via electronic filing secretary federal · pdf filesecretary federal communications commission...

16
VIA ELECTRONIC FILING February 4, 2014 Marlene H. Dortch Secretary Federal Communications Commission 445 12th Street, SW Washington, DC 20554 Re: Notice of Ex Parte Presentation Oceus Networks and Space Data Corporation PS Docket No. 11-15 Dear Ms. Dortch: On January 31, 2014, Jerry Knoblach, Chairman and CEO and Jerry Quenneville, VP, Business Development of Space Data Corporation, and Douglas Sharp, Director of Engineering, and Jay Chauhan, Oceus Networks, Inc. met with David Simpson, Bureau Chief; Kenneth Moran, Senior Deputy Chief; Thomas Beers, Chief, Policy Division; Eric Panketh, Chief, Operations and Emergency Management Division; Clete Johnson, Chief Counsel for Cybersecurity; Rasoul Safavian, Chief Technologist; and Behzad Ghaffari, Chief, Systems Engineering, of the FCC Public Safety and Homeland Security Bureau (“PSHSB”). Space Data Corporation and Oceus Networks (“DACA Testing Partners”) briefed the PSHSB attendees on the results of a July 2013 test of a high altitude balloon platform outfitted with a 4G LTE payload to assess the viability of using a deployable aerial communications architecture (DACA) for communications restorations within the first 72 hours of a disaster. DACA Testing Partners highlighted the key results of the test and recommended further actions

Upload: hoangnhan

Post on 25-Mar-2018

214 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: VIA ELECTRONIC FILING Secretary Federal · PDF fileSecretary Federal Communications Commission 445 12th Street, ... with a 4G LTE payload to assess the ... Protocol timing (max timing

VIA ELECTRONIC FILING

February 4, 2014

Marlene H. Dortch SecretaryFederal Communications Commission 445 12th Street, SW Washington, DC 20554

Re: Notice of Ex Parte Presentation

Oceus Networks and Space Data Corporation PS Docket No. 11-15

Dear Ms. Dortch:

On January 31, 2014, Jerry Knoblach, Chairman and CEO and Jerry Quenneville, VP, Business Development of Space Data Corporation, and Douglas Sharp, Director of Engineering, and Jay Chauhan, Oceus Networks, Inc. met with David Simpson, Bureau Chief; Kenneth Moran, Senior Deputy Chief; Thomas Beers, Chief, Policy Division; Eric Panketh, Chief, Operations and Emergency Management Division; Clete Johnson, Chief Counsel for Cybersecurity; Rasoul Safavian, Chief Technologist; and Behzad Ghaffari, Chief, Systems Engineering, of the FCC Public Safety and Homeland Security Bureau (“PSHSB”).

Space Data Corporation and Oceus Networks (“DACA Testing Partners”) briefed the PSHSB attendees on the results of a July 2013 test of a high altitude balloon platform outfitted with a 4G LTE payload to assess the viability of using a deployable aerial communications architecture (DACA) for communications restorations within the first 72 hours of a disaster.DACA Testing Partners highlighted the key results of the test and recommended further actions

Page 2: VIA ELECTRONIC FILING Secretary Federal · PDF fileSecretary Federal Communications Commission 445 12th Street, ... with a 4G LTE payload to assess the ... Protocol timing (max timing

that the Commission could take to enable the use of DACA by FirstNet and other public safety users in the event of a disaster.

The materials presented during the meeting are attached as Appendix A. In addition, a full DACA test report prepared by the DACA Testing Partners is filed as a separate attachment.

Please contact me with any questions.

Respectfully submitted,

/s/ Jay Chauhan___________Jay Chauhan

Regulatory Counsel for Oceus Networks

cc: David Simpson Kenneth Moran Thomas Beers Eric Panketh Clete Johnson Rasoul Safavian Behzad Ghaffari

Page 3: VIA ELECTRONIC FILING Secretary Federal · PDF fileSecretary Federal Communications Commission 445 12th Street, ... with a 4G LTE payload to assess the ... Protocol timing (max timing

Dep

loya

ble

Aer

ial

Com

mun

icat

ions

Arc

hite

ctur

e (D

AC

A)

4G L

TE B

RO

AD

BA

ND

Test

Flig

ht, R

esul

ts, a

nd

Rec

omm

enda

tions

Rec

omm

enda

tions

Pre

sent

ed to

FC

C P

SH

SB

Sta

ffJa

nuar

y 31

, 201

4

App

endi

xA

:Pre

sent

atio

n

Page 4: VIA ELECTRONIC FILING Secretary Federal · PDF fileSecretary Federal Communications Commission 445 12th Street, ... with a 4G LTE payload to assess the ... Protocol timing (max timing

Expe

rimen

t Ove

rvie

w

•D

ate:

Jul

y 2,

201

3•

Loca

tion:

Nea

r gov

ernm

ent f

acili

ties

in B

ould

er, C

olor

ado

to fa

cilit

ate

coor

dina

tion

with

the

Nat

iona

lTel

ecom

mun

icat

ions

and

Info

rmat

ion

Adm

inis

tratio

n(N

TIA

)w

ithth

eN

atio

nalT

elec

omm

unic

atio

nsan

dIn

form

atio

nA

dmin

istra

tion

(NTI

A),

Nat

iona

l Ins

titut

e of

Sta

ndar

ds a

nd T

echn

olog

y (N

IST)

, and

the

Pub

lic S

afet

y C

omm

unic

atio

ns R

esea

rch

(PS

CR

) pro

gram

•D

urat

ion:

4H

ours

Dur

atio

n:4

Hou

rs•

Max

imum

Hei

ght:

Con

trolle

d A

scen

t to

70,0

00 F

eet

•Si

gnal

Cov

erag

e A

rea:

100

mile

radi

us•

DA

CA

Test

Plat

form

:S

pace

Dat

aS

kyS

iteB

allo

onou

tfitte

dw

ithm

odifi

edO

ceus

DA

CA

Test

Plat

form

:S

pace

Dat

aS

kyS

iteB

allo

onou

tfitte

dw

ithm

odifi

edO

ceus

Net

wor

k X

ipho

s 4G

LTE

uni

t •

Test

Cas

es E

valu

ated

: –

Initi

ate

sign

al tr

ansm

issi

on fr

om g

roun

dg

g–

Det

erm

ine

whe

ther

gro

und

base

d us

er d

evic

es c

ould

com

mun

icat

e w

ith D

AC

A

–A

sses

s pe

rform

ance

of p

latfo

rm a

s it

rose

into

the

stra

tosp

here

Exp

lore

pote

ntia

l int

erfe

renc

e is

sues

with

non

-syn

chro

nize

d te

rres

trial

net

wor

ks

Copy

right

Spa

ce D

ata

Corp

. / O

ceus

Net

work

s 201

3

pp

y

1

Page 5: VIA ELECTRONIC FILING Secretary Federal · PDF fileSecretary Federal Communications Commission 445 12th Street, ... with a 4G LTE payload to assess the ... Protocol timing (max timing

Rap

idly

Dep

loya

ble

Wid

e A

rea

Cov

erag

e

Line

of S

ight

7:3

0 A

MLi

ne o

f Sig

ht 8

:30

AM

Lim

b of

Ear

th50

0 km

Copy

right

Spa

ce D

ata

Corp

. / O

ceus

Net

work

s 201

32

Page 6: VIA ELECTRONIC FILING Secretary Federal · PDF fileSecretary Federal Communications Commission 445 12th Street, ... with a 4G LTE payload to assess the ... Protocol timing (max timing

Rap

idly

Dep

loya

ble

Wid

e A

rea

Cov

erag

e

Line

of S

ight

11:

15 A

MN

IST

Bou

lder

Bou

lder

I-70

tow

ard

Eise

nhow

erEi

senh

ower

Tunn

elC

lear

line

of

sigh

t int

o m

tn.

Dow

ntow

n

gva

lleys

not

a

prob

lem

Den

ver

Inte

rnat

iona

l

Den

ver

Copy

right

Spa

ce D

ata

Corp

. / O

ceus

Net

work

s 201

33

Inte

rnat

iona

lA

irpor

t

Page 7: VIA ELECTRONIC FILING Secretary Federal · PDF fileSecretary Federal Communications Commission 445 12th Street, ... with a 4G LTE payload to assess the ... Protocol timing (max timing

4G L

TE F

light

Tra

in

2000

g La

tex

Wea

ther

Bal

loon

sC

LOSE

UP

Red

unda

nt90

0M

Hz

SkyS

ites

Red

unda

nt90

0M

Hz

SkyS

ites

Con

trol

link

, ven

t & b

alla

st

Para

chut

e

Xiph

os B

and

14 L

TE N

etw

ork

in a

Box

mas

s re

duce

d w

ith 6

hr.

batt.

= 4

9 lb

s

Dow

ntilt

ed R

X A

nten

na

Dow

ntilt

ed T

X/R

X A

nten

naR

adar

Ref

lect

or w

ith

Tran

spon

der

Copy

right

Spa

ce D

ata

Corp

. / O

ceus

Net

work

s 201

34

Tran

spon

der

Page 8: VIA ELECTRONIC FILING Secretary Federal · PDF fileSecretary Federal Communications Commission 445 12th Street, ... with a 4G LTE payload to assess the ... Protocol timing (max timing

Xiph

os 4

G L

TE P

aylo

ad

•Pa

yloa

d: M

odifi

ed O

ceus

Xip

hos

4G L

TE s

yste

m re

duce

d in

si

ze a

nd w

eigh

t for

Sky

Site

Pla

tform

inst

alla

tion

–D

igita

lUni

t–E

ricss

onD

UL1

0–

Dig

italU

nit–

Eric

sson

DU

L10

–R

adio

Uni

t -E

ricss

on R

US

01

•Ty

pe A

ppro

ved

by th

e FC

C u

nder

Typ

e ID

: TA

8AK

RC

1189

5-1

on21

Oct

ober

2011

TA8A

KR

C11

895

1on

21O

ctob

er20

11•

Pow

er –

Cap

able

of 6

0W P

ower

; Tes

t Run

at 2

0W–

Evo

lved

Pac

ket C

ore

(EP

C)

•M

ME

,PG

W,S

GW

,HS

S,O

AM

-Oce

usN

etw

orks

MM

E,P

GW

,SG

W,H

SS

,OA

MO

ceus

Net

wor

ks•

Com

putin

g H

ardw

are

Sys

tem

-O

ceus

Net

wor

ks–

GP

S R

ecei

ver –

Eric

sson

Ant

enna

–D

iver

sity

dual

-om

nidi

rect

iona

l–S

pace

Dat

a

LT

E P

aylo

ad

Ant

enna

Div

ersi

ty,d

ualo

mni

dire

ctio

nal

Spa

ceD

ata

–B

atte

ry s

yste

m –

Spa

ce D

ata

•Sp

ectr

um:O

pera

ted

inFi

rstN

etS

pect

rum

(Ban

d14

)und

er

Copy

right

Spa

ce D

ata

Corp

. / O

ceus

Net

work

s 201

3

Spec

trum

:Ope

rate

din

Firs

tNet

Spe

ctru

m(B

and

14)u

nder

STA

and

per

mis

sion

of F

irstN

et B

oard

5

Page 9: VIA ELECTRONIC FILING Secretary Federal · PDF fileSecretary Federal Communications Commission 445 12th Street, ... with a 4G LTE payload to assess the ... Protocol timing (max timing

LTE

SkyS

ite C

over

age

Geo

met

ryN

o Ti

min

g O

ffset

•C

over

age

Circ

le s

ize

limite

d by

tim

ing

and

link

budg

et–

Link

bud

get c

ompe

nsat

ed b

y U

E E

RP

and

gai

n of

ant

enna

, LN

A, a

t Sky

Site

–P

roto

col t

imin

g (m

ax ti

min

g ad

vanc

e fo

r LTE

= 0

.67

us o

r 100

km

roun

d tri

p)A

t20

klti

td

(65

617

ft)d

lt

tf1

00k

•A

t20

km a

ltitu

de(6

5,61

7ft)

and

max

. sla

nt ra

nge

to u

ser o

f100

km–

Del

ta fr

om n

eare

st to

farth

est u

ser =

100

-20

= 8

0 km

–Fr

ee s

pace

pat

h lo

ss is

–13

0.2

dB a

t 700

MH

z–

Min

. use

r ele

vatio

n an

gle

is 1

1.1°

equi

vale

nt to

bei

ng 0

.2 m

iles.

from

a 2

00-fo

ot to

wer

gg

•M

otor

ola

LEX

700

han

dset

out

put i

s 23

dB

m re

sults

in -9

5.3

dBm

pow

er a

t Sky

Site

R

ecei

ver a

fter S

kyS

ite 1

2 dB

i gai

n, 1

20 d

eg a

nten

na

20 k

m

Eart

h

Not

toS

cale

Copy

right

Spa

ce D

ata

Corp

. / O

ceus

Net

work

s 201

36

Not

toS

cale

Page 10: VIA ELECTRONIC FILING Secretary Federal · PDF fileSecretary Federal Communications Commission 445 12th Street, ... with a 4G LTE payload to assess the ... Protocol timing (max timing

Win

d St

eerin

g K

eeps

Bal

loon

ove

r Are

aSp

otlig

ht A

nten

na li

mits

Spe

ctru

m U

se A

rea

Stra

tosp

here

: man

y st

rata

of w

ind

with

var

ious

dire

ctio

ns/s

peed

s to

sel

ect f

rom

–V

entin

g to

des

cend

or b

alla

stin

g to

asc

end

sele

cts

a de

sire

d w

ind

laye

r–

Mid

-win

ter/m

id-s

umm

er w

inds

all

in o

ne d

irect

ion:

nee

d 2-

4 la

unch

es/d

ay th

enPl

atfo

rm is

sta

ble

enou

gh to

poi

nt d

irect

iona

l ant

enna

at c

ente

r of d

isas

ter a

rea

–D

irect

iona

l ant

enna

bea

m c

an s

potli

ght a

rea

to re

stric

t spe

ctru

m a

rea

of u

se

8500

0ft

Wi

dt

Et

75,0

00 ft

85,0

00ft

Vent

Win

d to

Wes

t

Win

dto

Eas

tB

alla

stFl

ying

“th

e B

ox”

Ant

enna

Bea

m w

idth

po

ints

at c

ente

r of

dis

aste

r ar

eaA

nten

naB

eam

wid

th

poin

ts a

t cen

ter

ofdi

sast

erar

eaTy

pica

lly 1

00 k

m

acro

ss w

ith

3 hr

s. be

twee

nlti

td

h

ofdi

sast

erar

ea

Copy

right

Spa

ce D

ata

Corp

. / O

ceus

Net

work

s 201

37

altit

ude

chan

ges

Dis

aste

r Are

a

Page 11: VIA ELECTRONIC FILING Secretary Federal · PDF fileSecretary Federal Communications Commission 445 12th Street, ... with a 4G LTE payload to assess the ... Protocol timing (max timing

DA

CA

2JU

L13

Flig

ht:

3D S

kySi

te F

light

Pat

h 7:35

AM

: Lau

nch

Bal

loon

3D

Tra

ckVi

olet

–70

+ kf

tB

lue

–60

+ kf

tG

reen

–40

+ kf

t

Clim

b O

ut W

inds

Sou

thJe

tstre

am 1

00 m

ph @

42

kft

15 m

in. t

ick

mar

ks8:

37: S

low

est W

ind

3 m

ph @

66

kft

1:30

PM

Rel

ease

Bal

loon

Gro

und

Trac

k -B

lack

8:47

AM

: 72

km e

ast o

f NIS

T @

73

kft

Hea

ding

eas

t tow

ard

NIS

T at

~18

mph

9 A

M:

Max

Alti

tude

75

kft

Cha

se V

ehic

le T

rack

-Red

9:15

AM

: Det

erm

ined

LTE

Tra

nsm

itter

ha

d Sh

utdo

wn

42 k

m E

ast o

f NIS

T al

titud

e lo

wer

ed to

68

kft

to c

atch

win

ds h

eadi

ng S

W T

o R

ecov

ery

Site

Copy

right

Spa

ce D

ata

Corp

. / O

ceus

Net

work

s 201

38

2:00

PM

Par

achu

te o

n G

roun

d, -

Rec

over

ed b

y 3

PM

Page 12: VIA ELECTRONIC FILING Secretary Federal · PDF fileSecretary Federal Communications Commission 445 12th Street, ... with a 4G LTE payload to assess the ... Protocol timing (max timing

Up

Vide

o at

Alti

tude

Show

s Ve

ry S

tabl

e A

nten

na

BLA

CK

OF

SPA

CE

SUN

SUN

Bot

tom

Bal

loon

Bot

tom

Sky

Site

Para

chut

e

Seat

belt

Stra

pH

arne

ss

Ant

enna

Copy

right

Spa

ce D

ata

Corp

. / O

ceus

Net

work

s 201

39

Page 13: VIA ELECTRONIC FILING Secretary Federal · PDF fileSecretary Federal Communications Commission 445 12th Street, ... with a 4G LTE payload to assess the ... Protocol timing (max timing

Mad

e th

e K

USA

Den

ver N

ews

Copy

right

Spa

ce D

ata

Corp

. / O

ceus

Net

work

s 201

310

http

://w

ww

.dig

tria

d.co

m/v

ideo

/def

ault.

aspx

?bct

id=2

5246

4049

2001

Page 14: VIA ELECTRONIC FILING Secretary Federal · PDF fileSecretary Federal Communications Commission 445 12th Street, ... with a 4G LTE payload to assess the ... Protocol timing (max timing

Key

Fin

ding

s

Key

Fin

ding

s1.

Long

rang

e or

“boo

mer

cel

l” op

erat

ion

with

LTE

is p

ossi

ble

prov

ided

the

“ ext

ende

dra

nge”

para

met

eris

impl

emen

ted

and

setw

ithin

the

eNod

eBO

urin

itial

exte

nded

rang

epa

ram

eter

isim

plem

ente

dan

dse

twith

inth

eeN

odeB

.Our

initi

alex

perim

ent w

as s

ucce

ssfu

l with

sta

tions

bot

h at

the

cent

er a

nd e

dge

of c

ell.

2A

lleq

uipm

entf

low

ndu

ring

DA

CA

oper

atio

nm

ustb

eha

rden

edto

with

stan

dth

e2.

All

equi

pmen

tflo

wn

durin

gD

AC

Aop

erat

ion

mus

tbe

hard

ened

tow

ithst

and

the

hars

h en

viro

nmen

t of h

igh

altit

ude

oper

atio

n. H

arde

ning

sho

uld

incl

ude,

but

mig

ht

not b

e lim

ited

to, f

requ

ency

refe

renc

e os

cilla

tors

, GP

S a

nd ti

min

g re

fere

nce

equi

pmen

t, an

d he

at g

ener

atin

g co

mpo

nent

s (li

ke p

ower

am

plifi

ers)

.

3.S

ome

leve

l of i

nter

fere

nce

betw

een

non-

sync

hron

ized

sys

tem

s w

as fo

und.

Fu

rther

test

dat

a w

ould

be

requ

ired

to e

xact

ly q

uant

ify.

4.E

xist

ing

FAA

regu

latio

ns a

llow

con

trolle

d hi

gh a

ltitu

de fl

ight

s. W

inds

of 3

mph

at

66,0

00 fe

et w

ould

hav

e pr

ovid

ed fu

ll 8

hour

s of

bat

tery

life

for m

issi

on w

ith o

nly

24

mile

sof

drift

even

with

outv

entin

g/ba

llast

ing

ballo

onto

diffe

rent

altit

udes

Copy

right

Spa

ce D

ata

Corp

. / O

ceus

Net

work

s 201

3

mile

sof

drift

even

with

outv

entin

g/ba

llast

ing

ballo

onto

diffe

rent

altit

udes

.

11

Page 15: VIA ELECTRONIC FILING Secretary Federal · PDF fileSecretary Federal Communications Commission 445 12th Street, ... with a 4G LTE payload to assess the ... Protocol timing (max timing

Nex

t Ste

ps

Nex

t Ste

ps:

FCC

sho

uld

furth

er s

tudy

the

feas

ibili

ty o

f cer

tain

DA

CA

con

figur

atio

ns, i

nclu

ding

, but

no

t lim

ited

to:

1.A

utho

rizat

ion

of D

AC

A p

latfo

rms

oper

atin

g in

pub

lic s

afet

y br

oadb

and

spec

trum

(L

TE 3

GP

P B

and

14),

unde

r a g

over

nanc

e m

odel

acc

epta

ble

to F

irstN

et, w

hich

fa

cilit

ates

rapi

d re

stor

al o

f com

mun

icat

ions

with

out i

nter

fere

nce

to e

xist

ing

grou

nd

bd

tba

sed

syst

ems.

2.D

eplo

ymen

t of D

AC

A in

Ban

d 14

usi

ng th

e m

ost a

ppro

pria

te d

eliv

ery

plat

form

. (H

igh

Alti

tude

Airb

orne

/Airc

raft

base

dTe

ther

edop

erat

ion)

(Hig

hA

ltitu

de,

Airb

orne

/Airc

raft

base

d,Te

ther

edop

erat

ion)

3.O

ptio

ns to

syn

chro

nize

and

ope

rate

in c

onju

nctio

n w

ith e

xist

ing

grou

nd b

ased

P

ublic

Saf

ety

LTE

syst

ems

Pub

licS

afet

yLT

Esy

stem

s.

4.In

vest

igat

e LT

E S

mal

l Cel

l dev

elop

men

ts a

s re

duct

ions

in S

ize,

Wei

ght a

nd P

ower

of

eNod

eBeq

uipm

entw

illal

low

long

erba

ttery

life;

espe

cial

lysi

nce

test

show

ed

Copy

right

Spa

ce D

ata

Corp

. / O

ceus

Net

work

s 201

3

ofeN

odeB

equi

pmen

twill

allo

wlo

nger

batte

rylif

e;es

peci

ally

sinc

ete

stsh

owed

less

than

20

W o

f tra

nsm

it po

wer

is n

eede

d to

clo

se li

nks

to U

ser E

quip

.

12

Page 16: VIA ELECTRONIC FILING Secretary Federal · PDF fileSecretary Federal Communications Commission 445 12th Street, ... with a 4G LTE payload to assess the ... Protocol timing (max timing

Rea

dy to

Pol

linat

e th

eW

orld

with

Bro

adba

nd Tha

nk Y

ou

Copy

right

Spa

ce D

ata

Corp

. / O

ceus

Net

work

s 201

313