version: 6 december 2016 - queen's university...medical examiners.” american sociological...

17
SOCY 303: Sociology of Professions & Occupations / p. 1 Sociology 303 Sociology of Professions and Occupations Winter 2017 Tuesdays 11:30 AM to 12:50 PM and Fridays 1:00 to 2:20 PM Mackintosh-Corry Hall, Room B-201 Version: 6 December 2016 Professor: Dr. F. Kay Office: Room D-527, Mackintosh-Corry Hall Telephone: 533-6000 ext. 74486 Office Hours: 1:00 to 3:00 PM Tuesdays (or by appointment) E-mail: [email protected] Teaching Assistants: Ashley DePaola, [email protected] Alexandra Cieslowski, [email protected] COURSE DESCRIPTION: This course offers an introduction to theories and empirical studies on professions and occupations. Using theories and case studies of lawyers, physicians, engineers, scientists, accountants, social workers, and other occupational groups, this course examines historical change, social structure, market competition, career advancement, workplace interaction and culture, job satisfaction, demographic diversity, social service, and other aspects of occupations and professions from the late nineteenth century to the age of globalization. A LITTLE MORE DETAIL: As the economies of Canada and other developed nations move increasingly in the direction of knowledge-based services, a growing proportion of the labor force engages in what is thought of as “professional” work. But what is professional work, exactly? Can we define it? Is it useful to define it? Why do professional occupations receive greater rewards than others? Is there something distinctive about the work professionals do, and what is it? Do professions create normative communities that socializeand exercise social control overtheir members? How has professional work changed in recent decades, and do we need new theoretical models in order to understand those changes? This course considers the sociological theory and research that has addressed these questions, from the mid-twentieth century to today.

Upload: others

Post on 26-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Version: 6 December 2016 - Queen's University...Medical Examiners.” American Sociological Review 70: 311-333. Harrits, Gitte S. and Lars T. Larsen. 2016. “Professional Claims to

SOCY 303: Sociology of Professions & Occupations / p. 1

Sociology 303

Sociology of Professions and Occupations

Winter 2017

Tuesdays 11:30 AM to 12:50 PM and Fridays 1:00 to 2:20 PM

Mackintosh-Corry Hall, Room B-201

Version: 6 December 2016

Professor: Dr. F. Kay

Office: Room D-527, Mackintosh-Corry Hall

Telephone: 533-6000 ext. 74486

Office Hours: 1:00 to 3:00 PM Tuesdays (or by appointment)

E-mail: [email protected]

Teaching Assistants: Ashley DePaola, [email protected]

Alexandra Cieslowski, [email protected]

COURSE DESCRIPTION: This course offers an introduction to theories and empirical studies on

professions and occupations. Using theories and case studies of lawyers, physicians, engineers,

scientists, accountants, social workers, and other occupational groups, this course examines

historical change, social structure, market competition, career advancement, workplace

interaction and culture, job satisfaction, demographic diversity, social service, and other aspects

of occupations and professions from the late nineteenth century to the age of globalization.

A LITTLE MORE DETAIL: As the economies of Canada and other developed nations move

increasingly in the direction of knowledge-based services, a growing proportion of the labor

force engages in what is thought of as “professional” work. But what is professional work,

exactly? Can we define it? Is it useful to define it? Why do professional occupations receive

greater rewards than others? Is there something distinctive about the work professionals do, and

what is it? Do professions create normative communities that socialize—and exercise social

control over—their members? How has professional work changed in recent decades, and do we

need new theoretical models in order to understand those changes? This course considers the

sociological theory and research that has addressed these questions, from the mid-twentieth

century to today.

Page 2: Version: 6 December 2016 - Queen's University...Medical Examiners.” American Sociological Review 70: 311-333. Harrits, Gitte S. and Lars T. Larsen. 2016. “Professional Claims to

SOCY 303: Sociology of Professions & Occupations / p. 2

PREREQUISITES: Sociology 122 (Introductory Sociology) or equivalent.

LEARNING OBJECTIVES The main goal of this course is to foster an understanding of the professions and the sociology of

work and occupations more broadly.

My teaching goals are for students to:

Become familiar with a variety of research questions and empirical studies of issues

related to work and occupations.

Think about how these research questions are related to more general theories of

work, social organization, and institutions.

Understand how professions and occupations are currently conceived of in terms of

expert knowledge, market control, professional orders, and codes of conduct.

Critically read, analyze, and write about sociological (both theoretical and empirical)

literature on the professions and occupations.

Consider various social and economic policy initiatives by which problems related to

work might be addressed.

Apply course material to real work and daily life examples.

REQUIRED READINGS

Volti, Rudi. 2012. An Introduction to the Sociology of Work and Occupations. Second edition.

Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.

There is also a collection of articles and book chapters. These readings are available on Q and in

the Queen’s library system. A reading list is provided on the following pages.

RECOMMENDED BOOKS (Good general references for those feeling a bit lost)

Abbott, Andrew. 1988. The System of Professions: An Essay on the Division of Expert Labor.

Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press. (This is a classic book in the field)

Adams, Tracey and Sandy Welsh. 2007. The Organization and Experience of Work. Toronto,

ON: Thomson Nelson.

Hodson, R. and T. A. Sullivan. 2012. The Social Organization of Work (5th Edition). Belmont,

CA: Wadsworth.

Leicht, Kevin T. and Mary L. Fennell. 2001. Professional Work: A Sociological Perspective.

Wiley.

Pupo, Norene, Ann Duffy and Daniel Glenday. 2017. Crises in Canadian Work: A Critical

Sociological Perspective. Don Mills, ON: Oxford University Press.

Vallas, Steven P., William Finlay, and Amy S. Warton. 2009. New Sociology of Work:

Structures and Inequalities. Oxford University Press.

Page 3: Version: 6 December 2016 - Queen's University...Medical Examiners.” American Sociological Review 70: 311-333. Harrits, Gitte S. and Lars T. Larsen. 2016. “Professional Claims to

SOCY 303: Sociology of Professions & Occupations / p. 3

EVALUATION

Requirement Proportion Due Date

Participation 10% weekly in class

Midterm exam 25% 14 February 2017

Essay 1 or 2 25% 7 March 2017

Final exam 40% April 2017 exam schedule

DETAILED REQUIREMENTS

Participation (short assignments): Come to class prepared to discuss the week’s readings.

Participation will be in the form of short writing assignments, group project discussions and

quizzes that address assigned reading material. I will drop your lowest 2 scores from the grade

calculation (or you may elect to skip 2 assignments in the event of missed classes). These

assignments are worth 10% of the final grade.

Midterm exam: The midterm exam is scheduled during regular class time and consists of

multiple choice and short answer questions. The midterm exam is worth 25% of the final grade.

Essay: The assignment is 15 pages in length (double-spaced). The questions ask you to integrate,

reflect on, and apply the issues, theories and research findings in the readings and lectures. You

will need to do some additional research. There are two different assignments (choose the topic

that you prefer). The essay is worth 25% of the final grade.

Final exam: The final exam consists of multiple-choice and short answer questions. The exam is

3 hours in duration. The exam covers the entire semester and is worth 40% of the final grade.

COURSE POLICIES AND FRIENDLY REMINDERS

Fairness: I typically grade papers and exams anonymously (by student identification

numbers rather than names) to avoid favoritism or other biases. Universal standards and

strict deadlines are the best way I know to provide equal opportunities to all students.

Exams: The midterm exam is 14 February 2017 during regular class time, and the final

exam will be set by the university. If you have other plans for these dates (weddings,

holidays, etc.), you cannot take this course at this time. If others have plans for you (your

parents booked your ticket without telling you), you will not be allowed to reschedule

your exam.

The assignment: is due in class on 7 March 2017. If you meet this deadline, you will

receive one bonus mark over the assigned mark. If you need extra time, your paper is due

in class on 14 March 2017 (no bonus mark). I strongly encourage you to aim for the first

deadline and start this assignment well in advance of the deadline. Extensions beyond the

14 March 2017 deadline, if granted, will be granted only with a penalty.

Page 4: Version: 6 December 2016 - Queen's University...Medical Examiners.” American Sociological Review 70: 311-333. Harrits, Gitte S. and Lars T. Larsen. 2016. “Professional Claims to

SOCY 303: Sociology of Professions & Occupations / p. 4

Make-up process for a missed class: In order to make up for any in-class work during a

missed day of class, you may see me to complete a short assignment. This assignment

must be submitted within 2 weeks of the missed class. The assignment consists of a 1,000

word summary and analysis of a designated research article in the field of sociology of

work and professions. The option is available to all students and no documentation is

required to receive the assignment and extension.

Class notes: If you miss class, copy the notes from one of your classmates. Then see the

teaching assistant or myself to clarify anything you do not understand. I am happy to

assign supplementary readings in the event of missed classes. I will make topic outlines

available on Q.

Grading: At the end of the semester, I compute a total score for each student (for

example, 83.5 out of 100 possible points). I then make cut-points for the grades based on

the class distribution of scores. I try to ensure that students who do all the reading, attend

lectures, and participate actively can generally earn grades of B or better in my classes.

Blowing off readings or lectures is almost certain to hurt your grade.

Attendance: I do not take attendance in class, but missing lecture more than twice is

likely to compromise your ability to succeed in the course.

Reading: This is a reading-intensive upper-division course. You should read and

understand about 60 to 100 tough pages weekly. The readings are not typically repeated

in lecture and the lectures are not duplicated in the readings. Lectures and readings

complement each other.

Reaching us: I encourage students to post questions to the class discussion board on Q.

Often other students have the same question or concern. The teaching assistant and I will

respond regularly to questions on this platform, benefiting all students with shared

information.

Reaching me with questions specific to you: You will need to visit my office for

questions regarding disability accommodations, missed classes, and extensions. Use e-

mail to request an appointment outside posted office hours (and note “SOCY303” in the

subject line).

Plagiarism/academic: You do not need to cheat. You do not want to cheat. Bad things

will happen if you cheat. Do not cheat.

Detailed department/university policies (attached).

Page 5: Version: 6 December 2016 - Queen's University...Medical Examiners.” American Sociological Review 70: 311-333. Harrits, Gitte S. and Lars T. Larsen. 2016. “Professional Claims to

SOCY 303: Sociology of Professions & Occupations / p. 5

COURSE READING SCHEDULE

SOCIOLOGY 303: SOCIOLOGY OF PROFESSIONS AND OCCUPATIONS

*Indicates required readings. Other readings listed are recommended.

Week 1

10 and 13 January

Introduction: Sociology of Work, Occupations and Professions

Questions: What do we mean by the concepts of jobs, occupations, organizations, industries, and

classes? What have been the main changes to occupations in the 20th century? How are

occupations likely to continue to change in the 21st century?

10 January: Changing occupational structure

*Hollister, Matissa. 2015. “Professions at the Helm or Left Behind? Trends in the

Occupations of American College Graduate Since the Second World War in the United

States.” Journal of Education and Work 28(3): 301-331.

Wyatt, A. Ian D. and Daniel E. Hecker. 2006. “Occupational Changes during the 20th

Century.” Monthly Labor Review (March): 35-57.

13 January: Theory and definitions in work and occupations

*Volti book, chapters 1-3 & 15.

Damarin, Amanda Kidd. 2006. “Rethinking Occupational Structure: The Case of Web

Site Production Work.” Work and Occupations 22: 429-463.

Week 2

17 and 20 January

Knowledge claims

Questions: Does a claim to expert knowledge define a profession? Are there other occupations

that are justified in claiming knowledge and ability?

17 & 20 January: Expert knowledge claims

*Volti book, chapter 5.

*Timmersmans, Stefan. 2005. “Suicide Determination and the Professional Authority of

Medical Examiners.” American Sociological Review 70: 311-333.

Harrits, Gitte S. and Lars T. Larsen. 2016. “Professional Claims to Authority: A

Comparative Study of Danish Doctors and Teachers, 1950-2010.” Journal of Professions

and Organization 3(2): 154-169.

Williams, Alex. 2008. “The Falling-Down Professions.” New York Times. Page 9. See:

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/01/06/fashion/06professions.html?_r=0

Page 6: Version: 6 December 2016 - Queen's University...Medical Examiners.” American Sociological Review 70: 311-333. Harrits, Gitte S. and Lars T. Larsen. 2016. “Professional Claims to

SOCY 303: Sociology of Professions & Occupations / p. 6

Week 3

24 and 26 January

Professional Status and Professionalization

Questions: Why are some occupations designated as professions and others not? When does an

occupation become a profession?

24 & 26 January: Becoming a profession

*Volti book, chapter 9.

*McCann, Leo, Edward Granter, Paula Hyde, and John Hassard. 2013. “Still Blue-Collar

after all these Years? An Ethnography of the Professionalization of Emergency

Ambulance Work.” Journal of Management Studies 50(5): 750-776.

*Maroto, M. L. 2011. “Professionalizing Body Art: A Marginalized Occupational

Group’s use of Informal and Formal Strategies of Control.” Work and Occupations 38(1):

101-138.

Welsh, Sandy, Merrijoy Kelner, Beverley Wellman, and Heather Boon. 2004. “Moving

Forward? The Professionalization Process of Complementary and Alternative Medicine.”

Sociology of Health and Illness 26(2): 1-26.

Week 4

31 January and 3 February

Professions as Monopoly: Market Control and Jurisdictional Conflicts

Questions: Why do professions receive greater rewards—money, prestige, autonomy, power—

than other occupations? Which occupations are rated more highly than others by the public?

How stable are these rankings over time? What accounts for the persistence of low-wage

occupations? Is their competition between the professions?

31 January: Professions as monopoly *Adams, Tracey. 2004. “Interprofessional Conflict and Professionalization: Dentistry and

Dental Hygiene in Ontario.” Social Science and Medicine 58(11): 2243-53.

3 February: Jurisdictional conflicts

*Kay, Fiona M. 2009. “‘The First Legal Profession’ of New France in Jeopardy or

Revival?: History and Futures of the Quebec Notariat.” International Journal of the

Legal Profession 16(1): 1-32.

Page 7: Version: 6 December 2016 - Queen's University...Medical Examiners.” American Sociological Review 70: 311-333. Harrits, Gitte S. and Lars T. Larsen. 2016. “Professional Claims to

SOCY 303: Sociology of Professions & Occupations / p. 7

Week 5

7 and 10 February

Entry to Professional Schools and Labor Markets

Question: So you want to be a professional–How do you get into professional school and get

hired?

7 February: Entry to professional schools

*Gladwell, Malcolm. Outliers: The Story of Success. New York, NY: Little, Brown and

Company. Pages 77-89.

Schleef, Debra. 2000. “‘That's a Good Question!’ Exploring Motivations for Law and

Business School Choice.” Sociology of Education 73: 155-174.

10 February: Hiring and labor markets

*Volti book, chapter 7.

*Rivera, Lauren. 2012. “Hiring as Cultural Matching: The Case of Elite Professional

Service Firms.” American Sociological Review 77: 999-1022.

Week 6

14 and 17 February

Becoming a Professional: Identity and Socialization

Questions: How does professional formation lead to a shift in identity? What does it mean to say

“Learning to think like a lawyer” or “To be professional” or “In my professional opinion…”?

Where does professional socialization take place? (e.g., in degree programs, placements or on-

the-job?)

14 February: Midterm test in class.

17 February: Identity and socialization

*Volti book, chapter 8.

*Bevort, F. and R. Suddaby. 2016. “Scripting Professional Identities: How Individuals

Make Sense of Contradictory Logics.” Journal of Professions and Organization 3(1): 17-

38.

*Williams, C. L. and C. Connell. 2010. “Looking Good and Sounding Right: Aesthetic

Labor and Social Inequality.” Work and Occupations 37(3): 349-377.

Kellogg, Katherine C. 2009. “Operating Room: Relational Spaces and Micro-institutional

Change in Surgery.” American Journal of Sociology 115: 657-711.

Mertz, Elizabeth. 2007. The Language of Law School: Learning to ‘Think Like a

Lawyer.’ Oxford: Oxford University Press. Chapter 4 (just pages 43-63).

Page 8: Version: 6 December 2016 - Queen's University...Medical Examiners.” American Sociological Review 70: 311-333. Harrits, Gitte S. and Lars T. Larsen. 2016. “Professional Claims to

SOCY 303: Sociology of Professions & Occupations / p. 8

Week 7

21 and 24 February

Reading Week

*No assigned readings

Week 8

28 February and 3 March

Getting Ahead in Professional Careers

Questions: What matters for moving up career ladders? What determines the elite, high paying

specialties? Who gets promoted and why?

28 February & 3 March: Promotions and careers

*Volti book, chapters 10 & 11.

*Umney, C. and L. Kretsos. 2015. “That’s the Experience: Passion, Work Precarity, and

Life Transitions among London Jazz Musicians.” Work and Occupations 43(3): 313-334.

Kay, Fiona and Jean Wallace. 2009. “Mentors as Social Capital: Gender, Mentor

Capitalization and Career Rewards in Law Practice.” Sociological Inquiry 79: 418-452.

Butler, Don. 2016. “Wage gap widens, study finds.” Kingston Whig Standard. Tuesday

July 26, 2016, page B-1.

Week 9

7 and 10 March

Job Quality, Job Satisfaction, and Work-Life Balance

Questions: What do we mean by “job quality”? What are the different dimensions of job quality?

What accounts for differences among and professionals in their levels of job satisfaction? What

constitutes “meaningful work”? Is professional work more demanding work? How do work and

personal lives intersect and with what consequences?

7 March: Job quality and job satisfaction

*Volti book, chapters 12 & 14.

*Bunderson, J. S. and J. A. Thompson. 2009. “The Call of the Wild: Zookeepers,

Callings, and the Double-Edge Sword of Deeply Meaningful Work.” Administrative

Science Quarterly 54: 32-57.

10 March: Work-life balance

*Wallace J. E., and J. Lemaire. 2013. “Physician Coping Styles and Emotional

Exhaustion.” Industrial Relations 68: 187-209.

John Hagan and Fiona M. Kay. 2011. “The Emotional Toll and Exhilaration of Human

Rights Activism: Gender and Legal Work at The Hague International Criminal Tribunal.”

Queen’s Law Journal 37(1): 257-301.

Page 9: Version: 6 December 2016 - Queen's University...Medical Examiners.” American Sociological Review 70: 311-333. Harrits, Gitte S. and Lars T. Larsen. 2016. “Professional Claims to

SOCY 303: Sociology of Professions & Occupations / p. 9

Week 10

14 and 17 March

Autonomy, Ethics and Commercialism

Questions: Are professions normative communities? Do professionals have their own codes of

ethics? What does it mean to be a self-regulating profession? How effective are the professions

at controlling misconduct?

14 March: Essays 1 & 2 due in class.

14 & 17 March: Ethics & Self-regulation

*Timmersmans, Stefan and Hyeyoung Oh. 2010. “The Continued Social Transformation

of the Medical Profession.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior 51: S94-106.

*Muzio, D., J. Falconbridge, C. Gabbioneta, and R. Greenwood. 2012. “Bad Apples, Bad

Barrels and Bad Cellars: A ‘Boundaries’ Perspective on Professional Misconduct.” In

Don Palmer et al. (editors). Organizational Wrongdoing. Cambridge: Cambridge

University Press.

Gendron, Y., R. Suddaby, and H. Lam. 2006. “An Examination of the Ethical

Commitment of Professional Accountants to Auditor Independence.” Journal of Business

Ethics 64: 169-193.

Week 11

21 and 24 March

A Calling: The Role of Service

Questions: Is a profession a “calling”? Have professionals lost their service orientation? Are

professionals becoming simply “knowledge-based” or “expert” occupations? Do professionals

have an obligation to provide access to services for disadvantaged groups (e.g., the poor,

refugees, children, animals, victims of human rights violations, those injured and without

medical insurance)?

21 March: A ‘calling’ to the profession

*Gorman, Elizabeth and Rebecca Sandefur. 2013. “‘Golden Age,’ Quiescence, and

Revival: How the Sociology of Professions Became the Study of Knowledge-Based

Work.” Work and Occupations 38(3): 275-302.

24 March: Service orientation of professions (access to justice, healthcare)

*Cummings, Scott and Rebecca L. Sandefur. 2013. “Beyond the Numbers: What We

Know—and Should Know—about American Pro Bono.” Harvard Law and Policy

Review 7: 83-111.

Page 10: Version: 6 December 2016 - Queen's University...Medical Examiners.” American Sociological Review 70: 311-333. Harrits, Gitte S. and Lars T. Larsen. 2016. “Professional Claims to

SOCY 303: Sociology of Professions & Occupations / p. 10

Week 12

28 and 31 March

Diversity in the Professions and the Business Case for Diversity

Questions: What explains the occupational segregation of men and women? Why are some

occupations considered to be “women’s work” and others to be “men’s work”? On what basis

were women and racial/ethnic minorities banned from the professions? How do racial minorities

fare in the professions today? What should be the roles of government, business and labor in

addressing discrimination and other work-related problems?

28 March: Diversity in the workplace

*Volti book, chapter 13.

*Herring, Dedric. 2009. “Does Diversity Pay? Race, Gender and the Business Case for

Diversity.” American Sociological Review 74: 208-224.

31 March: Policies aimed at curbing discrimination

*Williams, C. L., K. Kilanski, and C. Muller. 2014. “Corporate Diversity Programs and

Gender Inequality in the Oil and Gas Industry.” Work and Occupations 41(4): 440-476.

Ely, Robin J., Pamela Stone, and Colleen Ammersman. 2014. “Rethink What You

‘Know’ About High-Achieving Women.” Harvard Business Review (December): 101-

110.

Week 13

4 and 7 April

Contemporary Changes: Bureaucracies, Autonomy, and Globalization

Questions: How has the changing organizational context of professional work changed the

structure and operation of professional occupations? Have physicians, accountants and lawyers

lost their autonomy? Do professionals increasingly work in bureaucracies? How has

globalization changed the way professionals do their work?

4 April: Bureaucracies

*Volti book, chapters 4 & 6.

7 April: Globalization

*Harrington, B. 2015. “Going Global: Professionals and the Micro-Foundations of

Institutional Change.” Journal of Professions and Organization 2(1): 78-102.

Faulconbridge, J. R. and D. Muzio. 2012. “Professions in a Globalizing World: Towards

a Transnational Sociology of the Professions.” International Sociology 27(1): 136-152.

Fourcade, Marion. 2006. “The Construction of a Global Profession: The

Transnationalization of Economics.” American Journal of Sociology 112: 145-194.

Final examination: April exam schedule.

Page 11: Version: 6 December 2016 - Queen's University...Medical Examiners.” American Sociological Review 70: 311-333. Harrits, Gitte S. and Lars T. Larsen. 2016. “Professional Claims to

SOCY 303: Sociology of Professions & Occupations / p. 11

ESSAY 1: What’s to like (or not) about this job?

Due: 7 March 2017 in class

Choose an occupation that you would like to know more about. You can focus on a specific job

within the occupation or an occupation overall. If you choose a specific job, be sure to discuss it

in relation to its broader occupational context.

Part 1: Job Context: Your paper should include a definition of the job or occupation, what kind

of work is involved, and a brief historical overview (e.g., How and why did this job/occupation

come about? What changes have occurred and why?).

Part 2: Demographics of the Job: You should discuss the following in the Canadian context:

1) Demographic composition (gender, race/ethnicity, age, etc.). Has it changed over time?

2) General training and compensation data (salary/wage range) for this type of work. You

may refer to Statistics Canada or if the job requires registration or membership, their

association home page.

Part 3: Job Issues: What you see as one or two important issues this job/occupation faces and

why? These issues may be identified by someone in the job, a newspaper article, websites linked

to the job or a research article on this occupation (or job). Refer to at least two academic journal

articles that discuss this issue and discuss their relevant findings in your paper. The sample

questions below may help you think about these issues in relation to the topics covered in the

course. Discuss what strategies or solutions you propose to address these issues or how would

you “reconstruct” this job/occupation for the future in relation to the issues you raise.

Below are some typical issues that you may choose to examine through your research:

1) Satisfaction and Alienation: What are the most satisfying or alienating/stressful aspects

of this job? Are there health or safety issues that affect this job/occupation or those who

hold it? Can a worker make a reasonable living? If not, discuss. Does it offer other

intrinsic rewards? What other compensation issues arise?

2) How Technology Influences Work: How is this job typically organized and how does

technology influence this type of work? Is this job highly skilled? Is this job/occupation

generally “upgrading” or “deskilling”? To whom is this job/occupation responsible? Is it

closely supervised or not? How much autonomy? What appear to be the job/occupational

trends for the future?

3) Class, Race and Gender: Does this job seem to be equally represented by gender and a

diversity of ethnic/racial groups or does one gender or race/ethnic community seem to be

dominant? How does this impact on the work experiences of those under-represented

groups? Has the workforce changed in any major way (e.g., demographics, education,

etc.)? Do any inequalities exist in this job/occupation? (e.g., discrimination, harassment,

tokenism, exploitation, abusive practices, systemic advantages, disadvantages)?

4) Work and Family: What are the challenges of balancing the demands of this job with

having a family? What time commitment does this job/occupation take? Does it allow for

flexibility in scheduling? How compatible is this job/occupation with family/childcare

responsibilities? How conducive is it to nontraditional work patterns or arrangements?

Page 12: Version: 6 December 2016 - Queen's University...Medical Examiners.” American Sociological Review 70: 311-333. Harrits, Gitte S. and Lars T. Larsen. 2016. “Professional Claims to

SOCY 303: Sociology of Professions & Occupations / p. 12

Use your course readings and lecture material where relevant to help you discuss the issues you

have chosen. You will need to do some outside reading on your job/occupation. How many

sources you need depends on what issues you choose to cover, and how comprehensive the

sources are. Be sure to cite whatever sources you use. You may find the following journals

helpful for finding academic journal articles: Work and Occupations, Journal of Vocational

Behavior, Journal of Organizational Behavior, Administrative Science Quarterly, and Work,

Employment and Society.

The essay (the bibliography does not count in the page limit) represents 25% of course grade. I

will evaluate how well you can apply course concepts and material to analyze key topics or

issues in relation to a job/occupation and the issues you examine.

Formatting Requirements

Length: Maximum of 15 pages, excluding list of references (strictly imposed).

Font: Use Times New Roman font 12 (which is what this is).

Page Numbers: Insert page numbers.

Spacing: Double-space all of the text.

Margins: Use default margins (2 cm).

References: Use A.S.A. format.

Cover page: Be sure to include your student ID number (check it twice) in the TOP RIGHT

corner of the page. Elsewhere on the cover page include a title for your paper, course number

and title, instructor’s name, and date.

Page 13: Version: 6 December 2016 - Queen's University...Medical Examiners.” American Sociological Review 70: 311-333. Harrits, Gitte S. and Lars T. Larsen. 2016. “Professional Claims to

SOCY 303: Sociology of Professions & Occupations / p. 13

ESSAY 2: Professional Training and Work Issues

Due: 7 March 2017 in class

For this project you will select one profession and you will address the questions below about

your profession of choice. Possible professions include: physician, veterinarian, lawyer,

accountant, engineer, dentist, scientist, architect, teacher, registered nurse, registered social

worker (if your profession of interest is not on the list, see me for approval). Your paper should

include a definition of the profession and a description of what kind of work is involved.

Part 1: Training, Education and Certification: This information is to be based on university

degree requirements as well as mandatory training or qualifying exams of the Provincial

Association for your chosen profession. Provide a summary of the following information on the

requirements for:

1) applying to the program (e.g., standardized exam scores, GPA, years of undergraduate

training or degree, and other considerations—for example, moral character);

2) completing the program (e.g., length of program, costs, practicum component);

3) Provincial membership certification or licensure (e.g., standardized examination, special

ceremony, continuing education). Are there any requirements that surprised you?

Part 2: Demographics of the Profession: Using the same web pages, or possibly the Canadian

Association website or Statistics Canada, collect information on the Ontario or Canadian

membership of your chosen profession. Examples include: the number of members, average

salaries and breakdowns of where they work (e.g., by specialty or employment setting), gender

and/or racial/ethnic composition, age or years of experience of members, and foreign trained

representation if available. Indicate whether any of these demographics have changed over time.

Part 3: Professional Issues: From the provincial and/or national association web pages, identify

what you think are two important issues this profession faces and why. These issues might

include: recruitment in general or of specific types of members (e.g., women, international

recruits), recruitment to specific areas (e.g., more needed in certain specialties, employment

settings or locations), or member stress/wellness. Refer to at least two academic journal articles

that discuss this issue and discuss their relevant findings in your paper. Discuss whether you

think this issue is unique to this particular profession. Discuss what strategies or solutions you

would propose or how you might change or reconstruct this occupation for the future in relation

to the issues you raise.

Use your course readings and lecture material where relevant to help you discuss the issues you

have chosen. You will need to do some outside reading on your job/occupation. How many

sources you need depends on what issues you choose to cover, and how comprehensive the

sources are. Be sure to cite whatever sources you use. You may find the following journals

helpful for finding academic journal articles: Work and Occupations, Journal of Vocational

Behavior, Journal of Organizational Behavior, Administrative Science Quarterly, and Work,

Employment and Society.

Page 14: Version: 6 December 2016 - Queen's University...Medical Examiners.” American Sociological Review 70: 311-333. Harrits, Gitte S. and Lars T. Larsen. 2016. “Professional Claims to

SOCY 303: Sociology of Professions & Occupations / p. 14

The essay (the bibliography does not count in the page limit) represents 25% of course grade. I

will evaluate the presentation of your data, the clarity and logic of your analyses, and the

completeness of your project.

Formatting Requirements

Length: Maximum of 15 pages, excluding list of references (strictly imposed).

Font: Use Times New Roman font 12 (which is what this is).

Page Numbers: Insert page numbers.

Spacing: Double-space all of the text.

Margins: Use default margins (2 cm).

References: Use A.S.A. format.

Cover page: Be sure to include your student ID number (check it twice) in the TOP RIGHT

corner of the page. Elsewhere on the cover page include a title for your paper, course number

and title, instructor’s name, and date.

Page 15: Version: 6 December 2016 - Queen's University...Medical Examiners.” American Sociological Review 70: 311-333. Harrits, Gitte S. and Lars T. Larsen. 2016. “Professional Claims to

SOCY 303: Sociology of Professions & Occupations / p. 15

A REMINDER OF OTHER POLICIES

Make-up Examinations: Arrangements for special examinations may be made directly with the professor. Circumstances for missing an

exam include, but are not necessarily limited to: verified illness, participation in athletic events or other group

activities sponsored by the university, serious family emergencies, subpoenas, jury duty, military service, and

religious observances. It is the responsibility of the student to notify the instructor of such circumstances as far in

advance as possible.

Essay Extensions:

All requests for an essay extension due to health reasons or family emergency (such as death of a family member)

must be accompanied by official written documentation. This is in fairness to all students in the class.

Final Exam:

As noted in Academic Regulation 8.2.1, “the final examination in any class offered in a term or session

(including Summer Term) must be written on the campus on which it was taken, at the end of the

appropriate term or session at the time scheduled by the Examinations Office.” The exam period is listed

in the key dates prior to the start of the academic year in the Faculty of Arts and Science Academic

Calendar and on the Office of the University Registrar’s webpage. A detailed exam schedule for the Fall

Term is posted before the Thanksgiving holiday; for the Winter Term it is posted the Friday before

Reading Week, and for the Summer Term the window of dates is noted on the Arts and Science Online

syllabus prior to the start of the course. Students should delay finalizing any travel plans until after the

examination schedule has been posted. Exams will not be moved or deferred to accommodate

employment, travel /holiday plans or flight reservations.

There are no re-writes on any exams in this class and no extra credit work will be given. If you anticipate any

difficulties meeting any of the class requirements, please make sure to discuss your concerns with the professor

before the deadline.

Accessibility Queen’s University is committed to an inclusive campus community with accessible goods, services, and facilities that respect the dignity and independence of persons with disabilities. Your course syllabus, assignments and exams are available in an accessible format or with appropriate communication supports upon request. Please contact me directly.

Academic Accommodation: Queen's University is committed to achieving full accessibility for persons with disabilities. Part of this

commitment includes arranging academic accommodations for students with disabilities to ensure they have

an equitable opportunity to participate in all of their academic activities. If you are a student with a disability

and think you may need accommodations, you are strongly encouraged to contact Student Wellness Services

(SWS) and register as early as possible. For more information, including important deadlines, please visit the

Student Wellness website at: http://www.queensu.ca/studentwellness/accessibility-services/

E-mail: Place “SOCY303” in the subject line. When sending e-mail messages, remember to address the recipient by

name, sign the e-mail note with your full name, use your Queen’s e-mail account, and use full words and sentences

for clarity of expression. Treat e-mails as you would any other professional communication.

Classroom etiquette:

You are entitled to a good learning environment in the classroom. Students whose behavior is disruptive

either to the instructor or to other students will be asked to leave.

Students are to use laptops only for note-taking. Do not text, check e-mail or surf the internet during class.

This disrupts other students’ learning and is disrespectful to me.

Videotaping and recording lectures is strictly forbidden without written permission in advance from the

instructor.

Page 16: Version: 6 December 2016 - Queen's University...Medical Examiners.” American Sociological Review 70: 311-333. Harrits, Gitte S. and Lars T. Larsen. 2016. “Professional Claims to

SOCY 303: Sociology of Professions & Occupations / p. 16

Copyright of Course Materials (lectures and power point slides):

This material is designed for use as part of SOCY303 at Queen¹s University and is the property of the instructor

unless otherwise stated. Third party copyrighted materials (such as book chapters and articles) have either been

licensed for use in this course or fall under an exception or limitation in Canadian Copyright law. Copying this

material for distribution (e.g. uploading material to a commercial third-party website) can lead to a violation of

Copyright law. Find out more about copyright here: http://library.queensu.ca/copyright.

Academic Integrity:

Academic Integrity is constituted by the six core fundamental values of honesty, trust, fairness, respect,

responsibility and courage (see www.academicintegrity.org). These values are central to the building, nurturing

and sustaining of an academic community in which all members of the community will thrive. Adherence to the

values expressed through academic integrity forms a foundation for the "freedom of inquiry and exchange of

ideas" essential to the intellectual life of the University (see the Senate Report on Principles and Priorities

http://www.queensu.ca/secretariat/policies/senate/report-principles-and-priorities).

Students are responsible for familiarizing themselves with the regulations concerning academic integrity and for

ensuring that their assignments conform to the principles of academic integrity.

Information on academic integrity is available in the Arts and Science Calendar (see Academic Regulation 1

http://www.queensu.ca/artsci/academic-calendars/regulations/academicregulations/regulation-1), on the Arts and

Science website (see http://www.queensu.ca/artsci/academics/undergraduate/academic-integrity), and from the

instructor of this course. Departures from academic integrity include plagiarism, use of unauthorized materials,

facilitation, forgery and falsification, and are antithetical to the development of an academic community at Queen's.

Given the seriousness of these matters, actions which contravene the regulation on academic integrity carry

sanctions that can range from a warning or the loss of grades on an assignment to the failure of a course to a

requirement to withdraw from the university

The Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy legislation disallows the practice of having students

retrieve assignments and exams from a public place (e.g., outside a professor’s office, the department office, etc.) or

posting grades on office doors or via e-mail. Examination results must be returned to students individually. Students

can retrieve their tests and essays from their Teaching Assistant in class and at my office.

Grade Reappraisal: Within two weeks of the date of the exam/assignment is returned, students seeking reappraisal

of examinations or assignments must submit a written response to the instructor explaining the basis for

reconsideration of one’s mark. The instructor will reconsider the grade assigned and will then book a time with the

student to discuss his or her work and rationale. It should be noted that a re-assessed grade may be raised, lowered,

or remain the same.

Posting of Grades: The Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy legislation disallows the practice of

having students retrieve assignments and exams from a public place (e.g., outside a professor’s office, the

department office, etc.) or posting grades on office doors or on-line. Assignments and examination results must be

returned to students individually, during class or during the professor’s office hours.

Useful websites at Queen’s University

Peer Academic Support Service: http://www.queensu.ca/artsci/pass

Faculty of Arts & Science Advising Services & Resources: http://www.queensu.ca/artsci/advising/index.html

Health, Counseling & Disability Services: http://www.queensu-hcds.org/

The Ban Righ Foundation: http://www.queensu.ca/dsao/ind/banrighmain.htm

International Centre: http://www.queensu.ca/quic

The Writing Centre: http://queensu.ca/writingcentre

Arts & Science Undergraduate Society (ASUS): www.asus.queensu.ca/acsfacts

Page 17: Version: 6 December 2016 - Queen's University...Medical Examiners.” American Sociological Review 70: 311-333. Harrits, Gitte S. and Lars T. Larsen. 2016. “Professional Claims to

SOCY 303: Sociology of Professions & Occupations / p. 17

Queen’s Official Grade Conversion Scale

Grade Numerical Course

Average (Range)

A+ 90-100

A 85-89

A- 80-84

B+ 77-79

B 73-76

B- 70-72

C+ 67-69

C 63-66

C- 60-62

D+ 57-59

D 53-56

D- 50-52

F 49 and below