vietnam and its major trade pacts or how the country could have deep impact on our global supply...

62

Click here to load reader

Upload: oliver-massmann

Post on 11-Jan-2017

2.118 views

Category:

Law


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

©2010 Duane Morris LLP. All Rights Reserved. Duane Morris is a registered service mark of Duane Morris LLP.

Duane Morris – Firm and Affiliate Offices | New York | London | Singapore | Los Angeles | Chicago | Houston | Hanoi | Philadelphia | San Diego | San Francisco | Baltimore | Boston | Washington, D.C. Las Vegas | Atlanta | Miami | Pittsburgh | Newark | Boca Raton | Wilmington | Cherry Hill | Princeton | Lake Tahoe | Ho Chi Minh City | Duane Morris LLP – A Delaware limited liability partnership

OLIVER MASSMANN - Partner, General Director

DUANE MORRIS VIETNAM LLC

VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR

HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP

IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

Page 2: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

AGENDA:

• OUTLOOK ON VIETNAM’S POLITICAL SITUATION

• OVERVIEW OF THE RECENT TRADE PACTS: ASEAN

ECONOMIC COMMUNITY (AEC), EU- VIETNAM

FREE TRADE AGREEMENT (EVFTA) AND THE

TRANS-PACIFIC PARTNERSHIP (TPP)

• MARKET ACCESS COMPARISON OF CERTAIN

COMMERCIAL SECTORS IN THE WTO, AEC, EVFTA

AND TPP

• CONCLUSION

2

Page 3: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Vietnam to be Asia’s second fastest growing

country

• In 2016, Vietnam’s GDP is expected to grow at 6.9%, higher than the

6.6% forecast, through better construction activity and manufacturing

strength (Standard Chartered Bank)

• The second fastest-growing economy in Asia, second only to India.

• Progressing for the third year in a row, Vietnam reached the 56th

position in 2015 on the Global Competitiveness Index (GCI) list, a jump

of 12 positions compared to 2014.

• Vietnam tops 6 European Union countries on the GCI list

• Consumption is likely to remain the biggest growth driver in 2016,

closely followed by investment.

• China’s economic slowdown and the US Federal Reserve increasing

interest rates were driving investor withdrawals from emerging markets.

3

Page 4: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

OUTLOOK ON VIETNAM’S

POLITICAL SITUATION

4

Page 5: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Vietnam Quo Vadis

• Central Committee of Communist Party Vietnam:

180 official members; 20 alternate members. 104

members are re-elected.

• Average age: 53

5

Page 6: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Vietnam Quo Vadis (cont.) • The loss of power of Prime Minister Nguyen Tan Dzung …

– Secretary General Nguyen Phu Trong continues his next 5-year term

– Components of the new Government are elected 3 months sooner than scheduled

– PM Dzung is not allowed to perform another term

– Mr. Tran Dai Quang – Minister of the Ministry of Public Security was elected to be the

President.

– The Secretary General is pro-China while PM Dzung is pro-America.

Mr. Trong was hesitant to criticize China when it brought Drill 981 to the Paracels in 2014

Mr. Dzung in his capacity of the PM has supervised the foreign investment inflow and improved

relations with top US leaders. He criticized China more strongly than other members of the

Congress of its defiant acts in the East Sea.

• ….and the fear of “Vietnam could move back”:

– PM Dzung is considered to be better at dealing with foreign investors and more willing to

remove the cover of Marxism ideology of the Congress than Mr. Trong

• However: Vietnam was and always is a consensus driven society

No person cult --- No “God” like figures as Mao in China

6

Page 7: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

ASEAN ECONOMIC COMMUNITY

7

Page 8: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

AEC establishment • One of the 3 pillars of ASEAN Community, together

with ASEAN Security Community and ASEAN Socio-

Cultural Community

• Originated from ASEAN Vision 2020 adopted in 1997

on the 30th anniversary of the Association of Southeast

Asian Nations

• The realization of the end goal of economic integration

as espoused in the Vision 2020, which is based on a

convergence of interests of ASEAN member countries

to deepen and broaden economic integration through

existing and new initiatives with clear timelines.

8

Page 9: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

9

Page 10: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

AEC Market Snapshot – Asia’s main

investment hub

• GDP: US$2311.3 billion (2012)

• GDP per capita: US$3748.4 (2012)

• Population: 620 million, 60% under the age of 35

• AEC % of world GDP: ~3.3%

• AEC % of world population: 9%

• AEC’s merchandise exports: US$1.2 trillion - ~54% of total

ASEAN GDP and 7% of global exports

• If ASEAN were one economy, it would be the 7th largest in

the world – 4th largest by 2050 if growth trends continue

10

Page 11: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Key characteristics of AEC

11

Page 12: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

AEC Tariff Liberalization

• Started in 1992 when the Common Effective Preferential Tariff

Scheme (CEPT) was signed.

• The ASEAN Free Trade Agreement (AFTA) was created with an

aim to further tariff reduction and elimination of goods with

ASEAN origin.

• The ASEAN Trade in Goods Agreement (ATIGA) in 2009 and its

enforcement in 2010 made it possible for traders to enjoy much

reduced tariff rates under this Agreement.

• In 2014, the average ATIGA rate was 0.04% for ASEAN-6

(Brunei Darussalam, Indonesia, Malaysia, Philippines, Singapore

and Thailand). For other countries (Laos, Cambodia, Myanmar and

Vietnam), this was 1.33%. 12

Page 13: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

ASEAN Rules of Origin

• Products are considered as originating from ASEAN

countries if:

– They are wholly obtained or produced in the exporting Member

State; or

– They are not wholly obtained or produced in the exporting Member

State but satisfy substantial transformation requirements such as

regional value content; change in tariff classification or some other

product-specific requirements.

• In order for a good to be eligible for preferential tariff

treatment, the exporting Member State has to obtain a

Certificate of Origin (Form D) issued by a Government

Authority designated by the exporting Member State. 13

Page 14: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

EU – Vietnam Free Trade Agreement

(EVFTA)

14

Page 15: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

EU- Vietnam trading partnership

• The EU is currently the second largest trading partner and

one of the 2 largest export markets of Vietnam.

• By the end of 2014, 23 out of 28 EU countries have invested

in Vietnam with over 2,000 projects worth more than USD37

billion.

• Vietnam’s main exports to the EU: footwear, textile products,

coffee, seafood and wood products, etc.

• EU’s main exports to Vietnam: machines, chemicals, milk

and milk products, steel products, etc.

15

Page 16: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

EVFTA – Bilateral negotiations

16

Launch of

negotiations

First

round in

Hanoi

15 rounds

alternately

in Vietnam

and

Brussels

Last

round in

Hanoi

Agreement

in

principle

06/2012 10/

2012

Conclusion

of

negotiation

FTA text

released

Page 17: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

EVFTA – Comprehensive agreement

• Trade in goods

Market access for goods – tariffs

Rules of Origin

Export duties

Technical Barriers to Trade (TBT)

Sanitary and Phytosanitary Measures

Customs and Trade Facilitation

Administrative Cooperation in Customs Matters

• Services and investment:

National treatment

Liberalisation commitments / market access

Investment to state dispute settlement

17

Cross-cutting issues

Dispute Settlement and Investment

Dispute Settlement

Government Procurement

State Owned Enterprises & Subsidies

Intellectual Property Rights

Geographical Indications

Trade and Sustainable Development

Cooperation and Capacity building

Annexes (car; green tech and pharma)

Page 18: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

EVFTA – Tariff Liberalization

• Tariff liberalization:

– 99% of tariffs both value and number of tariff lines

– After 7 years for EU

– Vietnam: 10 years

• Coverage at entry into force:

– 70.3% of value of Vietnamese exports / 86% tariff lines

– 65% value of EU exports / 49% tariff lines

18

Page 19: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Rules of Origin in the EVFTA

• Products are considered originating under the agreement if they

meet one of the following requirements:

– wholly obtained in the EU Member States or in Vietnam

– products produced in the EU or in Vietnam incorporating materials which

have not been wholly obtained there, provided that such materials have

undergone sufficient working or processing within the EU or Vietnam.

• There are prescribed set procedures for certain goods that must be

completed within the EU or Vietnamese borders to be qualified as

originating goods.

• Procedures such as breaking-up and assembly of packages; simple

painting and polishing operations or sharpening, etc. are exempted

areas of working to obtain originating status.

19

Page 20: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

EVFTA – Benefits for Vietnam

• Vietnam’s annual economic expansions rate may grow an additional 15%

every year (said Tomaso Andreatta, representative of the European Business

Association in Vietnam (EuroCham), at the Vietnam Business Forum 2014)

• Tariffs for most of Vietnamese export product to the EU will gradually

reduce to 0% and Vietnam’s export to EU is expected to grow about 35%

for next few years

• The real wages of skilled laborers may increase by up to 12% while real

salary of common workers may rise by 13%

• The EVFTA is the legal framework for a more stable relationship in bilateral

trade for Vietnam when competing in the international market

• The EVFTA will generate greater effects, e.g. increased quality of

investment flows from EU, acceleration of the process of sharing expertise

and transfer of green technology and the creation of more employment

activities

20

Page 21: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

TRANS-PACIFIC PARTNERSHIP

21

Page 22: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com 22

Page 23: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

History of the TPP

23

Trans-pacific Strategic

Economic Partnership

(P4) signed

Scope of negotiation

extended with

participation of other

countries, including the

US Negotiation of the

TPP officially launched First negotiation round in

Melbourne- Australia

with 7 members Other countries such

as Malaysia, Japan,

Canada and Mexico

participated in the

negotiation

Finally agreement reached

in Atlanta negotiation

round

05 Oct. 2015

03 June 2005

Dec 2009

Oct 2010 –

July 2013

2007

March 2010

Text released on 05 Nov.

2015 and the agreement

was signed on 4 Feb 2016

Page 24: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

How is the TPP Different?

• GDP of 12 TPP Members is nearly $28 trillion, 40% of global GDP and

one-third of world trade

• The TPP is being touted as a “high-standard agreement” meaning “a

landmark, 21st-century trade agreement, setting a new standard for

global trade and incorporating next-generation issues”

• So-called "key elements" including the notion of comprehensive

market access, a fully regional agreement, cross-cutting issues

(regulatory coherence, competiveness and business facilitation, small and

medium sized enterprises, and development), new trade challenges

(particularly rules on state owned enterprises); as well as, finally, the

notion of a living agreement.

24

Page 25: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

TPP Trade in Goods

• Tariff and non-tariff barriers on most industrial goods are

eliminated immediately, with tariffs on some sensitive products will

be phased out as agreed by the TPP Parties.

• Each TPP Parties provide a tariff schedule covering all goods.

• Parties agree not to use performance requirements, such as local

production requirements.

• Parties agree not to impose WTO-inconsistent import-export

restrictions and duties. If any, they are required to notify the others

about the procedures to ensure transparency and promote trade

flows.

25

Page 26: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Trade in Services

• Negative approach, meaning that their markets are fully

opened to service suppliers from other TPP Parties, except

otherwise indicated in their commitments (non-conforming

measures)

• In order to make such reservations, the member state must

prove the necessity of such preservation and negotiate with

other member states. If approved, the non-conforming

measures are only limited to such list, except for measures in

certain sensitive sectors which are included in a separate list

• Ratchet approach: Member states are only allowed to adopt

policies that are better than what they commit

26

Page 27: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Rules of Origin

• Originating goods:

– Wholly obtained or produced goods;

– Produced in and from materials originating from TPP countries; or

– Produced in and using material not originating from TPP countries nut

satisfying TPP rules of origin.

• Separate rules of origin for each specific type of goods

• Separate chapter on rules of origin for textile products

• Rules of origin in TPP are predominantly based on a specified shift in

tariff classification, regional value content and production stages

• No requirement for certificates of origin under TPP, or third-party

certification of origin but self-certification is sufficient

• Note that Vietnam applies different schedules of tariff elimination/

reduction for different categories of goods 27

Page 28: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Textiles and Apparel

• Most tariffs on textiles and apparel will be eliminated

immediately, although tariffs on some sensitive products will

be phased out as agreed by the TPP Parties.

• Yarn-forward rule of origin: requires use of yarns and fabrics

from TPP countries in end products qualifying for

preferential treatment under TPP.

• Exceptions:

– a carefully tailored short supply list (when certain yarns and fabrics

not widely available in the region).

– de minimis

– 1 for 1 rule applied for women’s and men’s cotton trousers exported

to the US

28

Page 29: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Yarn-forward rule: Impact on Vietnam’s textile industry

• Current status and Issues:

– Around 6,000 textile companies in Vietnam - ~600,000 machines have to be replaced

– 60% of imported materials sourced from other non-TPP countries (mainly China)

– Domestic production of materials has not met the demand

– Yarn production must go together with weaving and dying but environment protection

is currently an issue.

• Impacts and what to do next:

– More foreign investment in textile industry with investment value of up to USD1

billion.

– Sourcing managers are looking for alternatives due to rising costs, labor shortages, strict

compliance and environmental regulations and a move to production of high value

products in China

– Establish domestic supply chain

– Bring into operation domestic yarn production factories

29

Page 30: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

How will TPP benefit Vietnam? 70% 70% of the total export value of Vietnam’s textile industry is from TPP countries. By participating in

the TPP, the market is expected to double. Export turnover to the US may reach USD55 billion in 2025

0% The average tax rate on textile products into

the US market is currently 17.5%, after TPP

it falls down to 0%

0% The whole import tariffs on footwear currently

from 3.5% to 57.4% also falls down to 0%

USD 335.7 billion According to a study by East – West Centre (USA), Vietnam’s GDP may increase by USD35.7 billion,

equivalent to 10.5% until 2025. At the same time, Vietnam’s exports also increase by 28.84%, equivalent

to USD67.9 billion

Investment increases by 9.2% TPP helps Vietnam’s GDP increase by 1-2%/year as a result of an increase in investment by 9.2% (mostly

inbound investment), consumption increase by USD6.9 billion and production increase by USD2.4 billion

Opportunities to

export flagship

products

Create more than 6

million jobs in textile

industry until 20

Liberalizing investment

environment among TPP

countries

Expectation on more competitive business

environment, cheaper goods and services at

higher quality

TPP offers free market access for enterprises

operating in service sectors

30

Page 31: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS)

• Through binding arbitration, including for violations of the investment

and financial services chapters.

• ISDS provisions are expected to include protections commonly found in

investment agreements such as non-discrimination; fair and equitable

treatment; full protection and security; the prohibition of expropriation

that is not for public purpose, without due process, or without

compensation; the free transfer of funds related to investments; and the

freedom to appoint senior management positions regardless of

nationality.

• Expected new protections in the TPP:

– Transparency in arbitral proceedings, disclosure of filings and arbitral awards, and

participation of interested non-disputing parties to make amicus curiae submissions

to a tribunal

– Safeguards to ensure government’s ability to regulate in the public interest (public

health, safety and the environment)

31

Page 32: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com 32

Page 33: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com 33

Page 34: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

TPP and AEC intersection

34

Thailand

Malaysia

Brunei

Canada Australia

Cambodia

Indonesia Myanmar

Peru

Philippines

Japan

Laos

Mexico New Zealand

Singapore

The United States

Vietnam

Chile

Page 35: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

ASEAN TPP: Market Access Liberalization as

Consequence of TPP

• Indonesia plans to loose restrictions on foreign investment in

nearly 50 sectors, including e-commerce, retail, healthcare,

movie and several other industries

• Indonesia prepares for the so-called “Negative Investment

List”, which provides a greater openness to foreign

investment and gets itself ready for the TPP

• China, Korea, the Philippines, Indonesia and Thailand are

also keen to join the TPP to overcome the disadvantages

35

Page 36: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

MARKET ACCESS COMPARISON OF

CERTAIN COMMERCIAL SECTORS IN

THE WTO, AEC, EVFTA AND TPP

36

Page 37: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Notes regarding the market access

commitments

• The WTO, AEC and EVFTA take a positive approach,

meaning what is open to foreign investment is listed.

• The TPP only lists the restrictions, meaning what is not

written therein is fully open (negative approach).

• In WTO Market Access Service Sector the principle applies:

Who does not ask and demand might not get the market

access for investment. There is NO Automatic Right for

Market Access for the WTO members in the WTO Services

Sectors in principle.

37

Page 38: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Distribution sector

38

Distribution of cigarettes and cigars,

publications, precious metals and stones,

pharmaceutical products and drugs, explosives,

processed oil and crude oil by foreign

investors are still prohibited

Page 39: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Distribution sector

WTO / AFAS EVFTA TPP

The establishment of outlets for

retail services (beyond the first

one) shall be allowed on the basis

of an Economic Needs Test

(ENT)

Same as in the WTO / AFAS but

added cases for ENT exemption

and timeline for ENT abolishment

In case of establishing an outlet

less than 500m2 within the area

planned for trading activities and

already completed construction of

infrastructure, ENT is not

required.

5 years from the date of entry into

force of the Agreement, the

requirement of the ENT will be

abolished.

Same as in the EVFTA but

clarifies the criteria of the ENT.

The main criteria of the ENT

include the number of existing

service suppliers in a particular

geographic area, the stability of

market and geographic scale.

39

WTO / AFAS requires an ENT for establishment of outlets for retail services (beyond the first one). EVFTA

requires the same but adds cases for ENT exemption and timeline for ENT abolishment. Meanwhile, in addition

to what EVFTA covers, the TPP clarifies on what basis the ENT is conducted.

Page 40: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Power/ Energy Sector

Level of commitment in Power / Energy sector

40

WTO / AFAS

EVFTA

TPP

N/A Low High

Page 41: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Power/ Energy Sector

WTO / AFAS EVFTA TPP

N/A Commitments are only made

in 3 sub-sectors

Vietnam makes commitments in

all sub-sectors with listed

restrictions (no other

restrictions are permitted).

41

Page 42: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Transport Services

42

Maritime Transport

WTO =

AFAS =

TPP

EVFTA

Internal Waterways Transport

WTO =

TPP

AFAS =

EVFTA

Rail Transport

WTO =

EVFTA TPP AFAS TPP

WTO =

EVFTA AFAS

Air Transport

Low High Low High

Page 43: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Transport Services

• Maritime transport

– WTO / AFAS/ EVFTA: joint venture with maximum 49% foreign ownership

while the TPP allows joint venture with maximum 70% foreign ownership

• Internal waterways transport

– WTO/ TPP: joint venture with maximum 49% foreign ownership while EVFTA/

AFAS allows joint venture with maximum 51% foreign ownership.

• Rail freight transport

– WTO/ TPP/ EVFTA: joint venture with maximum 49% foreign ownership while

AFAS allows joint venture with maximum 51% foreign ownership.

• Air transport (Selling and Marketing of Air Transport Services)

– WTO/ EVFTA: Airlines are permitted to provide service in Viet Nam through their

ticketing offices or agents in Viet Nam but in the AFAS, there is no such restriction.

Meanwhile, the TPP does not make any commitment in this sub-sector.

43

Page 44: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Transport

44

Page 45: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Insurance Services

Level of commitment in Insurance sector

45

EVFTA

WTO / AFAS

TPP

Low Med High

Page 46: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Insurance Services

EVFTA WTO / AFAS TPP

No commitment

regarding cross-border

supply of health

insurance services

Non-life branches of

foreign insurance

enterprises shall be

permitted subject to

prudential regulations. No

specific conditions are

specified, meaning the

Government can adopt

conditions as it wishes to.

No restriction regarding

cross-border supply of

health insurance service

Same as EVFTA

Supply of Cross-border services by foreign insurance company

must be conducted via an insurance broker which has the

license to establish and operate in Vietnam.

Non-life branches of foreign insurance enterprises shall be

permitted with conditions. The Government can adopt

different conditions than what mentioned but must not be

more restricted.

46

The TPP provides the same requirements as the EVFTA/ WTO/ AFAS but clarifies the

conditions to apply such requirements.

Page 47: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Banking Services

47

WTO = AFAS =

EVFTA TPP

Low High

Page 48: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Banking services

WTO/ AFAS / EVFTA TPP

Mode 1: No commitment, except:

Provision and transfer of financial information, and financial data

processing and related software by suppliers of other financial

services; and

Advisory, intermediation and other auxiliary financial services on all

activities listed in subparagraphs from (a) to (k), including credit

reference and analysis, investment and portfolio research and advice,

advice on acquisitions and on corporate restructuring and strategy.

Mode 3: Foreign purchase of shares in each Viet Nam's joint-stock

commercial bank may not exceed 30% of the bank's chartered capital.

A branch of foreign commercial bank is not allowed to open other

transaction points outside its branch office, excluding ATMs.

Mode 1: No restriction

Mode 3: No other restrictions other than:

A foreign credit institution or a foreign institution engaged in a

banking operation shall only be permitted to establish one

representative office in each province or city under central authority.

General directors (directors), deputy general directors (deputy

directors), chief accountants, directors of branches and directors of

subsidiary companies and people assuming equivalent positions must

reside in Viet Nam during their term of office whenever they assume

the positions in the Board of Directors of a credit institution.

48

Mode 1: The WTO/ AFAS/ EVFTA only commits on 2 sub-sectors with restrictions

while the TPP does not place any restriction for all sub-sectors.

Page 49: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Securities services

49

WTO =

AFAS EVFTA TPP

Low High

Page 50: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Securities services

WTO/ AFAS EVFTA TPP

Commitments on 6 sub-sectors

Mode 3:

foreign securities service suppliers are

permitted to establish representative

offices and joint ventures with maximum

foreign ownership of 49%.

After 5 years from the date of accession,

securities service suppliers with 100%

foreign-invested capital shall be

permitted.

Same commitments in 6 sub-sectors

Commitments on 2 additional services:

Provision and transfer of financial data

processing; and credit reference and

analysis.

Mode 3: Same as the WTO/ AFAS

No restrictions except the following:

The operation and services provided by

branches of foreign securities company

and fund management company in Viet

Nam are subject to approval of the

Government of Viet Nam, including the

imposition of conditions for the approval.

Foreign participation from above 49% to

less than 100% of charter capital of a

securities company, fund management

company in Viet Nam is subject to

approval of the Government of Viet

Nam, including the imposition of

conditions for the approval.

50

The TPP allows 49-100% foreign ownership right at the time of effective date subject to

Government’s approval while the WTO/ AFAS / EVFTA only allows 49%. 100% ownership

is only permitted after 5 years from the date of accession.

Page 51: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Telecommunication Services

51

WTO =

AFAS EVFTA TPP

Low High

Page 52: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Telecommunication Services

52

• Non facilities-based services: WTO/ AFAS:

maximum 65% foreign ownership forever but in the

EVFTA after 5 years, this could be 75%. For the TPP

after 5 years, this is 100%.

• Other services - Virtual Private Network (VPN):

maximum 70% foreign ownership forever but in the

EVFTA after 5 years, this could be 75%. For the TPP

after 5 years, this is 100%.

Page 53: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Government Procurement

53

Low High

Page 54: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Government Procurement

• Thresholds: EVFTA provides shorter period of time and

higher initial transitional threshold.

• Entities covered: under the EVFTA, more entities are

subject to government procurement rules than in the

TPP.

• Application of offsets: under the EVFTA, offsets are

applied based on value of a contract (including non-

covered procurement) but in the TPP, it is based only on

the covered procurement.

54

Page 55: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Government Procurement Criteria EVFTA TPP

Monetary values that determine whether

procurement by central government is

covered under an agreement

130,000 Special Drawing Rights (SDRs) (US$191,000) from 15 years

since the entry into force of the agreement

Initial transitional threshold: 1.5 million SDRs

130,000 Special Drawing Rights (SDRs) (US$191,000)

from 25 years since the entry into force of the agreement

Initial transitional threshold: 2 million SDRs

Procurement of construction services by

central government entities

Initial threshold: 65.2 million SDRs

After 15 years, 8.5 million SDRs

Initial threshold: 40 million SDRs

After 15 years, 5 million SDRs

Entities covered 22 central government bodies (added the Ministry of Public Security)

42 other entities: added two state-owned enterprises (Vietnam

Electricity and Vietnam Railways) and two universities (Vietnam

National University – Hanoi and Vietnam National University – Ho Chi

Minh City)

Sub-central government coverage: Adds 2 cities: Hanoi and Ho Chi

Minh – expansion of the list within 15 years since the entry into force of

the agreement

21 central government bodies

38 other entities

No sub-central government coverage - expansion of the

list within 3 years since the entry into force of the

agreement

Exclusion of preferences for SMEs Broad exclusion applies only to procurement of goods and services whose

value is estimated at 260,000 SDRs or less and may not be

applied to SMEs with more than 500 permanent full-time

employees.

Application of offsets Based on value of a contract Based on the total value of covered procurement 55

Page 56: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Recommendations for enterprises

• Carefully study rules of origin in each trade agreement

• Understand which specific procedures apply for own

products to build an effective sourcing and product

development plan accordingly

• Note that while different countries apply different tariff rates

for the same products, the rules of origin are still the same. It

means that if a product satisfies the rules of origin in an

agreement, it will be entitled with tariff preferential treatment.

56

Page 57: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

Questions & Answers

57

Page 58: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

DUANE MORRIS VIETNAM LLC

Thank you very much!

HANOI OFFICE HO CHI MINH CITY OFFICE

Pacific Place, Unit V1307/08, 13th Floor, Suite 1503/04, Saigon Tower

83B Ly Thuong Kiet, Hoan Kiem District 29 Le Duan Street, District 1

Hanoi, Vietnam Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam

Tel.: +84 4 39462200 Tel.: +84 8 3824 0240

Fax: +84 4 3946 1311 Fax: +84 8 3824 0241

Contact email:

[email protected] Do not distribute to third parties, all IP rights reserved!

58

Page 59: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

References (1)

59

Page 60: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

References (2)

60

Page 61: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

References (3)

61

Page 62: VIETNAM AND ITS MAJOR TRADE PACTS OR HOW THE COUNTRY COULD HAVE DEEP IMPACT ON OUR GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS

www.duanemorris.com

References (4)

62