violence nobel symposium

7/25/2019 Violence Nobel Symposium

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/violence-nobel-symposium 1/24

!"# %#&'()# *+ !"#$%&' )#&*$"+',! !"#$

!"

!"# %&'& !"#$$% !"#$

!"#$%"&' )*+*&&, "-. /"##*0 /*12,&"# 3"&'45

!"#$% '()*"+,-) ./.0 12$ 34-+$+ "5 6$47$8 9-:$ .;<.=8 >?./8 @$AB$:8 !"AC4(8 D!"#$%

E"-:F4G,":H

EIJ'1 KJLE1<6%$4+$ F" :"G 7,G$ C,G2"-G *$A),+,": "A *-#%,74G,": "5 5,:4% *A"7$$F,:B+M

"#$$%&'0 N$ *A"*"+$ 4 )$G2"F"%"B( G" %""O 4G P,"%$:7$ ,: *4AG,7-%4A8 4:F "G2$A 4+*$7G+ "5

Q-4:G,G4G,P$ 2,+G"A,"BA4*2( ,: B$:$A4% ,: 4 C4( 7")*4G,#%$ C,G2 +G4G,+G,74% ,:5$A$:7$8 C2,72

:$$F+ G" 477"))"F4G$ G2$ 54G<G4,%$F:$++ "5 G2$ F4G4 4:F G2$ -:A$%,4#,%,G( "5 G2$ A$*"AG+ "5

7":5%,7G+M N$ ,:P$+G,B4G$ G2$ G2$+$+ "5 R%":B *$47$S 4:F FA"* ,: P,"%$:7$ 4:F 5,:F G24G G2$+$

4A$ +G4G,+G,74%%( ,:P4%,F 4:F A$+-%G,:B 5A") 5%4C$F 4:F :4,P$ )$G2"F"%"B,$+8 ,:7")*4G,#%$

C,G2 54G G4,%+ 4:F :":<A"#-+G G" ),:"A 724:B$+ ,: F4G4 5"A)4GG,:B 4:F )$G2"F"%"B,$+M 12$A$

,+ :" +G4G,+G,74% #4+,+ G" 7%4,) G24G RG,)$+ 4A$ F,55$A$:GS "C,:B G" G2$ %":B ,:G$A<4AA,P4% G,)$+

#$GC$$: 7":5%,7G+T G2$A$ ,+ :" #4+,+ G" F,+7-++ 4:( RGA$:FS8 4:F :" +7,$:G,5,7 #4+,+ 5"A

:4AA4G,P$+ 4#"-G 724:B$ ,: A,+OM N$ F$+7A,#$ :4,P$ $)*,A,7,+) -:F$A 54G G4,%+M N$ 4%+"

$+G4#%,+2 G24G P,"%$:7$ 24+ 4 RGA-$ )$4:S G24G ,+ -:F$A$+G,)4G$F ,: G2$ GA47O A$7"AFM 12,+ ,+ 4

2,+G"A,"BA4*2,74% 4F4*G4G,": "5 G2$ A$+-%G+ ,: 3,A,%%" 4:F 14%$# D>?./HM

!"#$%&'#

12$ 5,A+G G2$"A( "5 R%":B *$47$S ,+ 4+ 5"%%"C+M I: .=;=8 ":$ UM1M @-7O%$ CA"G$0

124G G2,+ #4A#4A"-+ *-A+-,G ,+8 ,: G2$ *A"BA$++ "5 +"7,$G(8 +G$4F,%( F$7%,:,:B8 )-+G #$

$P,F$:G8 $P$: G" G2$ )"+G 24+G( A$4F$A "5 V-A"*$4: 2,+G"A(M I5 C$ 7")*4A$ ":$

7"-:GA( C,G2 4:"G2$A8 C$ +24%% 5,:F G24G 5"A 4 P$A( %":B *$A,"F C4A+ 24P$ #$$:

#$7"),:B %$++ 5A$Q-$:GT 4:F :"C +" 7%$4A%( ,+ G2$ )"P$)$:G )4AO$F8 G24G8 -:G,% G2$

%4G$ 7"))$:7$)$:G "5 2"+G,%,G,$+8 C$ 24F A$)4,:$F 4G *$47$ 5"A :$4A%( 5"AG( ($4A+0 4

. K$%5G I:+G,G-G$ "5 1$72:"%"B( 4:F 14:F": '72""% "5 V:B,:$$A,:B8 !$C W"AO X:,P$A+,G(M 12$

7":GA,#-G,":+ "5 G2$ 4-G2"A+ G" G2,+ *4*$A 4:F G2$ B$:$A4% +G4G,+G,74% +G-F,$+ 4++"7,4G$F C,G2

,G8 4A$ $Q-4%M N$ G24:O 34*G4,: Y4A7 N$,+$:#"A: 5"A 2,+ F,%,B$:G 4:F ,:F$54G,B4#%$ C"AO ,:

7"%%$7G,:B8 72$7O,:B8 4:F 7")*4A,:B F4G4M



>

7,A7-)+G4:7$ -:*4A4%%$%$F DMMMH 12$ Q-$+G,": 4A,+$+8 4+ G" C24G +24A$ "-A )"A4%

5$$%,:B+ 24P$ 24F ,: #A,:B,:B 4#"-G G2,+ BA$4G ,)*A"P$)$:GM D@-7O%$8 .=;=H M

@-7O%$ C4+ *$A24*+ RA,B2GS D C,G2 ),:"A 2,7O<-*+H 5"A 4:"G2$A 5,P$ F$74F$+8 #-G )"A4%

5$$%,:B+ "A :"G8 G2$ 7$:G-A( 5"%%"C,:B YAM @-7O%$Z+ *A"+$ G-A:$F "-G G" #$ G2$ )"+G

)-AF$A"-+ ,: 2-)4: 2,+G"A(M

12$ 5,A+G [ "#P,"-+ [ *A"#%$) ,+ G24G @-7O%$ )4F$ 4 +$P$A$%( 5%4C$F A,+O 4++$++)$:GM 12$

+$7":F ,+ G24G 2$ 5$%G "#%,B4G$F G" )"-:G 4 :4AA4G,P$ $:G4,%,:B R)"A4% 5$$%,:B+S 5"A C24G 2$

*$A7$,P$F C$A$ G2$ 724:B$+ ,: G2$ $:P,A":)$:GM !"G$ G24G @-7O%$ C4+ *%47,:B 2,)+$%5 ,: G2$

GA4F,G,": "5 R+7,$:G,5,7S +"7,4% +7,$:7$ "5 L-B-+G$ 3")G$M

L:"G2$A $P$:GM I: >??\8 @$: @$A:4:O$8 G2$: 4 )$)#$A "5 G2$ #"4AF "5 G2$ E$F$A4% J$+$AP$

@4:O "5 G2$ X:,G$F 'G4G$+ *A"7%4,)$F G24G $7":"),7 %,5$ C4+ -:F$AB",:B 4 RBA$4G

)"F$A4G,":S8 ": G2$ #4+,+ "5 4: -:*A$7$F$:G$F +G4#,%,G( "5 $7":"),7 P4A,4#%$+ D14%$#8 >??]8

>?.?HM ^,O$ @-7O%$8 2$ 5"-:F G2$ A$4+":+ 5"A G24GM 12$ G2$"A( #$74)$ G2$ :"A) -:G,% G2$

7A,+,+ "5 >??] C2$: C$ $_*$A,$:7$F 4 +,),%4A A$P,+,": "5 #$%,$5M```

12,+ 4AG,7%$ ,+ "AB4:,a$F 4+ 5"%%"C+M E,A+G C$ *A$+$:G G2$ *A"#%$)+ 4++"7,4G$F C,G2 2,+G"A,74%

4:4%(+$+ "5 P,"%$:7$M '$7":F8 C$ F,+7-++ G2$ Q-4:G,G4G,P$ 4**A"472$+ +,:7$ J,724AF+":

D.b\=H 4:F *A$+$:G G2$ +G4G,+G,74% 5%4C+ 4:F )$G2"F"%"B,74% $AA"A+ ,: G2$ C,F$%( 2$%F

G2$"A,$+ +-72 4+ G2"+$ ,: 6,:O$A D>?..HM 12,AF8 C$ F,+7-++ "-A 4**A"472M E"-AG28 C$ *A"P,F$

4 +%,B2G%( )"A$ G$72:,74% #47O-*M E,5G28 C$ B,P$ "-A P$AF,7GM

)*%# !"*&'#%+ ,- ./$-0,0$0,1# 2,+0*",*3"$456

'G-F(,:B G2$ 2,+G"A( "5 P,"%$:7$ G" F$G$7G GA$:F+ 4:F 724:B$+ "P$A 4 G,)$ *$A,"F ,+ 4 :":<GA,P,4% G4+O 5"A 4 +7,$:G,+G 7":+GA4,:$F #( A,B"AM N$ %,+G 5,P$ *A"#%$)+ G24G 4A$ *4AG,7-%4A G"

P,"%$:7$8 #-G )4( #$ -:,P$A+4% G" 4:( 5"A) "5 Q-4:G,G4G,P$ 4:F +G4G,+G,74% 2,+G"A,"BA4*2(M

(&)*+,$ -. /%0 0%1+23 E,A+G8 C$ 4A$ F$4%,:B C,G2 4 R54G<G4,%$FS *2$:")$:":M N$ F$5,:$

P,"%$:7$ +$$: Q-4:G,G4G,P$%( 4+ $,G2$A R54G4%,G,$+ "P$A 4 +*$7,5,7 G,)$ *$A,"FS "A R54G4%,G,$+ *$A

+*$7,5,7 $P$:GS 4:F #"G2 4A$ 54G G4,%$F P4A,4#%$+M N24G 724A47G$A,a$+ 54G G4,%$F P4A,4#%$+c

12$+$ 24P$ G2$,A *A"*$AG,$+ D+-72 4+ G2$ 4P$A4B$H F"),:4G$F #( $_GA$)$ $P$:G+8 G2"+$ d,:

G2$ G4,%+dM 12$ )"+G *"*-%4A%( O:"C: P$A+,": ,+ G2$ d64A$G" =?e>?d D=? f "5 G2$ *$"*%$ ,:

IG4%(8 64A$G" :"G,7$F8 "C: >?f "5 G2$ %4:F8 4:F P,7$ P$A+48 C2,72 #( A$7-A+,": %$4F+ G" .f "5

G2$ *$"*%$ "C:,:B ;gf "5 G2$ %4:FHM

12$+$ G""%+ 4A$ :"G h-+G R724:B,:B G2$ 7"%"A "5 G2$ FA$++S8 #-G G2$( A$Q-,A$ 4 :$C +G4G,+G,74%

5A4)$C"AO 4:F 4 F,55$A$:G C4( "5 G2,:O,:B8 B",:B 5A") G2$ G4,% G" G2$ #"F( D+G4:F,:B G2$-+-4% +G4G,+G,74% %"B,78 C2,72 7":+,+G+ "5 B",:B 5A") G2$ #"F( G" G2$ G4,%8 ": ,G+ 2$4FH [4:F G2$

BA$4G )4h"A,G( "5 A$+$4A72$A+ C2" 4A$ GA4,:$F ,: +G4G,+G,7+ 4A$ :"G 54),%,4A C,G2 G2$ #A4:72$+

"5 G2$ F,+7,*%,:$ 4:F G2$"A$)+ :$$F$F 5"A 54G G4,%+ D+$$ 14%$# >??]e>?.?8 >?./HM 1" 4FF G"

G2$ *A"#%$)8 "-A $_4),:4G,": +2"C+ G24G C4A G-A:$F "-G G" #$ G2$ )"G2$A "5 54G G4,%+8 54A

C"A+$ G24: G2$ *"*-%4A =?e>?0 G2$A$ 4A$ 5$C *2$:")$:4 +-72 4+ 5%-,F G-A#-%$:7$ "A G2$A)4%

+*,O$+ ": G2$ +-A547$ "5 G2$ +-: G24G 74: A,P4% G2$ 54G<G4,%$F:$++ "5 P,"%$:7$M E-AG2$A8

2,+G"A,74% F4G4 4A$ G$)*"A4% D+*A$4F "-G "P$A G,)$H 4:F +G4G,+G,74% 4:4%(+$+ "5 G,)$ +$A,$+

D+-72 4+ 5,:4:7,4% F4G4H A$Q-,A$ 54A )"A$ +"*2,+G,74G,": G24: +,)*%$ +G4G,+G,74% G$+G+ 5"-:F ,:

$)*,A,74% +7,$:G,5,7 *4*$A+M E"A ,:+G4:7$ ":$ 74::"G #%,:F%( -+$ G2$ +4)$ )$G2"F+ G"

7")*-G$ G2$ +G4G,+G,74% *A"*$AG,$+ "5 7,G( +,a$ 4:F G2$ G,)$ +$A,$+ "5 C4A [+,:7$ ,: G2$ %4GG$A



g

74+$ G2$ "#+$AP$F *A"*$AG,$+ F$*$:F ": "-A +-AP,P4% D+4( 4 .b/? :-7%$4A C4A C"-%F 24P$

*A$P$:G$F -+ 5A") 24P,:B G2,+ F,+7-++,":H8 2$:7$ A$+GA,7G,": 4**%( G" C24G 74: "A 74::"G #$

,:5$AA$F DG2$A$ ,+ 4 F,55$A$:7$ #$GC$$: $:+$)#%$ *A"#4#,%,G( 4:F G,)$ *A"#4#,%,G(8 G2"-B2

:"G 4%C4(+8 4:F G2$ $55$7G "5 G2$ #,4+ :$$F+ G" #$ $+G4#%,+2$FHM

(&)*+,$ 4. 5)#67,76,223 !"G ":%( 4A$ C$ F$4%,:B C,G2 $_GA$)$ 54G G4,%+8 #-G G2$ $55$7G ,+

#"-:F$F8 C,G2 4: 4%)"+G *A$7,+$%( O:"C: -**$A %,),G [:" C4A 74: O,%% )"A$ G24: G2$

*"*-%4G,": "5 G2$ *%4:$GM 12,+ #A,:B+ ,: 4: 4FF,G,":4% )4G2$)4G,74% 7")*%,74G,":8 +,:7$ 4%%

G$72:,Q-$+ 5"A 54G G4,%+ A$Q-,A$+ 4: ,:5,:,G$ +-**"AG 5"A G2$ P4A,4#%$M 12$ #"-:F$F:$++

A$Q-,A$+ +")$ 5"A)-%4,7 4Fh-G)$:G G" G2$ +G4G,+G,7+ "5 P,"%$:7$ [C2,728 4+ C$ +2"C ,: +")$

F$G4,%8 24+ 24F +" 54A 4 )4G2$)4G,74%%( 4:F +G4G,+G,74%%( :4,P$ %,G$A4G-A$M @-G ,G ,+ :"G 4%% #4F

:$C+ +,:7$ G2$A$ C,%% #$ 4 +G4G,+G,74% R)$4:S8 C2,728 74A$5-%%( ,:G$A*A$G$F8 74: 2$%* ,: G2$

4:4%(+,+ [ C2,%$ :4,P$ +G4G,+G,74% 4:4%(+,+ *A"F-7$+ 4: R,:5,:,G$S "A R-:F$5,:$FS )$4:M

(&)*+,$ 8. 9,+1%*1+10' ): ;120)&1<%+ 7%0%3 12$ 4:4%(+,+ :$$F+ G" ,:7"A*"A4G$ G2$

-:A$%,4#,%,G( "5 2,+G"A,74% F4G4 [G2$A$ ,+ :" C4( G" B" #47O 4:F 547G<72$7O G2$ 74+-4%G,$+ ,: G2$

6$%"*":$+,4: C4A 4:F C$ A4A$%( ":%( 24P$ )"A$ G24: ":$ +,F$ G" G2$ +G"A(M V+G,)4G$+ "5 C4A

74+-4%G,$+ 4A$ "5G$: 4:$7F"G4%8 +*A$4F,:B P,4 7,G4G,":+8 4:F #4+$F ": P4B-$ 7")*-G4G,":+8

4%)"+G ,)*"++,#%$ G" P$A,5( -+,:B *$A,"F +"-A7$+M VP$: )"A$ A$7$:G $P$:G+8 +-72 4+ G2$

L%B$A,4: C4A "5 G2$ .b/?+ 24P$ GC" *"%4A,a$F +,F$+ G" G2$ +G"A(T 4:F8 ,: +")$ 74+$+ +-72 4+

G2$ LA)$:,4:<'(A,47 B$:"7,F$ "5 .b.;<.b.]8 G2$ :-)#$A+ F" :"G 7":P$AB$8 4:F 24P$ 47G-4%%(

#$$: F,P$AB,:B "P$A 4 7$:G-A(M 12,+ -:A$%,4#,%,G( A$Q-,A$+ G4O,:B ,:G" 477"-:G 4:"G2$A %4($A

"5 -:7$AG4,:G(M I: 4FF,G,":8 G2$ 4:4%(+,+ )-+G 7":+,F$A G24G )4:( C4A+ C$:G -:A$*"AG$F [C$

h-+G F" :"G O:"C 2"C )4:(8 4:F +-72 4 :-)#$A ,+ ,G+$%5 4 A4:F") P4A,4#%$M

(&)*+,$ =. >;, 7,:16101)6 ): %6 ,?,603 L 2-AF%$ 74: #$ G2$ *A$7,+$ F$5,:,G,": "5 4: $P$:G8

C2,72 4**$4A+ G" #$ 4 5-:7G,": "5 G2$ +"*2,+G,74G,": "5 G2$ 2,+G"A,4: 4:F 2,+ "A 2$A 7%"+$:$++

G" ":$ +,F$ ,:P"%P$F ,: ,GM N$ )$:G,":$F $4A%,$A G2$ -:F$A%(,:B +G4G,+G,74% P4A,4#%$ F$5,:$F 4+

R54G4%,G,$+ *$A +*$7,5,7 $P$:GS8 #-G G2$ P$A( F$5,:,G,": "5 4: $P$:G )4GG$A+ [4:F G2$ 4:4%(+,++2"-%F :"G #$ 5A4B,%$ G" G2$ +*$7,5,74G,":M E"A ,:+G4:7$8 6,:O$A D>?..H GA$4G+ 4+ 4 +,:B%$ $P$:G

G2$ RY":B"%,4: ,:P4+,":+S C2,72 %4+G$F )"A$ G24: 4 7$:G-A( 4:F 4 Q-4AG$AM 12,+ +C$%%$F G2$

:-)#$A+ !"# "%"&' "P$A G2$ Y,FF%$ LB$+ 4:F 7":GA,#-G$F G" G2$ ,%%-+,": G24G P,"%$:7$ 24+

FA"**$F +,:7$8 B,P$: G24G +-#+$Q-$:G R$P$:G+S 24F +2"AG$A F-A4G,":+M V55$7G,P$%( G2$ )4,:

+"-A7$+ +-72 4+ 62,%,*+ 4:F L_$%A"FZ+ g<P"%-)$ (&)*)+,!"-./ ,0 1/# %,+G :-)$A"-+ 7":5%,7G+

,: *%47$ "5 dY":B"% I:P4+,":+d [G2$ )"A$ +"*2,+G,74G$F G2$ 2,+G"A,4:+ ,: 4 B,P$: 4A$48 G2$

)"A$ %,O$%( G2$( 4A$ G" #A$4O 7":5%,7G+ ,:G" F,55$A$:G d:4)$Fd $P$:G+ 4:F8 F$*$:F,:B ":

2,+G"A,4:+8 Y":B"%,4: C4A+ A4:B$ #$GC$$: .> 4:F ;; 7":5%,7G+M I5 +")$ Y":B"%,4:<7$:GA,7

6,:O$AZ+ 7"-:G$A*4AG CA"G$ 4#"-G V-A"*$4: C4A+8 2$ C"-%F 24P$ #-:F%$F G2$ *$A,"F 5A")

G2$ EA4:7"<6A-++,4: C4A G" NN II 4+ di$A)4:D,7H C4A+dM

!"G ":%( 4A$ d!4)$Fd 7":5%,7G+ [ *4AG "5 C24G J,724AF+": 74%%$F RF$4F%( Q-4AA$%+S [4:4A#,GA4A( F$+,B:4G,": G24G8 "5G$:8 F"$+ :"G )4O$ +$:+$ +G4G,+G,74%%(8 #-G 4 7":5%,7G 74: 24P$

GC" "A )"A$ :4)$+T GC" "A )"A$ 7":5%,7G+ 74: 24P$ G2$ +4)$ :4)$8 4:F C$ 5"-:F :"

+4G,+547G"A( 7%$4A<7-G 2,$A4A72( #$GC$$: C4A 4:F 7":5%,7GM j-A +"%-G,": ,+ .H G" GA$4G $P$:G+

4+ G2$ +2"AG$A "5 $P$:G "A ,G+ F,+4BBA$B4G,": ,:G" -:,G+ C,G2 4 )4_,)-) F-A4G,": "5 >; ($4A+

$4728 C2,72 7"AA$+*":F+ G" 4 B$:$A4G,":8 4:F >H *$A5"A) 4 +G-F( "5 +G4G,+G,74% A"#-+G:$++ D":

C2,72 )-728 5-AG2$A F"C:H G" 4++$++ C2$G2$A "G2$A G,)$ C,:F"C+ 4:F B$"BA4*2,7

A$F$5,:,G,":+ *A"F-7$ F,55$A$:G A$+-%G+M

^,O$C,+$8 G2$ F4G4 )4O$+ ,G 24AF G" 4++$++ C2$G2$A G2$ :-)#$A+ ,:7%-F$ *$"*%$ C2" F,$F "5

+,F$ $55$7G+ "5 C4A+ [+4( 5"A $_4)*%$ ,G )4O$+ 4 F,55$A$:7$ C2$G2$A G2$ P,7G,)+ "5 54),:$

5A") G2$ +,$B$ "5 9$A-+4%$) 4A$ ,:7%-F$F "A :"G ,: G2$ 2,+G"A,74% 5,B-A$+M



\

(&)*+,$ @. A6102 :)& 0;, B6%+'2123 '2"-%F ":$ 7":+,F$A8 ,: 4 GA$:F 4:4%(+,+8 A4C "A A$%4G,P$

:-)#$A+8 G24G ,+ 47G-4% :-)#$A "5 *$"*%$ O,%%$F "A G2$,A A4G," G" G2$ G"G4% *"*-%4G,":c i,P$:

G24G G2$ *"*-%4G,": "5 G2$ $4AG2 24+ #$$: ,:7A$4+,:B "P$A G,)$8 4 7":+G4:G A4G$ "5 P,"%$:7$

C"-%F B,P$ G2$ ,%%-+,": "5 A,+$ ,: 74+-4%G,$+M

j-A *4*$A 3,A,%%" 4:F 14%$# D>?./H +$G G" 7":+GA-7G G2$ )"+G +G4G,+G,74%%( A"#-+G *,7G-A$ "5

2,+G"A,74% P,"%$:7$ 5"A R:4)$F 7":5%,7G+S C$ 7"-%F )4O$ 2&-"# '3" ),&4'#/.&'4 B,P$: #( G2$+$

5,P$ *A"#%$)+M 1" F$4% C,G2 G2$ 5,A+G *A"#%$) DE4G G4,%+H C$ )4F$ -+$ "5 4 #A4:72 74%%$F

V_GA$)$ k4%-$ 12$"A(M E"A *A"#%$) > C$ 24F G" F$P$%"* 4 G$72:,Q-$ G" 4%%"C #"-:F$F:$++

,: G2$ 4:4%(+,+ 4:F *-#%,+2 4+ +G4:F4%":$ 4+ ,G 4**%,$+ G" "G2$A +,),%4A *A"#%$)+ D14%$#8 >?./8

14%$# 4:F 3,A,%%"8 >?.;HM 1" F$4% C,G2 *A"#%$)+ g G2A"-B2 ; C$ A$%,$F ": P4A,"-+ )$G2"F+

5A") G2$ #A4:72 "5 A"#-+G +G4G,+G,7+M

7$0 8$,'+ $-9 85#*",#+ *: ;,*'#-<#

12$ 5,A+G )4,: 4GG$)*G G" )"F$% P,"%$:7$ -+,:B *"C$A %4C+ C4+ F":$ #( G2$ *"%()4G2 ^$C,+

EA( J,724AF+":8 ,: .b\=8 C2$: 2$ 5,G 4 P,+-4% *"C$A %4C -+,:B l,*5 6%"G+ G" F4G4 #$GC$$:

.=>? 4:F .b\;M l,*5 *%"G+ 4A$ 4 P,+-4% G$72:,Q-$ :4)$F 45G$A i$"AB$ l,*5 C2" *"*-%4A,a$F

64A$G"Z+ %4C #( 4**%(,:B ,G G" *2$:")$:4 +-72 4+ %,:B-,+G,7+ DC"AF 5A$Q-$:7(H 8

F$)"BA4*2,7+ D+,a$ "5 7,G,$+H8 4:F "G2$A+M J,724AF+": 2,)+$%5 74)$ 5A") F,+7"P$A,$+ "5 +$%5<

+,),%4A,G( 4:F +74%,:B ,: :4G-A$8 *4AG,7-%4A%( 7"4+G%,:$+ 4:F +")$ G-A#-%$:G *2$:")$:4

DY4:F$%#A"G .b=gHM

I:G-,G,P$%(8 C$ 74: $_*%4,: *"C$A %4C+ 4+ 5"%%"C+0!!"!#$% !"##"$%

!"#$

!!!"

!""!

!!"!#$% !"##"$%

!"#$

!!!"

!"! 4**A"_,)4G$%(

$Q-4% G"

!!"!#$% !"##"$% !"#$ !!!" !""!

!!"!#$%

!"##"$%

!"#$

!!!"

!""! M 12,+ R+74%4#,%,G(S ,+ 7A-7,4% 4+ ,G )4O$+ G2$ %4C #"G2)"A$ ,:G-,G,P$ 4:F GA47G4#%$M Y"A$ *A$7,+$%( G2$A$ ,+ 4: R$_*":$:GS ,: G2$ G4,%+8 +-72 G24G8 5"A

4 %4AB$ F$P,4G,": 5 8

!"#$%$&'&() !" !"#!!$%&' ! ! !"#!#"$%#&'(

!" !!!

C2$A$ R4%*24S ,+ G2$ G4,% $_*":$:G 4:F G2$ )4h"A F$G$A),:4:G G" G2$ +24*$ "5 G2$

F,+GA,#-G,":M 12$ %"C$A G2$ 4%*248 G2$ 54GG$A G2$ G4,%+M !"G$ 2$A$ 4 2$%*5-% *A"*$AG( G24G G2$

4%*24 F"$+ :"G 724:B$ ,5 ":$ G4O$+ 24%5 G2$ F4G4 4:F F"-#%$+ ,GM IG )$4:+ G2$ 4%*24 ,+ #,624'

', 7/&* 7.4'/8"4 .& -/'/M L%+" :"G$ G24G G2$ *A"*"AG,":4%,G( 2"%F+ ,: G2$ G4,%+ ,M$M 5 P$A( %4AB$8

#-G :"G :$7$++4A,%( 5"A +)4%%$A P4%-$+M

Y4:( A$+$4A72 *4*$A+ +-#+$Q-$:G%( 7":5,A)$F G2$ *"C$A %4C "A R64A$G,4:,G(S "5 G2$ F4G4

D4%G2"-B2 3,A,%%" >?.g +2"C+ G24: )4:( *2$:")$:4 ,F$:G,5,$F 4+ *"C$A %4C+ 4A$ ,: 547G%"B:"A)4%8 G2"-B2 +G,%% 54G<G4,%$F #$74-+$ "5 G2$,A 2,B2 P4A,4:7$H [#-G G2$ *A47G,7$ ,: G24G 5,$%F

C4+ G" 5,:F 4 )$724:,+) G24G h-+G,5,$+ 4 +G4G,+G,74% %4C *A,"A G" 4F"*G,:B ,GM Y$724:,+)+

4#"-:F8 4:F 45G$A G2$ C"AO+ "5 Y4:F$%#A"G D.b=gH %,:O,:B G2$ *2$:")$:": G" 5A47G4%

B$")$GA( D4+ J,724AF+": F,FH8 )4:( #A4:72$+ "5 R7")*%$_,G( G2$"A(S C$A$ #"A:M 3$F$A)4:

D>??gH %""O$F 4G 4 #A"4F$A +$G 4:F Rh-+G,5,$FS G2$ *A"7$++ G24:O+ G" 4 7%4++ "5 )"F$%+ 74%%$F

/9"&':6/4"- G24G 24P$ #$$: O:"C: G" *A"F-7$ *"C$A %4C+M 3$%%-%4A 4-G")4G4 4:F )"F$%+ "5

,:G$A47G,": #$GC$$: 4B$:G+ 24P$ :"C 5%"-A,+2$F *A"P,F,:B -+ 4 %4AB$ 7")*-G4G,":4%<#4+$F

)"F$%,:B 4**4A4G-+T ,G +-55,7$+ G" +*$7,5( G2$ 7":F,G,":+ 4:F G2$ )4G2$)4G,74% 4:F

7")*-G4G,":4% 5A4)$C"AO ,: *%47$ 4%%"C+ -+ G" 72$7O C2$G2$A *"C$A %4C+ $)$AB$ "A :"G

D+$$ N"%5A4)8 >??> 4:F Y4G2$)4G,74Z+ *A"BA4)),:B %4:B-4B$T :"G$ G24G G2$+$ )"F$%+ 4A$



;

:"G 4:4%(G,7<5-:7G,":4% #-G 4%B"A,G2),7 A$Q-,A,:B 7")*-G4G,":4% )$G2"F+HM IG ,+ :"G *4AG "5

G2,+ 4:4%(+,+ G" F,+7-++ G2$+$ )"F$%+ ["-A F")4,: ,+ +G4G,+G,74% ,:5$A$:7$ :"G )"F$% #-,%F,:BT

C$ 5"7-+ ": G2$ +G4G,+G,74% #47O-* G24G 4%%"C+ G2$ A$h$7G,": "A R477$*G4:7$S "5 +")$ )"F$%+M

N$ :"G$ G24G 4%% R54G G4,%+S 4A$ :"G *"C$A %4C+8 G2$A$ 4A$ F,+GA,#-G,":+ G24G *A"F-7$

7":7$:GA4G,": [,G ,+ h-+G G24G *"C$A %4C+ 4A$ )"A$ :4G-A4% #$74-+$ "5 G2$,A +74%4#,%,G( 4:F

4**$4% G" -+$A+ #$74-+$ G2$( 4A$ GA47G4#%$ 4:4%(G,74%%(M @-G G2$A$ 4A$ 7%4,)+ ":$ +2"-%F

:$P$A 74+-4%%( )4O$ ,: G2$ *A$+$:7$ "5 54G G4,%+8 *"C$A %4C+ "A :"GM ^$G -+ :"C *-G G"B$G2$A

G2$ *A"#%$)+ "5 +G4G,+G,74% ,:5$A$:7$ -:F$A 54G G4,%+M

7$0 8$,'+ = >*-3 !#$<#= $-9 05# 7*/-9$0,*-$' !",-<,4'#+ *: )0$0,+0,<$' ?-:#"#-<#

6,:O$A D>?..8 >?..#H +G4AG$F G2$ *A")"G,": "5 4: ,F$4 G24G P,"%$:7$ 24+ FA"**$F8 C,G2

+,),%4A G" @-7O%$ [$$A,%( +,),%4Am 4: ,:P"74G,": G" G2$ P4A,"-+ )"A4% P4%-$+ 74-+,:B C24G 2$

74%%+ RG2$ "#+"%$+7$:7$ "5 )4h"A C4A+S D6,:O$A >?..#HM U$ CA,G$+8 @-7O%$<%,O$8 R12$ )"+G

*A"),+,:B $_*%4:4G,":8 I #$%,$P$8 ,+ G24G G2$ 7")*":$:G+ "5 G2$ 2-)4: ),:F G24G ,:2,#,GP,"%$:7$ m C24G L#A424) ^,:7"%: 74%%$F RG2$ #$GG$A 4:B$%+ "5 "-A :4G-A$S m 24P$ #$7")$

,:7A$4+,:B%( $:B4B$FMS

IG ,+ ,)*"AG4:G G" F,+7-++ G24G #""O #$74-+$ ,G 24+ #$$: 7,G$F 4+ R$P,F$:7$S 5"A G2$ FA"* ,:

P,"%$:7$ 47A"++ *"%,G,74% +7,$:7$M 6,:O$A F$4%+ C,G2 G2$ *2$:")$:": "5 P,"%$:7$8 4:F ,G+

)4:,5$+G4G,":+ 4G F,55$A$:G +74%$+8 5A") 2"),7,F$+ 4:F A4*$+8 G" A,"G+ 4:F C4A+8 5A") F$4G2

*$:4%G( 4:F G"AG-A$ ,++-$+8 G" 7,P,% A,B2G+ P,"%4G,":+ 4:F F$:,4%M 1" $_*%4,: 4:F +-+G4,: 2,+

P,+,": 4#"-G G2$ B$:$A4% F$7%,:$ ,: P,"%$:7$8 6,:O$A F$P$%"*+ G2$ )$G4*2"A "5 4 7":+G4:G

#4GG%$8 C,G2,: 2-)4:,G(8 4)":B +")$ nnI::$A K$)":+S8 %,O$ 5"A $_4)*%$ A$P$:B$8 +4F,+) 4:F

,F$"%"B(8 4:F +")$ nn@$GG$A L:B$%+S8 +-72 4+ $)*4G2(8 +$%5<7":GA"% 4:F A$4+": D$P$: ,5 ,G ,+

:"G 7")*%$G$%( 7%$4A8 4G %$4+G G" -+8 C24G ,G ,+ G24G 6,:O$A 74%%+ A$4+":HM K$)":+ 4A$ )4,:%(

$_*A$++,":+ "5 4G4P,7 5$$%,:B+ 4:F 7")*-%+,":+8 C2,72 4A$ A$%4G$F G" G2$ "A,B,:4% #$4+G ,: -+ML:B$%+ 4A$ 4 A$+-%G "5 7,P,% $P"%-G,": 4:F A$4+": F$P$%"*)$:GM L:F +,:7$ 7,P,%,a4G,": +$$)+ G"

#$ 4: -:+G"**4#%$ *A"7$++8 L:B$%+ 4A$ #"-:F G" C,: G2$ #4GG%$M

X+,:B 4 +"AG "5 )$G4<4:4%(+,+8 A$%(,:B ": "G2$A+Z A$+-%G+8 6,:O$A 7"%%$7G+ 4 #-:72 "5 5,B-A$+ G"

+-**"AG G2$ ,F$4 "5 4 F$7%,:$ ,: P,"%$:7$ ,: G2$ 2,+G"A( "5 2-)4:,G(M

1" 4A)$F 7":5%,7G+8 ,: 4%% G2$,A *"++,#%$ $_*A$++,":+8 2$ F$P"G$+ GC" 724*G$A+0 G2$ 5,5G28 nn12$

^":B 6$47$S8 4:F G2$ +,_G28 nn12$ !$C 6$47$SM I: G2$ +*$7,5,7 74+$ "5 C4A+8 2$ A$%,$+ ":

*A$P,"-+ 4:4%(+$+ #(8 5"A $_4)*%$8 3$F$A)4: D>??gH 4:F J,724AF+": D.b/?HM @-G G2$ C4( ,:

C2,72 2$ A$4F+ 4:F ,:G$A*A$G+ G2$ A$+-%G+ "5 +72"%4A+ %,O$ J,724AF+": A$P$4%+ 4: 4GG$)*G "5

#$:F,:B $)*,A,74% $P,F$:7$ G" 2,+ "C: G2$"A(8 $MBM C2$: 2$ F$4%+ C,G2 G2$ 6",++": :4G-A$ "5

G2$ &276"# "5 4A)$F 7":5%,7G+ "P$A G,)$M L+ C$ 4%+" 5,:F "-G ,: "-A F4G4 4:4%(+,+8 7":+,+G$:GC,G2 J,724AF+": D.b/?H8 G2$A$ ,+ :" +-55,7,$:G $P,F$:7$ G" A$h$7G G2$ :-%% 2(*"G2$+,+ "5 4

2")"B$:"-+ 6",++": *A"7$++8 ;3.)3 -"&."4 '3" !#"4"&)" ,0 /&* '#"&- .& '3" 6"++.9"#"&)" ,0

327/&.'*< !$P$AG2$%$++8 6,:O$A A$5$A+ G" +")$ ($G<-:+*$7,5,$F )4G2$)4G,74% )"F$% G24G

7"-%F 4%+" +-**"AG +-72 4 F$7%,:$ ,: P,"%$:7$8 C24G 2$ 74%%+ 4 R:":+G4G,":4A(S *A"7$++8 $P$: ,5

F4G4 %""O G2$ C4( G2$( %""OM IG ,+ ": G2$ #4+,+ "5 G2,+ 4:F "G2$A 4*"F,7G,7 +G4G$)$:G+ G24G

6,:O$A #-,%F+ 2,+ :4AA4G,P$ 4#"-G P,"%$:7$M

6,:O$A8 ,: 4FF,G,": #-,%F+ 4 G2$"A( G24G ,+ :"G 4G 4%% +G4G,+G,74%%( A"#-+G G" *A"#%$)+ g 4:F \ "5

G2$ *A$P,"-+ +$7G,":[+-72 4+ 4+ 724:B$+ ,: G2$ L: ^-+24: $+G,)4G$+ "A G2$ BA4:-%4A,G( "5 G2$

Y":B"%,4: :4)$F 7":5%,7GM



/

@-G 4G G2$ 7"A$8 6,:O$AZ+ +$P$A$ ),+G4O$ ,+ ":$ "5 +G4:F4AF :4,P$ $)*,A,7,+) [#4+,74%%(

),+G4O,:B F4G4 D47G-4%%( 4#+$:7$ "5 F4G4H 5"A $P,F$:7$ 4:F #-,%F,:B 2,+ G2$"A( "5 ;3*

P,"%$:7$ 24+ FA"**$F C,G2"-G $P$: 4+7$AG4,:G,:B ;3"'3"# %.,+"&)" -.- .&-""- -#,!M 12,+ ,+

:"G G" +4( G24G 6,:O$AZ+ +"7,"<*+(72"%"B,74% G2$"A,$+ 74:ZG #$ A,B2G0 G2$( 4A$ h-+G :"G+-55,7,$:G%( 7"::$7G$F G" F4G4 G" +G4AG A$)"G$%( %""O,:B %,O$ +7,$:7$M E-:F4)$:G4%%(8 +G4G,+G,7+

,+ 4#"-G $:+-A,:B *$"*%$ F" :"G #-,%F +7,$:G,5,7 G2$"A,$+ 5A") 2"G 4,A8 G24G ,+ C,G2"-G

+,B:,5,74:G F$*4AG-A$ 5A") A4:F")M jG2$AC,+$8 ,G ,+ *4G$:G%( d5""%$F #( A4:F"):$++dM L:F C$

24P$ 4 P$A( 7%$4A ,F$4 C24G F$*4AG-A$ 5A") A4:F") )$4:+M

E"A 54G G4,%$F P4A,4#%$+8 G2$ 7":P$:G,":4% )$724:,+) "5 G2$ %4C "5 %4AB$ :-)#$A+ D": C2,72

+G4G,+G,74% ,:5$A$:7$ A$*"+$+H ,+ 7":+,F$A4#%( +%"C$A 4:F +,B:,5,74:7$ A$Q-,A$+ )"A$ F4G4 4:F

%":B$A *$A,"F+M 14%$# D>?./H +2"C+ G24G G2$ 64A$G" =?e>? G4O$+ .?.g )"A$ F4G4 G24: 4

7"AA$+*":F,:B !"A)4% F,+GA,#-G,": G24G ,+ -#,Q-,G"-+ ,: G$_G#""O+ ,5 ":$ %""O+ 4G G2$ +4)*%$

4P$A4B$M ',)*%(8 G2$ +4)*%$ 4P$A4B$ ,+ :"G 4 B""F $+G,)4G"A "5 G2$ RGA-$S )$4:T ,G 24+ C24G ,+

74%%$F 4 +)4%% +4)*%$ #,4+ C2$: F4G4 ,+ ":$<G4,%$F D,M$M 74: ":%( G4O$ $,G2$A *"+,G,P$ "A

:$B4G,P$ P4%-$+8 4+ ,+ G2$ 74+$ C,G2 P,"%$:7$HM I: "G2$A C"AF+8 :"G ":%( F" C$ :$$F 4 %"G "5F4G4 G" O:"C C24GZ+ B",:B ":8 #-G 8 4+ ,: G2$ 74+$ "5 P,"%$:7$8 C$ +2"-%F $_*$7G G24G G2$ )$4:

P,"%$:7$ 4+ )$4+-A$F ,: +4)*%$ G" #$ %"C$A G24: G2$ GA-$ )$4:M 12$ +G4G,+G,7,4: C"-%F :$P$A

)$4+-A$ G2$ )$4: ,:<+4)*%$ #-G -+$ 4:F C$ C,%% F" R#47O<F""AS )$G2"F+ 4:F )"A$ A,B"A"-+

)4_,)-)<%,O$%,2""F G$72:,Q-$+M

IA":,74%%(8 G2$A$ 4A$ 7%4,)+ G24G 74: #$ F":$ ": %,GG%$ F4G40 ,:5$A$:7$ ,+ 4+())$GA,7 -:F$A 54G<

G4,%$F F")4,:+M 1" #"=2.#" 7,#" -/'/ ', /44"#' '3/' '3"#" /#" &, 6+/)8 4;/&4 '3/& ', /44"#'

'3/' '3"#" /#" 6+/)8 4;/&4 2$:7$ C$ C"-%F :$$F )-72 )"A$ F4G4 G" 7%4,) 4 FA"* ,: P,"%$:7$

G24: G" 7%4,) 4 A,+$ ,: ,G M

E,:4%%(8 +G4G$)$:G+ G24G 4A$ :"G F$$)$F +G4G,+G,74%%( +,B:,5,74:G [4:F +2"C: G" #$ +" [+2"-%F

:$P$A #$ -+$F G" 7":+GA-7G +7,$:G,5,7 G2$"A,$+M K$+7A,*G,P$ +G4G,+G,7+8 G2"-B2 F$$)$F

-:+7,$:G,5,7 4:F 4:$7F"G4%8 74: #$ -+$5-% 5"A $_*%"A4G"A( F,+7-++,":+8 #-G :"G C,G2 54G G4,%$F*A"7$++$+M

12$+$ 5"-:F4G,":4% *A,:7,*%$+ 4A$ "5G$: ),++$F #$74-+$8 G(*,74%%(8 +"7,4% +7,$:G,+G+Z +G4G,+G,74%

GA4,:,:B ,+ %,),G$F G" )$724:,+G,7 G""%+ 5A") G2,: G4,%$F F")4,:+M I: *2(+,7+8 ":$ 74: "5G$:

7%4,) $P,F$:7$ 5A") +)4%% F4G4 +$G+8 #(*4++,:B +G4:F4AF +G4G,+G,74% )$G2"F"%"B,$+8 +,)*%(

#$74-+$ G2$ P4A,4:7$ 5"A G2$+$ P4A,4#%$+ ,+ %"C D"A G2$ *A"7$++ 24+ 4 +GA":B G2$"A( P$A,5,$F ":

4 %"C P4A,4:7$ F4G4HM 12$ 2,B2$A G2$ P4A,4:7$8 G2$ )"A$ F4G4 ":$ :$$F+ G" )4O$ +G4G,+G,74%

7%4,)+M E"A 54G<G4,%+8 G2$ P4A,4:7$ ,+ G(*,74%%( 2,B2 4:F -:F$A$+G,)4G$F ,: *4+G F4G4M L:F8 4+

C$ +2"C$F ,G FA"*+ P$A( +%"C%( -:F$A 4P$A4B,:B DG2$ %4C "5 %4AB$ :-)#$A+ )$4:+ G2$

+4)*%$ 4P$A4B$ #$7")$+ %$++ 4:F %$++ P"%4G,%$ 4+ ":$ ,:7A$4+$+ F4G48 G(*,74%%( 4G G2$ A4G$ "5

G2$ +Q-4A$ A""G "5 4FF,G,":4% F4G4 7"-:G+T G2,+ ,+ :"G G2$ 74+$ 2$A$HM

12$ +$7":F [)"A$ +$A,"-+ [$AA"A 6,:O$A )4F$ ,: 2,+ 7":7%-+,": ,+ G" #$%,$P$ G24G G4,% $P$:G+

4:F G2$ )$4: 4A$ +")$2"C F,55$A$:G 4:,)4%+8 :"G A$4%,a,:B G24G G2$ )$4: .&)+2-"4 G2$+$ G4,%

$P$:G+M >2#'3"#? 0,# 0/':'/.+"- %/#./6+"4? '3" 7"/& .4 /+7,4' "&'.#"+* -"'"#7.&"- 6* "@'#"7"4< A0

*,2 /#" 2&)"#'/.& /6,2' '3" '/.+4? '3"& *,2 /#" 2&)"#'/.& /6,2' '3" 7"/&M IG ,+ G2-+ ,:7"2$A$:G

G" +4( G24G P,"%$:7$ 24+ FA"**$F #-G )4(#$ :"G G2$ A,+O "5 G4,% $P$:G+T ,G C"-%F #$ %,O$ +4(,:B

G24G +")$":$ ,+ d$_GA$)$%( P,AG-"-+ $_7$*G F-A,:B G2$ +72""% +2""G,:B $*,+"F$ C2$: 2$

O,%%$F g? +G-F$:G+d8 "A G24G :-7%$4A C$4*":+ 4A$ P$A( +45$ 4+ G2$( ":%( O,%% 4 +)4%% *$A7$:G4B$

"5 G2$ G,)$M



]

@/" %#05*9*'*36

>;, C%0%. N$ +$%$7G$F 4%% 4P4,%4#%$ "#+$AP4G,":+ "P$A G2$ *$A,"F .<>?.; LK8 -+-4%%( 4A)$F

7":5%,7G+ C,G2 )"A$ G24: g8??? 74+-4%G,$+ ,: 4#+"%-G$ G$A)+8 7"-:G,:B #"G2 +"%F,$A+ 4:F

7,P,%,4:+M

12$A$ 4A$ 4 5$C $_7$*G,":+ ,: "-A F4G4 +$G8 +")$ $P$:G+ G24G 74::"G #$ 7":+,F$A$F +G4:F4AF

4A)$F 7":5%,7G+ ,: G2$ F$5,:,G,": "5 N4%%$:+G$$: 4:F '"%%$:#$AB D>??.HM 12$( 4A$ +")$ "5 G2$

#%""F,$+G F,7G4G"A+2,*+ "5 2,+G"A(8 +-72 4+ 'G4%,:Z+ A$B,)$M 12,+ 72",7$ 24+ #$$: )4F$ G" #$

7":+,+G$:G C,G2 "G2$A C"AO+ 4#"-G C4A P,7G,)+ 4:F P,"%$:7$ D$MBM Y-$%%$A8 .b=bT 6,:O$A8

>?..HM

12$ F4G4 7")$ 5A") F,55$A$:G +"-A7$+8 +-72 4+ 62,%%,*+ 4:F L_$%A"F D>??\H (&)*)+,!"-./ ,0

1/#4? 4:F !$7A")$GA,7+ D>?.;H8 C,G2 +")$ 7":+,F$A4G,":+ "5 +$%$7G,":+ #( @$A%,:+O, D>??bH8

i"%F+G$,: D>?..H8 Y-$%%$A D.b=bH8 6,:O$A D>?..H8 4:F N2,G$ D>?.gHM E"A +")$ ":%,:$

A$+"-A7$+ %,O$ !$7A")$GA,7+ D>?.;H8 C$ F"-#%$<72$7O$F G2$ F4G4 4B4,:+G G2$ 7,G$F A$5$A$:7$+M

12$ 5,A+G "#+$AP4G,": ,: "-A 7"%%$7G,": ,+ G2$ @"-F,774Z+ J$P"%G "5 /?</. LK8 C2,%$ G2$ %4+G ":$

,+ G2$ +G,%%<"*$: ,:G$A:4G,":4% 4A)$F 7":5%,7G 4B4,:+G G2$ I+%4),7 'G4G$ "5 IA4Q 4:F G2$ ^$P4:GM

N$ $:F$F 7":7$:GA4G,:B ": ;/; *,$7$+M

L :4G-A4% Q-$+G,": ,+ C2( C$ 24P$ 72"+$: G" ,)*"+$ 4 g???<74+-4%G,$+ G2A$+2"%F8 C2$:

7"%%$7G,:B G2$ "#+$AP4G,":+ 4#"-G 4A)$F 7":5%,7G+M N$ 24P$ G2A$$ )4,: A$4+":+0

• N$ F" :"G :$$F +)4%%$A 74+-4%G,$+ G" B$G G2$ *A"*$AG,$+8 4+ +)4%%$A 74+-4%G,$+ F" :"G

455$7G G2$ 4P$A4B$ DJ,724AF+": 2,)+$%5 :"G$F8 RL:(":$ C2" GA,$+ G" )4O$ 4 %,+G "5 d4%%

G2$ C4A+d $:7"-:G$A+ G2$ F,55,7-%G( G24G G2$A$ 4A$ +" )4:( +)4%% ,:7,F$:G+8 G24G +")$

A-%$ 24+ G" #$ )4F$ G" $_7%-F$ G2$)MS DJ,724AF+":8 .b\=HM 12$ 2,B2$A G2$ G2A$+2"%F8

G2$ 5$C$A G2$ "#+$AP4G,":+ 4:F G2$ %"C$A G2$ :",+$ 4:F ,)*A$7,+,":M• 12$ )4,: "#h$7G "5 "-A 7":7$A: ,+ G4,% A,+O8 G24GZ+ G2$ A,+O "5 )4h"A F$+GA-7G,P$

7":5%,7G+M 12$ +G4G,+G,74% G$72:,Q-$+ C$ -+$ G" +G-F( G2,+ G(*$ "5 $_GA$)$ $P$:G+

A$Q-,A$ G2$ ,)*"+,G,": "5 G2A$+2"%F+ 5"A 4%% G2$ 4**A"_,)4G,":+ G" 2"%FM

• 3":5%,7G+ C,G2 )4:( P,7G,)+ 4A$ )"A$ %,O$%( G" #$ A$B,+G$A$F 4:F +G-F,$F #(

2,+G"A,4:+M IG C"-%F #$ ,)*"++,#%$ G" 24P$ A$%,4#%$ ,:5"A)4G,": 4#"-G R+)4%%S #4GG%$+

C,G2 G$:+ "5 P,7G,)+M V)*,A,74%%(8 g??? P,7G,)+ *A"P$F G" #$ 4 B""F +$%$7G,":

G2A$+2"%F 5"A "G2$A 4+*$7G+ "5 G2$ 4:4%(+,+M

• L g???<74+-4%G,$+ G2A$+2"%F B,P$+ -+ 4 #$GG$A 7":5,F$:7$ 4#"-G G2$ $+G,)4G$F :-)#$A

"5 74+-4%G,$+8 G24:O+ G" G2$ *"++,#%( %4AB$A :-)#$A "5 +"-A7$+ G" 7")*4A$M U"C$P$A8

G2$ A,+O "5 "P$A<$_4BB$A4G,":8 $+*$7,4%%( 5"A G2$ %4AB$ 7":5%,7G+ "5 4:G,Q-,G( ,+

+")$G2,:B C$ 24F G" G4O$ ,:G" 7":+,F$A4G,":M

I: "AF$A G" #$ 7":+,+G$:G C,G2 G2$ +"7,"%"B,74% %,G$A4G-A$ ": 4A)$F 7":5%,7G+8 C$ 24P$ -+$F

F,55$A$:G G(*$+ "5 F4G4 ,: "-A 4:4%(+$+0

• B)'2/+ -/'/8 ,M$M F4G4 4+ 7"%%$7G$F #( 2,+G"A,4:+M 'G4G,+G,74%%( +*$4O,:B G2$+$ 4A$ G2$

A4C F4G4M

• C"4)/+"- -/'/8 ,M$M 74+-4%G,$+ $_*A$++$F ,: G$A)+ "5 G"F4(Z+ C"A%F *"*-%4G,":8 ,: "AF$A

G" 24P$ 7")*4A4#,%,G( ,: G$A)+ "5 A$%4G,P$ ,)*47G "5 C4A+M

J$+74%$F F4G4 4A$ "#G4,:$F #( F,P,F,:B G2$ :-)#$A "5 74+-4%G,$+ ,: 4 B,P$: ($4A #(

G2$ C"A%F *"*-%4G,": ,: G24G ($4A8 4:F G2$: )-%G,*%(,:B $P$A(G2,:B #( G"F4(Z+ C"A%F

*"*-%4G,":M



=

N2$: A$+74%,:B F4G48 C$ 24P$ -+$F G2$ *"*-%4G,": $+G,)4G$+ "5 o%$,: 4:F P4: KA$72G+

D>??/H8 4:F X:,G$F !4G,":+ D.bbb8 >?.;HM

• D#/&40,#7"-:#"4)/+"- -/'/8 G24G ,+ F4G4 "#G4,:$F P,4 G2$ +"<74%%$F F-4%

GA4:+5"A)4G,":8 C2"+$ 4,) ,+ G" F$4% C,G2 G2$ #"-:F$++e-:#"-:F$:$++ "5 G2$+-**"AG "5 G2$ F,+GA,#-G,": "5 C4A 74+-4%G,$+ D14%$#8 >?./T 14%$# 4:F 3,A,%%"8 >?.;HM

12,+ GA4:+5"A)4G,": ,+ )"A$ G$72:,74%8 #-G8 4+ C$ #A,$5%( $_*%4,: ,: G2$ +$7G,": 4#"-G

Y$G2"F+8 ,G ,+ )$4:G G" 7"AA$7G 5"A 4: ,:G$A*A$G4G,": $AA"A 4#"-G G2$ 4**4A$:G

,:5,:,G$<)$4: :4G-A$ "5 C4A 74+-4%G,$+Z F4G4M

I:G$A$+G,:B%(8 "-A A$+-%G+ 2"%F :"GC,G2+G4:F,:B G2$ F$5,:,G,": "5 F4G4M !-)$A,74% $+G,)4G$+

)4( P4A(8 #-G G2$ Q-4%,G4G,P$ ,:G$A*A$G4G,": +G4(+ G2$ +4)$M

C%0% (&)*+,$2. E,A+G "5 4%%8 ,G ,+ ,)*"AG4:G G" :"G,7$ G24G "-A F4G48 $+*$7,4%%( 5"A C24G

7":7$A:+ 4:G,Q-,G(8 4A$ %,O$%( G" +-55$A 5A") +$%$7G,":e2,+G"A,"BA4*2,74% #,4+M IG C4+ ,: 547G

:"G *"++,#%$ G" 7"%%$7G "#+$AP4G,":+ 4#"-G G2$ 7":5%,7G+ G4O,:B *%47$ ,: G2$ L)$A,74+ 4:F

L-+GA4%,48 #$5"A$ G2$,A RF,+7"P$A(S #( V-A"*$4: 7":Q-$A"A+M !4G-A4%%(8 G2,+ %47O "5 $P,F$:7$

F"$+ :"G )$4: G24G :"G2,:B 24**$:$F ,: G2"+$ 4A$4+ ,: G2$ *4+GM

',),%4A%(8 #$74-+$ "5 *A"#%$)+ C,G2 +"-A7$+8 C$ *A"#4#%( ),++ +")$ 7":5%,7G+ "5 4:G,Q-,G( ,:

V-A"*$8 "A8 +4(8 ,: 32,:4 ,: G2$ +,_G$$:G2 7$:G-A(M U"C$P$A8 C$ 74: 4++-)$ G24G G2$ )4h"A,G(

"5 G2$+$ 7":5%,7G+ 4A$ :"G ,: G2$ P$A( G4,% "5 G2$ F,+GA,#-G,": "5 74+-4%G,$+8 +4( ,: G2$ G"* .? "A

>?fM IG ,+ ,: 547G :"G A$4%%( *%4-+,#%$ G24G 2,+G"A,4:+ 24P$ :"G A$*"AG$F 4 7":5%,7G "5 . ),%%,":

74+-4%G,$+ D"A )"A$H8 +" G24G +-72 4: $P$:G ,+ :"G *A$+$:G ,: "-A +"-A7$+M

K$4%,:B C,G2 2,+G"A,74% F4G48 +")$ F4G,:B #47O G" G2$ 5,A+G 7$:G-A( LK8 4%+" A$Q-,A$+ +")$

4GG$:G,":8 #$74-+$ "5 G2$ *A"#4#%( *A"#%$)+ "5 ,:7":+,+G$:7( 4:F %47O "5 -:,5"A),G( ,: G2$

4GGA,#-G,": "5 74+-4%G,$+ #( 2,+G"A,4:+M IG 74: #$ F,55,7-%G [ ,5 :"G ,)*"++,#%$ [ G" F,+G,:B-,+2

74+-4%G,$+ 5A") F,A$7G P,"%$:7$ 5A") G2"+$ 4A,+,:B 5A") +-72 +,F$ $55$7G+ 4+ 7":G4B,"-+

F,+$4+$+ 4:F 2-:B$AMN$ )$:G,":$F $4A%,$A G24G A$*"AG+ C$A$ 2,B2%( +"-A7$ F$*$:F$:G C,G2 4: ,)*"++,#,%,G( G"

547G<72$7OM '")$ F4G48 +-72 4+ G2$ L: ^-+24: A$#$%%,":8 $+G,)4G$F #( 6,:O$A D>?..H G" 24P$

O,%%$F g/ ),%%,": *$"*%$ D4A"-:F \g? ),%%,": #( G"F4(Z+ *"*-%4G,":H 4A$ 2,B2%( F-#,"-+

DK-A4:G8 .b/?H [4:F 2$%* *$A*$G-4G$ G2$ ,)*A$++,": G24G G2$ C"A%F ,+ R%$++ P,"%$:GSM IG )4(

24P$ #$$: .g ),%%,":8 4:F G2$ :-)#$A+ C$A$ G2$ A$+-%G "5 G2$ 7$:+-+ 4:F F,+*$A+,": "5

"55,7,4%+ ,: A$P$:-$ F$*4AG)$:GM DE,GaB$A4%F8 .bg;8 @@3 >?.>H

K4G4 4BBA$B4G,": ,+ 4:"G2$A ,++-$M N$ +4,F G24G 7":5%,7G+ +-72 4+ G2$ +"<74%%$F RY":B"%,4:

I:P4+,":+S 4A$ :"G2,:B )"A$ G24: 4AG,5,7,4% F$+,B:4G,":+8 C2,72 :$$F G" #$ GA$4G$F 74A$5-%%(8

4+ +(:G2$G,7 "#+$AP4G,":+M 12$+$ $P$:G+ 4A$ ,: 547G 4AG,5,7,4% 7":G4,:$A+ 7A$4G$F #( 2,+G"A,4:+

G" 4BBA$B4G$ G2"+$ #4GG%$+ +24A,:B ,)*"AG4:G 2,+G"A,74%8 B$"BA4*2,74% 4:F *"%,G,74%

724A47G$A,+G,7+8 #-G G24G :$P$A A$4%%( $_,+G$F 4+ 4 +,:B%$ $P$:GM E"A2,+G"A,74%e2,+G"A,"BA4*2,74% A$4+":+8 G2$+$ $P$:G+ G$:F G" #$ )"A$ *A$+$:G ,: 4:G,Q-,G( 4:F

G2$ Y,FF%$ LB$+8 G2-+ *"++,#%( 74-+,:B 4 :4,P$ "P$A$+G,)4G,": "5 G2$ +$P$A,G( "5 7":5%,7G+ ,:

G2$ *4+GM VP$: 4)":B G2$+$ 4BBA$B4G,":+ G2$A$ 4A$ )4h"A F,55$A$:7$+0 NN. 4:F NN>

:4G-A4%%( 4%+" ,:P"%P$F +$P$A4% G$:+ "5 #4GG%$+ ,: P$A( F,55$A$:G %"74G,":+8 #-G G2$+$ #4GG%$+

G""O *%47$ ,: 4 )-72 +2"AG$A G,)$ *$A,"F8 C,G2 :" )4h"A G,)$ +$*4A4G,": 4)":B G2$)M

D#&16E 0;, 7%0% F&)*+,$2. L%% G2$+$ F4G4 *A"#%$)+ 74: #$ F$4%G C,G2 #( 7":+,F$A,:B $472

+,:B%$ "#+$AP4G,": ,: "-A 7"%%$7G,": 4+ 4: ,)*A$7,+$ $+G,)4G$8 ,: G2$ F$5,:,G,": "5 k,$AG%

D.bb;HM j-A G$72:,Q-$ 5"A A"#-+G:$++ ,+ 4+ 5"%%"C+M X+,:B Y":G$ 34A%" )$G2"F+ 8 4:F



b

4++-),:B G24G G2$ A$4% :-)#$A "5 74+-4%G,$+ ,: 4 7":5%,7G ,+ -:,5"A)%( F,+GA,#-G$F #$GC$$: G2$

),:,)-) 4:F G2$ )4_,)-) $+G,)4G$ ,: G2$ 4P4,%4#%$ 2,+G"A,74% A$7"AF+8 G2$ G4,% $_*":$:G p8

G2$ Q-4:G,G( G24G B"P$A:+ G2$ G4,% "5 "-A C4A 74+-4%G,$+Z F,+GA,#-G,":8 ,+ :"G 455$7G$F8 4*4AG

5A") G2$ :$B%,B,#%$ F,55$A$:7$+ ,: G2$ +)4%%$A F$7,)4%+M N$ F,F 4:"G2$A #4GG$A( "5 G$+G+ 5"A"G2$A P4A,4#%$+M D'$$ E,B-A$+ . 4:F > 5"A 4: ,F$4 "5 2"C C$ 7":F-7G$F G2$ G$+G+MH

EA") 4 +G4G,+G,74% *",:G "5 P,$C8 G2$ )$G2"F+ C$ -+$ G" +G-F( G4,% A,+O 4A$ A"#-+GM I: +,)*%$

C"AF+8 G2,+ )$4:+ G24G "-A A$+-%G+ [ 4:F G2$ A$%4G,P$ ,:G$A*A$G4G,":+ [ 4A$ ,))-:$ G" +)4%%

724:B$+ ,: G2$ F4G4M VP$: )"A$0 "-A A$+-%G+ 74::"G #$ A$P$A+$F ": G2$ #4+,+ "5 4 5$C

"#+$AP4G,":+8 4FF$F8 A$)"P$F "A R7"AA$7G$FSM L G2"A"-B2 4:4%(+,+ "5 A"#-+G:$++ +2"C+ G24G

"-A $+G,)4G$+ 4A$ *A$+$AP$F 4:F C"-%F A$*%,74G$ $P$: ,5 C$ ),++$F ":$ G2,AF "5 G2$ F4G4M

1" 7":7%-F$ G2,+ +$7G,": 4#"-G RF4G4 *A"#%$)+S8 C$ G2,:O ,G ,+ ,)*"AG4:G G" +GA$++ G24G "-A

F4G4 +$G8 F$+*,G$ ,G+ $P,F$:G G$)*"A4% 7"::"G4G,":8 F"$+ :"G 5"A) 4 *A"*$A G,)$ +$A,$+M IG ,+ ,:

547G GA,P,4% G" :"G,7$ G24G G2$ F,55$A$:G 7":5%,7G+ "5 2-)4:,G( F" :"G +24A$ G2$ +4)$ +$G "5

74-+$+M @4GG%$+ #$%":B,:B G" F,55$A$:G 7$:G-A,$+ 4:F 7":G,:$:G+ 4A$ :"G ":%( ,:F$*$:F$:G8 #-G

4%+" +-A$%( 24P$ F,55$A$:G "A,B,:+M I: +G4G,+G,74% C"AF+8 C$ 74::"G 4++-)$ G2$ $_,+G$:7$ "5 4

-:,Q-$ ),&0+.)' 9"&"#/',# !#,)"448 4+ ,5 7":5%,7G+ C$A$ 7"),:B 5A") G2$ +4)$ +"-A7$M

E"A G2,+ A$4+":8 C$ #$%,$P$ G24G *$A5"A),:B G,)$ +$A,$+ 4:4%(+,+ ": G2,+ O,:F "5 F4G4 ,+

-+$%$++8 ,5 :"G F4:B$A"-+8 B,P$: G24G ":$ 7"-%F $_GA4*"%4G$ ),+%$4F,:B GA$:F+8 4+ F":$ 5"A

$_4)*%$ ,: 6,:O$A D>?..HM U"C 7"-%F G2$ L: ^-+24: A$#$%%,": ,: 32,:4 D];; LKH #$

F$*$:F$:G ": G2$ ',$B$ "5 3":+G4:G,:"*%$ #( G2$ LA4#+ D].] LKH8 "A 24P$ 4: ,)*47G ": G2$

k,O,:B J4,F+ ,: IA$%4:F D5A") ]b; LK ":Hc

!"G,7$ G24G C$ 4A$ :"G +4(,:B G24G 4%% 7":5%,7G+ 4A$ ,:F$*$:F$:G0 F-A,:B NN>8 G2$ 4GG47O ":

6$4A% U4A#"A 4:F G2$ @4GG%$ "5 EA4:7$ C$A$ :"G ,:F$*$:F$:G8 :"GC,G2+G4:F,:B G2$ +*4G,"<

G$)*"A4% F,P,F$8 4:F G24GZ+ C2( 2,+G"A,4:+ )$AB$ G2$) ,:G" ":$ +,:B%$ $P$:G8 4+ C$ 24P$

4%A$4F( :"G,7$F #$5"A$M L:F C2,%$ C$ 74: 477$*G G24G8 2,+G"A,74%%(8 )"+G "5 G2$ 74-+$+ "5 NN>4A$ A$%4G$F G" NN.8 ,G ,+ #$GG$A G" 4P",F GA4:+%4G,:B G2,+ F$*$:F$:7$ C2$: +G-F(,:B G2$

:-)#$A "5 74+-4%G,$+0 ,G C"-%F #$ Q-,G$ 4#+-AF G" #$%,$P$ G24G G2$ :-)#$A "5 P,7G,)+ ,: .b\\

24F 4:(G2,:B G" +" C,G2 G2$ F$4G2 G"%% ,: .b.]M U"C 7"-%F G2$ )4B:,G-F$ "5 NN> F$*$:F ":

NN.c



.?

/1E#&, - G)H H, 0,20,7 )#& &)*#206,22 0) 0;, &,+1%*1+10' ): ;120)&1<%+ &,F)&023 I, <&,%0, -JJKJJJ 71::,&,60

;120)&1,2 %2 #61:)&$ &%67)$ 6#$*,&2 *,0H,,6 ;1E; %67 +)H ,201$%0,2 :&)$ 0;, 7%0% 2,02 LH;1<; #67,&

%EE&,E%01)6 %FF,%& M%#221%6N %67 <;,<O 1: &,P<)$*16%01)62 +,%72 0) 71::,&,60 &,2#+02 LH, #2,7 0;, FP

?%+#,K %<0#%++' -PFP?%+#, :)& 0;, 2<%+, F%&%$,0,& 6)0 *,<%#2, H, &,+' )6 FP?%+#,2 *#0 *,<%#2, FP?%+#,2 %&,

,Q0&,$,+' 2,62101?, 0) <;%6E,2 16 7%0%N3 ")$, ;120)&1,2 16<+#7, (16O,&R2 ,Q%EE,&%0,7 6#$*,&2 :)& 0;, B66

S#2;%6 &,*,++1)6K )0;,&2 7)6R03

/1E#&, 4 >;, 0%1+ ,QF)6,60 :&)$ $%Q1$#$ +1O,+1;))7K 6)0 TU>K 12 16?%&1%60 0) ,&&)&2 16 0;, &,F)&016E ):

<)6:+1<023

A#05*9+

',:7$ C$ 4A$ ,:G$A$+G$F ,: $+G,)4G,:B G2$ G4,% A,+O "5 P,"%$:G 7":5%,7G8 G24G ,+ G2$ A,+O "5 %4AB$

F$+GA-7G,P$ C4A+ 4:F 4A)$F 7":5%,7G+8 C$ -+$ G""%+ 5A") $_GA$)$ P4%-$ G2$"A( DVk1H G"

!"# !"$ !"% !"& '"!( )*+!"!!

!"!,

!"'!

!"',

!"-!

!"-,

./

!"#$ !"#% !"$! !"$& !"$' !"$$ !"$%

!"!!

!"!&

!"!'

!"!$

!"!%

!"(!

!"(&

)*



..

-:F$A+G4:F G2$ #$24P,"A "5 G2$ A,B2G G4,% "5 G2$ F,+GA,#-G,": "5 C4A 74+-4%G,$+M Vk1 ,+ 4 #A4:72

"5 +G4G,+G,7+ F$4%,:B C,G2 $_GA$)$ 4:F A4A$ $P$:G+8 ,: G2$ 5"A) "5 )4_,)4 4:F ),:,)4

Di-)#$%8 .bg=T V)#A$72G+ $G 4%M8 >??gT F$ U44: 4:F E$AA$,A48 >??/HM

N,G2,: G2$ #A"4F 5,$%F "5 Vk18 C$ )4,:%( -+$ G2$ +"<74%%$F i$:$A4%,a$F 64A$G" Di6H

4**A"_,)4G,": D@4%O$)4 4:F F$ U44:8 .b]\T 6,7O4:F+8 .b];H8 477"AF,:B G" C2,72 4%% G2$

$_7$$F4:7$+ 4#"P$ 4 2,B2 G2A$+2"%F8 ,5 G2,+ G2A$+2"%F ,+ 7"AA$7G%( 72"+$:8 G$:F G" 5"%%"C 4 i6

F,+GA,#-G,":8 4 +O$C$F F,+GA,#-G,":8 C2,72 74: #$ 724A47G$A,a$F #( 54G G4,%+M

12$ 5-:7G,": 5"A) "5 4 i6 F,+GA,#-G,": ,+

!"# !! !!!!! !

! ! ! ! ! !!!

!

!

!

!! ! !

! ! !!

!!!

! ! ! !

8

C2$A$ ! ! ! 5"A ! ! !8 4:F ! ! ! ! ! ! !!! 5"A ! ! !8 C,G2 !! ! ! ! 4:F ! ! !M

12$ *4A4)$G$A ! ,+ G2$ )"+G ,)*"AG4:G ":$ 5"A -+8 4+ ,G 7":GA"%+ 5"A G2$ 54G:$++ "5 G2$ A,B2G

G4,%M 12$ %4AB$A !8 G2$ 54GG$A G2$ G4,%M E"A ! ! !!!8 G2$ i6 F,+GA,#-G,": 24+ 4: ,:5,:,G$ P4A,4:7$M

E"A ! ! !8 $P$: G2$ )$4: ,+ :"G 5,:,G$M

E"A C24G 7":7$A:+ C4A 74+-4%G,$+8 C$ 5,:F G24G G2$ 64A$G,4: G4,% ,+ 47G-4%%( +" 54G G24G8 5A") 4

G2$"A$G,74% *",:G "5 P,$C8 G2$ )$4: "5 G2$ F,+GA,#-G,": ,+ :"G 5,:,G$ D! ! !HM I: +,)*%$ C"AF+8

G2,+ )$4:+ G24G G2$ G4,% A,+O ,+ +" %4AB$ G24G ":$ +,:B%$ $P$:G8 ":$ +,:B%$ C4A8 7"-%F F$+GA"( G2$

C2"%$ 2-)4:,G( D]Mg #,%%,": *$"*%$HM

I: A$4%,G(8 G2,:B+ 4A$ 4 %,GG%$ #,G )"A$ 7")*%,74G$F8 #$74-+$ F4G4 74: #$ ),+%$4F,:B8 $P$: C2$:

4**A"472,:B 4 *A"#%$) -+,:B G2$ 7"AA$7G )$G2"F"%"B( DVk18 C2$: +G-F(,:B G4,%+HM N2,%$ C$

+2"C G24G G2$ G4,% A,+O "5 P,"%$:G 7":5%,7G ,+ 47G-4%%( %4AB$ [ )-72 %4AB$A G24: C24G ":$ 7"-%F

+,)*%( ,:5$A -+,:B +G4:F4AF F$+7A,*G,P$ 4:F ,:5$A$:G,4% +G4G,+G,7+ D:"G 4**A"*A,4G$ ,: G2,+

74+$H8 C$ 4%+" *",:G "-G G24G ,G 74::"G #$ ,:5,:,G$8 4+ F4G4 G$:F G" +-BB$+G :4,P$%( -+,:B Vk1M

I: 547G8 :" +,:B%$ 7":5%,7G 74: O,%% )"A$ G24: G2$ C2"%$ C"A%F *"*-%4G,":M 12,+ ,)*%,$+ G2$

*A$+$:7$ "5 4: -**$A #"-:F G24G C$ 74: -+$ G" 7"AA$7G "-A $+G,)4G$+M 12$ -2/+ -.4'#.62'.,&

4**A"4728 #4+$F ": 4 +*$7,4% %"B<GA4:+5"A)4G,": "5 F4G48 ,+ G2$ C4( ,: C2,72 C$ F$4% C,G2

4**4A$:G%( ,:5,:,G$ )$4: *2$:")$:4 %,O$ C4A 74+-4%G,$+M E"A )"A$ F$G4,%+ 4#"-G "-A

)$G2"F"%"B(8 $+*$7,4%%( 5"A G2$ -+$ "5 G2$ F-4% F,+GA,#-G,":8 C$ A$5$A G" 3,A,%%" 4:F 14%$#

D>?./HM

j:7$ 4B4,:8 ,G ,+ C"AG2 -:F$A%,:,:B G24G 4%% G2$ +G4G,+G,74% )$G2"F+ C$ -+$ 4A$ A"#-+G8 G24G ,+

G" +4( G2$( G$:F G" #$ ,))-:$ G" $P$: G" :":<GA,P,4% 724:B$+ ,: G2$ F4G4 D-* G" >?f "5 "-A

F4G4 7"-%F 724:B$8 4:F +G,%% "-A A$+-%G+ 4A$ *A$+$AP$FHM

>;, 7120&1*#01)6 ): H%& <%2#%+01,2. *%21< :%<02

N2$: %""O,:B 4G G2$ F,+GA,#-G,": "5 C4A 74+-4%G,$+8 G2$ 5,A+G G2,:B C$ :"G,7$ ,+ G24G ,G ,+ 2,B2%(

+O$C$F C,G2 4 P$A( 54G A,B2G G4,%M E,B-A$ g 7":G4,:+ 4 +,)*%$ 2,+G"BA4) -+,:B 47G-4% F4G40



.>

C2,%$ )"+G 4A)$F 7":5%,7G B$:$A4G$ 4 5$C G2"-+4:F+ P,7G,)+>8 ": G2$ %$5G<24:F +,F$ "5 G2$

*,7G-A$8 4 5$C 7":5%,7G+ 74-+$ ),%%,":+ "5 74+-4%G,$+8 C,G2 NN> G"G4%,:B #$GC$$: \=M; 4:F =;

),%%,": P,7G,)+8 F$*$:F,:B ": G2$ +"-A7$ D,: G2$ BA4*2 C$ +2"C G2$ 4P$A4B$0 ]g ),"HM

/1E#&, 8. G120)E&%$ ): H%& <%2#%+01,2 #216E &%H 7%0%3

12$ 4P$A4B$ :-)#$A "5 74+-4%G,$+ ,: "-A +4)*%$ ,+ .Z?/]Z;/=M 12$ ,:<+4)*%$ +G4:F4AF

F$P,4G,": ,+ ;Z]g=Z;\.M U"C$P$A8 +,:7$ G2$ +G4:F4AF F$P,4G,": ,+ :"G 4 A$%,4#%$ )$4+-A$

-:F$A 54G G4,%+8 B,P$: G24G G2$ G2$"A$G,74% P4A,4:7$ )4( :"G $_,+G DV)#A$72G $G 4%M8 >??gH8 C$

4%+" *A"P,F$ G2$ )$4: 4#+"%-G$ F$P,4G,":8 "A YLKg0 .Z]\]Z=/bM 12,+ :-)#$A +2"C+ G2$

$_GA$)$ P"%4G,%,G( "5 C4A 74+-4%G,$+8 +")$G2,:B 7")*4G,#%$ C,G2 4 54G<G4,%$F *2$:")$:":M

> 6%$4+$ :"G,7$ G24G C$ 4A$ :"G B,P,:B 4:( $G2,74% h-FB$)$:GM N2$: C$ +4( q 4 5$C P,7G,)+ r8

C$ G2,:O "5 G2$) 4+ +G4G,+G,74% F4G48 :-)#$A+M EA") 4: $G2,74% *",:G "5 P,$C8 ":$ P,7G,) ,+

4%A$4F( G"" )-72M

g 12$ YLK ,+ G2$ )$4: "5 4%% G2$ 4#+"%-G$ F$P,4G,":+ "5 $472 F4G4 *",:G 5A") G2$ +4)*%$

)$4:M E"A)4%%(0 YLKD_HsVtu<VvuwtM



.g

jG2$A -+$5-% +G4G,+G,7+ 4A$ G2$ )$F,4: D\?Z???H8 G2$ 5,A+G Q-4AG,%$ D.gZ;g=H 4:F G2$ G2,AF

Q-4AG,%$ D.=>Z???H0 ];f "5 4%% 4A)$F 7":5%,7G+ B$:$A4G$ %$++ G2$: .=>Z??? 74+-4%G,$+8 4:F +G,%%

G2$ +4)*%$ )$4: ,+ 4%)"+G / G,)$+ %4AB$Ax

E,B-A$+ \ 4:F ; +2"C G2$ :-)#$A8 4:F G2$ A$%4G,P$ )4B:,G-F$ C,G2 A$+*$7G G" C"A%F

*"*-%4G,":8 "5 C4A 74+-4%G,$+ "P$A G,)$8 C2$: -+,:B GC" F,55$A$:G F$5,:,G,":+ "5 F4G40 47G-4%

4:F A$+74%$F "#+$AP4G,":+M

/1E#&, =. I%& <%2#%+01,2 )?,& 01$, H3&303 H)&+7 F)F#+%01)6 #216E %<0#%+ 7%0%3

IG ,+ ,:G$A$+G,:B G" :"G,7$ 2"C G2$ 72",7$ "5 G2$ G(*$ "5 F4G4 )4( %$4F G" F,55$A$:G

,:G$A*A$G4G,": "5 GA$:F+ 4:F *4GG$A:+M EA") A$+74%$F F4G4 DE,B-A$ gH8 ":$ 7"-%F 5"A $_4)*%$

+-*$A5,7,4%%( ,:5$A 4 F$7A$4+$ ,: G2$ :-)#$A "5 74+-4%G,$+ "P$A G,)$M IG ,+ ,: 547G "#P,"-+ G24GA$+74%,:B F4G4 C,%% G$:F G" ,:5%4G$ *4+G "#+$AP4G,":+8 4+ 4%A$4F( :"G,7$F #( V*+G$,: D>?..H8

C2" 4%+" "#h$7G G24G A$+74%,:B )4( B$:$A4G$ *4A4F"_,74% +,G-4G,":+M 3,G,:B 2,)0 RvMMMw C2(

+2"-%F C$ #$ 7":G$:G C,G2 ":%( 4 A$%4G,P$ F$7A$4+$c @( G2,+ %"B,78 C2$: C$ A$472 4 C"A%F

*"*-%4G,": "5 :,:$ #,%%,": ,: >?;?8 6,:O$A C,%% 7":7$,P4#%( #$ +4G,+5,$F ,5 4 )$A$ GC" ),%%,":

*$"*%$ 4A$ O,%%$F ,: C4A G24G ($4ASM

L+ G" G2$ :-)#$A "5 4A)$F 7":5%,7G+8 #"G2 5,B-A$ ; 4:F ] +$$) G" +-BB$+G 4: ,:7A$4+$ "5

#$%%,B$A$:7$ "P$A G,)$8 +,:7$ )"+G $P$:G+ 4A$ 7":7$:GA4G$F ,: G2$ %4+G ;?? ($4A+ "A +"M 12,+ ,+

P$A( %,O$%( h-+G 4: ,%%-+,":8 *A"#4#%( F-$ G" 4 A$*"AG,:B #,4+ 5"A G2$ 7":5%,7G+ "5 4:G,Q-,G( 4:F

$4A%( Y,FF%$ LB$+M IG ,+ 7$AG4,:%( $4+,$A G" "#G4,: F$7$:G ,:5"A)4G,": 4#"-G )"A$ A$7$:G



.\

7":5%,7G+8 G24G ,+ C2( C$ 24P$ )4:( A4G2$A *A$7,+$ "#+$AP4G,":+ ,: G2$ %4+G F$74F$+ 4:F

7$:G-A,$+8 C,G2 A$+*$7G G" C24G 24**$:$F ,: G2$ G2,AF 7$:G-A( LKM

1" 7"AA$7G%( +G-F( G2$ G4,% A,+O "5 4A)$F 7":5%,7G+8 C$ :$$F G" -:F$A+G4:F C2$G2$A "-A F4G4

A$4%%( $_2,#,G 4 64A$G,4: A,B2G G4,%8 4+ +-BB$+G$F #( E,B-A$ \M 12$ 4:+C$A ,+ 455,A)4G,P$M E"A

$_4)*%$8 ,: E,B-A$ ]8 C$ +$$ G24G8 ": 4 %"B<%"B +74%$8 G2$ F,+GA,#-G,": "5 C4A 74+-4%G,$+ +2"C+

4 7%$4A %,:$4A #$24P,"A ,: G2$ A,B2G G4,%M E,B-A$ ] ,+ 4 l,*5 *%"G D)$:G,":$F $4A%,$AH8 4:F ,G

A$*A$+$:G+ 4 2$-A,+G,7 G""% G" %""O 5"A 64A$G,4:,G( ,: F4G4 D3,A,%%"8 >?.gH8 #( -+,:B 4 *A"*$AG(

"5 G2$ +-AP,P4% 5-:7G,": "5 4 64A$G" F,+GA,#-G$F A4:F") P4A,4#%$M Y4:( "G2$A *%"G+ 74: #$

-+$F G" P$A,5( G2$ *A$+$:7$ "5 4 54G A,B2G G4,%8 +-72 4+ Y4_,)-)<G"<'-) 4:F )$4: $_7$++

*%"G+8 4:F C$ A$5$A G" 3,A,%%" 4:F 14%$# D>?./H 5"A )"A$ F$G4,%+ 4:F F,+7-++,":+M

/1E#&, @. I%& <%2#%+01,2 )?,& 01$, H3&303 H)&+7 F)F#+%01)6 #216E &,2<%+,7 7%0%3

E,B-A$ ] :"G ":%( 7":5,A)+ G2$ ,F$4 "5 4 64A$G,4: A,B2G G4,%8 #-G ,G 4%+" +-BB$+G+ G24G G2$ C2"%$

F,+GA,#-G,": "5 C4A 74+-4%G,$+ )4( #$ ,: G2$ F")4,: "5 4GGA47G,": "5 4 54G<G4,%$F F,+GA,#-G,":M

12$ %,:$4A,G( "5 G2$ +-AP,P4% 5-:7G,": +G4AG+ ,:F$$F 5A") G2$ P$A( %$5G<24:F +,F$ "5 G2$ *%"GM I:

4FF,G,": E,B-A$ ] +2"C+ 2"C G2$ A,B2G G4,% G$:F+ G" 7%"+$ F"C: 4 %,GG%$ #,GM 12,+ ,+ 4

*2$:")$:": 7"))":%( O:"C: 4+ 5,:,G$ +4)*%$ #,4+M IG ,+ ,: 547G 2,B2%( ,)*A"#4#%$ G" #$ 4#%$

G" "#+$AP$ 4 +-55,7,$:G :-)#$A "5 )4_,)4 ,: G2$ F4G48 +" G24G G2$ G4,% F$7A$4+$+ %,:$4A%( -:G,%

G2$ $:FM

14#%$ . 7":G4,:+ +")$ ,:5"A)4G,": 4#"-G G2$ "77-AA$:7$ "5 4A)$F 7":5%,7G+ "P$A G,)$M E"A

$_4)*%$8 ,5 C$ %""O 4G $P$:G+ B$:$A4G,:B 4G %$4+G ;??Z??? P,7G,)+8 C$ F,+7"P$A G24G8 C2$:



.;

-+,:B A4C F4G48 C$ 24P$ G" C4,G 4: 4P$A4B$ "5 >\ ($4A+ G" "#+$AP$ +-72 $P$:G+M 12$

7"AA$+*":F,:B )$4: 4#+"%-G$ F$P,4G,": ,+ gg ($4A+M I58 ": G2$ 7":GA4A(8 C$ -+$ A$+74%$F F4G48

G2$ 4P$A4B$ ,:G$A<4AA,P4% G,)$ ,+ .? ($4A+8 C,G2 4 YLK "5 .>M

12A$+2"%F LPB J4C YLK J4C LPB

J$+74%$F

YLK

J$+74%$F

;??O >\ gg .? .>

. ),% g\ \= .g ./

> ),% ;] ]g >? >\

; ),% bg ..] g\ \g

.? ),% .g/ .gb ;> /.

>? ),% >;> >/] ]g =/

;? ),% g]> g/> .?\ ..\

>%*+, -. B?,&%E, 160,&P%&&1?%+ 01$,2 %67 0;,1& $,%6 %*2)+#0, 7,?1%01)6K 16160,E,& ',%&2K :)& 71::,&,60 <%2#%+01,2V 0;&,2;)+723



./

/1E#&, W. X1F: (+)0 L+)EP+)E F+)0 ): 0;, 2#&?1?%+ :#6<01)6N ): H%& <%2#%+01,2 #216E%<0#%+ 7%0%3

I5 C$ ,:7A$4+$ G2$ G2A$+2"%F\8 4:F 7":+,F$A 7":5%,7G+ C,G2 4G %$4+G ; ),%%,": 74+-4%G,$+8 C$

:$$F G" C4,G bg "A g\ ($4A+8 F$*$:F,:B ": G2$ F4G4 F$5,:,G,":M I:G-,G,P$%(8 G2$ #%""F,$A G2$

7":5%,7G8 G2$ %":B$A G2$ ,:G$A<4AA,P4% G,)$M E"A 4 7":5%,7G C,G2 4G %$4+G ;? ),%%,": P,7G,)+8 4 P$A(

$_GA$)$ 4:F 2"*$5-%%( A4A$ $P$:G8 G2$ 4P$A4B$ ,:G$A<4AA,P4% G,)$ ,+ g]> ($4A+8 -+,:B A4C F4G48

C,G2 4 YLK "5 g/>M

L%% G2,+ G$%%+ -+ G24G G2$ 4#+$:7$ "5 4 7":5%,7G B$:$A4G,:B )"A$ G24: [ +4( [ >? ),%%,":

74+-4%G,$+ ,: G2$ %4+G >? ($4A+ ,+ 2,B2%( ,:+-55,7,$:G G" +G4G$ G24G ,G+ "77-AA$:7$ *A"#4#,%,G( 24+F$7A$4+$F "P$A G,)$8 B,P$: G24G G2$ 4P$A4B$ ,:G$A<4AA,P4% G,)$ ,+ >;> ($4A+ D]g 5"A A$+74%$FH8

C,G2 4 YLK "5 >/] D=/ 5"A A$+74%$FH ($4A+x X:5"AG-:4G$%(8 C$ +G,%% 24P$ G" C4,G Q-,G$ +")$

G,)$ G" +4( G24G C$ 4A$ %,P,:B ,: 4 )"A$ *$47$5-% $A4T G2$ 47G-4% F4G4 C$ 24P$ 4A$ :"G ,: 54P"A

:"A 4B4,:+G 4 +GA-7G-A4% 724:B$ ,: P,"%$:7$8 C2$: C$ F$4% C,G2 C4A 74+-4%G,$+M k$A( +,)*%(0

C$ 74::"G +4(M

\ 12$ G2A$+2"%F+ ,: 14#%$ . 4A$ h-+G 4A#,GA4A(8 4:F )$4:G G" B,P$ -+$5-% ,:5"A)4G,": ,: 4

7")*47G G4#%$M jG2$A G2A$+2"%F+ 74: #$ 72"+$:8 #-G ":$ B$:$A4% )":"G":$ #$24P,"A 74: #$

"#+$AP$F8 ,: 477"AF4:7$ C,G2 ,:G-,G,":0 G2$ 2,B2$A G2$ G2A$+2"%F8 G2$ %":B$A G2$ 4P$A4B$

,:G$A<4AA,P4% G,)$M

1e+04 1e+05 1e+06 1e+07 1e+08

0 . 0

0 1

0 . 0

0 5

0 . 0

1 0

0 . 0

5 0

0 . 1

0 0

0 . 5

0 0

1 . 0

0 0

Zipf Plot of war casualties (actual data)

x (on log scale)

1

! F

( x ) ( o n

l o g

s c a l e )



.]

>;, 0%1+ &12O ): %&$,7 <)6:+1<02

L+ +4,F #$5"A$8 -+,:B $_GA$)$ P4%-$ G2$"A(8 4:F ,: *4AG,7-%4A G2$ B$:$A4%,a$F 64A$G"

4**A"_,)4G,":8 C$ 74: $_GA4*"%4G$ ,:5"A)4G,": 4#"-G G2$ G4,% A,+O "5 4A)$F 7":5%,7G+M

12$ $+G,)4G,": "5 G2$ *4A4)$G$A+ "5 4 i6K 74: #$ *$A5"A)$F ,: F,55$A$:G C4(+8 4:F C$ A$5$A

G" V)#A$72G+ $G 4%M D>??gH8 "A F$ U44: 4:F E$AA$,A4 D>??/H 5"A )"A$ F$G4,%+M N,G2 "-A F4G48

G2$ #$+G A$+-%G+ 4A$ "#G4,:$F -+,:B )4_,)-) %,O$%,2""F D3,A,%%" 4:F 14%$#8 >?./HM

14#%$ > 7":G4,:+ "-A $+G,)4G$+ 5"A G2$ B$:$A4%,a$F 64A$G" 4**A"_,)4G,": 5"A G2$ F,+GA,#-G,":

"5 C4A 74+-4%G,$+8 -+,:B #"G2 47G-4% 4:F A$+74%$F F4G4M E"A #"G2 F$5,:,G,":+8 C$ 74: +$$ G24G

G2$ G2A$+2"%F+ 4#"P$ C2,72 G2$ i6K 4**A"_,)4G,": 2"%F+ 4A$ F$5,:,G$%( %4AB$A G24: G2$

"A,B,:4% g??? 74+-4%G,$+ C$ 24P$ ,)*"+$F ,: 7"%%$7G,:B G2$ F4G4M U"C$P$A8 ,: #"G2 74+$+84%)"+G /?f "5 4%% G2$ "#+$AP4G,": %,$ 4#"P$ G2$ GC" G2A$+2"%F+M ',:7$ C$ 4A$ ,:G$A$+G$F ,: G2$

A,+O "5 P$A( %4AB$ 7":5%,7G+8 F$4%,:B C,G2 G2$ G"* /?f "5 4%% 7":5%,7G+ ,+ F$5,:,G$%( )"A$ G24:

+-55,7,$:G 5"A "-A *-A*"+$+;M

12$ )"+G ,:G$A$+G,:B A$+-%G "5 14#%$ > ,+ G2$ Q-4%,G4G,P$ ,:5"A)4G,": C$ 74: $_GA4*"%4G$ 5A")

! DF$7,)4%+ 4A$ )-72 %$++ A$%$P4:GHM E"A #"G2 47G-4% 4:F A$+74%$F F4G48 C$ 7%$4A%( +$$ G24G

! ! !M 12,+ ,:F,74G$+ G2$ *A$+$:7$ "5 4: ,:5,:,G$ )$4: *2$:")$:":8 G24G ,+ 4 *2$:")$:":

C2"+$ A$4%,a4G,":+ 74: #$ +" %4AB$ 4:F $AA4G,7 G24G G2$ )$4: ,+ :"G 4 A$%,4#%$ Q-4:G,G(M L:F ,5

G2$ )$4: "5 G2$ i6K ,+ :"G 5,:,G$8 G2$: G2$ )$4: "5 G2$ C2"%$ F,+GA,#-G,": "5 C4A 74+-4%G,$+

)-+G #$ ,:5,:,G$M I: 547G8 +,:7$ G2$ G4,% )$4: ,+ 4 7")*":$:G "5 G2$ C2"%$ F,+GA,#-G,": )$4:8 ,5

G2$ 5"A)$A ,+ :"G 5,:,G$8 G2$ +4)$ 2"%F+ 5"A G2$ %4GG$AM

K4G4-

DG2A$+2"%FHp y

J4C >;O .M\b=; b?/>?

J$+74%$F .\;O .M;=/= \b]\g/

; I: )"+G 4**%,74G,":+ "5 Vk18 ":%( G2$ G"* ;f D"A %$++H "5 G2$ "#+$AP4G,":+ %,$ 4#"P$ G2$

B,P$: G2A$+2"%FM j-A /?f ,+ F$5,:,G$%( P$A( %4AB$8 7":5,A),:B G2$ ,F$4 "5 4 C2"%$ F,+GA,#-G,":

,: G2$ F")4,: "5 4GGA47G,": "5 4 54G<G4,%$F F,+GA,#-G,":8 %,O$ G2$ EAz72$G DV)#A$72G+ $G 4%M8

>??gHM



.=

>%*+, 4. Y%Q1$#$ +1O,+1;))7 ,201$%0,2 :)& 0;, F%&%$,0,&2 ): 0;, M(C

%FF&)Q1$%01)6 ): 0;, &1E;0 0%1+ ): 0;, 7120&1*#01)6 ): H%& <%2#%+01,23 B++,201$%0,2 %&, 21E61:1<%60 H10; % 0'F, Z ,&&)& ): @[3

L+ +4,F8 G2$+$ A$+-%G+ 4A$ A"#-+G G" ),++,:B "A ),++*$7,5,$F F4G4M L+ +2"C: ,: 3,A,%%" 4:F

14%$# D>?./H8 -+,:B G""%+ %,O$ #""G+GA4*8 -* G" >?f "5 G2$ "#+$AP4G,":+ D,: G2$ G4,% "A :"GH

7"-%F 724:B$8 C,G2"-G 455$7G,:B G2$ A$+-%G+ "5 G2$ 4:4%(+,+M

@-G ,5 G2$ )$4: "5 G2$ F,+GA,#-G,": "5 C4A 74+-4%G,$+ ,+ :"G 5,:,G$8 G2$: ,G )$4:+ G24G G2$ G4,%

A,+O "5 4A)$F 7":5%,7G+ ,+ :"G 5,:,G$M I: "G2$A C"AF+8 C$ 7"-%F $_*$A,$:7$ 4:( +$7":F 4 +,:B%$

$P$:G 4::,2,%4G,:B 2-)4:,G(M L :-7%$4A 2"%"74-+G8 "A $P$: C"A+$M

@-G 74: G2,+ A$4%%( #$ G2$ 74+$c

N2$: F$4%,:B C,G2 G4,%+8 $_GA$)$ P4%-$ G2$"A( ,+ G2$ A,B2G 4**A"472M IG C"-%F #$ CA":B 4:F

2,B2%( ),+%$4F,:B G" 4**A"472 G4,%+ -+,:B "G2$A G$72:,Q-$+8 )4,:%( A$%(,:B ": :"A)4%,G(M

U"C$P$A8 C2$: -+,:B Vk18 ,G ,+ $_GA$)$%( ,)*"AG4:G G" G4O$ ,:G" 7":+,F$A4G,": G2$ A$4%

:4G-A$ "5 F4G4M 34: 4 7":5%,7G O,%% )"A$ G24: G2$ C2"%$ C"A%F *"*-%4G,":c

12$ 4:+C$A ,+ 7%$4A%( :"M L:F G2,+ 547G :$$F+ G" #$ G4O$: ,:G" 477"-:G8 ,5 C$ F" :"G C4:G G" #$

5""%$F #( F4G4M

12$ F,+GA,#-G,": "5 C4A 74+-4%G,$+ ,+ :$7$++4A,%( #"-:F$F0 C$ +-A$%( 74::"G O,%% 4 :$B4G,P$

4)"-:G "5 *$"*%$8 #-G8 ": G2$ "G2$A +,F$8 C$ 74::"G O,%% )"A$ G24: G2$ C2"%$ C"A%F

*"*-%4G,": D4G *A$+$:G8 ]Mg #,%%,": *$"*%$8 477"AF,:B G" G2$ X:,G$F !4G,":+HM EA") 4 +G4G,+G,74%

*",:G "5 P,$C8 #"-:F:$++ 24+ ":$ ,)*"AG4:G ,)*%,74G,":0 4%% G2$ )")$:G+ "5 G2$ F,+GA,#-G,":

:$$F G" #$ 5,:,G$8 G2-+ ,:7%-F,:B G2$ )$4: 4:F G2$ P4A,4:7$M 12$+$ 4A$ G2$ +24F"C )")$:G+8,: G2$ G$A),:"%"B( "5 14%$# 4:F 3,A,%%" D>?.;H8 ,M$M )")$:G+ G24G 74::"G #$ 7"AA$7G%( ,:5$AA$F

5A") F4G48 -:%$++ C$ G4O$ ,:G" 7":+,F$A4G,": G2$ $_,+G$:7$ "5 4: -**$A #"-:F8 4:F C$ 7"AA$7G

5"A ,GM

X+,:B G2$ +"<74%%$F F-4% F,+GA,#-G,": D3,A,%%" 4:F 14%$#8 >?./H8 G24G ,+ 4 *4AG,7-%4A %"B<

GA4:+5"A)4G,": "5 G2$ "A,B,:4% F4G48 G" )4* G2$) ": G2$ #"-:F$F +-**"AG8 ":$ 74: "#G4,: G2$

47G-4% )")$:G+ "5 G2$ F,+GA,#-G,": "5 C4A 74+-4%G,$+M 12$+$ )")$:G+ 4A$ :4G-A4%%( 5,:,G$8 #-G

G2$( G$:F G" #$ )-72 %4AB$A G24: G2"+$ ":$ 7"-%F $+G,)4G$ 5A") F4G4 -+,:B G2$,A +,)*%$

$)*,A,74% 7"-:G$*4AG+ DC2,72 4A$ G2$A$5"A$ :"G A$%,4#%$HM E"A $_4)*%$8 -+,:B A$+74%$F F4G48

C$ F,+7"P$A G24G G2$ G4,% )$4: "5 C4A 74+-4%G,$+ 4#"P$ G2$ . ),%%,": G2A$+2"%F ,+ /M>. ),%%,":8

4B4,:+G 4 7"AA$+*":F,:B +4)*%$ )$4: "5 gMb; ),%%,": D.M;] G,)$+ %4AB$AHM E"A 4 G2A$+2"%F "5

;? ),%%,": P,7G,)+8 G2$ +4)*%$ )$4: ,+ >=M>> ),%%,":8 C2,%$ G2$ GA-$ D+24F"CH )$4: ,+ /]M.]D>Mg= G,)$+ %4AB$AHM

N2$: F$4%,:B C,G2 G4,% A,+O8 4:"G2$A +$G "5 ,)*"AG4:G +G4G,+G,7+ ,+ A$*A$+$:G$F #( Q-4:G,%$+M L

Q-4:G,%$ ,+ G2$ P4%-$ 4#"P$ C2,72 4 7$AG4,: *$A7$:G4B$ "5 "#+$AP4G,":+ %,$M 12$ G"* ;f

Q-4:G,%$ ,+ G2$ P4%-$ 4#"P$ C2,72 C$ 74: 5,:F ;f "5 4%% G2$ "#+$AP4G,":+M 14#%$ g 7":G4,:+ G2$

G"* Q-4:G,%$+ "5 G2$ F,+GA,#-G,": "5 C4A 74+-4%G,$+8 -+,:B G2$ F-4% F,+GA,#-G,": 4**A"472 ":

#"G2 47G-4% 4:F A$+74%$F F4G4M 12$ A$+-%G+ 4A$ 5A,B2G$:,:B0 G2$A$ ,+ 4 ;f *A"#4#,%,G(8 -+,:B

47G-4% F4G48 "5 "#+$P,:B 4 7":5%,7G B$:$A4G,:B 4G %$4+G >{g=?{??? 74+-4%G,$+T 4:F 4 .f

*A"#4#,%,G( "5 7":5%,7G+ C,G2 4G %$4+G >/M= ),%%,": P,7G,)+M VP$: C"A+$0 "-A F4G4 4%+" +-**"AG 4

?M.f *A"#4#,%,G( "5 4 C4A O,%%,:B +")$G2,:B %,O$ =?? ),%%,": *$"*%$8 )"A$ G24: .?f "5 G2$

C2"%$ C"A%F *"*-%4G,":M 12$+$ 5,B-A$+ 4A$ $P$: +74A,$A C2$: C$ -+$ A$+74%$F F4G4M



.b

f4#"P$

J4C K4G4|.?]

J$+74%$F K4G4|.?]

;f >{g=?Z??? .;{\??Z???

.f >/{=??Z??? .b=Z>??Z???

?M.f =?.{.??Z??? \{];.Z;??Z???

>%*+, 8. >)F \#%601+,2 :)& 0;, 7120&1*#01)6 ): H%& <%2#%+01,2K %2 )*0%16,7 ?1% 0;,7#%+ 7120&1*#01)63

"#$%&'()#$* +( ,-./. 0$1 ,/.$23

12$ +2"AG 4:+C$A ,+ :"M

j-A F4G4 F" :"G +-**"AG G2$ *A$+$:7$ "5 4:( *4AG,7-%4A GA$:F ,: G2$ :-)#$A "5 4A)$F

7":5%,7G+ "P$A G,)$M U-)4:,G( +$$)+ G" #$ 4+ #$%%,B$A$:G 4+ 4%C4(+M !" ,:7A$4+$8 :"A F$7A$4+$M

!4G-A4%%( C$ 4A$ +*$4O,:B 4#"-G G2$ G(*$ "5 7":5%,7G+ 5"A C2,72 C$ 24P$ *$A5"A)$F "-A

4:4%(+,+8 G24G ,+ G" +4( G2$ %4AB$+G 4:F )"+G F$+GA-7G,P$ ":$+M N$ 74::"G +4( 4:(G2,:B 4#"-G

+)4%% 5,B2G+ C,G2 4 5$C 74+-4%G,$+8 +,:7$ G2$( F" :"G #$%":B G" "-A F4G4 +$G [2"C$P$A ,G ,+

7A-7,4% G24G8 4+ 4 7$:GA4% *A"*$AG( "5 G2$ 54G<G4,%$F:$++ "5 G2$ *A"7$++8 4 F$7%,:$ ,: 2"),7,F$

F"$+ :"G 455$7G G2$ G"G4% *A"*$AG,$+ "5 P,"%$:7$ 4:F 4:(":$Z+ A,+O "5 F$4G2M L+ C$ +4,F8 G2$)$4: ,+ G4,% FA,P$:M

LG G2$ #$+G "5 "-A O:"C%$FB$ :" 4P4,%4#%$ F4G4 +$G 7":G4,:+ $:"-B2 ,:5"A)4G,": G" )4O$

7A$F,#%$ +G4G$)$:G+ 4#"-G +G4G,+G,74%%( +,B:,5,74:G GA$:F+ ,: G2$ :-)#$A "5 7":5%,7G+ "P$A G,)$8

-:%$++ C$ A$4%%( G2,:O ,G ,+ A$4+":4#%$ G" $_GA4*"%4G$ %":B<G$A) GA$:F+ ": G2$ #4+,+ "5 +,_G(

($4A+ "5 "#+$AP4G,":+8 %,O$ G2"+$ 45G$A NN>M i,P$: G2$ ,:G$A<4AA,P4% G,)$+ C$ 24P$ "#+$AP$F

4#"P$8 ,G C"-%F #$ Q-,G$ :4}P$ G" 47G G24G C4(M

I5 C$ 5"7-+ "-A 4GG$:G,": ": "-A F4G4 +$G8 4:F ,: *4AG,7-%4A ": G2$ "#+$AP4G,":+ #$%":B,:B G"

G2$ %4+G /?? ($4A+ D5A") .;?? LK ":H8 5"A C2,72 ),++,:B "#+$AP4G,":+ +2"-%F #$ 5$C$A 4:F

A$*"AG,:B $AA"A+ +)4%%$A8 "-A 4:4%(+$+ +-BB$+G G24G G2$ :-)#$A "5 %4AB$ 7":5%,7G+ "P$A G,)$

5"%%"C+ 4 2")"B$:$"-+ 6",++": *A"7$++M I: 4 +,),%4A *A"7$++8 G2$ :-)#$A "5 "#+$AP4G,":+

"P$A G,)$8 ":7$ C$ 5,_ 4 B,P$: G,)$ ,:G$AP4% D+4( ;? ($4A+H8 5"%%"C+ 4 6",++": F,+GA,#-G,":M12$ :-)#$A "5 $_*$7G$F F4G4 *",:G+ ":%( F$*$:F+ ": G2$ %$:BG2 "5 G2$ G,)$ ,:G$AP4% C$

72""+$M E"A ,:G$AP4%+ "5 G2$ +4)$ +,a$8 G2$ $_*$7G$F :-)#$A "5 "#+$AP4G,":+ ,+ G2$ +4)$8

#$74-+$ G2$ ,:G$:+,G( "5 G2$ *A"7$++ F"$+ :"G P4A( "P$A G,)$M I: +,)*%$ G$A)+8 G2,+ 5,:F,:B

+-**"AG+ G2$ ,F$4 G24G C4A+ 4A$ A4:F")%( F,+GA,#-G$F 477,F$:G+ "P$A G,)$8 :"G 5"%%"C,:B 4:(

*4AG,7-%4A GA$:F8 4+ 4%A$4F( *",:G$F "-G #( J,724AF+": D.b/?HM

j:$ 5,:4% 7"))$:G ": G2$ 5,:$A<BA4,:$F *$A,"F +,:7$ NN>M E,B-A$ ] ,%%-+GA4G$+ G2$ ),+G4O$

)4F$ ,: G2$"A,a,:B 4#"-G C24G 24+ 24**$:$F +,:7$ .b\;M L+,F$ 5A") G2$ 547G G24G C$ 4A$

*,7O,:B 4 +*,O$ 4:F G24G 4 FA"* ,+ :4G-A4% 45G$A $P$A( +*,O$M 12$ C4( G" *A"*$A%( %""O 4G G2$

,++-$ ,+ G" 7":+,F$A G2$ $:G,A$ 2,+G"A( "5 C4A+8 +,)-%4G,:B 5A") G2$ *A"7$++8 4:F 72$7O,:B 2"C

)4:( *$A,"F+ F" :"G %""O %,O$ G2$ +GA$G72 +,:7$ .b\; [D#( B$:$A4G,:B +,)-%4G$F A$BA$++,":



>?

7"$55,7,$:G+HM L%4+8 C$ 4A$ 4#"-G Mg] +G4:F4AF F$P,4G,":+ 4C4( 5A") 4#+$:7$ "5 GA$:FM !"G$

G24G C$ 4A$ ,B:"A,:B G2$ +-AP,P"A #,4+M

/1E#&, ] U1)+,6<, 7&)F 216<, -^=@3 C1?,&E,6<, :&)$ 0;, F&)<,22 0) <%++ 10 % _0&,67` 12 F%0,60+' 6)0

20%01201<%++' 21E61:1<%60K 38][ ): % 20%67%&7 7,?1%01)6 %H%'3 a) 2<1,60120 *#1+72 % 0;,)&' :&)$ 38] 20%67%&7

7,?1%01)623

/1E#&, b ";%7)H $,%6 %0 71::,&,60 0;&,2;)+73

!"#$ !"%$ &$$$

'($!!$!

!($!!$"

!('!!$"

&($!!$"

!"#$%&"' (%#)%&*+"# ,-.-!/0"#"1*

!"#$%& '(#)

!#*+,( '(#)

-.. ... /.. ... 0.. ... 1.. ... 2.. ... 3.. ...4"5(6"%,$

7!7.!

8!7.!

-!7.!

/!7.!

0!7.!

1!7.!

2!7.!

'(#)



>.

/1E#&, ^ "%$F+, $,%6 Lc)#&6%+1201<N %67 $%Q1$#$ +1O,+1;))7 $,%6 %0 71::,&,60 ?%+#,2 ): 0;, 0%1+

,QF)6,603 I, 6)01<, 0;%0 % 7&)F 16 0;, 0%1+ ,QF)6,60 <%#2,2 %6 %2'$$,0&1< ,::,<0 K ;,6<, #6<,&0%160' %67

+%<O ): F&,<121)6 %*)#0 0;, 0%1+ $,%62 H)&2, $,%6 L>%+,* 4J-WN3

E,:4%%(8 G2$ 547G G24G G2$ R+24F"C )$4:S "A )4_,)-) %,O$%,2""F )$4: ,+ ,: $_7$++ "5 G2$

+4)*%$ )$4: DE,B-A$ =H ,+ :"G GA,P,4%M IG )$4:+ G24G $P$: 4 RA$4%S +G4G,+G,74%%( +,B:,5,74:G FA"*,: P,"%$:7$ C"-%F :"G 4%G$A #( )-72 G2$ BA4P,G( "5 G2$ +,G-4G,":0 G2$ C"A%F ,+ $P$: )"A$

F4:B$A"-+ G24: ,G %""O+M

B#:#"#-<#+

@4%O$)48 LMLM8 F$ U44:8 ^M J$+,F-4% %,5$ G,)$ 4G BA$4G 4B$M 12$ L::4%+ "5 6A"#4#,%,G( ;8 ]b><

=?\ D.b]\H

@@3 D>?.>HM I: "-A G,)$+0 12$ L: ^-+24: J$#$%%,":M

2GG*0eeCCCM##7M7"M-Oe*A"BA4))$+e#?.#(=)+M

@$A%,:+O,8 KM 12$ K$P,%Z+ K$%-+,":0 LG2$,+) 4:F ,G+ '7,$:G,5,7 6A$G$:+,":+M @4+,7 @""O+8 !$C

W"AO8 D>??bH

@-7O%$8 UM1M E.4',#* ,0 F.%.+.G/'.,& .& (&9+/&- 8 k"%M .8 ^":F":0 9"2: NM 64AO$A 4:F '": D.=;=H

3$F$A)4:8 ^MVM Y"F$%,:B G2$ +,a$ "5 C4A+0 5A") #,%%,4AF #4%%+ G" +4:F*,%$+M 12$ L)$A,74:

6"%,G,74% '7,$:7$ J$P,$C b]8 .g;<.;? D>??gH

!"#$%& !'()*+,"%-./-0'" 1&",

1"2 3-4&%-5))6 1&",

7",8& )9

:;<: :;<= :;=: :;== :;>: :;>= :;?:

@ #@:!

A #@:!

B #@:!

< #@:!

= #@:!

> #@:!

? #@:!

C #@:!

1&",



>>

3,A,%%"8 6M LA$ ("-A F4G4 A$4%%( 64A$G" F,+GA,#-G$Fc 62(+,74 L0 'G4G,+G,74% Y$724:,7+ 4:F ,G+

L**%,74G,":+ gb>8 ;b\]<;b/> D>?.gH

3,A,%%"8 6M8 14%$#8 !M!M j: G2$ +G4G,+G,74% *A"*$AG,$+ 4:F G4,% A,+O "5 P,"%$:G 7":5%,7G+M 62(+,74 L0

'G4G,+G,74% Y$724:,7+ 4:F ,G+ L**%,74G,":+ \;>8 >b<\; D>?./HM

3%4-+$G8 LM8 N""F4AF8 JM V+G,)4G,:B G2$ 2,+G"A,74% 4:F 5-G-A$ *A"#4#,%,G,$+ "5 %4AB$ G$AA"A,+G

$P$:G+M 12$ L::4%+ "5 L**%,$F 'G4G,+G,7+ ]8 .=g=<.=/; D>?.gH

3":G$+G4G,":M 9"-A:4% "5 3":5%,7G J$+"%-G,": ;g8 bg\<;? D>??bH

3"_8 ̂ MLM8 iA$$:#$AB8 YMJM D$F+MH '*$7,4% I++-$0 LFP4:7$+ ,: 1$AA"A,+) J,+O L:4%(+,+M J,+O

L:4%(+,+8 ":%,:$ I''! .;gb</b>\8 D>?.gH

F$ U44:8 ̂ M8 E$AA$,A48 LM V_GA$)$ k4%-$ 12$"A(0 L: I:GA"F-7G,":M @$A%,:8 '*A,:B$A '$A,$+ ,:

j*$A4G,":+ J$+$4A72 4:F E,:4:7,4% V:B,:$$A,:B8 >??/

K-A4:F8 9K8 R12$ *"*-%4G,": +G4G,+G,7+ "5 32,:48 LK > [ .b;g8S H,!2+/'.,& I'2-."4 D.b/?H8 k"%M

.g8 !"M g8 *M>?b8>>g

!"#$%&'()* ,-* ./0 1**$%#$AB8 3M8 Y,O"+72 1M Y"F$%%,:B V_GA$)4% VP$:G+M '*A,:B$A8 @$A%,:8

V*+G$,:8 JM @""O J$P,$C0 12$ @$GG$A L:B$%+ "5 j-A !4G-A$0 N2( k,"%$:7$ U4+ K$7%,:$FM

'7,$:G,5,7 L)$A,74:8 j7G"#$A ]8 D>?..H

E4%O8 YM8 U~+%$A8 9M8 J$,++8 JMKM ^4C+ "5 +)4%% :-)#$A+0 $_GA$)$+ 4:F A4A$ $P$:G+8 @,AO2•-+$A8

@$A%,:8 D>??\H

E,GaB$A4%F8 324A%$+ 64GA,7O8 F3.&/J / I3,#' F2+'2#/+ E.4',#*? Cresset Press,

,1935

EA,$F)4:8 9MLM X+,:B *"C$A %4C+ G" $+G,)4G$ 7":5%,7G +,a$M 9"-A:4% "5 3":5%,7G J$+"%-G,": ;b8

.>./<.>\. D>?.;H g;

i!"#"!$%& ()*) +,- ./ #012-03,20%! .0402 5" #, 2"-4" #6,!" 1 5"-0" /. 5"/2%0-") 7!!/.1 %8

Y4G2$)4G,7+ \\8 \>g<\;g D.b\gH

i"%F+G$,:8 9M^M N,::,:B G2$ C4A ": C4A0 G2$ F$7%,:$ "5 4A)$F 7":5%,7G C"A%FC,F$M 6$:B-,:8

!$C W"AO8 D>?..H

i-)#$%8 VM9M 'G4G,+G,7+ "5 V_GA$)$+M 34)#A,FB$ X:,P$A+,G( 6A$++8 34)< #A,FB$8 D.b;=H

U4($+8 @M 'G4G,+G,7+ "5 K$4F%( €-4AA$%+M L)$A,74: '7,$:G,+G b?8 .?<.\ D>??>H

U"A:$8 LM L '4P4B$ N4A "5 6$47$M !$C W"AO J$P,$C @""O+ 3%4++,7+8 !$C W"AO8 D>??/H8g\

I:O$+G$A8 !M D$FMH LA)$F 3":5%,7G '-AP$( >?.;M II''8 ^":F":8 D>?.;H

o%$,#$A8 3M8 o"Ga8 'M 'G4G,+G,74% ',a$ K,+GA,#-G,": ,: V7":"),7+ 4:F L7G-4A,4% '7,$:7$+8 N,%$(8!$C W"AO8 D>??gH

o%$,: i"%F$C,hO8 oM8 P4: KA$72G8 iM UWKV gM.0 3-AA$:G 4:F 2,+G"A,74% *"*-%4G,": 4:F %4:F

7"P$AM I: @"-C)4:8 LME8 oA4)8 1M8 o%$,: i"%F$C,hO8 oM D$F+MH I:G$BA4G$F )"F$%%,:B "5 B%"#4%

$:P,A":)$:G4% 724:B$M L: "P$AP,$C "5 IYLiV >M\M !$G2$A%4:F+ V:P,A":)$:G4% L++$++)$:G

LB$:7(8 12$ U4B-$ D>??/H

Y4:F$%#A"G8 @M @M <12$ 5A47G4% B$")$GA( "5 :4G-A$8 EA$$)4:; D.b=gH

Y4A"::48 JM8 Y4AG,:8 JMKM8 W"24,8 kM J"#-+G 'G4G,+G,7+ < 12$"A( 4:F Y$G2"F+M N,%$(8 !$C W"AO8

D>??/H



>g

Y-$%%$A8 9MVM J$GA$4G 5A") K"")+F4(0 G2$ "#+"%$+7$:7$ "5 )4h"A C4AM @4+,7 @""O+8 !$C W"AO8

D.b=bH

!$7A")$GA,7+8 D>?.;H LP4,%4#%$ 4G0 2GG*0ee:$7A")$GA,7+M7")M

!"AG":<14(%"A8 JM i%"#4% 4A)$F 7":5%,7G+ #$7"),:B )"A$ F$4F%(8 )4 h"A +G-F( 5,:F+M 12$

i-4AF,4:8 N$F:$+F4( >? Y4(8 D>?.;H LP4,%4#%$ 4G0

2GG*0eeCCCMG2$B-4AF,4:M7")eC"A%Fe>?.;e)4(e>?e 4A)$F<7":5%,7G<F$4G2+<,:7A$4+$<+(A,4<

,A4Q<45B24:,+G4:<($)$:

62,%%,*+8 3M8 L_$%A"F8 LM V:7(7%"*$F,4 "5 N4A+ g<k"%-)$ '$GM I:5"#4+$ 6-#< %,+2,:B8 !$C W"AO

D>??\H

6,7O4:F+8 9M 'G4G,+G,74% ,:5$A$:7$ -+,:B $_GA$)$ "AF$A +G4G,+G,7+M G2$ L::4%+ "5 'G4G,+G,7+ 8 .8

..b<.g. D.b];H

6,:O$A8 'M 12$ @$GG$A L:B$%+ "5 j-A !4G-A$0 N2( k,"%$:7$ U4+ K$7%,:$FM k,O,:B 6A$++8 !$C

W"AO8 D>?..H6,:O$A8 'M 8 14),:B G2$ @$4+G N,G2,: X+8 !4G-A$8 \]=8 g?b<g..D>?..#H

!"#$$% !'% ()*+,$% -' ./,/#$/#0,1 23,14$#$ *5 67/8"+" 9,1:"$% ;#8<) =,:$"8% ;"81#3% >?@@AB

J,724AF+":8 ̂ M EM k4A,4G,": "5 G2$ EA$Q-$:7( "5 E4G4% €-4AA$%+ C,G2 Y4B:,G-F$M 9"-A:4% "5 G2$

L)$A,74: 'G4G,+G,74% L++"7,4G,": \g8 ;>g<\/ D.b\=H

J,724AF+":8 ̂ MEM 'G4G,+G,7+ "5 K$4F%( €-4AA$%+M €-4FA4:B%$ @""O8 32,74B" D.b/?H

'724A*58 LM8 '72:$,F$A8 iM8 !"28 LM8 3%4-+$G8 LM E"A$74+G,:B "5 G2$ A,+O "5 $_GA$)$ )4++47A$+ ,:

'(A,4M V-A"*$4: J$P,$C "5 I:G$A:4G,":4% 'G-F,$+ .8 ;?</= D>?.\H

'$(#"%G8 1M@M8 LA":+":8 9MKM8 E,+722"558 @M D$F+MH 3"-:G,:B 3,P,%,4: 34+-4%G,$+8 L: I:GA"F-7G,":

G" J$7"AF,:B 4:F V+G,)4G,:B !":),%,G4A( K$4G2+ ,: 3":5%,7GM j_5"AF X:,P$A+,G( 6A$++8 j_5"AF8D>?.gH

'*4B4G8 YM8 Y47O8 LM8 3""*$A8 1M8 oA$-Ga8 9M V+G,)4G,:B N4A K$4G2+0 L: LA$:4 "5

14%$#8 !M !M <12$ @%47O 'C4:0 12$ I)*47G "5 G2$ U,B2%( I)*A"#4#%$ EA4B,%,G(M J4:F") U"-+$

4:F 6$:B-,:8 D>??]e>?.?HM

14%$#8 !M!M I.+"&' C.48 D>?./HM LP4,%4#%$ ":%,:$0

CCCM5""%$F#(A4:F"):$++M7")eE4G14,%+M2G)%

14%$#8 !M!M8 4:F 6M 3,A,%%"M dj: G2$ +24F"C )")$:G+ "5 4**4A$:G%( ,:5,:,G$<)$4: *2$:")$:4Md

/#K.% !#"!#.&' /#K.%JLMLN<NOPQL D>?.;HM

X:,G$F !4G,":+ < K$*4AG)$:G "5 V7":"),7 4:F '"7,4% L554,A+M >?.; J$P,+,": "5 N"A%F6"*-%4G,": 6A"+*$7G+M X! 6A$++8 !$C W"AO8 D>?.;H

X:,G$F !4G,":+ < K$*4AG)$:G "5 V7":"),7 4:F '"7,4% L554,A+M 12$ N"A%F 4G ',_ @,%%,":M X!

6A$++8 !$C W"AO8 D.bbbH

P4: F$A N,hO8 9M I:O")$:+< $: k$A)"B$:+P$AF$%,:BM 6-#%,74G,": "5 G2$ !$F< $A%4:F+72

k,$AG%8 JMM 'G4G,+G,74% Y$G2"F+ 5"A !":<6A$7,+$ K4G4M 3J3 6A$++8 @"74 J4< G":8 D.bb;H

k,%%4+$:"A<L%P48 9MLM8 i":a4%$a<V+GA4F48 VM L #""G+GA4* B""F:$++ "5 5,G G$+G 5"A G2$ B$:$A4%,a$F

64A$G" F,+GA,#-G,":M 3")*-G4G,":4% 'G4G,+G,7+ 4:F K4G4 L:4%(+,+ ;g8 g=g;< g=\. D>??bH



N4%%$:+G$$:8 6M8 '"%%$:#$AB8 YM LA)$F 3":5%,7G .b=b<>???M 9"-A:4% "5 6$47$ J$+$4A72 g=8

/>b</\\ D>??.H

N2,G$8 YM 12$ iA$4G @,B @""O "5 U"AA,#%$ 12,:B+M NMNM !"AG": 4:F 3")*4:(8 !$C W"AO

D>?..H

N2,G$8 YM LGA"7,G,$+M NMNM !"AG": 4:F 3")*4:(8 !$C W"AO8 D>?.gH

N"%5A4)8 'M B R"; 5.&- ,0 I)."&)"8 N"%5A4) J$+$4A72 D>??>H

C?@)

!4++,) !,72"%4+ 14%$# +*$:G >. ($4A+ 4+ 4 GA4F$A 4:F *A47G,G,":$A "5 )4G2$)4G,74% 5,:4:7$

4:F 7")*%$_ F$A,P4G,P$+ #$5"A$ #$7"),:B 4 A$+$4A72$A ,: )4G2$)4G,74% 4:F *A47G,74%

*A"#%$)+ C,G2 *A"#4#,%,G(8 *4AG,7-%4A( $_GA$)$ $P$:G+M 14%$# ,+ G2$ 4-G2"A "5 4 )-%G,P"%-)$

$++4(8 G2$ A&)"#', DD3" S+/)8 I;/&? >,,+"- 6* C/&-,7&"44? /&- B&'.0#/9.+"H 7"P$A,:B #A"4F

547$G+ "5 -:7$AG4,:G(M IG 24+ )"A$ G24: ..? GA4:+%4G,":+ ,:G" g/ %4:B-4B$+M

14%$#8 ,: 2,+ +$7":F 74A$$A8 24+ *-#%,+2$F8 4+ 4 #47O-* "5 G2$ A&)"#',8 )"A$ G24: ;? +72"%4A%(

*4*$A+ ,: +G4G,+G,74% *2(+,7+8 +G4G,+G,7+8 *2,%"+"*2(8 $G2,7+8 $7":"),7+8 ,:G$A:4G,":4% 4554,A+8

4:F Q-4:G,G4G,P$ 5,:4:7$8 4%% 4A"-:F G2$ :"G,": "5 A,+O 4:F *A"#4#,%,G(M U$ ,+ 7-AA$:G%(

K,+G,:B-,+2$F 6A"5$++"A "5 J,+O V:B,:$$A,:B 4G !WX{+ 14:F": '72""% "5 V:B,:$$A,:B 4:F

*A,:7,*4% "5 G2$ J$4% N"A%F J,+O I:+G,G-G$ ^^3 M U,+ 7-AA$:G 5"7-+ ,+ ": G2$ *A"*$AG,$+ "5

+(+G$)+ G24G 74: 24:F%$ F,+"AF$A Dd4:G,5A4B,%$dH 4:F 4 *A"BA4) 5"A +G4G,+G,74% ,:5$A$:7$ -:F$A54G G4,%+M

64+Q-4%$ 3,A,%%" +*$7,4%,a$+ ,: A,+O 4:4%(+,+ 4:F $_GA$)$ P4%-$ G2$"A(8 C,G2 4**%,74G,":+ ,:

$7":"),7+ 4:F G2$ +"7,4% +7,$:7$+M ',:7$ L-B-+G >?.> 2$ 2"%F+ 4 *"+,G,": 4G K$%5G X:,P$A+,G(

"5 1$72:"%"B(8 G2$ !$G2$A%4:F+8 ,: G2$ L**%,$F 6A"#4#,%,G( iA"-*8 C2$A$ 2$ 7""AF,:4G$+ G2$

E,:4:7,4% V:B,:$$A,:B '*$7,4%,a4G,": "5 G2$ Y4+G$A ,: L**%,$F Y4G2$)4G,7+M

U$ A$7$,P$F 2,+ 6A"5$++"A,4% U4#,%,G4G,": ,: L**%,$F 'G4G,+G,7+ 5A") G2$ X:,P$A+,G( "5 @$A:8

'C,Ga$A%4:F8 4:F 2,+ 62K ,: Y$G2"F"%"B,74% 'G4G,+G,7+ 5A") @"77":, X:,P$A+,G(8 IG4%(M I:

4FF,G,": G" +G4G,+G,7+8 2$ +G-F,$F $7":"),7+ 4G '4:G{L::4 '72""% "5 LFP4:7$F 'G-F,$+ ,: 6,+48

IG4%(M

@$+,F$+ G2$ 474F$),7 74A$$A8 4+ 4 +G4G,+G,74% 7":+-%G4:G8 2$ 24+ 7"%%4#"A4G$F C,G2

,:G$A:4G,":4% ,:+G,G-G,":+8 %,O$ G2$ N"A%F @4:O 4:F G2$ V-A"*$4: E""F '45$G( L-G2"A,G(8

4:F )4:( *A,P4G$ 7")*4:,$+ 4:F #4:O+M U,+ Yjj3+ ,: A,+O 4:4%(+,+ 4:F )4:4B$)$:G 24P$

#$$: 4GG$:F$F #( G$:+ "5 G2"-+4:F+ +G-F$:G+ M

violence nobel symposium

Documents