were used on each occasion, it is reasonable to expect that the rate of gastric emptyingshould have been the same on each of the three trials. The composition of the test drink wasalso the same on each occasion, so the rate of water uptake should be the same. There havebeen rather few published studies in which the day-to-day variability in these processes hasbeen reported, but one study suggested that the daily variability for gastric emptying wasabout 29 % (Beckers et al. 1991) and another study reported 31 % daily variability for thesteady state segmental jejunal perfusion technique (Leiper & Maughan, 1988). The results ofexpt 3 follow the expected pattern: when the rate of delivery of a labelled solution of constantcomposition to the small intestine is also constant, the rate of appearance in the circulation ofthe added tracer is closely related to the tracer concentration.

In most of the experimental situations where the deuterium tracer method has been used,solutions of different composition have been compared. The test drinks chosen for thesestudies, including those of Davis et al. (1987) and Rehrer et al. (1992), were known to bedifferent in their rates both of gastric emptying and of intestinal absorption. Indeed, thepurpose of using this method, rather than measuring either of those processes separately, is todetermine the integrated response. Rehrer et al. (1992) measured gastric emptying and blooddeuterium accumulation rates simultaneously after ingestion of drinks of differentcomposition, and found a reasonably good (r= 0-627; P <0.01) agreement between themeasured rate of gastric emptying and the rate of 2H accumulation in the blood. There was notgood agreement between the rate of blood deuterium accumulation for the different drinksand the measured rates of net water absorption in the small intestine, but 2H uptake wasmeasured during exercise and intestinal absorption was measured at rest on a separateoccasion.

In spite of the evidence to show that the tracer accumulation method produces results thatare in broad agreement with predictions made on the basis of the known gastric emptying andintestinal water absorption characteristics of the test drinks compared, doubts have been raisedas to the usefulness of this technique (Gisolfi et al. 1990). In the study of Gisolfi et al. (1990),the net rate of water flux in a segment of the small intestine was measured using a triple lumenperfusion method while three diff'erent solutions were perfused at a fixed rate; the test solutionswere distilled water, .a 600 carbohydrate- electrolyte solution and a 10)% glucose solution.Deuteiium was a-dded as a tracer to tall the test solutions. No difieirence between the differentsolutions in the rate of' blood 2H accumulation was fbound, although ther-e were, aLis expected,differences between solutions in the rate of net water absorption meeasured usinCg the perfus]ionmethod: a net secretioin of' water flux in this segment of- the intestine was promoted by the

397

Page 8: USE OF A DEUTERIUM TECHNIQUE TO FLUIDS INGESTED BY … · SUMMARY Deuteriumoxide (2H20) has beenadded todrinks as a tracer for water estimate the availability to the body water pool

C. P. LAMBERT, D. BALL, J. B. LEIPER AND R. J. MAUGHAN

concentrated glucose solution, but there was nevertheless an increase in the blood tracerconcentration. The tracer method, of course, is a measure of unidirectional water flux only,and water can move freely in both directions across the mucosal wall. The bidirectional fluxesof water are large relative to the net absorption rate and suggest that minor changes in eitherinflux or efflux rates can result in considerable changes in net transport. The authors concludedthat the rate of appearance of a 2H tracer added to solutions present in the small intestine doesnot give a reliable measure of the net water movement.These results, however, do not provide adequate grounds for rejecting the use of this method

as it has beern applied in other studies. In reply to a query regarding this study the authorsindicated that while unidirectional flux of deuterium out of the jejunal lumen occurred fromall three solutions, the relative flux rates followed a pattern which was consistent with themeasured net water movement from these solutions (Gisolfi et al. 1992). It is possible that theflux of deuterium from such a large, constant supply of tracer masked the difference whichcan be detected in the blood accumulation rate when a single bolus of labelled drink isconsumed. The use of a continuous infusion into a short segment of the small intestine of atest solution with a constant tracer concentration does not reflect the situation that exists afteringestion of a single bolus of a test drink of the same composition. Solute and water fluxes willvary greatly along the length of the small intestine, and the short (40 cm in the study of Gisolfiet al. 1990) segment through which the test solution is perfused may not be representative ofthe situation that exists when the whole length of the gut is available for exchange (Rolston etal. 1990). After ingestion of a single bolus of a labelled solution, the concentration gradientfrom lumen to mucosa will decrease as the tracer is absorbed. The composition of the luminalcontents, with regard to the content of actively absorbed solutes and electrolytes, will alsochange over time, but the perfusion method does not allow for the effects of these changes toinfluence the measured absorption rates: fresh perfusate is added at the top end of the segmentperfused and unabsorbed solution is removed at the end of the test segment. Given theseconstraints on the interpretation of data obtained using the perfusion method, the criticisms ofthe technique implied by the results of this study may not be valid.

In contrast to the results of Gisolfi et al. (1990) and Rehrer et al. (1992), there are data toshow that there is good agreement between the results of perfusion studies and those obtainedwith the deuterium tracer method. Leiper et al. (1988a) have reported that the rate ofdeuterium accumulation was about 50% faster after ingestion of a dilute carbohydrate-electrolyte solution than after ingestion of plain water: this same solution was shown to slightlyslow the rate of gastric emptying (Leiper et al. 1988b) but to promote an increase in the rateof intestinal water uptake (Leiper & Maughan, 1986).

REFERENCES

BECKERS, E. J., REHRER, N. J., SARIS, W. H. M., BROUNS, F., TEN HOOR, F. & KESTER, A. D. M. (1991).Daily variation in gastric emptying when using the double sampling technique. Medicine and Sciencein Sports and Exercise 23, 1210-1212.

COSTILL, D. L. & SALTIN, B. (1974). Factors limiting gastric emptying during rest and exercise. JournalofApplied Physiology 37, 679-683.

DAvis, J. M., LAMB, D. R., BURGESS, W. A. & BARTOLI, W. P. (1987). Accumulation of deuterium oxidein body fluids after ingestion of D20-labeled beverages. Journal of Applied Physiology 63,2060-2066.

ELLIOTT, E. J. (1989). The role of human perfusion techniques in the assessment of oral rehydrationsolutions. Acta Paediatrica Scandinavica (suppl 364), 31-39.

398

Page 9: USE OF A DEUTERIUM TECHNIQUE TO FLUIDS INGESTED BY … · SUMMARY Deuteriumoxide (2H20) has beenadded todrinks as a tracer for water estimate the availability to the body water pool

A TRACER METHOD FOR WATER ABSORPTION

FORSTER, H. V., DEMPSEY, J. A., THOMSON, J., VIDRUK, E. & DOPICO, G. A. (1972). Estimation of arterialP°2, PCo2, pH and lactate from arterialised venous blood. Journal ofApplied Physiology 32, 134- 137.

GISOLFI, C. V., SUMMERS, R. W., SCHEDL, H. P., BLIELER, T. L. & OPPLIGER, R. A. (1990). Humanintestinal water absorption: direct v's. indirect measurements. American Journal of Physiology 21,G216-222.

GISOLFI, C. V., SCHEDL, H. P. & SUMMERS, R. D. (1992). Measurement of intestinal water absorption(letter). American Journal of Physiology 262, G377-378.

LAMB, D. R. & BRODOWIcz, G. R. (1986). Optimal use of fluids of varying formulations to minimizeexercise-induced disturbances in homeostasis. Spor-ts Medicine 3, 247-274.

LAMBERT, C. P. & MAUGHAN, R. J. (1992). Accumulation in the blood of a deuterium tracer added to hotand cold beverages. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 2,76-78.

LEIPER, J. B., FALLICK, A. E. & MAUGHAN, R. J. (1988a). Comparison of water absorption from aningested glucose-electrolyte solution and potable water using a tracer technique in healthy volunteers.Clinical Science 76 (suppl 18), 68P.

LEIPER, J. B. & MAUGHAN, R. J. (1986). Absorption of water and electrolytes from hypotonic, isotonicand hypertonic solutions. Journal of Physiology 373, 90P.

LEIPER, J. B. & MAUGHAN, R. J. (1988). Experimental models for the investigation of water and solutetransport in man: Implications for oral rehydration solutions. Druigs 36 (suppl 4), 65-79.

LEIPER, J. B., MAUGHAN, R. J., DAVIDSON, J., GEMMELL, H. G. & SMITH, F. W. (1988b). Evaluation of ascintigraphic technique for measurement of gastric emptying of liquids in healthy volunteers. ClinicalScience 76 (suppl 18), 22P.

LUKASKI, H. C. & JOHNSON, P. E. (1985). A simple, inexpensive method of determining total body waterusing a tracer dose of D20 and infrared absorption of biological fluids. American Jour-nal of ClinicalNutrition 41, 363-370.

MAUGHAN, R. J., LEIPER, J. B. & MCGRAW, B. A. (1990). Effects of exercise intensity on absorption ofingested fluids in man. Experimental Physiology 75, 419-421.

MITCHELL, J. B. & VoSS, K. W. (1989). The influence of volume on gastric emptying and fluid balanceduring prolonged exercise. Medicine and Science in Spor-ts and Exercise 23, 314-319.

MURRAY, R. (1987). The effects of consuming carbohydrate-electrolyte beverages on gastric emptyingand fluid absorption during and following exercise. Sports Medicine 4, 322-351.

NOAKES, T. D., REHRER, N. J. & MAUGHAN, R. J. (1991). The importance of volume in regulating gastricemptying. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 23, 307-313.

REHRER, N. J., WAGENMAKERS, A. J. M., BECKERS, E. J., HALLIDAY, D., LEIPER, J. B., BROUNS, F.,MAUGHAN, R. J., WESTERTERP, K. & SARIS, W. H. M. (1992). Gastric emptying, absorption, andcarbohydrate oxidation during prolonged exercise. Journal ofApplied Physiology 72, 468-475.

ROLSTON, D. D. K., ZINZUVADIA, S. N. & MATHAN, V. I. (1990). Evaluation of the efficacy of oralrehydration solutions using human whole gut perfusion. Gut 31, 1115-1119.

SCHOLER, J. F. & CODE, C. F. (1954). Rate of absorption of water from stomach and small bowel ofhuman beings. Gastroenterology 27, 565-577.

SHI, X., SUMMERS, R. W., SCHEDL, H. P., CHANG, R.-T., LAMBERT, G. P. & GISOLFI, C. V. (1994). Effectsof solution osmolality on absorption of select fluid replacement solutions in human duodenojejunum.Journal ofApplied Physiology 77, 1178- 1184.

399